Content deleted Content added
→Discussion: 2 more responses |
support |
||
Line 264:
* an example directly from [[WP:NATURAL]]: [[Turkey (bird)]] is an individual bird named "Turkey"?
--[[User:PigeonIP|PigeonIP]] ([[User talk:PigeonIP|talk]]) 17:33, 20 September 2014 (UTC)
* '''Support''' restoring all to their original titles ('''except''' those for which {{u|Anthony Appleyard}} has raised objection) per experienced editors in this area including {{u|Richard New Forest}} ({{diff|Talk:Canadian Speckle Park|prev|626360831|here}}), {{u|Steven Walling}} and {{u|BlindEagle}} above, and particularly {{u|PigeonIP}} whose detailed analysis and careful rationale at [[Talk:Strasser pigeon]] is completely convincing. SMcCandlish writes above that [[WP:NATURAL]] "requires" us to use his preferred format. It doesn't do anything of the sort. It specifically enjoins us to avoid made-up names, and most certainly does not suggest that we ignore [[WP:COMMONSENSE]] to the point of creating titles with mixed capitalisation such as [[White-faced Black Spanish chicken]]. What next, [[Harvard university]] (possible rationale: " ... the word 'university' is just a disambiguator and is not part of the common name of the institution")? [[User:Justlettersandnumbers|Justlettersandnumbers]] ([[User talk:Justlettersandnumbers|talk]]) 12:52, 24 September 2014 (UTC)
| |||