Scribd
Upload
124 views2 pages

IEC Protocols Comparison Overview

The document compares features of different protocols for communication with relays and RTUs. It provides a table with 38 rows comparing features such as supported data types, addressing schemes, services, and more. The protocols compared include IEC 60870, DNP3, IEC 61850, and proprietary protocols for specific vendors. Flexibility and the ability to define new models, data types, and services are some of the key factors discussed.

Uploaded by

raj151857
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
124 views2 pages

IEC Protocols Comparison Overview

The document compares features of different protocols for communication with relays and RTUs. It provides a table with 38 rows comparing features such as supported data types, addressing schemes, services, and more. The protocols compared include IEC 60870, DNP3, IEC 61850, and proprietary protocols for specific vendors. Flexibility and the ability to define new models, data types, and services are some of the key factors discussed.

Uploaded by

raj151857
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

RajeshSharma

SerialNo. Features ModBus Afew(3)Applicationspecific datatypes NO NO NO Index(CommonAddr:8,16) NO Afewofsametype&same COT IEC608705101 IEC608705104 IEC608705103 SomeApplication Specificdata NO NO Less Fixed Index(Common Addr:8,16) YES Afewofsametype& sameCOT NO ApplicationSpecificInformationModel 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Afew(3)Applicationspecific Afew(3)Applicationspecific datatypes datatypes NO NO NO Fixed Index(CommonAddr:8,16) YES Afewofsametype&same COT NO NO Openforadditionalmodels 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 DataRead DataWrite ClockSync ExchangeIntegratedtotals RemoteSubstitutions(Online) SubstitutionIndication Timeseriesdata SequenceofData Log&retrieveSelecteddata value(Historical)atanytime ParameterSettingscontrol 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 GOOSE SampleValueExchange(forCT&VT) DefineGroupofdata Selectdataforreporting Enable/Disbalecommunicationcontrol Object Changereporting/loggingBehavior LoadConfiguration FEW NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO Single Single NO NO NO NO NO YES NO NO Single Single YES YES NO QualityIndication YES YES NO NO Single Single NO YES NO QualityIndication YES YES NO NO Single Single YES NO NO NO YES YES NO NO MANY MANY YES YES NO QualityIndication YES YES NO NO NO NO Fixed Index(CommonAddr:8,16) YES Afewofsametype&same COT NO DNP3 PermitUSto create application specific extensions NO YES FULL Flexible Index(Common Addr:8,16) YES Severalofany type Some IEC61850 100Logicalnodesclasseswith200+data classes SupportInheritance,Encapsulation. YES FULL Flexible HierarchicalNames YES Manyofanytype DataName,Type,Function characterstic,reporting,triggeringOption deadbandetc,foranydataclassdefined& accessible Flexible:[Link]& Commondataclasscanbedefinedforother applicationarea MANY MANY YES YES YES QualityIndication YES YES YES

ObjectOrientedModeling DataObject&MessageIndependentof eachother CommonApplicationLayer/Encoding IndependentofdataDefination SupportedDataType Address/Identification Timestamping >1valueinonemessage(Data Groups,DataSets) Selfdescriptionofdata(foronline retrieval)

FEW NO NO NO NO YES YES YES

FEW NO NO NO NO YES YES YES

Changesome ONLYpredefined Communication Protectionsettinggroup related Parameters NO NO NO NO NO YES NO YES NO NO NO YES YES YES

Flexible(definechange&edit) YES YES YES YES YES YES YES

LocationofConfiguration 28 29 30 31 AutomaticVerificationofOnline&Offline configuration DataModelIndependentofservices CommunicationSystemSupported

ConfigurationofRTU/Relay database&application

ConfigurationofRTU/Relay database&application NO NO V.24/V.28orX.24/X.27

ConfigurationofRTU/Relay database&application NO NO TCP/IPoverethernet

Configurationof RTU/Relaydatabase& application NO NO RS485/Fiber

Configurationof TheCompleteconfigurationisintheRelay> RTU/Relay atanytimeconsistentadditionallyinthe database& XMLfile. application NO YES V.24/V.28or X.24/X.27 4Layer(Serial)or 7LayerTCP/IPor UDP/IP FullDuplex IP PseduoTransport over serial/TCP/IP NO YES YES V.24/V.28orX.24/X.27

No NO RS485/Fiber/TCP/IP

Layering 32 33 34 Mode Routing Transportprotocol 35 36 37 38 39 Openforothers Speed Redudancy MaxRelays

3Layer UnBalance NO NO NO MAX: NO

3Layer UnBalance NO NO NO

7Layer Balance IP TCP/IPoverethernet NO

3Layer Unbalance NO NO NO NO

7LayerTCP/IP FullDuplex IP,OSI,NP TCP/IP,OSITP YES YES

You might also like