Canadian History: Post-Confederation

JOHN DOUGLAS BELSHAW

Contents

About the Book xii

Acknowledgments xiii
Preface xv

Part I. Prologue

1. Introduction to Post-Confederation Canada 2

Part II. Chapter 1. Confederation and the Peoples of Canada

2. 1.1 Introduction 7
3. 1.2 Historical Demography of Canada, 1608-1921 9
Lisa Dillon, Dpartement de dmographie, Universit de Montral
4. 1.3 The Age of Federation 14
5. 1.4 Contributory Factors of Confederation 17
6. 1.5 Constitutional Crisis 20
7. 1.6 Summary 25

Part III. Chapter 2. Confederation in Conflict

8. 2.1 Introduction 30
9. 2.2 Nova Scotia's Second Thoughts 33
10. 2.3 British Columbia and the Terms of Union 36
11. 2.4 Prince Edward Island 42
12. 2.5 Canada Captures The West, 1867-70 44
13. 2.6 Canada and the First Nations of the West 50
14. 2.7 Rebellion 1885 56
15. 2.8 Making Sense of 1885 61
16. 2.9 The Railway 65
17. 2.10 The North 70
18. 2.11 The Provincial Rights Movement 76
19. 2.12 The Judicial System of Post-Confederation Canada 80
Jonathan Swainger, Department of History, University of Northern British Columbia
20. 2.13 The Other Dominion 82
21. 2.14 Summary 88

Part IV. Chapter 3. Urban, Industrial, and Divided: Socio-Economic Change, 1867-1920

22. 3.1 Introduction 93

23. 3.2 Industrialization, Labour, and Historians 99
Robert Sweeny, Dept. of History, Memorial University of Newfoundland
24. 3.3 The National Policy 102
25. 3.4 Rise of a Working Class 109
26. 3.5 Urbanization and Industry 121
27. 3.6 Craft and Industrial Unions 130
28. 3.7 Limits of Democracy 140
29. 3.8 Early Womens Movement(s) in Canada 145
Nancy M. Forestell, Department of History, St. Francis Xavier University
30. 3.9 The Great War and the General Strike 149
31. 3.10 Summary 157

Part V. Chapter 4. Politics and Conflict in Victorian and Edwardian Canada

32. 4.1 Introduction 167

33. 4.2 John A. Macdonalds Canada 169
34. 4.3 Succession Planning 174
35. 4.4 The Sunny Ways of Sir Wilfrid Laurier 179
36. 4.5 Imperialism vs. Nationalism 184
37. 4.6 Canada and Africa 189
38. 4.7 Edwardian Crises 194
39. 4.8 Summary 199

Part VI. Chapter 5. Immigration and the Immigrant Experience

40. 5.1 Introduction 203

41. 5.2 Immigration and the National Policy 205
42. 5.3 Immigrants by the Numbers 207
43. 5.4. The Clifford Sifton Years, 1896-1905 211
44. 5.5 The Promised Land 217
45. 5.6 The Ukrainian Westerners 219
46. 5.7 Culture and Adaptation 221
47. 5.8 Race, Ethnicity, and Immigration 224
48. 5.9 Immigrants and War 234
49. 5.10 Female Immigrants and the Canadian State, 1860s through the 20th century 237
Lisa Chilton, Department of History, University of Prince Edward Island
50. 5.11 Post-War Immigration 240
51. 5.12 The Chinese in Canada 246
Timothy J. Stanley, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
52. 5.13 Summary 249
 Part VII. Chapter 6. The War Years, 1914-45

53. 6.1 Introduction 256

54. 6.2 Borden vs. Borden 258
55. 6.3 The Great War 260
56. 6.4 Assessing Canadas War 265
57. 6.5 Suffrage and Prohibition 272
58. 6.6 The Interwar Years 276
59. 6.7 The Natural Governing Party: The King Years 281
60. 6.8 Canadian Fascists 286
61. 6.9 The Road to WWII 288
62. 6.10 Canada Goes to War 291
63. 6.11 Newfoundland Goes to War 294
64. 6.12 Status Indians and Military Service in the World Wars 296
R. Scott Sheffield, Department of History, University of the Fraser Valley
65. 6.13 Canada between the UK and the US 299
66. 6.14 Global War 301
67. 6.15 The Home Front 304
68. 6.16 Enlisted Women, Conscription, and the Zombie Army 309
69. 6.17 Japanese Canadians in the Second World War 312
Jordan Stanger-Ross (University of Victoria) Pamela Sugiman (Ryerson University) &
the Landscapes of Injustice Research Collective
70. 6.18 From V-E to V-J 316
71. 6.19 Summary 319

Part VIII. Chapter 7. Reform Movements from the 1870s to the 1980s

72. 7.1 Introduction 326

73. 7.2 Social Reform 328
74. 7.3 Poverty, 18671945 330
Eric W. Sager, Department of History, University of Victoria
75. 7.4 Families and Property Rights in Canada 332
Chris Clarkson, Department of History, Okanagan College
76. 7.5 Womens Organizations and Reform 336
Melanie Buddle, Department of History, Trent University
77. 7.6 Social Gospel 340
78. 7.7 Temperance and Prohibition 348
79. 7.8 Eugenics 358
80. 7.9 Reform Politics: 3rd Parties 366
81. 7.10 The Second Wave of Feminism 377
Robert Rutherdale, Department of Philosophy & History, Algoma University
82. 7.11 Greenpeace 379
83. 7.12 Summary 382
 Part IX. Chapter 8. The Economy since 1920

84. 8.1 Introduction 390

85. 8.2 The Staples Model 391
86. 8.3 Capital Markets 394
Robert Sweeny, Dept. of History, Memorial University of Newfoundland
87. 8.4 Economic Cycles 398
88. 8.5 The Great Depression 401
89. 8.6 The New Economy 410
Doug Owram, Department of History, University of British Columbia - Okanagan
90. 8.7 Three Sectors 413
91. 8.8 The Shipping Industry in Canada, 1867 1945 414
Eric W. Sager, Department of History, University of Victoria
92. 8.9 Canadas Ocean Fisheries 416
Miriam Wright, Department of History, University of Windsor
93. 8.10 Oil and Gas and the New West 419
94. 8.11 Fashioning a Post-War Economy 427
95. 8.12 The Postwar Settlement in Canada 431
Peter McInnis, Department of History, St. Francis Xavier University
96. 8.13 The Atlantic Provinces 434
97. 8.14 Economic Nationalism 442
Doug Owram, Department of History, University of British Columbia - Okanagan
98. 8.15 The Boom Years, the Bust Years 446
99. 8.16 The New World Economic Order 449
100. 8.17 Post-Industrial Canada 454
101. 8.18 Summary 459

Part X. Chapter 9. Cold War Canada, 1945-1991

102. 9.1 Introduction 468

103. 9.2 One Dominion 471
104. 9.3 The North: Economy and Territory 477
Kelly Black, Department of History, Vancouver Island University
105. 9.4 The Cold War 484
106. 9.5 Post-War Leadership and State-making 494
107. 9.6 Dief is the Chief 501
108. 9.7 The Pearson Interlude 507
109. 9.8 Trudeau I 510
110. 9.9 Cold War Quebec 513
111. 9.10 The October Crisis 523
112. 9.11 Quebec and the ROC 528
113. 9.12 The 1980s 534
114. 9.13 Cold War Society: Cities and Suburbs 542
115. 9.14 Rural Canada in an Urban Century 550
Daniel Samson, Department of History, Brock University
116. 9.15 Cold War Themes 554
117. 9.16 The 1960s Counterculture 560
118. 9.17 The Sexual Revolution 566
119. 9.18 Summary 572

Part XI. Chapter 10. This is the Modern World

120. 10.1 Introduction 583

121. 10.2 Defining Modernism 585
122. 10.3 Antimodernism 590
Sharon Wall, Department of History, University of Winnipeg
123. 10.4 Consumerism 593
Tracy Penny Light, Thompson Rivers University
124. 10.5 Secular Canada 595
125. 10.6 Religion And Irreligion In The Postwar World 597
Tina Block, Department of History, Thompson Rivers University
126. 10.7 Gendered Roles after the Wars 599
Robert Rutherdale, Department of Philosophy & History, Algoma University
127. 10.8 Canada Noir 603
128. 10.9 Historicizing Childhood: The Changing Fortunes of Children and Youth in 610
Canada
Georgia Sitara, Department of History, University of Victoria
129. 10.10 Teenage Rampage 614
130. 10.11 Historical Experiences of Adolescence at Mid-century 616
Katharine Rollwagen, Department of History, Vancouver Island University
131. 10.12 Youth and Moral Panics 620
Katharine Rollwagen, Department of History, Vancouver Island University
132. 10.13 Modern Culture 622
133. 10.14 A Culture under Siege? 630
134. 10.15 The National Pastime(s) 636
135. 10.16 Sport and Leisure in Post-Confederation Canada 639
Robin Anderson, Department of History, University of the Fraser Valley
136. 10.17 Commercial Sport and Spectating 648
Russell Field, Faculty of Kinesiology and Recreation Management, University of
Manitoba
137. 10.18 Tourism in 20th Century Canada 652
Michael Dawson, Department of History, St. Thomas University
138. 10.19 Summary 655

Part XII. Chapter 11. First Nations from Indian Act to Idle No More

139. 11.1 Introduction 662

140. 11.2 Environment and Colonialism 664
141. 11.3 Natives by the Numbers 667
142. 11.4 Aboriginal Newcomer Relations before Confederation 672
Jennifer Pettit, Department of Humanities, Mount Royal University
143. 11.5 Aboriginal-Newcomer Relations since Confederation 676
Jennifer Pettit, Department of Humanities, Mount Royal University
144. 11.6 Living with Treaties 678
Keith Smith, Departments of History and First Nations Studies, Vancouver Island
University
145. 11.7 From Agricultural Training to Residential School 685
Jennifer Pettit, Department of Humanities, Mount Royal University
146. 11.8 WWI to 1970 689
Jennifer Pettit, Department of Humanities, Mount Royal University
147. 11.9 The Aqueduct and Colonialism 691
Adele Perry, Department of History, University of Manitoba
148. 11.10 Canada and the Colonized, 1970-2002 693
149. 11.11 Residential Schools 701
150. 11.12 Idle No More 707
Mary-Ellen Kelm, Department of History, Simon Fraser University
151. 11.13 Summary 711

Part XIII. Chapter 12. Canada at the End of History

152. 12.1 Introduction 719

153. 12.2 The End of the Cold War 723
154. 12.3 Postmodern Politics 731
155. 12.4 Political Recalibrations 738
156. 12.5 Identity Politics 742
157. 12.6 Building a National Identity 747
158. 12.7 Queer and Other Histories 758
John Belshaw and Tracy Penny Light, Thompson Rivers University
159. 12.8 The Art of War 764
160. 12.9 The Historical Record in the Born-Digital Age 770
Ian Milligan, Department of History, University of Waterloo
161. 12.10 Digital Histories 772
John Bonnett, Department of History, Brock University
162. 12.11 Oral History: The Stories Our Grandmothers Tell Us and More 775
Katrina Srigley, Department of History, Nipissing University
163. 12.12 Monuments and Memory 778
Alan Gordon, Department of History, University of Guelph
164. 12.13 Summary 783

Appendix: Glossary 788

About the Author and Contributors 825
Other Books by John Douglas Belshaw 828
Versioning History 829
About the Book

Canadian History: Post-Confederation was written by John Douglas Belshaw. This book is a part of the BC Open
Textbook project. This book is the second in a two part collection by this author; also see Canadian History: Pre-
Confederation.

In October 2012, the BC Ministry of Advanced Education announced its support for the creation of open text-
books for the 40 highest-enrolled first- and second-year subject areas in the provinces public post-secondary sys-
tem.

Open textbooks are open educational resources (OER); they are instructional resources created and shared in ways
so that more people have access to them. This is a different model than traditionally copyrighted materials. OER
are defined as teaching, learning, and research resources that reside in the public domain or have been released
under an intellectual property license that permits their free use and re-purposing by others (Hewlett Founda-
tion).

BC Open Textbooks are licensed using a Creative Commons license, and are offered in various e-book formats
free of charge or as printed books that are available at cost.

For more information about this project, please contact opentext@[Link]. If you are an instructor using this
book for a course, please let us know.

xii
Acknowledgments

This open textbook follows on the Canadian History: Pre-Confederation volume produced under the auspices of
BCcampus, and it continues along a nicely oscillating learning curve begun just over two years ago. The original
goal was to assemble Open Educational Resources (OER) for Canadianist historians; it became something vastly
more ambitious. Along the way there has been much to learn about the nature of copyright law, the extent of
resources available online, and who was at the cutting edge of research on Canadian history.

There have been several formal opportunities to reflect on the process of developing an open textbook. OER
symposia, BCcampus Open Textbook conference, and developing presentations to potential user groups have
been important developmental moments. Co-writing a study on different ways to build open textbooks with Rajiv
Jhangiani (Kwantlen Polytechnic University) and Arthur Gill Green (Okanagan College) added new wrinkles
to my understanding of process and issues; it was also great fun.

My colleagues at Thompson Rivers University, particularly in the Open Learning division, played an important
role in this project. The Instructional Design Group, led by Michelle Harrison, and the Curriculum Services
department, led by Naomi Cloutier, provided both resources and editorial support in the form of Danielle
Collins, Carolyn Hawes, Wayne Egers, Mona Hall, Dawn-Louise Macleod, and Christopher Ward. Many thanks
for keeping me on my game. Open Learning also found resources to build a suite of video interviews with his-
torians in BC and Ontario. These were planned out by Norm Fennema (a talented historian at TRU-OL and the
University of Victoria) and executed by the gifted Jon Fulton (TRU-OL). Some of the interviews are incorpo-
rated into both the Pre and Post-Confederation Open Learning courses, so I would like to acknowledge the more
than two dozen historians who participated. Im pleased, as well, to acknowledge the continued resourcefulness
of TRU Librarian, Brenda Smith.

BCcampus continues to contribute leadership to the task of making quality resources available to students for free.
More than that, the organization is committed to the ideal of pedagogical assets that enable the transformation of
teaching and learning. Using this open textbook as one would a conventional textbook is a bit like employing a
smartphone exclusively as, well, as a telephone. This is the message that Mary Burgess (Executive Director),
Amanda Coolidge (Senior Manager), Clint Lalonde (Manager, Education Technologies), Lauri Aesoph (Manager,
Open Education), and Denise Goudy (Director, Education Projects) are working hard to get out. Looking at adop-
tion rates for the open textbooks in British Columbia and Canada generally, Id say they are succeeding. My
thanks to everyone at BCcampus for their commitment to this project and for their patience as one deadline after
another slipped silently by.

xiii
xiv ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

And a shout-out to the Ministry of Advanced Education (AVED). The open textbook initiative came from the Min-
istry a few years ago with significant resources attached. The results have been remarkable and British Columbia
is now, pound-for-pound and ounce-for-ounce, the leading jurisdiction in this field. This is worth bragging about,
not least because being the leader in OER means being the most enthusiastic to share, to make freely available, to
eschew petty proprietorship for the greatest possible benefit of students and in the interest of energized teaching.
Thats real leadership, AVED.

Early on in the development of the Post-Confederation textbook it occurred to me that it would be enriched by
the direct involvement of the leading lights in our field from across the country. These bright and dedicated folks
are listed by name on the About the Author and Contributors page. I am privileged to be part of this community
of scholars, and I am inspired by their work.

As this project was underway the work of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada (TRC) was wrap-
ping up in the form of an enormous, multi-volume report. There are times when, if one looks closely, it is possible
to see History with a capital-H pressing its thumbprint on our times. The TRCs proceedings and report are just
such a moment. It marks a watershed in the national, social, legal, moral, cultural, environmental, and human his-
tory of many peoples in the northern half of North America. There will be no turning back. The TRC provides
generations to come with testimony that repositions what we have written to date on the post-1867 era. I am glad
to have lived in a time when so many voices are set free and allowed to speak. As a Canadian who lives on the
unceded territory of three Aboriginal communities, I acknowledge the contribution made to this history by Inuit,
First Nations, and Mtis peoples.

Family and friends have provided encouragement in the course of this enterprise, though none more than Diane
Purvey. How often can I thank you? As this project reached its conclusion we lost our cat and companion of 21
years, Reepicheep, without whose demands for feeding and entertaining I might never have got out of my chair. I
shall not be able to think of the open textbook without remembering her as well.

Finally, although many people have contributed to what is great about Canadian History: Post-Confederation,
only one individual may lay claim to its faults, and that is me.
Preface

The interesting times in which I have been fortunate to live include the 1960s most of which I remember. On
reflection, what stands out is how one age seemed to be closing while another opened.

We started school days with The Lords Prayer, until that stopped. At assemblies we sang God Save the Queen,
until we did so no longer. There was one particularly fearsome Grade 4 teacher who kept a strap in the top drawer
of her desk and she wasnt afraid to use it, until she was no longer permitted to do so. There was a class project on
the new flag and bitter muttering on the part of the plentiful WWII vets in the neighbourhood about losing the old
Red Ensign. We stopped singing God Save the Queen in favour of O Canada, the lyrics of which changed a few
years later. (I remain conflicted as to which version I should sing at sporting events.) We used Imperial measures
until, in 7th Grade, Canada annoyingly went metric.

All the children in my class were White, with the possible exception of a small number who might now be com-
fortable identifying as Mtis; I dont remember more than a couple of Chinese Canadians in the whole school.
By the end of the 1960s there were Indo-Canadians in our suburban neighbourhood, a pioneer wave of the Asian
immigration that would transform Greater Vancouvers demographics in the 70s and 80s. Homosexuality, in
those days, was illegal and punishable in brutal ways; consequently no one was gay, a term that itself would not
emerge for nearly decade. Normal was carefully policed. For the most part diversity was a couple of Ukrain-
ian families, a very small contingent of Catholics, and an African-Canadian household. Not much diversity, really.

The focus was on belonging, not on differentness. There was a profoundly nationalistic worlds fair in Montreal in
1967, and we all learned rather sappy nationalistic songs, which we sang at the top of our little nationalistic lungs.
The world was divided neatly into Leafs fans and Habs fans until, in 1970, the Canucks joined the NHL.

Our mothers were all stay-at-home housewives, or at least thats how it seemed. Many of them, my own included,
had been Canadian Womens Army Corps (CWACs) or nurses during World War II, a couple were war-brides,
some had worked in the Vancouver shipyards. My mother had a piece of shrapnel that nearly claimed her life dur-
ing the Blitz in London, and she had been involved in the relief of a concentration camp in Germany. She wasnt
the only woman whose quiet life in suburbia was in sharp contrast with dramas in the past. By the end of the 60s
many of her cohort were shedding domesticity and finding their way back into employment.

Our parents nearly all of them, it seemed had false teeth; women talked about the wisdom of getting their
chompers pulled in their early 20s because, after all, who had the time or money for dental pain and surgery?
Then, rather suddenly, dental hygiene became a suburban cult and people just got caps, but nothing more, for the
one or two Chiclets they lost playing ball or hockey.

xv
xvi PREFACE

The other thing about teeth was they were almost always stained yellow by tobacco. Black and white television
a technology that persisted until around 1969 in our household spared us from the worst blemishes and dis-
figurements of world leaders. Those who had hung around since the 1950s or earlier all had the same puffy and
jowly faces, haggard and creased like old leather shoes. The suits they wore seldom fit well. Their wives always
seemed terrifically myopic. Then, overnight, they were all replaced by angular, smooth-featured, telegenic, less
Kremlinesque figures who didnt wear trilbies or fedoras. Diefenbaker and Pearson, like Dwight Eisenhower and
Harold MacMillan, were all born in the 19th century.

Kennedy and Trudeau were not part of that generation. In fact, the new generation of leaders and journalists were
born after the Great War, the war to end all wars, the war that had an even bigger sequel, the war that everyone
feared would turn out to be the first in a trilogy with a still bigger atomic finish. One of my earliest memories
of watching the TV news and this is something I recall with uncharacteristic clarity came during the Cuban
Missile Crisis of 1962. I was nearly five years old. They presented a map that showed the probable striking-range
of Soviet nuclear missiles launched from Cuba. I was pleased to see and to have confirmed by my parents that
although Toronto and Montreal would be incinerated (too bad about the Habs, I remember thinking), Vancouver
was just beyond the missiles reach.

Being part of the baby boom generation, even a later part of it, means that most of my memories are in some mea-
sure shared with a very large share of the current Canadian population. People my age and older talk about where
they were when John Kennedy was shot, Woodstock (cmon, I was 10 of course I didnt go), and hearing The
Beatles Yellow Submarine played repeatedly yes, the entire album on one of a small number of rock radio sta-
tions. This was another way in which our lives changed: Media was being transformed. Suburban flocks of birds
roosted on ridiculous television antennae on long poles attached and lashed like tallship masts to the rooftops of
homes. Ours picked up two local stations, a redundant channel from Victoria, and a slightly exotic CBS station
from over the border in Washington State. Occasionally a phantom station Channel 11 from Tacoma would
come in clear enough to make out a few foggy images. Then cable arrived and we had twelve channels, albeit
still in black and white. The rooftop antennae were dismantled and redeployed as badminton net posts. FM radio
arrived around the same time, utterly changing our music choices and sources of information. The possibility of
another Yellow Submarine moment when everyone in the country listened to the same album on the same day
had passed.

These changes are recalled in one way or another by almost everyone my age who grew up in Canadas cities and
suburbs in the 1960s. In some respects they are sharply Canadian memories; in others they are borrowed whole-
sale from the United States. As a historian, I look over this flotsam and jetsam of baby boom nostalgia and see
transitions and continuities, the end of one vision of Canada leading seamlessly into a very different set of expec-
tations.

The country turned 100 years old in 1967. In this respect it was a success. It had endured a whole century, during
which time it had grown geographically, matured technologically, and in the twenty-five years before the Cen-
tennial transformed economically. Ironically, Canada was about to enter into a period of renegotiated federal-
ism, an age of uncertainty in which the dissolution of the Dominion was a real possibility. Bombs were exploding
in mailboxes in Montreal; political hostages were murdered; martial law was declared. People informed and
rational people would talk seriously about the possibility of border wars along the Labrador frontier and in the
Eastern Townships. Our current culture places a high value on ironic detachment; in the 1960s and 70s the joys
and trials of being a Canadian were enough to reduce folks to genuine tears.
 Preface xvii

Canada since 1867

This textbook introduces aspects of the history of Canada since Confederation. Canada in this context includes
Newfoundland and all the other parts that come to be aggregated into the Dominion after 1867.

Where it begins is relatively easy to pinpoint. Where it ends is not. We are now well into the 21st century. Our
feet have crossed the threshold and the welcome mat as well. Some of the developments of the new millennium
are possible to contextualize in longer histories, while others, of course, are too recent to interpret. History is not
tea-leaves waiting to be read: We cannot reasonably predict how events will unfold based on what has occurred
in the last 10 or 20 years. What can be shown, however, are the many ways in which the past pursues us into the
future, clinging to our heels and ankles, refusing to release us entirely or ever. This is one reason why we study
history.

Another benefit of history is to grow analytically. Being able to interpret evidence and to revisit established ver-
sions of events is key to being a good historian and an alert human being. There are historical traditions about
Canada that arise in the 19th and 20th century that merit revisiting. Demonstrating how that work has been done
and suggesting ways in which you might continue that work is part of the purpose of this textbook.

The Challenge of Canada

Canadian history since 1867 involves an over-arching constitutional narrative: the story of a country forged not
in fire but at a bargaining table. How it transforms from a mutually convenient administrative arrangement into a
country for which individuals have real sentiments and a collectivity that can and occasionally does accomplish
something of consequence is, certainly, at the heart of that story. As well, however, it is the story of how Canada
initially a consortium of four rather bickersome colonies came to dominate half of a continent. Inevitably that
tale involves the imposition of one groups rule over others. Canada is an empire in its own right. It has had its
own colonies and it continues to engage with certain of its citizens in ways that can only be described as colo-
nial. As well, it is an economic machine. The British North America Act was designed in part to enshrine the
private ownership of property, facilitate commerce, and enable the making of profit. It is an artifact and an instru-
ment of 19th century capitalism and, as such, it has framed relations between social classes. And, at the very heart
of Canada there is an implicit assumption about the relationship between humanity and the environment. It was
originally called the Dominion of Canada to distinguish it from the Republic to the south and the United Kingdom
to the east. The word derives from the biblical story of Genesis, in which humanity is given dominion over the
fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the air, and over the cattle, and over all the Earth. As a nation of hewers of
wood and drawers of water, Canadians have imposed themselves with force on their landscape and, occasionally,
on one another.

This makes the writing and reading and understanding of Canada challenging. An older generation of historians
of Canada emphasized the ways in which the country grew politically and as a civic experiment. Alternative iden-
tities, such as those described by gender, sexual orientation, race, Aboriginality, and social class (to name only a
few), were viewed by older historians as divisive. Canadian historians since the 1980s have struggled with this
task of describing a people and a nation at the same time when the two things are not, clearly, the same thing.
xviii PREFACE

Organization
Much of this text follows thematic lines. Each chapter moves chronologically but with alternative narratives in
mind. What Aboriginal accounts must we place in the foreground? Which structures (economic or social) deter-
mine the range of choices available to human agents of history? What environmental questions need to be raised
to gain a more complete understanding of choices made in the past and their ramifications?

Each chapter is comprised of several sections and some of those are further divided. In many instances you will
encounter original material that has been contributed by writers other than myself. These sections are the work
of university historians from across Canada who are leaders in their respective fields. They provide a diversity of
voices on the subject of the nations history and, thus, an opportunity for you to experience some of the complex-
ities of understanding and approaching the past.

Pedagogical Tools
Canadian History: Post-Confederation includes several learning and teaching assets. The first section (the x.1) of
each chapter includes Learning Objectives. These are, I think, consistent with what most introductory Canadian
History courses hope to accomplish.

Key Points are provided in most chapter sections. These are intended to help you identify issues of over-arching
importance. There are, of course, other key points to be found in the chapters, so do read carefully.

Recent interviews with historians from across Canada have been captured in video clips that are embedded
throughout this book. These, and links to other videos, are highlighted by placing them in a shaded textbox. If you
reading a hard copy or e-reader, refer to the web version of this book ([Link] to
view these videos.

At the end of each chapter, the Summary section includes additional features: Key Terms, Short Answer Exercises,
and Suggested Readings. The key terms are bolded in the text, but it is likely that there are additional (or fewer)
terms for which youd like to see definitions. One of the advantages of an open textbook is that you can do some-
thing about that. The key terms are collected in a Glossary at the very end of the textbook. The Short Answer
Exercises are a means of testing your understanding of the material covered. And, of course, the Suggested Read-
ings are there to help you launch your research and further your voyage of discovery into the history of Canada
and its peoples. Everything listed in the Suggested Readings ought to be available through your university or col-
lege library.

You will also find Exercises throughout the textbook. No one likes doing exercises but, then, no one likes that
cramped feeling you get from sitting too long in front of the computer either. Think of these as a chance to stretch
and renew yourself as you work your way through the textbook. They are designed as a chance to get you think-
ing like a historian. And one of the things that historians do is see the past around them manifest in buildings,
landscapes, faces, music, plants and animals, and even smells. For the mind that is trained to understand history,
historical processes, and historical actors, the world is perceptible in many dimensions. It is an incredibly impres-
sive feeling and we want to share it with you.
 Preface xix

Nomenclature
What is Canada? Is it what it encloses now or what it was on 1 July 1867? Is it its people or its geography? These
sound, probably, like hair-splitting questions but think about it for a moment. Much of the Acadian population
in the Maritimes was sent into exile in 1755, where large numbers of their descendants remain today. If Cana-
dian history is about the Canadian people, then the Acadians are part of that story, regardless of their zipcode.
In the 19th century Euro-North Americans drew brutally straight lines across the continent and, in the process,
chopped in half the Niitsitapi Confederacy, sheered off large Anishinaabe communities from one another, and
deeply inconvenienced the St:l of the Fraser Valley. So, whose history are we studying and to what extent are
we really concerned with the Canadian peoples? If we prefer to look at the geography as the determining factor,
what if this course stopped in 1948? No Newfoundland! But since we cover the time since the union of the two
Dominions, Canada inherits Newfoundlands history as though it were some kind of dowry. What if, just imagine,
Canada annexed the Turks and Caicos Islands in the West Indies? Or Belize? This might sound ridiculous but
the proposal to do so has been made several times over the last century or so. Would Canada thus inherit their
history as well? Could Manitobans thereafter intone on their Mayan heritage the way those of us who have never
been to Newfoundland have appropriated the story of Guglielmo Marconis telegraph breakthrough in St. Johns
in 1902?

The point is that we make some choices about what is to be covered, and those choices are often arbitrary. That
should not stop us, however, from remembering that the decision of Newfoundlanders to join Confederation in
1949 was not inevitable; nor does it delete the island colonys own historical identity. What it does, however, is
1
reveal the extent to which Canadian history is national rather than transnational or even hypernational.

The same is true, if not more so, of Aboriginal peoples in Canada. The First Nations have histories that are vastly
older than Confederation. The period since 1867 may have presented challenges to Aboriginal communities no
one would argue otherwise but it is, in terms of time and historical encounters, a blip on the radar screen. The
depth of First Nations history is not a topic into which this textbook goes, but it is one that this textbook assumes.
To that end, the nomenclature preferred by Aboriginal groups is, as often as possible, used here. If the Heiltsuk
tell us that they have always been Heiltsuk and that Bella Bella was just a convenient term used by Europeans,
who am I a Euro-Canadian to question that? Heiltsuk it is, then. The question of terminology, however, is
complicated by centuries of colonialism. If youre reading a 19th century account of Aboriginal-White relations,
youre bound to encounter the colonial terms. To help, this textbook provides the current (and usually ancestral)
name along with the most well-known alternative where it seems appropriate to do so. For example: Niitsitapi
(aka: Blackfoot); St:l (Coast Salish); Innu (Montagnais or Naskapi).

As is the case with the companion text, Canadian History: Pre-Confederation, an exception to this rule has been
made of the Cree. In the post-1867 period the various people associated with this term whose lands stretch from
northern Quebec west through Ontario and across the central plains to northern Alberta have developed a com-
mon, if occasionally fragmented, collective identity. The use of Cree may be problematic and even artificial,
but it has been reinforced by the experience of the Numbered Treaties and Canadian imperialism, and sustained
by a shared language and historical heritage. For want of a better metaphor, Cree is used as a flag of convenience
here.

1. On this topic, see Allan Greer, "National, Transnational, and Hypernational Historiographies: New France Meets Early American His-
tory," Canadian Historical Review, 91, 4 (2010): 695-724.
xx PREFACE

Inevitably the word Indian comes into play. There was, of course, a Department of Indian Affairs and a slew of
Indian Residential Schools. Journalists spilled gallons of ink on various Indian issues, and Aboriginal leaders
themselves appropriated the term. I have endeavoured to use these vexed terms with historic accuracy and with
sensitivity; I would encourage you to do the same.

Think Like a Historian

There are ways to get history wrong. Clearly, events that come after cannot be used to explain events that came
before (not causally, although they may reveal something of intent). The person that a historical figure becomes
is not the person that they once were; We might look for evidence of poor ethical choices in the youth of John A.
Macdonald to explain how he winds up entangled in the Pacific Scandal, but the Pacific Scandal does not prove
that he was always morally lax. As well, the absence of something does not prove that it once existed. (Given
the fact that the universe is overwhelmingly an airless and gravity-free blackness, theres clearly no truth to the
rumour that nature abhors a vacuum.) An outcome with which we have become comfortable (e.g.: Allied victory
in 1945) is by no means pre-determined. And it is very seldom the case that human beings have no choice: Some-
times they have alternatives that are simply very bad alternatives. That doesnt mean they are not historic actors;
it just means they are historic actors faced with rotten decisions.

Of all the historic fallacies and bad practices, the one that looms largest in a subject area like modern history is that
of presentism. This is the representation of the current state of affairs as the pinnacle of historic development. It
projects current circumstances into the past in such a way as to suggest a direct connection between earlier events
and the here and now. For example, one often reads that it is thanks to the sacrifices made in the Great War that
we enjoy the freedoms we have today. This, of course, eclipses generations of struggle to translate the events of
1914-18 into laws that actually provide real freedoms. It overlooks the many challenges to those freedoms in
the interim. It pays no heed to the fact that our freedoms are not shared by everyone equally and so are demon-
strably not our freedoms at all. Worse, it has the immodesty to assume that our freedoms are greater and/or
better than those of past generations. Worst of all, it neglects to consider how one might consider those sacrifices
if freedoms were to be lost. I write this in the shadow of the passing of Bill C-51, which palpably reduces
the freedoms of some if not all members of our country with an eye to mitigating a perceived terrorist threat. I do
not judge this legislation here but I do say this: We now have fewer freedoms than we did a few months ago. In
that light, should one interpret the events of WWI thus? It is due to the sacrifices made in those terrible years of
conflict that many Canadians feel their rights have been compromised.

The point is to look at the past and people in the decades and centuries gone by as acting and living in the past. If
they hoped for a future, they certainly didnt have yours in mind. The present is special; so too is the past.
 PART 1

Prologue

1
Introduction to Post-Confederation Canada

Figure I.2 Benched a collectors card in the Canadian Hockey

Girl series of 1903. Artefacts like this one remind us that the past
may be a foreign country, but its not necessarily a dull, old place.

Canada is a physically difficult place to govern and a difficult place to adequately conceive of as well. Culturally
it presents enormous and largely unique challenges. There are other bilingual countries, such as Belgium, but they
are typically small countries. There are other nations that claim vast territories, such as the United States, Russia,
and China, but their populations are comparatively gigantic. There are other federations, though most share some
definitive historic moment or condition that binds them together (revolutionary America, isolated Australia, and
post-Berlin Wall Germany come to mind). Some former colonies threw off the imperial yoke in such a way as to
create a common vocabulary of independence, but Canada did not. Internal division between communities in some
countries Northern Ireland, Spain, and South Africa, to cite only three examples from the developed nations
were bloody and lethal in the 20th century; by contrast, Canadas internal fractures seem much less severe. How,
then, did the exercise of creating, managing, and living within a country of this scale and complexity play out in
the 19th and 20th centuries?

The Long 19th Century

Eric Hobsbawm (1917-2012), a historian of Britain and the world, coined the term the long 19th century to
describe the period from the French Revolution (1789) to the outbreak of global war in 1914. It is a useful concept
because, first, it invites us to think outside of calendar boundaries and look at long-term trends in human expe-
rience; and second, it underlines the persistence and continuity of historic relations rather than focusing on less
consequential ruptures. In the long 19th century the ideals of democracy spread across Europe and the Atlantic.
Indeed, one could argue that this process began a decade sooner in what would become the United States. Regard-
less, it influences the development of colonial cultures like those in British North America. The three ideals of
the French Revolution libert, galit, fraternit make it possible to question institutions like slavery, and
they provide a vocabulary with which to challenge oligarchies and exploitative employers later, in the age of
industrialization.

2
 INTRODUCTION TO POST-CONFEDERATION CANADA 3

This set of beliefs becomes foundational to the 19th century philosophy of liberalism. The individual under-
stood to be, in practice, an adult male has rights; such a concept would have been impossible to sustain before
the 1780s and yet it was generally embraced around the time of Confederation. When one looks at the history
of colonies in the 17th and the 18th centuries, one finds a much more biological language of settlement, popula-
tion, and sustenance. The village and the commons, the seigneury and the Clergy Reserves are all more corpo-
rate ways of seeing the world. By the late 19th century the homestead emerges as a model of colonization based
on the emergent ideal of the nuclear family. The paternalism of earlier generations does not go away, but it is
refashioned so as to emphasize the authority of the senior adult male in a household of dependants rather than the
relationship of many males to the seigneur, or the lord of the manor, or the slave owner.

This kind of liberalism is difficult to escape when one looks at Canada from 1867-1914. Loyalty to the monarchy
is unshaken and there is important continuity there but, in practical terms, Parliament in Ottawa and in West-
minster is sovereign. And it becomes sovereign by the will of the electorate. Every addition to the landscape of
Canada is conceived within the context of a language of individual rights: voters rights, land rights, the freedom
to believe in whatever creed appeals (providing it is Christian), and a vocabulary of reciprocal obligations to the
maintenance and protection of the source of these liberties. It is for this reason that so many conflicts undertaken
in the years from 1850-1918 are conceptualized as battles for freedom and the protection of liberties. This is a
kind of language almost reflexively associated with the United States but it resonates around the Atlantic rim and
across Canada in 1914 every bit as much. Too, the Canadian version incorporates the notion of freedom from the
United States. This aspect is invoked in 1869-70 when talk of American annexation of Ruperts Land catalyzes
Canadian imperialism in the West; it is invoked again in 1885 when Louis Riel returns from exile in the United
States to lead further resistance to Canadian authority. At that juncture we see collective identities Mtis, Abo-
riginal, and others being invoked by Riel and others (some in Quebec) as concepts equivalent to if not greater
than that of the individual. The victory of Canada in the North-West Rebellion is, therefore, interpreted by the
Canadians themselves as a triumph of democratic and individual values over something closer to tribal, an con-
cept that is dismissed as older and less progressive.

Progress and Modernity

Indeed, no word so fully captures the spirit of the 19th and 20th centuries as progress. It is bound inexorably
with the notion of modernity. Clearly, social changes occurred repeatedly in the pre-19th century world but the
combination of scientific and philosophical developments led to a widespread belief that the past was largely sta-
tic and the present not to mention the future were domains of positive transformation. Scientific knowledge
progress was increasingly viewed as key to improving human life and social conditions. As society progressed,
so too would the individual. Progress thus became an all-consuming force, a tide of change that led in only one
direction: toward continuous improvement.

Among historical writers, this view of onward-and-upward change was embodied by the Whig School. They
looked to the past for evidence of human, social, and material progress and understood recent historical events as
further proof that the world was improving. Indeed, this has proved to be a powerful and persistent way of view-
ing past events and peoples. If we are the product of progress, then those who came before us were necessarily
less advantaged and we are merely a stage on the path toward something better still. It is a view that does not
easily accommodate setbacks and, of course, it privileges what it views as progressively valuable: reason, democ-
racy, rights, equality, greater human numbers, technological innovation, the conquest of nature, and so on. It is no
4 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

coincidence that the ideals of progress are contemporary with the ideas associated with biological evolution and
Charles Darwin.

The whole package came to be understood as modernity. The modern world is marked by a break with the pre-
modern. Science versus superstition; individual merit and upward social mobility versus a life-sentence in a single
social class determined by the status of ones parents; cities rather than the countryside. In each respect, modernity
constitutes a revolution in its own right, a rejection of the norms of previous centuries wherein authority resided
in the landed gentry and the clergy.

Modern Canada was, as one might expect, created in the forges of modernity. The values of that day and age were
hard-wired into its constitution, and many were embraced and advanced by advocates of the new nation-state
dominion. In this sense, the history of Canada since 1867 is the story of an idea: modernity. Much else happened,
to be sure, but this intellectual context one that is shared and advanced by more than 150 years worth of media
and educational institutions is not to be ignored.

Contrary Winds
There are contradictions bolted onto the framework of late 19th century modernism. The most outstanding and
portentous of these are race, class, and gender. While the individual was increasingly viewed as a self-defining
and free-acting agent of his (definitely his) destiny, that doesnt mean that the modern mind is free of the notion
of collectivities and categories. Racial categories were widely accepted as commonsensical, scientific, and essen-
tially immutable. These categories extended to what we might now think of as ethnicities or visible minorities in
a culture dominated by what were increasingly called Caucasians: White Europeans descended mostly from the
British or French. The emergence of the industrial working class produced a collective response to grim working
conditions, poor compensation for labour, and political oppression. That collective response which sometimes
took the form of labour organizations like unions was viewed by the Canadian middle- and upper-classes (and
by many artisans as well) as corrosive of individual values. Finally, the language of individual rights was chal-
lenged very directly by the call for womens rights. So long as the definition of individual was inherently male,
movements that were led by women (mostly middle-class women at that) and which called for social reform,
electoral reform, and general equality for women would be viewed by the male establishment as problematic at
several levels.

And here is the twofold contradiction. Generations that called for individual rights denied them to groups that
were described as collectivities outside of the paradigm of individualism. Thats one contradiction. Individual
Aboriginal people, individual Asian immigrants, individual women from any quadrant of Canadian society
they were all denied individual rights and equality. Whats more, in racializing the Chinese and the First Nations,
White Canada racialized itself. In classifying working people as an other, middle-class Canada held up a mirror
to itself as a distinct social element with its own collective identity. In essentializing women as a population that
lacked a claim on rights, or the intellectual, moral, or physical ability to participate in civic life alongside men,
male Canadians were essentializing themselves as a set of values at the same time.

In so many respects the Great War challenged these perspectives and changed the course of modernity. Before
conscription there was voluntarism the individual male choosing to serve king and country. Womens suffrage
was repeatedly rejected, as were working-class demands for improved conditions and wages. As the war wore
 INTRODUCTION TO POST-CONFEDERATION CANADA 5

on, however, women gained the vote, the relationship of labour and the state was revisited, and conscription was
introduced to override individual choice and (without irony) to force Canadian males to fight for their liberty.

The Short 20th Century

Whether measured from August 1914 or the Treaty of Versailles that ended the Great War, the short 20th century
is said to have concluded in 1991. The collapse of Europes old dynastic regimes gave way to a century of modern
nation-building, the rise of two conflicting ideologies and, after 1945, two superpowers. It ends with the fall of
the Berlin Wall and the Soviet Union. In this phase, modernity becomes bound up in the nature of industrial and
commercial production, comprehensive liberal democracies at odds with tyrannies on the right and left, a more
expansive state that moves into fields associated with energy production, healthcare, and social welfare, and a
reconsideration of race and inclusion.

For Canadians the short 20th century starts badly. The economy is in tatters on the eve of the Great War and
it barely recovers in the Interwar period. The prosperity of the post-World War II era is all the more important,
historically, because of the long period of denial and hardship that preceded it. Racism and xenophobia were
commonplace during World War I, and they never fully abated. There were internment camps for the enemy popu-
lation in WWI whose loyalty to foreign and hostile regimes was assumed to be visceral and not a matter of choice.
These would be reopened and expanded in the 1930s to house unemployed men, and then again in 1939-45 when
Italian, German, and Japanese Canadians found their liberties severely curtailed. Asian and Aboriginal Canadians
would have to wait until 1948 and 1960 respectively to get the franchise and access to professions that racist legis-
lation previously closed off. Working-class movements were lively and effective in the years between 1914-1920,
but they were so in the face of considerable opposition. Women (that is, White women) got the vote, but their
conditions under the law were largely unchanged from Victorian constraints.

Two World Wars and a Cold War later, Canada was a very different place from what it had been in 1867. In
the space of little more than a century it passed from industrialization through de-industrialization. Its city cen-
tres transformed from commercial centres, to industrial hubs, to hollowed out postwar strips, to revitalized and
densely repopulated metropolitan capitals. Gender roles transformed repeatedly with no apparent constant course
of direction for many decades. Aboriginal peoples, who were systematically contained on small pockets of land
with their movements restricted, their choices narrowed, and their culture under continuous assault, found them-
selves increasingly taking a leading role in redefining and reorienting the country as a whole. These themes of
change and contradiction are at the heart of the history of Canada since Confederation the theme of continuity
is as well.

Attributions
Figure I.2
Benched The Canadian hockey girl Series no 2, photo no 2 (HS85-10-15498) by British Library is in the public
domain.
 PART 2

Chapter 1. Confederation and the Peoples of

Canada

6
1.1 Introduction

Figure 1.1 Canadas territorial evolution from 1867 to 2003.

Canada in 1867 covered an area roughly equivalent to the original Thirteen Colonies of Britain the core
elements of the United States of America (U.S.) in 1783. However, Ontario (formerly Canada West), Quebec
(formerly Canada East), New Brunswick, and Nova Scotia were much more sparsely populated, and the new
Dominion was a curious mix of highly concentrated and urban populations on the one hand, and overwhelmingly
rural and remote on the other. For example, much of southern Ontario was farmland, and the northern coastline
of Lake Superior was forestry and mining territory in which only small clusters of Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal
people lived. There was some degree of industrialization underway from which a Canadian working class
emerged. Cities like Hamilton, Ontario transformed from leafy commercial towns in the 1850s to smoky industrial
engines in the late 1860s. The former colonies now provinces were not uniformly happy to be part of the
new federation. Britains role in the post-1867 era was still unclear. Indeed, the meaning of the new federal union
of colonies (and, to be clear, although they were provinces they were all still colonies as well) was not entirely
obvious to the British North Americans themselves.

Historians have debated for many years just what was accomplished in the British North America Act (BNA
Act) of 1867. There is the matter of what the so-called Fathers of Confederation believed they were doing and
agreeing to. And there was also the question of Britains objectives: The new constitution might have signaled
greater decision-making autonomy when it came to internal matters, but there was no suggestion of colonial inde-
pendence. What, too, did the rest of the British North Americans the people of the Plains and British Columbia,
for example believe was underway? Was the BNA Act a pivotal moment for them? And what of the Aboriginal
peoples whose ancestral and current territories were now captured within the boundaries of the new Dominion?
This chapter summarizes the steps that led to the new constitution, and identifies the many peoples who both com-
prised the emergent country and who were soon (or not so soon) going to be entangled in Canadian expansionism.
It may be convenient to think of 1 July 1867 as a new beginning but it was, in a great many respects, more about
continuity than change.

7
8 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Learning Objectives

Describe the political and economic background to Confederation.

Identify the principal features of the Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal people in the northern half of
North America.
Explain the residual uncertainty about, and the hostility toward, the Canadian project.

Attributions
Figure 1.1
Canada provinces evolution 2 by Golbez is used under a CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.
 1.2 Historical Demography of Canada, 1608-1921

LISA DILLON, DPARTEMENT DE DMOGRAPHIE, UNIVERSIT DE MONTRAL

Sustained settlement of Canada by Europeans began in the St. Lawrence Valley, where the colony named le
1
Canada stretched over 500 km from Quebec City to present-day Montreal. From its founding in 1608 by Samuel
de Champlain, the colony grew modestly until 1663, when the King of France, Louis XIV, and Jean-Baptiste Col-
bert, his minister of finance, instituted measures for the colony to grow through natural increase. Male immi-
grants dominated the colony in its early years, creating a severe sex ratio imbalance. However, between 1663 and
1673, the arrival of 716 filles du roi French women whose immigration was financed by the King allowed
2 3
marriages and families to form in more significant numbers. By 1760, the population had risen to 70,000. Con-
sidered a founder population, a population deriving from a small initial influx of immigrants, present-day Que-
becois who trace their origins to the French colonists are descended from just 8,573 men and women who married,
4
had children, and whose children married in turn.

A family reconstitution database of the Quebec Catholic population, the Registre de la Population du Qubec
Ancien (RPQA), allows us to trace the growth of this population throughout the French and British colonial
period. The Quebec population was long considered exceptional because of its very high fertility: Married women
bore on average seven to eight children, while women who lived a complete reproductive period could have 11
children. Since the inception of the RPQA database, scholars have emphasized the exceptionalism of this pop-
ulation in terms of comparatively generous land availability for new farm establishment, concomitantly large
proportions of children marrying, and high fertility. More recent research, while confirming these trends, now
emphasizes the differentiation of patterns. Such research has shown that while most Quebec youths married, eldest
daughters had the highest propensity to marry and married the fastest, and about three-quarters of Quebec chil-
5
dren married in birth order. Through high fertility and intermarriage, Quebec families developed dense kinship
networks: Nearly a quarter of families married their children in exchange marriages in which brothers and sis-

1. Hubert Charbonneau, Bertrand Desjardins, Jacques Lgar and Hubert Denis, The Population of the St. Lawrence Valley, 1608-1760, in
Michael Haines and Richard Steckel, eds., A Population History of North America (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000): 99.
2. The Programme de recherche en dmographie historique (PRDH) list of the Filles du Roi (the Kings Daughters). Montreal: Universit de
Montral, [Link]
3. Charbonneau et al., Population of the St. Lawrence Valley, 131.
4. Bertrand Desjardins, La contribution diffrentielle des immigrants franais la souche canadienne-franaise, Annales de Normandie, no.3/
4 (2008): 74.
5. Lisa Dillon, Parental and Sibling Influences on the Timing of Marriage, 17th- and 18th-century Quebec, Annales de Dmogra-
phie Historique, no.1 (2010): 139-180.

9
 10 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION
6
ters married siblings from the same family. Fertility and mortality were intimately intertwined in this population.
7
Mothers who bore the largest number of children also experienced the highest infant losses; on the other hand,
women gave birth to their last child on average at age 40, and a late age at last birth was associated with an older
8
age at death.

Over the course of the 18th and early 19th centuries, the Quebec population experienced increased pressure and
risks. While adult mortality remained stable, the growth of the colony and circulation of its inhabitants resulted in
rising infant mortality, which increased from 50 to 100 per thousand before 1700 to 250 to 300 per thousand in the
9
period 1750-1775. The colony passed from control of the French crown to the British in 1760, joining Nova Sco-
tia. Several thousand immigrants to Nova Scotia and the newly-formed colony of New Brunswick arrived from
the New England colonies, both before and after the American Revolution, with a African-American community
established in Nova Scotia. Meanwhile, the Quebec population continued to grow exponentially. English-speak-
ing immigrants from the United States also began to settle parts of present-day Quebec and Ontario, while Nova
Scotia and Prince Edward Islands populations were boosted by British immigrants, particularly Scottish High-
landers. The new colony at Red River likewise grew from Scottish sources in these years. Following the War of
10
1812, the colonies of Upper and Lower Canada began to receive more British immigrants in general.

Despite these important inflows, childbearing was an important source of Canadian population growth during the
19th century. McInnis estimates that between 1811-1861, when Canada grew from 511,000 persons to 3,175,000
persons, 84% of population growth was on account of natural increase which makes natural growth more
11
important than immigration. Quebecs population itself increased thirteen-fold from 1761-1851; at the same
12
time, the mean size of farms declined by a third. Children who could not launch a farm household instead moved
to cities or to the United States. From 1840-1940, Lavoie estimates that one in ten French Canadians emigrated to
13
the U.S., of whom about two-thirds headed to New England.

Sources of growth were countered by significant mortality rates. Infant mortality levels across 19th century
Canada differed on the basis of urban-rural residence and francophone and anglophone identity. The infant mor-
tality rate for all of Quebec (190 per thousand) was higher than that for Ontario (115) as well as New Brunswick
14
(132, excluding Saint John), Nova Scotia (120, excluding Halifax) and Prince Edward Island (116). Rising pop-
ulation density in Montreal and Quebec City created a sharp urban-rural contrast in death rates within Quebec,
15
with as many as 285 infant deaths per thousand births in Montreal.

Although fertility was relatively high in mid-19th century Canada compared to European countries, it began to

6. Marianne Caron and Lisa Dillon, Exchange marriages between sibsets: A sibling connection beyond marriage, Quebec 1660-1760, Paper
presented to the IUSSP Conference, Busan, Korea, 2013, p.14.
7. Marilyn Amorevieta-Gentil. Les niveaux et les facteurs dterminants de la mortalit infantile en Nouvelle-France et au dbut du Rgime
Anglais (1621-1779). Doctoral thesis. Montreal: Universit de Montral, 2010.
8. Alain Gagnon et al., Is There a Trade-off between Fertility and Longevity? A Comparative Study of Three Large Historical Demographic
Databases Accounting for Mortality Selection. PSC Discussion Papers Series, vol. 22, no. 5 (2008).
9. Amorevieta-Gentil, Les niveaux et les facteurs dterminants, 131.
10. Marvin McInnis, The Population of Canada in the Nineteenth Century, in Haines and Steckel, eds., A Population History of North Amer-
ica: 374-8.
11. Ibid.: 379.
12. Serge Courville, Quebec: A Historical Geography (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2009).
13. Yolande Lavoie, Lmigration des Qubcois aux tats-Unis de 1840 1930 (Quebec, 1981): 53; Yves Roby, Les Franco-Amricains de la
Nouvelle-Angleterre: Rves et ralits (Sillery, Quebec: Les ditions du Septentrion, 2000).
14. McInnis, The Population of Canada, 403-4.
15. [Link], [Link], and [Link], Mortality in Qubec during the nineteenth century: from the state to the cities, Population Studies,
51(1) (March 1997): 93-103; McInnis, The Population of Canada, 403.
 1.2 HISTORICAL DEMOGRAPHY OF CANADA, 1608-1921 11

fall during the last third of the 19th century. Married couples began to limit their childbearing; in Ontario, declin-
ing marital fertility has been linked to urban development and land availability. More recent research on Quebec
demonstrates class and ethnic differentials in childbearing behaviour, with French Canadian married women man-
ifesting higher fertility than their Quebec anglophone counterparts. Yet, among French Canadian women alone,
16
those living in medium-sized and large cities had lower fertility than rural French Canadian women. Intensive
historical demographic research on Montreal has demonstrated further important cultural differences in demo-
graphic behaviour. By 1901 in Montreal, the total fertility rate, or the average number of children a woman would
bear, with all married or unmarried women included in the measure, was 5.6 for French Catholics, 3.6 for Irish
Catholics and 3.9 for Protestants. The earlier age at marriage of French Catholic women accounted for this ethnic
differential: the percentage of women aged 20 to 24 who were married in Montreal during the 1890s was 43%
17
for French Catholics, 32% for Irish Catholics, and 27% for Protestants. These analyses portray a set of distinct
ethno-religious demographic regimes within the city which, with further research, could potentially be general-
ized to the broader Canadian population.

Figure 1.2 The principal instrument of demographic history is the

census, particularly the enumerators ledgers, like this one from
Winnipeg in 1901.

Following Confederation, Canada expanded its territory to the Pacific coast; whereas the 1871 Census of Canada
enumerated the populations of New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, Quebec, and Ontario, the 1881 Census of Canada
encompassed provinces from British Columbia to Prince Edward Island (PEI). By 1901, the population numbered
5,371,000 and the country had undergone significant urbanization, with rapid growth in Montreal and Toronto and
18
the emergence of new cities to the west including Vancouver and Winnipeg. The first decade of the 20th cen-
tury was marked by a rate of immigration that was 2.8% of the average population; according to McInnis, immi-
gration in this decade was one of the most pronounced episodes experienced by any nation in recorded world
19
history. These new immigrants helped to populate the new western provinces, and by 1921, when Canada num-
20
bered 8,788,000 persons, more than 25% of Canadas population was living in BC and the Prairie provinces.
During these years, marital fertility in Canada continued to decline, but an increase in the proportion of women
21
marrying offset this trend. Canadians suffered some 50,000 deaths from the Spanish flu epidemic of 1918-19,
22
notably in the age group 20 to 40 years. But more generally, infant mortality in Canada fell after 1910 on account
of improved sanitary practices, the creation of pasteurized milk distribution stations, and the promotion of clean-

16. Danielle Gauvreau, Diane Gervais and Peter Gossage, La Fcondit des Qubcoises 1870-1970: Dune exception lautre (Quebec: Boral,
2007): 128-30.
17. Sherry Olson and Patricia Thornton, Peopling the North American City: Montreal 1840-1900 (Montreal: McGill-Queens University Press,
2011), 137-9.
18. McInnis, The Population of Canada: 419.
19. Marvin McInnis, Canadas Population in the Twentieth Century, in Haines and Steckel, eds., A Population History of North America: 534.
20. Ibid.: 539.
21. Ibid.: 547.
22. A. Gagnon, M. Miller, S. Hallman, R. Bourbeau, D. A. Herring, D.J.D. Earn and J. Madrenas, Age-Specific Mortality During the 1918
Influenza Pandemic: Unravelling the Mystery of High Young Adult Mortality, PLOS-One, August 5, 2013.
 12 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION
23
liness in the care of infants. Thus, western development, high immigration, rapid urbanization, and declining
fertility and mortality set the stage for Canadas century.

Exercise: Think Like a Historian

The Manuscript Census

For anyone interested in demographics, family reconstitution, community histories, occupational mobility,
and many other population behaviours, the census-takers manuscript record is invaluable. As well, they
provide information on people who generally didnt leave other kinds of records behind; children, prison-
ers, and immigrant enclaves like the Chinese are all covered.
The job of census-taker was a small piece of patronage that was handed off to a party loyalist attached
to the local constituency. There were, necessarily, hundreds of census-takers in late 19th century Canada,
each one facing particular challenges, applying idiosyncratic methods, and demonstrating varying levels of
conscientiousness. In 1891 the census-taker in Kamloops asked his bosses in Ottawa what he should put in
the occupation category when it came to sex trade workers (aka: prostitutes, brothel keepers, and a half
dozen other euphemisms). The reply he received tells us a lot about late Victorian sensibilities: write them
up as dressmakers. As a result, one can find in many towns of the far west what looks like a substantial
textile industry.
The manuscripts were transcribed into aggregate data and published as the decennial Canada Census. Cen-
tury-long and then 90-year long restrictions on access to the manuscripts meant that we are only now
able to access 1911 data here. (The 1921 records have been farmed out to [Link].)
Take a look at these examples from 1891. The Vipond household in Nanaimo is a big one and includes
Jane and Georges son-in-law (although their eldest daughter appears to be missing). What does the record
reveal about migration, religion, occupation, fertility, and birth intervals? The second block shows three
neighbouring coalmining households headed respectively by Cuthbert, Cornish, and Scales. Tragedy has
struck these people. The Elliott children have evidently been adopted by the Cuthberts, as has one of the
Cornish children, Mamie, whose mother (born in Mauritius) has apparently died, leaving Thomas a wid-
ower and able to manage only three children on his own. One of those children, William Cornish, is 14
and working in the mines not as a labourer but as a miner, which indicates hes been doing this for
a while. Hannah and David Scales have taken in Mamies sister Lily. What were seeing here are sur-
vival strategies. What else is visible? Religious affiliation (C.E. denotes Church of England, Meth. is
Methodist, Presb. is Presbyterian, S.A. = Salvation Army), birthplace, occupation. Make a list of the
ways in which identities congeal, intersect, are transmitted from generation to generation.

Key Points

Population growth under the French regime and between 1763 was principally driven by natural
growth (that is, high marital fertility).
Following a rush of immigration to Nova Scotia and Upper Canada, childbearing resumed its posi-
tion as the leading source of growth.

23. Neil Sutherland, Children in English-Canadian Society: Framing the Twentieth-Century Consensus (Waterloo: Wilfrid Laurier University
Press, 1973), 59-61.
 1.2 HISTORICAL DEMOGRAPHY OF CANADA, 1608-1921 13

Mortality rates were high in pre-Confederation Canada, especially infants.

Canada began the process of a demographic transition to lower fertility around the time of Confeder-
ation.
By the early 20th century, immigration, urbanization, and the opening for resettlement of the Prairie
West and British Columbia changed the character and distribution of the population.

Attributions
Figure 1.2
1901 Winnipeg, Manitabo, Canada census by Valorc is in the public domain.
1.3 The Age of Federation

Figure 1.3 Most Confederation-era Canadians were engaged in

work that had not changed a great deal in hundreds of years.
Harvesting Hay, Sussex, NB, by William G.R. Hind, ca. 1880.

One month after the creation of the Dominion of Canada, the United States finally acted on its threats to annex
territory to the north. Instead of some part or all of British North America (BNA), however, the Americans pur-
chased Alaska. This was an audacious move. The idea of claiming territory that was thousands of kilometres away
from the nearest American settlement, cut off by the presence in between of British North American territory, was
a far cry from annexing contiguous lands. The same, of course, could be said for the Americans earlier wresting
of California from Mexico. While much more of the American Empire was captured incrementally by squatters,
settlers, and cavalry charges, the Alaskan purchase stands out for what it implies. That is, it was possible now for
former colonies to administer sovereignty in remote lands. Canada watched and learned.

Fragile Unions
Canada had its own imperial ambitions. George Brown Toronto newspaperman, Clear Grit reformer, coalition
government partner, and a Father of Confederation made his support of the coalition and Confederation con-
ditional on the purchase of Ruperts Land from the Hudson Bay Company (HBC). The sale of the vast territory
(encompassing the whole of the Prairie West from Hudsons Bay to the Rockies and from the 49th parallel to the
Arctic Ocean) went through in 1869, but the process was badly flawed. The Canadians (in Ottawa and on the
ground in the Red River Colony) rushed matters and aggravated local sentiment. The Mtis community around the
confluence of the Assiniboine and Red Rivers wasnt alone in its dissatisfaction with Ottawa, but their resistance
and the Provisional Government became understood in the new Dominion as an act of hostility against a legiti-
mate government by an illegitimate junta. The execution of Thomas Scott by the Provisional Government would
embitter Canada against the Manitobans and the Mtis for years to come (see Sections 2.5, 2.6, 2.7 and 2.8).

All in all, the Dominion of Canada was off to a rather poor start. Provincial leaders in Nova Scotia and New
Brunswick were able to muster widespread support for taking a second look at Confederation. The possibility of

14
 1.3 THE AGE OF FEDERATION 15

secession might be ruled out by Westminster, but as far as Halifax and Fredericton anti-Confederationist politi-
cians were concerned this was a matter of popular consent and/or discontent.

Federations, as the 1860s and 70s would demonstrate, are difficult creatures. In this respect, the timing of the
creation of the Dominion of Canada is important. It took place at a time when similar experiments were being
launched or revised around the world. The most obvious case is that of the United States, where a century-old
federation came apart along the Mason-Dixon Line. Although the South and the North were eventually re-united
and re-federated, that change came about after years of a terrible civil war. Similarly, the 1860s saw a bloody
campaign across the Italian States that completed the main work of the Risorgimento (the unification of Italy) by
1870. Less than a year later, the Franco-Prussian War, 1870-1871, produced a unified Germany under Prussian
leadership. Federations including the Canadian one are generally understood to be consensual partnerships
between sovereign or semi-sovereign jurisdictions. What these other federations/unifications and the suppression
of the Red River Rebellion in Manitoba point out is that federal membership is occasionally helped along by the
point of a bayonet.

Why is that the case? Modern historians have wrestled with the meanings of Canadian confederation just as their
Victorian contemporaries did. Was it an Act or a pact? That is, was it a reorganization of colonies stickhandled
along and then imposed by Britain, or was it an agreement by (essentially) sovereign parties to share some of their
authority with a new entity, the Federal Government? Were the provinces junior partners in the new federation
or key stakeholders? This became a pressing matter (as we shall see) when Ottawa invoked its ability to kill any
provincial legislation with which the central government did not agree. It persists as a pressing matter when one
looks at the rhetoric of sparatisme in the late 20th century, a discourse that positions the province of Quebec as a
partner with the ability to leave the table if and when it should decide to do so. Nova Scotians clearly held to the
same belief in the late 1860s; they were persuaded to stay and not compelled by Westminster (let alone Ottawa)
to stay.

Another lens through which to view Confederation is as a means to colonial independence, an apparent contra-
diction in terms. Britain in the Age of Free Trade was eager to offload some of its colonial responsibilities and
to normalize relations with the United States. Giving the British North Americans greater responsibilities and
authority in their own domain was one way of doing that. However, the Americans recognized that Britain was
still invested in North America and they were slow to recognize Canadas own national authority.

Unity, Disunity, and Nationhood

The ongoing fragmentary identity of Canadians is, thus, something that existed at the time of Confederation and
has persisted. John A. Macdonald sought union but not necessarily unity, although it is difficult to speak of one
without implying the other. George-tienne Cartiers vision was more along the lines of collaboration in a dual-
ity of French and English cultures. Outlying provinces Nova Scotia and British Columbia, for example
were principally concerned with the economic advantages promised by Confederation.

Many of the challenges that Canada would face in the century and a half that followed Confederation stem from
its timing and a lack of consensus as to what it all meant. At the heart of the problem is the idea of the nation
state.

A nation is generally understood to be a culture or peoples, the main features of which include a shared language,
16 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

ancestry, and perhaps a shared creed. A state is, more plainly, an administrative organization and a geopolitical
realm. For Germany in 1871, the challenge was to inflate shared cultural features while downplaying sectarian
differences, lingering loyalties felt in some regions to their neighbours (including France, Austria, and Switzer-
land), and the fact that some of the German states had been at one anothers throats for centuries. Old histories of
difference had to be superseded by histories of sameness and mutual interest. Italy a linguistic patchwork that
at least shared a common Catholic heritage (however vexed relations might have been between Italy and the Papal
States) seized upon Dante as the father of the Italian language and, like Germany, sought to minimize historic
rivalries between regions. A new iconography of the Italian state, with General Giuseppe Garibaldi at its spiritual
centre and a new king in a shared capital, were key to creating an Italian nation state. Increasingly the United
States would invoke the language of nation as well, most notably in its Pledge of Allegiance in 1892 in which
the nation and the federal state become indistinguishable.

Clearly some nation states in the late 19th century were less unified culturally than others. Canadas odds in this
respect were hardly worse than those of many other newly emergent countries. But it is worth noting that there
was, at the time of Confederation, confusion about what constituted a nation state, a sense that expansion and ter-
ritorial unification was a legitimate part of building a country, and that nation building involved more than a
railway or two.

Key Points

The last half of the 19th century witnessed the organization and reorganization of several federal
nation states.
Scholars and politicians are divided on whether Confederation constitutes an Act imposed by Britain
or an agreement between sovereign colonies.
The concept of the nation state was still emergent and definitions were flexible.

Attributions
Figure 1.3
Harvesting Hay, Sussex, New Brunswick (Online MIKAN no.2835767) by Library and Archives Canada, Acc.
No. 1982-204-9 is in the public domain.
1.4 Contributory Factors of Confederation

Figure 1.4 The 60th Battalion braces itself for a Fenian Raid in
May 1870.

Confederation answered constitutional questions about Canadas organization and governance, but it was also an
economic strategy, and it had a military and diplomatic face as well. British North Americans bought into the new
federal structure in part because it promised a more certain future. Its success, to some extent, has to be measured
against these concerns.

Civil War America

The American Civil War in the 1860s, coming to a close in 1866, consumed the United States. It entailed carnage
on a massive scale and national productive capacity was severely damaged. It did, however, leave the United
States with the largest standing army on the planet, and it was a battle-hardened army at that. The Aboriginal peo-
ples of the western half of North America would see this massive military machinery deployed in their territories.
British North Americans had cause to be concerned that they would confront this military machinery as well.

British diplomatic missteps during the Civil War hardened American opinion against both Britain and British
North America. The Reciprocity Treaty of 1854 which enabled freer trade between the colonies and the
United States was cancelled by the Americans at the end of the war. Fear grew of further retributive moves by
the Americans. Indeed, a series of largely ineffectual invasions of British North America (BNA) by Irish-Ameri-
cans, bound together as an anti-British Fenian Army, catalyzed colonial will to build a united regime that would
offer greater mutual protection. Invasions took place across the borders of the three contiguous BNA colonies
(Canada East, Canada West, and New Brunswick), and of those that were spared, Nova Scotia, PEI, and British
Columbia shared in the sense of pending attacks. American acquisition of Alaska, in 1867, reminded British
Columbians and other Westerners that the Americans held on to their belief in a manifest destiny to rule the
whole of the continent.

Was a Canadian federation any more able to defend itself against an American invasion than the separate colonies?
Probably not. The population discrepancy between BNA and the re-United States as well as the enormity of the
experienced American forces, not to mention the superiority of American arms, makes the question absurd. Con-
17
18 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

federation reduced British military obligations and did little to increase the size and preparedness of Canadian
militias. It did, however, create the impression of unity and an emergent nation state, rather than low-hanging
colonial fruit that might be picked at the convenience of the United States. The emergence of a Canadian mili-
tary culture after 1867 was slow in coming, and the almost calamitous performance of militia units in the North
West Rebellion in 1885 only underlines the extent to which fear of America did not result in any palpable steps to
improve Canadian defense.

A Post-Mercantilist World
In the mid-19th century Britain moved inexorably toward freer trade. Laissez-faire capitalism became the order
of the day. For the BNA colonies, this meant an end to preferred access to markets in the British Isles. Reciproc-
ity with the United States was a step designed to offset market losses across the Atlantic. The end of Reciprocity
raised serious questions about whether the British North American economy could survive. Confederation, in this
context, was represented as a commercial as well as a political union. Clearly, the colonies could have achieved
commercial union without putting political union on the table as well; the former did not necessitate the latter.
After all, the point of reciprocity with the United States was to prevent political annexation, not pave its way.
Nevertheless, federal union held out the prospect of improved inter-colonial trade.

There are problems with the inter-colonial trade scenario, the foremost of which is the absence of complementary
products. All of the BNA colonies from Canada West (Ontario) to the Atlantic Coast produced lumber, shipping,
mostly the same cereal crops, and fish. What was left to trade? Increasingly coal and iron ore were considerations,
but these would benefit few Canadians directly. For Canada East (Quebec) and Canada West (Ontario) in partic-
ular, the two Maritime provinces were hardly a substitute for the millions of customers south of the border. Nev-
ertheless, the prospect of new infrastructure connecting the colonies, access to ice-free ports in Halifax and Saint
John, and accelerated trade was yet another reason presented for pulling the colonies together into some kind of
union.

The Railway
Commercial success was predicated on the idea of a railway. The Intercolonial Railway had been touted for years
before Confederation, and it was so central to the whole project that it is enshrined in Section 145 of the BNA
Act (1867). It took another decade to complete, and its round-about route far from the American border via
Chaleur Bay and the Miramichi Valley reflected the contemporary fears of an attack from the United States,
but this was meant nevertheless to be a key element in the economic union. Obviously the colonies might have
built a railway regardless of Confederation. Less obviously, the railway itself was an engine for economic growth:
Railways require miles of steel rails, thousands upon thousands of wooden ties, and significant rolling stock as
well. The Intercolonial and the railways that followed its construction were thus meant to do more than connect
economies: they were meant to generate industrial activity.
 1.4 CONTRIBUTORY FACTORS OF CONFEDERATION 19

Key Points

British North Americans saw in Confederation a solution to several pressing issues.

The American Civil War and the Fenian Invasions compelled border colonies to consider unification
as a step toward improved defence.
The loss of Reciprocity and the introduction of Free Trade encouraged colonial elites to find ways to
increase intercolonial commerce.
Railway technology held out the promise of greater security, increased intercolonial trade, and an
industrialized economy.

Attributions
Figure 1.4
The Pigeon Hill (Eccles Hill) camp of the 60th Battalion which played a major part in the Fenian Raid of 25
May 1870 (Online MIKAN no.3192302) by William Sawyer / Library and Archives Canada / C-033036 is in
the public domain.
1.5 Constitutional Crisis

While it is true that the British North America Act, 1867 marks a point of departure, it is also just another step
along a treacherous path of constitutional crises. This was especially true for the two largest parties in the new
federation.

On 1 July 1867 it became possible, for the first time, to describe Nova Scotians and New Brunswickers as Cana-
dians. The coolness with which this change was received in the Maritimes is discussed below. Names changed,
as well, in the old Province of Canada. The changing nomenclature and identities might appear to be cosmetic,
but they were much more than that.

The End of Canada

While it is true that delegations from Canada West and Canada East were present at the constitutional discussions
in Charlottetown and Quebec City in 1864 and in London in 1866, the fact is they represented one colony, not
two. The Province of Canada created by the Act of Union in 1840-41 was a single entity hinged at the
middle, along the Ottawa River. The BNA Act thus simultaneously divided Canada into two provinces and united
what was Ontario and Quebec into a federal system. Unification, that is, was predicated on division.

Why was this the case? The Act of Union was the fourth Canadian constitution since the Conquest in 1763. Like
its predecessors (the Royal Proclamation of 1763, the Quebec Act of 1774, and the Constitutional Act of 1793),
the Act of Union contained measures for the management of the French Canadians. The Act of Union was less
concerned than the earlier efforts with the Catholic Church in Canada, but it was built on the premise outlined
by Lord Durhams 1839 Report on the Affairs of British North America that assimilation of the French Canadi-
ans was essential to the future of the larger colony. Giving an equal number of seats to predominantly French-
Catholic Canada East and almost wholly English-Protestant Canada West advantaged the anglophones because
Montreal (in Canada East) was an important and politically powerful node of anglophone parliamentary seats. The
Act of Union effectively reunited anglophone Canada West with anglophone Montreal (and outlying anglophone
constituencies as well), creating what Durham imagined would become a majority Anglo-Protestant government.
That is not, however, how things turned out.

Ideology stepped in to complicate linguistic and sectarian differences. Reformers and Tories, Rouges and Bleus,
along with an assortment of smaller parties, turned Durhams famous phrase inside out. Instead of two nations
warring within the bosom of a single state, Canadas political culture quickly evolved into factions of two nations
who occasionally cooperated within the bosom of a united colony. There were, of course, issues that kept potential

20
 1.5 CONSTITUTIONAL CRISIS 21

allies apart, and by the late 1850s it was virtually impossible to forge a coalition in the Legislative Assembly that
could muster enough votes to build a government. Non-confidence motions spelled the end of one administration
after the next. Some politicians and commentators felt that Canada was effectively ungovernable under these cir-
cumstances.

Two critics of the status quo were also two of the most effective participants when it came to exploiting its weak-
nesses. George-tienne Cartier and John A. Macdonald dominated the colonys administration from 1857-1862.
Out of power for the next two years, they were nevertheless able to hobble the Clear Grit administration of John
Sandfield Macdonald (unrelated to John A.) and wrestle his chief ally, George Brown, into a new Great Coali-
tion in 1864. The Cartier-Macdonald-Brown alliance had two primary goals: resolving the impasse that the Act
of Union created and acquiring new territory for agricultural settlement. Brown, the Grits, and much of south-
ern Canada West (Ontario) were increasingly concerned about the shrinking amount of available farmland in the
colony. The Americans were extending their reach deep into the New Northwest of Illinois, Wisconsin, and
Minnesota. Ruperts Land, just to the north, was vulnerable to the expansionist Americans and desirable to the
Ontarians. A commitment on the part of Cartier and Macdonald to acquire Ruperts Land secured the Grits agree-
ment to explore the prospect of dividing the Province of Canada once again and forging a federal relationship
between the two partners. Happenstance and a bit of vision allowed the Canadians to expand this prospective
union to include other British North American colonies.

Responsible Government and Constitution Building

There are distinctive features to this process. For all intents and purposes, colonial politicians were writing their
own constitution for the first time. All previous constitutions had been imposed by the British regime. Some, if
not all, of those earlier efforts reflected the British experience with the Thirteen Colonies that became the United
States. Too much legislative autonomy might create forums for unrest and revolutionary talk. Better to have a
handpicked local and loyal Executive, at least that was the view until the 1840s. At that time, British enthusiasm
for Free Trade in the age of laissez-faire capitalism was taking off. It raised the question of whether old-style,
mercantilist colonies like the Province of Canada or Nova Scotia were consistent with new economic and market
philosophies. On the whole, the British realized there was a contradiction and began cautiously allowing for colo-
nial responsible government (that is, making the Executive responsible to the majority of votes in the Assembly).
Responsible government came first in Nova Scotia, then in Canada (both in 1848). It was allowed subsequently in
Prince Edward Island (1851), New Brunswick (1854), and Newfoundland (1855). By the time of the September
1864 Charlottetown Conference of colonial leaders, each of the colonies had experienced nine to sixteen years of
trying to make their constitutions work (as opposed to decades of criticizing their failings).

It is also important to note that no one in the Great Coalition could say for certain how this would turn out. Sepa-
rating Canada West from Canada East might create competitive units incapable of cooperating on economic goals.
Macdonald believed in the ability of the federal level to moderate those tendencies and to override provincial
autonomy when it came to the cross-boundary movement of goods. But that had to be tested to destruction in the
laboratory of constitutional practice. In short, there were risks.

No colony more desired a federal system than Canada West (Ontario): Its economy was rapidly expanding; its
towns were growing into cities; production was industrializing; and the population was increasing at a prodigious
rate. The political stalemates of the 1850s and 1860s were holding it back, and the Anglo-Protestants of the inland
 22 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

colony inevitably regarded French Canada as a drag on their progress. Did the soon-to-be-Ontarians seek the elim-
ination of the French language and the Catholic religion? Certainly some regarded the Church as a secondary and
competing centre of authority whose influence was governed from Rome. But most folks in Canada West saw
far more Irish Catholics than French Catholics in the course of a lifetime. Cartier and Macdonald, not to men-
tion Baldwin and LaFontaine before them, demonstrated that collaboration was possible, but autonomy would be
better. And at the federal level, the Anglo-Protestant interest would be inflated by members from Nova Scotia
and New Brunswick. Best of all, the influence of Montreal would be reduced and Toronto could really spread its
wings as the centre of influence west of the Ottawa River.

Canada East approached the question with more equanimity. A French-Catholic dominated provincial Assembly
was appealing. No less than Canada West, Canada East had suffered from sluggish administration during the
years of political quagmire, and no one among the Franco-Catholic political community could forget that the Act
of Union had, at its heart, the goal of assimilation into an Anglo-Protestant mould. George tienne Cartier had
worked non-stop since 1840 to manage the constitution that bound the two Canadas together; he achieved much
by asserting Canada Easts power to control the Assembly and thus the Executive. His pre-eminence in political
circles for more than two decades created the very logjam that Brown wanted to dislodge. Cartiers strategy in the
1860s was to forego complete independence as unachievable, and pursue a federal union instead. Cartiers Fran-
cophone opponents in Canada East wanted more and less at the same time: If they were going to enter a new era
free of Canada West then independence and, possibly, annexation to the United States was preferable to a federal
union with the Ontarians; conversely, the status quo was working out rather well for Canada Easts interests
there were good reasons to object to change of any kind. Cartiers enemies, moreover, complained that he gave
away too much at the Charlottetown and Quebec conferences. Francophones would be outnumbered by anglo-
phones in the federal Assembly, which was a little like handing the English-speakers the rep-by-pop theyd been
clamouring for since 1851. Cartiers pro-Confederation side won the day, albeit narrowly. This victory was the
sine qua non of Confederation: If Cartier had failed, then the whole project would have crumbled. Pragmatic Que-
bec politicians thereafter looked for ways to make the new system work to continue preserving French culture and
values, while promoting their economic advantage and while retaining a historically-rooted fear that things might
1
turn out badly in this sea of anglophones.

The Conflicted Atlantic Colonies

First and foremost, the federal solution was the answer to a Canadian question. The Atlantic colonies werent
constitutionally disputatious: They had no Constitutional Act to throw off; there was no Act of Union that forced
them to work together; and no colonial culture was regarded as inferior when compared to any other. Assimilation
was simply not an issue for anyone in mainstream society in the four colonies (although Aboriginal and Acadian
peoples were constantly confronted by assimilationist attitudes). The principal question before the three Maritime
colonies, in 1864, was whether it made sense to reunify the region, to restore the shape of 18th century Nova
Scotia so that it once again included PEI and New Brunswick. It was over this issue Maritime Union that
they assembled at Charlottetown when the Canadians came calling.

A union of the three colonies PEI, New Brunswick, and Nova Scotia was endorsed by Britain, and the local
economic elites for the most part agreed. The Reciprocity Agreement with the United States was still in effect (the

1. Claude Blanger, "Quebec and the Confederation project (1864-1867)," Quebec History (Marianopolis College, 2004), accessed 27 August
2015, [Link]
 1.5 CONSTITUTIONAL CRISIS 23

Americans would cancel it in 1866) and trade around the whole of the Atlantic Rim was generally thriving. But
these were three small colonies small in area and small in population that had to adjust to Britains retreat
from direct colonial involvement and support.

Each of the four Atlantic colonies had three possible options. First, unite with one or two or three other regional
colonies. Second, pursue the Canadians suggestion of a larger British North American union. Third, carry on with
the status quo. Half of the Atlantic colonies chose the Canadian path, and the other half chose the status quo.

Figure 1.5 An 1864 map of the Atlantic colonies (less Labrador).

Geography and sealanes pulled them in many directions,
including into the Gulf of the St. Lawrence. (Alvin Jewett
Johnson, 1827-1884)

New Brunswick the keystone colony had a role to play in bridging the geography and economy between
the St. Lawrence colony and Nova Scotia. There was resistance to the idea of union with the other colonies, and in
1865 it took the form of an Anti-Confederation Party. Led by Albert Smith (1822-1883), a Conservative politician,
the Party pulled into its ranks a small but vocal cross-section of New Brunswick figures. The resultant alliance of
2
Tories and Reformers won the general election in 1865 but were defeated by the Confederation Party in 1866.
With a fresh and massive majority, the Confederationists pursued what they viewed as a comprehensively good
package: defense against the United States and its Fenian armies, a completed railway, Canadian goods pouring
through the ice-free port of Saint John, and a protected Dominion market for New Brunswick products.

The Nova Scotians were also prepared to come on board with Confederation. Like the merchants of Saint John,
the Haligonians saw themselves as probable beneficiaries of Canadian plans for an ice-free port. A railway across
New Brunswick and the Chignecto Isthmus would connect the industrial heartland of Canada East to the largest
Nova Scotian port. Halifax, Sydney, and Yarmouth were already leaders in shipping production; handling more
Canadian exports and more foreign imports would be a further boon. By the same token, the Nova Scotian econ-
omy was resilient and far reaching. Opposition existed and was narrowly contained in the lead up to 1 July 1867.
There existed in the province fear that the Canadian giant would overwhelm the smaller Maritime economies and
that the federal government (sure to be located in Ottawa rather than a Maritime centre) would be heavily domi-
nated by Ontarians and Quebeckers. These fears continued after the BNA Act was proclaimed, and are considered
further in Section 2.2.

Both Newfoundland and Prince Edward Island demurred when the offer arrived to join Confederation. Newfound-
land traded little with the other British North American colonies, its cultural and economic orientation was toward
Europe (with some West Indian trade as well), and its economic circumstances were on the rise (see Section
2.13). While the Canadians and New Brunswickers might have been motivated to bond together in mutual defense
against American or Fenian attacks, those threats did not resonate in St. Johns, Newfoundland. Whats more, if
Newfoundland had to defend itself against an assault on its territory, such an attack would come from the sea

2. This did not, however, spell the end of New Bruinswick's concerns: In the first federal election in 1867, five of the provinces 15 seats were
won by Anti-Confederates.
24 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

precisely the same place from which the colony would be defended. The Canadians and the Maritimers had no
navy, nor were they likely to get one soon. Britains Royal Navy, on the other hand, dominated the Atlantic. Jeop-
ardizing that protection in the hope that some benefits might be forthcoming in the future simply did not appeal to
the leaders of Newfoundland.

Key Points

Creating Confederation meant dissolving the union of Lower and Upper Canada.
Each colony had its own particular reasons for entertaining or rejecting Confederation.
The attractions of Confederation were not evenly felt.

Attributions
Figure 1.5
Johnsons New Brunswick by BotMultichill is in the public domain.
 1.6 Summary

Figure 1.6 What an ice-free port does not look like. Montreal
harbour, ca.1880.

Lets consider one decade: 1863-1873. At the start, there were seven colonies in British North America (one of
them a combination of two very large colonies), and a massive commercial district in the West and North. At the
end, there were two colonies: Canada and Newfoundland. This represented a very significant administrative reor-
ganization. In roughly the same period, the population of the colonies rose from about 3.17 million to just short of
1
3.7 million.

The fur trade across BNA was shrinking by the 1860s, but it was in crisis in the 1870s. Aboriginal peoples on the
Prairies were at war with one another and with the American cavalry in the 1860s, trying to decide who had con-
trol over the remnants of the bison herds; by the 1870s they were facing famine. There were false starts in other
resource-extraction sectors, such as the gold rush in British Columbias Cariboo district, which peaked around
1863, and then slipped into an irrevocable decline. The beginnings of a continent-wide environmental transforma-
tion were also visible: pristine landscapes and watersheds in Cape Breton, on Vancouver Island, on the Cariboo
Plateau, around Lake Superior, and throughout northeastern New Brunswick were being denuded of trees and
subjected to the leeching of soils and heavy metals.

In the 1870s the Industrial Revolution in British North America got underway in earnest. The people of BNA,
for whom Confederation was meant to create a particular kind of polity, were themselves being changed by new
economic and social relations. Confederation came along at a time when so many other elements of life in the
colonies were quickly changing. While it is tempting to think of 1 July 1867 as a turning point, the constitutional
changes that took place in the Victorian years (1837-1901) were less consequential than the social and economic
changes that began earlier, and were to continue into the post-Confederation years.

1. Statistics Canada, "Estimated population of Canada, 1605 to present," accessed 22 April 2015, [Link]
[Link]#table1.

25
26 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Key Terms

Act of Union: The third Canadian constitution since the Conquest in 1763. The Act of Union contained
measures for the management of French-Canadians, built on the premise (from Lord Durhams 1839
Report on the Affairs of British North America) that assimilation of French-Canadians was essential to
the future of the larger colony.
Clear Grits: Reformers in Canada West (Ontario) before Confederation. Anti-Catholic and largely anti-
French, the Grits opposed John A. Macdonalds Tories and advocated the annexation of Ruperts Land.
In the post-Confederation period they became one section of the Liberal Party.
Executive: Also called the Cabinet. The highest offices either elected or appointed in Canadian
politics: before the 1840s, a mostly appointed Executive Council led by the Governor General; after
1867, an elected body comprised of members of the current House of Commons and supported by a
majority of votes in the House of Commons.
family reconstitution: In demographic studies, the consolidation of population information from cen-
suses, church records, and civic documents to enable a complete history of a family, street, or commu-
nity in terms of births, marriages, deaths, divorces, movement, and other demographic behaviours.
Father of Confederation: Term used to describe anyone involved in the Charlottetown or Quebec Con-
ferences leading to Confederation; sometimes extended to the first premiers of the new Dominion as
well; term sometimes used to describe Newfoundland Premier Joey Smallwood from 1949.
federation: An assemblage of states or provinces with roughly comparable rights in which all the con-
stituent parts relinquish some of their authority to a separate, central government.
Fenian: Irish-Americans, bound together as an anti-British army; mounted and/or threatened invasions
of British North America in the 1860s and 70s.
founder population: A population deriving from a small initial influx of immigrants.
Great Coalition: In 1864, an alliance between the Bleu-Conservatives and the Clear Grits in the
Province of Canada. The Great Coalition launched a renewed effort to revise the Canadian constitution,
a campaign that culminated in Confederation.
Legislative Assembly: Until 1968 all Canadian provinces had a Legislative Assembly, either as their
only house of elected representatives or as a lower house in either instance equating to the federal
and British House of Commons. In 1968 the Quebec Assembly was renamed the National Assembly
of Quebec. Sitting members are described in most provinces as Members of the Legislative Assembly
(MLAs) and in Ontario as Members of the Provincial Parliament (MPPs). In Quebec they are Members
of the National Assembly (MNAs).
manifest destiny: American notion that it could control, and was destined to control, the whole of North
America; literally, it was the will of God (destined) and it was apparent (manifest) in the incremental
territorial expansions of the United States.
Maritime Union: A proposal to create one colony out of New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, and Prince
Edward Island; the original impetus for the Charlottetown Conference; abandoned in favour of Confed-
eration.
Mason-Dixon Line: Boundary between the American colonies, then states, of Maryland and Pennsyl-
vania; also used to define the American South from the American North, and slave and non-slave states.
 1.6 SUMMARY 27

natural increase: The growth of population from more births than deaths; that is, not by immigration
and not factoring in emigration.
Reciprocity Treaty (ch 1): 1854 agreement between the British North American colonies and the
United States; enabled freer trade; was cancelled by the Americans at the end of the Civil War.
responsible government: Government in which the Executive level (or Cabinet) is responsible to
and can be dismissed from office by the majority of votes in the Assembly. In contrast to pre-Con-
federation systems in which the Executive was appointed by and was responsible to the Crown or its
representative.
rep-by-pop: Representation by population; the higher the population of a province, the higher the num-
ber of seats allocated for that province in the House of Commons.
sex ratio: The ratio of men to women. A sex ratio of 2:1 indicates that there are two men for every one
woman.
Thirteen Colonies of Britain: The Atlantic Coast colonies established in the 17th and 18th centuries;
rebelled against British rule in 1775-83 and became the core elements of the United States.
Westminster: Refers to the seat of British parliamentary government in Westminster, London.

Short Answer Exercises

1. What were the main engines of population growth in the 19th century?
2. How had the population of Canada (or British North America and Newfoundland) changed
between the pre-Confederation period and the early 20th century?
3. What was the context of Canadian nation-building and federation?
4. What external and economic factors catalyzed the conversation about a union of British North
American colonies?
5. Why federalism? What questions did such a structure answer?

Suggested Readings
Ajzenstat, Janet. Human Rights in 1867. In Canadian Founding: John Locke and Parliament, 49-66. Montreal
& Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 2007.

Dunae, Patrick A. Sex, Charades, and Census Records: Locating Female Sex Trade Workers in a Victorian City,
Histoire Sociale/Social History, 42, no. 84 (Novembre-November 2009): 267-297.

Macdonald, Heidi. Who Counts?: Nuns, Work, and the Census of Canada, Histoire Sociale/Social History, 43,
no. 86, (Novembre-November 2010): 369-391.

Smith, Andrew. Toryism, Classical Liberalism, and Capitalism: The Politics of Taxation and the Struggle for
Canadian Confederation. Canadian Historical Review 89, no. 1 (March 2008): 1-25.
28 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Attributions
Figure 1.6
Ice shove, Montreal harbour, QC, about 1880 by William Notman / McCord Museum / Notman photographic
Archives McCord Museum has no known copyright restrictions.
 PART 3

Chapter 2. Confederation in Conflict

29
2.1 Introduction

There are, today, approximately 35 million Canadians. Coincidentally, that is almost exactly the number of people
who were living in the United States in 1867. At the time of Confederation, there were 3.4 million people in all
of Canada (that is, Ontario, Quebec, New Brunswick, and Nova Scotia), and today there are more people than
that in metro Montreal. In other words, in 1867, Canada contained fewer people than exist today in the countrys
second largest city and yet the Dominions original government had the temerity to think they could capture the
whole northern half of a continent and thus foil the expansionist interests of an incredibly well-armed country to
the south, whose population outnumbered the Canadians 10-to-1. It seems improbable.

It is perhaps even more improbable that the original 1867 version of Canada would eventually claim enough ter-
ritory to become the second largest country in terms of area on Earth. At the time of Confederation, Canada
was hardly more than the core elements of New France. Its boundaries did not include much beyond Acadia and
the St. Lawrence Valley, along with what had once been Wendake (or Huronia), and the lands of a clutch of other
Iroquoian confederacies, most of which were allied to New France in the 17th century.

Exponential Expansion
In 1869-70, Canadas tumultuous annexation of Ruperts Land and the North-Western Territory gave the new
Dominion access to the whole of the West and the North. What lay beyond the Rockies joined the federation in
1871. Two years later, Prince Edward Island assented as well. In 1880, the British Arctic Territories were trans-
ferred to Canada. New administrative territories were carved out of the North: Keewatin in 1876; Assiniboia,
Saskatchewan, Athabasca, and Alberta in 1882; Franklin, Mackenzie, and Ungava in 1895; and the Yukon Terri-
tory in 1898.

Although Manitoba negotiated its way into the Dominion, both Alberta and Saskatchewan were created (in 1905)
by bureaucrats in Ottawa wielding straight-edged rulers with willful disregard for historic and topographic bound-
aries. In 1912, Manitoba would benefit from this exercise as well, when Ottawa transferred much of the District
of Keewatin to the original western province. At the same time, Ontario and Quebec would each engorge enough
of the lands of the Lowland/Swampy Cree and Innu as to double in size. The Sverdrup Islands in the Arctic were
ceded to Canada by Norway in 1930. In 1949, 82 years after the Charlottetown Conference that first introduced
the idea of a colonial union, the Dominion of Newfoundland (with Labrador, the mainland annex assigned to it by
Britain in 1927) joined the federation. Since then, the only significant additional adjustment of the map has been
to establish the District of Nunavut in 1999 out of portions of the Districts of Franklin, Mackenzie, and all of what
remained of Keewatin.

30
 2.1 INTRODUCTION 31

What this litany of administrative and boundary changes indicates is that the question of how to govern lands and
peoples that are remote from one another has been at the forefront of the Canadian project from the outset.

Confederation and Cultures

Culture has also played a critical and central role in the history of Canada over the last 150 years. This is a country
that began with a duality at centre stage. In 1867, there was rough parity between the anglophone population of
Ontario and the francophone peoples of Quebec. That model of dichotomy the idea that the two provinces are
culturally the yin to the others yang has never been true. There were always francophones in what emerged as
Ontario. Likewise, an anglophone and Protestant elite, centred in Montreal, dominated Quebec society and econ-
omy while the majority descended from the colonists of New France inevitably took on many British values
and habits.

Indeed, no province then or since has been without cultural complexities. Provinces and colonies that pre-
sent as mainstream anglophone contain many different tributaries. The former Acadian lands in the Maritimes
have always contained strong Franco-Catholic communities; likewise, Manitoba was erected on a (quickly chal-
lenged) principle of duality, one that was led by the Mtis. Francophones comprised a considerable portion of the
population across the Prairies in the early 20th century. A little over a century ago, the Port au Port Shore (or
French Shore) on the west coast of Newfoundland was a slice of French commercial and settlement activity
that survived from the 18th century and was populated by Breton and Norman fishing households. Francophone
nodes could be found, as well, in pre-1914 British Columbia, although what stood out more were the resilient set-
tlements of Chinese, Japanese, and Indians. Anglophone-Protestant dominance was often challenged by Anglo-
and Irish-Catholicism too not to mention by Canadian Protestantism, which splintered into Baptist, Methodist,
Congregationalist, and other sects.

The strength of a Canadians national identity was thus counterbalanced by their identification with language,
creed, and increasingly ethnicity. Regional identity was another obstacle to erecting a national sensibility in
the years immediately after Confederation. Maritimers may have had common interests but they also had a cen-
tury of intercolonial competition and rivalry under their belts. British Columbians referred to Canadians con-
temptuously and regarded the BNA colonies on the other side of the continent as at least as foreign as Americans.
Regional and provincial accents were strong, even among the English-speaking populations.

This chapter examines the new federal unions growth in the years from 1867 to about 1900. During these years, it
became clear that there was no singular vision of Canada to which everyone could subscribe. The conflicts that
arose between several of these competing views were very often vocal and sometimes lethal. Keeping in mind
that the previous Canadian constitution the Act of Union of 1841 lasted a mere 26 years before being tossed
out, one can understand how the three decades after Confederation were understood to be pivotal.

Learning Objectives

Describe the territorial growth of Canada from 1867 to circa 1914.

Account for Canadas struggle to attract certain colonies into the fold.
32 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Explain the rise of secessionist movements in the 19th century.

Outline the relationship between Canada and First Nations during this period.
Detail the institutions that were created and utilized for the purpose of expanding the Dominion of
Canada.
 2.2 Nova Scotia's Second Thoughts

Nova Scotia was, of course, one of the original parties to the federal union. From the outset, however, there were
political and economic leaders in the colony who had qualms. Nova Scotia would have been the leading third in
the proposed Maritime Union with New Brunswick and Prince Edward Island. Halifax was easily the largest city
and one of the most industrially advanced. Even if it didnt become the political capital of the United Maritimes,
it would emerge almost certainly as the economic capital of this new configuration. The 1864 Maritime Union
plan was put aside to make way for Confederation, and many Nova Scotians continued to think that was a mis-
take.

Buyers Remorse
The most prominent and highly appealing opponent of Confederation was Joseph Howe. A journalist and writer,
his political speeches and editorials were of an exceptional calibre. His initial opposition to Confederation
stemmed from a belief in a broader British imperial federation that might include the West Indian islands with
which Nova Scotia had deep and vital links. Unable to stop the union between Nova Scotia and the other British
North Americans, he sought to reverse it as early as the autumn of 1867.

In elections that season, Nova Scotias pro-confederate candidates were routed provincially and federally. The
anti-confederates (led by Howe) won 36 of 38 seats in Nova Scotia and 18 of 19 seats in Ottawa. Their winning
rhetoric underscored the colonys orientation toward the Atlantic and not toward the heart of North America.
Repeatedly, the image was invoked of a once-proud colony being reduced to poverty by avaricious Canadi-
ans obsessed with over-ambitious railways and colonization of the West.

Howe led a repeal delegation to London to have the British North America Act overturned; the best he could
obtain, however, was a commitment to have Ottawa re-examine proposed tariff and fisheries policies. This failure
was compounded in 1868 when the new British government confirmed its commitment to the Dominion model.
Howe, a strident loyalist, was deeply disappointed by Westminster, and his sentiments were probably shared by
many others in the province. Certainly there were elements among the anti-confederates who considered annex-
ation to the United States a preferable option, and still others who preferred outright independence. Howe was
speaking for that last position when he said that, were it not for his continued loyalty to Britain, I would take
1
every son I have and die on the frontier before I would submit to this outrage meaning Confederation.

1. Quoted in J. Murray Beck, HOWE, JOSEPH, in Dictionary of Canadian Biography, vol. 10, (University of Toronto/Universit Laval,
2003), accessed 30 April 2015, [Link]

33
 34 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Be that as it may, Howe and his followers acquiesced. He was able to negotiate better terms for Nova Scotia and
agreed to give the federation his backing by standing for a federal seat. He won, but it cost him his health and
much of his reputation for integrity in Nova Scotia. It is perhaps one of the great ironies of early post-Confedera-
tion history that Howe, in his capacity as Secretary of State for the Provinces, was instrumental in persuading the
Manitobans that federal union was a deal worth pursuing.

Figure 2.1 Many Nova Scotians used to carry a portrait of Joseph

Howe in their wallets it looked like this.

Howes vision of an imperial federation would find an echo in the last decades before the Great War (World War
I). Imperialists in English-Canada would articulate an ambition and a model that was first brought to public
attention by Howe (see Section 4.5). Before then, the Nova Scotian Repeal Movement would take a last stab at
secession.

The Repeal Movement

The Dominion of Canada was not two decades old when Nova Scotians would again reconsider their place in
Canada. The Maritime economy had slowed and a structural decline was underway. Ship construction had plum-
meted from a high point in 1864 of 73,000 tons to 21,000 in 1886, and 14,000 tons in 1887. Population growth
slowed severely to only 2% in the 1880s. Natural increases (more births than deaths) were offset by out-migration
mostly to the western reaches of the new Dominion and to New England. Rural Nova Scotia was changing at
a particularly rapid rate, as the industrializing centres of Cape Bretons collieries (coal mines), Halifax, Lunen-
burg, and a half-dozen other port towns attracted young women and men from the countryside. Lobster exports
from Halifax to American ports fell by 75% in 1885 alone, and other trade with the United States was similarly
affected. In this context, the pre-Confederation era of Reciprocity with the Americans, robust population growth
(of around 15%), powerful shipyard industries in the major ports, and thriving rural communities including
their proud churches, energetic civic organizations, and densely networked families seemed like a golden age
2
in Nova Scotias recent history. What had changed? Confederation.

Party politics in Nova Scotia increasingly coalesced around Conservative and Liberal parties. If the former was in
power federally, the latter stood a better chance of holding power provincially. This was certainly the case in 1886
when William S. Fielding (1848-1929) a self-described anti-confederate led the Liberal Party to victory with
a simultaneous call for secession and better subsidies from Ottawa. The two options reflected divisions between
unionists and secessionists within the Liberal Party. If the subsidies were not forthcoming, Fielding insisted that
Nova Scotias legislature would vote for a repeal of the BNA Act. He was also inclined to take Nova Scotia, with
New Brunswick and PEI, out of Confederation and into a revived version of Maritime Union. This was a project
in which neither of the other two colonies showed much interest.

In the end it was a combination of internal disagreement within the provincial Liberal Party and the federal elec-
tion of 1887 that defeated the movement. Insofar as the campaign against Canada could be personalized, it was an

2. Colin D. Howell, W.S. Fielding and the Repeal Elections of 1886 and 1887 in Nova Scotia, Acadiensis [online], VIII, No.2 (Spring 1979),
28-30, accessed 24 August 2015, [Link]
 2.2 NOVA SCOTIA'S SECOND THOUGHTS 35

attack on the policies and practices of the Conservative Partys John A. Macdonald, effectively the face of federal
rule. When Fieldings Liberals took to the polls in 1887s federal election, they found it difficult-to-impossible
to campaign for the federal Liberal Party and against remaining in Confederation. Conservative candidates held
14 of the 21 federal seats and showed special strength in areas where industrialization was speeding ahead. In
3
those areas, the National Policy (see Section 3.3) appeared to be working. As a measure of popular support for
secession, the federal election results were the exact opposite of what was suggested in the provincial elections a
year earlier. This would not be the last election in which specific issues (like separation) would become confused
with voter decisions about who might constitute the better government. Nor would it prove to be the last time the
country looked likely to come undone.

Key Points

The anti-Confederation movement in Nova Scotia was a significant political force from the
1860s-1880s.
Britains support for Confederation was critical in undermining the anti-Confederation movement
under Joseph Howe.
Support for repeal and secession reflected substantial and rapid social and economic change in Nova
Scotia.

Attributions
Figure 2.1
881 $5 Bill Bank of Nova Scotia by Hantsheroes is in the public domain.

3. Ibid., 43-4.
2.3 British Columbia and the Terms of Union

Figure 2.2 The HBC bastion overlooking the busy Coal Harbour
at Nanaimo, 1906.

Nowhere was the ambition of the new Dominion more evident than in the recruitment and securing of British
Columbia as the sixth province in 1871. Canada had not yet subdued and annexed Manitoba when it turned its
attention to the Pacific Slope. As the crow flies, the nearest settlement of any size would have been Kamloops
2,000 km west of Winnipeg with no road in place. By sea, in the days before the Panama Canal, it would involve a
voyage of more than 13,000 nautical miles from Halifax to Victoria via Cape Horn. Annexing islands in the West
Indies would make more sense logistically, as would making British Honduras (now called Belize) a province (an
idea that was touted from time to time). Canadian interest in the farthest west carried forward themes that can be
found in all the other annexations, but it reflects unique interests as well. Why British Columbians decided to join
a remote and essentially alien federal state is perhaps less obvious.

A Big Country
British Columbias boundaries in 1867 were a little uncertain, especially concerning Alaska and the Peace River
valley. Nevertheless, even the most constricted view of its geography at the time would make it the largest of the
British North American colonies and also the most sparsely populated. This points to one of the paradoxes of BC:
It is a big area with few people, but the population is more tightly concentrated than is the case elsewhere in North
America.

Topography and resources tell the tale. Narrow mountain valleys, canyons, deep coastal fjords, and one range of
towering peaks after the next meant that options for settlement sites (before and after contact) were limited, and
the colonys geology was exposed and invited exploitation. It created conflicts as well, given that the Aboriginal
population was large in the 1860s (especially before the smallpox epidemic of 1862-1863) and the European tide
demanded access to cleared and arable land.

There was a long list of gold rushes in the 1850s-1860s in the mainland colony, and these did much to shape
the character of the colonial administration. Gold found in the Queen Charlotte Islands (aka: Haida Gwaii) led

36
 2.3 BRITISH COLUMBIA AND THE TERMS OF UNION 37

to very limited intrusion, but the mainland was far more penetrable. The first discoveries near Kamloops were
followed up by the more famous and lucrative placer opportunities along the Fraser and the Thompson rivers in
1858. At around the same time, smaller pockets of activity appeared along the Similkameen River, near what is
now Allenby (near Princeton), at Rock Creek (east of Osoyoos), and in the Peace River district. The largest strike
was made in the heart of the Cariboo in 1861, centred on Barkerville. There were other, less noteworthy gold
rushes along the Stikine River in the same year and in the Shuswap district shortly thereafter. In 1864-1865, min-
ing operations appeared at Leechtown (west of Victoria), Cherryville (east of Vernon), at Fisherville (near Fort
Steele), and on the Big Bend of the Columbia River. The Omineca Gold Rush launched in 1869, and there was a
small rush into the Burnt Basin near the Kettle Valley. In short, the colonial map was dotted with gold finds and
compact and energetic mining centres. In addition, service communities sprang up to feed and fleece the miners,
including everything from cattle ranches to dance halls.

The distribution of these new towns presented administrative challenges for the colonial regimes. Civil suits at
the local level constituted an important part of a decentralized system of government. Itinerant jurists and local
county courts were important features of life in a colony with a very high homicide rate, a sobering track record of
1
public hangings, and predictable conflict over competing claims to mining leases and other property. Until 1866,
the mainland was governed from New Westminster; thereafter, the colonies of British Columbia (the mainland)
and Vancouver Island were united and governed from Victoria. The distance between the capital and Barkerville
is 900 km a longer and rougher road than that between Fredericton and Montreal. The Big Bend, Cherryville,
Fisherville, and the Similkameen were all more easily accessed from the Washington Territory (later Washington
State). Indeed, Ruperts Land was easier to reach from the Kootenays than the Kootenays were from the coast.
The existing transportation infrastructure was limited. There was a wagon road system between the Fraser Canyon
and the Cariboo; paddlewheelers worked the Shuswap and the coastline, but the inland systems were susceptible
to freeze-up and to violent seasonal fluctuations in water levels, and the coastal network was exposed to storms.
The ability to assert colonial authority under these circumstances was limited, although symbolic efforts were
repeatedly made.

A Vulnerable Colony
Building the Cariboo Wagon Road had effectively bankrupted the united colony of British Columbia. It was the
first of what would be many government subsidies to private enterprise, the hope being that royalties and license
revenues would offset the heavy capital investment in infrastructure. Another was the graving dock at Esquimalt
that made the Vancouver Island port, in the calculations of the Royal Navy, even more critical.

The heavy capital investment at Esquimalt had the added benefit of increasing interest in the coal mines at and
around Nanaimo. Industrial production in the Victoria area was on the increase as demand grew for chains, saw
blades, and nails. Logging was well underway in several locations, including the Burrard Inlet nodes of Port
Moody, Moodyville, and Stamps Mill, that harvested what were reckoned to be some of the largest trees on earth.
This steam-powered economy further stimulated the collieries and reinforced connections with markets in Cal-
ifornia, Hawaii, China, Mexico, and Chile. Virtually nothing, at this time, was exported to Canada. Given the
prevailing winds of the Atlantic, Liverpool was regarded as closer to British Columbia than Quebec City; there-
fore, thats where the sea traffic gravitated.

1. Tina Loo, Making Law, Order and Authority in British Columbia, 1821-1871, (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1994).
 38 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

That is not to say that Canada did not exercise any influence on the colony. It did so in a variety of ways. First,
like the rest of British North America, British Columbia had a fraught relationship with the United States. The
boundary with the American territories to the south was established in 1846, but the fear remained that Ameri-
can gold-seekers were probing for weaknesses and opportunities to see the BC mainland annexed to the Amer-
ican republic. Likewise, the dispute over the San Juan Islands (known colloquially as the Pig War) percolated
along from 1859-1873. The American purchase of Alaska in 1867 was an additional reminder to the local colonial
regime that the United States was not merely talking about a manifest destiny, it was acting on it. In this light,
British Columbians saw the welcoming arms of Canada as a refuge from American imperialism, although they
preferred the idea of continuing with the Royal Navy and British power.

Canadians in British Columbia

The gold rushes brought to the West Coast a complex mix of peoples. The multitude of Aboriginal peoples and
nations were invaded by thousands of Americans (Euro- and Afro-), Chinese, Europeans (including British, of
course), as well as Mexicans, South Americans, Hawaiians (aka: Kanakans), and fortune-hunters from even fur-
ther afield. They also attracted Canadians, Nova Scotians, New Brunswickers, and a few Prince Edward Islanders.
Two of these Amor de Cosmos (a Nova Scotian) and John Robson (a migrant from Canada West) brought
their journalistic careers to the Far West. They also undertook political careers that echoed the language of east-
ern BNA. Together they were founders of the Confederation League in 1868, using their newspapers to promote
the idea of union with Canada while directly lobbying administrations in Victoria, Ottawa, and London. Meet-
ing at the Yale Convention that year, they set out their goals: responsible government in the colony, reciprocity
with the United States, and austerity measures to address colonial debt. The British-appointed Governor, Freder-
ick Seymour (1820-69), was cool to these ideas; his successor, Anthony Musgrave (1828-88), less so. Musgrave
had served as Governor of Newfoundland when its assembly failed to endorse union with the rest of British North
America. He had made mistakes and wasnt about to repeat them on the West Coast.

The Canadians position was further helped by fears that a Fenian invasion was pending. Beginning in 1866, it
was believed that Fenians were mustering in San Francisco with the goal of completing the American coastline
from California to Alaska. Pro-annexationist voices in the colony were muted, however, until an Annexationist
Petition was sent to Washington, DC in 1869 by a group of Victorian merchants. Their audacity in this regard
served to increase support for the Confederation League.

By this time, it was clear to British Columbians that Britain could not be trusted not to abandon the colony. I do
not know why, wrote one British emigration officer in London to his superior,

we should go out of our way to lead settlers to make an erroneous choice. I by no means agree that it is good general
policy to try to swell the English population in B. Columbia [sic]. The fewer Englishmen that are committed to the place,
the better it may prove to be in no distant times. As to hoping that we can by Emigrants round Cape Horn outnumber the
natural flow of Emigrants from California and the United States, one might as well make the old experiment of keeping
2
out the Ocean with a mop.

Britains commitment to the Pacific Coast continued to shrink. Pressure grew to consider the Canadian option.

2. Letter from T.W. Murdoch to F.F. Elliot, 26 April 1867, (marginal notes), Public Records Office, Colonial Office 60 (30), Kew, UK.
 2.3 BRITISH COLUMBIA AND THE TERMS OF UNION 39

Figure 2.3 In 1871 the newcomer population in BC

was still greatly outnumbered by Aboriginal people
who were, nevertheless, being hustled onto
reserves and mostly without treaties. A Sto:lo
woman, weaving baskets, n.d.

The Terms of Union

Governor Musgrave selected a delegation to send to Ottawa, consisting of: Dr. R. W. Carrall, a physician from
Goderich, Ontario, who had practiced in Nanaimo before moving to Barkerville in the late 1860s; Chief Com-
missioner of Lands and Works, Joseph Trutch, an Englishman with a familial connection to Musgrave; and Dr.
John Sebastian Helmcken, a Londoner, another physician, and a holdover from the days of the HBC. The party
had significant interests in the outcome of the talks with the Canadians. Helmcken, for his part, played the role
of delegation skeptic. He said that British Columbia had no love for Canada; the bargain for love could not be,
3
and was more inclined to continuing with the status quo. Carrall was an enthusiastic supporter of Confederation
and the whole concept of the Dominion. As a Cariboo resident, he had a keen sense of the necessity for improved
infrastructure and of its cost. Trutch, for his part, was a career administrator who was concerned that Ottawa
would oblige Victoria to make concessions to the Aboriginal people for whom he had a very low regard, even
by contemporary standards. Unlike the Confederation League, these men were never enthusiastic supporters of
4
responsible government.

The deal they struck with Ottawa included elimination of the colonys debt, funding for the graving dock at
Esquimalt, and the building of a railway from Canada to the West Coast, the construction of which was to be
complete within ten years (see Section 2.9 for more details). The Canadians accepted an inflated population fig-
ure for the colony (on which financial and electoral issues would be based), but not as inflated as the delegation
proposed. Ottawa was careful, as well, not to wade into the murky local debate over responsible government and
colonial handling of Aboriginal affairs, and so left both to the British Columbian administration to resolve in its
own time. On the last point, the language of the British Columbia Terms of Union, 1871 (the Terms) suggests that
Trutch very effectively misrepresented his approach to reserve lands:

[Article] 13. The charge of the Indians, and the trusteeship and management of the lands reserved for their use and benefit,
shall be assumed by the Dominion Government and a policy as liberal as that hitherto pursued by the British Columbia
5
Government shall be continued by the Dominion Government after the Union..

Ottawas hands were now tied; successive administrations in Victoria would monitor Aboriginal policies to ensure
that they were as liberal as Trutchs, but not more so.

3. Quoted in Jean Barman, The West Beyond the West: A History of British Columbia (Toronto:University of Toronto Press), 346.
4. Jack Little, Foundations of Government, The Pacific Province: A History of British Columbia, gen. ed. Hugh J.M. Johnston (Vancouver:
Douglas & McIntyre, 1996), 88-91.
5. Senate of Canada, Article 13 of Schedule: Address of the Senate of Canada to the Queen, in British Columbia Terms of Union (UK: Court at Windsor, 16
May 1871), accessed 13 May 2016, [Link]
 40 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 2.4 John Helmcken at 93 years in 1917. He had little

affection for Canada and his insistence on the Terms helped earn
BC the nickname Spoilt Child of Confederation.

With the Terms in hand, the British Columbians were inclined to watch their Canadian suitors closely. The dele-
gation had hoped for a wagon road; they were promised a railway. The Canadians were clearly motivated by both
their own faith in modern infrastructure and the economic opportunities it presented, on the one hand, and on the
demonstrable advantage a railway to the West Coast would lend them in terms of territorial conquest. No one,
however, had given sufficient thought to the business of crossing the Rockies and reaching the coast. They had
given themselves a decade to get it done and the clock was ticking loudly in British Columbia from the very start.

Nothing but the Terms

Resistance to the whole idea of Confederation was perhaps strongest among the old British elite in Victoria and
New Westminster. These were people with strong HBC ties and few connections to Canada. They were also
staunchly opposed to responsible government. Individuals like the provinces Senators, Clement Cornwall (the
owner of Ashcroft Manor) and W. J. Macdonald, allied with Edgar Dewdney (MP and colonial road-builder) to
warn John A. Macdonald of the problems brewing in BC politics. Even the provinces limited male suffrage drew
their criticisms and accusations that it had produced a populist assembly.

The present Legislative Assembly is perhaps taken together as inferior a body of the sort as could well be imagined; and if
the Province is to be unmistakably [sic] given up to their tender mercies without the interposition of experienced guidance
6
and some extent repression from Ottawa, no thoughtful mind can view the picture without the gravest apprehension.

However appalled the senators and the MP may have been, the Assembly looked far more British than Canadian.
British North America-born politicians remained a minority in the Legislature until the 20th century. According
to mid-20th century historian, Walter Sage, Canadians were regarded contemptuously as tight-fisted spendthrifts
7
who were more likely to send money home to families in the East than leave it in the local stores. Confederation
delegate Dr. Helmcken shared some of this anti-Canadian sentiment. He recognized that British Columbias loy-
alty to Canada would come only with material benefits and, perhaps, with time. Love for Canada, he wrote in
8
1870, has to be acquired by the prosperity of the country, and from our children.

Prosperity and advantage were key to retaining British Columbias involvement in the Canadian project; the stage
was set for wrangling over the progress of the Canadian Pacific Railway.

6. Draft of a Memorandum from Cornwall, Macdonald, and Dewdney to Sir John A. Macdonald, sent 7 May 1879, quoted in Hamar Foster, The Struggle for
the Supreme Court: Law and Politics in British Columbia, 1871-1885, Louis A. Knafla, ed., Law and Justice in a New Land: Essays in Western Canadian
Legal History (Calgary: Carswell Legal Publications, 1986), 168. Emphasis in original.
7. Walter N. Sage, British Columbia becomes Canadian, 1871-1901, Historical Essays on British Columbia, Jean Friesen and Keith Ralston,
eds. (Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1976): 58.
8. Quoted in ibid.: 57.
 2.3 BRITISH COLUMBIA AND THE TERMS OF UNION 41

Key Points

British Columbia was a sparsely populated, geographically huge colony with concentrated settle-
ments that were mostly devoted to mining.
Size and the expense of building roads, as well as fear of American expansionism, turned the colony
toward the Canadians.
British Columbias willingness to join the Dominion depended on the construction of a trans-conti-
nental railway, Ottawas absorption of colonial debt, and funding for a dry dock on Vancouver
Island.

Attributions
Figure 2.2
View of Nanaimo Harbour showing the bastion and shipping (HS85-10-18676) by LibraryBot is in the public
domain.

Figure 2.3
Sto:lo woman with cedar basket (PN996) by Themightyquill is in the public domain.

Figure 2.4
Photograph of Hon John Sebastian Helmcken (HS85-10-33253) by LibraryBot is in the public domain.
2.4 Prince Edward Island

Islander indifference to Confederation had its roots in a thorny land ownership issue that had irritated local affairs
for nearly a century. This question stretched back to the colonys early days under British rule.

Escheat
In 1767, the British government divided up the island into 67 lots of about 20,000 acres apiece and gave title away
in a lottery involving wealthy and well-connected British landlords in London. The owners were expected to send
settlers to the colony; few did so, most failed to maintain their properties or meet their obligations to settlers and
the colonial administration. The Colonial Office consistently backed the absentee proprietors against the colonial
tenants. In the mid-19th century, this was the issue that dominated Island politics; the search for a mechanism for
gaining ownership of the proprietors lands and selling them on to the tenants called escheat was regarded
as an economic issue and also one that would help PEI society grow and thrive. In 1864, there was nothing the
Canadian government could do to help this process along. Islanders believed they were at last making headway
with Westminster and that a resolution was in sight. Staying with Britain at least until absentee landlordism
was addressed was the most prudent path to follow.

PEIs links to the mainland colonies were important and unlikely to change by staying outside of Confederation.
Islanders regularly took seasonal work in the mines and forests of New Brunswick, Cape Breton, and mainland
Nova Scotia. Their labour was welcomed and no treaty or constitutional change was necessary to this relation-
ships continuance. The colony had good trade relations with the United States as well, and produced enough
shipping to be active in the West Indies and cross-Atlantic commerce. There was some talk of exploring annexa-
tion to the United States and about as much interest in becoming a Dominion in its own right, as Newfoundland
would do in 1907. On the whole, the status quo appealed most of all.

This inertia reflected divisions within Island society and the lack of advantages to be gained in joining Confeder-
ation. The PEI Liberals and Conservatives were supported, respectively, by comparable populations of Catholics
and Protestants. The Tenant League advocates for an end to the system of absentee landlordism was more
associated with the Liberals and thus with Catholicism. These were fracture lines that preoccupied the colonys
leaders. Against that, the PEI delegates at the 1864 Charlottetown Conference articulated a reasonable fear that
the colony would be lost within Confederation. Being one-third of a Maritime Union was one thing; being a tiny
sliver of a federated Canada was quite another.

42
 2.4 PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND 43

The Cradle of Confederation

What changed? The Islands government hoped that it could expand economic prospects by negotiating freer trade
with the United States. Without British support this could not happen. Concern for the colonys economy began
to grow which set the stage for a bout of railway fever. A colonial railway that was meant to be the key that
would unlock economic diversification and tourism swallowed up the colonial budget. By 1871, PEI was looking
at a desperate financial situation. Stagnant trade, government deficit, incomplete infrastructure, and the lack of
funds with which to resolve the absentee landlord issue were the pushes that the colonial elite needed to pur-
sue new terms with Canada. Ottawa provided the necessary pulls: it would pay off the railway debt, guarantee
a year-round steamship link to the mainland, and buy out the landlords. The Islands Liberal government, under
R.P. Haythorne (1815-91), had spent the colony into near-bankruptcy and placed the end to tenancy at the top of
PEIs political agenda; the Conservatives, under James Pope in 1873, were able to use their leverage with John
A. Macdonald to win better terms. In this case, both parties were eager to see Confederation succeed, and they
were able to obtain everything the colony required at the time. On 1 July 1873, PEI entered the federal union;
despite having dismissed the idea of Confederation in 1866, the newest and smallest colony began a long tradition
of packaging itself as the Birthplace of Confederation.

Key Points

Land ownership issues dominated in pre-Confederation Prince Edward Island.

The Escheat Movement worked to eliminate leasehold tenures and absentee landlordism.
PEI rejected Confederation in the 1860s, and reconsidered its position in the 1870s mainly due to
colonial debt.
2.5 Canada Captures The West, 1867-70

George Brown entered into a coalition government with John A. Macdonald and George-Etienne Cartier in the
1860s with a grocery-list of conditions. One of the Toronto newspapermans demands was that Canada in what-
ever form it was to take would annex Ruperts Land. There was no talk in 1867 no serious talk at least
about adding British Columbia to the mix. After all, as the crow flies, Victoria was as remote from Toronto as
British Honduras; a sea voyage to New Westminster from Halifax could take months.

The relationship between the West and the core elements of the Dominion of Canada was complex. They had a
history together and it was sometimes invoked to justify the extension of Canadian control into the Northwest.
But that history was not straightforward and the Canadians tended toward the simplest understanding imaginable:
the West had been British and, as of 1870, it simply belonged to the Dominion.

French traders, explorers, and diplomats had ventured into the southern regions beginning in the 1730s. After the
Conquest of New France in 1763, there was a struggle for control of the southern and western fur trade a strug-
gle that was eventually won by the North West Company (NWC). The Montreal-based fur trading consortium
pressed further westward and aggressively extended its commercial reach. By 1812 the NWC had established
posts throughout the Interior of what would become British Columbia, and was operating a network that reached
the Pacific Ocean. Nine years later, however, the Canadian firm was forced into a merger with the larger, older
Hudsons Bay Company (HBC), the commercial monopoly incorporated in London in 1670. The HBC claimed
exclusive right to trade across the northern half of the continent, in all the lands draining into Hudson Bay. This
territory, called Ruperts Land, includes what is now northwestern Quebec, northern Ontario, eastern and northern
Manitoba, the northern two-thirds of Saskatchewan, the northern half of Alberta, and almost all of Nunavut. The
merger gave the British firm effective trading, and nominal administrative control over everything north of the
49th parallel and all the way to the Pacific Ocean.

By the 1860s land in Ontario was becoming scarce, and the same was true in the Dominions three other founding
colonies. Young families were, consequently, migrating out of Canada and into the United States where land was
as yet abundant and effectively free. Grafting the West onto Canada and, in particular, onto Ontario would
mean free land for generations. Obtaining Ruperts Land from the HBC would also reunite this economic hinter-
land with its old commercial metropolis in the St. Lawrence (in effect, reversing the consequences of the 1821
corporate merger).

The diversity of nationalities and syncretic cultures arising from a fur trade society is a feature of the utmost
importance to the history of Western Canada. Most of the people in the Red River Settlement what would

44
 2.5 CANADA CAPTURES THE WEST, 1867-70 45

become the core of the new province of Manitoba were Mtis. They were the genetic heirs of Europeans
(mostly French-Canadians but also, French, Swiss, and Scots) who traded out of Montreal from the 18th century
on. They were, as well, descended from a range of Aboriginal cultures, especially Anishinaabe (aka: Saulteaux),
Cree, and Assiniboine but also Chipewyan and others. Culturally, they were more than the sum of their ances-
tral parts: the Mtis were a new nation with their own dialect, economic practices, organization, and values.
Catholicism was an important part of the mix and many Mtis demonstrated an easy ability to move from the
bison hunting society to the parlours of Montreal and back again. As the 19th century advanced, however, their
awareness of their different-ness (the fact that they were related to, but not identical to, their Aboriginal and Euro-
pean neighbours) grew stronger.

Another group, described by historians as the country born, was also significant in numbers around Red River
and to the north. This community was the product of intermarriage between HBC employees (mostly English and
Scottish men) and Chipewyan, Cree, and Anishinaabe women. Their journey to a truly syncretic culture was dif-
ferent from that of the Mtis. They tended to be Anglican or Presbyterian in their religious beliefs, usually spoke
English, and were not part of the Plains culture of the bison hunt. While some were, for all intents and purposes,
Aboriginal, others were de facto Europeans.

Through the 1860s, Anglo-Canadian expansionist ambitions would inform relations between the West and
Canada. In 1864 at the Charlottetown Conference and again at the Quebec Conference, the prospect of an expan-
sive and clearly imperialist Canada dominating the West was promoted. The desire of Franco-phobes like Brown
to encircle and overwhelm Quebec with Anglo-Protestant populations was no secret. Toronto-based advocates
agitated for annexation of the West, many of them with an outspoken assimilationist agenda. Quebec francopho-
nes, for their part, werent opposed to annexation, but they feared that Anglo-Protestants would interfere in what
should be a reunion between two branches of the Franco-Catholic family.

In 1867, London was getting ready to divest the HBC of its trade monopoly and administrative role in Ruperts
Land. At the same time, the Americans were in an annexing mood. As far as the Canadians were concerned, time
was of the essence; the timeline of Canadian expansion into the West would need to be brought forward. As far as
the Mtis majority at Red River was concerned, they had some important choices to make, and they felt strongly
that these choices were theirs alone.

Historical accounts of relations between the Mtis and the country born are sometimes contradictory, no doubt
because every attempt to draw a composite picture is complicated by the existence of numerous and compelling
exceptions. Sectarian boundaries were probably more critical in the mid-19th century than language, and per-
sistent Scottish-French sympathies complicated things further. Broadly speaking, however, Westerners of Anglo-
Protestant heritage viewed themselves as politically on the ascendant, mainly because of increased Anglo-Cana-
dian interest in the region. This led to significant divisions among the Mtis and Country Born communities of the
Red River. Other historical interpretations have the two communities more fully recognizing their shared interests
as they were increasingly subject to the rising racism boiling out of Canada West. Certainly, this was the dawn
of modern racism: increasingly, what Anglo-Canadians saw when they looked at the country born were inferior
half-breeds rather than co-religionists or champions of Anglo-Celtic culture. As for the the Mtis in these years,
the Anglo-Canadians only had more contempt for them.

The community would, in 1869, resist Canadian annexation and demand provincial status. Red River was daring
in some respects. It had grown dramatically in the 1860s, but only to about 12,000 people (about one-eighth the
46 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

size of Prince Edward Island). The majority was still Mtis, followed by Scots and country born, but many of
their neighbours were Ontarian Anglo-Protestants drawn by the promise of cheap land and the prospect of being
pioneers in the colonization of the West by English Canada.

The West Resists

The relationship between the people of Red River and the HBC was far from straightforward. The company was
an important source of imported goods and a source of revenue. It had acted for years as the local administration.
Many of the local residents were former HBC employees, some of them retired from work much further north. In
some respects the HBC was exploitative and put its own interests first; in others, it was a benevolent and pater-
nalistic firm that had invested nearly 200 years in the region. Suddenly that continuity was broken.

In the 1860s, Canada began a campaign to win Ruperts Land away from Britain. Westminster was happy to
cooperate. The HBCs monopoly (which was, from 1849, more myth than reality) was purchased for 300,000,
and administrative control of the region was passed to the Dominion government. Certain conditions applied.
The Canadians had to negotiate treaties with the Aboriginal populations before the deal would be formalized.
Ottawa proved far too hasty in this respect and others. Lieutenant-Governor William McDougall (1822-1905) was
appointed even while the HBC Governor of Assiniboia, William Mactavish (1815-1870), was still in charge. The
Canadians sent in land survey teams to redraw the map of the Red River settlement using the section and quar-
ter-section block system, which ran lines right across existing colonists farms; all of these older farm lots were
arranged along the riverfront in long narrow strips, as was the case under the seigneurial system of New France.
This upset the Mtis and it alerted the country born and Scots that their rights were not secured. The surveyors
were duly chased out of the colony. No consultations took place between Ottawa and the Red River colony, which
further inflamed local opinion. And, of course, no attempt was made to address the issue of treaty negotiations.

Figure 2.5 The beginning of the Section Land Survey

in the Red River Plain (1869). Canadians were
imposing their system of geography.

Events proceeded quickly. Only a month passed between the Ruperts Land deal and the creation of a Provisional
Government in Red River. Days later, at the end of December 1869, Louis Riel (1844-1885) would become its
president. Riels father (Louis senior) was himself a Mtis lawyer and leader who played a key role in the 1849
Sayer Trial. Julie Laginmonire, Louis juniors mother, was part of the French-Canadian community at Red River.
She provided connections with relations in Montreal to whom Riel would later turn. Young Louis grew up in the
French parish of St. Boniface opposite modern-day Winnipeg, and had an interest in joining the priesthood. He
travelled to Montreal in the 1860s to study, fell in love, became engaged, and then found himself jilted because the
Canadienne womans parents were intolerant of Riels mixed-race ancestry. Depressed and perhaps heart-broken,
he abandoned his studies and returned to Red River when his father died in 1864. Riels familiarity with the Cana-
dians, his ability to conduct himself credibly in English, and his apparent intellectual ability made him a good
 2.5 CANADA CAPTURES THE WEST, 1867-70 47

candidate to lead the Mtis National Committee. Photographs of Riel in 1870 show a man with broad shoulders
and a large head; it is easy to overlook the fact that he was only 25 years old.

Figure 2.6 The Provisional Government with Riel in the centre.

Ottawa regarded the Provisional Government as something akin to treason. The Canadians tactical errors, how-
ever, meant that their takeover of Ruperts Land was to be stalled. In the absence of a legitimate Canadian claim,
the sovereignty of the whole of the Northwest was now a grey area. The possibility that Riels government might
take Red River into the United States stoked Canadian fears. At the same time, the Provisional Governments
proposals for provincehood for the Northwest were unacceptable to Ottawa. Red River was demanding the same
kind of provincial status enjoyed by the four former British colonies that formed the heart of the Dominion. That
included control over natural resource revenues. Ottawas perspective was that Red River had never been a British
colony per se, and that the whole point of annexing the West was to enrich the Canadian project with resources,
not to hand them over to the Mtis in perpetuity.

In Red River, there was an influential and potentially dangerous Canadian faction that plagued the Provisional
Government. Riel and the Mtis addressed the issue of community solidarity by doubling the size of the govern-
ment and adding a number of English/Scottish/Country Born members to balance the Franco-Catholic representa-
tives. The local Canadians, however, were unwilling to be brought to the table. Led by Dr. John Schultz, the Red
River Canadians included recent arrivals from Ontario, and individuals who would benefit directly from Ottawas
surveying contracts in the region. A brief skirmish led to the arrests of several in the Canadian Party, including
a young Orangeman from Northern Ireland, Thomas Scott. By all accounts, Scott was toxic a hateful, violent
man fueled by an anti-Catholic rage. While all of the other Canadian prisoners were released in an effort to culti-
vate goodwill, Scott was executed.

The execution of Scott is seen by most historians as the turning point for Red River and Canada. While negotia-
tions between the two governments became more fruitful, a public campaign calling for revenge for the martyr-
dom of Scott took off in Anglo-Protestant Canada. Clearly this would have ramifications for Red River, but it
would also fracture the delicate relationship between Ontario and Quebec only three years after Confederation.
The Red River delegation was unable to secure resource revenue, but it did get provincial status for Manitoba and
the promise that Mtis and other existing farms in the region would be respected and registered. Amnesty for the
leadership of the Provisional Government was not forthcoming.

Riel fled to the United States. Still a young man, he was restless and as would become clear in later years
deeply disturbed by the events of 1869-70. He was so (rightly) fearful of being captured and murdered by Ontar-
ian Orangemen, that much of his time was spent on the run. The Manitoba Act (1870) offered up the possibility of
a dualist (French/English, Catholic/Protestant) province created by the federal government. For some Canadians
this was a hopeful sign, but that hope would be dashed. The Canadian troops that arrived in Red River, hard on
Riels heels, intimidated and brutalized the Mtis population. Land registrations did not take place, and within a
couple of years the core Mtis population deserted the new province for opportunities further north and west.
48 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 2.7 Canadian troops on the shores of Lake Superior, on

their way to Red River, 1870.

Politics and Personality

Dr. John Christian Schultz (1840-1896) would emerge from all of this as one of historys big winners. The
creation of Manitoba gave him several stages on which to perform as a political leader. He was elected
repeatedly (and always under suspicious circumstances) to Ottawa, was appointed to the Senate by Mac-
donald in 1882, and then became the Lieutenant-Governor of Manitoba in 1888. His motives are likely to
be called into question, but Schultzs record on Aboriginal (especially anglophone Aboriginal) affairs as
an advocate is noteworthy. He even advocated for the Mtis to some extent but remained a vocal oppo-
nent of Riel. Schultzs rising star was entirely due to the displacement of the Mtis from Red River and
Manitobas resettlement by English-Canadians. As an out-rider of colonial power, Schultz demonstrated
unwavering contempt for the First Nations at the outset, and then demonstrated the imperialists urge to act
as their guardian once institutions were in place.

Key Points

One of the objectives of the leaders of the confederation movement was the annexation of Ruperts
Land the West to enable the agricultural expansion of Ontario, Quebec, New Brunswick, and
Nova Scotia.
Annexing Ruperts Land was made urgent by the loss of population to the United States, and Ameri-
can interests in expansion in the region.
The inhabitants of the West included the Mtis, the country born, some Canadian migrants, and First
Nations. Of these, only the Canadians were particularly interested in the prospect of annexation.
The Dominion, in its haste, rushed administrative representatives into place (specifically, land sur-
veyors) and it failed to negotiate treaties with the Aboriginal population. These errors would provoke
reactions from the locals.
Late in 1869 the Mtis-dominated community at Red River established a Provisional Government
and mounted a resistance to annexation. The local Canadian faction responded with attempts to sub-
vert the authority of the government led by Louis Riel.
The execution of Thomas Scott by the Provisional Government divided feeling in Ontario and Que-
bec, hardened Protestant Ontarian resolve to drive out the Catholic Mtis, and sent Riel into exile.
The Provisional Governments negotiations with Ottawa produced the Manitoba Act and the
colonys willing entry into Confederation as a more-or-less equal partner.
 2.5 CANADA CAPTURES THE WEST, 1867-70 49

Attributions
Figure 2.5
The Beginning of the Section Land Survey as Shown on J.S. Dennis Plan for the Survey of the Red River Plain
(1869) by Wyman Laliberte is used under a CC-BY-2.0 license.

Figure 2.6
Councillors of the Provisional Government of the Mtis Nation (Online MIKAN no.3194516) by Library and
Archives Canada / PA-012854 is in the public domain.

Figure 2.7
Red River Expedition, Colonel Wolseleys Camp, Prince Arthur Landing on Lake Superior (Online MIKAN
no.2833387) by Library and Archives Canada / PA-012854 is in the public domain.
 2.6 Canada and the First Nations of the West

Change swept across the Prairies in the 15 years after the Manitoba Act. Commitments made to the Mtis of Red
River in the Confederation negotiations were, in effect, dismissed if not broken. The possibility of cultural dual-
ism was crushed in the Manitoba Schools Act. The numbered treaties were signed and reserves established, but
famine and dislocation could be found everywhere. Aboriginal populations were increasingly concentrated and
managed by newcomers as the bison herds collapsed across the continent. Immigrants were coming swiftly to
the southern plains along the CPR route, and the railway itself was changing the shape of the local economy. In
less than a generation, Winnipeg had emerged as a respectably-sized city of 27,000 while, by 1881, there were
approximately 118,000 people on the Canadian Prairies. This was a comprehensive wave of change that took
place quickly and relentlessly. For many, it was experienced as nothing less than a crisis of the first order.

The Canadian Northwest

The Canadian administration of the Northwest gradually took form in the 1870s. The District of Keewatin was
carved out around Hudsons Bay in 1876. From 1882 the name Assiniboia, formerly associated with the Red River
Settlement, applied to the borderlands stretching west from Manitoba to the Cypress Hills. This was the terri-
tory most heavily populated by the Cree. In the same year, the District of Alberta was created next door and north
along the spine of the Rockies, covering almost all of the Canadian Niitsitapi (Blackfoot) territory. Saskatchewan
was the heartland of the Mtis, encompassing much of the river drainage, and it was also home to large numbers
of Cree. The District of Athabasca, also created in 1882, ran north from Alberta; the District of Franklin extended
north of Saskatchewan into what is now the Northwest Territories. There were thus seven administrative units on
the Plains, including Manitoba, of which six were governed either directly or indirectly from Ottawa.

The key administration in the context of the 1885 rising was Assiniboia. Its capital was Regina which, but for the
southern route of the railway, would have been of very little consequence. The site was chosen by Lieutenant-
Governor Edgar Dewdney, the surveyor and politician from British Columbia whose career was, according to his
biographer, a continuous quest for a sinecure. The selection of the site of the new territorial capital adjacent to his
1
personal landholdings in 1882 was the most egregious example of self-serving opportunism. Dewdneys execu-
tion of his responsibilities have drawn much criticism from historians. In one well-documented case, we find him
turning away cut-rate cattle sales from local ranchers whose stock might have addressed Aboriginal famine, in all
likelihood because he had a financial interest in another source of beef. Venal and lacking empathy, Dewdney is

1. Brian Titley, The Frontier World of Edgar Dewdney (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 1999), 143.

50
 2.6 CANADA AND THE FIRST NATIONS OF THE WEST 51

outstanding for his singular dedication to Canadian expansion into the region regardless of its impact on the native
population.

Canadian trepidation about Aboriginal and Mtis affairs in the West crossed party lines. The Mtis resistance of
1869-70 had, after all, won provincehood for Manitoba something that Ontarios leadership deeply resented.
George Brown and the Clear Grits had been drawn into the Great Coalition and the Confederation plan largely on
the strength of their desire to see Ontario settle the Plains. No one could or would say for sure that the Mtis might
not have further plans or the ability to upset Canadian ambitions again. As for the Cree, Niitsitapi, and Anishi-
naabe (Ojibwa) of the southwestern Prairies, the Canadians could be only less certain. Wars between the much
better armed US Cavalry and the Indigenous peoples of the lands south of the 49th parallel were in full swing.
The Sioux and the Niitsitapi moved freely back and forth across the Medicine Line and thus posed a threat to
both Euro-North American nation states. On 24 October 1870, the Cree and Niitsitapi engaged in a bloody con-
frontation: the Battle of Belly River, near Fort Whoop-Up in present-day Lethbridge. At the time, there was no
way of knowing that this was to be the last major Aboriginal war on the Plains. The Niitsitapis upset victory over
the Cree (who lost as many as 300 warriors) would only serve to reinforce a growing sense in the popular mindset
of Canadians that the native people of the Plains were warlike and an obstacle to national progress. Somehow that
threat would have to be diminished.

The first step to doing so was the numbered treaties. Of the first seven signed, three were drawn up under Macdon-
alds Conservative regime and four under the Liberal government of Alexander Mackenzie (1822-92). These met,
in the barest sense, Ottawas obligation to get treaties in place, but their principal goal was to pacify the West and
make it attractive to non-Aboriginal settlers. A large part of that, of course, involved getting individual Aboriginal
leaders to take treaty by selecting and accepting reserve lands. Everything else could be opened to settlement.
As for the Mtis, Ottawas approach was once burned, twice shy. There was no love lost between the Mtis and
the Canadians, and the federal government believed that it had met all its obligations to the former residents of
Red River. When the Mtis protests began, the Canadians were inclined to dismiss them as evidence of insatiable
greed on the part of a population too feckless to get on with successful farming.

Figure 2.8 The numbered treaties.

Not all Canadians shared the priorities of Ottawa. Settlers in the Northwest, for example, were witness to the des-
perate plight of the Aboriginal peoples. While some were less sympathetic than others, former HBC employees
who had a longer-term perspective on Cree, Assiniboine, and Niitsitapi societies decried the state of affairs fac-
ing First Nations. Canadian settlers, too, shared in some of the grievances registered by the Saskatchewan Mtis.
The original course of the CPR was to come north through the Saskatchewan River valleys, where the best farm-
land was to be found. Canadian migrants had rushed into the area as a consequence, and the CPRs decision to use
the southern route instead left them hundreds of kilometres from a rail link. Among these farmers was William
Henry Jackson (aka: Honore Joseph Jaxon, 1861-1952), a Torontonian whose family relocated to Prince Albert.
Offended by Ottawas apparent arbitrary behaviour and the duplicity of the CPR, Jackson headed to Batoche to
join the growing Mtis protest. University-educated, Jackson filled the position of secretary to Riel and was the
draughtsman of the 1884 grievances. (It is an interesting contrast, one that French-Canadians did not miss, that
 52 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Jackson was arrested at the end of the uprising and tried for treason, like Riel, but found not guilty by means of
2
insanity. He was thus spared the noose and committed to an asylum at Fort Garry, Manitoba.) Canadian settlers
in Assiniboia and Saskatchewan, too, complained that they were being administered like a branch of an Ottawa
bureaucracy and they demanded provincial status.

The Aboriginal West

One of the conditions of Canadas acquisition of Ruperts Land was that the new Dominion would enter into
treaty-making with the Indigenous peoples. This was a necessary prerequisite to confirming Canadian power in
the region. Stabilizing the area for settlement was certainly another motivation for doing so. Either way, speed
was thought to be of the essence. For these reasons the process of negotiating and signing the numbered treaties
was a rushed business. Historians remain uncertain as to what it was the Aboriginal signatories thought they were
agreeing to. In Treaties 4, 5, 6, and 7 there were promises of land, medicine chests, farming training, agricultural
equipment, and even livestock. From the Canadian perspective this was a package aimed at transitioning Aborig-
inal peoples into Canadian farmers. From an Aboriginal perspective it was consistent with the gift-giving diplo-
macy of past generations, it offered up emergency relief in the face of hardship from famine or disease, and it
purchased peace. Some Aboriginal leaders refused to sign, mostly because they recognized that the treaties didnt
really promise land; instead, the treaties proposed to take all of the land away, except for a small amount that
would be marked on maps as reserves. Extinguishing Aboriginal claims to the land was not something likely to
succeed quickly. Circumstances, however, would soon work against the Aboriginal hold-outs.

Until the 1980s, historians writing on the topic of the Riel Rebellions typically emphasized the role of the Mtis
leader and tended to subsume the Aboriginal agenda. In fact, this was a three-cornered confrontation and the Abo-
riginal situation was very distinct from that of the Mtis not to mention the Canadians.

The crisis that brought the Indigenous peoples of the Plains to the treaty table in the 1870s was rapidly worsening.
What was left of the bison herds was now under assault by better-armed hunters (native and non-native). The
repeating rifle was only one of several technological innovations that would severely compromise the remaining
herds. Pressures from the American side of the 49th parallel which includes increased access to bison grounds
by rail and the rise of the sports hunter resulted in herds pressing into the southwest corner of Alberta. The
process began in the 1860s, and by the late 1870s even the Niitsitapi (Blackfoot) Confederacy could no longer
count on this resource. What had only decades earlier been a continental population of hundreds of thousands of
plains bison was reckoned to have plummeted to a few hundred in the early 1880s.

For the Cree in the 1870s, the inevitable crisis was delayed, thanks to shared access to what was left of the bison
herds in Niitsitapi territory. The peace the Cree had negotiated with Canada in Treaties 1 through 6 (1871-76),
however, meant that even a much reduced version of the older Plains lifestyle could continue for less than a
decade. Although reserves had been mapped out, they were not immediately enforceable. There was nothing to
stop the Cree in particular from heading out to the last vestiges of promising hunting territory: the Cypress Hills.
Indeed, the terms of treaties encouraged the Indigenous signatories to stake out their territories, something on

2. Donald B. Smith, "William Henry Jackson, The Canadian Encyclopedia, August 2014, accessed 15 May 2015, [Link]
[Link]/en/article/william-henry-jackson/.
 2.6 CANADA AND THE FIRST NATIONS OF THE WEST 53
3
which Canada would later renege. By 1879, even the Cypress Hills resource was largely played out. It wasnt so
much the case that the clock was ticking; for the Cree and their neighbours, alarm bells were ringing.

Additional pressure was applied on the foodstocks of the Plains by the arrival of refugees in the 1870s and 1880s.
This is an often overlooked aspect of the period. We have become accustomed, in the 21st century, to seeing
images of people fleeing war-torn homelands and setting up rag-tag camps in which disease and starvation stalk
the population. In the Victorian era, there was no United Nations to intervene with aid or food, no Mdicins
sans Frontires to stay the progress of epidemics, no international corps of journalists to bring attention to suffer-
ing. What occurred on the Great Plains in these years thus went largely unobserved by the rest of the world. The
crisis begins in 1877, when the Sioux and their allies combined for one final push against the genocidal attacks of
the US Cavalry and, at Little Bighorn, they inflicted the most severe defeat that United States forces would suffer
until Pearl Harbor. Theirs was a pyrrhic victory, however, and Ta-tanka I-yotank (aka: Sitting Bull, 1836-1890)
and his people were forced to flee to sanctuary across the Medicine Line. Their refugee camps were swollen with
newcomers in the years that followed, and by 1880 their plight was desperate.

Beginning in 1879, famine swept across the Prairies. Provisions meant to be delivered under treaty were not sup-
plied. What cattle that did arrive on the Plains to be used as draught-animals were, instead, eaten. The Cree,
Assiniboine, and Saulteaux who conformed to Ottawas expectations and remained on reserve were, as a conse-
quence of their choice, vulnerable to starvation when Canada failed to meet its obligations. Those who rejected
treaty and the reserves including Cree under the leadership of Piapot (1816-1908), Mistahimaskwa (aka: Big
Bear, 1825-1888), and Minahikosis (aka: Little Pine, 1830-1885) faced hardship just the same. Whats more,
Ottawa exploited these conditions to try to reorient the recalcitrant factions onto reserves and into a European-
style regime of agriculture. To be clear, Canadian authorities knew that famine was on the march. They had
resources warehoused nearby, and yet withheld supplies in order to achieve a political goal: the submission of the
Cree and their neighbours to Canadian authority.

The situation was no better for the Niitsitapi. Reports of twenty-five starvation deaths in the last days of 1879
signalled that the last refuge of the bison was also in peril. Successive hard winters compounded conditions for
everyone in the southwest Prairies and along the foothills. Despite fears of American attacks, many of the Niitsi-
tapi relocated to the United States in pursuit of food or, perhaps, rations.

By 1881-83, most of the groups that had resisted taking treaty were on reserves. Minahikosis buckled in 1879 and
signed Treaty 6, but he worked for the remaining six years of his life to expand and draw together the reserve
lands into a contiguous pattern so as to create a Plains Cree homeland. Ottawa, however, feared Aboriginal efforts
to create contiguous reserves that would constitute an Indian Territory and enable the growth of stronger politi-
cal and military resolve. As a result, the Cree reserves were dissolved into smaller and more distinct parcels. This
approach, of course, made the administration of aid still more difficult. Whats more, these concentrated popula-
tions also created promising conditions for epidemics to emerge. As if disease was not enough, food poisoning
appeared. Tainted meat was, in desperation, consumed on many reserves and in many towns, with predictable
results.

Still the Canadian government adhered to an austerity-first policy and the notion of the vanishing Indian gained
ground. Some late 19th century Canadian critics of rationing and relief argued that supporting native peoples was
throwing good money after bad: if the Aboriginal population was doomed to disappear, what would be the point?

3. John Milloy, The Plains Cree: Trade, Diplomacy and War, 1790 to 1870 (Winnipeg: University of Manitoba Press, 1988), 120.
 54 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

In this respect, both the Liberals and the Conservatives in Ottawa were on the same page. Prime Minister John
A. Macdonald took the view that relief to anyone who was not actually starving would create dependence rather
than self-reliance. And yet even in famine the Plains peoples were not being supported. One of the last big pushes
to get bands onto reserves came in the spring of 1882 to clear all the lands south of the CPR route in Assini-
boia (now southern Saskatchewan). As one historian frames this, every move made by Ottawa had cynicism at its
heart: Within a year, 5,000 people were expelled from the Cypress Hills. In doing so the Canadian government
4
accomplished the ethnic cleansing of southwestern Saskatchewan of its indigenous population.

One strategy for minimizing Aboriginal dependency was agricultural education, something which was promised
in the treaty-making process. The Cree, in particular, were prepared to transition into a farming economy ide-
ally on their own terms and provision was made for farm instructors to be sent out from Ontario. Needless to
say some instructors were better than others, and many were used as de facto administrators and Canadian diplo-
mats. Progress on this front, as with rations, was too slow for the Cree and the Niitsitapi. In 1883, several Cree
leaders petitioned Ottawa, clearly stating that they felt betrayed by Canadas lacklustre commitment to the terms
of the treaties:

Nothing but our dire poverty, our utter destitution during this severe winter, when ourselves, our wives and our children
are smarting under the pangs of cold and hunger, with little or no help, and apparently less sympathy from those placed to
watch over us, could have induced us to make this final attempt to have redress directly from headquarters. We say final
because, if no attention is paid to our case we shall conclude that the treaty made with us six years ago was a meaningless
matter of form and that the white man has indirectly doomed us to annihilation little by little. Shall we still be refused,
and be compelled to adhere to the conclusion spoken of in the beginning of this letter, that the treaty is a farce enacted to
5
kill us quietly, and if so, let us die at once?

By 1884 the Cree were prepared to respond as a single body under the leadership of Mistahimaskwa. In response,
the Canadians led by Dewdney and embodied in the newly-formed North-West Mounted Police (NWMP)
began detaining native leaders as they attempted to travel to meetings, breaking up gatherings where legal resis-
tance and court challenges were being discussed, and once again using rations to squeeze the Plains peoples into
submission. The government also turned to the banning of Indigenous cultural practices. In 1884-85, Aboriginal
movement was restricted as a pass system emerged (see Section 11.6) and arrests were made of native diplomats
visiting reserves other than their own. Disagreements between the Niitsitapi under Isapo-muxika (aka: Crowfoot),
the Sioux, led by Ta-tank I-yotank, the Cree, and the Mtis further weakened the possibility of a united front
6
emerging across the Plains.

As 1885 approached, relations between Aboriginals and Canadians in the West were at a low ebb. The worst of
famine had passed in some quarters but the trauma and the death toll were hardly going to be expunged overnight.
Cree leaders like Piapot and Mistahimaskwa had watched for more than a decade as the Canadians neglected their
treaty obligations and communities were purposely shattered and brought to heel.

Ironically, it was the Dakota Sioux who fared the best in these years; they brought their farming skills (honed for
more than 50 years) to their existing settlement hubs in Canada. They were not covered by numbered treaties and,
as a result, fell between the administrative cracks. They were thus able to get on with adjusting to the new par-

4. James Daschuk, Clearing the Plains: Disease, Politics of Starvation, and the Loss of Aboriginal Life (Regina: University of Regina Press,
2013), 123.
5. Bobtail, Ermine Skin, Samson, et al. to John A. Macdonald, 7 January 1883, quoted in Jennifer Reid, Louis Riel and the Creation of Modern Canada:
Mythic Discourse and the Postcolonial State (Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, 2008), 15.
6. J.R. Miller, Skyscrapers Hide the Heavens: A History of Indian-White Relations in Canada, revised edition (Toronto: University of Toronto
Press, 1991), 170-5.
 2.6 CANADA AND THE FIRST NATIONS OF THE WEST 55

adigm without willful mismanagement by the Canadians. How serious was this distinction? Very. Of the Plains
people in the 1880s, only the Sioux escaped the tuberculosis epidemics and they did so likely because they were
better fed, more self-sufficient, and not economically destabilized.

Key Points

The period between 1870-85 in the West saw dramatic and catastrophic changes take place among
the Aboriginal communities.
Ottawas administrative presence in the West was reflected in the creation of new territories, new
political offices, and the creation of the NWMP.
The crisis among First Nations was precipitated by an accelerating decline in bison populations,
leading to a final armed conflict over the remaining herds at Belly River, 1870.
Facing food shortages and the arrival of migrants from Canada, the First Nations of the region
agreed to the numbered treaties, which they understood to be an ongoing relationship and not a once-
and-for-all submission to Canadian authority.
Non-Aboriginal settlers in the West were often critical of Ottawas approach to the region.
Famine years began in 1879 and continued through 1885. These conditions were exploited by
Ottawa to win further treaties, resettle signatory nations on reserves, and secure the submission of
First Nations to Canadian rule.
Aboriginal support for protest and resistance was growing by 1884, creating conditions that would
contribute the the Northwest Rebellion of 1885.

Attributions
Figure 2.8
Map of Numbered Treaties of Canada by Themightyquill is used under a CC BY SA 2.5 license.
2.7 Rebellion 1885

Figure 2.9 Efforts by the Anglo-Ontarian population in Winnipeg

to intimidate the francophone community included an election
riot in 1872 that targeted newspapers that were critical of John
Schultz including these printing presses at The Manitoban.

After the Canadians arrived in Red River, much of the local Mtis population departed. Canadian failure to respect
the scrip they issued to the Mtis for land was one factor, as was the virulent hostility of Orangemen outraged at
the martyrdom of Thomas Scott. The Mtis had options and there were many other communities on the Prairies
to which they might turn. The most promising of these were arranged along the Saskatchewan River, particularly
the South Branch.

Mtis Discontent
By 1875, Canadians had pretty much over-run the old Red River colony and Winnipeg was, for all intents and
purposes, a Canadian city. More Mtis, disenchanted with the ways in which the Canadian regime neglected to
address the issue of land entitlement, drifted toward the Saskatchewan Valleys. There were just enough bison left
on the plains in the mid-1870s to create hope among the Mtis that at least one aspect of their old livelihood might
continue. They established new farms made up of long and narrow strips that were a legacy of the seigneurial
system in New France and erected churches and other elements of established communities. The most important
settlements were QuAppelle, Duck Lake, and Batoche. It wasnt long before Canadian surveyors arrived in the
region and began redrawing local maps along the square section plan that had, in 1869, caused unrest to erupt in
and around Red River.

In 1884, the dissatisfied and worried Mtis of the South Saskatchewan sought out Louis Riel.

Riel after 1870

The life and times of Louis Riel are dominated by his two confrontations with the power of Ottawa and the ambi-

56
 2.7 REBELLION 1885 57

tions of Canada. It is easy to lose sight of the fact that he was very young in 1869, and a persecuted and confused
1
man entering middle age in 1885.

Soon after negotiations with Canada were concluded in 1870, Riel decided to flee to the United States. He was
only a few steps ahead of the Ontarian Orangemen who had volunteered for regiments that staggered toward Man-
itoba with a vendetta for Riels execution in mind. On three occasions he was elected by voters in the West
to represent them in the House of Commons in Ottawa; fearing for his life, he never took his seat.

Figure 2.10 Depictions of Riel run the gamut from opera to nude
statues. Chester Browns Louis Riel: A Comic-Strip Biography is
an example, and evidence, of the continuing purchase Riel has on
the public imagination.

Macdonald, eager to avoid a rupture in Canada, sent Riel money to remain in the United States. He was granted
amnesty, provided he stayed out of Canada for five years. But Riel suffered a mental health collapse and travelled
to Quebec where he was a patient in two asylums. In one, according to historian Dan Francis, Riels treatment was
brutal:

He was routinely trussed up in a straitjacket because of his violent behaviour. He was allowed to exercise only under
guard in the yard behind the main building and, he complained in a letter, I spend the night with chains around my feet
2
and hands.

Figure 2.11 The Science of Cheek; or, Riels Next

Move. Riel (loq.) Five Toussand Dollares! By gar,
I shall arrest ze scoundrel myself! J.W. Bengough is
widely regarded as the pioneer of political cartooning
in Canada. This one from April 1874 finds Riel in
Ottawa, where it was alleged he stole into the
Commons, signed the register, and snuck off again.

He thereafter joined a Mtis community in Montana the American Northwest and Pacific Northwest was pep-
pered with such enclaves, some of which dated to the 18th century. He married a Mtis woman (Marguerite
Monet, ne Bellehumeur) and they had three offspring, none of whom survived childhood. Riels mental health
issues may not have been fully resolved, as he announced that he was receiving visions of a sovereign Mtis state
in the Prairie West. He wrote prolifically, taught at a Montana school, joined the Republican Party and took out
American citizenship. In June 1884, Gabriel Dumont (1837-1906) arrived with a delegation of Mtis, anglophone
country borns, and Canadian settlers. They persuaded Riel to return to Canada (that is, to the Northwest), and ini-

1. A very good survey of the many historical representations of Louis Riel is Douglas Owram, The Myth of Louis Riel, Louis Riel: Selected
Readings, ed. Hartwell Bowsfield (Mississauga: Copp Clark Pitman, 1988): 11-29.
2. Daniel Francis, Sane or Insane? The Case of Rose Lynam, Reading the National Narrative, [Link]
lynam, accessed 15 May 2015.
 58 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

tiate a new round of negotiations with Ottawa. Riel agreed, with conditions. It would dawn on Dumont and the
rest of the delegation only later that Riel was not the man he had been in 1870.

From Protest to Rising

At the start, Riel demonstrated good organizational skills and made use of key personnel. He set about building
a coalition of disaffected peoples on the Prairies. Under Riels leadership and by the hand of Canadian settler
William Henry Jackson, the communities of the area around Prince Albert produced a petition calling for: relief to
the Aboriginal peoples, land disbursements to the Mtis, easier access to additional lands for homesteaders, free
elections, and the establishment of new provinces with rights at least as great as those of Manitoba. Riel and his
allies would dress this up in the language of loyal British subjects so as to douse the idea that this was a docu-
3
ment produced by people who rejected Ottawas rule.

In March 1885, after three months and with no reply from Ottawa, the coalition took its next step. As was the case
15 years earlier at Red River, they established a Provisional Government. Within a week Dumonts troops engaged
a body of 53 NWMP, along with more than 40 volunteers in the Prince Albert militia, on a snowy road between
Fort Walsh and Duck Lake. The skirmish lasted barely 30 minutes and the NWMP/Volunteer casualties were
severe: a dozen dead and another eleven injured. The Mtis lost five, including Dumonts brother, Isadore, and the
Cree leader Assiwiyin. The small battle set off a panic among the NWMP, who withdrew from the Saskatchewan
River Valley in haste. Even if their strategy was badly underdeveloped, at this stage the Mtis had established a
considerable advantage over Canada. Duck Lake was enough to instigate a Canadian military response but it was
soon eclipsed by events at Battleford and Frog Lake.

Aboriginal unrest finally spilled over. A farming instructor was murdered on the Mosquito Reserve and the north-
ern Cree leader, Pitikwahanapiwiyin (aka: Poundmaker, 1842-1885), marched his followers and some Nakoda
(aka: Stoney) Sioux into Battleford on 30 March. The town was abandoned by alarmed settlers and the Indian
Agent was unwilling or unable to offer the Cree-Nakoda protest group any food or resources. Looting of empty
homes followed. At Frog Lake on 2 April, Mistahimaskwas Cree broke with their moderate leader and attacked
and killed nine settlers, including the Indian Agent. Two weeks later Fort Pitt was captured, although this time
without bloodshed.

Figure 2.12 The Halifax Provisional Battalion fords a stream near

Swift Current, part of the Canadian expedition into the
Northwest in 1885.

The tide was about to turn violently against the Mtis and Aboriginal forces. Only one day after the battle of Duck
Lake, news of the incident reached Ottawa via the new telegraph technology that paralleled the Canadian Pacific
Railway line. This was one feature of a technological revolution that had taken place on the Plains since the Red
River resistance. Macdonald had barely to request volunteers for militia duty: local newspapers across Canada,

3. Jennifer Reid, Louis Riel and the Creation of Modern Canada: Mythic Discourse and the Postcolonial State (Albuquerque: University of
New Mexico Press, 2008), 18.
 2.7 REBELLION 1885 59

from Fort William to Sydney, were calling for and sponsoring local regiments. The troops who showed up to head
west were proof of how a Canadian sentiment was growing across the former separate (and sometimes rival)
colonies; they were also proof of a badly underdeveloped Canadian military. Each regiment wore colours associ-
ated in some way with their home communities rather than with a national regiment, let alone an army. Two weeks
after call-up, about 8,000 soldiers (almost all of them inexperienced) were boarding trains and speeding west. The
ability to do so had not been there in 1870; Riels failure to cut the rail line or telegraph line suggests that he did
not appreciate the extent to which the world had changed since Red River.

Major-General Frederick Middleton and Lieutenant-Colonel William Otter led a two-pronged attack on the Cree-
Nakoda forces and the Mtis Provisional Government headquarters at Batoche. Over three days, from the 9th
through the 12th of May, Middletons Winnipeg Militia pounded away at the Mtis position. Vastly outgunned,
the Mtis nevertheless held out until their ammunition was exhausted. In a battle that was reminiscent of the
Mtis-Sioux clash at Grand Couteau in 1851 and foreshadows the Belgian theatre of war in 1916-17, the Mtis
sharpshooters picked off their enemies from a series of trenches dug in preparation for the assault. As the Mtis
resistance failed, many of their troops and leaders fled. Three days after the battle, Riel surrendered to Middleton.
He would be tried, convicted, and hanged in Regina.

The Cree vs. Canada

The resistance to Canadian ambitions in the West was not over. Otters troops performed less well against the
Cree: at Cut Knife Hill and Eagle Hills, and at Frenchmans Butte and Loon Lake, the Cree scored significant vic-
tories. However, the Canadians were wearing them down. The leadership status of Pitikwahanapiwiyin and Mis-
tahimaskwa was compromised when they surrendered on 26 May and 2 July respectively.

In the 1885 trials that followed in Battleford, the outcomes for the Aboriginal leadership were particularly bad.
Eight men among them Kapapamahchakwew (aka: Wandering Spirit), and the two Nakoda leaders, Itka and
Man Without Blood were tried in October and condemned to hang. Some traditional Plains cultures believe
that the soul is located in the neck and so the idea of hanging was especially horrific. One of the condemned
men unsuccessfully requested death by firing squad instead. A gallows large enough to hang eight men at once
was built and the mass execution took place on 27 November. The fate of Pitikwahanapiwiyin and Mistahi-
maskwa (considered in Section 2.8) was only slightly better.

In the aftermath of the executions, many Cree and Nakoda fled to the United States. While the story of Sitting Bull
and the Dakota Siouxs flight into Canada is relatively well known, the fact that a couple of hundred Aboriginal
4
people from the Canadian Plains thought themselves safer south of the Medicine Line is not.

Key Points

Canadian disregard for the Mtis, country-born, and Aboriginal peoples in the West led to diplomatic
and then armed conflict in 1885.

4. Blair Stonechild and Bill Waiser, Loyal till Death: Indians and the North-West Rebellion (Calgary: Fifth House Publishers, 1997), 222-5.
60 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Louis Riel was recruited by a delegation from Saskatchewan to lead a second protest against Ottawa.
In March 1885 violence erupted involving several different and not unified groups.
The Canadians now had the ability to transmit information via telegraphs and to expeditiously move
troops to the West, and were thus able to suppress the rebellions.
The leadership of the Cree and Nakoda Sioux were punished severely for their role in these events,
effectively crushing the likelihood of further Aboriginal resistance in the region.

Attributions
Figure 2.9
The press room in The Manitoban printing office after the riot during the election (Online MIKAN no.3192361)
by James Penrose / Library and Archives Canada / PA-165779 is in the public domain.

Figure 2.10
Louis Riel, by Chester Brown by Random McRandomhead is used under a CC-BY-2.0 license.

Figure 2.11
The science of cheek by John Wilson is in the public domain.

Figure 2.12
Men of the Halifax Provisional Battalion crossing a stream (Online MIKAN no.3194522) by Library and
Archives Canada / C-005826 is in the public domain.
 2.8 Making Sense of 1885

1
According to one view, there were fewer than 400 insurgents directly involved in the Rebellion. By any account,
that makes it a very small civil war indeed. The impact of the events of 1885, however, was widespread and long
lasting.

The rising gave Canada an excuse to imprison, punish, and more forcefully dominate members of the Aboriginal
community on the Plains. Mistahimaskwa, who had lost credibility as a Cree leader, repeatedly attempted during
the protest to rein in the frustrated and angry members of his community (including his own son), counselling
peace and negotiation with the Canadians. He mostly failed in those efforts, although at Fort Pitt he was respon-
sible for the safe passage of the Canadian population and the NWMP detachment. Whats more, as a leader, he
stepped forward at the end of the unrest and surrendered himself to the Canadian authorities. He was charged with
treason and felony, found guilty, but spared the noose. He received a three-year jail sentence which, for a 60 year
old, was severe in its own right. Broken by the whole experience, he died shortly after his release two and a half
2
years later. A similar fate befell Pitikwahanapiwiyin (aka: Poundmaker), who served one of three years at Man-
itobas Stony Mountain Penitentiary before being released due to failing health. He died four months later. These
events effectively decapitated Aboriginal leadership and resistance for a generation.

Figure 2.13 Pitikwahanapiwiyin

(ca.1842-1886) in the year before his
death.

Assessing Riel
Notwithstanding his tactical and political errors in 1885, Riel served as a lightning rod for the Mtis and their set-

1. Jennifer Reid, Louis Riel and the Creation of Modern Canada: Mythic Discourse and the Postcolonial State (Albuquerque: University of
New Mexico Press, 2008), 1.
2. Rudy Wiebe, Mistahimaskwa, in Dictionary of Canadian Biography, vol. 11 (University of Toronto/Universit Laval, 2003), accessed 19
May 2015, [Link]

61
 62 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

tler neighbours as well. As was the case at Red River, he proved effective at building collaborative and respectful
partnerships among the aggrieved. At his trial, however, much hinged on the issue of Riels sanity.

Two experts (such as they were) declared that Riel was suffering from a personality disorder that took at least two
different forms. The court was not convinced. For the Orange Lodge, still baying for blood after the execution of
Thomas Scott in 1870, a successful insanity plea would cheat them of their revenge. For the Mtis, it would look
as though they had allowed themselves to be misdirected by a lunatic. As far as the government was concerned,
a successful insanity plea would spare them the inevitable schism between Ontario and Quebec. Riels lawyers,
too, had only one endgame in mind: keep their client off the gallows. It was to this end that Riel responded when
he said, while the Crown, with the great talents they have at its service, are trying to show that I am guilty
of course it is their duty my counselors are trying my good friends and lawyers who have been sent here
3
by friends I respect, are trying to show that I am insane. Riel would have none of it. If he was declared insane,
Riel argued, the reasonable demands of the Mtis would be dismissed as well. The insanity plea collapsed.

The court found Riel guilty of treason (though many believed he was being tried for the murder of Scott) and,
despite a recommendation of mercy from the all Anglo-Protestant jury, the judge assigned the death penalty.
Protest in Quebec rose up immediately after sentencing, putting Macdonald in the position of having to con-
sider a second amnesty. In what soon became a famous affront to French Canadians, Macdonald declared himself
4
resigned to the courts decision and to Riels doom, though every dog in Quebec bark in his favor. Riel was
hanged in Regina on 16 November 1885.

Figure 2.14 Surrounded by NWMP (drawn to look

like a regiment of Prussian troops), Riel faces his
end on the gallows (le gibet).

It is safe to say that no figure in Canadian history has so divided Canadians and Canadian historians as Louis
Riel. The Mtis leader has been portrayed variously as a martyr, a murderer, a madman, and a messiah. The cir-
cumstances of his trial and execution divided French from English Canada, as the former embraced him as a
representative of francophone and Catholic traditions. Insofar as the hardline Protestants of English Canada were
concerned, yes, Riels Catholicism was a significant issue. Those Ontarians leading the charge into the West cer-
tainly had no appetite for a dualist society collaboratively built by French and English hands together. The Anglo-
Protestants were inclined to unravel agreements that promised to respect cultural diversity. One result of the
inhospitable climate created by Anglo-Manitobans and by the execution of Riel was a lack of migration from
Quebec into the West.

Catholic Quebecs relationship with Riel was not, however, nearly as straightforward. The Riel who re-emerged
from exile in Montana was a changed man. He has been described by one of his many biographers as part of

3. Quoted in Douglas Linder, "The Trial of Louis Riel," (University of Missouri-Kansas City (UMKC), School of Law, 2004), accessed 15 May
2015, [Link]
4. Alan D. McMillan, Native Peoples and Cultures of Canada (Vancouver and Toronto: Douglas & McIntyre, 1988), 285.
 2.8 MAKING SENSE OF 1885 63

a larger global trend of nativist millenarians who represented Indigenous peoples under imperialism. The 1885
rising coincides, roughly, with the Ghost Dance movement in the the West and the Mahdi of the Sudan, both of
5
which envisioned a world swept clean of the outsiders and newcomers. In the case of Riel, his vision of cultural
resurrection and a promised land for the Mtis combined ultramontanist Catholicism with elements of numerol-
ogy, as well as Mormon-style polygamy and a Saturday Sabbath. Some of these features of Riels belief system
raised eyebrows among the Catholic clergy, and the most critical of them were prepared to have Riel excommu-
nicated. For this constituency, he was not a hero although his eleventh-hour reconciliation with the Church
helped matters significantly.

Figure 2.15 Riel as a prisoner in the camp of Major-General

Middleton.

For the Mtis, of course, Riels failure of leadership and his apparent retreat into spiritualism raised mixed feel-
ings. His record stands in sharp contrast with representations of Gabriel Dumont as a more hard-nosed and effec-
tive general. Riel was meant to be a galvanizing figure but, even among the Mtis, he was frequently polarizing.
Nevertheless, his execution brought home to the Mtis their relative powerlessness in the face of Canadian impe-
rialism in the West.

Anglo-Celtic Protestant Westerners celebrated the failure of the uprising and Riels execution for a generation or
two. There was, however, a persistent undercurrent of concern that conditions that led to the rising were caused
or manipulated by Ottawa. By the mid-20th century, anti-Ottawa feeling in Western Canada resulted in an ideo-
logical and symbolic resurrection of Riel. He was increasingly celebrated as a kind of founding father of Mani-
toba, among other things. Monuments appeared across the three Prairie provinces beginning in the late 1960s, and
provincial premiers (even Conservatives) invoked the memory of Riel as a powerful symbol for Western alien-
ation as when they engaged Ottawa in debates over resource revenues and constitutional issues. The radical left
also embraced Riel in the 1960s and 1970s. His criticisms of Canadian capitalists and his resistance against the
armed might of the state resonated in an era of anti-Vietnam War protests. Among the many streets and centres
named for Riel in these years was a dormitory at politically stormy Simon Fraser University: Louis Riel House.
Decoding the meaning of Riel requires that we engage with intent and see beyond the outcome. Perhaps the
last word on this subject belongs to J.R. Miller, a distinguished historian at the University of Saskatchewan. He
observed It is a painful but real fact of life that the only thing that justifies rebellion is success. The successful
6
revolutionary is a statesman, the unsuccessful a criminal.

Aboriginal people, for their part, have spent more than a century distancing themselves from Riel, claiming that
they had their own very specific agendas (which they did), that they were not followers caught in the slipstream
of the Mtis nor of their charismatic leader (which they were not), and that no one else paid more dearly for the
consequences of Riels guilt.

5. Thomas Flanagan, Louis David Riel: Prophet of the New World, revised edition (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1996), 197-8.
6. J.R. Miller, Skyscrapers Hide the Heaven: A History of Indian-White Relations in Canada (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, rev. ed.
1991), 186.
64 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Key Points

Riels trial and execution divided opinion in Canada and acted as a wedge between English and
French in Ontario and Quebec.
Riels legacy is a complex one in that he was vilified in the English-speaking provinces, lionized in
French-Catholic Quebec, regarded with some suspicion by the Catholic establishment, treated with
ambivalence by the Mtis and First Nations, and subsequently held out as a symbol of Western and
popular resistance in the late 20th century.

Attributions
Figure 2.13
Poundmaker, also known as The Drummer, (ca. 1842-1886), a Cree chief, later adopted by Crowfoot of the
Blackfoot Nation (Online MIKAN no.3241485) by O.B. Buell / Library and Archives Canada / C-001875 is in
the public domain.

Figure 2.14
Hanging of Louis Riel from Historylcchs is used under a CC-BY-SA 3.0 license.

Figure 2.15
Louis Riel, prisonnier, au camp du major-gnral F.D. Middleton (Online MIKAN no.3623590) by James
Peters / Library and Archives Canada / e011156619_s3 ; C-003450 is in the public domain.
2.9 The Railway

Completing the Intercolonial Railway between the original four provinces was a condition of Confederation. That
task could be accomplished without too much difficulty. After all, the colonies had laid some 3,200 km of track
by 1865. Finding a company with the wherewithal to build a railway from Montreal to the Pacific was a whole
different order of magnitude. The Grand Trunk Railway was the obvious candidate but its directors balked at the
prospect of an all-Canadian route. The newly-established Canadian Pacific Railway (CPR) was a contender in
1873, but that plan ran off the proverbial rails when it was discovered that Macdonalds Conservative Party had
received significant funds from the CPR. The Pacific Scandal cost Macdonald his administration, brought the
Mackenzie Liberals into office, and a substitute railway company could not be found. The Mackenzie adminis-
tration was not without accomplishments in this regard: in one term of office it oversaw the construction of sev-
eral north-south lines that would assist Canadian exports. Returned in 1878, and faced with an almost apoplectic
British Columbian body politic that was calling for The terms [of union], the whole terms, and nothing but the
terms, Macdonald resumed the search for a contractor. Again, the CPR stepped forward and the project, started
in 1880, was completed in a remarkable six years. Built with heavy government subsidies and other incentives
provided to the CPR Company, it represented a genuine engineering achievement. It was also a massive corporate
accomplishment.

The CPR as Land Baron

The legal mechanism that made possible the distribution of western lands was the Dominion Lands Act of 1872,
aspects of which were highly problematic. For one, it disregarded Aboriginal title in violation of treaty agree-
ments. Aboriginal peoples continue to protest this situation. The Act had implications, too, for the provinces of
the West. Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, Ontario, and Quebec (and, a little later, PEI) all had exclusive control
over their natural resources (with a few exceptions like fisheries), but land and other natural resources across the
whole of the Prairie West and the Peace District in northeastern British Columbia were Ottawas to control, tax,
and dispense. Establishing settlers increased traffic on the railway. This increased the movement of supplies and
farm equipment from east to west, it stimulated steel production in the original provinces, and as capital and sweat
were invested in farms, it created a market for land and further revenues for the state. Ottawa became wealthy on
western lands while western territories and provinces did not. Finally, the parceling out of western lands in sec-
tions determined a human geography on the plains that was brutally rigid. Roads were driven at one- or two-mile
intervals that corresponded with the grid of sections. The effect was to separate neighbours by miles of landscape
and to leave settlers access to fresh water and woodlots up to chance. Community and sustainability, however,
were not concerns of the CPR or the Lands Act.

65
 66 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

One way of speeding along the process of commodification of land involved the CPR very directly. A mammoth
swath of territory on either side of the railway right-of-way 25 million acres (roughly 10 million hectares)
was granted to the CPR as an incentive. Inevitably, this was considered some of the most desirable land on the
Prairies because proximity to a railway station was critically important to the financial viability of a wheat farm in
the days before gasoline-powered trucks. The CPR quickly became an integrated corporation, consisting of pas-
senger/freight transportation, communications, and land sales (at $2.50 an acre) combined with a recruitment and
marketing arm that aimed to lure Canadians and immigrants into the West. The CPR even purchased a fleet of
vessels to ship settlers across the Atlantic, and built another to extend its reach across the Pacific to Asia.

The gallows in Regina were barely cleared off following the events of 1885 when the CPR moved into an entirely
unforeseen enterprise: the hotel and tourism business. After he became president of the railway in 1888, William
Cornelius Van Horne (1843-1915) sought to capitalize on the growing market for travel by promoting the explo-
ration of the Victorian version of the wilderness in comfort, in a specially designed sleeping car. If we cant
1
export the scenery, well import the tourists, he is reported to have announced. The company erected imposing
structures like Glacier House near Rogers Pass, Mount Stephen House at Field (both opening in 1886), Fraser
Canyon House at North Bend (1887), and the Banff Springs Hotel (1888), even before turning its attention to
the monumental hot springs hotel at Banff. Some of these were modeled on hunting lodges, some on European
chateaus, and all of them were an expression of the CPRs role as an extension of North Atlantic civilizations
values, economy, and systems.

Figure 2.16 As a land vendor, the CPR needed buyers and

it looked overseas to find them. Notice how the branding
developed by the CPR reduces Canada to something
inconsequential: the Railway and Manitoba are the
message.

Routes to the Pacific

The CPRs route across the West, from Ontario to the Pacific Coast, is one of the sharpest points in the history of
the early Dominion. As the initial infrastructural, administrative, and economic extension of Canada, it had (and
continues to have) a powerful influence on many aspects of life.

The most critical decision in routing was made at the very outset. Chicago had already emerged in the 1870s as
the leading transportation hub in the interior of North America. It was possible to ship goods without interrup-
tion from western Ontario via Lakes Huron, Superior, and Michigan, directly to the Illinois port. Whats more,
Chicago had established its primacy in railway transportation as well. One option open to the Canadians was,
therefore, to build a route across southern Michigan to Chicago and then north to Manitoba. The cost would be
a fraction of any all-Canadian route, but it exposed an important national link to unpredictable relations with the

1. E.J. Hart, See this World Before the Next: Tourism and the CPR, The CPR West: The Iron Road and the Making of a Nation, ed. Hugh A.
Dempsey (Vancouver: Douglas & McIntyre, 1984): 151.
 2.9 THE RAILWAY 67

United States. Canada, after all, had been founded with the threat of American invasion in mind; if defending the
West against American expansionism was one reason for (a) annexing Ruperts Land in the first place, and (b)
building infrastructure that would enable the quick movement of troops, then it made no sense to stake all of that
on a railway that passed through American territory.

That meant shifting the route north across the Canadian Shield. The Shield contained some of the most difficult
terrain that surveyors and engineers encountered, and that includes the Rocky Mountain passes. The Shield slowed
down construction and ramped up costs exponentially. It also frightened off investors, particularly those in the
United States.

Ottawa responded with lucrative incentives to the Canadian Pacific Railway Company of Montreal. The CPR,
under the leadership of Sir Hugh Allen (1810-1882), replied with gifts of money to the Conservative Party in
1872. These donations totaling approximately $350,000 were exposed in April 1873 in what became known
as the Pacific Scandal. John A. Macdonalds government began to topple. By the autumn coinciding with the
Panic of 73 (a financial crisis that gripped the United States and was related directly to overbuilding of rail-
ways) Macdonalds position was irretrievable. An election in January 1874 saw the Liberals, under Alexander
Mackenzie, form a government for the first time. The economic situation was poor, however, as was Mackenzies
timing.

The Liberals put their trust in the Department of Public Works and Sandford Fleming (1827-1915), a civil engineer
(and the inventor of worldwide standard time) who surveyed and approved a route through the Yellowhead Pass
in 1872. The northern route would head off from Winnipeg to the Saskatchewan River Valley, and thence to Fort
Edmonton and the north-central Rockies. Beyond there, the most promising option seemed to be through the Cari-
boo to Bute Inlet, across Seymour Narrows (at what is now Campbell River), and south to Esquimalt.

The northern route presented several advantages, the first of which was the agricultural potential of the territory
through which it passed. The Saskatchewan River Valley and the parklands of the central Prairies contain good
water and soil resources, and they are well-treed an asset from a log-house building perspective and with regard
to fuel. This was a sharp contrast with the more arid lands of Assiniboia, which included Pallisers Triangle,
an area of poorer, brown soils that stretches, roughly speaking, along the 49th parallel from what is now mid-
Saskatchewan to Lethbridge in the west and Drumheller in the north. Crossing the Rockies was going to present a
challenge whichever direction was chosen, but from a farm economy perspective the northwestern route seemed
the logical choice. Certainly the earliest settlers thought so. Mtis who were displaced in Manitoba headed into
the region, while country born and Canadian migrants formed nodes of their own, drawn by early promises of
railway connection with the CPR. These small but well-established settlements were, however, an obstacle when
it came to finding sufficiently lucrative land for the CPRs grant.

The company opted in 1881 for the southern route instead, heading more or less straight across the Prairies from
Winnipeg to Banff and the Kicking Horse Pass. As historian of Saskatchewan, Bill Waiser, notes:

This decision, one of the most controversial in western Canadian history, completely changed the axis of development in
the region by focusing attention on the southern prairies the North-West effectively became the west. In the process,
2
the future province of Saskatchewan became associated in Canadian minds with the flat, treeless prairie.

2. Bill Waiser, Saskatchewan: A New History (Calgary: Fifth House, 2005), 27.
68 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

As well, the southern route meant that the most intensively farmed lands were located in an arid belt that would
generate environmental and economic tragedy in the 20th century (see Section 8.5).

The southern route had repercussions in British Columbia as well. The Bute Inlet to Victoria route was swept
away by Macdonald when the Conservatives returned to power. Instead, the CPR terminus would be located in
Port Moody, a milltown at the head of Burrard Inlet. As a kind of consolation, and in recognition of the commit-
ment made in 1871 regarding a railway to Victoria, the Esquimalt & Nanaimo Railway (the E&N) was built
by coal magnate Robert Dunsmuir to connect his mining operations at mid-island with the capital. Each of these
changes improved the CPRs position as a real estate company. Each of these changes embittered local farmers,
investors, speculators, Indigenous peoples, and the Mtis, who saw the CPR seize the most profitable land and
determine where the biggest cities were going to go all while abandoning whole communities.

Figure 2.17 Fire trap. Hot weather, woodframe buildings, and an

obvious abundance of tinder spelled disaster for Gastown/
Granville/Vancouver in 1886.

Gastown to Granville
Nowhere was the city-building ambitions of the CPR clearer than along Burrard Inlet. On both the north and
south shore of the fjord there had been logging operations in play since the 1850s. The largest and oldest of these,
Moodyville (named for Sewell Moody, an American entrepreneur), was located on the north shore and was a poor
candidate for a rail terminus from the east. At the head of the inlet was Port Moody (named for Colonel Richard
Clement Moody, a Royal Engineer and Lieutenant-Governor of BC), which enjoyed good access to the mostly
level Fraser Valley. This made Port Moody a prime choice for the CPR. The challenge facing the company was
that speculators had reached Burrard Inlet first, buying up much of Port Moody in the hope of being bought out by
the CPR at a handsome profit. Actual railway construction heading east began here and the town was, officially,
the terminus until the line was finally completed. Shortly thereafter, in 1886, a devastating fire destroyed a third
of Hastings Mill and its commercial area (known officially as Granville and unofficially as Gastown). The largely
flat landscape was almost completely denuded of trees and stumps (as well as almost all of its building stock).
The CPR announced a change of plans and extended the line from Port Moody another 24 km west, to a vast new
land grant in the newly incorporated city of Vancouver. The recently-logged West Side of Vancouver was entirely
within the companys grant, while the shattered and recovering parts of Granville now constituted the East End.
The move bifurcated the community, an event that is manifest to this day in wealth on the West Side, poverty on
the East, and street misalignments in the middle.

Describing the many ways in which the CPR and its later competitors changed the landscape, demographics,
resource exploitation, economy, and townsites still merely scrapes the surface. Behind the CPR was not only a
political network but also a dense web of interlocked commercial and financial boards. Directors of the CPR also
sat on the boards of the Royal Bank, Dominion Bridge, Dominion Iron and Steel, and international oil companies
(see Section 8.3). Donald Smith (later styled Lord Strathcona and Mount Royal) was not only president of the
Bank of Montreal but an influential Conservative Member of Parliament for Montreal. The intersection of Hast-
 2.9 THE RAILWAY 69

ings and Granville Streets in Vancouver provide a physical manifestation of the extent of this influence. On one
corner, there was the Bank of Montreal, opposite it the Bank of Commerce, across Granville there were the offices
of the federal government, and just down the hill facing the water was (and is) the CPR station itself.

Key Points

The Canadian Pacific Railway was both a unifying and divisive instrument of Canadian expansion.
The decision to change to a southern route created hardships in the north-central plains.
The CPR operated as a railway and construction company, as well as a land dealer and hotel opera-
tor. It was, as well, closely linked to the Bank of Montreal and so was integrated with many other
corporations.
The choice of routes had significant impacts on the West Coast, where Vancouver was eventually
selected as the site for the terminus, leaving both Port Moody and Victoria disappointed.

Attributions
Figure 2.16
Land ticket by Will Jahns is in the public domain.

Figure 2.17
Str P8 [Water Street looking east] (Reference Code: AM54-S4-: Str P8) by City of Vancouver Archives is in
the public domain.
 2.10 The North

At the heart of imperial expansion is the need to redraw maps, to impose new patterns of communication, and
to reconfigure economic orders to fit the new paradigm. Canada through more than two centuries of French
and then British colonial effort was not a truly northern entity. It was an inland colony that extended down the
throat of the St. Lawrence River and into the gut of the continent along the Great Lakes. It related to the rest of
North America through river systems that flowed into the Great Lakes and the Laurentian system. It extended no
further north, in political terms, than the Canadian Shield and the height of land. Leaping over that barrier into the
Ruperts Land watershed was a significant task, part of which it accomplished through the North West Companys
trade network in the West before 1821. However, from 1821 (and including the merger of the NWC with the Lon-
don-based HBC), Canadian influence in the West was modest. The annexing of Ruperts Land in 1869-70 flagged
a movement beyond the old colonial boundaries, but these efforts primarily concentrated on Manitoba and what
would become the Prairie provinces. The expansion into the North held out less drama but it was no less porten-
tous.

The North in the Late 19th Century

At the time of Confederation, the North probably contained significantly fewer human beings than it had two (or
even just one) hundred years earlier. The boreal forest regions held large populations of larger mammals deer,
moose, and woodland caribou, for example on which a human population could survive, but the fur trade with
Europeans and Canadians reduced mammal numbers to very low levels in the parkland or prairie regions. Fishing
remained a reliable economic activity for subsistence communities, but the wherewithal for trade with Euro-Cana-
dian companies was not as great as it once was.

Much of the northern human population west of Hudson Bay fell into two linguistic/cultural groups. Across the
middle of the region and into the north and far west (the Yukon), Athapaskan-speakers dominated. The Dunne-za
(aka: Beaver), Chipewyan, and Dene (aka: Slavey) held much of the southern part of this zone, while the T ch
(aka: Tlicho, Dogrib) dominated in the north and west of the Mackenzie River. To the east and hugging the North
Saskatchewan River were the Cree, along with the relative newcomers, the Mtis. European numbers were small,
1
made up of traders, missionaries, and a handful of others.

To the south and east of Hudson Bay (still very much to the north of Old Canada) were Cree and Innu (aka: Mon-

1. Donald Wetherell and Irene R.A. Kmet, Albertas North: A History, 1890-1950 (Edmonton: University of Alberta Press, 2000), 4-5.

70
 2.10 THE NORTH 71

tagnais) communities which had experienced extensive contact with the French and later the British through the
fur trades emanating from Montreal and Quebec on the one hand, and HBC forts like Moose Factory on the other.

Still further north, along the Arctic and around both lips of the mouth of Hudson Bay were large Inuit populations.
Limited contact with Europeans, down to the late 19th century, had insulated the Inuit from some of the worst
effects of exotic diseases. And while metal imports had found their way into the Inuit toolbox, life as a whole had
not (as yet) been overhauled.

Infrastructural Change
The story of the Prairie peoples armed resistance in 1885 invariably points to the significance of the CPR in
delivering the telling blow of Canadian military power. What is often overlooked is the role played by steamboats
on the Saskatchewan River. Although northern rivers iced up annually, they were the principal highways of the
region in the spring and summer months and beyond. The potential of steamboat and paddlewheeler technology on
these corridors was never fully tested. The rapid expansion of rail systems saw to that. River shipping nevertheless
marks an important transition from the old York Express corridor of river and lake transportation, which oriented
northern trade across the middle of what is now Western Canada to Hudson Bay and then to Europe, to one that
was more southern-looking.

Figure 2.18 Sandbars and freeze-ups were obstacles to river

traffic across the northern plains, but steamers persisted for years.
The Pas in 1929.

Perhaps this transition is most evident in Manitoba. In the years before Confederation, the Red River settlement
was the metropolis of a trading network that extended from what is now North Dakota to York Factory on Hudson
Bay. The chains of rivers and lakes oriented trade from the warmer semi-agricultural highlands of the Selkirk set-
tlement to the entrept and gateway to Europe in the north. After 1912 and north of the 49th parallel, all
of this was contained within the provincial boundaries of Manitoba. The arrival of Canada in 1870 meant that
Winnipeg would shift its view from the north to the southeast. Instead of prairie wheat finding an outlet in the
Arctic, it was pulled to Canada. Instead of Churchill emerging as a major centre of transshipment, Thunder Bay
2
(aka: Port Arthur and Fort William) did so instead.

A similar pattern had emerged, before 1900, in what was then the District of Athabaska (called Northern Alberta
since 1905). In the 1880s, steam-powered shipping was introduced to Athabasca River and Lake with the effect
of shifting trade and population into that corridor. Stretching as far north as Great Slave Lake and the Mackenzie
River, this network ensured the emergence of Edmonton as the key economic node in the northwestern prairies.
This region, too, was being incorporated into an economic system based in the Laurentian heartland of Canada.

2. In the 1870s and 80s there was a ferocious political and physical battle between Manitobans and Ontarians regarding the boundary between
the two provinces. The epicentre of the dispute was the town of Rat Portage (aka: Kenora), where both provinces established a jail and a
courthouse and sent in their own officials (who then fell to fighting one another). What was at stake was the gold and other mineral reserves
of the region. Needless to say, Manitoba lost this battle and thus any hope of direct access to the Great Lakes.
 72 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Cultural Changes
The events of 1885 resulted in a substantial re-migration of Mtis into the northern-Northwest. Progressively dis-
placed in many instances systematically so by the incoming Canadian populations, the Mtis found their
economic niche was beginning to disappear. The bison hunt was at an end, provisioning forts was no longer a
sustainable business for more than a few, and the freighting industry that had made such good use of the Red
River cart and the Mtis ox teams was evaporating. The new steam-age transportation technology first cut them
out of the southern plains and then, with extensions to the northern plains by branch lines even before 1900, the
Mtis were driven north of Edmonton and Saskatoon into the boreal forests. This movement, of course, had con-
sequences for the Athapaskan-speakers of the central-north, whose resource base was now doubly strained. At
Fort Chipewyan, for example, the Mtis and the Chipewyan generally did not mix (nor did the French-speaking
and Catholic Mtis have much to do with the English-speaking and Anglican merchant class which was, to make
3
matters more complex, a socio-economic barrier as well). Elsewhere in the Northwest there were many instances
where the Mtis married and/or assimilated into Aboriginal societies and re-configured their self-identity as Dene
or Dunne-za.

The presence of missionaries from the mid-19th century across much of the sub-Arctic suggests cultural change
was underway. Certainly cultural or at least spiritual assimilation was the missionaries goal in these years, not ser-
vice to communities or some kind of administrative interface. If they were educators, they were educators within
a Euro-Canadian Christian tradition. In this respect, at least, the role of missionaries had not changed much since
the days of the Jesuits in Wendake (aka: Huronia) in the 17th century. Scholars like Kerry Abel have questioned
the extent to which the missionary message in the North was persuasive. Certainly there were different levels of
exposure to the Christian doctrine, and Aboriginal bands that gathered in trading post communities were more at
risk of proselytization than the more remote and nomadic peoples. And there was, to be sure, initial curiosity and
even enthusiasm for the missionary message. By 1900, however, that early interest had diminished and Christian-
ity was either peripheral or hybridized into a syncretic belief system among Aboriginal converts.

As the representatives of Euro-Canadian society in these communities, the missionaries had a special role to play.
They monitored social and economic change and reported to Central Canada as conditions shifted. It has been
suggested that there is a fairly consistent trend in Canadian history that sees the arrival of traders followed by mis-
sionaries, and then military or police power of some kind: commerce, Christ, and cops. This pattern is certainly
evident across the North as the missionaries increasingly called upon the state to provide NWMP/RCMP backup
from the 1890s-1930s.

Figure 2.19 Chipewyan people at Churchill, along with the ruins

of the old fort battery, August 1926.

3. Ibid., 6-7.
 2.10 THE NORTH 73

Economic and Demographic Change

The fur trade, however, sustained and built an economic bond between the Inuit and Euro-Canadians. As was the
case in other fur trade frontiers in North America, pressure to hunt commercial species meant that Inuit attention
was drawn away from subsistence hunting. Dependency grew as a result. When demand for luxury products like
furs collapsed in the 1930s, many of the Inuit fur-hunting communities were pitched into poverty and hardship.

The 1920s had witnessed a boom in the fur-trade tied to the brief flicker of an international luxury market aimed
at the growing middle class in Europe and the Americas. This was good news for Native trappers and traders
who were being paid much higher prices for more kinds of animals than was the case even 20 years before. In
part this was driven by the arrival in 1901 of the Parisian Revillon Frres fur trading company. Prices went up
as Revillon went toe-to-toe with the local HBC traders. This situation, of course, invited growing competition
from non-Native trappers and hunters, some of them long-residents in the region by now. The Innu of Labrador,
for example, found themselves pushed further and further inland in the 1920s, trying to eke out an existence now
based almost entirely on the trade in furs. The possibility of fishing and hunting for food was, by this point, so
reduced that they had no option but to adopt a European diet and factory-produced Euro-Canadian clothing made
4
available through the trade in furs.

Figure 2.20 A supply runner, Komatik, arrives at a Revillon

Frres post on Wakeham Bay, QC, 1928.

European, Canadian, and American intrusions into the North increased as the 19th century was drawing to a close.
American whaling fleets began working the Beaufort Sea in the western Arctic and British whalers intensified
their efforts in the eastern Arctic. Inuit people found economic opportunities with the fleets but they also found
alcohol, sexually transmitted diseases, smallpox, and other exotic illnesses. The Beaufort ports were, according to
one source, the scene of unprecedented debauchery and the Sadlermuit of Southampton Island were wiped out
5
by smallpox. The difficulty of disease transmission across great distances between relatively small numbers of
hosts no doubt limited the impact of any one epidemic like smallpox or measles; the increase in foreign shipping
along the coastline mitigated the advantages of isolation. The original Inuvialuit people of the Yukon shore of the
Beaufort Sea were effectively extinct by 1920. Even the arrival of the RCMP in 1895 could do little to stabilize,
let alone reverse this trend. Changes in womens fashions (which effectively put an end to the whale-bone corset)
6
and the shift from whale oil to mineral oil did, however, cool the heat of change in some parts of the Arctic.

The front on which the colonization of the indigenous economy was being fought in the Yukon shifted south in
1896. At that time gold was discovered at Bonanza Creek. Canadian responses included an increased RCMP pres-
ence, but tactics devised to prevent lawlessness were ill-suited to the protection of Aboriginal interests. As was the
case in the Cariboo 40 years earlier, Aboriginal fishing sites were seized and river ecosystems compromised by

4. Lynne D. Fitzhugh, The Labradorians: Voices from the Land of Cain (St. Johns: Breakwater, 1999), 375.
5. Donald Purich, The Inuit and Their Land: The Story of Nunavut (Toronto: James Lorimer & Company, 1992), 30.
6. Olive Dickason, Canadas First Nations: A History of Founding Peoples from Earliest Times, 3rd edition (Don Mills: Oxford University
Press, 2002), 361-2.
 74 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

foreign miners. The RCMP did address Aboriginal concerns regarding the newcomers use of poison on traplines,
but they also elected to enforce the regulation of hunting among First Nations.

Being part of Canada meant many things in this context. It meant a shift from localized subsistence economies,
which depended on a mobile population able to strike out in a timely way to pursue migratory herds, spawning
fish, briefly available plants, and opportunities to trade with neighbours. In its place a new infrastructure of com-
merce and human intercourse arrived via steam-powered vessels. Its personnel included representatives of alien
belief-systems (some of which were locked in competition), law enforcement officers whose laws were them-
selves exotic and seemingly arbitrary, and a commercial/administrative environment which increasingly encour-
aged permanent settlement in fixed communities. Ottawa formally took on responsibility for northern populations
in 1924 when the Indian Act was amended to include the Inuit. The Inuit, however, were not viewed as Indians
7
and so fell between the administrative cracks.

The Race to the Pole

The first three decades after Confederation were marked by an international fascination with the polar region. Sci-
entific missions were the order of the day, although Canada did not engage in this particular stampede. The race
to the North Pole was one aspect of this enterprise, one that set international teams against one another in highly
publicized and popularized adventures. Charting the Northwest Passage was another feature of this phenomenon.
All of this activity increased traffic in the region and increased the likelihood of Inuit exposure to disease vectors.
In also facilitated the movement of Inuit people themselves, with Greenland Inuit reputedly appearing on both
8
Ellesmere and Baffin Islands.

To substantiate Canadian claims to sovereignty in the region and to counter foreign incursions, Ottawa established
several missions whose task it was to make an official claim on the northern islands and seas. American and Euro-
pean opposition to these claims obliged still further investment in expeditions and regular patrols. Every one of
these efforts brought Canada more regularly into contact with the Indigenous peoples of the region. At the same
time, Canada viewed the Inuit with a curious ambivalence. The Inuit were international they were to be found
in American and Danish territories as well as Canadian and there were few opportunities to integrate them into
the growing southern economy before the mid-20th century.

Key Points

At the time of Confederation the North was of limited interest to Canada.

The regions population was diverse but vulnerable. Disease and economic dislocation were the
main and ongoing threats.
The arrival of steam-powered shipping throughout the region increased integration into the continen-
tal and global economy, while exposing populations to new disease vectors.
Population movements accelerated, as did missionary efforts to effect cultural change.

7. Ibid., 36-7.
8. Ibid., 32.
 2.10 THE NORTH 75

The most dramatic short-term impact on the region arrived with the Yukon gold rush and the Beau-
fort Sea whaling industry. Increased activity in the fur trade in the 1920s also had significant conse-
quences.
Canadian territorial and sovereignty issues increased in the early 20th century, resulting in a greater
state presence.

Attributions
Figure 2.18
Steamer Trip on Saskatchewan River, The Pas, Man. [Str. David N. Winton]. July 1929 (Online MIKAN
no.3393978) by Canada. Dept. of Mines and Technical Surveys / Library and Archives Canada / PA-014005 is
in the public domain.

Figure 2.19
Chipewyan indian, and old Chipewyan woman, Churchill; Views of old battery, Churchill Harbour (Online
MIKAN no.4848722) by Department of Indian and Northern Affairs Canada / Library and Archives Canada,
Accession 1974-366 is in the public domain.

Figure 2.20
(Hudson Strait Expedition). Komatik with supplies at Revillon Frres post (Online MIKAN no.3223225) by
Library and Archives Canada / PA-055573 is in the public domain.
 2.11 The Provincial Rights Movement

The last place one might expect to find dissent within the new federation is Ontario. After all, Ontarian politicians
had done the lions share of crafting the federal constitution: they had successfully annexed the West, the capital
was located in Ontario (which is to say, not in Montreal the largest city in the country and thus three
provinces away from Nova Scotia), and the first two Prime Ministers (Macdonald and Mackenzie) were Ontari-
ans. Of the first three Premiers of Ontario after 1867, two were Macdonald stalwarts and one Oliver Mowat
(1820-1903) was himself a father of Confederation. Despite all of this, or perhaps because of it, Ontario
emerged as the leading force in favour of limiting federal strength and empowering the provinces.

The Genesis of Confederation

In order to understand how Canadian federalism adjusted in these years, it is necessary to understand what was
at its heart. Five British North American colonies considered uniting in a federal form, two walked away from
the table leaving Canada (one colony that would soon become two), Nova Scotia, and New Brunswick. All three
signed on and then the largest underwent the constitutional equivalent of cellular fission, creating Ontario and
Quebec. Keep in mind that neither Canada West (Ontario) nor Canada East (Quebec) had their own legislatures,
let alone their own governments. What they did have was separate votes. Half of the Canadian assembly (the
Anglo-Protestant half) then voted overwhelmingly for federation; the other half (the largely Franco-Catholic half)
voted for it but with less enthusiasm. What they were implicitly voting for was the creation of the two central
Canadian provinces. Ontarians were delighted to be freed of what they called the millstone of Canada East;
popular opinion regarded the old Province of Canada as a parasitical relationship in which the down-river Canadi-
1
ans fleeced the majority who lived up-river. For Quebec, federation meant relief from the threat of interference
with culture, language, and religion from the Orangemen of Ontario.

This is clearly complicated: two distinct colonies were united with two others that voted themselves into exis-
tence. Soon after, they were joined by another two volunteers (PEI and BC) and one that bargained its way into
existence through a federal act of legislation (Manitoba). In other words, the provinces were not created equally.
The question that arises here, then, is this: were the provinces signatories to a pact, or were they the product of a
legislative act (that is, the BNA Act)?

What John A. Macdonald wanted at the outset was a legislative union and unitary state. The federal model was

1. Robert C. Vipond, Constitutional Policy an the Legacy of the Provincial Rights Movement in Canada, Canadian Journal of Political Sci-
ence, vol. 18, issue 2 (1985): 270.

76
 2.11 THE PROVINCIAL RIGHTS MOVEMENT 77

based in no small measure on the American system, in which the states were semi-autonomous bodies with an
over-arching central government in Washington, DC. The unitary model to which Macdonald was drawn was, of
course, that of the United Kingdom. His logic was, moreover, very sound. In the face of American aggression
what was needed was a strong central state to defend the Dominion; in an uncertain economic world a single
government would be more efficient and less expensive than a crop of provinces. Any hope of expanding across
the Northwest would be better realized by one administration with a unified vision than a consortium seeking
2
something like consensus. One of Macdonalds biographers maintains that the Conservative leader aimed for a
3
genuine federal system, warts and all, which is what he got. Nevertheless, there were times when one could argue
that Macdonalds behaviour as prime minister suggests that he was carrying on as though he were at the head of a
unitary state.

The compromise in 1867 was a federal union with a strong central government. Each province was to have exclu-
sive control over local affairs and Ottawa would deal with issues of national consequence. The remaining ques-
tion, of course, was this: where to draw the line between the two?

POGG
The BNA Act includes a clause regarding residual or residuary powers. That is, it covers everything either not
itemized or as yet not imagined in the constitutional division of authority. Sections 91 to 95 deal with the division
of powers and they begin with this passage in Section 91:

It shall be lawful for the Queen, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate and House of Commons, to make
Laws for the Peace, Order, and good Government of Canada, in relation to all Matters not coming within the Classes of
4
Subjects by this Act assigned exclusively to the Legislatures of the Provinces.

Everything not allocated to the provinces would be the jurisdiction of Ottawa. And Peace, Order, and good
Government (referred to by scholars, politicians and commentators as POGG) could cover anything and every-
thing. The division of powers, moreover, was not absolutely clear: there were overlaps and things were a bit messy
with regard to immigration. In short, there remained questions as to which level of government had a superior
claim in grey areas, and the extent of federal residual powers in general. None of this addressed the relative sov-
ereignty of the provinces the consenting participants in the constitutional relationship. Who would decide and
how would they do so?

Disallowance
To the leading figures in the Confederation debates and in the provincial legislatures after 1867, the answer was
clear: Confederation was a product of the provinces. Some of their peers, such as Macdonald, could reply: if
Ottawa is a level of government generated by the provinces, then surely it should have oversight? The BNA Act
gave substance to this argument in the form of disallowance. This was an effective veto held by Ottawa that could
be used to overturn provincial legislation. It was, however, not something to be used recklessly. Macdonald was
5
very deliberate in his efforts to define the boundaries of disallowance. Clearly anything that was outside of the

2. Ibid.: 271.
3. Ged Martin, John A. Macdonald: Canadas First Prime Minister (Toronto: Dundurn, 2013), 90-100.
4. Section 91 of the British North America Act, 1867.
5. Vipond, Constitutional Policy, 275-6.
 78 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

constitutionally-defined powers of the provinces was fair game, but there was far more that remained unantici-
pated or ambiguous. From 1867-73, Macdonalds approach was to ameliorate differences of opinion by liaising
directly with provincial Premiers. Alexander Mackenzies position was similar. After 1878, upon Macdonalds
return, Ottawa was more willing to push back with the veto. Historians attribute this change in direction to a num-
ber of factors, including the establishment of several genuinely national institutions. The NWMP (1873) and the
National Policy (1878) were two; there was also the Post Office Department (1867), the Supreme Court (1875),
the national penitentiary system (effectively in place by 1875), and the emergence of a more stable and permanent
6
national political party system that coalesced around the Conservatives and the Liberals. Commitment to build-
ing a national railway was, in this context, another string to Canadas bow another facet of a growing national
infrastructure. The Bank of Canada would not appear until 1935 and, until then, the Treasury commissioned the
commercial Bank of Montreal to print currency an arrangement that gave the Treasury a presence of sorts on
every Main Street. As Ottawas reach extended across provincial boundaries via these institutions and agencies,
so too did its interests. The lines between provinces and Ottawa were increasingly blurred.

The mechanism for vetoing provincial legislation arose from an almost identical relationship between Ottawa and
Westminster. If legislation proposed in the Canadian House of Commons passed third reading and was approved
by the Senate, it was still within the authority of the governor general to refuse to sign it into law and to send it on
to England for further discussion by the British Cabinet. In this way, Britain still the imperial centre could
disallow or veto Canadian federal laws. It made some sense to mirror this relationship with the provinces: just as
the governor general was an imperial appointment, the lieutenant-governor was Ottawas. If provincial legislation
offended federal sensibilities, the provinces lieutenant-governor would refuse to sign it, and would send it on to
Ottawa for consideration. The Cabinet would then decide how to proceed. One option was to simply neglect the
proposed legislation for a year and allow it to die from administrative inertia.

From 1867-1873, Macdonalds government exercised their ability to withhold assent on 16 of 24 occasions.
Mackenzies Liberals also vetoed provincial legislation. Provinces had the option of reintroducing and passing
the legislation repeatedly it became the convention that passing a bill three times at the provincial level would
force Ottawa to approve it but that depended often on the durability of a provincial administration or on the
existence of all-party support for the initiative at the provincial level. The provinces, however, maintained that the
courts were the proper place to settle jurisdictional disputes, not the federal Cabinet (which, clearly, had a stake in
7
the outcome). It was this avenue that the premiers collectively and individually opted to pursue.

The premiers could reach consensus on this subject in part because, at the time, most of them were Liberals.
The first 30 years of Confederation rewarded the Conservatives with office in Ottawa for all but five years the
Mackenzie administration of 1873-78. Liberal weakness at the federal level was countered with strength in the
provinces (although not in British Columbia, where until 1903 politicians took pains to avoid Conservative
or Liberal banners so as to be more free to criticize whatever regime was in power nationally). And, of course,
they had all experienced the inconvenience (not to say insult) of having their legislation disallowed.

Appealing to the Supreme Court of Canada was something of a non-starter. The provinces therefore appealed
to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in England. This was an effective way of entrenching in law

6. Jonathan Swainger, The Canadian Department of Justice and the Completion of Confederation, 1867-78 (Vancouver: University of British
Columbia Press, 2000), 4-6.
7. Peter Russell, Constitutional Odyssey: Can Canadians Become a Sovereign People?, 3rd ed. (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2004),
37-9.
 2.11 THE PROVINCIAL RIGHTS MOVEMENT 79

though not in the constitution the notion of provincial rights. By the 1890s, the principle of co-equal levels of
government had been established. Under Wilfrid Laurier (an advocate of provincial rights), after 1896, the issue
ceased to carry the kind of divisive power it once had.

Key Points

The ways in which the colonies joined the federation varied, creating uncertainty as to the relative
status of Ottawa and the provinces. The question repeatedly arose as to whether there was a senior
level of government in Confederation.
The POGG clause indicates that residual powers belong to Ottawa but, because these could not be
clearly defined, it provoked decades of disagreement.
Ottawas power of disallowance was challenged by the Provincial Rights movement, championed by
Ontarios Conservative government under Oliver Mowat.
Appeals to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in England gradually resolved the issue in
favour of provincial rights.
 2.12 The Judicial System of Post-Confederation Canada

JONATHAN SWAINGER, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, UNIVERSITY OF NORTHERN BRITISH COLUMBIA

Canadas judicial system that is its system of federal, provincial, and territorial courts is a product of the
nations colonial history, the ideas of those individuals responsible for the British North America Act, 1867, and
subsequent alterations, additions, and refinements designed to meet the nations evolving needs. Owing to the
division of powers established in 1867, both the federal and provincial governments occupy a direct role in shap-
ing the nations court system. Section 92 (14) of the BNA Act established provincial responsibility for the consti-
tution, maintenance, and organization of provincial courts, both of civil and criminal jurisdiction, and including
1
procedure in civil matters in those courts. Because of the desire to maintain control over the quality of judges
and patronage opportunities for prestigious judicial positions on the nations most senior courts, Section 96 of the
constitution provided the federal government with the authority to appoint judges to the provincial superior courts
that is the superior and appeal courts in each province or territory that are descendants of colonial era courts
2
and the English common law courts. As a consequence, in each province or territory, there exists a provincially-
created court system in which the lower courts where the vast majority of the nations legal business occurs
are administered by provincially appointed judges. In that same province the superior courts, which hear trials
involving serious criminal offences, divorce petitions, civil suits involving amounts above a specified limit, and
appeals from the provinces lower courts, are supervised by federally appointed judges.

For most of the nations first century, complaints about sitting judges were handled either through the provincial
attorney generals offices or through the Department of Justice in Ottawa, depending on which governmental
3
level had been responsible for the initial appointment. At the federal level, concerns about the effectiveness of
4
such methods eventually led to the creation of the Canadian Judicial Council in 1971. Chaired by the chief jus-
tice of the Canadian Supreme Court, the Council is composed of the chief justices and associate chief justices
of Canadas superior courts, the senior judges of the territorial courts, and the chief justice of the Court Martial
Appeal Court of Canada. In these assessments the Council relies upon its Ethical Principles for Judges as one
measure of whether a judge has acted inappropriately. Historically, judges have been rarely removed from the

1. Canada, Constitution Act, 1867, s.92(14).

2. On the culture of judicial patronage, see Jonathan Swainger, "Judicial Scandal and the Culture of Patronage in Early Confederation,
1867-78," in Jim Phillips, R. Roy McMurtry, and John T. Saywell, Essays in the History of Canadian Law A Tribute to Peter N. Oliver
(Toronto: Osgoode Society for Canadian Legal History, 2008): 222-56.
3. See Jonathan Swainger, "A Bench in Disarray: The Quebec Judiciary and the Federal Department of Justice, 1867-1878," Les Cahier de
Droit, vol.34, no.1 (March 1993): 59-91.
4. On the Canadian Judicial Council, see [Link]

80
 2.12 THE JUDICIAL SYSTEM OF POST-CONFEDERATION CANADA 81

bench. Nonetheless, the Council may forward a recommendation to the federal minister of justice who, in turn,
5
requires approval from the House of Commons and Senate before a judge can be removed. At the provincial
level, complaints are managed in various ways according to provincial statute but typically a provincial judicial
council investigates allegations before forwarding a recommendation to the government of the day. While all fed-
erally appointed judges are eligible to hold their positions until the age of 75, some provincially or territorially
appointed judges remain on the bench until age 70.

Considerably smaller than the provincial court system, the nations federal court system includes the Federal
Court, the Federal Court of Appeal, and the Supreme Court of Canada and a number of specialized courts deal-
6
ing with tax issues and appeals from the nations military court system. While the superior courts in the provinces
have jurisdiction over most issues, only those concerns that are specified in legislation as being a federal matter
can be heard in federal courts. Specifically, this includes disputes between the provinces and territories, disputes
between the provinces or territories and the federal government, cases involving intellectual property, questions
concerning citizenship, and cases in which a crown corporation or a federal department of state is involved.

At the time of Confederation and as a legacy of Canadas colonial relationship with Great Britain, it was still pos-
7
sible to pursue a case to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council (JCPC) in England. Although Canadian
legislators attempted to end these appeals when the Supreme Court of Canada was created in 1875, it was not until
the passage of the Statute of Westminster in 1931 and a series of judicial rulings in Canada and England, that the
path was cleared for Canadas Parliament to abolish these appeals in 1949. The final Canadian case to the JCPC
was not resolved until 1960.

Key Points

The Canadian judicial system is an essential part of the structure of government, comprised of many
parts.
Its main features are derived from the pre-Confederation colonial systems and reflect subsequent
modifications arising from the original British North America Act, along with changes negotiated
between the provinces and Ottawa.
Although provinces are not junior to Ottawa in the BNA Act, nor in the Canada Act, the provincial
courts are junior to the federal courts.
The complex web of relations between the lower and higher provincial courts, the federal courts, and
the federal government is a mechanism for resolving legal disputes and appeals, as well as differ-
ences between the various levels of government.

5. See William Kaplan, Bad Judgment: The Case of Mr. Justice Leo A. Landreville (Toronto: The Osgoode Society for Canadian Legal History,
1996).
6. See James G. Snell and Frederick Vaughn, The Supreme Court of Canada: History of the Institution (Toronto: University of Toronto Press,
1985); Ian Bushnell, The Captive Court: A Study of the Supreme Court of Canada (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queen's University Press,
1992); and Ian Bushnell, The Federal Court of Canada: A History, 1875-1992 (Toronto: The Osgoode Society for Canadian Legal History,
1997).
7. John T. Saywell, The Lawmakers: Judicial Power and the Shaping of Canadian Federalism (Toronto: The Osgoode Society for Canadian
Legal History, 2002) and Frederick Vaughn, Viscount Haldane: The Wicked Step-father of the Canadian Constitution (Toronto: The Osgoode
Society for Canadian Legal History, 2010).
2.13 The Other Dominion

Figure 2.21 Newfoundland shifted from British

sterling. which linked it more closely to West Indian
currencies, to the North American dollars and cents.
Its economy continued to rely heavily on the cod
fishery.

The decision of Newfoundland to stay out of Confederation in the 1869 election was different in tone from PEIs
brief demur. The Islanders were preoccupied with land issues bound up in what was called the Escheat Move-
ment and Canada offered little in the way of solutions. Four years later, PEI was heavily in debt from a calami-
tous railway-building exercise and only slightly closer to settling the tenant-landlord issue; Canada now came
forward with a solution to both problems, and PEIs disinterest was quickly reversed.

By contrast, Newfoundlanders rebuffed the Canadian project entirely. Canadas political issues the stalemate in
Parliament, the need to expand westward for more farmland, language and religion, and fear of an American or
Fenian invasion were not just uninteresting to Newfoundlanders, these issues appalled them. Canada was not a
place you should run to, it was a place you should run from. The depth of Newfoundland feeling on this score was
tested repeatedly: the colony had to face down the sort of debt that turned Islanders heads, international diplo-
macy and threats to security, and divisive internal debates over imperial-versus-colonial loyalties. Newfoundlan-
ders, however, resisted the temptation to join the colonial alliance on the mainland.

A Divided Colony
By the late 1860s, Newfoundland was made up of several parts. The apparent unity of the economy based
heavily on fisheries (in which every outport, St. Johns included, participated) and timber was not enough
to ensure social or political harmony. There were essentially three regions to Newfoundland: Labrador on the
mainland, the French (or West) Shore, and the rest. In addition, the English-speaking part of the colony was
divided between Protestants (mostly Anglicans and Methodists, but also including Congregationalists and Pres-
byterians) and Catholics (overwhelmingly Irish). Labrador was sparsely settled by Europeans and was principally

82
 2.13 THE OTHER DOMINION 83

home to Inuit and Innu (aka: Naskapi and Montagnais), many of whom were being missionized by the Mora-
vian Brethren who had no presence on Newfoundland proper. These various social divisions preoccupied local
politicians and clergymen while the fisheries and seagoing trade continued to provide an irregular and unreliable
income for much of the population.

Self-sufficiency in the outports was challenged by a volatile marketplace for Newfoundlands exports. Continued
colonial status was meant to ensure a position within British Atlantic rim commerce. It did not always do so. Nor
would the cod fishery or the whale pods always cooperate. Unemployment stalked the villages of the colony from
the mid-19th century to 1914 and promoted emigration. The colonys communities were caught in an economic
trap: large numbers of personnel were needed for three to four months every year to work the fisheries effectively.
During the remaining eight to nine months, most were surplus to requirements. Seasonally, and notwithstand-
ing pack ice and absent fish, there was work for all. Beyond that, however, there was hardship. Scaling back the
population overall would mean depleting the fisheries of its essential labour force. Providing relief of some kind
which the state and the churches did for years only encouraged too many people to stay and face cyclical
underemployment.

It was for these reasons unreliable cod behaviour, a narrow window for economic activity, and potentially
appalling North Atlantic weather that Newfoundlanders pursued a variety of economic alternatives, and did
so aggressively. Mining the sea for codfish was a way of doing more of the same and with greater intensity. This
strategy predictably produced gluts on the market and falling prices. Another response was to attack the seal nurs-
eries and build an export economy there as well. Other fish types and lobsters were added as a way to break out
of the monoculture staple economy of cod. Improvements in fish product processing were pursued in the 1880s
and 1890s, as were a succession of trade treaties with the United States that would allow Newfoundland products
freer entry into the American marketplace.

The engagement of the churches with economic and political issues manifested itself in a variety of ways. Unem-
ployment was a parish and congregation matter as well as a state matter. Political parties in the 1860s, with a
few exceptions, identified with Protestant or Catholic interests in a manner that was inevitably divisive. Although
this feature of Newfoundland politics lost its sharp edge in the 1870s, it did not go away. The Harbour Grace
Affray of 1883 saw Orange Lodge Protestants and Catholic neighbours come to blows. Guns were fired, and five
men (four Protestants and one Catholic) were killed, and more than a dozen wounded. The trials and debates that
followed served to deepen sectarian division across the floor of the Legislature and the colony. Fears grew that
Harbour Grace would be followed by larger and widespread acts of sectarian violence.

In this context, the accomplishments of Newfoundlands leadership in the field of education is almost astonishing.
Uniquely, Newfoundland committed to a denominational education system beginning in 1876. Isolated ports
might have one, two, or even three denominations, each of which demanded recognition and funding for a school.
Administering them from St. Johns would be highly problematic and expensive, so authority devolved to denom-
inational school boards at the local level. This, too, was unique. Funding was provided on a per capita basis,
which set up some local competition between the religious communities. By the 1890s, a secondary school system
was emerging that was coordinated from the colonial capital and included a shared curriculum. Common exams
ensured that outcomes were comparable (if not always equal) across denominations.

In part, this accommodation of religious interests in education was possible because of Harbour Grace. As one
historian observed, the shock that followed the Harbour Grace encounter was not simply a religion-oriented reac-
 84 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

tion. It was a recognition that Englishmen had not killed Irishmen; nor was it Catholics and Protestants killing one
1
another. Newfoundlanders were killing fellow Newfoundlanders for no good reason. Newfoundlanders turned
2
away from that precipice, which is why 1886 must be regarded as a turning point in Newfoundland history.

Figure 2.22 A circa 1883 depiction of the Newfoundland seal

hunt. Source: [Link] & M. Harvey, Newfoundland, the Oldest
British Colony (1883).

Colonial Crises, 1880-1914

Perhaps more than most colonies, Newfoundland was regularly rocked by catastrophes. Many of these arose from
a combination of weather and the local economys dependence on resources drawn from the sea. Storms battered
outports, ice packs teeming with seals promised some wealth and invited disaster, and whole fleets could be lost
at sea. St. Johns one of the busiest of the Atlantic ports was always vulnerable to epidemic diseases. 1892
and 1893 witnessed a mix of bad news that included diphtheria, the razing of St. Johns by fire which left 12,000
homeless, and the loss of two dozen Trinity Bay sealers on the ice. In 1894, the two commercial banks in New-
foundland collapsed. These bankruptcies left a vacuum that was subsequently filled by Canadian chartered banks,
a change that subordinated Newfoundland to Canadian monetary policies. While the fisheries regularly claimed
lives it was the seal hunt that would continue to serve up death on a large scale: 48 more sealers would perish of
exposure in 1898, and in 1914, 78 more died of exposure and drowning.

Figure 2.23 The shell of St. Johns Anglican Cathedral after the
1892 fire.

Economic and foreign relations crises, too, seemed to roll across the colony on a regular basis. These were
addressed in very different ways.

The Newfoundland Railway

Canada mythologizes the construction of a railway as an act of nation-building; Newfoundlanders saw it as an
economic policy, plain and simple. By the mid-19th century it was clear that the colony contained large stands of
commercially-viable timber, and there was tremendous optimism as regards the mining industry as well. Clear-
ing out forests could be followed up with agricultural settlements inland: Newfoundlanders were looking at their
very own farming frontier. It was even suggested in the enthusiasm of the moment that Newfoundland might soon

1. Frederick W. Rowe, A History of Newfoundland and Labrador (Toronto: McGraw-Hill, 1980), 300.
2. Ibid.
 2.13 THE OTHER DOMINION 85
3
become an exporter of livestock to England. All of this also implied the establishment of sufficient industrial
capacity to produce at least some elements of the infrastructure, even if that was only wooden ties and gravel. Iron
ore mining was initiated on Bell Island in Conception Bay in 1895 but steel production took place elsewhere. A
survey of the route would provide the means to extend the colonial governments influence over land sales from
St. Johns to the edge of the French Shore. All of this was cast in a frame much like the Canadian National Policy,
4
called in the case of Newfoundland the Policy of Progress.

As with the CPR, massive land grants were given to the contractor to subsidize the expense of construction. Even
so, thanks to the railway, by 1896 St. Johns was $9 million in debt. The colonial regime teetered on the brink of
bankruptcy and was only pulled back by a further and rather desperate deal with the railway contractor and oper-
ator, Robert Gillespie Reid (1842-1908). Even the British government felt that Newfoundland was selling off the
proverbial silverware to achieve some stability. The end result, however, was a line that curled from the Avalon
Peninsula around the north of the colony and down the southwest coast to a terminus that connected to shipping
lines to Canada. Trade between the two colonies increased but, rather than draw them closer together, it served
to give Newfoundlanders sufficient confidence that they did not need to seek, at this time, economic security in
Confederation. In some respects, they already had it. The Canadianization of Newfoundlands monetary system
was a significant step towards a loss of sovereignty to another colony.

Figure 2.24 Newfoundland minted unique $2 gold coins until

about 1888. The bank crash of 1894 resulted in hoarding of the
increasingly rare coin.

Foreign Relations
Newfoundlands government pursued several and successive trade agreements with the United States. As a colony
of Britain, it had to do so with the Crowns approval which it had. In those negotiations, however, the Domin-
ion of Canada often played the role of the spoiler. In the late 19th century there was just enough dissatisfaction
with Confederation among the Maritime provinces that Canada could scarcely afford to see independent New-
5
foundland set a bad example by succeeding too much. Furthermore, Ottawa had few resource responsibilities but
fisheries was one of them. A coordinated fishing policy and administration, one that covered the whole of the Gulf
of Saint Lawrence, only needed Newfoundlands cooperation to be complete. The smaller colony, however, saw
little advantage in that. Canadian reprisals were probably inevitable.

More complex and longstanding were relations with France. Prior to 1713 and the Treaty of Utrecht, France had
established robust little settlements on Newfoundland. After Utrecht, Newfoundland belonged entirely to Britain
but the French were allowed exclusive use of the West Shore. Despite being prohibited from settling the French
Shore, individual English, Scots, and Irish found their way into the region over the 150 years that followed
Utrecht. The Treaty of Paris (1763) that ended the Seven Years War saw Britain make a further concession to the
defeated France: exclusive title to two small islands just south of Newfoundland St. Pierre and Miquelon. The

3. Patrick OFlaherty, Lost Country: The Rise and Fall of Newfoundland, 1843-1933 (St. Johns: Long Beach Press, 2005), 139.
4. Margaret R. Conrad and James K. Hiller, Atlantic Canada: A Concise History (Don Mills: Oxford University Press, 2006), 133.
5. Frederick W. Rowe, A History of Newfoundland and Labrador (Toronto: McGraw-Hill Ryerson, 1980), 303.
 86 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

goal of Britain throughout the 18th and the 19th century was to minimize friction with France by making a gen-
erous allowance for continuation of a historic fishing industry. That this was not in the best interest of Newfound-
landers was made increasingly clear. After achieving responsible government in 1855, colonial voices became
increasingly shrill in their criticism of the French presence and the constraints it put on Newfoundlanders who
worked and settled in the region. An agreement was subsequently struck between Britain and France, with grudg-
ing support from St. Johns, which allowed French activity to continue on the West Shore. Growing competition
over the lobster fishery and canneries tested the modus vivendi, but Newfoundlanders gritted their teeth until 1904
when they pressed Britain to find another solution. In that year a diplomatic outcome was arrived at in the Entente
Cordiale, an agreement struck between the two empires, and Newfoundland was made whole for the first time.
Only St. Pierre and Miquelon remained French, as they continue to be today.

In one other area Newfoundland seemed disinterested in formalizing diplomatic relations. Aboriginal populations
in the colony on both sides of the Strait of Belle Isle were small but increasingly vulnerable from the 1890s on.
Typhoid, measles, and influenza made inroads into the formerly isolated Inuit communities of northern Labrador
as the size of the transient Newfoundland fishing fleets grew and encounters with Euro-colonists increased. Com-
mercial and sport hunting grew in the interior of Newfoundland and in Labrador, impacting the 200 or so Mikmaq
and the Innu respectively. There were, however, no treaties in place and nothing like Canadas Indian Act to
6
guide policy and behaviour. The anguish expressed earlier in the 19th century at the tragic disappearance of the
Beothuk peoples was not, it seems, followed up by any measure to protect other Aboriginal communities.

Figure 2.25 Preparing cod within sight of the St. Johns skyline,
ca. 1900.

Newfoundland on the Eve of War

In 1907, Newfoundland sent Prime Minister Robert Bond to the Imperial Conference hosted by British Prime
Minister Henry Campbell-Bannerman. Representing a poor and struggling colony, Bond did his best to argue
for colonial autonomy within an imperial association while avoiding commitments to expensive British military
projects. (Newfoundlanders had volunteered for the British campaigns against the Boers in South Africa but the
colony had not mustered a regiment, unlike Canada.) Bond carried the day and Newfoundland was recognized as
a Dominion, a status that made it diplomatically equivalent to Canada, Australia, the Cape Colony (later called
South Africa) and New Zealand (sometimes collectively described as the White Dominions).

By this time, the population of Newfoundland was much larger than it had been 50 years earlier. It nearly doubled
7
from 1860 to 1901, rising from 130,000 to 242,000 (of which just 3,949 were found in Labrador). Natural popula-
tion increase combined with continued immigration from Ireland, Scotland, and England to push up the numbers.
These numbers were kept somewhat in check by outmigration to Canada and the United States.

6. Conrad and Hiller, Atlantic Canada: A Concise History, 136-7.

7. Newfoundland, Colonial Secretarys Office, "Table 1. Population, sex, condition, denomination, profession, etc.," Census of Newfoundland
and Labrador, 1911 (Statistics Canada Collection), accessed 2 June 2015, [Link]
 2.13 THE OTHER DOMINION 87

Although Canadas influence in Newfoundland was growing in the period before the Great War, the colony
remained oriented in the opposite direction. Even Labrador seemed lost in St. Johns rear-view mirror. Were it not
for the chain of little hospitals established by the English physician and missionary, Wilfred Grenfell (1865-1940),
from 1893, very few services would have reached the impoverished fishing populations (transient and resident) on
the mainland. In 1901 the 37-year old Italian physicist, Gugliemo Marconi, sent the first cross-Atlantic wireless
message from Signal Hill in St. Johns to Cornwall, England. It is perhaps significant that he did not attempt
communication with Montreal.

Key Points

Newfoundland displayed little interest in joining the rest of British North America in a federation or
any other kind of union.
The colony consisted of three main parts: Labrador, the French Shore, and the rest of Newfoundland.
Its population was deeply divided by region, ethnicity, language, and religion.
The economy was based mostly on fisheries that were seasonal, as were sealing ventures, contribut-
ing to underemployment in the off-seasons.
Social divisions peaked in 1883 with the Harbour Grace Affray.
The colony developed a distinctive approach to education based on denominationalism.
Infrastructural change and the expansion of a farming frontier were attempts to diversify the econ-
omy which met with limited success.
Canadian control over the monetary affairs of the colony and Canadian interference in Newfound-
lands diplomatic channels drew the colony closer into the other Dominions sphere of influence.

Attributions
Figure 2.21
Codfish Stamp by Jcmurphy is in the public domain.

Figure 2.22
Seal hunting in Newfoundland by MatthewVanitas is in the public domain.

Figure 2.23
The Anglican Cathedral by Jcmurphy is in the public domain.

Figure 2.24
Canada Newfoundland Victoria gold by Heritage Auctions is in the public domain.

Figure 2.25
Drying codfish by Muse McCord Museum is in the public domain. This image is available from McCord
Museum under the access number MP-0000.4.14.
2.14 Summary

Figure 2.26 MOTHER BRITANNIA. See! Why the dear

child can stand alone!
UNCLE SAM. Of course he can! Let go of him Granny; if he
falls Ill catch him! In 1870 Canada annexed the West (almost at
bayonet point), but was it strong enough to stand on its own or
would it collapse in its infancy?

The first decades after Confederation were not easy. While it is true that the federation expanded quickly to cover
almost the whole of the northern half of the continent, it did so in a way that provoked conflict and division.
The record of additions is straightforward. In 1870 Manitoba signed on and British Columbia followed in 1871.
Prince Edward Island returned to the table and settled its issues with Ottawa in 1873. Elements of the North were
added on quietly as Britain shuffled further and further away from being an imperial presence in the Western
hemisphere. Against these achievements, one has to recall that from 1867-1869 Nova Scotia wriggled on the hook
of Confederation; from 1869 through most of 1870 the fate of the Northwest was uncertain. The Canadian pres-
ence at Red River was led by men unafraid of violence and they were met by force as well. Blood was shed and
an antipathy grew between Ontarians and Manitobans (especially the Mtis). The 1873 Pacific Scandal created
serious doubt on the likelihood of an all-Canadian route for a railway to the West let alone to British Colum-
bia. BCs demands for the Terms might have seemed to Ottawa like petulance, but it threw further into doubt
the prospect of the Confederation lasting even one generation. The 1880s witnessed the return of Louis Riel and
armed conflict across the Prairies. The government would exploit its ability to deliver troops into the thick of
the second Northwest uprising to vindicate the railway project, but the mishandling of Mtis complaints and the
treaties looked bad. The hanging of Riel did nothing, of course, to reassure Quebec that Canada was anything
more than an Anglo-Ontarian and Orange project in which punitive raids were conducted against francophone
Catholics. The 1880s also saw the return of the Nova Scotia Repeal Movement. The Bluenose anti-Confederates
were tamed but their campaigns brought to the fore compelling evidence that the Maritimes were not at all better
off for having become a province of Canada. It is difficult to know whether events further west informed their
discontent, but it is equally challenging to imagine that they would have been reassured by separatist talk in BC
and expensive wars on the Prairies.

88
 2.14 SUMMARY 89

Even Ontario arguably the most committed to, and the chief beneficiary of, Confederation bridled under
Ottawas maneuvers. The Provincial Rights movement established the principle that the provinces were partners
in Confederation, that they had entered into the agreement under their own free will and could, therefore, leave if
need be. The pact or compact model of Confederation supplanted the act interpretation and, in doing so, set
a path for federal-provincial relations for the next century.

The rise of Quebec nationalism in the years immediately after Confederation was to have important ramifications
in the early 20th century. The abandonment of dualism as a way to build a country based on the credibility and
integrity of two European cultures was a significant blow to unity. The treatment of the Mtis and the vociferous
tone of Orange politicians sent a powerful message to Quebec. The Orange Orders loyalist and royalist creed
sought more British-ness, not less. Quebec sought more Canadian-ness instead. This division would vex Macdon-
ald and his successors in the decades before the Great War in 1914.

Key Terms

Beothuk: Aboriginal people of Newfoundland; believed to have disappeared due to exotic diseases,
loss of territory, and armed conflict with European colonists by the second quarter of the 19th century.
Cariboo Wagon Road: A pair of routes to the gold-bearing regions on the Interior Plateau of British
Columbia, initiated in 1860. One begins in Fort Douglas, the other at Yale.
Confederation League: Founded by Amor de Cosmos and John Robson in 1868, promoting the idea of
union with Canada through newspapers and direct lobbying of administrations in Victoria, Ottawa, and
London. Their goals included responsible government in the colony, reciprocity with the United States,
and austerity measures to address colonial debt.
disallowance: An effective veto held by Ottawa that could be used to overturn provincial legislation.
Dominion Lands Act: 1872; the legal mechanism that made possible the distribution of western lands.
Escheat Movement: An organized movement in 19th century Prince Edward Island with the objective
of ending absent landlordism and the distribution of lands to tenant farmers.
Esquimalt & Nanaimo Railway: 1871; the E&N was built to connect the coalfields of the central island
with the British Columbia capital, Victoria.
graving dock: Also called a dry dock; repair facility for shipping.
Harbour Grace Affray: 1883 Newfoundland dispute in which Orange Lodge Protestants and Catholic
neighbours came to blows; led to five deaths and a dozen casualties.
Indian Agent: An agent of the federal governments Department of Indian Affairs (or, later, DIAND)
with responsibility for managing and/or supervising one or more Aboriginal communities.
Kanakans: Hawaiians or Pacific Island workers; this term may have been used disparagingly or in a
derogatory fashion, however, the word means human being in the Hawaiian language.
Medicine Line: The 49th parallel north, so named by the First Nations of the Plains because it worked
as an invisible barrier to stop attacks northward by United States soldiers.
Moravian Brethren: An early Protestant sect from central Europe; established missions in Labrador,
with the first permanent site established at Nain in 1771.
Nativist millenarians: Movements among mostly Indigenous peoples under imperialism that attempt to
90 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

throw off their occupiers and return to an idealized past way of living; sometimes imbued with a mysti-
cal element that could involve divine intervention.
Pacific Scandal: 1873; Macdonalds Conservative Party was given significant funds from the Canadian
Pacific Railway, which caused the CPR to lose the opportunity to complete the Intercolonial Railway,
cost Macdonald his administration, and brought the Mackenzie Liberals into office.
Peace, order, and good government (POGG): From Section 91 of the BNA Act as regards residual
or residuary powers (granted to the Queen, the Senate, and House of Commons to make laws), and
which could cover anything and everything that was either not itemized or as yet not imagined in the
constitutional division of authority.
Pig War: Colloquial name for a dispute between the United States and the British Empire over the San
Juan Islands, from 1859-1873.
populist: In politics, an appeal to the interests and concerns of the community by political leaders (pop-
ulists) usually against established elites or minority or scapegoat groups. The rhetoric of populists
is often characterized as vitriolic, bombastic, and fear-mongering.
scrip: A system introduced by Canada for extinguishing Mtis land title, beginning in 1870. Scrip doc-
uments indicated individual entitlement to land, although not necessarily to land on which one was
already settled. While the numbered treaties dealt with whole First Nations communities collectively,
scrip was negotiated on an individual and household basis.
section and quarter section (block system): The system used by land surveyors to divide land and
property. One section is meant to be 1 mi (1.6 km) square.
seigneurial system: Used in New France; based on a feudal system in which land was granted under a
royalty system, and the tenant was responsible for farming the land to meet their physical needs (food,
heat, and shelter). This system was abolished in 1854.
Treaty of Paris: Ended the Seven Years War. France ceded all of its territory east of the Mississippi to
Britain (including all of Canada, Acadia, and le Royale) and granted Louisiana and lands west of the
Mississippi to its ally Spain. Britain returned to France the sugar islands of Guadeloupe. France retained
St. Pierre and Miquelon along with fishing rights on the Grand Banks.
ultramontanist: Elements in Catholicism that emphasize papal authority over secular authority and,
after 1870, papal infallibility. Seeks a large, extensive role for the church in daily life and objects to the
main features of modernity, especially the growth of the secular state. Although ultramontanism faded
in Europe after 1870, it remained a powerful force in Canada to the 1960s.
White Dominions: Former British colonies dominated by a European population or elite; includes
Canada, Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, and Newfoundland to ca. 1934-1949.
Yale Convention: Meeting between British Columbian delegates to determine the colonys demands as
regards joining Confederation.

Short Answer Exercises

1. Why did some politicians in Nova Scotia, British Columbia, and New Brunswick toy with the idea
of pulling out of Confederation in the first two decades after 1867?
2. In what ways was British Columbia distinct from the rest of Canada?
 2.14 SUMMARY 91

3. What forces brought PEI to the table in 1873?

4. Was the establishment of the Red River Provisional Government an act of rebellion?
5. What flaws in Confederation were highlighted by the Provincial Rights movement?
6. What strategies did Canada adopt in annexing the West?
7. Why were First Nations prepared to sign treaties with Canada?
8. What conditions led to the events of 1885 in the Northwest?
9. Why was the question of Riels sanity so problematic?
10. How did the CPR figure into Canadian expansionism?
11. In what ways were the lives of Northerners changing in the period between 1867-1930?
12. What were the distinguishing features of life, economy, and politics in Newfoundland before the
Great War?

Suggested Readings
Keough, Willeen. Contested Terrains: Ethnic and Gendered Spaces in the Harbour Grace Affray, Canadian His-
torical Review, 90, no. 1 (March 2009): 29-70.

McCoy, Ted. Legal Ideology in the Aftermath of Rebellion: The Convicted First Nations Participants, 1885,
Histoire Sociale/Social History, 42, no. 83 (Mai-May 2009): 175-201.

Miller, J.R. Owen Glendower, Hotspur, and Canadian Indian Policy, Ethnohistory, 37:4 (Fall 1990): 386-415.

Milloy, John. Our Country: The Significance of the Buffalo Resource for a Plains Cree Sense of Territory, in
Kerry Abel and Jean Friesen, eds., Aboriginal Resource Use in Canada: Historical and Legal Aspects (Win-
nipeg: University of Manitoba Press, 1991): 51-70.

Read, Geoff, and Todd Webb. The Catholic Mahdi of the North West: Louis Riel and the Metis Resistance in
Transatlantic and Imperial Context, Canadian Historical Review, 93, no. 2 (June 2012): 171-95.

Waite, P.B. Canada in 1874: An Overview, in Arduous Destiny: Canada 1874-1896 (Don Mills: Oxford Uni-
versity Press, 1971): 1-12.

Attributions
Figure 2.26
1870 political cartoon by Skeezix1000 is in the public domain.
 PART 4

Chapter 3. Urban, Industrial, and Divided:

Socio-Economic Change, 1867-1920

92
3.1 Introduction

Figure 3.1 Coal sorters at work at the Atlas Mine in Alberta, n.d.

The Industrial Revolution was well underway in Britain and the northeastern United States by 1867. The system-
atized production of manufactured goods woolen or cotton garments or iron tools was made possible by
a reorganization of labour, from independent and cottage-based production to one where the work was produced
collectively, and increasingly with the use of machinery. The creation of low-valued manufactured products
required the development of new systems of transportation. The early (or first) Industrial Revolution generated
a parallel revolution in infrastructure that included canals, railways, and shipping.

Canadas Industrial Revolution piggybacked on that of its neighbour and Britain. However, the most rapid tran-
sition of the Canadian economy came after 1850, and accelerated through the last half of the 19th century. Con-
federation and the resulting creation of a common financial system that included a shared currency and mint
was, in fact, an enabling step in industrializing British North America. It created an open colonial marketplace
without tariff barriers, facilitated the movement of investment capital, and superimposed a modern freight-han-
dling capacity that realigned trade from north-south to east-west. Victorian Canada was, in every sense, industri-
alizing Canada.

Figure 3.2 Industrialism didnt put an end to homespun,

particularly in poorer, rural communities. But it severely reduced
the economic viabilty of the handloom weaver and other artisans.

93
 94 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Industrial British North America

Start by listening to historian Craig Heron (York University) describe the industrial revolution.

In the 1860s, industry was breaking out all over. New Brunswick dominated by forest industries and shipbuild-
ing was, on a per capita basis up until 1871, only a little less industrialized than Ontario and Quebec. Nova
Scotias industry was distinctively divided between the metal and coal industries of Cape Breton, and the tex-
1
tile mills and sugar refineries in the western part of the province. Vancouver Island, with its coal mines at and
around Nanaimo and the vertically-integrated heavy industries that included Royal Navy shipyards in Esquimalt
and chain-making in Victoria, was another outpost of industrialization.

These parallel developments were not happenstance. By keeping local land prices high, the colonial and then
provincial governments of British Columbia demonstrated a desire for wage-earning workers rather than farm set-
tlers a striking signal that industry, not agriculture, was central to their vision. The engagement of the state
in the building of an industrial order is itself part of the suite of ideas associated with modernity a concept
pursued throughout this text. Industrialism, the term used to describe the new economic order emerging in the late
19th century, was thus more than a pattern of like practices and institutions; it was something to which govern-
ments, investors, and workers were all striving.

Figure 3.3 Iron ore from Bell Island is loaded onto a metal-hulled
ship, ca. 1903.

The economics of industrialization are staggering insofar as they require the movement of capital, raw materials,

1. Margaret R. Conrad and James K. Hiller, Atlantic Canada: A Concise History (Don Mills: Oxford University Press, 2006), 131-2.
 3.1 INTRODUCTION 95

personnel, and products across huge distances. Industry requires, too, the mobilization, training, housing, and dis-
cipline of a workforce with little to no prior exposure to industrial systems. The pre-Conquest iron forges at Saint-
Maurice, near Trois-Rivires, depended on fuel and ore and labour that could be obtained locally. By 1890,
industries in Central and Maritime Canada were using iron ore from Labrador and Newfoundlands Bell Island;
coking coal from Cape Breton was finding its way to Ontario; and workers in Canadian industry were migrating
from one province to another, from coast to coast. Workers were being recruited from industrializing Lancashire
and Yorkshire, Wales, Lowland Scotland, and Germany. Industrial workers were also coming to Canada from rural
and non-industrialized corners of Italy, Ireland, Hungary, and China. The intensification of mechanized, and then
automated, work ensured that peasant populations whose home countries were still mostly feudal would be thrust
directly onto the cutting edge of industrialization. It also meant that untrained Canadian labour specifically
children would find themselves very literally at the coalface.

In addition to personnel, industry requires energy. In 1867, the dominant sources of energy grew in forests or
walked on four legs. Waterpower had made some inroads, particularly in rural areas where waterwheels could take
advantage of local rapids. At Lachine, Quebec, the canals provided power as well, driving the Montreal areas
earliest industries. Bringing energy sources into city centres, however, where other resources could be assembled,
posed a challenge; a challenge that was overcome by following Britains lead and adapting the new steam-power
[Link] a very short time period, there was a shift in industrial and urban Canada from organic and
water-based power sources to fossil fuels.

Figure 3.4 Horse power moved goods and people, was fuelled by
oats and hay, and was adapted to work in Canadian conditions.
Montreal, ca.1877.

Figure 3.5 Before steam power augmented machines, horses were

regularly employed.

This change in the energy economy had the important advantage in Canada of diminishing the impact of season-
ality. Waterwheels were powerful innovations and their application to the increased use of machinery in produc-
tion, was literally revolutionary. Nevertheless, watercourses freeze up in Canada, which meant an interruption in
power supply and in the transportation of necessary supplies along rivers. The transition from organic to inorganic
energy sources changed all that. Factories could work year-round and steam-powered engines could be used to
move larger and larger quantities of raw materials from source to market in shorter time. Applied to land-based
transportation along rails, steam and coal could free much of Canadian manufacturing from the dictatorship of
winter.
 96 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 3.6 Heavy industry comes to Nova Scotia and, with it,
plenty of steam and smoke. An artists rendering of the Cape
Breton coking ovens applauds the regimentation of smoky
industry at the start of the 20th century.

Once factories began operating throughout the four seasons, the possibility arose for workers to take on wage-
labour full time. The increasing use of cash in the Canadian economy was one attraction to doing so. Many
agricultural workers went into industrial labour as a temporary measure, a step toward saving enough money to
purchase a farm of their own. This was also true of immigrant industrial workers who imagined their future in
2
Canada as independent landowners. That transitional stage never fully ended, as rural populations in the 21st
century continue to augment farm income with wage-labour. In the 19th century, however, limits on transporta-
tion made such moves increasingly permanent. By the 1870s wage-labour in many regions matched agriculture as
a practical strategy for survival. The population of ready workers increased and expanded across Canada. From
1861-71 the labour force grew by about 15% and then, from 1871-81 by 26%. Its growth slowed thereafter to a
3
still-respectable 21% and then 11% in each of the two decades that followed. Labour inputs, however, are only
part of the equation.

The introduction of machinery, and especially steam-powered machinery, was transformative. Output could be
increased dramatically, quality could aim for (and sometimes achieve) reliable standards, and the skill sets needed
to do a particular job changed from that of a master craftsman to those of someone able to keep up with the metal
and wood machinery. The cumulative effect was to bring down wages while raising productivity and de-skilling
the workforce. New skills emerged particularly those associated with maintaining machinery but shoe pro-
duction, for example, went from being a handicraft associated with years of apprenticeship and journeyman study,
to something that was done by children. A good example is Lawsons, a tailoring business in Hamilton, that intro-
duced 10 sewing machines in the 1860s. This led to the departure of 71 of their 100 skilled male tailors, and their
4
replacement with 69 women (who were regarded, rightly or wrongly, as unskilled). Mechanization and, in
the 20th century, automation would change the way work is done, but its spread was entirely dependent on the
ability of capital to invest in emerging technologies. This process of intensified capital inputs on the shop floor
would accelerate 30 years after Confederation.

The Second Industrial Revolution

Despite significant changes in the orientation and character of the economy until the mid-1890s, growth was not
outstanding. An important measure of the health of Canadas economy is its population and, rather remarkably,
from 1861-1901 Canada was a net exporter of people. The American economy was expanding more rapidly and as
land and employment opportunities arose, it served as a magnet for thousands of Canadians. Additionally, many

2. British coal miners who moved to Vancouver Island in the late 19th century repeatedly indicated that they saw West Coast mine work as a
stepping stone to independence on their own land. See John Douglas Belshaw, Colonization and Community: The Vancouver Island Coalfield
and the Making of the British Columbian Working Class (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 2002), 161-3.
3. Statistics Canada, Historical Statistics of Canada, 2nd ed., F. H. Leacy, ed. (Ottawa: Statistics Canada, 1983): D498-511.
4. Bryan D. Palmer, Working-Class Experience: Rethinking the History of Canadian Labour, 1800-1991, 2nd ed. (Toronto: McClelland &
Stewart, 1992), 87-8.
 3.1 INTRODUCTION 97

of the immigrants to Canada during this period proved to be just passing through. On balance, then, more peo-
ple left than arrived. From a historians perspective, this is a sure sign that industrialization in the new Dominion
provided fewer opportunities, or less competitive opportunities, than agriculture in the western plains of North
America. This was not yet a consumer-led economy so the net loss of population until 1901 did not mean the
simultaneous loss of household markets, at least not in the same way it might in the mid-20th century. It did man-
ifest a shortage of labour resources, however, in some corners of the country. As the Maritimes economy began
to seize up in the 1870s and 1880s, for example, out-migration was another factor in driving investment to more
populous centres in Ontario and southwest Quebec.

In the 1890s, there were several important advances in technology and technique that gave industrialization a
new shape. The foremost of these was the development of the Bessemer system for manufacturing steel. Vastly
stronger and cheaper than earlier forged metals, this innovation propelled the steel industry and everything that
utilized steel. As well, it contributed to the further growth of coking coal production and iron mining and the
building of infrastructure to transport these raw materials to processing points. The establishment of the Nova
Scotia Steel and Coal Company at New Glasgow in 1882 was followed by the Dominion Coal Company at Glace
Bay 11 years later. The Dominion Iron And Steel Company opened in Sydney in 1900, and the Nova Scotia Steel
and Coal Company opened at Sydney Mines the same year. All of these developments reflect the accelerating
transformation of the industrial order in Canada as a whole and the rise of international markets for output. It also
points to a change in industrial capitalism: whereas earlier industrialization depended mostly upon bringing more
labour to the task of producing goods, capital inputs were now rewarded. In Ontario alone, the amount of capital
5
invested in the economy leapt from $37 million in 1871 to $175 million in 1891, rising to $595 million in 1911.
Machinery, reconceptualized workspaces and architecture, and metal-hulled ships that could move heavy goods at
a fraction of the cost of wooden vessels all contributed to the changes associated with what is called the Second
Industrial Revolution.

The change could be seen in the Canadian labour force. In 1901, the number of operatives and labourers combined
6
(nearly 789,422) surpassed the total number of farmers and farmworkers (715,122). The proportion of Canadians
living on the land was still greater than that of urbanites, but, as of 1901, the number of Canadians earning an
income from wages pulled ahead of those earning farm incomes. And those wage-earning workers were doing so
increasingly in industries and factories that did not much resemble what existed in the 1860s.

Figure 3.7 As late as 1910, the boundary between rural life and
industrial employment was not a great one. The countryside
forms a backdrop to a shoe factory in Aurora, Ontario, ca. 1910.
Postcards like this one were a way of framing modernization and
material progress.

Industrialization marked a significant departure from the pre-Confederation economy, and it brought in its wake
social and economic changes that could hardly have been predicted. It was, however, part of a conscious strategy

5. Gregory S. Kealey, Workers and Canadian History (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queen's University Press, 1995), 245.
6. Canada, Historical Statistics of Canada, 2nd ed., F. H. Leacy, ed. (Ottawa: Statistics Canada, 1983): D86-106.
98 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

for nation-building and making economic policy. The most obvious expression of that strategic (and, yes, hopeful)
thinking was the National Policy.

Learning Objectives

Develop an understanding of the causes and contours of the Second Industrial Revolution.
Explain the rise of a working class and describe its main features.
Assess the main features and goals of the National Policy and its individual components.
Discuss the ways in which age and gender shaped the historic experience of industrialization.
Connect the phenomena of industrialization with urbanization in the pre-1914 period.
Describe the strategies explored by working people to improve their conditions.
Account for the rise of the first-wave of feminism.

Attributions
Figure 3.1
Coal Mining, Alberta picking coal before same leaves on conveyor Atlas Mine (Online MIKAN
no.3351151) by Library and Archives Canada is in the public domain.

Figure 3.2
Habitant series weaving loom (Online MIKAN no.3349488) by Library and Archives Canada is in the public
domain.

Figure 3.3
The loading pier at Bell Island by Verne Equinox is in the public domain.

Figure 3.4
A horse-drawn winter tram by Tim Pierce is in the public domain.

Figure 3.5
Drawing of a horse-powered thresher by Bogdan is in the public domain.

Figure 3.6
Artist rendering of the Sydney Nova Scotia by Verne Equinox is in the public domain.

Figure 3.7
Shoe factory, Aurora, Ontario, Canada by Special Collections Toronto Public Library is used under a CC BY
SA 2.0 license. This image is available from Toronto Public Library under the identifier PC-ON 65.
 3.2 Industrialization, Labour, and Historians

ROBERT SWEENY, DEPT. OF HISTORY, MEMORIAL UNIVERSITY OF NEWFOUNDLAND

Figure 3.8 Postcards like this one were a means to promote the
industrial culture emerging in towns like Oshawa in 1910.

Canada was the first colony to industrialize, and it did so in the third quarter of the 19th century. Although well
after Great Britain and Belgium, this was only a decade or so behind the United States, more or less contempo-
raneous with France, and well ahead of Germany, Italy, Japan, Spain, and Russia. Prior to the 1970s, however,
Canadian historians did not realize this. Instead, historians debated whether industrialization resulted from Sir
John A. Macdonalds National Policy of 1879 or under the Laurier government at the turn of the century. Both
sides attributed this late industrialization to an over-reliance on the export of staples: cod, furs, timber, and wheat.
As the presumed centrality of political leaders in these narratives suggests, most historians considered industrial-
ization to have been the result of federal government policy, rather than an organic maturation of settler colonial-
1
ism. Starting in the mid-1970s, two complimentary but distinct new schools of thought changed this historical
debate.
2
In French Canada, influenced by the work of Stanley Ryerson, researchers at the Universit du Qubec Mon-
tral pushed back the start date for industrialization in Montreal to the late 1840s when, harnessing the hydraulic
3
power of the locks of the Lachine Canal, the first large-scale factories were built. From the outset, this new
research stressed the importance of social history, itself a reflection of the turbulent debates (at that time) over
the national question in Quebec. Strikes by journeymen shoemakers over the introduction of machine tools
and by carters opposed to the Grand Trunk railway monopoly were depicted as challenging the new indus-

1. The classic statement, which went through five editions by 1977, is Arthur R. M. Lower's Colony to Nation: A History of Canada (Toronto:
Longmans, Green, 1946).
2. Stanley B. Ryerson, Unequal Union: Roots of Crisis in the Canadas, 1815-1873 (Toronto: Progress Books, 1968).
3. This idea formed the cornerstone for the highly influential interpretation of Quebec as a typical part of North America, a position first devel-
oped in Paul-Andr Linteau, Ren Durocher, and Jean-Claude Robert, Histoire du Qubec Contemporain, Tome 1 De la Confderation la
Crise (1867-1929) (Montreal: Boral Express, 1979).

99
 100 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION
4
trial order, while the dire living conditions for the emerging working class became a major focus of historical
5
work. Soon debates on method, particularly over how we should interpret census data, led to a considerably
6
more nuanced view that challenged this early misrabiliste literature; at the same time, careful analysis of work
7
processes demonstrated the significance of gender to understanding working class resistance. More recent work
has shown both substantial inter-generational social mobility, most strikingly among Irish Catholics, and a serious
8
deterioration in the status of women. The focus has remained on Montreal, the financial and industrial capital of
Canada until the 1930s, but detailed studies of moulders and iron workers in the Saint-Maurice Valley and ships
labourers in Quebec City have shown how integrated 19th century labour markets were in North America.

Meanwhile, in English Canada, a group of graduate students interested in labour history built on the pioneering
work of Manitoban H. Claire Pentland (1914-78) to chronicle the industrialization of Toronto and Hamilton in
9
the 1860s and 1870s. In 1975, these young scholars created their own journal, Labour/Le Travail. Rejecting tra-
ditional, largely institutional, labour history and highly critical of quantitative historical sociology, these schol-
ars focused on working class culture. They argued that skilled male craftsmen drew on a producer ideology,
which was highly critical of lawyers, merchants, middlemen and bankers, to develop their own alternate view of
the world. This critical stance was presented by historians as a powerful and potentially revolutionary defence
of the working man, one that spoke out strongly against prevailing business values. Workers made their mark in
various institutions and movements including the Knights of Labor (which may have organized as many as one
in five waged workers in Ontario during the 1880s), the struggle for a shorter working day, and print media
10
edited by brain workers. The significance of class conflict in Ontario has since been questioned by the sug-
11
gestion that, there, industrialization was more a case of craft capitalism. More generally, the idea of a coherent
working class culture has been challenged by the work of Ian McKay of Queens University. Initially he applied
to the Maritimes the idea, developed by British historian Raphael Samuel (1934-96), that industrialization was
not a simple process of factories with machines replacing older ways of making things. Rather, it was a complex
process involving both hand and machine tools in an uneven development characterized by a limited number of
factories servicing numerous highly competitive workshops and manufacturers. This complexity meant no single
working class experience was ever possible. Indeed, this very diversity of experience contributed to the remark-
able social stability of late-Victorian Canada, by impeding the growth of a shared sense of class. A new coherent
critique of industrial society did emerge, but only slowly and it never represented all or even most of the working

4. Joanne Burgess, "L'industrie de la Chaussure Montral 1840-1870 le Passage de l'Artisanat la Fabrique," Revue d'Histoire de
l'Amrique Franaise, vol. 31, no. 2 (1977): 187-210; Margaret Heap, "La Grve des Charretiers Montral, 1864," Revue d'Histoire de
l'Amrique Franaise, vol. 31, no. 4 (1977): 371-96.
5. Jean De Bonville, Jean-Baptiste Gagnepetit: Les Travailleurs Montralais la Fin du XIXe Sicle (Montreal: L'Aurore, 1975); Bettina Brad-
bury, Working Families: Age, Gender, and Daily Survival in Industrializing Montreal (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1993).
6. Gilles Lauzon, "Cohabitation et Dmnagements en Milieu Ouvrier Montralais,"Revue d'Histoire de l'Amrique Franaise, vol. 46, no. 1
(1992): 115-42.
7. Jacques Ferland, "Syndicalisme Parcellaire et Syndicalisme Collectif: Une Interpretation Socio-Techniques des Conflits Ouvriers dans Deux
Industries Qubcoises (1880-1914)," Labour/Le Travail, 19 (1987): 48-88.
8. Sherry Olson and Patricia Thornton, Peopling the North American City: Montreal 1840-1900 (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queen's Uni-
versity Press, 2011); Bettina Bradbury, Wife to Widow: Lives, Laws, and Politics in Nineteenth-Century Montreal (Vancouver: University of
British Columbia Press, 2011).
9. H. Clare Pentland's 1961 doctoral thesis at the University of Toronto was published 20 years later as Labour and Capital in Canada,
1650-1860 (Toronto: James Lorimer, 1981). The two most influential works by this group of scholars were Gregory S. Kealey, Toronto Work-
ers Respond to Industrial Capitalism, 1867-1892 (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1980) and Bryan D. Palmer, A Culture in Conflict:
Skilled Workers and Industrial Capitalism in Hamilton, Ontario, 1860-1914 (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queen's University Press, 1979).
10. Gregory S. Kealey and Bryan D. Palmer, Dreaming of What Might Be: The Knights of Labor in Ontario, 1880-1900 (Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press, 1982).
11. Robert B. Kristofferson, Craft Capitalism: Craftworkers and Early Industrialization in Hamilton, Ontario, 1840-1872 (Toronto: University
of Toronto Press, 2007).
 3.2 INDUSTRIALIZATION, LABOUR, AND HISTORIANS 101

class. Furthermore, it shared rather than challenged the positivist, masculinist and most importantly as Canada
12
once more became a destination for immigrants racist ideas then dominant in bourgeois society.

Moving industrialization back a full generation or more changes how we conceive late 19th century Canada.
Rather than a peaceful kingdom taking a constitutional road to democracy that slowly industrialized under the
guidance of wise political leaders, post-Confederation Canada is now seen as a country struggling with the serious
social and economic problems of early industrial society. Confederation, the purchase of Ruperts Land, the num-
bered treaties, the Indian Act, the Mtis rebellions, and the resettlement of both the Prairies and British Columbia
are now seen in quite a different light. These events were all parts of a complex process of remaking the northern
half of North America into an industrial capitalist society.

Key Points

Industrialization began earlier in Canada than in many other jurisdictions, and earlier than was long
thought to be the case.
Workers experiences of industrialization were diverse, which had consequences for the develop-
ment of a working class consciousness.
Industrialization brought in its wake significant social transformations and challenges.

Attributions
Figure 3.8
Oshawas Factories (HS85-10-22386) by LibraryBot (from the British Library) is in the public domain.

12. Samuel's path-breaking analysis appeared as "Workshop of the World," History Workshop Journal, 3 (1973): 3-61. McKay's analysis of work
in the Maritimes began in his graduate studies and then appeared in several articles, the most important of which is "Capital and Labour in
the Halifax Baking and Confectionery Industry During the Last Half of the 19th Century," Labour/Le Travail, 3 (1978): 63-108. His Mac-
donald Prize-winning analysis of working class politics is Reasoning Otherwise: Leftists and The People's Enlightenment in Canada,
1890-1920 (Toronto: Between the Lines, 2008).
3.3 The National Policy

John A. Macdonalds National Policy remains a touchstone of Canadian economic history. It combined three core
elements infrastructure, tariffs, and population growth as a strategy to reshape and expand the post-Confeder-
ation economy. It was not, however, a single policy; it was a combination of several strategies which had comple-
mentary qualities that, once recognized, were shrewdly re-presented to Canadians as a comprehensive package.

Many of the elements of the National Policy were in place very early in the conversation about Confederation or
at least they were implied. Barriers to trade between the BNA colonies were eliminated as they became provinces.
Funding for the railway construction that linked all four original provinces was promised at the outset. Expansion
into the West to provide a vent for surplus Canadian farm population (magically transforming them into prairie
settlers) was a first-level objective. What was added onto this framework by Macdonalds several administrations
was something rather more ambitious.

The Railway
The trans-continental railway is the most obvious and arguably the most lasting element of what became known
as the National Policy. It both served to deliver manufactured goods to captive markets in the West and acted as
a critical element in populating the Prairies with colonists. Moreover, by the end of the century, the railway had
demonstrated an ability to crush local industries in the far west by flooding the market with mass-produced central
Canadian products.

Figure 3.9 In 1893 the Stoney Creek steel

bridge replaced a wooden trestle. It is a
testament to the rising influence of
engineering and improved materials in the
late Victorian era. It is, as well, a graceful
structure.

The railway fulfilled several functions at once. It is, obviously, a means of moving goods and people: it is trans-
portation infrastructure. For Canada in the 1880s and 1890s, it also served as an instrument of control, the means

102
 3.3 THE NATIONAL POLICY 103

by which troops and the NWMP could be sped to trouble spots. This was clearly demonstrated in the Canadian
militias quelling of the 1885 uprising in Saskatchewan. The CPR both its rail and telegraph service pro-
vided a quick and critical communications system that enabled Canadian state power to extend far beyond south-
ern Ontario or the St. Lawrence Valley. One of the challenges faced by crown colony governors on the West Coast
had been the interminable slowness of communications between Victoria or New Westminster and London. After
1886, Canadas imperial representatives in the West or on the Pacific Coast, by contrast, could receive instructions
and reinforcements in a matter of days, if not hours.

The CPR, however, was also a major land owner and very much in the settlement business. It was clearly in the
best interests of the Railway to get farmers onto the land so that they could buy freight and ship grain. Railways
were, as well, a critically important component in Canadas economic transformation. Historians Paul Craven and
Tom Traves made this observation over 30 years ago:

Railways were not just simple transportation companies. [] In some respects they operated almost like states unto them-
selves; their company rules had the force of law, they employed their own police, and their executives, as the Grand
1
Trunks goods manager put it, were as important as generals in an army or Ministers of State.

The need for rails, rolling stock, engine parts, and the metal for seats and carriage doors meant everything had
to be fabricated according to the individual railways specification. Universal standards had not come into play
yet, even within single companies. (The Great War would play an important role in moving that process for-
ward.) Everything including machine parts and simple fasteners like nuts and bolts needed to be made (and
repaired) in-house. As early as 1871, the Great Western Railway (GRW) employed 984 people at its Hamilton
shops, paying out the then-astronomical sum of $500,000 annually in wages. The GWR was the largest but the
Grand Trunk (in Pointe Saint-Charles near Montreal) employed 790 and the four next largest companies (two
2
of them in Toronto, one in Brantford, and the fourth in Montreal) employed more than a 1,000 between them.
And this all predates the creation of the Canadian Pacific Railway, not to mention the many streetcar systems that
appeared in towns and cities across the country from the 1890s to the 1920s.

Figure 3.10 A sod turning in Thunder Bay in 1912 for a new

Canadian Car and Foundry shop. Labour is not represented
among the dignitaries.

The railway technology shrank Canada; it made long-distance travel manageable and should be appreciated as a
revolutionary achievement. In the 1850s, the Prairie West was still perceived by the Canadians and Maritimers
as an extension of the Great American Desert; an arid plain with little agricultural potential and fearsome locals
with whom to contend. A generation later, that perspective was replaced with a more optimistic view that changed
Canadian attitudes toward the interior of North America. This was reflected most clearly in the railways impact
on land use.

1. Paul Craven and Tom Traves, Canadian Railways as Manufacturers, 1850-1880, Historical Papers/Communications Historiques (1983): 254, reprinted in
Perspectives on Canadian Economic History, ed. Douglas McCalla (Toronto: Copp Clark Pitman, 1987): 118.
2. Kenneth Norrie and Douglas Owram, A History of the Canadian Economy (Toronto: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich Canada, 1991), 237-9.
 104 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Immigration and Land

The second piece of the National Policy was immigration and settlement of the West. By creating a productive
agricultural frontier of independent producers, the reasoning went, Canada would also be generating an internal
marketplace for clothing, farm machinery, and household goods produced in the original four provinces. And, of
course, the railway would be the means of delivering that population and those goods to the West.

Broadly speaking, the CPR was an instrument of change. It delivered settlers to the West, whose goal it was to
extend the reach of European-style agriculture. The whole concept of a settler someone who establishes a per-
manent and fixed residence where, it is assumed (almost always incorrectly), no one lived before is bound
up in farming and ranching. To see the significance of this, observe how the coal miners of Drumheller or the
Crowsnest Pass are seldom described as settlers, despite their long tenure on (and below) the landscape. The CPR
thus did not just deliver settlers, it made them.

Figure 3.11 A Mennonite block settlement at Rat River,

Manitoba, drawn by Lord Dufferin in 1881.

The CPR, as a land agency, was directly involved in recruitment and land sales, but so too was Ottawas land
policy. At the heart of this system was the township survey, made up of 36 sections of 640 acres of land. Of the 36
sections, two were reserved for schools, one (sometimes more) for the HBC as part of the sale price of Ruperts
Land, and about half of the remaining sections for the Canadian Pacific Railway. What was left was available as
free homestead land and it was all geometrically rigid. Sections of 160 acres (64.7 hectares) were mapped out with
a blind disregard for topographical barriers, bodies of water, or variations in environmental conditions like wind,
rainfall, or soil quality. This unit of measure was almost sacred: the 1 square-mile section and the quarter-section
were the currency of homesteading in the United States where, similarly, the whole of the West had been overlain
with a graph-paper pattern. Bernard DeVoto, a historian of the American West, argued in 1953 that the quarter
section acquired a huge symbolic value as the buttress of our liberties, and the cornerstone of our economy.
What he had to say on this score is as apposite for Canada as for the US:

It was certainly true that if you owned 160 acres of flat Iowa farmland or rolling Wisconsin prairie, you had, on the
average, a farm which would support your family and would require all its exertions to work. So the quarter-section,
thought of as the proper homestead unit, became the mystical one. But in the arid regions 160 acres were not a homestead.
3
They were just a mathematical expression whose meanings in relation to agricultural settlement were disastrous.

As in the United States, Canadian homesteaders were promised a whole section of free land under the Dominion
Lands Act (1871). All the pioneer settler had to do was put a quarter-section (40 acres or 16.9 hectares) under the
plough and build a house on it within three years. Successful homesteaders were, furthermore, entitled to obtain
the title to a neighbouring section once they had proved up their first quarter-section. This practice led to a rapid
expansion of staked and claimed farmland across the Plains.

It was with regard to settling the West that the National Policy struggled most. It was wrongly assumed at the

3. Bernard DeVoto, Introduction to Wallace Stegner, Beyond the Hundredth Meridian (Toronto: Penguin Books, 1954 and 1992): xix.
 3.3 THE NATIONAL POLICY 105

outset that Ontarians and Canadians from further east would flood the Prairies. Instead, they continued heading
south. Immigrant recruitment was slow to make gains and many newcomers turned into Canadian emigrants, join-
ing the exodus of Dominion citizens leaving for the United States. Through to 1901, Canada continued to be a net
loser of population. The Canadian West was growing in population numbers, but nothing like as fast as the Amer-
ican West. Ironically, it was under the Liberal administration of Wilfrid Laurier (Prime Minister from 1896-1911)
that things suddenly accelerated. Thereafter, from 1896 to the Great War, the rate of Canadian population growth
outstripped that of the United States, and the Dominion experienced net population growth for the first time since
Confederation.

The Tariff
Only a fraction of the landscape encountered by pre-War settlers had ever encountered the plough before their
arrival. The fact that the CPR an infrastructure built on steel rails and wheels and carriages with the ability to
move very heavy freight easily coincides with the spread of the chilled steel plough in North America, is not a
coincidence. Wooden ploughs (sometimes called mouldboards) were far less effective in breaking the soil for the
first time, particularly the densely packed stuff of which the Prairies is made. The agricultural machinery industry
in Ontario was already well advanced by this stage. The links between steel production, agricultural equipment,
and railway development are central to the CPR story. The CPR had a stake in the growth of manufacturing capac-
ity in the East and in the shipment of manufactured goods and, thus, in the success of the tariff.

Figure 3.12 Shoe factories replaced the work of

individual cobblers from mid-century, leading to
large-scale production in a protected Canadian
marketplace. Ottawa Boot & Shoe Company,
1875. (William James Topley)

The tariff placed cheap imports from the United States at a disadvantage to protect embryonic Canadian industries.
This approach was tried and tested in many countries. (The mid-century American termination of reciprocity with
British North America was itself based in part on a fear that British goods would be introduced via BNA and then
sold cheaply (or dumped) in the United States, thereby killing New Englands manufacturing sector.) Until the
mid-1870s, there was sufficient demand in the North American economy that Canadian tariffs could be kept at a
moderate level. By the late 1870s, however, competition from American producers was on the upswing. Canadian
manufacturers were calling for protection for their products, and there were more of these manufacturers than ever
before. The tariff policy was unpopular in the Maritimes and with those Canadians many of them Liberals
who looked forward to a return to reciprocity. Beginning in 1878, the Macdonald administration assembled a suite
of tariffs that ranged from 17.5% to 20%. These were predominantly assessed on the products of heavy industry
4
and mining.

4. Kenneth Norrie and Douglas Owram, A History of the Canadian Economy (Toronto: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich Canada, 1991), 312-4.
 106 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 3.13 Tethered to a Conservative majority in the likeness of

Macdonald, Miss Canada resists the attractions of American
business interests. Joseph Keppler in Puck Magazine, ca. 1880.

The tariff may have been necessary, but it was unpopular, even with Conservatives. Every Canadian government
from the 1860s-1911 held out the prospect of a return to reciprocity with the United States. Having a good trading
relationship with the large economy next door only made sense, but it proved to be unappealing to American and
Canadian manufacturers alike. The Liberal Party with much of its base in rural Canada was more aggres-
sive in calling for free trade with the United States. Ironically, it was under Laurier that tariffs surged upward to
over 30% on certain manufactured goods. After 15 years in office, Laurier went back to the electorate with a free
trade agreement in hand, already approved by the US government. The voters turfed him out in 1911 and handed
the reins to a staunchly protectionist Conservative leader, Robert Borden, whose campaign slogan was the mem-
5
orable, No truck nor trade with the Yankees.

By the end of the pre-War era, however, the National Policy had done its work. There were competing railways,
Canada had a healthy manufacturing sector, the economy had diversified in ways that would sustain further indus-
trial growth, prairie settlement was well advanced, and the wheat boom was (with a few interruptions) underway.
The National Policy had done one other thing that had a sustained consequence for Canada: it created a wall over
which products might not pass, but through which capital investment moved as though a barrier were not there.
American investment in Canadian productive capacity accelerated with the National Policy. Peter DeLottinvilles
study of a town straddling the Maine-New Brunswick border shows how capital from Canadas financial centre,
Montreal, was joined by American money that hoped to make a profit from selling protected Canadian cotton
6
products inside the protected Canadian market. British money similarly arrived in Canada, although it tended to
come in portfolio investments rather than directly from industry. The irony of the tariff, then, is that it protected
industry against competition while opening up the Canadian economy to international influences through invest-
ment.

Figure 3.14 The Victrola Talking Machine Co. was a New

Jersey-based company (later subsumed into RCA-Victor), famous
for its trademark dog, Nipper, listening for His Masters Voice.
Victrola also exemplifies the early generation of American
branch plants. Montreal, ca. 1910.

Tariff walls could not, therefore, isolate the Canadian economy. The Canadian-American border was utterly
porous with regard to people and money, regardless of how much of a barrier it was to manufactured goods. The

5. Ibid., 314-5.
6. Peter DeLottinville, Trouble in the Hives of Industry: The Cotton Industry comes to Milltown, New Brunswick, 1879-1892, in Labour and
Working-Class History in Canada: A Reader, eds. David Frank and Gregory S. Kealey (St. Johns: Institute of Social and Economic
Research, Memorial University of Newfoundland, 1995): 134-6.
 3.3 THE NATIONAL POLICY 107

Canadian-American border was also wide open with regard to ideas. The southern alignment of the Canadian
Pacific Railway and the building of connecting lines to the south ensured that Calgary would be influenced by
centres in Montana and Idaho, Winnipeg by Milwaukee, Minneapolis, and Chicago, and in BC, the Kootenays by
Spokane, and Vancouver by Seattle and San Francisco. These influences can still be seen in commercial and resi-
dential architectural styles from the Victorian and Edwardian eras but, at the time, they were most clearly evident
in working-class affairs.

Cause and Effect

No area of historical research attracts debate quite like economic history. In the case of late 19th century
Canada, economic historians are divided on several issues. Providing land for free was universally
regarded as necessary to the settlement of the West, but was it? In giving away land, was Ottawa forgoing
significant revenues? (Certainly the CPR and other land agents did very well by land sales.) Was the sub-
sidy to the CPR necessary? Was it excessive? Were tariffs especially those of as much as 30% essen-
tial? At what point did they cease being about protection of embryonic industries and a guarantee of profits
for inefficient industries? Or, were they principally a tax on commerce, a means of raising government
revenues?
These questions are raised because of the opportunity costs entailed where might Canada have spent
railway subsidies otherwise? The objection raised by Western farmers at the time was that they were pay-
ing for Canadian industrialization and were held back from being more productive because they could not
purchase goods in a freer market.
In short, historians have not resolved whether the National Policy did the job or not, whether its success
rests on one strategic pillar or on all three. What is certain is that the National Policy succeeded as an orga-
nizing principle and a way of encapsulating Canadas economic unification and transformation. Macdonald
and his peers wanted to see a modernizing Canada. What they got was one which had to make room for
new social categories and challenges.

Key Points

Three policy areas railway construction, immigration, and protective tariffs on manufactured
goods came to be considered as a package known as the National Policy.
The Canadian Pacific Railway connected the southern half of the Dominion. It was also an important
land dealer, manufacturer, and employer.
Immigration into the West began very slowly, showing few returns to the National Policy before the
late 1890s.
The resettlement of the West involved imposing a new, systematic, artificial, and highly standardized
system of land ownership.
Tariffs aimed to protect central Canadian industries that were exposed to more cheaply priced Amer-
ican and British manufacturers products.
Western farmers complained that they paid too much for tariff-protected Canadian goods.
108 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

The tariff wall encouraged new patterns of investment in Canadian industry.

Attributions
Figure 3.9
The Stoney Creek Bridge by David R. Spencer is used under a CC BY SA 3.0 license.

Figure 3.10
Turning of the Sod at Canadian Car & Foundry by City of Thunder Bay Archives is in the public domain. This
image is available from Thunder Bay Archives under the reference number 1991-6 #129.

Figure 3.11
Dent(1881) 1.378 Manitoba by John Charles Dent is in the public domain. This image is available from British
Library under the accession number HMNTS 9555.f.7..

Figure 3.12
Ottawa Boot & Shoe Factory, New Market Street (Online MIKAN no.3246578) by William James Topley /
Library and Archives Canada / C-002207 is in the public domain.

Figure 3.13
Its Only a Matter of Time. Old Fogyism may hold her back for a while, but she is bound to come to us
(Online MIKAN no.2837922) by Puck Magazine / Library and Archives Canada, Acc. No. 1959-71-37 is in the
public domain.

Figure 3.14
RCA Victor factory by Jeangagnon is in the public domain.
 3.4 Rise of a Working Class

Figure 3.15 A Canadian working class arose in the major urban

centres; it was also fashioned in relatively remote resource towns
like Port Essington on the northwest coast where Aboriginal,
Euro-Canadian, and immigrant labour from Asia and Europe met
for the first time.

The Canadian working class was emerging well before 1867. By Confederation one could say for the first time
that the growth of the working class was now unstoppable. The creation of the Dominion of Canada took place
precisely at that moment when widespread industrialization was visibly underway. In 1851, fewer than a quarter
of Hamilton, Ontarios workers laboured in workshops of ten or more employees; by 1871 the share was more
1
than 80%. In less than two decades, Hamilton had been transformed from a market town dominated by com-
merce into a powerful symbol of heavy industry. Significant and startling though this change was at the time, it
was dwarfed by developments in the 1890s. In that decade, Canadian economic growth simultaneously intensified
in the older cities and found new fields in which to flourish in the West. The population of Canada in 1901 was
5,371,315; ten years later it was 7,206,643 an increase of 34%. At the same time, however, the labour force grew
2
from 1,899,000 in 1901 to 2,809,000 in 1911, a phenomenal 50% increase. To put this into some perspective,
there were only 3,463,000 people in the Dominion in 1867 by 1911 there were close to that many working,
wage-earning Canadians. The working class were motivated and shaped by different factors in the various regions
of the country, although common themes were quick to arise.

Workplace Conditions
A middle-aged factory worker in 1870 would likely remember very clearly working in settings where having a
half-dozen other employees felt crowded. In the 1860s, working spaces were designed for small teams of mostly
manual labourers and artisans. That was about to change.

Industrializing employers were finding their way in a new kind of business. Some came into it from their

1. Bryan D. Palmer, Working-Class Experience: Rethinking the History of Canadian Labour, 1800-1991, 2nd ed. (Toronto: McClelland &
Stewart, 1992), 83.
2. Statistics Canada, Historical Statistics of Canada, 2nd ed., ed. F. H. Leacy (Ottawa: Statistics Canada, 1983): D498-511.

109
110 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

own smaller operations: small producers (some of them artisans) began employing more staff, mechanizing
some processes, moving to larger spaces, and becoming manufacturers. This evolutionary model co-existed with
instances where factory owners arrived ready-made from other parts of Canada, but more often, from the United
States or the United Kingdom. Increased linkages across industries and systems also meant that capitalists and
factory owners in one line of business regularly sought to close gaps in supply lines by means of vertical integra-
tion.

These varied circumstances created distinctive conditions of work. For example, the two principal coal mining
operations on Vancouver Island in the late 19th century were owned by the London-based and investor-driven
Vancouver Coal Mining and Land Company (VCMLC) and the Dunsmuir family. The former sent out managers,
sometimes recruiting support staff locally, and generally encouraged their workers to buy their own homes and
to build community institutions. The latter was led by Scottish immigrants, Robert and Joan Dunsmuir, their son
James, and a son-in-law. Robert had been a miner in Ayrshire, Scotland and James spent some of his youth learn-
ing the trade first-hand beneath Vancouver Island. Their involvement in the miners lives was much more perva-
sive and included the use of company housing and stores (both as services and as weapons during disputes). The
VCMLC operation had to generate dividends for shareholders, while the Dunsmuir mines were run with an eye to
making money for the owners and their kin, and as such were far less arms-length operations.

Figure 3.16 Their coalminers lived in shacks but the Dunsmuirs

lived in style. James Dunsmuirss Hatley Castle near Victoria has,
since his death, served as a military college and Royal Roads
University, as well as the home of the X-Men in a series of
movies.

Coal mines and other resource-extraction industries in these years were a critical part of the pre-Great War econ-
omy. Providing fuel for steam power made coal important but it was also key to heating food and urban homes;
cities and forest clearing had outstripped the ability of town people to find their own fuel. Likewise the food pro-
duction industries of the late 19th century existed only because urbanites the fastest growing demographic on
the planet could not address their own food supply. The grain economy boom of the turn of the century was
part of this and so, too, was the growth of canneries. These appeared in fruit- and vegetable-growing regions but
they were most impressive in the fisheries. What these resource-extraction industries had in common, then, was a
growing market that was certain to continue growing and, in the years between 1867 and 1914, a need for large
numbers of labourers.

Craig Heron (York University) discusses the creation of workers communities and a working class.
 3.4 RISE OF A WORKING CLASS 111

Race and Class

West Coast coal mines and canneries were sites of diversity, where Euro-Canadians worked alongside Chinese,
Aboriginal, African-American, and Japanese labourers. These environments did not emerge by accident. Indus-
trialization in Europe witnessed mass migrations off the land and into cities and the simultaneous conversion of
peasant populations into urban industrial workers. This pattern could be seen in Scotland as farmers flooded into
the factories and shipyards of Glasgow, and in Liverpool, which was awash with Irish immigrants performing all
manner of labour. In Canada, there wasnt much in the way of a peasantry to convert into industry; it had to be
imported from elsewhere. In places like British Columbia, the choices came down to the proletarianization of
Aboriginal people or the import of unskilled and mostly agricultural workers from Asia. If British Columbia had
a more pastoral landscape and not a lot of mineral, timber, or fishery resources, then it is likely that the population
would have been very differently composed.

Figure 3.17 It would be difficult not to be simultaneously

impressed by innovative machinery like this one and concerned
about the displacement of labour that it entailed. The Iron
Chink revolutionized the salmon canning industry on the Pacific
Northwest coast.

Wages and conditions of work in factories, mines, and mills varied sharply according to race. Age was another
factor. If the question was: Where do we find largely unskilled labour that will work under supervision in indus-
trial conditions at rates that will profit employers? one answer was to find labour from a displaced or stressed
peasant population. Another answer: from among the child population.
 112 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 3.18 Children contributed to the

household income in a variety of ways, including
coal gathering, which provided fuel to
households and could be sold as well. A young
girl in Toronto, ca. 1900.

Childhood and Labour

Boys and girls had very different experiences in wage labour. Even in urban environments girls labour was
conceived of within certain gendered boundaries: Domestic work, child-minding, and fine-work textiles
and stitchery were likely destinations. Girls work was, too, comparatively undervalued so the likelihood was
3
always stronger that boys, rather than girls, would be sent out first to find wages for the household. Female
income levels were generally capped, too, by expectations that they would become either dependents (in a male
breadwinner model) or their income was little more than a supplement to the husbands or fathers wage. Boys,
on the other hand, were part of a gendered culture of apprenticeships and the expectation that, with age and expe-
rience, their income levels would rise. Boys were welcomed into the workplace from the age of eight years until
the late 1870s when social pressures and legislation began to push the acceptable starting age upward to approxi-
mately 12 years. Child labour practices, in this respect, varied from province to province for two reasons: labour
legislation was a provincial responsibility and different industrial activities predominated across the country with
practices being tailored to meet those local conditions. There was no consensus about a vision for childhood:
whether children should be sent into often dangerous workplaces or into schools was one of several points of
debate. Child labour legislation might protect working children from some hazards but it also barred them from
contributing to the household wage. As one study of children in mining observes,

Efforts to define childrens dependence clashed sharply with the working-class family wage economy, whereby boys and
girls began to labour for wages at a young age as a key survival strategy. For this reason, working-class parents were
4
among the principal opponents of legislation aimed to restrict childrens employment.

Some employers echoed these working-class qualms, principally because they saw child labour laws as a way of
reducing profits by forcing the employers to hire more expensive adults. On the West Coast, restrictions on child
labour chased the regulation of Asian labour and vice versa. The goal of a sufficient household wage among Euro-
Canadian and Aboriginal workers could be undercut by adult Chinese and Japanese labourers, who were willing
to work for about the same amount as boys. The racist context of debate on the issue of child labour was some-
thing of a distraction in that the English-speaking world was moving away from the use of children in industry. On
the opposite coast, for example, and in the absence of a competing immigrant population, Nova Scotian collieries
boys represented a falling share of an expanding workforce from 1866-1911, during which time their presence

3. Bettina Bradbury began considering these relationships between household members, gender, and the economy in a series of studies she
undertook from the late 1970s to the early 21st century. Her earliest work The Family Economy and Work in an Industrializing City:
Montral in the 1870s, Canadian Historical Association, Historical Papers/Communications Historiques (1979): 71-96 remains a land-
mark.
4. Robert McIntosh, Boys in the Pits: Child Labour in Coal Mines (Montral & Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 2000), 40.
 3.4 RISE OF A WORKING CLASS 113

shrank from as much as 27% of the workforce underground (at Sydney Mines in 1886 and 1891) to as little as
5
5.5% in 1911 (at Springhill). The tide was turning against child labour.

This change in attitude is found throughout the 1889 Report of the Royal Commission on the Relations of Labor
and Capital. Established in 1887, this was the eighth investigative enquiry into social, economic, and adminis-
trative issues. One study describes it this way: The Royal Commission is a testament to not only the turbu-
lent economic relations in late-Victorian Canada, but the emergence of the Canadian states active role in social
6
relations. The Royal Commissions recommendations apart from the idea of an annual Labour Day were
mostly ignored by the federal government (which claimed that changes in labour conditions were rightly in the
provincial jurisdiction) but its disclosures about child labour were widely covered in newspapers and aroused pub-
lic concern. In the commissioners own words:

In some parts of the Dominion the employment of children of very tender years is still permitted. This injures the health,
stunts the growth and prevents the proper education of such children, so that they cannot become healthy men and women
or intelligent citizens. It is believed that the regular employment in mills, factories and mines of children less than 14
years of age should be strictly forbidden. Further, [we] think that young persons should not be required to work during
the night at any time, nor before seven oclock in the morning during the months of December, January, February and
7
March.

Under the ominous heading of Child-Beating, the commissioners made this recommendation:

The darkest pages in the testimony are those recording the beating and imprisonment of children employed in factories.
Your Commissioners earnestly hope that these barbarous practices may be removed, and such treatment made a penal
offence, so that Canadians may no longer rest under the reproach that the lash and the dungeon are accompaniments of
8
manufacturing industry in the Dominion.

Provincial restrictions on child labour and on other aspects of workplace safety and laws were only as
good as the inspectors whose business it was to keep employers in line. In the British Columbia Ministry of
Mines Annual Reports, for example, one finds one or two inspectors in the pre-1914 era attempting to cover an
industry that extended from Vancouver Island to the Kootenays and into the Cariboo. Their arrival was always
anticipated, so there was little chance of a surprise inspection. The reports issued by the inspectors, moreover,
indicate a willingness on the part of mine owners and supervisors to comply with the law but whenever a disaster
occurred and mine explosions in Nanaimo claimed over 200 lives in 1887-1888 the roll-call of the dead
invariably revealed children well under the legal age.

An Inspector Reports

James R. Brown, a Toronto factory inspector testified to the Royal Commission on the Relations of Labor
and Capital that his team had been set the task of inspecting Ontarios factories and that the work was
largely completed.

5. Ibid., 71.
6. Stephen J. Cole, Commissioning Consent: An Investigation of the Royal Commission on the Relations of Labour and Capital, 1886-1889,
unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, (Kingston, ON, Queens University, 2007): ii.
7. Canada. Royal Commission on the Relations of Labor and Capital, 1889, republished and edited with an introduction by Greg Kealey in Canada Investi-
gates Industrialism: The Royal Commission on the Relations of Labor and Capital, 1889 (Abridged) (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1973), 13.
8. Ibid., 14.
 114 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Q. Did you find in many places where women were employed that they were working longer than the
[1884 Ontario Factories Act] contemplates?
A. Not in a great number of places. I found that principally in woolen [sic] mills.
Q. What were the longest hours for which you found women employed?
A. Sixty-six hours a week.
Q. Did you find any opposition to shortening the hours?
A. No; in each case where I found them working that time the employers stated that they were not aware
the Act had been in force, and they were waiting for some formal intimation about the matter. Of course,
they stated they would comply with the Act and reduce the hours of labour, so as not to exceed 60 hours.
Q. Did you notice [] any large percentage of children?
A. Yes; in some of them in the cotton mills and some woolen mills, in cigar factories and knitting
works, and some others.
Q. Were there many of those children below the age designated by the Act?
A. Well, I found about 40 girls under 14. Girls are not allowed under 14 nor boys under 12. I found six
boys altogether nine years of age, and some ten or eleven.
9

Long hours were only one source of complaint among factory workers. Punishments abounded and were often
arbitrary. Testimony from a 14 year old journeyman cigar maker in Montreal in 1887-1889 revealed a regime of
arbitrary beatings (a crack across the head with the fist) when a job was done poorly and the possibility of being
imprisoned in the factory in a black hole, a windowless room in the factory cellar for upwards of 7 hours at
10
time. Adults might escape beatings but not fines; dismissals were not uncommon. Moreover, involvement in a
labour organization or a strike particularly in a leadership capacity could result in a workers name being
added to a blacklist. Canada was large enough a country that a blacklisted worker might outrun this sanction, but
sometimes the sanction followed them even into the United States. Civil suits were sometimes launched against
labour activists and many labour leaders spent some time behind bars. In the 20th century, as the size and distribu-
tion of industries and corporations increased, managers came to rely heavily on intelligence gathered by industrial
spies. Employers, at times, sympathized with some of the social goals of workers organizations, or unions, and
began experimenting with what has come to be known as corporate welfarism. This is an array of services and
benefits provided by the employer (but generally outside of a collective agreement). Employers did not, however,
sympathize with the unions themselves and were often ruthless in disposing of the organizations and their sup-
porters.

Class and Gender

Women were on the frontlines of industrialization and the creation of a working class. In 1901, 53% of all Cana-

9. Canada. Royal Commission on the Relations of Labor and Capital, 1889, republished and edited with an introduction by Greg Kealey in
Canada Investigates Industrialism: The Royal Commission on the Relations of Labor and Capital, 1889 (Abridged) (Toronto: University of
Toronto Press, 1973), 95-7.
10. Canada. Royal Commission on the Relations of Labor and Capital, 1889, republished and edited with an introduction by Greg Kealey in
Canada Investigates Industrialism: The Royal Commission on the Relations of Labor and Capital, 1889 (Abridged) (Toronto: University of
Toronto Press, 1973), 214-16.
 3.4 RISE OF A WORKING CLASS 115
11
dian females were participating in the labour force, compared to 78.3% of all males. The labour of women was
less visible than that of men in these years because of the persistence of cottage labour or, in urban environ-
ments, outwork. Materials would be taken home by women workers and stitched together or in some other way
refined so as to add value. This kind of labour (sometimes referred to as sweated labour) could easily be as gru-
elling as any factory work. Women were employed for both types of work in Toronto in 1868, when the Globe
12
newspaper reported that some 4,000 women were either factory workers or they were engaged in outwork. Over-
all, the mechanization and systematization of work created more and more opportunities for women to engage in
wage labour. The growing obsession of the 19th century state (federal and provincial) with surveying populations
and businesses means that we have suggestive (if not comprehensive) information on the range of womens expe-
riences in the workforce.

Womens wages were typically a fraction of mens, regardless of sector. The 1889 Royal Commission on the Rela-
tions of Labor and Capital reported that womens wages in Ontario were about one-third those earned by men.
The assumption that a patriarchal breadwinner brought home the bulk of the household wage was widespread and
difficult to dislodge (and, indeed, persists in some quarters today). Womens wages were thus trivialized as top-ups
or pin money. As mens wages lowered due to mechanization and increased competition for work that required
fewer skills, the proportional contribution of women to the household economy became greater and greater. Chil-
dren, too, were increasingly in demand in the industrial workforce, even sometimes taking jobs that had otherwise
been the preserve of adult males.

Figure 3.19 Poorhouses were disappearing but, in

1871, they were still a refuge for desperate
Canadians and a source of some dread.

In cities like Montreal, living conditions were particularly bleak in the last 40 years of the century. Housing was
of a poor quality and cramped; infant mortality rates were high, as were maternal mortality rates. Historian of the
working-class, Brian Palmer, describes these domestic situations as potentially dangerous ones for women:

The underside of the adaptive families of Victorian Canada is a history of husbands deserting wives, of brutality in which
women and children suffered the presence and power of abusive men, and of males (and, occasionally, females) appro-
priating the paid and unpaid labour of their spouses and offspring as well as availing themselves of sexual access to those
13
who, emotionally and physically, had few resources to resist.

By the end of the century, something like one-in-every-eight wage earners was a woman. The needle trades
were dominated by women, and textile towns saw industrialism effectively feminized. The systematization of
cigar production allowed the penetration of what was once an adult male enclave by large numbers of boys, girls,
and women. Womens involvement in the labour force increased dramatically from 1891-1921. In an era when the

11. Statistics Canada, Historical Statistics of Canada, 2nd ed., ed. F. H. Leacy (Ottawa: Statistics Canada, 1983): D107-123.
12. Bryan D. Palmer, Working-Class Experience: Rethinking the History of Canadian Labour, 1800-1991, 2nd ed. (Toronto: McClelland &
Stewart, 1992), 83.
13. Bryan D. Palmer, Working-Class Experience: Rethinking the History of Canadian Labour, 1800-1991, 2nd ed. (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1992), 101.
 116 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

population overall and the size of the labour force doubled, the number of gainfully employed women expanded
even more rapidly. In the professions (which include teaching and nursing), the numbers leapt from fewer than
20,000 to nearly 93,000; clerical and sales workers exploded from 8,530 to just shy of 128,000. The category
operatives, which mostly covers industrial workers, saw womens involvement rise from 150,649 to 240,572.
However, the number of women on farms was flat and, as a share of the population, that number was falling. The
number of women listed as labourers fell from 1,049 to 441, but rebounded to 11,716 in 1931 which suggests
14
that the categorys definition was an issue.

Figure 3.20 Mechanization and systematic organization of the

workplace were defining features of deskilling in industrial
settings. Women in war production at Canadian General Electric,
Peterboro, ca. 1914-18.

One distinctive aspect of womens work lives was the influence of reproduction on labour. That is, the raising
of families. While boys would rise through a process of apprenticeship through journeyman to adult worker and
would continue on that rarely-broken path until they retired or died, girls and women entered and withdrew from
the workforce more intermittently. Girls labour in the late 19th century was more heavily regulated (most provin-
cial legislation kept them out of the workforce for two years longer than boys) and so they were more likely to get
some formal education or take hidden work in domestic settings or outwork. If the households income improved,
girls might be withdrawn from paid work in order to contribute more to the rearing of younger siblings a strat-
egy that would perhaps free up adult women in the household for wage-earning opportunities. Bettina Bradburys
studies of women in industrializing Montreal show wives participation in the workforce proceeding through life
cycle stages. The highest levels of participation are likely to come before the arrival of children, dipping with the
arrival of infants and then dropping severely when the household contains children between one and 10 years of
15
age. Participation rates recover and peak once again when at least one of the children passes the age of 11 years.

Historians have struggled to recover what class awareness and experience meant to women at this time. State-
ments of solidarity and a commitment to political and social reform were often tempered by the social conventions
of the Victorian era. While women might have challenged some of those limitations, they perpetuated others.
In some womens union locals in Ontario in the 1880s and 1890s, the membership was so reluctant to take on
16
unfeminine leadership roles that they requested the appointment of male organizers. Associations like the
Knights of Labor gave a high priority to what were considered at the time to be gender issues. It is safe to assume
that these positions reflect the feelings of their female membership, as well as at least a considerable proportion
of the male Knights. Historian of labour, Brian Palmer, has commented on this phenomenon:

[The Knights] deplored the capitalist degradation of honest womanhood that resulted from exploiting women at the work-
place; many took great offence at the coarse language, shared water closets (toilets) and intimate physical proximities that
came with virtually all factory labour in Victorian Canada. Nor did the Order turn a blind eye to domestic violence and

14. Statistics Canada, Historical Statistics of Canada, 2nd ed., ed. F. H. Leacy (Ottawa: Statistics Canada, 1983): 86-106, D123
15. Bettina Bradbury, The Family Economy and Work in an Industrializing City: Montreal in the 1870s, in Cities and Urbanization: Canadian
Historical Perspectives, ed. Gilbert A. Stelter (Toronto: Copp Clark Pitman, 1990): 141.
16. Bryan D. Palmer, Working-Class Experience: Rethinking the History of Canadian Labour, 1800-1991, 2nd ed. (Toronto: McClelland &
Stewart, 1992), 136.
 3.4 RISE OF A WORKING CLASS 117

the ways in which men could take advantage of women sexually. Local assembly courts could try and convict members of
the Knights of Labor for wife-beating, and the Ontario Order was a strong backer of the eventually successful campaign
17
to enact seduction legislation.

What all of these studies reveal is that industrialism brought women and children along with men into the urban
cauldron of change in the same era. Moreover, this constituted a perceived change in the long-standing rural and
commercial way of doing things. Life courses changed, conditions of work were invented out of nothing, new
anxieties replaced old, and there was in this mesh of experiences a realization that a new social class was
emerging.

Class Consciousness and Resistance

Studies of the birth of working classes identify two aspects in particular: the shared experiences of belonging to
a population dependent on wage-labour in an industrializing economy, and awareness of the same. Loyalties cut
across societies and cultures in many directions, muting the possibility of working people seeing themselves as
members of a common socioeconomic category or class. One measure of that emerging and evolving class con-
sciousness is the incidence of labour disruption in the 19th century.

The pre-Confederation era saw a rapid rise in labour disputes, accelerating in the 1860s. These principally
involved small local associations of skilled craftsmen employed in factories. People of this generation could
recall being independent craftsmen and transitioning into wage labour; now they were facing the mechanization
of processes and a consequent devaluation of their hard-earned skills. These workers were generally literate and
aware of political and international events. They recognized that their struggles echoed those occurring in Britain
and the United States. Every strike, in this context, was like a flare sent up from a ship in distress. Inevitably,
others would respond.

By 1880, it is estimated that there were approximately 165 labour organizations in Canada, some of them local,
many of them international. Virtually all of these were craft-based. As such, they perpetuated many of the asso-
ciational rituals and practices from pre-industrial times. Marches, banners, oaths of loyalty, and the building of
assembly halls were the most visible of these. Less obvious was the role that early unions played as social safety
18
nets. Almost all had a benevolent society component to their work that involved life insurance for members
families. The importance of this role could be seen when industrial accidents most spectacularly in coal min-
ing disasters snuffed out lives a hundred at a time. Providing for widows and orphans was thus core to their
mandate and an important part of building identification between labour and its community.

17. Bryan D. Palmer, Working-Class Experience: Rethinking the History of Canadian Labour, 1800-1991, 2nd ed. (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1992), 146.
18. Bryan D. Palmer, Working-Class Experience: Rethinking the History of Canadian Labour, 1800-1991, 2nd ed. (Toronto: McClelland &
Stewart, 1992), 94-6.
118 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Table 3.1 Work force by occupational category and sex, 1891-1921

All occupations

Total M F
1921 3,173,169 2,683,019 490,150

1911 2,725,148 2,358,519 366,629

1901 1,782,621 1,544,050 238,571
1891 1,607,945 1,411,936 196,009

Owners, managers
Total M F

1921 264,245 253,825 10,420

1911 219,008 207,923 11,085
1901 84,040 81,004 3,036

1891 78,639 74,668 3,971

Professional

Total M F

1921 173,222 80,249 92,973

1911 84,153 49,817 34,336

1901 85,590 42,389 40,201

1891 58,893 33,184 19,709

Clerical and sales

Total M F

1921 389,886 262,023 127,863

1911 226,448 175,434 51,014

1901 111,041 91,402 19,639
1891 84,474 75,944 8,530

Operatives
Total M F
1921 996,020 755,448 240,572

1911 933,577 689,890 243,687

1901 663,755 498,102 165,653

1891 543,560 392,911 150,649

Farm & Farm Labourers

 3.4 RISE OF A WORKING CLASS 119

Total M F
1921 1,040,787 1,022,906 17,881

1911 929,847 913,067 16,780

1901 715,528 706,627 8,901

1891 734,122 722,021 12,101

Labourers

Total M F
1921 309,009 308,568 441
1911 332,115 322,388 9,727

1901 125,667 124,526 1,141

1891 114,257 113,208 1,049
Data source: Statistics Canada, Historical Statistics of Canada, 2nd ed., ed. F. H. Leacy (Ottawa: Statistics Canada,
1983): D86-106.

Rise of Management
Another development that confirmed the change in workers status since the mid-19th century was the rise of new
management styles. Management generally became more widespread and dignified as a career in its own right.
This was apparent in many environments, even underground, where new techniques for extracting (or winning)
coal enabled greater supervision.

The workforce as a whole was growing in the three decades before 1920 and in no category more so than in
owners and managers (as can be seen in the table above). Starting at 78,639 in 1891, the total number grew to
84,040 in 1901, and 219,008 in 1911. The number of women in this category leapt from 3,036 in 1901 to 11,085
19
in 1911. Early in the 20th century attempts were made to rationalize systems of production that had lurched for-
ward for 50 years without much thought given to systems. The most well-known body of thought on this subject
is the scientific management model pioneered by the American Frederick Winslow Taylor (1856-1919). Some-
times referred to as Taylorism, these new approaches considered everything from the coordination of shift work,
the positioning of machinery, and the inculcation of new industrial virtues like punctuality.

Taylorism was part of a growing middle class agenda of social reform that included child labour legislation,
universal education, and temperance or prohibition. While Canadians beyond the working-class acknowledged
that excesses of exploitation needed to be curbed and that the most vulnerable needed to be protected, an inter-
ventionist state was still some decades away. And, of course, Canadian federalism meant that social legislation
would arise at the provincial level, so it would be unevenly developed and potentially idiosyncratic. Middle-class
engagement in these issues, however, could only go so far and reformism quickly ran up against emerging class-
based antipathies. These tensions would explode in the first two decades of the 20th century.

19. Statistics Canada, Historical Statistics of Canada, 2nd ed., ed. F. H. Leacy (Ottawa: Statistics Canada, 1983): D86-106.
120 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Key Points

Industrialization produced a class of wage earners whose numbers grew rapidly in the 19th century.
Working conditions in factories and mines were diverse but generally dangerous and unpleasant.
Racial and gender categories divided and complicated the working-class experience.
Children contributed to working-class household incomes, but were regularly abused in the work-
place and were increasingly subjected to regulation by the state.
Early labour organizations campaigned for improved working conditions for women and children as
well as men.
More complex systems and larger scales of production helped to produce a growing class of man-
agers and supervisors.

Attributions
Figure 3.15
Port Essington by Unknown is in the public domain.

Figure 3.16
Hatley Castle by Smably is in the public domain.

Figure 3.17
The Iron Chink by upyernoz is used under a CC BY 2.0 license.

Figure 3.18
Young girl probably with bag of coal gathered from beside box cars (Online MIKAN no.3194020) by Library
and Archives Canada / PA-118224 is in the public domain.

Figure 3.19
Rules and Regulations of the County Poor House (Online MIKAN no.2988345) by Library and Archives
Canada, Acc. No. 1984-4-901 / Committee of Management of the Poor House has nil restrictions on use.

Figure 3.20
Women working on primers, [Canadian General Electric Co. Ltd., Peterboro, Ont. (Online MIKAN
no.3371002) by Canada. Dept. of National Defence / Library and Archives Canada / PA-024490 is in the public
domain.
 3.5 Urbanization and Industry

Figure 3.21 The largest city in English Canada, Toronto covered a

relatively small area. Public celebrations like this one for the
Boer War in 1901 brought thousands into the streets. Notice
how pedestrians, cyclists, streetcars, and horse-drawn wagons
compete for space.

Industrialization took place in existing cities and it called into existence new industrial cities. There was,
therefore, a changing urban landscape in some cases, but also a kind of urban template was developed for emer-
gent cities, onto which industrial relations were imposed. Cities were sites of class struggle and the negotiation of
new social relations, regardless of whether they were Canadian metropolises or small mining towns like Green-
wood, BC or Frank, AB. The common denominator was the role that capital played in creating landscapes and
cityscapes that gave priority to productive processes, sometimes with a brief horizon in mind.

The Dominion of Cities

1
Between 1871-1911, the population of Canada nearly doubled, from 3,689,000 to 7,207,000. Most of that growth
was in urban areas as the share of the workforce engaged in non-agricultural pursuits rose from 51.9% to over
2
60% in the same period. Even in Nova Scotia, where the benefits of industrialization were not long lasting nor
very deep, the impact on the scale of urban settlements was very dramatic: in the decade after Confederation, Hal-
ifax grew by 22%, New Glasgow by 55%, Sydney Mines by 57%, and Truro by 64%. From 1891-1901, a decade
of immigration strongly associated with the growth of population and farm settlement in the West, Sydney tripled
3
in size, emerging as the second largest city in the province.

These figures, respectable though they were, are totally eclipsed by the growth of Western towns and cities. Cal-
gary held fewer than 4,000 people in 1891, and added only 500 over the next 10 years. Then its population leapt
to 43,704 in 1911 and 63,305 in 1921 with an economy built mainly around distribution, food processing (e.g.,
4
meat packing), and housing materials. In 1891, Winnipeg became the first western city to join the ranks of the

1. Statistics Canada, Historical Statistics of Canada, 2nd ed., ed. F. H. Leacy (Ottawa: Statistics Canada, 1983): A78-93.
2. ibid., D1-7
3. Statistics Canada, Census of Canada, 1931, vol.1, Table 13 (Ottawa: 1932).
4. Max Foran with Edward Cavell, Calgary: An Illustrated History (Toronto: James Lorimer & Company, 1978), 70.

121
122 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

10 largest centres in Canada, arriving in ninth spot with a population of 25,642. The very next census saw it pull
ahead of all the Maritime cities (including Halifax), and in 1911, it was the third largest city in the country, with
136,035 people. Likewise, Vancouver joined the top-10 in 1901, with only 26,133 people, and moved into fourth
place in 1911 with 120,847. By 1921, four of the 10 largest cities in Canada were in the West, but the older eastern
members of this club of leading cities were not going to be easily overtaken. Ottawa, after all, doubled every 20
years from 21,545 in 1871 to 44,156 in 1891, and 87,082 in 1911; the Dominion capital passed the 100,000 mark
by 1921, but by that time its population had dropped from its best ranking of fourth (in 1901) to sixth.

None of these cities was without an important industrial component. Vancouver, Calgary, Regina, and Winnipeg
each had important rail yards and repair shops associated with the CPR (as did, to a lesser degree, Kamloops,
Medicine Hat, and Brandon). Industrializing the production of food was another shared feature, whether in the
form of canning salmon or packing meat or shipping enormous quantities of grain. Housing materials was also
important to the regional booming population. Door and sash factories and lumber mills appeared in all of the
biggest cities, in addition to other expressions of industrialism such as printers, cigar makers, and newspapers.
Each of the western cities, too, had a role to play in goods distribution. This involved the handling of foodstuffs
and construction materials needed by an increasing population, but also the manufactured goods produced in cen-
tral Canada. An example of this is the distribution system developed in the 1890s by Toronto department store
owner Timothy Eaton (1834-1907). Warehouses for Eatons goods were built in the major centres but actual stores
only appeared in the West in 1905. In the meantime, one could order from catalogues and have delivered a huge
variety of manufactured products including houses as buildable kits.

Figure 3.22 The Neils Hogenson House in Stirling, Alberta was

ordered from the Eatons Catalogue in 1917 as an
assemble-it-yourself kit.

What is conspicuous by its absence from the western cities at the turn of the century is heavy industry. Textiles did
well for a while in Winnipeg, but steel manufacturing and the production of machinery both remained an effective
monopoly of central Canada. When the automobile industry arrived in Canada, it was in Walkerville and Mon-
treal, not Edmonton or New Westminster (let alone Halifax or Charlottetown). Processing primary products with
very little value added was the norm in the West. It is partly for this reason that workers in the emergent service
industries streetcar drivers, milk deliverymen, fire fighters were important players in the trade union land-
scape of the West.

Figure 3.23 The clean lines of brick factories, the bold

smokestacks and water towers, and the promotional branding
visible on this textile mill were all indicators of industrial
progress and capitalist confidence in central Canadian
communities like Renfrew, Ontario.
 3.5 URBANIZATION AND INDUSTRY 123

While urbanism was spreading alongside industrialism and capitalism, the power of Montreal and Toronto was
growing greater with each passing generation. In 1871, there were slightly more than 100,000 people in Mon-
treal; Toronto at 56,092 was slightly smaller than Quebec City. By 1891, Montreal had a population of
nearly 220,000 and Toronto was three-times the size of Quebec City at 181,000. These two economic and indus-
trial centres were rapidly emerging as a first-rung category of cities, the countrys two metropolises. In 1911, the
census found nearly half a million people in Montreal and 380,000 in Toronto. By the end of the Great War, both
had passed the half million mark and the next nearest city, Winnipeg, was less than half as large with fewer than
200,000. Torontos rate of growth and transformation was more sudden and spectacular than Montreals but both
were, even in 1900, nothing like what they had been in 1867. Both cities hosted large manufacturing operations,
as did second- and third-tier cities in Ontario and in Quebecs Eastern Townships. In the immediate catchment of
each of the two major cities, a metropolitan influence was obvious as the local economies became more closely
knit. The foremost example of this is the so-called golden horseshoe at the western end of Lake Ontario: Toronto
was the unchallenged heart of this conurbation that grew (and became an almost continuous urban sprawl) through
the 20th century.

The links between the second industrial revolution and urbanization are described by historian Craig
Heron (York University).

Urban Conditions to 1920

Figure 3.27 A survey of working-class housing in Montreal in

1903 found high density and badly deteriorated conditions.

City growth is a companion process of industrialization and, as we have seen, industrialization was enabled by
 124 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Confederation. Maritime historian, Larry McCann, captured this when he wrote, The transformation of Nova
Scotias economic structure and the growth of its towns and cities in the post-Confederation period occurred
5
simultaneously with the provinces integration into the continental economy. Larger factories replaced smaller
shops and these factories, of course, were located in towns. Opportunities to earn cash wages attracted young peo-
ple off the land, especially those who were unlikely to inherit the family farm. Newcomers from abroad, naturally,
came ashore in large port cities and those port cities were the outlets for manufactured goods. The ability to con-
solidate dumps of fuel, whether wood or fossil fuels, was greater in cities that had port and rail, or even canal
facilities. The cities, too, were centres of finance, and industrialism was nothing without capital.

Sean Kheraj (York University), a historian of environmental questions considers the function and mean-
ing of parks specifically Vancouvers Stanley Park in the context of modern cities.

The effect was a self-reinforcing pattern. Factories moved to towns that had financial credibility (that is, either
wealth or the ability to borrow wealth), infrastructure (docks, railyards, etc.) and an established workforce. This
was the case in 1879 when Hart Massey closed the last of his agricultural implements business in Newcastle,
ON (where it had moved in 1849 from the tiny inland village of Bond Head) and relocated everything to Toronto
6
where it merged with its chief competitor. By 1891, Massey-Harris employed nearly 600 people.

Figure 3.25 Slaughterhouses, breweries, and markets were an

important part of any urban landscape, and were usually found in
the very centre of cities. City Market, Saint John, NB in 1910.

While the competition was visibly fierce for investment, giving rise to a generation of civic self-promoters called

5. L.D. McCann, The Mercantile-Industrial Transition in the Metals Towns of Pictou Country, 1857-1931, in Cities and Urbanization: Cana-
dian Historical Perspectives, ed. Gilbert A. Stelter (Toronto: Copp Clark Pitman, 1990): 88-9.
6. Peter G. Goheen, Currents of Change in Toronto, 1850-1900, in The Canadian City: Essays in Urban History, eds. Gilbert A. Stelter and
Alan F.J. Artibise (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1979): 63.
 3.5 URBANIZATION AND INDUSTRY 125

boosters, it was no less pitched when it came to attracting and retaining a population of wage-earners. It was
the ability of Canadians and immigrants to move from town to town in search of work that made industrializa-
tion possible. Free labour (untied to the land or to a feudal relationship) was fundamental to the transition to
industrialism. This worked well enough when the economy was surging and opportunities beckoned. But when
the economy troughed, workers found themselves effectively trapped in the cities where they last hoped to find
work. The 1870s, for example, were marked by dramatic protests and hardship in Ottawa, Montreal, and other
centres as families complained that they were starving for want of work. In Toronto, the local House of Industry
7
received 2,000 applications for refuge between 1879-1882. Cities might create circumstances in which building
rental housing for an emergent working class was both necessary and remunerative. In becoming a tenant, how-
ever, workers exposed themselves to impermanence and the possibility of eviction. If they lived in tied housing
and carried debt at the truck shop or company store, their vulnerabilities could be greater still.

Figure 3.26 Company towns like Britannia Beach, BC provided

rows of identical housing to employees and created small
urban-industrial nodes in otherwise rural areas.

Overcrowding was widespread. Health conditions were often poor. Sewage systems were deplorable and only
began to improve in the 1890s in most Canadian cities and towns. Water supplies were regularly tainted. Immi-
grant, Aboriginal, and African-Canadian neighbourhoods generally endured worse conditions than those occupied
by Anglo- and Franco-Canadians. Housing in some industrial areas was more like dormitories than apartments
because of the extensive occupancy of single men and single women. These conditions prevailed at the very time
when wealthy and leafy suburbs were being created for the owners of industry. Generally located upwind from
the smoke and noise of factories and mills, these wealthy Nob Hills paid obeisance to the capitalist hub of
Canada Montreal and the power of the CPRs elite in their names. A Mount Royal neighbourhood occurs
in cities all along the main CPR line. Vancouvers upper-class Shaughnessy neighbourhood was named in 1907
for the then-president of the CPR, and there are Van Horne streets in cities across the country. The hundreds who
worked in the switching and freight yards thus lived downwind and often downhill from their economic superiors
and employers. Cities had always had elements of spatial segregation based on class and role, but this was being
imposed on Canadian cities in a very purposeful way. Awareness of these differences in quality of life and expe-
riences was not unusual.

Figure 3.27 A view of the Montreal docks in 1896 reveals

working class housing tucked in among the factories and works
yards. Note the laundry on the line in the lower foreground.

7. Bryan D. Palmer, Working-Class Experience: Rethinking the History of Canadian Labour, 1800-1991, 2nd ed. (Toronto: McClelland &
Stewart, 1992), 115.
 126 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Single Industry Towns

Nanaimo, on Vancouver Island, and Sydney, NS are good examples of industrial-era towns with effectively no
8
prior market-town existence. Instant cities of this kind quickly boasted of having the urban amenities found
in other 19th century cities: libraries, schools, concert halls, breweries, hotels, restaurants, and newspapers.

The small and new industrial towns generated urban problems as well. The shocking infant mortality rates of
industrial Montreal in the last quarter of the 19th century running to 285 deaths out of every 1,000 births
barely surpassed Nanaimo in 1881 with 250 per 1,000 births. Kamloops, a booming railway and lumber mill town
built atop a cattle and fur trade settlement (not to mention ancient Aboriginal villages), had an infant mortality
9
rate of 380 of 1,000 births in 1891.

What Nanaimo and most the Cape Breton mining towns had in common was the fact that they were essentially
single industry communities. The same was true of Drumheller (from 1911), the Crowsnest Pass colliery towns,
the Kootenay hardrock mining towns, and a great number of lumber mill towns across the Maritimes and much
of the rest of the country. In British Columbia, there was a cohort of 25 towns with population of between 500
to about 2,000 people that sprang into existence around 1891. These were primarily mining towns and the largest
share of them were in the Kootenays. Only a handful existed a decade earlier and some would become ghost
towns by 1911.

In some instances, these communities were not just limited by a lack of variety of employment opportunities: they
were in essence (or formally) company towns in which the chief employer was also the landlord, and possibly
responsible for civic authority as well. Communities like these were many and they proved to be highly vulner-
able to changes in the economic weather. As one historian of a New Brunswick cotton textile town observes,
by 1890 there were over one hundred villages comparable to Milltown. These small towns contained over 4,500
10
industrial establishments representing over $2.5 million of invested capital and almost 25,000 jobs. The same
historian adds that these small industrial nodes constituted only one-fourteenth of the industrial capacity of the
46 major Canadian cities, and yet the pattern was cast widely and echoed many of the developments witnessed
in larger centres. There were representatives of this tier of industrial centres in every province and they were an
important part of the Dominions web of industrial activity.

Figure 3.28 Calgary, ca. 1885. Even small service centres were
home to warehouses and processing operations in the industrial
age.

8. This is not to say that they had no prior history as human settlements. Both were sites of permanent and semi-permanent Aboriginal commu-
nities before, during, and after industrialization.
9. John Douglas Belshaw, Becoming British Columbia: A Population History (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2009), 180.
10. Peter DeLottinville, Trouble in the Hives of Industry: The Cotton Industry comes to Milltown, New Brunswick, 1879-1892, in Labour and
Working-Class History in Canada: A Reader, eds. David Frank and Gregory S. Kealey (St. Johns: Institute of Social and Economic
Research, 1995): 131.
 3.5 URBANIZATION AND INDUSTRY 127

Exercise: History Around You

Street by Street

Figure 3.29 The imposition of a tramway intersection on an older

streetway, like this one in Montreal in 1893, would dramatically
change the way the street was used.

The transportation systems of the past leave indelible fingerprints on the dimensions of our cities. Take
a look at the oldest part(s) of your city or town. How wide are the streets? If you live in Lillooet, BC,
for example, theyre extremely wide. Thats also the case on the main streets of downtown Winnipeg. In
Vancouvers Gastown, Water Street is perhaps a quarter as wide. In the Old Town of Quebec or around
Montreals Ville-Marie they are narrower still, as they are in the heart of St. Johns.

Figure 3.30 The appositely named Breakneck Steps in Quebec

City were clearly not designed for animal traffic nor for trams.

Can one conclude from this that people in the past were much thinner than they are now or that Winnipeg-
gers need wider roads to negotiate a turn?
The answer can be found in the dominant transportation technology of the day. St. Johns, Montreal, and
Quebec were built with military concerns in mind and some of the topography was (and is) challenging,
but what distinguishes them most from later cities is that horses were rare. Most of the carting that was
done was powered by human legs. And the turning radius of a handcart is very narrow. Merchants shipping
goods into the Cariboo gold towns via Lillooet had something in common with Mtis freighters in Win-
nipeg: they made use of ox teams. The turning radius of a team of oxen pulling a wagon is necessarily very
large. In between are the cities where horse traffic dominated. The warehouses of Gastown, in Vancouver,
depended on fleets of carters whose moderate-sized horses had to be able to make a U-turn with a small
wagon in tow. Multiple horse teams pulling larger wagons required more space though not as much as
a team of oxen and that transition can be seen in slightly later street layouts.

Figure 3.31 A boy and a horse on Hastings Street near Carrall in

downtown Vancouver, ca. 1897. Some of the oldest buildings had
stables in their basements.

Late 19th and early 20th century cities were typically horse towns. The introduction of streetcars added a
new wrinkle, as can be seen across Vancouver where the streetcar system rapidly outstripped the building
128 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

of neighbourhoods. Streetcar tracks plunged into the forests and through the stumps of South Vancouver
and Point Grey, anticipating the arrival of new housing. Before the arrival of the automobile, these various
forms of transportation foot, hoof, electricity-powered streetcar, and bicycles, too shared the streets
in a way that blends the orderly and the chaotic, as can be seen in this 1907 film taken from the front of
a streetcar in Vancouver, filmed by United States filmmaker (and victim of the Titanic sinking) William
Harbeck.
Where you live and where you work is shaped by the dominant infrastructure of the day. Consider how
your towns transportation history can be seen in the size and shape of its streets and how the physical
space in which you move is, itself, a historic document.

Key Points

Urbanization in the period before the 1920s was a diverse and uneven process.
Two major cities Montreal and Toronto emerged that would dwarf all others; the growth and
economic health of both was based on industrial economies.
New cities in the West were challenging the lead held by Central and Eastern Canadian cities.
Cities increasingly developed sections exclusively occupied by higher or lower social classes, in
which conditions were very different.

Attributions
Figure 3.21
Pretoria Day 1901 by James Salmon is in the public domain.

Figure 3.22
Hogenson House by Cocopie is in the public domain.

Figure 3.23
[Renfrew Textiles Limited factory, Renfrew, Ont.] (Online MIKAN no.3326637) by Hinchley, Harry / Library
and Archives Canada / PA-100649 is in the public domain

Figure 3.24
The Ward as viewed from Eaton factory by William James is in the public domain.

Figure 3.25
Postcard of the Saint John City Market by unknown is in the public domain. This image is available from
McCord Museum under the access number X13436.

Figure 3.26 Britannia Mg & Smelting Co.s mine, Britannia Beach, B.C. (Online MIKAN no.3373553)
by Canada. Dept. of Mines and Technical Surveys / Library and Archives Canada / PA-013798 is in the public
domain.
 3.5 URBANIZATION AND INDUSTRY 129

Figure 3.27
Houses for Mr. Meredith, Montreal, QC, 1903 by McCord Museum has no known copyright restrictions.

Figure 3.28
Calgary Alberta circa 1885 by William Notman is in the public domain. This image is available from Library
and Archives Canada under the reference number C-017804.

Figure 3.29
Tramway crossing under construction, Ste. Catherine and St. Lawrence St., Montreal, QC, 1893 by McCord
Museum has no known copyright restrictions.

Figure 3.30
The Breakneck Steps, Qubec by Louis-Prudent Valle is in the public domain. This image is available from
McCord Museum under the access number MP-0000.321.2.

Figure 3.31
A boy and horse on Hastings Street near Carrall Street by Major James Skitt Matthews is in the public domain.
This image is available from City of Vancouver Archives under the access number AM54-S4-: Str P175.
 3.6 Craft and Industrial Unions

Figure 3.32 Labour Day celebrations in Toronto, ca. 1900.

In the 19th century, there was little in the way of what we call collective bargaining. Workers regularly entered
into contracts directly with employers where the terms may or may not have been standardized. Typically, employ-
ers would post a scale of pay as a means of attracting employees but variations could occur. The implications of
this situation could be severe. Going on strike constituted a breach of contract between the employer and the indi-
vidual employee, making the worker liable to dismissal, legal liability (including fines), and even jail time.

The British Masters and Servants Act still prevailed in the Dominion in the 1870s. Elements of it would survive
for decades due to the divided constitutional responsibility for labour: federal and provincial laws both came into
play. As one study demonstrates:

Fines and imprisonment for simple breaches of employment contracts remained available in several provinces, and in the
Dominion employment jurisdiction, well into the 20th century. [] Despite the brave promises of its preamble, the true
policy of the [Dominions labour law] was not to place employers and workers on a footing of legal equality, but to leave
1
the provinces to their own devices while seeming to be doing something to keep the trains on time.

In short, the Trade Unions Act of 1872 offered little to organized labour other than to recognize its growing impor-
tance on the Canadian political and economic landscape.

Tory and Liberal politicians both recognized a constituency in the making when they looked at the working class,
but their first instincts were to support employers and the economic viability of Canada. That should hardly come
as a surprise. Canadian democracy before the 1870s extended only to adult male property owners: the fathers of
Confederation were white-collar professionals, merchants, and landowners, not artisans (let alone factory work-
ers). As regards labour relations, the goals of Confederation (at both the federal and provincial level) were to
achieve stability and reduce the possibility of workplace and strike violence, and to do that through increased
regulation of labour associations. In the face of an obvious alliance between the provincial and federal state and

1. Paul Craven, 'The Modern Spirit of the Law': Blake, Mowat, and the Breaches of Contract Act, 1877, Essays in the History of Canadian Law: In Honour
of R.C.B. Risk, eds. G. Blaine Baker and Jim Phillips (Toronto: Osgood Society for Canadian Legal History/University of Toronto Press, 1999): 159, 162.

130
 3.6 CRAFT AND INDUSTRIAL UNIONS 131

employers, working people took a page from the book of labour elsewhere and began to organize so as to mitigate
their weaknesses and amplify their voice.

The Nine Hour Movement

Local unions have their own histories and, therefore, the history of labour in Canada is the tale of a great many
organizational processes and struggles. As a whole, however, Canadian labour in the 19th century could turn to a
handful of events that were landmarks in the development of a working class.

The first of these was the Nine Hour Movement. Spurred by similar movements in Britain and the United States,
agitation for a standardized workday began early in 1872, spreading outward from a hub in Hamilton. The Move-
ment failed at this time, damaged by the decision of George Browns employees in the Typographical Union to
pursue their own agenda separately. The ongoing political rivalry between Brown and John A. Macdonald also
played a role. Macdonald saw the strike at Browns shop as an opportunity to undermine his opponent: he supplied
funds to the printers, shoring up their Ontario Workman newspaper through the strike. While this intervention cost
organized labour their Nine Hours, it presented a separate opportunity of sorts. In the aftermath of the strike, Mac-
donald cleared away the most repressive of federal anti-union laws and introduced the Trade Unions Act, 1872.

Historians have weighed Macdonalds motivations in promoting this legislation. Was he hoping to co-opt the
labour movement and to ensure it could be regulated? Was he making a concession to unions which he saw as a
necessary evil and an imminent reality? Was he hoping to win the support of the emergent working class by cham-
pioning their ability to organize? Alternatively, was he merely playing catch-up with Britain? There, the Trade
Union Act of 1871 legalized unions for the first time. It has been suggested, in this regard, that Macdonald was
anxious to ensure that Canada remained appealing to potential British emigrants and worried that an archaic atti-
tude toward labour organizations would deter engineers and other skilled workers from coming to Canada. What-
ever Macdonalds motivations, the Act opened up enough room that year for the establishment of the first attempt
at a national labour centre: the Canadian Labour Union (CLU).

The CLU had the misfortune of arriving just as a severe economic downturn took hold. It collapsed within three
years. In the next decade, however, local Trades and Labour Councils would be established in the major cities, and
from these would arise the successor institution, the Trades and Labour Congress of Canada (TLCC) in 1883.
This organization had far greater staying power and survives to this day (though considerably altered) in the form
of the Canadian Labour Congress (the CLC).

Craft Unions
The older crafts accessed through long apprenticeships were the first to organize and did so before Confeder-
ation. Craft unionists had employed several tactics to secure favourable conditions in the workplace. One of their
concerns regarding skilled workers raised repeatedly was that mechanization, new production systems, and
intensification of supervision would cost them their independence and devalue their experience. As deskilling
progressed, some of these unions advised their members against training new craftsmen so as to control the supply
(and thus the price) of their labour. They also opposed competition from prison labour, unapprenticed workers,
2
child labour, and the exploitation of immigrant workers who might accept lower wages. The craft workers are

2. Craig Heron, The Canadian Labour Movement: A Short History, (Toronto: James Lorimer & Company, 1989), 16.
 132 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

sometimes described as the aristocracy of labour, the best paid and most highly skilled community of workers.
Respectability was highly valued among craft workers and their ideal in terms of industrial relations was a
respectful relationship with employers in which they would be treated as equals in an emergent liberal democratic
order. This meant that, at times, the craft workers inclination was to draw a line between themselves and unskilled
labour.

The Knights of Labor

Several omnibus labour organizations flourished and then fizzled-out in the period between Confederation and
1920 three in particular. Of these, the first provides a transition between the old crafts-based organizations and
the new trade unions. It recognized the connected agendas and priorities of labour in the broadest sense. This was
3
the Noble and Holy Order of the Knights of Labor.

Figure 3.33 A Knights of Labor procession in Hamilton, ca.

1885.

Drawing on the traditions of secret societies, benevolent associations, and religious symbolism, the Knights had
at least as much in common with fraternal orders like the Masonic Lodge as they did with the trade unions
that followed. Founded in Philadelphia in 1869, the Knights crossed the border into Canada in the 1870s.

The Knights were enormously popular for several reasons. They drew all trades and crafts under their umbrella,
included men and women, promoted temperance with regard to alcohol, and in the early years, their organization
was shrouded in the mystery of secret rituals. The movement and it was a movement in that it touched many
aspects of life and spoke to a whole way of being, and not just industrial relations was deeply imbued with the
idea of a respectable working class. The older, skilled crafts that shared a common tradition of artisanal training
and discrete organization in an era when unions were illegal put their stamp on the attitude and approach of the
Knights. Its membership, however, was much broader.

In Canada, the Knights were noteworthy for their organizational skills and also for pulling into one body workers
from English- and French-Canada. The Knights were also popular in the less industrialized communities of the
West and extremely popular among workers in British Columbia. Their vision of a revitalized and reformed soci-
ety, economy, and democracy had an enormous and general appeal in an era of rapid change and wild fluctuations
in employment opportunities:

Somehow their moral outrage and vision of a more communitarian alternative caught the mood of thousands of anxious
workers, who were prepared to take a stand against the dominant social and economic developments of the late 19th cen-
4
tury. The sense of a great moral crusade was in the air.

The Knights, of course, had enemies; in Canada the Catholic Church of Quebec was in the forefront. Archbishop

3. Because the Knights began in the United States, the American spelling of labor is always applied.
4. Craig Heron, The Canadian Labour Movement: A Short History (Toronto: James Lorimer & Company, 1989), 26.
 3.6 CRAFT AND INDUSTRIAL UNIONS 133

Taschereau (1820-98) went so far as to issue an excommunication decree which forbade good Catholics from
5
membership in the Knights. Did the Archbishops fulminations matter? The Vatican told him to retreat, and in
6
the year that followed nearly two-dozen new local assemblies of the Knights were established in Montreal. (The
Knights did, however, drop the Noble and Holy Order title in the 1880s because Catholic members and clergy-
men were troubled by the apparent connection with Freemasonry.) The Knights had less success in Nova Scotia,
where workers were reluctant to join this international organization. There, an indigenous working-class body
the Provincial Workmens Association filled the space that was elsewhere occupied by the Knights.

Although the Knights were largely inclusive, the door was not open to everyone. Bankers, lawyers, stockbrokers
(and speculators in shares), and liquor vendors were not welcome nor was Asian labour. The Knights were par-
tially colour-blind in that they included African-Americans and African-Canadians. However, Asian immigrants
constituted the one visible minority for which the Knights had no tolerance. The Knights backed Asian exclusion
laws in the United States and in Canada, and portrayed Chinese labour as an army of potential strike breakers.
Race riots in the Pacific Northwest targeting Chinese-Americans resulted in deaths and confirmed the Knights
adamant hostility to Asian workers. This was part of the appeal (and part of the limitation) of the Knights in
British Columbia, where anti-Asian workers groups abounded from the 1860s through the early 20th century.

The rhetoric, it must be said, was complex. What non-Asian workers had to say went well beyond a racist objec-
tion to working alongside Chinese labourers or losing their place in the workplace to immigrants. On Vancouver
Island in the mid-1880s, the Knights argued that Chinese labour had a deleterious effect on the confidence and
ability of young people. Our boys, complained the Knights at Nanaimo, grow up to near manhood without an
opportunity to earn any part of their living such as they might have were there no Chinese, and such as boys have
in other parts of the world. The mine manager went so far as to invoke fear of adolescent delinquency:

where Chinese labour is easily procured white youths from 15 years of age and upwards do not find such ready employ-
ment as elsewhere, and consequently are not so well trained in habits of industry. [There] is growing up amongst us a
7
class of idlers who will not conduce to the well-being of the state.

The impact of Asian workers on non-Asian youth, however, was at the end of the day another arrow in a quiver
that overflowed with objections real and imaginary.

The Knights began to fade in the 1880s, although they survived as active participants in labour negotiations here
and there until the eve of the Great War in 1914. Their slide was a manifestation of the very economic uncertainty
that the Knights wanted to address. As competition for jobs intensified, the opportunities to wring concessions
from employers evaporated. Internal divisions over the Knights rather tepid position on industrial militance cost
them support. Workers increasingly wanted results and, if needs be, confrontations with recalcitrant employers.
Dual membership in craft unions and the Knights allowed some workers to enjoy the philosophical and socio-
logical ambitions of the Knights while fighting more concerted battles for better wages and working conditions
through their unions. In 1886, the dangers of dual unionism came to the fore when the Knights endorsed cigar
makers who were not part of the Cigar Makers International Union (CMIU). This created competing associations
in the same trade. Tobacco processing had a presence in every town of any size in Canada and the CMIU mem-
bership was outraged. Thereafter, the cigar makers began an exodus into a different kind of association.

5. Nive Voisine, TASCHEREAU, ELZAR-ALEXANDRE, in Dictionary of Canadian Biography, vol. 12, University of Toronto/Universit
Laval, 2003, accessed 29 June 2015, [Link]
6. Palmer, Working-Class Experience, 131.
7. Canada, Sessional Papers, Royal Commission on Chinese Immigration, no.54a (Ottawa: 1885): xvii, 88, 158.
134 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 3.34 Historic view of the Inland

Cigar Factory in Kamloops, 1895. Note the
presence of child workers.

The International Craft Unions

The Knights loss of support fed the growth of a new labour centre. In the United States, this took the form in
1886 of the American Federation of Labor (AFL), headed by the cigar makers leader, Samuel Gompers. The
same year, the Canadian equivalent the Trades and Labour Congress was established as a federation of local
Labour Councils in the major cities. Canadian unions were the rule, not the exception at this time. Gompers goal,
however, was to unite Canadian and American workers along international craft lines.

While Canadian politicians were engaged in nation-building, skilled workers were simultaneously looking to
international organizations for their future. Immigrants to Canada brought with them the labour traditions of their
homelands and awareness that there were organizations onto which Canadians might graft their own. Some of the
first international unions in Canada were based in Britain, but it was American craft unionism that led the way.
Coopers, iron moulders, and shoe makers established cross-border alliances and shared strategies back and forth.
Withdrawal of labour (in a strike) was invariably countered by employers with the introduction of new workers
who were referred to as strikebreakers or, in the colloquial, scabs. Strikers had to adopt tactics to keep out strike-
breakers, whether at the factory door or at the international border. Violent conflict between strikers and strike-
breakers was a common occurrence and US-based organizations helped Canadian craft unions by discouraging
American workers from playing the strikebreaker role, and by providing financial resources to sustain their Cana-
dian partners.

International unionism of this kind took place in an industrial environment dominated by Great Lakes cities like
Toronto, Buffalo, Hamilton, Cleveland, Windsor, and Detroit. Workers moved back and forth over the borders and
across the lakes, raising the prospect of American strikebreakers showing up during Canadian disputes, and vice
versa. There was also the possibility that, during strikes, factories on one side of the frontier would flood markets
on the other side with goods in such a way that the striking unions position would be undermined. Speaking with
one voice had distinct advantages and clearly many Canadian craft workers agreed. The AFL-TLC alliance would
prove to be a very long-lasting one.

AFL influence over Canadian locals increased through the 1890s, and in 1902 AFL elements took control of the
TLC at its annual conference. The AFLs Canadian organizer, John Flett, was elected president; Knights and Cana-
dian unions alike were expelled.
 3.6 CRAFT AND INDUSTRIAL UNIONS 135

Industrial Unions and the IWW

The 1902 break with non-craft and purely Canadian organizations, however, left a gulf in the state of labour orga-
nization.

The process of deskilling was one factor in the rise of industrial labour. Another was the creation of wholly new
industries unrelated to the sorts of things done by craft workers 50 years earlier. A good, and often militant, exam-
ple was the street railway sector in the major cities, most of which were run by private businesses and none of
which could be said to displace an older mode of production.

Both new industries and deskilling led to growing numbers of workers with limited skills to defend themselves,
and a greater likelihood that they would face instability over their working career. Once work had achieved a
degree of mechanization and automation, or where it had been reduced to the simplest of physical labours, it was
possible to create a class of workers for whom apprenticeships held no attraction and few advantages. This class
of less skilled worker, however, was an interchangeable part, easily dismissed and easily replaced. In addition,
the industrial worker lacked the cultural capital of the craft and even the trade worker. There was no associational
tradition, no history of organization or mutual support on which to erect a new movement. Industrial workers
were often new immigrants with limited abilities in French or English which put them at a further disadvantage.
If they were recruited by labour agents they might be obliged to work to repay their immigration costs, so they
were financially vulnerable, too, and sometimes fearful of deportation. Nevertheless, no class of workers posed as
significant a threat to the ascent of capitalism as the industrial workers, particularly in the form of the Industrial
Workers of the World (the IWW).

Figure 3.35 Organizing men and women,

Canadians and immigrants alike, the IWW took the
novel approach of printing materials in several
languages and using songs to transmit their message.
The chief songwriter of the IWW, Joe Hill, has an
important connection with Canada.

The qualities that made industrial labour desirable from the perspective of capitalism, also made it dangerous. The
very mobility of the unskilled meant that they were difficult to discipline. They were most often found in resource
extraction industries like the silver mines and smelters of the Kootenays in BC, where single (or at least wife-less)
men dominated. The Western Federation of Miners (WFM) organized many of these workers and preached a rad-
ical doctrine that disturbed the AFL-TLC. Their low skill levels meant that they moved from one industry to the
next, from road building to dock work to mills and lumber camps. This interchangeability made it possible for
the IWW to talk about one big union, an organization that took in everybody, including Asian-Canadians. As one
West Coast Socialist Party leader said in 1912, workers must get wise to the fact that what is needed is bigger
8
unions and less unions.

8. R.P. Pettipiece, quoted in Mark Leier, "Solidarity on Occasion: The Vancouver Free Speech Fights of 1909 and 1912," Labour/Le Travail, 23
(Spring 1989): 56.
 136 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Employers certainly didnt pull their punches in response. A pronounced lack of solidarity from the crafts unions
did not help matters, but employer intrigue, use of private security companies, subversion of the unions, and
deployment of local militias both punished and galvanized the industrial unions. A good example of this is the
1903 waterfront strike in Vancouver, led by the United Brotherhood of Railway Employees (UBRE) against the
CPR. The local labour leader, Frank Rogers, was elevated to the ranks of labour martyr when he was shot to
death on the docks. The UBREs position became increasingly untenable but strike activity spread to the coal
mines at Extension on Vancouver Island. There, the WFM was engaged in its own struggle, one that was painted
by the CPR (one of the main clients for coal from the Extension mine near Ladysmith) as an illegal sympathy
strike. John Hinde, describing the reaction of authorities in Victoria, Ottawa, and the boardrooms of the CPR,
captures the intersection of class-warfare and nationalist sensibilities of the time:

Fearful of sympathy strikes, an unambiguous statement of union and working-class power, the authorities subsequently
led a frontal assault on the strikers and their unions. [] they viewed the Extension strike as part of a wider conspiracy by
illegitimate revolutionary socialist organizations affiliated with American labour interests to disrupt the Canadian econ-
9
omy and to corrupt Canadian workers, and were therefore determined to crush the union.

This confrontation hurt the WFM, which began a downward spiral from which it never recovered. Some of its
American leadership the most noteworthy being William Big Bill Haywood (1869-1928) shifted their
energies to a new industrial union, the Industrial Workers of the World.

The IWW (nicknamed the Wobblies on account of the way some immigrant members pronounced the Ws), was
the antithesis of the parallel layers of craft unions organized along skill lines and working in a particular indus-
try. The Wobblies called for a singular labour organization to which every individual worker could belong. It was
mobilized by one idea: the defeat of capitalism.

Not only did the IWW propose to dismantle the business unions of the AFL and dilute the skill pool within the
craft and trade unions, it proposed to overturn the system entirely and favoured a socialist alternative. The instru-
ment with which the IWW proposed to accomplish this was an all-encompassing labour action, a general strike.
Building toward this goal involved several sectoral strikes along the way.

The Pre-War Labour Revolt

Labour unrest was increasing from 1896 on, but it spiked in the years leading to the Great War. In 1901, there
were 99 strikes and lockouts. This number peaked in 1907 at 188, and then again in 1912 at 181. The number
of employees involved leapt from 285 in 1901 to more than a thousand in each of 1903, 1910, 1912, and 1913.
What was most dramatic, however, was the aggregate number of working days lost. In 1901, it was 737,808 but
10
by 1911 it had reached 1,821,084. Labour relations were badly unsettled and strikes got both longer and more
11
numerous between 1910 and 1913. This pattern includes the dramatic Canadian Northern Railway (CNR) strike
of 1912, which involved some 7,000 railway construction workers drawn from more than a dozen different lan-
12
guage groups.

Whenever workers in pre-WWI Canada went on strike, they knew that they were stepping into a legal minefield.

9. John R. Hinde, When Coal Was King: Ladysmith and the Coal-Mining Industry on Vancouver Island, (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press,
2003), 133.
10. Statistics Canada, Historical Statistics of Canada, 2nd ed., ed. F. H. Leacy (Ottawa: Statistics Canada, 1983): E190-208.
11. Statistics Canada, Historical Statistics of Canada, 2nd ed., ed. F.H. Leacy (Ottawa: Statistics Canada, 1983): E190-197.
12. Craig Heron, The Canadian Labour Movement: A Short History, (Toronto: James Lorimer & Company, 1989), 43.
 3.6 CRAFT AND INDUSTRIAL UNIONS 137

The right to strike was not enshrined and striking was the equivalent of breaking a contract, which subjected
workers to the possibility of federal state intervention. Immigrant workers faced deportation. In some industries,
particularly during wartime, labour stoppages were tantamount to treason. Even in peacetime, the militia was not
infrequently dispatched to protect strikebreakers and evict strikers from company housing. In these circumstances,
the interest of the state and capital were unambiguously aligned.

Of the international trade unions in this period, the United Mine Workers of America (UMWA) stands out. It had
a powerful influence in the coal- and metal-mining communities in Nova Scotia, Alberta, British Columbia, and
elsewhere. The UMWA followed craft union strategies, focusing on working conditions and wages, but it would
be an error to understate its militance. In the hardrock mines of the Kootenays and the collieries of the Crowsnest
Pass, the UMWA emerged as the dominant international trade union. The union was in Lethbridge, too, and in
1906 there erupted a strike that lasted for nine months. What was significant about this confrontation one of
many in a period marked by intensifying labour-capital conflict is the role played by the state. A 32 year old
bureaucrat in Ottawa, William Lyon Mackenzie King (1874-1950), the Deputy Minister of Labour since 1900,
was sent to Alberta to diffuse the situation. (Winter was coming and there were fears of a coal famine on the
Prairies.) This third-party bargaining was a novel approach and it had the effect of reducing the strikers strength
even though the employer might have buckled. King followed this up with the Industrial Disputes Investigations
Act (IDIA) of 1907, legislation that inserted the federal government as a third-party in specific kinds of labour
disputes. Whenever the IDIA was invoked, strikers were required to return to work in a cooling-off period while
bargaining proceeded. The effect was to build up stockpiles of goods so that the employer was no longer desperate
13
for a settlement. The unions, naturally, hated this.

It was this context of growing confrontation and frustration at the intransigence of employers, government, and
business unions, which radicalized parts of the Canadian workforce and labour movement. The Wobblies appeal
reflects the limitations of craft unionism, particularly in sectors that would not be organized by the crafts. Faced
with some of the worst and most dangerous working conditions, the posture of the IWW and the One Big Union
(OBU) movement became more radical. It took on employers but it also took on the law. The Free Speech protests
of 1909 and 1912 in Vancouver, are a good example of confrontations in which the Wobblies played a key role,
14
and which were not specifically about working conditions or wages.

Figure 3.36 Mounted police arrive at Oppenheimer Park to put

down a Free Speech demonstration in Vancouver, 1912.

The militance of the pre-Great War years crested in 1912 but threatened to resume in 1914. As far as the anti-
labour elements were concerned, in this regard the war arrived just in time. Wartime conditions and the radicaliza-
tion of the working class globally, however, would present very different conditions in the period from 1914-1920.

13. H. Blair Neatby, KING, WILLIAM LYON MACKENZIE, in Dictionary of Canadian Biography, vol. 17, University of Toronto/Univer-
sit Laval, 2003, accessed 29 June 2015, [Link]
14. Mark Leier, "Solidarity on Occasion: The Vancouver Free Speech Fights of 1909 and 1912," Labour/Le Travail, 23 (Spring 1989): 39-66.
138 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 3.37 Southeastern British Columbia was, in the 1890s, a

constellation of small-to-middling mining towns. These hardrock
miners from the Tariff Mine near Ainsworth were heavily
influenced by labour organizations out of the nearest metropolis:
Spokane, Washington.

Key Points

The creation of an industrial working class created new tensions in Canadian society.
The ability to organize into defensive associations or unions arrived in the 1870s.
Craft unions represented the most skilled and best paid workers, and presented the respectable face
of labour.
The Knights of Labor originated in the United States and organized workers from across many crafts
and industries into one body.
Individual craft unions pursued a more confrontational approach and built international bodies to
advance their interests, with the AFL emerging as the dominant labour organizer.
Deskilling and new kinds of work produced a population of less skilled industrial workers who, in
the absence of support from the international craft unions, established industrial unions.

Attributions
Figure 3.32
Labour Day parade by Papa November is in the public domain.

Figure 3.33
Knights of Labour Procession on King Street by W. Farmer is in the public domain. This image is available
from Library and Archives Canada under the reference number 3386883.

Figure 3.34
Historic view of the Inland Cigar Factory by City of Kamloops Museum and Archives / Canadian Register of
Historic Places taken in 1895 is copyright by Canadian Register of Historic Places and is available solely for
personal, educational and non-commercial public use.

Figure 3.35
Cover of The Rebel Girl by Joe Hill is in the public domain.

Figure 3.36
 3.6 CRAFT AND INDUSTRIAL UNIONS 139

Mounted police at a Free Speech demonstration on the Powell Street Grounds, 371-971 by Major James Skitt
Matthews / City of Vancouver Archives is in the public domain.

Figure 3.37
Tariff Mine near Ainsworth by Unknown is in the public domain.
 3.7 Limits of Democracy

The 1850s and 1860s witnessed the rise of a new class of political leaders and a new style of politics in British
North America. The aristocratic airs of the Family Compact in Upper Canada and the HBC squirearchy on Van-
couver Island were trademarks of a leadership caste on whom the sun was setting. In their place were men
and they were all men of business, the law, and journalism. They were very much unlike their predecessors:
wheelers, dealers, and professionals practiced at speaking and arguing a point. They werent without airs but they
were willing to wade into a crowd and take on the mantle of populism. They were also men on the make; corrup-
tion, graft, and bribery were mainstays of Canadian politics. The Pacific Scandal was only the most consequential
of what would be generations of pay-offs associated with the railway hucksters whose avarice and ambition,
1
according to one historian, plunged Canada into an orgy of railway overproduction. These conditions were not
exclusive to Ottawa and federal politics: the railway binge in British Columbia that began in the 1890s and accel-
erated under Premier Richard McBrides Conservatives was no less dubious in its ethics.

The culture of democracy in Victorian and Edwardian Canada was, effectively, an exclusive club. The federal
government represented landowning farmers, merchants, and professionals people who, by dint of their invest-
ment in the economy, were seen as stakeholders in the running of the country. And their qualifications were gilded,
generally, by a better education. This is what privilege looked like in the late 19th century, and it helps to explain
why the thought of overthrowing rather than voting out the government appealed to so many radicals in the labour
movement and political activists on the left. It simply wasnt their government.

The Franchise
The ballot box and Canadian-style parliamentary democracy held out the promise of an empowered public. The
principle of responsible government was a premise of membership in the Dominion: it was seized upon by British
Columbia when the colony became a province in 1871 and would be part of the package that created Alberta and
Saskatchewan in 1905. What remained at issue was how to define that public. Who was the electorate and how
(and when) should they be allowed to express their preferences and cast their votes?

For working people these questions were extremely important. An electorate made up of the wealthy would result
in governments that were bound to be unsympathetic to workers concerns. As workers populations increased in
urban areas, the disconnect between governments (civic, provincial, and federal) that represented economic elites

1. Bryan D. Palmer, Working-Class Experience: Rethinking the History of Canadian Labour, 1800-1991, 2nd ed. (Toronto: McClelland &
Stewart, 1992), 82-3.

140
 3.7 LIMITS OF DEMOCRACY 141

rather than the majority of city-dwellers became more apparent. As well, urban working people sometimes found
themselves at odds with rural Canadians.

In large measure these conditions arose because of property qualifications and other limits on the electorate. Dur-
ing the period from 1867-1920 the provinces decided their own electoral rules and, for many of these years, they
determined the federal qualifications as well. These were based first and foremost on race and gender. With few
exceptions, Aboriginal people simply did not have the vote. Nor did Asians. Nor, until the Great War, did women
of any ethnicity or social class. What most constrained the size of the (male) electorate, however, were qualifica-
tions based on property and income.

In 1885 the Macdonald government brought control of the federal franchise back to Ottawa. Adulthood was
defined as 21 years and an income qualification was added at this time: $150 annually for rural Canadians; $300
2
for urban Canadians. At this time $2 a day in factory wages was fairly good for men working a six-day week.
Keep in mind that stoppages occurred for many reasons, including weather conditions. To take one example, the
relatively well-paid coal miners of Vancouver Island appear to have only worked a 222-day work-year on aver-
age, which severely cut into their apparent high wages of $3 a day. In short, while some working men might have
made the income target, many others did not. Property-ownership requirements were a further, and longer-stand-
ing restriction on working people, the majority of whom rented their homes. Technically the 1885 Electoral Fran-
chise Act made allowances for tenants but this, too, was deceptive. Federally and provincially, what appears to
be universal male suffrage was in fact only extended to males who satisfied residence requirements. While this
might be an easy bar to reach in rural areas and small towns, it was much more elusive in areas of high labour
mobility. Where seasonal labour prevailed, conditions might be worse still. In an environment where winter con-
ditions prohibited work year-round in the forests, on the seas, along canals, and in the fields, the requirement of
12 months residence in the constituency was for many working people the last and highest hurdle.

Whole classes of men were excluded from the franchise for reasons beyond their control. Legal barriers were
erected to prevent Aboriginal men from voting in several provinces, and in British Columbia it was illegal for Chi-
nese men to vote, regardless of their wealth. Macdonalds Electoral Franchise Act, 1885 took on these limitations
and extended them to Aboriginal peoples who had earlier been able to vote. Whats more, Macdonald exploited
provisions for a federally-managed voters list that would be assembled by party loyalists. This had predictable
results. Voter fraud and impersonation, arbitrary and purposeful sabotage of voters names on the electoral rolls
(which could leave them unqualified to vote), and the buying and selling of votes continued to be part and parcel
of Canadian elections well into the 1890s.

The Liberal government under Wilfrid Laurier was more favourably disposed to decentralized management of
elections and passed the voters rolls back to the provinces. This time, however, the ability to discriminate on
the basis of local biases was curtailed. Aboriginal voting rights remained entangled in a complex of rules but the
direct obstacles to Asians voting were lifted and then re-imposed via literacy requirements. Manitoba similarly
restricted Slavic voters by requiring literacy in English, German, French, or a Scandinavian language. Putting the
provinces in charge meant inevitable national disparities. Property qualifications remained in place in Quebec and
the three Maritime provinces. The overall effect was to create and to entrench rules that ostensibly gave the vote
to every male, aged 21 or more, who was a British subject (Canadian citizenship having not yet been invented),

2. Information on wages in the 19th century is difficult to come by and few studies extant offer comprehensive data. The Royal Commission on
the Relations of Labor and Capital of 1889 interviewed workers and supervisors who generally placed mens wages between $7 and $15 per
week. Womens wages were typically half that of men, and childrens wages sometimes half again.
142 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

but to perpetuate local quirks that could strip a Canadian of his federal vote the moment he crossed a provincial
boundary line.

Figure 3.38 The Conservatives campaign for the working mens

vote, 1891.

Labours Parties
Internationalism was a tenet of the socialist movement in the 19th century. But forging connections with labour
organizations in Britain, let alone France or Germany, was an improbable task for Canadian workers. By default
international became continental, as Canadian associations partnered up with larger American organizations. As
a threat to the Canadian political elite, this was a kind of double-jeopardy: not only did the unions pose an appar-
ent threat to the profit margin of Canadian businesses, they were aligned with organizations based in what many
Canadians regarded as a (commercially and politically) hostile neighbour.

Despite the impediments, popular interest in electoral politics grew and by the 1880s the working class was mak-
ing forays into electoral politics. One way they did so was through an American organization: Knights of Labor
candidates began to run in Canadian elections. At the same time, middle-class Liberal and Conservative candi-
dates were cutting their own cloth so as to appeal to workers, adopting policies and taking positions that echoed
working-class concerns. The Tories and the Grits even endorsed working men in single-industry towns to run for
office under their respective banners. The mainstream parties certainly made efforts to attract worker votes, and
they embraced a more inclusive political rhetoric to that end.

For a while something similar happened in Britain and the other White Dominions. The Liberal government of
Prime Minister William Gladstone won the loyalty of more than a generation of working-class British voters by
significantly broadening the franchise to working men. In response, in the 1880s, British trade unionists and social
reform-oriented intellectuals made their way into Gladstones Liberal Party and ran for election (with some suc-
cess) as Liberal-Labour (Lib-Lab) candidates. More definitively, working-class parties also emerged: the Scot-
tish Labour Party was founded in 1888 and the Independent Labour Party in 1893. In 1900, the Trades Union
Congress (the British equivalent of the TLC) established the foundation of what later became the Labour Party
in 1906. Parallel events occurred in Australia (from 1891) and New Zealand (between 1901 and 1916) but not in
Canada. Why did turn-of-the-century Canadian labour move in a different direction?

The TLCs close ties with the AFL offers an explanation. In the United States, the AFL favoured a strategy of
pitting the Democrats against the Republicans on workers issues. The AFLs leader, Samuel Gompers, took the
view that labour should reward its friends and punish its enemies at the ballot box, and did not offer up an inde-
pendent partisan alternative. As the AFLs influence over the TLC grew, the door closed on a labour-left political
alliance in Canada. Gompers regarded the socialists with contempt, describing them as political healers, akin to
faith healers and mystics whose commitment to workers conditions was secondary to winning power. He was in
favour, instead, of getting trade unionists elected to office who would then change the attitudes of the major North
 3.7 LIMITS OF DEMOCRACY 143

American political parties from the inside. The TLC followed this course and in 1902 voted the Knights out of the
Congress membership and kept the SPC at bay. Direct involvement in politics by the TLC would have to wait
until the 1960s.

The TLCs strategy in the early 1900s was to run sympathetic candidates in the Liberal Party (generally regarded
as more favourably disposed toward unions, at least until about 1906) and this met with some success. Canadian
Lib-Lab candidates promoted an agenda of labourism, which consisted mostly of democratic reforms, the eight-
3
hour day, a minimum wage, and educational opportunities for all. The TLC in 1906 considered establishing a
Labour Party but the British Columbian delegates saw this as too moderate an approach and established the Social-
ist Party of BC (SPBC). Other provincial labour centres then began generating parties of their own. In Manitoba,
Ontario, and Nova Scotia, Independent Labour Parties appeared. Credible candidates ran successfully in urban
and mining districts. A Labour Party competed in elections in Quebec, principally in Montreal.

Ideological differences separated these various tactics and parties. As each organization grew stronger and as fac-
tionalism continued to grow, the opportunities for forging a national alliance receded. The first two decades of the
20th century would see the emergence of a distinct strain of revolutionary socialism on the West Coast that was
profoundly out of sync with the rest of Canadas labour movement, particularly those elements most influenced
4
by what was going on in Britain. This left wing of labours political arm rejected reformism and was stridently
uncompromising when it came to capitalism and even more so when it came to labourist gradualism and it
was popular. Between 1907-1909 the SPBCs support grew from 10% to 22% of the provincial vote and it elected
two members of the legislative assembly. Its career thereafter is considered further in Chapter 8.

One Man, One Vote

If ever there was a golden age of Canadian democracy, it wont be found in the years before the Great War. Mid-
dle-class arguments for inclusion in a democratic order revolved around the idea of being invested in a commu-
nity: having a home, a residence, a business, and being part of that wealth-generating class that at first drove the
market towns and was now building the industrial cities. Giving the vote to working men who lacked wealth,
education, and property, not to mention a permanent residence in the community in which they proposed to vote,
required a significant readjustment of principles. There were, too, those who expected working men to vote as
their employer told them to. This was, in fact, how things worked in the days before the secret ballot, which only
arrived in most parts of Canada in 1874.

In short, democratic avenues to social and political change were not especially welcoming to working people.
Efforts were made to make it otherwise, but it would take the transformative power of a World War to effect real
changes. Organizations like the Knights stand out as an early attempt to lay claim to the politics of identity: they
articulated a kind of class consciousness one based on the dignity of labour but they were not socialists.
Where the impact of the Knights was more lasting was in its role as a movement of reform. It offered a critique of
the values of late Victorian capitalism that survived in various forms for generations.

3. Palmer, Working-Class Experience, 177.

4. Donald Avery, Reluctant Host: Canada's Response to Immigrant Workers, 1896-1994 (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1995), 64-5.
144 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Key Points

Democracy in early post-Confederation Canada was limited by income, property, residence, race,
and gender.
Provincial restrictions on the franchise influenced federal rules as well.
Political organizations representing labour and/or working people did not develop in Canada the
same way they did in other parts of the British Empire.
Labours political strategies often involved supporting the Liberal or Conservative parties, although
the hard left ran socialist candidates.

Attributions
Figure 3.38
A Vote for the National Policy (Online MIKAN no.3939876) by Library and Archives Canada, 1983-33-1095
is in the public domain.
 3.8 Early Womens Movement(s) in Canada

NANCY M. FORESTELL, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, ST. FRANCIS XAVIER UNIVERSITY

Figure 3.39 Mrs. Willoughby Cummings (ne

Emily McCausland, 1851-1930) was a key figure
in the National Council of Women. As a pioneer
female journalist and editor at the Globe
newspaper, she exemplifies the activist and
professional sides of first wave feminism.

Alongside and sometimes overlapping with the various social reform causes which emerged in the latter part of
the part of the 19th century was the first wave of the Canadian feminist movement. While historians once iden-
tified the creation of the Toronto Womens Literary Society in 1876 as marking the official origin of a womens
movement, more recent scholarship indicates that a variety of women and organizations were engaged in pursuits
related to fair treatment and equal rights at least several decades earlier. The specific context of British North
America as a settler society shaped by histories of colonialism and slavery had a significant influence on womens
activism from the outset. Belated acknowledgement is now being given to the Indigenous roots of the first wave
in North America with documented cases of Aboriginal women demonstrating a critical gender consciousness,
acting in what they perceived to be their own best interests as women as human beings, and most often to
1
combat the deleterious consequences of colonialism. One prominent example involved the Anishinaabe woman,
Nahebahwequa (also known as Catherine Sutton), who protested in 1860 against her dispossession from land she
considered a birthright, an event that arose because she had married a non-Aboriginal man. Another key element
in the genesis of feminist activism was the ongoing legacy of slavery and female engagement in international
abolitionist networks. By the mid-19th century, concerns about the injustices of slavery became increasingly con-
nected with another kind of bondage seen to be experienced by women. It remains unclear the extent to which
Black and White female abolitionists were able to easily or consistently overcome the racial divide, but there is

1. Jean Barman, Indigenous Women and Feminism on the Cusp of Contact, in Indigenous Women, and Feminism: Politics, Activism, Cul-
turei, eds. Cheryl Zuzack et al. (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2010): 93.

145
 146 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

a record of mixed race attendance at lectures on anti-slavery and womens rights as well as mutual support for
integrated education in the 1850s and 1860s. These initiatives were accompanied by efforts to secure womens
property rights, the quest for higher education, and the formation of female-exclusive church organizations. Alto-
gether, they laid the basis for women to pursue the attainment of additional rights and play a more significant role
in public campaigns for social reform. As in other national contexts, there was not a singular womens movement
in Canada as such; rather, a diverse range of activists who dedicated themselves to a wide array of political, social,
economic, and cultural issues.

In the latter part of the 19th century and continuing into the 20th century, two main arguments were put forward
by feminists to secure greater civil and political rights, and to achieve greater influence for Canadian women in
civil society. One was premised on an equal rights ethos that women and men shared a common humanity, and
hence, women should be able to attend university, gain access to selection occupations, vote, and etc. as a matter
of natural justice. The other emphasized womens differences from men, and in particular that their near universal
role as mothers specially equipped them to participate in a wide range of reform and political campaigns. Referred
to as maternal feminism, this form of argument emphasized that women could apply the knowledge and attrib-
utes they acquired as mothers to address various inequities and social ills. While some female activists solely
employed one position over the other, many strategically used both. Nonetheless, those who came to predomi-
nate among the mainstream womens organizations, namely middle-class Anglo-Celtic Protestant women, most
closely identified with maternal feminism. They were especially prevalent in the first national umbrella womens
organization, the National Council of Women of Canada (NCWC), formed in 1893. They were not the only ones
of course, as francophone Catholic women who became part of the provincial group, the Fdration National
2
Saint-Jean-Baptiste (FNSB), founded in 1907 also saw themselves as maternal feminists.

Figure 3.40 The 1898 NCWC gathered at Rideau Hall in the

company of one of its champions, Lady Aberdeen (centre) and
her husband, the governor general.

One of the central issues of the first wave was the struggle for female suffrage which involved a protracted
campaign with feminist activists laying claim to full political citizenship. While single-issue suffrage groups in
Canada remained relatively small and mainly confined to urban centres until the turn of the 20th century, the
large female prohibition group the Womens Christian Temperance Union (WCTU) was a vocal proponent
from the 1870s onward. As with a number of other womens reform groups at the time, the WCTU did not view
the attainment of female suffrage as the primary goal in and of itself, but rather as a means to achieve greater
political influence for social improvement. Although the suffrage campaign was dominated for the most part by
Anglo-Celtic bourgeois reformers, other groups of women participated. For example, female immigrants from
Iceland were supporters from early on, as were women originally from Finland, especially after their home coun-
try granted women in the vote in 1906. In the specific case of Quebec, the staunch opposition of the Catholic
church to womens enfranchisement combined with the higher priority female reformers gave to advances in their

2. Karine Hbert, A Maternalist Organization in Quebec: The Fdration Nationale Saint-Jean-Baptiste and the Struggle for Womens Suf-
frage, in Quebec Since 1800: Selected Readings, ed. Michael Behiels (Toronto: Irwin, 2002): 461-491.
 3.8 EARLY WOMENS MOVEMENT(S) IN CANADA 147

legal rather than political status, meant that support for womens suffrage was more muted there and the campaign
longer.

At the federal level, decades of struggle resulted in the achievement of a partial franchise with the passage of
the Wartime Elections Act in 1917. Against the backdrop of World War I, this legislation granted the vote to the
female relatives of Canadian soldiers, a large majority of whom were of British ancestry, and withheld the vote to
any immigrant citizen from enemy countries who had been naturalized after 1902. These provisions in the legis-
lation not only meant that significant a proportion of non-British immigrants were left out entirely, but also that
French Canadians were greatly under-represented among the women who were enfranchised. Although universal
adult suffrage was introduced the next year, select populations of women and men were explicitly left disenfran-
chised: Aboriginal people, as well as Chinese, Japanese, and Indian immigrants.

Figure 3.41 The final push for womens

suffrage in 1917 saw men taking a more
enthusiastic role as allies.

Other key issues garnered the time and attention of feminists beyond the vote. Working-class women, on occasion
in concert with middle-class allies, attempted to oppose the inequities of industrial capitalism and inequities within
the labour movement. They also specifically agitated as wives and mothers protesting high consumer prices. Farm
women lobbied for legislative changes which would allow them greater financial independence and power espe-
cially as related to homestead rights and dower laws. There were still other efforts to raise the moral tone of
Canadian society primarily by Euro-Canadian middle-class women. These feminists were not alone in this battle,
but far more than others, they raised concerns particular to the situation of women and with a view to altering
existing gender relations through the attainment of a single moral standard. Social hierarchies of class, race, reli-
gion, and colonial status were at times questioned and contested during the first wave but far more they were
3
unquestioned and re-affirmed.

Key Points

Aboriginal women were early campaigners for womens rights as regards property.
Legal and property rights were a continuing focus for several generations of post-Confederation
women, especially in Quebec.
The movement to abolish slavery provided opportunities for women to develop activist and political
skills and for alliances that crossed racial lines.

3. Nancy Forestell with Maureen Moynagh, eds., Documenting First Wave Feminisms: Canada National and Transnational Contexts, Vol-
ume 2 (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2013).
148 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

First wave feminism engaged ideas like equal rights and maternal feminism: the first emphasizing
the similarities between men and women; the latter highlighting differences based on motherhood.

Attributions
Figure 3.39
Mrs. Willoughby Cummings (Emily McCausland Cummings) Toronto corresponding secretary of the National
Council of Women of Canada by Library and Archives Canada is in the public domain. This image is available
from Library and Archives Canada under the reference number 3214496.

Figure 3.40
National Council of Women group at Rideau Hall, Ottawa, Ont. by Library and Archives Canada is in the public
domain. This image is available from Library and Archives Canada under the reference number 3366133.

Figure 3.41
Woman Suffrage: You will wish to hear the Canadian woman suffrage leader Flora McDonald Dennison and
Mr. Frank Dunham, Thursday, October 25, 8:00 p.m. by Library and Archives Canada is in the public domain.
This image is available from Library and Archives Canada under the access number 1984-4-917.
 3.9 The Great War and the General Strike

Figure 3.42 A crowd on the streets of Winnipeg in the spring of

1919.

The history of labour is simultaneously the history of industry and capitalism. No event so announces the triumph
of industrial capitalism as does the first industrialized war in 1914-1918. The Boer War of 1899-1902 was a testing
ground for new technologies like the Maxim machine gun and some refinements in artillery. It was nevertheless,
a conflict marked by an old-style dependency on horses for moving troops and cavalry charges. What erupted in
1914 was very different. The most industrialized nations in Europe were now capable of producing arms, motor-
ized land and air vehicles, armed and mobile artillery (tanks), and chemical weapons, and putting them all into the
field of battle. A century of Industrial Revolutions across the northern hemisphere brought the world to this: the
possibility of killing human beings on an industrial scale. And it had also produced large numbers of humans to
kill.

Earlier European conflicts faced limits based on potential army size. There was always a balance to be struck
between professional or mercenary regiments and the national armies. The latter became more the norm in the
19th century as the nation-state emerged. Nowhere was this more obvious than during the American Civil War.
The standing army was a development that coincided with the rise of the Dominion of Canada (and fear of
the American standing army was a factor in Canadas expansion). There was also a trade-off, even during the
Napoleonic Wars (1803-1815), between recruiting an army and depopulating the countryside. An army, as the
saying goes, marches on its stomach. Early industrial nations had no recourse but to recruit from the farming pop-
ulation, but there was always a tipping point where too many soldiers would mean too little food.

Industrialization didnt resolve that conundrum but it certainly changed the shape of the problem. Between
1750-1900 the population of Europe and Russia grew from about 146 million to 422 million; the population of
1
the United States in 1775 was 2.5 million and in 1914 was nearly 100 million. Canadas population growth was
hardly less incredible: from 90,000 in 1775 it grew to nearly 8 million in 1914. Some of this growth particu-
larly in North America and Russia took place on agricultural frontiers, but everywhere across the combatant

1. Massimo Livi-Bacci, A Concise History of World Population, 2nd ed., trans. Carl Ipsen (Oxford: Blackwell, 1997), 31.

149
 150 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

countries there were now millions upon millions of industrial workers who could be pressed into service with-
out compromising food production. At the same time, essential industries required essential workers. Shipyards,
coal mines, smelters, munitions factories, agricultural toolmakers, and the transport sector all had to be kept hum-
ming along. Still, strip away the so-called non-essential industries and there was a huge population of workers
that might be transformed into soldiers. Canada alone would find 620,000 of them, only the slenderest fraction of
whom were trained to be warriors before the war.

In 1914, no one knew with certainty how long the Great War would last (see Sections 6.2, 6.3, 6.4, and 6.5). It
was meant to be Great in its importance, not its length or body count. It would prove to be transformative in
many ways globally and in Canada and this is evident in the history of Canadian working people.

Figure 3.43 War industries increased demand for labour even as

large numbers of workers were heading overseas. A scene from a
Canadian Linderman Co. plant.

Labour at War
The military and political response of working Canadians and Canadians in general to the outbreak of hos-
tilities in 1914, is considered elsewhere in this text. How labour (meaning working people and organized labour)
met the experience of living in a country engaged for the first time in total war is what matters here. The foremost
measure of working Canadians encounters with these new conditions is strike action.

The war began two years after a high-water mark in labour unrest. The year 1912 saw a spike in the number of
disputes and, although this barely changed in the following year, the number of workers involved plummeted from
43,104 to 4,004. In 1914, there were half as many strikes and half as many days lost. The incidence and length
of strikes would continue to fall in 1915 although the number of workers involved now began to rise and would
continue to do so, doubling annually from 1914-1917. In 1917 the year of Vimy Ridge and Ypres there were
222 strikes with 50,327 strikers involved and over a million workdays lost. This marked a return to the levels of
2
1912.

What lay behind the plunge in labour disputes and then the meteoric rise in job actions as the war progressed?
Canada contributed more than half a million soldiers, sailors, and other participants to the cauldron of war, and
most of those individuals came out of industry. This created job shortages and, as a consequence, unemployment
levels fell sharply. As the war progressed, there were gaps on the shop floors in critical industries like armaments.
These gaps were filled by recruiting women into the workforce. As a result of these developments, working class
families experienced a rise in wages and living standards. Less than a year into the war and these changes were
being observed (unevenly) across the country. Very soon, labour shortages gave unions an opportunity to negoti-
ate better conditions and wages.

2. Gregory S. Kealey, Workers and Canadian History (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 1995), 295.
 3.9 THE GREAT WAR AND THE GENERAL STRIKE 151

Working people faced several issues at once. While improvements were being noted in wages, prices were also
rising. Income gains were quickly being eroded. New industries like munitions were being heavily supervised
and routinized. Machinists, in particular, found their work more structured and managed something to which
they objected. Skilled workmen also bridled at the idea of women taking on factory positions that had previously
been the preserve of craft union members. Women were, to be sure, a highly visible sign of deskilling and, thus, a
lightning rod attracting the criticism of organized labour. Untrained men were also contributing to the deskilling
process and were no less a source of unease for the trade unions.

Popular perceptions of the war also changed. Within two years of the declaration of war in August 1914, it was no
longer a brief and glorious confrontation between the British Empire and its rivals; the Great War had descended
into a relentless and inglorious meat grinder of a conflict. Aggressive army and navy recruitment drives and talk
of compulsory service were met with calls for the conscription of capital and not just soldiers. It was becoming
clear that throwing more men into the trenches was not a winning strategy, and working class critics began point-
ing to industrialists profiteers who were growing fat off government wartime contracts.

Finally, the role of the state was changing. The War Measures Act, 1914 gave the federal government extensive
powers of censorship, arrest, and deportation, and control over the transportation sector (on land and in the har-
bours). It also allowed Ottawa to engage more directly in the manufacturing sector as a participant with a vested
interest. As labour historian Craig Heron points out, the censoring of newspaper accounts of industrial disputes
was viewed by socialists and labour leaders as an abuse of the Act; whats more, the introduction of prohibition in
3
1917 was deeply resented. As working-class unrest simultaneously spread across Europe and manifested itself in
revolutionary socialist movements, the left wing in Canada came under surveillance by the RCMP and under fire
from the Dominion government. Radical political organizations were infiltrated by police spies and suppressed;
arrests and deportations of socialist leaders followed, which only aggravated labours unease. Labour organiza-
tions and left-wing political movements began to turn the official wartime propaganda line back on the govern-
4
ment: these attacks on rights were, they said, nothing less than Prussianism or Kaiserism at home.

The labour movement rebounded and union membership shot up. By the end of the War, there were no fewer
than 378,000 members in craft and industrial unions, as well as in the emerging civic unions that now included
police, civil servants, and white-collar workers. Craig Heron points to the exceptional levels of collaboration and
cooperation between craft unions and even between craft and industrial unions; these alliances facilitated commu-
nity-wide bargaining in smaller industrial towns and sectoral bargaining in larger cities. He also notes a greater
5
spirit of inclusivity that extended to women and ethnic minorities in unions.

Two factors contributing to labours growth remain to be mentioned. The first is success at the bargaining table.
Wartime conditions, labour shortages, and a more muscular movement won concessions during strikes, and noth-
ing succeeds like success when it comes to organizing labour movements. The second echoes the first: the success
of revolutionaries in Russia inspired workers movements around the world. The possibility of wringing signifi-
cant systemic reforms from the state and employers was in sight; the prospect of overturning capitalism entirely
and establishing a socialist political, economic, and social order was also closer than ever before. These develop-
ments provide the material and intellectual context of events in 1919.

3. Craig Heron, The Canadian Labour Movement: A Short History, 2nd ed. (Toronto: James Lorimer & Company, 1996), 47.
4. Craig Heron and Myer Siemiatycki, The Great War, the State, and Working-Class Canada, in The Workers Revolt in Canada, 1917-1925,
ed. Craig Heron (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1998), reprinted in Readings in Canadian History: Post Confederation, 7th ed., eds.
R. Douglas Francis and Donald B. Smith (Toronto: Thomson Nelson, 2006): 372.
5. Heron, The Canadian Labour Movement, 48-9.
 152 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 3.44 The Canadian governments antipathy toward

socialism extended to participation in an attempt to suppress the
Russian Revolution. Members of the Canadian Siberian
Expeditionary Force (CSEF) in 1919 were few in numbers and
saw little combat.

The General Strike

No single labour dispute in Canadian history is as well known and as regularly invoked as the Winnipeg General
Strike of 1919. Lasting six weeks, from May through June, it constituted an important moment in the workers
revolt of the period that began in the 1890s and concludes (or at least takes a break) in the mid-1920s. The events
in Winnipeg are important in many respects, but it is important to note as well that general strikes sprang up else-
where: in Amherst, Nova Scotia, Calgary, Vancouver, Victoria, and in many other centres from one end of the
country to the other. Some of these strikes were motivated by local conditions and others in sympathy with Win-
6
nipeg. Indeed, the rolling tide of disputes related to the Winnipeg General Strike would continue to 1925.

The idea of a work stoppage across industries had been touted for decades by the IWW and others on the more
radical and industrial side of the labour movement. In the aftermath of the Great War, there were enough com-
mon issues and irritations to arouse the Canadian working class. As historian of labour, Greg Kealey, points out,
World War I, while providing specific sparks to light the flame of working-class struggle in 1919, should not be
7
viewed as its cause. If not, then what causes lay behind a wave of unrest that brought out more than 149,000
workers in more than 400 strikes and claimed more than 3.4 million workdays lost in 1919?

Rising unemployment was a factor. The end of war meant the closing of munitions plants. Now, too, there were
hundreds of thousands of returning soldiers to inflate demand for work. In addition, ex-servicemen expected to
return to their old jobs, which meant displacing women and men who had been brought into those positions dur-
ing the war. All of this created an atmosphere of uncertainty in the workforce while mobilizing, at least part
of, a large female workforce in protest. Politically, too, the returned troops were something of a wildcard. Some
were outraged at the anti-war and anti-conscription postures struck by many on the labour-left, to say nothing of
their hostility toward the Russian Revolution and its supporters. There were also instances where returned British-
Canadian soldiers turned their ire against Central and Eastern European, people they described as enemy aliens,
who had taken their jobs. Other veterans felt that the radical critiques of profiteering, incompetent generalship in
Europe, and international capitalism were entirely on the mark. Ottawas disinterest in the fate of returning sol-
diers pushed many veterans still closer to the labour-left camp.

6. See, for example, David Bright, The Limits of Labour: Class Formation and the Labour Movement in Calgary, 1883-1929 (Vancouver: Uni-
versity of British Columbia Press, 1998), 145-61, and Benjamin Isitt, Searching for Workers Solidarity: The One Big Union and the Victo-
ria General Strike of 1919, Labour/Le Travail, 60 (Fall 2007): 9-42.
7. Gregory S. Kealey, Workers and Canadian History, (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 1995), 294.
 3.9 THE GREAT WAR AND THE GENERAL STRIKE 153

Figure 3.45 Some returned soldiers and the Citizens Committee

regarded the strike as a treasonous conspiracy stirred up by
Eastern European immigrants in Winnipeg.

Divisions between craft unions and industrial unions also played a role in the growing labour militance after the
war. The old tensions resurfaced in 1918-1919, following an attack by the Trades and Labour Congress of Canada
on radical (and mostly western) elements within the unions. Regional leadership subsequently met in Calgary in
March 1919, to form a syndicalist organization with roots in the old IWW: the One Big Union (OBU). Interna-
tional locals in the west were quickly brought into the OBU fold. Workers who were impatient for a confrontation
with employers responded favourably to the OBUs radical language and rejected the AFL-TLC business union
line. Precise numbers are impossible to obtain, but historians agree that anywhere from a quarter to a third of
union membership in Western Canada and specifically in Winnipeg was in the OBU.

Figure 3.46 A crowd gathers outside Winnipeg City Hall in 1919

during the General Strike.

Of course, local conditions played a role. Events in Winnipeg arose initially from a bargaining dispute in the
building and metal trades. The right to collectively bargain was one of the chips on the table and when employers
would not budge, the Winnipeg Trades and Labour Council (WTLC) called for a general strike. The response was
unprecedented. A few days later, approximately 30,000 Winnipeggers were on strike. Public transit, the factories,
the police department, fire stations, retail shops, post offices, and several utilities closed down. The Central Strike
Committee established by the WTLC bargained with the city and employers while authorizing essential
services like milk delivery.

Figure 3.47 Members and supporters of the Citizens Committee

identifiable by their armbands and clothing prepare to
confront the strikers on Bloody Saturday.

The Winnipeg establishment came out united in its opposition to the strike. A Citizens Committee of One
Thousand was their coordinating body and they had deep pockets, a tight network of connections to the Borden
government in Ottawa, and the full support of local and national newspapers. Describing the strike as a Bolshe-
vik uprising (echoing fears of a Russian-style revolution) led by foreigners and traitors, the Citizens Committee
turned attention away from the issue of collective bargaining and raised the spectre of a revolutionary crisis.
 154 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Matters came to a head in mid-June 1919. On the 17th of June, ten OBU leaders were arrested, among them the
leading Social Gospel Methodist minister in Winnipeg, James S. Woodsworth (see Chapter 7). The mass arrest
launched a demonstration of solidarity and a final buildup of state resources that collided on Bloody Saturday,
the 21st of June 1919. The deployment of troops, Mounties, and Specials volunteer police drawn from the
8
Citizens Committee in the words of one historian, turned Winnipeg into virtually an occupied city. The
Royal North-West Mounted Police (as the RCMP were called at the time) appeared and charged on horseback
into the crowd three times before opening fire: 30 were injured and two killed. The federal governments clear
commitment to defeating the strike was manifest in cavalry charges against protesters, whose numbers included
large numbers of Great War veterans. It was also evident in amendments to the Immigration Act and the Criminal
Code that allowed Ottawa to deport British citizens and to charge strikers with sedition.

Figure 3.48 The RNWMP ride into the crowd on Bloody

Saturday.

The Legacy of Winnipeg

The Panama Canal was an invisible participant in the General Strike. Opened in 1914, it cut deeply into the cost
of shipping grain and lumber from Vancouver to the east coast of North America. The movement of Western prod-
ucts along the CPR through Winnipeg suffered badly. The effect was delayed by the War, but by 1919, it was
being felt in falling wage rates and a rising cost of living in Manitoba. Winnipegs economy never fully recov-
ered. A decade after the strike, the city slipped out of 3rd place among Canadas largest centres and continued to
become less and less consequential in the 20th century. One study has argued that the local labour unions were
so demoralized by the events of 1919 and under such heavy state scrutiny, that they were thereafter incapable of
9
fighting for competitive wages and working conditions.

The strike produced other consequences, at least one of them very long-term. Six of the strike leaders were sen-
tenced to a spell behind bars, some getting terms of two years. Woodsworth was released and almost immediately
elected as an MP from the Independent Labour Party (ILP). He would go on to found the Cooperative Common-
wealth Federation (CCF), the precursor of the New Democratic Party (see Section 7.9). Other figures, drawn from
the leadership ranks of the strikers, picked up the thread of revolutionism and established a communist political
party.

Among historians, Winnipeg occupies a place of contention. Was it an expression of a peculiar kind of Western
radicalism or part of a larger Canadian workers revolt? Does it constitute as the Citizens Committee of One
Thousand feared a nascent Bolshevik revolution, or was it a local labour dispute with very limited goals: better
wages and collective bargaining rights? These issues have divided labour historians for more than a generation.

8. David Jay Bercuson, Confrontation at Winnipeg: Labour, Industrial Relations, and the General Strike, revised ed. (Montreal & Kingston:
McGill-Queens University Press, 1990), 187.
9. Kenneth McNaught and David J. Bercuson, The Winnipeg Strike: 1919 (Don Mills: Longman Canada, 1974), 118-20.
 3.9 THE GREAT WAR AND THE GENERAL STRIKE 155

Recently it has been argued, perhaps unsurprisingly, that it was both a matter of local bargaining and a combina-
10
tion of radical rhetoric coupled to a comprehensive reaction by the authorities and the establishment.

It has also been argued that the chief beneficiary of the Winnipeg Strike was the RNWMP. On the brink of being
disbanded because its frontier mandate was no longer relevant, the Mounties found renewed purpose as an agency
11
of state surveillance and subversion of leftist organizations. What can be said with some certainty is that the
events of 1919 hardened the federal and provincial states attitudes toward labour; collective bargaining rights,
welfare, veterans support, and many other labour and social initiatives may have been postponed as a reaction to
1919. More pointedly, as one study reveals:

After crushing the Winnipeg strike, the federal government collaborated in the anti-radical Red Scare that businessmen
and conservative journalists were promoting across the country. The workers revolt had thus pushed the state to create
12
more powerful, centralized mechanisms for combating radicalism than had existed in pre-war Canada.

At the very least, the events of 1919 determined the size of a labour union. The state was to restrict them in such
a way that one big union would become an impossibility in the future.

Key Points

The Great War created conditions that facilitated the growth of militant labour.
The end of the war saw a sudden reversal for working people, the emergence of divisions
between returned soldiers and workers, and a state crackdown on leftist labour organizations.
The Winnipeg General Strike was the foremost of several similar disputes across Canada that pitted
a broad-based alliance of working people against an economic elite combined with imperialist fac-
tions and the armed representatives of the government.

Attributions
Figure 3.42
Street scene during the Winnipeg Strike of 1919 by Library and Archives Canada is in the public domain. This
image is available from Library and Archives Canada under the reference number 3574292.

Figure 3.43
War production by Canada. Dept. of National Defence/Library and Archives Canada is in the public domain.
This image is available from Library and Archives Canada under the reference number 3371011.

Figure 3.44
Canadian Siberian Expeditionary Force in Vladivostok 1919 by Raymond Gibson is in the public domain. This
image is available from Library and Archives Canada under the reference number 3194493.

10. See Reinhold Kramer and Tom Mitchell, When the State Trembled: How A. J. Andrews and the Citizens Committee Broke the Winnipeg
General Strike (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2010).
11. See Lorne Browne, Depression and Repression: Canada Between the Wars, Canadian Dimension, vol. 49, issue 2 (March/April 2015):
27-37.
12. Heron and Siemiatycki, The Great War: 386.
156 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 3.45
Street scene during the Winnipeg strike of 1919 by Library and Archives Canada is in the public domain. This
image is available from Library and Archives Canada under the reference number 3574291.

Figure 3.46
Winnipeg General Strike by The Montreal Star Publishing Company is in the public domain. This image is
available from Library and Archives Canada under the reference number 3192170.

Figure 3.47
Winnipeg riot by Royal Canadian Mounted Police / Library and Archives Canada is in the public domain. This
image is available from Library and Archives Canada under the reference number 3615116.

Figure 3.48
Winnipeg Riot by Royal Canadian Mounted Police / Library and Archives Canada is in the public domain. This
image is available from Library and Archives Canada under the reference number 3615118.
3.10 Summary

Figure 3.49 Civic pride and the expectation of

continued city growth is embodied in the great city
halls of the late 19th century, including Winnipegs,
ca. 1887.

Imagine a skilled craftsman around the time of Confederation. Born in the mid-1840s, his talents were honed
through a process of apprenticeship and work in a small shop alongside a master and perhaps two or three other
workers. The community was small a large city might contain fewer than 30,000 people and even the largest
covered a small, walkable space. The work setting was probably familial: the master his employer was also
the head of the household in which the apprentice lived from childhood. Other family members old and young
worked alongside him as he grew.

By 1870, competition is increasing as others working in the same trade combine their efforts under one roof, sell-
ing their skills for wages. Soon there are a couple of dozen workers per factory. Then a hundred. By the time our
craftsman has reached his 30s he will have seen his area of expertise and skill increasingly challenged by machin-
ery and the employment of less skilled workers, including women, children, and perhaps immigrants.

In the late 1880s, at the age of about 45, he looks about himself and sees an urban environment that is utterly
different from the commercial market-towns of his childhood. He is working in a shop that is becoming more
and more mechanized, the work broken down into component parts. Respect for his skills is diminishing and hes
coming under increasing pressure to be efficient.

He is married and his wife easily recalls the rhythms of rural Canada. There were long working days and not
much about it that was very charming or romantic, apart from (possibly) better housing conditions and a degree of
independence that is being eroded in factory work. Her own skills as a tailor are being undermined by machinery
and her wages are barely half those of the men in the factory. Their children work the same long hours and are
at the mercy of supervisors who will discourage talking or playing or daydreaming with physical punishment of
their small and tired bodies and minds.

157
158 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

The industrial, urban world presents new social opportunities. Joining lodges and churches are an option. So are
new organizations like the Knights of Labor and the Provincial Workmens Association. For Ontarian and Qube-
cois working people, the prospect of crossing the border for work is nothing new; the idea of joining an American
labour organization that promises to protect the dignity of labour is an easy choice to make.

This is the new normal for a generation of Canadians who can remember that pre-industrial past and, in the 1870s
and 1880s, are looking at a future that offers little certainty. Their children 10 to 20 years old in 1887 will
take those years of lightless childhood with them into the trade unions sponsored by the AFL and the TLC, or into
the IWW. It is also very likely they will take those experiences (remember that this generation has far less claim
on a pre-industrial standard) into the militant years from 1907-1925. They will take all this with them into the far
west, as well, where they will find company towns and new systems of discipline in labour disputes that include
the police, local militias, national troops, specials, and private security companies.

The grandchildren of our original craftsman born in the early 1880s-1890s will grow up watching a world
of conflict in their factory, mine, mill towns, and their distinctly working-class neighbourhoods. Most will expe-
rience orphanhood the death of at least one parent before they turn 15 and they will likely spend some time
moving around their province or across the country as part of a transient workforce. This railway generation is the
first for which a trans-continental conception of Canada is easily arrived at. They also have a greater likelihood
of receiving a substantial educational experience and they will be the subject of far greater middle-class reform-
mindedness than their predecessors. They will object to militarism, but they will die in their thousands in Belgium
and France.

Reading the Working Class

If we approach the history of working-class Canada institutionally, from the history of trade unions or the growth
of factories, we can easily miss the way it might have appeared to participants on the ground. No one involved in
the 1919 General Strike would be much younger than 16 nor much older than 50. If that is all we know about the
people involved, then we know they had probably come some distance perhaps generations from the farm-
ing, fishing, and market town peoples of the first four provinces. We know that many of them would necessarily
be immigrants whose experience of work was influenced by local prejudices. We also know that industrial capi-
talism was a widespread way of life and not something new. It had been around long enough, and the exploitative
qualities were sufficiently and frustratingly familiar that a working-class response was timely.

If it seems as though changes in the experiences of working people and their organizations came quickly and
repeatedly, it is partly due to the fact that change in the economy and in the way workers lived, was also occurring
at a breakneck speed sometimes erratically. New technologies and resource industries produced significant and
very new problems in short order. Some of the organizational shifts were, however, particularly decisive.

Take the differences between the Knights of Labor with their largely autonomous Local Assemblies and the
AFL-TLC led craft unions. Distinct constitutions and memberships, and a centralized and bureaucratic leadership
marked the latter. A craft union in the late 1880s might discourage one of its locals from mounting what the lead-
ership regarded as an imprudent strike simply by withholding strike funds. The Knights allowed more local free-
dom while depending simultaneously on the strength of deference to the senior ranks. The craft unions had a local
and sectional view of the world while the Knights and the Wobblies had a sector-wide perspective.
 3.10 SUMMARY 159

The growth of these institutions was important to Canadian history in that they reframed the language of citizen-
ship and rights. They posed a challenge, in some instances, to the emergence of capitalism. They had something
to say about culture and respectability, and they certainly had something to say about class. Greg Kealey com-
pared working-class testimony from two Royal Commissions the 1886-89 investigation into Relations between
Capital and Labour and the 1919 study of Industrial Relations and concluded that respectability had been sup-
planted by radicalism. In the space of 30 years, the working class had changed at a foundational level and at a
cultural level as well it was a much bigger phenomenon and it included far more than the original craft union
elements. Along the way, its instincts had changed from a desire to fit into a bourgeois vision of Canadian society
1
to one that had grown increasingly cynical of the state and employers.

Historians continue to debate whether Canada was on the brink of a revolutionary uprising of working people
in the first two decades of the 20th century. Without a doubt, it is the direction some outspoken and influential
leaders wished to head. Others sought to test the limits of democratic reform. Together, the excitement of events
in Russia and the rise of the British Labour Party created a sense that change could be achieved with or without
the ballot box. It is also clear that Canadian workers exhibited less unity than they might have precisely because
of their federal system and because of cultural differences. This period saw the rise of labour organizations, but
we must keep in mind, their immediate reach was never great. On the eve of the Great War, barely one-in-ten of
Canadian workers belonged to a union. Their concentration in certain key industries, however, gave these early
organizations far greater potential than their numbers indicate.

Just as industrialism built a new economy, it was midwife to a new kind of modern Canadian who was very typ-
ically a town or city dweller, a wage-earner (or someone dependent on a wage-earner), probably a renter, and
someone who worked and lived alongside many other people most of whom were unrelated. This is a far cry
from the Canada of 1867 and it was one in which new bonds were being forged.

Key Terms

abolitionists: Individuals and groups associated with the movement to end slavery in the United States.
In Canada, abolitionists assisted African-Americans fleeing the United States, whether they were slaves
or otherwise. The abolitionist movement built the foundation for subsequent social movements in
Canada.
American Federation of Labor (AFL): Established in 1886 as an umbrella organization of craft unions
in the United States.
automation: A manufacturing process in which assembly or some other part of the production system
is performed by machines that are subject to control systems.
blacklist: Sanctions taken by employers against workers whom they associate with labour organization,
strikes, certain ideological movements, or other actions contrary to the employers interests. Technically,
a list of individuals who were denied work on the basis of their involvement in pro-labour activities.
Bloody Saturday: 21 June 1919; during a mass demonstration of solidarity (after ten OBU leaders were
arrested, including J. S. Woodsworth) in which a buildup of state resources (troops, Mounties and Spe-
cials) were brought in. 30 protesters were injured and two killed.

1. Gregory S. Kealey, Workers and Canadian History (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 1995), 289-328.
160 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Bolshevik: A workers party that led the Russian Revolution in October 1917 under the leadership of
Vladimir Lenin.
boosters: Civic promoters.
business unions: Trade or craft unions that approach activism from a non-revolutionary position; asso-
ciated with the unions of the AFL, the TLC, and later the CLC.
Canadian Labour Congress (CLC): Founded in 1956 in a merger of the Trades and Labour Congress
(TLC) and the Canadian Congress of Labour (CCL). Subsequently joined with the Cooperative Com-
monwealth Federation (CCF) to create the New Democratic Party (NDP).
capitalism, capitalists: An economic system (and its practitioners) that is based on the ability of private
individuals to accumulate and invest money (capital) in profit-making enterprises. Also, a system that is
dominated by the private ownership of the means of production.
chilled steel plough: A significant late 19th century advance in plough manufacturing. Stronger steel
enabled the cutting of faster and deeper furrows and the breaking of densely packed prairie soil.
Citizens Committee of One Thousand: During the Winnipeg General Strike, 1919, an organization
established by the citys business and political elites to break the strike and challenge the authority of
the Strike Committee.
collective bargaining: Negotiation of working conditions, pay, and other issues or benefits by an asso-
ciation a union of employees. Replaced the many individual arrangements made in one-on-one
agreements.
company store: An outlet owned by an employer, one that sells goods to employees of the same firm.
Commonplace in company towns. See also company towns.
company towns: A community with one major employer and few other employers; one in which most
or all services in some instances including housing and the supply of food are controlled by the
employer. Associated with remote resource extraction communities.
corporate welfarism: Equates subsidies to corporations with social welfare paid to individuals. In 1972,
NDP leader David Lewis coined the phrase corporate welfare bums as a way of identifying what he
perceived as the hypocrisy of attacks on the poor by anti-welfare business leaders.
craft capitalism: Refers to a transition to capitalism led by craftworkers.
deskilling: Mechanization and automation of work, as well as assembly lines permits the systematiza-
tion of work and a commensurate reduction in the skills and training needed to perform key functions.
The work is said to be deskilled and, thus, the workforce too is deskilled.
dower laws: Formal recognition of a widows lifetime interest in matrimonial property on the death of
her husband. See also homestead rights.
equal rights: In the context of feminism, the belief that rights accorded to men and women ought to be
the same. Diverges somewhat from maternal feminism which claims rights based on gendered differ-
ences.
essential industries: Sectors identified in a crisis (such as wartime) as fundamental to the survival of
the economy or society or war effort. Workers in those sectors are typically protected against conscrip-
tion and may also be restricted in their ability to move to other jobs. In some instances, the state takes
direct control of the industries for the duration of the crisis or longer.
Family Compact: The elite network in pre-Confederation Canada that dominated colonial politics; in
Quebec (aka: Canada East, Lower Canada) it was referred to as the Chateau Clique.
 3.10 SUMMARY 161

Fdration National Saint-Jean-Baptiste (FNSB): Founded in 1907, francophone Catholic women

activists who also saw themselves as maternal feminists.
female suffrage: One of the central issues of the first wave feminists, involving a protracted campaign
with feminist activists laying claim to full political citizenship.
feminism: An ideological position that advances the ideal of equality of women and men.
first wave: More fully: first wave feminists. Advocates for womens rights in the late 19th and early
20th centuries; also sometimes called maternal feminists.
fossil fuels: Includes coal, oil, natural gas, and petroleum; any fuel based on the compression of carbon
matter over geological time.
free labour: Workers who are not tied to a feudal relationship, slavery, or indentured servitude and are
able to move from one employer (or location) to another based on the size of pay and the character of
the work.
general strike: A labour stoppage involving most or all unions or workplaces. General strikes have been
held that call on all workers in a particular city or a particular sector or across an entire country.
ghost towns: Abandoned communities; associated principally with resource extraction often mining
towns that have a very short lifespan and which close up once the resource is removed or the market
disappears.
gradualism: The idea that great change can occur incrementally in slow, small, and subtle steps, rather
than by large uprisings or revolutions. Among left-wing activists, a belief that reforms to capitalism
can produce a social and economic order of fairness for working people; sometimes called Fabianism;
derided by revolutionaries as delusional. In the context of Quebecs independence movements the equiv-
alent term is tapisme. See also reformist and impossibilist.
homestead rights: The Dominion Lands Act protected womens interest in homesteads by forbidding
the sale of the homestead by a husband without the wifes written consent.
household wage: A way of measuring income that extends beyond the breadwinner model and incorpo-
rates incomes earned by every member of the household/family.
House of Industry: A facility typically funded out of philanthropic/charitable donations that provides
housing and food for impoverished citizens with the expectation that they will do work in return. In the
19th century, associated with workhouses for the poor.
industrial relations: The diplomatic business of negotiating contracts and conditions between employ-
ers and employees; typically between employers and labour organizations (unions).
Knights of Labor: Fully, the Noble and Holy Order of the Knights of Labor. Established in the United
States in 1869-70; expanded into Canada in the next decade; organized workers regardless of race (apart
from Asians), sex, or skill levels. Competition with the new craft unions resulted in the Knights expul-
sion from the Trades and Labour Congress in 1902, and its gradual disintegration thereafter.
labourism: Canadian Liberal-Labour (Lib-Lab) candidates promoted an agenda that consisted mostly
of democratic reforms, the 8-hour work day, a minimum wage, and educational opportunities for all.
Labour Party: In Britain, the political face of the Trades Union Congress; established in 1906. While
Labour Parties also appeared in Australia and New Zealand, one never fully materialized in Canada.
Liberal-Labour (also Lib-Lab): Typically a pro-labour candidate, sometime running under a Labour
or Independent Labour banner, who joined the Liberal caucus on being elected.
maternal feminism: Also called first wave feminism; a movement to achieve greater civic rights for
162 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

women; based its appeal on the biological differences between women and men, arguing that women
have a natural nurturing instinct and ability which ought to be welcomed in a democratic system; women
could apply the knowledge and attributes acquired from their universal role as mothers to address vari-
ous inequities and social ills.
mechanization: The process of replacing manual labour with machinery; distinct from automation,
which is a later phase in the deskilling process.
modernity: Also modern and modernism; term given to a constellation of behaviours and beliefs asso-
ciated with the industrial, urban era. It is associated with challenges to traditional values and ways of
looking at the world, and is often used in connection with 20th century artworks, literature, and archi-
tecture.
National Council of Women of Canada (NCWC): A feminist activist group formed in 1893; predom-
inantly Anglo-Celtic Protestant women who mostly identified themselves as maternal feminists.
National Policy: John A. Macdonalds linkage of three policies into one: a tariff wall to exclude Amer-
ican manufactures; an transcontinental railway (the CPR) to link the Maritimes with British Columbia;
and the settlement of the West. Although most of the components were in place by 1876, it was only
touted as a single National Policy in 1879.
one big union, One Big Union (OBU): In the first instance, the idea (pioneered by the Knights of
Labor) that working people should belong to a single organization that can fight for their rights collec-
tively; secondly, an actual organization the OBU formed after 1919, as a revolutionary industrial
union (which included workers in support of the Bolshevik and other left-wing revolutions).
partial franchise: With the passage of the Wartime Elections Act in 1917, female relatives of Canadian
soldiers were granted the vote.
populism: In politics, an appeal to the interests and concerns of the community by political leaders (pop-
ulists) usually against established elites or minority or scapegoat groups. The rhetoric of populists
is often characterized as vitriolic, bombastic, and fear-mongering.
profiteers: Industrialists and others who were able to profit from government contracts in wartime.
prohibition: A total ban on the production, sale, and consumption of alcohol products.
proletarianization: The transformation of non-industrial workers or skilled workers and small employ-
ers into wage labourers.
proportional representation: Distinct from the first-past-the-post system; can take several forms but
common aspect is that political parties will be elect a number of seats that reflect in some measure the
percentage of votes the parties receive. For example, in a first-past-the-post system a party might win
49% of the votes in every constituency but not elect a single candidate if the only other party running
wins 51% of the votes; proportional representation (sometimes called PR) would ensure that the second-
place party received something closer to 49% of the seats.
Red Scare: A complex of political, social, economic, and cultural responses to the rise of pro-commu-
nist feeling in Canada and internationally; fear of communist revolution at home or abroad and partic-
ularly of pro-communist spies and supporters working clandestinely to advance a communist agenda;
manifest in security campaigns against perceived enemies of the state, the creation of blacklists, and
other acts of intimidation.
respectability: A term used and an ideal pursued by mid-19th century organized labour particularly
skilled craft workers and some of their successors; embraced the ideals of fair treatment, law-abiding
 3.10 SUMMARY 163

behaviour, equality, and a commitment to the nations stability and growth. Manifest in many ways
including working class campaigns for literacy, temperance, and rational recreation.
Second Industrial Revolution: Usually placed between ca. 1870 and 1914, renewed technological
innovation which saw a significant expansion in iron and steel production, railway construction, and
communications technologies like the telegraph and telephone.
Social Gospel: A social reform movement stimulated by Christian beliefs that linked personal engage-
ment with social salvation.
Specials: Volunteer police drawn from a local population; in the case of the Winnipeg General Strike,
the Specials were recruited from the Citizens Committee.
squirearchy: Colloquial term used to describe the elite in colonial British Columbia.
standing army: A full-time, permanent, usually salaried army, as opposed to a volunteer militia.
strikebreakers: Colloquial term for a worker who continues working, or who takes a job, while a strike
is ongoing. Also called a scab.
sweated labour: Work that takes place over long hours; exhausting and generally poorly paid; very
often involves outwork, the taking home of materials that are assembled there, usually by female
employees, who are paid on the basis of output.
sympathy strike: A labour stoppage by supportive workers who are not directly involved in a dispute.
syndicalist: Advocate of syndicalism, the belief that industry would be best run by syndicates made up
of industrial workers who would own and operate the factories themselves.
tariff: Charges (a tax) added to imported goods so as to make their sale price higher than domestic goods
and, thus, make domestic goods more competitive.
temperance: One strand of the anti-liquor campaign in the 19th and 20th centuries, focussed on the per-
sonal impact of alcohol and personal resolve in limiting or giving up drink. Contrast with prohibition,
which called for an all-out ban on the production, sale, and consumption of liquor.
tied housing: In company towns, housing that is owned by the employer and provided to employees. In
some cases, residence in tied housing is a condition of employment, which enables the employer to evict
strikers during labour disputes.
total war: Describes the engagement of the whole nation in conflict, and not just the military. In the
20th century, applies only to the two World Wars.
Trades and Labour Congress of Canada: A national association of craft unions modelled on the
American Federation of Labor; established in 1883 and merged with the Canadian Congress of Labour
(CCL) in 1956 to create the Canadian Labour Congress (CLC).
truck shop: An outlet owned by an employer, one that sells goods to employees of the same firm. Com-
monplace in company towns. See also company store.
universal adult suffrage: Introduced a year after the partial franchise, to grant adults the right to vote;
however, select populations of women and men were explicitly left disenfranchised: Aboriginal people,
as well as Chinese, Japanese, and Indian immigrants.
universal male suffrage: Extension of the franchise the right to vote to all adult males. In practice
in Canada, it excluded non-Euro-Canadians (i.e. Aboriginal and Asian) adult males until the mid-20th
century. Also constrained by residency requirements until the mid-20th century.
vertical integration: In economics and business, a system in which the whole or most of the supply
164 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

chain is owned by the same individual(s) or firm. Early examples come from the steel industry which in
some cases controlled the production of coking coal, the supply of iron ore, foundries, and railways that
consumed the final product.
wheat boom: An expanding demand for wheat leading to a rapid expansion of farmland dedicated to
wheat production; in Canada from ca. 1880-1914.
Womens Christian Temperance Union (WCTU): One of the largest and most effective anti-drink
lobbies in Canada. Established in 1874, months after its first branch was announced in the United States,
the WCTU emerged as a vehicle for contiguous reforms in public behaviour, the political environment,
and social conditions.

Short Answer Exercises

1. Define the Industrial Revolution. What were its main features in the late 19th century?
2. How did infrastructure and the energy economy change in the post-Confederation era?
3. What were some of the main features of working-class life?
4. Was the Industrial Revolution a social revolution as well as an economic transformation?
5. What were the main features of the National Policy?
6. What sort of roles did children play in urban and industrial society? To what extent were the expe-
riences of boys and girls distinct?
7. How did urban life change the experiences of women?
8. In what ways was urbanization connected to industrialization? In what ways were Canadian cities
distinct from one another?
9. How did craft unions differ from industrial unions?
10. What were the goals of the early labour centres, such as the Knights of Labor?
11. What were the key features of Canadian democracy in the late 19th century?
12. Explain the rise of first wave feminism, and what is meant by maternal feminism?
13. How did the Great War change Canadian labour and its political ambitions?

Suggested Readings
Bullen, John. Hidden Workers: Child Labour and the Family Economy in Late Nineteenth-Century Urban
Ontario, Labour/Le Travail, 18 (Fall 1986): 163-87.

Dunae, Patrick A., Donald J. Lafreniere, Jason A. Gilliland, and John S. Lutz, Dwelling Places and Social
Spaces: Revealing the Environments of Urban Workers in Victoria Using Historical GIS, Labour/Le Travail,
72 (Fall 2013): 37-73.
 3.10 SUMMARY 165

Kealey, Gregory S. State Repression of Labour and the Left in Canada, 1914-1920: The Impact of the First World
War, Canadian Historical Review, 73, 3 (1992): 281-314.

McCann, Larry. Seasons of Labor: Family, Work, and Land in a Nineteenth-Century Nova Scotia Shipbuilding
Community, The History of the Family, 4, Issue 4 (1999): 485-527.

Radforth, Ian. Playful Crowds and the 1886 Toronto Street Railway Strikes, Labour/Le Travail, 76 (Fall 2015):
133-64.

Strong-Boag, Veronica. The Citizenship Debates: The 1885 Franchise Act, Contesting Canadian Citizenship:
Historical Readings, eds. Robert Adamoski, Dorothy E. Chunn, and Robert Menzies (Toronto: Broadview
Press, 2002): 69-94.

Attributions
Figure 3.49
City Hall and Volunteer Monument, Winnipeg, MB, 1887 by William McFarlane Notman / McCord Museum
has no known copyright restrictions.
 PART 5

Chapter 4. Politics and Conflict in Victorian

and Edwardian Canada

166
 4.1 Introduction

Figure 4.1 The role of the Canadian state included the

punishment of crimes and deviance. The ability to assign the
death penalty was reserved to the federal government until it was
abolished in 1976. In this 1901 photograph from inside the jail at
Hull, Stanislaus Lacroix (hooded) prepares to be hanged while
observers watch from neighbouring rooftops.

Governing Canada presents rather distinctive, if not unique, challenges. Even when the Dominion consisted of
just four provinces, there were substantial issues of distance and scale. The core of English-Canadas population
and its economic engine was in southwestern Ontario, a long way from Halifax. Railways and telegraphs closed
that gap somewhat, but annexing the West and pulling BC into the Dominion just worsened matters exponentially.
Distance might be compromised again with more rails and more roads but cultural issues are far less amenable to
a technological fix. The idea of a federation as opposed to a unitary state stemmed principally from French-
Canadas long-standing, and entirely justified, fear of assimilationist anglophones and anti-Catholic Protestants.
One very large part of the new nation, then, had signed on to a political unit that it inherently mistrusted. Could
that mistrust be tempered by adopting a national policy of dualism? Would that just prove offensive to the Eng-
lish-Protestant majority? These issues could not be ignored: While the provinces might enjoy primacy in the area
of culture and education, the federal government must somehow hold together the whole. These were issues that
the countries against which Canadians were likely to measure themselves the United States, Britain, Australia,
and France never had to deal. Twenty years after Confederation, its architect, John A. Macdonald, was not con-
vinced that it was possible to sustain the federal union: [I] have watched the cradle of Confederation & shouldnt
1
like to follow the hearse.

Which raises the question: What is the role of the federal regime? Constitutionally, its powers are limited but it
does, from time to time, play a considerable and active role in many facets of Canadian life. Political history is
about much more than constitutional history, but the constitution and the division of powers found therein are the
ground rules for the Dominions governmental processes. As well, the British North America Act functioned in
the first three decades of Confederation as a kind of strategic plan. It is highly unusual for a constitution to include
provision for a railway; in the BNA Act it stands out like a contractual obligation, and this was a facet that was

1. Quoted in Ged Martin, John A. Macdonald: Canada's First Prime Minster (Toronto, ON: Dundurn, 2013), p.176.

167
168 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

reinforced in BCs Terms of Union in 1871. Likewise the BNA Act, and the debates that brought it together, made
it clear that Canada was to be a mutual defence pact between a small group of colonies that were highly anxious
about American appetites.

Measuring the performance of 19th century governments in particular thus means that we have to look at the tasks
they were given and how they interpreted their responsibilities.

Learning Objectives

Describe dualism and account for its fluctuating support.

Explain the political successes of the Conservative Party from 1867 to the 1890s.
Interpret the role played by the Catholic Church, and religion generally, in Canadian politics.
Account for the rise to power of Wilfrid Laurier and the Liberal Party.
Describe the crises faced by Laurier and how they illuminate Canadian political culture and society.
Outline the principles of Canadian imperialism and nationalism, ca. 1900.

Attributions
Figure 4.1
Lexecution de Lacroix (HS85-10-13176) by the British Library is under the public domain.
 4.2 John A. Macdonalds Canada

The issue that faced John A. Macdonald and his contemporaries at the federal level was the extent to which Ottawa
could build a nation on the basis of two founding cultures. (This, of course, was an exercise that completely
ignored the presence of Aboriginal cultures except insofar as it endeavoured to subjugate and/or alter them.) For
the most part Macdonalds generation opted to focus on economic bonds rather than cultural bridges. Macdonalds
National Policy may be understood in this context as an articulation of a vision of Canada. The tariff protected
Canadian manufacturers and therefore shielded Canada against American economic aggression. The Intercolo-
nial Railway was quickly overshadowed by a railway to the Pacific, which had the same goals. The deployment
of a national constabulary and temporary military units in the West affirmed Canadian determination to execute
its territorial strategy against American possibilities. In these ways, and in others, the National Policy has been
interpreted as an instrument of nationalism as well as economic development. The mixture of technology, science,
engineering, and notions of progress on which the railways depended was something that informed public life
and became a premise of the new Dominion. As one historian has argued, this was a philosophy of railways,
a commitment to an instrument of Canadian ambitions that was simultaneously economic, political, nationalistic,
1
and cultural. And it was on this project that Macdonald pinned his career and the success of his party.

As a politician, Macdonald was regarded as crafty, a term that was not always offered as praise. Macdonald
was unafraid of hard work (he is reckoned to have almost single-handedly drafted the Quebec Resolutions that
led to the BNA Act) and his earlier position as an outsider within the Tory Party may have driven him to labour
twice as hard to be half as good. He drank heavily and was beset by some of the ill-health that comes with too
much alcohol. His wit was sharp and he was often self-effacing. Macdonalds ability to delay and postpone, and
wear out his opponents, earned him the nickname Old Tomorrow. His biographers paint a picture of a man who
simultaneously led from the front while demonstrating a preference for serving his caucus rather than having his
caucus serve him.

This last point is important because of the extent to which Canadian politics have become characterized by what is
sometimes called presidential prime ministers. The Canadian system does not provide for the election of a prime
minister, only two or more caucuses, one of which (ideally) is large enough to form government. It is implicit in
responsible government that the executive (or cabinet) serves at the sufferance of the largest caucus (from which
it is drawn), and that the caucus may, if needs be, direct the government to change direction. Macdonalds career
was profoundly shaped by debates about responsible government; building a majority in the House was his spe-

1. A. A. den Otter, The Philosophy of Railways: The Transcontinental Railway Idea in British North America (Toronto: University of Toronto
Press, 1997).

169
 170 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

cialty and he had been doing so since the 1850s. Dividing Canadian history along the benchmark of 1867 means
we sometimes lose sight of the fact that Macdonald spent decades fighting and winning in politics.

Macdonald was effective as a leader in large part because he had strong co-leaders in Quebec whom he treated as
partners and confidantes. The first of these, of course, was George-tienne Cartier (1814-73), without whom it is
unlikely that Quebec would have agreed to Confederation. Cartier, too, played the pivotal role in negotiations with
Britain regarding the annexation of Ruperts Land, and he pressed vigorously for the addition of British Columbia.
It was Cartier who put the idea of a Pacific railway on the table. Cartiers death in 1873 produced a great pub-
lic outpouring of grief, much of it stage-managed but not all: 50,000 to 100,000 spectators lined the route of his
funeral procession. Macdonald was stricken and, when he announced Cartiers passing to the House of Commons
2
he was silenced by his own sobbing.

Figure 4.2: An enormous and extravagant state funeral was held

for George-tienne Cartier in Montreal, 1873.

Hector-Louis Langevin (1826-1906) subsequently took up the task of leading Quebec within the Conservative
government, but he had a difficult time of it. The execution of Riel poisoned relations between French-Catholics
and the Tory Party. Langevin won re-election in 1887 (despite being called a hangman) but few of his Conser-
vative colleagues were so lucky. Macdonald appreciated Langevins efforts and skills and made him Minister of
Public Works a fateful decision. Public works played an important role in the building and maintenance of,
among other things, bridges and docks, which made it an effective instrument of patronage to loyal supporters
of the government. It also placed the minister in the path of temptation. Allegations of corruption with respect to
railways in Quebec and British Columbia circled around Langevin. Another potential scandal in Ontario had the
potential to end the career of the prime minister as well as Langevin: a dry-dock construction project in Macdon-
alds own constituency of Kingston involved public contracts assigned to a man who did not exist. Despite this,
Macdonald held on to the bitter end to the ideal of a French-Canadian successor, and it was Langevin he had in
mind. This was an indication of the depth of Macdonalds conviction that the two founding nations ought to rule
the country together.

Macdonalds commitment to this perspective was older than the Dominion itself. His close alliance and friendship
with Cartier a rebel of 1837, a Bleu leader 30 years later, and the governments man in Quebec was pivotal to
the successful inclusion of Quebec in Confederation. Macdonald knew through his work with Cartier that culture
mattered. At the same time, Macdonald and his supporters were committed to the view that the northwest would
be Canadianized, which for all intents and purposes meant cleared of First Nations and Mtis, and remade in the
shape of Ontarian, Anglo-Protestant society. The diffusion of Anglo-Canadian values took place in a variety of
settings, including the courts and the legal system, the legislatures, and the schools.

2. J.-C. Bonenfant, CARTIER, Sir GEORGE-TIENNE, in Dictionary of Canadian Biography, vol. 10, University of Toronto/Universit
Laval, 2003, accessed 5 August 2015, [Link]
 4.2 JOHN A. MACDONALDS CANADA 171

Figure 4.3 An unusual and

unequivocally hostile depiction of
Macdonald (along with New Brunswick
Conservative MP Robert Moffatt) on an
early baseball card, ca. 1885.

No event in his long political career so defined Macdonalds legacy as the hanging of Riel (see Sections 2.7
and 2.8). As one French-Canadian Tory MP from Montreal said, Sir John saw the dawn of his political career
lit by the glow from the burning parliament buildings in Montreal; its sunset will fade behind the gallows in
3
Regina. While Ontarios Orange Lodges were baying for blood they wanted Riel to hang for the murder of
Thomas Scott in 1870 and not necessarily for treason in 1885 Quebec was incensed by Ottawas treatment of
the Catholic-French Mtis community since the Red River uprising. The failure to create a French/English society
in the West, the subsequent marginalization of the Mtis population, the heavy-handed performance of centralist
federal politicians, and Ottawas apparent disregard for the Quebec economy was all read as a long trail of broken
promises. The hard-line ultramontanist movement became increasingly active in criticizing francophone Conserv-
atives as serving Ottawa and Macdonald rather than Quebec and the French-Catholic culture. This was paralleled
by the growth of nationalist sentiment among the Canadiens.

There was, too, a growing sense in Quebec that industrialization and modernization threatened the rural stability
of francophone society. There was a great deal of truth in the fact that industrialism was being imposed on
French-Canadians and on the countryside because all but a handful of the industrial elite was anglophone and
urban. While the CPR might function in English Canada in the 1880s as a symbol of technological and economic
progress, in Quebec it represented for many a diversion of wealth to a francophone-hostile Western periphery and
the resultant high unemployment. A consequence of this economic impact was the emigration of Qubecois youth
to the United States. All of these ingredients were simmering when the Northwest Rebellion of 1885 occurred.
Sympathy for the Mtis was easy to evoke, but Riel was more complicated: The Catholic clergy recognized their
flock in the West but had to be firm in their opposition to Riels heretical pronouncements. Once Riel recanted
his more idiosyncratic beliefs, the whole of Qubecois society seemed on his side. His hanging provoked a mass
demonstration in Montreals Champ-de-Mars at which Macdonald was burned in effigy.

Thereafter, the fortunes of the Conservative Party in Quebec crashed. With the exception of some seats in Mon-
treal and a few scattered over the countryside, there was by 1887 little left of Cartiers Bleu-Conservative machine.
Indeed, the Conservative Party in Quebec would never fully recover, although it might have were it not for the
compounding effects of Bordens conscription legislation in the Great War.

3. Andre Dsilets, LANGEVIN, Sir HECTOR-LOUIS, in Dictionary of Canadian Biography, vol. 13, University of Toronto/Universit
Laval, 2003, accessed 25 February 2016, [Link]
172 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 4.4 Toeing the party line, according to the

Canadian political cartoonist John Wilson
Bengough, was common practice under
Macdonald. This cartoon appeared in Grip in
1877 and refers to damage-limitation efforts on
the part of the Conservative Party as it prepared
for an election.

Macdonald led the government through two parliaments in 1867-73, was pushed out of office on a tide of cor-
ruption allegations known as the Pacific Scandal, and returned for four more parliaments from 1878 to his death
in 1891. The Macdonald administrations are mostly remembered for the National Policy (see Section 3.3), and
it has been argued that the Conservatives and Alexander Mackenzies Liberals from 1873-1878 could not
build a nation based on a culture and so opted for economic unity, but this was a unity that was far from equal.
It did, however, create a separate economic order north of the United States. Historians have both praised the
tariff policy as the source of Canadas industrial take-off, and criticized it for suffocating industry in the West and
the Maritimes while encouraging Americans to set up their own factories in Canada. These early branch plants
were a harbinger of 20th century developments that would see a closer integration of the two nations economies,
regardless of the tariff. The weight of votes was in the manufacturing hubs of central Canada, something even the
Liberals could not ignore forever. By 1896 the Grits abandoned their pro-reciprocity position (at least temporar-
ily) and joined the tariff camp.

Figure 4.5 The Conservative Party message in the 1891 election:

American goods will flood Canada without the tariff.

Macdonald maintained to the bitter end that the tariff was essential to protecting more than Canadian industry.
It protected Canada as a whole. In part this was rhetoric, displayed most clearly in his 1891 campaign which
was explicitly nationalistic and pro-tariff, but it was also sincerely believed. There were enough continentalists in
the Liberal Party including its 1880s leader Edward Blake (1833-1912) and his outspoken colleague Goldwin
Smith (1823-1910) to demonstrate that a return to reciprocity or, worse, a common tariff policy with the United
States was likely to be the first step toward the end of Canada.
 4.2 JOHN A. MACDONALDS CANADA 173

Key Points

John A. Macdonald enjoyed success in federal politics by dint of forging important alliances with
francophone political leaders in Quebec.
The strengths of Conservative political partnerships in Quebec were tested to destruction by the exe-
cution of Riel.

Attributions
Figure 4.2
Funeral procession of George-tienne Cartier by Jeangagnon is in the public domain. This image is available
from the Bibliothque et Archives nationales du Qubec under the reference number 3234.

Figure 4.3
A Double Play (Online MIKAN no.3805663) by Library and Archives Canada, Acc. No. R1300-535 is used in
the public domain.

Figure 4.4
Sir John revises history by Wehwalt is in the public domain.

Figure 4.5
What the Result of the Grit Policy Would Be (Online MIKAN no.2989918) by Library and Archives Canada,
Acc. No. 1983-33-1126 is has nil restrictions on use.
4.3 Succession Planning

Figure 4.6 Charles Tupper and Hugh

John Macdonald were both contenders
for the leadership of the Conservative
Party in the early 1890s.

Finding a successor was Macdonalds last great challenge, and it was to prove his greatest failure. The 1891 elec-
tion saw a 76-year old Macdonald out-campaign the 50-year old Wilfrid Laurier, but the Conservative victory was
narrow and the Tories were thoroughly beaten in Quebec. Macdonalds health, already taxed, began to fade and
yet at that moment his political heirs proved to have feet of clay.

Langevins reputation for corruption sabotaged his own chances; Ontarios DAlton McCarthy (1836-1898) was,
at one time, a likely successor but he was emerging as the nations most passionate and vitriolic opponent of
everything French and Catholic; Charles Tupper (1821-1915) a Nova Scotian father of Confederation might
have done the job five years earlier but he, too, was in his 70s and also felt strongly that the mantle should go to a
francophone; another capable Nova Scotian, John Thompson (1845-1894), was hated in much of English Canada
because he had converted to Catholicism. John Abbott (1821-1893), the Conservative leader in the Senate, even-
tually took the job, even though Macdonald thought him unqualified. Worse, he was old. Abbott was 70 when he
became prime minister, was forced from office by brain cancer less than two years into his term, and died months
later. Bad luck continued to dog the Conservatives when Thompson reluctantly took the job, and then followed his
predecessors to the grave when he died in office, suddenly, at 49 years. Another septuagenarian, Senator Macken-
zie Bowell (1823-1917), became prime minister from 1894-1896; however, his cabinet turned against him and
brought in Charles Tupper. Before Tupper could be sworn into office, his government was thrust into an election
that he was destined to lose. Tupper would serve for 69 days still the briefest tenure of any Canadian prime min-
ister.

From 1867-1893 there had been only two prime ministers: Macdonald and Mackenzie. From 1893-1896 there
were five, including Laurier. Failure to plan for life after Old Tomorrow badly damaged the Conservatives.

174
 4.3 SUCCESSION PLANNING 175

They would rebound under the leadership of Robert Borden (1854-1937) in 1911, but the structural damage they
had sustained would endure for another century.

Figure 4.7 The Molson Brewing Company

was probably banking on Macdonalds
reputation as a dignified Victorian
politician, and not as a heavy drinker, when
they conceived this 1924 advertising
campaign.

Macdonalds Legacy
Macdonald is something of an enigma in Canadian history. His impact is undeniable and, as the founding father,
he is sometimes treated as something like a national hero. But he was ruthless in his politics and unsparing when
it came to winning. His decision to starve western Aboriginals after they had signed treaties, so as to bring them
into what he saw as a position consistent with the letter of the treaties, was simply brutal. While one may find
quotes from this long-serving politician that display admiration for First Nations, his actions speak louder still.
It is difficult to judge the extent of his corruptness in politics because the standards of the time were so slippery.
Patronage was expected and even the buying of votes was winked at. However, the Pacific Scandal was not, and
nor would the public have appreciated the Kingston dry-dock deal, had Macdonald lived long enough to see it
exposed fully. And yet he was skilled at achieving a kind of political stability that was, arguably, necessary for a
young country.

His relationship with Britain was not straightforward either. Macdonald saw Britain and the imperial connection
as a necessary counterweight to what he regarded as a genuine American threat. Keeping in mind that Macdonald
was the Province of Canadas Minister of the Militia during the Fenian War, and that he carried a gun against
the Upper Canadian rebels of 1837 (who he regarded as American-inspired republicans), when he said that The
Yankees are very bad neighbours, he meant it. At the same time, Macdonald wanted greater independence for
Canada and was mistrustful of British motives when it came to North American diplomacy and treaties.

Macdonald did much that our generation regards as bad, some of which we can contextualize and mitigate by say-
ing that most of his peers at the time likely felt much the same way or would have acted the same way. He was a
racist (privately and publicly) and that was quite common at the time. But in other instances he was found lacking
in some ethical or personal spirit by his contemporaries, and that is something to which we must pay some heed.
The situation in the Northwest in 1885 was one such situation where Macdonalds approach to the First Nations
complaints and the fate of the Mtis was sharply criticized. Macdonald clearly had a compromised moral com-
pass. One of his biographies states, if Macdonald thought of the ends, he was insufficiently concerned with the
1
means.

1. J. K. Johnson and P. B. Waite, MACDONALD, Sir JOHN ALEXANDER, in Dictionary of Canadian Biography, vol. 12, University of
Toronto/Universit Laval, 2003, accessed 25 August 2015, [Link]
 176 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

And, famously, he had a fraught relationship with alcohol and sometimes he was a reckless (though seldom, if
ever, an ugly) drunk.

In 1886 John, his wife Agnes, and their daughter Mary decided to tour the West. Macdonald had served as the
Member of Parliament for Victoria in the early 1870s a safe seat that he needed when he lost his own Kingston
riding, one that he could pick up because of the two-week-long elections of the era. But he had never been west
of Ontario, and he wanted to catch a glimpse of the country he had annexed. Macdonald did what generations
of 70-somethings would do from the 1880s to the present: he booked a railway tour. The family stayed in rail-
way hotels, measured up towns like Calgary (promising), New Westminster (wouldnt give it a second night), and
Vancouver (burnt to the ground six weeks before their arrival), and they admired Mount Baker at sunset. As their
train passed through the Rockies, Agnes came up with the idea that they ride on the very front of the engine, on
2
the cow catcher. They did so and the story goes that they covered 200 km in that position. It is a trivial thing and
of no real matter to the political history of Canada, but it has to be said: It is difficult to imagine very many of
Macdonalds successors doing the same.

Figure 4.8 Lady Susan Agnes Macdonald

(ne Bernard) in 1886, only months before
she demonstrated that Victorian ladies were
not above riding a cowcatcher.

Exercises: Documents

Fire Insurance Maps

Long before there was Google Earth, there was the fire insurance map. Its one of the most useful doc-
uments for anyone interested in the shape of neighbourhoods of the past. Every structure, no matter how
small, is identified, along with details like height, use, building materials, and in the case of industrial
buildings the number of employees. Out-buildings like stables and even outhouses toilets are
included, too. Fire insurance maps also tell us, right off the top, that fire insurance was now a thing, and
that selling fire insurance had emerged as a job. The City of Vancouver Open Data Catalogue will provide
guidance on how to read them.
Consider the three examples here. What kinds of historical questions can be answered by closely analyzing
this type of primary document?

2. Ged Martin, John A. Macdonald: Canadas First Prime Minister (Toronto, ON: Dundurn, 2013), 173-4.
 4.3 SUCCESSION PLANNING 177

Figure 4.E1 Calgary, 1911.

Figure 4.E2 Vancouvers Chinatown along

Princess (now Pender) Street, June 1901.

Figure 4.E3 Downtown Montreal, Quebec,

Volume 1, June 1914.

Key Points

Macdonalds legacy as a politician and a long-serving prime minister includes his failure to plan
effectively for the long-term success of the Conservative Party.
His politics were highly flexible, morally slippery, and mostly effective.

Attributions
Figure 4.6
The Old Flag! The Old Guard and the Old Principle! by Skeezix1000 is in the public domain. This image is
available from the McCord Museum under the reference number M967.128.1.

Figure 4.7
Advertisement for Molsons Ale by Skeezix1000 is in the public domain. This image is available from the
Library and Archives of Canada under the reference number 1996-278-2.34.

Figure 4.8
Lady Susan Agnes MacDonald (Ne Bernard) (Wife of Sir John A. MacDonald) by Topley Studio / Library and
178 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Archives Canada is in the public domain. This image is available from Library and Archives Canada under the
reference number PA-025530.

Figure 4.E1
Insurance plan of Calgary, Alberta, October 1911, v.1. Library and Archives Canada, MIKAN 3805540 is in
the public domain.

Figure 4.E2
Vancouvers Chinatown, 1897 (revised June 1901) Library and Archives Canada, MIKAN 3807867 is in the
public domain.

Figure 4.E3
Downtown Montreal, Quebec, Canada, Volume 1, Apr. 1909, revised June 1914. Library and Archives Canada
/ 3825720 is in the public domain.
4.4 The Sunny Ways of Sir Wilfrid Laurier

Figure 4.9 Laurier throws the reader a

sidelong glance on the cover of
Man-to-Man magazine (later rebranded as
Westward Ho! and then British Columbia
Magazine) published in Vancouver, ca.
1910.

The years between Confederation and the Great War were dominated by two national politicians: Macdonald and
Laurier. Between the two of them, they headed governments for 34 out of 47 years. Macdonald was prime minis-
ter for a longer amount of time, but Laurier won more consecutive elections. Both were devoted in very different
ways to nation-building. Lauriers contribution to Canadian political history is every bit as profound as Macdon-
alds, as is his reinterpretation of the national culture.

Laurier in Quebec
As described previously, the Liberal Party distinguished itself from the Conservatives on the issue of the tariff.
The 1850s Reciprocity Treaty was regarded by many as the key to prosperity. It gave Canadian farmers access
to growing American urban markets and made the less expensive American manufactured products available in
Canada; although the Liberal Party was strong in the cities, its anti-tariff position ensured that it would be more
popular in the countrys farming districts. This explains some of the Partys strength in Quebec, where rural cul-
tural values were especially strong and important.

Lauriers own background was not in farming. His father was a teacher and mayor in a small town north of
Montreal. The young Laurier spent much of his childhood and youth studying in New Glasgow, where he was
immersed in the culture and language of recent British immigrants to Quebec. He then trained in law at McGill,
an uncommon accomplishment for a francophone at the time. His professional years were marked by struggle and
intermittent poor health. Politically, he was a Rouge, and in 1866-67 he was entirely opposed to the concept of
Confederation which, he wrote, constituted the second stage on the road to anglification mapped out by Lord

179
 180 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION
1
Durham. He entered provincial politics first in 1871 at the age of 30, and quickly switched to federal affairs
(and, at about the same time, had an extra-marital affair as well). A young French-Canadian lawyer with excellent
ability in English, Laurier was too good to pass up when it came time for Mackenzie to form a cabinet in 1874:
Laurier was appointed the Minister of Inland Revenue (which is roughly comparable to the current Canadian Rev-
enue Agency).

Figure 4.10 Seen here in his early 30s in 1874,

and wearing the upright collar that would be
his trademark, Laurier became a cabinet
minister that same year.

Lauriers relationship with the Catholic Church exemplifies some of the challenges of politics in late Victorian
Quebec. Laurier was anticlerical, an advocate for the separation of church and state. This did not make him pop-
ular with the clergy, even though he saw himself as a champion for Catholics in Canada. He was, however, a
powerful orator and, in 1877, was able to convince Bishop George Conroy (1832-1878) and an audience of 2,000
that the Liberal Party posed no threat to the rights of the Church providing the Church did not use intimidation
to chase votes toward the Conservative Party.

Despite a promising start, Laurier almost lost his way in the mid-1880s. He was influential in Quebec Liberal cir-
cles, but was not viewed so much as a leader anymore. Then Riel happened. Genuinely offended by the death sen-
tence handed down to the Mtis leader, Laurier also recognized an opportunity to forge links between Canadien
nationalists of all stripes in Quebec. Riel was the wedge that could be driven between the Conservative Party on
the one hand, and the Qubecois electorate and the Catholic clergy on the other. Rising in the House of Commons,
Laurier pointed a finger at Macdonald, accusing him of stirring up events in the West and persecuting a branch of
the francophone and Catholic family. In one of his famous statements, while speaking before 50,000 people at the
Champ-de-Mars rally days after Riels execution, Laurier suggested that had he been in Saskatchewan at the time,
he would have taken up arms against the Ottawa government.

The Great Conciliator

An opponent of Confederation as a young man, Laurier appears to have returned to that position in his mid-40s.
However, his kind of nationalism was one that accepted the federal system as an environment in which Quebec
could, with the right guardians, thrive. This was a precisely dualist vision of the country: A vision in which both
French and English coexist respectfully, and compromise is sought at all costs. When the Liberal Party failed
once more at the polls in 1887, its leader Edward Blake (1833-1912) handpicked Laurier as his successor. (There
were no leadership conventions at this time, just the discretion of the party leader.) It was a potentially disastrous
choice, but possibly the shrewdest move in Blakes otherwise unimpressive run.

1. Ral Blanger, LAURIER, Sir WILFRID, in Dictionary of Canadian Biography, vol. 14, University of Toronto/Universit Laval, 2003,
accessed 25 August 2015, [Link]
 4.4 THE SUNNY WAYS OF SIR WILFRID LAURIER 181

Laurier failed to win government for the Liberals in 1891. Macdonald used the Liberals promise of Universal
Reciprocity to whip up fear of an American takeover of Canada. In Quebec the Tories were able to mobilize
an ultramontane fear of Lauriers Rouge background to drive voters away from the Liberals. (The old saying in
Quebec, alleged to have been coined by priests offering advice at election time, was la ciel est bleu, lenfer est
rouge. You cant get much clearer direction than that!) It was a bitter reward for Lauriers support of Macdonald
during a dispute over a piece of Quebec legislation, The Jesuit Estates Act, 1888. In that instance both leaders
called for tolerance of Papal intervention in a Quebec dispute over property claimed by several religious orders,
a move that outraged Orange anti-Catholic feeling in Ontario. On the cultural and economic front, then, Laurier
was measured and found wanting.

Five years later, the situation would be much changed. Macdonald was gone, the Conservative Party was careen-
ing from one endangered leader to the next, and most importantly the Liberals had come to terms with the
tariff. The economy in the mid-1890s was desperately poor and the American response involved erecting a tariff
wall of their own. Protectionism was the order of the day. What Laurier could promise, in good conscience, was
no free trade for now but later, when the time became right. In embracing Macdonalds National Policy, however
gingerly, Laurier became electable. Once he abandoned the tariff (and he would do so in 1911), he would again
become exposed.

One irony of Lauriers rise to power is the role played by the Provincial Rights Movement (see Section 2.11).
Oliver Mowat (1820-1903), the Premier of Ontario and the most effective and unrelenting advocate of decen-
tralized confederation, was joined by Nova Scotian Premier William Fielding in an endorsement of Laurier. The
ongoing acrimony between the provinces and Ottawa over federal powers had the effect of boosting the cause of
the Liberals provincially: Both Mowat and Fielding were Liberals and thus motivated to see a change in Ottawa.
What this meant, of course, is that Laurier wanted federal power but not so much of it that he would alienate his
own base of support. He promised to build consensus rather than punish his foes: This was the crux of his com-
mitment to sunny ways. History tends to view Laurier as a master of compromise, the Great Conciliator, and
this (honouring provincial rights and holding federal power) was possibly his neatest trick. In 1896 he became
prime minister.

Culture Wars
The first Laurier government faced several issues immediately. The foremost of these was the Manitoba Schools
Act, 1870. Separate, publicly-funded schools for Catholics was an issue in all provinces. Prior to Confederation
there was a consensus across British North America that religion and education could not only co-exist in the
schools, but they were both essential parts of the moral and intellectual development of children. Where a church
and community established a school, public funding generally followed. Confederation gave to the provinces
exclusive authority over education so that a majority of MPs in Ottawa could not impose their denominational
biases on the nations schools. Read simply, it was intended to stop Orangemen (from English Canada) attacking
Catholic schools in Quebec. Although, the expectation was that Catholic and French language education else-
where would be preserved and nurtured as well. The BNA Act, 1867, also guaranteed the continued funding of
existing denominational schools in each of the provinces.

It was this second protection that was first to erode. As early as 1871 New Brunswick legislators were keen to
move from denominational to secular education with a single, uniform curriculum, and with provincial govern-
182 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

ment (rather than church) oversight. Welcomed by the Protestant denominations, this move was resisted stren-
uously by the Catholic (mostly Acadian) communities. The official Catholic position was that education was a
matter for the clergy, and the state could not and should not interfere. Frederictons response was consistent with
the anticlericalism that marked Victorian liberalism and modernism: The separation of church and state in civic
life was necessary for the well-being of a successful democratic society. The Common Schools Act, 1871 became
a flashpoint as Protestant legislators argued that there had been no pre-1867 formal arrangement with the denomi-
national schools so the Catholics had no rights to lose. The Catholic church, including Quebecs Bishop Ignace
Bourget (who would later be a nemesis of Laurier), encouraged their adherents to withhold school taxes and per-
suaded at least two Catholic members of the New Brunswick government to resign. Clergymen were arrested and
property was seized in lieu of taxes. This increasingly rancorous disagreement culminated in tragedy in the Aca-
dian community of Caraquet in 1875; a confrontation between a volunteer Protestant constabulary and Catholic
opponents of the Common Schools Act came to blows, gunfire was exchanged, and both sides claimed one dead.

The New Brunswick case began under Macdonalds watch and ended under Mackenzies. Neither federal admin-
istration was inclined to interfere, and each successive administration feared a replay in a different province. New
Brunswickers found a route to compromise, but theyd paid a terrible price to get there. This was not a pattern
anyone wished to reproduce, although the conflicting pressures a modernist need for secular and consistent
education versus a conservative clerical desire to control curriculum on faith and language were not dissipat-
ing.

In the early 1890s this issue was coming to a head in Manitoba, and it became the most prominent matter during
the 1896 federal election. One of the promises made in negotiations with the Red River Mtis (in 1870) covered
the provision of publicly-funded separate schools in which the Catholic faith and French language could be part
of the curriculum. Declining numbers of Mtis in Manitoba (and an increase of anti-Mtis feeling after the 1885
Northwest Rebellion) constructed an argument for dispensing with separate schools. Premier Thomas Greenway
(1838-1908), a notable advocate of provincial rights as early as 1883 and a Liberal by necessity as much as by
inclination, saw in educational reform a chance to forge a common, pragmatic front among Liberals and Conser-
vatives in Manitoba. His government put an end to the bilingual production of legislation and government records
(a move that was overturned by the courts nearly a century later), effectively ended French as an official language
in the province, and removed public funding from confessional schools. Parents who wished to send their chil-
dren to a Catholic school could still do so, but they would have to pay the full costs directly and, in addition to
that, they were expected to pay school taxes to support the secular, provincially-run system. There was widespread
hope among federal politicians that this thorny issue might be resolved by the courts, but the Judicial Committee
of the Privy Council responded that it was up to Ottawa. The Conservatives in Ottawa threatened to disallow the
legislation but failed to do so before losing the 1896 election in part, rather bizarrely, because Laurier blocked
the passage of their disallowance bill. The Manitoba Schools Question now fell to Laurier to resolve.

The new Prime Ministers response was one that would characterize his strategy of seeking compromise, one
that he would follow for a generation. Laurier through his delegate, Oliver Mowat convinced Greenway
to provide some very small degree of funding and support for French-language instruction and Catholic schools,
although the official language issue stayed off the table. The compromise was based on numbers: 10 francophone
pupils in rural areas or 25 in urban areas could trigger after-class instruction. The deal had the enormous political
benefit of getting the issue off the federal agenda, which was a great relief to Laurier. Historians have pointed
to the outcome as the inevitable result of a changing demographic and, in that context, Laurier is seen to have
 4.4 THE SUNNY WAYS OF SIR WILFRID LAURIER 183

secured some reasonable if small concessions. Others have argued that this was a critical moment in Canadian
history when Laurier sacrificed the principle of minority rights and the federal governments constitutional
obligation to protect them in order to entrench Anglo-Protestantism as the norm across the West. The consen-
sus is that this example of compromise brought peace and that it was staged expertly, but that the concessions
made by Manitoba were pitifully small and ungenerous.

The issue of education thereafter moved entirely to the provincial level. When Lauriers ally, Premier Flix Marc-
hand (1832-1900), attempted in 1890 to reform the education system in Quebec with an eye to taking it away from
the clergy and into the hands of the state, he was defeated by an alliance of Anglican and Catholic elements in the
2
provinces Legislative Council. Laurier did not intervene.

Key Points

Wilfrid Laurier was intermittently an opponent of Confederation.

The execution of Riel was a turning point in Quebec politics and in Lauriers career.
The Liberal Partys victory in 1896 was helped by Lauriers willingness to mute the partys commit-
ment to free trade.
Laurier was first tested as prime minister on the issue of separate schools. His compromising
approach hints at what would become his modus operandi in successive crises.

Attributions
Figure 4.9
Laurier 1910 Vol 06 no 07 Man-to-Man Magazine cover by Skeezix1000 is in the public domain. This image is
available from Vancouver Public Library, courtesy of Jason Vanderhill.

Figure 4.10
Wilfrid Laurier, M.P. (Drummond-Arthabaska, Quebec) (Online MIKAN no.3194714) by William James Top-
ley / Library and Archives Canada / PA-026430 is in the public domain.

2. Nova Scotia and Quebec retained their Legislative Councils into the 20th century. The Council in Halifax was dissolved in 1928, but the
Quebec Council endured until 1968. The Legislative Councils acted as appointed provincial-level senates. Ontario never wrote one into its
provincial constitution, BC never implemented plans to have one, and Manitoba, PEI, and New Brunswick were quick to dispose of theirs.
The term used to describe a legislature with two tiers in the Canadian case, typically called an Assembly and a Council is bicameral.
 4.5 Imperialism vs. Nationalism

So long as the majority of Canadians have two countries, one here and one in Europe, national unity will remain a myth
and a constant source of internecine quarrels.
1
Henri Bourassa, ca. 1907

I am an Imperialist because I will not be a Colonial.

2
Stephen B. Leacock, 1907.

It was on Lauriers watch that there arose a vocal debate among Canadians about empire and nation. Briefly, there
were those who believed Canadas destiny was in the arms of the British Empire, where it would mature and
inevitably wield greater and greater authority, perhaps someday challenging Britains leadership of the whole.
There were others who contended that Canada was a North American nation, one that need not be drawn into
imperial adventures, a nation that had conquered half a continent and which would be better off autonomous and
self-confident. Inevitably, elements of the two sides bled into one another: The imperialists were nationalists and
the nationalists rhetoric was littered with imperialist language. One was outward looking; the other inward. The
imperialist view called on strong pro-British sentiments that echoed the ordeals of the Loyalists of 1783, and the
defence of British North America against the United States in 1812 and 1866; the nationalists invoked the accom-
plishments of the voyageurs and the Hudsons Bay Company, the native political traditions embodied in the rebel-
lions of 1837-38, and the peculiar, dual cultural qualities of Canada.

There were many who embodied these contradictions. One was Madge Robertson Watt (1868-1948), a youthful
activist in womens organizations. As her biographer writes, Watt

represented a number of emerging trends in the early 20th century: While she embraced the ideal of the New Woman,
she firmly maintained a great emphasis on respectability and conventionality. She was a proud Canadian with unabashed
loyalty to the Empire. She is known for exporting a Canadian idea to the mother country Womens Institutes, an orga-
3
nization for rural women, which she succeeded in transplanting to England and Wales.

An appetite for change and a tireless devotion to improving the condition of women internationally, as the case of
Watt demonstrates, could be very closely aligned to a socially conservative way of being; nationalism and impe-
rialism could be found in the same heart.

1. Quoted in Jean-Charles Bonenfant and Jean-Charles Falardeau, "Culture and Political Implications of French-Canadian Nationalism," Canadian Historical
Association Report (1946): 56-73.
2. Stephen B. Leacock, "An Address before the Empire Club and Toronto Educationists," The Empire Club Addresses (Toronto), 19 March 1907: 276-305.
3. Linda M. Ambrose, A Great Rural Sisterhood: Madge Robertson Watt & the ACWW (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2015), 4.

184
 4.5 IMPERIALISM VS. NATIONALISM 185

Lauriers nationalism was, rather typically, one that sought to find a compromise; which is not to say it was disin-
genuous. He had a long career of lauding British institutions and especially British liberalism. Was he that fer-
vently loyal? Its possible, but it is also certain that, as a French-Canadian and a Catholic he felt rightly that
Anglo-Protestants needed regular reassurance on this score. And while he was espousing a deep personal loyalty
to the Crown, he believed that Canada was a North American country with a powerful North American neighbour
whose economy was increasingly important to the success of Canada.

Two of the most prominent voices in the debate over Canadas future were a pair of contemporaries, both born in
the first two years of Confederation: the Quebec Nationaliste, Henri Bourassa (1868-1952), and the English-Cana-
dian Imperialist, Stephen Leacock (1869-1944). Their disagreement played itself out in the two decades before
the Great War, although it had begun before them in the mid-19th century. It would continue in different forms
throughout the 20th century. In a society in which the individual was more important than the whole society, schol-
ars and politicians and journalists at the turn of the century struggled to describe the society or nation to which the
individual should belong. Whats more, these ideas about Canadian-ness were deadly serious insofar as they were
freighted with disagreement over what constituted Canada and when, and under what conditions, Canada should
send its people to war. A Canada-wide ambivalence on this topic marked the administration of Wilfrid Laurier in
particular, but it has never fully gone away.

The Canada Firsters

The Canada First movement was established in 1868. It drew in some of the most articulate English-Canadian
politicians and writers of the day, including Edward Blake, Charles Mair, Robert Grant Haliburton, and
John Schultz. This was a very mixed bag, held somewhat more firmly together by the influence of British historian
Goldwin Smith (who arrived in Toronto in 1871 from Oxford via Cornell University). What united the group was
a suspicion of American ambitions and a belief that Canada represented the best hope for a northern, Protestant,
and Aryan race. In this regard they were starkly anti-Irish, anti-French, and anti-Catholic, as Schultz and Mair
both demonstrated at Red River in 1869-70. Their shared Aryanism was typical of the racist and imperialist views
of the day. Efforts to produce a competitive Canada Party in federal politics failed, but much of the spirit of this
movement was to survive in a variety of forms and its ideas would help to formulate, eventually, a restructuring
of the British Empire.

Imperialism in Canada points in two directions. Firstly, it is oriented outward and inward from the St. Lawrence,
looking toward Britain while taking in as Canadas own empire the West and the North. While the Maritimes
also came under its sway, that regions population also and independently felt the tug of the North Atlantic econ-
omy and had done so for centuries. Secondly, Canadian imperialism is enmeshed in the larger British imper-
ial enterprise: Canadians like John A. Macdonald applauded British territorial and commercial gains and were
pleased to bask in the reflected glory of Britains military and economic might. The question for Canadian imperi-
alists of this kind, however, was whether Canada was as junior a colony as the many African and Asian territories
claimed by Britain, or was it a senior and largely autonomous member of the British imperial family? Conve-
niently, an influential group in the very heart of London provided an answer.

The Imperial Federation

The Imperial Federation movement began in England in the 1880s and quickly gained momentum in Canada.
186 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Among its leaders on this side of the Atlantic were the enormously popular writer and satirist Stephen Leacock,
the cleric George Monro Grant, and the educator and writer George Robert Parkin. The Canadian Imperialists, as
historians describe them, ranged in age from the youthful Leacock through the very middle-aged Grant, but they
were solidly Upper Canadian Ontarians. From 1868 to the Great War and beyond they presented a vision of a
Canada that was not only embedded in the Empire but a likely heir to its leadership. Canada was draped in the
Union Jack but with rippling muscles and vitality bursting from every pore, unlike the tired old British lion, care-
worn by years of managing an empire and physically degraded by decades of industrial labour, crowded cities,
and bad food. The Canadian Imperialists drew on Canadas northern-ness as a source of collective and mythic
cultural strength. As imperialists they expected that Canada would join in British wars abroad because those were,
effectively, Canadian wars. And (as Leacock indicated at the outset) they rejected being subservient and pathetic
colonials looking to Britain to protect their interests and sovereignty. They would be imperialists active, con-
tributing, committed because being colonials was narrow and emasculating. They were, in this regard, out-
ward-looking and internationally-minded, even if they perpetuated the Anglo-philic and Franco-phobic tendencies
of the Canada Firsters.

Figure 4.11 Stephen Leacock in 1913, on the brink of

the war between the empires.

Imperialist anger simmered when Prime Minister Laurier tried to moderate imperialist and nationalist antipathies
at the outset of the Boer War (see Sections 4.6 and 4.7). While many Qubecois remained hostile to the war,
imperialists were enthusiastic and celebrated what were viewed as landmarks in an emerging Canadian military
tradition. Huge parades welcomed troops home, the dead were mourned with honours and ceremony, and regi-
ments added South African names to their banners and crests. It was, however, at this very peak that imperialist
sentiment cracked a little. In 1903 a specially-struck international commission ruled on the Alaska-Canada bor-
der dispute in favour of the United States. Anti-Americanism was ramped up a few steps, but so too was anti-
British feeling, even among some imperialists. The commissions decision was transparently an effort on the part
of Britain to improve relations with the United States, regardless of Canadian interests. This would feed the cur-
rent within Canadian imperialism that sought greater autonomy and authority within the Empire, as opposed to
the cohort that was more likely to be uncritically loyal to Britain.

Les Nationalistes
This understanding of Canada was very much at odds with the nationalism articulated by Henri Bourassa. The
grandson of Louis-Joseph Papineau the leader of the Lower Canadian Rebellion and a long-time politician,
both before and after 1837 Bourassa was a youthful powerhouse. He was first elected to office at 22 years of
age as the mayor of Montebello (the town created by his grandfather on the ancestral seigneury). He was sub-
sequently elected as a Liberal MP in the 1896 campaign that saw Laurier become prime minister. The still very
young Bourassa was to be a gadfly to Laurier, constantly denouncing concessions made to the imperialist element
while developing a cogent nationalist position.
 4.5 IMPERIALISM VS. NATIONALISM 187

Figure 4.12 Henri Bourassa in 1917, around

the time of the conscription crisis.

In 1899 Bourassa resigned his seat in protest (though he quickly won it back) over Canadas participation in the
Second Boer War. He likened the Boers Dutch-speaking settlers in South Africa to the French-Canadians:
a linguistic minority whose demands for independence were being suppressed. Like many of his contemporaries,
Bourassa envisioned a Canada that could be dualistic in language and beliefs. He maintained that this cultural
complexity sufficiently defined the country and that embracing it would be enough to protect the Dominion from
American influences. He said on one occasion that the Qubecois should be as French as the Americans are Eng-
lish, which is to say, only in language. Like many nationalist visions, Bourassas was ultimately inward looking
and suspicious of the outside world.

Two events in the early 20th century impacted the fortunes of both groups. The Alaska Boundary Dispute pro-
duced a result that outraged many Canadians and disappointed imperialists in particular. Subsequent British
requests for Canadian financial contributions to the Royal Navy were divisive, not only between French-Canadian
nationalists and English-Canadian imperialists but among English-Canadians, who were now articulating some-
thing like an English-language version of Canadian nationalism themselves. The Great War reinvigorated impe-
rialism in some measure, but what was hoped in some quarters would be a military romp lasting a few months
turned into something much more tragic. British commanders competence was drawn into question, and the effect
of the Canadian victory at Vimy Ridge (followed by the disaster at Passchendaele) in 1917 was to feed national-
ist sentiment and leech away imperialist support. Gradually elements of the two perspectives were moving closer
together, even if animosity between French- and English-Canadians persisted.

Bourassas long career in public affairs, the volume of writing he produced, and his prominent role in many of the
key debates in national affairs made Bourassa an enormous influence on thinking about Canada and not just
in Quebec. The cross-cultural nationalism that emerged in the 1950s and 1960s owed a lot to Bourassa. Likewise,
Leacock a brilliant humourist was one of the most widely read writers in the English language in the first
quarter of the century, and his call for a self-assured, morally-centred, and globally invested Canada echoes in the
countrys mid-century role as a middle power and peacekeeper.

Figure 4.13 Canadian involvement in the Boer War divided

nationalistes from imperialists, and set the tone for disagreement
on Canadas international role.
188 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Key Points

English-Canadians with strong loyalties to the British Empire and aspirations for a larger Canadian
role in world affairs became known as imperialists.
French-Canadians whose suspicion of Britains international agenda combined with a North Amer-
ica-centric view of Canada articulated a nationaliste perspective.
The leading figures in these two movements were men of letters, respectively: the humourist
Stephen Leacock and the journalist Henri Bourassa.
Satisfying the polarized interests of these two groups became one of the great challenges of Lauriers
administrations.
Both movements contributed ideas that would gird greater claims for autonomy within the Empire.

Attributions
Figure 4.11
Stephen Leacock by YUL89YYZ is in the public domain.

Figure 4.12
Henri Bourassa by Jeangagnon is in the public domain.

Figure 4.13
Canadian troops in armoured train South Africa Jan 1902 LAC 3407086 by Rcbutcher is in the public domain.
 4.6 Canada and Africa

The debate between imperialists and nationalists (surveyed in Section 4.5) came to a head in the late 1890s as
Britain lurched into a colonial war in South Africa. This was not Britains first conflict in Africa, nor was it
Canadas. The failed Nile Expedition of 1884-85 often overlooked set the stage for Canadas involvement
in the turn of the century war, and was one of several crises in Lauriers tenure.

Sudan 1884-85
A botched attempt to evacuate British troops and civilians from the Sudanese city of Khartoum in the winter
of 1884 resulted in a year-long siege. Lieutenant-General Garnet Wolseley (1833-1913), an Irish-British career
soldier and colonial administrator, was given charge of an expedition to relieve the Britons trapped in Sudan.
Wolseleys connection to Canada was this: He had charge of the Canadian expedition sent to Red River in 1870.
In subsequent engagements in West Africa, Wolseley recruited Canadians and other veterans of the Red River
invasion to support his efforts. In 1884 coincidentally, on the eve of the Northwest Rebellion Wolseley put
in another call for Canadian troops, obtaining 390 voyageurs in actuality, a mix of former fur trade workers,
Mohawk from Kahnaw:ke, and loggers from the Ottawa Valley to assist the movement of more than 5,000
British troops up the Nile. The whole episode was a failure, and Khartoum fell two days before Wolseleys troops
were anywhere near. Moreover, about 200 of the Canadians abandoned their African adventure and hurried home
1
when their six-month contracts expired. Sixteen of their number died on the Nile.

Figure 4.14 A few hundred French, English, and Mohawk

Canadians volunteered to lend their river-navigating skills to an
ill-fated British mission in 1884.

Although this was not a conflict in which Canada declared a direct interest, the Nile Expedition established a post-
Confederation precedent: the Dominions human resources were available to Britain in wartime. Canada would
not be called on again to contribute men to war for another 15 years, but the principle of defending the Empire
was in place.

1. O. A. Cooke, WOLSELEY, GARNET JOSEPH, 1st Viscount WOLSELEY, in Dictionary of Canadian Biography, vol. 14, University of
Toronto/Universit Laval, 2003, accessed 21 August 2015, [Link]

189
 190 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Boer War, 1899-1902

The Second Boer War began in 1899 as the South African Republic and the Orange Free State (colonized by
Dutch settlers) resisted British attempts to annex their territories into a larger Cape Colony. Mineral wealth and the
goal of a Cape-to-Cairo chain of colonies was what motivated Britain and its agents in South Africa. The origins
of the Second Boer War can be traced, also, to the overlap between imperial and capitalist agendas in South Africa.
Britain had what it regarded as strategic objectives, and these were funded and driven forward by private plans
to exploit mineral, human, and other resources, but specifically diamonds and gold. Two colonies the South
African Republic (aka: Transvaal) and the Orange Free State stood in the way. These were colonies left over
from the days of the Dutch East India Companys activities at the southern tip of the continent, and they had long
been in conflict with British forces. They were, moreover, hardened by their experience of persecution by neigh-
bours and their conflict with the regions Indigenous peoples in the so-called Zulu Wars. These trials, along with
their migration into the interior of South Africa, contributed to a strong sense of Boer Trekker (or Voortrekker)
2
community identity and a sharpened and highly conservative religious culture. The Boers were not wealthy, nor
were they particularly close physically or diplomatically to the coastal Afrikaners (other descendants of the
Dutch colonial experiment). To private British interests in the region they seemed ripe for the picking and efforts
were made to stir up a Boer rebellion that would necessitate an official and armed British relief effort and then a
conquest. This failed, so the British opted for less subtle means and war was declared in October 1899.

Canadian involvement began with 1,000 volunteers under the command of Lieutenant Colonel William Otter,
who had (poorly) led the Canadian Permanent Force against the Mtis and the Cree in 1885. Enthusiasm among
English-Canadians, however, was so great that a further 6,000 recruits were easily obtained. This was (with the
exception of a regiment of Constabulary) a one-year commitment for recruits time enough to sail across the
Atlantic and spend a Canadian winter in sunnier climates while fighting for the honour of the Empire. Recruits
were paid, public donations poured in to insure their lives and protect their wives and children from penniless
widowhood and orphanhood, and a whole contingent the Strathcona Horse was assembled and paid for by
Donald Smith (now Lord Strathcona), the former CEO of the Hudsons Bay Company, Conservative MP, and dri-
ving force behind the Canadian Pacific Railway.

The course of the war was nothing glorious, despite initial excitement among imperialists. Britains military
strategies were transparently ineffective, the Boers were better armed, better prepared, and better motivated than
expected and much more so than they had been in the First Boer War. 1899 ended on a low note as the tempo
changed to a grinding guerrilla defence running up against a steady, if plodding, march on the capitals, Pretoria
and Bloemfontein. It was in this phase that the British began to deploy concentration camps and engaged in a
scorched-earth policy that targeted Boer farms. At Paardeberg Drift in February 1900, two Canadian units from
the Maritimes wore down a much larger Boer force and secured a badly needed victory for the Empire. The Cana-
dians distinguished themselves individually, but Paardeberg was otherwise their high-water mark in the war. And

2. The terminology used to describe the Dutch settlers of South Africa is complicated and often misleading. Some of them were French
Huguenots and not Dutch at all. The settlers most closely connected with the Dutch Companys forts and harbours are historically more
likely to be described as Afrikaners, and the rural populations as Boers (Dutch for farmers). The whole of this population is linked by the use
of Afrikaans, a dialect comprised largely of Dutch but also Indonesian and African elements. The Boer resistance to the British stemmed in
part from their decades-long effort to avoid British rule by migrating north and inland. The Voortrekkers self-imposed exile hardened their
attitude towards both the British and the coastal Afrikaners, some of whom joined in the War on the side of the British. One can easily find in
this story elements of the Mtis situation 15 years earlier, insofar as the former Red River Colony was largely abandoned to the Canadians
and the Mtis forced off into the interior where they were significantly less well off and running out of places to hide from imperial forces.
 4.6 CANADA AND AFRICA 191

while medals were handed out (including four Victoria Crosses) and the troops were feted on their return, there
3
was also a crack opening in the Canadian imperialist armour.

Figure 4.15 Becoming more legendary by the minute, NWMP

Superintendent Sam Steele (sitting, left) at midnight in the Yukon
with friends. At the right is Henry Burstall, later a Major General,
who was knighted as well.

This was the Dominions first international (as opposed to cross-border) conflict and it was transformative. Impe-
rialist sentiment was such that Canadian troops and officers initially deferred to British commanders, whose
performance subsequently proved to be worthy of reproach. Returning soldiers complained about British class
snobbery and incompetence in the field. Now, complaining is something that soldiers are wont to do, but in the
particular context of Edwardian Canada, this did less to subtract from loyalty to Britain than it did to add to
an embryonic English-Canadian national sensibility. It reinforced a growing sense that, as a part of the Empire,
Canada ought to be treated less as a subordinate and more as an equal. (In this there are echoes of the contempo-
raneous Provincial Rights Movement that sought to erase the belief that Ottawa was superior to the provinces.)

The Boer War left several other legacies. It cemented the already near-mythical reputation of Sam Steele
(1848-1919). A militiaman who fought Fenians in 1866, a member of Canadas first regular army unit, one of the
earliest members of the NWMP, a veteran of 1885 (he fought the Cree at Frenchmans Butte and Loon Lake), a
Mountie in the East Kootenays and also in the Yukon during the Klondike gold rush, Steele was placed in charge
of the Strathconas Horse Regiment at the ripe age of 50. Steele served as a model of masculinity for a generation
of Canadians, and as a symbol of Canadas maturing strength as a nation.

Figure 4.16 A regiment of Canadian soldiers returns from South

Africa and is met by a huge public reception on King Street in
Toronto on May 31, 1900.

The South African conflict also led Canadians to think that international wars might be relatively short with tol-
erable casualties. In two and a half years of combat there were only about 250 Canadian casualties from 7,000
troops, and it is reckoned that more than half of these died from disease, not battle wounds. (At worst this mor-
tality rate was a third of what would be recorded in the Great War.) When August 1914 rolled around, then, it
was South Africa that Canadians remembered, and not the much more comparable (and vastly more damaging)
Napoleonic Wars a century earlier.

3. The most comprehensive source on this topic is Carman Miller, Painting the Map Red: Canada and the South African War, 1899-1902 (Mon-
treal & Kingston: Canadian War Museum & McGill-Queen's University Press, 1993).
 192 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Canadas Century
In the midst of the Boer War, Laurier realized that he needed to be able to galvanize nationalists and imperialists
alike and not just keep them from one anothers throats. In 1905 he told the House that as the 19th century had
4
been the century of the United States, so the 20th century would be the century of Canada. This was a sentiment
both sides could embrace, but only, of course, if Laurier could stop the country from imploding.

South Africa drove deeper the wedge that existed between English-Canadians and French-Canadians. It also
served to alienate from the Anglo-Canadian vision of Canada many of the immigrant communities that identified
more with the Boers than with the British forces.

Nationalistes were opposed for two main reasons: they argued that Canada ought not to be sucked into Britains
imperial vortex and that the situation of the Boers was not entirely unlike that of the French-Canadians. Indeed,
there were echoes of the Northwest Rebellion: Not only was an agrarian, non-anglophone population caught
squarely in the gun sights, but the very same personnel were holding the rifles. The Royal Canadian Regiment of
Infantry sent to South Africa was under the command once again of William Otter and the mounted regiment was
led by the ubiquitous Colonel Steele. By contrast, imperialists viewed Canadian involvement in the Boer War as
a matter of duty and also as an opportunity to demonstrate the growing maturity and capacity of the Dominion.

Lauriers instincts were always to find a compromise, and they were never better illustrated than in 1899. Refusing
to support a deployment of regulars, which would have sent French-Canadians into battle against the Boers, he
opted to muster a corps of volunteers. At first this was only a force of 1,000, but it grew eventually to 7,000.
Anglophone imperialists were offended by the smallness of Canadas engagement, especially at the start; fran-
cophones opposed to the war rioted for three days. Laurier faced several poor options, and his compromise was
less divisive than any of the other choices open to him. If elections are the final litmus test, the opportunity for
voters to turn on him came in 1904 and he survived.

Figure 4.17 Criss-crossing the country at election time (in this

case, 1904) was made possible by the extensive railway network.
Politicians like Laurier could hit one community after the next,
meeting briefly with locals and then moving on to the next
whistlestop.

Key Points

By 1900 Canada had been involved in two military expeditions at home and two abroad.
The two campaigns in Africa Sudan in 1884-85 and the Second Boer War were in support of
British imperial goals.

4. Canada. House of Commons, Debates, 21 February 1905.

 4.6 CANADA AND AFRICA 193

Both conflicts were small adventures with few casualties, which may have led to Canadians underes-
timating the seriousness of the Great War when it began in 1914.
The Boer War was profoundly divisive in domestic politics.

Attributions
Figure 4.14
The Nile Expedition for the Relief of General Gordon, from The Graphic, 29 November 1894 by Moonraker is
in the public domain.

Figure 4.15
Midnight in the Yukon, June 1899 Online MIKAN no. 3710400 by Library and Archives Canada / e008128889
is in the public domain.

Figure 4.16
Celebration of the end of the Boer War, Yonge Street by Skeezis1000 is in the public domain. This image is
available from the Government of Ontario Archives, under the reference number F 1143, S 1244.

Figure 4.17
Sir Wilfrid Laurier speaking from the platform of a railway observation car during the federal election cam-
paign (Online MIKAN no.3364640) by Library and Archives Canada / C-002616 is in the public domain.
4.7 Edwardian Crises

Figure 4.18 A failed attempt to escape the

19th century.

Transforming Canada
The Boer War crisis was acute and relatively brief. Other issues offered more ongoing and chronic discomfort,
and the need for quite a lot of adjustment. The most dramatic of these is the accelerated rate of immigration under
the Laurier regime and, specifically, under the guidance of his Minister of the Interior, Clifford Sifton (see Section
5.4). Between 1896-1911 the demographics of Canada changed spectacularly. There is irony in the fact that Lau-
riers first days in office were spent addressing the demographic marginalization of Franco-Catholics in Manitoba:
by 1911 the hundreds of thousands of Mennonites, Germans, Doukhobors, Americans, and others who poured into
the Prairies would transform the region to such a point that some aspects of the Manitoba schools crisis would
seem already remote.

The issue of how best to manage international commerce was another of Lauriers ongoing concerns. It was
largely resolved by introducing a preferential tariff that was meant to encourage other nations to bring down their
own barriers. Insofar as it didnt remove tariffs altogether the policy pleased manufacturers. Because it showed
preference to Britain as a trade partner, it pleased imperialists. Without substantially addressing any of the agri-
cultural communitys complaints, it left homesteaders and farmers feeling neglected and wondering if either of
the two national parties would ever come around to their way of seeing things.

Timing, however, is everything. The world economy was, in 1896, entering into a recovery phase. As settlers
poured into the West, demand for wheat and mineral products grew. Historians disagree as to whether the pref-
erential tariff had a direct effect on the Canadian economy because it was introduced on a rising tide. As grain
production and exports climbed rapidly, so too did manufacturing sales. There now emerged for the first time sig-
nificant bottlenecks in the movement of goods. Perhaps carried away by the booming economy, Laurier in 1903
launched a campaign to build a new transcontinental railway that would serve neglected parts of the Maritimes,

194
 4.7 EDWARDIAN CRISES 195

northern Ontario, the northern Prairies, and a Pacific outlet in the new port-city of Prince Rupert. This was taking
a page from Macdonalds playbook. The Canadian Northern (later called the Canadian National) Railway and the
Grand Trunk Railway increased capacity and penetrated the northern West while a dense network of smaller lines
and branch lines cross-hatched the face of the Prairies before 1914. There were at least 15,000 km of track run-
ning east and west and north and south in Canada. One government after the next subscribed to the view that rail-
ways were good politics: They created jobs and markets, stimulated industrial growth, and tied the whole together
tighter and tighter.

Figure 4.19 The Toronto-born surveyor and photographer Frank

Swannell in 1912, surveying for the Grand Trunk Pacific Railway
at (and in) Takla Lake.

Improved conditions after 1896 led to increased Canadian self-confidence. Queen Victorias Diamond Jubilee
was marked in London by an unprecedented meeting between colonial leaders and the British Colonial Secretary
Joseph Chamberlain (1836-1914), whose goal it was to build an Imperial Federation. As was his tendency in the
past, Laurier publicly espoused an intense loyalty to and affection for Britain, but at the meeting table he was
unwilling to relinquish any Canadian sovereignty to a proposed British-led global federal system. Laurier knew,
as no other leader around that table could have, the challenges of co-existence within a federal structure and, what-
ever his disagreements with Henri Bourassa, he was looking toward a day when Canada would be more and not
less independent. After winning a second mandate in 1900, Laurier would similarly turn down British offers of an
Imperial Council, an Imperial Navy, and an Imperial Commercial Union. As he explained to the House of Com-
mons, the first loyalty of the Canadian government was to the Canadian peoples (however that might be defined),
not to London.

The economy that had once been Lauriers ally began to outrun him at the turn of the century. Urban growth cre-
ated cities that the small-town lawyer did not understand, and an industrial working class that was still more alien
to Lauriers experiences. He kept one eye on an ultramontane clergy and the other shut tight against the new issues
inherent in 20th century modernization. The creation of a new position Deputy Minister of Labour was a nod
toward industrial issues, but the legislation that arose from it mostly kept the state on the margins of disputes and
out of the way of expanding and monopolistic enterprises. These conditions, coupled to immigration and growth
in the West, all conspired to change the electorate and to move the goalposts of Canadian politics. A compromise
made in 1896 on behalf of 5 million Canadians might not have the same resonance in 1911 when there were 2
million more.

By 1909 Lauriers health never good was increasingly a problem. The Liberals had now been in office for 13
years and had won four consecutive elections. Canada was vastly changed from what it had been when Laurier
first came to office and the energy that Laurier and his original cabinet brought to the job was largely spent. One
final major issue would finish off the government.
196 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

The Naval Crisis

The second great challenge of Lauriers administrations echoed the first and picked up on a theme that dogged
him from the start of his time as prime minister. After 40 years of relative autonomy from Britain, Canadas mili-
tary capacity was still seriously underdeveloped. Dependence on Britain to provide the necessary muscle now had
to be reassessed. The British would have preferred a cheque from Canada to cover the cost of building additional
Royal Navy vessels, but nationalist voices in the Dominion (including Lauriers own) were more comfortable with
the prospect of a Canadian Navy.

There was a need for some urgency on this issue: Germany was building up its navy (as was France and the
United States) and Britain was anxious not to lose its advantage at sea. The Conservatives, under Robert Bordens
leadership, called for Ottawa to purchase a pair of Dreadnought-class battleships for the Royal Navy and to defer
the issue of a Canadian Navy until the next election. How that scenario might have turned out would be difficult
to guess because the naval issue had the potential to split the imperialists down the middle: some were Canadian
nationalists in imperialist clothing while others were British imperialists first, last, and always. Laurier decided to
press on and introduced the Naval Service Bill early in 1909, proposing to assemble a Canadian Navy that could
be available on loan to Britain at the discretion of the Dominion Parliament. Consisting of six destroyers and five
cruisers, it was instantly ridiculed as a tinpot navy. Caught once again between Anglo-Protestant imperialists on
one side, who moaned it was not enough, and Franco-Catholics on the other side, who cried that it was too much,
Laurier found there was little appetite in Canadian politics for his variety of compromise.

The last nail in Lauriers political coffin was that old chestnut, reciprocity. A delegation to Washington, DC had
finally managed to get American agreement on a deal that would provide free access to American markets for
natural resources and agricultural products along with limited trade in manufactured goods. This should have sat-
isfied farmers in the West and industrialists in the central and eastern provinces. It did not. Manufacturers and
investors who had hitherto supported the Liberal Party turned on it, as did Clifford Sifton. Wounded on two fronts,
Laurier was exhausted and called an election, which he lost.

Lauriers Legacy
It is difficult to assess Lauriers long record of compromise objectively. He kept the worst Canadian divisions
under control, it is true, but many of his compromises either irritated underlying fault lines or they proved to be
very poor deals indeed. The creation of the provinces of Saskatchewan and Alberta in 1905 offers a case in point.
The territorial administration under Premier Frederick Haultain had limited, sub-provincial powers, despite an
elected assembly at Regina. Local politicians favoured the creation of a single new province that would stretch
from (still undersized) Manitoba to the Rockies. Laurier preferred two provinces and sought to restore minority
rights in the West in the form of publicly-funded separate schools. He would win on the provinces and their bound-
aries, but he lost badly on the schools issue. It cost him the support of Sifton, who was an unflinching supporter of
the anglicization of the West, and Henri Bourassa, who resigned from the government years beforehand but had
hitherto maintained a lukewarm relationship with Laurier. Now the prime minister found two of his nations most
effective leaders attacking him at the same time for being simultaneously an ally and an enemy of French-Catholi-
cism.

Many of Lauriers tests ended the same way. Of course it is the business of opposition politicians to puncture the
 4.7 EDWARDIAN CRISES 197

support of the government, so one can hardly blame figures like Charles Tupper and Robert Borden for finding
fault with Lauriers deals. Henri Bourassas role and Clifford Siftons: those are more complex. When Bourassa
left Lauriers cabinet over the matter of the Boer War, Laurier said to him, I regret your going. We need a man
1
like you at Ottawa, although I should not want two. Bourassa was uncompromising and tapped into Qube-
cois fears of liberalism, modernity, and imperialism as he sniped at Laurier. At the same time, his articulation of
a nationalist position was as erudite and gifted as anything coming out of the imperialist camp. Siftons role is
harder to measure. There was none more entrepreneurial in the Laurier cabinet, nor was there anyone whose job
(as Minister responsible for immigration) required that he think long and hard about the mixing of cultures. Sifton
simply concluded early on that a Canada built on dualist principles was unsustainable and that the future belonged
to English-Canadian virtues and habits.

Figure 4.20 Laurier on the campaign trail in 1910 in New

Westminster.

It was an unholy alliance of imperialists and nationalists that laid Laurier low in 1911. His career was marked
by conflict with the conservative, ultramontane Catholic clergy in Quebec, and he spoke so often about his fear
of religious strife in Canada that one cannot but conclude that he genuinely believed it was possible. More than
that, he believed that being in office meant doing good. When I am premier, he said in 1890, you wont have to
2
look up figures [statistics] to find out whether you are prosperous: you will know by feeling in your pockets. He
attacked Macdonald in 1886 for his actions with regard to the Northwest, saying What is hatefulis not rebel-
lion but the despotism which induces the rebellion; what is hateful are not rebels but the men, who, having the
enjoyment of power, do not discharge the duties of power; they are the men who, having the power to redress
wrongs, refuse to listen to the petitioners that are sent to them; they are the men who, when asked for a loaf, give
3
a stone. This was a leader who listened to all sides, perhaps too much.

Key Points

The 20th century opened with a suite of political and social crises in Canada.
Continuing immigration from east and central Europe was transforming the population.
Massive new railway construction projects stimulated the economy and tightened Canadas grip over
the West and BC.
The Naval Service Bill divided Canadians between those who sought to serve Britain and the Empire
first, and those who saw a Dominion fleet as an important step toward independence.

1. Quoted in J. Schull, Laurier: The First Canadian (Toronto: MacMillan, 1965) 459.
2. Quoted in O.D. Skelton, The Day of Sir Wilfrid Laurier: A Chronicle of Our Own Time (Toronto: Glasgow, Brook & Company, 1916): 327.
3. Canada, Official Report of the Debates of the House of Commons of the Dominion of Canada, 1886, vol. XXI (Ottawa: Queen's Printer
1886): 179.
198 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Attributions
Figure 4.18
A century run or bust two photographs (HS85-10-11914) by the British Library / Fred L. Hacking is in the pub-
lic domain.

Figure 4.19
Frank Swannell at Takla Lake by Frank Swannell is in the public domain.

Figure 4.20
Sir Wilfrid Laurier at New Westminster, B.C. (Online MIKAN no.3259139) by William T. Cooksley / Library
and Archives Canada / C-008816 is in the public domain.
4.8 Summary

Figure 4.21 Canadas ambivalent relationship with an expanding

United States and a seemingly disinterested Britain was a theme
that lasted well beyond the Victorian years. (Artist: Tom Merry,
ca. 1885-90).

Macdonald and Laurier were 19th century, Victorian-era men. They witnessed industrialization, imperialism, and
urbanization first-hand. Most of Lauriers time in office occurred during the Edwardian years; a period that was
marked by a rising middle class, and renewed optimism in social progress and equality, the arts, and technologi-
cal transformation. Macdonald died too soon to see motion pictures and automobiles; he missed, too, the bicycle
craze and the Suffragettes. He also missed the most compelling signs of Britains economic slide against its com-
petitors, including the United States and, significantly, Germany. Laurier wasnt too late into politics to see the old
western frontier, but by the time he was prime minister the days of the Red River cart and the bison were fading
or gone. The importance of the Edwardian era is that, after 64 years of one monarch and the Pax Britannica
the era of relative peace associated with British global power its start in 1901 signalled the beginning of a new
century and renewed possibilities. In the midst of the prosperity and self-confidence that Canada enjoyed in the
years up to 1912, one can see the consolidation of many of the ideas and practices that defined the country for the
century to come. The aspiration to be something more than a colonial appendage was one theme that would come
out of these years and would strongly influence politicians and writers in the generations ahead.

Edward VII died in 1910 and Laurier was toppled the very next year. The economic boom times would come to a
grinding halt beginning in 1912. What lay ahead was much worse.

Key Terms

anticlerical, anticlericalism: Someone who believes that the separation of church and state in civic life
is essential for the well-being of a successful democratic society.
branch plants: Typically American-owned companies that avoided tariff barriers by establishing plants
on the Canadian side of the border.

199
200 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Canada First: Established in 1868, an English-Canadian nationalist movement.

confessional schools: Religious schools run by Catholic or Protestant denominations.
dualism: The idea that Canada could or should construct its culture and institutions around two cultures,
French and English. In contrast with unification (which favours one culture) and pluralism or multicul-
turalism in which French in particular is at risk of becoming a minority culture.
Manitoba schools question: In 1890 the provincial government turned its back on commitments in the
Manitoba Act (1870) to provide a dual French and English system of education, a move that was
stimulated by declining French and Catholic populations. The Privy Council determined (twice) that
the federal government had the power to reverse this decision. In opposition, Wilfrid Laurier blocked
Ottawas attempt at disallowance; in government he negotiated a compromise with Manitoba.
Orange: Refers to the Orange Order, its members, and its values; a Protestant fraternal association with
roots in Ireland; marked by a strong antipathy for Catholics and Catholicism, as well as a fierce loy-
alty to the Crown. Supported Protestant immigrants and made use of violence and political networks to
achieve its ends.
pragmatic: In politics, the focus on existing conditions rather than ideological considerations or objec-
tives. Also called realpolitik.
preferential tariff: Charges (a tax) added to imported goods so as to make their sale price higher than
domestic goods and, thus, make domestic goods more competitive; some trade partners are less discrim-
inated (they are preferred) over others.
Rouge: Also Parti rouge. Political party and tradition in Quebec; established in the 1840s, it became
increasing more pro-secular, anticlerical, and opposed to hereditary privilege; opposed to Confederation,
embraced provincial rights; after 1867, merged with the Clear Grits to form the Liberal Party.

Short Answer Exercises

1. What was dualism? Where were its weaknesses most exposed?

2. Account for the success of Macdonalds Conservatives to 1896.
3. What role was played by the Catholic Church in the politics of Quebec and Canada?
4. What was the relationship between the Liberal Party and the tariff issue?
5. What were the most divisive issues faced by Lauriers administration?
6. What were the respective positions of imperialists and nationalists in pre-WWI Canada?
7. In what ways did these two visions of Canada make the country almost ungovernable?
8. In what ways had Canada changed politically between 1867 and 1914?

Suggested Readings
Backhouse, Constance. Dont You Bully Me Justice I Want If There is Justice to Be Had: The Rape of
Mary Ann Burton, London, Ontario, 1907, People and Place: Historical Influences on Legal Culture, eds. Jon
Swainger and Constance Backhouse (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2003): 60-94.
 4.8 SUMMARY 201

Beaulieu, Eugene and J. C. Herbert Emery, Pork Packers, Reciprocity, and Lauriers Defeat in the 1911 Canadian
General Election, The Journal of Economic History, 61, no. 4 (Dec 2001): 1083-1101.

Lord, Kathleen. Representing Crime in Words, Images, and Song: Exploring Primary Sources in the Murder
of Mlina Mass, Montreal, 1895, Histoire Sociale/Social History, 43, no. 86 (Novembre-November 2010):
249-55.

Martin, Ged. John A. Macdonald and the Bottle, Journal of Canadian Studies, 40, no. 3 (Fall 2006): 162-85.

Miller, Carman. Framing Canadas Great War: a case for including the Boer War, Journal of Transatlantic Stud-
ies, 6, no. 1 (April 2008): 3-21.

Attributions
Figure 4.21
Trying Her Constancy, or, a dangerous flirtation (Online MIKAN no.2838080) by Library and Archives
Canada, Acc. No. R9266-3552 / Peter Winkworth Collection of Canadiana is in the public domain.
 PART 6

Chapter 5. Immigration and the Immigrant

Experience

202
 5.1 Introduction

Figure 5.1 Prairie immigrants typically lived in sod huts or other

simple shelters until they had the resources and time to build a
house. Stefan Waskiewiczs family, LaCorey, AB, ca. 1930.

The history of immigration is, simultaneously, the history of emigration. It is very much about the motivations of
people who choose to leave behind what they and generations of their forebears knew and built. The rather inel-
egant dichotomy of pushes and pulls fails to take into consideration other countervailing forces but it does
serve to remind us that people here were once people there. A recent and beautifully succinct answer to the ques-
tion What made them leave? tells us about the motivations for Swedes who left their homeland between the
1880s and the 1940s, but it might easily be applied to a great many other nationalities as well:

At the beginning of emigration, the main reason was the lack of hope for breaking the cycle of poverty that affected
many families. Later came labour unrest, when participants were blacklisted and unable to find work. Other push factors
included compulsory military duty for young men, degrading class distinctions, restrictions on the right to vote, the
lack of a democratic spirit, the dominant position of the church, and personal reasons, such as escaping from a debt or an
1
unhappy marriage.

To use the language of 21st century marketeers, what Canada had to offer was a brand democratic (socially and
politically), free (in terms of movement and land availability), secular (insofar as it lacked a state church), tolerant
of pacifist views (for a while), underpopulated, and capable of experiencing sustained economic growth that
was preferable to the comfortable familiarities of home. As any study of Canadian history will show, however,
there were times when Canada had little to offer other than grief and maybe some money.

The first step to understanding the history of immigration to Canada is demographic. The magnitude of the flow
of humans into the Dominion after 1867 has to be appreciated, as does their distribution across the cities and
farms and resource-extraction towns. Who the immigrants were in terms of ethnicity and places of origin matters.
The second facet is the political and economic context of immigration: that is, the policies and opportunities that
framed the immigrant waves.

The social context of immigration is of immense importance as well. Canadas relationship with immigrants has
been uneven, to say the least. At times it was nothing short of exploitive; at other times it was xenophobic and

1. Elinor Barr, Swedes in Canada: Invisible Immigrants (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2015), 14.

203
204 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

hostile; and at others still, generous and welcoming. Recent events in Canada, including mixed messages from
governments about the kind of reception Syrian refugees might expect, serves to remind us that these attitudes
have a long pedigree in Canada. A historical study of immigration and immigration policy thus informs us of the
ways in which past generations understood questions about recruitment, assimilation, inclusion, citizenship, and
rights.

Learning Objectives

Describe the main historic features of post-Confederation immigration.

Account for the timing of immigrant waves.
Explain the preferential or inhospitable treatment shown to select groups at different times.
Identify the goals of immigration policy and the forces that led to changes.
Assess the strategies employed by immigrant groups and communities to achieve success in Canada.
Describe the role played by racism and nativism in the history of immigration.

Attributions
Figure 5.1
Shelter Stefan Waskiewiczs family lived until they built their house (Online MIKAN no.3263577) by Library
and Archives Canada / PA-178587 is in the public domain.
 5.2 Immigration and the National Policy

What came to be known as Prime Minister John A. Macdonalds National Policy was, as shown in Section 3.3, a
three-cornered set of initiatives. All of these, in the words of historian Reg Whitaker, were designed:

to attach the interests of the wealthy and influential elements of Canadian society to continent-wide development. The
encouragement of immigration thus became identified with the private interest of the large companies making profits out
1
of national development.

First, there was the railway. Linking the Atlantic to the Pacific meant more than running steam engines across the
country. It also meant providing a powerful stimulus for heavy industry. The steel mills of Ontario and Quebec
would be the principle beneficiaries and another was the engineering sector. Building and adapting railways, steel-
works, and engineering operations might begin with native-born labour, but that would soon run out.

The answer to that problem was, of course, managing the movement of people. In the first instance, that meant
retaining Canadians who were migrating to the United States. Insofar as that strategy failed or was simply not
enough, the logical next step was to encourage immigration. The Intercolonial Railway would move Canadians
and immigrants around the old provinces, but it was the West that held out the prospect of real growth. The CPR
was essential to settling migrants from old BNA across the former Ruperts Land; it would also be the means by
which immigrants would be deposited deep into the new Canadian hinterland. The CPR owned much of the arable
right-of-way between Lake Superior and the Rockies, so settlers enriched the Railway as customers and as tenants
or purchasers of land. The CPR made it possible to accelerate the process of Prairie settlement and thus to advance
the business of producing food for the industrial working people of the older provinces in a tidy symbiosis. Set-
tlement and railways also combined as a strategy for asserting sovereignty across the West against American and
Aboriginal ambitions and counter claims.

Third, there were tariffs. Obviously the new farming population would need supplies and equipment. Ideally, this
material would be shipped west to them on the same railway that carried their grain output eastward. Tariff barri-
ers would ensure that Western farmers, home builders, and businesses would purchase their supplies from central
Canadians at a higher price than they would pay to get the same goods from the United States. This compli-
cates the immigration strategy. Having assigned to immigrants and Canadian migrants the task of opening up an
agricultural frontier not a small task by any measure the National Policy then taxes them for the privilege
of doing so. These tariffs would sustain central Canadian industries, yes, and that would benefit other immigrants
in terms of jobs, but it was in the West that the project of building a new economy based on the labour of immi-
grants was most apparent and the rise of a new, more diverse Canada was taking place. Of course, and as we shall

1. Reg Whitaker, Canadian Immigration Policy Since Confederation (Ottawa: Canadian Historical Association , Booklet no. 15, 1991), 5.

205
206 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

see, these new Canadians were not always welcomed by nativists in Ontario and Quebec who regarded with some
suspicion the value of foreigners and questioned the assimilability of Russians and Poles, Mennonites and Hut-
terites, whose ethnic, linguistic, and religious traditions were highly distinct from those of the founding nations.

How, then, did the immigration aspects of the National Policy fare? Not especially well.

Key Points

Immigration was a key piece of the National Policy.

It was first used to beef up the supply of wage labour in expanding industries in the central and east-
ern provinces.
The main part of pre-Great War immigration was directed toward farms in the West.
The relationship between these newcomers and established Canadian populations was regularly neg-
ative.
 5.3 Immigrants by the Numbers

Figure 5.2 Immigrants from Arab countries faced a cool welcome

in Canada. Tagged by the Immigration officers, three hopeful
candidates in Quebec, 1908.

We have already observed that Canada was a net exporter of people from 1867-1896. Newcomers arrived, but
they were very often just passing through. The end to free land in the American West in the 1890s was one factor
in redirecting the tide of emigrants from Europe toward the north. Another, from 1896, were the new approaches
taken by the Laurier administration under the leadership of Clifford Sifton (see Sections 4.4 and 5.4).

This is not to say that the immigration that was recorded from 1867-1896 did not matter. Hundreds of thousands
were added to the mix and the composition of Canadian settler society changed significantly. British immigrants
were the most numerous, but people who described themselves as German in origin increased by a third from
203,000 in 1871 to 310,000 in 1901. Three immigrant groups stand out in particular through to 1901: Chinese
numbers reached 17,312 (increasing from 4,400 in 1881 to 17,000 in 1901); Russians at 19,825; and Scandina-
vians (Norwegians, Swedes, Icelanders, and Finns grouped together) at about 31,000. None of these groups had
much of a presence in Canada prior to Confederation (although there were Chinese in British Columbia in signif-
icant numbers before 1871).

Tables 5.1 and 5.2, respectively, show the growth in population generally and the numbers of immigrants arriving
yearly between 1867-1920. What may be seen immediately is: 1) the slowness of immigrations growth before
the 1890s (notwithstanding a couple of spurts); 2) the fact that it was actually in retreat through most of the 1880s
and into the 1890s; and 3) the great take-off of immigration as Canada moves into the 20th century. The peak on
the eve of the Great War is also unmistakable, in that it is followed by a near-collapse as the conflict rages. In
the years 1911, 1912, and 1913 between 300,000 and 400,000 immigrants arrived each year, most of them from
1
Britain and continental Europe.

1. Roderic Beaujot, Population Change in Canada: The Challenges of Policy Adaptation (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1991), 105.

207
 208 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Table 5.1. Estimated Population of Canada, 1867-1920.

Table 5.2. Immigrant Arrivals, 1867-1920.

The complexion of the population in aggregate changed dramatically. On the eve of Confederation, fewer than
one-in-five Canadians were born somewhere else, principally in the British Isles or the United States. That share
started to decline almost immediately until 1911 when it pushed back through the 22% mark; as a result, a very
different country was created. In 1871 there was a significant German community in Canada but otherwise French
and English were the norms. By 1911, a quarter of the immigrant tide was coming from continental Europe and
most of that from central, eastern, and southern Europe. By 1921, the main ethnic immigrant groups constituted
more than one-in-eight of the population. The majority (just over half) of the foreign-born to 1931 came from
Britain and Ireland; another 20% or more were born in the United States. Regardless of point of origin, as of 1921
2
the immigrant population in Canada was proportionally larger than in the United States.

We know as well that immigrants in the pre-Great War period were overwhelmingly male. Men are over-repre-
sented in every age category from 10 to 14 years and up (after 65 years, the ratio of men to women nearly bal-
anced out). This suggests that either boys were demonstrating a particular determination to emigrate from Europe
and Asia or that they were preferred to daughters when it came time to move (principally because their prospec-
tive job prospects were better). In other words, families with more sons than daughters might be more inclined to
emigrate than those with more daughters. As to young adults, these sex ratio imbalances had serious ramifications.
In the 20 to 34 age cohorts, there were more than twice as many men as women in 1911. Women and daughters
might be sent for later, but this pattern of maleness persists throughout much of the 20th century. The sex ratio
among the foreign-born reaches a peak of 1.68 men to every woman in 1911 and among certain immigrant groups
it could be much higher. Among the Chinese it hovered around 200:1 for decades, and among the Scandinavians
in 1931 it was 268:1. These last examples are very definitely outliers, but the implications of a distorted sex ratio
for marital fertility ought to be obvious.

What is more, we know that the immigrant population was young but adult. The foreign-born on the eve of
the Great War were mostly under 40 years of age and 20-somethings was the largest cohort. Despite photogenic

2. Donald H. Avery, Reluctant Hosts: Canadas Response to Immigrant Workers, 1896-1994 (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1995), 22.
 5.3 IMMIGRANTS BY THE NUMBERS 209
3
images of immigrant families, surprisingly few foreign-born children appear in these statistics. Having said that,
the arrival of immigrants brought higher fertility rates, so much so that they slowed and, in places, reversed a
significant downward trend in Canadian fertility rates. The estimated annual average number of births per 1,000
4
population in Canada in 1851-61 was 45; in 1901-11 it fell to 31 and slid to 29 between 1911-1921. Without the
high fertility of immigrant communities these numbers would have been more depressed.

Distribution of immigrants provides a different sense of this change. The Maritime provinces and Quebec expe-
rienced little demographic change arising from immigration. Lebanese Christians were an important addition to
Prince Edward Island, but there were few other ethnic enclaves in the region by the Great War. The share of pop-
ulation that was foreign born in the Maritimes was only 5.2% in 1901, rising to a little more than 6% in 1911 a
level that held nearly steady for 30 years. Quebec was similarly mostly native-born in 1901 a comparable 5.4%
of the population was foreign but from there the share increased more markedly to 7.3% in 1911 and more than
8% in the Interwar years. West of the Ottawa River, however, 15% of Ontarians were foreign-born in 1901 and
that passed the 20% mark before the Great War and continued to rise to nearly 25% in 1931. The Prairie provinces
taken as a region began the century with a quarter of the population born abroad, rising to 49% in 1911. The share
dropped to 21% in 1921 but that reflected the impact of immigrant fertility the newcomers were adding sig-
nificant native-born children to the population and thus shrinking their own share of the total. Still, the renewal
of immigration in the 1920s created a second surge and by 1931 nearly 37% of Prairie Canadians were born else-
where. British Columbia behaved differently from the rest of Canada in this respect, being the least native-born
population of the lot. Foreigners constituted 44% of the population in 1901, rising to 57% in 1911 and only taper-
ing slightly to 50% in 1921. From 1901 to 1961, British Columbias population was, proportionately, the most
foreign-born of all regions. Of all the regions, only the North-West Territories reversed the trend. Starting at 37%
in 1901, the share of Northerners born abroad fell to 20% 10 years later and then 15% in 1921, where it stayed for
5
the next two decades.

Studies of immigrants in Canada tend to focus on their experiences as newcomers adjusting to new circumstances,
or as outsiders to which the established population reacts, or as ethnic enclaves whose cultural resilience and
change is subject to examination. As a demographic phenomenon, however, their profound impact is often too
quickly forgotten. Within little more than a generation, post-Confederation immigrants had fundamentally trans-
formed the populations main features while changing in significant ways its fertility, family size, and nuptial pat-
terns. In each of these regards, they had a lasting impact.

Key Points

Immigrants in the post-Confederation period rapidly changed the ethnic and age composition of the
population, as well as the gender ratio in many regions.
Immigration was slow to take off but it did so between 1896-1914, and again in the 1920s, making
Canada more foreign-born than the United States.
The distribution of immigrants was wildly uneven, barely impacting the Maritimes and Quebec.

3. Warren E. Kalbach, The Impact of Immigration on Canadas Population (Ottawa: Dominion Bureau of Statistics, 1970), 54.
4. Warren E. Kalbach and Wayne W. McVey, The Demographic Bases of Canadian Society (Toronto: McGraw-Hill, 1971), 56-7, 134-5.
5. Warren E. Kalbach and Wayne W. McVey, The Demographic Bases of Canadian Society (Toronto: McGraw-Hill, 1971), 143.
210 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Attributions
Figure 5.2
Immigrants, Arabs (Online MIKAN no.3630050) by John Woodruff / Library and Archives Canada /
PA-020917 is in the public domain.

Table 5.1
Estimated Population of Canada, 1867-1920 (000s) by John Douglas Belshaw is used under a CC-BY 4.0 Inter-
national license.

Table 5.2
Immigrant Arrivals, 1867-1920 by John Douglas Belshaw is used under a CC-BY 4.0 International license.
5.4. The Clifford Sifton Years, 1896-1905

Figure 5.3 Doukhobor women pull a plough, breaking the prairie

soil for the first time at Thunder Hill Colony, MB, ca. 1899.

Among the most able and imaginative of Lauriers cabinet ministers was Clifford Sifton (1861-1929). Born in
southern Ontario, Sifton entered adulthood in Manitoba where he established himself as a lawyer, entrepreneur,
and politician. Under Laurier he was Minister of the Interior, which put him at the helm of Canadas evolving
immigration policy.

In the 30 years after the BNA Act was proclaimed the population of the West increased at a rate that was unmatched
in the history of British North America. From a few thousand around Red River and similar numbers across what
would become Alberta and Saskatchewan in 1905, the North-West Territories (that is, the Prairies beyond little
Manitoba) surpassed 56,000 by 1881. Ten years later, this had nearly doubled to 99,000. In 1896, therefore, Sifton
inherited a portfolio that was already doing well, though not as well as it might.

The Victorian Food Revolution

Mechanized farming, new crops, new transportation technologies that cut the time and distance between harvest
and market, and the need to feed burgeoning urban populations were together revolutionizing farming on a global
level. Over the course of the 18th and 19th centuries central Europe had become a complex patchwork quilt of eth-
nic, farming enclaves. Germanic settlers moved into the Ukraine, and minority religious sects often associated
with pacifism established farming communities with strong cooperative sensibilities. Some had reasonably
deep roots but much of the lands between the Baltic Sea and the Black Sea were farming frontiers in their own
right. Similarly, agricultural lands were opening in Argentina on the Pampas, in Australia, and across southern
Africa. In the United States three million families were drawn into the American West by the promise of home-
steads. This was a global phenomenon and as the Indigenous populations were being removed by the colonial
regimes settlers were being recruited into various farming colonies with an assortment of promises and assur-
ances. In short, the business of finding farmers was competitive.

Siftons timing was good. The American frontier as the United States historian Frederick Jackson Turner

211
212 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

announced in the 1890s was closed: free land in the United States was all but gone. Sifton replied with
a campaign to bill the Canadian Prairies, famously, as The Last Best West. Employing a variety of sales and
advertising strategies and gimmicks that were startlingly innovative, Sifton and his department changed the face
of Canada in the space of one decade.

Selecting Prairie Society

Sifton established a list of preferred sources for immigrants. This is interesting for a few reasons, which are worth
enumerating. First, the outcome of his preferential list can be seen even now in the ethno-linguistic and cultural
make-up of the Prairie West. Second, it reveals contemporary thinking about the nature of race and ethnicity.
Sifton, like most of his peers, believed that ethnicity signalled essentialized qualities: that is, all Italians were, in
their essence or fabric, the same. Stereotyping, then, was something he regarded as part of informed decision-
making, not a case of narrow-mindedness or bigotry. Third, the composition of the immigrant pool included peo-
ple whose ethnic differentness from Anglo-Protestants and Franco-Catholics (not to mention Aboriginal peoples)
were in some instances profound, and that very differentness created a perceived need to build institutions and
policies that would foster their assimilation. As Prairie settlers they might reasonably have been assimilated into
the bilingual and bi- or multicultural heritage of the Mtis; they might have been assimilated into a new, bicultural
French and English Canada. Steps were taken, however, to transform these new arrivals into anglophones. And
this would prove profoundly divisive among Central Canadians who were, predictably, not in agreement on the
privileging of Anglo-Protestantism over Franco-Catholicism.

So who did Sifton prefer? White Americans, mostly. People who had had experience homesteading and who spoke
English (and who were likely Protestants) were the principal group he hoped to recruit. Of course, Americans
brought with them the possibility of disloyalty, something which made Canadian politicians generally wary. But
even the Macdonald regime (more than a little America-phobic) had circulated recruitment materials in the United
States, mostly in the hope of finding Canadian emigrants who could be lured back home to the West. Almost
one million people arrived in Canada from the United States in the 14 years leading to the Great War, and many
of those immigrants were, in fact, returning Canadians. Many more were German and Scandinavian immigrants
to the United States who simply kept moving until they landed in the Canadian West.

Figure 5.4 African-Americans made their way to north-central

Alberta, like this group at Athabasca Landing.

African-Americans, among whose numbers there were many with homesteading experience, were desirous of
coming to Canada but Sifton regarded Africans and people of African descent dimly. He was inclined at first to
recruit from the British Isles but recognized quickly that mixed-farming on small-holdings in the United Kingdom
was a far cry from producing wheat on a quarter-section of land on the Prairies, and Sifton knew, too, that British
recruiters would trawl the under-employed urban populations first. He turned his attention to continental options.

German farmers had proven their skill in various settlement projects that had occurred since the 18th century. For
100 years and more, the German states had been sending out farmers to populate borderlands in places across
 5.4. THE CLIFFORD SIFTON YEARS, 1896-1905 213

the Austro-Hungarian Empire and as far east as Imperial Russia. Sifton thought highly of the Germans and the
Scandinavians. But the further south in Europe he turned, the less impressed he became. Italians and Greeks, in
particular, he thought of as worthless to the settlement process. Jews were also to be avoided, as were Arabs.

Eastern Europeans Ukrainians, Poles, and Russians fared better in Siftons eyes. In an oft-quoted statement,
the western booster described what he saw as the ideal immigrant:

When I speak of quality I have in mind something that is quite different from what is in the mind of the average writer
or speaker upon the question of immigration. I think that a stalwart peasant in a sheepskin coat, born to the soil, whose
1
forefathers have been farmers for ten generations, with a stout wife and a half-dozen children, is good quality.

Sifton made this statement in 1922, 17 years after resigning his cabinet post and looking back on his works in ret-
rospect. From 1896-1905, however, immigrants from Eastern Europe were something of an unknown commodity.
And, for a cabinet minister in a narrow-minded Protestant community, they were a bit of a gamble. The Eastern
Europeans arrival in bulk numbers, their enthusiasm for mutually-supportive block settlements, and their overall
record of success, however, converted Sifton to their value.

Figure 5.5 Siftons ideal immigrants. A family newly arrived

from Galicia, ca. 1911.

Sifton was likewise convinced that religious sects that had strong internal cohesion and familiarity with the kind
of farming that would be conducted in the West were highly desirable. These included Mormons from the United
States, Mennonites from Central and Eastern Europe, and pacifist Hutterites and Doukhobors from Russia. Eth-
nicity, experience, and the likelihood of community success thus became key principles of the recruitment process.

Against this list of preferences, Sifton was highly suspicious of urban and industrial workers. In an era where
modern was acquiring a cachet all its own and in which civic growth even that of Siftons beloved Winnipeg
was a principal measure of success, there is something very 18th century about Siftons 20th century vision.

Sifton the Salesman

Sifton recognized early on that simply putting up posters at shipping offices in Hamburg and Liverpool would not
draw the numbers he required. So in 1899 he established a network of recruiting agents in Europe under the aus-
pices of a shadow corporation called the North Atlantic Trading Company. Shipping agents in European ports
were paid to direct farm emigrants toward Canadian ports. This was a clandestine operation in part because the
European countries targeted were all trying to stop the bleeding off of their population to new settlement societies
like Canada, the United States, Argentina, and Australia. Siftons strategy paid off: in the space of a decade, the
Prairie population more than doubled to 211,649 by 1901 the greatest part of that growth taking place after the
Laurier government arrived in Ottawa in 1896.

Diversity was, as a consequence of these recruitment efforts, growing rapidly in the West and in some Atlantic

1. "Only Farmers Need Apply: Clifford Sifton, The Immigrants Canada Wants, Macleans Magazine, 1 April 1922: 16, 32-34.
 214 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

port towns. It was politically imperative that English Canadians be reassured that their culture was not at risk. To
that end, Sifton stepped up efforts to recruit from Britain in 1903. The results were significant: 1,200 arrived in
Canada in 1900 and 65,000 in 1905. This was not, however, a typically agrarian population. This Edwardian-era
wave was made up of professionals, merchants, urban labourers, mineworkers, and others whose conditions in
a rapidly growing and changing country were in some jeopardy. Canada was presented to them as Brit-friendly,
just like home, and an opportunity to enjoy real social mobility something that the entrenched class sys-
tem in Britain stifled at best and prevented at worst. It was this generation that repopulated the Okanagan Valley
and southwestern Alberta, with visions of becoming gentleman orchardists and ranchers. It was also this gen-
eration that supplied many of the early trade union leaders and members whose experience with Britains new-
born Labour Party would produce echoes across Canada and especially in British Columbia. On Vancouver Island,
British immigrants would cultivate two contrary myths of British-ness characterized by both an ersatz upper-class
Britophilia in Victoria and British-style labour militance in the coal mining towns of Nanaimo, Wellington, Lady-
smith, and Cumberland. Both of these movements overlay existing Island political and social traditions so deeply
that they effectively eclipsed them to the point that Britishness became part of the Vancouver Island brand.

Figure 5.6 Imperialism, steam-powered paddlewheelers, railways,

and telegram systems made it possible to transplant British and
Anglo-Celtic Canadian culture to the gentlemanly business of
orcharding in the Okanagan. Kelowna, 1909.

However much the British immigrants of the pre-Great War years played a role in reaffirming imperial connec-
tions and the primacy of Anglo-Protestantism, they were not always welcomed by the locals. Canadians were
often irritated by British sensibilities and signs appeared in shop windows across the country, No English Need
Apply. There was a sense, too, that many of the British immigrants were simply impoverished social detritus,
incapable of functioning in their own society let alone in Canada. Tens of thousands of children part of a
migration referred to as the Home Children were plucked from British slums and orphanages and placed into
apprentice-like situations on Canadian farms. Scandals and outrages plagued the Home Children project as news
leaked out from time to time of horrible physical abuse and neglect of the 8 to 10 year old immigrants. It was,
however, the failure of the Barr Colony project, an attempt to settle British farmers in a Prairie block, that drew
the greatest criticism of Siftons office and further confirmed the Canadian belief that British immigrants made
2
for poor farmers.

Figure 5.7 Some 8,000 boys passed through the St. Georges
Home in Ottawa as part of the Home Children migration.

2. Valerie Knowles, Strangers at Our Gates: Canadian Immigration and Immigration Policy, 1540-1997, revised ed. (Toronto: Dundurn Press,
1997), 70-6.
 5.4. THE CLIFFORD SIFTON YEARS, 1896-1905 215

Post-1905
Sifton resigned from the Laurier government early in 1905, seemingly at the top of his game. The recurrent issue
of sectarian, French-language schooling and the cultural agenda in the West was his last round-up. The North-West
Territories had enjoyed non-denominational schools under the territorial regulations of 1901. This was slated to
come to an end with the arrival of provincial status for Alberta and Saskatchewan and the extension of guarantees
of separate and state-funded schools for Catholics. Laurier, who cautiously promoted the ideal of dualism in the
West, would not give way and Sifton who preferred the vision of an Anglo-Protestant West resigned. Later,
Laurier found himself obliged to change course, but Sifton did not re-enter the cabinet.

In many respects, Sifton was not only an architect of Western Canada: he was an example of what it was becom-
ing. A relentless booster of Winnipeg and Brandon, he was an advocate of social reforms (his wife, Elizabeth Bur-
rows, led the Brandon Womens Christian Temperance Union), and a champion of non-denominational schools in
the West (often used as coded-language for anti-French or anti-Catholic education). The society he envisioned in
1896 was not one that all Canadians at the time embraced: drawn from different and diverse locales, peoples of
many languages and cultures would open the economic potential of the West and, thus, Canada. In return, they
would be Anglo-Canadianized and offered what Dominion officials immodestly regarded as a superior and more
humane cultural alternative to that of the United States. Although many factors independent of Sifton contributed
to what was to follow, the fact remains that many aspects of his vision were realized.

Key Points

The late 19th century saw a rapid expansion in global food production to feed industrializing com-
munities and nations. Canadas expansion into the West was part of this process.
Canada had to compete for immigrants and did so through strategies that targeted specific groups
and whole communities.
Clifford Siftons term as Minister of the Interior coincides with the largest waves of immigrants to
the West and thus gave shape to the population that arrived around the turn of the century.
Siftons preferences as regards immigrant groups were explicitly in favour of northern Europeans
over southern Europeans, Whites over non-Whites, and people with experience farming in prairie-
like conditions.
Concerns among British-Canadians that their culture might be under threat was met by new recruit-
ment of British immigrants in the early 20th century.

Attributions
Figure 5.3
Doukhobor women are shown breaking the prairie sod by pulling a plough themselves, Thunder Hill Colony,
Manitoba. c 1899 (Online MIKAN no.3193404) by Library and Archives Canada / C-000681 is in the public
domain.
216 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 5.4
Black Colony, Athabasca Landing, Alberta (Online MIKAN no.3193364) by Canada. Dept. of Interior / Library
and Archives Canada / PA-040745 is in the public domain.

Figure 5.5
Galician immigrants (Online MIKAN no.3193424) by William James Topley / Library and Archives Canada /
PA-010401 is in the public domain.

Figure 5.6
Pear blossoms in Mr Stirlings orchard, Kelowna, British Columbia (HS85-10-21790) by the British Library is
in the public domain.

Figure 5.7
Immigrant Boys for the St. Georges Home, Hintonburg (Online MIKAN no.3624193) by Library and Archives
Canada / PA-020907 is in the public domain.
 5.5 The Promised Land

Figure 5.8 A photo of John Lanquist, Gino Pakkala, and Harold

Malm Sr. in Sointula, B.C.

Before the Industrial Revolution, working the land was what most people did, in one way or another. And, since it
was the norm, it was nothing special.

Then cities took off in earnest, and the cities became not merely bigger versions of their former selves but indus-
trial hives: crowded, dirty, dangerous, unhealthy, and exploitative, and subject to violent economic and political
upheavals. Under these circumstances, the land acquired a connotation of relative purity; held up against the cities,
the countryside positively glowed with wholesome and godly virtues. Avoiding city life and the prospect of work-
ing for someone else became the objective of many Canadians and immigrants. Owning ones own land and being
ones own boss was highly desirable and it was seen, too, as having a special virtue.

God Made the Country, Man Made the Town

In a 2007 collection of essays on the settlement of the West, several scholars pursue the theme of the promised
land. The suffragette, writer, and moralist Nellie McClung saw the West as a place where conditions were good
for the raising of Christian-spirited, temperate (that is, free of liquor), and empowered generations although
1
she experienced disillusion in every regard by the 1920s and 1930s. The leading Social Gospeller of his day (and
eventually the founding leader of the Cooperative Commonwealth Federation), J. S. Woodsworth, believed that
the kingdom of God could be established on Earth and specifically that the fertile soil of the Canadian prairies
2
nurtured the right conditions for the growth of Gods heavenly kingdom on earth the Promised Land. In this
regard, Woodsworth wasnt too far out of step with Louis Riels 1885 millenarian vision of the West as a nurturing
3
refuge for an assortment of religious creeds. This became something of a reality for the Mennonite and Hutterite

1. Randi Warne, Land of the Second Chance: Nellie McClungs Vision of the Prairie West as Promised Land, The Prairie West as Promised
Land, eds. R. Douglas Francis and Chris Kitzan (Calgary: University of Calgary Press, 2007): 217-219.
2. R. Douglas Francis, The Kingdom of God on the Prairies: J. S. Woodsworths Vision of the Prairie West as Promised Land, The Prairie
West as Promised Land, eds. R. Douglas Francis and Chris Kitzan (Calgary: University of Calgary Press, 2007): 225.
3. Thomas Flanagan, Louis David Riel: Prophet of the New World, revised ed. (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1996), 101.

217
 218 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

colonies that erupted on the Prairies and in pockets in southern Ontario and in the Fraser Valley. A similar, though
more checkered, experience was shared by the Doukhobors.

Parallels could be drawn, too, with West Coast utopian communities. These appeared in several locations, notably
at Ruskin and, somewhat more successfully, at Sointula on Malcolm Island. While these two experiments had
ethnic and working-class roots, there were others that tapped into upper-class aspirations, the best example of
which is Walhachin, west of Kamloops, where well-to-do English immigrants attempted to rebuild a throwback
village lifestyle in 1909, one that included a cricket oval, fox hunts, and a smart hotel which boasted a dress code.
Historian Patrick Dunae has written on the widespread cultural, economic, and political impact of this cohort of
gentlemen emigrants and remittance men second or third sons of money who were unlikely to inherit much
4
if they stayed at home in Britain. There were strong anti-materialist threads in all of these enterprises, as there
was in individual homesteading. These were themes that would reappear sporadically in the 20th century in the
context of back-to-the-land movements, especially in the 1960s and early 1970s.

Figure 5.9 The hotel in Walhachin, BC, an upper-class settlement

surrounded by sagebrush, rattlesnakes, and desert.

Key Points

Agricultural settlements at the beginning of the 20th century were often associated with virtues and
values that were regarded by some as superior to life in the cities.

Attributions
Figure 5.8
View of John Lanquist, Gino Pakkala and Harold Malm Sr. in Sointula, B.C by UBC Library is in the public
domain. This image is available from the UBC Library, Fishermen Publishing Society under the digital identi-
fier BC_1532_1373_9.

Figure 5.9
Walhachin Hotel by CindyBo is in the public domain.

4. Patrick Dunae, Gentlemen Emigrants: From the British Public Schools to the Canadian Frontier (Vancouver: Douglas & McIntyre, 1981).
 5.6 The Ukrainian Westerners

Of the Prairie immigrants, few were so visible numerically as the Ukrainians. Outwardly a homogeneous group,
the Ukrainian experience as immigrants was defined far more by their internal divisions. As part of the Empire
of Austria-Hungary, they came from one of the most ethnically and denominationally diverse nations on Earth.
The Catholicism of Polish-Ukrainians contrasted sharply with the Orthodox Christianity of Ukrainians, who had
stronger connections to Russia. Differences of dialect were important too, but the centrality of religion to the peas-
ant life in Galicia produced deep rifts between the immigrant communities when they arrived in Canada.

Canadian administrators were frustrated by these divisions. They were obliged to keep immigrants who
came from Bukovyna (now in northern Romania and southwestern Ukraine) separate from those originating in
Halychnya (stretching west from Bukovyna to southeastern Poland), both on the land and even in the immigration
sheds. The immigrants desire was to settle in blocks, which Ottawa preferred. As was the case with Mennonites
and Doukhobors, Ukrainian block settlement improved the chances of economic and agricultural success, and the
block settlements tended to fill up with chain migration. Among the Ukrainians, however, there was a definite
preference to settle in either Bukovynan or Halychnyi blocks, regardless of the quality of the land. In 1898 one
land commissioner despaired to the deputy minister,

They are apparently an obstreperous, obstinate, rebellious lot. I am just sick of these people. They are worse than cattle
to handle. You cannot get them, by persuasion or argument, to go to a new colony except by force. They all want to go
1
where the others have gone.

What the land commissioner disliked were the very things that leant strength to the newcomer population: cultural
integrity, mutual support, and the ability to fabricate an expatriate community based around familiar institutions
and practices. Distinctive dialects survived; churches were sustained; and agricultural techniques refined in the
Steppe and forests of Eastern Europe were honed further to suit conditions on the Prairies. Their ability to succeed
in these respects helps to explain the scale of Ukrainian settlement; by 1914 there were 170,000 immigrants from
2
Galicia in the West. The strategies that made Ukrainian and other block settlements viable were antithetical to the
Anglo-Celtic Canadian ideals of individualism and the family as the principal independent productive unit; they
were also at odds with various legal practices associated with property ownership and liability, as well as repre-
senting a serious challenge to cultural assimilation. One study has argued that:

1. W. F. McCreary, Commissioner of Immigration, Winnipeg, to J. A. Smart, Deputy Minister of the Interior, Ottawa, 14 May 1897, RG 76, vol. 144, file
34215, pt.1, Public Archives of Canada, quoted in John C. Lehr, Kinship and Society in the Ukrainian Pioneer Settlement of the Canadian West, People,
Places, Patterns, Processes: Geographical Perspectives on the Canadian Past, ed. Graeme Wynn (Toronto: Copp Clark Pitman, 1990): 141-2.
2. See John C. Lehr, Kinship and Society in the Ukrainian Pioneer Settlement of the Canadian West, People, Places, Patterns, Processes:
Geographical Perspectives on the Canadian Past, ed. Graeme Wynn (Toronto: Copp Clark Pitman, 1990): 139-60.

219
 220 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

The emergence of ethnic communities played a useful role in helping their members to adjust from one linguistic envi-
ronment to another, and sometimes from a rural way of living to an urban one. However, in some cases, the ethnic com-
3
munity acted as a brake on the individual achievement and social mobility of its members.

Although Canadian officials might have in mind a variety of schemes for achieving immigrant assimilation, con-
texts varied sharply across the West and in urban centres. The question of adaptation was, more often than not,
one of immigrant strategy rather than host-nation policy.

Key Points

Immigrants from Ukraine included people with very different and sometimes mutually hostile
backgrounds.
Established Canadians of British or French ancestry tended to view the Ukrainians as a homoge-
neous group.
Building communities around block settlements enabled the survival of pre-emigration values and
cultural features while sometimes dampening the need or ability to adapt to the Canadian host cul-
ture.

3. Donald H. Avery, Reluctant Hosts: Canadas Response to Immigrant Workers, 1896-1994 (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1995), 12.
 5.7 Culture and Adaptation

There is, writes the historical sociologist Gillian Crease, no common standard immigrant experience in
1
Canada. The gradations of adaptability, acceptance, material success, biological well-being, and cultural fulfill-
ment are severe. Male immigrants who arrived in cities intent on working in the expanding industrial economy of
the post-1945 period generally found far more opportunities to become integrated, to be immersed in the language
of the locals, and to develop networks of friends and colleagues who might in some measure substitute
for the loss of community from abroad, than did female immigrants. It was not unusual in these years to find
immigrant households (particularly in suburban Canada) in which the father/patriarch spoke at least passable
sometimes heavily inflected English, the children spoke with the flattest Canadian accents and were functional
in one or more ancestral language, while the stay-at-home mother/matriarch remained effectively unilingual. The
immigrant experience was thus gendered and also impacted by age. Some immigrant groups struggled more than
others to adapt.

Take, for example, immigrants from the British Isles. Like all other newcomers they gravitated toward neighbour-
hoods in which recognizable institutions and languages could be found. That these were not considered ethnic
enclaves speaks to the position of British culture in English-Canada as the reference or cultural context group.
To be sure, there were class lines that structured the experience of British immigrants: In Vancouver the work-
ing-class newcomers planted themselves in East and South Vancouver where housing was affordable and where
they had close access to the docks and industries where so many of them found employment; middle-class British
immigrants settled in Kerrisdale and Dunbar, effectively ghettos of more plummy English and Scots accents.
The landscape of denominationalism was often the clearest sign of these divisions and concentrations: well-to-
do High Anglican and Presbyterian congregations to the west, Methodist, Baptist, and after 1925 United
Church chapels to the east. Distinctions could be seen, too, in the use of recreational space: cricket ovals and
rugby grounds to the west; soccer pitches (and baseball diamonds, too) to the east. In the struggle to determine
how best to use the newly-created Stanley Park at the turn of the century, as historian Robert A. J. McDonald has
shown, English working-class requests for a large stadium and an amusement park (all accessed by transit of some
2
kind) were pushed aside in favour of a cricket oval, a yacht club, and contemplative gardens.

For White, English-speaking immigrants from Britain or the United States, the acculturation process involved

1. Gillian Crease, The New African Diaspora in Vancouver: Immigration, Exclusion, and Belonging (Toronto: University of Toronto Press,
2011), 3.
2. Robert A. J. McDonald, "'Holy Retreat' or 'Practical Breathing Spot'? Class Perceptions of Vancouver's Stanley Park," Canadian Historical
Review 45, 2 (1984): 17-53.

221
 222 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

some challenges but comparatively few. In the West, as historical geographer John Lehr has argued, Anglophones
were,

settling a territory that, in many important respects, maintained the basic societal framework of their points of origin.
They encountered familiar elements of law and administration; the creed of the ruling majority was Protestant; and Eng-
3
lish was the de jure, if not the de facto, language of all in the newly settled west.

This was true of all parts of Canada outside of Quebec (less Montreal and the Eastern Townships), not just the set-
tler West. Anglophone settlers constituted a replenishing of the context group, the mainstream civilization whose
values and expectations were so dominant as to be invisible. Newcomers from England might complain that they
had trouble overcoming the barrier of accents Canadians strained to pierce their regional tones and the English
struggled to understand Canadians but as one English immigrant in the post-1945 period described the process,

For the first week I found people incomprehensible. We were talking the same language, and I couldnt understand what
4
they were saying. It took about a week to get into the rhythm of the language. So that was a bit of a shock.

A whole week to break the codes of language, idiom, and tone. For non-English speaking immigrants these could
take years to crack. For them, the challenges of adaptation were much greater.

Figure 5.10 Ukrainian students of English at the School for

Immigrants, Vegreville, AB, 1916.

Some had a greater incentive to adapt than others. Germans, for example, constituted significant numbers in the
Canadian population from the 1890s on, but the two World Wars obliged the German Canadians to develop strate-
gies to reduce their differentness. One approach was to simply keep a low profile. In 1971 the census showed
that Vancouver better known for the large size of its Asian community than for its German diaspora was
7% Chinese but 8% German. The German language was spoken in more Canadian homes in 1961 and 1971 than
any language other than English and French. Finding a German enclave, however, was next to impossible and
the institutions that signalled an ethnic presence church, community hall, specialty stores were often very
discrete.

In sharp contrast, Eastern Europeans and South Asians who arrived in large groups were often able to establish
whole communities that sustained older cultural practices and strategies of mutual support (like language, shared
parenting, and religion). Indeed, the church, temple, synagogue, or gurdwara often did much more than offer a
spiritual anchor to newcomers in urban and rural areas: in the case of the gurdwara, it served as a political forum
and a site of strategizing to influence policy-makers. A foreign-language press sprang up in many centres which
both served the immigrant community and mitigated the need to assimilate into the mainstream. In particularly
stark cases, like that of the Chinese community in British Columbia, ghettoization ensured that all the services
needed by the community could be found within a few city blocks, the ancestral language was preserved, educa-
tional institutions arose that passed the culture on to new generations, churches and temples could be built and
filled, and the need to venture out into the non-ethnic world was reduced. These institutions were social and eco-

3. John C. Lehr, Kinship and Society in the Ukrainian Pioneer Settlement of the Canadian West, People, Places, Patterns, Processes: Geographical Perspec-
tives on the Canadian Past, ed. Graeme Wynn (Toronto: Copp Clark Pitman, 1990): 140.
4. Marilyn Barber and Murray Watson, Invisible Immigrants: The English in Canada since 1945 (Winnipeg: University of Manitoba Press, 2015), 103.
 5.7 CULTURE AND ADAPTATION 223

nomic hubs, capable of facilitating individual and/or group entry into the mainstream society and economy or
preserving in the face of assaults the values and relationships that the immigrant group most treasured.

This remarkable and rich accomplishment, of course, invited further resentment of outsiders who used the term
clannish to describe any ethnic enclave. Indeed, assaults from the Canadian host community would come in
many forms.

Key Points

Adapting to the host society and its expectations was a contextual, community, and personal experi-
ence and not a singular process.
Even British immigrants developed strategies and institutions to enable their acceptance into the
mainstream society.

Attributions
Figure 5.10
Students of English, School for immigrants, Vegreville, Alberta (Online MIKAN no.3368064) by George E.
Dragan / Library and Archives Canada / PA-088507 is in the public domain.
5.8 Race, Ethnicity, and Immigration

Canadas immigration boom was made possible and made necessary, simultaneously, by the spread of the indus-
trial economy and mechanized transportation. The late 19th century delivered the wherewithal to move large num-
bers of people faster, further, and in far greater safety than ever before; there was also a rising demand for grain
to feed factory towns and coal to feed industrys furnaces. These economic and technological developments hap-
pened to come along at the very moment that racism became a much more powerful way of looking at the world.
To say that the Canadian experience included elements of racism is a little like saying that the Canadian Pacific
Railway involved a little steel.

Racism is not merely a suite of regrettable or embarrassing attitudes expressed by a reliably odious share of the
population at large. Racism constitutes a force in the modern world, a near- or crypto-ideological position that
was broadly accepted in mainstream society as commonsensical. If one believed as a great many did that
different races were inherently and unchangeably different from one another in terms of intelligence, morality,
work ethic, personality, and health (among other qualities), and if one also believed that the mixing of races in a
society or in a marriage would inevitably have the effect of diluting the strength of superior races and weakening
the community overall, then policies to control for these factors were a logical consequence. The belief that race
was more than a social construct obliged 19th and 20th century policy makers to erect barriers to the arrival and/or
successful establishment of people belonging to inferior races. Racial stereotyping advanced from caricatures
of 19th century Irish and Chinese immigrants to enclose Japanese and Indian arrivals, Eastern and Mediterranean
Europeans, Arabs, Jews, and African-Americans. Aboriginal peoples were subject to similar discrimination and
that is considered in Section 11.1. Racist policies also evolved.

Cultural Demography
Through to 1914 the ethnic shape of the older parts of the country was, with a few pockets of exceptions, much as
it had been 50 years earlier. White Anglo-Celtic Protestants dominated Ontario and the Eastern Townships of Que-
bec; while they were the clear majority, a significant Franco-Catholic population and concentrations of African-
Canadians lived in the Maritimes. Quebec, of course, was overwhelmingly French and Catholic, and Quebec City
especially so.

Montreal, however, was a major port of entry, and many who stepped off the ships did not proceed much further
inland. Italian, Jewish, and Polish immigrants could be found in significant numbers and concentrated in specific
neighbourhoods in Montreal, which was principally an English-speaking city with a large French minority. Hali-
fax was another entry point, and it acquired diversity in much the same way. The same immigrant groups had sig-

224
 5.8 RACE, ETHNICITY, AND IMMIGRATION 225

nificant impacts on the largest industrial towns of Ontario (specifically Toronto and Hamilton) not least because
those cities were magnets of employment and opportunity.

Figure 5.11 The company town of Powell River contained

greater diversity among its immigrant community than most
older central Canadian and Maritime communities.

The pattern from the Maritimes through Central Canada is, however, uneven. Some smaller centres Sydney,
NS, Sault Ste. Marie, and Fort William (aka: Thunder Bay) for example attracted and retained ethnic com-
munities while much larger cities contained remarkably little diversity. Sydney became a hub of ethnic variety
for the same reason some small towns in the West like Cumberland and Powell River in BC, and Trail and
Drumheller in AB were diverse. That is, they were all part of the emergent industrial world that globalized a
particular kind of labour market. People who could work in foundries, mines, mills, and on roads and rails were
circulating around the planet through increasingly sophisticated systems of recruitment, transportation, settlement,
1
and resettlement.

The West as a whole was a mosaic of immigrants from Eastern and Northern Europe. Before the War, this was
instantly visible in the city, town, and Prairie skylines as onion-shaped domes and Eastern Orthodox crosses
topped centres of worship from the Ontario-Manitoba border to the Rockies. While cities like Winnipeg, Regina,
Calgary, and Edmonton announced their British loyalty as loudly as any other centre, they were also sites of accul-
turation and assimilation of non-British newcomers and the newcomers parallel struggle to retain pre-emigration
cultural elements.

Further west, in British Columbia, diversity was visible in communities that mixed Euro-Canadians with immi-
grants from both Europe and Asia. The British Columbian population before the Great War was increasingly
Canadian-born (even BC-born) and the share of Chinese residents was actually falling from one-in-five to one-
in-twenty between 1881-1921. Immigrants from Japan and the Punjab lifted the Asian numbers a little prior to the
War. Each of these Asian communities employed different economic and social strategies in the face of system-
atized discrimination. Unlike virtually all other immigrant groups, Asians were repeatedly described as unassimi-
lable; barriers to their integration thus created a self-fulfilling prophecy of Asian separateness.

The Welcome Mat

Canadians often did little to smooth the path of newcomers. Organized labour and even native farm labourers
regarded most immigrants as part of a plot to reduce workers living standards by creating a split labour market.
Anglo-Canadian homesteaders, too, demonstrated their own biases in the hiring of seasonal workers and tended
to favour Canadian, British, American, and even German labour over Eastern Europeans. Some Prairie newcom-
ers were thus frustrated in their efforts to earn enough money to meet the costs of setting up a homestead. Many

1. John Zucchi, A History of Ethnic Enclaves in Canada (Ottawa: Canadian Historical Association, 2007), 4-5.
 226 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

turned, instead, to public works like road building and railway construction. Some and this was true particu-
larly of Slavic and Scandinavian immigrants acquired a poor reputation with the railway companies precisely
because they had achieved some success in farming. They made their farms a priority and framed their wage
2
labour around the rhythms of planting and harvesting. This is worth underlining: A great many rural immigrants
were, nonetheless, industrial immigrants.

Nowhere was this more visible than in the mining towns of the West. In Alberta, coal mining workforces typically
ran to more than 14% and as high as 25.5% Italian. Slavics (an all-purpose category that captures Russians and
immigrants from the Baltic and Balkan nations) were even more numerous, constituting as much as 36% of the
mining workforce in some districts. The same was true in British Columbia, where British miners were a sig-
nificant factor, as were Finns, Chinese, Italians, and Americans. Employers were happy to have minority immi-
grants, who would work for less than the Anglo-Canadian and British miners, sometimes for a fraction of their
pay. The Western Federation of Miners complained in the Sandon Paystreak newspaper that they were being
pushed to the brink in the Kootenays by employers who were,

importing cheap foreigners from the Minnesota iron ranges to displace union miners [some employers] have it fig-
ured out that if they can run in Dagoes [Italians] at the rate of about two a day they will soon have the union locoed
if [they] can get enuf [sic] of them in, wages can be cut to a whisper and Rossland mapped as a colony of Italy. Already
3
about 35% of the Rossland pay-roll is [Italian].

The Paystreaks screed is not exceptional. The principal instrument for transmitting ideas of racially-inherent
physical, character, and moral flaws was the newspaper press. Reporting on a devastating local fire in 1908,
the Fernie Free Press assigned to the diverse community that was battling the blaze the usual (and purportedly
immutable) stereotypes: measured against the serene indifference to danger of the Anglo-Saxons there was the
Italian, with his excitable nature and glib tongue, the Oriental, with his inherent dread of danger, and his equally
4
great regard for personal safety, [and] the stoic Slavonian [sic]. The pulpit also played a role in this as was
seen very clearly in the rise of eugenics (see Section 7.8). There were, too, nativist responses from immigrants
(largely British or American) and the grown children of immigrants (providing they were White) that worked to
(a) denigrate the outsider, and (b) advance the claims of the nativist to inclusion in the mainstream. This can be
seen in the hostility shown toward African-Americans on the Prairies in the 1920s and 1930s by Central Euro-
peans, whose families had themselves arrived hardly a generation earlier.

Racism thus became a bar over which some populations would attempt with mixed results to hurdle. Others,
usually by dint of skin colour or religion, could not.

African-Americans
There are many immigrant populations in Canada who faced on arrival a dense thicket of racist attitudes.
The experience of African-Americans is illuminating in this respect. Their numbers were not significant until
about 1907, at which time conditions in the southern and central states deteriorated and word of opportunities
on the Canadian prairies reached African-Americans struggling under Jim Crow Laws. Thirteen hundred

2. Donald H. Avery, Reluctant Hosts: Canadas Response to Immigrant Workers, 1896-1994 (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1995), 29-30.
3. Quoted in Jeremy Mouat, Roaring Days: Rosslands Mines and the History of British Columbia (Vancouver: University of British C0lumbia Press, 1995),
96-7.
4. Quoted in Leslie A. Robertson, Imagining Difference: Legend, Curse, and Spectacle in a Canadian Mining Town (Vancouver: University of
British Columbia Press, 2005), 57.
 5.8 RACE, ETHNICITY, AND IMMIGRATION 227

reached Saskatchewan and Alberta in the years that followed. The governments response was necessarily crafty
because Ottawa feared stirring up diplomatic anger in Washington. As one study describes the tactics deployed,

Agents were sent into the South to discourage black migrants; medical, character, and financial examinations were rigor-
ously applied at border points, with rewards for officials who disqualified blacks; American railways were influenced to
5
deny blacks passage to Canada.

Liberals and Conservatives alike pursued these strategies to stem the flow of African-American immigration. It
was largely successful.

Figure 5.12 A Chinese workcamp along the CPR line, Kamloops,

1886.

Chinese Communities
The post-Confederation Chinese unlike their Cariboo gold rush predecessors were largely drafted in to build
the CPR between tidewater and the Rocky Mountains. Thereafter, some found work in the Vancouver Island coal
mines but principally they settled in the cities and towns, especially along the CPR mainline. These enclaves var-
ied tremendously in size but they hosted a familiar variety of services and institutions. Populated overwhelmingly
by males (single or, if married, living there without their wives who were still in China), Chinatowns provided
immigrants with employment in restaurants, laundries, and grocery outlets that served both the Chinese and the
non-Chinese populations. Buddhist temples and clan halls (or tongs) provided cultural anchors while the Chinese
Benevolent Association provided some degree of political coordination in what was a largely hostile, anti-Chi-
nese environment. Chinese emigration like most Asian out-migration in these years was stimulated by agri-
cultural crises at home (connected, in China, to drought) and political instability. Those pushes were paired with
the prospect of making enough money in British Columbia (aka: Gum Shan) to rescue or advance family-owned
farming operations in, mainly, Guangdong. A strong entrepreneurial culture was thus emblematic of the commu-
nity and instruments for making capital available to members of the Chinese enclave including the hui were
6
well developed. Living conditions, however, were often very poor: The elements that defined the Chinese experi-
ence across Canada and distinguished it from that of European settlers included wages that were a fraction of what
was earned by adult White males, overcrowded living conditions in Chinatowns, and the almost total absence of
family comforts. Although Chinese market farms in suburban areas became an early and important source of food
in West Coast Canadian cities, few Chinese were able to become farmers nor were they able to escape the urban
neighbourhoods into which they were cast. In large urban areas and even in smaller resource-extraction towns,
Chinese immigrants could be found working in the homes of others as cooks and houseboys.

5. James W. St. G. Walker, Racial Discrimination In Canada: The Black Experience (Ottawa: The Canadian Historical Association, Historical Booklet No. 41,
1985), 14-15.
6. Paul Yee, Business Devices from Two Worlds: The Chinese in Early Vancouver, BC Studies, 62 (Summer 1984): 44-67.
 228 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 5.13 BC Premier Amor de Cosmos

pictured evicting a Chinese immigrant, 1879.
The cartoonist, J. Weston, uses caricatures but
his blade has two edges: The Chinese
immigrants refusal to assimilate means, to
de Cosmos, an unwillingness to drink
whiskey, and talk politics and vote like us.

Anti-Chinese Policies
Probably no immigrant group has been as heavily managed as the Chinese. Sought out as cheap contract labour,
they were recruited to meet finite economic and infrastructural goals. While some Chinese arrivals saw them-
selves as sojourners temporary immigrants who would return to their country of origin once theyd amassed
some money many more were in for the long haul. This was not part of Ottawas plan and so steps were taken
to limit immigration and thus encourage return migration.

The Head Tax was the main instrument used by Ottawa to regulate Chinese arrivals down to 1923. Some 81,000
people found the wherewithal to pay this fee before it was abolished, even though it rose from $50 in 1885 to $500
in 1903. In this respect, the Head Tax initiative was a failed attempt to stop Chinese immigration. It was, however,
a money-maker: It is reckoned that the Head Tax pulled in $22 million for Ottawa, which equates to more than
$300 million in 2015 dollars. Not everyone in the Euro-Canadian community supported the Head Tax, though for
reasons that we might now consider discomfiting. A group of Euro-Canadian women argued that reducing the
Head Tax would attract more immigrants, some of whom could be employed as houseboys and cooks. The Lib-
Lab Member of the BC legislature, Ralph Smith, supported this idea and one local newspaper chided him that he
was worried that his gallant wife should have to roast her comely face over the kitchen fire every day because
7
the Chinese Head Tax makes it impossible for him to get a Chinese cook. Working Mothers and the Child Care
Dilemma: A History of British Columbia's Social Policy (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2015),
30. The rate of Chinese immigration varied because of the tax and global events and, like much human movement
during World War I, numbers fell. After the war, immigration resumed. By this time, however, there was grow-
ing fear among the White community of the opium trade and allegations that young Euro-Canadian women were
being lured into the sex trade, what was called at the time White slavery. Emily Murphy a leading figure
in first wave feminism, the suffrage movement, and counted among the Famous Five wrote a series of highly
popular pieces on the drug trade and its connections with Chinatown. The Black Candle (as it appeared in book
form) was one of several diatribes against the Chinese community, one that catalyzed a revision of immigration
legislation.

The 1923 Chinese Immigration Act terminated legal Chinese immigration and remained on the books until 1947.
This complete ban on arrivals from a specified country was uniquely and exclusively applied to the Chinese.
Prejudice might stand in the way of other groups but no others were treated this way in law. What immigration

7. Quoted in Lisa Pasolli,

 5.8 RACE, ETHNICITY, AND IMMIGRATION 229

occurred between 1923-1947 was illegal and much of it involved reuniting spouses and family members. The
1923 Act, introduced on the 1st of July and thus coinciding with Dominion Day, was commemorated in the Chi-
nese community as Humiliation Day in the years that followed. (For more on this topic, see Section 5.12.)

Limits on immigration is one thing; limits on immigrants is another. Chinese populations were contained (some-
times by choice but usually by civic regulations) to small urban areas Chinatowns. They were forbidden, in
Vancouver, from purchasing homes and opening stores outside of a few blocks of the city core. Like members of
some other ethnic/racial/visible groups, they were also forbidden for years from attending post-secondary insti-
tutions and specifically from pursuing degrees through the University of British Columbia School of Pharmacy,
a restriction that echoed Sinophobic associations between the Chinese community and drug trafficking. Many of
these constraints would survive into the 1970s and early 1980s.

Anti-Semitism
Parallels can be drawn with the Jewish community. By 1914 there were reckoned to be 100,000 Jewish-Canadians,
roughly 75,000 of whom could be found in Montreal and Toronto. Not all Jewish immigrants went to cities and
towns, and there were Jewish farm colonies to be found in Saskatchewan. Enclaves ghettos without walls
could be found in Montreal and Winnipegs North End in particular, although they were less visible in the other
major cities. Vancouvers second mayor, David Oppenheimer, was Jewish and instrumental in founding the citys
first synagogue in the heart of the East End. The population that gravitated to that neighbourhood dispersed, how-
ever, as newer and poorer immigrants intruded and as the Jewish community became more prosperous. A new
spiritual and educational hub appeared on the south side, but it was never an enclave in the truest sense. In those
cities where the Jewish population was more concentrated, there was inevitably a higher degree of visibility. In
largely Catholic Montreal this drew anti-Semitic attacks, especially in the 1930s with the rise internationally of
rabidly anti-Semitic political movements.

The Jewish diaspora had more experience of minority status than any other immigrant group in Canada. Centuries
of ghettoization in Europe along with religious and legislative oppression had strengthened the communitys
instinct to erect institutions of mutual support, social welfare, and education. In Canada this meant that a desig-
nated burial ground was the first objective, followed by a synagogue, and related institutions for women, men,
and children. The Zionist movement also spilled out of Europe and into Canadian enclaves. In 1919 the pro-Zion
Canadian Jewish Congress was established and acted as a voice for the community as a whole. This did nothing,
however, to dampen Ottawas hostility toward Jewish immigration in the 1930s. Fearful of anti-Semitic violence
in Germany, Austria, and, indeed, throughout Central and Western Europe, many Jewish families hoped to find
sanctuary in Canada. Ottawa responded by holding the door firmly shut. Through to 1939 Canada accepted fewer
8
Jewish refugees as a proportion of total population than any other nation in the West.

Early Japanese Immigration

The Japanese community began arriving in Canada in the 1890s. Like the Chinese, they participated in the coal
mining frontier on Vancouver Island and were drawn to the cities. In Vancouver, Chinatown and the Japanese
enclave were only two city blocks apart. One important distinction, however, was the important role that Japanese

8. Still the definitive work on this question is Irving Abella and Harold Troper, None is Too Many: Canada and the Jews of Europe, 1933-1948
(Toronto: Lester & Orpen Dennys, 1983).
 230 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

immigrants played in the fishing industry, principally as owners and operators of fishing vessels. While Chinese
men and Aboriginal women laboured in the late 19th and early 20th century canneries, much of the fishing fleet
depended on Japanese captains and crews.

Figure 5.14 Vancouvers anti-Asian riot of

1907 resulted in extensive damage in the
Chinese and Japanese quarters. W. L.
Mackenzie King (to whom this photo is
credited) was sent by Laurier to investigate;
34 years later King would oversee
Japantowns depopulation.

Like the Chinese, Japanese immigrants faced discrimination when it came to immigrant recruitment and host com-
munity hospitality. Public opinion among the non-Asian population was against them, as was demonstrated in a
1907 window-smashing and head-bashing riot led by the Asiatic Exclusion League (in which organized labour
played a key role) that swept through the Chinese and Japanese quarters. This followed on the arrival of more
than 8,000 Japanese newcomers earlier in the same year and the prospect of an Indian/Sikh migration north from
Washington State. Heightened pressure from the non-Asian community caused the Canadian government to nego-
tiate with Japan a Gentlemens Agreement (aka: the Lemieux-Hayashi Agreement) in 1908. This pact restricted
the number of people leaving Japan for Canada. It capped the number of men who could travel to Canada, but
it left open the possibility of female migration across the Pacific by not restricting the emigration of wives. The
phenomenon of picture brides developed from there and in the decades that followed, significant numbers of
women relocated from Meiji Japan to Canada where they met, for the first time, their husbands. The picture brides
endured lives with men who were hitherto strangers, many of them living in small fishing or other resource-
extraction communities on the northwest coast; despite powerful Meiji traditions of female submissiveness, some
9
women sought their own path and abandoned prescribed gender roles. As for the host community, Euro-Canadi-
ans were mostly hostile to the prospect of Japanese-Canadian family formation and the likelihood of growth from
natural increase. What is more, Japanese success in the fisheries was so remarkable that new anti-Japanese restric-
tions on commercial fishing licenses were introduced in the 1920s. The 1923 Immigration Act extended new con-
straints to human movement between Japan and Canada to such an extent that Japanese migration was effectively
as limited as that of the Chinese. The wartime and post-War experience of the Japanese-Canadian community is
explored in Sections 5.11 and 6.17.

Immigration from the Indian Subcontinent

The third group to arrive from Asia came mainly from the Punjab. The Sikh migration is another in which males
vastly outnumbered females. In each of these cases China, Japan, India Britains relationship with the source
country is important. Of the three, only India was a British colony and that factored into the treatment meted out

9. Midge Ayukawa, "Good Wives and Wise Mothers: Japanese Picture Brides in Early Twentieth Century British Columbia," BC Stud-
ies, nos.105-106 (Spring/Summer 1995): 103-118.
 5.8 RACE, ETHNICITY, AND IMMIGRATION 231

to potential and eventual immigrants. It also informed the Indian communitys strategies and tactics when it came
time to fight for rights or survival.

Figure 5. 15 Immigrants from India on board the Komagata

Maru. The groups leader, Gurdit Singh, wears a light-coloured
suit.

Neither a Head Tax nor a Gentlemens Agreement were possible in the case of India, so the method used to block
migration was the continuous voyage requirement of the amended Immigration Act of 1908. Immigrants would
be allowed from India (or Japan) into Canada if they could demonstrate that their vessel had travelled directly
to a Canadian port without putting into another foreign harbour along the way. Given the distances involved and
the ships of the time, this was effectively a barrier to Indian immigration. Sikh nationalists like Gurdit Singh (a
merchant based in Singapore) accepted this challenge, chartered a vessel the Japanese Komagata Maru and,
in 1914, attempted to bring nearly 400 potential immigrants to Vancouver. The ship was kept in harbour for two
months. The passengers seized control of the ship from its Japanese crew and waited as lawyers for the Crown
argued that the immigrants had departed from Hong Kong, not India, and so were in breach of the continuous
voyage requirement.

The Komagata Maru incident is complex in that it draws together many different threads. Some of the parties
involved were anti-British and sought Indian independence; the British, for their part, were anxious about divisive
Indian politics just as tensions with Germany were becoming greater; Singh in concert with Indo-Canadians
wanted to challenge the continuous voyage requirement just as much as he wanted the immigrants to succeed
in reaching Canada; the British were as interested in putting down anti-colonial upstarts as they were in blocking
immigration to Canada. Euro-Canadians, for their part, demonstrated little sympathy for the passenger/migrants
10
and seemingly held fast to their desire for a White Canada Forever. The Komagata Maru was driven from
Vancouver harbour by the courts. Its passengers returned to India only to face jail and death at the hands of the
British authorities.

Figure 5.16 Cyclone Taylor, former hockey

player and no. 3 immigration officer in
Vancouver in the Komagata Maru incident.

Anxieties about the Indian population before the war were rooted in the White communitys racist and xenophobic
perspective on the world. Even so, it is in some respects a challenge to understand. There were, in 1911, fewer than

10. See W. Peter Ward, White Canada Forever: Popular Attitudes and Public Policy Toward Orientals in British Columbia, 3rd ed. (Montreal &
Kingston: McGill-Queen's University Press, 2002) and Hugh J. M. Johnston, The Voyage of the Komagata Maru: The Sikh Challenge to
Canada's Colour Bar, revised ed. (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2014).
 232 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

3,000 Indians in Canada and that number was roughly half of what it had been only five years earlier. Rather than
posing a demographic threat, the community was in something like free fall. It was a fear of being overrun and
outnumbered that motivated many racists at the time. H. H. Stevens, the Conservative Member of Parliament who
played a key role in the Komagata Maru affair, for example, was terrified that Asian populations had a much
higher fertility rate and an almost endless stockpile of potential emigrants on which to draw. Stevens would prove
to be a lifelong opponent of any kind of Asian immigration. He and his peers saw Canada as a White mans coun-
try, and regarded any arrival by visible minorities to be the thin edge of the wedge and a disaster in the making.

Racism, Health, Deviance

As historian Esyllt Jones observes, the state and medical officials gave physical health an ethnic face. Crowded
housing and poor water and sewage widely recognized as causal factors when it came to infectious diseases
were disregarded when dealing with the immigrant, working poor, and non-White races. It was race and eth-
nicity (and social class) that Canadian authorities believed made newcomers sickly and, as well, a fertile ground
11
for epidemics. Local police authorities extended this way of thinking to social behaviour. Prostitution became
associated with ethnic and visible minorities, particularly Chinese, Slavic, and Italian communities. Bootlegging
the production and sale of alcohol is an example of an ancient rural practice that became criminalized in
the early 20th century and used as an excuse to police the ethnic other. Organized gambling was another thread
of moral corruption that was traced back to ethnic enclaves. Finally, the import and/or production and sale of
restricted drugs from opium to heroin was transformed from a criminal practice into an ethnic and racial cri-
sis. Described as morally, physically, and socially diseased, Canadas ethnic and racial others were wrapped
in a language that took on scientific and epidemiological tones. Once these notions were affixed to immigrant
groups, the logic of barring them from medical schools and positions of responsibility became all but unassailable.

While it is true that official anti-Asian sentiment began to decline around 1947, prejudices remained. Anti-Semitic
positions proved especially resilient, as did xenophobia regarding Muslims, Sikhs, Hindus, and members of other
minority, non-Christian faiths. Twenty years ago, the distinguished Canadian historian Desmond Morton, wrote
that pre-WWII Canada was a poor country, full of people who were generous to those they knew, mean-spirited
12
to those they didnt, and harsh about the distinctions. This tension between a country that needed and wanted
immigration but didnt necessarily want immigrants took new forms in the years after the Great War.

Key Points

Racism constituted a set of beliefs about racial hierarchies and policy alternatives.
Some regions acquired greater diversity than others, including the largest cities and the Prairie West.
These were the areas where acts of racial and ethnic discrimination were most widespread.
Anti-African and anti-Asian racism was expressed in policies and practices aimed to reduce or at

11. Esyllt W. Jones, Disease as Embodied Praxis: Epidemics, Public Health, and Working-Class Resistance in Winnipeg, 1906-19, The West
and Beyond: New Perspectives on an Imagined Region, eds. Alvin Finkel, Sarah Carter, Peter Fortna (Edmonton: Athabasca University
Press, 2010): 207-9.
12. Desmond Morton, 1945 - When Canada Won the War, Historical Booklet No. 54 (Ottawa: Canadian Historical Association, 1995), 3.
 5.8 RACE, ETHNICITY, AND IMMIGRATION 233

least limit the size of the communities in question.

The only European community that faced comparable discrimination was the Jewish diaspora.
Immigrant communities developed their own respective strategies to secure survival at least and
prosperity at best.

Attributions
Figure 5.11
View of part of the town of Powell River, British Columbia, and the pulp and paper plant of the Powell River
Company by Harry Rowed / National Film Board of Canada. Photothque / Library and Archives Canada is in
the public domain.

Figure 5.12
Chinese camp (Canadian Pacific Railway), Kamloops, British Columbia. 1886 (Online MIKAN no.3243526)
by Edouard Deville / Library and Archives Canada / C-021990 is in the public domain.

Figure 5.13
The Heathen Chinese In British Columbia (Online MIKAN no.2914880) by Library and Archives Canada is in
the public domain.

Figure 5.14
Damage to property of Japanese residents (Nishimura Masuya, Grocer, at 130 Powell Rd. S.) (Vancouver, B.C.)
(Online MIKAN no. 3363536) by William Lyon Mackenzie King / Library and Archives Canada / C-014118 is
in the public domain.

Figure 5.15
Sikhs aboard Komagata Maru by Siddhartha Ghai is in the public domain.

Figure 5.16
Cyclone Taylor by PM800 is in the public domain.
5.9 Immigrants and War

Figure 5.17 Christmas 1916 at an internment camp.

Perhaps the single greatest irony of Canadians relationship with immigrants and visible minorities (including
Aboriginal people) rose to the surface in the course of two World Wars. Keen to welcome nation-building immi-
grants but critical of their cultures and suspicious of the kind of nation they might build, Canadians tied them-
selves in knots when it came time to engage in military adventures.

The diversity introduced to Canada from the 19th century complicated ideas of loyalty. Recall that Anglo-Cana-
dians were extremely suspicious of Franco-Catholic loyalties to the Vatican as articulated by the ultramontanists.
The loyalty of the French at the secular level was regularly drawn into question so often so that the apparent
disinterest of Qubecois in volunteering for service in 1914-17 (see Section 6.4) was both expected and viewed as
demonstrable proof of disloyalty to the Crown regardless of the fact that Anglo-Canadian numbers in the ranks
were shored up mightily by recent British immigrants. French Canadians, for their part, characterized Anglo-
Canadians as absurdly loyal to an absent monarch in a foreign country, rather than to the country of their birth:
Canada. What, then, were they to make of the hundreds of thousands of Europeans and Asians drawn from beyond
the borders of France and Britain?

Local xenophobia was, thus, amplified by the arrival of war in 1914. Germans were instantly persecuted, their
property attacked, and calls raised for sweeping arrests. Germanic names were part of the landscape of British
North America for centuries and now they were Anglicized to demonstrate loyalty and to reduce visibility. Even
the Ontario city of Berlin took the name of the British general in the Boer War, Kitchener. Austro-Hungarians
that is, Austrians, Hungarians, many Ukrainians, and almost everyone from the Balkans were also targeted.
The Hapsburg Empires vilification in wartime propaganda gave license to indulge prejudice and hostility toward
those Central and Southern European immigrants who had been recruited at no small expense to build the
Canadian Wests economy. Whats more, eugenicists already regarded the Austro-Hungarians as a liability in the
building of a forthright, strong, British nation; Austro-Hungarians were perceived by government and civic offi-
cials as inherently impoverished and therefore feckless and unhealthy as well. And now, in wartime, they were
subject to arrest and incarceration in internment camps.

234
 5.9 IMMIGRANTS AND WAR 235

Anglo- and Franco-Canadians, however, proved flexible in their distaste for foreigners. At the end of WWI, when
the map of Europe was redrawn at Versailles, much of the Ukraine now fell within the borders of Poland, a belea-
guered nation-state towards which the public had some sympathies. To be an Austro-Hungarian was to be an
enemy; to be a Pole was to be reinvented as a brave ally.

The Pacificists
Pacificism was another barrier to inclusion during wartime. Several immigrant communities were recruited under
Siftons watch with the promise that their pacifist beliefs would be honoured in Canada. For the Mennonites in
particular, this was a critical assurance. In Russia, they were the target of violent repression by the Czarist regime
precisely because of their anti-war stance; Canadas offer to respect their pacificism was a deal-maker.

The Doukhobor experience in this regard offers an example. A dissenting sect established in Russia and Georgia
during the 17th century (if not earlier) the Doukhobors critique of established church authority and the secular
state in Russia attracted repression. This peaked in 1895 when the regime of Nicholas II sent in storm troops
in this case, Cossacks to force Doukhobor compliance with state laws and universal conscription. These
events produced an international outcry and the search for a new home for the Doukhobors (something which the
frustrated Czar was only too happy to permit). Siftons ministry stepped forward and offered block settlements in
Saskatchewan and Alberta totalling more than three-quarters of a million acres. The communal-ownership model
preferred by the Doukhobors was to be respected, as was their anarchist reluctance to engage with the bureau-
cratic machinery of the state. As well, the Doukhobors were reassured by revisions to the Dominion Military Act
that exempted them from military service.

Figure 5.18 The village of Vosnesenya Thunder Hill Colony. Its

architecture and village layout were copied from the Doukhobor
villages in Caucasia.

Three factors caused the Canadians to change their position on the Doukhobor agreements. The bureaucracy of the
modern state became more rigorous: Siftons replacement, Frank Oliver, began insisting on individual land reg-
istrations and pressures grew to send Doukhobor children to public schools. As tensions grew in Europe, an oath
of allegiance to the Crown was required. Provincial governments were established in Alberta and Saskatchewan;
now the Doukhobors had several levels of government with which to deal.

The communities fractured and the largest part, calling itself the Sons of Freedom, migrated to the southeast of
British Columbia. There, their anti-materialist protests (which involved nude demonstrations and the burning of
buildings) and their opposition to public schooling peaked in the 1920s and then in the mid-20th century. The
growing state formation under W. A. C. Bennett moved to capture Doukhobor children and to educate them in
facilities secure from parental influence. Arrests of the Freedomites followed. While all of these steps were taken
within the letter of the law, the Doukhobor community experienced their incarceration and the abduction of their
children as nothing short of state terrorism. Within only a few decades the Doukhobor experience in Canada
looked very much like what it had been under the Czars.
236 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

What this history demonstrates is, in part, the conflicting currents of modernism which involves the growth of
the state, record-keeping, militarism, and the primacy of the individual and the survival of pre- or antimod-
ernist belief systems and inclinations including the idealization of rural and communal life, spiritual versus
materialist priorities, and anarchistic resistance to the very idea of the nation-state.

Key Points

Canadian policy, and much of the public, turned against Central and Eastern European immigrants
during wartime.
Certain groups were characterized as enemy aliens and faced internment during the Great War.
Pacifist colonies in the West and elsewhere in Canada were increasingly confronted by public opin-
ion and governments that reneged on earlier assurances of tolerance.

Attributions
Figure 5.17
Christmas celebration at Internment Camp in Canada, W.W.I 1916 (Online MIKAN no.3193850) by Intern-
ment Camps / Library and Archives Canada / C-014104 is in the public domain.

Figure 5.18
Doukhobor Village of Vosnesenya Thunder Hill Colony by Themightyquill is in the public domain.
5.10 Female Immigrants and the Canadian State, 1860s
through the 20th century

LISA CHILTON, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, UNIVERSITY OF PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND

Figure 5.19 Four women outside the

Finnish Immigrant Home in Montreal, ca.
1929.

In the middle of the 19th century, women who immigrated to Canada became the focus of special attention. Phil-
anthropists and social reformers began to lobby officials of the Canadian state to help support their efforts to man-
age and protect this special class of newcomers. In part, the impetus behind treating female immigrants differently
to men was a growing sense that the Canadian nation would be defined by the quality of the people who were
settling it. As mothers symbolically and literally of future generations of Canadians, female immigrants were
considered by architects of the new nation to be particularly significant additions to the population.

The Canadian government (like its counterparts in the United States, Britain, Australia, and other parts of the
British Empire) initially resisted pressure to invest in special programmes and facilities for female migrants.
The earliest initiatives were all privately funded. But by the turn of the 20th century various government bodies
were supporting programmes designed by organisations such as the British Womens Emigration Association,
the Young Womens Christian Association, and the Travellers Aid Society to treat women as both a particularly
vulnerable and a potentially problematic class of immigrants. For example, the earliest women-only hostels and
transatlantic chaperone programmes were all fully funded by charitable and philanthropic organisations. By the
beginning of World War I women-only immigrant reception homes, established and run by women associated

237
 238 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

with the British Womens Emigration Association but financially underwritten by Canadas federal government,
1
were in place in major urban centres across Canada.

The Canadian governments consideration of female immigrants as a group requiring particular care came to a
head after World War I. In 1920, after much lobbying by Canadian womens associations, the Canadian federal
government established a special branch of the Canadian Department of Immigration and Colonization to recruit
women for domestic service and other female-gendered forms of paid employment that Canadian women were
unlikely or unavailable to perform, and to manage the movements of all unaccompanied women coming into
the country. The Womens Division functioned as a separate unit for just over a decade before the government
imposed restrictions to immigration during the Great Depression and the flow of immigrants dried up, making
2
their work essentially unnecessary.

While the Womens Division disappeared, the gendered assumptions and attitudes behind its establishment con-
tinued to play major roles in state programmes associated with newcomers after World War II. Womens sexual
histories were interrogated as a part of the selection process to a far greater extent than were those of men. Local
government bodies funded immigrant reception programmes that encouraged female immigrants to embrace
mainstream Canadian parenting and homemaking practices. And, as had been the case since at least the begin-
ning of the 20th century, the government barred entry to women and even deported female immigrants for past
experiences and behaviours that might have been overlooked in their male counterparts. Thus, for example, in the
early 20th century, unmarried women who became pregnant were vulnerable to deportation proceedings on the
grounds of their immorality and the likelihood that they would require some sort of charitable assistance if they
3
were allowed to stay in Canada.

Figure 5.20 Awaiting deportation, Quebec, 1912.

The most consistent area of investment relating to female immigrants by the Canadian government concerns
recruitment. Because household work and care for the young, the ill, and the elderly typically have been low-
paid, exploitative areas of female-gendered employment, Canadian citizens in a position to be more selective
have shunned this work. At the same time, prospective employers were quick to assign stereotypes to immigrant
women seeking work in these fields: The newly arrived female worker was caricatured as morally suspect because
of her race or ethnicity. Public fears and xenophobia in this respect produced extensive scrutiny and regular criti-
cism of government programmes, even as the number of recruitment exercises grew. Perhaps more than any other
aspect of the Canadian governments immigration work, the governments recruitment programmes associated
with domestic and caregiver work represent Canadas most conservative social politics.

1. Lisa Chilton, Agents of Empire: British Female Migration to Canada and Australia, 1860s-1930 (Toronto: University of Toronto Press,
2007); Marilyn Barber, Immigrant Domestic Servants in Canada (Ottawa: Canadian Historical Association, 1991).
2. Rebecca Mancuso, "Work 'Only a Woman Can Do': The Women's Division of the Canadian Department of Immigration and Coloniza-
tion," The American Review of Canadian Studies (Winter 2005): 593-620.
3. For the late 19th and early 20th centuries, see Mariana Valverde, The Age of Light, Soap and Water: Moral Reform in English Canada,
1885-1925 (Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1991). For the post-World War Two period, see Franca Iacovetta, Gatekeepers: Reshaping
Immigrant Lives in Cold War Canada (Toronto: Between the Lines, 2006).
 5.10 FEMALE IMMIGRANTS AND THE CANADIAN STATE, 1860S THROUGH THE 20TH CENTURY 239

Through domestic servant, caregiver and nurse recruitment schemes, many thousands of women have immigrated
to Canada since Confederation. Before World War I, the majority of domestic servants in major urban centres
and in the Canadian West were immigrants from the British Isles. They had been recruited by philanthropic orga-
nizations heavily subsidized by the Canadian federal government. Throughout the 1920s, the Canadian govern-
ment continued to invest heavily in the recruitment of British women for this work, though it also struck deals
with transportation companies and community groups that wished to support the immigration of European women
for domestic employment. In the period after World War II, the government began to openly recruit women for
domestic work from a list of preferred European origins. For example, in little over a decade (1951-1963) over
4
10,000 Greek women became Canadian immigrants through such a scheme. Since the 1970s, the government has
moved to a system whereby women recruited to perform domestic or caregiver work in Canada will not necessar-
ily receive immigrant status. Rather, recruitment schemes targeting women in the Philippines or certain Caribbean
countries, for example, have been structured around term employment contracts that provide the migrants with
5
limited support and no certain future in Canada.

Key Points

Female immigrants have been treated by many administrations as a separate category of recruit and
applicant.
The ways in which prospective immigrants were interrogated for eligibility was gendered.
Class prejudices and ethnic biases combined to create particular niches for immigrant females,
specifically in areas of work that did not appeal to Canadian women because of low pay or poor
working conditions.

Attributions
Figure 5.19
[Four women on steps of Finnish immigrant home, Finnish Seamens and Immigrant Mission, Montral,
(Qubec).] (Online MIKAN no. 3367692) by Kangas, Victor / Library and Archives Canada / PA-127086 is in
the public domain.

Figure 5.20
Immigrants to be deported (Online MIKAN no. 3365973) by William James Topley / Library and Archives
Canada / PA-020910 is in the public domain.

4. Noula Mina, "Taming and Training Greek 'Peasant Girls' and the Gendered Politics of Whiteness in Postwar Canada: Canadian Bureaucrats
and Immigrant Domestics, 1950s-1960s," Canadian Historical Review, 94:4 (Dec. 2013): 514-39.
5. Abigail Bakan and Daiva Stasiulis, Negotiating Citizenship: Migrant Women in Canada and the Global System (Toronto: University of
Toronto Press, 2005).
 5.11 Post-War Immigration

When it comes to immigration, the century can be divided in two along the fulcrum of WWII. Prior to the war,
immigration was principally understood within the context of building an agricultural colossus and assembling
an army of workers to tear down forests and wrest ore from the belly of the Earth. And it took place within the
context of a kind of cultural sensitivity that was mostly alert to anything that would challenge the dominance
of Anglo-Celtic Protestant and Franco-Catholic founding nations. It was for this reason that Buddhist, Shinto,
Sikh, Muslim, and Jewish immigrants in particular alike in that none were Christian were especially margin-
alized. The cataclysms of 1939-45 changed both circumstances and minds.

Post-War Refugees
After 1945 Europe opened its floodgates as hundreds of thousands sought refuge from a devastated continent.
British emigrants were fleeing cities destroyed by the Blitz and diets stunted by rationing; there were, too, 41,000
war brides and nearly 20,000 children fathered by Canadian soldiers stationed in the UK during the war. Refugees
poured out of Germany, especially in the wake of the quartering of the nation (and Berlin) into Soviet and Western
zones (see Section 9.4). The same was true of Czecho-Slovaks uncertain of their countrys future and disconsolate
about its immediate past. In Italy, Austria, France, the Netherlands, and Belgium refugee camps were established
in the late 1940s. Called DP Camps for Displaced Persons these were the focal point of efforts to sort the
human chaos into emigrant streams. (Immigrants in this wave were casually, sometimes derisively, referred to as
DPs regardless of whether they had endured the camps.)

Canadians played an important role in both the United Nations Relief and Rehabilitation Administration
(UNRRA) and the International Refugee Organization that succeeded it in 1947. Ottawa was committed to accept-
ing significant numbers of able-bodied refugees, although Canadian anti-Semitism continued to throw up obsta-
cles to Jewish refugees and survivors of death camps. As the Cold War got underway, anti-Communist applicants
were favoured over others: Poles and Ukrainians together represented 39% of the 165,000 in this refugee wave,
followed by Germans and Austrians (11%), Jews (10%), and smaller measures of Baltic and Central European
emigrants. One historical study of this migration by Franca Iacovetta points to the role of Canadian gatekeepers
1
who processed applicants in what she describes as a worldwide labour relocation program. There were many
ironies and tragedies in this process, possibly the most outstanding being that anti-fascist resistance fighters were
often viewed by Canadian authorities as insufficiently anti-Soviet and they were, for that reason, less likely to be

1. Franca Iacovetta, Gatekeepers: Reshaping Immigrant Lives in Cold War Canada (Toronto: Between the Lines, 2006), 3-5.

240
 5.11 POST-WAR IMMIGRATION 241

allowed into the country. This was notably the case among Jewish refugees whose animosity toward the fascists
was understandably greater than their hostility toward communism.

Barely had the immediate post-war exodus tapered off in 1953 when new Cold War migrations got underway.
In November 1956, as Soviet tanks rolled across a rebellious Hungary, 30,000 of some 200,000 exiles fled to
Canada. There was a humanitarian agenda here, to be sure, but it is also important to note that providing sanc-
tuary and opportunity to Soviet-bloc Europeans during the Cold War had propaganda value as well. And it cut
two ways: their successful integration into a prosperous postwar Canadian democratic order taunted those who
remained behind and, at the same time, anti-communist refugees spread a message among Canadians of Soviet
oppression and terror.

Figure 5.21 Refugee crisis, 1956. An immigration interpreter

assists with the interview of a Hungarian applicant.

The first waves of Cold War-era immigration from Europe were followed in the 1950s and 1960s by family
reunification arrivals. As siblings and other relatives found their way to Canada, the majority made their way to
urban Ontario. Diversity existed there before WWII but in the 1960s it became transformative. The established
British-Canadianism of Toronto and Hamilton was itself being reduced to enclaves of what former Prime Minister
Stephen Harper once described approvingly as old stock Canadians.

Ideological turmoil had consequences for Asian immigrants as well. Liberalization of attitudes toward Chinese
immigration began in 1947, in large measure because China had been a target of Japan (an enemy of the Allied
forces during World War II). Chinese Canadians were quick to volunteer for service in the Canadian Army in
wartime and, after official barriers were dropped, they joined the Navy and Air Force as well, all of which con-
tributed to a change in attitude in White society. In 1947, then, the 1923 Immigration Act was repealed and it
became possible for Chinese immigrants and their descendants to obtain Canadian citizenship. Four hundred did
2
so that year in a mass ceremony in Vancouver.

The timing of the policy change, however, was poor. In 1949 the Chinese Revolution brought Mao Zedong (aka:
Mao Tse-tung) and his Communist Party to power in Beijing. Almost immediately barriers to emigration were
erected and once again Chinese (outside of Hong Kong and Taiwan) were unable to join members of the dias-
3
pora. Emigration from Hong Kong would continue, however, and it accelerated in the 1980s as Britain reluctantly
prepared to hand over control of the colony to the Peoples Republic of China (PRC) in 1997. Large numbers
of (mostly wealthy) Chinese made their way to Canada at this time, establishing a significant enclave in Rich-
mond, BC, and appearing in most major cities. Changes within the PRC and a growing economy enabled main-
landers to emigrate as well, and by the first decade of the new century the Chinese community in Canada had
become vastly more complex, consisting of old families some of which had roots in Canada going back to

2. Timothy J. Stanley, Contesting White Supremacy: School Segregation, Anti-Racism, and the Making of Chinese Canadians (Vancouver: Uni-
versity of British Columbia Press, 2011).
3. Wing Chung Ng, The Chinese in Vancouver, 1945-80: The Pursuit of Identity and Power (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press,
1999).
242 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

the 1850s, most of whom had originated in Guangdong, and the majority enjoying modest incomes while still
strongly oriented toward community institutions in Chinatowns contrasting with wealthy and super-wealthy
recent arrivals from Hong Kong and the PRC, a great many of whom spoke Mandarin (Putonghua) rather than
Cantonese (Guangdong speech) and almost none of whom regarded Chinatown as representative of their history,
experience, and aspirations. (For more on this topic, see Section 5.12.)

Post-Centennial Immigration
The centennial year marked a further change in immigration policy. Up to this time, Ottawa preferred settlers
from the British Isles, the United States, and Western Europe. In 1967 the government introduced a points system.
Under this regime applicants were given preference if they knew either (or both) French or English, were non-
dependent adults (that is, not too old to work), had jobs lined up already in Canada, had relatives in the country
(to whom they might turn for support), were interested in settling in parts of the country with the greatest need
for workers, and were trained or educated in fields that were in demand. The economy was still expanding and
in some regions it would continue to do so for many years. Canadians have not always demonstrated sufficient
mobility to fill the hiring needs of some regions, nor to fill some economic niches (especially what are often called
entry-level jobs). Under these circumstances the new legislation was to prove key in attracting large numbers of
new Canadians from sources that were considered non-traditional.

In the 1970s, Montreal was no longer Canadas largest metropolis, the increasingly multicultural Toronto having
shot past its downriver rival. This was only the most easily observed demographic change. Proportionally greater
transformations were seen in cities like Vaughan, ON. Located north of Toronto, Vaughan was a small town until
the late 20th century, when it leapt from fewer than 16,000 in 1961 to 182,000 in 2001 (and it has nearly doubled
since then). Most of that growth came from Italian and Jewish post-WWII immigration which, combined with
immigrants from other sources, made it one of the fastest growing centres in Canada: the English Canadian pop-
ulation in Vaughan is, as a consequence, almost insignificantly small. Similar patterns can be seen in suburban
settings like Vancouvers Richmond and Surrey, where growth rates have outstripped all other centres in Canada
in the last decade or more.

Some rural areas enjoyed growth spurts in the post-WWII period. In the 1960s young American men and women
fled to Canada to avoid being drafted into the United States Army for duty in the Vietnam War. Especially large
nodes were established in British Columbias Kootenays, in the Gulf Islands, and along the Sunshine Coast. Oth-
ers followed, including counter culture, back-to-the-land advocates who were more pulled than pushed into
Canada (see Section 9.16). At around the same time, Indo-Canadians coupled suburban living with exurban and
rural agriculture, becoming a dominant feature in British Columbias farming sector. Hispanic immigrants fol-
lowed a similar trajectory, particularly in regions that were linked with strong farming settlements immediately
south of the border.

African Immigrants
The numbers of Canadians from Africa has been growing rapidly since the 1990s. Urban areas see considerable
concentrations drawn from many parts of Africa. One study on the African diaspora in Vancouver indicates that
these immigrants consistently experience downward social mobility because their education and skills are often
not recognized or valued in Canada. Many are drawn from professional and semi-professional careers in Africa
 5.11 POST-WAR IMMIGRATION 243

only to find that they must pursue very low status and vulnerable jobs. Access to free farmland is not an option
available to this generation of new arrivals nor, because of the diverse sources of African immigration, are social
agencies comparable to the Chinese Benevolent Association. Somalians and Nigerians, Sudanese and Mozam-
bicans lack the common set of cultural, political, and economic interests and inclinations to establish what was
4
possible among the more cohesive Guangdonese and Punjabi immigrant communities 100 years ago.

Toward a Cultural Mosaic

Although Canadian society has long been composed of diverse elements, the two founding nations narrative
prescribed absorption, assimilation, and exclusion as strategies for managing newcomers. The idea of a cultural
mosaic as opposed to the American melting pot >would have been anathema to most English and French
Canadians before the 1960s. Several developments produced a more inclusive society.

The first of these was purely demographic. Large numbers of Laurier-era immigrants had large numbers of chil-
dren; immigrant fertility especially in rural areas was high. That meant that by 1960 there were at least
two generations of growing numbers of what Conservative Prime Minister John Diefenbaker called hyphenated
Canadians. Some were finding their way into post-secondary education pioneers in their families in this respect
and were critical of narratives they encountered that privileged French and English Canadians. Additionally,
incompletely assimilated urban and rural communities now represented significant voting blocks and they could
not be treated with condescension by hopeful politicians. The Liberal Party, in particular, was well positioned
to take advantage of these changes and did so. Diefenbaker (whose career is surveyed in Section 9.6) occupies
an ironic position in this story: a German Canadian, he was critical of hyphenation, seeing it as a kind of sec-
ond-class status. So, while he might decry special privileges to any minorities because it served to perpetuate that
minority status, a growing chorus of Liberal Party voices called for more pluralism. As the party that was most
likely in office when post-WWII immigrant families first arrived, the Liberals reaped some benefits at the polls
in gratitude. The first Chinese Canadian candidates were Liberals and the party prominently ran Italian and Por-
tuguese Canadian candidates as well.

The changes to the Immigration Act in 1967 produced waves of arrivals from Asia, Africa, and the Middle East.
The vast majority of these New Canadians headed to the urban centres, especially the largest five or six cities.
After 1971, despite much higher fertility rates in rural Canada, cities continued to grow at a more rapid rate,
mostly from new immigration. Typically, newcomers gravitated towards lower-income neighbourhoods where
rents were cheap and familiar foods might be obtained. A recent study calls these immigrant nodes within metro-
politan areas arrival cities, landing pads for migrants who, since the 1960s, have been coming by air and not by
5
sea or rail. These immigrants further reinforced the advantages enjoyed by the Liberal Party.

By the 1960s there had occurred, too, a change in popular attitudes. The Nazi war crime trials in the late
1940 that revealed the extent of the Jewish holocaust under the Hitler regime proved to be a turning point and
spurred efforts to develop language around human rights. Full citizenship for many groups, however, only came
into reach slowly; Asians, for example, got the vote in the 1960s (as did some Aboriginal people). At about the
same time in the early- to mid-1960s we see the beginnings of official multiculturalism and inclusivity. The

4. Gillian Crease, The New African Diaspora in Vancouver: Immigration, Exclusion, and Belonging (Toronto: University of Toronto Press,
2011), 17.
5. Doug Saunders, Arrival City: The Final Migration and Our Next World (Toronto: Vintage Canada, 2011).
 244 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

1963 Royal Commission on Bilingualism and Biculturalism didnt issue a report until 1969 but its mandate and
early claims for the precedence of English and French in Canada catalyzed a reaction among Third Force Cana-
dians Canadians whose ancestry was neither French nor English.

Espousing a new inclusivity was both a political strategy for election day and a way of breaking with the old dual-
ity of Confederation. The Liberals under Pierre Trudeau were simultaneously building a bilingual and bicultural
society while rolling back assimilative requirements for immigrants. Rather than divide the growing immigrant
demographic along ideological lines, they reasoned, it might be held together as a Liberal block if its own (vari-
ous) values were respected. As early as 1969, Trudeau was quoted saying, For the past 150 years nationalism has
been a retrograde idea. By an historic accident Canada has found itself approximately 75 years ahead of the rest
of the world in the formation of a multinational state. Practices and rhetoric in the 1970s increasingly reflected
these values, and was manifest in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms of 1982. This movement culminated in the
Multiculturalism Act of 1988.

None of these changes erased the reality of bias and prejudices that confronts immigrants, but they did created a
legal framework in which discrimination might be challenged. Two such challenges came from the Asian com-
munity in British Columbia in the 1980s. While Eastern European immigrants to the Prairie West experienced
xenophobia and disadvantage in the 20th century, they were not taxed on entry in an attempt to both control their
numbers and to generate government revenue. This, of course, was the experience of Chinese immigrants under
6
the Head Tax regime. Nor were any European, American, or African immigrants confronted with special legis-
lation to stop the arrival of their family members and to deter further immigration from their ancestral homeland.
This, too, was the experience of the Chinese community under the federal Chinese Immigration Act (also called
the Chinese Exclusion Act) of 1923. And although it is true that some German, Ukrainian, Bulgarian, Turkish,
and Italian Canadians were interned as enemies of the state during the two World Wars, these were predominantly
select individuals who were outspoken supporters of enemy regimes and very few of them suffered extensive or
permanent loss of personal property; nor did these internments constitute a community-wide, round-up based on
ethnicity alone. For the Japanese Canadians in World War II, the situation was starkly different: property was con-
fiscated, auctioned off, and never returned. The entire community, including infants and the elderly, was captured
and incarcerated in camps for the duration of the war with Japan; the end of internment brought further barriers to
reintegration and the prospect of deportation to Japan (see Section 6.17). Because of these significant, not to say
monumental, differences in the experiences of the Japanese and Chinese communities, apologies and compensa-
tion were sought from various levels of government from the 1980s on.

Figure 5.22 Internment camp for Japanese Canadians in

British Columbia.

Successive Quebec governments dealt with the issue of multiculturalism differently. Fearing that the majority of
immigrants would gravitate towards or even demand schooling in English for their children, the provincial gov-

6. Lisa Rose Mar, Brokering Belonging: Chinese in Canadas Exclusion Era, 1885-1945 (New York: Oxford University Press, 2010).
 5.11 POST-WAR IMMIGRATION 245

ernment took steps in the 1960s-1980s to close off that avenue. While a disproportionate share of immigrants to
Canada from former French colonies chose to settle in Quebec (especially Montreal), there were also large num-
bers of immigrants who spoke neither English nor French. These newcomers described as allophones were
a significant demographic and were courted by both the Liberals and the Parti Qubcois, especially during the
referendums on Quebec sovereignty. (See Sections 9.11 and 12.3 for more on this topic.)

Key Points

Post-WWII immigration included refugees from war-ravaged Europe and from communist regimes
in Eastern Europe.
New sources of immigrants were being increasingly tapped, and greater numbers were heading to
cities than to the countryside.
After 1967 much of the focus of new immigration was in suburban centres.
The increased diversity of the Canadian population created political opportunities; politicians seized
on ideals like multiculturalism and recognized long-standing ethnic community grievances.

Attributions
Figure 5.21
Immigration interpreter aids Hungarian refugee (Online MIKAN no. 3298778) by Canada. Dept. of Manpower
and Immigration / Library and Archives Canada / PA-181009 is in the public domain.

Figure 5.22
Japanese internment camp in British Columbia by jkelly is in the public domain.
5.12 The Chinese in Canada

TIMOTHY J. STANLEY, FACULTY OF EDUCATION, UNIVERSITY OF OTTAWA

People from China have been in what is today called Canada since before the country existed. Indeed, 50 carpen-
ters and shipwrights from Canton became the first permanent resettlers on Canadas West Coast when the English
sea captain John Meares abandoned them at Nootka Sound in 1789. Ironically, their efforts at building a fur trad-
ing fort and ship consolidated the British claim to the Pacific Coast.

Figure 5.23 Washing gold on the Fraser River, ca. 1875.

Those of Chinese origin have been continuously present in British Columbia since the 1858 Fraser River gold
rush, arriving at a time when the territory was a First Nations one and the non-First Nations population was a few
hundred. By the 1880s, Chinese (mainly made up of people from Guangdong province in south China) were likely
the second largest group in BC after First Nations. However, after Confederation in 1871, the first legislature of
the Province of British Columbia ensured that people of European origins would dominate the new Dominion by
taking the right to vote away from Chinese and First Nations peoples. At the time, the racialized White minority
was less than 20% of the population.

By World War I, at virtually every turn, legislated discrimination surrounded people of Chinese origins living in
British Columbia. In addition to being barred from voting, they could not work for provincially incorporated com-
panies, for the government itself, underground in coal mines, or on crown licenses. Indeed, by 1914 the province
had enacted 112 pieces of discriminatory legislation against them and other Asians. In the face of this discrimina-
tion, many Chinese moved to other provinces, where discrimination was common but not as systemic. They often
worked with other Chinese immigrants in labour-intensive settings that required little initial capital. By the 1940s,
virtually every town of any size in Canada had a Chinese restaurant or hand laundry.

246
 5.12 THE CHINESE IN CANADA 247

Figure 5.24 Head Tax receipt issued to Lee Don in 1918. The
Chinese Immigration Act of 1923, which largely restricted the
immigration of Chinese into Canada was passed on the same day
as Dominion Day, causing Chinese Canadians to close their
businesses and boycott Dominion Day celebrations every July 1,
referring to the event as Humiliation Day.

In 1885, John A. Macdonald extended disenfranchisement to the federal level and introduced a discriminatory
immigration Head Tax on Chinese workers and their families. By 1904, the Head Tax reached $500, more than
an average workers yearly wage. In 1923, the federal government banned Chinese immigration to Canada out-
right. Between 1923-1947, when the legislation was repealed, Chinese immigration to Canada effectively ended.
The future Governor General Adrienne Clarkson and her family were among the handful of exceptions allowed.
This discriminatory legislation prevented Chinese families from being reunited in Canada. In 1941, 95% of the
married Chinese men in Canada were still separated from their families. Supposed bachelors in Canada endured
years of loneliness while their wives and kin in China were caught in poverty, civil war, and the Japanese inva-
sions of the 1930s and World War II. It was not until the 1980s that the family structure of Chinese-Canadian
communities came to resemble that of other Canadian communities. In the 1980s-1990s, China became the most
important source country for immigrants to Canada, moving away from the communitys historic roots in Guang-
dong province in south China, to northern China. Today, the Chinese community in Canada includes a majority of
people who are immigrants and who speak Mandarin as their ancestral language and who come from professional
and entrepreneurial backgrounds in China. At the same time, there are others who are seventh or even eighth gen-
eration Canadian whose ancestral languages are various dialects of Cantonese, Taishanese, and Hakka, but whose
primary languages are English or French. As such, there are many different Chinese communities in Canada.

Throughout their history in Canada, people of Chinese origins and their Canadian-born children, have fought for
full political and democratic rights, and for full participation in Canadian life. They have helped to make Canada
the democratic and inclusive society that it is today. They organized associations and governing institutions to
protect their interests and for mutual support. They formed political organizations designed to make China strong
so that it could protect their rights. They fought for inclusion in peoples idea of Canada, moving it from one that
was originally envisioned as a White, European nation to one that includes all of its peoples equally.

Key Points

The Chinese presence in British Columbia predates the Fraser River and Cariboo gold rush, but the
numbers grew rapidly during that time and increased again in the 1880s.
Chinese immigration was managed through the imposition of a Head Tax in 1885 and restrictive leg-
islation in 1923.
The diversity of emigrants from China has produced a complex pattern of distinct immigrant com-
munities in Canada.
248 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Attributions
Figure 5.23
Chinese man washing gold (Online MIKAN no.3192437) by Library and Archives Canada / PA-125990 is in
the public domain.

Figure 5.24
Head Tax Recipt by Shizhao is in the public domain.
 5.13 Summary

Figure 5.25 Immigrants in the years between the 1890s and the
1920s often lacked the capital to buy the kind of machinery that
would make their worklives easier and some, indeed, rejected the
new technologies. Men and women alike worked the fields, ca.
1890.

Across the century that began with the Great War in August 1914, the complexion of Canada changed signif-
icantly. And while the transition from a mostly rural to a mostly urban society continued on course, much of
that work had been accomplished by 1921. The population patterns that emerged thereafter mostly reinforced
existing urban settlement, adding ethnic complexities in close contact within one another. In 2006, nearly half
of Torontos population described themselves as belonging to a visible minority; about the same proportion
1
now make the same claim in Vancouvers population. It is not true, however, of the rest of Canada. The share
of Atlantic Canadas population that is comprised of non-northern European stock is tiny. In Newfoundland and
2
Labrador, for example, the foreign-born constitute fewer than 2% and half that share are people of colour.

The effects of these patterns have been significant. Earlier in this chapter it was pointed out that the immigration
waves of the 20th century did not reframe Canada in the same way as the Edwardian waves. This is true. But they
did recalibrate the country from a dualistic to a pluralistic society. Setting aside for the moment the relationship
between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal Canada, the non-Native demographic has been transformed. While that
non-Aboriginal pluralism may not be experienced to the same extent in rural Manitoba or small-town Ontario, and
while it might not be highly visible in Prince Rupert or Medicine Hat, its influence is widespread. That is partly
because of the enormous ability of our metropolises to control the national conversation; it is in these major cities
that the proverbial rubber hits the road.

Canadian attitudes toward immigration have blown hot and cold, often at the same time. Settlers in the West were
necessary to laying claim to that territory; at the same time, these settlers proved to be overwhelmingly foreign-
ers, not locally-raised farm men and women from the original provinces. Immigrants of many different cultures

1. Statistics Canada, Visible minority population, by census metropolitan areas (2006 Census), accessed 16 October 2015, [Link]
[Link]/tables-tableaux/sum-som/l01/cst01/[Link].
2. Gillian Crease, The New African Diaspora in Vancouver: Immigration, Exclusion, and Belonging (Toronto: University of Toronto Press,
2011), 5.

249
 250 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

were thus essential tools in the building of the nation and yet, at the same time, their foreignness was regarded as
problematic. The newest newcomers promoted economic growth and, simultaneously, competed with native-born
Canadians for jobs in an industrializing society. Immigrants thus played a critical role in steadying and expand-
ing the Canadian economy while, usually without knowing it, competing against and undermining the power of
3
labour. Even as they offered to lay down their lives for Canada in wartime, the immigrants were treated as not-
quite-belonging.

Accounts of immigrants experiences tend to focus on host community responses. It is for this reason that
immigration policies and narratives of prejudice prevail. This is, however, an approach that many historians of
immigration have rejected. Their preference is to place greater emphasis on the role played by the immigrant
instead. Ethnic community groups, the orchestration of emigration, the development of employment strategies in
response to an often prejudicial environment, the extent to which they embraced, rejected, or found unpredicted
4
advantages in programs of assimilation all of these aspects point to agency. The very language of rights in
Canada has been strongly influenced by immigrants and their descendants, and the anti-racist movements of the
late 20th century owe much to acts of resistance and survival that were launched by visible minorities from the
1890s on. This is worth underlining because the history of immigration is a complex interplay of the personal, the
political, the global, and the local.

Key Terms

allophone: A person whose first language is neither French nor English.

anarchist: An individual who advocates the dismantling of the state and the creation of a structure based
on voluntary association and participation.
antimodernism: A retreat from modernization and modernity, often associated with rural and traditional
values, spirituality, and social hierarchies.
back-to-the-land: Refers to any of several anti-urban agrarian movements in which city dwellers are
encouraged to return to simpler, pre-modern ways of living.
Barr Colony: Located west of Saskatoon covering a massive area that extended to and across what
would become the Saskatchewan-Alberta border, the colony was populated by some 2,000 immigrants
recruited directly from Britain.
block settlements: An initiative in settling the West with groups drawn from the same ethnicity or creed
allocated contiguous lands so as to take advantage of cultures of mutual support.
bootlegging: Unlicensed, typically illegal production of alcohol. Also, in some instances, the sale of the
same or of other illicit goods.
Chinatowns: Colloquial term for enclaves of Chinese immigrants. In Canada and primarily in British
Columbia, these appeared from 1858 on, with the greatest increase occurring during the construction of
the Canadian Pacific Railway. Created by external forces (Euro-Canadian civic authority limiting Chi-
nese property ownership and business licenses to a small area) and internal needs (the concentration of
Chinese financial and social institutions).

3. Roderic Beaujot, Population Change in Canada: The Challenges of Policy Adaptation (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1991), 103.
4. Franca Iacovetta, The Writing of English Canadian Immigrant History (Ottawa: The Canadian Historical Association, Canadas Ethnic
Group Series Booklet No.22, 1997), 6.
 5.13 SUMMARY 251

Chinese Benevolent Association: An organization that coordinated the interests and politics of the vari-
ous community organizations in Chinatowns, and provided different levels of social support for its mem-
bers.
context group: In a society comprised of some diversity, refers to the most influential group whose cul-
ture other groups seek to adopt or are obliged to assimilate into. See also, reference group.
continuous voyage requirement: Regulation passed by the federal government in 1908 to restrict
immigration from India and Japan; required immigrants to reach Canada by means of a single, contin-
uous, unbroken voyage. Would affect long journeys that necessitated a stop in either Japan or Hawaii.
Tightened in 1914, leading to the challenge posed by the Komagata Maru.
counter culture: A challenge to mainstream culture posed by a groups rejection of dominant values. In
the 1960s youth movements and specifically the hippy movement constituted a counter cultural moment.
cultural mosaic: In contrast to the concept of a melting pot, refers to a multi-ethnic and multicultural
society in which differences are permitted to continue, rather than face assimilation into a single typol-
ogy.
Displaced Persons: Peoples (principally in Europe) dislocated by World War II; refugees.
Doukhobors: An immigrant group comprised of pacifists belonging to a Russian dissident religious
movement. Settled first on the Prairies then mostly relocated to British Columbia. Persecuted in the 20th
century for their pacifism and their rejection of material culture.
exurban: Refers to residential lands that lay beyond the suburban fringe.
founding nations: In Canada, typically refers to French and British Canadians.
Galicia: Term formerly used to describe an area of what is now part of Ukraine and Poland, which pro-
duced many immigrants to Western Canada. Also the name of a part of Spain, which did not.
Gentlemens Agreement: 1908; also known as the Lemieux-Hayashi Agreement; the Japanese govern-
ment agreed to restrict the number of people leaving Japan for Canada. A loophole allowing wives to
join their husbands led to significant use of the picture bride system thereafter.
Head Tax: A fee levied by the British Columbian and then the federal government on Chinese immi-
grants, beginning in 1885 and continuing to 1923.
Home Children: Over 100,000 children who were exported from Britain to Canada between 1869 and
the late 1930s. Organized by charitable church organizations to alleviate overcrowding and to provide
improved and more healthy alternatives. Stories of abuse abound, although many of the children who
were distributed to farms across Canada did enjoy improved circumstances.
human rights: Any right thought to belong to every person. Enshrined in the United Nations Universal
Declaration of Human Rights, 1947.
Hutterites: Along with the Mennonites and Amish, the Hutterites are an Anabaptist sectarian group;
emigrated from Europe in the late 19th and early 20th century, where they faced oppression for their
pacifist beliefs and the practice of adult baptism; many arrived in Canada after attempts to settle in the
United States. A communal farming community that resists modernization.
Jewish holocaust: The campaign launched in the 1930s and early 1940s by the German National Social-
ist government aimed at the eradication of the Jewish population in Europe. Estimates of the number
killed run to 6 million or more.
Jim Crow Laws: In the United States, post-Civil War racial segregation laws that discriminated against
252 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

African-Americans; most formal elements dissolved in the 1950s and 60s in the Civil Rights Move-
ment; was one cause of African-Americans emigrating to Canada in the Laurier and Borden eras.
Mennonites: Along with the Hutterites and Amish, the Mennonites are an Anabaptist sectarian group;
emigrated from Europe in the late 19th and early 20th century, where they faced oppression for their
pacifist beliefs and the practice of adult baptism; settled in communities in Ontario, in Manitoba and
across the Prairies, and in parts of British Columbia. A communal farming community that has resisted
modernization, though with less intensity than the Hutterites.
nativist: A movement or individual committed to preserving privileges to established members of a
community over newcomers; often translates into anti-immigration attitudes; many nativists are them-
selves merely earlier immigrants; has nothing to do with Native peoples.
New Canadians: Term used since the late 1960s to describe recent immigrants, particularly those arriv-
ing from non-traditional sources like South Asia, Latin America, and Africa.
Nootka Sound: On the west coast of Vancouver Island; traditional territory of the Nootka (Nuu-chah-
nulth) First Nation; site of sustained contact between European, Mexican, and American traders and
Aboriginal peoples, along with a significant population of imported Chinese labourers in the late 18th
century.
pacifism: An anti-war position; pacifists typically will not volunteer for and refuse to be conscripted
into conflict. Many eastern European religious groups brought pacifist beliefs with them to Western
Canada before 1914.
pluralism: In contrast to dualism, supports the concept of a community or state made of diverse parts,
particularly as regards aspects like ethnicity, creed, and/or language.
racism: A set of beliefs and practices that involve the creation of largely arbitrary categories of human
peoples and assigning to them behaviours, traits, and tendencies that are essentialized that is, thought
to be an inherent and immutable part of who they are. For example, laziness, alcoholism, unbridled
libido, personal restraint and self discipline, deceitfulness, superior or inferior intelligence, greed, cor-
ruptibility, cowardice, and courage have, at various times, been regarded as unchangeable qualities of
one race or another. As an ideology, argues that the assumed existence of these differences justifies
and necessitates the development of social policies that reduce the impact that might be had by the
less desirable races.
reference group: In a society comprised of some diversity, refers to the most influential group whose
culture other groups seek to adopt or are obliged to assimilate into. See also context group.
Sinophobic: Fear of China or Chinese.
sojourners: Immigrants whose intent is to work for a period of time, accumulate savings, and return
to their home country (or province). Historically associated mostly with Chinese labourers who were
brought to Canada under contract to the Canadian Pacific Railway, for example.
Sons of Freedom: Or Freedomites; a radical anarchist faction within the Doukhobor diaspora in
Canada; broke away from the main settlements in Saskatchewan and resettled in southeastern British
Columbia; anti-materialist protests and anti-statism led to confrontations with the provincial government
in the 1920s, and 1950s-1960s.
split labour market: A labour market in which employers have the option of hiring cheaper labour that
is differentiated by race, ethnicity or, possibly, creed. Doing so improves profits and it will embitter rela-
tions between the two labour supplies. Used as a theory (split labour market theory) to explain racial
divisions between workers.
 5.13 SUMMARY 253

war brides: At the end of both World Wars, European women principally British who married
Canadian servicemen and relocated to Canada when their husbands returned home.
war crime trials: Internationally-convened trials to address allegations of crimes against humanity
including (but not limited to) murder of civilian populations and enslavement.

Short Answer Exercises

1. Where did most of Canadas immigrants come from? Why?

2. Describe the main features of immigrant waves from the 1880s-1920s.
3. How was agricultural change reflected in the timing of immigrant waves?
4. What preferential standards did individuals like Clifford Sifton apply to immigrant recruitment,
and why?
5. What were the main goals of Canadas pro-immigration policy in the period before WWI?
6. What were the principal goals of immigrants to Canada in these years?
7. What was the response of Canadian society to these first waves of immigration?
8. In what ways were racist and nativist reactions to immigration expressed?
9. How did immigrant communities respond to Canadian ambivalence toward immigrants?
10. How did the recruitment of women differ from the recruitment of farming families?
11. What features of immigration changed between the World Wars and after 1945?

Suggested Readings
Chilton, Lisa. Preventing the Loss of Imported Labour: Trains, Migrants, and the Development of the Canadian
West, 1896-1932, in Place and Replace: Essays on Western Canada, eds. Adele Perry and Esyllt W.
Jones (Winnipeg: University of Manitoba Press, 2013): 93-106.

Iacovetta, Franca. From Contadina to Woman Worker, in Such Hardworking People: Italian Immigrants in
Postwar Toronto (Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 1992): 77-102.

Lehr, John C. Settlement: Farm Families and a New Environment, Community and Frontier: A Ukrainian Set-
tlement in the Canadian Parkland (Winnipeg: University of Manitoba Press, 2011): 25-53.

Menzies, Robert. Race, Reason, and Regulation: British Columbias Mass Exile of Chinese Lunatics aboard the
Empress of Russia, 9 February 1935, Regulating Lives: Historical Essays on the State, Society, the Individual,
and the Law (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press): 196-230.
254 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Attributions
Figure 5.25
Two unidentified woman and an unidentified man harvesting grain with a cradle farm equipment (A1615) by
Provincial Archives of Alberta has no known copyright restrictions.
 PART 7

Chapter 6. The War Years, 1914-45

255
 6.1 Introduction

1
The years from 1914-1945 are marked by turmoil, what one historical text calls decades of discord. Not only
was there conflict abroad, there was also tension at home. The workings of parliament and the democratic order
in Canada underwent change, some degree of transformation, abuse, and challenge. The culture of Canada
like many western democracies changed dramatically because of the war. The increasingly interventionist state
might be ascribed to many causes but there was certainly a sense that the sacrifices of the Great War entitled all
Canadians to greater security and care. There was an interesting bridge to cross here, one that took Canadians
from a society of families, through the atomistic society of individuals, to a vision of Canada as a social state.
Not socialist as yet, but the cost of two World Wars and one enormous economic Depression changed peoples
expectations.

Imagine someone just old enough in 1914 to enlist or to replace a militia volunteer at their position in a factory
or shipyard. Boys and girls of 15 born just before the turn of the century were part of that particular cohort.
Some of them saw war; Canadas substantial mortalities in Europe would ensure that many would never return
home. Those who did, however, and assuming they survived the 1918 influenza pandemic as well, would reach
their 20th birthday in the year of the Winnipeg General Strike perhaps while the Canadian Siberian Expedi-
tionary Force was providing a small backstop for the anti-Bolshevik forces in eastern Russia. Theyd live through
a brief economic depression before the economy began to recover in earnest. Prohibition would come and go,
women would enjoy unprecedented and expanding legal rights, and then, just as their work lives were getting
well underway, the worst economic downturn in the history of capitalism would hit them. The whole of the 1930s
this cohorts own 30s would see the economic advances of the pre-war years and what recovery there was
in the 1920s blow away in dust. If they werent married before 1929, they were less likely to marry in the next
decade than any generation of 30-somethings in Canadian history. If they were too young to fight in the Great
War they might well prove too old to fight in the Second World War. From adolescents to middle-aged adults, the
Canada they knew was almost constantly in a state of crisis.

Does this generation matter? Given the number of young immigrant couples who arrived between 1891 and 1911,
they certainly do. The birth rate a pre-WWI baby boom created a generation of Canadians that was too
young to know the certainties of the Victorian era, too young to know a Canada that wasnt already ethnically
diverse, and old enough to grow both cautious of and eager for, change.

1. John Herd Thompson with Allen Seager, Canada, 1922-1939: Decades of Discord (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1986).

256
 6.1 INTRODUCTION 257

Learning Objectives

Explain and describe Canadas involvement in the two World Wars.

Assess the impact of both wars on Canadian society and economy.
Describe the domestic social, economic, and political changes that took place between 1914 and
1945.
Account for and list the significant changes in the status of women in this period.
Outline the experience of Japanese-Canadians and Aboriginal people in wartime.
6.2 Borden vs. Borden

Figure 6.1 The Bordens at sea, 1912.

While Macdonald took Canada to war in its own territory and allowed a party of adventurers to join the Nile Cam-
paign, and while Laurier was Canadas first PM in global wartime, the commitment involved and the investment
of resources in Red River, Saskatchewan, or in Africa, was insignificant compared to what followed in 1914-18.
The toll on lives was much greater as well.

So, too, was its impact on Canadian political culture. When Robert Borden took on the role of Prime Minister after
the 1911 election, he was a sharp contrast with his predecessor in at least one regard: he was not a compromiser.
Speaking to an election gathering in Winnipeg in September 1911, he articulated his position on freer trade with
the United States: I am absolutely opposed to reciprocity and if the West were prepared to make me Prime Min-
ister tomorrow, if I would support that policy, I would not do it. Reciprocity, he claimed, would not only weaken
Canadian industry and the Dominions economy as a whole; it would lead to American annexation and the loss of
a whole way of life. It wasnt just a trade deal, as far as Borden was concerned it was a catastrophe.

Many of the other things Borden believed in were comparably solid and unflinching. Before 1916, there was little
to suggest that he supported womens suffrage, even though his wife, Laura Bond (1861-1940), was the Presi-
dent of the Local Council of Women of Halifax, a pro-suffrage organization. Theres even less to indicate that
he sought prohibition of liquor, despite or perhaps because of the strident teetotalism of Minister of Mili-
tia Sam Hughes. Borden was an imperialist throughout his career and his partys position on the Naval Service
Bill was very clear: he would rather build up the British Navy than sponsor a Canadian tinpot navy. And, sig-
nificantly, when the war started he was staunchly opposed to conscription.

But, and this is where he gets interesting, it was Borden who challenged Canadas subordinate role in the Empire
and paved the way to full-blown autonomy in the 1920s and 30s. It was also Borden who gave women the vote
(albeit under peculiar circumstances and in a tremendously cynical way). It was Borden who forged links with
Liberals to create a Union Government in wartime. It was Borden who brought in prohibition and it was Borden
who introduced conscription. The ways in which he achieved his goals have been routinely condemned by histori-

258
 6.2 BORDEN VS. BORDEN 259

ans but the fact remains that Borden unlike some politicians of the era demonstrated a profound willingness
to change direction.

Key Points

Robert Bordens term as prime minister witnessed extensive challenges to deeply entrenched policy
positions and social attitudes.

Attributions
Figure 6.1
Rt. Hon. and Mrs. Robert L. Borden aboard S.S. ROYAL GEORGE en route to England (Online MIKAN
no.3191880) by Library and Archives Canada / C-017778 is in the public domain.
 6.3 The Great War

Figure 6.2 Are we Afraid? NO! A 1915 cartoon captures the

spirit of the Imperial war and the Canadian Imperialists view of
the larger world.

Insofar as there is any truth to the old line that generals are always ready to fight the last war, the Boer War had a
disastrous influence on Canada as well as on Britain. The idea that a 20th century campaign in Europe could be
conducted with cavalry, with glory, and with few casualties was to prove a nonsense. The martial spirit that was
inspired by the adventures of Sam Steele and his peers in 1899-1900 paired up with 19th century enthusiasms for
muscular Christianity to produce a decade of jingoism.

These passions had social consequences. Fears of racial degeneration and the weakening of industrial workers by
poor conditions and suboptimal diets created room for a perceived crisis in national readiness. It is no coincidence
that this was the era that produced the Boy Scout (or Scouting) movement under the leadership of a British offi-
cer and veteran of the South Africa campaigns, Robert Baden-Powell. Self-discipline, child discipline, and mili-
tary-like organization became more widely valued and promoted across Canadian society, even in Quebec, where
1
cadet training enjoyed particular popularity. There was resistance to these attitudes the Industrial Workers of
the World (see Section 3.6) declared paramilitary organizations, including the Boy Scouts, anathema. And the
persistent division between francophones and anglophones over the issues of imperialism and nationalism (see
Section 4.5) had the potential to turn further international conflicts into a national disaster. Beginning in 1870 at
Red River, through the North-West Rebellion and the Boer War, taking up arms meant straining the very fabric of
the Canadian project. What was to come in 1914 would test it further still.

The Imperial War Effort

Economic and imperial tensions between Germany and its chief competitors France and Britain produced
a spiders web of alliances and promises that entwined almost every nation in Europe and a few in Asia as well.
The Triple Alliance (Germany, the Austro-Hungarian Empire, and Italy) was balanced off by the Triple Entente
(France, Britain, and Russia). An attack against one member would result in the other partners defending its inter-

1. Desmond Morton, A Military History of Canada, 5th edition (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 2007), 123.

260
 6.3 THE GREAT WAR 261

ests. There were also secondary alliances, such as Britains with Belgium. So long as fear of the balance of power
was greater than enthusiasm for war, peace would hold. In the meantime, it was easy to imagine someone making
a misstep.

This happened on 28 June 1914 when the Austrian Archduke, Franz Ferdinand, was assassinated by a Serbian
nationalist, Gavrilo Princip. A bubbling crisis in the Balkans (coveted by Austria, protected by Russia) erupted,
and by 4 August all the major powers in Europe were at war. The bullet that Princip put into the Archduke, how-
ever, was only a proximate cause. There were many others involved and historians continue to debate which were
most important. For Canada in the summer of 1914, only one catalyst existed: Britain was at war, so Canada was
as well.

A great many Canadians were thrilled. The build up to the war had been ongoing for nearly two decades and
marginal wars had been fought around the colonial edges of Africa and Asia. A continental war would settle the
issue of imperial dominance once and for all and would put paid to further colonial sideshows. What is more, the
economy in Canada had started to sour in 1912 and war was reckoned to be good for business. While Nationalists
in Quebec might decry Canadas involvement, constitutionally there was no question that Britains decision to go
to war made the choice for the Dominion as well.

Figure 6.3 Its all a great adventure until you get to the trenches.
Enthusiastic crowds turn out to see troops depart Hamilton in
1914. Few likely suspected that this was going to be a war of
attrition and not glory.

Was Canada ready? The Naval Services Act that brought Lauriers defeat in 1911 was scrapped after the election,
and any plans for a Canadian Navy went with it. Worse, Bordens effort to secure $35 million to pay for the con-
struction of three dreadnought-class warships was blocked in the Senate. Now Canada had neither a Navy nor
could it reasonably claim to have contributed to building up Britains. The militia was in better shape. In 1898
it had a budget of only $1.6 million, a budget that, under Laurier, increased to $7 million. Then, on the eve of
2
war, Borden raised it to $11 million. There were slightly more than 74,000 men in the various regiments but only
3,110 in the permanent force. This was still an amateurs army, not a professional standing army, but the Canadian
offer to Britain of 25,000 men under arms was regarded as a bold demonstration of imperial loyalty. Bordens
administration took the exceptional step of introducing the War Measures Act, 1914, which extended wide-reach-
ing powers to the federal government for the duration of the war. These included the ability to suspend civil rights
and thus enabled the arbitrary internment of enemy aliens. It was not, however, meant to extend the life of the
government, although Borden would use the circumstances of war to avoid going back to the polls in 1916.

The war, of course, did not play out according to the bombastic script provided by Imperialists. A few quick
advances in 1914 were followed by stalemates along Germanys western and eastern frontiers. The German
attempt to outflank French troops by marching through Belgium brought British forces into play in northwestern
Europe. By the spring of 1915, German forces were quite literally entrenched. The Canadian Expeditionary
Force (CEF) arrived just in time in March 1915 to see the beginnings of an unprecedented war of attrition.

2. Desmond Morton, A Military History of Canada, 5th edition (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 2007), 127.
262 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

A month later, the Germans deployed chemical weapons for the first time and Canadians were among the regi-
ments hit hardest at Ypres. From that moment until the end of the war, the Western Front moved one way and then
the other, but without any real result other than massive mortalities.

The conditions that led to the bloodbath that was the Western Front, were many. The terrain was impenetrable:
irrigation and drainage dykes in the Low Countries gave away under shelling, burst their banks, and turned the
farm fields to gumbo. Canadian equipment particularly the Ross Rifle was inadequate and came in for a
great deal of criticism. An innovation that made ranching possible across the Canadian Prairies barbed wire
was now deployed against Canadian farm boys (and they used it as well against the enemy). Cavalry charges
were, of course, out of the question but aerial bombardment wasnt. The American Wright Brothers were quick
to weaponize and market their flying invention to each European state and both sides of the war now had to face
machine guns on the ground and in the air. The Germans, stretched to their limit on two fronts, relied on technol-
ogy to make up the difference: hence their decision to use banned chemical gasses as early as 1915.

Chance made matters worse. The weather didnt cooperate: it was an outstandingly wet, cold, and miserable cou-
ple of years. The trenches in which the Entente forces found themselves pinned were saturated with rain and field
water; muddy collapses and horrible deaths were inevitable. Although ceasefires allowed for some casualties and
mortalities to be recovered, shelling reduced many soldiers to ground meat. Latrine facilities were severely want-
ing; hygiene was dreadful and infection was rampant. Trenchfoot plagued soldiers whose boots were far from
waterproof. Well-fed rats of legendary size terrorized the troops. Mental health was not a consideration at the time
and attempts to run away to desert were typically met with a firing squad. This was grisly stuff and it would
produce a great many physically and psychologically maimed veterans.

Figure 6.4 The Battle of Vimy Ridge was painted by the

Canadian war artist, Richard Jack (1866-1952). Although, for the
first time, motion pictures brought combat to screens, oils on
large canvases were still a compelling vision of the first total war.

Canadian regiments accomplished a great deal against tremendous odds. The Ypres campaign hardened troops and
tested officers. Canadian leaders resisted British attempts to take over their regiments and developed an effective
strategy of practice and rehearsal that led to unexpected victories. The most noteworthy was at Vimy Ridge in
the northeast of France. The hilltop offered the German artillery an ideal cover for shelling Entente positions and,
of course, the best view of their enemies in this lowland terrain. The French Army had sustained astronomical
casualties in their attempts to capture Vimy; it is reckoned that in excess of 150,000 French troops died on this
one battleground. The British tried their hand at it from February to May 1916 under the command of Lieutenant-
General Sir Julian Byng (1862-1935), with little success. At the end of the British assault, Byng took command of
the Canadian Corps. (His connection with the CEF was one reason why Byng was subsequently made Canadas
governor general.)

Byngs earlier experiences were valuable here and his tactics did much to shape this important chapter in Canadian
military history.
 6.3 THE GREAT WAR 263

Figure 6.5 The Canadians sharpened their pre-assault plans using

scale models of the battlefields like this one of the trenches
northwest of Lens, autumn 1918. The small sign in the middle
indicates No Mans Land.

Byng brought together for the first time the four Canadian divisions. Nearly 100,000 Canadians were
involved in the campaign, aided by British artillery units. A year of planning, punctuated with vicious trench-
raids, produced an assault that began on the 9th of April 1917 and was complete on the 12th. The Canadians had
accomplished what the French and the British could not. To be fair, the Canadians would not have overcome the
German obstacles without the hard-won intelligence gathered by the earlier assaults. But the battle resonated at
the time as a Canadian victory and the adage began to circulate soon thereafter that Canada went up the ridge a
colony and came down a nation.

In August 1918, Canadian troops were once again involved in a major push, but the course of the war was already
decided. The Americans entered the fray as the Canadians were taking Vimy; by the time the Entente turned its
guns on German positions east of Amiens, there were half a million fresh American troops in the field. Demoral-
ized, exhausted, and fooled into thinking an attack was not coming, the German troops were overrun by a tightly
organized Canadian attack that was part of another, larger venture involving at least four nations. The effect was
to crack German resolve, which ultimately led to the Armistice of 11 November 1918, after which treaty negoti-
ations got underway. The impact of peace and the Treaty of Versailles on Germany goes beyond the purview of
this narrative but it is important to note that it embittered a great many and set the stage for political and social
unrest that sharpened an appetite for further war a generation later.

Key Points

The expectation on the eve of the Great War was that it would be brief and that Canada would enter
on the side of Britain without debate.
Some Canadians welcomed the outbreak of war insofar as it might stimulate the economy and
reduce the likelihood of further colonial wars.
Most politicians and many military leaders badly misunderstood the kind of war with which they
were faced. As a result, mortality rates were shockingly high.
Canadian victories at Vimy Ridge and Amiens contributed to the growth of national self-confidence
and a post-Imperial identity.

Attributions
Figure 6.2
Are we Afraid? NO! (cartoon) (HS85-10-29954) by the British Library is in the public domain.
264 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 6.3
Off to the front, World War I (WWI) soldiers leaving Hamilton, Ont. from Grand Trunk Railway (G.T.R.). Stu-
art St. Station (Online MIKAN no. 3277194) by Andrew Merrilees / Library and Archives Canada is in the
public domain.

Figure 6.4
The Battle of Vimy Ridge (Online MIKAN no.2837452) by Richard Jack / Library and Archives Canada is in
the public domain.

Figure 6.5
Model reproduction of German lines N.W. of Lens (Online MIKAN no.3397952) by Canada. Dept. of National
Defence / Library and Archives Canada is in the public domain.
 6.4 Assessing Canadas War

Figure 6.6 Beginning in the 1920s, cenotaphs began to crop up

across Canada to memorialize the fallen of the Great War.
Vancouver, ca. 1924.

The British historian, Arthur Marwick, contributed to the study of 20th century war a model for assessing its
impact. Total war, in military terms meant targeting factories and food production, and not just enemy armies.
It meant, in that regard, that civilians who were supporting the enemy were legitimate targets as well. This was
a change in military practice, especially in terms of the scale of casualties and damage that industrialized forces
could inflict. Marwick took this understanding of war and modified it so that total described the engagement of
1
the whole nation in the conflict. Whether manifest in rationing, industrial employment, limitations on civil free-
doms, or its impact on culture, 20th century wars have swept along far more than armies and munitions plants,
even in Canada.

Marwicks Principle looked at the changes wrought by war and measured them in four ways. First, there is what
he called the extent of destruction involved, which can include the burning out of factory machines, the loss of
productive capacity, and very definitely the loss of human life and ability. Second, there is the level of participa-
tion in a wartime society; Marwick pointed to instances where participation increases (women working in facto-
ries, getting the vote) and where it decreases (foreign-born Canadians thrown into internment camps), although he
mainly shows how going through that change in participation levels can result in post-war changes in engagement,
too. Third, and this pertains very definitely to the enormity of the human waste involved in industrialized warfare,
there is the psychological impact, including the ways in which it challenges pre-war ways of thinking. Finally,
there is war as a test. Total war is a crucible through which armies and ideas, systems, and values pass. Some
survive intact, others prove wanting and are either reformed or they are allowed to die away. How did Canada fare
in its first Total War?

Destruction and Loss

61,000 Canadians dead. Over 170,000 wounded. Newfoundland contributed an additional 1,305 dead and still

1. Arthur Marwick, Britain in the Century of Total War (London: Little, Brown, 1968).

265
 266 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

more casualties. Twenty Canadians were shot by firing squads for the crime of desertion and another 180 con-
demned men were spared execution. There wasnt much glory in this conflict, although Canadians seized upon the
victories at Vimy and Passchendaele as symbols of national maturation, a culture of toughness, and indefatigable
resolve. Certainly, the armed forces were forced to grow up. The militia-based model that Sam Hughes champi-
oned from 1911 to 1916 gave way to a more professional version. Borden promised grateful Britain 25,000 troops
in the summer of 1914; by Armistice there were more than 600,000 men and women enlisted.

The fact that this took place under the auspices of the War Measures Act is significant. Canada went to war to
defend liberal democratic values against what was characterized as a dictatorial Prussian militarism and, along
the way, Ottawa stripped civil liberties from many, directed the militarizing of much of the economy, and intro-
duced compulsory service. Also, income tax was introduced as a temporary measure. Elements of the growing
role of the state could be seen, as well, in the economy as Canadas modest demand-led economy gave way to a
command-led model, in which the state became the principal client of manufacturing. Able to influence the flow
of raw materials and to specify the character of output, Ottawa built up what it regarded as the essential sectors
while implicitly starving others.

There was, by wars end, a Royal Canadian Navy (albeit a very small one). Canadian fighter pilots distinguished
themselves in the air most notably William Billy Bishop (with 72 victories) and Raymond Collishaw (with
60) and thereby established the foundations of a Canadian Air Force. By 1918, errors made by British leaders
in London and in the field also contributed to a stronger sense of a Canadian identity.

Participation
The trade depression that began in 1912 showed no sign of recovery by the end of 1914. Had the war been as brief
as touted in the press and by politicians, the economy would have hardly felt its impact. Through 1915, however,
demand for production increased, soldiers in the CEF created job opportunities as they departed for the Western
Front. By 1916 the search for workers meant that women, in particular, were finding employment in factories and
offices.

Internment camps for enemy aliens were used to contain recent immigrants whose loyalties were questioned by
xenophobic Canadians. Some were opened in the Rocky Mountains, where internees spent the war building much
2
of the campsite infrastructure of the national parks. Given that most of the internees were drawn from a popula-
tion that had been in Canada less than twenty years, their detention can be seen as an expression of nativism and
an indication of just how thin the Canadian welcome mat really was.

Aboriginal peoples participation in the war has also attracted comment. As Scott Sheffield writes, First Nations
that historically honoured warriors viewed the conflict as an opportunity to reinvigorate such traditions. (See
Section 6.12 below.) Aboriginal Canadians were welcomed into the ranks and some 200 Chinese Canadians vol-
unteered and were accepted for service. In sharp contrast, African Canadians were not permitted to serve.

Test
Voluntarism was possibly the most profoundly polarizing issue for Canada from 1914-1918. Initial enthusiasm

2. Bill Waiser, Park Prisoners: The Untold Story of Western Canadas National Parks, 1915-1946 (Saskatoon: Fifth House, 1995).
 6.4 ASSESSING CANADAS WAR 267

saw Bordens request for 25,000 troops surpassed by another 10,000 volunteers. As a proportion, English Canada
was over represented. Given the long-standing, inward-looking nationalism of Quebecs most prominent states-
men, English-Canadians assumed that French-Canadians generally were cool on the war. There was some mea-
sure of truth to this. While many English-Canadians could be rallied, from time to time, with calls for loyal
support of the Imperial homeland, French-Canadians were typically less enthusiastic (Lauriers ready, aye ready
notwithstanding). Nor did French-Canadians have a profound affection for France. One hundred and fifty years
had passed since the Conquest and more than a century since the French Revolution. The status of the Catholic
Church and clergy in France was very different from its position in Quebec, something that Canadien priests had
been pointing out for the whole of the 19th century. The whole ultramontanist movement in Quebec was a rebuke
to French secularism. German attacks on France, therefore, did not automatically strike a deep chord of sympathy
in Quebec.

The strong nationaliste strain in Quebec was opposed to supporting Britains war. Whats more, it could point to
intolerance in Ontario as something worth fighting that didnt entail going overseas. Ontario introduced severe
limits on French-language instruction in 1912-1913 with Regulation 17. Borden managed to deflect responsibility
to the provincial level where even the Irish Catholic bishop was siding with the Anglo-Protestants to end French
instruction. French-Canadians were outraged and the Quebec MPs in Bordens caucus pleaded with him to inter-
vene. Huge delegations descended on Ottawa to the same end. Borden could reasonably (and probably correctly)
claim that the constitution was clear that education was a provincial matter. Whats more, Lauriers experience
with Manitoba could be invoked: attempting disallowance was likely to be fruitless. But Lauriers actions sug-
gested, too, that there was room to pursue negotiation and to plead for some symbolic act of generosity from the
provincial legislature in Queens Park. The Franco-Ontarian minority was alienated from the Tories as a result of
Bordens inaction but their votes counted for little.

Regulation 17 had wider consequences, though. Had the issue been resolved by August 1914, Regulation 17 might
have been of little consequence, but it festered well into 1915 and kept crawling out of its grave in the 1920s.
It turned feeling in Quebec very sharply against Ontario. Qubecois disinterest in military voluntarism and hos-
tility to conscription may not have been shaped by Regulation 17 but it was certainly scented with it. When, in
the course of the Great War, attempts to amend the law met with unyielding resistance from Anglo-Canadians,
Henri Bourassa decried the Prussians of Ontario, a reference to the German enemy. What values, then, would
a Qubecois volunteer be defending in the CEF? This question was asked by French-Canadians who saw Anglo-
Canadian aspirations for autonomy and true national status as bound up in intolerance and assimilationism.

Recruitment efforts in Quebec were a further contributing factor. The province was home to many of the nations
war industries so there was work to be had and wages to be earned. Recruitment into a volunteer army failed to
address that fact. Whats more, Hughes efforts in Quebec were notoriously clumsy. There was only one French-
speaking battalion the 22nd (aka: the Vingt-Deux or Van Doos) and precious few Francophone command-
ing officers. Hughes would trot out the usual paraphernalia of imperial patriotism but Red tunics and the Union
3
Jack worked in Orillia, not Victoriaville.

Setting all that aside, English-Canadian voluntarism deserves a second look. The two decades before the war
witnessed huge migrations of British men and women to all parts of Canada. They were vastly over-represented
in the ranks of volunteers in 1914-16, just as they are in the list of Canadian Victoria Crosses. It goes some

3. Desmond Morton, A Military History of Canada, 5th edition (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 2007), 123.
 268 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

distance to explain why British Columbia with only 5% of Canadas population contributed 10% of its war
4
dead. Once the excitement of August 1914 had dissipated and once it was clear that the boys would not be
home by Christmas, Canadian-born English-Canadians coast-to-coast demonstrated a level of voluntarism that
was roughly comparable to that of French-Canadians. Some could legitimately claim to be part of the essential
industries that fed a total war campaign: farming, factories, and transport. Maritimers who had few factories on
which the war effort depended were particularly unwilling to join up, which may suggest that deeper Canadian
roots were hardest to pull up. English-Canadians who resolved not to be drawn into the war were often targeted
as cowards. Shaming campaigns were part of the recruiters arsenal and there were instances where white feathers
symbols of cowardice were handed out by young women to men of service age who were reluctant to join
up. None of this not the statistics nor the campaigns of shame served to diminish attacks in the press on
French-Canadian disloyalty. With an army of half a million, and no more than 13,000 of them francophones, the
issue was bound to attract attention and it poisoned relations between Anglo- and Franco-Canadians for decades.

Figure 6.7 Women from Africville walk towards Halifax on

Campbell Road, days after the explosion of the SS Mont Blanc in
Halifax harbour on 6 December 1917.

Figure 6.7 The explosion of the SS Mont Blanc in Halifax

Harbour on 6 December 1917, cost 2,000 lives and 10,000
injuries. The ship was carrying munitions when struck at low
speed by another vessel, caught fire, and produced the largest
pre-nuclear explosion on record. Windows throughout the city
were blown out and much of the centre of Halifax was levelled.

War profiteering was another divisive feature of the war years. Corruption was rife. It dogged the career of Sam
Hughes, whose teetotal morality was in sharp contrast to a caustic and bullying approach to colleagues and staff.
His defense of the Ross Rifle fine for target shooting but useless if fired repeatedly was more about Hughes
preference for Canadian manufacturers than it was for military utility. Hughes followed a well-documented prac-
tice of securing posts and contracts for friends and families. His son-in-law was one beneficiary but the worst
revelations came in the munitions scandals of 1916. These were errors on which the opposition and the labour
movement both pounced. In November 1916 Borden obtained Hughes resignation.

Psychology
Comparing levels of deference from one generation to the next is always fraught with problems. The environments
in which one group defers to another change and so the sentiment may no longer be relevant. Having said that,

4. John Douglas Belshaw, Becoming British Columbia: A Population History (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2009), 172.
 6.4 ASSESSING CANADAS WAR 269

several changes in the mindset of Canadians took place between the Edwardian years of Laurier and the roaring
twenties.

Canadians understanding of the state was profoundly changed by the war. The War Measures Act enabled far
more direct and widespread intervention by Ottawa than had been the case before. Some of this was decidedly
temporary but it exposed the possibility of state participation in the economy and in social welfare. At the end of
the war Ottawa owed $2 billion almost all of it to Canadians who had purchased Victory Bonds. The begin-
nings of the welfare state could be seen in 1918; in the 1920s veterans widows and veterans themselves would
receive some state monies while, at the same time, mothers allowances made an appearance.

Figure 6.8 John McCraes poem was first published in December

1915 and, to use a 21st century phrase anachronistically, it went
viral almost immediately thereafter. Here, two lines are deployed
in the service of Victory Bonds.

Canadian anticlericalism the belief that the church and state should be kept at arms length was always tem-
pered by a loyalty to the congregation, sect, denomination, and chapel. Religious affiliation was, to Victorians and
Edwardians, as powerful a representational quality as team sports would be in the late 20th century (see Sections
10.6, 10.16, 10.17). Religion provided a sense of belonging and community, and a common language of hymns
and rituals. The Great War tested to destruction the faith of a great many Canadians (and others) and opened the
possibility of seeking spiritual succour through newer and more dynamic evangelical creeds. The rising popularity
of spiritualism before the war picked up momentum and delivered into the 1920s a generation that was prepared to
5
explore eastern religions, other faiths, and the possibility of communication with spirits. William Lyon Macken-
zie King, Canadians learned long after his death, was but one of many highly-placed Canadians who hoped that
spiritual mediums could do for the dead what the telephone did for terrestrial voices (see Mackenzie Kings
Secret Life in Section 9.5).

Patriarchal values did not collapse but they were sorely challenged. Womens increased economic independence,
their experience of employed work in factories (and in the public sphere generally during the war) all contribute
6
to the creation of what historian Veronica Strong-Boag describes as girls and women of the new day. The war
inflated the incidence of widowhood in the interwar years; single mothers were commonplace in a way that they
had not been in Lauriers day. This meant, of course, that orphanhood the loss of at least one parent was
more widely experienced by Canadians whose fathers perished in combat or at sea. It is true that the business
world was effectively closed to women and that the doors of politics were open only a crack, but the need to find
work and the need to find workers in the growing economy of the 1920s was bound to change womens experi-
ences and challenge the pre-war beliefs about the pater familias.

The war changed labours relationship with elites in several countries. In Russia, this produced revolutionary com-

5. For one account of the European response, see Jay Winter, Sites of Memory, Sites of Mourning: The Great War in European Cultural History
(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2014).
6. Veronica Strong-Boag, The New Day Recalled: Lives of Girls and Women in English Canada, 1919-1939 (Toronto: Copp Clark Pitman,
1988).
 270 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

munism. Western nations had good reason to fear that it would not end there. In the Victorian era, Canadian militia
units were dominated by affluent young men who could afford the time to play soldier. The trenches of France and
Belgium, however, were filled with farm boys and wage-labourers whose lives were sacrificed wholesale. The
commander of the Canadian corps at Passchendaele, Sir Arthur Currie, demonstrated a chillingly accurate assess-
ment of what victory would cost when he estimated that it would require 16,000 Canadian lives; he overestimated
by 346. The scale of sacrifice demanded of this new kind of conflict threw into question class assumptions that
had evolved through the industrial revolution. For some, a more democratic society in the sense of one that was
less hierarchical and automatically deferential was what was called for. For others, nothing short of a social and
political revolution was in order. Farmers, long the bedrock of Canadian political parties, broke with the Liberals
and Conservatives and formed their own parties (see Section 7.9).

If the institutions of state, church, household, and industrial capitalism were challenged in ways that are some-
times difficult to measure, the tone of Canadas relationship with Britain was much more visible. From Bordens
demand for greater input in war planning, through the Imperial War Cabinet, the Balfour Declaration of 1926,
and the Statute of Westminster, 1931, the trend toward greater national autonomy and independence was clear. It is
difficult to imagine Laurier in 1906 insisting, as Mackenzie King could in 1926, that Canada was equal in status
with Britain. Nor would Mackenzie King declare in 1922, as Laurier did a mere decade earlier, that the call to
support Britain in the Chanak Crisis found Canada ready, aye, ready. Canadian affection for Britain strong,
weak, and mixed may not have changed but deference to Mother England was no longer an easy pill for any
but the most ardent Imperialist to swallow.

The Peace Dividend

The writer Lucy Maud Montgomery was troubled by the changes she saw taking place in Canadian society as the
war marched on. On 17 June 1916 she wrote, Our old world is passed away forever and I fear that those of
7
us who have lived half our span therein will never feel wholly at home in the new. Canada was in many ways
changed by the war. Rank British imperialism gave way to a distinctive Canadian nationalism; womens roles
changed as they moved into the public sphere and into the polling stations; technology advanced dramatically and,
with it, war became something in which there was little glory, only gore.

Bordens experience charts some of the nations changes. An imperialist at the start of the war, he emerged a
nationalist. His quiet frustration with British commanders and the condescension they displayed toward the Cana-
dian troops was certainly a factor. Westminsters implicit belief that the colonies should contribute resources and
men without strings attached was bearable when Britain looked effective and honourable. Thereafter from
1916, at any rate Borden became an increasingly vocal advocate for Canadas place at the table of nations.
In the spring of 1917, British Prime Minister David Lloyd George responded to Canadian complaints by includ-
ing the Dominions (Newfoundland, Canada, South Africa, Australia, New Zealand) in the Imperial War Cabinet.
Canada joined in the peace negotiations in Paris, although its presence was largely for show. Nevertheless, it was
an important step along a road to greater autonomy, as was Bordens successful plea to have Canada eligible for
8
election to the council of the League of Nations. While this was unfolding, Borden embraced womens suffrage,

7. Quoted in Mary Henley Rubio, Lucy Maud Montgomery: The Gift of Wings (Toronto: Doubleday Canada, 2011), 204.
8. The United States was prevailed upon by Britain to recognize the Dominions as separate entities from the Imperial centre, possibly the most
significant symbolic gesture of all.
 6.4 ASSESSING CANADAS WAR 271

deficit spending, an interventionist role for government, and prohibition. These were extraordinary moves taken
by a Conservative PM from whom one might not have imagined possible a decade earlier.

Borden retired from office undefeated in 1920. Laurier died in office the year before. Both the Liberal and Con-
servative parties were thereafter headed by men who were much younger and whose feet were planted firmly in
the 20th century. For two decades, however, Laurier and Borden had wrestled, in their own ways, with issues
of nationalism and imperialism. The former was inclined to a nationaliste perspective but pronounced strongly
(sometimes strategically) on the side of imperialism. The latter was a dyed-in-the-wool imperialist who became a
champion of Canada as an autonomous nation. As the short 20th century opened and the modern era got more
fully underway, the goalposts of Victorian and Edwardian Canada were not merely moved they disappeared
from view.

Key Points

The concept of total war encourages us to examine the various levels at which Canada experienced
and was changed by the Great War.
Mortality rates ran to more than 61,000 Canadians and Newfoundlanders.
The federal state became more interventionist and directly involved in the economy.
The war divided Canadian society in many ways but especially on the issue of conscription.
Many values and relationships that were seemingly permanent before 1914 turned out to be change-
able and, in some cases, disposable.

Attributions
Figure 6.6
CVA 99-1477 [Cenotaph and Victory Square looking south] by Thompson Stuart / City of Vancouver
Archives is in the public domain.

Figure 6.7
Women walking from Africville, 1917 by James & Son is in the public domain. with no known copyright
restrictions. This image is available from the Nova Scotia Archives.

Figure 6.8
If ye break faith, we shall not sleep : buy victory bonds by John McCrae is in the public domain. This image is
available from the Toronto Public Library under the call number 1914-18. Victory bonds. Item 1. L.
 6.5 Suffrage and Prohibition

Womens Suffrage
Objections to women having the vote federally, provincially, and municipally were many. Keeping in mind
that the right to vote was closely tied in the 19th century to property ownership and that womens legal right
to own property was significantly circumscribed, one of two changes needed to take place in Canadian society.
Women had to have improved access to property ownership and/or that requirement had to be mitigated, if not
eliminated. In the 1870s, working mens campaigns for the vote did much to reduce the strength of the property
issue but it was not eliminated entirely. At the municipal level, female property owners (who were, thus, civic
taxpayers) started gaining the vote in the mid-19th century. Although the laws permitted these women to vote, the
1
culture which viewed landownership through a patriarchal lens didnt help. The womens franchise stalled
at this point, needing another issue to activate it as a movement.

Enthusiasm for womens suffrage in the post-Confederation era was catalyzed by experiences of women in pro-
temperance organizations (see Section 7.5). By 1900, the early feminists were campaigning on two fronts: the
end of alcohol sales and the start of female enfranchisement. Increasingly at the turn of the century, the move-
ment was influenced by what many middle- and upper-class women regarded as the pernicious effect on Canadian
society of new immigrants. Many newcomers were raised in cultures where consuming alcohol did not carry the
moral stigma that was often found in Anglo-Celtic societies. What is more, many of the newcomers were quickly
made into property-owners and that meant that the men among them enjoyed electoral rights that were not avail-
able to French- and English-Canadian women whose family roots perhaps ran very deep in Canada. Increasingly,
maternal feminists (including Nellie McClung) framed the suffrage issue in nativist terms: Canadian society faced
degeneration by foreign arrivals and only Canadian-born women, they argued, could offset that influence.

Figure 6.9 Nellie McClung, early 20th

century feminist.

1. Veronica Strong-Boag, 'The Citizenship Debates: The 1885 Franchise Act, in Contesting Canadian Citizenship: Historical Readings, eds.
Robert Adamoski, Dorothy E. Chunn and Robert Menzies (Peterborough: Broadview Press, 2002): 72-3.

272
 6.5 SUFFRAGE AND PROHIBITION 273

There were powerful cultural themes that stood in the way of women getting the vote, too, and these should not
be ignored. It was seen as unfeminine by some, immoral by others, and unnecessary by many. In a patriarchal
culture with a pronounced division between the private and public sphere, an invitation to women to leave the
safety of the former for the (oft-claimed) rough-and-tumble of the latter was to put their very womanhood at risk.
Politics, it was claimed, was about moral compromises and if, as the maternal feminists declared, women were
the uncompromising moral bedrock of the community, then the two should not mix. Finally, so long as fathers,
husbands, brothers, and sons executed their electoral rights responsibly, the democratic interests of women were
looked after. To some commentators it seemed unthinkable that a woman would vote differently from her husband
and, therefore, her vote would simply duplicate his without changing electoral outcomes. It was, therefore, redun-
dant.

This is where the battle against liquor comes back in. Getting the vote was increasingly seen as the way to achieve
prohibition. Husbands and other male relations might not support prohibition and so this was clearly an area where
household voting patterns might prove to be starkly different.

The western provinces took the lead in the debate about enfranchising women. Manitoba gave women the right to
vote provincially in January 1916; Saskatchewan followed in March, and British Columbia and Alberta in April,
as did Ontario. Electoral law at the time meant that the provinces standards were imposed on Ottawa too. Borden
sought to retrieve control of this situation and to use it to his advantage under the Wartime Elections Act, 1917.

The circumstances for and conditions behind this extension of the franchise were both a departure from the tone
of the suffrage movement to that point in time and consistent with some of its premises. By 1917 it was clear that
voluntarism was not going to be enough to meet Canadas military commitment in Europe. Conscription was the
logical next step but Bordens government was loath to impose it on a divided country. Opposition to conscription
in Quebec was vocal and there was less and less enthusiasm for it nationwide. As Bordens biographer writes,

Potential recruits [in 1916] had a choice not open to many in 1914 and early 1915 when unemployment had reached seri-
ous levels: there was a very dangerous job available at $1.10 a day in France and another at unprecedented wages in the
2
home-front war economy.

Borden had to act and he had three goals: get a fresh mandate, win on the conscription issue, and manage womens
suffrage. Elected in 1911, he should have returned to the polls by 1916. Making the argument that Canada was
too busy facing a national emergency to pause for a divisive election, Borden sailed through 1916 and into 1917.
He could not, however, unilaterally and without the legitimacy of a new mandate force compulsory enlistment on
Canadians. The conscription issue thus forced his hand: he would have to go to the polls.

Figure 6.10 The conscription election of 1917 at the front. A

vote against the Government means You are here for life

The forces arrayed against conscription and thus against the Borden government were extensive. French-

2. Robert Craig Brown, BORDEN, Sir ROBERT LAIRD, in Dictionary of Canadian Biography, vol. 16, University of Toronto/Universit Laval, 2003,
accessed 6 November 2015, [Link]
 274 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Canadians were strongly opposed, most of the Liberal Party saw conscription as Bordens soft underbelly, and
immigrants who had achieved citizenship (as British subjects) included many from Germany and Austro-Hun-
gary. Borden (and many feminists) reasoned that immigrants had a vested interest in ensuring that Canada did
not send reinforcements to the front. The Wartime Elections Act gave the vote not to all women but to some: to
women who were related to men serving in the CEF. Borden was calculating that this select group of women
would support conscription to provide support for their men abroad. Simultaneously, the Act disenfranchised nat-
uralized immigrant Canadians as though they were all enemy aliens. It also allowed soldiers votes to be assigned
to constituencies where they would most help the pro-conscription Conservative cause. This was, without a doubt,
the most cynical feature of the new Elections Act, and it was used to topple Liberal candidates where anti-con-
scription sentiment was strong but beatable.

Bordens government, now augmented by a handful of Liberals and recast as a Union government, was returned
easily. However, the 1917 election soured Qubecois voters against the Conservatives for nearly 70 years; there
was nothing left now of the old Cartier-Macdonald pact. Conversely, it solidified Liberal support in Quebec and
created a political bedrock for much of the 20th century.

Prohibition
The rhetoric of total war included calls to reduce needless spending on goods like alcohol. Drink, its opponents
argued, sapped the ability of workers on the homefront to produce the munitions and battleships needed in the
struggle against the Triple Alliance. Opposition to prohibition, moreover, was painted as unpatriotic. Anyone
3
who will vote in favor of liquor might as well enlist under the Kaiser, claimed one newspaper. Hard liquor
was particularly targeted and, despite opposition from organized labour and brewers alike, beer also came under
attack. In 1915 Saskatchewan was first to be dry, and plebiscites followed in Alberta and Manitoba the same year.
British Columbia held a controversial vote in 1916 and declared itself dry shortly thereafter. In the rest of English-
Canada, governments eschewed referenda and simply acted directly on the matter. Quebec brought up the rear of
the prohibition wave with legislation that compromised on lighter drinks.

The question of prohibition during wartime was complex. While Canadians at home struggled to obtain hard
liquor, soldiers abroad were provided with a daily tot of rum. While women in Canada who had male relatives
serving in the trenches could vote on conscription, men in the CEF were barely consulted about provincial prohi-
bition proposals. The move toward prohibition at the provincial level prompted the Union government to respond
with prohibition legislation that tackled the movement of liquor between provinces and from out of country. Wine
and beer were still available but in the weakest strengths: 2.5% was the maximum amount of alcohol permitted.
Stronger drink could be obtained for medicinal purposes and for scientific and sacramental uses. Saloons and
bars were closed, breweries shut down, and a whole sector of the Canadian economy that had made fortunes since
the original wheat boom of the early 19th century, was mothballed. One cannot say that this could only have hap-
pened in the context of the Great War prohibition arrived in the United States in peacetime, after all but the
war effort and the rhetoric and logic of total war certainly contributed to making prohibition a reality. (For more
on temperance and prohibition, see Section 7.7.)

3. Quoted in Craig Heron, Booze: A Distilled History (Toronto: Between the Lines, 2003), 178.
 6.5 SUFFRAGE AND PROHIBITION 275

Key Points

Opposition to womens suffrage softened during the Great War.

Bordens administration saw a way to use womens suffrage to gain a second (delayed) mandate and,
simultaneously, a victory on the issue of conscription.
Womens suffrage led to prohibition during wartime.
In the case of both suffrage and prohibition, it was provinces in the West that led the way.

Attributions
Figure 6.9
Nellie McClung (Online MIKAN no.3622978) by Cyril Jessop, Library and Archives Canada, Acc. no.
1966-094, PA-030212 is in the public domain.

Figure 6.10
Propaganda for the Dominion Elections of Canada in France, 1917, posted on a Salvage Coy. Dump (Online
MIKAN no.3394809) by Canada. Dept. of National Defence / Library and Archives Canada / PA-008158 is in
the public domain.
6.6 The Interwar Years

Figure 6.11 Architectural and clothing fashions changed

dramatically in the Interwar Years, reflecting changes in social
values and influences arising from ancient civilizations like
Babylon and Azteca. This detail is from the ceiling of the
Snowdon Theatre in Montreal, 1937.

No one knew, of course, that there would be a second World War. Not in 1918, not even in the mid-1930s. Such a
thing was barely conceivable to most people and many nations leaders did their utmost to avoid another conflict
or to ignore the signs of its coming. Three themes dominated public discourse in these years and all had their roots
in uncertainty.

To The Finland Station

Revolution in Russia in 1917 was a historic game-changer. In much of the western world in 1912-14, Marxist rev-
olutionary movements were on the rise, their ascent cut off by the outbreak of war. Several factors brought matters
to a head in St. Petersburg, the capital of one of Europes least industrialized nations. The foremost of these was
the conduct of the war as a battle between imperial houses, many of which were headed by blood cousins. The
inability of the Russian monarchy under the Czar to alleviate famine or entertain gradual political reforms allowed
its opponents led by Vladimir Lenin and the Bolshevik Party to sweep the Imperial regime from power and
then to withdraw Russia from the war altogether.

Western members of the Triple Entente regarded this as a kind of double-jeopardy. Not only had an important ally
left the battlefield (allowing Imperial Germany to focus its efforts fully on the Western Front) but a revolution-
ary communist government had arisen in a country where there was hardly an industrial proletariat to speak of.
What might happen in states such as Britain or France where industrialization was much further progressed and
an organized proletariat existed? The answer to that question came first from Germany, where social and political
unrest increased as the war concluded, culminating in the November Revolution of 1918-19. The German rising
was suppressed but its bloody demise inspired leftist movements across the West while terrifying conservative
regimes in the aftermath of the war.

276
 6.6 THE INTERWAR YEARS 277

Lenins regime in Moscow called on working-class organizations in other countries to rise up in support of the
new Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR) and the cause of world revolution. In part, this was a response to
the international campaign to overturn the Russian revolution; even Canada sent troops to Russia to (unsuccess-
fully) put down the Bolshevik regime. Mostly, however, it grew out of the belief that countries undergoing their
own revolution would be too busy to intervene in the USSR.

In Canada the sense of pending social and political crisis was fed by a series of general strikes and violent con-
frontations between workers, employers, and authorities in 1919-20. The most noteworthy of these was the Win-
nipeg General Strike (examined in Section 3.9). Working people were themselves fearful that the economic boom
of wartime would give way to an economic depression. They were also concerned that returning soldiers would
displace workers in the industries to which they were returning and/or veterans needs would be disregarded and
they would be thrust into poverty themselves. The Spanish Flu outbreak of 1918-19 was part of the background
to this discontent: very nearly as many Canadians died in the pandemic over the course of one year as died in the
War over the course of four.

The Influenza Pandemic, 1918-1919

Esyllt Jones, Department of History, University of Manitoba

During recent periods of anxiety about the emergence of a new deadly strain of the influenza virus, atten-
tion has returned to the end of World War I, when pandemic influenza took the lives of 50 million people
across the globe, and impacted the lives and futures of millions of others. Known as Spanish influenza
only because the uncensored Spanish press was the first in the West to report the pandemic, approximately
55,000 Canadians died from the virus and its complications (bronchitis or pneumonia), compounding the
human losses of the war. The most deadly of influenzas three waves in the years 1918 and 1919 began
in September 1918. Influenza was carried west across the country by the mobilization of Canadas Siberian
Expeditionary Force, sent to oppose the Red Army during a period of civil war following the Bolshevik
1
Revolution of 1917. The expansion of the war effort took precedence over public health.

Figure 6.12 Albertan men wearing masks during the influenza

epidemic, 1918.

Influenza, though it infected men and women from all races and classes, was not a democratic disease. The
death rate among the non-Native population in British Columbia was 6.21 per 1,000 people; for the First
2
Nations it was 46 per 1,000 people. In cities such as Hamilton, working class families were at greater risk

1. Mark Osborne Humphries, The Horror At Home: The Canadian Military and the Great Influenza Pandemic of 1918, Journal of the
Canadian Historical Association 16, 1 (2005): 235-260.
2. Mary Ellen Kelm, British Columbia First Nations and the Influenza Pandemic of 1918-1919, BC Studies 122 (Summer 1999): 25.
 278 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

3
of death than the well-off. Influenza, like other infectious diseases, was shaped by social inequality. It was
also unimpeded by significant state preparedness.
In 1918 there was no federal health department to coordinate an effective response to the disease. Many
local governments and provincial boards of health, however, attempted to implement containment mea-
sures such as public school and church closures, the wearing of masks, and providing temporary emer-
gency hospital beds where possible. Staffing these facilities was extremely difficult because of wartime
shortages of medical and nursing personnel, even in major urban centres. The volunteer efforts of women
were crucial to emergency health care, and to relief for the afflicted. Women provided food, clothing, and
bedding for the sick and their families.
Medical science had little to contribute to these efforts. Viruses were as yet unknown as disease agents,
and influenza was not isolated until the early 1930s. Although there were attempts to create a vaccine,
without the necessary medical knowledge, these were of little use.
Although for much of the 20th century, historical memory of the pandemic was overridden by the public
commemoration of the Great War, influenza changed the circumstances of thousands of families with
the loss of siblings, parents, and kin. It was woven into their family stories. Some were scattered as chil-
dren went to orphanages or lived with extended family. Widows struggled to support their children with-
4
out a male breadwinner; single fathers attempted to provide care for children without their wives. Other
influenza sufferers never fully recovered their health.
This dangerous variant of influenza lingered in Canada into the 1920s, and then faded from view. It had
some impact on our health care system, contributing to the creation of a federal department of health in
1920. But as a blow to the aspirations of modern medicine, influenza confounded the narrative of medical
progress. As a result, we still have much to learn about its history.

Economic uncertainty (grounded in clear signs of a downturn), the challenges posed by the return of nearly half a
million troops, unprecedented mortalities from influenza, labour unrest, and the example of a successful workers
revolution abroad thus created an environment of anxiety. Systematic planning for a post-war recovery was not
possible in these circumstances and the sense that things could go badly wrong in a hurry was slow to evaporate.
This sense of catastrophic possibilities forged in the fires of the Great War and sharpened in the months after
the Armistice is the first theme of the interwar years.

The 1920s Boom

The economy staggered for nearly four years after the war. By 1922, however, there were signs of a recovery. The
possibility existed, for the first time since about 1912, that immigration to Canada would resume in earnest. There
was a sense of peacetime prosperity that echoed the Edwardian years. How long would it last? How to make it
run for as long as possible? While Canadians were looking hopefully to a future of peace and jobs, they were also
looking backward to the pre-War years as their reference point. There was no small amount of nostalgia for an age
before the immolation of war. The Roaring 20s took their cue from the Gay 90s.

At the same time, the 1920s were distinctive socially and culturally. Historians have commented on their frenetic

3. D. Ann Herring and Ellen Korol, The North-South Divide: Social Inequality and Mortality from the 1918 Influenza Pandemic in Hamilton,
Ontario, in Magda Fahrni and Esyllt W. Jones, eds., Epidemic Encounters: Influenza, Society and Culture in Canada 1918-1920 (Vancou-
ver: University of British Columbia Press, 2012), 97-112.
4. Esyllt W. Jones, Influenza 1918: Disease, Death and Struggle in Winnipeg (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2007).
 6.6 THE INTERWAR YEARS 279

qualities, the enthusiasm for change and new ideas, new things. The rise of art deco expressed in sculpture,
household decoration, and most spectacularly in architecture was one lasting element; the spread of radio and
motion pictures was another; so, too, was the popularity of pulp novels, jazz music, suburban bungalows, and
automobiles. Even the flapper, that trademark female style of the 1920s, can be invoked as a landmark of change.
Skirt lengths went up, bustles a system of cushions or a framework of wire meant to exaggerate the dimen-
sions of the female rump disappeared, as did padding on the bosom. Boyishly thin bodies defined by straight
lines aroused fears of gender-bending and rumours swirled about sexual perversion, or at least confusion. The
amount of cloth that went into a typical pre-war dress ensemble ran to about 17 yards; by the late 1920s it had
5
plummeted to less than 9 yards.

Figure 6.13 By 1930 dress lengths were back over

the knees but the material was still a fraction of what
it was before the war.

Some of these changes might seem superficial or trivial, but together they represent a reaction to the dislocation
of the Great War, the loss of over 100,000 lives in combat and to disease, and a will to move on quickly from the
past. In this, the 1920s were categorically modern in that they mark a break with the first 50 years of Confed-
eration. Deeper needs were signalled by women who could vote and dress as they liked (and in defiance of the
old arbiters of behaviour), and by radically changed aesthetics, radical politics, and contempt for the old order.
One other expression of this change was the fall in fertility rates in the 1920s. Women may have been displaced
from war industries but they didnt retreat en masse to the home and hearth. Many continued to work, postponed
marriage, and experimented with (illegal) contraceptives. Canadian family size began a sharp downward turn that
even the 1940s-60s baby boom could not completely reverse. All of this can be lumped together as a second
theme: a sense that enough had been sacrificed by the people and the nation as a whole and a conviction that now
Canadians might pursue the new and, ideally, prosperity.

The 1930s Depression

The economic landscape of the interwar years is examined more fully in Chapter 8 but here its roughest outlines
must be drawn. The collapse of stock markets and the commodity markets in late 1929 ushered in a decade of
economic hardship. For those who had money, these were great years: buyers were few and far between, sellers
were many, prices were low. For wage-earning Canadians, however, this was an economic disaster that, at the
time, was often compared to the Great War. What the war had been in human conflict, the Depression was in
terms of economic suffering. What little welfare state existed at the end of the war was insufficient to address the
kind of dislocation experienced across the country. In British Columbia, for example, there was a new workmens
compensation program in 1916, a womens minimum wage introduced in 1918, and mothers pensions in 1920;
some of these were subject to wrangling over the moral fitness of applicants and most were weakened by the

5. Sharon Carstairs and Tim Higgins, Dancing Backwards: A Social History of Canadian Women in Politics (Winnipeg: Heartland Associates,
2004), 63-5.
 280 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION
6
mid-30s, if not earlier. The economic issue for politicians was as much a philosophical as a tactical one: should
one interfere in the workings of the economy and run the risk of worsening matters or stand back and allow suf-
fering to continue? Past experience taught Canadians and their leaders that trade depressions never lasted more
than a few years at a time. By 1935 few believed that to be the case anymore. As a generalization, one can say
that every government that was in office federally or provincially in 1929-30 was kicked out of office the
very first chance the voters got. The economic depression thus brought with it unprecedented political discontent
and a sense, too, that capitalism was taking its last laboured breaths.

This is the third of the three interwar themes: defining the role of the state in the face of economic disaster. Ottawa
wrestled with this for a decade and, in that regard, the 1930s are a crucible for economic thinking and policy for
the rest of the 20th century.

Key Points

The interwar years were marked with fear of a global proletarian uprising, triggered by events in
Russia.
The 1918-19 influenza pandemic claimed nearly as many Canadian lives as the Great War and over a
much shorter period of time, taking a tremendous toll on social and public health.
Economic recovery in the Roaring 20s was capped by economic collapse in the Depression of the
1930s.
Canadians expectations of the state underwent profound changes from the Great War, through the
1920s, and the 1930s.

Attributions
Figure 6.11
Snowdon Theatre by Sandra Cohen-Rose and Colin Rose is used under a CC-BY-NC-SA 2.0 license.

Figure 6.12
Men wearing masks during the Spanish Influenza epidemic (Online MIKAN no.3194045) by Library and
Archives Canada / PA-025025 is in the public domain.

Figure 6.13
Model wearing dress for Northway Co. advertisement (Online MIKAN no.3544610) by Library and Archives
Canada/PA-053423 is in the public domain.

6. Lisa Pasolli, Working Mothers and the Child Care Dilemma: A History of British Columbia's Social Policy (Vancouver: University of British
Columbia Press, 2015), 26.
6.7 The Natural Governing Party: The King Years

Borden departed the prime ministers office in July 1920, having governed Canada through what is arguably the
most dramatic decade in its history. Borden was the author of some of that drama, to be sure, but he never had
to defend his record at the polls outside of wartime. He resigned and handed the prime ministership off to Arthur
Meighen (1874-1960). Unelected, Meighen held on for 15 months until an election was unavoidable. He lost con-
vincingly to William Lyon Mackenzie King in the dying days of 1921.

Figure 6.14 Arthur Meighen (centre) during his brief stint in the
PMO in 1920.

Arthur Meighen
Meighen is one of those politicians caught in the cats paw of history. He failed in 1921 because Canadians were
tired of Borden and the Tory/Union government and its cynical manipulation of the 1917 election, angered by
the Military Service Bill (of which Meighen was the author), upset about the mess made at Winnipeg in 1919 (in
which Meighen played a prominent role as minister of justice and the man behind the anti-sedition amendment
to the Criminal Code, Section 98), and peeved about prohibition. Meighen himself was barely considered by an
electorate eager for change. In 1926 he was thrown into the job in the least defensible way and was thereafter
(unfairly) associated in the public mind with an attempt to subvert the democratic process. He is, however, worth
pondering for a moment.

Meighen was the first Canadian prime minister born in the post-Confederation period. He is the only one, as
well, to have come from a farming background, a remarkable fact for what was until 1921 a mostly rural country.
Meighen was raised and educated in Ontario and was part of that great westward migration to Manitoba. He was
as representative as anyone of the extent to which Ontarian legal, professional, educational, and gendered certain-
ties were being transplanted onto the plains. He is the only PM elected from Manitoba (his riding was Portage la
Prairie) and the first westerner to hold the job. He was bright, articulate, a sharp and witty debater, and absolutely
loathed by Mackenzie King a feeling that was returned with interest. The two men, when young and both
attending the University of Toronto, knew and disliked each other. This did not change. As Meighens biographer

281
 282 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

writes, Meighen was a dogged logician and orator who believed in straight talk. [King] was given to wordy plat-
1
itudes and endless consultations. Their temperaments clashed, and so did their ambitions.

King and Meighen, side by side, offer an insight into how much and how little had changed in Canadian politics.
Meighen came from modest roots and was a farm boy. Kings grandfather on his mothers side was William Lyon
Mackenzie, one-time mayor of Toronto, a radical-reform politician and newspaperman, a full-time thorn in the
side of the Upper Canadian establishment (aka: the Family Compact), a sometime rabble-rouser, and a promi-
nent leader of the 1837-38 Rebellion. In this sense, and perhaps ironically, it was King who had the political pedi-
gree. Meighen, however, carried the banner of the old political elites: he was a small-c conservative, an advocate
for pre-War values and social relations, and a man who kept wearing starched high collars long after modernists
like King disavowed them outside of formal occasions. Meighen was often decisive, sometimes to his disadvan-
tage. During the Chanak (or anak) Crisis of 1922, he urged the King government to recall parliament and ready
the troops in aid of Britain; King was in no rush to do so and the conflict was over before it had a chance to divide
French and English Canadians.

The careers of King and Meighen, however, seem almost intertwined. In fact, were it not for Meighen, King
never a particularly sympathetic character might not have gained, let alone held on to power. Meighen was
the ninth prime minister, all but two of whom were Conservatives. Over 54 years, the Liberals had formed the
government for only 20. Laurier said that the 20th century would belong to Canada; in point of fact, it mostly
belonged to the Liberal Party. But only after the Conservatives made a gift of it to King.

Meighen campaigned in 1921 at the head of what was called the National Liberal and Conservative Party, essen-
tially the remnants of Bordens coalition Union Government. Rather than make a break with the divisive past
that is, a scandalous 1917 election rigged to ensure the success of conscription and thus opening a chasm between
Quebec and the Conservative Party Meighen held on to the old symbols of the Union regime. He worsened his
chances by confirming his commitment to a return of the National Policy, including the tariffs. Canadian farmers
were almost universally opposed and many of them broke with the Tory Party to form the Progressive Party (see
Section 7.9). Frozen out in Quebec, the Conservatives lost much of rural Ontario as well and the Prairies. The
Liberals under King, however, did not romp to power. The Conservatives took 49 seats, the Progressives won 58
(one of which was claimed by Agnes Macphail, the first woman in Parliament), and the Progressives less well-
organized allies took another 10, leaving the Liberals with 118 seats the barest of majorities. With one Liberal
Member of Parliament in the Speakers Chair, the two sides of the House were balanced.

By all rights, the Progressives should have formed the Official Opposition. Their philosophy, however, included a
critique of the binaries of parliament. They sought to work with, rather than against. This provided the third party
leader, Meighen, with a chance to lead Her Majestys Official Opposition.

Figure 6.15 Mackenzie King (seated, fourth from the right) at the
1923 Imperial Conference faces an early moving picture camera.

1. Larry A. Glassford, MEIGHEN, ARTHUR, in Dictionary of Canadian Biography, vol. 18, University of Toronto/Universit Laval, 2003,
accessed 10 November 2015, [Link]
 6.7 THE NATURAL GOVERNING PARTY: THE KING YEARS 283

King and Commons

Putting the war behind the nation, binding up its wounds, and reducing the levels of animosity between the Eng-
lish and French, nativist Canadians and ethnic immigrants, labour and capital were Kings priorities. Like Laurier,
under whom he had served as Minister of Labour, King sought a path of compromise. This was especially chal-
lenging when it came to the issue of the tariff. Opposed by farmers, it was still embraced by manufacturers and
urbanites in industrial cities. King lowered it, but not too much. Indeed, his first administration was marked by
a lack of drama at home and abroad. The 1923 Imperial Conference gave King a chance to reiterate the case for
autonomous Dominions within what was now called the British Commonwealth of Nations. The economy was
recovering; grain was once again flowing off the Prairies and for this King could claim little credit. His skills at
building political bridges across the country were noteworthy but the electorate of 1925 evidently did not care.
The Conservatives under Meighen, rather remarkably, won 115 seats and the Liberals only 100. Just as Meighen
had lost his own Portage La Prairie seat in 1921, King lost his in 1925 and had to scramble to find a safe con-
stituency and a compliant Liberal MP who would make way for him. It was very nearly a disaster for the Liber-
als. The Progressives were once again the wildcard; they were not yet a spent force but they held on to 22 seats.
Meighen expected to form a government but King moved quickly to confirm Progressive support of a Liberal
minority.

Predictably, Meighen and the Tories were outraged. When a bribery scandal suddenly threatened the Liberal gov-
ernment, King acted with uncharacteristic decisiveness. Rather than wait for a vote of censure over the issue of
bribery and smuggling, he consulted with the Governor-General the former Lieutenant-General Sir Julian
Byng (the leader of the victory at Vimy) and asked for dissolution of the House of Commons and a new elec-
tion. Byng declined the request and King resigned as PM, allowing Meighen to step into the vacuum. This led to
a constitutional crisis in which King characterized Byngs constitutional ruling as the meddling of a non-elected
official appointed by a foreign power. Three days into Meighens administration a vote of non-confidence was
called and the combined force of Liberals and Progressives defeated the government. Byng promptly called an
election. This unusual interlude has been known ever since as the King-Byng Affair or, better still, the King-
Byng Thing and has been a reference point for every Governor-General on election night when the possibility of
a minority government looms at the polls.

Kings Liberals were returned and, with the support of ten Progressives, formed a majority government. The four
years that followed would see an extension of Canadas sovereignty at the 1926 Imperial Conference, recognized
formally in the Balfour Declaration. A rising economy improved the governments fiscal position so much so
that the Canadian National Railway a unified system of smaller railways brought together and nationalized
under the Borden government was at last showing a profit. Kings long-term interest in social welfare measures
was manifest in the first old age pension, introduced shortly after the election. But Kings administration was less
about big government than government as an arbitrator, a third-party, or fair broker. It was how King ran cabi-
net meetings and how he ran the country. He even reduced taxes, thus spending down the surplus that Ottawa had
accumulated.

His timing and his reading of the economic situation could hardly have been worse. In 1928 grain prices began
a long-term fall and the next year the stock market crashed. Going into 1930 and due for an election King
maintained that the economy was merely adjusting a bit and he advocated inaction (see Section 8.5). Canadians
disagreed and voted the Liberals out of office.
284 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

A Pyrrhic Victory
Kings defeat was comprehensive. Only Saskatchewan and Quebec returned more Liberals than Tories but even
in Quebec the Conservatives won 24 seats. Looking at the political history of Canada from 1867-1930 one could
argue that the Conservatives were the more successful party; the party of Macdonald and Cartier was still the nat-
ural governing party of Canada. The Depression, however, would destroy the Tories for more than a generation.

Richard Bedford Bennett (1870-1947) served in Bordens government, was briefly Meighens minister of justice,
and then failed to win a seat in 1921. In the brief Tory interlude of 1926, Bennett was the minister of finance. In
1927 he was party leader. Like Meighen, he represented a prairie constituency: Calgary West. Bennetts personal
wealth was substantial and he was believed to be financially independent by 1909. Like Meighen, he was a tough
debater but his appeal to Canadian voters was his own prosperity. Playing the role of the hard-nosed master of
high finance and industry, it meant something when Bennett promised to blast a way into the markets that were
closed to Canadian goods by tariffs. In the midst of a global depression, however, there were few markets into
which one might blast.

Like King, Bennett was inclined to think that the Depression might just go away on its own. By 1933, when things
were at an all-time low, he began to build a response. This included relief camps for the unemployed (highly
unpopular and condemned by the public as slave camps) and the promise of some major social reforms that
included unemployment insurance, health insurance, and income-based personal taxes. Like most politicians who
were in power in 1933, however, Bennetts time in office was to be cut short. He lacked imagination and the polit-
ical will to make changes in what was, to be fair, the worst economic crisis in the countrys history. Bennett was
nevertheless reviled, a lightning rod for the nations discontent. Disgusted, he soldiered on as Opposition Leader
until 1938 when he returned to his native England and retired with a viscountcy. Bennetts unpopularity was such
that no subsequent Canadian leader would accept a knighthood.

In 1935 the Conservatives were once again swept from power, still stigmatized in Quebec as the party of conscrip-
tion and Riels gallows. Now they were damned in western Canada, as well, as the party of the dust bowl.

King and Chaos

Kings economic and social policies were hardly better than Bennetts when it came to spending the countrys
way out of crisis. A slight up-tick in the economy after 1935 reversed in 1937 so there was little confidence that
the corner had truly been turned. Elected on the slogan King or Chaos, the Liberals offered only a few new
ideas that were meant to cushion the effects of the Depression. A National Housing Act was introduced but social
policies were otherwise missing. The principal legacy of this administration was the creation of the Canadian
Broadcasting Corporation (CBC) in 1936 and the National Film Board (NFB) in 1939 (see Section 10.14). The
beginnings of a national airline were laid out in Trans-Canada Airlines in 1937, which would eventually become
Air Canada.

As war in Europe approached, Kings inclination was to refuse to make commitments to Britain. An attack on
Britain would be defended, but British engagement in a continental war would be not be enjoined by Canadi-
ans. Like many of his contemporaries, King underestimated the ambitions of Fhrer und Reichskanzler Adolf
Hitler and his National Socialist government. What is more, King was inclined to see Hitler as a kind of roman-
tic and messianic figure with a spiritual mission. This reflected Kings own rather unusual spiritual outlook (see
 6.7 THE NATURAL GOVERNING PARTY: THE KING YEARS 285

Section 9.5). King had missed the Great War by dint of working as a consultant to the Rockefeller family in New
York and director of the Rockefeller Foundation from 1914-1918. During that time, he polished and formalized
his conception of the state as a third party in disputes between labour and capital, ideas that he would take into
inter-provincial diplomacy and, on the eve of the Second World War, into talks between Britain and the United
States. His revulsion for conflict would not, however, protect him from the struggle that was unfolding globally.

Key Points

The Meighen and King years demonstrate some of the constitutional liabilities of the Canadian par-
liamentary system.
Despite pronounced differences during election campaigns, the Liberal and Conservative govern-
ments of the interwar years had similar records when it came to social policy.
Canadas increased autonomy within the British Empire was welcomed by King.
Meighens failures in the 1920s, coupled with Bennetts in the 1930s, led to a long run of Liberal
governments.

Attributions
Figure 6.14
Premier Arthur Meighens inspection Toronto, Ont. Aug. 13, 1920 (Online MIKAN no.3657723) by Toronto
Harbour Commissioners / Library and Archives Canada / PA-097014 is in the public domain.

Figure 6.15
Group photo of delegates attending the Imperial Conference, 10 Downing Street (Online MIKAN no.3199796)
by Library and Archives Canada / PA-138871 is in the public domain.
 6.8 Canadian Fascists

Efforts to transform local movements into national political organizations have generally failed. Ideology provides
much stronger glue than localized hostility toward some practice or group. Perhaps one of the hidden benefits of
a divided Canadian dualism and pluralism is that it is difficult to muster a mass response to a putative scapegoat
group. In times of crisis like the Great Depression it becomes possible to mobilize anger and xenophobia as
a political movement.

One cannot, therefore, take too lightly the appearance of fascist movements and parties in Canada in the 1930s.
Of these, there were three main examples: the Canadian Nationalist Party led by William Whittaker and based in
Winnipeg, the Canadian Union of Fascists (a pro-Mosleyite, British fascist organization), and the Parti National
Social Chrtien (PNSC). The PNSC was the largest and most successful of the three, the political wing of a Que-
bec-based fascist movement under the leadership of Adrien Arcand (1899-1967). Heavily influenced by the rise
of anti-Semitic movements in Europe and especially by Adolf Hitlers German National Socialist (Nazi) Party,
Arcand was an enthusiastic promoter of an all-white, all-Christian vision of Canada. The PNSC looked beyond
the borders of Quebec, seeking sympathizers among Anglo-Canadians under the umbrella of the National Unity
Party of Canada (NUPC). The emergence of Ku Klux Klan chapters in Ontario and on the Prairies, as well as the
deeply entrenched anti-Asian sentiment among Euro-British Columbians made fertile ground for Arcands mes-
sage. Following on the example set by European fascists, Arcands group took to wearing distinctive uniforms
festooned with swastikas. While Hitler had his brown shirts, Benito Mussolini in Italy his black shirts, and
Oswald Mosley in Britain his green shirts, in Canada the fascists were blue shirts.

There is no doubt that Arcand and the NUPC enjoyed some support in Quebec. Even if he was not a member
of the NUPC, Montreals mayor, Camillien Houde was an outspoken supporter of European fascist powers and
hostile to Britain. But the extent of their appeal in the rest of Canada does not seem to have been great. Even
the 1938 alliance with Whittakers CNP and the creation of the optimistically named National Unity Party could
not address the obvious contradiction of a ferociously nationalistic and racist movement that was divided along
1
national and, by their own terms, race lines. Elsewhere in Canada, the half-million ethnic Germans in Canada
were divided in their feelings about Hitlers regime but members of the Deutscher Bund Kanada were vocal,
swastika-armband-wearing advocates, particularly of the claims of cultural superiority.

1. Jonathan F. Wagner, Brothers Beyond the Sea: National Socialism in Canada (Waterloo: Wilfrid Laurier University Press, 1981), 76-79.

286
 6.8 CANADIAN FASCISTS 287

Figure 6.16 A promotional postcard from Arcands PNSC, 1930s.

As Europe marched toward a second world war, the Canadian fascists were more closely watched by the state.
Having said that, when war was declared and the authorities set about corralling the Whittaker and Arcand parties,
their enthusiasm for doing so seems to have been lukewarm. Several facts may explain the tempered response to
fascists that contrasts so sharply with police and state commitment to putting down communist movements. First,
the authorities and the fascists shared a dislike of the socialists and communists. Second, German settlers enjoyed
a largely favourable reputation in Canada, despite the xenophobia stirred up by the Great War, so even ethnic pro-
Hitler groups like the Deutscher Bund Kanada might be treated with kid gloves. Third, anti-Semitic sentiments
were almost ubiquitous among Catholic and Protestant Canadians so this aspect of fascism did not set off alarm
2
bells. Arcands biographer suggests, furthermore, that powerful connections in government kept the party lead-
3
ership out of jail (at least for a while) and tipped off senior fascists of coming police raids. Arcand, however,
spent the war years under guard at Petawawa, a military camp in northern Ontario that served as an internment site
for Canadians involved in enemy organizations, including the former mayor of Montreal. Many of the Deutscher
Bund similarly wound up interned in New Brunswick for the duration of the war.

Remarkably, the Canadian fascists survived WWII. Arcand ran in elections in 1949 and 1953, finishing second
both times with 29% and 39% of the vote respectively. As late as 1965, he could still draw a crowd of 850 to a
rally in Montreals Paul Sauv Arena.

Key Points

As was the case in Britain and across Europe, extremists on the right found support in Canada for
fascist movements in the 1930s.
Support for the fascists was limited but not strongly opposed by the state.

Attributions
Figure 6.16
La clef du nouveau Canada by Jeangagnon is in the public domain.

2. Lita-Rose Betcherman, The Swastika and the Maple Leaf: Fascist Movements in Canada in the Thirties (Don Mills: Fitzhenry & Whiteside:
1975), 138-43.
3. Jean-Franois Nadeau, The Canadian Fuhrer: The Life of Adrien Arcand, trans. Bob Chodos, Eric Hamovitch, and Susan Joanis (Toronto:
James Lorimer, 2011), 232-3.
 6.9 The Road to WWII

Sixty years after the end of the Second World War, it is easy to misunderstand how it looked at the time.

In 1914 there were a handful of liberal democracies around the globe and there were many states in which hered-
itary monarchs and oligarchical systems of government dominated. In the aftermath of the Treaty of Versailles a
whole cadre of new democracies appeared, including the Weimar Republic in Germany. Sun Yat-sens revolution
had toppled the Emperor in China. There was a brand new League of Nations, created with the intent of insti-
tutionalizing global communication and the perpetuation of peace. Whats more, modernity was becoming more
widespread as a social and cultural movement, as well as an art movement. Consumerism was on the rise, suburbs
were appearing on the edges of cities across the western world, and planning was becoming something of a phe-
nomenon, extending from new urban areas through whole economies. The Union of Soviet Socialist Republics
that took the place of the Czarist regime in Russia held out the possibility of a post-capitalist society. Techno-
logical change, much of it stimulated by the Great War itself, seemed to be accelerating. Styles of dress changed
dramatically. Deference to religious authority was in sharp decline across Western Europe and the Americas as
secularism was more widely and more deeply spread. In short, the interwar era seemed to have potential.

That was the situation in the mid- to late-1920s. By the mid-1930s the promise of a world of peaceable democ-
racies was receding. Indeed, democracy was in retreat. Nations were rearming. Organized religion was terrified
by anticlericalism and was backing counter-revolutions across Latin America. Monarchists were digging in their
heels and throwing in their lot with anti-democratic fascists. The Soviet Union under Stalin and the Nazis under
Hitler were both calling for global domination and if two objects cannot occupy the same space at the same
time, then one of these two movements was going to have to yield. Modernism generally, was under attack in
Germany, Italy, Spain, and even in North America as degenerate. Racism was on the rise. The Spanish Civil
War was a kind of dress rehearsal for the conflict to come but it signalled something else: the fall of democracy.
As the British historian Eric Hobsbawm wrote,

Political liberalism was in full retreat in the Age of Catastrophe. Taking the world as a whole, there had been perhaps
35 or more constitutional and elected governments in 1920. Until 1938 there were perhaps 17 such states, in 1944 perhaps
1
12 out of the global total of 64.

One of those democracies, one of those increasingly rare holdouts against the tide of absolutism and despotism,
was Canada.

1. Eric Hobsbawm, Age of Extremes: The Short Twentieth Century, 1914-1991 (London: Abacus, 1996), 112.

288
 6.9 THE ROAD TO WWII 289

Canada between the Wars

All was not freedoms and liberties. Canadians were largely fearful of the outside world and inclined to restrict the
rights of anyone outside the charmed circle of white, Christian, male adulthood. Womens rights were expanding,
its true, but they were still something of an untested novelty in the 1930s. And they were rising from a very low
baseline. Voting rights might have been won but property, welfare, and workplace rights continued to reflect the
patriarchal values at the heart of Canadian society.

The situation of Canadians of colour was considerably worse and to be a woman of colour in Canada was, quite
simply, double jeopardy. Asian Canadians faced restrictions in terms of their place of residence, the schools they
could attend, and the professions they could join, not to mention the day-to-day humiliations of both pointed
and casual racism. African-Canadians might have greater access to democratic privileges but their educational
opportunities severely circumscribed, and the overall quality of life and public services in neighbourhoods like
Africville on the edge of Halifax was poor. Aboriginal Canadians, too, faced impoverished conditions both on
and off the reserve. Some could vote but their collective numbers were so small as to make them powerless as a
constituency. The remoteness of many First Nations communities meant that they were effectively invisible to the
larger Canadian polity. The Jewish community found across the country but heavily concentrated in the largest
centres and especially Montreal faced anti-Semitic discrimination in many forms. Racism coupled with a
strong eugenics movement was, for all intents and purposes, part of Canadas mainstream culture.

The limits on freedom of speech and freedom to meet had been tested repeatedly in the Depression. Unions were
being smashed; civic, provincial, and national police forces showed little compunction when it came to riding
horses into a crowd and swinging billy clubs and whips. The communist movement had been outlawed and mostly
driven underground while fascist parties were generally winked at; police surveillance of unions was common-
place. A decade of high unemployment and economic disaster had been largely unalleviated by the Liberals and
the Conservatives, and neither party appeared to care very much.

Having said that, the three levels of democracy in Canada civic, provincial, and federal meant that elections
were relatively common tests of the public will. The Canadian press remained free (notwithstanding state attacks
on the newspapers of the hard left). British parliamentary traditions remained strong and loyalty to Britain (com-
plemented by continued post-Great War enmity for the Germans) ensured that Canadas position on the eve of war
would be less complicated than that of the United States.

On the Brink
As relations worsened between Nazi Germany and Britain, France, and the USSR in the late 1930s, Canadians
became increasingly alert to the possibility of war. The Japanese invasion of Manchuria in 1931 marked the begin-
ning of turmoil along the Pacific Rim and stimulated tensions within the Asian-Canadian community that would
last until Chinas liberation in 1945. Italys attack on Ethiopia (aka: Abyssinia) followed in 1935 and the Spanish
Civil War broke out in 1936 between the Republic (supported by the Soviet Union) and the Nationalists under
General Francisco Franco (backed by fascist regimes in Italy and Germany). All of these conflicts were testing
grounds for expansionist countries building martial cultures around charismatic leaders and intense nationalistic
feeling.

Moreover, these invasions and contests introduced elements of total war that had not been as apparent in the Great
290 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

War. Civilian casualties, for example, were not a by-product of war but an intentional objective. This was seen
in every instance of the pre-WWII conflicts, including gas attacks on Abyssinian villages, the destruction of the
town of Guernica by the Luftwaffe (German Airforce), and most spectacularly, the Japanese Rape of Nanking
and the Empires application of a scorched earth policy across northern China.

Diplomatic efforts to reverse this tide failed repeatedly and embarrassingly. British and French politicians blun-
dered through attempts at appeasement of, first, Italy then Germany. The Soviet Union, for its part, used the Nazi
obsession with Russian power to their advantage in the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact of March 1939, which effec-
tively carved up Eastern Europe and the Baltic countries between the USSR and Germany. As a non-aggression
pact, it bought the USSR two years to prepare for conflict with Germany and allowed the Nazi Wehrmacht to
focus its energies on Western Europe.

Key Points

By 1939 the number of liberal democracies was in steep decline. Canada was one of few remaining.
Despite Canadas record as a liberal democracy, the rights of as much as half its adult population
were limited.
Two of the authoritarian regimes of the interwar years explicitly and openly made plans to spread
their systems across the globe.
International conflicts in the 1930s paved the way for a world war conducted against civilian targets
as often as military adversaries.
6.10 Canada Goes to War

Figure 6.17 A British Columbian regiment prepares

to depart from New Westminster, 1940.
(Wait for me daddy by Claude Dettloff)

On 1 September 1939, Germany invaded Poland, which triggered a declaration of war on the part of France and
Britain on 3 September. Both New Zealand and Australia declared war on the same day. William Lyon Mackenzie
Kings government, however, held back for four days.

This delay was entirely about optics. The government wished to demonstrate to Britain and, more significantly, to
Canadians that the decision to go to war was one that was made by Parliament in Ottawa and it was one that was
endorsed by French and English Canadian politicians alike. King feared a repeat of the divisive experience of the
Great War and that fear guided his actions throughout the Second World War. The delay of four days had nothing
to do with a lack of preparedness in fact, the government was vastly more prepared for war (at least organiza-
tionally, if not materially) than was the case in 1914 nor did it reflect concern about what the Americans might
do. King was committed to supporting Britain against Germany regardless of Washingtons position. The point
was to exercise the autonomy that had been won in the Statute of Westminster (1931) and enter the war as a free
democracy.

This was not cause for celebration. Unlike August 1914, there were no raucous and patriotic parades in the autumn
of 1939. Anyone over the age of 24 would have some recollection of the Great War and the parents of those men
and women most likely to serve in the armed forces would keenly recall the costs of the war that was meant to end
all wars. There was, too, the recollection of profiteering and corruption from the previous war. Of course, there
was also the memory of economic good times, rising wages, and a return to prosperity. It was on this prospect that
many Canadians hinged their hopes.

As in 1914, of course, optimists in 1939 predicted a short war that might be resolved at the bargaining table sooner
rather than later. From September 1939 to May 1940, Canada along with the rest of the British Commonwealth,
France, and the other Allied Nations was on the sidelines of what became known in French as the Drle de

291
 292 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

guerre, in German as Sitzkrieg, and in English as the Phoney War. There was so little in the way of actual warfare
going on that King was able to call an election for March 1940, which he won easily. Events in the winter and
spring of 1940 were to dispel any possibility of a negotiated peace.

While the Allies built up their resources, Germany attacked and annexed Denmark and Norway. On 10 May 1940,
the Wehrmacht finally turned its attention to the French Republic, which it invaded after storming through the
Netherlands and Belgium. The blitzkrieg assault allowed the Germans to capture the majority of Allied troops
stationed in France, although some 300,000 (including a Canadian battalion) escaped via Dunkirk.

This was a disaster of the first order for the Allies. Paris was in enemy hands, France bisected into the occupied
north and a puppet state in the south, centred on Vichy. The Alliance at this stage consisted principally of the
British Commonwealth and whatever resistance armies were able to either escape occupied Europe or disappear
into underground movements. Comfortably spread across northern and central Europe, the Germans turned their
guns on the USSR, launching an attack in June 1940.

The role of Canada and Newfoundland in the war at this point was principally to supply Britain with resources
necessary for survival during a long siege and to prepare for a German invasion of the British Isles. Supply ves-
sels, escorted by battleships, poured out of Montreal, Halifax, and St. Johns. The Royal Canadian Air Force
(RCAF) played a key role training British pilots and engaged in the defence of the UK during the Battle of
Britain. Apart from occupying Iceland on behalf of Britain in 1941, however, Canadian troops saw little action.
Many were stationed in Britain, anticipating a German sea invasion that never came. Others were deployed to
Newfoundland (recently put back under British administration) and to the West Indies.

The administrative structures necessary to success in total war were more rapidly and more fully deployed than
in 1914-15. The War Measures Act was again invoked and the policing of potential (that is, perceived or mis-
perceived) internal threats got quickly underway. Authority over much of the nations productive capacity was
centralized in one ministry under the leadership of C.D. Howe (1886-1960), a Port Arthur (now Thunder Bay)
engineer and businessman who took charge of the newly created Ministry of Munitions and Supply. Howe
recruited dollar-a-year men from businesses that covered the rest of their salaries to have experienced produc-
tion managers at his disposal. Described as the Minister for Everything, Howe nationalized industries, rapidly
expanded industrial production, and got the government involved in the Manhattan Project. Just as industrial
production became more controlled and influenced by Ottawa, the state itself also changed. A commentator in
1945 observed:

The War Measures Act converted Canada overnight from a confederation into a unitary state; the government overrode
or supplanted most of the normal procedures of peace; it became the largest and most important employer of labour; it
used its fiscal capacity and monetary powers to effect maximum war production, borrowing billions, raising billions by
taxation, and then bringing into play a reserve power by borrowing many millions from the banking system to inflate the
1
economy to full war capacity.

From a nation burdened with crushing rates of unemployment, Canada was transformed into one of the worlds
leading industrial economies, a major producer of food and ships, a leader in aircraft and munitions production,
and a state with a finger in many pies.

1. Quoted in Ian Mosby, Food Will Win the War: The Politics, Culture, and Science of Food on Canada's Home Front (Vancouver: University of British
Columbia Press, 2014), 14.
 6.10 CANADA GOES TO WAR 293

Figure 6.18 Minister of Munitions and Supply, C.D. Howe, tours

an aircraft plant in 1941.

Key Points

Unlike in 1914, when Britains declaration of war meant that Canada was automatically at war as
well, in 1939 Ottawa delayed declaring its involvement for four days.
Prime Minister Kings primary concerns were to avoid reopening the wounds that fractured Canada
in 1914-18.
Canadian involvement at the outset was small, although Canadian troops were part of the evacuation
of France via Dunkirk.
Creating an administrative structure that would mobilize the economy for an effective total war
effort was a first priority.

Attributions
Figure 6.17
British Columbia Regiment 1940 by City of Vancouver Archives / Claude Dettloff is in the public domain.

Figure 6.18
The Hon. C.D. Howe speaks to a woman worker at an aircraft factory (Online MIKAN no.3195719) by
National Film Board of Canada. Photothque / Library and Archives Canada is in the public domain.
 6.11 Newfoundland Goes to War

The situation in Newfoundland was different. The Dominion had lost its autonomy and democratic legislature
in the economic trenches of 1934; thereafter it was administered by a Commission of Government comprised of
four British appointees and three Newfoundland representatives. In effect, the ex-Dominion was a colony once
more. That meant that when Britain declared war, Newfoundland was instantly at war as well. It also meant that,
although there was a Newfoundland Regiment to provide home-defence, there was no separate Dominion regi-
ment sent abroad: the colonys volunteers were absorbed directly into British regiments.

The war had a revivifying effect on the North American economy as a whole but especially in Newfoundland.
Gander and Goose Bay became pivotal to the Royal Airforces mustering of aircraft being shepherded from fac-
tories in Canada to the UK; St. Johns was a naval centre and watchtower for the western Atlantic. Thousands
of Canadian troops were deployed across the island and Canadian oversight of Britains military interests in the
region was general. The American presence was even larger, running to 10,000 personnel. Newfoundland was of
enormous strategic importance, a fact that led to a welcome economic surge and a sudden modernization of infra-
structure.

Newfoundland was also at risk in a way that no part of Canada was, with the exception of Halifax. Naval convoys
providing food, arms, and other resources to a besieged Britain poured out of the St. Lawrence and Nova Scotia,
drawing the unwanted attention of German submarines. U-boat attacks multiplied quickly and disasters occurred
with fearsome regularity. The Newfoundland ferry Caribou was one such casualty in 1942 when a torpedo attack
1
took the lives of 137 crew and passengers. Ships carrying iron ore sailing from Bell Island were sunk; indeed,
any vessel sailing from the outports might be considered target practice for the U-boats. The submarines could
be used, as well, to shell land targets: in March 1942, three torpedoes were launched against ships and facili-
ties in St. Johns harbour. Rumours circulated (and continue to do so) of U-boat bases nestled in the many inlets
of Labrador and there is hard evidence of a German automated weather station along the mainland coast. Given
the catastrophic magnitude of Japans attack on Pearl Harbor in December 1941, it is easy to imagine the anxiety
felt by Newfoundlanders in these circumstances. The war was not in Europe; it was at their door, peaking inside.

1. Margaret R. Conrad and James K. Hiller, Atlantic Canada: A Concise History (Don Mills: Oxford University Press, 2006), 179-80.

294
 6.11 NEWFOUNDLAND GOES TO WAR 295

Key Points

Newfoundland was restored to British administration in 1934.

As a consequence, Newfoundland automatically followed Britain into the Second World War.
Because of its geopolitical value, Newfoundland experienced a sudden rush of investment in logis-
tics and the arrival of thousands of troops from Canada and, later, the United States.
WWII provided the Newfoundland economy with a boost and it simultaneously put its shipping and
people at greater risk than was the case in Canada.
6.12 Status Indians and Military Service in the World Wars

R. SCOTT SHEFFIELD, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, UNIVERSITY OF THE FRASER VALLEY

Figure 6.19 Aboriginal soldiers of the Canadian Expeditionary

Force (CEF) along with elders, ca. 1916-17.

In the first half of the 20th century, Canadas Status Indians faced many challenges. The Indian Act restricted
their freedoms and rights and Canadian society, which viewed Indians as an inferior and dying race, marginalised
them economically and socially. Despite this reality, when Canada marched to war in 1914 and 1939, First Nations
people joined the national efforts and volunteered for the military. In fact, more than 4,000 Status Indian men
enlisted in each World War, the majority as volunteers. Most First Nations were supportive but it is difficult to
generalise because the degree of engagement varied greatly, with some communities giving almost every able-
bodied man and others almost none. While the Army experimented with segregated all-Indian units in WWI, over-
whelmingly First Nations youth enlisted and served as individuals integrated into regular military units. During
WWII, racial barriers combined with stringent health and education requirements to bar First Nations from the
Navy or Air Force, funneling most into the Army. In both wars, when conscription was enacted it applied to Sta-
tus Indians, despite their ineligibility to vote and their status as wards of the state. First Nations leaders across the
country protested the application of the Military Service Act of 1917 to their people. The government responded in
early 1918 by exempting Status Indians from overseas combative service. In WWII, Status Indians were deemed
liable for conscription for home defence from 1940-45, despite nationwide protest and passive resistance amongst
Indigenous communities. When Ottawa sent conscripts overseas in late 1944-45, only a few First Nations who,
during treaty negotiations, were explicitly promised that the Queen would not ask her Indian children to fight
for her unless they wished, were exempted. After both wars, Status Indian veterans faced unequal access to ben-
efits and programs provided to help veterans re-establish themselves in civilian life.

The extent of First Nations military participation and the meagre reward received for their sacrifices in peacetime
raises the question of why Status Indians would volunteer and fight for the state that oppressed and marginalised
them. This is challenging to answer as the decision to volunteer differed slightly between the wars and between

296
 6.12 STATUS INDIANS AND MILITARY SERVICE IN THE WORLD WARS 297

cultural communities and individuals. During the Great War, First Nations that historically honoured warriors
viewed the conflict as an opportunity to reinvigorate such traditions. Although not prevalent everywhere, warrior
cultures were important amongst Plains First Nations as well as Iroquoian-speaking communities in central
Canada. Perhaps surprisingly, a heartfelt connection to the British Crown motivated many First Nations enlist-
ments; this was a legacy of historical traditions of military alliance with British since the 1600s and/or commit-
ment to treaties negotiated with Crown representatives. Moreover, for almost all, a desire to defend their peoples
ancestral territory, and by extension Canada and the British Empire, also spurred enlistment. And of course, many
young mens decisions came down to impulsiveness, a social need to join their buddies, a youthful hunger for
adventure, or an escape from restrictive reserve life.

Figure 6.20 Michel Ackbee, a sniper from

the Thunder Bay Band, during WWI.

In WWII, earlier motivations were still evident, but the nature of the conflict was different: this was less an impe-
rial contest and more explicitly a war for democracy and freedom against fascism, oppression, and state racism.
This meant Indigenous military service added meaning for both those enlisting and for Canadians who were pleas-
antly surprised by Status Indians patriotism. Volunteering for the military could now be a political act, calculated
to win greater respect, to prove ones worth, or claim enhanced rights. Highly decorated First Nations soldier,
Sergeant Thomas Prince, stated that he wanted to show they [Indians] were as good as any white man. At
home, Status Indian leaders argued that if our young men are good enough to wear the Kings uniform, they
should have the same civil rights and privileges as our white brothers have. The connection of military service
to democracy made such arguments difficult for Canadians to ignore. First Nations people were deeply moved and
motivated by the fight against fascism and wanted to participate in what became a national crusade. Canadians,
and their government, typically misinterpreted the First Nations wartime support and contributions as evidence
of their willingness to assimilate into mainstream society after the war. While they wished to take part and be
accepted, First Nations people were also declaring their right to be, and to remain, distinct cultural communities.

Figure 6.21 Brothers Tommy and Morris Prince

a sergeant and a private, respectively at an event
at Buckingham Palace, 1945.

After 1945, First Nations delegates took part in the post-war Parliamentary review that led to a new Indian Act in
1951. While far from revolutionary, the revised Act eased some restrictions on Status Indians and extended some
298 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

powers to Indian Band Councils. Overall, however, Status Indians remained on the margins of society, subject to
assimilation, and denied a federal vote until 1960. Was their contribution to Canadas war effort worth it?

Key Points

Aboriginal people were marginalized, oppressed, and neglected by the Canadian state and yet many
took up arms in support of Canadas effort in the two World Wars.
Conscription applied to Status Indians, a fact to which many First Nations people objected.
Resources made available to non-Aboriginal soldiers after demobilization were not extended to Sta-
tus Indian recruits.
Aboriginal people took advantage of the Second World Wars pro-democracy rhetoric to
advance their own agenda for greater liberties and recognition in Canada.
Despite the contribution made in wartime, fifteen years would pass between the end of WWII and
the enfranchisement of Status Indians.

Attributions
Figure 6.19
Elders and Indian soldiers in the uniform of the Canadian Expeditionary Force (Online MIKAN no. 3192219)
by Library and Archives Canada / PA-041366 is in the public domain.

Figure 6.20
WAR 1914 1918 ENLISTMENTS AND WAR ACTIVITIES OF INDIANS (PHOTOS OF INDIAN SOL-
DIERS) (Online MIKAN no.2095973) by Government is in the public domain.

Figure 6.21
Sergeant Tommy Prince (R), M.M., 1st Canadian Parachute Battalion, with his brother, Private Morris Prince,
at an investiture at Buckingham Palace (Online MIKAN no.3191550) by Christopher J. Woods / Canada. Dept.
of National Defence / Library and Archives Canada / PA-142289 is in the public domain.
6.13 Canada between the UK and the US

Figure 6.22 Meeting in Quebec City in 1943 (clockwise from the

rear): Mackenzie King, Winston Churchill, Governor-General the
Earl of Althone, and Franklin Roosevelt.

The fall of France in 1940 sent ripples across the Atlantic. It was clear that a German attack on North America
was not unthinkable. Americans were increasingly concerned, although their government officially held fast to a
policy of isolationism. If Britain fell and it might plans were afoot to transfer to Canada the Royal Family
and the British government, along with whatever war material and resources could be saved. The Germans would
never tolerate a government in exile so it was believed almost certainly that Canada would then be attacked.

Under these circumstances, King recognized the need to secure American support and on 16 August 1940, he met
secretly with President Franklin Delano Roosevelt (1882-1945) in a railcar at Ogdensburg, New York. Out of that
meeting came the Permanent Joint Board of Defense, a collaborative military body with oversight though not
control over the armed forces of both countries. The Ogdensburg Agreement, as it came to be known, was
an undeniable compromising of Canadian sovereignty but clearly one that King felt was essential under the cir-
cumstances. Kings own long experience of working with the Americans he spent the Great War in the United
States and was familiar with elite circles south of the border made him more comfortable with this arrangement
than would have been the case if the stridently pro-British leader of the Conservative party, Arthur Meighen, had
been in office.

Canadas economy was still reeling from the Depression and it lacked the financial wherewithal to put its indus-
tries on a wartime footing. Britains financial resources were also limited, so American involvement was required
to underwrite British contracts. This Lend-Lease Agreement extended the life of Canadian sales to Britain and
stimulated the Dominions industrial resurrection. Although the United States was not yet at war, it was building
up its own arms and could turn to Canada for additional capacity. An arrangement to do so and integrate the two
economies during the term of the war the Hyde Park Agreement was signed on 20 April 1941. Canadas
economic situation had suddenly and dramatically changed.

299
300 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Goods could now be made but they had to be delivered as well. Following on Ogdensburg, arrangements were
made to ship American supplies to Britain and Russia through Canadian ports. Doing so meant expanding the size
of a pitiably small pre-War navy (seven warships) into a force that could contribute to the Battle of the Atlantic.
Naval personnel tripled to 10,000 men and women by the end of 1940 while the Canadian fleet expanded rapidly
as well.

In 1943 Canada would host a meeting between Roosevelt and British Prime Minister Winston Churchill. The
First Quebec Conference allowed the two leading Allied powers and to a lesser degree, Canada to begin
planning for the invasion and liberation of France. Throughout these meetings and in other negotiations involving
the three nations, King played the role of the broker and the bridge; historians have tended to conclude, however,
that Kings role was peripheral.

Key Points

Britains vulnerability in 1940 persuaded King to look to the United States for financial and materiel
support in the war effort.
The Permanent Joint Board of Defense and the Ogdensburg Agreement mark the beginning of
Canadas new military relationship with the United States.
The Lend-Lease Agreement was key in supplying wartime Britain and rebuilding Canadian manu-
facturing after the Depression.
The Hyde Park Agreement involved a further integration of the North American economies.
Kings objective was to position Canada as a middle power between Britain and the United States.

Attributions
Figure 6.22
RooseveltChurchillMackenzie by Reisio is in the public domain.
6.14 Global War

The War in the Pacific

American reluctance to enter the war was abandoned on 6 December 1941 when the Japanese Navy bombed the
Hawaiian port of Pearl Harbor. The American Pacific Fleet was destroyed in a matter of hours and America was
at war. Canada declared war on Japan the very next day, despite the fact that it had already taken steps to counter
Japanese advances in East Asia. In November 1941, more than a thousand Canadian troops arrived in Hong Kong
to shore up British, Indian, and Chinese troops in the event of a Japanese attack. On 8 December, the Empire
turned its attention to the British colony, confronting Canadian troops for the first time on 11 December. Two
weeks and 290 casualties later, the Canadian troops surrendered, along with the rest of the Allied forces in the
area. The Canadian soldiers would spend the remainder of the war in notoriously brutal prisoner of war (POW)
camps where another 267 died. Canadians would play only a marginal role in the Pacific War thereafter, even
though Japanese submarines were found patrolling the waters off Nootka Sound where they shelled the lighthouse
at Estevan Point.

Figure 6.23 Canadian prisoners of war (POWs) in the aftermath.

A stunning failure: the Dieppe Raid tested German coastal
defences at the expense of Canadian troops.

War in Europe
After the hopeless task of defending Hong Kong, Canadian troops wouldnt see action until 19 August 1942. The
Dieppe Raid was meant to test resources, probe German coastal defences, and gather intelligence. Five thousand
Canadians many of them desperately bored after two years of being stationed in Britain were sent ashore
along with 1,000 British troops and a handful of American Army Rangers. They had inadequate air cover and their
understanding of the terrain and its obstacles was entirely inadequate. They were instantly pinned down by sniper
fire and unable to advance or retreat. More than 900 of the Canadian contingent were killed and nearly 2,000
captured; among those who made it back to the ships, a significant share was wounded. Losses totaling nearly
3,000 came as a terrible blow to Canadian morale and, although the British justified Dieppe as the practice-run
that made the subsequent Normandy invasion a success, for Canadians it was difficult to reconcile.

301
302 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Nearly a year later, Canadian forces got a third crack at the Axis nations, this time in Italy. The Canadian First
Division joined with the British Eighth Army in December 1943 and took Sicily in a week, despite strong resis-
tance from German troops. Moving onto the coast of Italy, the Canadians pressed northward, their progress
impeded mainly by surrendering Italians. The Italian government capitulated on 8 September 1943 and, in a panic,
German dispatched large numbers of their own troops to disarm the remaining Italian forces, seize control of Italy,
and block the invading forces.

Difficult terrain gave the Germans the advantage. Forward movement for the Allied troops was very slow and
bloody. The Germans established a series of defensive barriers south of Rome, and were able to use relatively
small numbers to pin down the much larger invading armies then retreat to newly erected barriers from which
they would continue their effective harassment.

The Allied invasion of Italy, in which Canadians played an important role, became bogged down. The Mussolini
government had fallen and the Italian Army was effectively no more; its replacement with an occupying German
army transformed the campaign almost immediately from one of conquest to one of liberation. Some 700,000
recalcitrant Italian troops were captured by the Wehrmacht and forced north to work in German labour camps.
There was only a small residue of pro-Hitler Italian troops left on the ground. The remaining Axis forces, how-
ever, were enough to stall Allied progress up the Italian boot. Victories were scored at Naples and, for the Cana-
dians in particular, at Ortona, but the gains came slowly and painfully. More than 1,300 Canadians from the 1st
Division were dead. Building-to-building fighting characterized much of the combat at Ortona and across the Ger-
man Gustav Line that guarded the southern access to Rome. The siege of Monte Cassino in which Canadians
played a significant role saw a 5th century Benedictine monastery bombed out of existence in an attempt to dis-
lodge German snipers; the rubble provided even better cover for the German troops and the Allied victory, when
it came, was purchased at a high price. The Gustav Line was breached and the Germans fell back to the Hitler
Line; fighting there was quick the Line fell in four days but it cost another 900 Canadian lives. It took
nearly two years to completely route the German forces and overcome the final barrier in the north of Italy: the
Gothic Line. This protracted battle saw the heaviest engagement of Canadian Armoured Divisions in the whole
of the war; 4,000 more Canadians died in a month of pitched fighting.

Oversight of Canadian troops continued to be a point of contention. The British Eighth Army subsumed a Cana-
dian Corps consisting most importantly of heavy armour, which alarmed some Canadian officials. Canadian
politicians, diplomats, and field officers were constantly alert to further British and American attempts to bring
Canadians under their command. This serves to remind us that the Allied field was dominated, not by the Cana-
dians, but by the Americans (who, in Italy, rolled into Rome with the support of the Free French) and the British
(whose battalions were a cosmopolitan mix of colonials, refugees from Poland and other countries conquered by
the Axis powers, and members of the local anti-fascist resistance). Canadians moved forward in the field when
the larger partners in the Alliance were ready and often had to wait patiently while the Americans and the British
sorted out their different goals and strategies.

D-Day
Rome fell on 4 June and two days later the Allies created a second western front. The Normandy invasions (Oper-
ation Neptune) constitute one of the most complex and largest military operations ever. Air, sea, and land forces
were deployed to soften up German positions, neutralize U-boat and naval countermeasures, and to secure the
 6.14 GLOBAL WAR 303

French shoreline. Five beaches were targeted and the Canadian forces focused on a 10 km stretch between the
towns of Saint-Aubin and La Rivire, code-named Juno.

As Second World War battles go, this was Canadas finest hour. The German defences at Juno survived the
preparatory air assaults and the beach was bristling with obstacles. In a matter of hours, however, Canadian troops
had overrun Juno and were pressing further and faster inland than either the British or the Americans. More than
1,000 Canadian casualties and missing troops constituted a significant loss but expectations were much worse.
And, indeed, there was worse to come. Largely inexperienced Canadian infantry fought battle-hardened German
troops and armoured divisions and they did so with inferior weaponry and inadequate relief regiments. Exhausted,
they nevertheless pressed on along the French coast, liberating ports including Dieppe, the scene of the disas-
trous assault in 1942, and Dunkirk.

As the battle across Normandy Operation Overlord made its way south and eastward, Canadian troops
were to prove their worth and to take severe losses in several confrontations with an increasingly desperate
Wehrmacht. The liberation of the Netherlands was principally a Canadian task, as was dislodging the German
positions in the Scheldt Estuary (the Battle of the Scheldt), which opened badly needed Allied supply lines
through Antwerp. At the Falaise Gap in the second week of August 1944 the First Canadian Army launched
Operation Totalize, which involved unusual and high risk nighttime tactics that won the goal but cost much in
lives. None of the German positions were easily cleared and matters worsened in the cold and wet winter of 1945
as Allied troops pressed into the Rhineland. A German counterattack caught the British and American leadership
napping, leading to the Battle of the Bulge. In response, the largest force under Canadian command launched
Operation Veritable into the Reichswald and Hochwald Forests, followed in late February by Operation Block-
buster that routed the German defences. Canadian and other Allied forces now had a clear route on German ter-
ritory. Two months later the Thousand Year Reich was finished.

Key Points

Canada followed the United States into the war against Japan, although its commitments in Hong
Kong already put it in the crosshairs of the Empire.
Losses in Hong Kong marked the effective end of Canadas role in the Pacific. Thereafter efforts
focused on the European theatre.
Major Canadian operations include the failed invasion at Dieppe, the Allied invasion of Italy, and the
D-Day attacks on the Normandy coastline.

Attributions
Figure 6.23
Canadian prisoners of war being lead through Dieppe by German soldiers (Online MIKAN no.3194292) by
Library and Archives Canada / C-014171 is in the public domain.
 6.15 The Home Front

Figure 6.24 By 1943 the war was being

fought on several fronts, including the front
yard (though mostly the back). Victory
Gardens symbolized here by the woman
with the hoe were a way in which
Canadians could contribute to the war effort
and a way in which they came to feel
engaged in what was otherwise a remote
event.

As was the case in what was now described as the First World War or World War I, the Second World War
called for sweeping civilian resources and involvement. The lessons of 1914-1918 were near enough in peoples
memories that the idea of Victory Bonds or women working in munitions factories needed little introduction. It is
unlikely that Rosie the Riveter did the same job in both wars, but entirely feasible that she was doing the sort of
work in the 1940s that her mother, or at least women of her mothers generation, performed two decades earlier.

The extent of Canadians engagement in the war was largely a function of numbers. Out of a population of 11 mil-
lion, only 8 million were over the age of 18 years. This was not enough to meet both the need for a million-man
army and the rapid increase in demand for food exports and munitions headed for Britain. Able-bodied men were
forced out of what were now regarded as non-essential jobs (like taxi driving, the production of sporting goods,
1
and the sale of real estate) so that they could tackle war industries or service in the forces. Conscription might be
an issue that the government wished to avoid but enlisting workers from non-traditional sources was a task they
hurried to manage.

Women in Industry
In March 1942, Ottawa took the unprecedented step of registering every woman born between 1918 and 1922
under an order-in-council called the National Selective Service Regulations. (Similar orders were passed that iden-

1. Desmond Morton, A Military History of Canada, 5th edition (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 2007), 184-5.

304
 6.15 THE HOME FRONT 305

tified and regulated men from 17 to 70 years of age, and ensured that key industries including school teaching
would not be abandoned by workers too eager to join up or find better paying work as it came along.) Within
a year there were 373,000 women in manufacturing jobs (of which 261,000 worked in munitions) and another
439,000 in the service sector. Nearly one-in-three workers in Canadas aviation industry mostly dedicated at
2
this time, of course, to fighter and transport aircraft were women. Overall it has been reckoned that there were
more than a million women in the full-time workforce, and that figure does not include women in the agricultural
3
sector, nor does it include women in part-time paid labour.

One area of spectacular expansion was shipbuilding. The collapsed economy of the 1930s witnessed a running
down of capacity along the nations waterfronts. It was thought that there were, on the eve of the war, three active
shipyards in the whole country and these employed fewer than 4,000 men. This expanded to 90 yards employing
4
over 126,000 women and men. Shipyards in wartime Vancouver alone employed some 17,000 workers per-
haps half of them women and the several slipways were launching a Victory Ship a week between them. The
Canadian fleet was, by the end of the war, probably the 5th largest on earth, a position onto which it would not
hold.

Figure 6.25 Starting in 1942, Vancouvers Burrard Drydock hired

more than 1,000 women. Here we see the unions shop stewards
eating in the shipyard canteen, ca. 1942.

The war opened opportunities, too, for women at levels above the shop floor. Probably the best known and most
honoured example is Elsie Queen of the Hurricanes MacGill (1905-80), the worlds first female aeronautical
engineer. She was the daughter of a prominent lawyer father and a feminist/suffragette mother Helen Gregory
MacGill who was a pioneer woman on the British Columbian bench. Elsie MacGills transition into manage-
ment of the Canadian Car and Foundry company put her in charge of a mainly female workforce that churned out
more than 1,400 fighter aircraft (Hawker Hurricanes) before the end of the war.

Figure 6.26 Elsie MacGill claimed early in her

career, Although I never learned to fly myself, I
accompanied the pilots on all test flights even
the dangerous first flight of any aircraft I
worked on.

2. Canadian War Museum, Democracy at War, accessed 15 November 2015, [Link]

canadawar/women_e.shtml.
3. Ruth Roach Pierson, "They're Still Women After All," The Second World War and Canadian Womanhood (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart,
1986): 9.
4. Canadian War Museum, Democracy at War, accessed 16 November 2015, [Link]
canadawar/shipping_e.shtml.
 306 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Sea blockades meant that raw materials necessary to war industries were feared to be in jeopardy from 1939
on. Women were tasked with organizing scrap drives, salvaging metals and rubber in particular but also kitchen
scraps. Bones and fat used in the production of ammunition were a special target; scavenging families in
5
Winnipeg accumulated more than a million pounds of fat and bones over the course of the war. In practice, it
was the children of urban areas who took the lead on salvage crusades, rather naturally lending it a competitive
flavour.

Figure 6.27 Recycling never looked so stylish.

Canadian women were called upon to reduce
waste and serve the war effort through
salvage.

The careful management of resources extended to the food supply. Britains trade corridors were cut off so Cana-
dian food production had to increase (difficult to do in times of labour shortages) and more had to be diverted
to exports. As early as 1941, Canada was providing 77% of Britains flour and wheat. By the end of the war a
quarter of the cheese, two-fifths of the bacon, and 15% of the eggs consumed in Britain came from Canadian
6
farms. While the Wartime Prices and Trade Board (WPTB) established limits on consumption and price-gouging,
Ottawas various agencies encouraged Canadians to turn their gardens into small farms.

Canadians could feel the war in their stomachs and see it on their plates. They could also wear the war effort
because of restrictions on fabric for clothing. Excessive trim was pared back, leading to narrower lapels on mens
suits and a narrower cut on womens clothes along with shorter hems. One explanation for the so-called zoot suit
riots of the closing years of the war was the apparent and unpatriotic use of too much cloth on the exag-
gerated shoulders and thighs of the zoot suiters eponymous jackets and trousers. (The fact that Vancouvers zoot
7
suiters were mainly drawn from the Italian community in the East End may have been another local factor.)

Figure 6.28 Lorne Greene (1915-87) would achieve notoriety

on the CBC as The Voice of Canada. Assigned the task of
reading out the names of soldiers and other Canadians killed in
combat or at sea and because of his deep resonant voice he
was more widely known as The Voice of Doom.

5. Ian Mosby, Food on the Home Front during the Second World War, Wartime Canada, accessed 15 November 2015, [Link]
[Link]/essay/eating/food-home-front-during-second-world-war.
6. Ian Mosby, Food Will Win the War: The Politics, Culture, and Science of Food on Canadas Home Front (Vancouver: University of British
Columbia Press, 2014), 4.
7. Zoot Suit Riots, Past Tense: Vancouver History, Lani Russwurm, accessed 17 November 2015, [Link]
2008/03/03/zoot-suit-riots-2/.
 6.15 THE HOME FRONT 307

Wartime Cultures
While escapism defined much of the entertainment produced in the 1930s, the war provided subject matter galore.
Canadian comic books enjoyed a brief period of popularity as competitive American publications were frozen
out of the market. The most successful of these, Johnny Canuck, appeared in 1941 but did not survive the war
years. Hollywood movies had all but completely superseded vaudeville by 1939; feature films and short (gen-
erally cheaply made) serials were an important means of transmitting anti-German and anti-Japanese sentiment.
They sometimes featured Canadian characters (usually played by Americans) so as to give American audiences
a sense of the role played by allies. The 1943 war-thriller, Northern Pursuit, featured the great matinee idol and
action actor, Errol Flynn, portraying a Mountie who captures German saboteurs determined to disrupt Canadian-
American supply lines. What is noteworthy about this film is that Flynn plays a German-Canadian whose eth-
nicity draws the suspicion of his RCMP colleagues until his loyalty to Canada is made clear. The Canadian film
industry, small though it was, produced propaganda-inflected films, including the National Film Boards Canada
Carries On series (many of which were narrated by Lorne Greene). Warclouds over the Pacific, for example, was
released on 1 December 1941, days before the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, but it made clear Canadas official
perspective on the dangers coming from that direction.

Radio was, in the 1930s and 1940s, at its peak as an electronic media. The presence of the CBC at this time
provided another government-controlled means of being bombarded with news about the war and further
demands for personal sacrifice. Radio waves were not as respectful of borders as print media, so American pro-
gramming and propaganda was part and parcel of most urban Canadians listening diet.

Many of these media traded in fear as a means of whipping up support for the war. Routine precautions training
children on the east and west coast on what to expect in the event of a surprise German or Japanese attack, or the
mandatory use of black-out blinds and headlamp covers so as to confuse aerial scouts from Japan added to the
sense that there was real danger nearby and not only on the war front.

In a multitude of ways, then, the Second World War certainly felt more like a total war. It was impossible to avoid
news, film, rationing, restrictions, admonitions, salvage drives, calls for volunteers, and requests for more Victory
Bonds. Canadians experienced it with a mixture of emotions, though, including grateful relief that the Depression
years were finally over (although fearful they might return). Full employment even at a time of rationing and
very little in the way of consumer goods to purchase was a good thing.

Key Points

As a total war, WWII made greater demands on Canadians on the home front than was the case in
1914-18.
Ottawa introduced regulations to manage the supply of labour and to ensure the continuation of
essential industries.
Women entered waged labour in war industries in large numbers, taking jobs that were vacated by
servicemen and newly created positions as well.
Scrap drives were a means of obtaining scarce materials and directly involving women and children
308 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

in the war effort.

Film and radio both mostly interwar innovations contributed significantly to the propaganda
campaign.

Attributions
Figure 6.24
Attack on all Fronts : war propaganda campaign World War II (Online MIKAN no.2860024) by Library and
Archives Canada, Acc. No. 1987-72-105 The Hubert Rogers Collection, Gift of Mrs. Helen Priest Rogers is in
the public domain.

Figure 6.25
Shop Stewards at Burrard Drydock by Skeezix1000 is in the public domain.

Figure 6.26
Elsie macgill by Elsie Gregory MacGill / Library and Archives Canada is in the public domain. This image is
available from Library and Archives Canada under the reference number 3206015.

Figure 6.27
Were in the army now by Canada. Dept. of Public Information is used under a CC-BY-SA 2.0 license. This
image is available from Toronto Public Library under the identifier 1939-45. Salvage. Item 12. L.

Figure 6.28
Commentator Lorne Greene broadcasting over the C.B.C. national network (Online MIKAN no.3191942) by
Ronny Jaques / National Film Board of Canada / Library and Archives Canada / PA-116178 is in the public
domain.
6.16 Enlisted Women, Conscription, and the Zombie Army

Figure 6.29 Personnel of the Canadian Womens Army Corps at

No. 3 CWAC (Basic) Training Centre, Kitchener, ON, 1944.

Mandatory military service was, for King and his contemporaries, the great bogeyman of Canadian affairs. It
drove a wedge between French and English Canadians in the First World War and there was no appetite for a
repeat of that experience. When asked whether he would introduce conscription, King famously replied not nec-
essarily conscription but conscription if necessary. Even the Conservative Leader of the Official Opposition,
Robert Manion (1881-1943) was hostile to the idea of conscription. Like Borden in 1914-17, King hoped for a
volunteer army. He had luck on his side.

The Depression had two consequences that supported early enlistments. First, people were poor and desperate for
a regular paycheque. Joining up meant an income and the government paid ones living costs as well. It also, for
a great many, meant dignity, something that was in short supply in the 1930s. In addition, many of the unemployed
and working Canadians sympathized and identified with the communists (both those crushed in the Spanish Civil
War and the regime in the Kremlin) and/or with the victims of German and Italian invasions in Europe and else-
where (see Section 7.9). An anti-fascist popular front had formed across communist and social-democratic lines
that replaced the pro-Empire sensibilities of August 1914 with something more ideological.

Demand for conscription was strong, however, in English Canadian circles, right from 1939. Its advocates argued
that this was a total war and that playing catch-up with troop numbers as Borden had was unacceptable.
The National Resources Mobilization Act, 1940 (NRMA) passed in June, when the war was not yet a year old and
Canadian troops had not yet seen combat, other than those who retreated via Dunkirk a month earlier. The Act
allowed Ottawa to register all men eligible for service and to call them up to for home defence if needed. There
was plenty of home defence work to be done and these conscripts contemptuously described by their peers as
zombies could attend to that. Support among Kings Quebec MPs was muted but it was a good compromise
in that it satisfied some on both sides of the question while not angering any single constituency.

By 1942, however, casualties abroad and in the Battle of the Atlantic meant that numbers needed to be replen-

309
310 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

ished. Arthur Meighen was once again leader of the Conservatives and, unlike his predecessor, Manion, was
enthusiastically in support of conscription. Kings strategy was to hold a plebiscite in April asking the electorate
to release him from his earlier promise to spare conscripts from service abroad. Although the aggregate returns
were 64% in favour of sending zombies abroad, the Quebec numbers were a very decisive 72% against. King now
had the instrument in his hands to recruit and mobilize more soldiers but felt powerless to use it.

Figure 6.30 Nursing Sisters Atala Coulombe, Elizabeth Gordon,

Nan Prescott, and Frances Tetlaw of the No.15 Canadian General
Hospital, RCA Medical Corps, at El Arrouch.

By 1944, the Canadian armed forces incorporated more than 500,000 fighting men; 21,600 women signed on for
the Canadian Womens Army Corps (CWACs), another 23,000 joined the RCAF (Womens Division) and the
Womens Royal Canadian Naval Service (WRCNS or, simply and elegantly, the Wrens), and nearly 5,000
more served as nursing sisters in the armed forces. Kings insistence that Canadian troops participate in the Italian
campaign split the armed services command and reduced the likelihood of reinforcements to either the Mediter-
ranean front or Normandy. Both Canadian armies were in some difficulty as a result. By mid-summer in 1944 the
question of conscription was back on the table. Reluctantly, in November 1944, King agreed to deploy some of the
zombies. Riots broke out in Montreal and Quebec and protests among zombies in camps across British Columbia.
The mutiny in Terrace in northwestern BC was the largest military rising, with French-Canadian conscripts joined
by English-Canadian zombies.

What saved Kings political career in this instance was the rapidly closing window of war. By the time the con-
scripts reached Europe the war was all but over.

Key Points

Voluntarism was made easy by the poor economic conditions in the 1930s and widespread working-
class opposition to European fascism.
Conscription was introduced to beef up the home defence campaign and Kings government
promised not to send unwilling conscripts abroad.
In the midst of the 1944 Italian and Normandy campaigns, King broke his earlier commitment and
ordered home defence conscripts or zombies into active service, producing a rash of
protests.

Attributions
Figure 6.29
 6.16 ENLISTED WOMEN, CONSCRIPTION, AND THE ZOMBIE ARMY 311

Personnel of the Canadian Womens Army Corps at No. 3 CWAC (Basic) Training Centre (Online MIKAN no.
3207287) by Canada. Dept. of National Defence / Library and Archives Canada / PA-145516 is in the public
domain.

Figure 6.30
Nursing sisters of No.15 Canadian General Hospital, Royal Canadian Army Medical Corps (R.C.A.M.C.), El
Arrouch, Algeria, 15 July 1943 (Online MIKAN no. 3599960) by Lieut. Terry F. Rowe / Canada. Dept. of
National Defence / Library and Archives Canada / PA-213771 is in the public domain.
 6.17 Japanese Canadians in the Second World War

JORDAN STANGER-ROSS (UNIVERSITY OF VICTORIA) PAMELA SUGIMAN (RYERSON UNIVERSITY) &

THE LANDSCAPES OF INJUSTICE RESEARCH COLLECTIVE

Figure 6.31 Sutekichi Miyagawas internment identification card.

The Second World War internment of all persons of the Japanese race serves as a powerful reminder to all Cana-
dians that the rights of citizenship can be legally revoked and that the history of our country is not one of racial
harmony.

In September 1946, a Japanese Canadian woman named Tsurukichi Takemoto wrote officials to protest what she
had experienced since Canadas entry into the war in the Pacific (7 December 1941). Alongside many others in her
community, Tsurukichi had been interned in Greenwood, a former ghost town in the interior of British Colum-
bia and one of several similarly isolated sites used by the federal government.

For roughly 22,000 Canadians of Japanese descent, regardless of social class, sex, age, and generation, it turned
out that race superseded citizenship. Angered by the violation of her rights, in two letters dated 5 September
1946, Tsurukichi forcefully reminded government officials, [w]e are not Japanese Nationals. With outrage, she
explained:

I did not answer until now because your letter just made me mad enough not to answer . . . Isnt the method
youre using like the Nazis? Do you think it is democratic? No! I certainly think youre just like the Fascists
confiscating peoples property, chasing them out of their homes, sending them out to a kind of a concentration
camp, special registration cards, permits for traveling [sic]. Dont you think this is the method used in dictator-
1
ship countries[?] Democracy means no racial discrimination, or is it the very opposite[?]

What historical conditions precipitated Tsurukichis anger? Did her charges hit their mark? What prompted some

1. Mr. Tsurukichi Takemoto to H.F. Green [Image 1634], and to G.B. Spain [1635], 5 September 1946, Office of the Custodian of Enemy Property Records,
Vancouver Office Files, Reel C9476, Hritage Project, [Link].

312
 6.17 JAPANESE CANADIANS IN THE SECOND WORLD WAR 313

Japanese Canadians to liken their treatment at the hands of the Canadian government to those enacted by the most
brutally racist regimes of the era? These questions remain troubling today.

The Governments wartime treatment of Japanese Canadians was supported by hundreds of legal enactments,
most of them made possible by the War Measures Act. The War Measures Act gave the cabinet of Prime Minister
William Lyon Mackenzie King the power to regulate all persons of the Japanese race through Orders-in-Coun-
cil: that is, declarations of law that bypassed debate in the legislature and proved resistant to judicial challenge.

Such policies had dramatic consequences for all Japanese Canadians. Property owned by Japanese Canadians
was stolen, looted, destroyed, and neglected. What survived was sold without the consent of its owners. While
they received some compensation for these sales, owners had no opportunity to challenge the (often highly
unfavourable) terms of exchange and they lost the right not to sell. Further, the proceeds of these sales were doled
out as allowances to Japanese Canadians who were struggling to support themselves while interned. Tsurukichis
letter highlights one womans resistance to the forced sale of her familys property. Informed that government
agents had sold her familys belongings for a fraction of their value, Tsurukichi became mad enough not to
answer. Family heirlooms, including fine Japanese pottery, she informed officials, are not what you think they
are: such belongings left in trust to Canadian officials had monetary value and emotional meaning that was all
but discarded as they were auctioned to eager buyers while their legitimate owners remained interned. Another
Japanese Canadian, whose home, 17.5 acres of land, and his personal belongings had been sold without his con-
sent, wrote, It does not seem just that as Canadians my family should be deprived of a home which to us meant
2
more than just a home. It was, to us, the foundation of security and freedom as Canadian citizens.

Figure 6.32 The roundup of fishing boats belonging to

Japanese-Canadian internees, prior to sale.

Internment meant different things for different groups of people. In addition to the wartime dispossession of prop-
erty, government policies required that Japanese Canadians carry special registration cards and obey curfews, face
restricted mobility and communications, and live with the constant threat of arbitrary searches of their homes.
As well, the internment resulted in the separation of families, forced labour for men, and for some, incarceration
in prisoner of war camps in northern Ontario. When the government declared Canadas west coast a protected
area, the entire Japanese Canadian population was uprooted. Some 12,000 Japanese Canadians were sent by train
to live in hastily constructed shacks and abandoned buildings in various parts of the BC interior: Greenwood, San-
don, Kaslo, New Denver, Rosebery, Slocan City, Bay Farm, Popoff, Lemon Creek, and Tashme. Approximately
4,000 were sent to labour on sugar beet farms in Alberta and Manitoba. And slightly over 1,000 who had suf-
ficient funds established so-called self-supporting camps where they essentially paid for the costs of their own
internment.

Toward the wars end, Japanese Canadians were forced to choose between a further uprooting to the unknown
territory of Eastern Canada and exile to Japan, a country that many had never before visited. Almost 4,000 Japan-

2. Mr. Rikizo Yoneyama to Minister of Justice [Image 1448], 31 July 1944, Office of the Custodian of Enemy Property Records, Vancouver
Office Files, Reel C9476, Hritage Project, [Link].
 314 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

ese Canadians were eventually deported to Japan. All Japanese Canadians were prohibited from returning to
British Columbia until 1949.

In the decades following these events, defenders of the policies have argued that they resulted from the pressures
of war. In the first year of Canadas war with Japan, many politicians and social commentators expressed genuine,
though ill-informed, concerns that Japanese Canadians could threaten the security of Canadas West Coast. How-
ever, the enforcement of policies that violated the rights and freedoms of all persons of the Japanese race, rather
than more targeted measures to regulate the lives of individuals specifically suspected of collusion with Japan,
reflected the racist ideologies that buttressed the wartime treatment of the Japanese Canadian community. Prime
Minister King expressed such ideologies in 1942 when he privately stated that no matter how honourable they
might appear to be, or how long they may have been away from Japan, naturalized, or even those who were born
3
in [Canada]. Everyone of them . . . would be saboteurs and would help Japan when the moment came. Cabinet
Minister Ian Mackenzie, the federal politician most closely connected with these policies similarly argued to a
constituent:

I do not think that any question of nationality [that is, Canadian citizenship] should prevent our having the right to advo-
cate . . . their complete removal to their own country. Their country should never have been Canada . . . I do not believe
4
the Japanese are an assimilable race.

Such positions, as critics such as Tsurukichi Takemoto realized, were not merely the regrettable isolated actions
of some Canadians who panicked at a time of war. Rather, they were part of the systemic racism that pervades
5
Canadas history.

Figure 6.33 A very young David Suzuki with his two sisters in an
internment camp during WWII.

Key Points

Following Pearl Harbor, some 22,000 Canadians of Japanese descent or nationality were stripped of
their property and interned under the War Measures Act.
Internees property was often auctioned off or otherwise sold with no compensation to the owners.
Japanese Canadians rights were severely curtailed and, at wars end, they were encouraged to either
migrate to Eastern Canada or choose exile to Japan.
White Canadians fears of the Japanese community were entangled in a racist notion that essential-
ized loyalty to the Japanese Empire.

3. The Diaries of William Lyon Mackenzie King, February 28, 1942, available online at Library and Archives Canada.
4. Letter to Godwin, 7 December 1942, File 70-25, MG 27 III-B5, Library and Archives Canada.
5. For information on the Landscapes of Injustice Research Collective and its publishing conventions, see [Link].
 6.17 JAPANESE CANADIANS IN THE SECOND WORLD WAR 315

Attributions
Figure 6.31
Back of Sutekichi Miyagawas internment identification card issued by the Canadian Government in com-
pliance with Order-in-Council P.C. 117 (Online MIKAN no. 3226949) by Library and Archives Canada/
PA-103543 is in the public domain.

Figure 6.32
Fishermens Reserve rounding up Japanese-Canadian fishing vessels (Online MIKAN no.3193627) by Canada.
Dept. of National Defence / Library and Archives Canada / PA-037467 is in the public domain.

Figure 6.33
David Suzuki and his two sisters in an internment camp (Online MIKAN no. 3526055) by Margaret C. Foster,
Library and Archives Canada, Acc. no. 1976-087, PA-187835 is in the public domain.
6.18 From V-E to V-J

Figure 6.34 As the German army collapsed, Canadian troops

liberated one town after the next in the Netherlands. The 7th
Canadian Infantry Brigade at Zwolle, 14 April 1945.

Victory in Europe, Victory in Japan

As winter settled in across western and southern Europe, the Canadian units in Italy had an opportunity to join up
with those in France and the Low Countries. The crisis of insufficient troop reinforcements that necessitated call-
ing up additional troops passed. Fighting resumed in March 1945 and did not let up until the collapse of Germany
on 6 May. Victory in Europe (V-E) was celebrated across Canada and with drunken rioting in Halifax. What Cana-
dians at home did not see and could barely be expected to imagine was the relief of slave labour camps across the
Reich, and especially the liberation of concentration camps.

Figure 6.35 A Canadian nurse at the site of

Bergen-Belsen shortly after it was relieved
(and demolished) by Canadian and British
forces.

The war as a whole, however, was still not over. Russian troops had met with Allied forces at the Elbe River, a
symbol of the military success of the Alliance in Europe. There was, however, no immediate likelihood of a Japan-
ese surrender. Stalin agreed to Roosevelts request to turn the Red Army to the east to liberate China. Although
Japan was struggling to maintain its shipping lanes and the flow of fuel to its navies, the Empires ground troops
put up enormous resistance on every island the Americans besieged. The back of Japanese resolve was finally bro-
ken when the Red Army took Manchuria and the Americans dropped atomic bombs on two major cities: Nagasaki

316
 6.18 FROM V-E TO V-J 317

and Hiroshima. Canadians participated in the development of the atomic bomb and in the supply of uranium but
otherwise they played no significant or direct role in the Asia-Pacific War. This did not stop them from celebrating
V-J Day (Victory over Japan Day), especially in Vancouver.

Figure 6.36 Japans war against China raged from 1931 to 1945,
so V-J Day was celebrated with enormous festivities and parades
in Vancouvers Chinatown.

Taking the Toll

The number of troops lost in the war overall represented another blow to the Canadian population, and it came
only a generation after the mortality of the First World War. Some 45,000 Canadians were killed in battle or at sea
and thousands more were maimed. As was the case at the end of the First War, the extent of psychological trauma
was unmeasured, although the stigma of shell shock had been replaced in the Canadian forces by a greater
1
respect for battle exhaustion. (The term post-traumatic stress disorder would not appear until the 1970s.) The
fall of Japan was followed by the liberation of POW camps containing Canadian prisoners. Their captivity began
in December 1941 with the capture of Hong Kong and their numbers were increased with other Canadians cap-
tured at Singapore. Their treatment was appalling, mortality rates were very high, and psychological damage was
severe. Reintegration of service men and women into Canada in peacetime would present challenges.

Against this toll, Canadas cities were not in ruins. Infrastructure was in some respects badly neglected and factory
machinery was worn out or in sore need of reorientation to peacetime production; in some respects, rebuilding
from scratch would have been easier than repurposing exhausted equipment and assembly lines. The ability and
will of the state to intervene in the economic and social well-being of Canadians was far advanced on what it had
been in the 1930s. Some of these social and economic themes are explored in the chapters that follow. What is
worth underlining here is that the wars were unprecedented events globally and for Canada in particular. Canada
had long been a country that looked upriver from the Gulf of St. Lawrence; on account of two world wars, Canada
was now a nation that had a growing sense of having a place in the wider world.

The Kamloops Kid

Kanao Inouye was born in Kamloops, BC to Japanese immigrants. He attended the local elementary school
and then the family moved to the coast where he attended Vancouver Technical School. In 1938 he trav-
elled to Japan to complete his education, and in 1942 he was an enlisted man serving as an interpreter in
the Imperial Army and on hand for the mopping up after the fall of Hong Kong.
Inouyes principal role was that of interpreter but he was given a long leash when it came to abusing and

1. Terry Copp and William McAndrew, Battle Exhaustion: Soldiers and Psychiatrists in the Canadian Army, 1939-1945 (Montreal & Kingston:
McGill-Queens University Press, 1990).
318 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

even torturing prisoners and suspected spies. He lashed out at Canadian POWs in particular, claiming that
he was getting even for years of ill-treatment by whites in BC. Known to the Canadian prisoners as the
Kamloops Kid, Inouyes brutality led to deaths and, subsequently, to his arrest after Japans capitulation.
While several Japanese officers stood trial at wars end for war crimes, Sargeant Inouye could not. Born in
Canada, he was viewed by the international tribunal as a Canadian citizen. This was technically impos-
sible as Canadian citizenship as opposed to British subjecthood was only introduced in 1946. Whats
more, as a Japanese Canadian his citizenship rights in Canada were poor before 1941 and they became
even more limited with the Internment. So, immediately after the war, it seemed that he was going to be
spared execution because of a citizenship that he could never have claimed at home in Canada.
The irony deepens. As a Canadian citizen Inouye was subject to Canadian laws, specifically those
regarding treason. In 1947 he was retried, found guilty, and hanged.

Key Points

The fall of Germany in 1945 was followed by the collapse of Japan after two atomic bombs were
dropped on populated centres.
The death toll among Canadian troops and other service men and women was not as great as in the
First World War, but it surpassed 45,000.
One effect of the war was to shift Canada toward a more global orientation, economically and politi-
cally.

Attributions
Figure 6.34
Infantrymen of the 7th Canadian Infantry Brigade liberating Zwolle, Netherlands, 14 April 1945 (Online
MIKAN no. 3191782) by Lieut. Donald I. Grant / Canada. Dept. of National Defence / Library and Archives
Canada / PA-145972 is in the public domain.

Figure 6.35
Bergen-Belsen by John Douglas Belshaw is used under a CC-BY-4.0 license.

Figure 6.36
CVA 586-3970 V.J. Day Chinese Dragon Parade by City of Vancouver Archives/Photo by Donn B.A.
Williams, 14 August 1945 is in the public domain.
6.19 Summary

Figure 6.37 Radio comedians Johnny Wayne and Frank Shuster

(aka: Wayne & Shuster) take on Hitler, ca. 1944.

Thirty-one years passed between the start of the Great War and the end of the Second World War, between an
assassination in Sarajevo and an atomic explosion over Hiroshima. Canada was at war for nearly a third of that
period. For another third, it was mired in an economic depression with terrible social consequences. The years
left over include peace and economic prosperity (albeit unevenly shared), along with a catastrophic influenza pan-
demic, a small but deep depression from 1918-21, and massive labour unrest. Looked at this way, the short 20th
century got off to a terrible start.

The wars provide a reliable theme in the writing and reading of Canadian history. They are invoked to show us
times when the nation pulled together toward a common goal against a common foe. These were nation-making
episodes. Vimy Ridge, in this account, is much more than a battle and an unspeakably bloody battle at that.
Vimy, Ypres, Passchendaele, Dieppe, Juno Beach: these are all hills that Canada went up as one thing and came
down another.

As soldiers know all too well, war is mostly waiting. And while Canadian troops and CWACs and Wrens and
others were waiting, the nation was not standing still. It found other ways in which to express itself. These
include the general suspension of civil rights and the arrest and dispossession specifically of enemy aliens in
both wars. The imposition of mandatory service conscription in both wars ran headlong into the old polar-
ities of imperialism versus nationalism, although even imperialism was being recalibrated somewhat. The state
conceded much to women during the Great War: from the position that temperance was a matter of individual
choice and morality, the nations leaders moved to outright prohibition of liquor. Likewise federal and provincial
politicians (all men at this time) abandoned the perspective that voting and life in the public sphere would place
the moral and physical fibre of Canadian womanhood at risk, extending the franchise and pressing women and
girls to serve the national interest by assuming roles in factories and civic life generally. It was also in wartime
that Ottawa submitted much of its economic and military autonomy to the country with which it had been at log-
gerheads for the better part of a century and a half.

319
320 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Certainties do not do well in times of war, although contradictions seem to thrive. While the first total war entailed
a dramatic extension of democratic rights (while reeling them back in from some groups of immigrants), the after-
math saw a crackdown on workers organizations. The interwar years continued the theme of suspicion between
the Canadian establishment and the working class, with one side claiming a monopoly on patriotic loyalty and the
interests of Canada and the other increasingly characterized as a foreign movement to be extirpated. The inabil-
ity of Depression-era governments to find and forge policies to fight crippling unemployment served to reinforce
the walls between labour and capital. R.B. Bennetts particular kind of anti-labourism cued up in the 1930s new
certainties regarding the limits of democracy. This sent activist workers running to socialist, communist, agrarian,
populist, and even fascist options many of which articulated a goal of toppling the system rather than modify-
ing it. These were new certainties going into the Second World War and it is one of the remarkable outcomes of
that conflict that it produced a post-war settlement between labour, government, and capital that would frame
prosperity for another 30 years.

At the end of the War of 1812, Aboriginal allies of the British colonies hoped for respect in return for their involve-
ment in the struggle against the United States. At the end of both World Wars, Aboriginal communities again
hoped that their warriors sacrifice and involvement would be repaid with respect. Another generation would pass
before democratic reforms would include Aboriginal voters. It would be another two decades before some of the
worst aspects of state- and church-management of First Nations would see the light of day.

It isnt that there was no appetite for reform, however. The next chapter demonstrates the extent to which Canada
as a nation wished to see extensive changes in social, moral, biological, and political relations in the post-Confed-
eration period. Viewed from that angle, one can see the war and Depression years as background to a prolonged
dialogue on the sort of people Canadians might become.

Key Terms

appeasement: Refers to Britains policy of avoiding war with Germany by making concessions.
art deco: A visual and decorative style associated with the first three decades of the 20th century and, in
its emphasis on symmetry and its association with technological advancement, is often regarded as the
foremost modernist style.
balance of power: In international relations, refers to a complex of evenly weighted alliances that theo-
retically prohibit any one participant or side from going to war.
Balfour Declaration: In 1926, a statement released at the Imperial Conference and named for the con-
ference chair, Lord Balfour. Formally recognizes the Dominions of the British Empire as autonomous
nations capable of independent action internationally and in the workings of the new British Common-
wealth of Nations.
Battle of Britain: A series of aerial attacks launched by Germany against Britain beginning in July 1940
and countered by an aerial defence. Along with the strategic night bombing campaign that followed (the
Blitz), it can be said to have lasted for nearly one year.
Battle of the Atlantic: A nearly continuous series of naval confrontations that began in 1939 and ended
only with the fall of Germany in 1945.
 6.19 SUMMARY 321

British Commonwealth of Nations: A voluntary association of Britain and its former colonies. Estab-
lished incrementally after 1919 and especially in the Balfour Declaration (1926).
Canadian Expeditionary Force (CEF): The name given to the troops sent overseas during the Great
War (World War I).
Canadian National Railway: Created in 1919 out of several financially troubled railway companies
that had been inherited by Ottawa, including the Canadian Northern Railway and the Grand Trunk Rail-
way; constituted a trans-continental operation in competition with the CPR.
Canadian Womens Army Corps (CWACs): Established in 1941 as a separate non-combatant unit
of the Canadian Army; provided support mainly as office staff, drivers/mechanics, and canteen work-
ers; some served overseas.
concentration camps: A prison camp established to contain and punish captured populations. The
British ran concentration camps for Boer prisoners in the Second Boer War; Canada placed suspected
enemy aliens Ukrainians and Germans in the Great War, Germans, Italians, and Japanese in the
Second in camps that were not punitive but nor were they appropriately provisioned; and the Ger-
mans infamously used concentration camps as the means of executing large numbers of Jewish prisoners
(along with other enemies of the Reich). Concentration camps continue to be used.
Dieppe Raid: 19 August 1942; also known as Operation Jubilee; an attack on the north coast of
France that was meant to gather intelligence for a larger subsequent invasion; of the 6,000 Allied troops
involved, 5,000 were Canadian. The mission was badly planned, atrociously researched, and tragic in its
execution. Nevertheless, it contributed intelligence that helped at Normandy three years later.
dollar-a-year men: Leading entrepreneurs, financiers, and manufacturers on loan from their companies
to the federal government for the duration of the Second World War for a nominal fee of one dollar.
Dunkirk: Refers to the hurried evacuation of Canadian, British, and other troops from the port of the
same name following their retreat in the face of Germanys invasion of northern France in 1940.
First Quebec Conference: Held in August 1943; a top-secret high level meeting between leaders and
representatives of the Canadian, British, and American governments. Canadas actual involvement did
not extend far beyond hosting the event.
flapper: Term used to describe fashionable young women in the interwar years; associated with hedo-
nism, social rebellion, and style.
Governor-General: The Crowns representative in Canada; appointed by the King or Queen.
Hyde Park Agreement, Hyde Park Declaration (1941): A wartime pact between Canada and the
United States; allowed Canadian-made goods manufactured for export to Britain to be covered under
the Britain-USA Lend-Lease Agreement.
interwar: The period between 1918 and 1939.
isolationism: The policy of isolating ones nation-state from international turmoil and alliances.
jingoism: Term coined in the 1870s; denotes patriotism applied in an aggressive foreign policy.
Canadas involvement in the Second Boer War contained elements of jingoism.
Juno: The invasion of France in 1944 code-named Operation Overlord targeted a series of beaches,
each of which was assigned its own operational name associated with alphabet call-letters. The Ameri-
can forces struck at Utah and Omaha; the British attacked Sword and Gold; the Canadian assault came
at Juno. Originally the British and Canadian beaches were named for fish (i.e.: Swordfish, Goldfish) and
Juno was called Jellyfish, but British Prime Minister Winston Churchill objected to the idea that soldiers
were bound to die on a beach code-named Jelly and insisted on the change to Juno.
322 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

King-Byng Affair: Also known as the King-Byng Thing, a constitutional crisis arising from Mackenzie
Kings test of Governor-General Byngs authority to call an election when requested by a Prime Minis-
ter.
Ku Klux Klan (KKK): An explicitly racist, anti-Catholic illegal organization with roots in the Amer-
ican South; established a presence and substantial following in Saskatchewan in the 1920s, where it
played a role in the outcome of the 1929 provincial election. Largely dissipated thereafter, the Klan
briefly reappeared in the 1970s in British Columbia, Alberta, and Ontario.
League of Nations: A post-Great War international assembly established in 1919, of which Canada
was a founding member. Its principal objective was to create conditions of collective security through
a mutual defence pact and the application of economic sanctions; failed largely because of the United
States refusal to join and member states (incuding Canadas) fear of being embroiled in conflicts (mil-
itary or economic) abroad.
Lend-Lease Agreement: Prior to declaring war against the Axis Powers in 1941, the United States
agreed to support the Allied war effort by selling materiel to Britain on a deferred-payment program.
Canada was able to take advantage of this arrangement, which led to rapid industrial recovery and
expansion. See also Hyde Park Declaration.
Manhattan Project: 1942-46; a secretive and international Second World War research and devel-
opment project conceived to develop the first atomic bomb. Canada contributed the uranium and, at
what was still a prototype reactor on the Chalk River in Ontario, developed the processes for extracting
weapons-grade plutonium.
mediums: Individuals thought to possess the ability to act as a bridge between the living and the dead;
they were the media through which messages could be transmitted; part of an early 20th century trend
toward spiritualism that was fed, in part, by the enormous mortality of WWI.
muscular Christianity: A late 19th century combination of Christian piety and athleticism, especially
as regards masculinity.
Ogdensburg Agreement: 1940, a wartime accord signed between United States President Franklin D.
Roosevelt and Canadian Prime Minister William Lyon Mackenzie King; produced the Permanent Joint
Board of Defence.
Permanent Joint Board of Defense: Established in 1940. See Ogdensburg Agreement.
Phoney War: Having declared war against Germany on 3 September 1939, France and Britain made
no effort to engage the enemy in combat for the next eight months. Note that in Canadian and British
English it is always spelled Phoney, with an e, whereas in American English it is spelled Phony.
popular front: A political alliance of left-wing, progressive parties and organizations to counter fascism
in the 1920s, 30s, and 40s.
prisoner of war (POW): In modern warfare there are conventions regarding the appropriate treatment
of captured soldiers or POWs. Most POWs are held for the duration of the war in guarded POW
camps. Camps were established in Canada to handle POWs from the European theatre of war in the
Second World War.
Progressive Party: Formed in 1920 as an alliance of the various United Farmer MPs elected to
Ottawa; initially a rural protest party with strong roots in Ontario.
Regulation 17: In Ontario, a provincial program to reduce the availability of French language educa-
tion; introduced shortly before the Great War; contributed to tensions between Francophone Quebec and
Anglophone Ontario and the federal government.
 6.19 SUMMARY 323

resistance armies: Also resistance forces, resistance movements; forces aligned against either a legit-
imate regime or an occupying regime; an unofficial army typically comprised of soldiers who have
deserted the national armed forces, as well as civilians who offer services and support to actual fighters
and sometimes fight themselves.
RCAF (Womens Division): Formed in 1941 when women from the British Royal Air Force (RAF)
arrived in Canada to assist training. Embarrassed, the RCAF agreed to accept women and became the
first branch of the armed forces to actively recruit women.
Royal Canadian Air Force (RCAF): Established in 1924 on the remains of several Great War flying
corps with Canadian personnel.
Section 98: Refers to Section 98 of the Criminal Code, which bans unlawful associations; introduced
following the Winnipeg General Strike of 1919; targeted organizations which advocate political change
through violent means; used to target the Communist Party in the 1920s and 1930s.
Status Indians: A legal identity created in the Indian Act, 1876. The Act determines who is, in law, an
Indian and who is not for the purposes of government services, annuities, suffrage, etc.
U-boat: German term for a submarine.
V-J Day: Victory in Japan Day, 15 August 1945; marked the end of the war against Japan and thus the
end of the Second World War.
Victory Bonds: Voluntary savings scheme originating in the Great War; purchasing 5 to 15 year bonds
was a means of lending funds to the federal government with which to conduct the war; paid back with
interest on their maturation.
Womens Royal Canadian Naval Service (WRCNS): Last of the womens corps to be established;
founded in 1942, it was disbanded in 1946 and reformed as a reserve force during the Korean War.

Short Answer Exercises

1. Why did Canada enter the First World War at the same time Britain did, but not the Second World
War?
2. Why did Borden opposed to womens suffrage agree to give women the vote during WWI?
3. In what ways and why did so many political leaders and military figures fail to anticipate the char-
acter of early 20th century warfare?
4. What does the term total war refer to and how is it useful in historical studies?
5. In what ways was Canada changed by the Great War?
6. What were the main features of the early feminist movement and what were its goals?
7. How did the Liberals emerge as the leading federal party in the interwar years?
8. What was the immediate economic and social impact of WWII?
9. In what ways was Newfoundlands experience of the Second World War distinct from that of
Canada?
10. How were womens lives changed by the war? What was different about womens experiences in
1939-45 compared to 1914-18?
324 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

11. What factors led to the internment of Japanese Canadians?

Suggested Readings
Cook, Tim. He was determined to go: Underage Soldiers in the Canadian Expeditionary Force, Histoire
sociale/Social history, 41, Number 81 (Mai-May 2008): 41-74.

Dick, Lyle. Sergeant Masumi Mitsui and the Japanese Canadian War Memorial, Canadian Historical Review,
91, Number 3 (September 2010): 435-63.

Humphries, Mark. Wilfully and With Intent: Self-Inflicted Wounds and the Negotiation of Power in the
Trenches, Histoire sociale/Social history, 47, Number 94 (Juin/June 2014): 369-97.

Mawani, Renisa. Regulating the Respectable Classes: Venereal Disease, Gender, and Public Health Initiatives
in Canada, 1914-35, Regulating Lives: Historical Essays on the State, Society, the Individual, and the Law
(Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press): 170-95.

Shaw, Amy. Expanding the Narrative: A First World War with Women, Children, and Grief, Canadian Histori-
cal Review, 95, Number 3 (September 2014): 398-406.

Attributions
Figure 6.37
Johnny Wayne and Frank Shuster performing in a CBC radio broadcast of The Army Show (Online MIKAN
no.3191855) by Canada. Dept. of National Defence / Library and Archives Canada / PA-152119 is in the public
domain.
 PART 8

Chapter 7. Reform Movements from the 1870s

to the 1980s

325
7.1 Introduction

Figure 7.1 The Salvation Army (aka: Sally Ann) was one of
many social reform movements that included a strong religious
element. Organized in ranks, the Salvation Army exemplifies the
crusading zeal of some of these movements. The Rat River
Salvation Army band, 1898.

There are many ways in which to contextualize reform historically. There are important economic and demo-
graphic contexts such as booms and busts, or a surfeit or dearth of children or workers and so one might be
inclined to study reform as a response to those particular circumstances. While it is true that there are often iden-
tifiable catalysts to reform movements, it is also the case that most reform movements outlive their initial context
and become much more: they become ways of viewing the world.

If this sounds vaguely religious, it should. Most movement cultures in Canada, over the last century or so, either
had roots in denominational Christianity or were a reaction to the influence of organized religion. It seems safe
to say that all were sustained over the longer term by a commitment to goals that were redemptive, a little mil-
lenarian, and sometimes purifying. All of the great reform movements of the post-Confederation era shared a few
common catalysts and structural elements as well, not the least of which were a sense of pending disaster and a
support base that was multi-provincial, if not national in its reach. There are exceptions but they are fewer than
the commonalities.

These shared characteristics make it both possible and necessary to consider many of the reform movements side-
by-side, regardless of their place on the nations timeline. There is spillover between them and the same faces
show up in a variety of movements; there are also deep schisms between a few and, from time to time, unflinching
hostility felt by participants in one movement to the champions of another. Social reform themes arise, in large
measure, from a kind of deductive logic. There is poverty and therefore there must be causes of poverty; there
is crime and fear and therefore there must be causes of disorder; there is inequity and unhappiness, danger and
ugliness and all of these things must arise from some cause. The answers that social reformers offered up became
banners the other kind of cause and thus rallying points for citizens from many backgrounds. This chapter
begins with the 19th centurys great social movements, and concludes with the environmental movements of the
20th century.

326
 7.1 INTRODUCTION 327

Learning Objectives

Identify the major reform movements of the post-Confederation era.

Describe the common features, tactics, goals, and beliefs of the reform movements.
Account for the popularity and longevity of specific reform movements.
Detail the influence of the social gospel, temperance, and maternal feminist movements.
Explain the rise of third parties as aspects of the reform movement.
Assess the apparent distinctions between the first and second waves of feminism.
Evaluate the extent to which late 20th-century movements like Greenpeace are part of a longer
reform tradition.

Attributions
Figure 7.1
Rat Portage Salvation Army Band by Cekli829 is in the public domain.
7.2 Social Reform

Victorian-era industrialization created conditions that called out for reform. Child-labour, sexual abuse, poverty-
level pay, filthy workplaces, and slum neighbourhoods were made visible by two things: urbanization from the
1860s through to the 1920s (which brought more observers and commentators within reach of factory life) and
the new investigative role of the state (in the form of Royal Commissions of Enquiry, for example). Certainly
there was poverty and abuse in rural Canada, but fewer observers there to catch it and comment on it, let alone act
against it. Factory-life problems became public problems.

The combination of science and urbanization elements that were at the heart of industrialization was key
to the identification and relief of social and political liabilities. The rise of Darwinian thought and the relatively
new concept of evolution transformed the publics understanding of biology and the engines of change. The germ
theory of infection was just gaining ground as the Dominion of Canada took its first steps, so the possibility of
employing strategies to avoid epidemics was increasingly well-understood. The cities were, in this context, labo-
ratories in which social and health experiments were going to occur.

What is more, the idea of society was undergoing profound change. The mid- and late-19th century witnessed
the rise of the scientific study of society. Sociology, political theory, and psychology are young and dynamic
fields in this era, led by powerhouse thinkers like Auguste Comte (1798-1857), Karl Marx (1818-1893), Frederick
Engels (1820-1895), mile Durkheim (1858-1917), and Herbert Spencer (1820-1903). This phenomenon
increased curiosity about how society works and how it might be changed systematically was itself made pos-
sible by the rise of the secular state. That is, by the arrival of forms of government in which the Church stood
well to one side, while government (Christian, but not subservient to the clergy) was both appropriating and being
handed responsibility for more and more of the social environment.

Into this mix stepped the new middle-classes. Professionals and merchants, they were almost by definition
urban. Their ranks included the well-educated, the literate, and the people who would be tasked with dealing
with outbreaks of illness (physicians), ignorance (teachers), political scandal (journalists), infrastructural disaster
(engineers), and moral turpitude (the clergy). As a new spokes-class, the bourgeoisie men and women alike
were increasingly connected to international movements and ideas. They were able to exploit their own rising
importance in Canadian cities to launch programs aimed at eradicating, or at least mitigating, the worst effects of
modernity.

What distinguishes this generation of reformers from the religious reformers of earlier generations is their shared
concentration on social change. The social reformers of the post-Confederation era were less concerned with

328
 7.2 SOCIAL REFORM 329

individual improvement and redemption than they were with achieving urgent, collective, society-wide change.
Meeting this goal would, they believed, create an environment in which individual betterment was more likely to
occur. Save society and then save the individual; ignore society and watch it crumble and take the individual with
it.

Among the most vulnerable populations in the 19th and early 20th century were the elderly. Historian of
institutionalization Megan Davies (York University) describes eldercare in the far west.

Key Points

The social reform movement was a product of urbanization and industrialization.

It was built on a bedrock of evolutionary science that taught that change was possible and desirable,
and with advances in medical science that created an awareness of public health.
It was informed by a growing body of social sciences thinking about the nature of society.
It was led by a growing middle class an industrial-era bourgeoisie with the cultural capital and
position to develop a common understanding of the need for social change, and the ability to attempt
it.
7.3 Poverty, 18671945

ERIC W. SAGER, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, UNIVERSITY OF VICTORIA

When the Dominion of Canada was created in 1867, governments did not assume direct responsibility for the
poor. Before 1867, only the Maritime colonies had adopted English Poor Laws; there were no workhouses, in
which the poor were given accommodation and food in return for work. Responsibility for the poor usually fell to
churches and charities, and very poor people often ended up in houses of refuge, mental institutions, or prisons.
Official and elite attitudes toward the poor were often negative or condescending. It was assumed that poverty
resulted from a moral failing on the part of the poor. Idealistic visions contributed to such attitudes: Canada was a
place with abundant land and resources where anybody willing to work was bound to prosper. This utopian vision
of Canada ignored the reality that farms were very difficult to establish, that resources were highly seasonal, and
that winter was a time of shortage and hardship for a large number of people.

In the last half of the 19th century, urbanization and early industrialization increased the number of urban poor.
A new type of poverty appeared: poverty that resulted from unemployment not merely seasonal job shortages,
but the shortage of wage-paid jobs due to economic cycles, the closing of businesses, short-term layoffs, and trade
depressions. Historians have shown that in major Canadian cities in 1901, one of every seven families could not
survive on the pooled wage earnings of family members. If the poor survived at all, they did so by participating
in an informal economy scrounging, bartering, growing vegetables, or keeping animals, or taking in lodgers, if
they had space. Many did not survive. Montreal, for instance, was one of the most dangerous cities in the Western
World for newborn babies. At the end of the 1890s, 26% of babies died before they reached their first birthday of
illnesses associated with poverty and malnutrition.

Studies of average wages in Montreal, Toronto, and Vancouver show that there was modest growth in real wages
(which means wages after adjusting for price inflation) in the early 1900s. During World War I, rapid inflation
halted the rise in real wages, and gains did not appear again until the 1920s. Then the Depression of the 1930s
caused an increase in poverty due to unemployment. It has been estimated that in the winter of 1933, at the depths
of the Depression, over 32% of all wage-paid workers were unemployed. In these circumstances, government
began, although very slowly and at first without success, to develop policies that would help to alleviate the prob-
lem of poverty. The first universal social welfare program in Canada was the Family Allowance program, intro-
duced by the federal government in 1944. The small unemployment insurance program, introduced during World
War II, was expanded after the war. These were the foundations of Canadas social security system or welfare

330
 7.3 POVERTY, 18671945 331

state. The problem of poverty was not solved, however, and relative poverty (meaning wide gaps between low-
income earners and others) persisted. Nevertheless, the social security system succeeded in reducing the impact
of poverty for many families.

Figure 7.2 A poor family in The Ward, Toronto, 1913.

Additional Readings
Copp, Terry. The Anatomy of Poverty: The Condition of the Working Class in Montreal 1897-1929. Toronto:
McClelland and Stewart, 1974.

Piva, Michael J. The Condition of the Working Class in Toronto 1900-1921. Ottawa: University of Ottawa Press,
1979.

Bartlett, Eleanor A. Real Wages and the Standard of Living in Vancouver, 1901 1929. BC Studies, no. 51
(Autumn 1981): 3-62.

Baskerville, Peter and Eric W. Sager. Unwilling Idlers: The Urban Unemployed and their Families in Late Victo-
rian Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1998.

Struthers, James. No Fault of their Own: Unemployment and the Canadian Welfare State, 1914-1941. Toronto:
University of Toronto Press, 1983.

Key Points

Industrial and wage-labour changed the character and incidence of poverty in the post-Confederation
era.
Poverty has been linked in the pre-World War II era with inflation rates that outstripped wage
increases.
Seasonal, sectoral, and catastrophic unemployment levels contributed to different understandings of
poverty. A state response was, consequently, slow in coming.

Attributions
Figure 7.2
Health Department photographs by City of Toronto Archives is in the public domain.
 7.4 Families and Property Rights in Canada

CHRIS CLARKSON, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, OKANAGAN COLLEGE

In the summer of 1872, Maria Cheffrey, a Spanish resident of Lytton, British Columbia, arrived in Judge Matthew
Baillie Begbies courtroom. Cheffrey and her husband had separated six years earlier. After their separation, she
worked in Lytton and maintained herself. But that July, he returned. Maria Cheffrey applied to Judge Begbie for a
protection order because she feared that her husband might seize her earnings and property. She had good reason
1
to be worried.

Until the middle of the 19th century, married men held what amounted to a monopoly over property rights within
Canadian families. Under the common law inherited by the English-speaking colonies, a married woman could
not enter into contracts, sue, or be sued. Upon marriage, her wages and personal property passed into her hus-
bands possession. He also gained the right to manage her real estate, and to control any rents or profits it might
produce. Minor children likewise lacked the right to contract, sue, or control property. In matters of inheritance, a
widow held the right to dower in most colonies, a provision that entitled her to the lifetime use of one-third of her
husbands real estate after his death. A husband could distribute all of his property by will (including his widows
life estate after her death) as he deemed fit. If he did not write a will, his property ultimately passed to his eldest
son. These laws were the cornerstones of a patriarchal social order, facilitating male headship of households and
the concentration of property among a small number of men. The law was structured so that married women and
minor children would be financially dependent. There were very few exceptions and those could be found in the
Court of Chancery, where married women with wealthy families or benevolent husbands could have property
set aside for their independent use through special settlements. The Court of Chancery was also charged with pro-
tecting minors from irresponsible parents. Yet for various reasons, including the high costs involved, very few
2
individuals were able to avail themselves of the protections offered by this court.

1. Chris Clarkson, Domestic Reforms: Political Visions and Family Regulation in British Columbia, 1862-1940 (Vancouver: University of
British Columbia Press, 2007), 47-8.
2. Ibid., 1-3, 38.

332
 7.4 FAMILIES AND PROPERTY RIGHTS IN CANADA 333

Figure 7.3 A widow (like this one in Ethelbert, MB, ca. 1924)
would have control over the estate of her deceased husband only
until the eldest son reached adulthood.

This situation changed slowly in the late 19th and early 20th centuries as colonial, and then provincial, legislatures
passed statutes changing the laws respecting family property in English Canada. The changes varied by province,
but the general trend over time was toward granting married women and children greater legal rights. The first
wave of legislation, passed during the 1850s and 1860s, granted limited property rights to wives in emergency
3
situations, at the discretion of the courts. Maria Cheffrey was fortunate enough to be the beneficiary of one of
these new laws, and Judge Begbie granted her a court order to protect her property from her husband. Over the
latter part of the 19th century, politicians in the English-speaking provinces granted married women substantial
new rights over earnings and property, as well as the capacity to contract, sue, and be sued all without the need
4
for a protection order. Then, in the early 20th century, some provinces imposed new obligations upon married
men. These new maintenance laws required men to support their legal families and children born out of wedlock.
In matters of inheritance, provincial legislators wrote new laws in the 19th century providing for a more equitable
5
distribution of property among spouses and children, in cases where husbands and wives failed to write wills.
In the early 20th century, legislators in every province took an even more activist approach to inheritance law
reform, adopting dependants relief statutes, which permitted family members to apply for a larger share of an
6
estate under certain circumstances.

Why were the laws changed? Lawmakers motives varied from province to province and from one decade to the
next. Frequently they were responding to the urging of feminist activists and legislators, but this was not always
the case. In passing the various laws, some proponents and legislators hoped to protect wives and children from
financial hardship and foster gender equality. Others intended to stimulate commercial activity and limit govern-
ment expenditures on emerging social welfare programs by holding family members legally responsible for main-
7
tenance.

The results of the laws were not easy to predict. For example, in several provinces, conservative judges attempted
to limit the impact of married womens new property rights. Even so, historian Peter Baskervilles research on
British Columbia and Ontario shows increased property ownership, borrowing activity, and entrepreneurship
8
among married women. Other evidence indicates that new rights produced new expectations among women, in
both their personal and political lives.

The rights of family members under Quebecs civil law were different. As Bettina Bradbury et al., have written,

3. Constance Backhouse, Married Womens Property Law in Nineteenth-Century Canada, Law and History Review 6, no. 2 (Fall 1988):
217-219.
4. Ibid.: 221-4, 230-1.
5. Peter Baskerville, A Silent Revolution? Gender and Wealth in English Canada, 1860-1930 (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queens Univer-
sity Press, 2008), 7.
6. See Manitoba. Law Reform Commission, Report on The Testators Family Maintenance Act, Report #63 (December 16, 1985): 3-4.
7. For discussions of political motives, see Backhouse, "Married Womens Property Law"; Lori Chambers, Married Women and Property Law
in Victorian Ontario (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1997); Clarkson, Domestic Reforms.
8. Peter Baskerville, Women and Investment in Late-Nineteenth-Century Urban Canada: Victoria and Hamilton, 1880-1901, Canadian His-
torical Review, vol. 80, no. 2 (June 1999): 191-218; and She Has Already Hinted at Board: Enterprising Urban Women in British
Columbia, 1863-1896, Histoire Sociale Social History 26, no. 52 (November 1993): 205-27.
 334 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Marriage automatically created a community of property, legally shared equally by both spouses, but adminis-
9
tered by the husband. Those final words are important. While the phrase community property sounds egal-
itarian, the husbands administrative rights meant that, in practice, he could generally dispose of the couples
property as he wished. Property inherited by either spouse was an exception to this arrangement: each retained
separate ownership of inherited property, yet neither had the right to dispose of that inherited property without
their spouses consent. In addition, a small number of wealthy couples signed marriage contracts specifying a
10
separation of goods, which permitted each spouse to maintain separate property. Even in these cases, however,
the law stated that wives needed their husbands authorization to manage their separate property, and the courts
interpreted this requirement quite strictly. With respect to inheritance, Quebec, unlike English Canada, operated
according to a system of a partible inheritance, in which the deceaseds property was divided amongst his or her
heirs. A widow or widower was entitled to a half-share of any community property. If the deceased left no will,
the remainder would be divided equally among descendants, or according to more complicated formulae among
other heirs. The situation with respect to spouses separate property was less favourable. Legislation passed over
the second half of the 19th century that gradually eliminated the widows customary right to dower in her hus-
11
bands separate lands, since traditional dower rights were a hindrance to land transfers. Childrens right to a fixed
12
share of their parents separate estates was likewise abolished. After these changes, separate property could be
distributed freely according to the terms of a will; in the absence of a will, it would be distributed to the children
or other heirs, with the spouse ranking 13th in the hierarchy of potential claimants.

The liberalization of family property rights came more slowly in Quebec than in the other provinces. This was not
due to the absence of feminist agitation. Feminists in Quebec campaigned for a better claim to family property
and greater legal independence throughout the early 20th century. While they gained improved inheritance rights
respecting the spouses separate property in 1915, other markers of improved status under the law were slow to
come. Women in Quebec gained the vote last, in 1940. Political and clerical opposition hindered their efforts to
achieve the franchise and to more radical changes to married womens property rights, and to gain them the legal
capacity to act for and represent themselves. Such change would have to wait for a resurgence of feminist activity
in the 1960s, accompanied by the social, religious, and governmental shifts engendered by the Quiet Revolution
13
(see Section 9.9).

Key Points

Property rights historically favoured males over females, including sons over wives.
Womens rights regarding marital property increased slowly and unevenly in the post-Confederation
era.

9. Bettina Bradbury, Peter Gossage, Evelyn Kolish, and Alan Stewart, Property and Marriage: the Law and Practice in Early Nineteenth-Cen-
tury Montreal, Histoire Sociale Social History, 26, no. 51 (May 1993): 16. On the continuities between the pre-Conquest Custom of
Paris/Coutume de Paris, and the Civil Code of 1866 regarding womens legal status, see Micheline Dumont, Michle Jean, Marie Lavigne,
and Jennifer Stoddart [The Clio Collective], Quebec Women: A History, trans. Roger Gannon and Rosalind Gill (Toronto: The Womens
Press, 1987), 124.
10. Bradbury et al, Property and Marriage, 16-17, 22-3, 35.
11. Bettina Bradbury, Wife to Widow: Lives, Laws, and Politics in Nineteenth-Century Montreal (Vancouver: University of British Columbia
Press, 2011), 121, 137-8; Dumont et al., Quebec Women, 125.
12. H.R. Hahlo, The Case for Family Maintenance in Quebec, McGill Law Journal 16, no. 3 (1970): 536-537.
13. Dumont et al., Quebec Women, 252-65, 314, 321-324, 336-339.
 7.4 FAMILIES AND PROPERTY RIGHTS IN CANADA 335

Inheritance laws in Quebec were distinct from those in the rest of Canada and were the focus of fem-
inist reform efforts in the early 20th century.

Attributions
Figure 7.3
Widow & children on farm in Ethelbert, Manitoba by George E. Dragan / Library and Archives Canada is in
the public domain.
7.5 Womens Organizations and Reform

MELANIE BUDDLE, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, TRENT UNIVERSITY

Figure 7.4 At 26 years of age in 1889, Bertha

Wright (later Mrs. Carr-Harris) was founder
and first president of the Canadian YWCA.

Beginning in the 1870s, a number of womens organizations and clubs formed locally, nationally, and internation-
ally. Some, such as the Young Womens Christian Association (YWCA), which opened a Canadian branch in
1870, the Womens Christian Temperance Union (WCTU), which opened its first Canadian branch in 1874, and
the National Council of Women of Canada (NCWC), which formed in 1893, were Canadian affiliates of interna-
tional womens organizations. These and other womens groups formed during a period of huge social upheaval.
At the end of the 19th century, industrialization, urbanization, and increased immigration led some women to take
public action against social ills that seemed to threaten traditional family life. They felt that the way to protect
women and children was to protest the evils of alcohol and attendant evils, such as prostitution, poverty, and poor
working conditions amongst the lower classes. The WCTU campaigned first and foremost for temperance (lim-
iting the use of alcohol and encouraging sobriety) and prohibition (laws to ban alcohol entirely) because they
blamed alcohol for social problems, such as poverty, immorality, and prostitution. Other groups had different man-
dates (education, working conditions for women, and philanthropy), but addressed the same social ills.

Inside meetings of literary clubs, temperance societies, and Christian associations, women critiqued the political
and educational limitations of womanhood but were careful to maintain the conventions of their time. Many main-
tained a mandate to support families, children, and womanly arts, and praised the conventional roles of women.
This was an effective strategy, as it was not particularly threatening to Canadian society at the time: men voted and
worked, and women were responsible for children and domestic labour although this was changing as more
women were joining the paid labour force.

336
 7.5 WOMENS ORGANIZATIONS AND REFORM 337

The WCTU shared features with other womens groups that formed during this period: a focus on Christian values
and on protecting women, children, and the less fortunate. These ideals formed what historians call the Social
1
Gospel: a Christian-influenced approach that brought an evangelical fervour to public reform (see Section 7.6).
Emerging womens clubs shared another feature: a growing commitment to a larger public and political role for
women, including steps toward womens voting rights. Some were more tentative than others in moving toward
womens rights to the vote (suffrage) but by the early 1900s many discussed it. These groups provided a discur-
sive space for women to talk about issues ranging from education, temperance, domestic arts and social reform,
to arts and crafts and literature and sometimes, female suffrage.

The NCWC, a national umbrella organization for womens groups, formed 20 years after the WCTU arrived in
Canada, and became an affiliate of the International Council of Women. Led by Lady Aberdeen (1857-1939),
wife of the Governor General, its first member was the Womens Art Association of Canada. Adelaide Hoodless
(1857-1910), a prominent social reformer who would be influential in the Canadian YWCA, co-founded the
NCWC. The NCWC had a mandate to improve the status of women, and social conditions for women and chil-
dren, but initially stopped short of supporting female suffrage. Interestingly, the WCTU influenced its formation
but refused to join because the NCWC was not religious enough. Yet in 1888, the WCTU was the first large
womens group to specifically support suffrage. The NCWC did not specifically endorse womens rights to vote
until 1910, and many of their member organizations, including some of the local Councils of Women across the
2
country, did not endorse, and even opposed, womens suffrage. Thus we see a mix of radicalism and conservatism
in many early womens groups.

Other womens organizations appeared in this fertile period. On the surface, national and local womens groups
such as the Canadian Womens Press Club (1904), the Womens Art Association of Canada (1892), the YWCA
(1870; Canada-wide in 1893), the Imperial Order Daughters of the Empire (IODE, 1900), and the Toronto
Womens Literary Club (1876) appeared devoted to artistic, educational, and professional or business pursuits.
Many promoted service to girls and women, such as the YWCA, which emphasized the temporal, religious, and
3
moral welfare of young women. But even outwardly more conservative groups such as the IODE (which resisted
suffrage and focused on patriotism, education and philanthropy) could become vehicles of social and political
change. The Toronto Literary Club was the first to publicly move in this direction, changing its name to the Cana-
4
dian Womens Suffrage Association, and becoming the first Canadian group with suffrage as its main aim. Clubs
could be screens for political action, and supporters of female suffrage were inevitably involved in one or more
of the other womens organizations, even those that did not focus on suffrage. The Canadian Womens Press
Club included female novelists, newspaper editors, and reporters and its early members included Nellie McClung
(1873-1951) and Emily Murphy (1868-1933), who were prominent social reformers and suffragists. And the very
fact that women were organizing and reaching out in a public way, regardless of the professed mandate or cause,
was in itself a radical move for women.

While working-class women also organized and protested the inequity of society, the most prominent female
reformers in the late 1800s and early 1900s were white middle- and upper-class women. Their approach to social

1. See Mariana Valverde, The Age of Light, Soap, and Water: Moral Reform in English Canada, 1885-1925 (Toronto: McClelland and Stewart,
1991).
2. Katja Thieme, Language and Social Change: The Canadian Movement for Womens Suffrage, 1880-1918 (PhD Thesis, University of
British Columbia, 2007), 31.
3. Toronto YWCA, Constitution of the Toronto YWCA, 1873, Article II, cited in Mary Quayle Innis, Unfold the Years: A History of the YWCA
in Canada (Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1949), 13.
4. Alison Prentice et. al., Canadian Women: A History, 2nd Edition (Scarborough: Thomson Nelson, 2004), 195-196.
 338 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

issues seemed to blame the fallen women and less fortunate: reformers attempted to preserve a fading Victorian
middle-class family life and their identification of the problem was sometimes the fallen themselves, rather than
industrial, economic, and related societal upheavals. Some of the same women supporting female suffrage and
social reform also supported eugenics (see Section 7.8), limiting immigration of non-whites, and extending the
5
vote only to white women, due to a fear of racial degeneration. Others, like Hoodless, opposed female suffrage;
6
she argued that women should exercise their influence through their sons and husbands.

By association, by marriage, by family status, and by community prominence, these women had time and energy
for art associations, moral reform campaigns, temperance groups, and art clubs. We can acknowledge their efforts
to provide aid and to give women more power through public life, and we can acknowledge that compared to
men, they were treated unequally and were subject to discrimination. But these same women had a degree of priv-
ilege not afforded to non-white and lower-class women in Canada. They were also divided in their support for a
more political role. Some women, and some groups, opposed suffrage or focused only on moral or spiritual issues.
Some focused on domestic science and handicrafts but moved toward suffrage, and others specifically supported
suffrage as the key to relieving other social ills.

Early supporters of female suffrage have been called maternal feminists because they argued that their role as
mothers and homemakers, as angels of the house, was the reason they needed more influence in society and
7
not, as later feminists would argue, because they ought to be treated as equal to men. Womens clubs were pivotal
in that they were early opportunities for women to discuss the increasingly public roles they could play in society.
We cannot dismiss them only as social gatherings for ladies of privilege, because they also led to important con-
versations about womens rights in society and in the political and professional realms. These groups were more
radical in their context than they might appear to us, looking backward. Despite the grounding of many clubs in
a narrow ideology of white womens rights, mothers rights, and Social Gospel purity arguments, they paved
the way for women like Agnes Macphail (1890-1954), Canadas first female member of parliament. Macphail, in
1925 said: I do not want to be the angel of any home, I want for myself what I want for other women, absolute
8
equality. After that is secured then men and women can take turns at being angels.

Figure 7.5 A good example of the rhetoric

used by maternal feminists: an appeal to
motherly feeling in the fight against the
Liquor Traffic.

5. See Anne-Maria Kinahan, Transcendent Citizenship: Suffrage, the National Council of Women of Canada, and the Politics of Organized
Womanhood, Journal of Canadian Studies 42, 3 (2008): 5-27.
6. Terry Crowley, HUNTER, ADELAIDE SOPHIA [HOODLESS], in Dictionary of Canadian Biography, vol. 13, University of Toronto/
Universit Laval, 2003, accessed 22 September 2015, [Link]
7. Thieme, Language and Social Change, 15-16.
8. Canada, House of Commons, Debates, 26 February 1925.
 7.5 WOMENS ORGANIZATIONS AND REFORM 339

Key Points

The 1870s witnessed the creation of important and influential womens organizations; more followed
before 1914.
Many of these organizations shared a strong Christian orientation and concern regarding social ills,
including the social and domestic consequences of alcohol abuse.
These organizations provided a springboard for female activism, early feminism, and demand for
greater female rights (including the right to vote).
Opposition to the franchise remained an important force in womens organizations.
Overwhelmingly, these were middle- and upper-class organizations representing white women with
extensive privilege and social and cultural capital. Many were, as well, highly radical in their con-
text.

Attributions
Figure 7.4
Miss Bertha Wright (later Mrs. Carr-Harris, first President of the Canadian Young Womens Christian Associa-
tion) (Online MIKAN no.3229086) by William James Topley / Library and Archives Canada / PA-167608 is in
the public domain.

Figure 7.5
Have You Any Boys? : Remember September 29, Down with the Liquor Traffic! (Online MIKAN no. 2988523)
by Library and Archives Canada, Acc. No. 1984-4-943 W.C.T.U Dominion is in the public domain.
7.6 Social Gospel

Figure 7.6 Urban missions began appearing in the late 19th

century. The Toronto Mission opened in 1896 and became a
centre for Social Gospel activism.

Of all the reform movements arising out of the 19th century, arguably none had as extensive a reach as the Social
Gospel. Faced with the new realities of urban overcrowding, grueling factory work, and grinding poverty, Chris-
tians in North America questioned whether their focus should be on the salvation of the individual or of society
as a whole. Conventional wisdom in the mainstream churches had always been that the issue of salvation was
entirely a personal matter. Urbanization and industrialization challenged that perspective. Increasingly, clergymen
and religious writers were of a mind that the physical environment in which the battle against sin took place was
so changed by industrialism that new approaches were necessary. They found a receptive audience in the middle-
and working-classes, and produced several generations of political, social, and cultural leaders as a result. The
values of the Social Gospel became the fuel behind many political and socio-economic movements in the first
century after Confederation, some of which were inevitably contradictory.

From the Pulpit to the Public

Two of the largest and most influential institutions in British North America at the start of the 19th century were
the Anglican (or Church of England) and Catholic Churches. Wherever there were Scots, there were Presbyterian
churches as well, although this was in fact a number of fractious denominations that only converged around the
time of Confederation. Methodists constituted the next most populous sect, and there were significant numbers of
Congregationalists in the colonies, particularly in New Brunswick. But the two principal Christian churches
Catholic and Anglican were head and shoulders above the competition in terms of adherents and political influ-
ence. The authority of the Anglicans was part of the very fibre of the Family Compacts in the English-speaking
colonies and in anglophone Montreal; Catholicism enjoyed a near monopoly in French-Canada. Both churches
were broadly engaged with civil society, providing much of pre-Confederation Canadas educational, welfare,
and healthcare infrastructure. Bishops and Archbishops endeavoured to set much of the moral tone and brokered
power between the colonial governors and the secular leadership. Their values were simultaneously very conser-

340
 7.6 SOCIAL GOSPEL 341

vative (in the case of Quebecs Catholic clergy, they were defensively so in the face of Anglo-Protestant hostility)
and community-minded.

Much of the history of political struggle in Canada overlaps with the history of sectarian conflict. The Presbyterian
and Methodist elements objected to the authority exerted by the Anglicans in what became Ontario; the mid-19th
century Reform Party was overwhelmingly drawn from the non-conformist churches, while the Tories were
essentially the political wing of the Anglican Church. The situation was similar in most parts of pre-Confederation
Canada, although clearly different in Quebec where Anglicans and Presbyterians were allied against Catholics.
Sectarian turmoil was not uncommon, and it is important to recall the vigour with which Orange elements attacked
the rights and the bodies of Catholics in Saint John, Toronto, Red River, and elsewhere in Victorian
Canada. This background underlines the extent to which divisions between denominations mattered, emotionally
and practically, to Confederation-era Canadians.

As the Dominion of Canada project got underway these relationships evolved and became important in new
ways. The Victorian years witnessed the rise of new Christian denominations while some older sects changed
their course. It is impossible to imagine these new elements occurring outside of the context of industrialism and
other socio-economic disruptions in the Victorian era. The Presbyterians, Methodists, and Congregationalists
along with Low Anglicans were already critical of the liturgical and hierarchical qualities (sometimes called
Churchianity as opposed to Christianity) of the High Anglican and Catholic Churches, and the instances
where it seemed political leaders were following the Archbishop or even the Pope rather than the electorate. But
the influence of evangelicalism was embodied in smaller denominations like the Lutherans and Baptists, in ele-
ments within Methodism and Congregationalism (both of which were growing in popularity), and in entirely new
churches like the Salvation Army posed a challenge to the established churches view of spiritual redemp-
tion and, implicitly, to social relations.

The 19th century evangelicals include profoundly different and distinctive voices and theological viewpoints.
Many the Salvation Army in particular were very urban in their outlook, and all took the perspective that
personal and direct salvation was a possibility. This was a critique of the older churches mediation of the rela-
tionship between the individual and God. While this brought the individual into sharp focus, it had the almost
perverse effect of making the social more obvious. The evangelicals view, however, was one of a society made
up of individuals (a view that was consistent with the rising tide of democracy), as opposed to one made up of
categories and castes. Evangelical itself derives etymologically from good news and the good news was
that everyone (and thus the whole of society) could be saved.

The infrastructure of the Social Gospel included bricks and mortar as well as personnel. The centre for much of the
movements development was Wesley College in Winnipeg, a Methodist post-secondary institution established
in 1888. The intersection of late-Victorian Methodism with its redemptive message, culture of outreach, and
largely working-class constituency and the city of Winnipeg growing at an explosive rate into the capital
city of the whole West was critical to the development of the ideals of the Social Gospel at Wesley College.
Salem Bland (1859-1950) moved from central Canada to a professorship at Wesley in 1903, where he nurtured a
generation of Social Gospel leaders. These include two founders of the Cooperative Commonwealth Federation
(CCF): James Shaver (J.S.) Woodsworth (1874-1942) and William Bill Irvine (1885-1962) (see Section 7.9).
Wesley College students, faculty, and graduates played an increasingly vocal role in criticizing the conduct of the
Great War, some of them (like Woodsworth) embracing pacificism, others attacking wartime profiteering. They
were also active in the events around the Winnipeg General Strike (Section 3.9) and together believed that if rev-
 342 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

olution was coming, it would be a revolution of religion and the establishment of a new order, with Social Gospel
1
evangelism at its centre.

Figure 7.7 The elegant, gothic sandstone facade of Wesley

Hall (opened in 1895). In 1938 it became United College, and in
1967 the University of Winnipeg.

What this new and extremely popular, entertaining, and challenging religious movement discovered, of
course, was that salvation was hard work particularly when the sinners in the crosshairs are living their lives in
squalor, poverty, addiction, and ignorance. Saving souls was one thing; saving society was another.

Building a Heaven on Earth

The range of projects in which the Social Gospellers engaged was broad but they shared some core elements.
Temperance was one, fighting the causes of poverty was another (although methods might differ drastically), and
a representative cross-section took an interest in eugenics. In Central and Eastern Canada the focus was heavily
on urban squalor and sin, while in the West there was a stronger emphasis on the project of building a new and
ideal society from the ground up.

Their approaches combined elements of faith and science, a feature that further distinguished them from the
Anglicans and Catholics (although both of the big churches would change in this regard in the 20th century).
Sometimes these combinations produced contradictions. The Social Gospel interest in eugenics, for example,
arose from an awareness of advances in biological sciences. It might be argued that their commitment to the view
that genes (nature) trumped environment (nurture) was inconsistent with their view that the physical world mired
the individual in sin. They criticized, as well, the role of the non-evangelical faiths in matters of government, while
simultaneously seeking to create a more activist and interventionist state. Regardless of these contradictions, the
Social Gospellers constitute the first generation of Christian thinkers to understand sin and redemption through a
science lens, and to attempt to resolve it through the further application of science and social innovation.

Social Gospellers were prepared to make full use of the arsenal of modern technology, engineering, and planning.
Clean water and well-lit streets were as critical to this project as any Sunday sermon. At the same time, they
recast the issues of moral failings from the individual (e.g., drinking or ignorance) to the social (e.g., alcoholism
or lack of educational opportunity). As the century closed and a new one began, some of the concerns of the
Social Gospellers shifted to questions associated with immigrant communities. Many of the newcomers were nei-
ther Protestant nor Catholic and were regarded by some Social Gospellers as a threat in their own right. Education
might play a role in assimilating immigrants, but reformers suspicion of the Eastern European or Asian Canadian
proved hard to shake, and it would provide part of the context for the spread of eugenics across the Social Gospel
movement.

1. Ramsay Cook, "Ambiguous Heritage: Wesley College and the Social Gospel Re-considered," Manitoba History, 19 (Spring 1990).
 7.6 SOCIAL GOSPEL 343

Targeting Reform
The array of crusades launched by the various branches of the Social Gospel movement included high-level pol-
itics and street-level service. Missions and settlement houses were established among the urban poor and in
Aboriginal communities. The Salvation Army became active in city centres, on reserves, and in the North. Wilfred
Grenfell opened his own mission in Labrador, in 1893. Methodists in the 1880s joined with other denominations
in establishing residential schools for Aboriginal students (see Sections 11.7, 11.8, 11.9, 11.10, and 11.11); support
for these projects came from Social Gospellers who saw them as an instrument of assimilation into an advanced
Christian- and Anglo-Canadian culture and also as schools that met the practical and physical needs of Aborig-
2
inal peoples. The settlement houses were, similarly, located on the boundary between social change and social
control: they offered daycare, some schooling, help finding employment, language classes for immigrants, and so
on, but they were also centres for transferring and imposing the dominant societies moral values to newcomers. It
was this combination of targeted Christian good deeds among the poor, the voiceless, and the colonized, the moral
regulation of deviant (including alien) behaviour, and efforts to counter the ill effects of capitalism and urban life
that characterized most Social Gospel activities.

The Social Gospel Style

Aimee Semple McPherson (1890-1944) was arguably the most famous Canadian of her time. Born Amie Eliza-
beth Kennedy in Salford, Ontario, she was influenced by the Salvation Army (still very much a new thing in late
Victorian Canada), married at 18, widowed at 19 (while pregnant with her first child), remarried at 22, divorced
at 29, married for a third time at 41 years, and divorced again three years later. Her travels across North America
matched her tumultuous personal life: she relocated to the United States in her 20s and dedicated her life to evan-
gelizing.

Semple McPherson was a barnstorming preacher who was increasingly associated with the emergent Pentacostal
faith. Moving to Los Angeles in 1918 put Semple McPherson at the centre of what was just emerging as Americas
West Coast metropolis and film industry capital. Huge and elaborate stage sets were produced for her revivalist
meetings, and the level of theatricality in Semple McPhersons sermons was both astonishing and of the high-
est quality. Her meetings were attended by as many as 40,000 at their peak, and were often chaotic and fevered;
their unpredictable and inventive features influenced other evangelicals and event producers for generations. The
most elaborate of her performances were not entirely unlike 1970s and 1980s stadium-venue rock concerts, and
the temple she built in Los Angeles owed more to music halls than to cathedrals. Moreover, Semple McPherson
crossed media by combining live performances with film and radio broadcasts. She was a superstar before the
term was invented.

2. Eleanor J. Stebner, More than Maternal Feminists and Good Samaritans: Women and the Social Gospel in Canada, in Gender and the
Social Gospel, eds. Wendy J. Deichmann Edwards and Carolyn De Swarte Gifford (Urbana and Chicago: University of Illinois Press, 2003),
57.
344 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 7.8 Small town Canadian girl makes good.

Aimee Semple McPherson was already a force with
which to reckon at 33 years of age when she raised the
Angelus Temple on the strength of donations in cash
and kind.

There was room for only one Aimee Semple McPherson, but the Social Gospel and the evangelical trend both
produced her, and was influenced by her. Some of the leading figures in the movement in Canada came from the
pulpits, and many learned how to be political and rally speakers from watching and hearing the evangelicals in
action. On the Left, J.S. Woodsworth was a Methodist minister and Tommy Douglas (1904-1986) was a Baptist
preacher. Both men went on to lead the early CCF as champions for social change. Nellie McClung (1873-1951)
was defined by her Social Gospel credo as much as her fathers Methodism; she sat in the Alberta legislature as
a Liberal member. Further to the Right, William (Bible Bill) Aberhart (1878-1943) was an ardent Baptist who
established his own evangelical organization the Calgary Prophetic Bible Institute and created the Social
Credit Party as a means to achieve greater social equity through financial reforms (see Section 7.9). His successor
at both the evangelical and secular level was Ernest Manning (1908-1996), who was raised in a generation that
could identify its creed as simply evangelical. Manning went on to become one of the most successful politi-
cians (in terms of longevity) in Canadian history, and he was the father of the late 20th century Reform Party
leader, Preston Manning (b. 1942). Both Ernest Manning and Aberhart followed Semple McPhersons pioneer-
ing work in radio as a means to reach into rural and urban households alike with social, economic, and political
messages. All of these individuals shared in that evangelical, crusading, and urgent approach to modernity that
demanded change based on the goal of a Christian moral civilization.

Figure 7.9 Tommy Douglas.

Watch this undated recording by Tommy Douglas on The Cream Separator. Tommy Douglas uses a famil-
iar clergymans rhetorical technique, the parable, to deliver a moral lesson that crosses into the political.
Many Canadian politicians still attempt to approximate this style, which is rooted in the Social Gospel
experience of the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

The Opposition
Mainstream resistance to the Social Gospel message was powerful and persistent. The Anglican and Catholic
Churches had their own agendas of social change, but these involved the preservation of social hierarchies, which,
 7.6 SOCIAL GOSPEL 345

the left-wing of the Social Gospel would say, were at the foundation of social injustice. The further to the left some
of the Social Gospellers moved, the more likely they were to be associated by their opponents with socialism and
communism. In truth, while some of the Social Gospellers found their way toward social democracy, the Christian
heart of the movement was a rampart against the secularism of communist movements. Right-wingers, too, fell
afoul of the mainstream. When Aberhart attacked the banking system and attempted to dilute the national currency
(with what was derided as funny money), he was twisting the tail of old money in Montreal and Toronto. (His
conservative evangelicalism and suspicion of international money interests also drew a charge of anti-Semitism.)

The very populism of the Social Gospel its mass appeal and its folksy, inclusive style was dismissed by Lib-
erals and Conservatives as the work of teachers and preachers. Calls for fair treatment of labour organizations,
relief to farmers caught by rising costs and falling farm produce prices at the end of the Great War, and money
support for the unemployed in the 1930s were ignored by the old parties. Their intransigence across the first four
decades of the 20th century cost them significant support and resulted in the creation of the United Farmers parties
across English-speaking Canada, several of which formed governments at the provincial level. The Progressive
Party followed, as did the CCF and Social Credit (see Section 7.9).

These Social Gospel experiments in politics also drew fire from the Left. Socialist and communist organizations
were suspicious and critical of the Christian agenda of the Social Gospel, regarding it as a fruitless and delusional
attempt to manage the worst excesses of capitalism. Achieving a society of justice, equality and freedom from
3
economic oppression, the socialists and communists argued, would require more than good Samaritanism.
Many of the countrys early 20th century hard-leftists were drawn from the new immigrant community; the Social
Gospels record of xenophobia (perhaps articulated best by Woodsworth in his 1909 book, Strangers Within Our
Gates) further alienated Eastern Europeans and Scandinavians who were comfortable with the politics of commu-
nism.

For Social Gospel women, the track record of the old political parties as regards temperance and suffrage spoke
for itself. Women who wanted to achieve social reform through electoral politics were more likely to find a
home in the newer, smaller parties than they were among the Grits and Tories. Agnes Macphail (Progressive),
Dorise Nielsen (CCF), and Gladys Strum (CCF) were three of the first five women elected to Ottawa. In 1944,
Strum became the first woman to head up a provincial or federal political party when she took the presidency
of the Saskatchewan CCF. At the provincial level, Louise McKinney (Nonpartisan League and United Farmers
of Alberta) and Roberta MacAdams (nonpartisan) were both elected in 1917. Although women would also enjoy
electoral success in the Liberal and Conservative parties, the progressive agendas of early feminists both con-
tributed to, and would be better received, in the third parties.

3. Eleanor J. Stebner More than Maternal Feminists and Good Samaritans: Women and the Social Gospel in Canada, Gender and the Social
Gospel, eds. Wendy J. Deichmann Edwards and Carolyn De Swarte Gifford (Chicago: University of Illinois Press, 2003): 62.
346 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 7.10 Andrew Carnegies unparalleled

campaign of personal philanthropy left a mark on
Canadian cities from coast to coast. This image
comes from the British Punch magazine in 1903.

Measuring the intellectual consequence of a movement like the Social Gospel is difficult. It was so diffuse and
appeared in so many guises that it inevitably overlapped with other engines of change. For example, the Scottish-
American industrialist Andrew Carnegie (1835-1919) was considered by his contemporary critics as the embodi-
ment of the rapacious industrialist, whose enormous wealth was won at the expense of terrible working and living
conditions for his employees; he wrote, however, on The Gospel of Wealth in 1889, calling for applied philan-
thropy on the part of his peers. In the last two decades of his life, he belonged to a Social Gospel church in New
York and contributed millions of dollars to the improvement of civic and social infrastructure, a good deal of it
in Canada. Philanthropy and charity were among the evangelical values promoted by the Social Gospel, and they
remain important qualities in Canadian society, but they do not necessarily speak to the goal of social redemption.
Nor, on the face of it, does social legislation like the Ontario Workmens Compensation Act of 1914, which was
nonetheless the product of Social Gospel lobbying. What can be said with some confidence is that the influence of
the social gospel outlasted its earliest spokeswomen and men, and can yet be seen in the fabric of social welfare
laws and in the language of debates about urban conditions and inequality.

Figure 7.11 Vancouver was one of many Canadian cities to

receive a Carnegie Library, which opened in 1903 next door to
the City Hall.

Key Points

The Social Gospel movement grew out of changes in Protestant denominations and the rise of new
churches in the 19th century.
It was informed by deteriorating social and economic conditions in cities, and approached reform in
urban areas and in remote and Aboriginal communities with missionary tactics.
Elements within the Social Gospel movement were centred on Wesleyan College in Winnipeg,
where a strongly social democratic wing developed.
Social Gospellers targeted urban and social reform and some adopted new media and performance
opportunities to produce a highly theatrical style outside of the traditional pulpit.
 7.6 SOCIAL GOSPEL 347

The influence of the Social Gospel on Canadian politics and urban landscapes remains significant.

Attributions
Figure 7.6
YongeStreetMission by Skeezix1000 is in the public domain.

Figure 7.7
UofW by KrazyTea is under a CC BY SA 3.0 license.

Figure 7.8
ASM-AngelusTemple Plaque 1923 02 by Foursquare Church Heritage Center is in the public domain.

Figure 7.9
Tommycropped by Samuell is in the public domain.

Figure 7.10
Carnegie-1903 by Louis Dalrymple is in the public domain.

Figure 7.11
Postcard: Carnegie Library and City Hall, c.1905 by Rob is in the public domain.
 7.7 Temperance and Prohibition

Alcohol consumption in Canada was prodigious in the early 19th century, and it hardly changed over the rest of
the century. Any economy so heavily dependent on the production of wheat, rye, and other grains is going to
quickly find a vent for surplus that involves fermentation. Some of the earliest and largest fortunes in both Upper
and Lower Canada (Ontario and Quebec) were made in the brewing and distilling industries. Home manufacture
was, of course, unregulated and widespread. The 19th century saw the growth of a movement culture around man-
aging liquor production, sale, and consumption. It had many facets, and it was to prove the core movement around
which many others revolved, and from which almost all 19th and 20th century reform movements would recruit
their campaigners.

Drink Canada Dry

Rural drinking did not go unnoticed, nor was it without its critics. But it was different from what came after Con-
federation. Early attempts to temper or manage the consumption of liquor in British North America appear in
the Canadas and the Maritime colonies in the 1830s and 1840s. These were collective acts of individualism; each
drinker who renounced the bottle was affirming the triumph of his or her will and the intent to meet the social and
1
economic challenges that lay ahead. Viewed this way, pre-Confederation temperance was not a mass movement
in that it was scaled down to the personal and the communal.

The late Victorian boom in city populations, however, propelled concern about liquor consumption to the forefront
of public debate, and called for a mass and collective, rather than individualistic, response. As the economy came
to value armies of men who could work in the resource-extraction sector or construction, the popularity of drink
only increased. It is no coincidence that British Columbia, in 1893, boasted a resource-extraction economy with a
2
severely distorted male:female ratio, and the highest per capita consumption of alcohol. Nor should it be surpris-
ing to find that womens consumption of alcohol increased in the Victorian era in step with the demand for single
women in wage-labour. Wage earning, generally, was a critical element in the construction of a wet Canada.

So, too, was the environment. Urban reformers focused much of their energy on water quality issues for good
reason. With horse manure carpeting town and city streets, pigs fouling the roads and streams, and human waste
disposed of in haphazard ways, there was no way that urban water supplies would remain reliable for long. The
situation in Nanaimo was probably not unusual. There, as early as 1864, locals were signing petitions about water

1. Cheryl Krasnick Warsh, John Barleycorn Must Die: An Introduction to the Social History of Alcohol, Drink in Canada: Historical
Essays, Cheryl Krasnick Warsh, ed. (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 1993): 12.
2. Warsh, John Barleycorn Must Die: 13-15.

348
 7.7 TEMPERANCE AND PROHIBITION 349

quality issues. Household sewage was being dumped by the bucket-load on the streets. Two decades later, it was
finding its way into a ravine or the harbour, where it was revealed on the shoreline with every low tide. Some
went into an abandoned coal mine underneath the downtown. As was the case with most Victorian towns before
the construction of sewers, a night soil scavenger collected human waste and removed it to a dump on the edge
3
of town. And, of course, it wasnt unusual for people to use human manure in their gardens. In short, there were
plenty of reasons to be concerned about the quality of drinking water; for many, the solution was tea or coffee
(made of boiled water) or alcohol (germ free, available in a multitude of flavours, and often served in sociable
surroundings).

Class and the Glass

The earliest and most constant critics of liquor consumption were the emergent Canadian bourgeoisie. Their lib-
eral ideal of democratic progress and their dependence on effective employees made it inevitable that they would
see liquor consumption and drunkenness as a threat to polity and productivity. One historian has argued that this
economic and political agenda was complimented by the rise of evangelical Christianity across Canada in the
mid-19th century. It wasnt just that the Baptists and Methodists disapproved of liquor: their creed emphasized
personal responsibility for redemption in a way that the established churches did not. It was, Craig Heron main-
tains, this constellation of forces that gave the Temperance Movement an appeal in Canada beyond what it enjoyed
in Britain and the other Dominions; the movement was comparably strong in the United States as well, making
4
this one of those cultural moments that has a continental complexion.

If temperance had remained the exclusive preserve of the Canadian bourgeoisie, it would have gathered little
momentum. But working people themselves were among the most vocal enemies of liquor. As a part of the com-
munity that sought greater inclusion in the political life of Canada and a better deal in the unfolding industrial era,
artisans and craft workers articulated a view of respectability that denied alcohol a place in working-class culture.
What is more, drink and a disciplined labour movement were incompatible. This was the position taken up by the
Knights of Labor across North America (see Sections 3.4 and 3.6) and it was one that would echo through Cana-
dian labour organizations into the 1920s.

The regulation of womanhood in the 19th century was also driving the emergent temperance movement. Maternal
feminists based their claim for improved womens rights and privileges on the strength of womens reproductive
power. In this context, women who drank to excess were jeopardizing themselves, their embryos, and the health
of the nation. They were also undermining the claim made by the feminists of superior female morality. Historian
Cheryl Krasnick Warsh has shown how the courts in late 19th century Ontario sentenced as many as 803 women
in one year under drunk and disorderly charges; womens share of convictions between 1881 and 1899 averaged
5
16% but ran as high 24% in 1895. Womens relationship with liquor was thus complex: increasingly dangerous,
but at the very heart of an emergent feminist movement.

Another motivating factor at the turn of the century was the arrival of immigrants from eastern and southern
Europe. Here we see the collision of different cultures of drinking and the (largely Anglo-Protestant) Canadian
fear of degenerate foreigners. Xenophobia, and prairie evangelism in particular, responded to the threat of for-

3. John Douglas Belshaw, Becoming British Columbia: A Population History (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2009), 162-3.
4. Craig Heron, Booze: A Distilled History (Toronto: Between the Lines, 2003), 372-3.
5. Cheryl Krasnick Warsh, Oh, Lord, pour a cordial in her wounded heart: The Drinking Woman in Victorian and Edwardian Canada, Drink
in Canada: Historical Essays, ed. Cheryl Krasnick Warsh (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 1993): 76-7.
 350 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

eign newcomers and their use of liquor, which simultaneously eliminated the possibility of support from immi-
6
grants.

Exercise: Documents

Temperance Posters
Consider the two pre-First World War posters promoting temperance (click on them to see larger versions).
The first makes a subtle eugenicist case for temperance can you see it? The other provides evidence that
smokers dont fare well when they try out for college teams. Whats wrong with those statistics?

Figure 7.E1 Dominion Scientific

Temperance Committee, ca.1912.

Figure 7.E2 Dominion Scientific

Temperance Committee, ca.1912.

Historian of the liquor economy, drinking, and the drys Craig Heron (York University) discusses temper-
ance.

6. Warsh,John Barleycorn Must Die: 16-17.

 7.7 TEMPERANCE AND PROHIBITION 351

Temperance
Before the Great War, the focus of the temperance crusade was the local and not the federal level. The possibility
of regulating the sale and consumption of liquor seemed reasonable to some, and in 1878, the federal government
passed enabling legislation, the Canada Temperance Act, which enabled the local option of prohibition through
referenda. Like all referenda, the local option effectively lifts from the shoulders of legislators the burden of mak-
ing a choice on behalf of their constituents. It necessitates the involvement of the local electorate in direct deci-
sion-making around an ideal that has not been expressed in the form of a policy. (Members of Parliament debate
actual bills that they can see and hold and on which they may offer editorial suggestions; referenda typically ask
for general agreement on a broad principal without providing any of the details.) The likelihood of winning a
national referendum on prohibition was slim but at the municipal level, it might succeed.

New Brunswickers seized upon the possibility of prohibiting public consumption of alcohol in the 1880s. Ten
 352 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

counties out of fifteen voted in favour of prohibition, and yet the sale of alcohol continued unabated. One study
observes that Moncton was, paradoxically, a prohibitionist town in which the liquor trade continued to flourish
7
from 1881 through the 1890s. Enforcement issues plagued this experiment (as it would in many others); local
police knew who was selling alcohol but were divided in their loyalties. One historian captures the situation per-
8
fectly: relations between members of the police force and the liquor community were fluid.

Figure 7.12 Fearing for their livelihood, Toronto barmen take to

the street in 1916.

No other province would advance the temperance campaign as far as New Brunswick until the 20th century. One
reason for the failure of the drys to gain ground was the presence and power of the wets. Commercial dis-
tillers in Canada could be found among the wealthiest member-families of the elite. Seagram, Labatt, Molson,
Keith, Wiser, Carling, OKeefe, and in the early 20th century Bronfman are names associated even now
with the alcohol industry, and with families who held powerful directorships in other industries (including banks
9
and railroads) and had significant political influence as well. They employed huge numbers of Canadians and,
despite the reach of the CPR, local breweries and distilleries were also competitive and important economically
until the 1920s.

Of course, not everyone in the middle or working classes wanted to go dry. Working men, returning soldiers, and
members of the non-evangelical churches were highly unlikely to favour diminished access to booze. Young mid-
dle class women who entered the workforce in large numbers in the Edwardian years, and during the war, were
a catalyst in the development of relatively respectable drinking lounges and, thus, became another population
opposed to temperance. But this was the face of public drinking; the consumption of alcohol in private spaces was
also a target of temperance agitators, and that aligned the elites and many middle class households against temper-
ance. Insofar as the ranks of prohibitionists overlapped with anti-Catholic forces, they drove the Catholic Church
into the arms of the wets (although where they were unbothered by assimilationist Protestants, the Catholic lead-
10
ership was as likely to be dry). There were, too, voices raised against the state regulation of liquor as a worrying
example of growing governmental power.

Prohibition
The efforts of the temperance movement peaked in 1914 and were stayed by the outbreak of war. Unwilling to
fight on two fronts, the issue was put to one side until it became clear that the Great War was not going to be brief.
Increasingly, the consumption of liquor at home seemed an offence to the sacrifice being made abroad. Concerns
were raised about productivity as well (a familiar theme in temperance circles in the industrial age). Province-wide
referenda were organized, and by 1917, prohibition had arrived or was on its way in every province but Quebec,

7. Jacques Paul Couturier, Prohibition or Regulation? The Enforcement of the Canada Temperance Act in Moncton, 1881-1896, Drink in
Canada: Historical Essays, ed. Cheryl Krasnick Warsh (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 1993): 146-7.
8. ibid.: 156.
9. Derrek Eberts, "To Brew or Not to Brew: A Brief History of Beer in Canada," Manitoba History, 54 (February 2007), accessed 26 July 2015,
[Link]
10. Heron, Booze, 191-6.
 7.7 TEMPERANCE AND PROHIBITION 353

where one could buy wine or light beers, but not hard alcohol (see Section 6.5). It didnt last. Returned soldiers
were upset that the country had gone dry in their absence and felt that they had earned the right to drink after
months and years in the trenches of Belgium and France. Quebec and British Columbia were the first to abandon
prohibition in favour of regulation and government-controlled liquor sales in 1921. Prohibition was lifted in three
provinces and the Yukon Territory by 1921; it didnt last much longer in Alberta and Saskatchewan, but it held on
longest in the Maritimes. The Dominion of Newfoundland prohibited possession or drinking of liquor from 1917
to 1924.

Thereafter, the legal and illegal production of liquor in both Dominions exploded in an attempt to meet demand
11
for the banned substance south of the border. American prohibition continued until 1933, creating a smuggling
industry in every West Coast, East Coast, and Great Lakes Canadian town within range of an American market.
While the heaviest traffic passed between the vicinity of Windsor, Ontario and Detroit, Michigan there was also
extensive illicit trade between the nominally-dry Maritimes and the whole American East Coast.

Figure 7.13 Liquor stills captured during prohibition in

Vancouver, 1917.

Rum-running was a feature of Vancouvers black economy as well. The chain of Gulf and San Juan Islands pro-
vided some cover, as did the multitude of tiny bays and inlets around Puget Sound. Fortunes were made on the
12
strength of boats that could outrun Coast Guard patrols and the RCMP. East Coast smugglers eluded local offi-
cials by claiming they were shipping out consignments to the Caribbean islands when, in fact, they were headed
to Boston or New York. There were accusations that the Newfoundland government, under Premier Sir Richard
Squires (1880-1940), had turned the Board of Liquor Control into a covert bootlegging operation, the prof-
13
its from private sales going into his political account. Inland smugglers thrived as well, including those in
Madawaska County (aka: the New Brunswick Panhandle) and the Kootenays in southern BC; both were remote
and lightly-policed areas with porous borders. On the West Coast, this was what one study calls the respectable
14
crime and the ranks of rum-runners in BC included members of very well-placed families.

Figure 7.14 The sail/steam combination ship, the Malahat

(described as a Mabel Brown class vessel) was known as the
Queen of Rum Row on the West Coast. It served as a floating
liquor warehouse to smaller, faster craft and was the source of
much of the wealth earned by Vancouvers Reifel family.

11. Mark C. Hunter, "Changing the Flag: The Cloak of Newfoundland Registry for American Rum-Running, 1924-34," Newfoundland and
Labrador Studies, 21/1 (2005).
12. Daniel Francis, Closing Time: Prohibition, Rum-Runners, and Border Wars (Vancouver: Douglas & McIntyre, 2014), 128.
13. Margaret R. Conrad and James K. Hiller, Atlantic Canada: A Concise History (Don Mills: Oxford University Press, 2006), 170.
14. Stephen J. Moore, Bootleggers and Borders: The Paradox of Prohibition on a Canada-U.S. Borderland (Lincoln: University of Nebraska
Press, 2014), 56.
 354 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Historical studies of rum-running mention women too often to suggest that their involvement was exceptional.
The production of small quantities of home-brew liquor was almost certainly work that women did, but they also
played frontline roles in the sale and delivery of banned cargo. One study explains that high unemployment rates
in the Maritimes in the 1920s were more crippling for women than for men, a fact that propelled many single
mothers some of them, of course, war widows into smuggling. A Mrs. Donnie Hart of Saint John stands
as a good example: arrested no less than once every year between 1916 and 1924, she worked as a bootlegger in
15
order to provide for her family.

Figure 7.15 A liquor raid at Elk Lake, Ontario, 1925. Illegal

production of liquor wasnt a problem before regulation.

Prohibition combined several contradictory forces. It was a manifestation of democratic will, a case of state inter-
vention in the economy, and it was instrumental in building up urban police forces as well. Simultaneously, it
diminished the rights of the individual, curtailed urban enterprise, and made public policy of private morality. It
was both a modern and anti-modern force (see Chapter 10). Both sides in this debate advanced the use and sophis-
tication of modern advertising as they campaigned for, on the one side, hearts and minds, and on the other, dry
throats and vulnerable livers. The campaign against liquor, then, introduces a panoply of historical themes. It also
introduces many of the key players in other crusades.

The Language of Liquor

Given the central place of liquor in the social lives of Canadians (past and present), it is no surprise to find
that the vocabulary around drinking is both extensive and potentially confusing. What follows is not an
exhaustive list of terms. It is weighted towards west coast usages and, worse still, none of these words are
used in the past or present with razor-sharp precision, but nonetheless it may be helpful.
Where:
Saloon Generally a drinking establishment not attached to a hotel or restaurant, usually urban. There are
few restrictions on standing or moving about, and probably not much in the way of food.
Pub or Public House These were often attached to roadside inns and milehouses in the mid- to late-19th
century. They provided drink by the glass, and in larger take-away quantities, and often served food as
well. A few survivors from that era kept the term in use and then it was revived in the 1970s with the spread
of faux pubs (essentially saloons with somewhat better food and design that mimics an ideal of English or
Irish drinking establishments).
Beer parlours/taverns 20th century; a regulated and licensed private establishment in which the public
can drink beer by the glass; standing at the bar is prohibited in most provinces; there is usually not much
in the way of food to soak up that beer. In British Columbia, there were for many years restrictions on
womens entry (they had to use the Ladies & Escorts door) to restrict heterosexual mingling and, ostensi-

15. Ernest R. Forbes, The East-Coast Rum-Running Economy, Drink in Canada: Historical Essays, ed. Cheryl Krasnick Warsh (Montreal &
Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 1993): 168.
 7.7 TEMPERANCE AND PROHIBITION 355

bly, the sex trade. In beer parlours until the late-20th century, moreover, patrons were not allowed to carry
their drinks from one table to another. Attempts to do so promoted the command to sit down and drink
16
your beer.
Boozecan, Blind pig, Speakeasy Colloquial terms for illegal drinking establishments. These were called
into existence by the increasing regulation of drink from the late Victorian-era, and especially so during
Prohibition. Even after Prohibition ended in Canada, there were illegal establishments that sought to evade
repressive regulation.
Who:
Drys Advocates for the limitation, if not outright prohibition, of alcohol production, sale, and consump-
tion.
Wets Opponents to the above. This camp includes people who wanted to drink and also the powerful
brewers, distillers, and other representatives of the liquor interests.
Womens Christian Temperance Union (WCTU) One of the largest and most effective anti-drink lobbies
in Canada. Established in 1874, months after its first branch was announced in the United States, the
WCTU emerged as a vehicle for contiguous reforms in public behaviour, the political environment, and
social conditions.
Rum-runners Vendors of alcohol (not just rum) who ship it illegally across provincial or national bound-
aries into territories where there are sanctions like Prohibition against the sale of liquor.
Bootleggers Anyone who sells liquor illegally. This term is used in the past to cover the rum-runners but
its domestic face, historically, was the couple who sold cheap homebrew off their back porch, and the taxi
driver who augmented his income with deliveries of bottles to homes and hotel rooms.
Liquor Control Boards Provincial agencies created in the 1920s to regulate post-prohibition drinking and
alcohol sales. These all became a major source of revenue for provincial governments.
When:
Sundays Highly unlikely. During the era of the six-day work-week, Sunday was the only opportunity
working people had to enjoy rest and leisure. That meant, too, that drinking was most likely to be heaviest
on Sundays. But this was a red rag to the Temperance Movement bull doubly bad because it combined
sin with the Sabbath. Sunday closing rules were subsequently introduced in the early 20th century, and
survived in most parts of Canada until the 1970s and 1980s.
When its quiet Music and performances of all kinds used to go nicely with a drink in the 19th century.
Joe Beefs Tavern in Montreal like many others in the Victorian era brought together music, dancing
bears, gambling, boisterous debate, and drink; low-brow entertainments became so closely associated with
17
public drinking that reformers targeted both simultaneously. As Craig Heron puts it, In English Canada,
both before and after prohibition, the isolation of public drinking from music and other forms of entertain-
ment undoubtedly stifled the growth of popular music and popular theatre in Canada, compared to what
was seen in Britain and Ireland. Montreals nightclubs were a special case, where drink and music were
allowed to co-exist and, coincidentally, where Canadas most vigorous jazz scene developed. Canadas
booze legislation, then, contributed to the countrys international reputation as a coldly austere, culturally
18
repressed country whose public cultural life matched its often forbidding climate.

16. Robert A. Campbell, Sit Down and Drink Your Beer: Regulating Vancouver's Beer Parlours, 1925-1954 (Toronto: University of Toronto
Press, 2001).
17. Peter DeLottinville, "Joe Beef of Montreal: Working-Class Culture and Tavern, 1869-1889," Labour/Le Travailleur, 8/9 (Autumn/Spring
1981/82): 9-40.
18. Heron, Booze, 378-9.
 356 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

What to Do:
Abstinence The anti-drink advocates began their crusade with a call to abstain from drinking. It threw
the responsibility onto the individual and, in the rhetoric of reform-minded Christianity, there were moral
and eternal consequences for not abstaining. The parallel moment in the anti-drug movement of the last 30
years would be the This is your brain on drugs campaign, launched in 1987.
Temperance If you cant completely give up the booze then at least drink in moderation. This approach
was adopted by many drinkers but by the 1870s, by fewer and fewer within the temperance movement
itself. By that time, the movement had become more intolerant of drink and organizations like the WCTU
called for all-out prohibition. Mid- to late-19th century temperance agitators moved the discourse around
drink from a personal and individual level to a social level, and from moral consequences to social conse-
quences; they argued that the impact of liquor extended far beyond the drinker.
Prohibition Taking the social agenda a step further, the prohibition movement called for state intervention
and the total eradication of liquor. Implicitly, this meant that the question of individual choice was resolved
in favour of state and police authority. Prohibition meant that individual effort was insufficient and that
moral consequences werent driving change fast enough: legal and financial consequences had to be
brought to bear, and these could (and did) include jail time.
Teetotalism Often misunderstood as tea-totalism, the teetotal movement was an expression of the absti-
nence movement in that it promoted personal resolve and self-restraint on the liquor issue rather than legal
sanctions.
Seek the help of a professional Fortunes were made during prohibition by the producers and vendors of
so-called medicinal alcohol. Products containing small quantities of alcohol were marketed as bitters,
19
cocktails, and energy drinks. A cooperative physician or pharmacist might be able to supply what you
need.

Key Points

Alcohol consumption in Canada increased and became more obvious with late 19th century urban-
ization.
The temperance movement gained extra force in Canada because of the parallel rise of the evangeli-
cal denominations, the support of working class organizations, the role of maternal feminists, and
fears associated with immigrants from non-traditional sources.
Temperance was initially implemented on a municipality-by-municipality basis. Provincial refer-
enda followed in the Great War, at which time both Canada and Newfoundland mostly went dry.
The end of Prohibition in Canada and its continuance in the United States created opportunities for
rum-runners on every shoreline.

Attributions
Figure 7.E1

19. Jason Vanderhill, "The Daniel Joseph Kennedy Story," Vancouver Confidential, ed. John Belshaw (Vancouver: Anvil, 2014): 39-58
 7.7 TEMPERANCE AND PROHIBITION 357

The Great Deceiver by Dominion Scientific Temperance Committee, Provincial Archives of Alberta,
PR1974.0001.0400a.0011 is in the public domain.

Figure 7.E2
Smokers and Sport by Dominion Scientific Temperance Committee, Provincial Archives of Alberta,
PR1974.0001.0400a.0011 is in the public domain.

Figure 7.12
One half mile of barmen along Yonge Street during the Prohibition parade (Online MIKAN
no.3193202) by John Boyd / Library and Archives Canada / PA-072524 is in the public domain.

Figure 7.13
CVA 480-215 View of liquor stills captured during Prohibition by Vancouver Police Department / City of
Vancouver Archives is in the public domain.

Figure 7.14
StateLibQld 1 147135 Malahat (ship) by John Oxley Library is in the public domain.

Figure 7.15
Raid at elk lake by C.H.J Snider fonds is in the public domain.
 7.8 Eugenics

Figure 7.16 Sir Francis Galton (1822-1911) was

a largely self-trained British social scientist,
a half-cousin of Charles Darwin, and the figure
most readily associated with Eugenics. It is
Galton who is credited with coining the
dichotomy: nurture vs. nature.

One of the earliest and longest lasting of the reform movements was associated with the ideals of eugenics. For-
mulated in its modern context in 1883 by the English intellectual, Sir Francis Galton, eugenics took its lead from
evolutionary and genetic theory, and was at the heart of what came to be known as scientific racism.

Gene Theory
The core idea of the eugenic theory is that genetic inheritance is a factor in the success or failure of a society.
Along with Galton, the proponents of eugenics believed that criminality, alcoholism, and feeble-mindedness
1
wereinherited. Individuals who are mentally or physically (and, sometimes, morally) challenged are doomed,
the eugenicists argue, to pass along those traits to their heirs (which, it is now widely understood, was never the
case). A person with a severe mental challenge like Down syndrome, for example, was reckoned incapable of
conceiving a child without Down syndrome. Poverty and laziness (often paired as personal qualities) were some-
times viewed as heritable as well. According to eugenic theory, poverty (a condition of life that can be instantly
changed with money) was not caused by changes in the economy or social circumstances: it was the consequence
of bad genes. Moral weakness was also aligned with feeble-mindedness. This was especially true as regards
eugenicists views of sexually active women (who were responsible, it was argued, for a rising tide of illegitimate
births) and sex trade workers.
2
The eugenicist strategy has been described as selective breeding, but that term does not do it justice. Selective

1. Angus McLaren, Our Own Master Race: Eugenics in Canada, 1885-1945 (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1990), 16.
2. R. Douglas Francis, Richard Jones, and Donald Smith, Destinies: Canadian History Since Confederation, 6th edition (Toronto: Thomson
Nelson, 2008), 173.

358
 7.8 EUGENICS 359

breeding invariably involves selecting in: that is, encouraging fit people (however defined) to have a significant
number of children. But the eugenics message in Canada was more about selecting out: to find ways to deter the
reproduction of what they regarded as fated populations who were doomed by their genes to imperil themselves,
successive generations, and the nation as a whole. In this campaign, they were not alone.

Part of the late 19th century context of eugenics in English-Canada was the falling fertility rate, particularly when
measured against that of French-Canada and immigrant communities (see Section 1.2). Eugenicists internation-
ally claimed that healthy societies were at risk from this fertility transition. Most of these cultures were hostile
to the idea of birth control because it would limit the reproduction of their own people, but the idea of sterilizing
the least healthy and least valued citizens had considerable appeal.

Nazi Germany, of course, ran headlong down this path and became notorious for the forced sterilization of roughly
360,000 individuals who failed to meet one test or another of normalcy. The fascists did not have a monop-
oly on eugenics: it is reckoned that, in the United States from 1910 to the 1970s, no fewer than 60,000 feeble-
minded citizens were forcibly sterilized. Canada sterilized proportionately fewer the total number is believed
to be slightly in excess of 3,000 but record keeping was inconsistent and there is little doubt that a true total is
3
unknowable.

What is distinctive about this particular branch of social reform in Canada is that its advocates sought to change
the human raw materials rather than the laws or conditions under which those humans lived. To quote the author-
ity on this subject, historian Angus McLaren, The eugenicists differed from most of their contemporaries not so
much in envisaging a radically different future, but in supporting the intrusive social policies they felt were needed
4
to bring it into being. While other social reformers were encouraging redemption through personal choice and
institutional supports, the eugenicists were advocating change at the sharp end of a scalpel.

A Nation of Thoroughbreds
Eugenics in Canada had two principal roots. These were the deteriorating health of urban working people and a
visible increase in the numbers (though not necessarily the incidence) of mental health cases. There was no short-
age of evidence that urban work made people less well and the eugenicists feared that those weaknesses would be
transmitted to successive generations. As for the mentally ill, their institutionalization and observation got under-
way in the mid-19th century with the construction of redoubtable asylums in the major cities. It was not until the
early 20th century, however, that eugenic thinking produced eugenic action. This took place at the provincial level
because of the allocation of powers under the BNA Act, but it was only Alberta and British Columbia that moved
forward with forced sterilization policies and campaigns.

Figure 7.17 The Provincial Training School for Mental

Defectives, Red Deer, AB, n.d.

3. Randall Hansen and Desmond King, Sterilized by the State: Eugenics, Race, and the Population Scare in Twentieth-Century North America
(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2013), 3.
4. McLaren, Our Own Master Race, 165.
 360 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Originally the Albertan legislation of 1928 did not permit involuntary sterilization but it was nevertheless coer-
cive. Patients were more likely to be discharged from an asylum or hospital if they elected to be sterilized; there
was an incentive, then, to go under the knife. This was evidently insufficient as far as Edmonton was concerned,
and under the Social Credit government of William Aberhart, the Board of Eugenics was given the power in 1938
to make sterilization compulsory. The Boards record of recommendations is astonishing: only 1% of cases con-
sidered were not recommended for immediate sterilization, and that tiny fraction was, in actuality, postponements.
5
As one study of the Alberta Board of Eugenics states succinctly, not once did it vote no.

Scholars working in this field think that British Columbias experiment with eugenic policies was less dramatic in
its numbers. The problem is that record keeping on this score was remarkably incomplete, and what records were
kept were subsequently destroyed or lost. We do know, however, that sterilizations were performed on inmates in
mental health and prison facilities beginning in 1933; perhaps a few hundred were affected.

The eugenics movement in Western Canada and the application of sterilization is discussed by historian
of institutionalization, Megan Davies (York University).

Fear of the Other

What these initiatives and the appeal of eugenics generally had in common was a fear of immigrants. One study
points to the convergence of the study and management of public health, reform of educational systems, and
concerns for immigrant selection in the 19-teens as a flashpoint in the development of eugenic sentiment. Accord-
ing to one historian of immigration, this was made

evident in a 1920 editorial of the Canadian Journal of Mental Hygiene, which observed that the feeble-minded, insane,
and psychopathic found in the province of Manitoba came out of all reasonable proportions from the immigrant class, and
it was found that these individuals were playing a major role in such conditions as crime, juvenile delinquency, prostitu-
6
tion, pauperism, certain phases of industrial unrest, and primary school inefficiency.

5. Hansen and King, Sterilized by the State, 97.

6. Donald H. Avery, Reluctant Host: Canadas Response to Immigrant Workers, 1896-1994 (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1995), 84-5.
 7.8 EUGENICS 361

If the project of nation building had as its goal a law-abiding, physically and mentally healthy population, these
werent just indicators of individual deviance: they were milestones of social decay and a call to action. In British
Columbia, where Asian immigration was part of the landscape in a way that it wasnt east of the Rockies, the
eugenics movement took on a particularly racist tone. J.S. Woodsworth an influential figure in the Social
Gospel movement described the Chinese as a nonassimilable element and advocated exclusion while one
asylum director in the Vancouver area, Charles Doherty, conspired to illegally deport feeble-minded Chinese to
Shanghai. His actions were consistent with the white majoritys fear that the Chinese constituted a virulent racial
plague that had invaded the unsuspecting western colonies and threatened to decimate the good works and dilute
7
the blood of its British forebears. With fewer rights to be stripped away than just about any other group, the
Chinese-Canadians who found themselves in BCs psychiatric and mental health facilities were exiled rather than
sterilized.

There was a kind of inexorable logic to it all. If the first principle of racism was correct and there was, in fact, a
hierarchy of races in which northwestern Europeans stood at the top, and if genetics was a predictable business,
then the intermingling of races might strengthen weaker peoples but it could only harm stronger nations. And if
strong nations had their share of feebleminded individuals, then weak races would have far more. It was also
widely believed that the poor, the racially inferior, and the mentally inferior had higher fertility rates than Anglo-
Canadians. By encouraging the immigration of lower-tiered races, Canada had thus invited into its midst people
whose mental, moral, and physical fabric posed a risk to the whole of this striving, ambitious Canadian project.
Doing so was described by the eugenicists as race suicide.

A couple of things are striking about this reform movement. First, it was championed principally by nominally
progressive elements. In Alberta, the United Farmers (UFA) party brought in sterilization legislation and it was,
in particular, the United Farm Women of Alberta who led the way in 1924, achieving legislation in 1928. J.S.
Woodsworth espoused eugenicist ideas in his anti-immigrant book Strangers At Our Gates (1909). Tommy Dou-
glas, the CCF leader and Premier of Saskatchewan, wrote his 1933 Masters thesis on The problem of the sub-
normal family and advocated sterilization of the mentally subnormal. As the Social Gospel moved further from
theological to sociological grounds and as that sociology became more allegedly scientific, the responses to men-
tal health became less redemptive and more clinical.

We also find maternal feminists in the frontlines of the eugenics movement. Having elevated motherhood to
womans highest calling, the quality of motherhood would inevitably come into question, especially if the fer-
8
tility of the defective population was left unchecked. Both Mary Ellen Smith (ca.1861-1933) and Emily Mur-
phy (1868-1933) were outspoken advocates of sterilization in BC and Alberta. Smith the first woman elected
to the BC legislature in 1918 (with the slogan, Women and children first!) and the first woman in the British
Empire to hold a Cabinet seat in government brought the issue to the provincial Assembly in 1925. Murphy
one of the Famous Five who were key to the 1929 Persons Case was brutally frank in her opinions on
the subject. In 1932, she wrote that if the state could protect the public against diseased and distempered cattle,
then it should also protect [the public] against the offal of humanity. She called on the government of BC to
9
do whatever it could to produce human thoroughbreds. Murphys position on Chinese immigration was made

7. Robert Menzies, Race, Reason, and Regulation: British Columbias Mass Exile of Chinese Lunatics aboard the Empress of Russia, 9 Feb-
ruary 1935, in Regulating Lives: Historical Essays on the State, Society, the Individual, and the Law, John McLaren, Robert Menzies, and
Dorothy E. Chunn, eds.(Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2002): 199-203.
8. Angus McLaren and Arlene Tigar McLaren, The Bedroom and the State: The Changing Practices and Politics of Contraception and Abor-
tion in Canada, 1880-1997, 2nd edition (Toronto: Oxford University Press, 1997), 68.
9. Hansen and King, Sterilized by the State, 99.
 362 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

clear in her attacks on the yellow peril in the pages of The Black Candle (1922) under the pseudonym of Janey
Canuck: she took the view that inferior peoples begat more inferior peoples and they were all inclined toward
criminality.

Figure 7.18 The Asylum for Idiots and Feeble-Minded at Orillia,

ON, ca.1910.

There were parallel movements in central and eastern Canada, though they failed to achieve legislation in support
of sterilization. The Eugenics Society of Canada was established in 1925 but really only began meeting in earnest
in the 1930s. More influential was the work of individuals in newly created professional fields. Dr. Helen Mac-
Murchy held the position of Inspector of the Feeble-Minded for Ontario, from 1906 to 1919, and was another
10
advocate of both institutionalization of the mentally sub-normal and sterilization. Like many conservative
first-wave feminists she was opposed to birth control. She felt the use of birth control by the dominant Anglo-
Celtic society would only cause the fertility rates of what she regarded as the better sort of Canadians to fall
11
against the unbridled fertility of inferior peoples (whose fecundity she sought to control through sterilization).

Immigrants and members of ethnic minorities were heavily targeted by the eugenicists, as were Aboriginal peo-
ples. Half-breed a term that carried with it a certain amount of pride and distinction in the previous century
was used by the eugenicists in the 20th century in rhetoric designed to show the debilitating effects of inter-
marriage between races. With that in mind, it is not surprising to find that Aboriginal and Mtis individuals were
vastly over-represented in the Albertan sterilization cases. Children, who enjoyed fewer legal protections than
adults in institutional settings, were also over-represented. So, too, were women. Overwhelmingly, eugenics in
practice was about sterilizing girls and women whose sexuality, morality, poverty, ethnicity, and intelligence com-
bined to constitute a perceived threat to the health and safety of the larger community.

Figure 7.19 The Provincial Lunatic Asylum in New Westminster,

shortly after it was opened in 1878. It would subsequently
become known as the Provincial Hospital for the Insane and,
from 1950, as Woodlands School.

Hard Language

In the 21st century, we are accustomed to using vocabulary that is sensitive and respectful as regards phys-

10. McLaren, Our Own Master Race, 30-6.

11. Erin L. Moss, Henderikus J. Stam, and Diane Kattevilder, From Suffrage to Sterilization: Eugenics and the Womens Movement in 20th
Century Alberta, Canadian Psychology, vol. 54, no.2 (2013): 105-107.
 7.8 EUGENICS 363

ical and mental illnesses and challenges. The language used in the 19th century and through most of the
20th, however, was far more direct and judgmental. It is difficult to convey the level of conviction held
by eugenicists if we use 21st century language. They didnt consider mental illness a disability; instead,
they made use of a rhetoric of retardation, insanity, immorality, and idiocy. Individuals with phys-
ical challenges were regarded as handicapped at best, but crippled most of the time. People, moreover,
became their affliction: individuals with what is sometimes called sub-normal intelligence were both
retarded and retards, perhaps morons or imbeciles. John Langdon Down (1828-1896), for whom
Down dyndrome is named, came up with the term mongoloids a disturbing reference to the phys-
ical appearance of his patients that, moreover, suggests a racist outlook as well. Individuals with physi-
cal disabilities were, of course, cripples. Women working in the sex trade were simply and inescapably
prostitutes.
These terms enabled 19th and 20th century reformers to objectify the individuals to whom they were refer-
ring. Understanding that (for us, discomfiting) relationship between language and reform is critical if we
are to understand the attraction and authority of movements like eugenics. A mental disability wasnt a
challenge to be overcome: it was a permanent state that defined the individual in question and from which
there was little likelihood of escape.

Whatever happened to Eugenics?

The eugenics movement survived in the post-war era to the 1970s. Involuntary sterilizations in Alberta and British
Columbia actually increased between 1945 and the late 1960s. Across the country, however, the tide started to
turn much earlier.

A visit to Nazi Germany in 1936 was enough to flush eugenicism out of Tommy Douglas portfolio of social
reforms. Physicians, theologians, and scientists in Quebec those who did not share in the Anglo-Canadian ter-
ror of being over-run by Catholics and foreigners focused their fire on the faulty science in hereditarian theory.
By 1945 they had made much headway in discrediting the movement. It is worth noting that the Catholic Church
came out as a consistent critic of eugenicist views, and it was particularly hostile to involuntary sterilization. This
opposition derived from several concerns. One that especially mattered in Canada was the xenophobic and Protes-
tant tone of eugenics: both the French and Irish Canadians were tarred with this hostile brush. In the years after
1945 increasing public awareness of the role played by eugenics in Hitlers program of racial purification and
genocide tempered Canadian attitudes.

Nonetheless, BC and Alberta held on to their policies and practices for another generation. Facilities like the
BC Provincial Hospital for the Mind (aka: Essondale, Riverview), Woodlands in New Westminster, and Red
Deers Provincial Training School for Mental Defectives (after 1977 known as the Michener Centre), saw the
majority of the provinces sterilizations in the 1950s. The westernmost provinces had something else in common:
Social Credit governments, both of which fell in 1972. The Alberta sterilization laws were repealed almost imme-
diately after the new Conservative administration led by Peter Lougheed came to office; the BC legislation was
repealed without fanfare in 1973 under the New Democratic Party government of Dave Barrett (b. 1930). In both
cases, the context of change was the rise of a stronger culture of individual and human rights. In the mid-1990s,
the Alberta government began the process of apologizing and offering compensation to victims of involuntary
sterilization. The British Columbia government did the same, but only when ordered to do so by the Supreme
Court in 2006.
 364 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

This is not to say that the eugenicist perspective disappeared entirely. Even in the absence of sterilization legisla-
tion, it was revealed in 1978 that Ontarian physicians were performing parent-approved sterilization on children
12
with developmental disabilities. But the social panics about high rates of unemployment, the rise of an urban
criminal class, a tidal wave of illegitimate births, and the degenerate qualities of the immigrant population
all of which contributed to the original calls for eugenicism described above had passed. By the 1960s, moder-
nity was entering into middle-age, and the social transformations that were being wrought by urbanization and
industrial labour were no longer news. This normalizing of modernity affected movement cultures as a whole and
gave way to newer, different tensions.

Differently Abled

Figure 7.20 Mary Macdonald, photographed in

1893 by William James Topley.

The word eugenics means well born. Mary Macdonald (1869-1933), hydrocephalic and confined to a
wheelchair, would have been fourteen years old when Sir Francis Galton coined the term. She was not well
born.
Her mother, Agnes Bernard, experienced an excruciating labour, and the infant Mary immediately dis-
played signs of the enlarged head that would guarantee, in the late 19th century, a lifetime of impairments.
Her parents were at first devastated although, as the years passed, they would demonstrate a commitment
to Marys welfare. Marys father was notoriously terrible with his finances and he struggled with alcohol,
but somehow he and Agnes found the resources to hire a pair of caregivers and to pursue what proved to be
fruitless medical treatments. They constructed a wheelchair-accessible gallery in their home that enabled
Mary to meet her fathers visitors. Not all Victorians, it seems, were fearfully ashamed of their childs men-
13
tal and physical disabilities. Not Agnes and Sir John A. Macdonald at any rate.

Key Points

Eugenics was based on a scientific theory that posited the inheritability of intelligence and defects in
intelligence, as well as morality, work ethic, and poverty.
Eugenicists sought to reduce the impact of inferior peoples by means of institutionalization and
sterilization, while fighting against campaigns for accessible birth control.
No fewer than 3,000 Canadians were sterilized, principally in Alberta and British Columbia.
Mostly, the subjects of sterilization were women, children, immigrants, Aboriginal people, and

12. McLaren, Our Own Master Race, 169.

13. Ged Martin, John A. Macdonald: Canadas First Prime Minister (Toronto: Dundurn, 2013), 116-17, 180.
 7.8 EUGENICS 365

Mtis.
Support for the eugenicist cause came from within the Social Gospel movement and early feminist
organizations.
Official sterilization campaigns ended in the 1970s.

Attributions
Figure 7.16
Sir Francis Galton is in the public domain.

Figure 7.17
The Provincial Training School in Red Deer, Alberta by Alberta Public Archives is in the public domain.

Figure 7.18
The Asylum, Orillia by McCord Museum is used under a CC-BY-NC-ND 2.5 license.

Figure 7.19
New Westminster Asylum 1878 by British Columbia Archives is in the public domain.

Figure 7.20
Mary Macdonald by William James Topley / Library and Archives Canada is in the public domain. This image is
available from Library and Archives Canada under the reference number FA-001.
7.9 Reform Politics: 3rd Parties

The American political system has been demonstrably inhospitable toward third parties for nearly two and a
half centuries. The British parliamentary system, however, allows for third parties and more. Admittedly, the
first-past-the-post arrangement eats into the likelihood of small party success. (While a party might secure 25%
nationally, they might not win enough votes in any one constituency to elect even a single MP.) But the possi-
bility of a breakthrough exists and this has encouraged the rise of several parties with limited prospects. Some
of these parties have punched well above their weight in terms of their political importance and/or influence on
the political forefront. Although some third parties never even achieve federal Official Opposition status, a few
have exercised power and influence in minority governments. Some have held office provincially, and thus won
a high profile there, even if nowhere else. All are expressions of Canadian political culture and values; none are
unworthy of study.

Since the early 19th century, political organizations that offer a critique of the constitution, the establishment,
or government practices have seized the reform banner. Some made use of the name while others described their
mission as one that had a reforming agenda. This distinguishes them from the mainstream parties (since 1867, the
Liberals and the Conservatives) in that they sought more than a crack at power. Beginning in the late 19th cen-
tury, social reform and financial reform movements generated political expressions. Perhaps because they had the
sensibilities of a movement, some of these political parties were able to survive years of disappointment.

First and Second Parties

In order for the Grits and the Tories to become the Liberals and the Conservatives, respectively, they had to create
the political machinery necessary to succeed at the polls across the country. This was no small task. In 1867, the
Grits were heavily concentrated in southern Ontario and the Tories were part of an urban and landed elite in both
Ontario and Quebec: neither showed much natural ability at expanding their reach. Within 30 years, however, the
Liberals and the Conservatives held a duopoly on the federal and provincial stages alike. There were a few excep-
tions. In British Columbia, for example, party lines were not introduced until 1903. Otherwise, the 19th century
closed with a political ecology in Canada that was all but identical to that of Britain, consisting almost exclusively
of Liberals and Conservatives.

What happened in the 20th century was, in some respects, a return to the politically fractious pre-Confederation
days of Grits, Rouges, Tories, Patriotes, Reformers, and Bleus. And while Canada did not follow Britains (and
Australias) lead in forming a Labour Party, neither did it conform to the rather limited vision of political options

366
 7.9 REFORM POLITICS: 3RD PARTIES 367

available to Britons, Antipodeans, and Americans. Canada experimented. Having said that, the multi-party sys-
tem that emerged by the 1920s did not produce a rash of minority governments comparable to what happened in
20th century France and Italy. At the provincial level, the Maritimes would remain loyal to the binary options of
Liberals and Conservatives in federal and provincial politics; the same could not be said of the rest of Canada, not
even Ontario.

Factionalists
Within the established parties there have always been small break-away movements. Most instances see a disaf-
fected elected representative or two leave their party caucus and sit as Independents. Sometimes Independent
candidates will successfully seek election, although to do so they have to overcome the party machinery on which
their opponents might call. More commonly in the 19th century, a hyphenated allegiance would be used in order
to make the best of two partisan brands. Macdonald tried this himself when he promoted his party as the Liberal-
Conservatives in the earliest days of Confederation. By 1873, the label had been dehyphenated and the Liberal
part appropriated by the Grit-Rouge alliance. At about the same time, a Conservative-Labour candidate was
elected to Parliament from Hamilton the first working-class MP. Seeking to distance themselves from imperial-
ists within their party, from 1878-1911, several Quebec Conservatives ran as Nationalist-Conservatives. By way
of contrast, the hard-line, anti-Catholic, anti-French politician Dalton McCarthy (1836-98) eschewed any part of
the established parties brand when he broke with the Conservatives and established his own slate of candidates
in the 1896 election. They were known (modestly) as McCarthyites. Only McCarthy himself was ever elected
and he died two years later in a traffic accident.

The 20th century saw still more schisms in the main parties, but most remarkable was the ability of the Conserv-
atives and Liberals to reel in their factional elements.

The United Farmers

It is perhaps ironic that farmers parties arrived on the scene when they did. After all, the 1921 census showed that
Canada had crossed a threshold and was now more urban than rural.

The first third party movement to win a majority of seats in any jurisdiction was the United Farmers of Ontario
(UFO) in 1919. Despite its urban centres, Ontario south of the Canadian Shield was still heavily rural. Every
constituency had enough farmers (and farmers allies) votes to leave the old parties behind. Although the UFO
administration was brief it lasted only one term, from 1919 to 1923 it was a breakthrough in that it showed
the possibility of sectoral appeals across a whole province. The 1919 campaign involved a tactical alliance with
the moderate Independent Labour Party of Ontario: the ILP didnt run candidates in rural areas and the UFO
stayed out of urban constituencies. The result was a coalition partnership that accomplished quite a lot in terms of
early welfare legislation, prohibition, and the establishment of co-operatives, but failed to deliver one of its more
innovative reforms: proportional representation.

The UFO election was followed quickly by similar triumphs in the West. The United Farmers of Alberta (UFA)
were elected to govern in 1921 and the United Farmers of Manitoba (UFM) won a significant number of seats in
1920. Ottawas wartime refusal to lift tariffs was an important source of UF popularity. Indeed, a common thread
in the rise of the United Farmers was their anti-Ottawa posture. Criticism of the tariff component of the National
Policy had failed to shift the Conservatives. The Liberals, for their part, blew hot and cold on free trade with the
368 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

United States, despite farmers demands for reciprocity. Whats more, a succession of Liberal and Conservative
provincial governments had failed to win concessions from federal governments. Local voters felt there was noth-
ing to lose in voting United Farmer.

The Progressives

In 1919, the federal Union Governments Minister of Agriculture, Thomas Crerar (1876-1975), split with the Bor-
den administration over its apparent disregard for farmers issues. The United Farmers ran candidates successfully
in a handful of federal by-elections in 1919 and 1920, which led Crerar to form a national pro-agriculturalist party.
The result was the Progressive Party, which ran its first campaign in 1921, stealing 58 seats nationally and form-
ing the second largest caucus in Ottawa. By rights, this should have made Crerar the head of the Official Oppo-
sition. The Progressives, however, were heavily influenced by populist and agrarian movements, particularly in
the United States. They didnt like caucus accountability and discipline and they preferred to vote their (individ-
ual) conscience. The Progressives turned down the opportunity to enter into a coalition with the Liberals under
King and they passed the title of Official Opposition off to the third-place Conservatives under Arthur Meighen
(see Section 6.7). While these decisions and tactics arose from the anti-party philosophy of the Progressives,
they doomed the organization to insignificance in the House of Commons. It has been suggested by some analysts
that the Progressives atomistic approach means that they werent a party at all, just an expression of the United
Farmers movement. This may be true, but it is all too easy to understate their appeal in the Canadian heartland:
half of their MPs came from Ontario, where the Progressives won a quarter of the provinces federal seats. (They
were unable to make much headway in the Maritimes.)

By 1926, the independently minded Progressives had unraveled. Crerar resigned and the House Leader was now
Robert Forke (1860-1934), a veteran of the Liberal Party from Manitoba. When the Conservatives briefly formed
a government in 1926, Forke took the Manitoban Progressives into the Liberal Party where they were quickly sub-
sumed into the older organization. Ontarian support dissolved and the more hard-line Albertan members washed
their hands of the Progressive label and sat as UFA representatives in Parliament. Although Progressives were
still winning seats in the 1930 election, their numbers were down to single digits. Some of the Albertans were part
of a more radical labour-farmer alliance with a strong social gospel pedigree. This group would go on to found
the core parliamentary element of the CCF (see below).

What remained of the Progressive Party disintegrated during the 1930s and Crerar was welcomed formally into
the Liberal fold. He was rewarded with a cabinet post and a seat in the Senate. The Progressive name, however,
was appropriated by the Conservative Party, thus the Progressive Conservatives from 1942 to 2003.

The Reconstruction Party

H.H. Stevens, a high ranking cabinet minister in the Tory governments of Meighen and Bennett, bailed on the lat-
ter on the eve of the 1935 election and formed the Reconstruction Party. Isolationist and inclined towards appease-
ment of the fascist powers in Europe, the Reconstruction Party finished third in the election with nearly 10% of
the popular vote but won only one seat: Stevens own in the Kootenays. The party folded and Stevens rejoined
the Conservatives, despite the fact that Reconstructions campaign split the vote in dozens of constituencies and
ended up costing the Tories dearly.
 7.9 REFORM POLITICS: 3RD PARTIES 369

The Left
Among the first political movements to achieve some measure of success were the Socialists. The Canadian Left
took many forms, however, and there were more splinters and fragments on this side of the ideological spectrum
than on the Right.

The Socialist Party

The Socialist Party of British Columbia (SPBC) was the first of several like-minded organizations to elect a can-
didate to a provincial legislature. They elected two in 1903: Parker Williams and James Hawthornthwaite. Late in
1904, the SPBC fused with socialist parties from across the Prairies and Ontario to create the Socialist Party of
Canada (SPC). The whole array was, from the 1890s through the 1920s, deeply divided over the issue of reform
versus revolution. An important and influential faction dubbed impossibilists argued against any gradu-
alist or reformist approach to capitalism, maintaining that ameliorating the worst effects of the existing system
would only enable it to last longer. This made the business of holding elected office exceedingly difficult for rep-
resentatives of the SPBC and SPC: if they were able to secure better conditions for workers, they would lose the
support of the impossibilist faction if they didnt, they would likely lose the support of the electorate. Even as
the SPCs membership and support level was growing during the first decade of the century by 1910 it was the
third largest party in Canada moderate elements were leaving to form more reform-oriented social democratic
parties.

The SPC continued to enjoy success in British Columbia until the Great War. In the 1912 provincial election,
the SPC won 11% of the vote, a high water mark for third parties in the furthest West before the end of the war.
Nationally, however, the party entered into a difficult phase. Its anti-war stance, which grew out of an interna-
tionalist view of the working-class, brought it under the lens of national security monitors. Its members were
harassed, its mail was tampered with and seized, and its newspaper (The Western Clarion) closed down. The rev-
olution in Russia in 1917 led to the formation of a Canadian communist movement that was increasingly critical
of the SPC. Attacked from the right and the left, the SPC staggered into the 1920s and collapsed in 1925, most of
its members having left to join the communists.

Communist Parties

The Russian Revolution of 1917 inspired some Leftists to pursue a new organizational approach. The War Mea-
sures Act was still in effect in 1921 when the founding meetings took place and the ban on any communist party
obliged the use of a different banner: the Workers Party of Canada. The ban was lifted in 1926 and the Commu-
nist Party of Canada (CPC) appeared. The Party struggled with the principal issue that divided communist parties
internationally: whether to pursue a worldwide revolution or to support the goal of a successful revolution in Rus-
sia. Factions supporting international revolution (Trotskyites) were expelled from the party by the dominant Stal-
inist elements representing the will of the Communist International (aka the Third International, the Comintern).

When the 1930s began and the western world entered into a deep and (as it turned out) protracted crisis in cap-
italism, support for the CPC and similar movements grew. This resulted in an escalation of state surveillance
and harassment. The 1931 arrest and imprisonment of Tim Buck (1891-1973), the leader of the CPC from 1929
to 1962, drove much of the CPC machinery underground. When Buck was released in 1934, he was met by a
17,000-person rally at Torontos Maple Leaf Gardens, a further sign that support for the CPC was growing while
370 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

the economy was sinking. CPC efforts to organize the single transient unemployed were particularly effective and
resulted in the establishment of the Relief Camp Workers Union and the Workers Unity League. The CPC was
also able to forge anti-fascist partnerships with more moderate left-wing movements and it played a leading role
in founding the 1500-member Mackenzie-Papineau Battalion that was sent to Spain to fight the fascists in the
Civil War in 1837-38. Not that this initiative improved their relationship with an increasingly anti-fascist govern-
ment in Ottawa: when war against Germany and Italy erupted in 1939, the Mac-Pap veterans were categorized
by the federal government as premature antifascists and potential subversives.

Figure 7.21 Tim Buck (left, seated) returns to Maple Leaf

Gardens in 1942.

At the provincial level the Communists were hounded particularly hard by the government of Quebec. The so-
called Padlock Law of 1937 (officially, in English, an Act to Protect the Province Against Communistic Propa-
ganda) was used to close down communist presses and to imprison anyone involved in production or distribution
of printed materials for up to three years. It would be another 20 years before the law was struck down as uncon-
stitutional.

Figure 7.22 Annie Buller (1895-1973) was a dynamic activist in

the CPC, leading a general strike of dressmakers in Toronto and
allegedly inciting a riot at Estevan, SK, during a coal miners
strike, both in 1931. She ran for office on at least three occasions
and was jailed repeatedly, mainly for belonging to the CPC.

The Party itself walked a difficult tightrope on international issues. Anti-fascist in 1938, they adhered to the Com-
interns anti-war strictures until 1941. The Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact of 1939 a mutual non-aggression agree-
ment between Nazi Germany and Soviet Russia was meant to produce a war between capitalist nations. In
that context the CPC was viewed by Ottawa as an organization intent on subverting the war effort of the western
Allies, not least of which because the Soviet Union was busily annexing the Baltic nations and badgering Finland.
When Germany invaded the Soviet Union in June 1941 and the USSR joined in the battle against the Axis Pow-
ers, the status of the CPC and its members improved dramatically.

The party reached a zenith of popularity in 1945, when Joseph Stalins Soviet Union was Canadas indispensable
ally. In the general election of that year, the CPCs Labor-Progressive Party (LPP) pulled in over 2% of the
national vote and won one seat. The LPP ran candidates until 1959 and the CPC after that. It failed to win a single
seat after 1945.

Support for the Communists was progressively gutted from the mid-1950s onward. Soviet President Nikita Khr-
uschevs damning 1956 speech on Stalin-era purges and atrocities caused some members to leave the party, as did
the Soviet suppression of the Hungarian Revolution that same year. Disclosures of anti-Semitism at the highest
 7.9 REFORM POLITICS: 3RD PARTIES 371

levels of the Soviet Union further alienated members of the CPC, many of whom were Jewish. The Soviet assault
on Czechoslovakias 1968 rising was cause for further desertions in the decade that followed.

There was a surge in electoral support for the CPC in 1974 when it secured 12,100 votes in the federal election.
But by any standard, this was an abject failure as a partisan endeavour. Things worsened for the party at the polls
as the Cold War ground to a close. The collapse of the Soviet Union flushed out divisions within the CPC and its
assets became, in 1991, the subject of an acrimonious and very public separation battle. The party re-established
itself thereafter as an organization dedicated to Marxist-Leninist ideals and it continues to operate in provincial,
civic, and federal elections.

Social Democrats

The branch of the political tree that produced the Cooperative Commonwealth Federation (CCF) and the New
Democratic Party (NDP) had roots in the social reform movements of the 19th and early 20th century: the United
Farmers movements, the Progressives (discussed below), labour organizations like the Knights of Labor, trade
unionism, the cooperative movement, and a wide range of socialist philosophies. Established as a national polit-
ical party in 1932, the CCF ran in its first election in 1933 in British Columbia, where it became the Official
Opposition. Thereafter, the party enjoyed success principally at the provincial level, particularly in three of the
four western provinces, but it also played a key role in federal politics both in its original form and, later, as the
NDP.

The core elements of the moderate socialist movement came together in 1924 in Ottawa. The Progressive Party
was nursing closer relations with the Liberal Party and were, some of its members believed, abandoning several
key values. Five United Farmers MPs from Alberta and one from Ontario formed a faction within the Progres-
sive Party a party within a party and they were joined soon after by five other Progressives, along with
four Labour MPs, and four Independent Labour Party MPs. Together this was the Ginger Group, a coalition of
like-minded men and one woman. What they brought together was a shared belief in the need for greater equality
of opportunity and living standards across the social classes, elimination of the worst effects of competitive cap-
italism, and political reform that included an extension of greater rights to women. In the midst of an economic
boom, their voices were largely drowned out. Eight years later, in the midst of the Great Depression, what they
had to say appealed to a far greater number of Canadians.

This wasnt the first attempt to forge a common front on the left of the Canadian political spectrum but it had cer-
tain qualities that gave it the possibility of greater longevity. For starters, it was a group made up mostly of men
who were in their mid- to late-forties; that is, they were all (but one) born in the late 1870s or early/mid-1880s
and were thus mostly too old to have served in the Great War. They constituted a peer group that was neither
too young to be dismissed as immature radical cranks, nor so old that they seemed out of touch with any par-
ticular demographic. Farming backgrounds were a common denominator, as was Methodism, Presbyterianism,
and a commitment to the goals of the cooperative movement. They had some occupational range: their number
included a lawyer and an upholsterer. The two outliers in the group were to have, arguably, the greatest impact on
the Ginger CCF project. J.S. Woodsworth (1874-1942) was the oldest and came into the Group with a reputation
as a writer, a Methodist minister and teacher, a pacifist, a labour activist, and a leading light in the social gospel
movement. He was also an architect of Canadas first old age pension legislation in 1926 and so demonstrated how
the state could play a direct role in alleviating hardship. This was a significant reversal from the old Poor Law
mentality of the 19th century and opened the door to social welfare legislation across Canada. Woodsworth would
372 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

become the de facto leader of the Ginger Group and officially, in 1932, of the CCF. The other peerless member
of the Group was Agnes Macphail (1890-1954), the youngest of the founders by three years, the only woman,
and the only representative of the United Farmers of Ontario. Macphail was a firster, first woman elected to
Parliament, one of the first women elected to the Ontario legislature, the first woman to represent Canada at the
League of Nations (the precursor to the United Nations), and the first president of the Ontario CCF. A Methodist
in her youth, she was swept up in the evangelical movement in the early 20th century. Macphail worked as a
school teacher before pursuing a career in politics, and the very act of being a female career politician consti-
tuted another first. She wasnt directly involved in the Persons Case of 1929 but was almost a beneficiary; she
was about to be offered a seat in the Senate when she died in 1954. Macphails significant contribution was both
symbolic and practical. She demonstrated by her presence that the social democratic movement was a welcoming
place for women in politics and, as a pioneer woman in Canadian politics, she set the bar high for accomplish-
ments.

By the 1930s the Ginger Group itself had fractured; some of its members had retired from politics or had been
voted out of office. The economic crisis, however, pulled others into the conversation about a political mechanism
for achieving social change. These included the League for Social Reconstruction (LSR), a socialist think-tank
(before the words think and tank were ever combined) led by two outstanding Canadian intellectuals. Frank
Underhill, a historian at the University of Toronto, and F.R. Scott, a Law professor at McGill University, very
informally founded the LSR with an eye to building a national network of intellectuals who could shift the con-
versation about the causes of and solutions to the Depression along a constructive, socialist path. Both Under-
hill and Scott were convinced that capitalism was at the root of the Depression, not moral or social issues; that
only systemic changes that delivered socialist policies could change things for the better. The LSR lasted barely
a decade and was responsible for building support for the idea of social, economic, and political planning across
the party spectrum. It was joined early on by two figures who would play important roles in Canadian politics:
Eugene Forsey (1904-91), a young political economist from Newfoundland via Oxford University and elite cir-
cles in Toronto, and David Lewis (1909-81), a brilliant Rhodes Scholar and political animal, freshly returned from
England. Lewis, like A. A. Heaps (1885-1954) one of the original Gingers was a Jew and a consistent and
strident opponent of the Communist movement.

In 1932, Underhill and Scott met with the Ginger Group in Ottawa and began the process of founding what they
initially called the Commonwealth Party. A convention was held in 1932 and, influenced by the agrarian social-
ism of the UFA, Cooperative was added to the partys name, and its many threads recognized in the word Fed-
eration. For a while the party banner also carried the words Farmer-Labour-Socialist. In 1933, at the second
convention, the main tenets of the Cooperative Commonwealth Federation were codified into the Regina Mani-
festo; these included an ambitious program of social welfare legislation, national ownership of key industries, and
a program of universal healthcare. The Manifesto also called for an end to capitalism, a resolution that would be
a red rag to anti-communists for the next two decades.

Almost immediately the CCF scored important victories that dwarfed the achievements of any other socialist party
in Canadian history. Official Opposition status came first in BC, then in Ontario, but it was in Saskatchewan where
the party first formed a government, in 1944. The first socialist government in North America, it would serve as
an example of social democratic programming for the rest of the country, piloting the universal healthcare pro-
gram that was embraced by Ottawa in the 1960s.

Outside of Saskatchewan and British Columbia (where it continued as the Opposition), the post-War years were
 7.9 REFORM POLITICS: 3RD PARTIES 373

grim for the CCF. The CCF found itself undermined by the Communists and targeted by an increasingly paranoid
Cold War media. To be sure, there were CCFers who came to the party via more ideologically Marxist organi-
zations and some espoused a radical position regarding property and capitalism. David Lewis spent years trying
to minimize their impact on the partys policies and profile. In 1956 he finally succeeded, replacing the Regina
Manifesto with the much milder Winnipeg Declaration. He was aided in this campaign by another CCF veteran
of the 1930s, M. J. Coldwell (1888-1974), who undertook a purge of the partys red elements and repositioned
the CCF as an opponent of the Soviet Union. By the late 1950s, however, campaigns against the Left had reached
such a pitch that the CCF was all but irrelevant in most jurisdictions.

At that point, the newly restructured national labour centre the Canadian Labour Congress (CLC) negotiated
a partnership with the CCF. This produced, in the course of nearly seven years, the New Party, a CCF-CLC
collaboration that changed its name in 1963 to the New Democratic Party (NDP). Tommy Douglas, the for-
mer CCF premier of Saskatchewan, took over the leadership and the social democratic partys fortunes began to
improve instantly. There was steady growth through the 1960s and in 1972, the NDP secured enough seats to hold
the balance of power in Pierre Trudeaus minority government. This was an opportunity to push through social
democratic legislation in exchange for propping up the Liberals. The next election, in 1974, cost the NDP dearly;
its share of the popular vote hardly changed but it lost half its seats in Parliament nevertheless and was reduced to
the third party once more.

There were, however, some victories at the provincial level. The first Manitoban NDP government was elected
in 1969 under Edward Ed Schreyer (b.1935); Allan Blakeney (1925-2011) revived the Saskatchewan NDP in
1971, forming a government that would last until 1982; in BC in 1972, David Barrett ended 20 years of Social
Credit government under W.A.C. Bennett but his NDP government would endure a mere three years; the Yukon
NDP formed its first government in 1985 under Tony Penikett (b.1945) and held on to power until 1992. In
Ontario, the provincial NDP would go from a position of strength in the 1970s to even greater strength in the
1980s. Beginning with David Lewis son Stephen (b.1937), then Bob Rae (b.1948), the NDP headed up the Offi-
cial Opposition in the legislature (Lewis, 1975-77) and held the balance of power (Rae, 1985-87), until forming
the government (Rae, 1990-95).

NDP claims of being a national party remained more wishful thinking than empirically verifiable through the late
20th century. The party continued to be marginal in Alberta, Quebec, and the Maritimes. In the rest of the country,
however, and especially under the leadership of Edward Ed Broadbent (b.1936) from 1975 to 1989, the NDPs
central role in federal politics became increasingly confirmed. By the end of the 1980s, it was clear that Liberal
and NDP candidates were fighting over Left-centrist votes, a fact that split their possible combined support and
thus contributed to two Conservative governments under Brian Mulroney. The last decade of the century would
see the NDPs fortunes slide. Audrey McLaughlin (b.1936), the first woman (and first Yukoner) to lead a national
party, took the NDP through the economic turmoil of the early 1990s and some of their weakest results nationally
(and worst years provincially) before handing the mantle on to Alexa McDonough (b.1944). McDonough, a Nova
Scotian, kept the party afloat to the end of the century when, in 2000, it narrowly avoided losing official party
status.

The CCF-NDP drew on several progressive threads in Canadian society and culture, some of which became
severely entangled. The agrarian radicalism of the Progressives and United Farmers, the militant unionism and
revolutionism of the Socialist Party of BC, the Fabian democratic socialism of the LSR, and the powerful and
persistent influence of the Social Gospel gave it both a broad foundation to build on and the raw materials for con-
 374 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

tinuous infighting. With the addition of the CLC it became a kind of Labour Party, but it did so in a way that would
guarantee tensions between the CLC elements and those more associated with CCF values. When, in 1969-71,
a faction within the NDP emerged that embraced left-wing nationalism, feminism, social activism and called for
an independent socialist Canada, many of the fracture lines within the Party were laid bare. The Waffle, as the
splinter group was known, failed to take over the leadership of the national party but the question remained as
to whether the NDP was the party of organized labour or the party of social justice and socialism. These debates
continue within the party and are unlikely to end anytime soon.

Social Credit and the Ralliement Crditistes

In 1924, a British engineer and former soldier, Major C.H. Douglas (1879-1952), published a densely argued trea-
tise on a flaw within capitalism. The costs of goods produced across a spectrum of industries, he pointed out, were
invariably greater than the wages paid out to the people producing them. This meant that there was not enough
money in circulation to purchase what was being manufactured. Consumers, he argued, were invariably at a dis-
advantage and the whole of the economy continually headed toward bottlenecks. To solve this conundrum, he
proposed a system of credits that would be applied across society and a radically changed democratic system that,
together, would empower the populace as consumers and political actors.

Douglas was one of a great many economic theorists in the Interwar years offering up ways to overhaul or
replace conventional capitalism and address the shortcomings of liberal democracy. His ideas and analyses were
complex and roundly criticized by economists. His suggestions, however, found purchase in two places in partic-
ular: New Zealand and Canada.

The concept of social credit landed in Alberta in the late 1920s and might have disappeared if not for the conjunc-
tion of several elements. Politics in Alberta had taken on a strong evangelical tone thanks, in part, to the social
gospel themes and rhetoric employed by the ruling United Farmers party. The idea of preachers in politics was
widely accepted and a certain amount of trust and even deference was enjoyed by evangelical clergymen. Not
surprisingly, the high-energy, tub-thumping, fire-and-brimstone preachers were among the most compelling.

The most widely recognized voice of religion in the early 1930s in Alberta was that of Bible Bill Aberhart
(1878-1943). A school principal and Baptist minister, Aberhart established the Calgary Prophetic Bible Institute
and took to the airwaves with a weekly radio evangelical program. He was a pioneer in this respect, what today
we would call an early adopter of communications technologies. Moreover, Aberharts own deep rolling voice
was joined behind the microphone by a team of actors who played out moral parables on live radio. His audience
was huge, and radio at this time played in the home on a wireless set that was often the beautifully designed
centerpiece of the parlour or front room was listened to in a manner that involved a kind of quiet engagement
by everyone in the household. Aberhart would invite his listeners to consider what they heard and to discuss it, as
though they were holding a seminar or a bible-reading group in their own home. Why does this matter? A member
of the Prophetic Bible Institute introduced Aberhart to social credit theory and the latter quickly saw it as a solu-
tion to the crisis of the Depression. He became so convinced of its potential that he promoted his understanding
of Douglas theories from the pulpit and, more importantly, through his radio program. (One particularly effective
episode involved a recurring character, the Man from Mars, who commented on the inexplicably strange things
1
Earthlings do, offering Martian solutions to crime, immorality, and unemployment and the use of social credits.)

1. David R. Elliott and Iris Miller, Bible Bill: A Biography of William Aberhart (Edmonton: Reidmore Books, 1987), 151.
 7.9 REFORM POLITICS: 3RD PARTIES 375

The failure of the United Farmers to take up the social credit idea launched Aberhart into politics. In 1935, the
Social Credit Party helped by scandal in the UFA won a landslide victory. Success at the polls was not
matched by fiscal victories: issuing social credits meant, in essence, producing a currency, something that was
exclusively reserved to the federal government. The coupons or scrip were fiscally, operationally, and consti-
tutionally problematic, so much so that the lieutenant-governor of Alberta refused to pass into law Aberharts
experiment, which became derided as funny money. This didnt stop Social Credit from holding onto power in
2
Alberta for the next 36 years, nor did it stop its spread across Canada.

Outside of Alberta, the ideas behind social credit produced three different partisan typologies. Douglas beliefs
regarding democracy were complex and in some ways idiosyncratic while simultaneously typical of the imag-
inative hothouse that was the 1920s. He advocated government by experts (he was, after all, an engineer) and
believed politicians should act as middlemen between the voters and the planners. Aberhart echoed this perspec-
tive, especially if he was cornered on a difficult aspect of economic theory. In a statement that acquired some
fame, he said:

You dont have to know all about Social Credit before you vote for it. You dont have to understand electricity to make
use of it, for you know that experts have put the system in and all you have to do about Social Credit is to cast your ballot
3
for it, and well get experts to put the system in.

But Aberhart was a partisan and Douglas didnt like parties. This thread of his thought took shape in Quebec in
the 1940s with the Union des lecteurs and briefly in Ontario by the similarly named Union of Electors.

The second typology was the more conventional party format, like that in Alberta and the Social Credit Party of
Canada (SCPC). The national party struggled from 1953 to 1958 when they were wiped out by the Diefenbaker
landslide in the West. But the party had a base of support in Quebec as well and it rebounded in 1962, winning
29 seats, all but four of them in Quebec. This gave Social Credit the balance of power in Parliament, which they
used a year later to oust the Diefenbaker minority. Shortly thereafter, the national party split and the larger part of
the caucus formed the Ralliement des crditistes under the leadership of Ral Caouette (1917-76), the remainder
keeping the SCPC brand. As a third party they typically finished fourth in Parliamentary seats, behind the NDP.
In 1972, Caouettes Ralliement won 15 seats but began an unbroken slide into the 1980s, after which it was frozen
out. Never at risk of forming a national government (nor a provincial one in Ontario or Quebec), the eastern and
national parties continued to support the economic theories of Douglas, and to espouse anti-Semitic and occasion-
ally pro-fascist sentiments. Caouette was, too, a Quebec nationalist but also a rabid enemy of radical separatists
like the Front de libration du Qubec (FLQ).

The third type of Social Credit Party was that of W.A.C. Bennett (1900-79), the charismatic premier of British
Columbia from 1952 to 1972. Bennett, a former Conservative Member of the Legislative Assembly, split with
his old party and was able to take the reins of a slow-moving Social Credit Party that was largely populated by
former Albertans. Once he formed government he never spoke again of funny money and the party, for all
intents and purposes, pursued the (right-of-centre) politics of populism and pragmatism. After he won a majority
in 1953, Bennett disposed of BCs peculiar preferential-ballot system and restored the conventional first-past-the-

2. Two studies addressing the theoretical elements of Douglas' social credit and the practicality of some of his aims in Alberta are Alvin
Finkel, The Social Credit Phenomenon in Alberta (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1989) and Bob Hesketh, Major Douglas and
Alberta Social Credit (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1997).
3. Aberhart to John Hargrave, and Albertans, during a 1935 election campaign. Originally from the Edmonton Journal, (14 August 1935), and cited in Harry
Hiller, Religion, Populism, and Social Credit in Alberta, p. 375, (PhD Thesis, November 1972), accessed 13 May 2016, [Link]
stream/11375/13785/1/[Link].
376 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

post model. Informed by small-town piety, devotion to private (especially small) enterprise, and a Cold War-era
loathing for unions and the Left, the party took a breather during the Barrett/NDP administration of 1972-75 and
then governed for another 16 years before falling apart in the 1991 general election.

Figure 7.23 Albertas Prosperity Certificates circulated

briefly under Social Credit. The bearer had to purchase a
penny stamp for the reverse side at the end of each week,
which meant that there was a frenzy to get rid of them every
seven days.

The conservative Christian values of Social Credits various incarnations has meant that its support has mostly
migrated to parties on the Right. Preston Mannings Reform Party attracted some based in part on the leaders
long connection with Social Credit (Mannings father succeeded Aberhart as Premier from 1943-68) as did the
electorally insignificant Christian Heritage Party. The pragmatism of the leadership exemplified by W.A.C.
Bennett and his son and successor, William Bill Bennett, also enabled its constituency to find a home in the BC
Liberal Party. The Ralliement articulated a conservative nationalism consistent with Duplessis Union Nationale
along with some aspects of both the Parti Qubecois and the Bloc Qubecois (see Section 9.9 and Section 9.10).

Key Points

The Canadian parliamentary system enables the establishment of alternative political parties.
Historically, some reform movements have taken the form of political parties. These have included
agrarian parties like the United Farmers and the Progressive Party, socialist parties like the Coopera-
tive Commonwealth Federation/New Democratic Party and the Communist Party of Canada, and the
various parties associated with social credit.

Attributions
Figure 7.21
Tim Buck at Maple Leaf Gardens by GRuban is in the public domain.

Figure 7.22
Annie Buller addressing a crowd before the Estevan Riot by Esemono is in the public domain.

Figure 7.23
1936 Alberta Prosperity Certificate by Awmcphee is in the public domain.
7.10 The Second Wave of Feminism

ROBERT RUTHERDALE, DEPARTMENT OF PHILOSOPHY & HISTORY, ALGOMA UNIVERSITY

In 1963 feminist author and activist, Betty Friedan, captured extraordinary attention with her book, The Feminine
Mystique. She struck a chord for many readers and a nerve among her critics. She wrote about the problem that
has no name, the unhappiness and dissatisfaction experienced by many women in their roles as homemaker,
mother, and feminine wife. At its source, she argued, was patriarchy. Notions of privileged males resonated with
the daily experience of many women in Canada, especially in the middle-class.

Inspired by The Feminine Mystique, and by Simone de Beauvoirs The Second Sex (1948, translated into English
in 1953), as well as by Germaine Greers The Female Eunuch (1970) a growing number of women across the
western world, including women in Canada, launched a significant activist movement in the late 1960s and early
1970s. The Womens Liberation Movement aimed to empower women in both their private and public lives.
This second wave feminist challenge staged public protests, producing iconic images that were easily consumed
on television screens and often sensationalized. They challenged assumptions about conventional roles for women
and the normalcy of patriarchy, leading in Canadas centennial year to the establishment of the Royal Com-
mission on the Status of Women, which produced its report in 1970 and established the National Action Com-
mittee on the Status of Women. Progressive changes in gender roles, with respect to enhancing womens power,
were attempted by establishing a portfolio on the status of women in the federal cabinet and in creating an Office
of Equal Opportunities in the Public Service Commission. A new Citizenship Act was passed in 1975 and legisla-
tion to amend the Labour Code was adopted in 1978. That same year, the Canadian Human Rights Act came into
effect, ensuring that equal pay for equal work be reflected in the workforce.

These shifts in public policy and public opinion provided space for a discussion of the brutal side of patriarchy.
Womens Liberation in the 1960s which was sometimes exuberant and even fun was followed in the 1970s
by a grim and growing recognition of gendered violence in the form of wife abuse. Friedans critique of a patri-
archal society made possible the revelation of life stories of battered women. She offered a challenge, taken up
by many readers in Canada beginning in the early 1960s, which had been largely absent in the popular discourse.
Even now, out-of-sight struggles from this generation (and others) are gradually being revealed by oral histories
and life writing. With renewed local community support throughout the 1970s, the rising number of womens and
family shelters provided a necessary, if distressing, measure of the problem of spousal abuse.

377
 378 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

At this point, two generations of Canadian women mothers who remembered the 1930s and beyond, and their
daughters could step past the so-called generation gap between parents and the young, to confront long histo-
ries of becoming a woman, altogether. In the 1970s Womens Studies courses and, later, programs were appearing
for the first time on Canadian university campuses; daughters enrolled in these newly instituted disciplines started
bringing home copies of the much reprinted Our Bodies, Ourselves (a key, and evolving, textbook, launched by a
Boston-based feminist movement established in 1969) for mom to have look at. Old assumptions about property
rights, income-earning potential for women (who often earned less than two-thirds pay for work of equal value
at this time), taxation laws, and child-care responsibilities spoke to the larger picture of patriarchys persistence
during and beyond the so-called good life of the 1950s. That the Dominion Bureau of Statistics (replaced by
Statistics Stats Canada in 1972) routinely recorded fathers and husbands in the conjugal family as household
heads, even in the early 1970s, is understandable: adult males earned much more as paid workers and their gen-
dered role conformed to Western cultural practice and expectations.

Despite these feminist challenges, most barriers to gender equality held fast beyond the 1960s. The second wave
had momentum, but it crashed again and again against opposition from both men and women, opposition that was
as much conditioned by past assumptions, as it was just plain reactionary. The trouble with normal, as Mary
Louise Adams put it, was that the great postwar experiment in restoring a heterosexual, gendered family regime
1
rooted in a mythical past had failed to live up to its billing. Dismantling its structures through new laws
and public policy in employment equity, day care provision, and family law reform continue to present day.

Probing these broad patterns can take us to unexpected places, as historians move from an era when mixed mar-
riages described a union across Christian denominations to one in which same-sex nuptials are protected by
Canadas Charter of Freedoms and Rights. In hindsight, from the end of the Second World War to the early 1980s,
gender roles did not obliterate old boundaries, but they shifted considerably in pushing them toward more equality.
Nonetheless, the ongoing task of translating legal gender equality into everyday realities in the continual making
of gender roles leaves work yet to be done throughout Canadian society, and by historians at work mapping
their historical contexts in the years ahead. Present-day trends have deep historical roots. Gender roles remain
defined more by patriarchy than equal partnership. It is also evident that they have been significantly challenged
in histories of the struggle for womens rights.

Key Points

The movement to improve the condition of women changed in the 1960s and 1970s, becoming vari-
ously known as the Womens Liberation Movement and second wave feminism.
A result of this activism and a stimulus to further action was the Royal Commission on the Status of
Women in 1970.
Legislation aimed at achieving gender equality was introduced incrementally, although barriers
proved resistant and continue to be so.

1. Mary Louise Adams, The Trouble with Normal: Postwar Youth and the Making of Heterosexuality (Toronto: University of Toronto, 1997).
7.11 Greenpeace

The 1960s ended with the apparent disappearance of an array of social movements. Some were exhausted, others
lost personnel, a few accomplished their limited goals and ceased to have a purpose. Mostly, however, they were
redeployed into other projects. Greenpeace is an example of a movement organization that combined a critique
of capitalism and Cold War politics with a strong environmentalist sensibility.

Established in Vancouver in 1971, Greenpeace opened its first office in Kitsilano, a neighbourhood deeply asso-
ciated with the hippy movement of the previous decade. Starting out as the Dont Make a Wave Committee,
the organization took the name of its first ship, the Greenpeace, for the organization as a whole. The catalyst was
American nuclear weapon testing on a remote Aleutian island in Alaska. The Americans, British, and French had
been testing atomic explosives in isolated island locations since the 1940s. With an arms race against the Soviet
Union well underway, the Americans were eager to both maintain their apparent technological lead, and to do
so as close to the Soviet hinterland of Siberia as possible. Environmentalists and anti-Cold War activists saw the
proposal to detonate a warhead beneath Amchitka Island (the third test on the island in ten years) as offensive and
dangerous. There were fears, too, that the test would cause a tsunami, and that radiation would inevitably seep
into the sea.

The organization cannily incorporated journalists and media figures into its numbers. Its leaders were principally
middle-class professionals who presented Greenpeace as inclusive and open; the opposite of the corporate forces
it was fighting. Within a couple of years, the focus of Greenpeaces activity had shifted to the international whale
hunt and, in the late 1970s, the Newfoundland-Labrador seal hunt. This latter campaign pitted the still-mostly
British Columbian organization against Newfoundland workers, and was (at least temporarily) highly divisive.

Thanks in part to the anti-sealing campaign launched in Europe, Greenpeace quickly became a global brand. Its
flag and emblems could be found across the western world and in ports across Oceania. However, it retained a
powerful presence in Canada. This would be seen again in British Columbia, from 1992-1996, in the War in the
Woods a mass protest and occupation of old growth forests that culminated in the arrest of 300 protesters in
one day.

379
 380 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 7.24 The fur trade between Canada

and Europe was fundamental to the growth
of colonial commerce and population but
by the 1980s it had become an economic
and moral battleground internationally.

Critics of Greenpeace have pointed to their record as enemies of working class people. Seal hunters and loggers
not to mention whalers as well as farmers working with genetically modified foods have been impacted when
the corporations for which they work have been targeted. Greenpeace also has a spotty record when it comes to
consulting with First Nations, an accusation that was levelled against it by the seal hunting Inuit of Labrador and
1
the Nuu-chah-nulth First Nation in whose ancestral territory the War in the Woods took place. Internal divisions
have wracked the organization since the 1970s, and it principally survives now as Greenpeace International.

From the perspective of Canada, Greenpeace did many incontrovertibly important things in the first 30 years of
its existence. It raised awareness of environmental issues as they pertained to the Cold War, global capitalism and
consumerism, and the difficulties inherent in policing a mobile operation like the whale hunt. As a movement, it
had greater international reach than any other has that originated in Canada. In mobilizing hundreds, if not thou-
sands, of people to put themselves in the way of corporate foes and at the risk of being arrested and jailed
Greenpeace created a generational cadre of environmental activists and shifted the political agenda (at least in
some quarters). Finally, Greenpeace carried forward many of the traditions of the social reform movements we
have been studying: largely middle-class, morally forthright, redemptive, and as inclined toward prohibition of
offending behaviours as it was to tempering practices. Greenpeace may be contentious in some quarters but it is
in many respects an illustration of Canadian historical traditions.

Key Points

Greenpeace originated in the anti-nuclear movement of the 1960s and 1970s, turning its attention to
animal rights issues in the late 1970s.
Increasingly associated with protests against whaling and sealing, Greenpeace became an interna-
tional movement in the 1980s, at which time it refocused again on the logging of old growth forests.
Founded in Vancouver, Greenpeace was an important late-20th century organization in Canada that
drew on the traditions of older reform movements.

1. John-Henry Harter, Environmental Justice for Whom? Class, New Social Movements and the Environment: A Case Study of Greenpeace
Canada, 1971-2000, Labour/Le Travail, 54 (Fall 2004): 83-119.
 7.11 GREENPEACE 381

Attributions
Figure 7.24
Stop the Seal Hunt by Alejandro Hernandez. is used under a CC-BY-2.0 license.
7.12 Summary

Figure 7.25 Temperance and prohibition

were causes around which 19th and 20th
century reformers could unite, and it
attracted a crusading Christian ethos.
(Published by Dominion Scientific
Temperance Committee, ca. 1912.)

Urban living and industrial working conditions, the prevalence of alcohol abuse, the vulnerability of families
(more visible now in urban conditions), and a nativist response to immigration, all contributed to the growth of
reform movements in the post-Confederation period. These were like crusades, their knights tilting at issues that
were, one after the other, guaranteed to cause the moral, economic, and even genetic destruction of whatever con-
stituted Canadian society.

Some reform movements sought to accomplish, on a society-wide scale, what the emergent labour movement
hoped to achieve at the factory level. Better conditions, more time for leisure and reflection, and supports for
the most vulnerable member of society were common goals. The things that animated reform movements var-
ied tremendously. Political reform movements in the West, for example, were united in their criticism of Central
Canadian imperialism.

After the Second World War, reform movements ceased to be a mass phenomenon. That is not to say they went
away. Many of the strategies and goals of pre-WWII reform movements were carried forward by the social demo-
cratic parties and some, too, were transmitted to the populist right-wing parties. In Quebec the Catholic Church
continued to play a role and there was, as well, the powerful secularization of the reform agenda in the Quiet
Revolution. In some respects the environmentalism of the late 20th century descended from conservationism
continues the reform movement tradition, as do prohibitionist movements like the war on drugs. These are,
however, movements that are either limited in their membership or so generalized as not to constitute a coherent
agenda of social change with clear objectives and outcomes. And, for the most part, they lack the cure-all quality
to many of the earlier reform programs. The rise of mass education, the professionalization of teaching, and the

382
 7.12 SUMMARY 383

development of a social work sector all became extensions of the reform movement tradition, but in ways that
closed off access and engagement to everyone but the experts.

Figure 7.26 Now known predominately as a source of

inexpensive recycled clothes, used books, and well-used
furniture, the Salvation Army today presents itself very
differently from its Victorian incarnation. While it is still engaged
in work among vulnerable populations, Sally Anns efforts to
save society as a whole have effectively ended.

Key Terms

anti-party: The position that political parties constitute an unwelcome constraint on democratic politics.
balance of power: In parliamentary politics, describes a minority government that is dependent on
another party to provide enough votes to prohibit defeat through a vote of non-confidence.
Comintern: Also the Communist International, the Third International; 1919-1943; called for world
revolution and the establishment of communist regimes.
cooperative movement: Also spelled co-operative. Established in growing numbers in Britain in the
mid-19th century and is associated with the Rochdale Pioneers; several typologies; goals include mak-
ing available goods and/or supplies to members at low costs by taking advantage of economies of scale
as a group, also obtaining optimal prices for community products by pooling output for sale. Surpluses
and profits are redistributed to members of the cooperative; some have an educational mandate as well.
Examples include grocery stores, housing co-ops, and the dairy industry. See also wheat pools.
Court of Chancery: In England, the Court dealt primarily with trusts; dissolved in 1875.
established churches: Organized religion recognized by the state. In Canada there are no officially rec-
ognized sects but the Anglican Church is the established church of England and the Queen is its head.
Similarly, the Catholic Church was historically the official church of French Canada and it retains in the
post-Confederation period a de facto official status.
eugenics: An early theory respecting genetic transmission of physical, social, intellectual, and moral
qualities which sought to advantage races that it considered superior stock against those that it
regarded as inferior.
evangelicalism: In Christianity, a belief that salvation is achieved through faith in Jesus; individualistic
in that redemption occurs at a personal, not a social level; evangelical denominations are often associated
with fundamentalism as well.
Fabian: A belief that reforms to capitalism can produce a social and economic order of fairness for
working people; sometimes called gradualism.
fertility transition: Demographic trend in which populations move from a level of high fertility to a
much lower level; associated with urbanization and modernization.
first-past-the-post: Electoral system in which the candidate receiving the greatest number (though not
384 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

necessarily a majority) of ballots wins; considered problematic by some when a party wins a majority of
seats while winning much less than a majority of votes.
generation gap: Notable differences in values, tastes, interests, and practices between individuals and
whole cohorts from different generations. In the 1960s, used extensively to describe the conflict in val-
ues between people born before WWII and the baby boom generation.
genocide: The premeditated extermination of an identifiable group of humans, often defined by race or
ethnicity. See also cultural genocide.
germ theory: The identification of microorganisms as the cause of some illnesses, particularly infec-
tious diseases.
Ginger Group: An alliance of progressive MPs in Ottawa that led to the founding of the Cooperative
Commonwealth Federation (CCF).
gradualist: The idea that great change can occur incrementally, in slow, small, and subtle steps, rather
than by large uprisings or revolutions. Among left-wing activists, a belief that reforms to capitalism can
produce a social and economic order of fairness for working people; sometimes called Fabianism;
derided by revolutionaries as delusional. In the context of Quebecs independence movements the equiv-
alent term is tapisme. See also reformist and impossibilist.
Greenpeace: An environmental movement founded in Vancouver in the early 1970s as part of an inter-
national anti-nuclear arms movement; became more directly associated with environmental issues like
sealing and whaling.
impossibilists: Among left-wing activists, a belief that it is impossible to reform capitalism and that it
must be overthrown rather than overhauled. See also gradualist and reformist.
internationalist: In the history of organized labour, the belief that workers of all countries had more
in common than they did with co-nationals who belong to other social classes. Views nationalist move-
ments as antithetical to the interests of working people.
League for Social Reconstruction (LSR): A socialist think-tank established by Frank Underhill and
F.R. Scott in 1932.
Left: Coined during the French Revolution to describe opponents of the monarchy; since then, used
to describe a spectrum of reform and radical positions and political organizations that includes some
Liberals, the Cooperative Commonwealth Federation, the New Democratic Party, the Socialist Party of
Canada, and at the far end of the Left the Communist Party and, in some instances, anarchists. See
also Right.
Mackenzie-Papineau Battalion: A 1,500-strong contingent of Canadian volunteers in the war against
the Fascists in Spain during the Civil War, 1937-38; took their name from the two leaders of the Rebel-
lions of 1837-38, Louis-Joseph Papineau and William Lyon Mackenzie (the grandfather of Prime Min-
ister William Lyon Mackenzie King).
Marxist-Leninist: Building on the scientific socialism of Karl Marx, which argued that socialist,
worker-led governments would supersede bourgeois capitalism, the Leninist thread arising in revo-
lutionary and post-revolutionary Russia introduced the idea of a vanguard of the proletariat, single-
party rule, internationalism, and a state-run economy. In Canadian communism, one of several variants
on Marxist doctrine.
maternal feminists: Adherents to the ideals of maternal feminism.
Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact (1939): A mutual non-aggression treaty signed between Germany and the
 7.12 SUMMARY 385

USSR; allowed Germany to move forward with its attacks on France and the Low Countries while the
Soviet Union annexed territories in the Baltic region.
National Action Committee on the Status of Women: Established in 1971 to agitate for implemen-
tation of the recommendations of the Bird Commission. See also Royal Commission on the Status of
Women.
New Democratic Party (NDP): Successor to the Cooperative Commonwealth Federation; created out
of the union of the Canadian Labour Congress (CLC) and the CCF in 1961.
non-conformist churches: A descriptive term attached to dissenting Protestant sects that broke with the
Anglican Church as early as 1660; associated specifically with Methodism, Congregationalism, and the
Baptist Church.
Official Opposition: In parliamentary systems, the party with the second largest number of seats in the
House of Commons. On occasion, the second largest caucus has refused the title of Official Opposition.
official party status: The recognition of a political partys representatives in an assembly as sufficient
to merit certain parliamentary privileges, including the right to ask questions during question period. In
Ottawa, the federal House of Commons requires that a party have no fewer than 12 MPs in order to
qualify for official status.
patriarchy: A socio-economic system in which males have legal, political, social, and economic pri-
macy and privilege, sometimes to the complete exclusion of women. Under a patriarchy, control over
children is also a male (fatherly) prerogative.
Poor Laws: A series of laws enacted in Britain, including several amendments in the 19th century;
aimed at providing support for the unemployed and impoverished; characterized by the use of poor
houses and workhouses in which conditions were sufficiently appalling to keep all but the least able-
bodied and most desperate off of the public dole.
progressive: In politics and social policy, the belief in the improvability of human society. In partisan
politics, associated with the Progressive Party (below) and the Progressive Conservative Party. In music,
indicates a sub-genre of rock and roll which tends to be more symphonic and influenced by electronic
jazz.
proportional representation Distinct from the first-past-the-post system; can take several forms but
common aspect is that political parties will be elect a number of seats that reflects in some measure the
percentage of votes they receive. For example, a party might win 49% of the votes in every constituency
but not elect a single candidate if the only other party running wins 51% of the votes; proportional repre-
sentation (sometimes called PR) would ensure that the second-place party received something closer
to 49% of the seats.
race suicide: An idea common to the eugenics movement; the idea that inferior races will inevitably
squeeze out superior races by dint of having higher reproductive rates; especially popular at times
when fertility in the anxious community is falling.
referenda: A public opinion poll for registered voters, the results of which may or may not be binding.
Members of Parliament debate actual bills that they can see and hold, and on which they may offer sug-
gestions and amendments; referenda typically ask for general agreement on a broad principal without
providing any of the details.
reformist: Among left-wing activists, a belief that incremental changes to capitalism can produce a
social and economic order of fairness for working people; derided by revolutionaries as delusional. See
also gradualist and impossibilist.
386 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Regina Manifesto: 1933; the original statement of purpose and beliefs of the Cooperative Common-
wealth Federation.
Right: Individuals, groups, and parties espousing a conservative perspective; a broad continuum that
includes Red Tories, Blue Tories, neo-liberals/conservatives, the late 20th century Reform Party, and
far to the Right fascists.
Royal Commission on the Status of Women: Created in 1967 and reported out in 1970; chaired by
Florence Bird; produced 167 recommendations that focussed on issues of equality of opportunity and
identifying the many institutional, legal, and systemic barriers to the same. While most of the recom-
mendations have been adopted, provision of day care remains an outstanding exception. The RCSW did
not address issues associated with sexual identity or sexual orientation and its failure to discuss violence
against women was a major oversight. The Office for the Status of Women was established as a conse-
quence of the Commissions report.
Salvation Army: Founded in England in 1865; a Christian denomination identified with charitable
works in urban industrial areas; adopted a military model with uniforms, marching bands, and ranks.
Introduced to Canada in 1882, where it is also known as the Sally Ann, sometimes as the Starvation
Army. Keenly interested in social justice issues, the Salvation Army was instrumental in the social
gospel movement.
scientific racism: The use of scientific technique or pseudo-scientific technique to provide a rational
and empirically verifiable basis of racial discrimination. Utterly demolished as a theory in the postwar
period, it nevertheless contributed not only to the spread of racism in Euro-Canadian communities but
to its legitimation and respectability.
second wave feminist: A renewal of movement feminism in the postwar era; focussed on rights in the
workplace, equality of opportunity and pay, reproductive rights, and violence against women. See also
Womens Liberation
social control: The regulation of social behaviour through direct (laws, policing) and indirect (social
pressure, moral suasion) means.
social credit: Primarily an economic theory and monetary policy, developed in the 1920s and touted as
a solution to the Depression in Canada by Social Credit political parties.
social democratic: A political movement that advocates reform that will achieve greater social equality,
a degree of socialist governance, and the preservation of democratic institutions. Associated with the
Cooperative Commonwealth Federation and New Democratic Party.
social reformers: Advocates of change at the social rather than individual level; associated with
19th century social movements like the suffragettes, maternal feminism, and temperance agitation.
suffrage: The right to vote in elections; associated strongly with womens suffrage.
third parties: Political parties other than the Liberals and Conservatives; distinguished from fourth or
fringe parties by their more respectable showing at the polls. Principally, the CCF-NDP, Social Credit,
and Reform Party of Canada. The Bloc Qubcois occupies a special place in this respect because it has
enjoyed a large following and has formed the official opposition in Ottawa, but is not a national party.
Waffle: A faction within the NDP in 1969-1971 that embraced left-wing nationalism, feminism, and
social activism, and called for an independent socialist Canada.
War in the Woods: 1992-1996; a series of mass protests against logging in old growth forests in British
Columbia.
Winnipeg Declaration: Fully, the 1956 Winnipeg Declaration of Principles of the Co-operative Com-
 7.12 SUMMARY 387

monwealth Federation; replaced the Regina Manifesto; significant in that it moved the party away from
socialism and closer to democratic socialism and a pro-union position; made possible the alignment of
the CCF with the CLC very soon after.
Womens Liberation Movement: Both an informal and loose organization of various womens advo-
cacy and political groups, and an alternative term for second wave feminism; first appeared in 1968.
Young Womens Christian Association (YWCA): Originated in Britain in 1855 as a faith-based orga-
nization in support of the first generations of women in urban industrial settings; first Canadian chapter
established in Saint John in 1870.

Short Answer Exercises

1. What were the main features of social reform movements in the late 19th and early 20th cen-
turies?
2. In what ways were they distinctive historic phenomena?
3. How was social reform connected to feminism and womens issues?
4. What was the Social Gospel and how did it understand the need for social change?
5. What role did alcohol production, consumption, and sales play in the social reform agenda?
6. In what ways did political parties take the social gospel and other social reform urges into the bal-
lot box?
7. What influence did eugenics have on social reform movements?

Suggested Readings
Baskerville, Peter. She Has Already Hinted at Board: Enterprising Urban Women in British Columbia,
1863-1896, Histoire sociale/Social History, 26, no. 52 (November 1993): 205-27.

Belisle, Donica. Crazy for Bargains: Inventing the Irrational Female Shopper in Modernizing English Canada,
Canadian Historical Review, 92, Number 4 (December 2011): 581-606.

Boschma, Geertje. Deinstitutionalization Reconsidered: Geographic and Demographic Changes in Mental

Health Care in British Columbia and Alberta, 1950-1980, Histoire sociale/Social History, 44, Number 88
(Novembre-November 2011): 223-56.

Clment, Dominique. Generations and the Transformation of Social Movements in Postwar Canada, Histoire
sociale/Social history, 42, Number 84 (Novembre-November 2009): 361-87.

Girard, Philip. If two ride a horse, one must ride in front: Married Womens Nationality and the Law in Canada
18801950, Canadian Historical Review, 94, Number 1 (March 2013): 28-54.
388 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Kelm, Mary-Ellen. Manly Contests: Rodeo Masculinities at the Calgary Stampede, Canadian Historical
Review, 90, Number 4 (December 2009): 711-51.

McDonald, Robert A.J. Telford Time and the Populist Origins of the CCF in British Columbia, Labour/Le
Travail, 71 (Spring 2013): 87-100.

Naylor, James. The British Columbia CCFs Working-Class Moment: Socialism Not Populism, Labour/Le Tra-
vail, 71 (Spring 2013): 101-21.

Attributions
Figure 7.25
Temperance poster promoting the prohibition of alcohol (PR1974.0001.0400a.0012) by Provincial Archives of
Alberta has no known restrictions.

Figure 7.26
A flyer from a Toronto Take Off Your Clothes clothing swap by Neelan Rach is used under a CC BY SA 2.0
license.
 PART 9

Chapter 8. The Economy since 1920

389
8.1 Introduction

The political transformations that ushered in the Confederation era were both a product and a reflection of the
economic changes that were underway. Chapter 3 considered the industrialization of the economy and how that
led to the emergence of new social classes and political agendas. However, there were also important continuities
in the Canadian economy.

This chapter explores the outlines of the Dominion economy from the 19th through the 20th century. It examines
the most commonly used theoretical model of the Canadian economy (the staples model) because of its implica-
tions for the economy in the past and the present. Some of the principal features of capitalism are reviewed as
well, including capital markets and business cycles. The enormous impact crater that was the 1930s Depression is
also considered, as is the emergence of what historians describe as the new economy in the 20th century. Three
persistent sectors shipping, fishing, and oil and gas offer insights into the rhythms of the national economy.
The post-war economic order is reviewed, as is the regional economy of the Maritimes. The chapter concludes
with an essay on economic nationalism, an idea that informed Macdonald and that continues to influence eco-
nomic policy-making.

Learning Objectives

Explain the concept of and the survival of the staples model.

Identify the roles played by capital markets, foreign investment, and branch plants.
Describe the economic cycles since 1867.
Account for the rise of the new economy.
Assess the extent to which old staples sectors have been industrialized.
Outline the differences between the economy before 1939, after WWII, and after the post-war boom.

390
8.2 The Staples Model

Historians point to common and long-running themes in the history of the Canadian economy, the most venerable
of which is the staples model. This interpretation sees Canada as a producer mainly of unprocessed goods that are
shipped out to international markets. The staples theory is not merely descriptive, it is explanatory, and part of
what it explains is the precariousness of the Canadian economy from one decade to the next and its struggles to
evolve into something more complex. The staples theory can also be used to gain an understanding of Canadian
society.

Fisheries to Fur Trade to Wheat Economy

From the 1600s to the 1800s, an important part of the economy of New France and then British North America
(BNA) was the fur trade. In the case of New France and the European enterprise in Ruperts Land, the fur trade
was pivotal. It operated on principles associated with mercantilism. That is, merchants in French or British ports
extended the capital needed to purchase a fleet and to buy trade goods that were transported to the St. Lawrence
Valley or to Hudsons Bay. These goods then were warehoused and/or transported further along inland waterways
and traded to Aboriginal merchants for a variety of pelts. Those furs were shipped directly to Europe because
there was no market to speak of in New France or British North America. Similarly, the very first economic link
between what is now Canada and Europe the fisheries was structured simply: send the ships, harvest the
fish, and sail the ships back to Europe or to Europes slave colonies in the Caribbean. Again, the fisheries them-
selves had little in the way of a market in the colonies.

After 1783, and with the development of settlements in New Brunswick and Upper Canada (Ontario) as well as
PEI and Nova Scotia, farming became more important. In the 1820s and 1830s, we see the emergence of a wheat
economy in and around the Great Lakes. This, too, was geared for export (mostly to Britain), as was the forest
industry that was found in almost every British North American colony between Lake Superior and St. Johns.
A growing population in BNA, of course, consumed a growing share of output, but these economies could not
sustain larger numbers, particularly since almost all of the staple industries were seasonal. Industrialization and
urbanization created greater demands for food production and, increasingly, lumber, steel, and brick were diverted
to domestic use. This was the era, of course, when Britain was the workshop of the world, so British North Amer-
icans never had to worry about the availability of manufactured goods. Instead, they had to be concerned that their
own infant industries would be strangled in the cradle by cheap imports from both Britain and the United States.
Unlike Canada, the United States could use tariff barriers to keep out British wares, and with its rapidly growing
urban and slave population in the 19th century, the United States could absorb far more manufactured goods.

391
392 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Confederation came along at a pivotal time for the Canadian economy as it industrialized and shifted from the
countryside to the cities and towns. More Canadians were earning wages, and those wages could be spent on man-
ufactured products, including clothing, hardware, furniture, books, and such middle-class accoutrements as pianos
and early phonographs. Nevertheless, unlike Britain or the United States, Canada was not exporting much steel,
farm tools, or cloth to a fully industrialized economy. The balance of trade continued to be achieved by exporting
grain, timber, and fish.

The settlement of the West extended the staples economy and vastly increased it. The Wheat Boom of the late
19th century was driven by accelerated urbanization in Europe that led to a monoculture economy in the West. In
this economy, the growing of wheat (and a few other grains) was worth pursuing to the exclusion of other options,
which prevented a regional industrial revolution. Wheat was joined by some minerals in the menu of Canadian
export commodities, but overwhelmingly this one staple remained dominant.

What did that mean for the Canadian economy and society? Wheat has a spatial component: large acreages, as
we have seen, produce a particular pattern of residence and social interaction. It also has an annual life cycle that
places heavy demands on the timing of ploughing, planting, harvest, transfer, movement, sale, and export. Grain
elevators were built to contain huge quantities of grain, and railways were conscripted to the cause of decant-
ing these prairie towers into boxcars that would take the years harvest to ports on the Pacific, Great Lakes, St.
Lawrence, or Atlantic. Sometimes economists call grain elevators, transportation, and port facilities forward link-
ages. One of the challenges with this forward linkage arrangement is that grain elevators can only be used for
grain and the same is true for the sort of ships that carry grain. Neither can be viewed as an underutilized capacity
that might be redeployed for, say, machinery production.

Also, throughout Canadian history, all of these forward linkages have been in the service of goods that are, for
the most part, high bulk and low value. Furs are a little different, but only by degree. Logs and lumber, fish and
whale oil, wheat and coal all are goods that are relatively cheap to buy but heavy and hard to move. (To suggest
one radical contrast, a briefcase might contain enough diamonds to match the value of a whole freighter full of
wheat.) The effect of the staples focus, then, is to specialize in economic flows and, through years of practice, in
investments and projects that reinforce the production and shipment of those commodities.

The legacy of structural features associated with staples is seen in a variety of areas in the 20th century. Some
of the following sections in this chapter explore the persistence of Canadas staples economy from wheat and
fish through oil and gas. Political leaders across the 20th century called for greater diversification of regional
economies, some of which are more geared than others to staples production. In some quarters the Atlantic
provinces in particular the limited impact of industrialization has led to less of a roller-coaster ride in the mar-
ketplace, but a lower level of prosperity overall.

Key Points

The Canadian economy has long been associated with the production and export of staples
largely unprocessed goods of relatively high bulk and low value.
The intensified emphasis on the wheat economy in the late 19th century derived from a growing
 8.2 THE STAPLES MODEL 393

market size and demand.

The demand for wheat and other staple commodities undermined attempts at diversification.
The staples economy in Canada produced forward linkages that are difficult and expensive to rede-
ploy to other purposes.
8.3 Capital Markets

ROBERT SWEENY, DEPT. OF HISTORY, MEMORIAL UNIVERSITY OF NEWFOUNDLAND

Figure 8.1 Driving home the last spike of the CPR, 7 November
1885.

This 1885 photograph (Figure 8.1) of a bearded gentleman in a top hat driving home the last spike of the Canadian
Pacific Railway completing the National Dream ranks among the best-known photographs in Canada.
Unlike the men crowded around, the man wielding the sledge hammer Donald Alexander Smith, vice-presi-
dent of the Bank of Montreal had no part in actually building the railway, but helped to finance it, which is
why this photograph is historically significant. It celebrates the first time a major piece of national infrastructure
was financed in Canada. More than driving home a spike, Smith is laying the cornerstone for the countrys capital
market.

Capital markets are relatively recent creations most capital markets have been created during and after the late
19th century. They may be recent, but they are important because controlling the countrys savings is an essential
characteristic for any advanced capitalist economy. We call it capitalism for a reason.

Capital markets generally have four functions and, in North America and Western Europe, each function histor-
ically has been carried out by different types of companies: brokerage houses, banks, life insurance firms, and
trust companies. The mere presence of such companies does not, however, mean that a capital market exists. A
functioning capital market requires a stock market where brokerage houses buy and sell stocks and bonds, lending
facilities for both the medium and the longer-term functions generally offered by banks and life insurance compa-
nies respectively, and a disinterested institution that can be trusted to distribute dividends and interest payments.
In Canada and elsewhere, such trust companies also manage the estates of wealthy families.

These differing types of financial intermediaries only develop when a capitalist economy reaches a certain level
of maturity. Take, for example, life insurance, which if you stop to think about it, is rather an odd idea. It is not
life insurance, but death insurance; since we are all going to die, how can a firm profitably sell insurance against

394
 8.3 CAPITAL MARKETS 395

something that inevitably will happen? Well, the short answer is reliable statistics on life expectancy, called actu-
arial tables, which allow the firm to reasonably assess the risk of issuing a policy to a particular person. The
statistical basis for such realistic evaluations of risk did not exist until governments started capturing demographic
data through censuses, which was not achieved in Canada until the mid-19th century.

Who would want to or need to pay the high costs of an insurance policy? If a family owned its farm or business,
the death of the male head of household would likely be an emotional, but not necessarily a financial, loss, as the
productive assets would remain with the family. If, however, a familys income and social position was dependent
on the salary earned by the male head of household as a professional or a manager, his death could spell finan-
cial ruin. Significant numbers of salaried men only emerged in Canada in the last quarter of the 19th century, in
the wake of the industrial revolution. This salaried and gendered middle class would remain the main focus of
life insurance companies in Canada until the standard of living for working class families began to improve with
unionization after World War II.

Insurance companies sell policies to young people and hope to benefit from decades of premium income before
they have to pay the death benefits. This means life insurance companies have an income stream that they can
invest for the long term. Banks, on the other hand, once they start to develop their deposit-taking business, have
more pressing concerns. After all, their clients are saving for something they hope to purchase long before they
die, so banks tend to specialize in short- and medium-term loans.

For most of the 19th century, banks in Canada were not particularly interested in deposits, and not at all
interested in consumer loans. Instead they financed merchants inventories and facilitated the international pay-
ments required by imports and exports. The wages paid to most workers during the industrial revolution were not
sufficient to allow for much in the way of savings. The shift happened gradually, and by the outbreak of the Great
War, savings deposits accounted for half of all bank liabilities. This, of course, required a completely different
type of banking system. At the time of Confederation, there was one bank branch for every 28,900 Canadians;
1
by 1920, there was a bank branch for every 1,900 people. The savings of both working-class and middle-class
families were being mobilized to finance Canadian industry.

Most firms in the 19th century financed their operations through retained earnings (that is, the profits they hold on
to). Utilities, railways, and financial intermediaries accounted for the overwhelming majority of shares available
for purchase on the embryonic stock markets of Montreal and Toronto. In 1880 (the year construction started on
what would be the CPR), $11.5 million dollars in new shares were issued in Canada; by 1900, that figure had risen
2
ninefold to $101 million; by 1910, it had ballooned to $712 million. Brokerage firms engineered these new stock
issues. These brokerage firms bought out regional industrial producers and merged them into pan-Canadian cor-
porate entities that were large enough to set prices in their respective industries. Exceptionally large fortunes were
made in these stock floatations, and the most successful brokers, such as Max Aitken (aka: Lord Beaverbrook) of
Royal Securities, were among the wealthiest financiers in the British Empire.

The changes wrought by corporate concentration profoundly affected the banking system and shaped the devel-
oping national capital market. In 1900, only a handful of businessmen and they were all men sat simulta-
neously on the boards of four or more leading companies. By 1930, a fifth of all directorships in the countrys

1. E.P. Neufeld, The Financial System of Canada: Its Growth and Development (Toronto: MacMillan of Canada, 1972), 102.
2. Ibid., 475.
 396 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION
3
leading firms were occupied by men and they were still all men who sat on five or more boards. The net-
works that tied these men and their firms to one of three financial groups, each centred on a chartered bank, are
clearly visible on the graph in Figure 8.2.

Figure 8.2 Directorships in common among the leading firms in

Canada, 1930. Research by Gilles Pidalue, graphic by Robert
C.H. Sweeny.

Michael Bliss, the leading conservative historian of Canadian capitalism, has characterized the emergence of a
group of companies linked to the Bank of Commerce as being All in the family, and there is an element of truth
4
to this. But unlike the situation in the United States, where families such as the Rockefellers, Morgans, and Mel-
lons effectively owned their own banks, none of the leading Canadian chartered banks were controlled by a single
family. Rather, families who controlled important industrials sat on the boards of the financial intermediaries that
financed their firms expansion. This familial control continued to characterize the English-Canadian capital mar-
ket until at least the 1970s, when no fewer than 88 men and 2 women sitting on the boards of leading financial
5
intermediaries had inherited their position from another family member.

The close connection between industry and finance did not characterize all the chartered banks. Smaller region-
ally-controlled pools of banking capital represented by the Imperial, Toronto, Dominion, and Nova Scotia banks
continued to be active in both national and international money and commodity markets. In Quebec, a slightly
different situation arose. In the heartland of the St. Lawrence River valley an integrated market linking small
insurance, trust, and banking operations emerged, but in the out-lying regions financial services consisted pri-
marily of mutuals, co-operatives, and credit-unions. It was only with the Quiet Revolution of the 1960s, and the
greatly enhanced economic role of the provincial government that one could reasonably speak of a single and dis-
tinct national capital market serving French Canada. This achievement did, however, build on the success of firms
largely created in the early 20th century, a period when in terms of political and educational rights French
6
Canada was in retreat.

Building a trans-continental railroad has long been understood as central to Sir John A. Macdonalds National
Policy. The resettlement of the Prairies and the resulting wheat boom were key to historians understanding of
economic growth in Canada until the collapse of the wheat economy in 1928. The lesser known creation of a
two-tiered capital market in English Canada and the simultaneous laying of the foundations of a separate capital
market in French Canada was, however, arguably the most enduring economic legacy of Macdonalds policy. The

3. Gilles Pidalue, Les groupes financiers au Canada 1900-1930 - tude prliminaire, Revue dhistoire de lAmrique franaise, 30, no. 1
(1976): 3-34.
4. Michael Bliss, A Canadian Millionaire: The Life and Business Times of Sir Joseph Flavelle, Bart., 1858-1939 (Toronto: MacMillan of
Canada, 1978).
5. Robert C.H. Sweeny, Banking as Class Action: Social and National Struggles in the History of Canadian Banking, Banking, Trade and
Industry: Europe, America and Asia from the Thirteenth to the Twentieth Centuries, eds. Alice Teichova, Ginette Kurgan van Henteryk, and
Dieter Ziegler (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997), 315-338.
6. Robert C. H. Sweeny, "Aperu dun effort collectif qubcois: La cration, au dbut du XXe sicle, dun march priv et institutionnalis de
capitaux," Revue dhistoire de lAmrique franaise, 49, no. 1 (1995), 35-72.
 8.3 CAPITAL MARKETS 397

remarkable longevity and solidity of the Canadian financial system formed in those years continues to shape the
contours of our economic life.

Key Points

Financial institutions appeared in Canada in greater numbers and variety in the late 19th century.
Their existence was a measure of the growing complexity of the local capitalist economy and the
rise of managerial middle class.
Banks, life insurance companies, trust companies, and brokerage houses took invested money and
made it available for loans. One result was a consolidation of smaller Canadian firms into larger
ones.
This also led to interlocking directorships centred on a chartered bank.
The financial systems that arose in the late 19th century continue to be influential in the 21st century.

Attributions
Figure 8.1
Hon. Donald A. Smith driving the last spike to complete the Canadian Pacific Railway. (Online MIKAN no.
3194527) by Alexander Ross / Library and Archives Canada / C-003693 is in the public domain.

Figure 8.2
Sweeny Directorships by Robert C.H. Sweeny is used under a CC-BY license.
8.4 Economic Cycles

Economic downturns are thought by many to be part of a cyclical readjustment. They have occurred throughout
history as debt mounts and trade falls. The South Sea Bubble of 1720 is generally regarded as the first stock mar-
ket led crisis, which involved widespread losses among a public that was encouraged to purchase shares in this
early joint-stock scheme. A similar crisis befell the Mississippi Company in New Orleans, in the same year, in
what was then New France. The Panic of 1796-1797 in the United States and Britain led to the creation of the first
American bankruptcy laws. It was, however, the depression at the end of the Napoleonic Wars that most affected
Canada in the modern era, not least because it provoked the British Corn Laws as a response, leading to three
decades of commercial uncertainty and then opportunity in the British North American grain sector.

Depression and Its Causes

From 1815 through the 1830s, the British, British North American, and American economies stuttered along from
one boom to the next bust. There were panics in 1825, 1837, 1847, 1857, and 1866. This instability in the North
Atlantic marketplace helps to explain the rapid development of financial institutions as moderating influences,
and the seeming obsession with tariffs (or, alternatively, free trade) as a mechanism for insulating the economy
from disaster.

The pre- and early-Victorian panics thus framed a lot of economic thinking, but it was the period from 1876 to
1896 that was to shape 20th century ideas about crisis management. In the course of a single generation, there
were four important downturns: the first produced a depression across the North Atlantic in 1873; the second, a
run on New Yorks Wall Street Stock Exchange, led to a North American economic crash in 1884; third, the col-
lapse of Londons Barings Bank followed in 1890; and fourth, in 1893 farm product prices collapsed and there
was a run on banks in North America, Europe, and Australia. This sequence of economic crises is sometimes
referred to collectively as the Long Depression, but it was 1893-1896 that became known at the time as the Great
Depression. In every instance, downturns were followed quickly by upticks in the commodities markets and in
trade. Depressions even that of 1893-1896 were relieved after only a few years. While there was inevitably
a scramble to address what appeared to be the proximate causes, the consensus that emerged was that government
involvement in the economy was unwelcome and unlikely to produce much positive change.

The recurrent financial crises from the 1700s on are evidence of the growing influence of capitalism, and its emer-
gence as the principal economic system in the Western world. The freedom to move money from one bank or
investment to another and to make a profit by doing so inevitably led to panics. Efforts to determine the
safest kind of currency preoccupied policy-makers through the late 19th century, and the alternatives of the gold

398
 8.4 ECONOMIC CYCLES 399

standard, silver, and paper were the focus of front-page debates for decades. This, too, reflects the extent to which
the economy had shifted to the exchange of cash rather than kind, which put more people in jeopardy. If the
currency collapsed, then so would the wages of every wage-earner.

Figure 8.3 The American writer, Frank L. Baum,

stuffed his most famous work, The Wizard of Oz,
with references to current fiscal debates, including
the Yellow Brick Road (made of gold bricks) and
the Land of Oz (oz. = ounces, the standard
measure for gold). Baum was also an advocate of
genocidal campaigns against indigenous peoples
in the West. (Artist: W.W. Denslow.)

The economic downturns also point to an increasingly integrated international economy. So long as British North
American grain was being produced mainly for British markets, the impact of a collapse in American grain prices
might be minimized. Rising industrialization, however, meant that capital was being invested in machinery and
factories with an eye to reaping dividends. In addition, all those industrial workers labouring away in the new fac-
tories of Ontario and Quebec now needed to be fed, ideally by farmers in Western Canada. In short, the economic
structures that produced the Long Depression would only become more acute in the early 20th century.

If you look at the pattern of booms and busts through the 19th century, what youll see is regularity. Each decade
had a peak and a trough of its own. The overall trend of the economy was, however, in an upward direction. So
each depression was followed by a recovery that quickly moved upward fast enough to match previous levels
of production and growth in Gross Domestic Product (GDP). After the 1893-1896 Great Depression, the North
American economy boomed and, despite a panic in 1907 in the United States, Canadas economy went from
strength to strength. This period has been referred to in Britain as the Indian summer of Edwardian England
because at the time and in retrospect after the Great War it seemed to be an uncharacteristically prolonged
stretch of prosperity. Edwardian Canadas own Indian summer, the Laurier boom, arose because of consumer
demand across the newly-settled Prairies. This, in turn, expanded the manufacturing output in Central Canada
and primary resource extraction industries across the whole of the country. The reckoning came in 1912, but that
severe social almost cataclysmic downturn was shortened by the arrival of a wartime economy in 1914.
What followed the war is critical for understanding the 1930s crisis.

The Roaring Twenties

The Great War was the first of Canadas total wars (see Section 6.4). Materiel, labour, and soldiers were
conscripted, as was capital to some extent. Every quarter of the economy experienced some readjustment from
1914-1918, and many marginal regions including the Maritimes and the Dominion of Newfoundland did
very well as a consequence. When the war ended, the economy had to shift again to a peacetime footing that
was demand-led, rather than command-led. Returning soldiers drove up unemployment rates in a cooling peace-
time economy. The Influenza Epidemic of 1918-1919 pounded the economy even further (see Section 6.6). In
400 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

1920-1921 there was a brief but sharp economic collapse. Having interfered extensively in the wartime economy,
the state pulled back at this time, trying to allow the capitalist market economy to take the lead. In other words,
the state very consciously retreated from all but a handful of welfare initiatives and from regulating the econ-
omy. The substantial improvement of the economy after 1921 vindicated this approach. Depressions were, by all
indicators, short sharp shocks that were tougher on some than on others, but a smart administration was one that
didnt blink, that allowed the invisible hand of the economy to do its job.

Key Points

New France, British North America, and Canada all experienced cyclical economic booms and
busts.
The incidence of economic crises was increasing at the end of the 19th century, and the pre-war era
ended with a severe downturn in 1912.
Readjustment to a peacetime economy was accompanied by an interwar downturn in the early
1920s.
Orthodox thinking in government and financial circles was that governments should not interfere in
the economy, a perspective that was to inform Ottawas response to the crisis in 1929.

Attributions
Figure 8.3
Dorothy meets the Cowardly Lion, from The Wonderful Wizard of Oz first edition by Durova is in the public
domain.
 8.5 The Great Depression

The 1930s Depression is profoundly and deeply associated, in the popular mind, with the prairie Dust Bowl, one
of the greatest environmental catastrophes in Canadian history. It was, in fact, something like a ticking time-bomb.

The British sent an expedition across the Prairies in the 1850s, led by John Palliser (1817-1887). Thereafter, his
name was given to a tract of arid land along the 49th parallel. Pallisers Triangle was identified as the northern
tip of the Great American Desert, a region identified in the 1820s as stretching like a wall north from Texas and
west from the 100th meridian to the Rocky Mountains. In 1874 a corps of 275 North-West Mounted Police, led
by Commissioner George Arthur French (1841-1921), were dismayed to find Pallisers Triangle so inhospitable.
Sent to the West to begin the process of the Canadian occupation of Aboriginal lands, Frenchs troops struggled
to find drinkable water and, when they met up with Sioux soldiers, French impressed upon them the fact that we
1
did not want their land. He wasnt lying. There was nothing about the region to suggest any farming potential to
French and the Mounties. Thereafter, the plains and prairies entered into a wet period, the landscape turned a more
promising shade of green, and its agricultural limitations were brushed aside by a Canadian government eager to
populate the region with producers of food and consumers of manufactured goods.

Elsewhere on the prairies, and deep into the American plains as well, the prevalent form of agriculture in these
years was dry land farming, which involves breaking the soil (with iron or steel ploughs) to a significant depth to
release the moisture captured below ground. Once that moisture is used by the crops or evaporates, there is little to
hold together the topsoil other than broken plant roots. After a generation or so under the plough, that part of the
soils integrity vanishes as well. A drought even a single year with little or no rain could cause significant
and widespread damage.

The southern route taken by the CPR ensured that Pallisers Triangle was quickly surveyed and homesteaded.
Improved grain prices in the 1920s led to more aggressive and widespread sod-busting across the prairies. When
drought began in 1930 an unfortunate coincidence with the Wall Street Crash the reach of modern agri-
culture across the centre of North America had reached a new peak. Everything came to a head in the 1930s due
to bad choices in the distribution of land, the heavy and sudden resettlement of the West, an over-aggressive and
industrial approach to soil use, the elimination of trees as windbreaks (instead, trees were used as fuel and build-
ing material for homesteads), a booming economy in the 1920s, and the depletion of aquifers.

1. Quoted in David C. Jones, Empire of Dust: Settling and Abandoning the Prairie Dry Belt (Edmonton: University of Alberta Press, 1987), 8.

401
 402 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

The Dirty Thirties

Palliser had recognized more than 70 years earlier that the southern Prairies were subject to drought con-
ditions and these, as it turned out, were cyclical. The conditions in the early 1930s were ideal for dust storms.
Prairie topsoil was picked up by the wind and blown from the southwest as far as Hudsons Bay. Dust storms
became increasingly common (and larger) as the Depression wore on. In 1935, one pan-continental storm turned
the skies black for days and reduced visibility to a matter of feet. Dunes of dust obliterated whole farms, leaving
the landscape unrecognizable. The influential 1941 Canadian novel As For Me and My House by Sinclair Ross
describes dust clouds lapping at the sky and the constant intrusion of dust under the windowsills and doorsills,
2
and into clothes, food, and the pores of exposed skin.

Figure 8.4 Southern Saskatchewan in the Dust Bowl years, ca.

1930-1935.

A quarter million Canadian farmers the greatest number from Saskatchewan fled this catastrophe between
1931 and 1941 by heading for British Columbia (mostly) and Ontario. Those who remained behind received some
support from a relief effort mustered by private citizens and government. The Dust Bowl changed the farming
landscape of the prairies, and it would have a long-term impact on farming practices. It also created a new dias-
pora out of first- and second-generation Westerners who had left behind other homelands to become homesteaders
and were now environmental refugees. As well, the Dust Bowl contributed significantly to the growth of distinc-
tive political ideologies and attitudes that propelled reform movements on the right and left.

When the Wall Street stock market crashed in October 1929, a dogmatic position of non-interference in the econ-
omy was orthodoxy. It was embraced by Canadas federal Liberal and Conservative parties alike. Given that the
core electorate in these years was still decisively in Ontario and Quebec (where economic diversification damp-
ened some of the worst impacts of the crisis) and the Maritimes (which, already in poor shape, didnt experience
the 1930s as a disaster of quite the same magnitude), the instinctive caution of federal politicians should have
come as no surprise.

A Perfect Storm
Even by 1928, more than a year before the stock market disaster, there were signs of trouble. Commodity
prices were wobbling and new house construction was slowing. Population growth was another issue. The inter-
war years (1919-1938) began with substantial out-migration from war-torn Europe, which decreased almost as
quickly. Immigration from China was effectively stopped by the Chinese Immigration Act, 1923. Growth in the
population of Canada was coming from a natural increase (births over deaths) more than immigration for the first
time since the 1870s, despite the fact that the number of men of marriageable-age was reduced by the mortalities
of 1914-1919.

2. Sinclair Ross, As For Me and My House (New York: Reynal and Hitchcock, 1941), 26.)[footnote] If this wasnt enough, the West faced two
other plagues: grasshoppers and hailstorms. More than a few contemporary writers have referred to these hardships as of biblical proportions.
 8.5 THE GREAT DEPRESSION 403

Indebtedness was another factor leading to a fall. The arrival of new combine harvester technology in the 1920s
meant that farm families borrowed to mechanize their output. As well, families were graduating from the sod-huts
and simple wood frame cabins of homesteaders into larger and more expensive homes. In addition, automobiles
were becoming more common, many of which were bought on credit.

Figure 8.5 On the eve of the Depression, combined

harvester-threshers reduced the need for itinerant threshing crews,
and pitched farmers into debt. High Prairie, Alberta, 1930.

There were external factors to consider as well. International currencies were in trouble, most spectacularly in the
Weimar Republic (Germany). The system of mutual dependence produced by Germanys obligation to pay repa-
rations after the Great War meant that all countries had a significant stake in what was occurring in Weimar. In
addition, most North Atlantic economies had returned to the gold standard (a commonly-pegged way of insuring
the value of a nations currency), but at the pre-WWI rate, which significantly disadvantaged several currencies.

Another factor often overlooked is the inexperience of new stock markets. Until 1914, the City of London was the
unquestioned financial capital of the world. As the interwar years began, there was growing competition for this
title from financial hubs and stock exchanges in Paris, Tokyo, and New York, among other places. Decentralized
control over the global investment economy pulled capital in different directions, increasing risks (and exposure
to inexperienced brokers) while adding little to the building of a global fiscal safety net.

Thus, the stage was being set for a massive economic collapse by inflated currencies, the popularizing of gambling
on the stock exchange, over-extension of household and industrial credit, heavy capital investment in machinery
and buildings, a teetering international monetary and capital network, and a bubble in the commodities exchanges.
When trade on the New York Stock Exchange crashed on Black Tuesday, 24 October 1929, the die was cast.

Living with Depression

In late 1929, no one could know for certain how long it would be before prosperity returned; few would have
guessed that a whole decade of economic pain would pass before the economy could be urged back to life. The
axiom that generals are always ready to fight the last war was, in fact, coined in the 1930s to describe the eco-
nomic strategies that were wheeled out to deal with the crisis. Ill-equipped to tackle either the fiscal complexities
of the Depression or the social catastrophe that it produced, governments in Canada (for the most part) shied away
from interfering and hoped for the best.

The collapse of the international commodities market dramatically impacted the Canadian and Newfoundland
economies. What, after all, was the commodities market but another term for the staple economy? Both Domin-
ions had been producing unprocessed goods for trade abroad since the 16th century and, despite some progress
in central Canadian manufacturing, they were doing much the same in the 20th century. Grain dominated, closely
followed by wood products (lumber and paper) and minerals. These were precisely the commodities that bottomed
out. The monoculture of Prairie farming was effectively vapourized by the Crash and the Dust Bowl. In British
404 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Columbia, the company towns and logging camps that relied on transient labour (much of it comprised of single
males) were likewise hit hard. Migrant workers from the prairies and BCs own seasonal workers followed a cycle
of working across the West and then back to Vancouver to ride out the winters. The citys oldest neighbourhood
was carpeted with hotels, flophouses, brothels, vaudeville theatres, and saloons to take advantage of this traffic.
The financial crisis occurred as the annual migration to the west coast hotels was underway, and when the 1930
work season arrived, vastly fewer jobs were available. As a mecca to the unemployed, Vancouver continued
to attract large numbers of unemployed through the course of the Depression, with explosive results on several
occasions.

Similar conditions prevailed on the East Coast. Unemployment and a stagnant economy was nothing new to the
Atlantic region, but the old strategy of out-migration and seeking greener pastures was no longer available. The
United States closed the door to Maritime immigrants, the Prairie West was wholly unattractive, and Canada
established restrictions on immigration from Newfoundland. While seasonal work as a way of making a living
survived in some regions, the appearance of full-time and continuous work in industry and in the office sector
complicated matters. It was no longer just a matter of surviving until the next season of work came around; unem-
ployment in the 1930s meant, for many people, the loss of full-time work. As unemployment climbed to 20%
across the Atlantic region, in Nova Scotia and New Brunswick, relief costs propelled one county after the next to
consider bankruptcy.

Figure 8.6 Unable to afford gasoline and having disposed of their

buggies, many Canadians gutted their cars and hitched them to
horses during the Depression. These hybrid vehicles were called,
bitterly, "Bennett buggies" after the Prime Minister.

The mechanization of farming across the Prairies had made possible massive increases in productivity while
reducing the year-round value of family labour. Farm boys and farm girls were increasingly surplus to the family
farm and, as they got older, they looked increasingly to urban or other rural pursuits. Some found work with
threshing crews teams of men and women who moved from farm to farm (at harvest time) along with the
newest machinery for processing the wheat crop. These crews depended heavily on temporary workers who were
hired and dismissed seasonally. Labour mobility was a critical part of the farm economy, and the cash income
of threshing crew workers was important for the household economy as well. With the collapse in grain prices
compounded by the Dust Bowl, seasonal work became immediately scarce, and impoverished by their inability to
produce or sell grain, family farms found it a real burden to feed these temporary workers. The eldest sons in par-
ticular often were compelled to seek work elsewhere, to try to survive on their own, typically in cities and mines.

It is important to note that the impact of the Depression was felt well beyond the corridor of cities and farms in
southern Canada. The 1920s had witnessed a boom in the fur-trade tied to the brief flicker of an international
luxury market. This was good news for Native trappers and traders in the North, as was the arrival in 1901 of
the Parisian Revillon Frres fur trading company; prices went up as Revillon went toe-to-toe with the local HBC
traders. This situation, of course, invited growing competition from non-Native trappers and hunters, some of
them by now long-residents in the region. The Innu of Labrador, for example, found themselves pushed further
and further inland in the 1920s to eke out an existence that now was based almost entirely on the trade in furs.
 8.5 THE GREAT DEPRESSION 405

The possibility of fishing and hunting for food was by this point so reduced that they had no option but to adopt a
3
European diet and Euro-Canadian clothing made available through the trade in furs. The 1929 Wall Street Crash
echoed even on the Labrador plateaus west of Nain and Kaipokok, and they would not be relieved like the rest
of the country until the outbreak of the Second World War.

No Relief in Sight
As the Depression deepened, governments across Canada typically did very little. Conventional economic think-
ing called for a hands-off approach to economic downturns, and most provincial and federal administrations were
very conventional in their thinking.

In retrospect, Mackenzie King was fortunate to have lost the election in 1930 because the worst years occurred
under the Conservatives led by R.B. Bennett (see Section 6.7). The Conservatives arguably were inclined even
more than the Liberals to allow the Depression to run its course, but they had no way of knowing how deep the
troughs could get. Although by 1931 things were very bad, a slight hint of recovery arose in 1932 or, at least,
things werent worsening as badly as in 1929-31. When 1933 came along, the Canadian economy plunged head-
long into the deepest trade depression in its history. Unemployment reached 30%, and real GDP shrank by more
than 10% in both 1931 and 1932. Some recovery would occur in 1934, but setbacks followed in 1935. Throughout
these years, the federal government took a minimalist approach, holding onto its faith in a temporary readjustment
and an unassisted return to prosperity. The electorate and the unemployed did not share that faith.

Thanks to the Depression, the 1930s would witness a dramatic politicization of the Canadian people. A variety of
new partisan strategies would be explored at the ballot box, including the social democratic CCF (provincially and
nationally), the monetarist Social Credit Party in Alberta, communist parties that could evade restrictions on their
legal status, and even some fascist parties (see Sections 6.8 and 7.9). However, the issues of unemployment, dis-
possession, homelessness, and even hunger were so acute that they could not wait for election day. Unemployed
workers, transients, and their supporters repeatedly took to the streets to register their bitter disappointment and
to challenge authority.

Nowhere was this life of politics beyond the ballot box more visible than in Vancouver. Beginning in 1930, there
were public demonstrations calling for action from civic, provincial, and federal levels of government. City char-
ters limited what municipal authorities could do, and their tax base was drying up rapidly. Seizing homes in default
of outstanding property taxes in a market like the 1930s only encumbered city governments. In the absence of
anything like unemployment insurance, and with only a very limited welfare state in place, cities were the first
stop for the unemployed looking for relief. This category of support could include anything from food (or chits
for food), temporary housing, cash for necessities, clothing hand-outs, and/or work. Anglo-Canadian Protestant
ethics made the case against relief as weakening recipients' resolve to find employment, creating dependency, and
as being demoralizing. Potential recipients likewise often found it shameful and degrading to accept, let alone ask
for, relief. In language that spoke to heterosexual and patriarchal norms, people said it wasnt manly. The sense
that unemployment was the fault of the unemployed, however, began to dissipate in 1931 when it became clear
that the Depression was the inevitable by-product of an international economic collapse. The result was that cities
like Vancouver resisted giving relief, and the unemployed only asked for relief when they already were desperate.
By 1931, many were desperate.

3. Lynne D. Fitzhugh, The Labradorians: Voices from the Land of Cain (St. Johns: Breakwater, 1999), 375.
 406 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Social welfare is constitutionally a provincial responsibility. Provincial governments were hardly better off than
the local authorities, and they were inclined to reinforce the message that it was first and foremost a local (that
is, civic or municipal) matter. At the same time, they demanded that Ottawa address a problem that was clearly
national in scope and made worse (in the case of many provinces) by the presence of migrant and out-of-province
workers looking for relief or dole.

Figure 8.7 The hobo jungles took many forms. This early
structure housed 14 unemployed men; things would soon get
much more desperate. Vancouver, 1931.

Conflict erupted in 1931, and again in 1933, in public demonstrations and around homeless mens camps also
called hobo jungles. Vancouver was especially attractive to the unemployed because it was at the end of the
rail line, and the winter weather was relatively mild and tolerable. Communist activists and evangelicals cam-
paigned in the hobo jungles. Both treated the unemployed community as a powder keg. The City of Vancouver
(and other urban governments) responded by evacuating the jungles and relocating their residents to federally-
built and Department of National Defence-run Relief Camps outside of the city limits, sometimes in remote parts
of BC. Others were established in the national parks of the Rocky Mountains. In the National Park Branch camps,
some of the infrastructure of holidaying (such as campgrounds and facilities) was created by unemployed work-
ers; but the unemployed in the Relief Camps mostly performed meaningless routine work, colloquially referred to
4
as boondoggles. The unemployed worked for 20 cents a day (hence the nickname of the camps as the "Royal 20
Centers") and under military-style discipline, which bought the city a little time that ran out quickly.

By 1933 conditions had worsened to such a point that the resident unemployed were clamouring for relief. What
the City could offer in terms of projects or payments was by this stage very limited. Police surveillance of the
unemployed was met with street fights and the occupation of public buildings and department stores. In 1933 the
communists organized the Relief Camp Workers Union, which mobilized the extremely alienated unemployed
across the region to abandon the camps and put their issues directly before Prime Minister Bennett. The On-to-
Ottawa Trek set off from Vancouver on 3 June 1935 but was stopped in Regina, the site of the RCMP head-
quarters. Trek leaders headed on to Ottawa to meet with Bennett, but the discussion was cut short and quickly
degenerated into name-calling. Once the leaders were back in Regina, a rally was called for the 1st of July
Dominion Day in Reginas Market Square. The Mounties riot squad surged into the crowd of 1500-2000 peo-
ple (most of them local residents) with truncheons swinging. The Trek leadership was arrested, one constable and
one protester died, and the campaign was broken.

4. Bill Waiser, Park Prisoners: The Untold Story of Western Canada's National Parks, 1915-1946 (Saskatoon: Fifth House, 1995).
 8.5 THE GREAT DEPRESSION 407

Figure 8.8 Unemployed workers board boxcars headed east from

Kamloops, BC for the On-to-Ottawa Trek, 1935.

On the face of it, the Regina Riot seems extraordinary, but in the context of the Dirty Thirties, it was not. Condi-
tions that led to the Battle of Ballantyne Pier were unfolding even as the Trekkers left Vancouver. Local dock-
yard workers had gone on strike and were replaced with strikebreakers brought in by the Shipping Federation (an
organization of waterfront employers). Fifteen days after the Trekkers left Vancouver, the strikers marched to the
waterfront, led by a Great War veteran and decorated hero. Confronted by mounted and armed City police, BC
Provincial Police, and Royal Canadian Mounted Police, the march rapidly turned into a melee. Fighting continued
for three hours across the East End, culminating in 24 arrests, about the same number hospitalized, and untold
numbers injured.

Figure 8.9 The Battle of Ballantyne Pier spills into residential

streets as Mounties pursue strikers down the sidewalk.

New Dealers
Another casualty of these events was R. B. Bennett. His counterpart in the United States, President Franklin
Delano Roosevelt (1882-1945), launched a New Deal program shortly after his election in 1933, aimed at stim-
ulating the economy through spending. This was heresy, in the context of conservative economic thinking, but it
was attractive to legislators and civil servants because it put them in a position to act rather than defend inaction.
Even Bennett seemed changed by this example. Beginning in January 1935, he endorsed economic intervention
by the federal government. He introduced the Bank of Canada and the Canadian Wheat Board, but did not
pursue economic pump-priming or efforts to spend his way out of the crisis. The electorate, worn out by conflict,
hardship, and lack of government solutions; shocked at the violence inflicted on Canadians by Canadians; and
convinced that the wealthy and snobbish Bennett was flinty-hearted tossed out the Conservatives in October 1935
and returned Mackenzie Kings Liberals.

Despite the rhetoric suggesting a greater sympathy for the unemployed, King turned out to be no more an inter-
ventionist than Bennett. Kings Liberal counterpart in BC, Thomas Dufferin Duff Pattullo, however, launched
his own Little New Deal that, warts and all, demonstrated Keynesian thinking was gaining traction in some
parts of Canada. King's response was to reintroduce the hated relief camps, albeit with some slight improvements
and significantly more isolation than before. These initiatives were not enough to still significant urban unrest.
On 20 May, 1938, unemployed protesters occupied the Vancouver Art Gallery, the Hotel Georgia, and the main
Post Office on Hastings Street at Granville. A month later, on Sunday, 19 June at daybreak, the Vancouver Police
oversaw the largely peaceful evacuation of the Art Gallery; and at the same moment, the RCMP stormed the Post
408 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Office with teargas and truncheons. A window-smashing campaign followed and, hours later, a demonstration of
support took place at an East End park where 10,000 to 15,000 locals gathered.

Figure 8.10 "Citizens Protest Police Terror" at Oppenheimer Park

on Bloody Sunday.

The Regina Riot and Bloody Sunday were merely the worst episodes in a long decade of street battles between
various police forces and the unemployed. The war that terminated the economic Depression would force a recon-
sideration of economic orthodoxy in a way that the financial crisis had not, and the events of 1929-1939 would
shape more than a generation of Canadian political culture. The sustained popularity of the CCF and Social Credit,
mistrust of Ottawa and civic police forces, and a widespread tolerance for state intervention in the economy were
only a few of the ways in which this one decade would transform Canada.

Key Points

The 1930s Depression consisted of several events, including the Dust Bowl and the collapse of the
commodities market.
Economic and environmental disaster produced an out-migration from the Prairies, particularly from
Saskatchewan.
Seasonality in employment was deeply impacted with bad results for tens, if not hundreds of thou-
sands of itinerant and semi-itinerant Canadian workers.
The downturn profoundly affected all parts of Canada, some more deeply than others.
Successive Conservative and Liberal governments developed few plans to directly reform the econ-
omy or introduce social welfare measures like employment insurance.
The massification of unemployment and the concentration of the jobless in cities like Vancouver cre-
ated conditions that led to violent street battle confrontations with police forces.

Attributions
Figure 8.4
A dust storm over the prairies is in the public domain. This image is available from the Provincial Archives of
Saskatchewan under the item number S-A295.

Figure 8.5
Combined Harvester-Thresher operated by tractor (Online MIKAN no.3337608) by Library and Archives
Canada / PA-040497 is in the public domain.
 8.5 THE GREAT DEPRESSION 409

Figure 8.6
Bennett Buggy by Steve Smith is in the public domain.

Figure 8.7
The "jungle" of the unemployed, summer of 1931. (Reference code: AM54-S4-: Re N10.06) by Matthews,
James Skitt, Major / City of Vancouver Archives is in the public domain.

Figure 8.8
Strikers from unemployment relief camps en route to Eastern Canada during "March on Ottawa" by Unknown
is in the public domain. This image is available from Library and Archives Canada under the reference number
3194934.

Figure 8.9
Battle of Ballantyne by Bobanny is in the public domain.

Figure 8.10
Citizens protest police terror by Bobanny is in the public domain.
 8.6 The New Economy

DOUG OWRAM, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA - OKANAGAN

The years after World War I marked the emergence of the modern Canadian economy. As a means of comprehend-
ing the longer-term trends underlying this development, it is useful to think in terms of continuities and changes.
As a nation with a vast geography and small population, the Canadian economy would continue to be shaped by
resources and the need to sell its goods internationally. However, urbanization, continuing industrialization, and
the shifting international landscape altered the precise way in which these factors interacted, often in a disruptive
fashion.

The years preceding WWI had been marked by the great expansion of the wheat economy. The so-called Laurier
boom was a rapid expansion of agricultural production and exports that, in turn, helped to fuel the overall Cana-
dian economy. The 1920s marked a transition. Agriculture continued to expand for a few more years but would
recede in scale and relative importance in subsequent decades. By the end of the 20th century, the change was
summed up in a statement of the Canada Year Book: In 1941 some 3.3 million people, then 27% of Canadas
population, lived on a farm. In 1996 this had dropped to only 267,000 people, or 2% of the working population.
Once a mainstay of Canadas economic health and security, [in 1996 ] farming represented just 2% of the coun-
1
trys GDP. Instead, Canadian employment growth depended much more on a new, non-agricultural base.

This budding economic foundation was manifested both directly and indirectly. Directly, the 1921 census marked
the first time that more Canadians were counted as urban than rural. This trend would never reverse. In the West,
major centres like Calgary, Edmonton, and Vancouver grew rapidly and were no longer just small service centres
for the surrounding agricultural communities. In Central Canada, new technology especially automobiles and
related sectors created significant employment opportunities. By the end of the 1920s, more than a quarter-
million vehicles were being produced annually. Vehicle production stalled during the depression of the 1930s and
in the face of wartime demands throughout 1939-1945, but took on an even greater importance thereafter. By the
1960s, autos and auto parts would become Canadas most important secondary industry.

The indirect impact of the new economic order came in the commodity sector. The growing urban, industrial, and
North American-wide market created a tremendous demand for materials. For example, minerals like nickel, cop-
per, and iron-ore were mined to feed industrial production in Canada and the United States. Two products deserve

1. Statistics Canada, Canada Year Book 1999 (Ottawa: Minister Responsible for Statistics Canada, 1999), 337.

410
 8.6 THE NEW ECONOMY 411

particular mention. First, in the inter-war years, pulp and paper expanded rapidly to support the rapid growth in
newspapers. Canadian production increased six-fold in the decade after the Great War, and Canada became the
largest pulp and paper producer in the world. Newsprint was very much an export product with some 80% of
interwar-era production going south of the border.

The second emergent commodity was oil. Beginning in the later 19th century, oil grew in importance to feed the
demand for kerosene lighting, and then industrial production and automobiles. Initially Canada produced very lit-
tle oil from only a few small fields in the Turner Valley of southern Alberta and near Sarnia, Ontario. However, a
major strike at Leduc, Alberta in 1947 ushered in a new era. Oil production increased from practically nothing in
the late-1940s to more than half a million barrels a day 20 years later, and more than two million barrels a day by
the turn of the 21st century.

Oil can be viewed as one segment of Canadas overall energy sector. Coal and natural gas also grew in these
years, but especially important was hydroelectric power. Major developments in the early 20th century, at Niagara
Falls and along Quebecs numerous rivers, created new opportunities for cheap industrial power, and convenience
for an increasing number of Canadian homes. Hydroelectric power also quickly became another export industry,
which continues to the present day.

However, as important as hydroelectricity is, oil is the most important energy product of the late 20th and early
21st centuries. Prices are notoriously volatile, but the commodity is always a vital part of a modern industrial
society. As with other key industries, oil has a series of important linkages that increase its importance. Pipelines
criss-cross Canada and the United States, transporting products to market. Refineries, which transform oil into
gasoline, were originally clustered near Edmonton and in southwestern Ontario for the most part. At the same
time, the exploration for new sources of energy became a significant employer in its own right. Most recently,
the oil sands around Fort McMurray have added a layer of intensive investment (and controversy) to the indus-
try. Energy overall, and oil in particular, remains a major engine of economic growth, creating a westward tilt in
Canadian politics, regional population movements, and income.

Figure 8.11 Oil sands were first exploited as a ready-made source

of asphalt. Mining tar sands near Waterways, AB, in 1925.

For all the changes that have occurred in the last century, commodities remain a central part of Canadas economy.
Another related continuity is Canadas reliance on international markets. Due to a strong commodity base and
small population, Canada is dependent on international trade for much of its prosperity. This hit home in an unfor-
tunate way when the world sank into the Depression of the 1930s. International trade collapsed as corporations
ceased to purchase materials and equipment, while nations increasingly retreated behind tariff barriers. Canada,
already affected by poor agricultural conditions, was hit harder than most. Indeed only two nations, the United
States and Germany, had a greater decline in overall economic activity in that decade.

Long after the depression ended, however, Canada remained a trading nation, dependent on international markets.
Once again, though, changes have occurred over time. In the interwar years, trade with the United States and Great
Britain predominated. After 1945 the United States was by far Canadas largest trading partner. By the mid-60s,
412 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Canadas exports to the United States were five times greater than the next largest partner, and represented more
than 60% of all Canadian exports. The importance of the United States was recognized with the Canada-United
States Free Trade Agreement of 1988, which subsequently was expanded into the North American Free Trade
Agreement (NAFTA) when Mexico joined in 1994. Most recently, the rise of the Asian economies has moderated
this trend, and countries like Japan and especially China have become important markets for Canadian goods.
However, the constants continue: commodities dominate, and trade remains vital to Canadas economic well-
being.

Key Points

As Canadas economy modernized after the Great War, its focus shifted increasingly from farming to
industry and services, from rural to urban.
In 1921 the population of the country as a whole was more urban than rural for the first time.
Despite slowdowns in the 1930s and during WWII, the automobile industry emerged as a leading
sector.
New sectors specifically pulp and paper and oil/petroleum emerged in the 1920s and 1940s, as
did hydroelectricity.
The energy sector as a whole grew throughout the 20th century.
Commodity sales remained important throughout the century, and trade relations with the United
States only grew in importance.

Attributions
Figure 8.11
Tar sand for bituminous pavements, 1/2 mile East of Waterways Station, Alta. (Online MIKAN no.3372785)
by Canada. Dept. of Mines and Technical Surveys / Library and Archives Canada / PA-019904 is in the public
domain.
8.7 Three Sectors

The first and foremost of Canadas resource-extraction industries was the fisheries. It is the oldest export-oriented
economic activity in the post-contact era that began in the 16th century. Fisheries made Canadas sea-going tradi-
tions critically important. At the time of Confederation, the necessity of an ice-free port was one of the attractions
of uniting New Brunswick and Nova Scotia to the old Province of Canada. Both of these Maritime provinces had
a long and distinguished record in the production and mobilization of fleets of fishing boats and globe-ranging
vessels. Prince Edward Island was not far behind. Also, Newfoundlands orientation to the sea has been all but
complete because of its very limited agricultural and forest hinterland. On the West and North coasts of Canada
as well, shipping has been a means to make a living and a symbol of sovereignty. Shipbuilding and the fisheries
two primary areas of commerce, employment, and investment are briefly explored in Sections 8.8 and 8.9.

More contemporary, the oil and gas industry is considered in Section 8.10. Supplying energy became a core ele-
ment of the industrial economy in the 19th century. Canada has participated in the energy revolution(s) in the
modernizing world since Basque whalers first visited the Labrador Coast in the 16th century (if not earlier). The
transition from organic sources of heat and light wood, whale oil, dogfish oil to inorganic sources like coal,
kerosene, oil, petroleum, natural gas, and uranium was relatively easy for a country that had access to all of these
options. In a fuel-hungry millennial world, energy is one staple export that comes close to balancing the bulk:value
ratio.

413
8.8 The Shipping Industry in Canada, 1867 1945

ERIC W. SAGER, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, UNIVERSITY OF VICTORIA

Figure 8.12 Launching of SS Ashby Park at Pictou Shipyards,

Nova Scotia, 1944.

Canada has the longest coastline of any country in the world, and a large overseas trade. However, for more than
50 years, the country has not had a large merchant marine. Why this apparent paradox? For much of the 19th cen-
tury, the colonies and the Dominion of Canada had relatively large shipping and shipbuilding industries. By the
1870s, the official statistics suggest that Canada had the fourth largest domestically-registered merchant marine
in the world. Most of the tonnage consisted of wooden-hulled sailing ships, most of which were registered in the
Maritime provinces and Quebec. The shipping industry had developed in large part to transport bulk commodities
mainly timber and wheat from the colonies to Britain. By the third quarter of the 19th century, Canadian
ships were deeply committed to the transport of bulk cargoes from the eastern United States to Britain and Europe.

Older history books have a simple explanation for the decline of the shipping and shipbuilding industries after
the 1880s. Wooden-hulled sailing ships became obsolete; therefore the industry declined. This explanation is
no longer acceptable, since it is considered technological determinism. Canadian shipowners operated iron
steamships, and Canada had the resources to build iron and steel ships. Some Canadian shipowners, such as Hugh
Allan, established liner companies that operated in the North Atlantic. Yet, shipping experienced a relative decline
because capitalists perceived better investment opportunities elsewhere in Canada; because governments did not
offer much support or protection for shipping; and because cheap shipping services were increasingly available
from other countries.

During the two world wars, Canada renewed its involvement in shipping and shipbuilding. In 1918 the federal
government created the Canadian Government Merchant Marine (CGMM), which operated merchant ships for
several years at a time when the war had caused a decline in available tonnage. During the Second World War,
another government-owned company, Park Steamships Limited, made a vital contribution to wartime trade with

414
 8.8 THE SHIPPING INDUSTRY IN CANADA, 1867 1945 415

Britain. After the war, the deep-sea merchant marine declined, and by the 1970s, few Canadian flag ships operated
in ocean trades.

Key Points

Canadian and Newfoundland shipping was a powerful and internationally credible sector of the
economy in the late 19th century.
Built to handle bulk goods, Canadian shipping played an important role in transporting goods
between the United States and Europe.
Although historians disagree over the causes of the decline of the Canadian shipping sector, the for-
mer emphasis on technological change has given way to a movement of capital out of shipping into
other investments.

Additional Readings
Heal, Syd C. A Great Fleet of Ships: The Canadian Forts and Parks. Ontario: Vanwell Publishing, 1999.

Sager, Eric W. and Gerald Panting. Maritime Capital: The Shipping Industry in Atlantic Canada, 1820-1914.
Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 1990.

Sager, Eric W. Seafaring Labour: The Merchant Marine of Atlantic Canada, 1820-1914. Montreal and Kingston:
McGill-Queens University Press, 1989.

Attributions
Figure 8.12
Ssashbypark1944 by Maggil07 is in the public domain.
8.9 Canadas Ocean Fisheries

MIRIAM WRIGHT, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, UNIVERSITY OF WINDSOR

Canadas Atlantic and Pacific coast fisheries changed dramatically in the years after Confederation. Marine crea-
tures, including fish, shellfish and marine mammals had sustained Aboriginal peoples on those coasts for thou-
sands of years, and these same resources later attracted European settlers. In the 20th century, however, new
technologies enabled people to catch far more fish. Fishing enterprises expanded and consolidated, changing the
structure of the fishing industry and greatly affecting the lives of men and women who earned their living from
fishing. These changes also affected fish, and by the end of the 20th century, many fish populations, including
Atlantic cod and Pacific salmon, were severely depleted.

Historically, Atlantic cod was the predominant fishery on the Atlantic Coast. In the late 19th and early 20th cen-
turies, merchants outfitted wooden ships and engaged crews to fish for cod off the coasts of Newfoundland and
Nova Scotia. As well, families, supplied with credit from merchants, fished inshore with small boats the men
and boys catching the fish, and the women and girls curing the catch on shore. In the days before refrigeration,
people salted the cod that went to markets in Europe, the Caribbean, and South America.

By the 1940s, advances in refrigeration and freezing technologies meant that fishing companies could sell fish
fresh or quick-frozen to customers in North America. Soon, women who had previously cured fish on shore were
working in fish plants owned by frozen fish companies. While many fishing people continued to use small boats
(although now equipped with gas engines), the companies acquired large fishing trawlers that operated offshore.
By the early 1970s, inshore fishing people, plant workers, and trawler crews in Newfoundland and Nova Scotia
had unionized to secure fair wages and control over prices in an increasingly industrialized environment. Industri-
alization, however, also put pressure on the cod populations as Canadian trawlers were joined offshore by vessels
from Europe. In 1992, after declining for decades, the cod populations were so weakened that the Canadian gov-
ernment declared a moratorium on fishing. Despite these protective measures, the Atlantic cod off the coast of
Newfoundland have not recovered. Other fisheries including crab and shrimp have replaced cod as the most sig-
nificant species in the region, but these new fisheries employ far fewer than the cod fishery once had.

Like the Atlantic coast fishery, Canadas Pacific coast fishery was diverse, including salmon (the most important
species by far), herring, and halibut. The rich salmon rivers of British Columbia, such as the Fraser and the
Skeena, have provided sustenance for Aboriginal peoples for thousands of years. Thus, Aboriginal people were

416
 8.9 CANADAS OCEAN FISHERIES 417

also among the first workers in the commercial fishery in the 19th century when non-Aboriginal people built can-
neries on the salmon rivers. Aboriginal families spent the summers at the canneries, with women on the canning
lines and men fishing from small wooden boats. Before long, other groups of immigrant workers arrived, includ-
ing Chinese men who worked inside the canneries, immigrants from Japan who fished, and people of European
descent.

In the 20th century, new technologies and industrial consolidation brought opportunities and challenges for those
involved in the British Columbia salmon fishery. Gas engines arrived in the 1920s, but the biggest changes came
after World War II: vessels became larger with more powerful engines and more effective nets and gear. The
salmon companies closed their older canneries, centralized their operations in Vancouver, and encouraged fishers
to invest in larger craft. While some did, others were shut out. Aboriginal peoples in particular found it harder to
stay in the fishery with the cannery closures and barriers to getting larger vessels. As well, a 1968 federal license
limitation plan removed hundreds of small boat fishers from the industry.

Figure 8.13 Halibut harvest, British Columbia, 1937.

Although fishing vessels had become larger and more efficient, catches, on the whole, declined in the decades
after the Second World War. By the 1990s, the salmon fishery was in crisis as salmon populations fell to historic
1
lows. Years of intensified fishing was certainly an important factor, but so were environmental problems. Decades
of mining, logging, and hydro-electric development along salmon rivers destroyed the fish habitats. As well,
changing conditions in the ocean, where salmon spend part of their lives, may also have been a factor. The federal
government was accused, by industry stakeholders and scientists, of not protecting the resource and supporting
the technological expansion of the industry. Although people in the industry have noted strong salmon returns in
2010 and 2014 for the important Fraser River sockeye, the future is still unclear.

The 20th century brought many opportunities for expansion and growth in both the Pacific and Atlantic coast
fisheries, but these opportunities came with a high price. Fishing people and plant workers found it increasingly
difficult to remain in an industry that favoured centralization and capital intensity. The wild species that had been
part of the rich ecosystems of both coasts were under pressure from humans fishing and destroying their habitat.
The destruction of these important ecosystems and habitats from over-fishing has threatened the livelihoods of
thousands, and whether or not Canadas wild ocean fisheries survive into the current century remains uncertain.

Key Points

Changes in fishing technologies and techniques in the 20th century drove certain stocks to a crisis
point.
The East Coast cod fishery was organized around offshore and inshore operations, both capitalized

1. Joseph Gough, Managing Canadas Fisheries (Sillery, QC: Septentrion, 2007), 455.
418 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

by local merchants.
The advance of refrigeration technologies shifted fisheries employment from villages to processing
factories, which led to a greater organization of fisheries labour.
More aggressive fishing led to the closure of the cod fisheries in 1992, producing widespread unem-
ployment in the Atlantic region.
Similar outcomes were reached on the West Coast in the context of the salmon fishery, which was
mechanized with motor vessels and canneries.
Over fishing and environmental damage resulted in salmon depopulation and cyclical crises in the
industry.

Additional Readings
Cadigan, Sean. Hope and Deception in Conception Bay: Merchant-Settler Relations in Newfoundland,
1785-1855. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1995.

Newell, Dianne. Tangled Webs of History: Indians and the Law in Canadas Pacific Coast Fisheries. Toronto:
University of Toronto Press, 1993.

Newell, Dianne and Rosemary Ommer, eds. Fishing Places, Fishing People: Traditions and Issues in Canadian
Small-Scale Fisheries. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1999.

Wright, Miriam. A Fishery for Modern Times: The State and the Industrialization of the Newfoundland Fishery,
1934-1968. Don Mills, ON: Oxford University Press, 2001.

Wright, Miriam. Building the Great Lucrative Fishing Industry: Aboriginal Gillnet Fishers and Protests over
Salmon Fishery Regulations for the Nass and Skeena Rivers, 1950s-1960s. Labour/Le Travail 61 (Spring
2008): 99-130.

Attributions
Figure 8.13
CVA 260-656 [Men unloading fish on the Vancouver Harbour Commission fish dock] by James Crookall /
City of Vancouver Archives is in the public domain.
 8.10 Oil and Gas and the New West

Figure 8.14 Leduc in 1947: its effects were,

literally, explosive.

In 1947, on the 13th of February, Leduc blew in.

Lets situate that in the context of mid-century Alberta. Following a period of promising growth before 1914 and
in the 1920s, the provincial economy was devastated by the Depression of the 1930s and the environmental cat-
astrophe of the dust bowl. Alberta was a poor and scruffy place. Paved roads were a rare sight. The major cities
were barely more than large towns. Winters were cold and long, and to heat their homes and businesses, Albertans
depended on wood (of which there was little in the Prairie region of the province) and coal, much of it mined in
the murderously dangerous mines of the Crowsnest Pass. The Second World War charged up the local economy
a bit, encouraging grain and livestock farmers as well as meat-packers in Calgary, but the return to peace raised
fears of a return to economic stagnation. The Great War was, after all, followed by an influenza pandemic, indus-
trial unrest, political instability, and an economic crisis in 1921. Albertans in 1947 could be optimistic only if they
made a point of ignoring the recent past.

Leduc changed everything. The first oil discovery in a field about 30 km south of Edmonton at long last vindicated
a generation of geologists. According to one account, Imperial Oil, which had drilled 133 dry holes and spent $20
million with little to show, finally had a major discovery. Thereafter it was madness: The spectacular Atlantic
No.3 well, which came in as a gusher in March 1948, blew wild for six months, spilling over a million barrels of
1
oil over the surrounding fields. The discovery at Leduc followed previous discoveries of naphtha gasoline at
Turner Valley near Calgary, and even older coal mining resources, so Alberta already had something of an energy
industry in place. However, this discovery was the start of something vastly larger, something that would alter the
face of both Alberta and Canada as a whole.

1. Howard Palmer with Tamara Palmer, Alberta: A New History (Edmonton: Hurtig, 1990), 300-301.

419
 420 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 8.15 What used to be called Turner Valley Skunk Juice

naptha gasoline is piped into drums, 1914.

The Rise of the West

The oil boom of the post-war years rekindled old resentments toward Central Canada. Ottawa had enjoyed exten-
sive control over the national economy during wartime, and the Minister for Everything, C.D. Howe, was still
of a mind that he could accomplish whatever was in the interest of Canada as a whole, even in peacetime. That
meant getting gas and oil from Alberta to factories in Ontario via a pipeline. For Albertans, this suggestion was
worrying in the extreme. The carbon energy resources of the province were, they believed, the key to economic
diversification. A province dependent on commodities like wheat and livestock would always be vulnerable to the
booms and busts of the international market. Cheap fuel, however, could improve the quality of life and create
new industries. In an age that lionized large-scale manufacturing, Alberta and the West as a whole still had
precious little secondary production capacity. Albertans could look to Texas, another oil-rich jurisdiction, to see
how its main cities had turned their wealth to good advantage. That vision would be realized in part, but not dur-
ing the mid-century.

What quickly became most evident was that Alberta was in the process of a socio-economic revolution. In 1921
the United Farmers of Alberta a political party based on cooperative values, social gospel instincts, and the
primacy of the agricultural sector formed the provincial government in Edmonton. They were succeeded in
1935 by the Social Credit Party, an antimodernist, monetary reform movement/party with strong fundamentalist
Christian values. These were political traditions that clearly had a religious component as well as an economic
aspect. In a province that was mostly made up of homesteads and small towns, this made sense in that the local
congregations were an expression of community and much of that community was doing the same thing: produc-
ing food. But Alberta was urbanizing slowly and then oil sped up the process.

Alberta tipped the scales to just slightly more urban than rural in 1951, 30 years after Canada as a whole. Fifteen
years later, more than 7 in 10 Albertans were city folks. Whats more, the rural population was not just shrinking
as a proportion: it was falling in real terms as well. In 1951 the high water mark for rural Albertans was reached
at 488,733; it would bottom out at 458,870 (25%) in 1976. The rural share of population steadily fell from 61% in
2
1941 to 25% in 1976 and further to 17% in 2011.

This reallocation of population took place against a background of profound growth. Between 1951 and 1961, the
overall population grew by 40%, much of that expansion coming from natural increase. In 1941 there were just
under 800,000 Albertans, and by 1971, that number had doubled to 1.63 million. There was, too, a renewal in
the arrival of immigrants, many of whom headed to the expanding cities. The population of Calgary and Edmon-
ton, both of which had languished for nearly two decades at around 80,000 residents, doubled in the 1950s, and
pushed past the half-million mark in the late 1970s. In 1941 their populations were at the bottom rungs of the top

2. Statistics Canada, Population, Urban and Rural, by Province and Territory (Alberta), accessed August 20, 2015, [Link]
tables-tableaux/sum-som/l01/cst01/[Link].
 8.10 OIL AND GAS AND THE NEW WEST 421

10 largest Canadian cities, but in 1961, Edmonton was the fourth largest and the third largest in 1971, eking out
Vancouver (not including its suburbs). During the same period, Calgary moved into fourth place and was 33%
larger than Ottawa.

This explosive demographic growth was spurred by economic expansion, most of which occurred in the oil
patch. Production more than tripled between 1960 and 1973. Ancillary industries associated with finance opened
branch offices in Albertan cities. Calgary in particular emerged by the 1980s as a centre of the insurance industry.
Economic diversification, however, remained elusive. The aging Social Credit regime faltered with the retirement
of long-time Premier Ernest Manning (1908-1996) in 1968, and a new, more aggressively pro-development Con-
servative government came to power in 1971 under Peter Lougheed (1928-2012). Fifty years had passed since
Albertans had elected one of the two mainstream parties to the legislature in Edmonton, and criticizing Ottawa for
provincial woes had become an institutionalized pastime. The Lougheed administration continued that tradition
while breaking sharply with the rural-oriented economic visions of the past, applying a stronger planning model,
and building on the Social Credit governments investment in education and training. Their timing was perfect.

Blue-eyed Arabs
Global oil prices were remarkably flat from the 1920s to the 1970s. Whether measured in real dollars (based on
2008 values) or unadjusted prices, there had not been much fluctuation, notwithstanding a bit of a trough in the
1930s. This stability was achieved by the collaboration between the Seven Sisters the largest international oil
companies and an economy-wide lack of price inflation. By 1970, however, American crude production was
falling, and Washingtons involvement in the 1973 Yom Kippur War in the Middle East spurred a dramatic and
overnight response from the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC). In October 1973 OPEC
raised the price of oil by 70%, imposed an embargo on sales to the United States, and cut output. What came to be
called the first OPEC oil shock combined with instability in global finances (caused by the collapse of the post-
WWII Bretton Woods system of currency alignments), which led to widespread price inflation, rising unemploy-
ment, industrial failures, and the beginning of an economic recession. In addition, some oil/petroleum rationing
occurred in North America. These features of the oil crisis were felt across the Western world (targeted by the
Arab-dominated OPEC nations) and were compounded by a sagging Canadian dollar, which impacted Canadian
manufacturers exports.

These events set the stage for rising economic and political tensions in Canada. Alberta, which to this point
had profited modestly on oil sales, suddenly became enormously wealthy. Its political and economic elites
described at the time as blue-eyed Arabs took the centre stage of national affairs and were increasingly
confrontational when it came to Ottawas involvement with the energy sector.

The constitutional context of the oil industry was important in these debates. Provinces control their natural
resources but only until they reach a borderline. Movement of oil or natural gas through pipelines into another
province let alone exports into the United States brought Ottawa into the equation. The Social Credit gov-
ernments had done much to ensure provincial oversight when it came to internal pipelines so as to limit Ottawas
influence. Demand from Central Canadas growing metropolises and factories guaranteed sales whenever Ameri-
can markets cooled, but it also ensured the involvement of the Ontario and Quebec dominated administrations in
Ottawa. In the late 1950s, both gas and oil/petroleum were being piped to Central and Eastern Canada, where they
had to compete with the oil being imported from the Middle East and elsewhere. In 1961, the federal government
 422 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

drew the Borden Line along the Ottawa River to create two oil markets in Canada, and oil in the market west of
the Borden Line was as much as a third more expensive.

This changed in 1973: first due to a new export tariff (introduced under Pierre Trudeaus administration) and
second with the OPEC oil shock. By this stage, Saskatchewan had joined the ranks of natural gas and oil pro-
ducing provinces, which already included British Columbia and Alberta. (Moreover, BC had had its own run-in
with Ottawa over energy policies when its government negotiated the Columbia River Treaty over hydroelectric-
ity exports with the United States in the early 1960s.) The possibility of a regional protest against federal energy
interventions was greater in the 1970s than in any previous decade, and the stakes were vastly higher. Ottawa took
the view that Alberta was enjoying windfall profits, which rightly belonged to all Canadians, although Alber-
tans felt differently. They disagreed with the National Energy Boards assessment that oil supplies were limited
in the extreme and should thus be preserved for domestic use and treated as a special commodity (with echoes
of wartime control over key supplies). Albertans were determined to use oil as part of a strategy to diversify the
provincial economy so that when the OPEC-produced windfall inevitably ended, Alberta would have a resilient
economic order in place.

Oilers Nation
Ottawa developed several strategies. The first was to ensure energy security for Canada by slapping an export tax
on shipments destined for south of the border. Even during the apparent oil shortage of the 1973 OPEC oil shock,
this tax reduced Albertas oil profits. Lougheed responded with an increase on royalty charges on publicly-owned
(Crown) resources. Oil companies had grown accustomed to writing off royalties in their federal corporate taxes,
and they hoped to weather this increase in provincial taxes by continuing to do so; however, Ottawa closed that tax
3
loophole. It took the rest of the decade to disentangle the bad feelings and confusion over pricing and revenues.

If tariffs and royalties were inadequate to the task of establishing national oil security, there were other options to
pursue. The foremost of these came into play in 1975 when the federal government launched a nationally-owned
oil company called Petro-Canada (aka Petrocan). In part this was a result of the Liberals having lost their major-
ity in the House and being dependent on an NDP balance of power (which was highly pro-Petrocan). Treated with
suspicion by Alberta, the new corporation was challenged to acquire high quality properties, processing capacity,
and oil reserves. Despite all of this, tempers cooled as the decade came to a close.

However, matters took a turn for the worse in 1979. The second OPEC oil shock (1979-1980) saw a return to snip-
ing between Ottawa and Edmonton. The return of the Trudeau government (restored after a 9-month Conservative
administration under Joe Clark) was quickly followed by the introduction of the National Energy Program (or
NEP). By this time, the price of crude oil had leapt from the pre-1973 price of $3 to nearly $40 a barrel.

The NEP addressed purported shortages by guaranteeing national energy self-sufficiency, taxing the fuel resource
to benefit Canadians outside of Alberta, and extending still further Canadian ownership of the oil sector through
the instrument of Petrocan. The whole package was based on predictions that oil prices would continue to rise
over the next decade. In fact, they reversed, falling to $10 a barrel. Ottawa was left carrying the cost of subsidies to
oil-consuming industries with none of the revenue-stream that had been anticipated. Federal deficits grew and the
governments popularity shrank. Opposition in Alberta was ferocious: the mayor of Calgary, Ralph Klein, advo-

3. Kenneth Norrie and Douglas Owram, A History of the Canadian Economy (Toronto: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1991), 613.
 8.10 OIL AND GAS AND THE NEW WEST 423

cated turning off the pipelines and snarled, Let the Eastern bastards freeze in the dark! a sentiment that after-
wards appeared on bumper stickers across the West. The NEP stirred up a hornets nest of constitutional disputes,
did little to support energy self-sufficiency, plunged Ottawa into debt, and undermined the principle of equaliza-
tion payments. It did, however, raise the question of whether there might be a Canadian national interest and
determined the extent to which regional disparities in wealth and opportunities should be suffered or ameliorated.

Oil Sands
The existence of oil-saturated sands along the banks of the Athabasca River had been known about for centuries.
The tarry substance was used by First Nations to seal the hulls of their canoes long before the arrival of European
traders. Commercial exploitation of the oil sands was, however, extremely limited until the 1970s. Its first com-
mercial use was as a kind of asphalt road surface mined straight out of the ground. By the 1960s there were several
methods available to extract the oil from the sand, but they were prohibitively expensive. The oil shocks of the
1970s changed that equation.

Following the first OPEC crisis, various companies were in a position to begin a commercial scale separation of
oil and sand. At the forefront of these companies was Syncrude, which began production in 1978. The downturn
in global oil prices after 1981 reduced interest in the oil sands, but improved processes, and the rising oil prices
enabled Syncrude to increase production to 90 million barrels per year in 2001.

An insatiable demand for skilled and semi-skilled labour turned the neighbouring town of Fort McMurray into one
of the countrys fastest growing communities in the 1970s and 1980s. In 1961 there were fewer than 2,000 people
in the village, and by 1971 6,800; this latter number more than doubled in the next 5 years, and then doubled again
to 31,000 in 1981. It is currently reckoned to have a population of 77,000 at least one-fifth of which is non-
permanent. Criticism of the environmental implications of oil sands extraction, and the subsequent transportation
of bitumen, may have taken some of the shine off of the oil sands industry, but it has significantly extended the
prosperity of Alberta.

Historian Sean Kheraj (York University) investigates the history of pipeline failures and Canadians con-
nection with their energy sources.
424 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Over a Barrel
The two oil crises of the 1970s had several important consequences. First, they pitched Alberta into the spotlight
of national events and made a national figure of Peter Lougheed an articulate and thoughtful politician. Second,
they created significant tensions within Canadian federalism, increasing demands for decentralized authority
or, what was called at the time, centrifugal federalism. These crises also undermined the federal formula for
have and have-not provinces that was based on provincial per capita incomes and assumed that wealthy
provinces would necessarily have large populations (not the case, relatively speaking, in Alberta). National equity
programs were suddenly in jeopardy, which was felt sharply in the Maritimes.

For most Canadians, what mattered was how the oil crises changed their daily lives. Inflation almost unheard
of since the 1920s was back with a vengeance. The cost of shipping food products grew dramatically, as did
household food expenditures. For the first time since 1945, Canadians were experiencing, on a very broad scale,
a fall in their average standard of living.

There were technological and environmental consequences as well. Gas-guzzling North American automobiles
were being challenged by smaller, lighter Japanese imports. A whole new sector of the Canadian auto-industry
would eventually emerge, along with the development of redesigned North American vehicle engines. Efforts to
reduce gas consumption, and thus operating costs, was complemented by attempts to diversify energy sources.
Experiments involving nuclear, solar, and wind energy accelerated in these years, although to little effect.

The global context of the oil crises would be felt by Canadians for years. OPEC was regarded by governments in
Washington as mostly antithetical to Americas national strategic interests (oil) in the Middle East. What began
as a protest against American and European involvement in the Yom Kippur War a chapter in the Cold War
in which the USSR was supporting Egypt catalyzed anti-Western feeling. The toppling of the Shah of Iran in
1979 (which precipitated the second oil shock) had consequences for regional affairs that would percolate into the
1990s and the 21st century, drawing Canada into wars and interventions in Kuwait, Iraq, and Libya (see Sections
9.12 and 12.2).
 8.10 OIL AND GAS AND THE NEW WEST 425

Figure 8.16 Alberta Premier Peter Lougheed (centre) and Quebec

Premier Ren Lvesque had a common foe in Ottawa. At a 1981
meeting of premiers.

Finally, the rise of Alberta in the 1970s complemented by a strong British Columbian economy and the growth
of the natural gas, potash, and uranium sectors in Saskatchewan tipped the balance of power in Ottawa. The
election of Calgary Conservative, Joe Clark, as PM in 1979 was one indication, however brief, that the tide was
turning. The much more successful government of Brian Mulroney, from 1984 to 1993, depended heavily on
western alienation for its success. In addition, the appearance of Western separatist sentiment and the Reform
Party led by Preston Manning (son of the former Albertan Premier) had deep roots in the events of the 1970s.
Reform would go on to transform the Progressive Conservative party into the Conservative Party led by
Stephen Harper, another Calgarian (see Section 12.3). Ironically, Alberta became much more Canadian through
this process: the oil patch created jobs that attracted Canadians from every province. Indeed, Mr. Harper (born
and raised in Toronto) moved as a young man to Edmonton to take up a low-level office job at Imperial Oil before
moving on to the University of Calgary to study economics.

Key Points

The oil economy in Alberta took off in the 1940s and 1950s, and accelerated with the first OPEC oil
shock in the early 1970s.
Some of the effects of the oil boom included a dramatic shift from rural to urban life, and a rapid
increase in population in Calgary and Edmonton in particular.
Federal attempts to capture some of the windfall profits of the oil shocks in the 1970s provoked stri-
dent anti-Ottawa feeling in the West.
Rising oil prices brought within reach the development of the oil sands, extending for decades
Albertas oil-based prosperity.
The oil crises of the 1970s and 1980s had international repercussions, but most Canadians felt it in
their wallets, since inflation reduced household incomes significantly and rapidly.

Attributions
Figure 8.14
Leduc oil by Spanwar is used under a CC-BY-SA 2.0 license.

Figure 8.15
Filling drums with oil at Dingman Well (HS85-10-28964) by the British Library is in the public domain

Figure 8.16
426 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Peter Lougheed and Ren Lvesque (Online MIKAN no.3575754) by Robert Cooper / Library and Archives
Canada is in the public domain.
8.11 Fashioning a Post-War Economy

Figure 8.17 The path to happiness in the post-WWII era is paved

not with gold but with blacktop. Consumerism as an economic
growth strategy and a lifestyle is embodied in the family
automobile, such as the short-lived Ford Frontenac, 1960.

Probably no period in human history has witnessed such a concentrated attempt to plan and shape the national and
international economy as the years after 1944. In the middle of a devastating World War, Western, Allied govern-
ments met at Bretton Woods in New Hampshire to identify the tools necessary to rebuild the liberal democratic
and capitalist order, assuming they could beat the Axis Powers. The World Bank and the International Mone-
tary Fund (IMF) were two institutions that emerged from Bretton Woods and, along with the Marshall Plan (aka
the European Recovery Plan or ERP) in 1947, they were geared to restoring Europes economic health so to
avoid the kind of post-war turmoil that followed the Treaty of Versailles in 1919. As Soviet interest in participat-
ing in the ERP waned, these instruments of investment and recovery became imbued with a stronger ideological
hue that reflected the sentiments of the emerging Cold War (see Section 9.4). They were about providing legiti-
macy for capitalism and turning off the appeal of revolutionary movements in the post-war world.

Cold War Capitalism

These measures were important to Canada for several reasons. First, although Canada was one of the very few
strong economies left standing at the end of the war, it depended on exports to survive. The United States could
absorb only so much, so Western European markets were essential to a Canadian transition to peacetime prosper-
ity. Canada engaged directly in recovery efforts in Europe for this reason, while establishing a role in the North
Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) as an instrument for economic regeneration. The Canadian establishment
also understood that the appeal of communism in Canada was enhanced in the 1940s by the alliance with Stalins
USSR, the appearance of several new communist regimes in Eastern Europe and, in 1949, the Peoples Repub-
lic of China. The most effective case against hard-left dissent was high levels of employment, good wages, and
overall prosperity at home. Capitalism had to appear as though it was working. To that end, Canada had to strike
a balance between sending resources abroad to rebuild markets on the one hand, and investing in jobs at home on
the other. Thse two goals werent necessarily at odds: Canada sold billions of dollars worth of materials to the

427
 428 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Marshall Plan in the late 1940s, which was a stimulant to economic growth. Almost simultaneously, from 1949
to 1953, tensions and then war in the Korean Peninsula proved to be a fillip to both the Canadian economy and
anti-communist rhetoric (see Section 9.4).

More generally, Ottawa and the provinces began to intervene more actively in the economy. New infrastructural
projects appeared in these years as the shift to an automobile economy was more fully underway and the demand
for cheap electricity grew. Highways and hydroelectric dams were to the post-war era what railways had been to
the pre-1914 Dominion. These were the elements of the command-led practices of the past that survived, although
Canadian economic planners laid greater emphasis on demand-led (consumer-led) growth. Critical pieces of the
puzzle involved stabilizing industrial relations (considered by Peter McInnis in Section 8.12) and encouraging the
growth of a working-class with disposable income. Economists had observed the benefits of consumerism in the
1920s and, conversely, what the loss of spending power meant in the Depression. Investing public money to create
jobs a Keynesian approach worked during the war, and this strategy would be applied during the following
three decades.

As well see in Chapter 9, much of this economic growth took place in the suburbs of the nations largest cities.
The engine that would drive forward a post-war Canadian economy included house construction, the development
of services (sewer, electricity, telephone lines), the sale of automobiles for commuters (and gasoline, of course),
and the furnishing of every home with appliances and televisions (starting in the 1950s). As Katharine Rollwagen
describes below, this process enlisted people at an early age, consciously fashioning generations of consumers.

Youth and Consumerism

Katharine Rollwagen, Department of History, Vancouver Island University

Todays teen-agers are cuddled, coddled, and courted and their juvenile notions on love, life and the cosmos are
1
eagerly sought and retailed by some of their raisin-brained elders. Frank Tumpane

In the 1950s, many young people were coming of age in an era of relative abundance. Goods that families
couldnt afford in the 1930s and couldnt purchase in the 1940s due to wartime restrictions on production
were becoming more common. New consumer products, too, were entering the market. Between 1950 and
1960, homes in Canadian cities and towns acquired items such as automatic washing machines and elec-
tric refrigerators (rural homes often didnt have the electricity and plentiful running water these appliances
required). New automobiles were increasingly abundant and affordable. Televisions were growing in pop-
ularity; the children of the 1950s were the first to grow up with access to this medium, which brought
advertising into the home in a new and some believed invasive way.
Although young people had more products to purchase after the Second World War, they were not the first
generation to be targeted by advertisers and retailers. In the early decades of the century, advertisements
first began offering parents specialized infant foods and clothing. Manufactured toys increasingly replaced
homemade ones, and young people had more commercialized leisure options, such as the cinema. Many
store owners liked the idea that they might secure customer loyalty early in life. They offered special pro-
motions to draw young people into their stores, hoping to ensure their business as they aged.

1. Frank Tumpane, Stop Pampering Our Teenagers, Macleans, May 26, 1956, 4, 65-66.
 8.11 FASHIONING A POST-WAR ECONOMY 429

The 1940s presented a new opportunity for retailers to reach a somewhat captive audience of teenagers. As
my research demonstrates, department stores, in particular, noticed the increase in high school attendance
and paid more attention to the school-aged customers in their stores. Stores like Eatons and Simpsons
presented the teenager as a new type of customer. The teenaged customer was more mature than little sister
or brother she (or he) shopped without their mother, placed a high value on peer approval, and were
decisive, savvy shoppers. Both Eatons and Simpsons joined a North American industry trend by creating
teenager advisory boards in the 1940s. These groups of high school students met weekly at department
stores in Canadian cities to discuss current fashion trends in their schools and to give their opinions of store
merchandise clothing, music records, shoes, and even furniture. Also in the 1940s, clothing manufac-
turers began making garments in a new teen size range, and producing style lines specifically for teenaged
girls and boys.
In the 1940s and 1950s, womens magazines, such Canadian Home Journal, ran special teenager features
and advertising, while Chatelaine started a monthly teen column called Teen Tempo. By the time Chate-
laine publishers decided to start their own magazine for teenaged girls in 1966, Miss Chatelaine, Canadian
girls had already been reading American teen magazines Seventeen and Young and Modern (also known as
YM) for twenty years, and purchasing (or coveting) the products sold in their glossy pages. At mid-century,
selling to youth had become an integral part of retail business in Canada.

Additional Readings

Owram, Doug. Born at the Right Time: A History of the Baby-Boom Generation. Toronto: University of
Toronto Press, 1996.
Rollwagen, Katharine. Eatons Goes to School: Youth Councils and the Commodification of the
Teenaged Consumer at Canadas Largest Department Store, 1940-1960. Histoire Sociale/Social His-
tory 47, no. 95 (2014): 683-703.

By the mid-1950s, the Canadian economy was well into a new industrial revolution during which consumer
durables intersected with popular culture. It was also when success was, for the first time since 1867, measured
less against the benchmark of the United States (although that persisted as well) and more against Cold War ene-
mies in the Soviet Bloc. The fact that this was political as well as economic is evident in the uneven division
of spoils across Canada in the post-War years. Economic growth took place principally in Ontario and Quebec,
Alberta, and British Columbia; the Prairie economies of Manitoba and Saskatchewan struggled, as did those of
Atlantic Canada (the subject of Section 8.13). These have-not provinces benefited from equalization payments
but continued to lag behind for decades. The fact that the post-war prosperity was not universally shared is further
underlined by the experiences of Aboriginal peoples (see Chapter 11).

Key Points

The post-WWII economy was built on renewed public sector investment in infrastructure and other
measures designed to stimulate the growth of consumer demand.
Internationally, Canada was part of a project to rebuild the European economy and markets for
Canadian exports, while keeping communism at bay.
430 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Much of the growth in domestic demand came from suburban growth and the creation of a culture of
consumerism among adults and children.

Attributions
Figure 8.17
1960 Frontenac Station Wagon (Canada) by Michael is used under a CC-BY-NC-SA-2.0 license.
8.12 The Postwar Settlement in Canada

PETER MCINNIS, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, ST. FRANCIS XAVIER UNIVERSITY

Canadian workers have long struggled to achieve improved job and living conditions for themselves and their
families. Most efforts to organize unions faced the combined might of employers and the state, and the resulting
discord often led to harsh repression and violence. Traditionally, only the most highly skilled craftsmen had oppor-
tunities to influence their working environment through collective action. Leverage was achieved, however, by
ensuring that the trade unions were inherently exclusive and limited only to those with specific training often
excluding racialized and gendered minorities. This rudimentary system of union organization functioned with lim-
ited success, but during times of economic downturn or overt oppression from employers and governments, these
early trade unions declined.

With the outbreak of the Second World War, Canada was forced to initiate a massive program of military expan-
sion to contribute to the Allied cause. A vital aspect of this project was enticing new workers to cooperatively
join in this rapid industrialization. The accelerated economic transition was especially challenging as the ten lost
years of the Great Depression had left Canadas industrial sector in disarray. In Ottawa, the Liberal government
of William Lyon Mackenzie King, equipped with extraordinary authority under the War Measures Act and fol-
lowing the lead of earlier American legislation, introduced a series of measures to spur wartime industrial growth.
One such measure was Privy Council Order PC 1003 (1944) that, for the first time, allowed unions to engage in
widespread organization and bargain collectively for job contracts. This change was advantageous to the many
workers drawn to wartime jobs and seeking representation from new unions (modelled on the concept of large
sectorial or industrial unions) that brought together members regardless of skill levels. As the numbers of unions
and union members increased exponentially, organized labour quickly assumed a higher profile in public deliber-
ations.

After the victory over Nazi Germany looked certain, the federal government started to scale down its war-related
industrialization. Wartime labour protections, such as PC 1003, were thus scheduled to end. The question before
many Canadians was whether unions would be once again forced to struggle (or even lose ground) to retain the
gains they had achieved during the war. In the immediate postwar period, many Canadians spoke of a desire
for a reformed nation that embraced greater fairness for all its citizens. Aware of this debate, most political par-
ties veered toward satisfying this progressive mood, whereas others sought to retrench conservative values. This
volatile atmosphere shaped the framing of the postwar settlement.

431
 432 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

An important strike in late 1945 at the Ford Motor Company in Windsor, Ontario resulted in a landmark legal
ruling by Mr. Justice Ivan C. Rand. The Rand Formula (1946) provided unions with a pathway to gain legit-
imacy and long-term stability if, but only if, they agreed to conduct themselves responsibly. In exchange for
receiving obligatory union dues (the check-off), labour groups promised to take charge of their membership and
1
ensure worker militancy was regulated strictly. For the most part unions were amenable to play by the rules of
the game and balance their rights against a set of procedures and obligations. This agreement was the foundation
of the postwar settlement, since it set out the semi-formal accord between labour, business, and the state to secure
workplace harmony in the years following the end of the Second World War. Workplace discord, in the form of
strikes and lockouts, continued sporadically during the 1940s-1950s, but labours postwar settlement appeared to
have achieved a decisive compromise between organized labour and business.

In the broader context, this postwar settlement also involved the widespread public consensus that Canada ought
to develop a mixed economy under the auspices of Keynesian economics and the introduction of a limited welfare
state. The achievement of unemployment insurance, child benefits, pension reforms, and publicly-funded health-
care were indicative of this expansive civil society, which invited unions to play an ongoing part in Canadian
society. This approach was in stark contrast to the rightward shift in the United States, where stridently anti-labour
legislation sought to curtail the growing power of unions.

Canadian unions, wary of invoking a conservative backlash, were careful to reinforce their hard-won legitimacy
by adhering to the federal and provincial labour regulations that made spontaneous, mid-contract wildcat strikes
illegal. This pragmatic stance alienated some of the more seasoned workers whose Depression-era experiences
taught them to use unions as a springboard to achieve far-reaching social reforms. This regime of bureaucratic
industrial legality may have also excluded recent converts to unionization who resented a top-down labour hier-
archy. Throughout the 1960s, a series of protracted wildcat strikes in both the public and private sectors led to a
2
formal inquiry the Task Force on Labour Relations (1968). This inquiry marked the beginning of a plan to
3
reset the initial terms of the postwar settlement, described by a some as the shift from consent to coercion. By
the 1970s, Canada was facing the dilemma of stagflation stagnant economic growth coupled with persistently
high rates of inflation. Limits applied to global petroleum production resulted in several oil shocks that shook
the confidence of many Western nations. Governments at all levels were under intense political pressure to reign
in unruly unions and redistribute the balance of power to employers and the state. The postwar settlement, along
with some components of the welfare state, started to unravel.

In the decades following the initial economic crisis of the 1970s, both governments and employers have acted to
limit the fundamental rights of unions to organize, negotiate collective agreements, and when necessary, strike
to compel a resolution to an impasse. Increasingly, unions have been forced to accept harsh concessions or have
been driven into dissolution. The postwar settlement as an expression of expanded workplace activism, and the
engagement of labour as a progressive force in Canadian society have been undermined and eroded consistently,
which has continued into our contemporary era under the mantra of neo-liberal austerity. Despite this, the accord,
remarkably, remains influential in its broadest contours and continues to exert a working-class perspective in the
ongoing campaign for a fair and equitable Canadian society.

1. Peter S. McInnis, Harnessing Labour Confrontation: Shaping the Postwar Settlement in Canada, 1943-1950 (Toronto: University of Toronto
Press, 2002).
2. Stuart Marshall Jamieson, Times of Trouble: Labour Unrest and Industrial Conflict, 1900-1966 (Ottawa: Task Force on Labour Relations,
1968), 395-451.
3. Leo Panitch and Donald Swartz, From Consent to Coercion: The Assault on Trade Union Freedoms, 3rd ed. (Aurora, ON: Garamond, 2003).
 8.12 THE POSTWAR SETTLEMENT IN CANADA 433

Key Points

Wartime demands led to PC 1003, which stimulated the growth and influence of unions. The return
of peace raised fears that the new rights enjoyed by organized labour would be withdrawn.
In 1946 the Rand Formula staked out a new relationship between labour, capital, and government,
which confirmed a post-war settlement that stabilized industrial relations.
This post-war settlement also entailed greater state interventionism and the establishment of a wel-
fare state.
By the 1970s economic and industrial conditions had changed and there was increasing pressure on
the state to regulate labour. Although some elements of the post-war settlement were abandoned,
others survived.
 8.13 The Atlantic Provinces

Figure 8.18 The cod fishery was central to

Newfoundlands economy for centuries, ca. 1941-44.

History has not been kind to the Maritimes. The liberal, progressive vision of an environment in which men and
women would be freed from arbitrary government (and thus able to better pursue their fortunes and best interests)
didnt play out as hoped. In the case of Nova Scotia, historians Ian McKay and Robin Bates have pointed to the
provinces frustratingly non-linear history:

[Nova Scotias] nineteenth-century enlightenment did not (at least by most conventional measures) eventuate in a twen-
tieth-century liberal society of contented and prosperous individuals, but in a de-industrializing province scarred by mass
1
unemployment, poverty and out-migration.

Even so, in the 20th century, Nova Scotia was the most successful of the Maritime provinces. The addition of
Newfoundland in 1949 to what was thereafter the Atlantic Provinces did nothing to change that. It just meant
there was one more province going to Ottawa with cap in hand.

Structural Traps
Early 20th century changes in the Atlantic Rim economy took a heavy toll on the Maritimes and Newfoundland.
The decline in shipping using wooden ships was compounded by falling markets for (and retreating sources of)
lumber. The regions traditional sources of trade were simultaneously undergoing change. The West Indies were
not the source of cane sugar and rum that they once were, having been overtaken by sugar beet production in
the United States, Canada, and Continental Europe, and the opening of distilleries closer to markets. With less
to trade, the Maritime connection with Britains Caribbean colonies declined. Other changes in the marketplace
worked against the Atlantic provinces as well, the foremost of which was the opening of the Panama Canal. British
Columbian (and American West Coast) timber, paper products, and tinned salmon could now reach the major mar-

1. Ian McKay and Robin Bates, In the Province of History: The Making of the Public Past in Twentieth-Century Nova Scotia (Montral and Kingston: McGill-
Queens University Press, 2010), 40.

434
 8.13 THE ATLANTIC PROVINCES 435

kets of the American East Coast more directly, faster, and cheaper than they could by rail via Montreal, Moncton,
and Halifax. Even the Annapolis Valley apple industry was affected: with very good sales to Britain after the war,
local producers saw no reason to diversify their crop away from an inexpensive but not very versatile variety; the
arrival of Okanagan species along with other competitors hard fruits forced the Maritime orchardists to undertake
an expensive and time-consuming readjustment, which involved tearing out older trees and replacing them with
newer varieties.

The Great War provided a boost to the regional economy, but it sank severely thereafter. British demand for fish
sagged, as it did in other markets; worse news, some Scandinavian countries were making headway into tradi-
tional markets for Maritime fish. Newfoundland fleets kept their costs razor thin (possibly to their own detriment)
and thereby outcompeted their Maritime rivals for a while. Then, in 1921, the Americans established a tariff on
imported fish. There was some recovery in the fisheries in the two decades that followed, particularly in the fresh
fish market, but this can be read as a bad sign: American buyers were scooping up Atlantic region fresh fish for
packing purposes. Processing and canning opportunities were thus being exported to the States, as Maritimers and
Newfoundlanders failed to build the forward linkages of canneries and packing houses.

Nova Scotias industrial leadership in coal and steel production also began to suffer after the Great War. Demand
for steel was down in peacetime; there was a postwar surplus of shipping capacity, and the railroad-building sector
on which the industry was founded was no longer crying out for rails and rolling stock. Jobs in the sector fell
2
by 85% between 1919 and 1921. Coal output shrank as a consequence, and was further hit by competition from
natural gas and oil as home-heating fuels, and by electricity as a fuel for lighting. Employment levels in Cape Bre-
tons industrial hubs began a long-term decline, which affected the province and the Atlantic region as a whole.

Figure 8.19 Pit pony and miner in a coalmine at New

Aberdeen, Nova Scotia, ca. 1949.

A large part of the Atlantic economic crisis was structural. The industrial economy of Nova Scotia was geared
toward large corporate consumers during wartime, such as railways and government. This was much closer to a
command-led than a demand-led economy. The same could be said of the fisheries that produced tons of mate-
rial purchased for processing elsewhere. Local urban markets were very small compared to the many cities of
central Canada. Even Halifax, hit hard by the 1917 harbour explosion, slipped out of the list of the top 10 largest
cities in 1921. Thus, local demand for manufactured consumer goods was negligible, and shipping costs to central
Canadian markets (especially in the face of iniquitous freight rates) made a transition to consumer manufacturing
nonviable without subsidy.

Regional sentiment also was bitter at the apparent advantages Ontario and Quebec had horded for themselves. By
annexing large chunks of what had been Ruperts Land, the two provinces achieved their current shape and access
to a multitude of natural resources. Likewise Manitoba and the two new prairie provinces had been gifted with

2. Margaret R. Conrad and James K. Hiller, Atlantic Canada: A Concise History (Don Mills, ON: Oxford University Press, 2006), 165.
436 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

large chunks of the North West Territories. Nothing similar came the way of the Maritimers who were obliged to
work with the resources they had to hand in 1867.

As their options narrowed, so did their strategies for recovery. Workers in Cape Breton waited for mine owners
to improve their conditions, for markets to recover, and for governments to intervene. None of those prospects
was likely in the 1920s, and especially not likely in the 1930s. Weakened before 1929, the regional economy was
crippled by the Depression.

Silver Lining

One bright spot in the region was the silver fox fur industry in Prince Edward Island. Beginning in the
1890s, the raising and processing of captive foxes made fortunes for some in PEI and provided small farm-
ers with the means to survive the Depression. Sales were divided between American urban markets and all
of Western Europe. The outbreak of war, however, closed the European option, and wartime austerity took
a bite out of North American demand. Subsequent changes in fashions meant that the fox industry never
fully recovered.

Figure 8.20 The so-called silver rush in PEI had nothing to do

with minerals or mining. The fur trade had become part of the
farm sector.

A fleeting but vocal Maritime Rights movement caught on in the interwar years, but resulted in few concessions
from Ottawa. As chance would have it, the prime minister in the earliest and worst years of the Depression was
R.B. Bennett, a native of New Brunswick. He may have been more sympathetic to the Maritimes plight than Lib-
eral leader Mackenzie King, or at least he understood the language of the regional economy. Incremental improve-
ments in Atlantic heavy industry could be seen, but this recovery was from a very deep nadir. The election of
Kings Liberals in 1935 did little to change matters significantly before the return of war.

Wartime, Boomtime
As was the case elsewhere, the Second World War brought a return to prosperity. Or at least relative prosperity.

Demand for steel and iron increased dramatically. Ship construction grew at a startling rate, and Maritime ship-
yards struggled to meet the need for supply. Naval vessels and convoy ships were being sent to the bottom of the
Atlantic by German submarines and had to be quickly replaced. Even agriculture recovered nicely in this com-
mand-led economy, as did the federal government-sponsored efforts to industrialize food processing. However,
the coal sector did not recover fully, and Cape Breton remained the site of conflict between miners and owners
interests, despite federal intervention. The presence of military personnel in the region in huge numbers was
another economic driver. Army, air force, and naval demand for services and resources provided rare opportuni-
ties for Atlantic Canadians. It also strained relations between locals and troops when they were in competition
for basic resources like water and food. Those tensions boiled over in Halifax when Victory in Europe Day (VE-
 8.13 THE ATLANTIC PROVINCES 437

Day) celebrations turned into riots. Some of the 18,000 naval personnel stationed in the city looted liquor outlets
and smashed store windows while scuffles broke out and civilians took advantage of the confusion to stock up on
shoes and clothing.

Watch this V.E. Day Riots in Halifax, Nova Scotia film without narration to see Haligonian crowds behav-
ing badly.

The Rowell-Sirois Royal Commission on Dominion-Provincial Relations reported, in 1940, that greater efforts
were needed to rebuild and redirect the Maritime economy. The outbreak of war put those recommendations to
one side, although there was widespread acknowledgement that the WWII wartime prosperity (as in WWI) would
not survive the peace. To avoid a return to desperate times, the federal government introduced a package of ini-
tiatives, which would not have been conceivable in the political climate of the 1920s or 1930s. What had changed
was this: Keynesian economic principles had found widespread support in Canada. Conventional economic wis-
dom had argued against deficit spending and relief to unemployed Canadians, but the 1930s and the Second World
War obliged political leaders to consider a more activist role for government.

There was hope in the Maritimes that this new enhanced role for Ottawa would include transfer payments,
improved social welfare grants, and investment in economic stability, if not growth. The relative position of the
region was poor by many measures. Despite a greater density of universities than any other part of Canada, pri-
mary and secondary education facilities were poor, school completion was low, and literacy levels were dragging
down the national average. There were, for example, believed to be 473 schools on PEI, 405 of which were single-
3
room schoolhouses, and 69 of which were in terrible condition. Unemployment rates in the Post-War era were
consistently higher in the Maritimes than in any other region. The outmigration of younger people meant that the
demographic aging of the remaining population was accelerating. Infrastructure was underdeveloped in much of
the rest of the country, but there were no plans in the Maritimes to change that situation, and certainly no means to
do so. In short, per capita incomes, education, opportunities, and security were all grossly uneven across Canada
and consistently the worst in the East. Measured by virtually any standard of living or quality of life indicator,
the Atlantic region fell significantly below any national average.

Addressing Regional Disparities

Two things changed the economic prospects of the region from the mid-1950s (which now included the new
province of Newfoundland). The first was the economic boom that Canada as a whole was enjoying in the Post-
War era. The Ottawa treasury was in a good position to fund programs that might alleviate the worst problems in
the East, and perhaps set some of the economy on an even keel. Regional equalization programs appeared first
in 1956. An Atlantic Development Board (ADB) followed in 1962 under Diefenbaker and continued under Pear-
son. It invested $188 million before being subsumed within the Department of Regional Economic Expansion
(DREE) under Pierre Trudeau in 1969. From a Maritimes perspective, Trudeaus initiative started strongly, but it
was quickly sucked under the wheels of counter-separatist politics in Quebec. From a high of 51% of DREEs

3. Ibid., 187.
 438 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

expenditures in 1969-1970, the Atlantic Provinces share fell to 38% by 1973-1974. Quebecs share rose in the
4
same period from 12 to 39%.

Second, the Atlantic provinces were responding, mustering, and presenting their case more effectively. The
Atlantic Provinces Economic Council (APEC), established in 1954, was led by non-partisan, and largely private,
individuals (that is, not politicians). The APEC coordinated much of the information and argument behind a more
comprehensive and strategic approach to remedying the regions continuing malaise. East Coast politicians fol-
lowed APECs lead and mounted what has been described as the Atlantic Revolution. What changed the most
in this regard was the tenor and effectiveness of political lobbying, although economic performance measured by
GDP barely budged.

There was, to be sure, new investment in the regional economy. Hydroelectricity projects were the main target
of the ADB and DREE grants, including the massive Churchill Falls Dam in Labrador (which opened with much
promise but was instantly locked into a money-losing contract with Quebec). The principal problem was that the
economic strategy was backward-looking: with the exception of pulp and paper mills, most of the growth took
place in 19th century sectors like mining, fishing, agriculture, and lumber. Tourism was the exception, the one
newish sector that became increasingly important. There was change as well in the farming sector, which was
marked by a trend toward consolidation, as smaller and less financially viable operations were sold to make way
for larger and more mechanized properties. Something similar was happening across Newfoundland as resettle-
ment initiatives resulted in the depopulation (and effective extinction) of about 300 small and marginal outports
between the 1950s and the 1980s.

Watch this Townships Moved By Sea video to see how the resettlement initiatives involved the physical
relocation of houses and roughly 30,000 people.

Larger centres were thought more capable of meeting community needs than the small and isolated outports. As
well, the shrinkage of the inshore fisheries meant a reorientation toward offshore resources, which were tapped by
larger fleets operating out of bigger ports. Similar moves were taking place in Labrador as the Moravian missions
consolidated their work with the Inuit. Formal relocation programs ended in the mid-1970s (and there has since
been a small but significant reversal of this migration).

Diversification
In the 1960s and 1970s, Nova Scotia enjoyed something like a surge in industrial diversification. French tire man-
ufacturer Michelin set up works in Granton, near New Glasgow, and expanded production in the late 1970s against
a backdrop of labour relations controversy. Swedish automobile-maker Volvo opened an assembly plant in Dart-
mouth, and began production in 1963. This initiative depended heavily on provincial and federal subsidies, which
provoked a diplomatic and legal battle with the United States as a consequence. Nevertheless, Volvo remained a
5
small but significant part of the regional economy until the late 1990s.

4. Donald J. Savoie, Pulling Against Gravity: Economic Development in New Brunswick During the McKenna Years (Montreal: Institute for
Research in Public Policy, 2001), 49.
5. Dimitry Anastakis, Building a New Nova Scotia: State Intervention, the Auto Industry and the Case of Volvo in Canada, Acadiensis, 34,
no.1 (2004), 3-30.
 8.13 THE ATLANTIC PROVINCES 439

Another attempt at secondary manufacturing came in the early 1970s when a safety sports car aimed at a spe-
cialty market was built in a disused shoe factory in Saint John, New Brunswick. The Bricklin suffered from many
design and manufacturing problems, and it failed to make the necessary breakthrough into the American market.
The plant closed in 1976. The fate of the Bricklin was echoed in several other regional attempts to build man-
ufacturing capacity. These failures drew a great deal of media attention and criticism, but it was the continuing
troubles of the coal mining and steel industries that imparted the most instability to the regional economy.

Newfoundland suffered similar bad luck. An oil refinery opened at Come By Chance in 1971 and closed a little
over two years later due to bankruptcy, despite heavy federal and provincial subsidies. The province seemed to
catch a break in the late 1970s, however, with the discovery of oil in the Hibernia Field, 300 km southeast of
St. Johns on the Grand Banks. Offshore oil exploration had been underway since the 1960s, but it took two oil
shocks in the 1970s to make development economically viable. Production would not come online, though, until
1997. In between, efforts to map the field were underway, one of which ended in disaster. In the early hours of
15 February 1982, a drilling platform the Ocean Ranger capsized in high seas, resulting in the death of all
84 personnel on board. The findings of a subsequent Royal Commission inquiry into the tragedy were damning
as regards personnel training, safety measures, and vessel design. A 20 million dollar legal settlement followed,
as did an overhaul of safety practices in the sector. (This event has been the subject of at least two films and a
novel, February, by St. Johns writer Lisa Moore in 2009.) Efforts by Newfoundland Premier Brian Peckford to
establish exclusive provincial control over offshore resources failed a 1984 test at the Supreme Court, although
some ground was regained the next year in the Atlantic Accord. The Come By Chance refinery reopened two
years after, a sign of things to come.

Prince Edward Islands economy diversified in the post-war era, but the gains it made were initially very small.
Fox farming collapsed and potato farms dominated the agricultural sector. Although PEI came to lead the potato
market in Canada, capturing as much as one-quarter of annual production, this is a high volume and low value
crop, exactly the opposite of the fur industry. Reflecting the limited opportunities available in the province, the
Islander population failed to grow at a rate comparable to the rest of the country; in fact, it fell from a high point of
109,000 in 1891 to a low of 88,038 in 1931, and recovered slowly through to the late 1960s. Two sectors showed
some improvement in the 1950s, and have come to define much of the shape of the PEI economy. The first is the
lobster fishery. Lobster meat had to overcome several obstacles to achieve a significant market value, not the least
of which was its reputation as poor peoples food. Canned lobster was sold in a variety of markets into the inter-
war era until the shipment of live lobster to major American urban markets elevated it to the status of a luxury
food. The economic downturn of the 1930s impacted the lobster fisheries, but the industry recovered in the 1940s
with the availability of more regular air and sea shipment, and advances in refrigeration. Starting in the 1960s, the
6
value of lobster output doubled every 10 years; from 1980 to 2000 it doubled every five years.

The other sector to experience revolutionary change in PEI was tourism. Many factors were involved but perhaps
the most important and enduring was the success in Japan of Lucy Maud Montgomerys novel Ann of Green
Gables. Adopted as part of the school curriculum in 1952, the book spawned a globe-straddling tourist industry.
An improved car-ferry infrastructure was a further and related advantage in the tourism sector so much so that
three new vessels, running from 1969 to 1997, were named the Lucy Maud Montgomery, the Holiday Island, and
Vacationland. The fleet was effectively replaced in 1998 by the opening of the Confederation Bridge, connecting

6. Della Stanley, The 1960s: The Illusions and Realities of Progress in The Atlantic Provinces in Confederation, eds. E.R. Forbes and D. A.
Muise (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1991): 421-459.
440 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

PEI to New Brunswick. However, none of these developments did much to alleviate PEIs relative poverty com-
pared to the other provinces of Canada. At the end of the Cold War, the Canadian Air Force abandoned bases on
the Island and these facilities were subsequently exploited by a growing aerospace industry which now claims to
have captured a quarter of the value of all exports from PEI. Given the low baseline for exports and the promi-
nence of spuds in that equation, this may not yet constitute a full-blown economic transformation.

The Atlantic region as a whole suffered through turmoil and loss in the fisheries. Although Canada in the 1960s
and 1970s finally began to define and patrol its national boundaries at sea some 340 km from shore the
cod fisheries was already in trouble. Over-harvesting had been underway since the 1950s, and it was believed
that a larger Canadian zone would enable conservationist measures to take hold. Instead, foreign competition was
replaced by Canadian over-fishing; Canadians were now using larger and more lethally efficient trawlers. A brief
collapse in cod numbers in the mid-1970s was followed by a sharp recovery, leading some authorities and fish-
eries into overestimating the ability of cod to rebuild its numbers. In 1992 the cod population utterly collapsed.
The fishery was closed for what was intended to be two seasons to allow for a recovery, but that turnaround did
not occur and still has not occurred to date.

Figure 8.21 Capture of the Atlantic northwest cod stock in

million tonnes, with Canadian capture in blue.

The impact on the Newfoundland economy in particular was disastrous. In excess of 35,000 people worked in the
fisheries and processing; it was the largest sector in the economy, and the source of much local culture and iden-
tity. The population peaked in 1991 at 586,000, and by 2005, more than 80,000 had moved away, many of them
heading to the oil patch of northern Alberta. The cod fisheries crisis and the shift to the crab and shrimp fisheries
continues to affect the Atlantic region.

Although the federal government made repeated commitments in the post-WWII era to the idea of regional devel-
opment, equalization payments, and diversification, its track record has not been very good. An acknowledgement
was made in the 1940s that the three Maritime provinces had suffered from discriminatory freight rates and the
westward focus of the National Policy. Ottawa began to act on the need to compensate for the disadvantages the
region had suffered, and under Diefenbaker (who was, significantly, a Westerner with influential support in the
Maritimes), steps were taken to strategically change the situation. Even after the political centre of gravity shifted
back to central Canada under Pierre Trudeau, the Liberal ideal of mitigating what were called regional disparities
enjoyed support. By the 1980s, however, Quebec separatism and increasing signs of trouble in the manufactur-
ing heartland of Ontario changed the rhetoric and reality of regional economic development. Ottawa concluded
prematurely that the West and the East were rising on a tide of oil revenues and that the federal focus needed
to be on Ontario and Quebec. It cannot be said, therefore, that the Atlantic region enjoyed so much as a sin-
gle generation of sustained support of the measures designed to retool, redirect, and repurpose the four Atlantic
provinces economies.
 8.13 THE ATLANTIC PROVINCES 441

Key Points

The Maritime provinces and Newfoundland struggled against external economic factors in the first
half of the century, including the loss of markets, technological change, and reorganization of the
modern economy.
Although almost all other provinces directly benefited from the Canadian capture and disbursement
of Ruperts Land, the Atlantic provinces did not.
WWII economic growth did not outlast the war, and demands were made for equalization or transfer
payments.
Outmigration from the region was made easier in the second half of the 20th century, which drained
off a workforce and taxbase.
Active efforts to reposition the Atlantic regions economy and to achieve greater equity in Confeder-
ation met with limited successes and some prominent failures (including the Bricklin project).
Newfoundlands foray into oil production did not begin to produce significant returns until the late
1990s.
Tourism became an important sector in the region as a whole, but was not large enough to offset
major losses in the fisheries.
Changes in national politics and in the manufacturing heartland of Central Canada in the 1970s and
1980s served to postpone further a coordinated response to Atlantic Canadas economic shortcom-
ings.

Attributions
Figure 8.18
Codfish, Newfoundland currency [philatelic record]. Philatelic issue data
Newfoundland : 1 cent. Date of issue between 1941 and 1944 (Online MIKAN no.2256000) by Library and
Archives Canada / Canada Post Corporation is used under the Conditions of access 90: Open access code.

Figure 8.19
Pit pony and miner in a mine in New Aberdeen / Poney et mineur dans une mine de New Aberdeen (Online
MIKAN no.3373531) by National Film Board of Canada/ John F. Mailer. Photothque / Library and Archives
Canada / PA-116676 is in the public domain.

Figure 8.20
Blue fox ranch, Montague, Prince Edward Island (Online MIKAN no.3259598) by Canada. Patent and Copy-
right Office / Library and Archives Canada / PA-030116 is in the public domain.

Figure 8.21
Time series for collapse of Atlantic northwest cod by Epipelagic is used under a CC-BY-SA 3.0 license.
8.14 Economic Nationalism

DOUG OWRAM, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA - OKANAGAN

Relatively speaking, Canada came out of the Second World War in good shape. It was able, over the next few
years, to absorb the wartime debt, convert its economy to peacetime production, and set the stage for nearly three
decades of prosperity.

Figure 8.22 In 1907 foreign investment in Canada equalled

British and American (direct and indirect) investment. By
mid-century the implications of an economy that was largely
foreign-owned were a growing concern.

However, there was a problem. Throughout much of its history, Canada sought to maintain political and economic
autonomy by balancing the overwhelming influences of its two most influential trading partners and cultural influ-
ences, Great Britain and the United States. The so-called North Atlantic triangle prevented Canada from being
pulled exclusively into the orbit of either of the much larger powers around it.

By the post-war years, that equilibrium was failing. Britain, already weakened by the First World War, left the
Second World War mired in debt and challenged by an obsolete manufacturing base. In contrast, the United States
was indisputably the worlds greatest economic and military power the first superpower. By the 1950s, two-
thirds of Canadas exports and imports were with the United States. Even more dramatically, more than three
quarters of all foreign capital invested in Canada came from south of the border. When such economic dominance
was compounded by the influence of Hollywood, American magazines, radio, and the emerging medium of tele-
vision, many worried as did Canadas foremost economist, Harold Innis that we had gone from colony to
nation to colony. Thus, economic policy in these years was inseparable from wider fears about Canadian identity.

442
 8.14 ECONOMIC NATIONALISM 443

Table 8.1 Foreign Long Term Capital invested in Canada (%)

Decade UK USA

1926 44% 53%

1945 25% 70%

1055 18% 70%

Data source: Canada. Domestic Saving and Foreign Investment in Canada. Royal Commission on Canadas Economic
Prospects, Final Report (Ottawa, ON: Queens Printer, 1958). Table 18.2, 381.

Over the next 20 years, Canadians wrestled with how to manage a relationship with an ally, economic powerhouse,
and dominant neighbour. For all political parties, Canadian nationalism and American influence became a signif-
icant and often contentious issue.

Traditionally, it was the Conservative party that had stood as the primary defender of the British connection and
opponent of excessive American influence. The pattern seemed to continue when, in 1957, John Diefenbaker
defeated the long-reigning Liberal party, to some extent, on the question of undue American influence in the build-
ing of a trans-Canada oil pipeline. However, old traditions were hard to maintain in the new world of the Ameri-
can superpower.

For the six years they were in power, the Conservatives tried various strategies. The first approach was both the
most traditional and the most unrealistic. The Conservatives sought, in various ways, to strengthen British trade
as a means to counter-balance American influence. Diefenbaker talked of diverting 15% of trade to Britain, but
he had no idea how to carry it through. Britains economic clout was no longer anything near that of the United
States. Second, the power that Britain retained was increasingly oriented to the European continent a direction
that would eventually lead Britain into the European economic zone. By 1963, the year the Conservatives left
office, British trade with Canada was lower in percentage than it had been in 1957.

The second approach to counteracting American influence was to try to develop internal measures that would
decrease the American presence. Drawing on John A Macdonalds vision for the west, Diefenbaker called for
Canadians to invest in the North. Through programs such as Roads to Resources, the government sought to
create the necessary infrastructure. Moreover, as the North was a territory not a province, the federal government
had a freer hand. In 1960 oil and gas regulations sought to limit outside influence. In the end, though, the north-
ern economic strategy remained more vision than substance, and investment patterns were not altered. American
multi-nationals still dominated key Canadian sectors like energy. Overall, during these years, American foreign
investment in Canada increased by around 30%, whereas British investment in Canada remained stagnant.

When the Liberals returned to power in 1963, they did so in part because of Canadians unease with Diefenbakers
policies toward America though more related to defense than trade. The message conveyed during the election
campaign by the new Prime Minister Lester Pearson (1897-1972), was to work for better relations with the United
States. Everything, therefore, seemed to point to less economic nationalism. Certainly, there were tendencies in
that direction, most importantly the 1965 Automotive Products Agreement (known as the Auto Pact) that created
a formidable North American market for Canadian-made autos and auto parts. The message seemed clear: co-
operation created jobs, even if the companies were American controlled.

Nationalism had not disappeared, however. On the right, Diefenbaker remained leader of the opposition, con-
444 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

demning the Liberals for abandoning British ties and selling out to American interests. On the left, the old CCF
party had transformed into the more urban and nationalistic New Democratic Party (NDP). American Cold War
policy, especially in Vietnam, made the NDP suspicious of the United States influence over any part of Canadian
life. In the increasingly restive mood of the 1960s, therefore, the Liberals were aware they had to watch pressures
from nationalism on the left and right.

Not all the pressure was external to the Liberal party. Walter Gordon, Pearsons Finance Minister, had chaired the
1955-1957 Royal Commission on Canadas Economic Prospects that raised questions about foreign ownership. In
his first budget, he moved on his concerns by instituting various measures, including a 30% takeover tax on for-
eigners buying control of a Canadian company. The reaction from business was immediate and harsh, and Gordon
had to retreat. Nonetheless, as Finance Minister until 1965, Gordon continued to propose nationalist measures.
Even after leaving the cabinet, he was able to use his influence to help establish a new study of foreign invest-
ment, led by economist (and NDP co-founder) Mel Watkins.

The findings of Watkins Task Force on Foreign Ownership and the Structure of Canadian Investment were even
more alarmist than Gordons study a decade earlier. The NDP embraced the Watkins Report (1968) and faced an
internal battle as elements within the party, known as the Waffle movement, took an even more radical position
in the following year by condemning American imperialism in all its forms. The extreme political rhetoric of the
later 1960s and early 1970s kept the issue before the public, while maintaining pressure on the governing Liberals
to take at least some action.

In response to both internal and external pressure, the Liberals under Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau took two
concrete steps. The first was the Canada Development Corporation (CDC), designed in 1971 to help increase
Canadian investment in Canadian companies. The second arrived in 1973 in the form of the Foreign Investment
Review Agency (FIRA), which gave government the power to review and possibly prevent a foreign takeover of
a Canadian company.

Although FIRA and the CDC remained on the books until the mid-1980s, the fact is that the high level of concern
about foreign investment was already waning. An economic recession in 1973 suddenly made new money more
attractive, whatever the source. The NDP expelled the Waffle movement in 1972 and, exhausted by its inter-
nal battles, turned increasingly toward a more domestic and less divisive focus. As for the Conservatives, John
Diefenbaker had been forced out in 1967, and the partys stance was morphing into a more pro-American one.
This shift would culminate in a major free trade agreement with the United States in 1988, crafted by Tory Prime
Minister Brian Mulroney.

Of course Canadian concern about American dominance will always be a part of our national landscape. However,
growing markets in Europe and Asia and growing pools of investment capital at home mean that viewed from
the perspective of the present the period from the 1950s through to the early 1970s stand out as a particularly
volatile era in Canadian economic nationalism.
 8.14 ECONOMIC NATIONALISM 445

Key Points

Canadas post-WWII economic recovery depended largely on transferring export dependence on

Britain to the United States.
It also involved accepting and encouraging American dominance in foreign capital investment.
Strategies to counter American influence in the Canadian economy included Roads to Resources,
tariff arrangements like the Auto Pact, and the establishment of FIRA.
Ottawas efforts to secure greater economic sovereignty have largely failed, and the issue has proved
divisive even with individual political parties.

Attributions
Figure 8.22
Postcard (postmarked 1907) depicting John Bull and Uncle Sam under sign To Canada bringing in sacks of
money for investment in Canada is in the public domain.
8.15 The Boom Years, the Bust Years

The Canadian economys dependence on staples created vulnerabilities when it came to the volatile commodity
market. Success depended on demand in foreign markets for fish, fur, wood products, paper, grain, etc. A reori-
entation toward consumer goods in the mid-20th century meant that Canadians themselves could contribute to
the stability of their economy by purchasing Canadian-made products. Also, after the Second World War, Cana-
dian products were easy to find in many sectors, although competition from American and, in the 1960s, Japanese
manufacturers would arise. The period from the early 1940s into the 1980s is sometimes described by economic
historians as the longest sustained boom in history; its very length gradually made prosperity seem normal and
hard times unthinkable. This was, of course, a delusion.

After 1945, much of the economic action in Canada continued to centre on cities. The major urban areas were
becoming metropolitan in their reach as suburbs spread outward into farmland. The rural periphery retreated to
make way for more roads, single-detached homes, and automobiles. These bedroom communities were in fact
the engines of economic growth for the manufacturing sector. Other resources, however, were being tapped. They
included hydro-electricity and mineral wealth, both of which were typically found well beyond city limits and
very often in the northern parts of Canadian provinces. The effect was to create new northern centres, greater
province-wide integration (Hydro Quebec, with its enormous James Bay dam, is possibly the best example), and
more provincial debt to service all of this new infrastructure.

This was, therefore, a time of expanding provincial economies and administrative structures. Just as nation-build-
ing was a feature of the first 50 years of the Dominion, province building became a dominant feature of the
political economy after 1950. The pulp and paper industry fed provincial coffers in most parts of the country, while
relatively new mining opportunities copper and molybdenum in BC, potash in Saskatchewan, nickel in Sudbury
and Timmins in northern Ontario reinvented the sector and created an important revenue stream for government.
Similarly, uranium-bearing ore was being mined at Great Bear Lake in the NWT, in northern Saskatchewan, and
at Elliot Lake and Bancroft in Ontario; it was refined at Port Hope on Lake Ontario where tonnes of ore were
required to produce grams of useable uranium. Smelting, a companion industry of the mining sector, was another
area of growth in Quebec and Ontario in particular but also in Trail and Kitimat in BC: the former continued as a
prominent centre for zinc and lead production, while the latter was a new, purpose-built aluminum smelting town
designed along the lines of a garden city made viable because of the cheap electricity that was provided by the
provinces monopoly BC Hydro.

Slight dips in GDP and little spikes in unemployment appeared in the early 1960s. It was only in the 1970s,
however, that severe readjustments became necessary. The oil shocks of the 1970s and 1980s (see Section 8.10)

446
 8.15 THE BOOM YEARS, THE BUST YEARS 447

signalled the beginning of the end for continuous growth, and ushered in threats to the states involvement in eco-
nomic growth.

Exercise: Think like a Historian

In Canada You Get to See the Mall (with apologies to Stompin Tom Connors)

Figure 8.E1 The prototypical shopping mall, Park Royal opened

in 1952 in what was becoming Vancouvers wealthiest suburb.
Soon, everyone wanted one.

Historians approach the study of shopping from many angles. Its part of economic history, but its also
rooted in social experience; its bound up in consumerism (which is, itself, a moving target) and has impor-
tant ramifications for gender studies. There are significant spatial aspects as well: where do people shop
for the many things they might need and how does that impact the function of a city?
In 1952 the first shopping mall in Canada, Park Royal, opened in chichi West Vancouver. Whether a plaza
or a full-blown mall consisted of department (or anchor) stores and many other outlets or just a large
grocery store, they always bragged of plenty of free parking. In colder parts of Canada, malls were typ-
ically enclosed so to fend off bad weather. Many of these were designed with all the attractive aesthetic
features on the inside, and plain, boring sheet walls on the outside.
The mall was a revolutionary break from the old high street model of small and specialized shops includ-
ing shoe repair, butchers, bakery, pharmacist, and hairdresser. Strip malls followed in the third quarter of
the 20th century, some of which have, in the last two decades, attempted to recreate the scale and feel of
the old urban or town environments. Big box stores arrived around the same time but went in another
direction away from the intimacy of small spaces to vast parking, utilitarian exteriors and interiors, and
a mostly impersonal consuming experience.
Look at the shopping environment around where you live. When was most of it built? What is its target
market? How does its existence impact the social and economic life of the community? What features
dominate? Parking or drive-thru? Attractive exterior or ugly box? What do these features tell you about its
historical context?

Key Points

In the post-WWII years, much of the infrastructure-building activity switched from Ottawa to the
provinces, which became more elaborate and sophisticated administrative units.
The economic boom from 1945 to the 1970s was fed by new, massive projects and by a rising con-
sumer demand in growing suburban areas.
448 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Attributions
Figure 8.E1
Park Royal Shopping Centre, 1952 is in the public domain.
 8.16 The New World Economic Order

The end of post-war prosperity coincided with unprecedented levels of public indebtedness, and it is difficult to
disentangle these processes. The baby boom created demand for housing and schools but also for toys and furni-
ture and a larger family car. The infrastructure to service these needs placed burdens on municipal, provincial, and
federal governments that nevertheless became wealthy from development fees, property taxes, and income taxes.
As the boomers aged into their late teens, demand increased for more university spaces, leading to the creation of
nearly 50 new post-secondary institutions and the expansion of the 18 or so that had existed before 1950. A better
educated and more skilled and flexible workforce fed new sectors of the economy while establishing a potential
disaster plan should mass unemployment return. A predominantly middle-class economy meant less power in the
hands of the nations trade unions, meaning that the postwar settlement might now be significantly amended by
1
the state and employers. Public budgets, in short, had expanded in an unprecedented manner and with the onset of
the OPEC crises, inflation, and stagflation, tax bases fell into decline, and debt levels became increasingly prob-
lematic.

Neo-Liberal Economics
These were global changes, and the solutions and models were increasingly found on a global stage. The rise to
power of Margaret Thatcher in the United Kingdom led to an end of the postwar settlement there, and to the pri-
vatization of assets like state-owned social housing. Her regime included a campaign for small government, the
shrinkage of the welfare state, and a return to the sentiment that unemployment was the fault of feckless workers
rather than a structural phenomenon. These perspectives derived from a set of ideas known as neo-liberalism that
came to be known almost instantly as Thatcherism. An American version associated with monetarism and the
trickle-down effect was led by President Ronald Reagan and, almost inevitably, was branded Reaganism.

Canadian politicians influenced by British and American political trends began to make similar noises in
Ottawa and in provincial capitals. As unemployment and interest rates moved upwards into double-digits for the
first time since the 1930s, voters began looking to austerity-minded regimes. From 1979, the Social Credit party
in British Columbia pursued an ideologically-charged Chicago School-inspired program of neo-liberalism under
the leadership of William Bill Bennett (1932-2015). Ironically, Bennetts father, W. A. C. Bennett, Premier
of British Columbia from 1952 to 1972, was a lauded province-builder who had established two new universi-
ties, more than a dozen community colleges, countless schools, the first continuous highway from Vancouver to

1. As regards the expansion of existing universities in the post-war period, a good example can be drawn from the University of Saskatchewan
that, in 1950 had about 200 faculty members, and in 1975 roughly 1,000. Peter MacKinnon, University Leadership and Public Policy in the
Twenty-First Century: A Presidents Perspective (Toronto, ON: University of Toronto Press, 2014), 17.

449
450 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Alberta, a massive hydro-electric generation system, and several publicly-owned corporations and utilities that he
nationalized. In the space of less than a decade, the political economy had changed dramatically from growing the
state to shrinking government.

In Ottawa this reorientation toward neo-liberalism was led by Conservative Prime Minister Brian Mulroney (b.
1939). Elected in 1984 and faced with a massive $86 billion deficit, the government set about reducing expendi-
tures. Attempts to index Canada pensions and to control unemployment insurance pay-outs were attacked by the
provinces and other critics, but Mulroneys government endorsed reducing the size of the welfare state and took
steps in that direction as well. In Ottawa and in the provincial capitals, the public sector unions came under attack
as governments sought to reduce the size of their payroll. These themes continued into the 21st century. Deregu-
lating the economy, downsizing the state, balancing budgets, reducing taxes, and liberalizing trade were all part
of the neo-liberal strategy of the 1980s and 1990s.

Since the end of Reciprocity in 1866, there has always been an element in Canadian business and politics that
wished to see an end to tariff barriers between Canada and the United States. Macdonalds government responded
to American protectionism with tariffs of their own, and this was a fundamental part of the Conservative Party
creed for a century. Liberal governments, by contrast, sought a return to reciprocity with greater zeal. Frustrated
by negotiations with the Americans, Wilfrid Lauriers government put free trade on hold until the 1911 election.
With an agreement in hand, Laurier went to the polls and was roundly defeated. Even the Americophile Macken-
zie-King could not bring free trade back onto the table, although the Ogdensburg Agreement (see Section 6.13)
did much to tie the two economies together. The United States emerged from the Second World War as Canadas
biggest market and, conversely, Canada was the largest importer of American goods. (This continues to be the
case: more than 62% of our exports go to the United States, and 45.5% of our imports come from south of the
border.) The trade barriers in place kept branch plants thrumming along, so Liberals saw little need for change.
The economic nationalism of the 1960s and 1970s called for more barriers, rather than fewer. Given this history
and the context, Prime Minister Mulroneys decision to pursue free trade with his fellow neo-liberal, United States
President Reagan, was a major change in direction.

The first Free Trade Agreement (FTA) in 1987 reduced tariff barriers and raised fears of manufacturing jobs
moving south of the border. It also raised concerns about the saturation of Canadian media with American televi-
sion and radio programming. The immediate effects of the FTA are difficult to identify: some 200,000 jobs were
lost in manufacturing in the early 1990s, but this may have been due more to a series of economic crises unrelated
to the FTA. Canadas cultural industries did not disappear, although some institutions the CBC, Canadian the-
atre, and a homegrown film industry might have done better without free trade. If a line may be drawn at this
time (and economic historians are still very much undecided), it would favour the emergent high-tech industries
in Canada (which did very well) and not the old heavy manufacturing sector whose decline led to the creation of
a rust belt. Whatever the short term impacts, the FTA was not rolled back. It was hugely unpopular in the 1988
general election (in which the NDP and the Liberal Party nevertheless split the anti-Conservative vote), and it was
unpopular again in the 1993 election that saw Mr. Mulroneys successor, Kim Campbell, defeated (see Sections
12.2 and 12.3). A Liberal government was returned under Jean Chrtien, but there was no reversal in the tariff
policy. Mulroney and Campbell had negotiated a successor treaty to the FTA, the North American Free Trade
Agreement (NAFTA), which added Mexico to the partnership. Chrtiens commitment to renegotiate (if not tear
up) the FTA and NAFTA came to little more than a few amendments, and NAFTA went forward in 1994. The
 8.16 THE NEW WORLD ECONOMIC ORDER 451

Liberals were once again the party of free trade. Protectionism (the legacy of a century of Conservatives) was now
the virtual monopoly of the New Democrats.

The FTA and NAFTA stimulated a cross-border movement of goods, but so too did the dollar. The Canadian
dollar traded poorly against the American dollar through most of the 1980s and 1990s. Allowed to float since the
early 1960s (apart from one brief return to fixed rates), the trend was progressively downward until it hit $0.63 in
August 1998. Further depths would be plumbed in the early 21st century. A cheap dollar, of course, means that
Canadian exports do well, but the cost of imports (which increasingly includes food) does not. Again, it is difficult
to isolate the effect of changing currency values from that of the free trade agreements. In the very year that the
FTA was signed, the Japanese car manufacturer Toyota opened its first two North American plants, one of which
is in Cambridge, Ontario. Within a decade of its first vehicle rolling off the assembly line, the plant produced a
million vehicles. The rising cost of importing foreign-made vehicles (caused by the falling dollar) made Canadian
manufacturing viable; the FTA made it possible to sell as much as two-thirds of the Cambridge output into the
Unites States. Cheaper (and less organized) plant labour also served to make the Toyota operation a success. Yet,
while this kind of manufacturing was increasing, industrial production in Canada as a whole was falling.

Deindustrialization
By the mid-1970s, the share of GDP contributed by manufacturing had collapsed from an all-time high in the
Second World War to a level comparable to the Depression. The movement of investment and employment out
of manufacturing was well underway. Canadas manufacturing share of GDP troughed in 1982 at about 16%.
Indexed to 1961 as a base year (=100), relative employment in manufacturing shrank by more than 40 points by
the mid-1990s, and by about 50 points in 2004. Part of this decline can be explained by greater automation and
a fall in relative prices; part may be explained, as well, by the enlarged share of GDP captured by other sectors,
2
including the service sector. Regardless, the move away from an old-style industrial order a process called
deindustrialization was clearly underway.

The electrical products industry in Canada associated so strongly with household appliances like washing
machines, refrigerators, and sound equipment was already competing badly against American competitors, but
even branch plants like General Motors and General Electric faltered when faced with the new competition from
abroad. The auto industry in central Canada along with its sibling plants across the border sputtered along
while Japanese imports established more successful, less expensive, and more fuel-efficient products on the
market. Shiploads of automobiles began arriving in Canada from Asia and Europe in these years, transforming
harbourfronts on the Pacific and Atlantic. Canadian ports were also reorganized in the 1970s and 1980s to handle
shipping containers rather than bulk goods. Fewer auto-plant workers and fewer longshoremen (aka: stevedores)
were needed, and the same was true for steel producers and machinists.

The industrial revolution with which Canada was launched in the 1860s was retreating in the face of off-shore
production and outsourcing, increased automation of manufacturing, improved oceanic and air transportation of
freight, and the reduction of state involvement in the economy as a whole. Falling fertility rates resulted in reduced
consumer demand for goods as market saturation points arrived. For example, dishwashers could be found in 26%

2. Statistics Canada, Ryan Macdonald and John R. Baldwin, The Canadian Manufacturing Sector: Adapting to Changes, Economic Analysis
(EA) Research Paper Series, no.2009057e, accessed October 15, 2015 [Link]
[Link]?teng=[Link]&tfra=[Link]&l=eng&loc=[Link].
 452 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

of Canadian households in 1979, rising to 38% in 1986. Clearly there were opportunities for greater market satu-
ration for that product, but the other key appliances refrigerators were in nearly 100% of Canadian households
from 1976, if not earlier had reached their ceilings and were being replaced only slowly. At the same time,
the oil economy in Canada was becoming stronger, and economic and political power was shifting to what was
commonly called the New West (see Section 8.10).

A Legacy of Laundry

Figure 8.23 A pre-WWII washing machine produced by Beatty

Brothers. Note the wringer or mangle in which childrens
fingers are going to get squished.

The Beatty Brothers firm provides a neat overview of the history of industrialism in Canada since Con-
federation. Established in Fergus, Ontario in 1874, it initially specialized in farm equipment. (Their first
plant was in a building that became known later as the Old Temperance Hall, an interesting overlap with
one of the leading reform movements of the day.) In 1879 they moved to a new purpose-built plant on the
Grand River that gave them access to water power. In 1911 they moved again, this time to a steampowered
factory that included extensive office space thus, managerial and clerical transformations were keeping
pace with technological change.
At around the same time, Beatty Brothers shifted their focus away from farm implements to barn equip-
ment. This change presumably reflected the end of the pioneering days of the Prairie West and the coin-
cidental expansion of the dairy industry. It was a small step to go from one indoor line of products to
domestic needs.
Pioneers in the design and production of mechanical washing machines in the interwar years, the Beatty
brand could be found in households throughout Ontario and the rest of Canada. Beatty Brothers benefited
from tariff barriers that kept out cheaper American manufactures, but they suffered as those same barriers
encouraged the establishment of branch plants north of the border. In the post-WWII era, American pro-
ducers like General Electric and Westinghouse had greater economies of scale and were able to dominate
production and distribution from the 1950s through the 1960s. Beatty Brothers disappeared when it was
bought by General Steel Wares (GSW) in 1969 in a wave of consolidations that would see many smaller
3
producers vanish.

Through the 1990s, the Canadian economy continued to adjust to what was clearly becoming a globalized mar-
ketplace. The end of the Cold War and the fall of the Iron Curtain opened eastern European markets to the West
for the first time since before 1939. Similarly, economic liberalization in the Peoples Republic of China created
new opportunities and witnessed accelerated trade between the Pacific Rim ports. This new development aug-
mented the rise of other Asian Tiger economies led by Japan and South Korea. While Canada exports high
value service products (like international education) to markets in Asia, it also continues its dependence on tra-

3. A diligently researched history of the company may be found at the "Old Time Trains" page at [Link], accessed October 15,
2015, [Link]
 8.16 THE NEW WORLD ECONOMIC ORDER 453

ditional commodities by exporting unprocessed (or barely processed) forest products, grain, coal, gas, and oil. In
return, Canada imports automobiles from Japan and South Korea and high tech equipment from across southeast
Asia. This new economic revolution of the 1990s saw steel mills, coal mines, and auto plants in Ontario and Nova
Scotia shuttered. The pattern was repeated across the whole spectrum of manufactured goods, as Canadian shoe,
clothing, and textile producers moved production elsewhere or simply went bankrupt.

Key Points

The end of the economic boom in the 1970s facilitated the growth and popularity of neo-liberal
responses to debt, and a strategy of shrinking the public sector.
Efforts to improve the economy included a new version of reciprocity: the FTA and NAFTA.
A long term shift out of manufacturing accelerated in the 1980s and 1990s as global competitors
entered the Canadian marketplace and competition for capital investment increased.
Deindustrialization was a narrowing of manufacturing diversity and a shedding of jobs in the sec-
ondary sector.

Attributions
Figure 8.23
Washer, wringer is in the public domain. This image is available from Canada Science and Technology Muse-
ums Corporation under the reference number 1977.0307.001.
8.17 Post-Industrial Canada

A great many Canadians continued to depend on wages and salaries in the industrial/manufacturing sector in the
last quarter of the 20th century. Even so, the sector was changing dramatically. Industrialization a century ago
required proximity to sources of energy, raw materials, shipping/railway infrastructure, and a source of cheap,
skilled labour. The information age required different strategies.

High technology industries were drawn to nodes where there was proximity, principally, to workers with extra-
ordinary skills in computer sciences. The founding of software giant Corel in Ottawa in 1985 nearly coincided
with the 1984 opening of Research In Motion (RIM) eventually renamed BlackBerry Limited in Waterloo,
Ontario, which both depended on the dense population of science and engineering graduates from nearby uni-
versities. These also were flagships of what was called the knowledge economy. The post-secondary sector
responded with increased investment in the mobilization of knowledge and commercialization. Just as Cana-
dian industrialists once looked south to the steel industry of Pennsylvania and the auto industry of Michigan, late
20th century entrepreneurs, cabinet ministers, and local governments wished to emulate the success of Californias
Silicon Valley, pairing entrepreneurial vision with fresh research coming out of the countrys leading universities.

Figure 8.24 The enormous success of Corel was manifest in its

$20 million sponsorship (and subsequent rebranding) of the NHL
Ottawa Senators new home arena in 1996.

It is probably too early for historians to judge the contrary currents flowing in the millennial decades. On the one
hand, globalization was viewed as a source of deindustrialization; at the same time, labour in Asia and engineer-
ing skill in India in particular was critical to the rise of the information age. From about 2001, the knowledge
economy and the creative economy are presented as heirs in a long succession of economic engines. Just as the
agricultural revolution of the 18th century made possible, and gave way to, the industrial revolution in the 19th,
they were both followed by the commercial and service revolution of the mid-20th century.

To use a well-stretched analogy, this may be making a silk purse from a sows ear. Do we cheer the arrival of new
activities so as to obscure the creaking sound from declining sectors? Without the agricultural revolution, there
would not have been the food nor the people to run the industrial revolution; however, the former didnt end with
the start of the latter. The agricultural and industrial revolutions had an ongoing co-dependence then and, indeed,
454
 8.17 POST-INDUSTRIAL CANADA 455

to this day. Industrialism provided the systems necessary to mass produce electronic goods, for example, and it
also established in partnership with state capitalism at mid-century and the rise of consumerism the intel-
lectual means and popular market for high-tech inventions. The extent to which the knowledge economy can lay
claim to the revolutionary qualities with which it is sometimes associated has yet to be proven.

Vancouver, Then and Now

A striking visual example of the rise of industrialism, and its retreat, can be seen along Vancouvers False
Creek. Currently, the subject of a significant urban plan, it is an area that has literally been re-formed
repeatedly in the citys 130 years.

Figure 8.25 The False Creek mudflats at high tide in 1890, only
recently denuded of trees but still a salmon spawning ground and
a source of clams.

Despite the name and the historic presence of several feeder ravines, it is not a creek at all but rather a
short inlet that once had extensive mudflats at its eastern extremity. Aboriginal peoples harvested a range
of foods here, including seals. Early Asian settlers grazed cattle and pigs across the marshes. European
immigrants made similarly benign use of the flats until the late 1880s and early 1990s when slaughter-
houses appeared on its south bank at the outlet of Brewery Creek. Waste from the eponymous breweries
joined the dumping of offal and animal scraps into the flats, and residents and the city on the eastern and
northern shore began disposing of their garbage in the most inland coves. By 1910 high tide marks were
littered with all kinds of debris and gore.
The eastern flats were drained and filled in between 1915 and 1917 to create space for new railyards
and warehouses. The remaining shoreline west of Main Street (repeatedly threatened with further massive
drainage projects) was populated with sawmills and railyards from the 1880s forward. Huge beehive burn-
ers belched sparks and smoke over the citys East End, and a towering gas plant hissed and glowed blue
above Chinatown. There was little housing along False Creek before the 1970s, apart from shanty housing
mostly shabby floathouses without plumbing and some nearby coolie housing (high density hous-
ing for single, and mostly poor, Chinese men). Sewage poured directly into the eastern part of the inlet, and
the whole stank terribly. Shipyards joined metal-bashing and barrel-making industries along the south side
of the inlet and grew at an enormous rate during the 1940s with the wartime production of Liberty Ships.
Crossed by three bridges, False Creek was the heart of industrial Vancouver until the need for larger sorting
yards pushed the lumber industry to the Fraser River; likewise, the shipyards shut down one after another
because they needed bigger slips on which to build a new generation of larger peacetime vessels and a
deeper, wider pond into which they could be launched.

Figure 8.26 The Big Smoke. False Creek in 1936, its size reduced
by one-third and its waters choked with log-booms.

Incrementally vacated by industrial leaders, the northern portion of False Creek was spanned by two high-
456 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

way viaducts in 1972, with more freeways believed to be on their way. At that point, City Council devel-
oped a new vision of the area and, in partnership with the Trudeau government, began to redevelop the
southwest side as a combination of street market and modest-density housing with green spaces and pedes-
trian seawalls. Granville Island Market was one outcome, and townhouses began to stretch eastward from
Granville Bridge. Consolidating the remainder of the land represented a challenge that was solved by host-
ing a Worlds Fair Expo 86. That opportunity cleared the way for converting the north shore of False
Creek from industry to fairground and then to high density tower housing in the space of a decade. More
glass towers followed on the eastern shoreline, leaving only the southeast corner for consolidation and
bulldozing, which was done to host the 2010 Winter Olympics, and the athletes dormitories were quickly
converted into market housing.

Figure 8.27 The Swiss Pavilion dominates this view of Expo 86.

What was once well within living memory a smoky, rat-infested, industrial septic field is now a
smart, green, sophisticated urban space. There are very few industries per se in the area, except for the
return of craft breweries. What has emerged along the shorelines of False Creek is a highly photogenic
example of the clean and urbane knowledge/creative economy.
It is easy to lose sight of the fact that the industrial core that gave Vancouver its nickname the Big
Smoke was also lauded in its time. Heavy industry and shipyards were profitable and they provided
jobs for thousands of skilled and unskilled workers (including more than 10,000 women during WWII)
who lived in the city core, on Fairview Slopes, and in the East End. More than that, these industries were
symbols of patriotism in the 1940s and through the Cold War. Mills and factories were as much an indica-
tor of Vancouvers modernity as condo-towers are a manifestation of the citys postmodernity.
Similar reinventions of industrial lands can be seen in every Canadian city. Whether it is the Canadian War
Museum (built on the railyard and working-class neighbourhood LeBreton Flats in Hull), the revitalized
packinghouse district on the waterfront of Kelowna, or almost any new arena or stadium in the country,
these brownfield projects re-purpose and, sometimes at enormous cost, rehabilitate industrial spaces for
post-industrial use.

Figure 8.28 Myfanwy MacLeods The Birds

dominates a public square in the Olympic Village
condo complex in a thoroughly deindustrialized
(but hardly natural) False Creek, 2011.

Bubbles
Several factors brought instability to the Canadian economy after 1982. The rising cost of fuels and other com-
ponents in the auto industry continued to reduce its profits. Startlingly high interest rates (close to 20%) gutted
the housing sector and reduced consumer spending in the early 1980s. Growing environmental concerns rocked
 8.17 POST-INDUSTRIAL CANADA 457

the pulp and paper and forest industries, resulting in a reduction of output and exports beginning in the 1980s and
accelerating through the 1990s. Volatility in the stock market was also a destabilizing factor.

Between the Wall Street Crashes of 1929 and 1987, there were no major stock market disasters, but then they
started to come quickly. Black Monday on 19 October, 1987 was followed two years later by the dramatic col-
lapse of the Brazilian stock exchange; in the summer of 1990, a three-year long recession began that was linked to
Iraqs invasion of Kuwait; in 1991 Japans meteoric rise ended with what was to be a two-decade long downturn;
the common European currency, the Euro, experienced a crisis of its own in 1992; five years later, the Asian eco-
nomic meltdown provoked a global crash of stocks and, in the summer of 1998, the Russian economy seemingly
collapsed. The century ended with the dot-com bubble crisis that marked the end of a stunning run for Internet
investors.

This last aspect of the new post-industrial economy in some ways resembles the frenzy of railway building in the
Victorian era. The Internet went from being a modest structure in the 1970s and 1980s to the World Wide Web
invented in 1989 and launched in 1991. It is now, along with cellular communications, the largest communica-
tion infrastructure in existence. At the consumer level, this is a vast and revolutionary change. More than 80% of
1
households now use a cellphone only, having dispensed with landlines. The future of Canada Post is uncertain,
and while it is still possible to send a telegram today, many do more for the sake of irony than efficiency.

Canadians observed these changes unfolding in the 1990s and were uncertain. What potential did the Internet
truly present? In 1989 only 10% of Canadian households had home computers; five years later, that figure had
more than tripled to 32%; in 2000 it reached 65%. Until the late 1990s, these computers were essentially word
processors: household Internet usage was only about 7% in 1997. Suddenly, in 2000, this leapt to 53%, and home
2
computers were in a position to revolutionize domestic, civil, and social life. Again, in the mid-1990s, this trans-
formation was being foretold by only a handful of early adopters. Resistance to these trends can be seen in the
apparent inability of print media to develop new strategies for survival, which is evident in the closure of many
local newspapers. At the same time, automobile sales continued to surge (sustained by sprawling cities), so dein-
dustrialization was far from complete. As was the case in the past, the post-industrial economy did not utterly
supersede the service or industrial or agricultural economies.

Key Points

Information technologies began in the late 1980s, and in the 1990s, began to mobilize more capital
and labour, even as traditional manufacturing sectors declined.
The knowledge and creative economies became increasingly referenced as cleaner and more sophis-
ticated models that would replace dependence on industrial production.
The Internet age began with a frenzy of investment that produced financial bubbles that inevitably
burst.

1. John Greenwood, Why Canadians are hanging up on their landline phones, Financial Post, June 24, 2014, accessed October 16,
2015, [Link]
2. Lance W. Roberts, Rodney A. Clifton, Barry Ferguson, Karen Kampen, and Simon Langlois, Recent Social Trends in Canada, 1960-2000
(Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 2005), 210.
458 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Technological change made significant inroads in everyday life in the 1990s, and accelerated at the
turn of the century.

Attributions
Figure 8.24
The Corel Centre, now known as Scotiabank Place, in Ottawa by Steggall is used under a CC-BY-SA 3.0
license.

Figure 8.25
View looking north on Main from 7th Ave. False Creek before fill by H.T. Devine is in the public domain.

Figure 8.26
View of mills on False Creek by James Crookall is in the public domain.

Figure 8.27
Expo 86 Switzerland by Colin Rose is used under a CC-BY 2.0 license.

Figure 8.28
Sculpture of a sparrow in Olympic Village, Vancouver by Guilhem Vellut is used under a CC-BY-SA 2.0
license.
8.18 Summary

Figure 8.29 Packing crate art and design became an industry in its
own right in the early 20th century, whether the produce was
Okanagan hard fruit or Nova Scotian lobster meat.

Two weeks after the start of the Great War the Panama Canal opened. In the 1920s, new grain elevators appeared
along the Great Lakes and on Vancouvers waterfront, a sign of the expanding market the canal created for the
foremost of Canadas staple exports: wheat. In the same decade, new processes enabled the growth of the pulp and
paper industry and hydro-electricity became an industry in its own right. The suburbanization that would charac-
terize the post-WWII years was evident in the 1920s as well, as new houses and early electric appliances took the
place of wood and coal stoves and ice-boxes. Ownership of the newest communications innovation the tele-
phone leapt from one-in-four households in 1921 to three-in-four by 1931; the electric radio very nearly kept
pace. The 1920s also saw an increase in Canadian trading with the United States. One consequence of this trad-
ing was the acceleration of the automobile industry and the extension of car-ownership to more and more Canadi-
ans. Governments borrowed heavily to build the infrastructure needed to support automobile ownership, and cities
started reshaping their streets to facilitate private transportation often at the expense of public transportation.
The 1920s were, in many respects, the defining decade of the 20th century.

It is easier to speak with confidence about events nearly 100 years ago than in the last decade or two. Historians
demonstrate a reluctance to weigh in on the recent past because the questions it raises are unsettled, the sources
one needs to tap are as yet unavailable, and the measures one might apply not fully clear. This is nowhere more
the case than in economic history. What can be said for sure about the Canadian economy since 1920 is that it
experienced three major watersheds: the Depression, the post-war boom, and the disruptions associated with the
post-industrial era. Some constants remain throughout this period. The Atlantic provinces continue to struggle
economically; for them, Confederation has not paid off as well as it might have. Dependence on staple products
has not gone away; for every BlackBerry or graphic arts design studio, there is a boxcar of coking coal headed
to a ship bound for Japan or China, a pipeline full of oil coursing its way to the American Midwest, and millions
of bushels of grain or perhaps rapeseed or soy heading into the Atlantic or Pacific. Consumerism, which
appeared first as a hopeful engine of growth, defined the 20th century and continues to assert itself in the 21st.
Although blue-collar wages have not continued their mid-century growth, the need for highly technical skills has
redirected students into fields where their post-secondary education may secure them middle-class salaries, or at
least will acculturate them to middle class values and spending habits.

459
460 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

The role of population in this story is quite possibly the most critical piece. The impact on Canada of two World
Wars was serious but nothing as bad as it was on Britain, Germany, the USSR, and Japan. Whats more, as a thriv-
ing economy in a world of badly ruptured economies, Canada was once again a highly attractive destination for
immigrants after 1945. Without the sort of food and fuel shortages that bedeviled other nations, Canadians were
well fed and warm. The baby boom, however, rounds this out. Without prior planning and largely by serendipity
alone, the baby boom provided a market for family-oriented products like suburban homes and washing machines,
bicycles, and station wagon cars. More than that, the timing was ideal in that all but the latest of the baby boomers
came into the job market during a rising economy. They could access high school and higher education like no
previous generation, and these advantages paid out in better wages and salaries. Working people also could find
work from an early age in the resource extraction industries. This created a generation with disposable income
and the ability to fire up the consumer economy. Their accumulation of wealth over a lifetime continues to have
a rising effect on the Canadian economy, even as they pass those savings onto their heirs. It takes little to imag-
ine what a baby boom born into a declining economy would look like. (Indeed, one gets a sense of what might
have happened in Canada by looking at baby boomers in the underperforming economy of Great Britain in the
1950s.) Doug Owram has written that, in terms of opportunities, the baby boomers were born at the right time.
As regards the needs of the economy, the same is true.

Key Terms

Auto Pact: The Canada-US Automotive Products Agreement was signed in 1965. It removed tariffs
on vehicles and automotive parts traded between Canada and the United States, creating a much more
dynamic Canadian automobile sector and improving the trade deficit in that sector.
Bank of Canada: Canadas central bank, introduced by R.B. Bennett, January 1935, as part of a federal
government economic intervention.
Battle of Ballantyne Pier: 18 June, 1935; a violent confrontation between striking Vancouver dockyard
workers and a force made up of city police, provincial police, and RCMP.
Black Tuesday: 24 October, 1929 (a Tuesday) was the day the New York Stock Exchange crashed,
beginning the decade-long Great Depression.
Bloody Sunday: Sunday at daybreak, 19 June, 1938, while the Vancouver Police peacefully evacuated
the Art Gallery (occupied by unemployed protesters), the RCMP stormed the Post Office with tear gas
and truncheons. A window-smashing campaign followed, and hours later, a demonstration of support
took place at an East End park where 10,000 to 15,000 locals gathered. Many were hospitalized that day.
boondoggles: Meaningless routine work, associated with work relief for the unemployed, intended to
keep them busy but not necessarily productive.
Bretton Woods: Established in July 1944, a system of institutions, principles, and processes by which
the international monetary system could be managed. The Bretton Woods system lasted until 1971 when
the United States ended the convertibility of the dollar to gold.
brownfield projects: Civic projects that re-purpose (sometimes at enormous cost) or rehabilitate indus-
trial spaces for post-industrial use.
Canadian Wheat Board: Canadas Marketing Board for wheat and barley was introduced by R. B.
Bennett in July 1935 as part of a federal government economic intervention.
 8.18 SUMMARY 461

Capital markets: A combination of institutions that enable the buying and selling of money through
instruments like loans and securities.
cellular: A telecommunications system involving a wireless connection. Cellular telephones first
became available to the public in the mid-1980s.
centrifugal federalism: Federalism as a dynamic process of decentralization and recentralization, or
centrifugal versus centripetal forces.
command-led economy: An economic order in which government is the principal buyer of goods pro-
duced, for itself or for distribution. See demand-led economy.
commercialization: In late 20th century post-secondary education, the search for opportunities to
develop revenue streams by taking new ideas to market.
consumer durables: Products that last a long time and which consumers do not have to buy often, for
example, cars, furniture, and appliances.
Corn Laws (1794-1846): A result of population growth and an economic downturn at the end of the
Napoleonic Wars; tariffs and restrictions were imposed on imported grain (to Britain), which increased
prices in an attempt to give domestic producers an edge.
creative economy: In the late 20th century, the idea that the economy was shifting away from an indus-
try-dominated model to one in which ideas and creativity would matter more.
deindustrialization: The process of moving away from an old-style industrial order, which typically
involves the shuttering of declining industries.
demand-led economy: An economic order in which the free market dominates and in which industries
and consumers are the principal buyers of goods, thereby determining what goods will be produced. See
command-led economy.
dole: Colloquial term for relief or welfare payments.
dot-com bubble: A late 20th, early 21st century investment frenzy based on advances in Internet-based
commerce that burst with the collapse of the market in 2000, which crippled growth in the sector for
several years.
Dust Bowl: Describes the drought conditions that occurred across the prairies and plains of North Amer-
ica in the 1930s and the concurrent poverty associated with the economic depression.
equalization: Refers to programs and policies geared to redistribution of wealth between provinces to
ensure a comparable level of services and quality of life in all parts of Canada.
forward linkages: Other industries are developed or expanded to help to link a product or staple export
from the suppliers to the customers, as part of the distribution chain, for example, transportation, grain
elevators, and port facilities.
Free Trade Agreement (FTA): Between Canada and the United States; signed in 1988, and brought
into effect in 1989, the FTA created a single market for most goods and services.
garden city: A movement among city planners beginning in the late 19th century imposed order on new
communities, including extensive greenspace and boulevards. A garden city is simultaneously modernist
and antimodernist.
gold standard: In monetary policy, the linking of a nations currency to the value of gold, which is also
called the gold exchange standard. Canada (and Britain) abandoned the gold standard at the start of the
First World War, resumed using the system in 1926, and then left it permanently in 1929.
462 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Gross Domestic Product (GDP): The value of all goods produced in a country during a specified period
of time.
have-not (provinces): As opposed to have provinces, the prosperity of have-not provinces is below
the average for the country as a whole; equalization payments were designed to address these inconsis-
tencies.
hobo jungles: Homeless mens camps, usually in marginal spaces in cities and towns, proliferated dur-
ing the 1930s Depression.
information age: A view of the post-industrial economy in which digitized information is the basis of
a new economic order.
International Monetary Fund (IMF): Created at Bretton Woods in 1944 to work with the World Bank
to reinvigorate post-war economies by achieving currency stability, stimulating international trade, and
rescuing national economies in distress.
Keynesian economic principles: Named for the British economist John Maynard Keynes, it broke with
orthodox thinking by advocating government spending during downturns so as to stimulate the econ-
omy; these principles also encouraged aggressive taxation during times of prosperity to offset recovery-
era spending. Resisted and rejected by orthodox economic thinkers and conservatives who deplore the
idea of a large, bureaucratic, and interventionist state.
knowledge economy: In the late 20th century, the trade in intellectual property and educational prop-
erty; the preeminence of technological and other kinds of knowledge and information as economic dri-
vers.
Laurier boom: The period of economic and demographic growth that coincided with the coming to
office of the Laurier Liberals in 1896; it concluded in the period 1912-1914.
Maritime Rights: An interwar-era political common front of New Brunswick, Prince Edward Island,
and Nova Scotia that argued for greater federal support for the regional economy.
Marshall Plan: Also called the European Recovery Plan (ERP); an American program giving billions
of dollars of aid to rebuild European economies after WWII, in part to restore markets but also to offset
the appeal of Communism.
mercantilism: The system of economic relations established between European empires and their
colonies; emphasis is on the use of merchants in the home country to establish production in a colony
of largely unprocessed goods that would be shipped to the home ports; leaves colonies economically
dependent and underdeveloped.
monetarism: In macroeconomics, the theory that the money supply and central bank policies are key
to understanding inflation and fluctuations in GDP. By controlling the money supply, monetarists argue,
one can contain inflation. One instrument for achieving these goals is to raise interest rates making
money more expensive and thereby reducing its velocity. Monetarist policies were introduced along
with austerity measures in Britain under the Thatcher government from 1979. Similar efforts (without
austerity) were attempted in the United States under Ronald Reagan. Both were influential on Canadian
fiscal policy.
National Energy Program (NEP): Controversial legislation introduced under Pierre Trudeaus admin-
istration in 1980-1985. The thrust of the policy was to secure Canadian oil for Canadian markets in east-
ern Canada (hitherto dependent on cheaper but, in the context of the second OPEC shock, insecure
imported oil). Prices for Albertan oil in Quebec would be lower than in the United States (to which
most of Canadas oil was sent), which meant lower profits in the oil patch.
 8.18 SUMMARY 463

neo-liberalism: An ideological position that favours smaller government, deregulation, freer trade, and
lower taxes; and is tied to monetarism.
New West: Term used to describe the Prairie provinces following their move from a monocultural econ-
omy based almost entirely on grain production and export to an economy with diverse and more valu-
able bases.
North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA): 1994; trade pact with the United States and Mex-
ico. Expands on the Free Trade Agreement (FTA) signed in 1988.
North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO): Established by the North Atlantic Treaty of 1949
that brought together the Treaty of Brussels nations (Britain, Belgium, Netherlands, Luxembourg, and
France), Canada, the United States, Iceland, Denmark, Norway, Italy, and Portugal as a mutual defense
league an attack on one would be an attack on all.
off-shore production: Manufacturing of goods or parts in another country.
oil patch: Shorthand for Albertas oil industry, from mining and processing to sales and financing, from
the field to the head offices in Calgary and Edmonton.
On-to-Ottawa Trek: Beginning in June 1933, the Relief Camp Workers Union mobilized the unem-
ployed in British Columbia to abandon the camps and put their issues directly before Prime Minister
Bennett, travelling across Canada on railway boxcars. The Trek started in Vancouver but was stopped in
Regina and culminated in a riot.
Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC): Established in 1960 as a regulating body
for the oil industrys biggest producers, most of which were located in the Middle East and Africa. By
1970 decolonization had advanced so far that emerging countries sought greater control over the value
of their oil exports. OPEC responded by setting higher prices, which triggered the first oil shock of
the decade.
outsourcing: The export of jobs; part of the process of deindustrialization.
post-war settlement: A suite of agreements between employers, unionized workers, and the state
in 1946; allowed for responsible labour activity while prohibiting excessive militance; committed
employers and the state to recognizing unions and supporting the checkoff of union dues. See Rand For-
mula.
Privy Council Order PC 1003 (1944): Allowed unions for the first time to engage in widespread orga-
nization and to bargain collectively for job contracts.
province building: The strategy pursued by some provinces to become more substantial players in their
jurisdictions by investing in economic expansion and engaging in a growing number of social programs.
Associated with the post-WWII period.
Rand Formula (1946): Based on a landmark legal ruling by Mr. Justice Ivan C. Rand, the Rand For-
mula provided unions with a pathway to gain legitimacy and long-term stability if, but only if, they
agreed to conduct themselves responsibly.
Reaganism: Also Reaganomics; associated with the neo-liberal (also neo-conservative) goal of reduc-
ing the size of government, expenditures of government, and size of personal and capital gains taxes;
tied, as well, to monetarism.
recession: Generally a down-cycle in economics characterized by price inflation, rising unemployment,
industrial failures, and lower household income.
Regina Riot: 1st of July 1935, at the conclusion of the On-to-Ottawa Trek, a rally called by the Relief
464 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Camp Workers Union in Reginas Market Square culminated in a confrontation between the Trekkers
and their supporters and the RCMP.
relief camps: The federal governments response to the massing of unemployed single men in Vancou-
ver early in the 1930s Depression; in 1932, a nationwide system of generally quite isolated camps run by
the Department of National Defense that became hotbeds of radical opposition to government inaction
on the economic crisis.
reparations: At the end of the First World War, Germany accepted responsibility for acts of aggression
leading to the conflict; the Treaty of Versailles (1919) ordered Germany to make extensive payments as
a consequence. Both the idea of war guilt and reparations became a contentious issue in Germany; the
countrys inability to pay the enormous reparations fees led to severe international economic instability,
particularly when Germany sharply devalued its own currency to pay the debts more easily.
rust belt: Former heavy manufacturing regions that have experienced deindustrialization.
service sectors: Those parts of the economy that support the financing, governing, feeding, administer-
ing, training, and health of the rest of the economy and the population. Examples include government
bureaucracy, education, restaurants, police, and financial services. Also called the tertiary sector, as
distinct from the primary (resource extraction) and secondary (processing and manufacturing) sectors.
Silicon Valley: Term used to describe the concentration of high-technology industries in the Bay Area
of California, particularly after the 1970s.
stagflation: Stagnant economic growth coupled with persistently high rates of inflation.
staple economy: The staples theory argues that an economy dominated by valuable and traditional com-
modities will be shaped in terms of the larger economy, the polity, and the society by the needs
and nature of the primary staple(s). Also a model for understanding the political economy of a country
in which staples are fundamental to the export economy. An approach developed by historians Harold
Innis and W. A. Mackintosh.
superpower: A leading economic and military power with a nuclear arsenal; a cold war era term applied
mainly to the USSR and the United States.
Thatcherism: Simultaneously the approach taken by and leadership style of British Conservative Prime
Minister Margaret Thatcher, and the array of anti-trade union, pro-free market policies and economic
philosophies that were popular in the Conservative Party from the 1970s through the 1980s; contains
some elements of neo-liberalism and what has been described as Reaganomics.
trickle-down effect: In neo-liberal economics, particularly Reaganomics, the idea that reducing taxes
on the wealthy and corporations will result in their increased profits trickling down to lower socio-
economic classes. Referred to also as free market economics and voodoo economics.
VE-Day: Victory in Europe Day, 7 May 1945; marked the end of WWII in Europe.
western alienation: The growing sense from the mid-20th century of the four western provinces that
Canadian political machinery and culture favoured Ontario and Quebec and that federal economic poli-
cies were devised to favour central Canada over the West.
wildcat strikes: Labour disputes launched by workers without the authorization or permission of the
union leadership; an unofficial strike that does not follow the established procedures for taking industrial
action.
World Bank: Created at Bretton Woods in 1944 to work with the International Monetary Fund to rein-
vigorate post-war economies. Dominated by the United States, it was used also as an instrument to
reduce communist influence in western Europe.
 8.18 SUMMARY 465

Worlds Fair: Alternatively, World Exposition, hence Expo; first organized in the mid-19th century
to showcase industrial and technological advances; the first Expo was hosted in Canada in 1967 at
Montreal, by which time the fairs were more about national showcases and culture; Canadas only other
Expo was held in Vancouver in 1986.
World Wide Web: A network of information connected via the Internet; emerged in the late 1980s.

Short Answer Exercises

1. What is the staples economy and why does it matter in Canadian history?
2. What are capital markets and how were they organized in Canada in the 19th and 20th centuries?
3. What causes economic upturns and downturns? What were the most significant peaks and troughs
in Canadian history to the 1940s?
4. In what ways was the New Economy a continuation of the old economic order in Canada?
5. What major changes occurred in shipping, fisheries, and fossil fuel production?
6. What were the major differences between the economy before and after WWII?
7. What was the Post-War Settlement and how did it impact the Canadian economy?
8. To what extent was 20th century Canada not one economy but several?
9. What is neo-liberal or neo-conservative economics? Why did it arise when it did in the late 20th
century?
10. What indicators suggest that we have left the industrial age behind?

Suggested Readings
Dawson, Michael. The Second World War and the Consolidation of the British Columbia Tourist Industry,
1939-50. In Selling British Columbia (Vancouver, BC: University of British Columbia Press, 2004). 116-152.

Forbes, Ernest. Consolidating Disparity: The Maritimes and the Industrialization of Canada during the Second
World War. Acadiensis 15, no. 2 (1986): 3-27.

McInnis, Peter S. Planning Prosperity: The Debate on Postwar Canada. In Harnessing Labour Confrontation:
Shaping the Postwar Settlement in Canada, 1943-1950 (Toronto, ON: University of Toronto Press, 2002).
47-85.

Marchildon, Gregory P. The Prairie Farm Rehabilitation Administration: Climate Crisis and FederalProvincial
Relations during the Great Depression. Canadian Historical Review 90, no. 2 (2009): 275-301.

Srigley, Katrina. Stories of Strife?: Remembering the Great Depression. Oral History Forum/dhistoire orale
29, Special Issue (2009): 1-20

Wright, Miriam. Building the Great Lucrative Fishing Industry: Aboriginal Gillnet Fishers and Protests over
466 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Salmon Fishery Regulations for the Nass and Skeena Rivers, 1950s-1960s. Labour/Le Travail 61 (2008):
99-130.

Attributions
Figure 8.29
Union Brand, Nova Scotia Archives, MG 6 vol 32 # 17 has no known copyright restrictions.
 PART 10

Chapter 9. Cold War Canada, 1945-1991

467
9.1 Introduction

Figure 9.1 The high-street grocery store like this one on

Ottawas Rideau Street in the late 1950s would face
competition from suburban shopping malls in the Cold War years.

The period from 1945 to 1991 was one of dramatic technological and social change. Much of the material texture
of life had so changed from the pre-war era that it is difficult to imagine that the two eras were somehow related.
The shape of cities, the availability of affordable clothes, the appearance of new household appliances, the explo-
sion of automobilism, and crucial developments in the area of media and entertainment all created a shockingly
new version of the modern world.

While there were massive watersheds, however, there was also continuity. Of these, William Lyon Mackenzie
King was only the most obvious. Even after Kings retirement from politics, his immediate successors were drawn
from the pool of politicians who were born in the late 19th century and could remember World War I almost as
clearly as World War II. That connection to the Edwardian let alone the Victorian era was, however, reced-
ing behind decades of social and economic trauma.

Demographically, the Canada that was emerging after 1945 was distinct from what went before. The young cou-
ples who were rushing to marry and restore what they regarded as normalcy after the Depression and World
War II were mostly products of the interwar years and were glad to put all that behind. Their children that
generation born as early as the late 1930s but especially after VE Day and in rising numbers to the late 1950s
were the baby boomers whose very existence transformed the economy. Rising fertility rates led to investment in
maternity wards; rising infant numbers to more childrens clothes and toy factories; rising child numbers to more
schools and skating rinks. The arrival of a generation of adolescents called for vastly more high schools and new
ideas about consumerism and music. And by the time the baby boomers were in their late teens and twenties, by
the time they were entering universities, the workforce, and the electorate, they were a democratic tidal wave.
This was a generation that was welcomed in the context of Canadians appetite for greater normalcy in domestic
relations. They were also an asset in the new consumer-led economy. The main legacy of the baby boomers, how-
ever, would be structural challenges to those underlying postwar values.

There was evidence of dissatisfaction, new ideas, and experiments in many aspects of Canadian life. Chapter 10

468
 9.1 INTRODUCTION 469

considers elements of modernity as it evolved from the early 20th century through the postwar years. This chapter,
however, focuses more specifically on the links between social, economic, and political changes that took place
in the Cold War years. It begins with a survey of the events leading to the amalgamation of the two Dominions
and a consideration of the experience of the North as the Cold War era took root.

It has been customary to think of the 1960s as a turning point that toppled old social and cultural values, and there
are elements of truth to that. What an overview of these years most clearly demonstrates, however, is the continu-
ing struggle between ideals like the liberal-democratic order, the interventionist state, the rights of the individual
versus collective identities, and the continuing vigour of conservative social and economic philosophies. Many of
these themes were picked up internationally, especially in the English-speaking world. The internationalization of
media was a critical element in that synchronizing process as was the internationalization of markets. In Canada,
discussions over what constituted progress were the backdrop for a return to the pre-WWI debate over what
constituted the idea of Canada. As it became increasingly clear that Quebecs visions of the future of Canada
were different from those of English Canada, the confederation skated close to the edge of disintegration from the
1960s to the 1990s.

Figure 9.2 No nukes is good nukes: a

mothballed Bomarc missile on display at the
Canada Aviation Museum, Ottawa in 2006.

Every debate about family, prosperity, unemployment, sexuality, entertainment, and technological developments
in these years took place in a unique historical context: the Cold War. After 1953 especially, the fear of mutually
assured destruction (MAD) amplified fears in the Western world of the threat posed to its particular social and
economic world by the Soviet Union and the expanding reach of communist regimes. A polarized world populated
every conversation. What happened in suburbia, factories, the bedroom, and the classroom had implications for
success or failure in the face of what was either just an alternative ideology or, as United States President Ronald
Reagan provocatively called it, the evil empire.

Learning Objectives

Describe the idea and experience of the Cold War and how it affected Canada and its regions.
Identify the main features of Newfoundlands economy and society and the factors that led to its
joining Confederation in 1949.
Assess the ways in which Canadas international role changed from 1939 to 1990.
Account for changes in Canadas political culture, including the rise of human rights.
Consider the changes in Canadas relationship with the United States.
470 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Outline the forces behind the Grand Noirceur and the Quiet Revolution.
Account for the popularity and the level of success achieved by Quebecs separatist movements.
Describe the proposed constitutional changes of the 1970s, 1980s, and 1990s and the extent to which
they succeeded and failed.
Expand on the social and economic changes in Canadas cities and in the countryside after 1945.
Discuss the cultural changes taking place after 1945 and especially in the 1960s and 1970s.

Attributions
Figure 9.1
IGA, Rideau Street, Ottawa, end of 50s by Lost Ottawa, Facebook is used under a CC-BY 2.0 Generic license.

Figure 9.2
Bomarc B missile Canada Aviation Museum Ottawa 2006 by Bzuk is in the public domain.
9.2 One Dominion

What constitutes a nations history? Canada is a combination of parts, some of which had very little to do with
one another during the modern era, not to mention the colonial period. Does adding them together create a quilt
of histories or a common heritage of historical experiences? To take one example, New Brunswick was once part
of Nova Scotia (and, before that, both were mostly Acadia). Does its history before 1783 belong to Nova Scotia,
and do those Nova Scotians who overnight became New Brunswickers continue to have a stake in Nova Sco-
tias history? Ought New Brunswickers to think of the larger region before 1783 as part of their historic heritage?
Might Nova Scotians think of New Brunswick since 1783 as a continuation of a Nova Scotian story?

Such questions seem abstract, but in the building of a national consciousness through historic awareness they are
very practical and real. Nowhere is this more apparent than in the history of another Atlantic colony.

Newfoundlands Crisis
The oldest area of European economic activity in North America, the site of the longest continuous commercial
link between North America and Europe, Newfoundland has a colonial history that follows a trajectory unlike
any other major settlement on this side of the Atlantic. Newfoundlands Aboriginal population was mostly eradi-
cated by the 1830s (a Mikmaq presence remained on the South coast despite the disappearance of the Beothuk);
European settlement proceeded slowly; there was almost no agricultural frontier; and the economy remained tied
to a seasonal round of fishing, sealing, forestry, and shipbuilding that remained largely unchanged from the 18th
century into the 20th.

Figure 9.3 The 1920 Newfoundland $2 bill features iron ore

miners (presumably on Belle Isle) and a caribou, but no
prominent politicians or royalty.

There are ways of looking at this that suggest a slow-to-modernize, backward-looking society and economy.
Certainly Newfoundland (and Labrador even more so) moved to a different historical rhythm than the rest of
North America. Sectarian rivalries between Catholic and Protestant communities persisted, while they declined
in Canada. The size and scope of government was so limited that Labrador communities were essentially left to
the missionaries to administer, well into the 20th century. The mainland annex mattered so little to St. Johns that

471
 472 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

the island Dominion of Newfoundland attempted repeatedly and without success to sell it to Canada. Corruption
in government was thought to be endemic, and the ejection of the Liberal-Reformers Party under the leadership
of Sir Richard Squires (1880-1940) was a violent affair that took Responsible Government down with it. The
Dominion of Newfoundland receded from view as a British-appointed Commission of Government restored, in
every way that mattered, the old colonial order from 1934 until its union with Canada in 1949. Newfoundland
before 1949 was pauperized, locked in the 19th century, riven with religious divisions and spite, and then stripped
of its hard-won autonomy as an independent member of the Imperial order.

This is only one way of looking at the situation. Another draws attention to the accomplishments of a small pop-
ulation in an inhospitable environment. The sea was the nations larder, which Newfoundlanders exploited in a
great variety of ways. The rise of the whaling industry, for example, was Newfoundlands entry to the lubricant
and fuel oil industry, a theme subsequently rejoined with off-shore oil. Sealers adapted to more versatile fleets,
and the fisheries repeatedly shifted its focus with changes in market and environmental conditions. Hydroelectric
development began in the 1880s; in the 1920s, the pulp and paper plant at Corner Brook and a smelting opera-
tion at Buchans were being fed by a hydro station on Deer Lake. Efforts were made to launch a Newfoundland
railway and to thereby open up agricultural, mineral, and forestry opportunities in the northern interior of the
Dominion, a scheme that echoed Macdonalds National Policy. Government became enlarged as a consequence,
though its tax base remained precarious and subject to the vicissitudes of the commodity market in the Atlantic
Rim. Sectarian division was, it is true, a fact of life in Newfoundland but it was, too, in Toronto (called in the
1
1920s the Belfast of Canada). Party loyalties largely reflected denominational loyalties (as they did in much of
Canada), although class lines were also important at the polls. There was widespread government corruption, but
one cannot look at the Squires bribery case without recalling the Pacific Scandal or, more contemporaneously, the
support of the Ku Klux Klan by Saskatchewan Conservative Premier James Anderson (1878-1946), or Alberta
UFA Premier John Brownlees (1883-1961) career-ending sexual relationship in 1934 with a young staffer in the
Attorney-Generals office. If immorality or unethical behaviour on the part of public figures was cause to relegate
a province to colonial status, there would be hardly anything left of Canada by the end of the 1930s.

Giving up Responsible Government was a setback for democracy but it was also a prudent move in a period of
political and economic turmoil. It was a tough decision to make but it was made by the legislature itself in 1934.
The new PM, Frederick Alderdice (1872-1936) of the United Newfoundland Party, thus oversaw his own redun-
dancy and thereby gave the island Dominion a respite from contentious politics. The Commission of Government
piloted Newfoundland through the rest of the Depression, into and out of World War II, and to the beachhead of
Confederation in 1949.

Figure 9.4 Battleships and cruisers cluster in St. Johns Harbour

in September 1942.

1. On this topic, see Mark McGowan, The Waning of the Green: Catholics, the Irish and Identity in Toronto, 1887-1922 (Montreal & Kingston:
McGill-Queens University Press, 1999), and William J. Smyth, Toronto, the Belfast of Canada: The Orange Order and the Shaping of
Municipal Culture (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2015).
 9.2 ONE DOMINION 473

From Commission to Confederation

If there is a recurrent theme in Newfoundlands political history, it may be unfounded optimism. The promises
made by incoming governments in the first half of the 20th century seem to repeatedly promote a sense of hope
among a population whose economic world was all too often unforgiving. Once disappointed, the electorate could
be unforgiving in return, as Prime Minister Squires discovered. The Commission of Government realized this
truth, too, in the late 1930s. The loss of responsible and autonomous government was a blow to the morale of
Newfoundlanders and, whatever good the Commission accomplished and it did do much to improve the admin-
istrative and educational environment in the former Dominion it was confounded in its efforts by the economy.
This changed almost instantly in 1939 with the outbreak of war.

Newfoundland, the easternmost point in North America, was immediately of strategic importance. Convoys of
supplies from Canada and the United States were necessary to sustain the British war effort, and these had to be
protected from German air and sea attacks. The investment in military infrastructure stimulated the Newfoundland
economy in ways that would have been unimaginable only months before. It is reckoned that 20,000 jobs were
created in construction and related jobs in 1942, as the United States entered the war and poured millions into for-
ward bases on the island and in Labrador. It was on the mainland that change sped ahead most rapidly: Labradori-
ans were not being ushered into a modern economy exemplified by automobiles and small factories; instead, they
were suddenly confronting military airbases where thousands of men and women worked with precision tools on
machinery that was delivered out of the sky. Democracy had not before this time reached the mainland of the old
Dominion, and its people had been pretty much left to their own devices. The Moravian missions and the Hud-
sons Bay Company between them had governed the region at the behest of St. Johns. With the war underway,
both Canadian and Newfoundlander influences grew in Labrador.

Figure 9.5 A British Digby Mark I aircraft is towed out of the sea
at Dover, Newfoundland, in the winter of 1942.

One of the conditions of the Commission of Government was that Responsible Government would return as soon
as Newfoundlanders wanted it. This was a vague assurance, not least because there was no clarity around how
popular desire for the old constitution might be measured. There was no legislative assembly, so elected officials
could not force the issue. The British administration had its own agenda: it wished to see Newfoundland indepen-
dent of imperial oversight and, moreover, it was anxious to avoid a return to the bad old days of rolling financial
crises. Britain had bailed out Newfoundland repeatedly and now felt the need to back out gracefully from that
commitment.
474 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 9.6 Building the massive American Fort Pepperell

provided jobs to hundreds of Newfoundlanders and confirmed a
United States presence in the former Dominion that drew it into
the orbit of Washington.

Timing was critical. By the middle of World War II, there was trans-Atlantic planning underway for a postwar
economy. The aftermath of WWI had been marked by trade depression and spikes in unemployment in Canada
and Britain; Westminster anticipated that wars end would see American, Canadian, and British investment in
Newfoundland quickly come to an end, and the former Dominion would be pitched into poverty once more. Echo-
ing fears that have been raised regarding the fate of every former British colony in North America since the
1860s, there was concern that the strong American influence in the region and the booming American economy
might reorient St. Johns toward Washington rather than Westminster (let alone Ottawa). Clearly, annexation with
Canada was a preferable outcome and, for once, Canadians seemed keenly interested.

Feeling in Newfoundland and Labrador was conflicted. While, historically, Newfoundlanders had viewed Cana-
dians with suspicion and even some contempt, wartime contact had softened that view. There were some who
wished to see a return to independent Dominion status the Responsible Government option and there was a
significant number who preferred to see the Commission of Government continue. What all sides feared most was
a return to the inequities and hardships of the pre-Commission days. The British administration sampled opinion
and empowered the local population to craft their own constitutional future through a national Convention, which
met from late 1946 to early 1948. The expectation was that voters would be offered up a referendum in which
Confederation would be a leading option. While there was a demonstrable appetite for union with Canada during
the Convention meetings, the delegates voted in favour of a two-choice referendum: Commission of Government
versus Responsible Government. Horrified, the British brushed aside the local process and inserted Confederation
on the ballot. The outcome was at first inconclusive: on 3 June 1948, the most popular option was Responsible
Government with nearly 45% of the vote, followed by Confederation with 41% and the remaining fraction going
to the Commission. A second ballot was held a month later. The Commission option was removed from the ballot
and Confederation pulled ahead, but with only 52.3% of the vote.

Figure 9.7 The delegation that negotiated Newfoundlands

annexation to Canada. Joey Smallwood stands on the far left, hat
in hand.

This was a highly divisive process. The British were seen to be moving the goalposts as regards the Conventions
mandate. The more heavily populated constituencies of the Avalon Peninsula went for Responsible Government,
while the sparsely populated rural and Labrador communities supported Confederation. The Orange Lodge
 9.2 ONE DOMINION 475

sensing that the winds of loyalism were blowing toward Ottawa accused the Catholic clergy of stirring up anti-
Confederation sentiment. For their part, Catholic voters feared that union with Canada would result in the loss of
their separate schools; indeed, Canadas track record on this issue was atrocious. Joey Smallwood (1900-1991) led
the pro-Confederation movement and pulled together a curious coalition. A former union organizer with the polit-
ically active (and typically anti-Catholic) Fishermens Protective Union, he worked mostly as a journalist, failed
as a Depression-era politician, and like many populist figures of his time moved into radio. As a delegate
at the Convention, he pushed the Canadian option and decried Responsible Government as an elitist scheme that
would see poverty continue unchecked. Thus, the vote was coloured along the fracture lines of class, sectarianism,
and rural versus urban.

Smallwood subsequently became the leader of the Liberal Party in Newfoundland and, as the new province of
Newfoundland entered Confederation in 1949, he became its first premier. This was an office he would hold for
nearly 23 consecutive years. As a writer and a public personality, he crafted much of his own legend over time and
into retirement, describing himself as the last living Father of Confederation. Newfoundlanders were divided
on the Smallwood legacy, particularly as it became more and more apparent that joining the mainland Dominion
was no guarantee of prosperity. There remained a strong sentiment favouring Newfoundland independence and
this was very slow to dissipate, not that it ever has done so entirely.

Figure 9.8 Prime Minister St. Laurent begins the process of

carving Newfoundlands coat of arms into the arch of the
Parliament Buildings in Ottawa.

Key Points

Newfoundlands special relationship with Britain preserved a political economy that was more ori-
ented to the Atlantic than to the rest of North America.
Economically vulnerable, Newfoundland and Labrador did not modernize much before the 1940s
and World War II.
In 1934, the political and economic situation in the Dominion was so bleak that the government
voted itself out of existence and back into colonial status.
The war led to significant improvements in the economy and a change in attitudes towards the main-
land. A referendum campaign concluded with a bare majority of Newfoundlanders preferring Con-
federation over independence and multilateral economic bonds.

Attributions
Figure 9.3
NFLD 2 dollar by TOlivero is in the public domain.
476 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 9.4
St. Johns, Newfoundland (Online MIKAN no. 4164991) by Government of Canada is in the public domain.

Figure 9.5
Pulling the Digby from the sea by Robbie Sproule is in the public domain.

Figure 9.6
St. Johns, Newfoundland (Online MIKAN no. 4164988) by Government of Canada is in the public domain.

Figure 9.7
Delegation negotiating the union of Newfoundland with Canada (Online MIKAN no. 3193186) by George
Hunter / National Film Board of Canada / National Archives of Canada / PA-128076 is in the public domain.

Figure 9.8
Newfoundland Confederation ceremonies, Prime Minister St. Laurent initiates the work of carving Newfound-
lands arms (Online MIKAN no. 3408567) by National Film Board / Library and Archives Canada / C-006255
is in the public domain.
 9.3 The North: Economy and Territory

KELLY BLACK, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, VANCOUVER ISLAND UNIVERSITY

In Canadian history, the concept of the North What is it? Where is it? What does it mean? has been a con-
tested and debated subject. At various times during Canadas past, the geographic location of the North shifted
as Canada acquired, surveyed, and mapped new territory. If we ask, Where is the North? we may think of the
provincial north (Fort St. John, British Columbia; Timmins, Ontario; northern Quebec; Labrador), the territorial
north (Yukon, Northwest Territories, Nunavut), or any land north of the 60th parallel.

Figure 9.9 The line between the north and the North is
generally agreed to be the 60th parallel.

Whichever location comes to mind, all are home to a diversity of Indigenous and non-Indigenous peoples. First
Nations, Inuit, and Mtis peoples have made these places their home since time immemorial, and each of these
peoples has specific territories and traditions. The North has also been central to the creation of particular nar-
ratives of Canadian identity. Historian Shelagh Grant has written that most southern Canadians view the Arctic
in terms of southern impact, such as the effect of weather patterns, the potential of untapped resource wealth, or
1
simply national pride in a unique, majestic landscape. Just as the North moulds the nation, the nation fashions
the North. The history of the North in Canada has been shaped by changing boundaries, changing priorities, and
the development of a national, northward-looking imagination.

Canada First
The creation of the Dominion of Canada in 1867 caused some English Canadians to consider what attributes
would define their new identity as Canadians. A group called Canada First was formed in 1868 when five men

1. Shelagh Grant, Arctic Wilderness - And Other Mythologies, Journal of Canadian Studies 32.2 (1998): 35.

477
 478 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

from Ontario gathered to consider a future as Canadians, and not as British colonists. Historian Carl Berger argued
that the Canada First movement used notions of the North to promote the idea that Canadians would rise to great-
ness in North America and abroad because of their northern character:
[blockquote}The adjective northern came to symbolize energy, strength, self-reliance, health, and purity, and its
opposite, southern, was equated with decay and effeminacy, even libertinism, and disease. A lengthy catalogue
of desirable national attributes resulting from the climate was compiled. No other weather was so conducive to
2
maintaining health and stimulating robustness. [/blockquote]
The idea that Canadians were hardy, masculine, and northern people stood in contrast with the United States to the
south. However, Canada First members also wanted to contrast Canadians with peoples from other colonies within
the British Empire. The idea that people from southern climates could not live in the North was taken directly
from the concepts of Social Darwinism emerging at the time. It was used to underwrite a cool welcome to (or
a door bolted against) immigration from the Mediterranean, the Caribbean, and the African-American diaspora.
Social Darwinism took Darwins theory of evolution survival of the fittest and natural selection and applied
these ideas to society and politics. Canada Firsts doctrine argued that a northern climate meant only hardy, manly,
and white peoples could live in Canada. This conveniently ignored the presence of Indigenous peoples but, to
most Canadians at the time, Indigenous peoples were understood to be vanishing. With this icy white national-
ism, as Eva Mackey has put it, whiteness, the rugged northern landscape, and climate came to signify Canada to
3
Canadians.

Figure 9.10 The Chilkoot Pass at the height of the Klondike gold
rush.

Territorial Expansion
The British government purchased Ruperts Land and the North-Western Territory from the Hudsons Bay Com-
pany (HBC) in 1870. Fearing annexation of the territory by the United States, Section 146 of the British North
America Act (1867) provided for the inclusion of the vast area into the newly created Dominion of Canada. This
acquisition brought an influx of settlers, particularly from Ontario, into the Red River area, and led to the Red
River Resistance by the Mtis and the creation of the postage stamp province of Manitoba in 1871. It was not
until 1905 that the provinces of Alberta and Saskatchewan were carved out of the territory and brought into Con-
federation. In 1912, the current borders of the prairie provinces and northern Ontario were established.

For much of the 19th and early 20th centuries, the far North, the lands North of 60, remained largely unknown to
southern Canadians. It was not until 1880 that Britain transferred possession of the high Arctic islands to Canada.
However, these islands were seen to be of little value to political leaders in Ottawa. Rather than being viewed
as the home of the Inuit, the Arctic was mired in myth as the site of ill-fated expeditions in search of the North-

2. Carl Berger, The Sense of Power: Studies in the Ideas of Canadian Imperialism, 1867 - 1914 (Toronto: University of Toronto Press), 129.
3. Eva Mackey, Death by Landscape: Race, Nature, and Gender in Canadian Nationalist Mythology," Canadian Woman Studies 20.2 (2000):
126.
 9.3 THE NORTH: ECONOMY AND TERRITORY 479

west Passage and thought to be a place of inhospitable climate; harsh landscape; and monstrous creatures such as
whales, narwhals, and walruses.

Figure 9.11 A footrace in Dawson City, ca. 1900.

The Klondike gold rush of 1896 brought an influx of gold seekers to the North (especially from the United States),
and the Canadian government responded by creating the Yukon Territory in 1898. Historians Ken S. Coates and
William R. Morrison note that the Klondike gold rush is one of the few events in Canadian history perhaps the
4
only one that has entered into the collective memory of the entire world. The word Klondike is derived from
Trondk Hwchin, the name of the First Nation upon whose territory gold was found. The rush to riches had
devastating impacts on the environment and First Nations cultures in the region, but it is the romance of the gold
rush that remains ingrained in the Canadian imagination through the poems of Robert W. Service (1874-1958)
, the books of popular historian Pierre Berton (1920-2004), and the famous images of stampeders climbing the
treacherous Chilkoot Pass route to the goldfields.

Figure 9.12 Robert W. Service, seen here in

1941 with screen star Marlene Dietrich
(1901-1992), struck gold with poetry.

Listen to this recording of The Cremation of Sam McGee. Service reads one of his best known poems,
The Cremation of Sam McGee.

The gold rush reminded the Canadian government of the need to assert its sovereignty in the North, and, in 1904,
the Liberal government of Wilfrid Laurier (1841-1919) commissioned the Canadian Arctic Expedition and the
ship Arctic to help with this task. From 1913 to 1918, the Canadian Arctic Expedition journeyed through the Arc-
tic and found major errors in previous maps. The expedition actually added four new islands to Canadas territory
that were previously unknown by the government. During this time, missionaries and the Royal North West/Cana-
dian Mounted Police established outposts throughout the provincial and territorial North. These outposts, along
with the Hudson Bay Company (HBC) stores, became central to the regions colonization and administration prior
to World War II.

Despite the acquisition of Ruperts Land by Canada, the HBC remained a strong presence in the North well
into the 20th century. In 1920, the company marked its 250th anniversary with the release of the silent film The

4. Ken S. Coates and William R. Morrison, Land of the Midnight Sun: A History of the Yukon (Montreal: McGill-Queens University Press,
2005), 77.
 480 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Romance of the Far Fur Country. The film reinforced the prominent role of the HBC in Canada and provided
southern audiences with one of their earliest glimpses into life in the Arctic. Two years later, the American film
Nanook of the North (nanook means polar bear in the Inuktitut language) was a huge success at the box office
and contributed further to the mystique of the North and its peoples.

Figure 9.13 Poster for Nanook of the North.

Watch Nanook of the North, a remarkable (if ethnographically unreliable) documentary.

World War II and the Cold War

World War II brought rapid and profound change to the North and to Indigenous peoples in the region. When the
United States and Canada declared war with Japan in December 1941, the Pacific coast of North America was par-
ticularly vulnerable to a Japanese attack. To aid the movement of troops and supplies into the North, work began
on the Alaska Highway in Fort Nelson, BC, in 1942. With Canadas permission, 10,000 American troops and
workers came to northern British Columbia and the Yukon to build a 1500-mile (2400-kilometre) road to Alaska.
As with the gold rush, the North was transformed almost overnight. American troops remained in the North not
only to build the highway but also to facilitate defence and the transportation of military supplies across the North.

Prior to the war, it was possible for many Indigenous peoples in the North to live their lives without interacting
with Canadian institutions and peoples. However, concerns about sovereignty and security quickly brought sci-
entific and military projects into the everyday lives of Indigenous peoples. A mine near Great Bear Lake in the
Northwest Territories supplied uranium ore for the Manhattan Project to develop the first atomic bomb. The
Dlne First Nation of Sahtu worked to extract the radioactive materials and were never informed by the govern-
5
ment of uraniums deadly effects: many died from various forms of cancer linked to their exposure. Advance-
ments in technology following the war meant that the Arctic very quickly went from a place of mystery to a place
that could be accessed, studied, defended, and monitored. During the 1950s, the Distant Early Warning (DEW)
Line was built across the North to provide radar surveillance and protection from a Soviet airborne invasion or
missile attack via the Arctic Circle. Although such an invasion never came, the United States military maintained
a strong presence in the North throughout the Cold War.

High Arctic Relocation

As southern Canadians came to know more about the North, the federal government extended the postwar welfare
state to Northern peoples. This was not simply an offer of social programs; the federal government wanted to
resettle Indigenous peoples off the land and into planned settlements in an attempt to reproduce life as it was

5. Peter C. van Wyck, The Highway of the Atom (Montreal: McGill-Queens University Press, 2010).
 9.3 THE NORTH: ECONOMY AND TERRITORY 481

for southern Canadians. This rapid transformation in peoples lives often meant disruption of traditional ways of
knowing and the break-up of family groups. The need for energy and other resources in the postwar years also
brought resource extraction to the North. In the quest for resources, traditional hunting grounds were destroyed
and settlements were relocated to make way for mining operations.

In the late summer of 1953, the government forcibly relocated several Inuit families from Inukjuak, Quebec, in
the name of Canadian arctic sovereignty. The families, along with a single RCMP constable, were sent to Resolute
Bay and Grise Fiord in the Northwest Territories as part of a government relocation program. Three other families
from Pond Inlet were sent to teach the Inukjuak families to survive in the high Arctic. All of these families were
told they were being sent north so that they could be provided better hunting and living opportunities. In 1955,
more people were relocated from Inukjuak and Pond Inlet to Resolute. The high Arctic was completely different
than the home territories of these families, and they were sent North with poor supplies and no knowledge of the
terrain or wildlife. In 1996, the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples found that the government relocated
these Inuit families for several dubious reasons:
6
To support Canadian sovereignty claims (in effect, using the relocated populations as human flagpoles);
To centralize Inuit in communities where they could provide labour for the Royal Canadian Air Force and
government weather station. Many Inuit did these jobs but were not paid. Their wages were kept by the
government and issued in the form of credits at the government store;
To fulfill a desire to improve the situation of Quebec Inuit whose livelihoods were thought to be under
threat due to decreased game stocks; and,
To reduce what was seen to be growing Aboriginal dependence on government assistance.

For decades, the federal government claimed that these families had moved voluntarily. Inuit rejected this claim
and spoke of the intergenerational trauma inflicted by forced relocations. It was not until 2010 that the federal
government issued an apology for these relocation programs.

Division of the Northwest Territories

Since 1867, the size and shape of the NT has been altered several times as districts, provinces, and territories were
created. Prior to the 1960s, the administration and governance of both the Yukon and Northwest Territories was
the responsibility of the federal government. In 1966, the Carruthers Commission recommended that the fed-
eral government begin to transfer these responsibilities to the people of the Northwest Territories. Following the
commissions report, the capital of the Northwest Territories was shifted from Ottawa to Yellowknife in 1967 and,
by 1975, a fully elected legislative assembly had been created. Gradually, control of education, local government,
and social services were handed over to both territories, a process known as devolution.

Throughout the 1960s and 1970s, Indigenous peoples of the North began to organize politically into groups such
as the Yukon Native Brotherhood, the Indian Brotherhood of the Northwest Territories, the Committee for Orig-
inal Peoples Entitlement, and the Inuit Tapirisat of Canada. These groups advocated for the protection of their
culture and traditions and called for the signing of treaties and the right to determine their own future. As a cre-
ation of Ottawa, the boundaries of the Northwest Territories were artificial and did not represent the cultural and

6. Bruce Campion-Smith, Ottawa apologizes to Inuit for using them as human flagpoles, Toronto Star, August 18, 2010.
 482 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

linguistic differences between Inuit and First Nations in the Eastern and Western Arctic. Inuit made up the major-
ity of the population in the East, while Dene and Mtis concentrated heavily in the West, around Great Slave Lake
7
and the Mackenzie River. In 1982, residents voted in a plebiscite that asked if they were in favour or against a
division of the Northwest Territories. Nearly 57% of voters cast a ballot in favour of the proposal. Ten years later,
in 1992, residents voted on and approved the proposed boundaries for the two territories. In 1993, the Nunavut
Land Claims Agreement was signed between Inuit of the Eastern Arctic and the federal government. The final-
ization of the land claim agreement was one of the last major hurdles towards the creation of Nunavut, which
became Canadas newest territory on 1 April 1999.

Key Points

The North has played an important role in the psychology of national identity since the earliest days
of Confederation.
In the early 20th century, much northern territory was divided between the Prairie provinces,
Ontario, and Quebec.
Efforts to assert Canadian sovereignty in the North were insignificant before the Klondike gold rush
and increased thereafter.
Government involvement grew and extended dramatically during World War II.
Mineral resources began being tapped in the Northwest Territories precisely as the Cold War began,
adding new concerns about sovereignty and a degree of militarization in response.
Human populations mostly Inuit have been repeatedly moved in the service of Canadian
claims.
Democratic institutions were introduced in the 1960s and 1970s while, at the same time, Aboriginal
peoples organized in response to Ottawas interest in their homeland.
One outcome was the establishment of Nunavut as a separate territory in keeping with Inuit ambi-
tions.

Additional Resources
CBC Digital Archives. The Creation of Nunavut: [Link]

Mapping the Way: Yukon First Nation Self-Government: [Link]

CBC Interactive Timeline: NWT Devolution [Link]

Attributions
Figure 9.9
60th parallel Canada by Bazonka is used under a CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.

7. Frances Abele and Mark O. Dickerson, The 1982 Plebiscite on Division of the Northwest Territories: Regional Government and Federal
Policy, Canadian Public Policy/Analyse De Politiques 11.1 (1985): 2.
 9.3 THE NORTH: ECONOMY AND TERRITORY 483

Figure 9.10
Packers ascending summit of Chilkoot Pass (Online MIKAN no. 3192704) by E.A. Hegg / Library and
Archives Canada C-005142 is in the public domain.

Figure 9.11
Foot race, Dawson City, YT, about 1900 by Muse McCord Museum is in the public domain.

Figure 9.12
Robert Service during the Spoiler with Marlene Dietric by Universal Studios is in the public domain.

Figure 9.13
Nanook of the north by Robert J. Flannery / Pathe Pictures is in the public domain.
 9.4 The Cold War

Figure 9.14 War is mostly about waiting. A soldier with the

Vandoos, Private G.U.I. Lambert, reads a comic book in a
foxhole in Korea, 1951.

The Cold War refers to the period of heightened tensions between the West (that is, the United States, Canada,
Britain, France, and their allies) and the Soviet Union, lasting roughly from 1945 to 1991. Its origins can be traced
to several sources but it rapidly became a war of postures and proxy wars between the two heavy-hitters, the
United States and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR). The Cold War was so named as it never fea-
tured direct military action between the two superpowers or their main allies. With the old great powers of
Europe exhausted and battered by World War II, the United States (largely unscathed, the main creditor state in the
world, and heavily industrialized) and the Soviet Union (badly beaten up but in a position to rebuild its defenses)
emerged as the dominant powers. The addition of atomic bombs to their respective arsenals entitled them to a new
1
title: superpowers.

The Allies Fall Out

Having combined to defeat the Axis Powers (Germany, Italy, and Japan), the Allies (principally, the USSR, the
United States, and the United Kingdom) found themselves disagreeing on the shape of the postwar world. At the
February 1945 Yalta Conference, the Allies could not reach a consensus on crucial questions like the occupation
of Germany and whether Germany should be forced to pay reparations again. Given Russias historical experi-
ence of invasions from the West and the immense death toll it recorded during the war (estimated at 27 million),
the Soviet Union sought to increase security by dominating the internal affairs of countries on which it bordered,
and especially Germany. On the other hand, the United States sought military victory over Japan, the achievement
of global American economic supremacy, and the creation of an intergovernmental body to promote international
cooperation.

1. Boundless. Origins of the Cold War. Boundless U.S. History. Boundless, 21 Jul. 2015, accessed 17 Dec. 2015 from [Link]
[Link]/u-s-history/textbooks/boundless-u-s-history-textbook/the-cold-war-1947-1991-27/origins-of-the-cold-war-210/origins-of-the-cold-
war-1159-9245/

484
 9.4 THE COLD WAR 485

At the Potsdam Conference in July 1945, the Allies met to decide how to administer the defeated Nazi Germany.
Serious differences emerged over the future development of Central and Eastern Europe. The atomic bombings
of Hiroshima (6 August 1945) and Nagasaki (9 August 1945) were, in part, a calculated effort on the part of the
American government to intimidate the Soviet Union, limiting Soviet influence in postwar Asia. The bombings
served to fuel Soviet distrust of the United States and are regarded by some historians not only as the closing act
of World War II, but as the opening salvo of the Cold War.

Canada lacked the profile of the Americans in these events but was up to its elbows in complicity. The Quebec
Agreement was signed by United States President Franklin Roosevelt (1882-1945) and British Prime Minister
Winston Churchill (1874-1965) on 19 August 1943 in the old capital of New France. The agreement ensured
British and American collaboration on what became known as the Manhattan Project; Canadian involvement was
simply assumed. In 1944, Canadian scientists and technicians joined the multinational team in the United States,
along with tons of uranium-bearing ore from the Northwest Territories. A Combined Policy Committee was estab-
lished on which Canada was represented; it had oversight and coordination responsibilities regarding the atomic
bombs. Canada was not, however, permitted to participate in the decision-making process as to when and where
to deploy the new weapons.

Figure 9.15 In April 1935, W.L. Britnell and Stan McMillan

unload the first shipment of uranium concentrate from the
Northwest Territories. The photo is good, but everyone in it was
overexposed.

Canadas role in the Manhattan Project and the corollary that there were Canadians who possessed sophisti-
cated knowledge about how to manufacture the worlds first weapon of mass destruction made Canada a target
worth spying on. In Ottawa on 5 September 1945, a Ukrainian cypher clerk slipped out of the Soviet Embassy
where he worked, carrying more than 100 top-secret documents detailing Russian espionage activities in Canada.
Igor Gouzenko (1919-1982) disclosed the existence of a spy ring that included sleeper agents working under deep
cover in Canada. The whole of the operation was geared towards uncovering nuclear secrets so that the Soviet
Union could match the American arsenal at the earliest opportunity.

By February 1946, the public was aware of the Gouzenko Affair, which played out in the press and in Parliament.
Fred Rose (1907-1983), the lone Communist Party MP in Ottawa, was implicated in the Gouzenko documents
and was subsequently jailed for nearly five years. The late 1940s, then, saw the beginnings in Canada of a panic
about spies that would push Canada further and faster away from her former Soviet ally and deeper into the orbit
of Cold War America.

Figure 9.16 The age of atomic espionage opens.

On 5 March 1946, Churchill gave a speech declaring that an Iron Curtain had descended across Europe. This
 486 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

metaphorical curtain divided East from West, leaving those nations behind it, as Churchill said, subject, in one
form or another, not only to Soviet influence but to a very high and in some cases increasing measure of control
from Moscow. To the Soviets, the speech seemed to intended to incite the West to war with the USSR, as it called
for a broad western alliance against the Soviets.

In response to perceived Western aggression, in September 1947, the Soviets created Cominform (Communist
Information Bureau) to enforce orthodoxy within the international communist movement and tighten political
2
control over Soviet satellites through coordination of communist parties in the Eastern Bloc.

Tensions between East and West continued to rise. In the spring of 1948, the focus shifted to Berlin. Germany
and Berlin along with Austria and its capital city, Vienna had been divided into British, French, Soviet,
and American sectors. The western Allies were on the verge of unifying their respective sectors of Germany as
a whole a development that the Russians were understandably unwilling to tolerate. In response, the Soviet
Army initiated a blockade of Berlin, ensuring that food and fuel could not reach the American, French, and British
zones in the capital. Unable to deliver goods by land or water through Russian-controlled Germany, the Western
nations gambled on an airlift into the city.

Just as these events were unfolding, Belgium, the Netherlands, France, Britain, and Luxembourg entered into
a new mutual defense treaty. The Berlin blockade and the vastly superior Soviet land forces in central Europe
obliged the Treaty of Brussels group to look to a wider association that would include the United States, Portugal,
Italy, Norway, Denmark, Iceland, and Canada. The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) was the outcome:
a mutual protection agreement under which an attack on one was to be regarded as an attack on all. For its first
few years, NATO was not much more than a political association; the first NATO Secretary General, Lord Ismay
(1887-1965), stated in 1949 that the organizations goal was to keep the Russians out, the Americans in, and the
Germans down. However, events quickly galvanized the member states, and an integrated military structure was
3
built up in which Canada played a prominent role.

By the late 1940s, the tone of global diplomacy and relations had changed dramatically from what it had been
in 1939. When Britain declared war on Germany, the Canadian delay in responding was, in part, symbolic of the
nations new relative autonomy; now, if Russia made a move on Luxembourg or Iceland, Canada would automat-
ically be at war, regardless of what Britain might decide to do. Thee agreements reflected fears of a conventional
attack involving aircraft, navies, and heavy armoured tank divisions. Then, in 1949, things became significantly
more complicated and ominous.

On 29 August 1949, the Soviet Union exploded its first atomic bomb. The United States monopoly on nuclear
weaponry was over. A few months later, on 1 October 1949, Chinese Communist Party leader Mao Zedong (Mao
Tse-tung, ???, 1893-1976) announced the triumph of the Chinese Communists over their Nationalist foes in a civil
war that had been raging since 1927. The Nationalist forces, under their leader Chiang Kai-shek (???, 1887-1975),
departed for Taiwan in December 1949. A few months later, an unresolved situation on the Korean peninsula
would lead to the first hot moment in the Cold War. The Soviet Union had been granted control of the northern

2. Boundless. Origins of the Cold War. Boundless U.S. History. Boundless, 21 Jul. 2015, accessed 17 Dec. 2015 from [Link]
[Link]/u-s-history/textbooks/boundless-u-s-history-textbook/the-cold-war-1947-1991-27/origins-of-the-cold-war-210/origins-of-the-cold-
war-1159-9245/
3. Boundless. North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO). Boundless U.S. History. Boundless, 21 Jul. 2015, accessed 17 Dec. 2015 from
[Link]
atlantic-treaty-organization-nato-1173-11110/
 9.4 THE COLD WAR 487

half of the Korean peninsula at the end of World War II, and the United States occupied the southern portion.
The Soviets displayed little interest in extending their power into South Korea, and Stalin did not wish to risk
confrontation with the United States over Korea. North Koreas leaders, however, wished to reunify the peninsula
under Communist rule. In April 1950, Stalin finally gave permission to North Koreas leader Kim Il-sung (???,
1912-94) to invade South Korea, and provided the North Koreans with weapons and military advisors.

Figure 9.17 With the possible exception of the comedian Dashan

(??, aka: Mark Rowswell), Dr. Norman Bethune is the most
famous Canadian in China. Given the numbers, this makes him
possibly the most famous Canadian historical figure. A medic in
Maos Peoples Army, he is seen here on the left in 1938.

The Korean War

On 25 June 1950, troops of the North Korean Peoples Democratic Army (PDA) crossed the 38th parallel, the bor-
der between North and South Korea. Within only a month, the PDA captured all but the southernmost region of
the peninsula. The first major test of the Wests policy of containment in Asia had begun, for the domino theory
held that a victory by North Korea might lead to further Communist expansion in Asia, in the virtual backyard of
the Wests former enemy and newest ally in East Asia Japan.

The United Nations (UN), which had been established in 1945, was quick to react. On 27 June 1950, the UN
Security Council denounced North Koreas actions and called upon UN members to help South Korea defeat the
invading forces. As a permanent member of the Security Council, the Soviet Union could have vetoed the action,
but it had boycotted UN meetings following the awarding of Chinas seat on the Security Council to Taiwan
instead of Maos Peoples Republic of China (PRC). Spurred by the UNs response, Canadas Secretary of State
for External Affairs, Lester B. Pearson (1897-1972), proposed that Canada send troops under the UN flag, led by
American military.

The Canadian troop commitment in the Korean War eventually reached nearly 27,000, and Canadians were
active on sea, on the ground, and in the air some of them flying combat jets, introduced in World War II but
used only sparingly before Korea. Canadians performed many tasks but saw the most difficult fighting in three
ground battles: Kapyong, Hill 355 (aka: Kowang-San), and Hill 187. Despite rapidly retaking not only the Repub-
lic of Korea but almost the whole of North Korea as well, the UN forces were confronted on the PRCs border
by hundreds of thousands of Chinese troops in the Peoples Volunteer Army, who pushed the front back to the
original dividing line, the 38th parallel, and forcing the American Eighth Army into a humiliating retreat. The
status quo ante bellum was restored in 1953 but not peace. Canadians stayed on duty in the PRC until 1957,
monitoring among other things the Demilitarized Zone (aka: the DMZ). Both Koreas remain, technically,
at war today. Five hundred and sixteen Canadians died in this conflict which, held against World War I or II, may
not seem a great number. Nevertheless, this remains the third-largest loss of warriors experienced by Canada since
Confederation.

Korea was a testing ground, too, for Canadas approach to the Cold War. While the American administration under
 488 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

President Harry S. Truman (1884-1972) and Secretary of State Dean Acheson (1893-1971) was gambling on an
Asian conflict that would cause the PRC to collapse in turmoil, the Canadians were much more committed to
the objectives of the United Nations. Pearson was repeatedly at odds with Acheson, and the two foreign affairs
offices developed a deep-seated mutual distrust and dislike. To take one example, Acheson claimed that a large
number of Chinese and Korean prisoners of war (POWs) requested that they be allowed to remain in South Korea
at the end of hostilities. The numbers were dubious, the whole idea was in conflict with the Geneva Conven-
tion, and Achesons transparent propaganda ploy blew up in his face when prisoners in the Koje-do Island POW
camp demanded that they be returned to the North and to the PRC. Canadian troops were deployed to put down
the ensuing riot, but without official Canadian consent. The effect was to entangle Canada in an affair that ran
counter to its own foreign policy. As one study demonstrates, Korea revealed the contradictions between the lib-
eral-internationalist desire for the peaceful resolution of differences and the limitlessly aggressive logic of the
4
anti-Communist Cold War crusade undertaken in Washington.

Figure 9.18 After the initial invasion of South Korea by the North
Korean Peoples Democratic Army (PDA), the United Nations
(UN) established a defensive line in the southern part of the
country. The landing at Inchon in September reversed the tide of
the war and allowed UN forces under General Douglas
MacArthur to retake the city of Seoul, which had fallen to North
Korean troops in the early days of the war.

A Frosty Cold War

The Soviet Unions involvement in Korea involved its new and impressive fleet of MiG-15 jet fighters, the PRC
demonstrated its ability to put a massive and effective army into the field, and the UN showed that it could call
on various member nations to contribute to the cause. It was also clear that the Americans had an agenda that was
rather different from that of the UN, although the stopped well short of deploying atomic weapons to bring about
a decisive victory. The Korean War, as well, served to establish a kind of Cold War protocol. Client states could
host proxy wars that would stand in for the toe-to-toe conflict between the two superpowers.

Joseph Stalins (1878-1953) death did nothing to blunt fear of a Russian attack on Western Europe. By the
mid-1950s, the West had come to terms with the need to re-arm West Germany (aka: the Federal Republic of
Germany) because no other state had the population or industrial capacity to act as a physical barrier to Soviet
aggression. A unified and re-armed West Germany was, of course, anathema to the Russians, who responded by
bringing together their Eastern European tribute states (Poland, Romania, Hungary, Czechoslovakia, East Ger-
many, and Bulgaria) into a mirror image of NATO: the Warsaw Pact. As in 1939, the northern hemisphere was
dividing between liberal democracies and regimes characterized by the use of authoritarian power.

4. Reg Whitaker and Gary Marcuse, Cold War Canada: The Making of a National Insecurity State, 1945-1957 (Toronto: University of Toronto
Press, 1994), 396-401.
 9.4 THE COLD WAR 489

Figure 9.19 NATO and NATO-aligned nations (in blue) square

off against the Warsaw Pact nations (in red, of course).

At home the Canadian response to the Cold War would take several forms. There were anti-communist purges
in trade unions, the civil service, and elsewhere in Canada even before the McCarthyite witch hunts in the
United States. Trade unions with a strong communist tradition, including waterfront workers organizations, were
smashed under the leadership of Hal Banks (1909-1985), an American brought in to replace the left-leaning
unions with the Seafarers International Union. As in Britain and other NATO countries, homosexuals were tar-
geted (for reasons discussed in Section 12.7).

American fears of homegrown communist movements springing up in the Americas and in Africa, the Middle
East, and Asia prompted interventions in various countries. In some instances, American involvement resulted
in defeat of legitimate left-wing movements; in others, liberal democratic regimes were propped up. In Cuba, an
unpopular regime faced local rebels who were supported by an American embargo. The government fell and was
replaced by a regime headed by Fidel Castro (b. 1926), which proceeded to turn sharply left and align with the
USSR rather than the United States. The Cold War was now in the Americas.

Polar and Polaris

Technologies associated with warfare rapidly evolved after World War II. Canadian interest in jet-propulsion was
led by A.V. Roe Canada (aka: AVRO), a British branch-plant in Malton, Ontario. Missile developments were also
accelerating. Much of the advance made after 1945 was due to the availability of former German engineers who
found themselves at the end of the war in either the Soviet or American spheres. In both the East and the West,
intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBMs) were being developed with a greater range and payload than con-
ventional bomber aircraft. These delivery systems brought Soviet and American targets within striking distance,
providing they crossed the Arctic and Canadian airspace. The 1971 post-apocalyptic novel by Ian Adams, The
Trudeau Papers, described Canadians worst fears in these years, not of being targeted by the Russians but just
being caught in between the two superpowers in a missile-slinging match. The spread of nuclear know-how and
armaments to France (the so-called Force de frappe) and Britain (with its arsenal of submarine-launched Polaris
missiles) did little to calm a growing sense that the world, including Canada, had no place to hide in the event of
a nuclear war. The first material expression of these fears was the construction of the Pinetree Line beginning in
1946 and improved through the 1950s. This radar system, running from west to east from 50 to 54 degrees lati-
tude, was introduced to detect an incoming Soviet bomber attack. In the 1950s, the Mid-Canada Line (or McGill
Fence) was added further north in the face of advances in jet engines, which meant a faster target to intercept. The
successor Distant Early Warning (DEW) Line followed in the late 1950s and through the 1970s as a response to
the possibility of ICBM attacks. Strung across the Arctic Ocean from Alaska to Baffin Island, the Dew Line still
stands as Canadas single largest investment in infrastructure in the high Arctic.
 490 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 9.20 Whether NORADs triple radar defence structure

would do what it was designed to do was never fully put to the
test.

Spy World

In 1963, British newspapers announced a scandalous liaison between Christine Keeler (a model and show-
girl, b. 1942) and the Secretary of State for War, John Profumo (1915-2006). Keeler was also having a rela-
tionship with a Soviet military intelligence officer, Yevgeny Ivanov (1926-1994). The Profumo Affair, as
it became known, set the tone for a similar scandal in Canada. In both, a femme fatale figured prominently
as a sexual predator who could compromise national security. The Canadian press latched onto details as
they came out of Ottawa, eager to sell a salacious affair to their readers.
Gerda Munsinger (1929-1998) was the main figure in this web of intrigue. She made several failed
attempts to emigrate from postwar Germany under her birth-name (Hesler, Hessler, or Heseler, although
she used several aliases). In 1955, she managed to elude immigration checks and arrived in Montreal,
where she worked for a year as a maid and then as a sex worker and a hostess at Chez Paree, a Montreal
nightclub. High-ranking government officials regularly frequented establishments like Chez Paree, and in
no time Munsinger was having sexual relations with several of them. Whats more, she established regu-
lar liaisons with two of John Diefenbakers (1895-1979) cabinet ministers: Minister of Transport George
Hees (1910-1996) and Associate Defence Minister Pierre Svigny (1917-2004). Both the American Cen-
tral Intelligence Agency (CIA) and the RCMP believed that Munsinger might pose a threat. Wiretaps on
her apartment confirmed that she was having an affair with one or more cabinet ministers. Svignys iden-
tity was allegedly confirmed by a thumping sound on the RCMP tapes that turned out to be his prosthetic
leg coming off and hitting the floor. There was, however, no evidence of a security breach. Diefenbaker
was advised of the situation in 1960; he instructed Svigny to break off the relationship, Svigny did so,
and the matter was left there until 1966.
Spy cases continued to surface. The new Liberal governments handling of one on the West Coast drew
fire from the Progressive Conservative Official Opposition. Diefenbaker criticized the Minister of Justice,
Lucien Cardin (1919-1988), of being lax in his pursuit of traitors; Cardin responded by invoking Diefen-
bakers involvement in the to this point, secret Munsinger case. Despite repeated attempts on Prime
Minister Pearsons part to contain the issue, Cardin disclosed what he knew to the press and was the first
to draw the comparison with the Profumo Affair. There were, however, no new revelations of espionage,
just marital infidelity on the part of Svigny.
By this time, Munsinger had returned to Germany, where she remarried. The investigative journalism pro-
5
gram, This Hour Has Seven Days , pursued the story and was abruptly cancelled thereafter by the CBC.
The Munsinger Affair which billed the central figure as a Cold War Mata Hari perpetuated the notion
of good men brought down by shady women working for enemy states. It was also something of a last gasp
of the pre-sexual liberation era and says much about domestic, monogamous heterosexuality as not only a
moral ideal but a matter of political and even national security as well.

5. From which the comedy troupe, This Hour Has 22 Minutes, derives its name and news-show format.
 9.4 THE COLD WAR 491

Figure 9.21 Canadian members of the UN Emergency Force

(UNEF) patrolling the border between Egypt and Israel, 1962.

Surviving the Cold War

Following the Suez Crisis in 1956 (see Sections 9.5 and 9.7), Canada engaged in a series of peacekeeping mis-
sions. These grew out of then-Foreign Affairs Secretary of State Lester Pearsons idea of a UN observer force to
calm relations between Egypt, Israel, France, and England. In the decade that followed, Canadian troops would
be sent to Lebanon, Congo, West New Guinea, Yemen, Cyprus, the Dominican Republic, and along the India-
Pakistan border sometimes as observers, sometimes as trainers, sometimes as a barrier between opponents still
snarling at one another despite a ceasefire, sometimes all these things at once. Eleven more missions would follow
in the years before the end of the Cold War. While some of these missions involved client states of the West and
East or their respective partisans, mostly they could be defined as events associated with decolonization. This was
the case in the Congo (as Belgium made an undignified exit), West New Guinea (where conflict arose between
colonialist Netherlands and newly independent Indonesia), and also in the long-running dispute between India and
Pakistan in the generation following their independence from Britain. The Cypriot Mission which began in
1964 and shows few signs of abating also came on the heels of independence from Britain, followed by Greek
and Turkish attempts to lay claim to what had been a Crown Colony. What is striking in these years is the extent
to which these Cold-Warera conflicts were more fundamentally about 19th century imperialism than postwar
superpower spheres of influence. This was not the case in Cuba.

The Cuban Missile Crisis in 1962 deepened Canadian fears of a nuclear war between Russia and the United States.
The long-range missiles that the Soviet Union proposed to deploy on Cuba would certainly reach major Canadian
population centres if they were ever launched. The Americans were insistent that the Soviets abort the project and,
for the better part of two weeks, Washington and Moscow (which was, itself, affronted by the forward deployment
of American missiles in Turkey) stared into the abyss.

Diefenbakers government offered support to the American government led by President John F. Kennedy
(1917-1963), but not unconditionally. Diefenbaker preferred the idea of a UN-led intervention, something that
got no traction whatsoever in Washington, DC. This tepid response led to heightened tensions between Canada
and the United States. The crisis overall contributed to Canadian fears that the Americans would, by their own
miscalculated actions, precipitate a nuclear holocaust. The Liberal Prime Ministers Pearson and Pierre Trudeau
would follow Diefenbakers lead and were publicly critical of American foreign policy. (Joe Clarks government
was in office only briefly but evinced a more cooperative position generally.) After 20 years of sanctions, Ottawa
opened discussions with China in 1968 and diplomatic recognition of the PRC in 1970. Canada (along with Mex-
ico) did not sever diplomatic ties with Cuba, and Trudeau was the first Western leader to pay a visit to Havana.
In 1972, Cold War drama played out on ice in the Canada-USSR Hockey Series (aka: the Summit Series); while
the overarching narrative was West versus East, capitalism versus communism, the event generated in Canada
considerable respect for the Soviet players, their coaches, and their fans, and thus put at least a small dent in the
Iron Curtain. More formally, in 1976, Trudeau travelled to Cuba to meet with Castro. This was in keeping with
492 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Trudeaus own foreign affairs perspective, and it was also in sync with the emerging American philosophy of
dtente. Nonetheless, growing American involvement in Cold War client-state wars from Vietnam through Africa
and Latin America led to growing anti-American feeling among the Canadian public and that was reflected in
Ottawas foreign policies.

The tenor of Cold War relations between Canada and the United States would continue to be mostly critical until
Trudeaus Liberal government was replaced in 1984 by Brian Mulroney (b. 1939) and a Conservative majority.
Mulroneys campaign to improve relations with the Americans led to a close personal relationship with United
States President and archCold-Warrior Ronald Reagan (1911-2004) and, eventually, to a free trade agreement
between the two countries (discussed in Section 9.12). The dying years of the Cold War, then, would see Canadas
position vis--vis the Soviet Bloc harden into something that more closely resembled the American view.

Key Points

The Cold War began at the end of World War II and persisted through the 1980s. It represents a
polarization of global forces into two camps: America and its allies (represented by NATO and
sometimes the UN) and the Soviet Union with its supporters (represented by the Warsaw Pact and
sometimes China).
Canadas entry into the Cold War came with the disclosure in 1946 of a spy ring led by Igor
Gouzenko.
Involvement in NATO and support for the UN led Canada to be an active participant in the Korean
War in 1949.
In 1949, the Soviet Union detonated its first atomic bomb, and the age of superpowers was launched.
Canadian defence strategies in the Cold War changed as Canada aligned more with the United States
and prepared for a missile assault across the Arctic. Ottawa also launched an anti-fifthcolumn strat-
egy to reduce the threat of homegrown communists.
Involvement in peacekeeping missions began in this period as an attempt to find diplomatic solu-
tions became a Canadian priority, in contrast with the American strategy of containment.

Attributions
Figure 9.14
[Private G.U.I. Lambert,B2nd nd Battalion Royal 22e Regiment, reads comic book in slit trench, Korea, 28
May, 1951.] (Online MIKAN no.3382576) by Paul E. Tomelin / Canada. Dept. of National Defence / Library
and Archives Canada is in the public domain.

Figure 9.15
W. L. Brintnell [left and] Stan McMillan [at Fort] McMurray [Alta.] First load of uranium concentrate flown
from Great Bear Lake to Fort McMurray (Online MIKAN no.3382001) by Brintnell, W.L. / Library and
Archives Canada / PA-102850 is in the public domain.
 9.4 THE COLD WAR 493

Figure 9.16
FBI Joins Ottawa Spy Hunt by unknown is used under a CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.

Figure 9.17
Meeting between Dr. Norman Bethune (left) and Nieh Jung-Chen (centre), Commander-in-Chief of the Chin-
Cha-Chi Border Region (Online MIKAN no.3194839) by Library and Archives Canada / PA-114787 is in the
public domain.

Figure 9.18
CNX History Korea Map by OpenStax CNX is used under a CC-BY-4.0 license.

Figure 9.19
Cold war europe military alliances map en by San Jose is used under a CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.

Figure 9.20
Dew line 1960 by the United States Government is in the public domain.

Figure 9.21
Canadian members of the United Nations Emergency Force (UNEF) on the border between Egypt and Israel
(Online MIKAN no.3194306) by Department of National Defence (Canada) / Library and Archives Canada /
PA-122737 is in the public domain.
9.5 Post-War Leadership and State-making

Figure 9.22 A rare picture of women voting. Nursing Sisters

on the Western front in WWI, 1917.

It is easy to misapprehend Canadian politics as an arena in which the rules are stable and the participants are easy
to identify. Politics, ultimately, is about power, who shares in it, and how it is divided up among those participants.
When Canada was created as a constitutional entity in 1867, it was with a particular body politic in mind. Fifty
years later, much about that political realm had changed. A century later, and it would have been unrecognizable
to the nations founding generation.

The Elect, the Electorate, and the Elected

There are several dimensions to political life and how it evolves, among which we can include participation. As
we have seen (in Chapter 3 and elsewhere), the limits of democracy were far greater in 1867 than any tendency
toward inclusiveness. The most dramatic changes in the franchise came in the 20th century. Universal male suf-
frage was still tightly constrained: Asians and most Aboriginal peoples could not vote, and property require-
ments ensured that many working men could not vote, as well. Rounding out race and class as restrictions on
the franchise was, of course, gender. Women were unable to vote provincially and federally until the 1910s and,
when the breakthrough came, the franchise only included women who fit the racialized categories of citizenship.
Restrictions against the female franchise in Quebec until 1940 impacted womens federal voting rights because the
province maintained both the provincial and federal voters list until the 1930s. Clearly, the move toward greater
democratic rights was not a one-way street; rather, it was a highway with a passing lane and room for parking on
the shoulder.

The Dominion Elections Act (1920) made womens suffrage a permanent arrangement rather than a temporary,
wartime expedient. It also created the office of the Chief Electoral Officer and insulated it from the pressures of
patronage politics. Preparation of voters lists, the enforcement of rules for behaviour on election day, and responsi-
bility for promoting awareness of electoral rights and polling station locations created a more level and consistent
playing field for politics at the federal level, though not overnight. Most provinces quickly followed this example.

494
 9.5 POST-WAR LEADERSHIP AND STATE-MAKING 495

By the 1940s, the formal property qualifications for the federal franchise had been excised, and transient working
people were thereby brought into the electorate.

Even as these improvements were being made for some, democracys welcome mat was being pulled in for others.
The 1920 Act allowed provinces to exclude voters for reasons of race. British Columbias legislators decided
repeatedly to block Asian immigrants from the polls and were successful; Chinese settlers in Saskatchewan suf-
fered the same fate. During the Japanese-Canadian internment of 1942 to 1945, British Columbians of Japanese
ancestry carried the question of their exclusion as they were moved to other provinces. While federal politicians
were generally prepared to turn a blind eye to British Columbian racism, they were less happy when it was brought
to their own doorstep. Nevertheless, wartime fears of the Japanese Empire were enough to ensure that racist
barriers to Asian-Canadian suffrage persisted. Reforms in 1947 actually worsened matters by disenfranchising
Doukhobors, Hutterites, and Mennonites ostensibly for their pacifism (members of these communities who served
in the military were exempt from the Acts provisions). The good news in 1947 was that the Chinese-Canadian
community was enfranchised; a year later, the Japanese-Canadian community won the federal vote and in 1949,
the British Columbia vote.

Figure 9.23 United States President Truman, British Prime

Minister Attlee, and Mackenzie King meet in 1945 to discuss the
atomic bomb. King wrestled briefly with the idea of a huge
number of civilian casualties but confided to his diary, It is
fortunate that the use of the bomb should have been upon the
Japanese rather than upon the white races of Europe.

By 1950, only two identity groups lacked the vote: some members of the pacifist/communal communities and
Status Indians. Legislation in 1955 removed religious beliefs as cause for electoral discrimination. In 1960, the
Canadian Bill of Rights extended the vote to all adult Aboriginals. Not all First Nations communities were enthu-
siastic supporters of the franchise. British subjecthood and, after 1947, Canadian citizenship and electoral rights
had always implied or entailed some loss of Aboriginal autonomy and identity. Indeed, many of the public and
legislative debates on this topic revolved around the assimilative prospects of the franchise. The rights granted in
1
1960, however, were presented as an unconditional opportunity and were broadly accepted.

Figure 9.24 Status Indians were able to vote for the first time in
1960. Lawrence Salleby, Chief Ralph Loucks, Lucy Musgrove,
and Eldon Muskrat at the ballot box in the Hiawatha Council
Hall, October 1960.

1. A useful survey of the franchise can be found at Elections Canada, A History of the Vote in Canada, [Link]
[Link]?section=res&dir=his&document=index&lang=e, accessed 22 December 2015.
496 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Who was left to enfranchise? Prisoners in Canadas penal system were excluded, as were the judges who sent
them to prison. Some Canadians with mental disabilities were not allowed to vote. Reforms in 1993 responded
to the existence of the new Charter of Rights by removing barriers to judges, people with mental disabilities, and
prisoners serving sentences of two years or less. At the time of writing, the largest group left without the franchise
is the non-adult population. It is worth considering that many of the arguments made, successively, against giving
the vote to working men, women, and Aboriginal peoples that they were insufficiently informed or knowledge-
able on political matters, subject to pressures from authority figures, and probably not interested in getting the
vote notwithstanding a few loud agitators, suffragettes (and so on) are often the very same objections raised
against enfranchising non-adults.

Mackenzie Kings Secret Life

Christopher Dummitt, School for the Study of Canada, Trent University

No other prime minister has ever been as successful as William Lyon Mackenzie King (1874-1950). No
other prime minister has ever been as strange.
The first claim is undoubtedly true. Mackenzie King governed the country for almost 22 years beginning
in 1921 and lasting until 1948, with only two periods out of office briefly in 1926 and then from 1930
to 1935. This isnt only a Canadian record. Its the longest time in office of any leader of a parliamentary
democracy. But was he also very odd?
This is what many Canadians came to think about Weird Willie Mackenzie King. While he was alive,
he was never very popular. He was not a great orator nor did he look the part of the great statesman. Yet
Mackenzie King was a shrewd and intuitive political leader who, time and time again, seemed to best grasp
what the largest share of the Canadian public wanted. At the time of his death in 1950, the newspapers
memorialized Mackenzie King as a great Canadian.
Only weeks after his death, the newspapers were also reporting that Mackenzie King had been a spiritual-
ist. That is, they claimed that he believed that he could communicate with ghosts. Over the years, more and
more stories emerged about how he had consulted mediums to speak to his dead mother and grandfather
and the ghosts of his political idols and former opponents. When his diaries were opened up to the public
in the 1970s, they seemed to show a man who had lived a double life; publicly, he was a staid politician
but privately, he engaged in the oddities of the occult. The diaries also revealed, some historians claimed,
that the bachelor prime minister had visited prostitutes as a young man and then returned home to confess
guiltily to his diary. Novelists and poets picked up on the figure of Weird Willie and he showed up in
novels, poetry, and plays he even earned his own CBC television miniseries.

Figure 9.25 Mackenzie King with his dog, Pat I, the

first of a succession of Pats with whom he
maintained a spiritual relationship after they died.

Other historians have challenged the accuracy and usefulness of this idea of our most successful prime
 9.5 POST-WAR LEADERSHIP AND STATE-MAKING 497

minister as a ghost-talking, sex-trade client. Yet whatever side one takes, perhaps the most interesting con-
clusion we can reach about the Weird Willie phenomenon is to think about why it happened at all. The
popularity of this idea of Mackenzie King having led a secret life tells us something about him, but it also
tells us about Canadian culture and politics in the years after he died.
At the time of Mackenzie Kings death in 1950, journalists and historians could have known about his
private life but chose not to delve too deeply into it. They remained deferential to the privacy of a states-
man. Indeed, a 1949 biography of Mackenzie King even mentioned his interest in what he called psychic
research. Yet no journalists followed up on these revelations.
If we fast-forward to the mid-1970s, Canadians were lining up to buy books about his double life that
exposed the allegedly lurid details of his sex life and his mystical beliefs. It wasnt only that new infor-
mation had emerged, something else had happened too: Canadian political culture had become much less
deferential. Journalists and citizens demanded more of their political figures. As a result of the sexual rev-
olution of the 1960s, some parts of life that had been considered out of bounds like speaking about
someones sex life were no longer taboo. What the ghost of Mackenzie King found out is that this new
openness and frankness applied even to dead politicians.
When we think about Weird Willie and his secret life, we are actually learning about two historical eras.
The first is the era in which King lived. The second is the years after Mackenzie King died, the postwar
decades. The transformation in Canadian values in these years led journalists and the public to want to lay
bare the secret lives of those who governed them.

Additional Readings

C P Stacey, A Very Double Life: The Private World of Mackenzie King (Toronto: Macmillan, 1976).
Michael Bliss, Right Honourable Men: The Descent of Canadian Politics from Macdonald to Chretien
(Toronto: Harper Perennial, 2004).
Christopher Dummitt, The People Unfooled: Mackenzie Kings Secret Life and the Making of an Irrev-
erent Democracy (Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, forthcoming).

Figure 9.26 Louis St. Laurent and W.L. Mackenzie King at the
UN Conference on International Organization in 1945.

Uncle Louis
Of all the 20th-century governments, it is probably easiest to undervalue the importance of the St. Laurent admin-
istrations. Louis St. Laurent (1882-1973) does not appear on Canadian currency. He was charismatic, but in an
understated and avuncular way (unlike Diefenbaker and Trudeau, who followed him). He was not even though
perhaps he should have been a Nobel Prize winner (unlike his successor at the head of the Liberal Party, Lester
B. Pearson), and he only (only!) held office for a decade, unlike his exceptional predecessor, Mackenzie King.
And yet remarkable things were accomplished under St. Laurent, and that first Cold War decade decided much
about the rest of the 20th century for Canada.
 498 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

St. Laurent inherited the Prime Ministers Office (PMO) from Mackenzie King and led the Liberals to their
largest majority ever in 1949. He did comparably well in 1953. The Liberals oversaw economic and governmental
expansion of a kind that was unparalleled before and after St. Laurents mandate. The economy rebounded from
the postwar doldrums and emerged from the Korean War in better shape than when it went into it.

Whats more, St. Laurent personally changed the political culture in that he humanized the role of leader. He was
old: when he took over the PMO, he was already 66, the oldest person to enter the position ever. Perhaps because
he came to the job late in life he lacked the stuffiness of Bennett, the careerism of King, or the hustle of Diefen-
baker. Indeed, St. Laurent was known to ignore voters and journalists if there were children nearby with whom he
could chat instead, for which he earned the epithet, Uncle Louis in English Canada, and Papa Louis in French
Canada.

Nevertheless St. Laurents peers described him as effective and intellectually sharp. His critics thought that he was
obsessively anti-communist and too quick to involve Canada in the wider world. St. Laurent would probably plead
guilty to both charges. He played a leading role in the creation of NATO, established permanent Canadian bases
in West Germany, took Canada into the anti-communist war in East Asia, committed resources to the Pinetree and
Mid-Canada radar defence lines, and contributed significantly to Canadas role in negotiating a diplomatic solu-
tion to the Suez Crisis in 1956.

St. Laurents worldview must have been formed decades earlier but his anti-communist instincts were sharpened
by the 1946 Gouzenko Affair. St. Laurents actions in these years speak to a Cold War-era fear of the Soviet Union
and concern that small wars Korea and the Israel-Egypt conflict could lead to full-blown nuclear holocausts.
Like King, he envisioned Canada occupying the position of middle power, playing a critical role and broker-
ing peace between high-flying superpowers and the major powers. As well, he saw a role in building an alliance
of like-minded nations with comparable influence. To that end, he championed the cause of an inclusive Com-
monwealth that went beyond the so-called White Dominions and included India (led in these years by its first
post-independence prime minister, Jawaharlal Nehru) and other emergent colonies in Asia and Africa. While he
advanced these arguably progressive objectives, St. Laurent in 1949 oversaw the wholesale purge of left-wingers
2
in the National Film Board.

In terms of social policies, St. Laurents administration promoted the agenda of the postwar settlement and the
welfare state. All Canadians over 70 years of age would get pensions; those over 65 were eligible for assis-
tance. The government pushed the provinces, too, with respect to post-secondary education and healthcare. Invest-
ments in infrastructure were part of Ottawas job-creation plan, and it was under St. Laurent that the St. Lawrence
Seaway, the Trans-Canada Pipeline, and the Trans-Canada Highway were completed. In this respect, St. Lau-
rent inherited from King a political environment that included social democratic, agrarian socialist, and populist
3
Social Credit traditions and parties. Holding the middle ground by borrowing from both sides was a Liberal Party
practice that St. Laurents regime refined.

St. Laurents anti-Soviet position inevitably brought him closer to the United States, something about which some
Canadians were conflicted and to which others were adamantly opposed. What would have inflamed opinion
among the latter group was the Prime Ministers role in the Suez Crisis. Britain (along with France and in support

2. Reg Whitaker and Steve Hewitt, Canada and the Cold War: The Making of a National Insecurity State, 1945-1957 (Toronto: James Lorimer
& Co., 2003), 10.
3. Alvin Finkel, Our Lives: Canada After 1945 (Toronto: James Lorimer & Company, 1997), 6-7.
 9.5 POST-WAR LEADERSHIP AND STATE-MAKING 499

of Israel) had blundered into an attempt to capture the Suez Canal. This took place just as the Americans were
protesting the Soviet Unions suppression of the Hungarian Uprising of 1956. Embarrassed by the timing of the
British military expedition against Egypt and fearing Soviet reprisals against NATO partners in Western Europe,
the Americans took a highly critical stance of Britain. For Canada to stand by while Britain was effectively at war
was one thing; for Canada to side with the Americans against Britain was entirely another.

This was, in many respects, continuity rather than rupture. Mackenzie King had always been closer to the United
States than to the United Kingdom. Ogdensburg certainly confirmed that. Mackenzie Kings so-called Minister of
Everything, C.D. Howe (1886-1960), was also St. Laurents chief planner and carried on through these crises as
though it was still 1943. Anti-American feeling, concern that members of the Liberal Party were getting fat off
of government contracts, and worn out by more than a decade of Howes steamroller approach to getting projects
done, Canadians took a renewed interest in the option of voting Conservative, especially as that party had found a
new, charismatic leader in John Diefenbaker.

Exercise: Documents

Do nothing by halves which can be done by quarters. (F.R. Scott, W.L.M.K.)

Mackenzie Kings diaries survived incineration almost by chance, and we are so much richer for it. He was
assiduous in maintaining a journal and surprisingly frank. And sometimes odd. Any kind of coincidence
caught his attention and he filled it with meaning. The hands of a clock both at 12, the recurrence of a
colour, similarities in names they all signaled to him some higher force at work.
No other public figure in the history of Canada left us such an extensive record of their private thoughts on
both personal and public matters.
Mackenzie Kings careful notebooks were transcribed in typescript, beginning in 1950. These are only par-
tial when compared to the original. Nonetheless, they present surprising detail. In December 1944, while
the world was at war, Mackenzie King had a night of interrupted sleep. In the middle of the night, he
recorded his recollection of a disturbing dream. In the morning, he receives news of still more psychic
events in Montreal. Are these the ramblings of an exhausted prime minister, or do they reveal something
of the inner workings of the early 20th century, modern mind?

Figure 9.E1 A page from the typescript version of

Mackenzie Kings journal, 10 December 1944.

Key Points

Changes in the democratic franchise continued to be made (federally and provincially) in the
500 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

mid-20th century, mostly tending toward greater inclusiveness, but there were significant reversals
as well, principally based on race and pacifism.
Mackenzie Kings complex and extensive secret life of spiritualism, seances, and superstition was
kept under the public radar because of greater deference shown to political leaders at the time.
The postwar boom was ushered in by the Liberals under Louis St. Laurent a decade that saw
Canada become active in global diplomacy, counter-espionage, communist hunts, and massive infra-
structure projects.

Attributions
Figure 9.22
Des infirmires militaires dun hpital canadien en train de voter aux lections fdrales canadiennes (Online
MIKAN no.3623046) by William Rider-Rider / Canada. Dept. of National Defence / Bibliothque et Archives
Canada / PA-002279 is in the public domain.

Figure 9.23
President Harry Truman and Rt. Hons. Clement Attlee and Mackenzie King boarding U.S.C.G. SEQUOIA for
discussions about the atomic bomb.(Online MIKAN no.3193181) by Library and Archives Canada / C-023269
is in the public domain.

Figure 9.24
In Hiawatha Council Hall on occasion of federal by-election (Online MIKAN no.3364668) by Nick Nickels /
Library and Archives Canada / PA-123915 has nil restrictions on use.

Figure 9.25
Rt. Hon. W.L. Mackenzie King, Prime Minister of Canada from 1921 to 1926; from 1926 to 1930 and 1935
to 1948 with his dog Pat I at Moorside Cottage (Online MIKAN no.3240769) by Yousuf Karsh / Library and
Archives Canada / PA-174051 is in the public domain.

Figure 9.26
Rt. Hon. W.L. Mackenzie King and Hon. Louis St. Laurent at the United Nations Conference on International
Organization (Online MIKAN no.3193179) by Nicholas Morant / National Film Board of Canada. Phototheque
/ Library and Archives Canada / C-022717 is in the public domain.

Figure 9.E1
Kings journal, 10 December 1944. Library and Archives [Link] Nicholas Morant / National Film Board of
Canada. Phototheque / Library and Archives Canada / C-022717 is in the public domain.
9.6 Dief is the Chief

From 1896 to 1957, the Liberal Party ran Canada, with only three intermissions. There was the decade from
1911 to 1920, when Robert Borden (1854-1937) and his Conservative/Union governments were in power. Arthur
Meighen (1874-1960) was Prime Minister for three months in 1926. R.B. Bennett (1870-1947) held the job from
1930 to 1935. Thats only 15 years of Conservative government, as opposed to 46 years of Liberal administration.
And most of that Liberal lock on power was on Mackenzie Kings watch. By the late 1950s, change was, arguably,
overdue, as the leadership of the Liberal Party looked more and more like an aging dynasty, one that included the
brusque and arrogant C.D. Howe. St. Laurents pro-Americanism grated in many quarters and there was a grow-
ing sense that big infrastructure projects helped contractors and their friends while the governments commitment
to social welfare more generally was tempered by a fiscal conservatism.

In 1957, the Conservatives under their new leader, John Diefenbaker (1895-1979), capitalized on Liberal weak-
nesses and a campaign that was noteworthy for embarrassing moments. Diefenbaker (aka: Dief) represented the
left-wing of the conservative tradition in Canada he was a Red Tory and was committed to the ideal of the
common good. His position on expanding the welfare state, for example, was more aggressive than St. Laurents,
a fact that probably cost the Co-operative Commonwealth Federation (CCF) some votes and, indeed, seats. A
populist speaker on the campaign trail, Diefenbaker had a near-legendary memory for faces and names; he was, as
well, the first credible non-francophone, nonAnglo-Celtic leader. He was, like so many Westerners, from central
European stock and was unencumbered by either the old Tory fetish for British royalism nor the reflexive North
American continentalist response. He surprised the pundits by winning enough seats to form a minority govern-
ment. In 1958, he went back to the polls and was returned with the biggest majority to date.

Two issues dominated the Diefenbaker years. One of these was civil and personal liberties. The other was relations
with the United States. These would all overlap in ways that could only have happened in the Cold War.

Diefenbaker and the Rise of Rights

Before 1960, the rights that were enjoyed by some Canadians and denied to others were of two kinds. There
were those established in British Common Law (some of which dated back to the Magna Carta) and those that
could be found in various pieces of legislation such as the Persons Act or the Indian Act. There was no single
statement of principles comparable to the American Bill of Rights. It is perhaps ironic that the Canadian prime
minister most associated with mid-century nationalism produced a legislative statement that brought the Canadian
culture of rights more into line with that of the United States. It was, however, a long-term project of Diefen-

501
 502 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

bakers. Begun in the 1930s when he was a Prince Albert lawyer, it was probably nudged along by the introduc-
tion of the Saskatchewan Bill of Rights in 1947.

Figure 9.27 Diefenbakers legal career put him in regular contact

with Aboriginal communities in Saskatchewan. More than any of
his predecessors, he took steps to involve First Nations directly in
public life and the economy.

The Canadian Bill of Rights (1960) arose in part from an increased postwar interest in human rights. This was
an ideal championed by the United Nations, made more pressing with the revelations of the Nuremberg Trials.
It was also a bedrock issue in the West as regards Cold War rhetoric. That is, rights were associated with free
democracies and not with communist or fascist regimes. In practice, the Canadian Bill of Rights was limited in its
impact. Its range was limited to federal laws, it did not involve a constitutional change, and it neither called for
nor engaged in the kind of housekeeping needed to eliminate contradictions in existing legislation. Nevertheless,
it was a landmark in that it was a bold and concise statement of rights that extended to all members of Canadian
society: to wit:

1. It is hereby recognized and declared that in Canada there have existed and shall continue to exist without dis-
crimination by reason of race, national origin, colour, religion or sex, the following human rights and fundamental
1
freedoms, namely,

(a) the right of the individual to life, liberty, security of the person and enjoyment of property, and the right not
to be deprived thereof except by due process of law;

(b) the right of the individual to equality before the law and the protection of the law;

(c) freedom of religion;

(d) freedom of speech;

(e) freedom of assembly and association; and

(f) freedom of the press,

Diefenbakers commitment to a more inclusive vision of Canada manifested itself in other ways, too. He extended
the franchise to Aboriginal peoples and, in 1960, appointed Ellen Fairclough (1905-2005) to his Cabinet, making
her the first woman to hold an executive position in the federal government, and he sent James Gladstone (aka:
Akay-na-muka, 1887-1971) to the Senate the first Aboriginal person to hold such an appointment.

The Canadian Identity

From 1867 to 1958, the essential debate over the nature of Canadian nationhood was between those who yearned
for unity in duality and those who sought a single (typically, anglophone) nationality. The Conservatives in the
1950s continued to suffer in Quebec from the legacy of Bordens conscription policies so much so that Diefen-

1. Bill c-44, Canadian Bill of Rights, S.C. 1960 (assented to 10 August 1960)
 9.6 DIEF IS THE CHIEF 503

baker did not bring a single Qubecois MP into his Cabinet. This did nothing to repair the relationship between
the Tories and Quebec. Moreover, Diefenbaker was adamantly opposed to dualism, which, given the history of
the Conservatives, might not be terribly surprising. But there was a new twist: Diefenbaker objected to special
concessions to Quebec and to francophones, not because he would rather they were anglophones or because doing
so would subtract from the rights of anglophones, but because the binary logic of dualism impaired the citizenship
of Canadians drawn from other ethnic/national groups and did nothing at all for Aboriginal peoples. For Diefen-
baker, legislation such as the Bill of Rights created guarantees for all Canadians rather than concessions based
on ancestry or culture. This was the essence of his One Canada policy that was dismissed by many Canadians,
although it contained the germ of what would become known as multiculturalism a decade later.

Diefenbaker and World Affairs

Although Pearson is the prime minister most often associated with diplomatic ability, Diefenbaker did much to
reorient Canada internationally. He was perpetually suspicious of American influences and sought to improve
Canadian trade with Britain and raise Canadas profile in the Commonwealth. When white voters in South Africa
decided by referendum in 1960 to become a republic (one in which black and Asian citizens would have far fewer
rights), the Commonwealth was asked to permit South Africa to continue as a member. Diefenbaker went on
record as hostile to apartheid and was able to persuade the Commonwealth countries (other than Britain and New
Zealand) that racial equality was a principle of the association. South Africa was thus obliged to withdraw from
the Commonwealth.

During the Suez Crisis of 1956, Diefenbaker chided Pearson and St. Laurent for getting too close to the Ameri-
cans. The White House took note and, observing Diefenbakers pro-Commonwealth orientation, expected that he
would be a difficult prime minister. But, in 1958, he carried forward the Liberal governments commitment to the
North American Aerospace Defense Command (NORAD) agreement with the United States. NORAD effec-
tively made Canada part of the American frontline of defense against a Soviet missile attack and it was responsible
for administering the Pinetree, Mid-Canada, and DEW Lines. It was under Diefenbaker, as well, that the promis-
ing Avro Arrow program was scrapped. The CF-100 Canuck was, in the early 1950s, the first of Avro Canadas
innovations in jet-powered aircraft, and it was followed by a much more sophisticated, delta-wing jet called the
Avro Arrow. The first operational unit was unveiled on 4 October 1957. The date matters because of the coinci-
dental launch that day of the first space satellite, the Russian Sputnik. What might have served as a cutting-edge
bomber interceptor had, in a stroke, been rendered inadequate by the possibility of long-range, rocket-launched
attacks.

Figure 9.28 No love lost. Diefenbaker and (to his right) Governor
General Georges Vanier host President John F. Kennedy in 1961.
First Lady Jacqueline Kennedy and Olive Diefenbaker can be
seen as well.

Rising costs, slumping demand from the Royal Canadian Airforce (RAF), an abject failure to sell units to the
504 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Americans or elsewhere internationally, and a growing sense that the Arrow would fare badly in an ICBM world,
cast the Arrow project in a dim light. The new Bomarc anti-aircraft missile promised to perform better and, pre-
sented with an either-or choice, Diefenbaker opted in 1959 to go with the missiles. Two American-built, Canadian-
managed Bomarc launch sites were constructed in Canada, but the question remained as to whether the missiles
would be nuclear-tipped. Diefenbaker and his cabinet procrastinated before deciding against the nuclear-tipped
option, as the 1962 election campaign drew closer. Although Diefenbaker had got on well enough with Ameri-
can President Dwight Eisenhower (1890-1969), there was little other than mutual loathing between the Canadian
prime minister and President John F. Kennedy. (Kennedy regarded Diefenbaker as a boring son of a bitch and
seemed determined to mispronounce the Prime Ministers surname. Diefenbaker said, likewise, of JFK, Hes a
fool too young, too brash, too inexperienced, and a boastful son of a bitch!) Pressed by Kennedy to join the
Organization of American States (OAS) a hemispheric alliance that critics regarded as an American-run Cold
War club Diefenbaker pushed back, rejected the OAS and the nuclear warheads for Bomarc.

Figure 9.29 The fate of the Arrow remains a sore point for many
Canadians.

The decision to cut Ottawas losses on the Avro Arrow (the few prototypes were subsequently cut up into scrap)
cost Avro thousands of jobs. This was politically bad enough but when coupled with the Bomarc dithering and the
poor contrast between Americas dashing new President and the far less photogenic Diefenbaker it was political
poison. To make matters worse, a deflating dollar it fell to 92.5 cents against the American dollar brought
taunts of Diefendollars and hurt the Tories chances of reelection. In 1962, the Tories were reduced to a minority
and then, in 1963, the Liberals snuck in with a minority of their own.

Beyond the Arrow

Figure 9.30 Canadian technical know-how

contributed to the Lunar Excursion Module,
thanks to lay-offs at Avro.

For the most part, Canadian technological achievements in the 1950s and 1960s were eclipsed by Ameri-
can and Soviet advances. Nevertheless, they are very much worth noting.
The Canadian automobile industry perpetually suffered against American imports and the dominance of
American design and parts. This would change somewhat with the Auto Pact (discussed in Section 8.14),
though not a great deal. Where Canadians did much better was, perhaps not surprisingly, in areas that
reflected the countrys particular environmental challenges.
 9.6 DIEF IS THE CHIEF 505

In the 1930s, a Valcourt mechanic, Joseph-Armand Bombardier (1907-1964), began work on a bus that
could run on snow. In 1937, he produced the first snowmobile, or auto-neige, a large multi-terrain vehicle
for use on Quebecs winter roads. When snowplough technology improved during the war, Bombardier
quickly refocused on military equipment and then on smaller versions of the snowmobile. The Ski-Dog
was intended for individuals and communities in the north where dog-teams were still widely used in win-
ter. An error in printing resulted in the 1959 Ski-Doo and the explosion of a recreational market. By 1969,
the late founders sons had taken over the firm and incorporated it as Bombardier Limited. Over the next
20 years, the company would move aggressively into air transport, rail technology, and rapid transit. Van-
couvers SkyTrain system (which opened in 1986), for example, relies heavily on Bombardier rolling stock
and technology. It was as a defence contractor that Bombardier first experienced significant success and it
is in that area that much Canadian technological innovation has occurred, especially in aeronautics.

Figure 9.31 Auto-neiges at or near

Sainte-Anne-des-Monts, ca. 1941.

Canadas involvement in the space race begins in earnest with the launching of the Alouette I satellite
in 1962, which made Canada only the fourth country in space. The size and shape of the country means
that Canada was bound to take an early interest in advances in telecommunications technologies. Direct
engagement with the space race competition between the Soviet Union and the United States to domi-
nate beyond the stratosphere was never on the cards. Indirect involvement, however, occurred in impor-
tant ways. When the Avro Arrow project was cancelled in 1959, nearly three dozen Canadian and British
engineers, including Owen Maynard (1924-2000), were freed up for work at the National Aeronautics and
Space Agency (NASA) in the United States. Maynard, an Ontarian, produced the preliminary designs that
led to the Lunar Module component of the first moon landing in 1969, and he was a chief engineer on
the Apollo 11 mission. Around the same time, Canada was invited by NASA to participate in the coming
Space Shuttle program; the end product was the Shuttle Remote Manipulator System, also known as the
Canadarm.

Figure 9.32 Two other 20th century

discoveries and innovations made by
Canadians are insulin (Frederick Banting
and Charles Best, 1922) and the humble but
highly efficient paint-roller (Norman
Breakey, 1940).

Not all administrations leave much in the way of a legacy. Diefenbakers definitely did, although it is not always
easy to see what it was. His One Canada mantra was enough to derail the two-centuryold discourse of two
founding nations and to begin the process of legitimizing diversity in Canada. The Bill of Rights was a significant
statement that replaced individual rights with human rights, without which the 1982 Charter of Rights and Free-
doms would have had little in the way of foundation material. Pearson was pivotal in the evolution of Canadas
role as a broker in international affairs; Diefenbakers stand against apartheid contributed to the view that Canada
was principled in that role, and not merely an impartial referee or a sidekick to Britain or the United States.
506 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

The Diefenbaker years saw Canada align more fully with the United States in the Cold War while, at the same
time, bridling against American imperialism through the OAS and American chauvinism generally. Even Pearson,
whom the Kennedy administration worked quietly to help elect, found relations with the American superpower
more difficult than he would have hoped.

Key Points

Diefenbaker (Dief) was the first Conservative Party leader to win government in a generation.
Diefenbaker proved less fiscally conservative than his Liberal predecessors and promoted welfare
statism as well as a breakthrough Bill of Rights.
Vocally nationalistic, Diefenbaker articulated a suspicion of growing American influence and, at the
same time, took Canada into NORAD and scrapped the Avro Arrow program.
Canadian involvement in the post-war acceleration of technological breakthroughs took several
forms, including terrestrial and extra-terrestrial transportation.

Attributions
Figure 9.27
Left to right: George Koneak, Fort Chimo, Que.; Shinuktuk, Rankin Inlet, N.W.T.; John G. Diefenbaker, Prince
Rupert, Sask.; Jean Ayaruark, Rankin Inlet, N.W.T.; Abraham Ogpik, Aklavik, N.W.T. In Ottawa, Ontario,
Canada, May 1959 (Online MIKAN no.3217847) by National Film Board of Canada. Photothque / Library
and Archives Canada / PA-114838 is in the public domain.

Figure 9.28
Visit of the President of United States John F. Kennedy and his wife Jacqueline. Group in front of the Govern-
ment House: President John F. Kennedy, Governor General Georges Vanier, Prime Minister John G. Diefen-
baker, Mrs. Kennedy, and Mrs. Diefenbaker (Online MIKAN no.3223704) by Duncan Cameron / Library and
Archives Canada / PA-154665 has nil restrictions on use.

Figure 9.29
DSC 6934 Canadian Pride by Dennis Jarvis is used under a CC-BY-SA-2.0 license.

Figure 9.30
5927 NASA by NASA Apollo Archive is in the public domain.

Figure 9.31
Autoneiges_-_Marsoui_Gaspesie by Jeangagnon is in the public domain.

Figure 9.32
Paint roller by Maggie is used under a CC-BY 2.0 license.
9.7 The Pearson Interlude

Figure 9.33 Pearson (at right) collected in one cabinet three future
PMs: Trudeau, Turner, and Chrtien, April 1967.

It is one of the remarkable features of Canadian political history that Lester B. Pearson is in some respects better
regarded and more widely recognized than Diefenbaker. He never won a majority government, he was at least as
much a compromiser as Mackenzie King, he did not stand up to the Americans, nor did he bring good continental
relations in his wake. Pearson does, however, have that Nobel Prize going for him, and it was under his one term
in office that many of the trappings of modern Canadian nationalism took form.

International Affairs
Pearson came to politics from a career in diplomacy. He joined the newly established Department of External
Affairs in 1927 and was subsequently posted to London for much of the World War II. His next posting was the
plum job of Canadian Ambassador to the United States. He was elected federally in 1948 and spent the next nine
years as Secretary of State for External Affairs. He had a hand in the establishment of the United Nations and
NATO. He was, of course,a key figure in resolving the Suez Canal Crisis of 1956, and successfully proposed to
the UN the idea of a peacekeeping force that could be deployed with sufficient authority and firepower that it
might keep warring sides at bay while diplomats sought a resolution outside of conflict. The Nobel Prize came to
him in 1957, just as St. Laurents government was about to collapse under the first Diefenbaker victory.

By 1962 domestic issues were competing with international affairs for the voters attention. The Cold War was
at its height, and some Canadians were drawn to a new Liberal Party leader who had a gold-plated resume in
diplomacy. Of course, many voters simply voted against the incumbent regime. Pearsons first administration,
however, was not marked by a resounding victory at the polls. The Liberals did well in Quebec, but they were not
yet restored to dominance there; indeed, the Social Credit (Socred) Party won enough seats to form a balance of
power in the Commons. It was worse elsewhere in the country. In point of fact, Pearsons government was elected
almost entirely from central Canada. Initially with the support of the Socreds, and then with the New Democratic
Party (NDP), Pearson was able to hold his minority together until another election in 1965. Thereafter, he had to
coax another minority administration along to 1968.

507
508 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Pearson campaigned in 1962 on the promise of 60 Days of Decision, a swipe at the Diefenbaker governments
inability to move forward on several key issues. Pearson quickly accepted the nuclear warheads for Bomarc mis-
siles, rushed into place universal health care under the Medical Care Act (1966), and introduced the Canada
Pension Plan (CPP). Pro-labour policies (including a minimum wage and mandatory vacation time) won support
from union elements in the NDP. Canada Student Loans were another product of the Pearson administrations.
Pearson demonstrated solid diplomatic ability when it came to making a minority government function well, but
he did less well against the Americans.

As the United States involvement in the Vietnam War increased, Washington requested that Canada commit
troops, as it had to in Korea from 1949 to 1957. The issue, from Washingtons perspective, was largely the same:
containment of communism. Pearson, however, resisted and sought to present Canada as a non-belligerent ally of
the United States. Canadian firms profited heavily from the war as they supplied necessary materiel to the United
States, including the controversial defoliant Agent Orange. Pearson did nothing to impede this trade but did speak
out against the American campaign. On 2 April 1965, speaking as a guest at Philadelphias Temple University,
Pearson endorsed the idea of a cessation in the United States bombing of North Vietnam so that talks might get
underway between the two sides. President Lyndon B. Johnson (1908-1973) was outraged that a foreign leader
would criticize his war policy, even more so because Pearson made his comments while visiting the United States.
The Prime Minister was summoned to the White House where Johnson a significantly larger man than Pearson
picked him up by the lapels and thundered, You pissed on my rug! After nearly an hour of being dressed
down, Pearson was permitted to leave and subsequently issued an apology.

The New Nationalism

Figure 9.34 Close, but not the winner: the Pearson Pennant, ca.
1964.

If St. Laurents nationalism contained elements of Henri Bourassas continentalism mixed with a global vision,
and Diefs was simultaneously anti-American and somewhat pro-British, Pearsons drew on old Imperialist
dreams of Canada as a leader on the world stage while disavowing both British and American orientations.

Pearson contributed to the dialogue on Canadian identity in several important, if highly symbolic ways. First, and
probably most notably, he was responsible for initiating the Flag Debate, out of which came the successor to the
Red Ensign, the Maple Leaf flag. Although his preferred version two blue borders on a white centre with three
red maple leaves failed to get support (it was mocked as the Pearson Pennant), the now-familiar red-and-
white flag emerged as the consensus favourite among those who supported the idea of a new flag at all; many did
not. Diefenbaker, pro-British elements, and veterans groups in particular remained hostile for many years there-
after. (They were, if possible, even less happy about O Canada replacing God Save the Queen as the national
anthem in 1965.) If the new flag spoke to Pearsons view that Canada was autonomous and ought to look the part,
his Royal Commission on Bilingualism and Biculturalism, launched in 1963, was an effort to have a conversa-
tion that Canadians had mostly avoided for the better part of a century. The Bi and Bi Commission would report
 9.7 THE PEARSON INTERLUDE 509

out after Pearson was gone from office, but its timing, along with that of the Centennial celebrations in 1967
(including Expo 67), would contribute to Pearsons legacy as a maker of a burnished Canadian nationalism.

Watch this Canada Starts To Produce New Flag video to see Pearson defending the Maple Leaf flag in
front of a largely hostile crowd of Legionnaires.

Watch this video on Diefenbakers Flag Crusade to see Diefenbakers reply.

Key Points

Pearsons contribution to Canadas role in international affairs is better known than his contribution
to the growing welfare state and, particularly, the introduction of universal health care and the
Canada Pension Plan.
Despite being ostensibly better disposed toward the United States than Diefenbaker, Pearson found
himself roundly criticized by American President Johnson.
Pearsons introduction of a new flag was an element in a larger attempt to develop an independent
and singular identity for Canada at mid-century.

Attributions
Figure 9.33
Pierre Elliott Trudeau, John Turner, Jean Chrtien et le premier ministre Lester B. Pearson aprs un
remaniement ministriel (Online MIKAN no.3623031) by Duncan Cameron / Library and Archives Canada /
PA-117107 has nil restrictions on use.

Figure 9.34
Canada Pearson Pennant 1964 by Zscout370 is in the public domain.
9.8 Trudeau I

Figure 9.35 Pierre Trudeau at the 1968

Liberal Leadership convention.

The election in 2015 of a government led by Justin Trudeau (b. 1971) has sharpened the publics memory of
his father, Pierre Elliot Trudeau (1919-2000). Raised in a well-to-do household in Outremont, Quebec, Pierre
Trudeaus roots in Canada wind back to the 1650s on one side, with Scottish-French ancestors on the other. Biog-
raphers have observed this apparent bridging of the two solitudes but everything else about Pierre Trudeaus early
life suggests a strong and very conventional allegiance to things Canadien. He was educated at an elite Jesuit
school and was imbued with a strong sense of French-Canadian nationalism. As a young man, he was old enough
to serve in the Second World War but, like most of his generation in Quebec, he opposed conscription. He com-
pleted a law degree at the Universit de Montral, then studied at Harvard University and the London School of
Economics. Although he failed to complete his doctorate, he was regarded in Montreal as an intellectual. Before
he was 30 years old, he had established a reputation as a dissident writer and journalist with a strong pro-labour
orientation. Personal wealth and extensive connections allowed him opportunities in Ottawa (where he worked as
an economic policy advisor to St. Laurent) and the wherewithal to establish Cit Libre, a publication that regularly
critiqued the Union Nationale government of Maurice Duplessis and gave voice to the early stages of the Quiet
Revolution. Duplessis, it is alleged, responded by ensuring that Trudeau could not find work in Quebec universi-
ties. Certainly it was not until after Duplessis death that Trudeau was taken on by the Universit de Montral as
a law professor. It was there that Lester Pearson approached him about a career in politics.

The Three Wise Men

In his mid-40s, Trudeau still had close ties with labour organizations and was favourably disposed toward social
democrats within and without the CCF/NDP. But he regarded their ability to achieve change as very limited and
was persuaded to join the Liberal Party in 1965 as part of a trio of Quebec recruits known as the Three Wise Men
(or les trois colombes): Trudeau, Grard Pelletier (1919-1997), who was another founder/writer for Cit Libre, and
Jean Marchand (1918-1988), who was a trade union organizer and activist. Marchand was, in many respects, the

510
 9.8 TRUDEAU I 511

high-profile member of the three, and he was quickly given a prominent role in the Pearson government. Trudeau
was made Parliamentary Secretary to Pearson, a kind of personal advisor, and he quickly acquired an understand-
ing of the Prime Ministers Office (PMO). Soon thereafter he was made Minister of Justice, despite having only
just joined the Liberal Party and having never before held elected office.

In 1967, the Liberal Party began the process of finding a successor to Pearson through a leadership convention.
Marchand was favoured to run as the French-Canadian candidate but he declined, claiming (correctly) that his
1
English was insufficient. Trudeau was persuaded to run but his candidacy was divisive. As Justice Minister he
had made divorce easier to obtain, he had permissive attitudes toward abortion, and was regarded by many in the
Party as radical on other social issues. It took four ballots for Trudeau to narrowly win with only 51% of the vote.

Figure 9.36 It is difficult to imagine Pearson or Diefenbaker

meeting and being photographed with rockstars. John Lennon,
Yoko Ono, and Pierre Trudeau in 1969.

The Leadership Convention received unprecedented media attention and served as a launchpad for the federal
election the same year. Echoing the appeal of British Invasion bands of the decade, public fascination with
Trudeau was promoted as Trudeaumania. Although he was nearly 50 years old, Trudeau was seen as youthful
and virile the personification of a generations desire to shake up establishment values. He arrived on the politi-
cal scene at roughly the same time that the Baby Boomers born in 1945-47 became voters and, raised on a cultural
diet of television news and the sexual revolution, they regarded Trudeau as one of their own. The contrast with
his two opponents Conservative Party leader Robert Stanfield (1914-2003), heir to a textile manufacturing for-
tune, a Red Tory, and a former Nova Scotian Premier, and Tommy Douglas, leader of the New Democratic Party, a
former Premier of Saskatchewan, and the author of the nations first healthcare legislation was sharp. Stanfield
and Douglas (both thoughtful and arguably no less intellectually gifted than Trudeau) had age and experience on
their side, but they also had age and experience working against them. Trudeau still something of a novice in
politics was suavely articulate in both languages, spoke out against radical nationalists in Quebec, and brought
little baggage with him. The results were a convincing majority for the Trudeau administration in 1968.

Figure 9.37 Even at the high point of Trudeaumania, the

popularity of the Liberal Party was far from universal.

In later years, Trudeau would be regarded as nationally divisive. If we look at the 1968 results, it is clear that some
of the fracture lines were already present. Although the Liberals did well in central Canada and British Colum-
bia, Manitoba was a wash, Stanfields Conservatives were runaway winners in Alberta and Atlantic Canada, and

1. To be fair, this sort of concern did not impact English-Canadian leaders the same way until the late 20th century. Diefenbaker-French was a
term widely used to describe a garbled version that was incomprehensible to Francophones but strangely recognizable to Anglophones.
512 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

the NDP came out on top (narrowly) in Douglas home province. The precariousness of Trudeaumania would
become clear only four years later.

Trudeaus first years in office were marked by controversial policies and events. The 1968 election took place
against a backdrop of increasingly violent separatist protest in Quebec. Indeed, Trudeaus unwillingness to leave
a viewing platform at the pre-election Saint-Jean-Baptiste Day parade, despite being heckled and bombarded with
bottles and stones, was seen by many as a demonstration of the toughness needed to stand up against separatism.
It is even regarded by some historians as a turning point in the election campaign. But it presaged the principal
difficulty he would face over the next 15 years: the challenge of Quebecs historic dissatisfaction with Confeder-
ation.

Key Points

Pierre Trudeaus arrival on the national political stage followed decades of activism in support of
organized labour and his writing as a dissident intellectual in Duplessis Quebec.
Trudeau was recruited by the Pearson Liberals as part of a package aimed at reviving party fortunes
in Quebec.
In a brief career as Minister of Justice, Trudeau was able to introduce new laws and more liberal atti-
tudes on social issues.
Despite being in his late 40s, Trudeau was regarded by the electorate as a fresh personality who
could be tough on separatism.

Attributions
Figure 9.35
[P.E. Trudeau at the] Liberal [Leadership] Convention, [Ottawa, Ont.] (Online MIKAN no.3364671) by Duncan
Cameron / Library and Archives Canada / PA-111213 has nil restrictions on use.

Figure 9.36
Singer John Lennon and Yoko Ono with Prime Minister Pierre Elliott Trudeau (Online MIKAN no.3401510)
by D. I. Cameron / Library and Archives Canada / PA-110805 has nil restrictions on use.

Figure 9.37
Canada 1968 Federal Election by Lokal_Profil is used under a CC-BY-SA-2.5 license.
9.9 Cold War Quebec

Figure 9.38 Maurice Le Chef Duplessis,

ca. 1950.

The mid-20th century produced several provincial leaders who would cast a long shadow over their provinces
in an age of growing government involvement in economic, infrastructural, educational, and social policy. This
has been called an era of province building. Its chief practitioners Ernest Manning in Alberta; Tommy Dou-
glas in Saskatchewan; Joey Smallwood in Newfoundland; W.A.C. Bennett in British Columbia; Richard Hatfield
in New Brunswick; and a trio of Conservative Premiers (Leslie Frost, John Robarts, and Bill Davis) who gov-
erned Ontario from 1949 to 1985 were each in office for at least a decade, and for as much as 22 and a half
years. Each of them had the time to map out and execute significant changes in their respective jurisdictions. Such
longevity in politics was rare before World War II; it has been rarer since 1990. They were, clearly, a generation
of leaders who had the good fortune to be in office in rising economic times. In Quebec, the political beneficiary
of these circumstances was Maurice Le Noblet Duplessis (1890-1959), an exceptional personality in Canadian
politics.

Pre-WWII Leadership in Quebec

The first half of the 20th century saw remarkable continuity in Quebecs political leadership. Between them, only
four men held the position of premier from 1905 to 1959. Lomer Gouin (1861-1929) became premier in 1905 after
a bitter struggle between factions in the Liberal Party in Quebec. Divided between moderate and radical wings,
the Liberals were torn on issues like support for modernizing industrial corporations and rapprochement with the
Catholic Church on the one hand, versus state control over education and a more aggressively pro-labour policy
on the other. Gouin stood out as a compromiser who had Wilfrid Lauriers support. He spent 15 years extending
Quebecs northern borders, enticing new industrial enterprises to invest in the province, and advancing the nation-
alist agenda by developing technical schools and programs that would enable more Quebecers to take advantage
of the emergent modern economy. Gouin also calmed the clergy by promising to keep the state out of education
and even enhancing Church control over technical education. Nationalistes and labour complained that Gouin was

513
 514 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

too keen to attract foreign investment and foreign-owned plants that siphoned off profits to other countries and
consigned Quebecers to low paying industrial jobs. Just as the West was crafted as an Anglo-Canadian settlement
frontier, the growing French-Canadian population was inclined to look to colonization opportunities within the
newly expanded Quebec. This was not, however, part of Gouins vision. His Conservative and nationaliste oppo-
nents alike attacked him for trading off Quebec lands for timber and mining purposes rather than making those
properties available for Qubecois resettlement and colonization. Gouins political instincts were, otherwise, out-
standingly shrewd. He supported Laurier in 1911 but swung to Bordens side at the outbreak of war. As con-
scription became a sharper issue, Gouin abandoned Borden and joined the chorus of nationalist voices in Quebec,
criticizing Ontarios Regulation 17 and Anglo-Canadian Francophobia generally (see Sections 6.3 and 6.4). By
1919, Gouin was demonstrably an ideological conservative a defender of Quebecs rights in Confederation,
while simultaneously a Canadian nationalist. He commanded respect in Quebec City and in the corridors of power
1
in Ottawa.

Gouins resignation in 1920 placed the Liberal Party and the provincial administration in the hands of Louis-
Alexandre Taschereau (1867-1952). Like Gouin, Taschereau would hold the reins of power for 16 years. Biogra-
phies of Taschereau describe him as more pro-industry and pro-business than his predecessor, as well as less likely
to defer to the Catholic clergy on education matters. This is true, but it is certainly the case that Taschereau inher-
ited a more industrialized and modernized society than the one first governed by Gouin. In other words, it may
be said that he was simply continuing the arc of earlier developments. And he was faced with long-term Qube-
cois concerns. Emigration from Quebec understood as a depopulation that sapped the strength of the French
nation in Canada had been underway since the mid-19th century. In the 1920s and, even more decisively, the
1930s, this exodus was renewed as young Qubecois people searched for work elsewhere and principally in the
New England states. Efforts on the part of the National Assembly to slow, halt, and even reverse that trend were
applauded by all flavours of French-Canadian politics and society. To that end, Taschereau was noteworthy for
developing some of the first major hydroelectric projects in Quebec, massive employers that offered a foretaste
of the economic nationalism of the post-1960 provincial economy. These and other initiatives favoured urbaniza-
tion over agrarian Quebec, the secularization of education (including an attempt to bring Quebecs large Jewish
community into the educational decision-making process), and adding cosmopolitan aspects to cultural life in an
otherwise very provincial province. These more controversial projects ran up against nationalistes, clergy, Con-
servatives, and radical Liberals alike, particularly as the 1930s Depression deepened. Elements of the left-wing of
the Liberal Party split off to form Action librale nationale (ALN), a new political party led by Gouins son, Paul,
which brought together nationaliste, socially progressive, and rural groups. Taschereau was in trouble, but he is
almost unique in Canada in that he was elected before the Depression and yet was re-elected twice in 1931
and 1935. A corruption scandal forced him from office in 1936, and the Liberal Party leadership was handed to
Adlard Godbout (1892-1956). Quebec returned to the polls in the summer of the same year and the Liberals lost
decisively.

The 1936 election was a landmark. In 1935, the opposition vote had been split between the Conservatives (with
19% of the ballots cast) and the ALN (29.4%). Although Godbouts Liberals saw their support shrink in 1936 from
46% to 39%, that would have been enough to defeat their opponents had they remained unaligned. The frustrated
Conservatives and ALN, however, had come to an agreement, forming the Union Nationale (UN) coalition under
the leadership of Duplessis. Gouin distanced himself from Duplessis even before the 1936 election and unsuccess-

1. Richard Jones, Gouin, Sir Lomer, in Dictionary of Canadian Biography, vol. 15, University of Toronto/Universit Laval, 2003, accessed
January 12, 2016, [Link]
 9.9 COLD WAR QUEBEC 515

fully attempted to resurrect the ALN from 1938 to 1939. What emerged was essentially a transformed Conserva-
tive Party an ideologically conservative UN with a broad base of rural, economically regressive, pro-Church,
and nationalistic voters. The UN turned its back on the Taschereau eras support for hydroelectric projects, a move
that condemned rural Quebec to another generation of wood stoves, gas and kerosene lighting, iceboxes, and no
radios or telephones. This anti-technological bent would persist in some form for nearly two decades.

Duplessis victory was initially a short-lived one. In 1939, as Canada stood on the brink of war, the spectre of
conscription returned to Quebec. Federal Liberals from Quebec promised to block attempts to reintroduce con-
scription, a commitment that served provincial Liberals well. Godbout was swept back to power with 70 of 86
seats, and the UN was reduced to a 15-seat rump. The Liberal wartime government introduced a slate of land-
mark legislation, including the provincial franchise for women (thereby bringing Quebec into line with all other
provinces), reforms to education to make it simultaneously more accessible and mandatory, and the introduction
of Quebecs first Labour Code. The first steps necessary to creating a provincially owned electricity monopoly
were also undertaken at this time. These changes were widely welcomed (and widely criticized in antimodernist
quarters), but what led to Godbouts defeat in 1944 was his governments insistence that it could obstruct con-
scription. Tied to that one issue, the governments fate was all but sealed when Ottawa finally introduced con-
scription.

The 1944 election returned the UN and Duplessis with fewer votes than the Liberals but a modest majority of seats
nevertheless. Duplessis bedrock of support was rural Quebec, where his antimodernist message had the greatest
purchase. Even in the late 1930s, Duplessis was building a populist base, reinforced with attacks on the Jehovahs
Witnesses and the Communist Party, both of which were despised by the Catholic Church. And a spell in opposi-
tion during the Godbout years helped him out: an outspoken moralist, Duplessis earlier term in office was marked
by binge drinking and a reputation as what was then called a ladys man. By 1944, he had dried out and was
regarded as a reliable opponent of pro-conscription Ottawa and a champion of Quebec autonomy (autonomisme)
within Confederation.

Post-War Quebec
Duplessis, who was nicknamed Le Chef, would hold on to office until 1959. During that 15-year era of relative
prosperity and economic growth, the Union Nationale like other populist parties in Canada behaved in
contradictory and sometimes confusing ways. While Duplessis sustained the ultramontanist elements within Que-
bec society and relied heavily on clergy support in rural areas, he also launched initiatives that gradually reduced
Church control over education while increasing state involvement. It has been argued that shrinkage in the number
of active clergy made this shift necessary, but it marks a sea change nevertheless. The UN was outspokenly a part
of rural Quebec, but it also now invested heavily in hydroelectric infrastructure. It was traditionalist and simul-
taneously perhaps unavoidably modernist in some of its policies. But Le Chefs anti-Ottawa, pro-rural,
traditionalist posture tended overall toward a kind of isolationist parochialism. Rather than encourage Qubecois
investment in mines and the pulp and paper industry let alone acting to create a state presence in those sectors
Duplessis encouraged foreign investment in industry. These Anglo-American operations provided only low-
paying and low-status jobs for French-speaking Canadians and a fraction of the royalty revenues that were won
in the same sector by other provinces. (In one dramatic case, Newfoundland was found to be taking nearly ten
times the royalty revenue that Quebec won from the same iron ore body located on the Quebec-Labrador border.)
Moreover, Duplessis was a social conservative whose social policies left Quebecers behind much of the rest of
 516 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Canada when it came to welfare provisions. Nevertheless, the UN years saw an overall improvement in economic
growth and, for once, the Quebec state system was able to dominate the clergy (to which it nonetheless contin-
ued to symbolically defer). This was all executed in an environment of systematized and extensive patronage that
ensured loyalty to the party and to Le Chef himself.

Duplessis legacy has been the subject of repeated criticism in the decades since his death. Quebec nationalists
dislike his anti-separatist stance, and liberals denounce his social conservatism. Some minorities resent the privi-
leges he granted to the Roman Catholic Church, while other religious groups were actively or passively discour-
aged. His critics hold that his inherently corrupt patronage politics, his reactionary conservatism, his emphasis on
traditional family and religious values, his anachronistic anti-union stance, his rural focus, and his preservation
and promotion of Catholic Church institutions over the development of a secular social infrastructure (akin to that
underway in most of the postwar western world), stunted Quebecs social and economic development by at least a
decade. It is for this reason that Duplessis term in office is sometimes described as the Grande Noirceur, black
2
years in which individual liberties were reduced, corruption abounded, and Quebec stagnated economically.

The Quiet Revolution

Regardless of Duplessis intentional legacy, it is certainly the case that his administration laid the groundwork
for the era of accelerated reform that followed. In 1959, Duplessis died and was replaced by the ill-fated Paul
Sauv (1907-1960), who followed Duplessis to the grave the next year at 53 years of age. Sauvs brief tenure was
marked by a severe change in UN direction. From 1944, Sauv served as the Minister of Social Welfare and Youth
(a position he continued to hold even as premier-designate), and his first steps in 1959 involved strengthening the
public education system and envisioning, publicly, a changed Quebec society. Whether he would have achieved
even a part of what he promised matters less than the fact that he urged upon Quebecers an attitude of transforma-
tion. The still shorter interregnum government of Antonio Barrette (1899-1968) fell to a revived Liberal Party led
by Jean Lesage (1912-1980), campaigning under the banner, Il faut que a change (Things must change).

Quebec in 1960 was not what it was in 1940. The population had grown from just over 3 million to 5.3 million, and
the movement of people off the land and into urban areas rendered Duplessis agrarian focus obsolete. Sprawling,
metropolitan Montreal in 1961 contained 2.1 million people, 40% of the provinces total population. Liberal Party
support and support for substantial social and economic change was to be found in the politically powerful
urban areas first and foremost. And it was there that modernization was most in demand. Improved educational
and social welfare programs were a first priority, as was the nationalization of the entire hydroelectric sector,
vastly increasing the capacity and reach of Hydro-Qubec.

Figure 9.39 Manic-2 (aka: the Jean Lesage Generating

Station) was assembled in the 1960s as part of the Quiet
Revolutions province building agenda.

2. Project Gutenberg, Self-Publishing Press: [Link] CC BY-SA 3.0

 9.9 COLD WAR QUEBEC 517

This prominent initiative was undertaken by the Minister of Hydraulic Resources, a former television journalist
named Ren Lvesque (1922-1987). It represented such a substantial step in public policy that the Liberals called
an election in 1962, only two years into their first majority mandate, on the issue of nationalization. They won
only 5% more of the vote, but won 12 additional seats in the 95-seat National Assembly. This improved man-
date was a signal that the key directions of Lesages proposed Quiet Revolution (Revolution tranquille) enjoyed
broad support. The hydroelectric monopoly allowed the government to ensure that Quebecers had first call on
construction-related jobs and that highly skilled francophones would not be denied management and technical
positions as they arose. The crown corporation functioned in French first and was the centrepiece of a suite of
policies aimed to achieve the Liberal goal: Matres chez nous (masters of our own house). Downstream benefits
included a standardized pricing system that would attract industry and energy independence. The provincial gov-
ernment thereafter applied similar nationalizing models to other areas of their resource sector, increasing jobs and
government revenue at the same time.

Figure 9.40 The Roman Catholic Archdiocese of

Montreal found itself increasingly overshadowed
by the state, finance, and commerce.

Educational reforms in support of this modernizing economic vision included improved access to state-run sec-
ondary education and an increase in the age of compulsory attendance from 14 to 16 years. These changes were
meant to address the parlous levels of high school completion in Quebec roughly half the rate found in English
Canada in the 1950s and to prepare a growing number of Qubecois for technical careers. To that end, the old
classical colleges were replaced with general and technical colleges, known as CGEPs. Most of these reforms
were mounted in 1964.

The timing of education reform was significant. Removing the Catholic Church from its dominant position in
education sometimes referred to as declericalization coincided roughly with the Second Vatican Council
(Vatican II). Reforms in the Church at this time were extensive and the possibility of careers for nuns and priests
as educators and health professionals was now in retreat. Whats more, Vatican II meant that the ultramontanist
elements in Quebec found little favour in Rome. The Quiet Revolution was not going to be derailed by an inter-
ventionist Pope.

All of these changes combined to be revolutionary in the sense that authority increasingly resided with the state,
not the Church; it was at home in the cities, not on the land. French-speakers were enabled and encouraged to
become managers and directors rather than day-labourers. Francophone technocrats and planners acquired a new
kind of prestige as leaders of change. The branchplant economy survived but it was increasingly challenged by
homegrown industries and sectors. The Liberals could convincingly point to evidence that Qubecois were, in
fact, becoming matres chez nous. Whats more, they were exporting this pride: as early as 1961, the Liberal gov-
ernment opened its first trade houses or Maisons du Qubec embassies without diplomatic status in London,
Paris, and New York.

These advances and the rhetoric of nationalism, embraced by the Liberals and articulated by the nationaliste news-
518 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

paper Le Devoir, was increasingly articulated in demands for greater autonomisme and, for the first time in many
decades, separatisme.

Nationalisme, Autonomisme, Separatisme

The 1940s and 1950s witnessed the decolonization of much of Africa and Asia. As imperial forces withdrew from
what were, mostly, nations conquered by European armies in the 18th and 19th centuries, some in Quebec began
to question whether it was time to liberate New France. Fear of assimilation and English oppression was a driving
force in Quebec politics from 1759 on. Two centuries after the Conquest, nationalistes (whose views were articu-
lated in Le Devoir , which was founded in 1910 by Henri Bourassa) were increasingly unconvinced that the strat-
egy of autonomisme implicit in Confederation was still a viable strategy for their community. The fact that most of
the wealth in Quebec was thought to be in the hands of English-speakers (huddled in Montreals Westmount and
in the Eastern Townships) led some Quebecers to conclude that Canada was an unequal bargain, a colonial rela-
tionship in which ethnicity, language, and religion worked systemically to the disadvantage of French-Canadians.
One example will suffice: clerks in Montreal stores were obliged to speak English to their customers, regardless
of the customers first language. How could this be experienced as anything other than colonization?

Figure 9.41 The symbolic value of a visit from

the French Minister of Culture the novellist,
veteran of the Spanish Civil War, and French
Resistance fighter Andr Malraux (right) was
enough, in 1963 to bring out Premier Lesage
(left), as well as the elite of Canadien culture and
society in Montreal.

As well, the 20th century was bearing down on Canadien culture. The rise of electronic media like radio, movies,
and television exposed francophones to an onslaught of images and values from English Canada and the United
States. Antimodernists, of course, were particularly critical of this tidal wave of entertainment-culture and one
response was to intensify relations with Metropolitan France, an option that had been largely closed off by years
of ultramontanist hostility toward the French Republic. Modernists, for their part, saw in nationalized industries a
means to advance Quebecs economy and society but only if that could be done in a context in which francoph-
ones were no longer discriminated against when it came to top jobs. As regards Ottawas priorities and values
in international relations, culture, trade, and even monetary policy, nationalistes believed those priorities did not
reflect their own.

Several strategies to achieve change emerged in the early 1960s. The first of these was constitutional change. In
order to address some long-standing concerns and immediate goals, there would need to be a means for amend-
ing the British North America Act. And, because the Act was a product of the British Parliament, there was the
issue of patriation. Nine anglophone provinces and one francophone province, however, saw this process rather
differently. The Fulton-Favreau Formula gained support at this time from every province but Saskatchewan;
it proposed consensus agreement on issues involving all provinces, regional consensus or single-province agree-
ment for more localized changes, and further subdivisions of process that made it, in the words of one constitu-
 9.9 COLD WAR QUEBEC 519
3
tional expert at the time, an unmitigated constitutional disaster. Nevertheless, opposition to Fulton-Favreau was
limited and even Lesage supported it; that support quickly dissipated as nationaliste elements in Quebec became
more vocal in their belief that this cumbersome system was more likely a means of perpetuating the inequities of
federalism rather than replacing them.

If federalism could not be changed by its own institutions, it was argued, then Quebec needed to reclaim its
pre-1867 authority (such as it had during the Confederation negotiations) or withdraw entirely or in part
from the federation. This was a position taken along a spectrum of alternatives by diverse groups in Quebec in the
early to mid-1960s. Conservative nationalistes like the Alliance laurentienne, founded in 1957 soon found
themselves arguing different sides of the same coin with left-wing nationalistes. In 1960, the Rassemblement
pour lIndpendance Nationale (RIN) brought together the Alliance laurentienne with more moderate and, even-
tually, more radical left-wing nationalists inspired by the vibrant campus protests and anti-colonial movements of
the time. The RIN engaged in electoral politics without success but maintained a high profile in public protests,
such as demonstrations against the Royal Visit of Queen Elizabeth II in 1964. When Pierre Trudeau freshly
appointed as Prime Minister designate took a seat in the main viewing platform of the Saint-Jean-Baptiste Day
Parade in 1968, it was the RIN that mounted a noisy protest that threw objects at Trudeau. The leader of the RIN,
Pierre Bourgault (1934-2003), was a participant in this last event and was arrested, along with hundreds of others.
In the midst of these street-level confrontations, more moderate and conservative members of the RIN split off to
form the Ralliement National (RN), another political party that would compete for separatist votes.

Further to the Left was the Action socialiste pour lindpendance du Qubec (ASIQ), the Rseau de rsistance
(RR), and the Comit de liberation nationale. These groups had closer relations with communist and anti-colo-
nialist movements and took inspiration from the Algerian and Cuban revolutions in particular. While there was a
tradition of civil disobedience in Quebec, this quickly became overshadowed by more violent tactics, including
vandalism and destruction of federal property.

Figure 9.42 Radio-Canada journalist Ren Lvesque

interviews Lester Pearson in Moscow in 1955.

Beginning around 1967 to 1968, these diverse movements began to coalesce around two principal ideals and
organizations. Those who favoured electoral strategies turned increasingly toward the new Mouvement sou-
verainet-association (MSA) led by Ren Lvesque, the former cabinet minister who abandoned the Liberal Party
over the issue of significant constitutional change. The RN merged with the MSA in 1968 to form the Parti
Qubcois (PQ); much of the membership of the RIN joined as well when that party was dissolved as well. The
concept that Lvesque championed, called sovereignty-association, represented a compromise between contin-
ued, reformed federalism and full-blown independence. Quebec would, in this vision, become an independent and
sovereign state but one with strong ties to the rest of Canada that bore some similarity to the arrangement struck
between the Low Countries in Europe (called Benelux) and the European Economic Community (EEC).

3. Bora Laskin, quoted in Editors Diary, The Search for an Amending Process, 1960-1967, McGill Law Journal, vol.12, no.4 (1966-67):
345.
520 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Against electoral separatism of the PQ were arrayed the several more starkly nationalistic movements who were
inclined to the view that change would not come through the ballot box. The Front de Libration du Qubec
(FLQ) embraced guerrilla tactics being used by Palestinians in their struggle against Israel. It also took advantage
of historical images of rebellion in French Canada, including the tri-colour flag used by Papineaus 1837 Patriotes
and the silhouette of an armed habitant from the 19th century Rebellions. Beginning in the spring of 1963, the
FLQ launched a series of largely ineffectual bomb attacks. They targeted Canadian Army barracks and a length
of rail line east of Montreal. The FLQ quickly graduated from Molotov cocktails to heavy explosives. In April
1963, a 65-year old custodian at a Recruiting Office was killed by an FLQ bomb, and a month later one of 11
explosives planted in post boxes severely injured an Army bomb disposal expert. By the end of 1968, the FLQ
could claim to have detonated close to 100 explosives of various shapes and sizes, all of which targeted federal
property of some kind. They had, as well, engaged in a robbery spree calculated to get both money and arms
for the movement. Along the way, the organization was responsible for the injury or death of at least four people.
In other decades, this might have been enough to alienate support but conditions were different in the 1960s. The
sustained support for the FLQ has to be understood within the context of growing opposition to the American war
in Vietnam, the civil rights and Black Panther movements in the United States, increasing youth unrest on cam-
puses, the spread of various liberation movements internationally (into which the FLQ networked), and the FLQs
well articulated socialist objectives in Pierre Vallieres 1968 book, Ngres blancs dAmrique (translated as White
Niggers of America).

Figure 9.43 Expo 67 pavilions, built on specially created

islands in the St. Lawrence.

In 1967 and 1968, then, and at the height of Centennial celebrations in Montreal at Expo 67, Quebecers found
themselves confronted by political movements of an unprecedented kind. The terrorist campaign undertaken by
the FLQ was decried by Lvesque and the PQ; the FLQ regarded the PQ as insufficiently aggressive in its objec-
tives and techniques. The Liberal Party, for its part, retained an interest in renegotiating elements of the constitu-
tion should a satisfactory patriation formula be found. In short, everyone in Quebec politics agreed that change
was necessary, but disagreed strongly on the extent of change and the means to achieve it.

Gaullism

A wildcard in the separatiste deck was the French President, General Charles de Gaulle (1890-1970). Ele-
vated to power during a coup dtat in 1958, de Gaulle viewed the English-speaking world with suspicion
and hostility. Rebuilding an independent French military and financial powerhouse was his principal goal,
and to that end he sought to diminish the power of his competitors, chiefly the United Kingdom and the
United States. Canada, which he understood first and foremost to be an English-speaking country, was a
less critical impediment to French advancement, but it was a potentially useful stepping stone. By destabi-
lizing relations between Quebec and the rest of Canada, he would destabilize North America as a whole.
Keeping in mind that this was a decade that witnessed leftist revolutions in several countries, the idea of
 9.9 COLD WAR QUEBEC 521

a radicalized, French-aligned, and nationalistic regime in Quebec would cause worry in Washington and
Ottawa alike.

Figure 9.44 French president Charles de Gaulle

destabilizes Canada at Montreals City Hall, 1967.

It was in this context that de Gaulle travelled to Canada in July 1967, ostensibly as part of the centennial
celebrations and Expo 67. Rather than head first to Ottawa, de Gaulles entourage landed at Quebec City
and drove in a motorcade along the banks of the St. Lawrence through the heart of old New France
along the route of the 18th-century highway, the Chemin du Roy. Passing by throngs of French tri-couleur
flag-waving Qubecois, it has been suggested that de Gaulle might have been reminded of his own tri-
umphal return to Paris in 1945 as the leader of the Free French. Whatever was on his mind whether it
was nostalgia, affection for Quebec, or causing a disturbance on 24 July, he took to a balcony of Mon-
treals City Hall and shouted to an ecstatic crowd, Vive le Qubec. Vive le Qubec libre! Then he went
home without meeting any Canadian officials.
The role of France in stimulating French-Canadian separatism is difficult to measure. It was there before de
Gaulle and it didnt need French support to keep it alive. The distinguished Canadian historian, J.F. Bosher,
has argued that Gaullists (de Gaulles followers in the Fifth Republic of France) conducted a kind of under-
cover and subversive operation in Quebec, providing resources and succor for a movement that might oth-
4
erwise feel entirely isolated. Whatever his motives, de Gaulles gun-and-run visit marked a dark day for
Quebec federalists, excited support for the sovereigntist and separatist movements, and irritated English
Canada.

Key Points

Provincial politics in 20th century Quebec were distinguished by the importance of sustaining good
relations with the Catholic clergy, addressing the needs of a large rural and anti-urban population,
and struggling to preserve and advance francophone opportunities in an economy dominated by
anglophones.
The Conservative Party was rendered unelectable by the conscription issue in WWI and needed to
reinvent itself as the Union Nationale in order to become an effective opponent of the provincial
Liberals.
The 15-year administration of Maurice Duplessis was viewed at the time, and since, by most histori-
ans as a period of antimodern, ultramontane, traditionalism, and/or a Grande Noirceur.
The economic and social stagnation of the Duplessis years contributed to the appeal of significant
change, embodied in the ideals of the Revolution tranquille, whose goal it was to make Quebe-
cers matres chez nous.
The Quiet Revolution included extensive state involvement in education and declericalization which
coincided with Vatican II. It focused, as well, on providing greater middle- and upper-management

4. J.F. Bosher, The Gaullist Attack on Canada, 1967-1997 (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 1999).
522 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

opportunities for Qubecois.

Increasingly nationaliste elements identified the limits to change that could occur under the existing
constitutional relationship with the rest of Canada. This produced an array of separatiste political
parties and movements that coalesced around the Parti Qubcois in electoral politics and the FLQ
in direct action politics.
Separatisme in 1960s Quebec occurred against a background of anti-colonial, civil rights, and guer-
rilla movements globally and in North America. The tone it took reflected its historic context.

Attributions
Figure 9.38
Quebec Premier Maurice Duplessis giving a speech (Online MIKAN no.3261260) by Library and Archives
Canada / PA-178340 is in the public domain.

Figure 9.39
Jean-Lesage Generating Station 01 by Bouchecl is used under CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.

Figure 9.40
Archidiocse Montral by Atilin is used under CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.

Figure 9.41
Andr Malraux, en prsence du premier ministre Jean Lesage lexposition franaise au Palais du commerce
de Montral, 10 octobre 1963 by Archives de la Ville de Montral is used under CC-BY-NC-SA-2.0 license.

Figure 9.42
Ren Lvesque, Radio-Canada reporter, interviewing Lester B. Pearson outside the Canadian Embassy in
Moscow (Online MIKAN no.3192029) by Soviet / Library and Archives Canada / PA-117617 has nil restric-
tions on use.

Figure 9.43
Expo 67 Montreal, P.Q. (Online MIKAN no.3408596) by Frank Grant / Library and Archives Canada /
C-030085 has nil restrictions on use.

Figure 9.44
Le gnral de Gaulle au balcon de lhtel ville de Montral, 24 juillet 1967 by Archives de la Ville de Montral
is used under a CC-BY-NC-SA-2.0 license.
9.10 The October Crisis

FLQ bombing attacks intensified in 1969 and early 1970. The targets now included American-owned businesses;
the homes and offices of elected and non-elected civic officials (including the City of Montreal Mayor Jean Dra-
peau, 1916-99); a traditionalist nationalist organization (the Sherbrooke Socit Saint-Jean-Baptiste); and busi-
nesses engaged in labour disputes. A National Airlines flight from New York to Miami was hijacked and the
Montreal Stock Exchange was bombed: 20 people were injured. Despite the arrest and imprisonment of nearly
two dozen members of the movement, it continued to operate and, early in 1970, its members began to roll out
a new strategy involving kidnappings and ransom demands. On separate occasions, police foiled plans to abduct
the Israeli consul and the American consul-general in Montreal. On 5 October, however, the FLQ was successful
in taking James Cross (b. 1921), the British Trade Commissioner in Montreal.

As this event elevated the separatist problem to an international level, Ottawa was directly involved. Prime Min-
ister Trudeaus response called for a coordinated strategy between the federal government, the provincial govern-
ment, and the City of Montreal. This put Mayor Drapeau and, to a lesser extent, Liberal Premier Robert Bourassa
(1933-1996) in the spotlight; neither was prepared to meet the FLQs demands for half a million dollars, the
release of 23 FLQ members in Quebec jails, and the broadcast of the FLQs manifesto. Attempts to block the
release of the manifesto were unsuccessful; several of the French-language newspapers reprinted it in full. Two
days into the crisis, it was broadcast on radio with an eye to reducing tensions and working toward Crosss release.
The FLQ cell or unit holding Cross repeatedly made it clear that his life was at stake while, in the meantime,
Montreal and Quebec authorities hoped for a successful police resolution to the standoff.

Five days after the kidnapping of Cross, a separate cell within the FLQ captured the Quebec Minister of Labour,
Pierre Laporte (1921-1970). Faced with the fact that one of their own was now at risk, the Quebec government
took a more conciliatory tone. At the same time, the federal government began ramping up its protection of offi-
cials and buildings, putting more security (including military personnel) onto the streets, and engaging the federal
RCMP more directly in attempts to track down the two cells. On 13 October, eight days into the October Crisis,
Trudeau was informally questioned by journalists on the steps of Parliament. This became famous as the Just
Watch Me interview.

How Far Would You Go?

This is a partial transcript of the interview of PM Pierre Elliott Trudeau conducted by the CBCs Tim
Ralfe and Peter Reilly of CJON-TV on 13 October 1970.

523
524 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

TIM RALFE: Sir, what is it with all these men with guns around here?
PIERRE TRUDEAU: Havent you noticed?
RALFE: Yes, Ive noticed them. I wondered why you people decided to have them.
TRUDEAU: Whats your worry?
RALFE: Im not worried, but you seem to be.
TRUDEAU: So if youre not worried, whats your Im not worried.
RALFE: Im worried about living in a town thats full of people with guns running around.
TRUDEAU: Why? Have they done anything to you? Have they pushed you around or anything?
RALFE: Theyve pushed around friends of mine.
TRUDEAU: Yes? What were your friends doing?
RALFE: Trying to take pictures of them.
TRUDEAU: Aha.
RALFE: Is that against the law?
TRUDEAU: No, not at all.
RALFE: Doesnt it worry you, having a town that youve got to resort to this kind of thing?
TRUDEAU: It doesnt worry me. I think its natural that if people are being abducted that they be pro-
tected against such abductions. What would you do if a Quebec minister another Quebec minister were
abducted or a federal minister?
RALFE: But isnt that one of the
TRUDEAU: Is your position that you should give in to the seven demands of the FLQ and ?
RALFE: No, not at all. My position is completely the opposite.
TRUDEAU: What is your position?
RALFE: My position is that you dont give in to any of them.
TRUDEAU: All right. But you dont protect yourselves against the possibility of blackmail?
RALFE: Well, how can you protect everybody that is going to be a possible target without a much bigger
military force, without putting somebody on everybody in the country, and turning it almost into a police
state?
TRUDEAU: So, what do you suggest that we protect nobody?
RALFE: How can you protect them all?
TRUDEAU: Well, you cant protect them all but are you therefore arguing that you shouldnt protect
any?
RALFE: Thats right.
TRUDEAU: Thats your position?
RALFE: Right.
TRUDEAU: All right. So Pierre Laporte wasnt protected and he was abducted. If you had hindsight,
would you not have preferred to protect him and Mr. Cross?
 9.10 THE OCTOBER CRISIS 525

RALFE: Well, second guessing is pretty easy, but you cant do it.
TRUDEAU: Well all right, but Im asking you to first guess now.
RALFE: No, because its impossible.
TRUDEAU: It would have been impossible to protect cabinet ministers of the provincial government or
diplomats?
RALFE: I would suspect so, with all the diplomats there are in this country.
TRUDEAU: Well, weve got a big army.
RALFE: Youre going to use it up pretty fast at this rate.
TRUDEAU: What do you mean at this rate?
PETER REILLY: Six and seven. If I could interpolate something here. You seem to be thinking, in your
statement in the House this morning you seemed to be saying that you thought the press had been less
than responsible in its coverage of this story so far. Could you elaborate on that?
TRUDEAU: Not less than responsible. I was suggesting that they should perhaps use a bit more restraint
which youre not doing now youre going to make a big news item of this I am sure.
REILLY: Well, the papers it is a big news item.
TRUDEAU: Yes, but the main thing that the FLQ is trying to gain from this is a hell of a lot of publicity
for the movement.
REILLY: A recognition.
TRUDEAU: Yes and I am suggesting that the more recognition you give to them the greater the victory
is, and Im not interested in giving them a victory.
REILLY: the proposition that perhaps it would be wise to use less inflammatory terms than bandits
when you talk about a bunch of people who have the lives of two men in their hands?
TRUDEAU: You dont think theyre bandits?
REILLY: Well, regardless of what I think, I dont think I would be inclined to wave a red flag in their
face if they held two of my friends or colleagues with guns at their heads.
TRUDEAU: Well, first of all, I didnt call them bandits. I called the people who were in jail now bandits,
who had been tried before the law and condemned to a prison term and I said that you people should
stop calling them political prisoners. Theyre not political prisoners, theyre outlaws. Theyre criminal
prisoners, theyre not political prisoners, and theyre bandits. Thats why theyre in jail.
RALFE: But with your army troops you seem to be combatting them almost as though it is a war, and if
it is a war does anything that they say have validity?
TRUDEAU: Dont be silly. Were not combatting them as if its war but were using some of the army
as peace agents in order that the police be more free to do their job as policemen and not spend their
time guarding your friends against some form of kidnapping.
RALFE: You said earlier that you would protect them in this way but you have said before that this kind
of violence, what youre fighting here, the kind of violence of the FLQ, can lead to a police state.
TRUDEAU: Sure. Thats what youre complaining about, isnt it?
RALFE: Well yes, but surely that decision is yours, not the FLQs.
526 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

TRUDEAU: Yes, but Ive asked you what your own logic is. Its to let them abduct anybody and not
give any protection to anyone call off the police, that seems to be your position.
RALFE: Not call off the police. Surely the polices job is to catch people who break the law.
TRUDEAU: Yes, but not to give protection to those citizens who might be blackmailed for one reason
or another?
RALFE: Which must be half of the population of the country, in one way or another. I explained it badly
I think, but what youre talking about to me is choices, and my choice is to live in a society that is free
and democratic, which means that you dont have people with guns running around in it.
TRUDEAU: Correct.
RALFE: And one of the things I have to give up for that choice is the fact that people like you may be
kidnapped.
TRUDEAU: Sure, but this isnt my choice, obviously. You know, I think it is more important to get rid
of those who are committing violence against the total society and those who are trying to run the gov-
ernment through a parallel power by establishing their authority by kidnapping and blackmail. And I
think it is our duty as a government to protect government officials and important people in our society
against being used as tools in this blackmail. Now, you dont agree to this but I am sure that once again
with hindsight, you would probably have found it preferable if Mr. Cross and Mr. Laporte had been pro-
tected from kidnapping, which they werent because these steps we are taking now werent taken. But
even with your hindsight I dont see how you can deny that.
RALFE: No, I still go back to the choice that you have to make in the kind of society that you live in.
TRUDEAU: Yes, well there are a lot of bleeding hearts around who just dont like to see people with
helmets and guns. All I can say is, go on and bleed, but it is more important to keep law and order in the
society than to be worried about weak-kneed people who dont like the looks of
RALFE: At any cost? How far would you go with that? How far would you extend that?
TRUDEAU: Well just watch me.

Increasingly there were calls to open negotiations. Lvesque and his eventual successor as leader of the PQ,
Jacques Parizeau (1930-2015), along with key figures in the Quebec labour movement and student groups
appealed to Bourassa. They called on the premier to take the lead, make concessions to the FLQ, and rescue
Laporte and Cross. Deadline after deadline (set by both sides) passed without resolution. Bourassa requested that
Ottawa deploy troops for security purposes so that the Montreal police and the Sret du Qubec could pursue
leads and a thousand soldiers suddenly appeared on Montreals streets. The next day, 16 October, the federal cab-
inet declared that the FLQ crisis was now an apprehended insurrection and thus a signal to impose martial law
under the War Measures Act. This is the only time in Canadian history that the Act has been invoked in peace-
time and it provided police and the military with the ability to arrest and hold without charge (that is, it removed
the need for habeas corpus). Over the next 48 hours, more than 250 people were arrested, but it was too late for
Laporte. On the 18th of October his body was found stuffed in the trunk of a car. Six weeks would pass before
Crosss location would be disclosed to police and his kidnappers allowed safe passage out of the country to Cuba.
 9.10 THE OCTOBER CRISIS 527

Figure 9.45 Pierre Trudeau and Robert Bourassa, leaving the

funeral of Pierre Laporte, 20 October 1970. James Cross was still
in the hands of the FLQ.

The impact of the October Crisis on Quebecs political culture and on Canada as a whole was substantial.
Although Ottawa, the RCMP, and the Liberals in Quebec City took advantage of the situation to vilify separatists
1
and sovereigntists alike, the experience of martial law pushed separatiste Quebecers closer to the PQ. Police
raids and illegal persecution of separatist movements (including the PQ) only served to harden attitudes toward
Ottawa and the partys fortunes further improved. Radical separatists who had formerly supported the FLQ were,
in many instances, alienated by the movements outrages. With the crackdown on the FLQ and its marginaliza-
tion, these voters had no place to go but the PQ. The spontaneous and unorganized energy of the FLQ disappeared
soon after the October Crisis but it would take nearly five years to see the extent to which the PQ was the political
beneficiary of these events.

Key Points

Beginning in 1969, the FLQ expanded its terror and robbery campaign from vandalism against fed-
eral properties to include attacks and robberies involving civic, social, business, and diplomatic tar-
gets.
In October 1970, British Trade Commissioner James Cross was kidnapped and held for ransom.
When this failed to produce the desired result, another FLQ cell kidnapped Quebec Labour Minister
Pierre Laporte.
The October Crisis produced a large-scale police operation and compelled the federal government to
invoke the War Measures Act. Canada was under martial law.
The murder of Laporte was followed by the release of Cross and the exile of his captors to Cuba.
The popularity of the Parti Qubcois grew as a consequence of public disapproval of the revolution-
ary option and the performance of the Liberal Party, federally and provincially, during the crisis.

Attributions
Figure 9.45
Pierre Elliott Trudeau and Robert Bourassa attending the funeral of Pierre Laporte (Online MIKAN
no.3222729) by Library and Archives Canada / PA-178340 has nil restrictions on use.

1. Bryan D. Palmer, Canadas 1960s: The Ironies of Identity in a Rebellious Era (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2009), 364-5.
 9.11 Quebec and the ROC

Figure 9.46 Quebec divided: Non voters felt obliged to insist

that they were no less Qubecois for wanting the status quo;
Oui voters talked about sovereignty association but imagined a
liberated Quebec.

In the aftermath of the October Crisis, neither the nation nor the province of Quebec turned against the Liberals
not immediately. Trudeau, Bourassa, and especially Drapeau enjoyed a significant bump in popularity and con-
fidence in the months immediately after the crisis. It did not last. In 1972, the Trudeau government was reduced
to a minority and the NDP led by David Lewis, a vocal critic of the emergency measures held the balance
of power. Remarkably, it was only in Quebec that the federal Liberals did especially well, losing out to the Tories
in every other province. The short-term effects for the Parti Qubcois (PQ) were also disappointing: from seven
seats in the National Assembly in 1970, they fell to six in 1973.

Canadian politics in the post-1970 years involved visibly addressing Quebecs issues in a variety of ways. Canada
joined the Organisation international de la Francophonie (aka: La Francophonie), an international forum of
nations (many of them former colonies of France) where the use of the French language was widespread. The
Royal Commission on Bilingualism and Biculturalism reported out in 1969, and there was a new urgency after
October 1970 to implement some of its recommendations. Material changes included more French language
instruction in schools and a reversal of decades-old policies in Ontario, New Brunswick, and Manitoba that min-
imized the rights of francophones to instruction in their first language. Access to services in French in the courts
was also addressed, and New Brunswick took steps to become officially bilingual. While these initiatives were
seen by some in Quebec as a distraction from the substantive issues of power relations between Ottawa and the
province, the changes were also decried by many in English Canada as evidence that Ottawa was shoving French
1
down our throats. This anglophone francophobia was to cost the Liberals dearly at the polls in the 1970s.

Efforts to reform the constitutional relationship between Quebec and the rest of Canada, moreover, continued to
flounder. Premier Bourassas efforts to negotiate better terms for Quebec consistently failed. The Victoria Char-
ter (1971) held out the prospect of a veto power for Quebec but it was rejected at the last minute by the premier

1. Michael Hayday, So They Want Us to Learn French: Promoting and Opposing Bilingualism in English-Speaking Canada (Vancouver: Uni-
versity of British Columbia Press, 2015), 4.

528
 9.11 QUEBEC AND THE ROC 529

because he feared a nationaliste protest. His inability to accomplish any meaningful change in this field con-
tributed in large measure to the success of Lvesque and the pequistes in the 1976 election.

The Pequistes in Office

In the 1973 election, the Union Nationale was effectively wiped out. It failed to elect a single candidate out
of a full slate of 110. The PQ, with only six seats, therefore, was the Official Opposition, squaring off against
Bourassas 102 Members of the National Assembly (MNAs). The three years that followed would see Lvesque
reposition himself and his party as more than a movement of constitutional change. This was helped by Bourassas
physical awkwardness and his stilted speaking style and the cascade of scandals that embroiled the government.
The 1976 Summer Olympics were held in Montreal and, despite Mayor Drapeaus promise that The Olympics
can no more lose money than a man can have a baby, it ran up a $1.5 billion debt. (Aislin responded with a
cartoon showing a very pregnant Drapeau.) The Olympic Stadium the Big O incurred huge overruns and
was incomplete when the games commenced. The credibility of the Liberals was now so low that Lvesque could
campaign less on separatism and more on the need for good government.

Figure 9.47 Opening ceremonies at the 1976 Olympics in

Montreal, marred by extensive boycotts (in the end, only 92
nations participated). Construction cranes can be seen looming
over the unfinished trunk of the stadiums tower.

For Canadians in what was becoming known as the Rest Of Canada (ROC), the election of the PQ on 15 Novem-
ber 1976 signalled the end of Confederation. The combination of terrorist attacks in the 1960s and early 1970s,
government misspending, a stagnating local (and global) economy, and fear of what the PQ might accomplish
constitutionally contributed to a significant out-migration from Quebec of individuals, families, and households. It
is reckoned that 99,000 people left the province, turning whole swaths of western Montreal from neighbourhoods
2
where English dominated into areas in which French was the principal language. Whole corporations exited as
well. Montreal was, historically, the centre of banking, insurance, and finance, a position that was being increas-
ingly challenged by Toronto. In the decade after the PQ election, many of these firms relocated their head offices
from Montreal to Toronto and, more dramatically, to Calgary. The most prominent of these moves was made by
Sun Life Financial, one of the largest employers in Montreal and almost certainly the largest employer of anglo-
phones. Following the PQ governments introduction of the Charter of the French Language (aka: Bill 101), which
established the primacy of French in all aspects of life from street signage to restaurant menus and protected
the rights of unilingual francophone employees against discrimination, Sun Life made a very public show of its
displeasure and then left. Montreals loss may have been Torontos gain (the two quickly swapped places as the
nations largest cities) but there was a strong sense that the exodus, as it was called, bode ill for Canada as a whole.

Within Quebec and the PQ there were many who hoped for precisely that outcome. As promised during the 1976

2. Marc V. Levine, The Reconquest of Montreal: Language Policy and Social Change in a Bilingual City (Philadelphia: Temple University
Press, 1991), 120-1.
530 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

campaign, Lvesque began working toward a referendum on Quebecs place in Confederation. The first step
involved reforming electoral laws so as to permit for a referendum of any kind. The second, was to settle on a
question. This became a consuming part of the process, as federalists in Quebec and the ROC mobilized their pitch
for continuing with the status quo. Within the PQ, there were elements calling for a direct and decisive approach
to the question of sovereignty, while others preferred a gradualist approach (tapisme). Pierre Trudeaus loss of
power in the 1979 election introduced a new player in the game, Prime Minister Joseph Joe Clark (b. 1939),
elected to lead a minority Conservative government in which western Canadian MPs were a powerful force. For
the separatists, this looked like a positive sign. Moreover, Trudeau who might have posed a greater threat in
Ottawa than the less-experienced Clark had announced his retirement from politics. Clarks government, how-
ever, stumbled and fell in a non-confidence vote. The resultant election drew Trudeau back into the role of Liberal
leader (a position he had never fully vacated) and, once back in office with a fresh majority, into the fray against
Lvesque.

Joe Clark and the Iranian Hostage Crisis

Trudeau had his hostage crisis. Joe Clark had his.

Figure 9.48 Joseph Joe Clark wins the Tory

leadership in 1976 and lands on the cover of Time
magazine.

Joe Clarks image was being diminished as soon as he moved into the public spotlight at 24 Sussex Drive.
He was seen (and depicted) as physically awkward and socially unsophisticated. He was and remains the
youngest person ever to become Prime Minister (the Trudeaus, pre et fils, came to office 9 and 4 years
older, respectively) and so could be forgiven for needing time to adjust. Certainly, time has demonstrated
his abilities, but in 1979 to 1980, the public could hardly imagine the extent to which the 39-year-old Clark
was prepared to endorse and shepherd along a successful international subterfuge.
In February 1979, the Shah of Iran, Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, was overthrown. A few months later, he
departed for the United States for medical treatment. The long history of American support for the Shahs
brutal regime and the offer of refuge for Pahlavi greatly angered Iranian revolutionaries. On 4 November
1979, a group of Iranian students and activists, including Islamic fundamentalists who wished to end the
Westernization and secularization of Iran, invaded the American embassy in Tehran and seized 66 embassy
employees. The women and African-Americans were soon released, leaving 53 white men as hostages.
Negotiations failed to free them, and in April 1980, a rescue attempt fell through when the United States
aircraft sent to transport them crashed.
Six of the American embassy staff escaped the compound before it fell and went into hiding with members
of the Canadian embassy. The Canadian Ambassador to Iran, Ken Taylor (1934-2015), arranged to smug-
gle the Americans out of the country with Canadian passports issued under a special order by the Clark
government. The Canadian Caper was ultimately successful; the arrival home of the American hostages
in January produced a burst of pro-Canadian feeling south of the border.
 9.11 QUEBEC AND THE ROC 531

The fanfare came too late to save two regimes. The fate of Jimmy Carters presidency had been settled in
the November 1979 elections, but Joe Clarks administration still had hopes of recovering from a non-con-
3
fidence vote. These ambitions would be dashed in the February 1980 general election.

The Referendum
On 20 May 1980, nearly 86% of Quebec voters went to the polls to vote in the referendum. Meanwhile, the rest
of Canada held its breath. As it turned out, federalism caught a break.

Trudeaus commitment to Quebecers in 1980 of a revamped federalism in which Quebecs aspirations might be
satisfied played well with part of the Non vote constituency. Scholars, however, remain divided over whether
the 60% who voted against Sovereignty-Association were, in fact, voting in favour of the status quo. The ques-
tion posed in the referendum, over which the PQ had laboured so long, was opaque in its meaning. It was entirely
possible for a separatist to conclude that the proposed agreement with Ottawa was too light on sovereignty and
too heavy on association. Thus, radical separatistes might vote Non so as to prevent anything less than com-
plete separation of Quebec from Canada. Certainly the victory of the Non side cannot be entirely explained by
enthusiasm for the Liberal position.

The provincial Liberals under Claude Ryan (1925-2004) conducted a poor campaign, and the federal Liberals
were hamstrung by legal restrictions on direct involvement (some of which they simply ignored). A turning point
came on International Womens Day when the Quebec Womens Affairs Minister, Lise Payette (b. 1931) made the
first of two speeches in which she critiqued the character of Yvette, who, in Quebec schoolbooks, was portrayed
as an ideal a docile, submissive girl. Payette wanted to see these representations removed from the curriculum
a reasonable goal. The next day, however, she publicly accused the Non side of being made up of Yvettes
and she specifically targeted Ryans accomplished wife, Madeleine Ryan, as one. Mme. Ryan embraced the title
4
and launched brunch des Yvettes, a rally of women opposed to sovereignty-association. Mme. Ryans campaign
appealed strongly to Quebec housewives who felt doubly diminished by their social status and Payettes conde-
scension. Quebecs vital feminist movement was divided,but now an important block was mobilized in support of
5
Non.

The results of the vote were decisive but far from conclusive. It was only the first campaign it what became known
as the Neverendum.

3. Openstax, U.S. History: "Jimmy Carter in the Aftermath of the Storm," [Link]
in-the-Aftermath-.
4. Stephanie Godin, The Yvettes as the Expression of a Federalist Feminism in Quebec, in Michael D. Behiels and Matthew Hayday, eds.,
Contemporary Quebec: Selected Readings and Commentaries (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 2011): 340-4.
5. Constance Backhouse and David H. Flaherty, Challenging Times: The Womens Movement in Canada and the United States (Montreal &
Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 1992), 112-13.
 532 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 9.49 Trudeau speaks to a Non

crowd hours before the referendum.

The long and short of it

When Trudeau first responded to the election of the PQ in 1976, he indicated that he would be glad to see
clarity on the constitutional issue in Quebec. Since then, the word clarity has figured prominently in
discussions on this topic. It did not, however, loom large in the final version of the 1980 referendum ques-
tion:

The Government of Quebec has made public its proposal to negotiate a new agreement with the rest of Canada,
based on the equality of nations; this agreement would enable Quebec to acquire the exclusive power to make its
laws, levy its taxes and establish relations abroad in other words, sovereignty and at the same time to main-
tain with Canada an economic association including a common currency; any change in political status resulting
from these negotiations will only be implemented with popular approval through another referendum; on these
terms, do you give the Government of Quebec the mandate to negotiate the proposed agreement between Quebec
6
and Canada?
Le Government du Qubec a fait connatre sa proposition den arriver, avec le reste du Canada, une nouvelle
entente fonde sur le principe de lgalit des peuples ; cette entente permettrait au Qubec dacqurir le pouvoir
exclusif de faire ses lois, de percevoir ses impts et dtablir ses relations extrieures, ce qui est la souverainet,
et, en mme temps, de maintenir avec le Canada une association conomique comportant lutilisation de la mme
monnaie ; aucun changement de statut politique rsultant de ces ngociations ne sera ralis sans laccord de la
population lors dun autre rfrendum ; en consquence, accordez-vous au Gouvernement du Qubec le mandat
de ngocier lentente propose entre le Qubec et le Canada?

Key Points

Although the Liberals held on to their support in Quebec immediately after the October Crisis, they
were in retreat in much of the rest of Canada in the 1970s.
Efforts to reform the constitution and to improve the status of francophones in Canada were made
but were viewed by many in Quebec as too little too late.
The PQ came to office in an election marked by spending scandals surrounding the 1976 Olympics
with the promise of a referendum to decide Quebecs future in or out of Confederation.
The four years that followed saw anglophone households, businesses, and corporations vacate Que-
bec; the collapse of the Trudeau governments popularity; and further failure to find a way out of the
constitutional impasse.

6. Canada. Quebec. 1980 Quebec Referendum (announced 20 December 1979).

 9.11 QUEBEC AND THE ROC 533

The referendum on 20 May 1980 produced a 60% Non vote which left the door open for further
referenda and renewed constitutional talks.

Attributions
Figure 9.46
Quebec divided by John Douglas Belshaw is used under a CC-BY-4.0 license.

Figure 9.47
Games of the XXIX Olympiad = Jeux de la XXIXe olympiade (Online MIKAN no.3929423) by Library and
Archives Canada, Acc. No. 1994-434-254 has nil restrictions on use.

Figure 9.48
Page couverture de la revue Time, dition canadienne du 1er mars, 1976 Photo de Joe Clark lu chef du
parti conservateur (Online MIKAN no.3214030) by Duncan Cameron / Library and Archives Canada has nil
restrictions on use.

Figure 9.49
Pierre Trudeau giving speech at NO referendum (flag in background) (Online MIKAN no.3588019) by
Robert Cooper / Library and Archives Canada has nil restrictions on use.
9.12 The 1980s

Figure 9.50 Referenda notwithstanding, it

was the story of Terry Fox that gripped
Canadians in 1980, a drama that unfolded
with a distinctive hopping gait and a tragic
end. Fox is seen here ca. 1977 before his
amputation.

The oil crises of the 1970s continued to damage the western economy, driving up government deficits in one
country after the next (see Section 8.10). Economic stagnation combined with inflation a rare occurrence to
produce what was called stagflation. The dominant economic theory of the time in Canada, a kind of modified
Keynesianism, offered limited help in dealing with this new phenomenon. Trudeaus 1975 to 1979 administration
responded with wage and price controls and limited the ability of trade unions to bargain for improved incomes
as a means of controlling inflation. This strategy undermined the postwar settlement and brought the Liberals into
conflict with labour, thereby enhancing the NDPs position.

At the same time, the most and increasingly popular economic theory on the right called for achieving
growth through monetary policy. Monetarism (described in Section 8.16) was invoked as a way of adjusting
incomes outside of wage settlements. Coupled to a belief in the efficacy of free markets and the necessity of reduc-
ing the role of the state, these approaches together constituted the neo-liberal (sometimes referred to as neo-con-
servative) agenda. Canadians were not in a hurry to embrace these policies, but the outside world specifically,
the United States and the United Kingdom did so from the late 1970s on. Canada was inevitably caught up in
this tide.

534
 9.12 THE 1980S 535

Figure 9.51 Queen Elizabeth II adds her signature to the Canada

Act, 1982.

Trudeaus Return

It is worth noting that Trudeaus unpopularity in 1979 particularly in the West did not recover during
the Clark administration. Ontario, Quebec, and the Maritimes returned a Liberal majority in 1980, in a
campaign in which Trudeau was regarded by his own minders as a liability to be kept mostly out of sight.
Apart from two seats in Manitoba, the West did not elect a single Liberal. If this reflected, in part, the
Liberal approach to energy politics the situation only worsened with the subsequent introduction of the
National Energy Policy (see Section 8.10). These developments were bound up in what became known as
western alienation, a parallel to Quebecs dissatisfaction with Confederation and longstanding Maritime
disenchantment.
What sustained Trudeaus standing nationally was his constitutional achievement in 1982. Efforts began in
1980 to recreate the consensus between provincial leaders that was briefly achieved at Victoria (in 1971)
but these ended in bitter disagreement between the premiers and Trudeaus designate in this process, Jean
Chrtien (b. 1934). A November 1981 meeting between Chrtien and a group of Premiers in the kitchen
of the Government Conference Centre produced what was called the Kitchen Accord (and its makers,
inevitably, were the Kitchen Cabinet). Lvesque arrived the following morning and rejected the Accord as
a betrayal of trust on the part of his colleagues, after which it was known in Quebec as the Night of the
1
Long Knives.
The federal government then settled on a unilateral approach to the problem, one that the provinces chal-
lenged unsuccessfully in the Supreme Court. This left the path open for Ottawa to request of Westminster
that the constitution be patriated to Canada. Faced with this seeming fait accompli, nine of the provinces
agreed to an arrangement in which the new Charter of Rights and Freedoms would protect some of their
interests through a notwithstanding clause in the forthcoming Canada Act (1982). An amending formula,
however, was not settled on.
Quebec remained a hold-out in these talks and has not relinquished that position since. At the time, Trudeau
(probably correctly) believed that Lvesque would not consent to any proposal to reform a constitution
from which he would prefer an outright break. Certainly, if Liberal premier Bourassa in 1971 felt pressure
from nationalistes to reject the Victoria Charter, the separatist premier Lvesque would feel that pressure
even more.
Despite the constitutional victory as it was seen by many Trudeaus personal popularity continued to
sag. By 1984, he had spent 15 years in the job and helmed the country through some of its most troubled
years. Generation gaps, campus unrest, FLQ bombs, the sexual revolution, second-wave feminism, two
OPEC oil crises, the end of the postwar boom, the arrival in adulthood of all of the baby boomers, and two
major constitutional battles including a nail-biting referendum in Quebec represent only a sample of
the seismic forces that were metamorphosing the country and exhausting the prime minister.
In the background, Trudeaus private life had gone from glamour to prurient gossip and judgment. It is
important to note in this regard the different values that were manifest in 1970s and 1980s Canada: as

1. This term alludes to events in Germany in June and July 1934 in which the Hitler regime brutally purged and murdered its internal opponents
as well as critics outside the National Socialist Party.
 536 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Christopher Dummitt shows in Section 9.5, a leader with a secret life as complicated and messy as that of
Mackenzie King could be in the spotlight for 20 years without fear of public or press prying. By contrast,
Trudeaus playboy lifestyle in the 1960s drew comment and criticism; his relationship with, marriage to,
and divorce from Margaret Sinclair (b. 1949) a woman 30 years his junior and described by the press as
a flower child was scrutinized at every turn. Sinclair came from the Liberal establishment in British
Columbia (her father was a cabinet minister under Louis St. Laurent), but she was 22 at the time of her
marriage and subjected to the first wave of political paparazzi whether at home, on official business,
or visiting her favourite discotheque. Sinclairs departure from 24 Sussex Drive (which she has described
2
bitterly as the Crown jewel of the federal penitentiary system ) was a blow to Trudeaus own well-being.
His role as the nations most famous single parent was yet another way in which he was a pioneer among
prime ministers.
Trudeaus legacy is a complex one. His administrations were buffeted by demands for change, and they
made many missteps along the way. There were important advances and substantial retreats as well. Mate-
rial change the Charter, the Constitution was probably less consequential in some respects than the
emotions he evoked in people. Early in Trudeaus prime ministership, the famously acerbic poet Irving
Layton said, In Pierre Elliott Trudeau, Canada has at last produced a leader worthy of assassination.
Trudeaus undoubted intellectual powers, his coolly rational, Jesuitical way of arguing a point, his disre-
gard for decorum (as when he slid down a bannister at the Chateau Laurier or did a pirouette behind the
Queen), and his cut-throat debating style in the Commons aroused feelings of admiration and accusations
of unbridled arrogance. As much as many of his predecessors have been disliked or their policies despised,
Trudeau was simultaneously the most celebrated and hated man to hold the office. His successors would
be held to a changed standard and all would prove to be no Trudeau.

Mulroney, Meech, and More

As neo-liberalism took hold in Britain and America, so too it acquired acolytes in Canada. The fading popularity
of the Liberals worked to the advantage of the Conservatives. Clarks failure to hold onto power put his leadership
in peril and, with it, the ability of the Red Tories to influence the party in a decade of rising social conservative
values. In 1983, the Progressive Conservative Partys leadership convention ousted Clark and elected Brian Mul-
roney (b. 1939) as leader.

Born in Baie-Comeau, educated in Quebec, New Brunswick, and, Nova Scotia, Mulroney was conspicuously flu-
ent in English and French and as much at home in boardroom Montreal as he was in rural Maritimes and Quebec.
A political animal from an early age, he worked in Ottawa under the Diefenbaker government before shifting to
corporate law. In the 1970s, he played an important and prominent role in the Cliche Commission enquiry into
labour issues at the James Bay hydroelectric project. His disclosure of Mafia involvement in union actions put him
in the public eye for the first time. The Commission also found Mulroney working alongside Lucien Bouchard (b.
1938) and in close contact with Bourassa, two political allies who would play important roles in the 1980s and
1990s. Understood to be an opportunist who could play the Blue and Red sides of the PC Party, Mulroney decided
in 1984 to move his campaign in a direction that was consonant with highly popular neo-conservative regimes in
Washington and London.

The 1984 campaign combined a swing to the right with a rejection of the Liberals now led by the very uncertain
John Turner (b. 1929). Turner, like Trudeau, had an earlier reputation as a good-looking, mid-century playboy (he

2. Quoted in Glen McGregor, "The Gargoyle - 24 Sussex: 'The Crown jewel of the federal penitentiary system,'" Ottawa Citizen, 19 June 2015.
 9.12 THE 1980S 537

had famously dated Princess Margaret in the 1950s) and as an effective Minister of Justice and then Minister of
Finance under Trudeau. But he broke with Trudeau in 1975 over the issue of wage and price controls and spent the
next nine years working on Bay Street as a corporate lawyer. He won a seat in the 1980 election but was not the
robust fighter he had been years before. He made an easy target for Mulroney and, in one of the earliest televised
debates between federal party leaders, Turner withered and crumbled under accusations that he lacked the nerve
to reverse egregious patronage appointments made by Trudeau on his way out of office.

Figure 9.52 Colour the nation blue. The Progressive

Conservatives in 1984 were the first in the postwar era to
dominate in every region.

The Liberal record in tatters, Mulroney did more than inherit office from a failing government. He built huge
momentum across the country. Although Diefenbaker had made headway into Quebec, it was Mulroney who
reestablished the party of Borden in that province, winning 58 of 75 seats. This massive majority in the Commons,
however, did not translate into an easy legislative ride. The Senate was dominated by years of Liberal appoint-
ments with little likelihood of change on the horizon. For the first time in decades, the upper house was inclined
to scrutinize legislation and send it back to the Commons for amendment. These practices frustrated Progressive
Conservatives who were hungry for change, and stimulated calls for senate reform. Mulroney faced other chal-
lenges, however, and some of these were internal. Having been out of office for a generation (notwithstanding the
Clark regime of nine months), there was a backlog of demands from patronage appointment hopefuls. As well,
the country was running a significant deficit, and attempts to reduce it only imperiled Mulroneys ability to fund
projects that would reward the party faithful.

The prime minister responded with closer relations with the United States and constitutional reforms.

New Reciprocity
Free trade had always been an issue associated with the Liberal Party; now Mulroney seized upon it from a neo-
liberal angle. The Auto Pact already provided for severely lowered tariffs in that sector and there were other sec-
toral trade discussions underway since the 1960s. Reducing trade barriers further and more generally was seen in
the 1980s as a means to boost activity in a slow moving Canadian economy. It also suited Mulroneys pro-Amer-
ican attitudes, which were put on display at a St. Patricks Day meeting in Quebec City in 1984 with President
Ronald Reagan. The Shamrock Summit between the two Irish-North American leaders laid the groundwork for
a freer marketplace, a sign that Ottawa was absorbing the neo-liberal view that government regulation of trade
was stifling growth. The Free Trade Agreement (FTA) that followed was resisted bitterly by some manufacturers
and many spokespersons for the cultural sector. The acclaimed author, Margaret Atwood (b. 1939), was only the
most prominent of the many writers and artists who challenged the proposed agreement on the grounds that it
would result in the destruction of Canadian culture. In a presentation to a parliamentary committee on free trade,
she said, Canada as a separate but dominated country has done about as well under the US as women, worldwide,
have done under men; about the only position theyve ever adopted towards us, country to country, has been the
 538 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION
3
missionary position, and we were not on top. The final agreement provided protection to Canadian education
systems, the health sector, and cultural industries; it did not, however, cover off American access to Canadian
water (for the economic impacts of the FTA, see Section 8.16).

The final draft left many Canadians uneasy and concerned about national sovereignty in an integrated North
American economy. The NDPs opposition was predictable, given its record of concerns about American commer-
cial and cultural imperialism; the Liberal Party also threw its weight against the proposed treaty, thereby claim-
ing the anti-reciprocity position that was, for a century, a trademark of John A. Macdonalds Conservative Party.
Faced with obstruction in the Liberal-dominated Senate, Mulroney opted to take the issue to the polls. The 1988
election that followed became a single-issue campaign, a poll on whether to accept the FTA. Although Tory domi-
nance survived only in Alberta and Quebec, the NDP and Liberals split the vote everywhere else and were unable
to avoid a second Mulroney majority. The FTA was proclaimed and in effect on 1 January 1989.

Figure 9.53 Get lost. Ive already been tricked. Mulroneys

success in the Free Trade election belies the fact that his
government otherwise faced comprehensive criticism.

The Meech Lake Accord

The possibility of constitutional change was able to take advantage of the momentum created by the Canada Act.
The most critical piece was the issue of an amending formula. Mulroneys popularity in Quebec was largely built
on his commitment to meaningful change in this area, so long as it would address Quebecers concerns. Lvesque
indicated a willingness to seek a resolution, a move that undermined his support in the PQ, led to his resigna-
tion as leader, and the Partys defeat at the hands of Bourassas revived Liberal Party in December 1985. In April
1987, Mulroney invited the provincial premiers to a retreat at Meech Lake, where a nine-hour meeting produced
agreement on an amending formula, a distinct society clause for Quebec, a system for filling senate openings and
Supreme Court positions with individuals recommended by the provinces, and greater provincial influence over
immigration issues. This was the only thing that was accomplished with alacrity in the brief life of the Meech
Lake Accord. In June 1990, the Accord was dead, unable to make it through the various shoals of Canadian pol-
itics. What had gone wrong?

The signs at first were promising. The opposition leaders John Turner for the Liberals and Ed Broadbent (b.
1936) for the NDP endorsed the Accord and the public seemed predisposed to support an agreement that would
put an end to the long-running constitutional saga. As Bourassa was inclined to point out, all of Quebecs require-
ments had been offered up by Ottawa at one point or another over the previous 20 years, so there was little new
to be concerned about. Only four of the premiers at Meech were not Conservatives, and one of those was BC
Social Credit premier Bill Bennett (1932-2015) (an ideological conservative); another was Bourassa, a Liberal,

3. Quoted in Frank E. Manning, Reversible Resistance: Canadian Popular Culture and the American Other, in David H. Flaherty and Frank E.
Manning, eds., The Beaver Bites Back: American Popular Culture in Canada (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press,
1993): 4.
 9.12 THE 1980S 539

who was adamantly supportive of the Accord. That left Howard Pawley (1934-2015) (NDP), who was replaced
within weeks by the Conservative government of Gary Filmon (b. 1942). All of this bode well.

And then, a month after the Meech Lake meeting, Pierre Trudeau resurfaced. No longer an MP, his thoughts on
the subject were nevertheless newsworthy. He called Mulroney a weakling for caving into Quebecs interests,
drew attention to the dilution of federal powers to the detriment of the whole nation, took aim at the distinct soci-
ety clause, and made salient points about the threat the Accord might pose to the Charter rights of less-privileged
Canadians. Federalists within the national and Quebec arm of the Liberal Party began deserting Turners support-
ive position.

This was not enough to completely derail the process. A signing ceremony in June 1987 in Ottawa turned into
an all-nighter of negotiations on fine points but agreement was reached and the document inked. Now, as per the
existing amendment process, the clock was running: Meech Lake required official Parliamentary and provincial
approval within three years or it would die on the order paper.

Three years is a long time in politics. First, Hatfields Conservative government in New Brunswick was devastated
at the polls by the Frank McKenna (b. 1948) -led Liberal Party which, remarkably, won every seat in the legisla-
ture. Then the Pawley government fell and a minority government took its place. In 1989, Newfoundland voters
threw out the Conservative Tom Rideout (b. 1948) government and voted in the Liberals under Clyde Wells (b.
1937), who along with McKenna believed that the Accord talks should be reopened.

Public opinion, too, was beginning to abandon the Accord. A turning point in this regard was the response of the
Quebec Liberals to a Supreme Court decision on the provinces sign laws. The Court found the extensive ban
on English-language signage violated Charter rights. Rather than concede the point, Bourassa drew up new leg-
islation, Bill 178, which used the notwithstanding clause to renew the commitment to French-only signs. One of
the aspects of the Meech Lake Accord was that the clause was not to be used to get around Charter rights. Eng-
lish-Canadian politicians in Quebec and elsewhere were appalled; both New Brunswick and Manitoba now turned
against the Accord.

In the absence of public hearings before Meech Lake, what followed was a public outpouring of criticism. There
was some support, to be sure, but accusations of elitism and the creation through the distinct society clause
of what was called asymmetrical federalism raised concerns from coast to coast. New Brunswicks opposi-
tion prompted Mulroney to appoint Jean Charest (b. 1964), a young cabinet member from Quebec, to head up
a Commission to find a way forward on some of these issues. The Charest Commission recommended that the
distinct society clause be subject to the Charter, a change that appealed to English Canadian premiers but which
did not play well in Quebec. Bourassa would have nothing to do with the amendments and Charests suggestions
prompted Mulroneys old friend and cabinet minister, Lucien Bouchard (b. 1938), to resign from the government
(some accounts claim he was fired). Always an undisguised nationaliste, Bouchard now declared himself com-
mitted to the sovereigntist vision of independence. Just as Turner was dealing with division in the ranks of the
Liberal Party, now Mulroney was facing down senior members in his own cabinet.

Mulroney was himself an important factor in the failure of Meech Lake. His management style worked well in
executive boardrooms, but it lacked any consultative features. There were no public hearings, admittedly a rarity
in the 1980s. The optics were bad as well: a roomful of white male politicians who were all with the exception
of PEIs Joe Ghiz (1945-1996), who was of Lebanese descent drawn from northwestern European stock, ought
540 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

to have noticed that they lacked credibility to speak for women, Aboriginal people, new immigrant Canadians,
and several other constituencies. No sooner was the Accord announced, some of these groups began to mobilize
opposition to the process as much as to its product. Mulroney has been criticized as being too much in a rush to
get an agreement and, thus, too ready to make concessions of federal authority where there were strong arguments
against doing so. In the aftermath of a final round of revisions and amendments in June 1990, Mulroney claimed
in an interview that his last strategy was to gather the premiers and force an agreement. It was in this interview
that he used the phrase roll the dice to describe the process. If the premiers had not felt manipulated or treated
with contempt before, several certainly did at this point. The public, too, was outraged by Mulroneys gaff. It
was this reaction that prompted Manitoba premier Filmon to call for public hearings. What support Mulroney had
enjoyed from Liberal leadership hopeful Jean Chrtien now evaporated.

Figure 9.54 David Neels Just Say No. The

catch-phrase of the war on drugs is repurposed here
in a tribute to Elijah Harper.

The final scene of the Meech Lake Accord drama was held in the Manitoba legislature. The process involved
in reaching the Accord consensus angered Aboriginal political figures, and they were dissatisfied as well with
the actual contents of the agreement. Aboriginal people were never consulted, and their role or place in Cana-
dian society was submerged beneath the rhetoric of two founding nations. Approval of the Accord by Manitoba
required two votes in the legislature, the first being a vote permitting the second vote. It was during this debate
that a northern Manitoba NDP member of the legislative assembly, Elijah Harper (1949-2013), holding a single
eagle feather, used legitimate procedural delays to obstruct the assembly. This act, conducted by a First Nations
man the first Treaty Indian in provincial politics was an important moment in drawing Canadians attention
to Aboriginal issues and the question of where they fit within the equation of constitutional discussions. Harpers
refusal in the face of substantial pressure to accede was noted widely and regarded as courageous and, in the end,
it was successful. The vote could not be taken, the deadline passed, and Meech died.

Key Points

Changing economic circumstances produced a change in the political culture, manifest in a turn
toward neo-liberal (aka: neo-conservative) positions.
Trudeaus success in patriating the constitution produced the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and
the Canada Act. What was missing was an amending formula.
Despite these accomplishments, Trudeaus popularity continued to fall, and it did so in an era of
increasingly personalized politics.
Brian Mulroneys prime ministership moved the Conservatives from a Red Tory to a Blue Tory posi-
tion on social policies.
 9.12 THE 1980S 541

Mulroney broke, too, with generations of Tory leaders by endorsing closer relations with the United
States in politics and in trade, manifest in the signing of the Free Trade Agreement.
The Conservative government also moved in 1987 to settle the issue of the amending formula. The
Meech Lake Accord was agreed between all ten provinces and Ottawa, but its support dissipated in
the three years that followed.
Canadian political culture generally became more ideologically charged in the 1980s, more personal,
and simultaneously more public, with growing demands for consultative and transparent processes.
The role of Elijah Harper in the defeat of the Meech Lake Accord is regarded as a watershed
moment after which Aboriginal peoples involvement was more consistently sought.

Attributions
Figure 9.50
Terry Fox by Simon Fraser University University Communications is used under a CC-BY-2.0 license.

Figure 9.51
Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II with Prime Minister The Rt. Hon. Pierre Elliott Trudeau signing the Consti-
tution. (Online MIKAN no.3205977) by Robert Cooper / Library and Archives Canada / PA-141503 has nil
restrictions on use.

Figure 9.52
Canada 1984 Federal Election by Lokal_Profil is used under CC-BY-SA-2.5 license.

Figure 9.53
Get lost, Ive already been tricked! (Online MIKAN no.2866224) by Library and Archives Canada, Acc. No.
1987-42-435 has nil restrictions on use.

Figure 9.54
Just Say No [Elijah Harper] (Online MIKAN no.2910105) by Library and Archives Canada, David Neel col-
lection, 1991-344, C-138082 has nil restrictions on use. Copyright assigned to Library and Archives Canada by
copyright owner Roy Carless.
9.13 Cold War Society: Cities and Suburbs

Figure 9.55 Even the smallest 20th-century cities, like

Whitehorse, adopted the suburban style of housing (among them,
the rancher and the split-level bungalow) and exploited
peripheral land rather than building higher densities.

At the turn of this century, only one city in the Atlantic provinces surpassed the 100,000 mark in population. Hali-
fax stood as the 14th-largest urban area in the country, with 359,111 people in 2001. St. Johns (in 20th place) had
a population of 99,182, and all of the rest were below 70,000. The combined populations of Saint John, Moncton,
Fredericton, and Charlottetown were hardly more than that of Saskatoon, and if St. Johns and Corner Brook were
added, they still wouldnt be a match for Halifax.

Because large urban areas make more media noise than smaller centres, because media and capital are centralized
in the biggest metropolises, and because the influence of the top three or four major cities is so pervasive, it is easy
to lose sight of the rather more modest urban experiences of some Canadian regions in what many commentators
called the century of the city. Rare, however, is the city of any size that has not been impacted by many of the
urban trends that define modern life, of which automobilism, suburbanization, the baby boom, multiculturalism,
and commercialization of space are only a few examples.

Figure 9.56 Atlantic cities may have grown more slowly but they
took on many of the suburbanized elements of much larger
centres, as Moncton reveals from the air.

An Urban Country
The size of Canada which includes many imperfectly mapped islands in the Arctic inevitably produces
shockingly low population density levels. At 3.4 per square kilometer in 2015, Canada ranks slightly ahead of
Iceland and Australia among developed economies but behind the rest. And yet, the majority of Canadians live in

542
 9.13 COLD WAR SOCIETY: CITIES AND SUBURBS 543

urban centres and have since 1921. In that year, 1.65 million people lived in cities with a population of 100,000 or
more (of which there were only six), out of a total national population of 8.8 million; in 1941, 2.6 million out of
11.5 million were living in that largest tier of cities (of which there were now eight); and, in 1961, 4.2 million out
of 18.2 million were big city dwellers. In 1976, nearly half of the 23 million Canadians were living in 100,000+
sized cities. By contrast, the percentage of Canadians living in cities of 5,000 or fewer has fallen from 19% in
1921 to 15% in 1951 and 11% in 1971. Small-town life has become more uncommon in part because small towns
became large towns and large towns became small cities, but it is clear that the social dynamics that defined the
lives of Canadians before 1921 changed dramatically in the 20th century.

Figure 9.57 The City of Surrey started as several distinct villages,

and that pattern has since been overlaid with a low-density
suburban grid. The city now struggles to create the density that
would enable improved public transit and reduced car
dependence.

Suburbia
Much of that growth was taking place not in the actual cities but in their neighbouring municipalities. It is worth
noting that there have been several resource extraction towns founded in the last 100 years but no new cities. The
late 19th century saw the birth of every major city in western Canada (apart from slightly older Victoria and New
Westminster), but the only truly new centres in the 20th century are satellites and suburbs of the largest metrop-
olises. Mississauga, Brampton, Surrey, Laval, Markham, Vaughan, and Burnaby are examples drawn from the
largest 20 cities in Canada, none of which contained more than a few thousand in 1914, all of which are very near
or past the quarter-million mark now. Each of these began as peripheral, spillover, bedroom communities asso-
1
ciated with a larger urban centre and, in that respect, they were very typical.

The setting for modernity was urban, but the lives of most Canadians in the 20th century increasingly became
defined as something different: suburban.

Beginning in the 1920s, Canadians began a migration away from city centres to the margin. Initially, what was
considered suburban was merely the outskirts of the original city. Suburbanization faltered in the 1930s and
early 1940s and then resumed in earnest in the postwar period. At that time, larger and larger numbers of city
dwellers evacuated old neighbourhoods for entirely new communities.

Suburbanization was driven by several push factors. Housing stock in the city centre had grown overcrowded due
to the poverty of the 1930s (as mortgage payments were missed and the number of rental units increased) and with
the arrival of large numbers of ex-soldiers after the war. Large older homes were converted to rooming houses
with less privacy and aging plumbing, heating, and wiring. In Vancouver, the second Hotel Vancouver was turned
into veterans housing, so pressing was the demand for accommodations. As well, the city centres and older neigh-
bourhoods were increasingly associated (rightly or wrongly) with crime, violence, and from the perspective of

1. Richard Harris, Creeping Conformity: How Canada Became Suburban, 1900-1960 (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2004).
544 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Anglo-Celtic and Francophone Canadians the presence of new immigrants and unfamiliar visible minorities.
Finally, the baby boom (considered below) was underway and the need for more spacious houses was widely felt.

Figure 9.58 Suburbs have been criticized for cookie-cutter

housing designs. In places like Don Mills, where the influence of
the 1920s Garden City movement and modernist architecture can
be seen, the whole design was in fact tightly controlled as a kind
of social experiment in creating a livable space.

The pulls of suburbia were also numerous. Some industries were relocating to the edges of cities, and population
followed. Housing prices were lower and so were property taxes. Suburban housing typically contained signifi-
cantly more floor space than was available in houses in older blue-collar areas. Suburban lots as large as 50
foot (15.24 metres) wide compared very favourably to the 25 or 33 foot (7.62-10 metre) lot commonly found
in the centre of western Canadian cities. Neighbours were, therefore, not cheek-by-jowl with one another. As sub-
urban infrastructure grew there were highways that connected outlying areas with urban industrial nodes and the
city centre. There were also new schools that were instantly a step up from the deteriorating facilities in the inner
cities. Young postwar baby-boom families were attracted by all of these features.

Watch this video on the New Super Super-Mart to see one of Canadas early suburban shopping centres.

Working without much effect against these pulls, were several drawbacks to suburban life. Urban families
tended to stick to identifiable neighbourhoods before 1945 generally, spaces that were associated with ethnic-
ity, church, and sources of preferred types of food. In the suburbanization process, siblings did not (or could not)
necessarily buy in the same areas, which meant that the supports formerly on offer between family members were
more tenuous.

Culturally, suburbs were thought to be deficient. Civic amenities might include parks, rinks, and pools, but it was
rare in the period from 1945 to 1970 to find art galleries or performance spaces outside of the old city cores. Zon-
ing that forbade commercial properties from residential areas meant that there was no corner shop to turn to for
small, immediate necessities; bottles of milk and loaves of bread were often delivered door-to-door, but if a pint
of cream was needed mid-week that meant a trip in the car to the nearest shopping plaza. Pedestrianism was dis-
couraged by distances and by the sprawling parking lots in shopping strips. As shopping malls appeared for the
first time in the 1950s there began a process of concentrating retail space in nodes (with plenty of free parking)
rather than along high streets, a fact that contributed further to the rise of automobile dependency. Most house-
holds therefore had to have two cars at their disposal. This luxury carried with it higher energy and individualized
maintenance costs, and a concomitant rise in demand for more road capacity and parking. There was as a result
more air pollution and alienation from the very greenspace that once made the leafy suburbs attractive. In lieu
of a natural town or village centre in most suburbs, the shopping mall emerged as the de facto focal point for
social interaction. Consumerism was thus encouraged by the lack of other possible sites of community contact.
 9.13 COLD WAR SOCIETY: CITIES AND SUBURBS 545

Figure 9.59 Brentwood in Burnaby was one of Canadas first

suburban shopping malls. It is simultaneously a shrine to
consumerism and a way of divorcing commerce from the
streetscape.

Return to Civvy Street

Readjustment to peacetime in 1945 was welcomed by a generation that had lived through economic disaster and
global conflict. It was also approached with some trepidation. The immediate postwar era a generation earlier had
brought unemployment, a pandemic, and labour unrest. Some of these concerns were addressed at the political
level (see Section 8.12). No initiative was as comprehensive in this respect as the 1944 Veterans Charter.

At wars end, there were some 900,000 men and women who had served in some capacity. The Charter provided
$1.2 billion to facilitate their reintegration. This included a one-time pay-out, cash for civilian clothing, and life
insurance. Funding was available for post-secondary education at university or in vocational schools. The Central
Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) was created in 1946 to assist Canadians with their first home
purchase and the renovation of older homes (neglected during the Depression and not helped by material short-
2
ages during the war). Oversight for these and other projects was provided by the newly-established Department
of Veterans Affairs (later renamed Veterans Affairs Canada).

Legislative and social pressures combined to enable returned soldiers to reclaim their old jobs (if, indeed, they
had been formerly employed). This meant, inevitably, removing women from the industrial workforce. For return-
ing servicewomen, however, no similar commitment was made. The end effect was to make marriage and house-
wifery the default career path for women who were not nurses, secretaries, or teachers.

Would suburbanization have occurred with such rapidity in the postwar years had it not been for this context? It is
unlikely. CMHC brought homeownership within reach of a generation that had, less than a decade earlier, expe-
rienced record-setting levels of unemployment, cash shortages, and falling wages. The economic boost provided
by the war had one other related impact that drove forward suburban growth.

The Baby Boom

As economic conditions began to improve slightly in the late 1930s, so too did the nuptiality (marriage) rate and
the number of births. The earliest hint of a fertility recovery, however, was nothing compared to what would come
after World War II. In 1911, there were 4.8 million Canadians over the age of 15 years, of whom 2.6 million were
married; that share about half survived until the 1950s, when it reached two-thirds and then crept up to
three-quarters in the early 1960s. In the post-war, Cold War years, being married, building a family, and yes,
being born was the experience of a growing number of Canadians.

The declaration of war in 1939 was followed by a veritable stampede to the wedding altar. In Vancouver, for

2. Jill Wade, Houses for All: The Struggle for Social Housing, 1919-1950 (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 1994).
 546 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

example, there was a 26.6% increase in the number of marriages registered over the previous year. To give this
more perspective, it represents a doubling over the 1933 incidence of nuptiality in the city. Births would follow
soon thereafter.

Nationally the number of births in 1937 was only 227,900 and then it shot up to pre-Depression rates in 1940,
surpassing every year in the 1920s other than 1921, at 263,993. The crude birth rate rose from 20.1 in 1937 to
24.3 in 1945 and kept going up until it peaked in 1947 at 28.9. It then sagged a bit and then recovered in 1954
to 1957, when it hovered just above 28 per 1000. There were twice as many live births in 1956 (450,700) than
there had been in any year in the 1930s. What is more, although the share of births that were illegitimate climbed
during the war years from 3.9 to 4.5% of the total number of births, illegitimacy declined to a mid-1950s trough
of about 3.8%.

More and more births took place in hospitals. In the 1920s, the share of hospital births was around 1 in 4; in the
1930s, it climbed to about 1 in 3, passing the 40% mark in 1939; by the end of the war, the figure was nearly
64%; by 1960, it was nearly 95%; and from 1965, it was 99%. Whatever the risks entailed in hospital births, the
neo-natal and infant mortality rate fell from 81 per 1000 live population in 1931 to 1935 to 26 in 1960-1965, a
remarkable achievement in public health. Likewise, stillbirths fell from nearly 32 per 1000 live births in 1931 to
3
fewer than 12 in 1965.

The enormity of immigration in 20th-century Canada (considered in Section 5.11) has tended to overshadow
another important demographic behaviour: migration. As with the arrival of newcomers, the movement of Cana-
dians from one province to another has had a westward bias. The other provinces and the Territories are more fully
represented in British Columbia and Alberta than in any of the Maritime provinces, and this has been the case
since the early 20th century. It is difficult to track interprovincial movement but we can identify out-migration pat-
terns. From 1921 to 1961, there was only one decade in which Nova Scotia saw fewer people leave than arrived; in
the same period PEI and New Brunswick (and, after 1949, Newfoundland) experienced substantial and sustained
net out-migration. The decade in which this softens the 1930s offered up such poor economic prospects in
the rest of the country that Maritimers were less likely to head down the road. Which suggests, of course, that
interprovincial pulls are at least as important as pushes. The West was not exempt from abandonment: Manitoba
was a net loser of population from 1921 and Saskatchewan from 1931. Alberta experienced net migration from
1931 to the 1950s. In fact, only British Columbia and Ontario registered net increases in migration across every
4
decade of the 20th century. Moving to where the jobs are became a powerful tradition in its own right in Atlantic
Canada in the mid-20th century.

White Flight
The ability to move to suburbia seemed, at the time, a very democratic one. But, in fact, it was one enjoyed mostly
by Canadians who held steady jobs, and most of those people were drawn from the British and French context
populations. New immigrants continued to pour into the old urban centres and their numbers were growing as the
postwar migrations gathered speed (see Section 5.11). West Indian, South Asian, and other visible minorities took
over spaces vacated by those who made their way to the suburbs. Growing diversity in urban cores contributed

3. Statistics Canada, Historical Statistics of Canada, 2nd edition., F.H. Leacy, ed. (Ottawa: Statistics Canada, 1983): B1-14, B23-50.
4. Warren E. Kalbach and Wayne W. McVey, The Demographic Bases of Canadian Society (Toronto: McGraw-Hill, 1971), 86.
 9.13 COLD WAR SOCIETY: CITIES AND SUBURBS 547

to still more movement to the suburbs by more established Canadian households in what has been called white
flight.

The effect on city centres of this evacuation is important to note. Downtowns in the first half of the 20th century
had been a focal point for entertainment and commerce; by the 1960s, many were gutted. Live theatre and music
venues closed down, old movie palaces became dilapidated and doomed for demolition, neighbourhoods that were
increasingly viewed as irredeemable slums were ploughed under to make way for freeways that would conduct
suburbanites to and from work. Downtown department stores retained some customer loyalty, but the spread of
suburban shopping malls were a blow from which they would never fully recover. The impact of this abandon-
ment of the city centres can still be seen in many Canadian metropolises. Some, like Winnipeg, are a patchwork of
vacant lots and are very unpopulated after dark. The leading cities, however, turned the availability of land in what
was now called the Central Business District (CBD) to advantage by erecting the countrys second generation
of skyscrapers. Built of steel, concrete, and glass, these mostly corporate-owned or chartered bank-owned towers
sprang up first in Montreal (the countrys financial capital at the time and the largest city) and were as much as
twice the height of pre-WWII towers. The skylines of the largest downtowns across the country followed suit and
began to reflect a pattern of trademark styles. The black glass Toronto-Dominion towers were instantly distin-
guishable from the white-edged Bank of Montreal skyscrapers. Montreal also led the way in suburban sprawl,
so much so that by 1996, 75% of Montrealers actually lived outside of the city proper.

Torontos leadership responded to the changes associated with population and spatial expansion in 1953 by cre-
ating a federated Municipality of Metropolitan Toronto. Known as Metro, the new administrative body took in
the City of Toronto and the suburban municipalities of Etobicoke, York, North York, East York, and Scarborough.
This new organism accomplished much but some of its projects were highly controversial.

Figure 9.60 Nanaimo is one of the oldest cities in western

Canada, but that has not saved it from sprawl. Its metro
population of 98,000 in 2015 covers 1,280 km2. Greater Toronto
(not Metro) covers 1,751 km2 but contains more than 5 million
people.

As the flight to the suburbs accelerated in the 1950s and pressures grew to develop more and better highway sys-
tems, a generation of planners appeared whose approach to depressed areas was to bring in the bulldozers. Some
took their lead from American cities where variegated downtowns were gutted to make way for sleek, high-den-
sity social housing projects and cloverleaf overpasses. Largely because the Canadian economy and population
lagged somewhat behind the Americans, some cities were spared the worst excesses of this period. Even in the
United States, however, the wisdom of obliterating whole communities in the name of faster traffic flow and ratio-
nalized modern housing was being questioned.

At the forefront of the debate was New Yorks Jane Jacobs (1916-2006). In the mid-1950s, Jacobs began a public
critique of slum clearance and urban renewal in Manhattan. Jacobs successful crusade was noted in the Canadian
media. When she emigrated to Canada in 1968 (in part to keep her draft-age sons out of the Vietnam War), she
 548 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

became a high-profile lightning rod for Torontonians angered at the proposed Spadina Expressway. The battle to
stop the project was ultimately successful. As Ontario Premier William (Bill) Davis (b. 1929) observed in 1971:

If we are building a transportation system to serve the automobile, the Spadina Expressway would be a good place to
5
start. But if we are building a transportation system to serve people, the Spadina Expressway is a good place to stop.

The collapse of the Spadina Expressway project in Toronto coincided with the death of radical proposals for
slum clearance. The Bonaventure Expressway took a bite out of Griffintown in Montreal and the Autoroute Ville-
Marie displaced hundreds. The construction of waterfront expressways and viaducts through Vancouvers East
End, Gastown, Chinatown, and Strathcona were stayed. These were unusual survivors, in that neighbourhoods
containing ethnic minorities and Aboriginal peoples generally did not fare well in the battle with bulldozers and
highways. An African-Canadian neighbourhood in Vancouver and Winnipegs Rooster Town, a Mtis community,
6
were both cleared to make way for, respectively, a viaduct and a suburban school. Clearances of these neighbour-
hoods, along with the wide variety of shantytowns that existed on civic peripheries (in defiance of modern norms
of property ownership and conceptions of public health), were a way to rationalize cities, to colonize neighbour-
hoods and pastureland alike with a modern vision of Canadian life.

Suburbanization gave the Canadians who could afford it the space they deeply wanted and a sense of building new
communities that echoed the pioneer experience. There were significant liabilities to this trend, including the
isolation of housewives on the periphery, the loss of access to cultural facilities, and huge environmental conse-
quences. Publicly owned transportation systems such as streetcars were pulled out of service to create more room
for privately owned automobiles. Less obvious is the extent to which private space became dominant, superseding
public space. The gathering in a town square, the crowded meeting at city hall, the spontaneous spilling of crowds
off a sidewalk onto the street to watch a parade or to engage in protest: these did not disappear entirely but were
much less common than they had been in the pre-WWII years. The authorities could point to this change with
some satisfaction because it meant that another general strike like Winnipegs in 1919 was unlikely. The possibil-
ity of rioting unemployed workers was likewise diminished. The trade-off was several generations that retreated
into their living rooms and recreation rooms to engage with the civitas only through a television screen.

What came out of suburbia was a population and culture unlike any before it. More highly educated and with
expectations of continued prosperity, the baby boomers challenged the state to keep up with demands for services,
institutions, and opportunities. As a voting population, they have been a decisive force since they first started vot-
ing in the 1960s. This was the first generation raised on television and nurtured by consumerism, a generation for
which car-ownership and home-ownership was a given, if not a right. By the 1970s, more of Canadas housing
stock had been built since 1945 than before, and the vast majority of that construction took place in suburban
tracts. The suburbs were the cradle of what would rapidly emerge as the majority of Canadians, and gradually it
became the case that these were more diverse neighbourhoods than the enclaves left behind in the old city centres.

Discounted by planners and often ridiculed (sometimes rightly) for their alleged soullessness, no exploration of
contemporary Canadian culture and values would be complete without a serious understanding of the legacy of
suburbanization.

5. John Sewell, The Shape of the City: Toronto Struggles with Modern Planning (Toronto, Ontario: University of Toronto Press, 1993).
6. David G. Burley, Rooster Town: Winnipegs Lost Mtis Suburb, 1900-1960, Urban History Review, XLII, no.1 (Fall 2013): 3-25.
 9.13 COLD WAR SOCIETY: CITIES AND SUBURBS 549

Key Points

The 20th century saw the number of large cities increase, the share of population living in large
cities rise and the experience of growing up or residing in small towns retreat.
Most urban growth in the second half of the 20th century took place in suburban neighbourhoods.
Suburbs were attractive for economic reasons and because the housing stock and schools were new,
automobilism made them (and workplaces) accessible, and shopping malls made them self-suffi-
cient.
Suburban life was made possible by social policies like the Veterans Charter and the CMHC.
The end of the Depression, the start of WWII, and demobilization all contributed to the baby boom
which, in turn, contributed to suburbanization.
Abandonment of city centres led to the collapse of downtown commerce and its replacement with
financial districts. It also led to massive highway projects that would obliterate older often ethnic
neighbourhoods.
Reactions against highways projects would rescue some Canadian centres from being paved over
and would generate a renewed interest on creating livable spaces in the cities.
Suburbia emerged as the new cradle of Canadian society and culture a place with a gendered
geography and a tendency to favour private space over public.

Attributions
Figure 9.55
Whitehorse Yukon Panorama Sept 2008 second version by Jd.101 is used under a CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.

Figure 9.56
Moncton Aerial 3847 by Sebastien Paquet is used under a CC-BY-2.0 license.

Figure 9.57
Surrey aerial view by Mateom28 is used under a CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.

Figure 9.58
Don Mills homes 2 by SimonP is used under a CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.

Figure 9.59
Postcard: Brentwood Shopping Centre, Burnaby, BC, 1963 by Rolly Ford is in the public domain.

Figure 9.60
Namaimo aerial 4 by KenWalker is used under a CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.
9.14 Rural Canada in an Urban Century

DANIEL SAMSON, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, BROCK UNIVERSITY

Figure 9.61 The states enthusiasm for science in the early 20th
century is embodied in the National Observatory in Ottawa on the
grounds of the Experimental Farm.

At the time of Confederation, Canada was a rural country. By the middle of the 20th century, the majority of the
country was urban. Today, its mostly urban. How did that happen? And what does that mean for our understand-
ing of the countrys history? The most obvious answer is that the late 19th-century emergence of industrial cap-
italism meant that waged work was available in the towns and cities of the country, and that the countrys farms
were able to feed this increasingly urban population.

Why were farmers able to feed so many more people? The most important change was the development of gas-
powered engines and machinery. Farm mechanization had begun in Canada in the early 19th century, but increased
dramatically in the years just before and after World War I. Productivity improved because mechanization meant
that fewer people could do more labour on ever-larger farms. In the 1830s, most wheat was harvested by hand,
greatly limiting the size of farms. Seventy years later, harvesting, winnowing, and threshing machines meant that
100s of acres, rather than 10s of acres, could be harvested and partially processed quickly and with far fewer
human labourers. Many people, however, feared that all that productivity came at a cost. Rural depopulation
also meant that rural communities shrank. Increased productivity, too, owed much to increased use of pesticides,
adding to costs and multiplying the environmental consequences of agriculture. Mechanization, pesticide pur-
chases, and other increasingly capital intensive techniques meant that steadily fewer families could sustain the
higher costs of industrial agriculture.

550
 9.14 RURAL CANADA IN AN URBAN CENTURY 551

Figure 9.62 Steam-powered tractors quickly transformed farm

productivity.

Many of those who were moving to the city did so because farming had become untenable. Often, the owners of
small farms sold out to larger producers. Indeed, farms continue to grow larger to this day. While the number of
farms peaked in the 1930s, total farm acreage has actually increased over the course of the 20th century. The aver-
age size of a farm in Saskatchewan in 1914 was about 200 acres; by 1936, it had doubled to 400; and by 1956, had
reached over 600 acres per farm. Today, that number is around 1,700 acres. By the early postwar period, farms
could no longer really be considered family farms; they were businesses larger in scale, capital intensive,
and demanding stable access to markets.

Improvements in transportation also encouraged the growth of farms. Larger producers found ready markets for
their products, and the increased availability of trains and steamships meant that Canadian farmers and ranchers,
even those far from the ocean ports of Halifax and Montreal, could get their products to markets in Britain and
the Caribbean. Rail integration in the 20th century opened access to the United States market. The Prairies were
Canadas breadbasket, producing more than four-fifths of the countrys wheat and exporting large quantities over-
seas, but none of that was even imaginable until the completion of the CPR and the integration of the West into
national and international markets.

Scale had a major impact on not only farm size and market conditions, but also on productive and gender rela-
tionships in farm households. In the 19th century, most butter and cheese production was done by women in farm
households. The rise of industrial butter and cheese production in the early 20th century pushed women out of
dairying, and moved them from major productive household responsibilities to largely reproductive ones such as
childrearing.

The state came to play a much greater role in the countryside. In the late 19th-century, federal experimental farms
in small places like Nappan, Nova Scotia; and Kamloops, British Columbia; provincial agricultural colleges in
places like Guelph, Ontario, and Truro, Nova Scotia; and statistical agencies across the country offered research,
education, and support. During World War II, the federal government stepped in to regulate grain supplies and
food production. State-run agencies like the National Wheat Board were created during the Great Depression to
provide price stability, particularly for farmers dependent on international markets. Along with cooperatives and
marketing boards for products like dairy and eggs, Canadian agriculture increasingly utilized market regulation
to protect individual farmers against the uncertainties of international markets and price competition from the
much larger United States agricultural sector.
552 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 9.63 Elements of urban life including well-stocked

libraries could not be transferred to rural Canada, but crusades
to improve literacy and education could. A bookmobile visits
northwestern Ontario at mid-century.

The fisheries in eastern and western Canada faced similar challenges. Local inshore fisheries were increasingly at
the mercy of industrial fishing operations with much larger ships, more productive gear, and direct relationships
with national and international processors. In the great Depression, much like Prairie farmers, Maritime fishers
turned to locally organized cooperatives and marketing agencies to allow them to compete against the industrial
vessels. Factory trawlers and international markets dramatically increased the ability of the industry to harvest
fish, resulting in near total depletion of major fish stocks like North Atlantic cod. By 1995, depletion was so great
that the federal government had to shut down the cod fishery, effectively ending the economic viability of hun-
dreds of small fishing communities in eastern Canada.

Canada also has a racialised dimension to its rural history. Indigenous people shaped their lives around partici-
pation in the fur trade, in small-scale agriculture, and local fisheries. Despite many political and social barriers,
their successes were owing to their skills in working those distinctly rural economies. And from the 18th and 19th
centuries onward, African-Nova Scotians were a predominantly rural population engaged in farming, fishing, and
forestry in rural parts of the province. That explains the poet George Elliott Clarkes reference to Africadians
gumboing the salty recipes of Acadian cooking with the fishy tastes of Coloured Refugees their culture,
too, was shaped by life on the land and the sea.

Rural Canada today faces innumerable challenges. The sheer scale of production, declining population, increasing
competition for prices and market share, and restrictive international trade agreements, and the difficulty of deliv-
ering basic social services even schools means that sustaining rural Canada is ever more difficult. Under-
standing the historic pattern helps us to better understand its complexities and its challenges.

Key Points

The century of the city was made possible by the increased ability of farmers to feed urban popula-
tions (achieved through mechanization, chemicals, heavy capital investment, and consolidation of
smaller farms into larger units able to achieve economies of scale).
The role of the state in agriculture became increasingly important and took the form of research,
marketing boards, and regulation of output.
Rural fisheries communities were challenged by the increasing industrialization of ocean harvesting.
In some rural areas the population became racialized: dominated by visible minorities including
African Nova Scotians and Aboriginal communities.
 9.14 RURAL CANADA IN AN URBAN CENTURY 553

Sources
The Encyclopedia of Saskatchewan [Link]

Saskatchewan Department of Agriculture [Link]

[Link]?DN=508d1598-3b66-428a-93ce-7ea9fa3abaee

Sarah Carter, Two Acres and a Cow: Peasant Farming and the Indians of the Northwest, 1889-1897, Canadian
Historical Review 70, 1 (March 1989): 27-52.

George Elliott Clarke, Whylah Falls (Vancouver, Polestar Press, 1990).

Daniel Samson, The Measure of Our Progress: The Commission on Agriculture, Ontario, 1881, in Nadine
Vivier, ed., The Golden Age of State Enquiries: Rural enquiries in the nineteenth century (Turnhout BE, Bre-
pols, 2014): 255-72.

Ken Sylvester, The Limits of Rural Capitalism: Family, Culture, and Markets in Montcalm, Manitoba, 1870-1940
(Toronto, University of Toronto Press, 2001).

John Thompson, The Harvests of War: The Prairie West, 1914-1918 (Toronto, McClelland & Stewart, 1978).

Miriam Wright, A Fishery for Modern Times: Industrialization of the Newfoundland Fishery, 1934-1968 (Toronto,
University of Toronto Press, 2001).

Attributions
Figure 9.61
Observatory Experimental Farm (Online MIKAN no.3318630) by William James Topley / Library and
Archives Canada / PA-010296 is in the public domain.

Figure 9.62
Steam plowing, Lethbridge, Alberta (HS85-10-23180) original by Canada. Patent and Copyright Office,
Library and Archives Canada is in the public domain.

Figure 9.63
A group of children gather around a librarian and his Bookmobile in rural northwestern Ontario (Online
MIKAN no.4369759) by Canada. Dept. of Manpower and Immigration / Library and Archives Canada is in the
public domain.
9.15 Cold War Themes

A signifier of cultural change in the Cold War years was the transformation of musical styles and tastes. Radio and
film contributed significantly to this process, as did the commercial recording industry. Music was increasingly
commodified and so, too, were musicians. Trends in English Canada which were strongly influenced by what
was going on in the United States and Britain were very different from what occurred in French Canada (ele-
ments of which are considered in Section 10.14). It would be wrong to say that this era saw the universal triumph
of rock music because, in Quebec as in much of the rest of the non-anglophone world, other traditions were more
important and more resilient.

Figure 9.64 Torontos Four Lads are the not-so-missing link

between the sounds of the 1940s and the beginnings of pop music
in the 1950s.

The Beat Goes On

The dominant threads in popular music in the early 1950s were strongly connected with the big band sound,
close harmony vocal groups (often made up of siblings), and the more accessible forms of jazz. American and
British musicians were increasingly challenging these standards, with electric blues, rockabilly, and skiffle all
forms that would contribute in some measure to what became known in the early 1950s as rock and roll (aka:
rocknroll). A transition phase saw the rise of closely managed studio productions, which are now more associ-
ated with pop music. The gospel-inflected The Mocking Bird by Torontos The Four Lads is generally thought
to be the breakthrough moment in Canadian pop/rock. It is markedly distinct from, but closely related to, WWII-
era swing and close harmony bands. This style did not entirely go away. Throughout this period and into the
1970s, artists like Juliette Cavazzi (b. 1927) remained popular, a fact that was made possible by CBC radio pro-
gramming that favoured more conservative sounds. The influence of the national broadcaster in this respects goes
some distance to explain the slow take-off of a younger sound.

554
 9.15 COLD WAR THEMES 555

Figure 9.65 Paul Ankas 1957 hit Diana had an immediate

impact on child-naming practices in Ontario.

It wasnt until 1957 that Canada produced its first genuine pop star, in Ottawas Paul Anka (b. 1941). His debut
hit song, Diana, is held to be responsible for the sudden surge in the popularity of this girls name in Canada (as
1
can be seen in the Ontario data in Figure 9.65 ). Ankas desperate plea he was a hormonally charged 16-year
old when Diana was recorded pulls the song out of the mainstream and into something much closer to the
crooner-rock of the 1950s.

American influences on popular music in Canada in the 1950s and early 1960s were extensive. The infrastructure
of commercial radio and television favoured American recording artists and placed Canadians at a huge disadvan-
tage. Ronnie Hawkins (b. 1935) moved to Canada from the United States and was highly influential from 1958
to 1964, establishing The Hawks, a Canadian backing band. It featured Garth Hudson (b. 1937), Richard Manuel
(1943-1986), Robbie Robertson (b. 1943), Rick Danko (1943-1999), and the American drummer Levon Helm
(1940-2012), who together would eventually re-launch themselves as The Band.

By the mid-1960s, however, the playing field had been somewhat leveled by the impact of the British Invasion.
Bands like the Beatles, the Animals, the Dave Clark Five, and the Rolling Stones combined elements of American
rock including the music and style of both Buddy Holly (1936-1959) and Elvis Presley (1935-1977) with
British soul, Merseybeat, and skiffle to produce a more aggressively dynamic sound. Even British pop and soul
singers like Petula Clark (b. 1932) and Dusty Springfield (1939-1999) were critical influences at this point. Amer-
ican musicians even acts like the Beach Boys, which were credited as an influence on the Beatles struggled
to reclaim prominence in their own market, as did Canadians.

Figure 9.66 Joni Mitchell (b. 1943) in 1974.

Swinging Sixties
In Canada, the major commercial breakthroughs came from the folk-blues-rock community. Oscar Brand (b.
1920) emerged as a leading performer and a godfather of the movement in 1963, as did Ian Tyson (b. 1933). Buffy
Sainte Marie (b. 1941) began her very long and extremely varied career with a folk hit in 1964, the same year that
Joni Mitchell (b. 1943) began singing in Toronto. Gordon Lightfoot (b. 1938) was writing songs for Tyson and his
partner Sylvia Fricker Tyson (b. 1940) in 1963 to 1964 and launched his own folk touring act in 1967. Leonard
Cohen (b. 1934) released Songs of Leonard Cohen in 1967, and a year later Anne Murray (b. 1945) recorded
Snowbird. All of these musicians benefited from a growing appetite in the United States for folk singer-song-

1. Ontario. Top names (female), accessed 13 January 2015 from [Link]

556 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

writers, typified by Bob Dylan (b. 1941); Joan Baez (b. 1941); Pete Seegar (1919-2014); The Weavers; Judy
Collins (b. 1939); and Peter, Paul, and Mary almost all of whom at some point performed music written by
their Canadian contemporaries. Looking at the birth-dates of these figures reminds us that the folk revival of the
1960s was led by people born before or at the very start of the baby boom and who were just that much closer to
a rural version of Canada than their younger peers in the rock movement.

Of that 1960s rocknroll generation, no one stands out more than Neil Young (b. 1945). The son of the prominent
sports journalist, Scott Young, Neil Young moved to California in the late 1960s, where he became part of a folk-
rock supergroup, Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young. In many ways, Young exemplifies the essence of a difficult-to-
define musical style in that his physically exhausting live performances, high degree of musicianship on guitar,
and emphasis on authenticity rather than studio work, thrashing chords, and studied affect are what most
stands out. Joni Mitchell, a contemporary and peer both in Canada and the United States, is comparable in that
she demands more of her chief instrument her voice than was typical of even 1950s harmony singers or the
earlier gospel-folk singers.

CanCon
Young and Mitchell were not the only Canadian musicians to seek fame and fortune south of the border. By 1968,
it was clear that Canadian talent was profoundly underappreciated at home. Without record sales and radio play in
the United States, a Canadian pop or rock performer could not expect to receive much attention from commercial
radio north of the border. Beginning in 1968, the Canadian Radio-Television and Telecommunications Com-
mission (CRTC) began a project to stimulate artistic output under Canadian content (CanCon) rules. From
1971, radio stations were required to devote one-quarter of their airtime to Canadian music. To do so, many sta-
tions had to actively search out producers and performers who could deliver records that met the criteria. The
focus was to be placed on Canadian songs performed by Canadian musicians.

Sometimes the criteria were stretched in bizarre ways: the British psychedelic/progressive rock band, Procol
Harum, in 1971 recorded their song Conquistador with the Edmonton Symphony Orchestra (ESO) providing
support. The ESOs involvement conferred on a clearly British product CanCon advantages: Conquistador went
to #7 in the Canadian charts. Other strategies for avoiding the CanCon constraints were pursued, as well. Some
radio stations addressed what they saw as revenue-draining local recordings by playing them continuously in the
small hours of the night, in what became known disparagingly as beaver hours.

The new CanCon rules took time to create benefits and some of the musicians who were supported at the begin-
ning were clearly filler rather than great local talent. The program nonetheless produced a generation of perform-
ers who could expect and would receive more playtime on Canadian commercial radio than their predecessors.
Bands like the Guess Who appeared in the late 1960s and early 1970s, and enjoyed enormous popularity in Canada
and abroad, as did their spin-off project, Bachman-Turner Overdrive. Rush emerged out of blues tradition and
moved into Progressive (Prog) Rock in the late 1970s. One could provide a long list of bands that enjoyed every
degree of popularity from one-hit-wonderdom to long term success: Trooper, Prism, FM, April Wine, and Chill-
iwack are among the most prominent of the 1970s and early 1980s bands. It is probably no coincidence that this
was the decade that saw the greatest number of baby boomers entering adulthood, a fact that no doubt explains the
endurance even now of both classic rock stations and what has become anthemic hockey-arena music. Which is
 9.15 COLD WAR THEMES 557

to say, it doesnt get played because its necessarily good; it gets played because of the demographic that nurtured
it along and still proclaims its popularity.

All this machinery making modern music

The conundrum facing Canadian musicians in general, and rock musicians in particular, was the business model
of the industry. Record labels stateside dominated the business through their control of distribution and their influ-
ence on radio networks. The sale of records was key to making a living as a musician. So, despite rocknrolls
do-it-yourself, or DIY attitude embodied in every four-piece band that wrote and performed their own music
it was necessary to make use of the recording industry. American labels like Capitol established branch plants
north of the border where they used the same business model, one of the features of which was exclusive own-
ership of a musicians product. A rock musician whose work was defined by live performances could now only
get meaningful engagements through recording agents and industry impresarios. Bands played live in support of
their studio product and, increasingly, merchandise like posters and t-shirts. As rock giants emerged, they could
demand arena and then stadium venues, absorbing more and more of the disposable wealth of a younger genera-
tion of consumers, and leaving less and less behind for bands that could not get, or did not want to get, signed to
an exploitative recording contract. Musicians who once appeared edgy or challenging were smoothed into mani-
cured products.

One reaction to this was the rise of alternative and independent recording artists and performers. Punk Rock was,
in its late 1970s incarnation, an expression of alienation from the pop music industrys emphasis on extravagance
in the studio and on the stage. Bands like DOA, Teenage Head, Viletones, Pointed Sticks, and the Subhumans
recorded very little but performed a lot, breathing second life into old downtown venues too small for rock gods.
Appreciated as much for their political, anti-authority stance as for their music, the Canadian punk movement
(and, to a lesser extent, New Wave) found audiences in the United States and Britain. World music influences
began to shape Canadian performers as well, as could be seen in Toronto especially. Jamaican and other West
Indian immigrants in the 1960s brought ska, rock steady, and reggae to Canada where it evolved its own sound.
Fresh immigration from a destabilizing Caribbean brought new artists but, by the 1980s, the Canadian variant was
distinctive for its less confrontational forms. Largely contained to the multicultural cities, this was and remains,
nevertheless, a vibrant field.

Figure 9.67 Canadian West Coast punk rockers,

DOA (led by Joey Shithead Keithley), enjoyed
international popularity. The DIY quality of their
performances and recordings is echoed in their
promotional posters.

While innovators in these areas were trying to recapture the spontaneity and DIY feel of earlier musical gener-
ations, the studio business model had its acolytes in Canada. Big rocknroll machines Bryan Adams, Prism,
Streetheart, Tom Cochrane, Headpins, Gowan, and Platinum Blond dominated the airwaves and the arenas in
558 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

the 1980s. These were bands that mostly echoed older rocknroll themes from the 1950s which included endlessly
cruising in cars, heterosexual adolescent love, and nostalgia. Nothing captures this better than Adams anachro-
nistic hit Summer of 69: born in 1959, Adams was probably not young and restless at the age of 10, nor is
it likely he bought a guitar at the five and dime. Few of these musicians had much to say about global politics,
although Prisms Armageddon conjures the possibility of a nuclear holocaust through which everyone just rocks
it out.

French-Canadian music evolved very differently in the Cold War years. Its roots were a combination of Qubecois
and Acadien fiddle/folk music along with the chansons of France, whose recordings were eagerly imported and
consumed. Agla (aka: Jocelyne Deslongchamps, 1933-1984) and Guylaine Guy (b. 1929) were two Qubecois
chanteuses who became very popular in mid-1950s Paris, reversing the flow of talent for a while. Michel Louvain
(b. 1937) was Quebecs foremost singer in the crooner tradition in the late 1950s. Other continental influences
in this period include the pop-rock form, y-y (somewhat akin to what is today called twee pop) taken up by
Nanette Workman (b. 1945) and the slightly more rocking styles of musicians like Louise Forestier (b. 1943) in
the late 1960s. Prog Rock became more popular, and earlier in French Canada than in English Canada, and jazz
remained more at home in Montreal than anywhere else in the country. Although one could point to two solitudes
in terms of popular and commercial music in these years, the influence of folk music remains a common (if dif-
ferently coloured) thread. For every Randy Bachman in these years, there seems to be, in English Canada at least,
one Bruce Cockburn; likewise, in Quebec, even pop-rockers like Forestier felt comfortable reviving music with
roots in the 19th if not the 18th century.

This is by no means a full survey of musical styles and innovations in the late 20th century, but it draws attention
to some important elements. Music matters in this period in part because it emerged as the dominant art form.
However grand the galleries or the symphony halls might have become in the 1960s and 1970s, nothing was quite
as likely as a daily encounter with pop music. AM stations multiplied, and FM took tentative steps in 1968 to
move away from easy listening and classical into album rock programming. More and more television airtime had
a pop music component. It became a means to express social change, even as it manifested change itself. Nowhere
was this more evident than in the transformation of youth culture in the 1960s.

Key Points

The postwar period would see the emergence of new musical styles that nevertheless drew on older
and even traditional forms.
Canadian pop music struggled for years in a commercial context that favoured both American and
British recording artists, large studios and distributors, and impresarios who featured big acts while
neglecting local talent.
The early strength in Canadian pop music came from the folk-blues-rock performers like Joni
Mitchell, Leonard Cohen, and Neil Young.
Government efforts to support Canadian culture extended to Cancon rules that were intended to ben-
efit homegrown musicians. In the short term, it reinforced a star system that favoured a few big acts,
but by the 1980s, there was a number of reasonably successful acts.
Alternative music broadly defined emerged as a reaction to and a kind of sub-culture of the
 9.15 COLD WAR THEMES 559

popular music industry, drawing on punk and immigrant cultures.

Popular music traditions in Quebec were, in almost every regard, distinctive in these years.

Attributions
Figure 9.64
Four Lads Greatest Hits by Peter Zimmerman is used under a CC-BY-2.0 license.

Figure 9.65
Diana by John Douglas Belshaw is used under a CC-BY-4.0 license.

Figure 9.66
Joni mitchell 1974 by Paul C Babin is in the public domain.

Figure 9.67
D.O.A. by kopper is used under a CC-BY-2.0 license.
9.16 The 1960s Counterculture

Figure 9.68 Sign of the times. An anti-hippy notice survives in a

Vancouver antique store.

There were international events that encouraged a questioning of the status quo, of which the Second Vatican
Council (Vatican II) beginning in 1962 was among the most prominent. Also, the apparent ratcheting up of tension
on the Cold War front gave people everywhere good reason to think that the current situation was untenable. The
American U-2 spy plane fiasco over Russia in 1960, the Bay of Pigs Invasion in April 1961, followed a few
months later by the erection of the Berlin Wall, and the near-catastrophe of the Cuban Missile Crisis of October
1962 all contributed to a sense of unease. The assassination of United States President John F. Kennedy on 22
November 1963 was similarly shocking and it gave a special posthumous force to his admonition to do service
through institutions like the Peace Corps.

Overwhelmingly, however, the single greatest factor causing social change was the numbers. By the mid-1960s
more than half of Canadas population of 20 million was under the age of 25. The baby boom started slowing in
the late 1950s, but it would take until the 1980s before it would finish growing up. Four decades of a population
juggernaut passing through childhood and adolescence into adulthood was bound to impact many aspects of Cana-
dian life.

The fact that other countries were experiencing the same phenomenon simply magnified the sense that this was all
part of an emerging global norm. Of course, the baby boomers were more likely to be found in countries that had
experienced prosperity in the 1920s, high unemployment in the 1930s, and total war from 1939 (or, in the case of
the United States, 1941) to 1945. Nations that retooled from command-led economies to demand-led consumer
economies were more like Canada than those that did not or (like Britain) were slow to do so. Canadian post-war
prosperity fed this demographic engine and created the conditions under which it would produce a critique of its
parents world.

The Kids Are Alright

Historian Christopher Dummitt has described how this generation began entering the workforce in large numbers

560
 9.16 THE 1960S COUNTERCULTURE 561

around 1960-63. The availability of good paying work and a shortage of labour meant that there was every incen-
tive for males in particular to leave school as early as possible typically at 16 and take a job. University
opportunities were increasing but still 90% of youth moved directly into the paid labour market. Within a matter
of years these young labourers were a significant presence within Canadian labour organizations and they were
in large part responsible for an astonishing 9.3% growth in membership between the start and end of 1965 alone.
These younger, new members, however, often had political agendas that were distinct from those of their elders.
They were, for one thing, less deferential toward authority, more likely to be advocates for workers control of the
workplace or industrial democracy, and inclined to question the career arc of working hard for one company for
years and settling into domestic normalcy. More young women wanted to work and to pursue careers, and more
1
young men experienced a sense of economic freedom rather than their parents fear of unemployment.

As for that 10% that went on to university, one-tenth of a rapidly growing pie strained the post-secondary system
across the country. Existing universities were expanded but the real growth occurred in the number and variety of
institutions. Between 1945 and 1959 only three new universities opened; between 1960 and 1969 another 13 were
added. The college sector grew as well, vastly increasing vocational training opportunities.

Canada is unique among the worlds leading economies and democracies, in that it does not have a national edu-
cation policy. That is because, of course, education resides in the provincial jurisdictions. While Ottawa might
use instruments to stimulate provincial action, the decision to launch new post-secondary institutions had to come
from the provincial governments. More than a dozen new universities might have translated into sectoral chaos,
but it did not. There is an unwritten, highly informal, and yet universally accepted principle between institutions
and provinces on what a Bachelors degree ought to look like, and there has been an informal understanding as
well that every universitys undergraduate degree meets standards that should get a student through the door of a
graduate, law, or medical school in another province, assuming their grades are sufficient. (This second consensus
is perhaps honoured more in principle than in the breech, and perhaps it was easier to do so 60 years ago when the
number of universities in Canada was much smaller and peers from one end of the country to the other knew one
another or at least knew their work.)

The expansion of Canada into the West brought with it models of education that had roots trailing back to the
St. Lawrence Valley and from there to New England, to Oxford and Cambridge, and even to Germany. The new
provinces might have experimented with different models but they all placed their bets on universities that would
disseminate established Euro-Canadian educational ideals of knowledge and learning. Consistency, rather than
innovation in this respect was more important. In this way, the universities of the West became instruments of
colonialism and also expressions of provincial power. This is perhaps most clearly seen in the history of the Uni-
versity of Saskatchewan, established as one of the foundational institutions of the young province, only two
2
years after the province itself came into being in 1905. This is to say that universities were not politically neutral
nor utterly objective institutions: they had a mandate. Their transformation in the 1950s, 60s, and 70s into mas-
sified operations witnessed challenges to many of these post-secondary sectoral assumptions.

1. Ian Milligan, Rebel Youth: 1960s Labour Unrest, Young Workers, and New Leftists in English Canada (Vancouver: University of British
Columbia Press, 2014), 4, 15.
2. As regards the expansion of existing universities in the post-war period, a good example can be drawn from the University of Saskatchewan
which, in 1950, had about 200 faculty members and in 1975 had roughly 1,000. Peter MacKinnon, University Leadership and Public Policy
in the Twenty-First Century: A Presidents Perspective (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2014), 21.
562 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 9.69 One of many new universities built to serve the baby
boom generation, Simon Fraser University opened to unrest and
student protests.

Campus Life
The growth of youth numbers in the workforce and on campus set the stage for what is sometimes called the coun-
terculture phenomenon. Several factors were involved.

American media played an important role in familiarizing Canadian households with dissent. United States news
broadcasts brought coverage of the often violent civil rights movement into Canadian living rooms. Adults and
youths far from Mississippi became familiar with the struggle of African-Americans to acquire a greater degree of
social and political equality in the 1950s and 60s. Likewise, the American war against Vietnam (which picked up
as the French imperialist forces retreated from Indo-China in the mid-1950s and lasted until 1975) produced news
of American atrocities and incompetence. These were echoed in images of growing domestic protests against the
war. Much of the activism behind both of these movements could be found on American university campuses.
American professors and students were making their way to expanding Canadian universities especially the
new ones and the traffic in ideas further bonded those campus environments together. The rise of Second Wave
Feminism in these years (see Section 7.10) provided yet another critique of the status quo, as did the emergence
of the American Indian Movement (AIM) (in which many Canadian Aboriginal men and women participated).

Socialist elements in these movements tended to align with what was called the New Left. Efforts to scotch pro-
communist feeling in North America in the 1950s had forced even social democratic parties like the Cooperative
Commonwealth Federation further to the right. Joined up with a fairly conservative trade union movement headed
by the Canadian Labour Congress in 1961, the emergent New Democratic Party attracted many young people on
the left but it fell short for many as well. Advocates of the New Left it was neither a party nor an organization,
more a set of shared beliefs directly challenged the anti-Soviet, red-baiting propensities of the Cold Warriors in
North America. On campus and on city streets, the protest leaders of this decade favoured civil disobedience over
the ballot box. Protest rallies, marches, sit-ins, and demonstrations or demos were the tactic of choice.

There opened in these years a gulf between the experiences of parents born before the Depression and their heirs,
born after WWII. This generation gap played out in many ways but it was evident at every turn. Arts and music
were one expression of this change. So was clothing (blue jeans became the uniform of a generation in these years
as suits and dresses were actively eschewed) and longer hair styles for men. Given that university was the exclu-
sive preserve of the countrys elite and most ambitious before WWII, the fact that a greater share of baby boomers
were able to attend the new institutions was viewed by some as a cross-generational reward for hard work and
evidence of social mobility. The fact that baby boomers turned some of those campuses into sites of protest and
conflict was a jarring turn of events. Simon Fraser University (SFU) opened in 1965 in the heart of NDP coun-
try: suburban Burnaby. By 1968 it achieved international notoriety for sit-ins and the occupation of administrative
offices. Most accounts of these developments cite the dismissal of teaching assistants and conflict within one or
 9.16 THE 1960S COUNTERCULTURE 563

two academic departments. What is often forgotten is the anti-colonialist element involved that effectively cri-
tiqued the nationalist historical narrative of Canada:

In the summer of 1968, members of the Students for a Democratic University, using their newly-acquired positions in
the Simon Fraser Student Society, passed a motion to change the name of the university to Louis Riel University. These
activists argued that rather than being a Loyalist, fur-trader and explorer, Simon Fraser was actually a member of the
vanguard of pirates, thieves, and carpet baggers which dispossessed and usurped the native Indians of Canada from their
3
rightful heritage.

The critique of establishment values was comprehensive. Working-class students typically the first in their
family to attend university or college were at the forefront of many of these struggles, some of which ended in
arrests. Simon Fraser University became a dependable source of headlines but comparable protests were occurring
on campuses across the country. Nationalist and conservative critics of these events pointed to the Americaniza-
tion of campuses and the influence of American leftists. This was itself a novel twist on the venerable Canadian
fear of a fifth column led by Moscow. The protests, however, were deeply rooted in decades-old traditions of free
speech protests and still older concerns for academic freedom. It was the fact that universities occupy this space
an arena for the free discussion of ideas that made them mostly impervious to censorship and, thus, attrac-
tive to a generation that wanted to take on the rules of normalcy, Cold War horrors, and what George Grant called
4
the crawl through university simply as a guarantee of the slow road to death in the suburbs.

Campus protests peaked in 1968, the same year as militance in Paris was cresting and the Prague Spring. It needs
to be said that many student populations in Canada were not radicalized and, on many campuses, student elections
soon saw moderates replace radicals. The impact of this brief moment in Canadian intellectual history, however,
was significant in that it drew into question hitherto unassailable institutions and politicized a generation of people
on- and off-campus.

Hippies And The Counterculture

The new wave of cultural dissent that arose in the 1960s was in many respects a resumption of earlier historic
trends. The total package of the counterculture offered an alternative to the bland homogeneity of middle-class
life, patriarchal family structures, self-discipline, unquestioning support for the United States, and the acquisition
of property. In fact, there were many alternative cultures, some of which were more visible than others.

Hippies rejected the conventions of traditional society. Men sported beards and grew their hair very long; both
men and women wore clothing from non-Western cultures, made a point of defying their parents, rejected what
were regarded as traditional social manners, and turned to music as an expression of their sense of self. Drug use,
especially of marijuana and psychedelic drugs like lysergic acid diethylamide (LSD) was common and symbolic
of a break with authority. Most hippies were also deeply attracted to the ideas of peace and freedom.

Some hippies dropped out of mainstream society altogether and expressed their disillusionment with the cultural
and spiritual limitations of the Western world. They joined communes, usually in rural areas, to share a desire to
live closer to nature and respect the earth, and share a dislike of modern life and a disdain for wealth and material

3. Robert Lexier, The Backdrop Against Which Everthing Happened: English-Canadian Student Movements and Off-Campus Movements for Change, His-
tory of Intellectual Culture, vol.7, no.1 (2007).
4. Quoted in James M. Pitsula, New World Dawning: The Sixties at Regina Campus (Regina: Canadian Plains Research Centre, University of
Regina, 2008): 299. See also, Paul W. Bennett, Campus Life in Canadas 1960s: Reflections on the Radical Campus in Recent Historical
Writing, Acadiensis, XLII, no.2 (2013).
 564 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

goods. Many communes grew their own organic food. Others abolished the concept of private property, and mem-
bers shared willingly with one another. Some sought to abolish traditional ideas regarding love and marriage; free
5
love was practiced openly, and there was some support for the emergent cause of gay rights.

Figure 9.70 An anti-Vietnam War protest march on Vancouvers

West Georgia Street in 1968.

Lines between movements were blurry. Many New Leftists were also hippies but not all hippies were consciously
supporters of the New Left. Nonetheless, a common denominator was their shared opposition to the war in Viet-
nam.

In Canada this played out as an increasingly vocal strain of anti-Americanism on the left, a movement that called
simultaneously for a more independent Canada. So, while in the United States hippies were challenging American
patriotism, in Canada Canadian hippies contributed ironically to a growing sense of Canadian nationalism.
Some 30,000 American males, many of them hippies, crossed the border in these years in the largest northbound
migration wave since the Loyalists arrived in the late 18th century. In this case, however, they were fleeing the
draft conscription to serve in the Vietnam War. White, middle-class Americans with some university educa-
tion were over-represented among the draft dodgers, so they proved to be an articulate and largely invisible group
in Canadas white, middle-class cities. Significant numbers including large numbers of women pursued the
goal of communal self-sufficiency on farms in the Kootenays and along the coast and islands of the Strait of Geor-
gia (aka: Salish Sea). Mark Vonnegut (b.1947), the son of the famous American anti-war author, Kurt Vonnegut,
6
wrote of his experiences on the coast in a hippie commune in The Eden Express (1975).

Hippiedom reached its highwater mark around 1970, after which its appeal diminished. Some of the political
energy went to the Yippie (Youth International Party) movement. The beginnings of the war on drugs also
played a role in the movements decline. The acid rock elements that were featured at the 1969 Woodstock
Festival in New York (attended by thousands of Canadians among the half million-strong crowd) included Jimi
Hendrix who spent much of his childhood in Vancouver. In 1970 Hendrix was one of several hippie/rock musi-
cians to die from a drug overdose, events that further compromised the hippie ideal. As the war in Vietnam wound
down, the movement lost another of its main rallying points. Economic uncertainty and rising unemployment fol-
lowing 1973 refocused many young people on finding a secure place in the mainstream. Inevitably, successive
cohorts of baby boomers would seek to express themselves in ways that were distinct from that of older (hippy)
siblings. The liberating impact of the hippies in terms of fashions, art, and sexual relations was doubtlessly the
movements greatest legacy.

5. Openstax, U.S. History: Identity Politics in a Fractured Society, [Link]

Fractur.
6. Historians have only recently turned their attention to these asylum seekers. See, for example, these memoir-based and scholarly accounts:
Douglas L. Hamilton and Darlene Olesko, Accidental Eden: Hippie Days on Lasqueti Island (Halfmoon Bay: Caitlin Press, 2014) and Kath-
leen Rodgers, Welcome to Resisterville: American Dissidents in British Columbia (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2014).
 9.16 THE 1960S COUNTERCULTURE 565

Key Points

The arrival of the massive baby boom generation in the workplace and on campuses served to chal-
lenge established norms of behaviour in the 1960s.
Increases in the size, number, and variety of post-secondary institutions was required by the rise of
the baby boom population and a relatively new demand for access by social classes and groups that
had not been much of a presence on campus before.
Events in the United States including the Civil Rights Movement and the war in Vietnam stim-
ulated the growth of protest movements there and these had an influence on Canadian youth as well.
Student protests were strongly influenced by the New Left and some campuses offered up a compre-
hensive critique of modern society and its institutions.
Elements of these protest movements contributed to the appearance of the hippy phenomenon and
the full-scale counterculture movement.
The arrival of American draft dodgers added around 30,000 young Americans to the population and
further contributed to a deepening generation gap.

Attributions
Figure 9.68
Hippies Please Use Back Door Antique Sign Robson Street Vancouver BC Canada by Adam Jones,
Ph.D. is used under CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.

Figure 9.69
Sfu 1967 by Soggybread is used under CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.

Figure 9.70
Anti Vietnam war demonstration. Vancouver, BC. 1968 by John Hill is used under CC-BY-SA-4.0 license.
 9.17 The Sexual Revolution

Figure 9.71 The Canadian-American actress, Norma Shearer,

won an Academy Award for her performance in The Divorcee
(1931).

Of the many challenges to established norms in the Cold War years, one of the more complex and lasting is the
sexual revolution. This was, again, a social change that occurred internationally not just in Canada nor just in
North America.

Origins of the Revolution

It seems both obvious and provocative to state that sex is at the heart of the Canadian project. Whether one looks
at the filles de roi of 18th- century New France, the bride ships of 1860s Vancouver Island, or the efforts to recruit
whole households to settle the West, the idea of the family as the core productive unit in Canada is a dominant
theme. So dominant, in fact, as to be largely unspoken. Historians have increasingly questioned the historic norms
of family and sexual relations because of what they reveal about the ideology of Canada and citizenship and
because of what they exclude.

The patriarchical structures of citizenship have been mentioned already. Men, particularly men who were under-
stood to be the head of household, were seen as the sole representative voice of their families. One study points
out the continuity between 19th- and 20th-century patriarchy, despite what mid-century modernists might claim:
Postwar Canadians could look askance at the backward Victorians and their patriarchal families even as they
1
continued to support a quite similar structure of family life. Married men had first call on citizenship in the
modern world. In industrial communities where housing was provided by the employer, first call went invariably
to married men and their families. A family sustained local shops more so than a single man; a family sustained
local churches and schools as well. And families produced labourers who would not need to be recruited from
elsewhere.

1. Christopher Dummitt, The Manly Modern: Masculinity in Postwar Canada (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2007), 9.

566
 9.17 THE SEXUAL REVOLUTION 567

Women were profoundly disadvantaged in this situation. Their entitlement to waged labour was vastly less pow-
erful than mens. Their bodies were considered engines of population growth and thus as good as the property of
the state. Women who defied social sensibilities (which advocated heterosexual marriage and reproduction) faced
considerable sanctions. In one particularly harrowing 1947 homicide case in Vancouver, a murdered woman
Viola Woolridge whom the court subsequently decided was, in life, a poor mother and an inadequate wife, was
effectively put on trial for her own death at the hands of her husband. She was found wanting as an example of
2
Canadian womanhood, and the charges against her husband/killer were dropped. It is not too much to say that
women were occasionally reminded that their defiance of what constituted normalcy could be repaid with their
lives.

Challenges to the patriarchal order were led in the 1960s by what became known as second wave feminism and,
later in the decade, the Womens Liberation Movement (described by Robert Rutherdale in Section 7.10). One ele-
ment of this movement was a reclaiming of womens bodies and biology in a way that inevitably addressed issues
of sexuality and sexual morality. Some feminists critiqued the institution of marriage itself as inherently repres-
sive and essentially about womens reproductive capacity. This was a position that could be taken because, at
mid-century, the question survived of whether sex served any purpose other than reproduction; womens sexual
activity, it was widely held, ought to be constrained to marriage where it served a rational purpose. Feminists in
this period and they came from a wide band of radicals, liberals, conservatives, and others proposed that
sanctions against pre-marital sex were obsolete. (Even this line of reasoning, however, often presumed the even-
tuality of marriage.)

Young feminists took this critique of normal into popular culture. The hippy movement advanced the case for free
love (that is, sexual relations outside of the institution of marriage and an end to marital monogamy). For men,
this could mean a variety of things; for women, it presented challenges as far as pregnancies outside of marriage
were concerned. Whatever advances feminists and counterculture spokespersons were able to make, society still
took a dim view of unmarried motherhood and illegitimacy. Finding the means to control fertility was, therefore,
a critical piece in the building of a sexual revolution.

Contraception
The significance of birth control changed through the 20th century. Before 1914, social sanctions against fertil-
ity controls were paired with fear of a falling fertility rate. Eugenicists tied this to race suicide, while imperial-
ists feared the ongoing fertility transition would weaken the nation when it came time to muster soldiers for war.
Although birth control and its advocacy remained punishable under the Criminal Code, statistical and other evi-
dence shows that middle class couples were clearly using some measures to reduce fertility even before the 1930s.
They were doing so, moreover, without much in the way of professional advice. The first family planning clinic in
Canada was established in 1932 in Hamilton under the direction of Dr. Elizabeth Bagshaw (1881-1982); it oper-
ated illegally until reforms allowed it fully into the light 1969. Morality and the law notwithstanding, unwanted
pregnancies were a profound economic issue in the Depression years; in wartime, illegitimacy was a greater con-
cern.

Part of the challenge arose from the lack of reliable techniques for reducing fertility, let alone preventing preg-

2. Diane Purvey, 'Woolridge Driven to Kill Wife: Lessons on How to Get Away with Murder, Vancouver Confidential, ed. John Belshaw
(Vancouver: Anvil Press, 2014): 205-14.
 568 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

nancy. Condoms, of course, would help, but their sale was illegal until the 1960s (although they were discretely
available through most barber shops). Besides, condoms were associated in the public mind more with prevent-
ing the transmission of venereal diseases than staving off pregnancies. A great deal of publicity and propaganda
accompanied campaigns to protect young men (not so much women) from sexually transmitted diseases, espe-
cially during and immediately after WWII. This issue perpetuated eugenicist sentiments with regard to race sui-
cide and its cure, muscular Christianity. Venereal diseases were principally blamed on promiscuous women or
female prostitutes (often understood by the police, the press, and the public to be one and the same) and seldom
3
on their clients. Sex outside of wedlock, for any purpose other than procreation was thus bound up in hazards, as
were condoms.

The context of discussions about birth control changed at mid-century. Fertility rates had recovered (thanks to
the baby boom) and illegitimacy was in retreat: consequently, opposition to contraception moderated. Moralists,
militarists, and eugenicists could no longer whip up hostility to the conversation about contraception as they had
earlier. Indeed, moral panics about teenagers (as surveyed in Sections 10.10. 10.11 and 10.12) created circum-
stances that favoured a reconsideration of contraception as a positive. Folk solutions were overshadowed by sci-
entific advances in technological barrier prophylactics like condoms and diaphragms, although these could still be
notoriously difficult to obtain. Rather suddenly, in 1960, there was a new option.

In that year, an American team produced the first state-approved oral contraceptive pill. The case for the
Pill advanced rapidly in part because it had the sanction of science behind it (even though that same science was
reeling at the same time from the thalidomide disaster). As historian Angus McLaren describes it,

[Physicians] drew their metaphors from the science of engineering. They appeared to be more comfortable given their
references to pelvic floors, follicle walls, cervical canals, storage and transport of ovum when regarding the
uterus as a construction site rather than as a human organ. Similarly, doctors who were still embarrassed to fiddle with a
messy cream or floppy rubber contraption were happy to distribute a pill, a product of scientific research, a preventive
4
medicine that was simply prescribed.

Because the Pill was so effective, simple, clean, easily packaged, distributed, and obtained (and, by the middle of
the decade, so widespread), it drew renewed but largely repositioned debate about the moral and health conse-
quences of premarital sex and promiscuity.

Never before had sexual activity been so abstracted from reproduction. For a couple using the Pill, intercourse
became purely an expression of love, or a means of physical pleasure, or both but it was no longer exclusively a
means of reproduction (not that it ever was). While this was true of previous contraceptives, their relatively high
failure rates and their less widespread use failed to emphasize this distinction as clearly as did the Pill. The spread
of oral contraceptive use thus led many religious figures and institutions to debate the proper role of sexuality
and its relationship to procreation. The Roman Catholic Church, for example, reiterated the established Catholic
5
teaching that artificial contraception distorts the nature and purpose of sex. These sanctions had particular res-
onance in Quebec, or they might have done so only a few years earlier. Despite the apparent authority of the
Catholic Church, Quebec womens fertility plateaued from 1947 to 1957, between 28 and 31 births per 1,000

3. Joan Sangster, Regulating Girls and Women: Sexuality, Family, and the Law in Ontario, 1920-1960 (Toronto: Oxford University Press,
2001), 85-130.
4. Angus McLaren, A History of Contraception From Antiquity to the Present Day (Oxford: Blackwell, 1992), 241-2.
5. Boundless. The Sexual Revolution and the Pill. Boundless U.S. History. Boundless, 21 Jul. 2015, accessed 17 Dec. 2015 from
[Link]
rights-movement-220/the-sexual-revolution-and-the-pill-1226-9275/
 9.17 THE SEXUAL REVOLUTION 569

women, and then halved in the next 15 years to 14.3 births. It continued to fall until 1986, when it rallied a little.
From the highest provincial fertility rate in Canada before the war (rates that were, as well, higher than those in
France, Britain, and the United States), the Quebec rate became the lowest from the mid-1960s to the millennium.
Clearly, this could not have been accomplished without resort to contraceptives or terminations. Resistance to
birth control did not, however, instantly evaporate: it wasnt until 1969 that aiding in birth control was removed
from the Criminal Code. Thereafter, the Planned Parenthood Federation of Canada became a more prominent
part of the public discussion about fertility limitation. The appearance of changing sexual behaviour beginning
in the early 1960s (if not earlier), then, reflected the arrival of the baby boomers into their years of sexual activ-
ity, diminished concern over falling fertility levels, and technological change. This was accompanied and com-
plemented by the advent of second wave feminism. In Quebec, the invitation to challenge assumptions that was
bound up in the Quiet Revolution also played a role. Social and demographic behaviours thus transformed in ways
that were, quite simply, revolutionary.

Termination
Cold War rhetoric positioned the family as the bedrock of the Western democracies; anything that undermined
the fundamental strengths of this social bond including obstructions to fertility was regarded dimly. And
yet evidence from Ontario and British Columbia suggests that it was precisely in these years that the rate and
number of abortion-related deaths was on the rise, an indicator that more abortions were taking place. Surgical
terminations abortions were illegal, so women sought out back-alley medical facilities and interventions
delivered by medical amateurs (including well-meaning women), or they turned to folk remedies involving toxic
substances. Between 1921 and 1946, it is reckoned that between 4,000 to 6,000 women died of bungled abor-
6
tions. This stands in evidence terrible as it is of the risks women were prepared to take in order to get a
termination.

Abortion remained a shadowy part of the birth control equation until a Montreal physician, Henry Morgentaler
(1923-2013), began in 1969 to challenge the existing laws by providing abortions from the nations first abortion
clinic. Prosecuted unsuccessfully under the Criminal Code (Quebec jurors refused to find him guilty), Mortgen-
taler became a target for the provincial state and spent 18 months in prison in 1973-1976, some of it in solitary
confinement. By the time he was freed, the provincial government had changed and the Parti Qubcois decided
that the law was unenforceable. For all intents and purposes, abortions were now legal, at least in Quebec. The
Criminal Code, however, was not amended to reflect the de facto changes until 1988. The fact that it took 20
years after the first change in abortion laws in 1968 to come up with provisions that actually allowed for and made
accessible safe abortions under any circumstances is an indication of how firmly some Canadians continued to
believe in the heterosexual and reproductive family as a foundational element of the culture.

The Post-Revolutionary Era

Fears of the sexual revolution leading to out-of-control fertility and illegitimacy proved unfounded. As one land-
mark study shows, teen pregnancies fell from 57,000 per year in 1974 to 38,000 in 1992, at a time when educa-
tional elements of birth control were advancing faster in Canada than south of the border. The authors add, The

6. Angus McLaren & Arlene Tigar McLaren, The Bedroom and the State: The Changing Practices and Politics of Contraception and Abortion
in Canada, 1880-1997, 2nd edition (Toronto: Oxford University Press, 1997), 49-51.
 570 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

fact that the Canadian teenage pregnancy rate was less than half that of the United States suggested that north of
7
the border birth control education had enjoyed some success.

Marriage, too, was undergoing changes in the 1960s and 1970s. Womens average age at first marriage actually
increased in the 1970s, which meant that first births were also postponed and subsequent births fewer in num-
ber. Co-habitation out of wedlock increased in the 1960s and continued to do so into the 21st century. In Quiet
Revolution Quebec, the backlash against clergy control of social and moral life produced a generation that opted
for civil marriage ceremonies rather than church services, or chose a common-law arrangement. In those cases,
co-habitation was as much an anticlerical political statement as it was a facet of the sexual revolution. These
actions did not have the same meaning in English-Protestant Canada, but anti-establishment attitudes and an ethos
of anti-conventionality certainly played a role. This could be seen as well in the shortened life-expectancy of mar-
riages.

Til Death Do We Part

Escaping unhappy marriages was one area where both women and men were limited by state and church authori-
ties that placed a high value on heterosexual marriage.

Divorce courts first existed in British Columbia, New Brunswick, and Nova Scotia, spreading to Ontario, Alberta,
8
and Saskatchewan before 1939. The involvement of Parliament was otherwise necessary and the only accepted
cause for divorce was adultery: physical abuse and desertion, to take only two other possible reasons to end a mar-
riage, were not sufficient. Despite these constraints, the divorce rate climbed steadily from the 1930s on, as did the
rate per hundred thousand population. In 1933, the rate was 8.8, rising to 21.4 in 1941, 42.3 at the end of the war,
and peaking (for a generation) at 65.6 in 1947. The number continued to rise, but not as fast as the population.
Because divorce was associated for years in the public mind with working women, the battle against liberalized
divorce laws became effectively synonymous with limiting female participation in the workforce. Laws ostensi-
bly about marriage were thus used to regulate the supply or oversupply of labour.

Divorce law in Canada prior to 1968 could be more accurately described as anti-divorce law because it set up
barriers to ending marriages (see Section 10.9). Under the more liberal Divorce Act (1968), the causes or require-
ments for a successful divorce case expanded from adultery to mental or physical abuse, desertion, and imprison-
ment of one spouse. The effect of these changes was immediate and dramatic: in 1968 there were 54.8 divorces
per 100,000 population; in 1969 there were 124. The rate continued to rise, passing 200 around 1974-1975, and
levelling off in the high-200s per 100,000 population in the mid-1980s. Further reforms to the Divorce Act were
introduced in 1985 and the rate nearly doubled, peaking at 355 in 1987. Thereafter, however, the rate began to
9
fall, heading to a rate once again below 200 per 100,000 population in the early 21st century. While the sexual
revolution was a factor in these changes, so too was the declining power of religious sanctions against divorce and
the increased availability of paid employment for women (which lends to a greater degree of independent security
albeit in a wage environment that still favours men). Social demographers have also identified the rising life
expectancies of Canadians as a factor: marriage unto death for a 25-year-old is a much greater commitment when

7. Angus McLaren & Arlene Tigar McLaren, The Bedroom and the State: The Changing Practices and Politics of Contraception and Abortion
in Canada, 1880-1997, 2nd edition (Toronto: Oxford University Press, 1997), 139.
8. Roderick Phillips, Untying the Knot: A Short History of Divorce (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991), 195-6.
9. Lance W. Roberts, Rodney A. Clifton, Barry Ferguson, Karen Kampen, Simon Langlois, Recent Social Trends in Canada, 1960-2000 (Mon-
treal & Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 2005), 126-7.
 9.17 THE SEXUAL REVOLUTION 571

the average life expectancy has leapt from 64.6 (in 1941) to 80 years (in 2001) and the probability arises of being
10
with the same partner for 55 years rather than 40.

But the focus on divorce rates belies other, increasingly important trends. Rising common-law unions or cohab-
itation as a share of marriages means that there are fewer marriages per se that can end in divorce proper. In
short, theres a difference it what we are attempting to measure. And some of this behaviour is driven by the sheer
weight of the baby boom as it ages. There was a bubble in marriages in the decade after 1963 and it is echoed, 10
years later, in the rate of divorces. That is to say, baby boomers born in or shortly after 1941 were entering their
marriageable years around 1963; they increased the incidence of marriages and, 10 years or so later, were getting
divorced. Once that wave had passed, the marriage rates declined and a decade later the divorce rates did
the same.

Key Points

Laws and attitudes toward the regulation and management of fertility and the extent of the states
control over a womans body changed throughout the 20th century, with significant new features
arriving in the 1960s.
The sexual revolution was made possible by a combination of changes in attitudes toward the family
unit, pre-marital or extra-marital sex, and birth control methods.
The Pill made it possible for individuals and society to disentangle heterosexual intercourse for plea-
sure from sex for reproduction.
Following on the fertility explosion of the baby boom, fertility rates across Canada and especially
in Quebec fell dramatically during the Cold War.
The heterosexual family unit was regarded as a fundamental piece of the Western worlds strategy in
the Cold War, which meant that challenges to that normative view might be regarded as dangerous.
Reforms came in the late 1960s, when counselling birth control and abortion was decriminalized and
divorce liberalized.

Attributions
Figure 9.71
Portrait of Norma Shearer by George Hurrell 1932 by he oincidental andy is in the public domain.

10. Ibid., 79, Table 3.

9.18 Summary

Drawing a line at the end of the Cold War era is not without challenges. Beginning in the 1980s, there were signif-
icant shifts in the political environment in Soviet Russia. Hardliners were on the way out. The USSRs president,
Mikhail Gorbachev (b. 1931), faced economic stagnation, increasing military expenditures in the arms race and an
unwinnable war in Afghanistan, and heightening international tensions; his response was to propose a significant
reduction in nuclear weapons on both sides. His twin policies of glasnost (openness) and perestroika (restructur-
ing) offered an olive branch to the West. United States president Ronald Reagan was able to obtain American
concessions that led to a rapid de-escalation of global sabre rattling. Within two years, border defenses between
the West and the Soviet Bloc were coming down. The most momentous of these events was the demolition of the
Berlin Wall, which began in November 1989. Liberal democratic regimes with free market sensibilities began to
appear across Eastern Europe. The last days of Soviet power were coming fast. Civil wars began to break out in
the south, and breakaway movements appeared in the Baltic States. A failed coup detatattempt broke the back of
the regime, and the USSRs constituent republics fell away. The Cold War was, for all intents and purposes, over.

For nearly half a century, the Cold War had given shape to Canadian politics and society. Economic growth, social
satisfaction, and social mobility were seen as the surest formula to inoculate against communist movements at
home; suburbanization and consumerism were instruments in the new demand-led economy; investing resources
to nuclear-age defenses would protect Canada from trans-Arctic assaults from the Warsaw Pact; positioning the
country as a middle power that supported UN efforts to de-escalate international tensions was meant to protect
Canada from a US/USSR nuclear holocaust. Reactions against these strategies included second wave feminisms
critique of patriarchal normalcy and a counterculture attack on the arms race and late 20th-century imperialism.
Nationally, politicians struggled in their relationship with the federal status quo and with the United States. It is no
coincidence that the two greatest legacies of the Mulroney years include an attempted constitutional rapproche-
ment and the Free Trade Agreement with Washington.

Holding the country together was a continuing theme from the early 1960s on. That is, it was a priority for fed-
eralists. For those in Quebec who had concluded that repairing federalism was either impossible or simply not
desirable, the drawn-out dialogue on patriation was simply a distraction. Finding a voice for these sentiments
took some into the more radical, guerrilla-style tactics of the RIN and the FLQ, while others pursued change
through democratic means, mainly through the Parti Qubcois. The emergence of these separatist and sovereign-
tist streams in the 1960s exposed the tentativeness of Canada as a project and the unavoidable necessity of work-
ing on that relationship continuously.

The Canada that emerged after 1945 was in a constant state of change and transformation. Nowhere was this more

572
 9.18 SUMMARY 573

evident than in Quebec, but in every province the increased force of secularism, state activism, consumerism, and
youth culture pointed at one shared phenomenon: modernity.

Key Terms

academic freedom: The privilege and responsibility on the part of scholars to conduct enquiry and com-
municate their findings free of sanction by external authorities.
Agent Orange: A herbicidal defoliant, used by the United States Army to destroy jungle cover in the
Vietnam War.
Alaska Highway: A highway built during WWII to facilitate the movement of troops and materiel from
the United States to its northern territory (not yet a state), Alaska. It was constructed between Dawson
Creek, BC, and Delta Junction, Alaska, and completed in 1942. It served to open the Yukon to greater
traffic and activity.
American Indian Movement (AIM): Founded in 1968, an advocacy group established to counter the
United States governments Indian Termination policies of the 1950s and 1960s. Inspired by the civil
rights movement, it was influential among Canadian First Nations activists.
apartheid: A political and social system predicated on racial discrimination and/or segregation; associ-
ated with the Republic of South Africa from 1948 to 1994.
asymmetrical federalism: A federation in which one or more constituent parts enjoys more autonomy
and/or authority than one or more of the other constituent parts. In the case of the Meech Lake Accord,
it was suggested that recognition of Quebec, as a distinct society would create an asymmetry in confed-
eration.
Avro Arrow: An interceptor jet aircraft designed and built by A.V. Roe (Avro) Canada in the 1950s,
capable of Mach 1.98. Production of the Arrow was stopped in what remains, in the mind of many Cana-
dians, a controversial political decision.
Bay Street: In Toronto, the location of Canadas leading financial offices, banks, and corporations, as
well as the Toronto Stock Exchange.
bedroom communities: Suburbs to which commuters return at the end of the day to do little other than
sleep before commuting out to jobs elsewhere; applies especially to those suburbs that are largely free
of industry and other sources of employment.
big band: A musical group involving as many as two dozen players; associated with jazz and swing
music from the interwar and early post-WWII years.
Bill 101: The Charter of the French Language, passed into law in 1977, which advanced the provisions
of the Official Language Act (Bill 22) of 1974, and which made French Quebecs official language. Bill
101 established the primacy of French in day-to-day life.
Bill 178: One of several amendments to the Charter of the French Language (see Bill 101); introduced
and proclaimed in December 1988 in response to a Supreme Court ruling that would end the unilingual
French signage provisions of the Charter. It is significant for its reference to the notwithstanding
clause of the federal Charter of Rights.
birth control: Any method or practice aimed at reducing fertility or preventing the complete gestation
of an infant; may include abstinence, the use of chemicals/drugs, termination, and prophylactics.
574 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Blacklist: A list of people suspected of having Communist sympathies who were denied work as a
result.
British Invasion: A surge of popularity enjoyed in North America by British musicians, artists, writers,
and film makers in the 1960s.
Canada Act (1982): Federal legislation that enabled the patriation of the Canadian constitution and the
possibility of its amendment in Canada, rather than in Britain.
Canada Pension Plan (CCP): Introduced by the federal government in 1965; the first publicly funded
pension plan in Canada; transfers earnings from working people to retired citizens.
Canada Student Loans: Replaced the Dominion-Provincial Student Loan Program (1939-1964); guar-
anteed the banks risk in extending loans to post-secondary students under the auspices of the program.
Canadian Caper: The rescue of six American diplomats during the Iranian Revolution of 1979 to 1980.
Canadian content (CanCon) rules: Under the authority of the Canadian Radio-Television and
Telecommunications Commission (CRTC), CanCon regulations were established to ensure a quota of
Canadian creative product in various media, particularly in television and radio.
Canadian Radio-Television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC): An independent gov-
ernment agency established in 1968 to regulate and supervise all elements of the broadcasting systems.
Carruthers Commission: Established in 1963 and reported out in 1966; recommended a devolution of
authority from Ottawa to the North-West Territories; headquartered at Yellowknife.
CGEPs: Publicly funded pre-university colleges in Quebec.
Centennial: A 100th anniversary; in Canada, is used as shorthand to refer to the 1967 celebration of
100 years of Confederation.
Central Business District: The concentration of commercial, business, and finance enterprises gener-
ally in the centre or downtown of most cities. Some cities, like Toronto, have several such hubs.
Central Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC): Created under the National Housing Act,
1944; enabled low income families (including demobilized servicemen and women) to obtain low cost
mortgages; created social housing; funded construction of new rental housing; and continues to function
in 2016.
Charter of Rights and Freedoms: Also known simply as the Charter; incorporated by the British gov-
ernment in the Canada Act, 1982; comprises the first part of the Constitution Act, 1982.
Civil Rights Movement: In the United States, beginning in the mid-1950s, this was a movement to
secure the rights promised in court decisions. Widespread protest, frequent violence, and growing sup-
port throughout the USA much of which was televised influenced Canadians who sought to
address inequities in their own society.
Cold War: The prolonged period of tension between the United States and the Soviet Union, based on
ideological conflicts and competition for military, economic, social, and technological superiority and
marked by surveillance and espionage, political assassinations, an arms race, attempts to secure alliances
with developing nations, and proxy wars.
containment: The American policy that sought to limit the expansion of Communism abroad.
crude birth rate: The number of births occurring in a community or nation per 1,000 population.
declericalization: A movement to replace church authority with state authority in the running of schools
and other institutions.
 9.18 SUMMARY 575

demonstrations (or demos): Protest events; includes marches, sit-ins, and occupation of offices, as well
as other forms.
dtente: The relaxation of tensions and improvement of relations between the West and the East in the
Cold War during the 1970s.
devolution: This is when a senior level of government hands some of its authority to a lower level or
ostensibly lower level of administration. In Canada in the 1960s, authority over the North-West Territo-
ries devolved to the new administration in Yellowknife, NWT.
Distant Early Warning (DEW) Line: The northernmost of three Cold War radar systems aligned from
west to east to identify incoming Soviet missiles in the event of an attack.
distinct society: A term devised during the Quiet Revolution to describe Quebec vis--vis the rest of
Canada; a distinct society clause was created that would recognize and enshrine that difference. In the
Charlottetown Accord, this was spelled out as recognition of a French speaking majority, a unique cul-
ture and a unique civil law tradition.
domino theory: The theory that if Communism made inroads in one nation, surrounding nations would
also succumb one by one, like a chain of dominos toppling one another.
draft dodgers: Principally refers to American men who avoided mandatory, selective service in the
Vietnam War by fleeing to Canada in the 1960s and 1970s.
Eastern Bloc: The alliance of pro-Soviet (or USSR-dominated) countries in Eastern Europe in the post-
WWII era, consisting of Poland, East Germany, Czecho-Slovakia, Hungary, Romania, Bulgaria, and,
more loosely, Albania; Yugoslavia, another communist-dominated country, regularly declared itself sep-
arate from the Eastern Bloc; formalized in the mutual security agreement, the Warsaw Pact, in 1955.
establishment: An elite, colloquially in the 1960s; the conventional social and economic order.
Expo 67: A Worlds Fair held in Montreal in 1967; part of the Centennial celebrations.
fifth column: A population within a community that supports the efforts of an external force to topple
that community or nation; examples include Cold War fears of Canadian communists who were loyal to
Moscow rather than Ottawa.
Flag Debate: Arising out of PM Lester Pearsons decision to replace the Red Ensign in the early 1960s.
free love: Sexual relations outside of the institution of marriage; critical of the idea of marital
monogamy.
free speech: A movement that begins in earnest in the early 20th century, calling for the elimination of
laws barring public discussion of any number of topics; some subjects regarded as seditious includ-
ing calls for violent overthrow of the regime have been subject to intermittent bans.
Fulton-Favreau Formula: A formula for amending the British North America Act (1867) developed in
the 1960s; rejected by Quebec in 1965; provided the framework for subsequent discussions in 1982.
Geneva Convention: 1864, 1906, 1929, 1949; a succession of international agreements on the treatment
of prisoners of war (POWs) and civilians.
Gouzenko Affair: Post-WWII espionage case involving a clerk at the Soviet embassy in Ottawa who
disclosed the existence of a spy ring in Canada.
Grande Noirceur: In Quebec, the period from 1944 to 1959 in which policies were introduced under
the Union Nationale government of Maurice Duplessis.
576 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

hippies: A youth movement originating in the 1960s that was anti-war (specifically, opposed to the war
in Vietnam), critical of social conventions, and associated with experimentation with psychedelic drugs.
housewive: A married woman whose principle (unpaid) occupation is the maintaining of her household,
including preparing food, cleaning clothes, providing pre-school education, and cleaning house.
illegitimate: In legal and demographic terms, a child born to unmarried parents (or out of wedlock).
intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBMs): Cold War-era surface-to-air missiles with no less than a
5,000 km range; typically nuclear-tipped.
Iron Curtain: A term coined by British Prime Minister Winston Churchill to refer to portions of Eastern
Europe that the Soviet Union had incorporated into its sphere of influence and that no longer were free
to manage their own affairs.
Klondike: The locus of the 1890s gold rush in the Yukon Territory, along the Klondike River val-
ley; used to describe the gold rush as a whole.
Korean War: A war that began in 1950 and ended inconclusively in Armistice in 1953; this was
Canadas first Cold War era military engagement, and it involved significant casualties.
Matres chez nous (Masters of our own house): The slogan used by Jean Lesages Liberals in Quebec
in the 1960 election, ushering in the Quiet Revolution.
marketing boards: An agricultural producers marketing tool; often established by the producers them-
selves or by government, which acts as a buyer of output and then a marketer. Constitutes a kind of
monopoly in that producers cannot sell their goods through any other means. See also wheat pools.
Meech Lake Accord: 1987; an agreement reached between all the provincial premiers and the Prime
Minister that provided for a constitutional amending formula, a distinct society clause for Quebec,
senate and Supreme Court reforms, and a devolution of some immigration issues to the provincial level.
Despite a promising start, the Accord failed to achieve final approval.
Metro: The federated Municipality of Metropolitan Toronto.
middle power: The idea that Canada might occupy a position between great power states like Britain
and the United States and, after the World War II, at a level between the superpowers (the US and
the USSR), the second tier of military and economic powers (e.g.: Britain and France), and other
nations; tied to Lester Pearsons vision of peacekeeping and Canada as a referee or fair broker.
mutually assured destruction (MAD): The Cold War belief that the sheer number of thermonuclear
devices and delivery systems in the hands of the Soviet Union and the United States meant that neither
side would survive an assault initiated by the other. By assuring their mutual destruction, they would be
deterred from initiating a nuclear war.
nationalization: The imposition of state ownership over a corporation or sector; examples include the
provincial nationalization of hydroelectricity providers (e.g.: Ontario Hydro, Hydro-Qubec , and BC
Hydro), and the water transport monopoly in British Columbia (BC Ferries).
Neverendum: The series of referendums dealing with Quebec separatism (or sovereignty-association)
and proposed changes to the constitution, beginning in 1980.
New Left: Associated with campus radicalism in the 1960s and the writings of German philosopher
Herbert Marcuse; less interested in the class struggle and labour power than with social justice.
North American Aerospace Defense Command (NORAD): Arising from a pact signed with the
United States in 1957; provides detection and defence against Soviet missile and other airborne attacks
on North America.
 9.18 SUMMARY 577

notwithstanding clause: Section 33 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms (1982); allows
any provincial, federal, or territorial government to override some select rights in the Charter for a fixed
period of time.
Nunavut Land Claims Agreement: 1993; set the stage for the Nunavut Act, 1999, which created the
new territory of Nunavut; the first major land claims agreement negotiated by the federal government
since Treaty 11 (1920 to 1921).
October Crisis: This was a combination of events in October 1970 including the kidnapping of James
Cross and Pierre Laporte, attempts to ransom the two men, the execution of Cross by his abductors, and
the use of the War Measures Act for the first time in peacetime.
paparazzi: Photo-journalists who principally target celebrities and public figures and whose technique
is sometimes intrusive.
patriation: The transfer to Canada from Britain of the British North America Act (an Act of the British
Parliament), thus enabling its amendment in Canada.
peacekeeping: Under the United Nations in the Cold War and post-Cold War era, the use of military and
other military personnel in non-combatant roles to maintain peace between adversaries so as to enable
the peace-making process.
(the) Pill: Refers to the first successful oral contraceptive; approved for public use in 1960.
Planned Parenthood Federation of Canada: Established in 1964, the Federation was the descendant
of a long line of organizations advocating education and support around birth control.
pop music: A music sub-genre within the larger rock and roll (rocknroll) genre; adheres to obvious
structural qualities, tends to be melodic, and aims at a younger audience.
Prague Spring: 1968, a brief period of liberalization of government policies and democratic rights in
Czechoslovakia; countered by the invasion of Warsaw Pact troops under the command of the Soviet
Union.
Prime Ministers Office (PMO): Also the Office of the Prime Minister or the PMO; the centre of polit-
ical decision making in the Parliamentary system, consisting of the Prime Minister and her/his chief
political advisors; in Ottawa, located in the Langevin Block on Parliament Hill.
proxy wars: Cold war era conflicts conducted by third party countries in which the United States and
the Soviet Union had a stake, rather than a direct conflict between the two superpowers.
punk rock: A variant of rocknroll that appeared for the first time in the late 1970s; marked by an anti-
establishment, anti-authority stance.
Quiet Revolution (Revolution tranquille): A period of rapid and consequential change in the character
of Quebec politics and society beginning in the late 1950s.
Red Tory: A Canadian Progressive Conservative who takes an essentially 19th century conservative
position on the social obligations of the upper classes; a position sometimes described as noblesse
oblige.
relocation programs: A federal government initiative in the mid-20th century to move Aboriginal peo-
ples in the North to locations where they would serve as a sign of Canadian sovereignty and/or where
services (education, healthcare, administration, and the church) might be more effectively centralized; a
program to which Inuit in particular were subjected, their lives disrupted, and their economies severed.
Rest Of Canada (ROC): A term used to describe all Canada apart from Quebec; has the advantage of
avoiding the idea of dualism (as in English vs. French Canada).
578 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

rock and roll (rocknroll): Also rocknroll and rock & roll; a musical style originating in the 1950s
characterized at first by a synthesis of blues, jazz, country, western, and boogie-woogie; became in the
1960s and later an umbrella term for many styles that incorporated any of these elements, including a
strong youth component; regarded at mid-century as rebellious in its presentation and content.
Royal Commission on Bilingualism and Biculturalism: Created in 1963 and reported out in 1969; co-
chaired by A. Davidson Dunstan and Andr Laurendeau (who was succeeded at his death by Jean-Louis
Gagnon); identified underrepresentation of Franco-Canadians in many areas of public life, second-rate
services in French in national and relevant provincial systems, and poor opportunities for Francophones
in post-secondary institutions outside of Quebec; recommended the establishment of a Commissioner of
Official Languages.
rural depopulation: Movement of people generally younger people off the land and into the
cities; associated with urbanization and also with the collapse of village and town economies.
Second Vatican Council (Vatican II): Convened by Pope John XXIII in 1959; ended 90 years of papal
infallibility by opening dialogue regarding doctrine and the relationship between the Catholic Church
and the modern world; upset many long-standing convictions about unchanging features of Catholic
life; in Canada, contributed to the sense of social, spiritual, and secular fluidity that was bound up in the
Quiet Revolution.
sexual revolution: A complex of social changes associated with the 1960s; loosening of moral codes
as regards premarital sex, illegitimacy, divorce and remarriage, pornography, and sex for pleasure (as
opposed to procreation).
sleeper agents: Espionage agents who are deeply embedded in the host community and dormant, await-
ing activation.
social mobility: The movement of individuals, households, or communities through social hierarchies;
generally associated with upward mobility but downward is also a possibility.
space race: Competition between the United States and the Soviet Union to establish a dominant com-
mercial, scientific, and military presence in near space; initiated with the launch of the Soviet satellite,
Sputnik I in 1957; marked by American determination to reach the moon first.
Space Shuttle: A low orbit space craft developed by NASA in the 1970s and launched first in 1981;
includes reusable sections and the craft is capable of reentry and a controlled surface landing on
return. Nine Canadians have flown in Space Shuttle missions.
Sputnik: The first artificial satellite, launched by the Soviet Union on 4 October 1957; credited with
starting the space race between the USSR and the United States.
suburban, suburban sprawl: The low density housing districts beyond the city limits; the expansion
of cities beyond their boundaries into bordering municipalities, creating low density and car-dependent
districts with few amenities other than housing.
Suez crisis: The 1956 invasion of Egypt by Israel, followed by France and Britain with the objective of
seizing the Suez Canal. The failure of England and France to inform their former Allies especially the
United States of their plans led to a rift between Britain and the USA in particular. Canadas response,
led by Lester Pearson, was to propose a large multi-national peacekeeping force in the region.
Thalidomide: A drug prescribed to pregnant women for morning sickness; available in Canada from
1959 to 1962; resulted in catastrophic side effects, including severe disfigurement and defects in more
than 100 infants in Canada alone.
Three Wise Men: Les trois colombes, a term used mainly by commentators to describe the trio of Jean
 9.18 SUMMARY 579

Marchand, Gerard Pelletier, and Pierre Trudeau when they were recruited to the federal Liberal Party in
the 1960s.
Trudeaumania: Term used principally by journalists to describe public and media fascination with
Pierre Trudeau in the course of the 1968 Liberal leadership convention and then the general elec-
tion; alludes to the phenomenon of Beatlemania, associated with the British Invasion.
two founding nations: The narrative of Canadian history that privileges the idea of the French and
British as co-equal founders of Canada; ignores roles played by Aboriginal nations and implicitly
reduces the importance of Canadians drawn from other ethnicities and countries; is at the heart of dual-
ism.
United Nations (UN): An international body established in 1942; originally was the rough equivalent
of the Allied Nations in the Second World War; expanded to a post-war role in 1945 as an intergov-
ernmental assembly and series of agencies tasked with reducing international tensions and addressing
international social and economic crises.
Universal Health Care: Provision of health insurance coverage to all members of society; pioneered
in German in the 1880s; similar programs appeared first in the British Commonwealth in New Zealand
(1939); in Canada, introduced first in Saskatchewan in 1962 and nationally in stages from 1966-72.
Veterans Charter: Introduced in 1944; provided funds to enable the transition to civilian life of Cana-
dian troops; included free university education, payment for time served, life insurance, and money for
civilian clothes. The Charter also guaranteed that ex-servicemen and women could reclaim their former
jobs, which had the effect of displacing women who had worked in industry during wartime.
Victoria Charter (1971): An agreement to patriate the British North America Act, which included
an amending formula, new civil, personal, and language rights, and provisions for regional equaliza-
tion; achieved agreement from nine provinces and narrowly failed to secure Quebecs approval from
Premier Robert Bourassa.
wage and price controls: Introduced as part of the Anti-Inflation Act, 1975 as a response to an inflation
rate approaching 11%; marked the beginning of a move away from the post-war settlement in that it
established new restrictions on organized labour. The controls and the Anti-Inflation Board were dis-
mantled in 1978.
white flight: Colloquial term for the migration of middle and working class European-Canadians from
declining and multi-ethnic city centres for the suburbs; associated earlier in the United States with racial
tensions in cities and more homogeneously Euro-American suburbs.
witch hunts: Colloquial term used to describe security campaigns conducted in capitalist democracies
during the Cold War which targeted, mainly, communists but also homosexuals and any other group
regarded as potentially seditious.
world music: An umbrella term used to describe mostly non-European, non-North American styles of
music, including indigenous and hybridized forms. The term is problematic in that it includes essentially
everything while, at the same time, implicitly otherizing anything that is not North American main-
stream.
Yippie (Youth International Party): Countercultural youth movement originating in the United States
in 1967; combined anarchist views with environmentalist perspectives.
580 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Short Answer Exercises

1. Why did Newfondland join Confederation in 1949?

2. What changes took place in the North in the 20th century? How were the lives of Northerners
affected?
3. What were the causes and principal features of the Cold War?
4. In what ways did the Cold War change Canadian society and politics?
5. What trends and institutions were challenged by the Quiet Revolution in Quebec?
6. How did Canadas relationship with the United States change between 1945 and 1990?
7. Why were the Liberals far more successful than the Progressive Conservatives in holding onto
power federally?
8. In what ways did Canada change technologically in the Cold War years?
9. What were the sources of separatism in 1960s and 1970s Quebec?
10. Why was the War Measures Act invoked in 1970?
11. What were the objectives of efforts to patriate the constitution?
12. Why were referenda the route to failure for the Parti Qubecois and for constitutional reformers?
13. In what ways do the 1980s indicate an end to the Postwar Settlement and, thus, a break with the
post-WWII order?
14. What were the key social changes of the Cold War era?
15. In an increasingly urbanized and suburbanized Canada, how was rural life changing?
16. How did youth culture emerge in the post-war era and how did it influence mainstream culture?
17. What changes led to and enabled the sexual revolution?

Suggested Readings
Carr, Graham. No Political Significance of Any Kind: Glenn Goulds Tour of the Soviet Union and the Culture
of the Cold War, Canadian Historical Review, 95, Number 1 (March 2014): 1-29.

Churchill, David S. Draft Resisters, Left Nationalism, and the Politics of Anti-Imperialism, Canadian Histori-
cal Review, 93, Number 2 (June 2012): 227-60.

Martel, Marcel. They smell bad, have diseases, and are lazy: RCMP Officers Reporting on Hippies in the Late
Sixties, Canadian Historical Review, 90, Number 2 (June 2009): 215-45.

Onusko, James. Childhood in Calgarys Postwar Suburbs: Kids, Bullets, and Boom, 1959-1965, Urban History
Review/Revue dhistoire urbaine, 43, number 2 (Spring 2015): 26-37.

Stettner, Shannon. We Are Forced to Declare War: Linkages between the 1970 Abortion Caravan and Womens
 9.18 SUMMARY 581

Anti-Vietnam War Activism, Histoire sociale/Social history, 46, Number 92 (Novembre/November 2013):
423-41.

Stevens, Peter A. Roughing it in Comfort: Family Cottaging and Consumer Culture in Postwar Ontario, Cana-
dian Historical Review, 94, Number 2 (June 2013): 234-62.

Stevenson, Michael D. Tossing a Match into Dry Hay: Nuclear Weapons and the Crisis in U.S. Canadian
Relations, 1962-1963, Journal of Cold War Studies, 16, Issue 4 (Fall 2014): 5-34.
 PART 11

Chapter 10. This is the Modern World

582
10.1 Introduction

Figure 10.1 The 20th century produced a

greater visual record than any earlier era.
From flash powder exploding in studios
(such as the one shown above) to
miniaturized digital cameras, from silent
motion pictures to talkies to satellite
photography, photographic technology has
made it possible for us to have an occasional
and unguarded glimpse of people in the past.

Modernity is the term given to a constellation of behaviours, values, and beliefs associated with the industrial,
urban era. This term is associated with challenges to traditional values and ways of looking at the world and is
often used in connection with 20th-century artworks, literature, and architecture. In some respects, the term is
a shorthand for the 19th-century break with traditional oligarchy and feudal authority; the rise of nation-states
and democratic society (with its emphasis on the rights of the individual); changes in the life-course (including
the emergence of childhood as a period of dependence, predominance of nuclear rather than extended families,
later first marriages, and falling fertility rates); and enthusiasm for public spectacle (such as vaudeville, movies,
spectator sports, and even religious revivals). Modernity was also stamped upon gender roles and ideals of both
womanhood and manhood. Science, technology, innovation, and professionalization are other facets of modernity,
as is the widespread belief in progress and, implicitly optimism.

This chapter explores several themes and aspects of modernity that are now so interwoven with the fabric of life
in Canada as to be almost invisible. At one time, however, they were revolutionary, or nearly so.

Learning Objectives

Provide working definitions of modernity and modernism.

583
584 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Identify the forces behind modernization, its constraints, and its opponents.
Describe the connections between modernism, secularism, and organized religion.
Assess the impact of modern values on gender roles and family households.
Account for changes in the experience of childhood and adolescence.
Outline developments in the arts, media, sports, and popular culture.

Attributions
Figure 10.1
Studio portrait of Noel Robinson and Bill Reed in military uniforms by Philip T. Timms is in the public domain.
This image is available from City of Vancouver Archives under the reference number CVA 677-423.
 10.2 Defining Modernism

Figure 10.2 Bicycling became enormously popular in the late

19th century, particularly among women, for whom it offered a
new if sometimes provocative independence. Mabel
Williams in Ottawa, 1898.

Modernity in Canada took many forms. It is nearly impossible to connect it to any one symbol or idea. The bicycle
comes close for late 19th- century modernism because it was so completely without precedent, an expression of
engineering and metallurgical skills, and very literally an expression of the power of the individual. As pro-
duction costs fell and competition in the sector rose, unit prices came down far enough by the late 1890s to make
the bicycle affordable to middle- and some working-class Canadians. The growing urban centres necessitated new
means of getting around (when weather permitted) and delivering goods that depended less on horses and carts
and more on individual mobility. Inveterate gamblers saw in bicycles an opportunity for competition and wager-
ing. In the first three decades after Confederation, as Glen Norcliffe states, Bicycles and tricycles presented men
and (later, when they became safer) women with a highly visible opportunity to demonstrate that they were in the
mainstream of modern life. Mass-produced and consumer-oriented, aligned with fitness (and sometimes with
temperance), and widely observed in urban settings, the bicycle was thoroughly modern, at least until the arrival
1
of the automobile.

Motorized transportation began its conquest of city streets shortly after streetcars had laid claim to much of the
original downtown landscape. The movement begun by the bicycle from collective to individual transporta-
tion thus continued, helped along by steam-powered and, later, petroleum-powered engines. There is no doubt that
the automobile constitutes one of the most powerful symbols of modernity in the 20th century, with its revolution-
ary technological sophistication, luxurious trappings, and of course speed, all of which would only advance
further and further over the course of the next hundred years. The automobile was also modern in that its man-
ufacture increasingly depended on managerial science and the refinements of the assembly line. As a consumer
item, it cost less than a house, but more than almost anything else a Canadian family would ever purchase.

The mechanisms for extending the reach of modern systems and values in Canada were numerous and subtle.

1. Glen Norcliffe, The Ride to Modernity: The Bicycle in Canada, 1869-1900 (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2001), 30-36.

585
 586 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Take the rural post office, for example. Historian Jack Little has described it as traditionally the centre of rural
2
conviviality, but also serving as the main point of contact with the outside world. The post office system across
southern Canada enabled the relatively rapid movement of information from other parts of the country. Letters
home from the cities allowed one generation to describe to another how their world was changing in material and
intellectual ways. Reports sent back from the farming frontier in the West or from the goldfields of the Yukon
stimulated latent wanderlust. Rural towns in economically less viable regions began to leech population. Demands
were made for more modern services such as telephones (which begin to appear in homes in the 1880s) and elec-
3
tricity (the use of which expanded rapidly after 1906). The telephone itself accelerated this process of dissemi-
nating modern values and ideas. Rural electrification and telephone service was vastly more expensive than the
same process in concentrated urban centres, an irrefutable fact that created different rates of modernization of
technologies, lives, and inevitably values. The idea of being so-called old-fashioned only makes sense
when something else is considered new-fashioned. Thus, the horse-and-buggy, wood stove, Sunday-suit-wear-
ing folks back East in the Gasp or the Petitcodiac, in the outports and across the whole of PEI, were decidedly
old-fashioned.

The links between modernity and energy sources are explored by York University historian, Sean Kheraj.

Little also points out how expanding and increasingly sophisticated systems of banking and communication dis-
4
solved small-town economies. This could be seen on Vancouver Island and throughout the Maritimes, where
wealthy families that had once dominated their local communities and provided some degree of beneficent phil-
anthropy began investing their money elsewhere. The CPR, the steel companies, and the farm machinery giants
were all attractive options with better returns and fewer headaches than reinvesting in local industry. The railway
could deliver goods from Toronto to any hamlet along a rail line. Why try, then, to produce redundant goods in a
village? The effect was to make economically backward (non-modern) towns more backward still, while advanc-
ing the modern age in privileged centres of production and innovation.

2. J. I. Little, The Other Quebec: Microhistorical Essays on Nineteenth-Century Religion and Society (Toronto: University of Toronto Press,
2006), 253.
3. in 1885, Ottawa became the first city on earth to have its streets all lit by electricity.
4. J. I. Little, The Other Quebec, 253.
 10.2 DEFINING MODERNISM 587

In short, it wasnt the case necessarily that non-modern settlements and whole regions were choosing to lag behind
in the march to modernity. There were structures at work that determined the reach of modern life. At the same
time, there were opponents to modernization in rural Canada and urban Canada as well, as is shown in Section
10.3. Consumerism, as discussed in Section 10.4, was a powerful antidote to those forces.

There was a shifting of gears after 1945. Technological achievements and the increased role of government in
the interwar years and WWII put Canada on a course for what is called high modernism. This is a period of
large-scale infrastructural projects funded by the public purse: freeway construction, hydro-electric dams, subway
systems, and urban renewal. It is also an era of intensified public involvement in the form of the welfare state,
increased investment in secondary and post-secondary education, and the growth of the healthcare sector (which,
in Canada, had a profoundly important public as opposed to private or corporate component). Historian
Christopher Dummitt describes this watershed:

After the war, Canadians retreated from much of the emphasis on hyper-efficiency that had characterized the war years,
but a widespread belief in the possibilities and benefits of control remained. This was reflected in a variety of ways.
Partly, it meant managing economic and social life through the welfare state, and a host of new programs came into place,
5
including the Veterans Charter, family allowances (1944), a new old-age pension (1951), and hospital insurance (1957).

These were all features of what has been called modern. It crops up in many parts of 20th-century culture and
is distinctive, almost instantly recognizable, as different from what one could find in the 19th century. Describing
modernity can be difficult, making it a job a job for

Superman

Figure 10.3 Sent to Earth from a

dying planet.

Growing levels of literacy in the interwar years a result of growth in public and mandatory education
and the extension of high school education to a larger segment of the adolescent-populationfed demand
for newspapers, serious literature, pulp fiction, magazines, and comic books. The last of these appeared in
the late 1930s and very quickly settled into a recognizable format and structure. Comic strips emerged ear-
lier in the century, and European publishers were ahead of North Americans in producing the sequentially
panelled and coloured storylines that would become defining elements of the comic book. But it is the
appearance in 1938 of Action Comics and the debut of Superman that signals a watershed in this evolution.
Superman was the creation of Joe Shuster (1914-92), a Canadian whose parents had emigrated from the
Netherlands and the Ukraine, and his American cousin Jerry Siegel (1914-96). Set primarily in the fictional
city of Metropolis based on Toronto, where Shuster grew up and at the Daily Planet newspaper
modelled on Torontos Daily Star, where Shuster worked, Action Comics and its Kryptonian protagonist
drew on Canadian experiences and values, some of which were rooted in a rural past while others arose

5. Christopher Dummitt, The Manly Modern: Masculinity in Postwar Canada (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2007), 9.
588 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

from a modern urban present. The alien refugee arrives in rural North America, a generation after the first
great waves of settlement spread out to colonize the West, and is raised in the morally upstanding and
old-fashioned but still recognizable grain belt of the plains. Grounded in seemingly indestructible values,
he moves to the big city where there is crime to fight which he does as an independent actor and not,
significantly, as a member of a police force. The famous trappings of the Superman story a rocket-
ship voyage to earth, a planet named for a recently discovered gas, a visual spectrum that includes X-rays
(another recent scientific breakthrough), and an ability to leap tall buildings in a single bound just as
city skylines were starting to sprout upward to as much as 30 stories speak to the modern technological
world in which Shuster and Siegel lived.

Figure 10.4 Vastly less successful and

memorable than Superman was
Shuster and Siegels late 1940s
attempt to put the comic back into
comic book.

Superman can act also as a metaphorical bridge between the modernity of the interwar years and the high
modernity of the post-1939 period. Superman is famously vulnerable to two things: magic and kryptonite.
As Dummitt reveals in Section 9.5, interest in spiritualism, and offshoots like magic and the occult, were
at a high water mark in the interwar years, and their influence reached the highest public office in Canada.
Pulp novels and radio programs in the 1920s and 1930s featured sword-and-sorcery storylines and pop-
ular fictional characters with magic-derived abilities, like the Shadow. Magic was as contemporary to
Shuster and Superman as were skyscrapers and rockets. So, too, was radiation. X-rays might be helpful but
they were known to be harmful as well. Radium like krypton gas and X-rays had been discovered in
the 1890s; by the 1930s, Canada was one of the worlds two leading producers of uranium. What is some-
times called big science would emerge in the course of World War II in the form of the Manhattan Project.
Thereafter and throughout the Cold War, public understandings of radiation poisoning were heightened
and kryptonite (a fictional radioactive substance derived from Supermans home planet) became a more
plausible and fearsome vulnerability than, say, Mandrake the Magician (who was, incidentally and
allegedly, based on Leon Mandrake, a Canadian performer).

Figure 10.5 New Westminsterite

Leon Mandrake began his career
in stage magic in the 1920s. The
comic strips he inspired would
spin off into radio series, books,
and films.

Katharine Rollwagen addresses the rise of the teenager in Section 10.11, observing that high schools were
necessary to the creation of this new phase in life. With the teenager came a panoply of new interests and
cultural artifacts, of which the comic book was one. (Quite obviously: no teenager, no Archie Comics.) But
 10.2 DEFINING MODERNISM 589

comic books in the era of high modernity were also subject to greater regulation, not least because they
were thought to incite serious anti-social behaviours, including homicidal impulses. As a cultural artifact
that both reflects and allegedly transformed a generations values, the humble comic book ought not to be
casually dismissed.

Key Points

Modernity consisted of technological, social, and intellectual changes and practices that began in the
19th century and accelerated through the 20th century.
Creating systems and products that made sense of new cities and new productive systems was at the
heart of modernization.
The modern state was, by definition, a more interventionist state which took on more roles in a secu-
lar environment.
Popular culture including icons like Superman can be analyzed to demonstrate the extent to
which modern (and high modern) values and obsessions permeate day-to-day life and the imagina-
tion.

Attributions
Figure 10.2
Mabel Williams with bicycle at 54 Main Street, residence of James Ballantyne (Online MIKAN no.3191717)
by James Ballantyne / Library and Archives Canada / PA-132274 has nil restrictions on use.

Figure 10.3
Superman Card Game by Whitman (1978) Green Kryptonite by Mark Anderson is used under a CC-BY 2.0
license.

Figure 10.4
Funnyman1 by Joe Shuster is in the public domain.

Figure 10.5
Mandrake the Magician Exhibit Card by Mark Anderson is used under a CC-BY 2.0 license.
 10.3 Antimodernism

SHARON WALL, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, UNIVERSITY OF WINNIPEG

Figure 10.6 Hirshfield House in Vancouvers West End is an

example of the Arts and Crafts style that recalled English village
life rather than embracing modern city life.

Just as enthusiasm for modernism and wonder at the fruits of scientific and technological progress were attaining
their early heights in the late-19th century, a counter-tendency we have come to call antimodernism developed
within North-American culture. While modernism touted the marvels of progress and civilized society, antimod-
ernists began to worry about the possibility of overcivilization, of the possibility of too much comfort, and about
1
the physical and psychological impact of a world devoid of hard work, physical activity, and struggle. For some,
life was becoming all too easy.

To compensate for the possibility of overcivilization, antimodernists glorified what they called the simple life;
2
to compensate for too much ease, they sought to rough it, especially in their leisure time. Just as production
was becoming more thoroughly mechanized and their work lives less physically demanding, early antimodernists
fuelled an Arts and Crafts revival movement, took a new interest in martial arts, and took a renewed interest
in back-to-nature activities. Men took up big-game hunting, while both men and women took part in canoeing,
camping, and wilderness vacations. Children were not left out either; many thought it was most discouraging to
observe how, even for them, life was becoming too easy. In response, the scouting, guiding, and summer camp
movements promised to take 20th-century children away from the evils of the city and back to the wonders and
3
simplicity of nature where, it was argued, their character would be strengthened. Overall, antimodernists sought
intense experience in all kinds of forms.

1. T. J. Jackson Lears, No Place of Grace: Antimodernism and the Transformation of American Culture, 1880-1920 (New York: Pantheon
Books, 1981).
2. David E. Shi, The Simple Life: Plain Living and High Thinking in American Culture (New York : Oxford University Press, 1985).
3. Sharon Wall, The Nurture of Nature: Childhood, Antimodernism, and Ontario Summer Camps, 1920-55 (Vancouver: University of British
Columbia Press, 2009).

590
 10.3 ANTIMODERNISM 591

Antimodernism affected more than just leisure; it was also a way of thinking about peoples, culture, and history.
Indigenous peoples were glorified and even imitated (though in very artificial ways) as Indians who lived the
4
simple life. In some cases, individuals romanticized their own histories; in Nova Scotia, an entire tourist industry
was built up around the notion of Nova Scotians as a simpler folk engaged more in the production of handicrafts
5
and folktales than industrial goods, a people whose lives had seemingly escaped the touch of modernity.

Not everyone was an antimodernist. One doesnt long for the simple life or thrill at the prospect of roughing it
unless one has already tasted the comforts of the good life. Most antimodernists came from comfortable middle-
and upper-class backgrounds: professional men, Christian ministers, intellectuals, and others who had already felt
the benefits of progress. These were people with time on their hands and a tendency toward self-analysis and
reflection. Women of these same classes could also feel antimodernist sympathies. Their homes were among the
first to benefit from such things as electric lighting, running water, and flush toilets, making living without such
amenities while camping or canoeing seem exciting.

The critique mounted by antimodernists, whatever their gender, contained fundamental contradictions. Founders
of summer camps, for example, often wanted to clean up nature, to add walk-in fridges and hot showers to make
life not quite so rough. People who glorified what they called Indians also appropriated land on which Indige-
nous people still hunted and fished. In Nova Scotia, images of simple folk ignored the fact that coal-mining and
industrial development were as important to the provinces history as folk ballads and handspun linen. Further,
these simple, folksy creations, as much as summer camps, wilderness vacations, and a host of other goods and
experiences which were valued for their connection to a pre-modern past, became modern consumer products to
be marketed and sold.

As these examples suggest, the antimodernist critiques were limited; by the 21st century, we might say they
were only half-hearted. Ultimately, few people ever truly wanted to turn back the clock to live a pre-modern exis-
tence. Antimodernist dissatisfaction, however, is a feeling that still lingers today as some question the merits of a
modern lifestyle that we cannot truly escape.

Key Points

Management, systemization, and regulation of daily life in the modern world was resisted in some
quarters.
Some antimodernists were concerned that modern life was too soft and would lead to a weakening of
the individual and society alike.
Modern styles were also resisted as cold and artificial while older traditions and economic underde-
velopment were celebrated as authentic and preferable.

4. Philip J. Deloria, Playing Indian (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1998).
5. Ian McKay, The Quest of the Folk: Antimodernism and Cultural Selection in Twentieth C>entury Nova Scotia (Montreal: McGill-Queens
University Press, 1994).
592 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Attributions
Figure 10.6
Hirshfield House 01 by Torecles is used under a CC-BY-SA 3.0 license.
 10.4 Consumerism

TRACY PENNY LIGHT, THOMPSON RIVERS UNIVERSITY

Figure 10.7 Large downtown department stores emerged in the

Interwar years as temples to consumerism. Window shoppers
outside Simpsons in Toronto view styles alongside the sizing
details of Hollywoods first generation of stars (including
Canadian Norma Shearer).

Magazines were important harbingers of consumerism in the 20th century. Not only did they bring goods for con-
sumption to many through advertisements, but they also brought messages about what Canadians should consume
and for what purpose. For women, they advertised products that would allow them to find and keep their husbands,
ranging from beauty products to appliances, as well as goods that promised to make them good mothers. For men,
they advertised products that would allow them to demonstrate their masculinity. While the advertisements (ads)
used slightly different copy and language over the 20th century to reflect broader cultural interests and to suit the
shifting norms and values, for the most part, the prescriptions for normal (middle-class, white) women and men
1
can easily be seen. As such, consumerism has been an important framing concept for Canadians throughout the
20th century. And it is a concept that shapes how other groups frame their discussions around different aspects of
life in Canada. For instance, the medical profession uses consumer culture to sell their services, whether it is by
reinforcing the suitability of products for consumers with their expertise (for instance, 97% of doctors say this
product will) or by selling their own expertise as a product in and of itself, a phenomenon witnessed especially
2
since the 1980s. Depending on the marketing vehicle, other groups, such as the legal profession or organized
religion, can also be seen to use consumerism to promote their positions on Canadian culture.

1. Tracy Penny Light, From Fixing to Enhancing: Shifting Ideals of Health and Gender in the Medical Discourse on Cosmetic Surgery in
Twentieth Century Canada, in Penny Light, Tracy, Barbara Brookes and Wendy Mitchinson (eds.), Bodily Subjects: Essays on Gender and
Health, 1800-2000 (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 2015): 319-346; Tracy Penny Light, Consumer Culture and
the Medicalization of Gender Roles in Interwar Canada, in Cheryl Warsh and Dan Malleck (eds.), Consuming Modernity: Gendered Behav-
iour and Consumerism before the Baby Boom (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2013): 34-54.
2. Tracy Penny Light, Healthy Men Make Good Fathers: Masculine Health and the Family in 1950s America, in Isabel Heinemann (ed.),

593
 594 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

While one could argue that the influence of consumerism is particularly subversive if consumers are not critical
in their consumption, there is also evidence to show that Canadians are good at using vehicles like magazines
to promote their own interests. In her study of Chatelaine magazine in the 1950s and 1960s, Valerie Korinek
demonstrates that women successfully advocated for changes to womens status in society through both the adver-
3
tisements and articles in the magazine. It is important to remember, though, that these were, generally speaking,
the perspectives of the privileged members of society. Marginalized groups (such as those with different racial,
class, or sexuality positions) tend to be overlooked even today. In fact, one might argue that the hegemony of
consumerism helps to reinforce existing inequalities.

Key Points

Constructing consumerism involved educating citizens in the business of buying things they didnt
know they needed.
Consumerism became a way of framing the economy and day-to-day life in the 20th century.
Magazines in mid-century became vehicles for dissemination of consumerist attitudes and the pro-
motion of group and professional interests.

Attributions
Figure 10.7
Window shopping at Simpsons 2 by Infrogmation is in the public domain. This image is available from City of
Toronto Archives under the archival citation Fonds 1257, Series 1057, Item 4762.

Inventing the Modern American Family: Family Values and Social Change in 20th Century United States (Frankfurt am Main: Campus Ver-
lag, 2012): 105-123.
3. Valerie Korinek, Roughing it in the Suburbs: Reading Chatelaine Magazine in the Fifties and Sixties (Toronto: University of Toronto Press,
2000.)
10.5 Secular Canada

Figure 10.8 Ideals of science, progress,

technology, and reason had been running up
against religion and faith for centuries. By the
20th century, the tide was running with the
secularists.

A key feature of modernity is secularism, the movement away from religious belief most often manifested in
the separation of church and state. Anticlericalism in the 19th century took the position that the business of the
church was saving souls, not running schools or hospitals, and certainly not influencing governments. In English-
speaking Canada, secularism was often a compromise solution to a culture that featured multiple denominations
mainly Anglican, Presbyterian, Methodist, Baptist, and Congregationalist none of which could lay claim to
a majority of the population. If there was not one creed that could lead, then none would. This goes some distance
to explain the suspicion and, indeed, hostility felt by many Anglo-Protestants to the roles played in Quebec by the
Catholic Church.

And yet, as the secular, democratic state was growing in modernist English Canada, so too was the popularity
of certain faiths. The consolidation in 1925 of the Methodist, Congregationalist, and (most of) the Presbyterian
churches into the United Church of Canada strengthened that wing of Protestantism, making it overnight the
third largest denomination in the country. Within the member-denominations of the United Church and among
the Anglicans as well there were strong Social Gospel elements (see Chapter 7). So, while secularism and
modernism called for a separation of church and state, religious activists were often political and social activists
as well. While United Church adherents would generally throw their support behind the Cooperative Common-
wealth Federation, Catholics supported the Liberal Party, and Anglicans the Conservatives.

Organized religion, in short, still played a vital role in political and social life. This was nowhere more apparent
than in the rise of evangelical Protestantism in the 20th century (aspects of which are considered in Sections 7.6
and 7.9). Essentially antimodernist in its outlook, sects like the Union Baptists and the Pentecostal Church tended
towards a study of and adherence to what they called the fundamentals of scripture, and thus became known
as fundamentalists. As Tina Block demonstrates in Section 10.6, there came a tipping point in the middle of the

595
596 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

20th century when secularism became a defining feature of Canadian society in tandem with multicultural trends,
at which point the antimodernist forces in Christianity and other creeds were marginalized.

And here we have one of those great 20th-century ironies. The Canadian regime most influenced by the Pente-
costal Church and fundamentalist values was that of W.A.C. Bennett in British Columbia from 1952 to 1972. Phil
Flying Phil Gaglardi (1913-1995), a leader of Pentecostalism in the Interior, regularly boasted that he was both
a minister of the Crown and a minister of God. Yet no administration embraced modernity more. The potential of
technology, engineering, and science to make a bigger and better economy was an article of faith among the BC
Socreds (Social Credit Party). One lesson to be drawn from this is that elements of modernity were so pervasive
that even the most conservative chapters of Protestantism could not fully resist their influence.

Religious organizations continued through the remainder of the 20th century to exercise an influence that belied
their fall from popular favour. No other organization or institution has sufficient influence to partner with the
state in the delivery of education, and the norm in Canada is that religious education is subsidized heavily by the
provinces (so as to ensure religious schools adherence to provincial curricula). Indeed, disenchantment with pub-
lic schools encouraged a renewed interest in clerical education in the late 20th century. Schools, however, were
also the setting for a worsening crisis in credibility: disclosures of abuse of children by clergy and church-spon-
sored educators in various settings, but most notably at Mount Cashel Orphanage in St. Johns and in many resi-
dential schools, poured forth during the 1980s and on and continue to trouble Canadians.

Key Points

Secularism the removal of organized religion from the running of the state and social institutions
is one of the dominant features of modernity.
Anticlericalism in Catholic-dominated Quebec played out differently from anticlericalism in multi-
denominational English-Canada.
Religious activists often took their perspectives and goals into public life in mainstream political
organizations.
Many denominations and faiths responded to modernism with hostility, seeing it as an agenda for
their marginalization.

Attributions
Figure 10.8
Secular Thought Cover Image (Jan. 1909) by J. S. Ellis is used under a CC-BY-SA 2.5 license.
 10.6 Religion And Irreligion In The Postwar World

TINA BLOCK, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, THOMPSON RIVERS UNIVERSITY

When one looks back at the 1950s, writes historian Doug Owram, religion stands as one of the great gulfs
1
separating that age from the present. In that era, Christianity occupied a privileged place in Canadian public
life, appearing in most public schools across the country, in the speeches of politicians, and even in the official
2
mandate of the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. The decade and a half following World War II was a time
of significant growth for Canadas Christian churches: church membership levels increased, new churches were
built at a rapid rate, and Sunday schools burst at the seams.

Despite clear indicators of church growth, there were also signs that Christianity was losing its hold on Canadian
life during the 1950s. Consumer culture was on the rise, and Canadians seemed more preoccupied with material
than with spiritual concerns. In cities across Canada, there was a growing demand for professional sporting events
3
on Sundays, challenging older patterns of Sabbath observance. Religious holidays, such as Easter and Christmas,
became increasingly commercialized. The church pews were filled on Sundays, but religious knowledge, inter-
est, and enthusiasm appeared to be fading. Christian leaders feared that postwar churchgoing had less to do with
genuine religious commitment, and more to do with a desire for stability and security after years of economic
depression and war.

Dechristianization and the Sixties

As it turns out, Christian leaders had reason to be concerned. Levels of church involvement fell across Canada
during the 1960s (the sixties). Moreover, the proportion of Canadians claiming to have no religion grew from
4
0.4% in 1951 to 4.3% in 1971 a sharper increase than at any other time in this countrys history. The changes
were especially dramatic in Quebec. As the Quiet Revolution unfolded in that province, many clergy left religious
orders and the influence of the Roman Catholic Church waned. Across the country, there were growing challenges
to the longstanding notion of Canada as a Christian nation. It was during the 1960s, according to historian Gary

1. Doug Owram, Born at the Right Time: A History of the Baby Boom Generation (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1996), 103.
2. Gary Miedema, For Canadas Sake: Public Religion, Centennial Celebrations, and the Re-making of Canada in the 1960s (Montreal:
McGill-Queens University Press, 2005), xv.
3. Brian Clarke, English Speaking Canada from 1854, in Terrence Murphy and Roberto Perin (eds.), A Concise History of Christianity in
Canada (Toronto: Oxford University Press, 1996): 357.
4. Mark Noll, What Happened to Christian Canada?, Church History 75:2 (June 2006): 248.

597
 598 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Miedema, that the historic privileging of Christianity in Canadian national public life began very visibly to crum-
5
ble.

Several factors account for the dechristianization of Canada during the sixties. In that decade, the Christian
churches in Canada and beyond came under attack from people both within and outside their congregations. For
example, in his 1965 bestseller The Comfortable Pew, Pierre Berton lambasted the mainstream churches as com-
6
placent and out of touch with the critical issues of the day. Charged with irrelevancy, Canadas Christian churches
were also edged out, by an expanding state, of their traditional domains of health, education, and welfare. Fur-
thermore, a postwar wave of immigration that included many non-Christian newcomers made the notion of a uni-
formly Christian Canada untenable. As Canada became more religiously diverse, its public schools came under
increasing scrutiny for privileging the Christian faith. In the public realm, Canada started to be represented as a
multi-faith nation (rather than exclusively Christian) at state-sponsored events such as the 1967 Centennial cele-
7
brations.

At the close of the turbulent sixties, Canada was a different place, religiously, than it had been when it emerged
from World War II. It had not become a wholly secular country most Canadians still maintained some religious
beliefs and affiliation. However, Christianitys position of unquestioned power and privilege in Canadian culture
had come to an end, and the churches were no longer widely recognized as the cornerstones of moral authority.

Key Points

At mid-century, materialism supplanted spirituality as a defining feature of Canadian life.

Church-going declined in the Cold War era, and a growing share of Canadians claimed to be atheists
or otherwise without religious beliefs.
Dechristianization has been explained by a failing of the mainstream churches, the arrival of new-
comers with different belief systems, and the rise of multiculturalism (which challenged the auto-
matic pre-eminence of Christianity).
The role of the church as arbiters and leaders in moral authority was no longer intact by the 1970s.

5. Miedema, For Canadas Sake, 4.

6. Pierre Berton, The Comfortable Pew: A Critical Look at Christianity and the Religious Establishment in the New Age (Philadelphia: Lippin-
cott, 1965).
7. Miedema, For Canadas Sake, 4.
 10.7 Gendered Roles after the Wars

ROBERT RUTHERDALE, DEPARTMENT OF PHILOSOPHY & HISTORY, ALGOMA UNIVERSITY

Figure 10.9 Gendered roles and ideals of normalcy were

transmitted through primary- school readers like the Dick and
Jane books (produced in the United States but reprinted in
Canada in French, and in corrected English in the 1950s).

Gendered roles in modern Canada have passed through a period of significant change since the interwar period,
especially during the 1960s. As the work of historians Veronica Strong-Boag, Mary Louise Adams, Magda Fahrni,
Elise Chenier, and others illustrate, the politics of home life and gendered family regimes was dominated by a
complex set of forces following demobilization in 1945-46 and into the late 1950s. Housing shortages were expe-
rienced in many parts of Canada; the peacetime restoration of domestic goods production and consumption took a
decade longer in Canada than in the United States. But the desire to impose, immediately after the war, a regime of
normalization, of bread-winning fathers and homemaking mothers, persisted throughout the 1950s. It was driven
in part by a new family formation manifest in the baby boom between 1939 and the late 1950s. Nancy Christie
and Michael Gauvreau have described this as an interregnum period, an extended era of post-war adjustment
1
that lasted to the mid-1950s. Historians situate changes in gendered roles and demographic patterns in the context
of shifting historical forces which shaped the masculine and feminine lives of men and women and their baby
boomer children.

For the parental generation, the dark shadows of the Great Depression and the devastation of the war years moti-
vated the search for security for jobs, for homes, and for a restoration of feminine domesticity supported by
masculine providers and a nationwide drive towards a better life. This was especially true for many newcomers
from war-torn Europe. Such hopes, however, were based on older models of gender relations arising in the era of
industrialization, some of which were already dated and challenged in the period from 1914-39. The re-mapping

1. Nancy Christie and Michael Gauvreau, eds., Cultures of Citizenship in Post-War Canada, 1940-1955 (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queens
University Press, 2003).

599
 600 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

of gender roles as Nazism was defeated and the Cold War loomed can thus be approached as a generational as
well as a gendered social historical script.

The societal urge for post-war normalization and security in Canada led many towards a search for home as
both a public-realm cultural ideal and a private-life aspiration. Explanations for origins of the baby boom itself
invariably point to a postwar-gendered and generational search for security through domesticity. The gendered
family regime of mothers, fathers, and children in the 1950s thus had deep historical roots yet was shaped by a
quest for normalization in its context as a postwar measure. Security through normalized gendered roles was a
classed (middle) and ethnically specific (white) ideal found and promoted in television advertisements and many
sitcoms of the era. It was also a cultural backdrop to the public discourse that often cut across class and ethnic dif-
ferences. Imposed from above through state policies and embraced from below by many Canadians, gender roles
were shaped in the 1950s and early 1960s by conformity to a nostalgic sense of the past one that was open to
challenge.

Early postwar patterns in gender roles were marked by patriarchal norms. This was especially true as a new gen-
eration of fathers and mothers began to form their own families in search of what both American and Canadian
journalists, writing for the middle classes, referred to as the good life. As I have suggested elsewhere, some
2
wives balked at the patriarchal power (sometimes called hegemonic masculinity by theorists today) it imposed,
but few fathers did. Postwar family life was, as Strong-Boag puts it, an ambivalent experiment: many wives,
mothers, and homemakers who reached maturity at this time (marriage ages were comparatively younger in the
3
1950s) did not look back on their home dreams with bitterness, but many other women did.

Mens experiences of postwar domesticity were not without problems. Notions of masculinity in crisis mod-
ern men facing a challenge to their identities as men, to cite a prominent example, had been a perennial concern
across many decades though each era, since the 19th century, generated its own mythologies about how men
suffer in the modern age. In the 1950s, mid-century modern men seemed to face three crises in parables of woe
that found considerable space in publications, not only in popular magazines like Macleans and Chatelaine, but
also in some of the leading sociological publications of the day, most notably Crestwood Heights: A Study of the
Culture of Suburban Life (1956). A particular triad of social forces was seen as standing against the modern man
as a self-disciplined, autonomous, inner-directed, assertive being: modern bureaucracies and the modern factory
system; family togetherness, which prescribed a new dictate for fathers play with your children as if you were,
almost, one of them; and, possibly worst of all, moms as matriarchal menaces, who exerted too much pressure on
sons some of whom, it was feared, would become homosexual as a result. This last challenge to manhood was,
of course, also a critique of womanhood; a mixing of messages endorsed the maternal housewife while condemn-
ing her at the same time.

With respect to lived experience, these cultural myths and storylines reflected little in terms of the enduring
inequalities in gendered roles in the private and public spheres. Following the immediate postwar forced exodus
of most women in non-traditional jobs, there was a slow and then accelerating return to the workforce by married
women. By the early 1960s, women comprised one-third of the paid workforce. Full-time earnings, however,
stood at only 59% of mens for the same labour categories and at just 54% for part-time female workers. Despite

2. On this topic, see R.W. Connell and James W. Messerschmidt. "Hegemonic Masculinity: Rethinking the Concept". Gender and Society, 19, 6
(2005): 829-859.
3. Veronica Strong-Boag, Home Dreams: Canadian Women and the Suburban Experience, 1945-60, Canadian Historical Review 72:4
(December 1991): 24-34.
 10.7 GENDERED ROLES AFTER THE WARS 601

the challenges to their masculinity that most men were supposed to be facing, work-time studies of womens
labour in the home as homemakers revealed an even more gender-skewed expectation that women were responsi-
ble as an essential characteristic of their gendered role for most infant child care and most housework.

Figure 10.10 Postwar women could find pink-collar

jobs in teaching and nursing but also in industry,
where they were valued for fine work but not so
much that they were paid as much as men. Women at
Canadian Marconi in Montreal, ca. 1949-58.

What stands out in histories of the postwar period, at least to the rise of the sexual revolution in the late 1960s,
was the equation of heterosexuality with what the state and society considered normal gender relations. Deviance
in this respect is considered in Section 12.7.

Connections between sexuality and gender roles are complex. They continue to be debated by historians today.
Gender roles, if approached as shifting social and cultural responses to sexual differences, consistently demon-
strate historical categories and powers that connect the body to boundaries of class, age, and ethnicity. In 2014,
the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) released its Better Life Index, indicating
that Canadian women spend, on average, some 254 minutes per day cooking, cleaning, and caring for children,
compared to 160 minutes for men performing the same tasks. These 21st-century trends have deep historical
roots in gender roles defined more by patriarchy than by equal partnership. Histories of the struggle for womens
rights and the gendering of experience are one means for challenging those persistent norms. Now more than ever
before, these confrontations with histories of inequality become apparent in legislation and official policies that
embrace still-wider notions of gender and identity. In this sense, the translation of historic roles and restrictions
into postmodern constructions of gender roles in Canada is part of a continuity of transformation, and not only a
landscape of change.

In the decade of the first postwar generation, as Bryan Palmer observes, the turbulent sixties brought with it a
generation gap in social mores and gender roles between young women and men in Canada, as elsewhere
4
but this came later, as the postwar generation of baby boomers reached maturity in the late 1960s.

Key Points

Normalizing gender roles in the form of bread-winner fathers and homemaker mothers was part of
the postwar project of rebuilding Canadian society and its economy.
This pursuit of a new gendered normal has been interpreted as part of a search for security and rel-

4. Bryan Palmer, Canadas 1960s: The Ironies of Identity in a Rebellious Era (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2009).
602 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

ative prosperity on the part of a generation directly impacted by the Depression and WWII. Nor-
malcy may have been imposed from the top but it was embraced from below as well.
Features of these gendered roles include a strengthening of patriarchal authority and privilege for
men in heterosexual circumstances.
By the early 1960s, women were returning to the workforce in significant numbers, despite wage
and other barriers to their participation.
Historical studies of gender roles and sexuality indicate a complex pattern of ongoing transformation
and show us that traditional roles are, themselves, transitory.

Attributions
Figure 10.9
on the road by In pastel is used under a CC-BY 2.0 license.

Figure 10.10
An assembly line of women working at the Canadian Marconi Company, Montreal (Online MIKAN
no.4369810) by Malak / Canada, Dept. of Manpower and Immigration / Library and Archives Canada has nil
restrictions on use.
 10.8 Canada Noir

Figure 10.11 Montreals Saint Catherine Street aglow in neon

lights, ca. 1937.

Modernity brought significant social, cultural, and moral changes that not everyone was pleased to see. This pro-
duced a rolling tide of uncertainty and anxieties, some of which we refer to as moral panics. The temperance
movement was rooted in moral panic, as were elements of eugenics. There was a succession of so-called red
scares in the 20th century, beginning in 1918-19 with the Russian Revolution and followed by a year of general
strikes in North America, a decade of unrest during the Depression, and Cold War fears of a nuclear apocalypse
(which continued until the fall of the Iron Curtain in 1989-91). Building a strong, moral, and disciplined nation
that deferred to authority was the goal of many Canadian leaders. Many Canadian citizens did not fall easily into
line.

Sins of the City

Figure 10.12 Anna Labelle (alias Mme. mile Beauchamp) was a

powerful Montreal brothel keeper before WWII who kept police
on the payroll.

In a recent study of crime and society in early 20th century Halifax, Michael Boudreau makes the argument that
Nova Scotian critics of modernity railed against the moral softening of an increasingly secular and ethnically
diverse society. This was an essentially antimodernist position that looked backwards to a time of ethnic and spir-
itual simplicity. Their response to these conditions? Ironically, it involved a very secular and modernist agenda
of government agencies, scientific police methods, and the employment of psychologists and other experts who
1
could treat the criminal and the deviant.

1. Michael Boudreau, City of Order: Crime and Society in Halifax, 1918-35 (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2012).

603
 604 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

What was happening in Halifax was playing out in different ways across the country. In Vancouver, long-time
mayor L.D. Taylor (1857-1946) repeatedly rebuffed morality crusades, proud of the fact that his city was not
a Sunday school town. Vancouvers middle-class voters, however, increasingly challenged his liberal view of
2
victimless crimes, and in 1928 defeated him under the banner of New Town, Not Blue Town. Taylors
relaxed attitude was replaced by an increasingly bureaucratic administrative structure that, at best, talked a good
fight. Modernist responses had to be made with the human resources available and many of the people involved
in administrations, police departments, and morality crusades were every bit as compromised as the people they
sought to change.

Figure 10.13 Race + drugs = double-jeopardy. The building

beside the middle telephone pole was an opium factory in
Vancouvers Chinatown, ca. 1907. Mackenzie King investigated
and drew up legislation designed to end the opium trade,
beginning the war on drugs even before the Great War got
underway.

Modern society was urban, and urban life was a problem that needed solving. Cities, it was feared, were corrupting
the morals and the very fibre of Canadians. Gambling, drinking, drugs, illegitimacy, and divorce not to mention
homosexuality were dreaded, criticized, and policed from the 19th through most of the 20th century. Crimi-
nality was often understood in xenophobic ways that, for example, held the Chinese community responsible for
gambling and opium; connected the Italian enclaves with violent crime, prostitution, and bootlegging; and con-
nected Eastern Europeans, African-Canadians, and Japanese women with brothels. Indeed, the sex trade seems to
have been widely regarded as a field into which Anglo-Celtics and Franco-Canadians could hardly hope to break.
Eugenicists weighed into these conversations with their fears for the future of the race (most often meaning the
British race), and alleging the corrupting moral influence of immigrants while pointing a finger at the decline of
Canadian manhood (and, eventually, womanhood) through urban living.

The goal of clean, safe, go-ahead, and ethical metropolises was elusive, however. Sometimes, it was easier to
promote a different vision. Throughout the mid-20th century, Vancouver and Montreal in particular enjoyed rep-
utations as cities in which sins could be serviced. Vancouver was the northern-most stop on an entertainment cir-
cuit based in San Francisco, then Los Angeles, and eventually Las Vegas, and which covered the western United
3
States. Vaudeville acts, musicians, and variety acts were mainstream elements in this network, but there was
also a lively culture of strip-shows and burlesque. Night clubs and music hall-style theatres sprang up across the
city centre; at one point, both Hastings Street (now the economically and socially depressed main artery of the
Downtown East Side) and Granville Street were billed as the citys Great White Way because of the enormous
quantity of neon lights that blazed outside entertainment venues. The Cave, Palomar, Penthouse, Commodore,
and Isys Supper Club (later, Isys Strip City) dominated what passed for the respectable trade, and between them
offered thousands of seats most nights to audiences and diners. On the east side, showrooms and tiny venues jos-
tled one another for space and offered a wide variety of entertainments. Because of restrictions on the serving of

2. Daniel Francis, LD: Mayor Louis Taylor and the Rise of Vancouver (Vancouver: Arsenal Pulp Press, 2004), 150.
3. Becki Ross, Burlesque West: Showgirls, Sex, and Sin in Postwar Vancouver (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2009).
 10.8 CANADA NOIR 605

liquor, some of these clubs facilitated sales of bootlegged alcohol and provided hiding spaces under the tables for
bottles brought in by customers. All had a reputation for keeping the local police happy with bribes. Some, more
than others, provided a setting for the negotiation of the sale of sex. The combination of alcohol, sex, and music
4
that had an African-American or Asian quality was viewed by critics as the triple-crown of immorality. Sex and
booze and ethnicity combined then to create a very artificial air of exoticism: the sense that this was something
not of Canada but, at the same time, available only in Canada.

Figure 10.14 In Vancouvers Chinatown, ca. 1936.

Montreals burlesque world was even more famous (or notorious) at the time, mainly because Canadas largest
city had a strong connection with both New York and Boston. Business elites of these American cities regularly
travelled to Montreal, where they were treated to a nightlife that seemed genuinely foreign and risqu. Brothels,
gin-joints, and gambling thrived through the first half of the century, mostly under the eye of Mayor Camillien
Houde (1889-1958). Like Taylor, Houde was a populist, a man of the people, despite his snappy suits and glossy
shoes. He supported fascists in the 1930s, opposed conscription and was branded a traitor by his English-speaking
opponents, served time at Petawawa during WWII, and reemerged in 1945 more popular than ever. Under Houde,
Montreal was an open city with limited restrictions on the sex trade, betting, and drinking. This was an affront
to the sternly moralistic Union Nationale regime of Premier Maurice Duplessis (discussed in Section 9.9), and
opposition to libertine Montreal grew through the 1950s. By 1955, a corner had been turned; brothels were being
closed and other elements of the citys entertainment industry were in peril. Houde stepped down and a new, more
5
censorious era began.

Figure 10.15 The staff at Chez Paree, a popular

Montreal nightclub, in 1951. Four years later it
would be the stage for a spy scandal (see Section
9.4).

The timing of Montreals clean-up campaign roughly coincides with Vancouvers. The Vancouver Police Depart-
ment (VPD) had repeatedly found itself at the wrong end of corruption enquiries beginning the 1920s and contin-
uing through the Depression into the postwar era. By the mid-1950s, it was clear that the rot extended to the Police
Commissioner and included bootlegging, numbers running, and prostitution all of which were being protected
by the VPD. Effective opposition to such practices in both Montreal and Vancouver reflected the growing influ-
ence of a middle class committed to their small-l liberal vision of individual rights, the protection of property, the
law as an instrument of morality, and professionalization of institutions like the police. They were motivated as

4. John Belshaw and Diane Purvey, Vancouver Noir: 1930-1960 (Vancouver: Anvil Press, 2011).
5. William Weintraub, City Unique: Montreal Days and Nights in the 1940s and 50s (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1996).
 606 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

well in the postwar era by those aspects of Cold War rhetoric that regarded anything that weakened the capitalist
West as a victory for the Soviet East.

To some extent, then, the moral liberality that could be found in some Canadian cities before the 1960s was an
expression of modernity and antimodernity at one and the same time. Its embrace of low-brow entertainments and
rejection of law-and-order agendas, its refusal to be controlled by the state, its lust for non-rational fun, and its
happy exploitation of differentness as a source of amusement seen most graphically in the persistence of fair-
ground freak shows but also in ethnic entertainments and slumming is all directly descended from pre-modern
practices. By the same token, these aspects of urban life could only be expressed in urban settings. Definitively
modern cultural symbols like jazz and the blues, all-night restaurants, and cocktail lounges belong to this era.

Figure 10.16 Even in the late 1960s, neon

lights and rain-soaked streets in downtown
Vancouver suggested film noir rather than
suburban domesticity.

So, too, did the tearing down of some of the racial and ethnic barriers that had been erected, ostensibly to protect
mainstream and white society from what that societys members considered as others. Chinatowns, like Van-
couvers (the largest in Canada), represented otherness, crime, unleashed sexuality, opium dens, gambling, filth,
6
run-down housing and mysterious back-alleys. As a neighbourhood, it was experienced by outsiders as a largely
inhospitable place until it was exoticized in the 1930s. Thereafter the ribbons of neon light, and the late-night
chop-suey houses and the nightclubs, provided a legitimate urban attraction while gambling provided a less legal
alternative. At that point in time, the status of Chinatowns across Canada began to shift from civic eyesore to civic
asset.

Figure 10.17 In 1946 Viola Desmond,

an African-Canadian Haligonian, sat
down in the Whites-only section of a
New Glasgow cinema. She was ejected,
roughed-up, and jailed overnight. Her
subsequent legal battle, though
unsuccessful, was a catalyst in the fight
for greater rights among
African-Canadians.

The experience of African-Canadians and African-Canadian communities was less straightforward. In the

6. John Zucchi, A History of Ethnic Enclaves in Canada (Ottawa: Canadian Historical Association, 2007), 9.
 10.8 CANADA NOIR 607

mid-20th century, performers like Oscar Peterson, Joe Sealy, and Eleanor Collins challenged colour barriers on
both sides of the border with their extraordinary talents. But long before and well after the Civil Rights movement
in the United States, African-Canadian neighbourhoods were regarded by civic and provincial leaders as problem-
atic spaces where crime and lack of hygiene were issues. African-Canadians have thus been especially vulnerable
to displacement from Canadian cities. The Bog, a Charlottetown neighbourhood near the city centre populated
by an economically and socially marginalized African-Canadian community, was redeveloped out of existence
around 1900. Vancouvers 20th-century African-Canadian neighbourhood, Hogans Alley, was viewed by law-
makers and journalists as the scene of immorality, petty crime, and poverty; what locals regarded as a lively and
vital community with its own African Methodist Church and businesses was bulldozed in the late 1960s to make
way for a pair of highway overpasses. In both cases, the African-Canadian community never again coalesced;
indeed, many of its members moved away for good.

Exercise: Documents

Les quartiers disparus

Often, historic artifacts document something other than what was intended. In the early 1960s, the City
of Montreal was planning the Autoroute Ville-Marie, a freeway that would cut through the old downtown
from one end of le de Montral to the other. This necessitated the removal of many buildings, homes,
and businesses along with their tenants and the construction of large swaths of social housing. The
City sent out a team to systematically photograph these spaces and residents before they all disappeared.
A selection of these photos can be viewed here.
Start with the following three pictures. What looks familiar to you and what looks alien? If you were asked
to document the material lives of 1960s Montrealers who were facing expropriation from their homes and
offices, what could you glean from these photos?

Figure 10.E1 The expropriation of 856 rue Richmond,

17 May 1967.

Figure 10.E2 Workers at Dominion Button Ltd., 1850

rue Saint-Antoine, 31 May 1967.
608 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 10.E3 Victoriatown, Montreal, 1963.

Key Points

Moral panics were a driving force in urban reforms in the mid-20th century, and the changes associ-
ated with modernism were among their many causes.
Behaviour that had been tolerated in early generations increasingly came under scrutiny as middle-
class city dwellers launched campaigns against gambling, drinking, drugs, the sex trade, and police
corruption.
Some cities were able to market themselves as entertainment hubs in which vices were actively pro-
moted and ethnic differentness were presented in a positive light as exotic.
By the mid- to late-1950s campaigns to clean up city life were carrying the day. Nightclubs were
closing, ethnic slums were being erased, and corruption was being punished. It is worth noting that
these changes took place precisely when the old downtowns were being abandoned for the suburbs.

Attributions
Figure 10.11
Sainte Catherine looking east at night by Conrad Poirier is in the public domain.

Figure 10.12
Anna Labelle, alias Mme mile Beauchamp, tenancire, 1939. P43-3-2_V26_E271-01 by Archives de la Ville
de Montreal is used under a CC-NC-SA 2.0 license.

Figure 10.13
CVA 677-580 [500 block of Carrall Street, looking north toward Pender Street] by Timms, Philip T. / City of
Vancouver Archives is in the public domain.

Figure 10.14
Men on street in front of Sai Woo Chop Suey House at 158 East Pender Street by James Crookall is in the
public domain.
This image is available from City of Vancouver Archives under the reference number CVA 260-452.

Figure 10.15
Montreal night life. Staff of 71 runs medium-sized Chez Paree club. Weekly wage bill is $3000 but earnings
 10.8 CANADA NOIR 609

are higher as many rely on tips for bulk of income (Online MIKAN no.3615421) by Louis Jaques / Library and
Archives Canada has nil restrictions on use.

Figure 10.16
Granville at night VPL 43347 by Vancouver Public Library Historical Photographs has no known copyright
restrictions.

Figure 10.17
Viola Desmond by Hantsheroes is in the public domain.

Figure 10.E1
The expropriation of 856 rue Richmond, 17 May 1967.(VM94-C1023-038) by Archives de la Ville de Mon-
tral is used under a CC-BY-NC-SA 2.0 license.

Figure 10.E2
Workers at Dominion Button Ltd. (VM94-C1027-084) by Archives de la Ville de Montral is used under a CC-
BY-NC-SA 2.0 license.

Figure 10.E3
Victoriatown, Montreal, 1963 (VM94C270-1114) by Archives de la Ville de Montral is used under a CC-BY-
NC-SA 2.0 license.
10.9 Historicizing Childhood: The Changing Fortunes of
Children and Youth in Canada

GEORGIA SITARA, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, UNIVERSITY OF VICTORIA

10.18 A boy, one of the Home Children, ploughs a field at Dr.

Barnardos Industrial Farm, ca. 1900.

The experiences of children and youth underwent profound change from the 19th century to the end of the 20th
century.

In the 19th century, children and youth were important contributors to the family economy. Most children learned
by working alongside adults. Childrens work, both paid and unpaid, was crucial to their own and to their fami-
lies well-being and survival. Only in the postwar (post World War II) era did mothers replace children as their
families secondary earners.

At the beginning of the 21st century, everyday life for most children in Canada revolved around school. This way
of life, which made schooling the central organizing principle of childrens lives, has its roots in the first Canadian
compulsory education legislation enacted in 1870 and mandated children to attend school for four months of the
year. Even then, work, family responsibilities, and other considerations meant that attendance for most children
remained irregular, despite families hopes for their childrens education and future.

The idea of childhood as a time in which children did not work took over a century to put into everyday practice.
The first Canadian legislation to regulate child labour, the Ontario Factory Acts of 1884, legislated boys, 12 years
and over, and girls, 14 years and older, to work no more than 10 hours a day, six days a week. Despite the protec-
tive legislation, families needs and individuals survival meant that in practice boys and girls continued to work.
Well into the 20th century, reform efforts and even child protection organizations expected children and youth to

610
 10.9 HISTORICIZING CHILDHOOD: THE CHANGING FORTUNES OF CHILDREN AND YOUTH IN CANADA 611

work. Work was considered a necessary part of their training in the habits of thrift and industry as well as respon-
sible citizenship.

In the images and voices of children and youth, captured in the oral history video series Growing Up
Canadian, we are reminded that they were proud to work, to bring home an income, and to make a contri-
1
bution to their families. In their stories, sometimes in fragments in the written record, and in surviving
photographic evidence, we can see that children and youth were capable, sometimes enterprising, heroes
of their own lives.

Historian Dorothy Chunn suggests that we should interpret education, labour, and other legislation as the codifi-
2
cation of childhood and youth as a time of dependence. In Dominion of Youth, Cynthia Comacchio demonstrates
3
that by the 1920s, children and youth were growing up very differently from their parents.

Alongside these historic shifts, children and youth continue to appear in the most unlikely places in the 20th cen-
4
tury. Between 1880-1930, over 80,000 Home Children immigrated to Canada without their families. At least
5
20,000 underage soldiers enlisted and served in World War I. One of the eight On to Ottawa Trek leaders to meet
with Prime Minister Robert Bennett in 1935 was 14 years old. Children and youth across Canada held a chocolate
bar strike in 1947 when, to their horror and disgust, the price of chocolate bars went from five to eight cents. From
the spectacular to the ordinary, children and youth made history.

10.19 Children in Edmonton protest rising prices in 1947.

Work continued to be a factor in most childrens lives. In the 1940s, some youth were self-supporting by the age
of 14. Neil Sutherlands work on the history of children and youth in British Columbia shows that as late as the
6
1960s, youth recall, we always had things to do. Indigenous children and youth in residential school always
worked more than they studied.

It is a painful irony, and it should not be ignored, that the century that invented childhood as a time of innocence
and dependence also endangered children and youth in unprecedented ways. Institutions that were established in
7
the name of protection, as Steven Maynard demonstrates, often locked danger in. Revelations about the brutal
and genocidal conditions in Residential schools were made as early as 1907 by the Indian Affairs medical officer

1. Growing Up Canadian, directed by Sheila Petzold and Susan Terrill, produced by Hoda Elatawi (Montreal: National Film Board, 2003)
[Link]
2. Dorothy Chunn. Boys Will Be Men, Girls Will be Mothers: The Legal Regulation of Childhood in Toronto and Vancouver. In Histories of
Canadian Children and Youth, ed. by Joy Parr and Nancy Janovicek (Don Mills: Oxford University Press, 2003): 188-206.
3. Cynthia Comacchio, Dominion of Youth: Adolescence and the Making of Modern Canada, 1920-1950 (Waterloo: Wilfrid Laurier Press,
2008).
4. Joy Parr. Labouring Children: British Immigrant Apprentices to Canada, 1869-1924 (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1994).
5. Tim Cook, He was Determined to Go: Underage Soldiers in the Canadian Expeditionary Force, Histoire Sociale, Social History 41.81
(2008): 41-74.
6. Neil Sutherland, We always had things to do: The Paid and Unpaid Work of Anglophone Children Between the 1920s and the 1960s.
Labour / Le Travail 25 (Spring 1990): 105-141.
7. Steven Maynard, Horrible Temptations: Sex, Men and Working-Class Male Youth in Urban Ontario, 1890-1935, Canadian Historical
Review 78. 2 (June 1997): 191-235.
 612 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION
8
P.H. Bryce, and disturbing disclosures continue to unfold in our own day. Richard Cardinals 1984 Diary of a
Mtis Child is a testament in a youths own words: policies and practices established for the protection of children
9
created suffering and have resulted in deadly harm.

The lives of children and youth were transformed over the course of the 20th century and not always in a good
way.

Questions for Discussion

What is the age of the historical subject in your head? Is adult the default historical subject?
What do children and youth gain over the course of the 20th century? What do children and youth lose?
In what ways did children and youth gain and lose power over the course of the 20th century?

Key Points

Childhood in the post-Confederation era changed over time, and its experience varied based on geo-
graphic and racialized context.
Childrens labour was a recognizable feature of life in Canadian households until after WWII.
Regulation of child labour was slow in coming, largely because the expectation was widespread that
childrens work was valuable in and of itself.
As early as the 1920s, the transformation of childhood into a period of dependence was visible.
The creation of more institutions and systems to regulate childhood too often created significant haz-
ards to the welfare of children.

Additional Readings
Adams, Mary Louise. The Trouble with Normal: Postwar Youth and the Making of Heterosexuality. Toronto: Uni-
versity of Toronto Press, 1997.

Dauda, Carol L. Childhood, Age of Consent and Moral Regulation in Canada and the UK. Contemporary Poli-
tics 16.3 (August 2010): 227-247.

Milloy, John S. A National Crime: The Canadian Government and the Residential School System, 1879 to 1986.
Winnipeg: University of Manitoba Press, 1999.

Parr, Joy and Nancy Janovicek. Eds. Histories of Canadian Children and [Link] Mills: Oxford University
Press, 2003.

8. Cindy Blackstock, Wanted: Moral Courage in Canadian Child Welfare, First Peoples Child & Family Review, 6.2 (2011): 35-46.
9. Richard Cardinal: Cry From the Diary of a Mtis Child, Directed by Alanis Obamsowin (Montreal: National Film Board, 1986).
 10.9 HISTORICIZING CHILDHOOD: THE CHANGING FORTUNES OF CHILDREN AND YOUTH IN CANADA 613

Parr, Joy. Ed. Childhood and Family in Canadian History. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1982.

Prentice, Alison. The School Promoters: Education and Social Class in Mid-Nineteenth Century Upper Canada.
Toronto: McClelland Stewart, 1977.

Rollings-Magnusson. Heavy Burdens on Small Shoulders: The Labour of Canadian Children on the Canadian
Prairies. Edmonton: University of Alberta Press, 2009.

Sutherland, Neil. Children in English-Canadian Society: Framing the Twentieth-Century Consensus. Waterloo:
Wilfrid Laurier University Press, 2000.

Truth and Reconciliation Commission. They Came for the Children: Canada, Aboriginal Peoples and Residential
Schools. 2012. [Link]

Attributions
Figure 8.18
Boy ploughing at Doctor Barnardos Industrial Farm (Online MIKAN no.3521627) by Library and Archives
Canada / PA-117285 is in the public domain.

Figure 8.19
EA-600-42a by Lenny Flank is in the public domain.
 10.10 Teenage Rampage

Another theme that recurs through the post-Confederation era and that played out mostly in urban areas is the pub-
lics fear of youth. Migration from the countryside into the cities from the 1860s brought children in tow and cre-
ated the demographic conditions for an explosion of young, dependent populations. Schooling was one response
to this development as a means to contain and channel the energies of children, and this became even more impor-
tant after the introduction of child labour laws that incrementally stripped economic purpose from children. Fear
of youth was, as well, a spur to the rational recreation movement of the late 19th century (explored in Section
10.16) and to the creation of a national militia. In 1913, before the Great War was fully on the horizon, the Min-
ister of the Militia Sam Hughes outlined his vision in this regard: he claimed that one purpose of military training
was to make the youth of Canada self-controlled, erect, decent and patriotic through military and physical train-
1
ing, instead of growing up as under present conditions of no control, into young ruffians or young gadabouts.
Prosperity in the 1920s and unemployment in the 1930s were both seen as contributing forces in the creation
of dangerous youths, and these were themes that were reinvested with urgency in the post-1945 period. From
zoot-suiters in the 1940s, through greasers in the 1950s, to hippies in the 1960s, the mid-20th century produced
2
a succession of caricatures of young men and women as deviant and disruptive. The creation of additional (and
freer) high schools and new post-secondary institutions were meant to absorb some of that unbridled energy as it
bubbled forth from the advancing baby boom. Historian Katharine Rollwagen comments on aspects of this moral
panic in Sections 10.11 and 10.12.

Inevitably these were principally urban concerns and they were bound up in modernity. The perceived weakening
of familial and clerical influences, the loss of the discipline associated with employment from an early age, the
appearance of too much leisure time, and the (presumably baleful) influence of popular culture through new media
like cinema, radio, television, and recorded music was the array of modern social features that connects Hughes
gadabouts to teenage hoodlums, juvenile delinquents, punk rockers, and late-20thcentury slackers. It also,
of course, played out in gendered ways, as women mothers were rather predictably held responsible for
deviant behaviour by the nations children. Finally, science notably in the form of psychology was mobilized
to address the issue of child and youth problems.

1. Quoted in Desmond Morton, A Military History of Canada, 5th edition (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 2007), 128.
2. Joan Sangster, Creating Social and Moral Citizens: Defining and Treating Delinquent Boys and Girls in English Canada, 1920-65, in Con-
testing Canadian Citizenship: Historical Readings, eds. Robert Adamoski, Dorothy E. Chunn, and Robert Menzies (Peterborough: Broad-
view Press, 2002): 338-9.

614
 10.10 TEENAGE RAMPAGE 615

Key Points

Growing numbers of children and youths, particularly in cities, fed a public fear of purposeless
young people who might pose a threat to property, values, and public order.
10.11 Historical Experiences of Adolescence at
Mid-century

KATHARINE ROLLWAGEN, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, VANCOUVER ISLAND UNIVERSITY

The idea that adolescence was a separate and vital stage of human development only emerged at the turn of the
20th century. By the end of the 1950s, when the largest cohort of children ever born in Canada reached adoles-
cence, the depiction of teenaged children as moody and rebellious was widespread, and psychologists and educa-
tors were publishing books to help parents understand, guide, and discipline their teenagers. Its likely that many
adolescents caused their parents no less and no more grief than they do today.

While kids these days may seem a timeless adult complaint, several aspects of adolescent experience changed
in mid-century Canada. One important change was the frequency of secondary school attendance and graduation.
In 1939 in Ontario, studies showed that for every 100 pupils that started school at age five, less than half reached
Grade 11 and only 12 finished high school. The secondary school curriculum was focused on academics and uni-
versity preparation, and at least half of teenagers left school as soon as they could, at age 16. In farming commu-
nities, boys education was often shortened or interrupted because their labour was needed on the farm; in urban
centres, working-class boys and girls continued to contribute to the family income, either through part-time or
full-time jobs. By 1951, the census recorded that 40% of young people aged 15 to 19 years were attending school.
More were obtaining high school diplomas than ever before.

Figure 10.20 The baby boom generation

stayed in school longer, causing
demand for new facilities and more
teachers. Laurentian High School, Ottawa,
1959.

As more young people remained in school, the high school became the institution most associated with teenagers

616
 10.11 HISTORICAL EXPERIENCES OF ADOLESCENCE AT MID-CENTURY 617

and with youth culture. The growing influence of youth culture was another important change in adolescent expe-
rience in mid-century Canada. High schools gathered more adolescents together, more often, and for longer peri-
ods than any other institution. In the postwar years, more Canadian high schools had sports teams, music bands,
and other extra-curricular activities to bring young people together. Since the 19th century, secondary school stu-
dents had fostered their own, age-based and class-based cultures; however, when fewer teenagers attended school,
the impact of that culture was not noticed beyond the schoolyard. By mid-century, adolescent trends, athletics,
and activities were widely reported in newspapers and magazines, and many adults from psychologists to jour-
nalists and medical doctors to advertising agencies saw the high school as the best laboratory in which to study
the habits, values, and desires of Canadian boys and girls. Teenaged behaviours were closely scrutinized and often
criticized as deviant and in the context of the Cold War potentially dangerous. For example, the media,
psychologists, and parents all questioned the teenaged trend towards going steady (developing longer and more
serious heterosexual relationships rather than dating a greater number of people). Teenagers claimed going steady
gave them the social advantage of always having a date, and that it relieved the economic pressure of spending
too much on social outings. Adults, on the other hand, worried that teenagers need to fit in reflected a tendency
towards social conformity that could undermine democracy.

Finally, if adolescence was prolonged, it ended more abruptly than it had for teenagers in previous generations.
School attendance, youth culture, and popular psychology encouraged the idea that the teenaged years were a dis-
tinct and crucial stage of personal development, but at the same time the generation that came of age in the 1950s
and 1960s reached conventional markers of maturity economic independence, marriage, employment much
sooner than their parents or grandparents. During the 1930s, unemployed young men riding the rails or populat-
ing the governments relief camps were unable to start their adult lives. Marriage and birth rates fell as couples
delayed starting families. In contrast, during and after World War II, the growing economy meant that high school
graduates and even drop-outs found jobs more quickly. A greater measure of economic security meant more
young people could marry at younger ages. In 1950, more than a third of all Canadian women were married by
the time they were 22 years old. Compare this to the first decade of the 21st century, in which only 10% of women
married before they were 25 years old.

Many adolescents at mid-century could look forward to greater access to education, more recreational opportuni-
ties, and a society that expected them to spend time with their peers, explore their own personalities, and delay
adult responsibilities. However, its worth remembering that many adolescents did not have these experiences.
Young First Nations boys and girls continued to have limited employment opportunities and were forced to attend
Residential schools, where many suffered physical, emotional, and sexual abuse. In Alberta and British Columbia,
several thousand adolescents defined as having developmental and physical disabilities were sexually sterilized,
sometimes without their knowledge or permission. Many more lived in institutions. Racial discrimination meant
that Chinese-Canadian, Japanese-Canadian and African-Canadian youth were rarely represented in the media, nor
targeted by retailers seeking teenaged customers. Historians strain to hear the voices of these adolescents in the
historical record, and little is yet known of their experiences of growing up.
618 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 10.21 The emergent norms

of teenagehood did not extend to
everyone. Angakkaq was born and
raised at Arviat on the west coast
of Hudsons Bay. She was in her
teens when she died of influenza in
the 1940s.

Key Points

Adolescence, as a stage of human development, was only widely recognized in the 20th century. It
was studied and increasingly treated as a problem for adults to solve.
Increased and prolonged enrollment in schools led to the creation of teenage culture and high
schools was the crucible in which that occurred.
Staying in school longer was enabled by an economy that could readily absorb young workers and
which thereby contributed to earlier and more widespread marriages.
Racialization of communities impacted the ability of many young Canadians to enjoy the opportuni-
ties made available to southern, urban, and European-Canadian teens.

Additional Readings
Comacchio, Cynthia. The Dominion of Youth: Adolescence and the Making of Modern Canada, 1920-1950.
Waterloo: Wilfrid Laurier University Press, 2006.

Sutherland, Neil. Growing Up: Childhood in English Canada from the Great War to the Age of Television.
Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1997.

Young in a Small Town (1967), produced for Camera West, a CBC television program.

Attributions
Figure 10.20
A geography class, Laurentian High School. Ottawa, Ont. (Online MIKAN no.4301846) by Library and
Archives Canada is in the public domain.

Figure 10.21
Young Inuit Woman [Angakkaq, born ca. 1928, daughter of Aliqqut, died as a teenager of influenza in the
 10.11 HISTORICAL EXPERIENCES OF ADOLESCENCE AT MID-CENTURY 619

1940s. Her brother Louis Angalik, born in 1938, still lives in Arviat.] (Online MIKAN no. 3576505) by D.B.
Marsh / Library and Archives Canada / e004665469 is in the public domain.
10.12 Youth and Moral Panics

KATHARINE ROLLWAGEN, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, VANCOUVER ISLAND UNIVERSITY

Sociologists use the term moral panic to describe what happens when a society overreacts to events or specific
behaviours, usually because there is a perceived threat to the social order. Exaggerated rhetoric from the media or
public figures can create the feeling that social morality is breaking down. During the 20th century, children were
the focus of moral panics over issues such as comic books, dance crazes, devil-worship, and unmarried pregnancy,
to name a few. In each case, young people were portrayed as victims amid calls for a new law or policy to reform
social morality and protect children. Casting youth in the role of victim makes sense when we remember that
Canadians increasingly saw young people as naturally innocent and easily corrupted. Many adults thus believed
children needed protection and separation from the mature, adult world. Children also represented the future of
the nation, both materially and symbolically, and so anything that threatened young people took on added signifi-
cance.

Moral panics can appear quaint, laughable, or simply unimportant in retrospect historians have been able to
demonstrate in several cases that exaggerated rhetoric and panic was unwarranted. However, historians can learn
from moral panics. Take comic books as an example. In the late 1940s, a group of Canadians educators, par-
ents, medical experts, and the media opposed comics that told graphic stories of crime, and called for such
comics to be outlawed. Comics were blamed for encouraging kids to be violent, prolonging illiteracy, and expos-
ing children to hidden sexual messages. Comics did not lead to the destruction of childrens minds and souls.
However, the opposition to them reveals a deeper social anxiety about how family life had changed during WWII.
The often-exaggerated concerns of adults also led to actual legislative changes that affected both those who made
comics and their youthful consumers. So, moral panics even if they overstate the extent, gravity, or outcomes
of a particular behaviour have consequences.

620
 10.12 YOUTH AND MORAL PANICS 621

Figure 10.22 Superior Publishers ran its own

line of comics until trade barriers made it
easier to reprint American titles for the
Canadian market.

Key Points

Moral panics related to childhood and youth may prove to be unwarranted but, in the moment, they
can produce substantive responses, as has been documented in historical studies.

Attributions
Figure 10.22
Mysteries #8 by Superior Publishers Limited is used under a CC-BY 3.0 license.
 10.13 Modern Culture

Figure 10.20 Descended from Black

Loyalists, the Nova Scotian vocalist Portia
White (1911-68) began singing in a Baptist
church choir and, in the 1940s, became
renowned for her command of European
classical and Negro spirituals.

Culture is a concept both widely understood and impossible to define. When it comes to music, entertainments,
the arts, and so on, the 20th century experienced a commodification of culture that alienated many of its forms
from day-to-day practitioners. One of the great themes of sport history is the transition from amateur athletics
(meaning top quality athletes who were sufficiently well off financially so they didnt seek compensation for play-
ing, running, rowing, or jumping) to professional athletics (originally a contemptuous term for men who were
paid to play and later a term associated with the highest caliber of physical prowess). The same could be said of
the arts generally in Canada. That is, they transitioned from an amateur phase to a professional one.

Historian of culture Maria Tippett has written of the late Victorian era as one that nurtured parlour-room musical
performances, local art exhibitions, and thousands of church choirs of many denominations. Because most
Anglo- and French-Canadians went to church every Sunday, its safe to say that they all either sang or heard
singing in the company of others at least once a week. Tippett describes the Jarvis Street Baptist Church of
Toronto, with its 250 voices in the early 1890s, as the basis for the professional and semi-professional perfor-
1
mance ensembles that emerged in the 20th century.

Although we tend to understand high culture or high style as elite art forms associated with the upper classes
and exemplified by opera, classical music and painting, and Shakespearean theatre, there is something of high
culture in those church choirs, too. That is, the form, sound, meaning, and purpose even the setting of choral
music was something that originated elsewhere, travelled around the world, was fairly rigid in that it wasnt really
locally modified (if at all), and was pretty much the same whether sung in Westminster or New Westminster, in

1. Maria Tippett, Making Culture: English-Canadian Institutions and the Arts before the Massey Commission (Toronto: University of Toronto
Press, 1990).

622
 10.13 MODERN CULTURE 623

Halifax, UK or Halifax, NS, in Paris or Parisville. Hymnal books provided a kind of corporate continuity within a
denominational and ethnic context across the globe. What, then, of local culture? Where were its shoots likely to
emerge?

Figure 10.21 Popular culture

(sometimes called low, low-brow, or
vernacular) began the process of
massification of culture in the
modern era. Daisy DAvara, pictured
here ca. 1909, was a dancehall girl in
the Klondike and a vaudeville
performer thereafter.

Canadas Got Talent

Jonathan Vance, a leading historian of Canadian culture at the University of Western Ontario, has argued that
the late 19th century witnessed the birth of a tension in Canadian society about cultural production. There was a
hope that, in creating a nation-state, Canadian culture would emerge and flourish. When French-Canadians heard
English-Canadians say culture they heard assimilation. The metaphorical ramparts around Fortress Quebec
remained up as a consequence. What is more, ultramontanism gave pre-enlightenment European art a leg-up in
Quebec, and European high-style was idealized. Meanwhile, in English Canada, the fetishizing of things British
persisted. The schooling system in English Canada celebrated British culture, idealized British history, and incul-
2
cated British values. And, of course, cultural growth in the expanding United States was producing an alterna-
tive and distinctive tradition of painters, sculptors, architects, writers, and even historians any of which could
be drawn upon by Canadian art buyers, governments, and readers.

Canadian artists, faced with these outward orientations, struggled to earn a crust. The idea of becoming a full-time
creator of music or statuary, paintings, or magazines in Canada was fraught with problems. The safest path was
to imitate the things that the Europeanists, Britophiles, and North American Continentalists admired and to avoid
the pigeonholing of originality. These constraints were fundamental in holding back the growth of an indigenous
English Canadian cultural form in the pre-1914 period. Similarly, the ultramontanist and conservative ideology
of many Quebec cultural leaders reinforced a rejection of the secular modernist imagination and the kind of cul-
tural experimentation that was going on in Paris. Quebec culture at the start of the 20th century was rooted in
the experience of New France and distinct from that of post-Revolutionary France; it stood apart in many ways
from Anglophone cultures, as much because of its aversion to modernism as for reasons of language and religion.
Canadian talent was trapped in an imitative blind alley.

Vance points out, too, the legal environment in which art was produced in the Victorian era. Copyright laws in
Canada did little to protect writers, whose works could be (and were) reproduced pirated by presses in

2. Jonathan F. Vance, A History of Canadian Culture (Don Mills: Oxford University Press, 2009), 168-9.
 624 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

the United States, Britain, and even by other Canadians. Cheap knock-off copies of three-cent popular fiction
the original pulp novels, so-named because they were made on low grade paper out-competed the origi-
nals, which sold for much closer to a dollar. A struggling Canadian writer might be able to get into the Dominion
market at seventy-five cents a copy but could not hope to attract the sort of sales and circulation that even rep-
3
utable publisher/pirates could generate. Nor could such a writer survive on pennies a copy. The establishment
of tariffs on American publications did something to shore up publishers in wartime in particular, but Canadian
presses struggled against both British and American novelists and poets who had strong markets at home. A Mark
Twain, Victor Hugo, or H.G. Wells could saturate the market while a Sara Jeanette Duncan, Ralph Connor, or
Lucy Maud Montgomery struggled to become recognized at home, let alone abroad. Not much would change in
this regard for English-Canadian writers of fiction and non-fiction before the middle of the 20th century.

French-Canadian writers might have fared differently. There was an opportunity there to build on an early 19th
century base and the histories of Franois-Xavier Garneau (1809-66), which predate Confederation, but the con-
servatism of the ultramontane establishment was powerful and effective in silencing modernist voices. Bishop
Ignace Bourget (1799-1885) initiated in 1858 what would become a 30-year campaign to destroy the liberal-
minded, anticlerical Institut Canadien (shuttered finally in 1885). What literature emerged in the early 20th cen-
tury was rural-focused and idealized a pre-industrial Quebec or, perhaps more accurately, one in which industry
was the exception. Although Montreal was the nations largest city, Quebec as a whole was more rural than urban
until 1941, which explains the anti-urban focus in literature to some extent. Phillipe Panneton (1895-1960) wrote
the novel Trente Arpents under the nom de plume Ringuet in 1938; the book was a landmark because it painted
rural life as one of repeated challenges above which the protagonists could not necessarily rise, and as part of a
world in which cities played a role. This was far from full-on modernist literature, but it broke out of Quebec with
a 1940 translation, won a Governor-Generals Award, and thus constitutes an early contribution to the develop-
ment of a national, pan-Canadian literature some 70 years after Confederation.

Figure 10.22 In the US market, Wilf Carter went by

the name Montana Slim but evidently composed
under his own name.

Modern Music
There are, of course, other avenues for artistic and cultural expression. The explosion of the folk art movement
in the early 20th century an expression of antimodernism fed the growth of fiddle music in the Atlantic
provinces and in Quebec and later the development of both country and western (originally and sometimes still
distinguished by loyal fans).

Wilf (Montana Slim) Carter (1904-96) is a common thread joining both the Maritime and Western traditions. Born
in Port Hilford, NS, he took up yodeling as a youth, left home at 15, and became an itinerant worker across the

3. ibid., 176-7.
 10.13 MODERN CULTURE 625

West, including a stint as a cowboy near Calgary. Singing while playing guitar something of an innovation
in its own right Carter is responsible for the links between Swiss yodeling and C&W vocals. His first radio
appearances in 1930 in Calgary were followed by a move to New York in the mid-1930s where he polished the
singing cowboy routine. Carter influenced his contemporaries including fellow Nova Scotian, Clarence (Hank)
Snow (1914-99) and other country and western (C&W) figures like the Maritimer/vagabond Charles Thomas
(Stompin Tom) Connors (1936-2013).

While these musical styles were rooted in vernacular forms that had, to some extent, developed locally in the
Maritimes, they were also an expression of the globalization of entertainment. The yodeling, for example, was
picked up from touring Swiss singers. And while performers like Snow and Carter were often antimodernist in
their focus on the virtues of rural life, they built early- and mid-20th century careers around the modern technolo-
gies of radio, recording, and television. They also felt it necessary to move to the United States in order to achieve
artistic success, a trend that would continue for generations (although in this respect, as in so many others, the
nationalistic Connors stood apart calling them out as turncoat Canadians).

Of all musical styles in the 20th century, no form is so associated with early modernism as jazz. Like folk/country,
jazz begins as a kind of vernacular form, spreading rapidly from New Orleans across North America. (It is worth
noting that early jazz contained elements of the French quadrille, and so is part of the legacy of New France.) The
jazz phenomenon was aided and abetted by railways that hurried performers from one venue and town to the next.
Vancouvers Patricia Hotel, for example, was home in the early interwar years to African-American jazz pioneers
Ferdinand (Jelly Roll) Morton (1890-1941) and Ada (Bricktop) Smith (1894-1984). Sustained by African-Cana-
dian communities in Montreal, Vancouver, and Toronto, jazz cross-fertilized other styles, including the big bands
of the era. Of these, the one that acquired the greatest fame and popularity is Guy Lombardo and His Royal Cana-
dians, led by Gaetano (Guy) Lombardo (1902-77) of London, Ontario.

Figure 10.23 The daughter of a

vaudevillian, Hamiltonian Florence
Lawrence is often described as the first
movie star.

Stage and Screen

The music halls and vaudeville theatres of the early 20th century were made possible by rapid urbanization and,
in return, were crucibles for talent and styles. Marie Dressler (1868-1934), Walter Huston (1883-1950), Flo-
rence Lawrence (ca.1890-1938), Mary Pickford (1892-1979), Raymond Burr (1917-93), and Yvonne de Carlo
(1922-2007) all learned their craft on the music hall stage in Canada before heading to success in Hollywood.
At the same time, a great many American and British actors (including Vincent Price, Jack Benny, and the Marx
Brothers) honed their skills touring Canadian theatres on their way to what was now, in the 20th century, called
stardom.
626 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

The dinner clubs and nightclubs of the major cities carried forward this tradition into the mid-20th century. As
entertainment overtook culture and became an industry in its own right, there were plenty of what was called
marquee talent or headliners whose musical or theatrical credentials were affirmed by appearances on live radio,
in movies, and beginning in the 1950s television. Entertainment was rapidly becoming a fully integrated
business and in every Canadian city (with the possible exception of Toronto), this was more fundamental to the
cultural lives of a greater number than professional ice hockey. Canadian talent like bebop musicians Moe Koff-
man (1928-2001) and Fraser MacPherson (1928-93) were part of a generation that benefited from this multi-urban
cultural ecology. Musicians had the further advantage of new recording technologies that took their performances
beyond the stage and even beyond live radio into canned performances on the air or into the home with the
diffusion of phonograph technology.

For the most part, these are examples of popular culture from the first half of the century. They were produced
for urban audiences, people who earned wages for a living. The suggestion that these kinds of entertainment can
be dismissed as escapist misses the point: they were meant to offer relief from lives of hard work, worry about
finances, wartime anxieties, and a rapidly changing, modernizing world. They were meant to provide distraction
and, yes, escape. If entertainments of this kind appear to us now, in retrospect, to be unsophisticated and stilted, it
has to be remembered that the years from the 1890s to 1939 saw the appearance of mediums of communication
and culture that had never before existed. These were years of unparalleled experimentation in music, film, and
theatre that would set the tone for the rest of the century. The energy generated by this new populist era provides,
as well, as stark contrast with the stagnation and limits of high style cultural practices like opera or the symphony
something that would generate increasing concerns by elites in the 1940s and 50s.

Figure 10.24 J.E.H. MacDonald was a founding

member of the Group of Seven. His Dark Autumn,
Rocky Mountains was painted in 1930.

Visual Arts
If writing, music, and film-making in Canada were limited by the size of the audience before WWII, that was not
the case for the fine arts. Some cultural productions will thrive in a marketplace dominated by wealthy patrons.
Such was the case of the Algonquin School, also known as the Group of Seven. Lawren Harris (1885-1970)
was heir to the Massey-Harris fortune (acquired in the production of agricultural implements and machinery) and
capable of acting as patron to the Group while being an active and gifted member himself. The thrust of their
philosophy was that the Canadian experience was intimately connected to the wild landscape and that the Groups
art, therefore, served a nationalistic purpose. The Group was 100% Anglo-Canadian and (despite the associa-
tion of non-member Emily Carr) 100% male. Influenced by the Symbolist movement in Europe and some of the
Expressionists, the Group of Sevens output was sufficiently accessible and the group so well connected that
their work became representative of the modern art movement as a whole in Canada. Based in Toronto, the Group
of Seven used their extensive social connections and their membership in the Arts and Letters Club of Toronto
(effectively a posh clubhouse for artists, writers, and performers) to advance their interests. The Art Gallery of
 10.13 MODERN CULTURE 627

Ontario and the National Gallery in Ottawa were quick to stock up on their work, displaying it approvingly as the
work of the nations leading artists.

Figure 10.25 Bertram Brookers Ascending

Forms, ca.1929.

There were many artists who did not fit within the Group of Seven paradigm. Their contemporaries in Montreal,
the Beaver Hall Group, was equally inclusive of women and men and more fully committed to a modernist and
urban sensibility that did not echo the Group of Sevens wilderness ideal of Canada. Abstract pioneers like Kath-
leen Munn (1887-1974) made connections with the Group but her outlook was simultaneously too modernist and
too international for their appetites. Her friend and fellow abstract painter, Bertram Brooker (1888-1955) had his
feet planted firmly in Canada, but also felt overshadowed by the Group, which he criticized in the 1930s as having
become the very orthodoxy against which they had once railed. The Group came in for further criticism from
artists in Montreal who rejected the nationalist aesthetic. The rival Eastern Group of Painters was established
in the 1930s and one of its members, John Lyman (1886-1967), championed its successor group, the Contempo-
rary Arts Society. These associations were, however, dominated by Anglophone artists. Further down the road
of modernist techniques, it was Les Automatistes led by Paul-mile Borduas (1905-60) who most fully embraced
abstract styles and did so as a critique of what they regarded as the repressive political culture of Maurice Dup-
lessis Quebec and the continuing influence of the Catholic Church on daily life in the province. The Automatistes
issued a manifesto in 1948 that was explicitly anticlerical, anti-religious, and anti-establishment. This document,
Le Refus global, remains a powerful example of the collision of modernist and antimodernist sentiment in the arts
and in society and is sometimes cited as a catalyst in Quebecs Quiet Revolution (discussed in Section 9.9).

Figure 10.26 Paul-mile Borduas

Composition 11, ca.1957.

Artists who were geographically, ethnically, or sexually on the margin of these central Canadian organizations
worked largely in isolation, influenced by what was becoming the dominant style while developing their own.
Of these artists, none is more deservedly well-known than Emily Carr (1871-1945), a British Columbian Post-
Impressionist artist whose lush and flowing canvases are populated by Northwest Coast housepoles and towering
cedars. While Tom Thomsons Jack Pine and Harris Lake and Mountains are typical of a Group of Seven view
in which people are conspicuous by their absence, Carrs paintings document and celebrate the interplay between
landscape and Aboriginal and contemporary societies. In her works, the environment is a place in which humans
must and do find their way and be neither dwarfed nor dumbstruck by it.
628 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 10.27 Kitwancool, 1928, by Emily

Carr.

Key Points

While high style cultural elements could be and were imported from abroad, Canadian artists
struggled in the first hundred years after Confederation to be recognized.
Those artists who neither imitated British, French, or American styles nor emigrated to make their
careers in larger, foreign markets, were constrained by the structure of the publication and perfor-
mance businesses in Canada, and a small and divided Canadian marketplace.
French-Canadian writers in particular turned away from urban and modernist themes and therefore
became too parochial for a national audience.
Musicians also took up antimodernist themes that celebrated the vernacular cultures of rural Canada,
although the most successful moved to the United States where opportunities were greater.
The links between urban performance venues enabled the circulation of modern musical innovations
like jazz and big bands, along with various stage performance styles.
Painting was an area where a few wealthy patrons could take the place of a mass market audience. In
that environment, artists associated with the Group of Seven thrived, producing a style that claimed
to reflect the wilderness as the basis of a distinctive Canadian culture.

Attributions
Figure 10.20
Portia White by Yousuf Karsh is in the public domain.

Figure 10.21
Signed photograph by Daisy DAvara of herself top-hatted in A Contented Woman (CVA 19-38) by City of
Vancouver Archives is in the public domain.

Figure 10.22
Wilf Carter, Montana Slim label, side 1 by Peter Zimmerman is used under a CC-BY 2.0 license.

Figure 10.23
Florence Lawrence02 1908 by Wisconsin Center for Film and Theatre Research is in the public domain.

Figure 10.24
Dark Autumn, Rocky Mountains James MacDonald by J.E.H. MacDonald is in the public domain.
 10.13 MODERN CULTURE 629

Figure 10.25
Bertram Brooker Ascending Forms by Bertram Brooker is in the public domain.

Figure 10.26
Composition 11 Borduas by La Serviette is used under a CC-BY-SA 3.0 license.

Figure 10.27
Emily Carr 1928 Kitwancool by Emily Carr is in the public domain.
10.14 A Culture under Siege?

Figure 10.28 Whats showing? An early cinema or nickelodeon,

so called because it cost a nickel (5 cents) to get in, on Queen
Street West in Toronto, ca. 1910.

Even as modern styles were stirring the pot of creativity and innovation in the first three decades of the century,
censorious clouds were gathering. The fear of the modern was expressed in antimodernist ways and through mod-
ern political movements that might, for example, admire scientific progress while simultaneously decrying the
emergence in the 1920s of the modern woman.

The Motion Picture Production Code (1930) in the United States tamed Hollywood movies so that popular cul-
ture would not be threatened by shifts in popular moral codes. While the Code had no impact on Canadian film-
making (such as it was at the time), it impacted the careers of Canadians in Hollywood and, of course, Canadians
experienced its effects whenever they visited a cinema.

This was the case, in part, because of the Americanization of Canadian culture. The movement of goods and ideas
never had much respect for the boundary lines between British North America and the United States, and the
20th century border was only more porous. Radio and, later, television signals swept back and forth across
the international frontier unimpeded. American listeners in the northern states picked up the few radio stations
producing signals in Canada, while Canadian audiences dialled in to programming that originated, principally, in
New York. It was then relayed through networks of private broadcasters to cities like Bangor, Duluth, or Spokane
from whence the AM waves worked their way into neighbouring provinces. Some American programming was
so popular in Canada that Canadian private stations carried the shows themselves. In many instances, American
radio station owners simply bought up private broadcasters in Canada and thus extended their reach.

630
 10.14 A CULTURE UNDER SIEGE? 631

Radio and TV Broadcasting

By Norm Fennema, Department of History, University of Victoria

As in the United States, radio broadcasting in Canada began in the early 1920s. Because radio use began
with mariners, licenses were initially available from the department of Marine and Fisheries for any
interested party, with payment of a $25.00 fee. By the mid 1920s, upwards of 30 commercial broadcast
licensees often churches or electrical equipment businesses operated limited daytime programming
in major centres such as Toronto and Montreal.
The impetus for a federal role grew in tandem with the growing availability and popularity of American
programming and the apparent chaos of the American commercial system. The formation in 1922 of the
British Broadcasting Corporation an early model of public ownership seemed to hold the promise
of aligning the broadcasting spectrum with its nation building potential. Action was hastened by a national
controversy over the cancellation of broadcasting rights of the Jehovahs Witnesses, operators of Canadas
first and only national network. An ensuing parliamentary firestorm was quelled by the governments
announcement of a Royal Commission on radio broadcasting the first of many.
The recommendation of the Aird Commission, named for the commission president, that broadcast-
ingbe placed on a basis of public service and that the stations providing a service of this kind should
be owned and operated by one national company was finally realized in the passage of the 1932 Broad-
1
casting Act, by which the Canadian Radio-Broadcasting Commission came into being. A major victory
in one of the hardest fought advocacy campaigns in Canadian history, the battle to realize the Commis-
sions vision was led by the indomitable patriot, socialist, and anti-American nationalist Graham Spry
2
(1900-1983). Mandated to regulate the existing commercial stations as their operations were being phased
out, the new public broadcaster formed an East-West system, partly through appropriation of the Canadian
National Railway Radio network, which included a French language service. Retooled as a Crown corpo-
ration in 1936, the rechristened Canadian Broadcasting Corporation was hamstrung by chronic under-
3
funding and the Depression. The original goal of a single public system was also contested by commercial
station owners through the Canadian Association of Broadcasters (CAB), whose lobbying efforts initiated
a battle that is played out to this day with the Friends of Canadian Broadcasting successor to Sprys
Canadian Radio League. The result was a hybrid system of public and private broadcasting, with the pub-
lic service continually mandated to provide a wide range of programming that informs, enlightens and
entertains and one that should be predominantly Canadian, serve the needs of the regions, be in English
4
and in French, and be available throughout Canada. Nationally popular programming such as Hockey
Night in Canada clearly fulfilled this mandate, while the French language Radio Canada helped engender
a renewed sense of Qubecois identity.
Reinjection of a nationalist raison dtre for broadcasting came in the context of renewed support for bilin-
gualism and the advancement of multiculturalism in the later 1960s. This resulted in a mandated minimum
of 60% Canadian content on television and 30% on radio for both systems. While leaders in news and
information programming, the much greater costs of television (20 times that of radio) meant CBC enter-
tainment and dramatic programming tended to compete poorly against American offerings.

1. Canada, Report of the Royal Commission on Radio Broadcasting, September 1929, in Roger Bird, Documents of Canadian Broadcasting
(Ottawa: Carleton University Press, 1988): 52.
2. Rose Potvin, Passion and Conviction: The Letters of Graham Spry (Regina: Canadian Plains Research Centre, 1992), 2, 79.
3. Mary Vipond, The Beginnings of Public Broadcasting in Canada: The CRBC, 1932-36, Canadian Journal of Communication, vol. 19,
issue 2 (1994): 155.
4. Broadcasting Act, subsection 3(1)(m).
 632 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

The CBC remains an important national institution, though dwarfed in size by the commercial system, still
without a guaranteed funding formula, and continually subjected to government cutbacks. Long-running
programs such as David Suzukis The Nature of Things (which began under Donald Ivey in 1960) and The
National are Canadian staples, and despite its loss of Hockey Night in Canada to Rogers Communications
in 2014, the network retains millions of viewers and experiences annual growth in online traffic.
A significant rationale for the existence of a public broadcaster was that it would provide that which a com-
mercial system would not. The Broadcasting Act of 1932 was a declaration of federal sovereignty over the
airwaves predicated on a conviction that radio broadcasting, in whatever form it might take, was a prima
facie public resource, a view that seems to still be supported by most Canadians.

Hollywood and the North

Cinema could have been different from radio. After all, cinemas were not obliged to show American films; and
the cans of motion picture reels, unlike radio programming, could be stopped at the border, if need be. Viewed by
not one government in Canada as worthy of investment or control, the American and (secondarily) British film
industries found their way into Canadian movie houses unobstructed. The worlds first national film production
office, the Canadian Government Motion Picture Bureau, was established in two stages from 1918 to 1923 and
from the start specialized in the news-reel style of film-making for national promotion purposes. Indeed, the first
movies made in Canada were overwhelmingly documentaries, some of them immigrant recruitment fodder about
life on the plains. Although fictional dramas followed early in the 20th century including some of the earliest
war movies, drawing on the 1660 Battle of Long Sault and the War of 1812 as source material these were to
prove exceptions to the rule. This early efflorescence was soon overwhelmed by American product, which was
something the Bureau actively encouraged. The first director of the Bureau, Bernard E. Norrish, was dismissive
of the possible success of a Canadian film industry, commenting that Canada had no more use for a large moving
5
picture studio than Hollywood had for a pulp mill. Other countries, recognizing the threat posed by Hollywood
to their own film artists, imposed quotas; nothing of that order occurred in Canada. Canadian cinemas were made
more deluxe this was the era of the movie palace so as to make the experience of moviegoing still more
escapist than the films subject matter. Hollywood might occasionally experiment with Canadian-themed movies
involving Mounties (some of them singing), but otherwise the experience of entering a darkened movie house in
Canada was much the same as it was in Des Moines, Iowa.

Figure 10.29 In 1945, the city centre cinemas were still

thriving. Shows were usually continuous, hence the
saying, this is where I came in.

By the late 1930s, there was not much left of the Canadian film business. It was with the nurturing of the docu-

5. Quoted in The History of the Canadian Film Industry, Historica Canada, accessed 10 December 2015, [Link]
[Link]/en/article/the-history-of-film-in-canada/.
 10.14 A CULTURE UNDER SIEGE? 633

mentary tradition in mind that the National Film Board (NFB) was established in 1939. Its mission was almost
immediately transformed by the outbreak of war. Still steering clear of fictional drama, the NFB now concentrated
on wartime propaganda. After WWII, efforts to build a Canadian film industry continued to fail. The consolida-
tion of the theatre chain system and its place in a vertically integrated Hollywood-based industry meant that the
major American studios controlled everything from story-pitch through production and distribution. Under these
circumstances, it was astonishingly difficult for a Canadian film to find a Canadian audience. By the late 1940s,
the Canadian film industry was another arena in which Canadian cultural sovereignty and health was becoming a
matter of some concern to policy makers as well as to artists, entrepreneurs, and social commentators.

The State and Culture in the Cold-War Era

Between them, the Group of Seven founder Lawren Harris and his contemporary and close friend Vincent Massey
(1887-1967) delivered the one-two punch of 20th-century Canadian culture. Both men were born in the 19th cen-
tury and were heirs to strong traditions of individualism and, more importantly, to the Massey-Harris industrial
fortune. Harris role in the founding and success of the Group of Seven is considered in Section 10.14. It was
Massey, however, who would advance the question of what was to be done about Canadian culture as a whole.

Massey played a managerial role at the family firm for a while before being drawn into politics by Mackenzie
King. By the mid-1920s while still in his early 40s Massey was playing important diplomatic roles for
Canada. In 1949, he was tasked by Prime Minister Louis St. Laurent with chairing the Royal Commission on
National Development in the Arts, Letters, and Sciences, eponymously known as the Massey Commission.

The Commission reflected growing concern on the part of government about the impact of American culture.
Even as Canada was gaining greater autonomy from Britain in constitutional and foreign affairs areas, there was
a growing reaction to the influence of the United States. Partly this was spurred on by the growing power of the
federal state. WWII had laid down the foundations of a vastly increased bureaucracy and government intervention
in the economy as well as in social and educational policy areas. The planning state could, quite naturally, extend
its reach to cultural concerns.

The Massey Report, issued in 1951, was both a response to American cultural imperialism and an alarm bell. It
legitimated government involvement in cultural institutions, laid out a game plan, and endorsed federal spend-
ing on post-secondary education for the first time. The Commissioners drew attention to the paucity of perfor-
mance venues for the high arts and the unlikelihood of all but a handful of artists earning a living from their craft
in Canada. American culture was saturating Canada and talented Canadians were heading south because in the
United States they could earn a living in the culture industries. Canadian genius went out with the tide and Disney
swept back in.

The Commissions recommendations resulted in the creation of the Canada Council for the Arts in 1957, which
stimulated the growth of both literature and research in the humanities and social sciences. This second role was
hived off in the 1970s into the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council (SSHRC). Leading figures in
the Liberal Party were not alone in their belief that Canadas newly won global prominence at the end of WWII
meant that the country should shed some of its outward backwardness and become more refined. They sought to
use culture as an instrument of a liberal and humanist nationalism and, conveniently, Americanization served as
a nice counterweight a palpable threat to the health of Canadian arts and letters. This provided a further
justification for Ottawas involvement and leadership in the field.
 634 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Critics of the Commission have jumped on their nationalism as a narrowing and necessarily proscriptive view
of Canada, one that held out little for people who came from cultures other than French and English. It has also
been dismissed as a bunch of stuffy college dons trying to force a good dollop of culchah down the throat of a
6
gagging Johnny Canuck. The Commissioners took pains to reassure Canadians that they had no interest in dic-
tating tastes; at the same time, their instincts ran strongly to high culture and large institutions. New homes for the
National Art Gallery and the National Library and Archives (now Library and Archives Canada) were called for
and eventually delivered; the NFB was beefed up; and money was made available for a generation of big theatres
that would be suitable for symphony orchestras, ballet performances, and serious theatre. The Commission also
indirectly encouraged investment and enthusiasm for the arts. The Winnipeg Ballet acquired the modifier Royal
two years after the Commission, and the Stratford Shakespeare Festival got underway in 1952. Cultural spokes-
people in Quebec were, however, particularly critical of the Commission, seeing it as an intrusion on the consti-
tutional space occupied by the provinces. Artists and consumers of art whose tastes were not those of the elites
were inevitably disappointed that the Commission had little to offer the culture of working Canadians. Finally,
the Commissions timing was such that it could not grasp fully the implications of the newest medium: television.
Finding ways to support Canadian literature, theatre, and humanist education and research was, at the end of the
day, an important investment in the development of a distinctive Canadian voice; failing to address the issue of
television was like leaving down the drawbridge.

The arrival on the scene of television in the early 1950s added a new technological wrinkle to the communications
and entertainment industry, effectively combining the radio industry with the film industry. The old radio giants
in the United States the Columbia Broadcasting System (CBS) and the National Broadcasting Company (NBC)
moved easily into the television market and enjoyed an immediate technological, talent, and distribution advan-
tage over all North American competitors, including the upstart American Broadcasting Corporation (ABC). The
CBC moved into television with fitful success based on its own national radio infrastructure and the cultivation
of teams of writers and performers in both English and French. Early television, however, depended heavily on
live performance and this presented enormous challenges in a country as wide as Canada. American broadcasters
moved more rapidly into taped/recorded programming, led by ABC. In the nearly twenty years between the first
appearance of television and the arrival of cable distribution in the late 1960s, American stations were as easy to
access as Canadian broadcasts in all of the large markets. Inevitably the CBC began purchasing taped editions of
American programming for broadcasting on their own channels within their own schedules.

The regulation of culture in the late 20th-century music industry is considered in Section 9.15. Canadian television
companies faced similar constraints on content and these were met without much enthusiasm or concern for qual-
ity. While Qubecois audiences were able to sustain locally made, French-language programming, English-Cana-
dian stations competed with expensively produced American dramas and comedies that could be purchased and
delivered more cheaply than the price of making something in Canada by Canadians. Some exceptions occurred,
including The Littlest Hobo (a Canadianization of Lassie), Quentin Durgens, MP (a political drama), and The
Beachcombers (which ran from 1972 to 1990), but most efforts faltered quickly. Some, like the notorious Trouble
with Tracy, were ostensibly produced at the lowest possible cost simply to satisfy regulators demands for Cana-
dian content. Documentaries and nature programs proved more durable, as did current events programs like W5,
which debuted in 1966. Childrens programming proved to be especially successful: both Chez Hlne and The
Friendly Giant first appeared in the 1950s and enjoyed very long runs.

6. Paul Litt, The Muses, the Masses, and the Massey Commission (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1992), 6.
 10.14 A CULTURE UNDER SIEGE? 635

These efforts could not, however, stem the tide of American television broadcasting. Even as the Massey Com-
missions recommendations were bearing fruit, they were doing so in the face of an increasingly suburbanized
populations infatuation with television. The history of communications, film, and broadcasting in Canada contin-
ues to reflect this bias that worked against an indigenous, homegrown creativity comparable to what one finds in
other English-speaking countries.

Key Points

Modern culture was increasingly dominated by electronic media like radio and television, both of
which were dominated in North America by manufacturers in the United States.
As Norm Fennema points out, attempts to regulate and stimulate the production of Canadian radio
and visual broadcasting began in the 1930s, with mixed results over the three decades that followed.
Cinema was not regulated and a branch plant system of American-owned screens in Canada ensured
the supremacy of American-produced movies.
The NFB gave Canadian filmmakers credibility, though principally in the field of documentaries.
State and elite concerns for the future of Canadian culture and for the threat of Americanization was
manifest in several forms, including the Massey Commission.
The Massey Report led to the creation of a cultural support infrastructure that put arts and academic
research funding into a kind of order. The kind of culture favoured by the Commission tended to be
highbrow, for which it was criticized.
Television escaped scrutiny for many years, by which time American programming dominated
Canadian television schedules, despite a few rare exceptions.

Attributions
Figure 10.28
Auditorium Theatre in Toronto by EraserGirl is in the public domain.

Figure 10.29
Strand Theatre box office showing advertising for The Last Chance by Jack Lindsay is in the public domain.
This image is available from City of Vancouver Archives under the reference number CVA 1184-2590.
10.15 The National Pastime(s)

Figure 10.30 Nothing says gentlemanly, amateur sports like

cricket, especially when its being played at Upper Canada
College. Social class barriers stood in the way of cricket
becoming the professional and commercialized product that it
became in other Commonwealth countries.

Canadians might agonize over American and other influences on their culture (they did, and they still do) but
one area that has remained largely exempt in that regard has been sports. Whether it is ice hockey or Canadian
football, issues of national cultural integrity are seldom as intense as they are with regards to content on radio or
television.

Robin Anderson and Russell Field explore aspects of sport history and the history of spectatorship in Sections
10.16 and 10.17. What both identify as critical in modern sports is the speed with which commercialization
became not only their defining feature but also the surest test of their quality: if you have to pay money to watch
it, it must be good. There were exceptions in the 20th century, and curling is merely the first that comes to mind.
Lacking the explosions of activity that made for good radio and difficult to professionalize until the late 20th cen-
tury, curling persisted as mostly a participant sport.

Figure 10.31 Enormously popular in places like Dartmouth, NS,

curling was nevertheless slow to professionalize. Even as an
amateur sport it had a low profile: it arrived at the Winter
Olympics in 1924 and then disappeared until 1998.

Of the masculine sports, Canadian rugbys two branches offer perhaps the greatest contrast. In the 1880s, college
teams from Ivy League institutions in the United States challenged Canadas premier university at the time
McGill in what started out as something very much like English rugby but which quickly acquired distinctive
features on both sides of the border. The mutated versions emerged as Canadian-rules and American-rules foot-

636
 10.15 THE NATIONAL PASTIME(S) 637
1
ball. The link between true rugby and the Canadian Football League is to be found on the Grey Cup itself, said to
be the oldest trophy in professional sports: it is awarded annually to the best team in the Canadian Rugby Union.
The cup has been stolen on at least two occasions: it is either a myth or a public secret that it was abducted by
members of the Canadian Rugby Union (aka: Rugby Canada). Both English rugby and Canadian rugby remained
amateur sports until the mid-1950s when the Canadian variant became the Canadian Football League (CFL), a
fully professional operation comprised of separate eastern and western unions. Rugby retreated to university cam-
puses and private clubs, although football by the mid-century had a grip on varsity sports as well.

Figure 10.32 Ottawa meets the Hamilton Tigers in a 1910

football game that looks a lot like rugby.

Lacrosse offers a contrary example of a sport that was widely played, quickly professionalized, and progressively
marginalized. Lacrosse enjoyed its best years as a spectator sport in the pre-1914 period. By the 1920s, the game
was moving indoors and was becoming professionalized, typically as an arm of existing pro-hockey teams like the
Canadiens, the Maple Leafs, and the Maroons. Despite the games current status as one of Canadas two national
sports, it has repeatedly failed commercially; clubs have folded and been revived, and it is sustained mostly by
a rabid (if small) fan base. What challenges lacrosse is the same thing that vexes the CFL: a limited television
market. The most profitable pro-leagues in North America have capitalized on advertising revenues to such an
extent that watching public sports in a private space (the home) has come to define the supporter experience for
Americans and Canadians. The size of a sports corporations profits were once tied to the number of fans they
could bring into an arena or stadium; that has not been the case since the 1960s for the NHL, American football,
or professional baseball.

As Anderson points out in Section 10.16, the history of Canadian sports is intensely gendered. The intersections
between the body, athleticism, the marketplace, and the crowd are facets of sports in the modern world that have
drawn attention from historians, and on which much research remains to be done.

Key Points

One of the features of the modern world is the rise of massified spectator sports. These shifted the
balance from the value of athleticism as a means to personal development to the commercial oppor-
tunities of arena sports and advertising revenues.

1. Robert A. Stebbins, Ambivalence at the Fifty-five-Yard Line: Transformation and Resistance in Canadian Football,The Beaver Bites
Back? American Popular Culture in Canada, eds. David H. Flaherty and Frank E. Manning (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queens Univer-
sity Press, 1993): 164-7.
638 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Attributions
Figure 10.30
Cricket, Upper Canada College, Forest Hill by Toronto History is used under a CC-BY 2.0 license.

Figure 10.31
Curling on a lake in Dartmouth, Nova Scotia, Canada, ca. 1897 by W.L. Bishop is in the public domain.

Figure 10.32
Ottawa and Hamilton Tigers football game (Online MIKAN no.3386005) by William James Topley / Library
and Archives Canada / PA-009601 is in the public domain.
10.16 Sport and Leisure in Post-Confederation Canada

ROBIN ANDERSON, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, UNIVERSITY OF THE FRASER VALLEY

Figure 10.33 A shinny match breaks out in 1919 Winnipeg.

The story of sport and leisure since the mid-19th century has been shaped by many factors, but three historical
processes stand out in particular. The first is social hegemony in sport, the process by which dominant groups
define the possibilities and limits on sport, leaving outlier groups having to struggle for inclusion. The second
is fan identification and representation, the process in which a sport grows from a haphazard set of localized
experiences to a phenomenon that fuels powerful allegiances to city, region, and nation. The third is commodifi-
cation, the process of turning what originally was an informal and voluntary set of sport and leisure practices into
a thoroughly commodified cultural marketplace. We will briefly look at each of these historical processes next.

Social Hegemony in Sport

As with most cultural activities, sport and leisure in the 19th and 20th centuries reflected the wider patterns of
existence, social hierarchy, and class behaviours of Canadians. While human societies have always displayed a
desire for play, organized sport with its emphasis on rational outcomes and fair play began in Great Britain in the
late 18th century and was exported to British North America in the early 19th century as an extension of the leisure
activities of the newly arrived British middle-class. Most historians agree that Montreals Anglophone middle-
class men defined many of the enduring structures and practices of organized sport across Canada by the middle
decades of the 19th century, including drafting the first rules of play, establishing the standard playing surfaces
and equipment, creating the first sport organizations, leagues and events, and articulating a set of middle-class
beliefs about the social and personal value of organized sport and leisure. Their vision of appropriate sport was a
limited one but one that lined up closely in its broad outlines with similar developments in Europe and the United
States.

While this relatively small group of sports-minded men had the money, leisure time, and social influence to define

639
640 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

much of the physical activity in the 19th century, less powerful groups were still able to play their games within
the nooks and crannies of rural and urban Canada. For instance, many of Canadas Aboriginal peoples continued
to play their traditional games, although some of these, like the richly complex and multipurpose Iroquoian stick
and ball game Tewaarathon, came under a re-forming process in the mid-19th century to become the standardized
and rationalized sport lacrosse to mimic other contained European field games. Ironically, many eastern-Canadian
Aboriginal communities embraced the simplified European game of lacrosse and used their superior fitness and
skills to regularly crush their white opponents. Other non-Anglo groups, including eastern European and Asian
immigrants in the late 19th century, faced similar challenges to maintain their sport and leisure practices in the face
of the dominant sport culture. And, while middle-class male enthusiasts refined the game of ice hockey, informal
varieties of shinny (ice hockey) continued to be played on frozen ponds by rural and working class Canadians.

Figure 10.34 A visiting British watercolourist attended a

Montreal v. Caughnawaga (Kahnawake) lacrosse match in ca.
1882-83 and painted six of the First Nations players.

Organized sport was also designed in the 19th century as something men did, and was defined as a training ground
for appropriate manhood. The masculinizing aims of sport shifted over time to reflect changes in the dominant
form of manhood, but the attachment of sport to men has always been its central feature. This had, and still has,
the effect of alienating some men who did not identify with the cultural messages around sport. And in much
greater numbers, women were overtly excluded from most organized sports. By the late 19th century, however,
women began to infiltrate and eventually demand equal access and resources within sport. The 1920s was a kind
of golden decade for female athletes; high-profile Olympians Fanny Bobbie Rosenfeld (1904-69), Myrtle Cook
(1902-85), and others simply represented the pinnacle of what were thousands of active women sports partici-
pants across the country. But the struggle was not over. Womens efforts to gain an equal foothold in sport would
continue through the 20th century in the face of ideological barriers about appropriate femininity, the supposed
limitations on the female body, and overt male resistance. We live in a world today where sport opportunities are
still heavily tipped in mens favour and where media sport culture functions like a virtual man cave.

Figure 10.35 Myrtle Cook crosses the line first in a 100-metre

heat at the 1928 Olympics.

Fan Identification and Representation

Notwithstanding the large crowds for sporting events in ancient Greece and Rome, there was a time more recently
when sport fans did not exist and no one thought they should. Modern organized sport began in the early 19th
century as private activities for the benefit of the participants alone. Over time, however, that changed. Sport spec-
tators, known as fans today, emerged as an important feature of sporting life and they came to identify local
 10.16 SPORT AND LEISURE IN POST-CONFEDERATION CANADA 641

sports teams and high profile athletes as representing them and their community. Sports historians refer to this
phenomenon as the representational value of sport, and its emergence parallels the growing commercialization
and professionalization of sport, and team sports in particular. Of course, Canada was not isolated from sporting
developments elsewhere. In Britain in the early 19th century, many of the enduring patterns of sport identity and
representation were established at competing public schools like Eton and Rugby; in the United States, profes-
sional baseball quickly took on representational value, following the American Civil War in the 1860s.

By the early 20th century, the notion of following your team was firmly established in Canada. And the energy
of this identification, combined with the pocketbooks of fans, helped to drive the growth of professional sports. In
Vancouver before the 1920s, as in most Canadian cities, three professional team sports field lacrosse, baseball,
and ice hockey competed for the attention and allegiance of local fans, albeit in more limited regional settings.
It was not until after WWII that city-based sport teams began to compete in leagues (such as the Canadian Football
League) that were truly national in scope. Even so, the NHL lost three Canadian teams between the wars, as the
league expanded into the United States in search of larger markets, and only added one the Vancouver Canucks
before 1979. By the end of the 20th century, team sport identification had become arguably the most powerful
communal attachment and experience that Canadians have. Today, the proliferation of local team jerseys worn as
flags to identify fan loyalty, the ubiquitous media saturation that accompanies the games, the huge amounts of
capital both real and emotional that are expended to support local teams demonstrate the apparently bound-
less power and appeal of sport representation. Ironically, however, the majority of players on the teams we choose
to represent us are not from our communities, and most leave once their playing days are over.

Figure 10.36 One jersey that never caught on. The womens
Fernie Swastikas (ca. 1922) wear a symbol that was not yet
associated with Nazism.

Arguably the most potent representational force in sport is its connection to nationalism. Sport nationalism was
slow to develop, and had to wait for the emergence and maturity of international sports organizations in the early
20th century. The modern Olympic Games, which began in 1896, first gave Canadians a taste of sport national-
ism during the interwar years, demonstrating that even amateur athletics had the power to capture sports repre-
sentational value. The 1928 Olympic Games produced sports heroes like two-time gold medalist sprinter Percy
Williams (1908-82) and the successful womens track and field team, the so-called Matchless Six. After the Sec-
ond World War, Canadas Olympic dreams shifted to the Winter Games, seen as more naturally suited to Canadas
northern character, with the success of skater Barbara Ann Scott (1928-2012) in 1948 and skier Nancy Greene
(b. 1943) in 1968. Canada would eventually host three Olympic Games, in Montreal (1976), Calgary (1988), and
Vancouver (2010), all of which became sites for intense national fervour and the rather dangerous emotional game
of placing the fate of the nation in the hands of a very few. Canadians were disappointed most of the time.

Even more than the Olympic Games, Canadian sport nationalism has focused on international hockey. For
most of the 20th century, the amateur code that governed most international sports organizations kept Canadas
best professional hockey players out of international competition. For generations, the National Hockey
642 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

League (NHL) operated in a North American bubble, but with the confidence that the best hockey players in the
world were those Canadians who toiled in the NHL. That began to change with the integrative forces of global-
ization from the 1960s onwards. In 1972, the NHL allowed its players to participate in an eight-game series with
the best players from the Soviet Union. The resulting Summit Series and all the drama that the heroic narrative
provided, capped by the iconic last-minute goal by Paul Henderson (b. 1943), became the high point of Canadian
sports nationalism and, in the minds of Canadians for several decades, the most important national event in the
countrys history. The importance of the Summit Series has begun to fade in the collective memory, but hockey
nationalism certainly has not. An estimated 16 million Canadians crowded around their television sets or joined
strangers in sport bars to watch both the Canadian womens and mens hockey teams win the 2010 Olympic gold
medal in front of home audiences in Vancouver.

Figure 10.37 Clint Praying Benny Benedict

(1892-1976) played for the Montreal Maroons, an
NHL team that was a casualty of the Depression.
Benedict pioneered the first goalie mask after
breaking his nose in a game against the crosstown
rival Canadiens.

Before Canadians hand their self-identity and emotional welfare over to the performance of hockey players, it
would be useful to remember several important points about hockey nationalism. First, no other country in the
world regards ice hockey as its most important national sport. In the United States, it is at best the fourth most pop-
ular team sport, and several other professional sports such as golf and NASCAR rate much higher in attendance
and viewership. When Canada won the two gold medals in Vancouver in 2010, both against American teams, the
Americans graciously complimented the Canadians and then went about their business. In some European coun-
tries, like Sweden, Finland, and Russia, hockey occupies an important place, but lags far behind football (soccer)
and other sports specific to their own sports heritage. Canada has chosen a sport to distinguish itself on the world
stage that no one else cares about, at least not nearly as much as Canadians do. Canadian accomplishments on the
soccer, rugby, or even cricket pitch would carry far more prestige on the worlds sporting stage.

We should also remember that a sport is an unusual and troubled way to define national character and purpose.
Canada is one of the few countries that holds up a game as a definer of what that country is. Some cultural histo-
rians and critics have argued that Canadas lack of coherent unity or any sense of collective values has forced it
to embrace an activity as a symbol of its essential nature. Some suggest Canadians are just lazy and wish to avoid
the conflicts that would accompany making those important choices. So, instead of choosing specific meaningful
ideals that reflect and shape what Canada is as a country a task that other countries have done Canadians
assign importance to the vagaries of a competitive game that presents conflicting messages to differing audiences,
one that is played by a small and diminishing minority of mostly boys and men, and a game whose elite perform-
ers and major decision makers choose to work in the United States.
 10.16 SPORT AND LEISURE IN POST-CONFEDERATION CANADA 643

Commodification
The final factor that shaped the evolution of sport and recreation commodification is arguably the most
important, and was probably unavoidable. The history of sport, after all, did not happen in a bubble, but rather par-
alleled the evolution of modern capitalism. As such, it has reflected the contours of social and cultural change that
accompanied the industrial revolution. So, the initial emergence of organized sport forms in the mid-19th century
has everything to do with the rise of industrial enterprise, the growth of wage labour, the expansion and increasing
demands of the marketplace, the rapid growth of urban areas, the proliferation of industrial technology (especially
advances in transportation), the invention of leisure time, and the growing confidence and recreational desires
of the middle-class. When we talk about sport commodification, we mean the commercialization of events, which
happened early, and the professionalization of players and athletes, which happened later and in some circles with
greater controversy.

Figure 10.38 Parallel universes. Amateur cricket in the

foreground and baseball a game at which one could make
money being played in Willowvale Park (now Christie Pits),
Toronto, 1920.

Right from the start, sport was attached to commercial opportunities, as enterprising individuals used athletic and
physical activities to generate money. One-time sporting events, including prize-fights, canoe races, impromptu
foot races, and strong-man competitions, were a common feature of 19th century Canadian life, and were almost
always used as opportunities for gambling. One odd but typical example was the so-called fat man races that
swept through Western Canada and the United States in the 1860s and 1870s. An advertisement in the Victoria
British Colonist newspaper from 1872 gave readers ample notice:

Novel Race: A match has been made between two well-known Fat Men of this town, to run a foot race on the Queens
birthday for 30 dollars a side. Beacon Hill [Park] will shake to its very base when these two great bodies are set in motion.
1
Timid persons are requested to leave town for the day.

Gambling helped fuel the process of commercialization in many sports in the 19th century. And with this eco-
nomic energy came sports professionalism, first with paid athletes in individual sports, and then, by the end of the
century, with professional rosters in team sports. The best known and certainly most colourful professional athlete
in 19th century Canada was the world single-sculls rowing champion Ned Hanlan (1855-1908). Hanlan grew up
in a working-class Irish family in the Toronto area and learned to row while helping his father illegally smug-
gle rum across Lake Ontario. After he mastered the new technology of the single-sculls sliding seat, a skill that
was crucial to his singular success, Hanlan went on to dominate the enormously popular rowing competitions in
Canada, the United States, and Britain in the 1880s. Hanlan and his backers knew how to milk the entertainment
value and gambling opportunities of a close and uncertain outcome, and quite often the consummate showman
Hanlan intentionally slowed down to make races appear closer than they actually were.

1. Ad from the British Colonist (Victoria, 1861), cited in Gary Kingston, "B.C.'s first "sports event" probably a cricket match," Vancouver Sun, (11 July 2008),
accessed 13 May 2016, [Link]
644 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 10.39 Ned Hanlan: Champion Sculler of the World, a

crayon and watercolour lithograph from 1880.

Sport historians are quick to remind us that even the strictest adherents of amateurism in the late 19th and early
20th centuries could not escape the needs of the marketplace, and even encouraged them. For instance, the Mon-
treal Amateur Athletic Association (MAAA), the first and most powerful multisport organization in Canada
before WWI, was formed in 1881 by Montreal middle-class sportsmen to pool capital to purchase land and club
facilities. If they wanted to stay afloat, the MAAA and other amateur organizations were going to have to come
to terms with the cash nexus. Money was needed for facility rentals, park development and the purchase of club-
houses, event expenses (including promotion and advertising), participant rewards and prizes, and the cost of
players equipment and team accessories. All sports organizations amateur included charged gate admission
to recover some or all of their related costs.

Amateur organizations like the MAAA were highly critical of professionalized team sports, which they saw as
debasing the true spirit of voluntary recreation and the ideals of sport for sports sake. The potent forces that came
to shape team sports, particularly the representational value of sport, 19th-century civic boosterism, and the over-
whelming need to win, led to the practice of hiring the best players. Most major team sports moved incrementally
from having the occasional paid player to stocking teams with dedicated professionals. By the early 20th century,
most team sports were ignoring the voices of amateurism as they counted paying spectators filing into the ball
parks, playing fields, and ice arenas across Canada.

Figure 10.40 The Vancouver Millionaires of 1913-14. Fred

Cyclone Taylor (2nd from right, back row) was a key figure on
the team and, also, in the Komagata Maru affair.

One early example of the possibilities of commodification in team sports was the Pacific Coast Hockey Associa-
tion (PCHA), a professional hockey operation that began in southwestern British Columbia by Frank and Lester
Patrick in 1911. The Patrick brothers are remembered as creative innovators in hockey history, bringing in a slew
of rule changes and practices that revolutionized the game, including the forward pass, the blue line, the use of
in-play line changes, and the post-season playoff format. However, the PCHA was also a prime example of a
fully commodified sports league. The Patricks owned and controlled every team in the PCHA, built state-of-the-
art arenas with artificial ice, and moved teams around frequently to maximize revenue. They stocked the league
with star players that were lured (some say raided) from the National Hockey Association (NHA), the leading
professional hockey league in eastern Canada that would become the National Hockey League (NHL) in 1917.
The best known of these star players was Edouard Newsey Lalonde (1887-1970) and Fred Cyclone Taylor
(1884-1979). Centralized team ownership meant that the Patricks could control player salaries and manipulate
team rosters to achieve parity in the league, two issues that vex professional leagues today. The stability and public
 10.16 SPORT AND LEISURE IN POST-CONFEDERATION CANADA 645

profile of the PCHA forced the NHA into a predictable east-west playoff structure for the Stanley Cup, effectively
ending the challenge cup format that was in place since 1893. As a result of the Patricks investments, the Van-
couver Millionaires were Stanley Cup champions in 1915, winning a best of three series from the Ottawa Senators
three games to none. The PCHAs Seattle Metropolitans would also win the Cup in 1917.

The opportunities for profit in sport increased exponentially in the second half of the 20th century. From the 1960s
onwards, Canadians experienced an acceleration of commodification as the marketplace entered every area of life.
Sport was part of this process. The revenue streams available to professional sports began to increase with televi-
sion coverage in the 1960s and the delivery of commercial advertising through sports entertainment. Rising ticket
prices to games reflected the higher income levels of certain segments of the Canadian population. Player salaries
also rose and soon escalated to keep step with the growing profits available in professional sports leagues. By the
1980s, sport commodification moved beyond television contracts and ticket revenues into retail sales and sponsor-
ship agreements. Today, professional sport is a foundational element of modern capitalism because its emotional
appeal is so easily attached to the capitalist marketplace.

The forces of sport commodification would eventually kill amateurism. The Olympic Games, or the Olympic
movement as advocates prefer to call it, positioned itself early in the 20th century as the global defender of ama-
teur principles. However, the lure of increased revenues for the Games after WWII proved too enticing even for
members of the International Olympic Committee (IOC), the appointed officials who governed the organiza-
tion. What began as relatively small television contracts for the Games in the mid-1950s soon mushroomed in
size to reflect profits to be made in media coverage. The IOC added sponsorship agreements to its revenue pool
in the 1980s, as giant corporations such as McDonalds, Coca-Cola, and Visa payed millions of dollars to be offi-
cial partners for the Games. Once the commercial door was blown open by huge amounts of corporate money, it
proved difficult to keep professionals out of the Games and maintain the principles of amateurism. For one, the
public demanded to see the best athletes perform, professional or not. To accommodate, in 1988 the IOC allowed
the international sports federations that governed each sport to define Olympic participation themselves. Most
would eventually choose to abandon the amateur code.

Figure 10.41 The survival of amateurism in sports narrowed to

events like the 1940 Highland Games in Antigonish. A kilted
stone-thrower in action.

Today, the Olympic Games stand as the quintessential example of a thoroughly commodified sports entity. Its
revenues rival the annual income of some countries, its commercial tentacles penetrate every market opportunity
imaginable, and its boardroom of lawyers vigilantly polices its trademarks and other marketable symbols. But of
course it is not alone. We uncritically admit today that modern sports organizations are businesses, first and fore-
most, and in so doing we allow them whatever latitude available to pursue their economic goals. However, we
usually fail to recognize the underlying context of expansionary capitalism that has moved sport and sport enter-
tainment into the centre of our lives. We also fail to see the gap that has developed between elite professional
sports celebrities and the rank-and-file sports fan.
646 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Key Points

Historians of sport observe that social hegemony works to privilege some activities and marginalize
others, which in Canada has meant the middle class definition of appropriate organized games was a
racialized and sexualized white and male space.
Spectator sports are historically tied to the notion of the representational value of the games, which
is tied to urbanization and the professionalization of playing.
Canadas obsession with ice hockey has eclipsed interest in sports with a far greater international
cachet.
Industrialization and urbanization contributed to the emergence of leisure time and the use of dispos-
able income to support sports enterprises. Sports became professionalized and turned into a com-
modity for sale.

Additional Readings
Bouchier, Nancy. For the Love of the Game: Amateur Sport in Small-Town Ontario. Montreal: McGill-Queens
University Press, 2003.

Burstyn, Varda. The Rites of Men: Manhood, Politics and the Culture of Sport. Toronto: University of Toronto
Press, 1999.

Hall, M. Ann. The Girl and the Game: A History of Womens Sport in Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto
Press, 2002.

Gruneau, Richard and Whitson, David. Hockey Night in Canada: Sports, Identities, and Cultural Politics.
Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1994.

Howell, Colin. Blood, Sweat, and Cheers: Sport and the Making of Modern Canada. Toronto: University of
Toronto Press, 2001.

Kidd, Bruce. The Struggle for Canadian Sport. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1996.

Morrow, Don and Wamsley, Kevin B. Sport in Canada: A History. 3rd Edition. Toronto: Oxford University Press,
2013.

Poulter, Gillian. Montreal and its Environs: Imaging a National Landscape, c. 1867-1885 Journal of Canadian
Studies 38:3 (2004): 69-100.

Attributions
Figure 10.33
Hockey (Online MIKAN no.3194100) by H.J. Woodside / Library and Archives Canada / C-079313 is in the
public domain.
 10.16 SPORT AND LEISURE IN POST-CONFEDERATION CANADA 647

Figure 10.34
Caughnawaga Indian Lacrosse players: study of five figures (Online MIKAN no. 3017355) by Library and
Archives Canada, Acc. No. R9266-224 Peter Winkworth Collection of Canadiana is in the public domain.

Figure 10.35
Myrtle Cook of Canada (left) winning a preliminary heat in the womens 100 metres race at the VIIIth Summer
Olympic Games (Online MIKAN no.3191809) by Library and Archives Canada / PA-150994 is in the public
domain.

Figure 10.36
Fernie Swastikas hockey team 1922 by Esemono is in the public domain.

Figure 10.37
Clint Benedict Montreal Maroons (Online MIKAN no.3653185) by Hockey Hall of Fame / Library and
Archives Canada / PA-048898 is in the public domain.

Figure 10.38
Cricket and baseball Willowvale Park by John Boyd Sr. is in the public domain. This image is available from
City of Toronto Archives under the archival code Fonds 1548, Series 393, Item 16432.

Figure 10.39
Edward (Ned) Hanlan (Online MIKAN no.3018711) by Library and Archives Canada, Acc. No. R9266-3343
Peter Winkworth Collection of Canadiana is in the public domain.

Figure 10.40
1914 Vancouver Millionaires by Stuart Thomson is in the public domain.

Figure 10.41
Highland Games, Antigonish, Aug. 1940, athlete throwing stone by Ronny Jaques is in the public domain. This
image is available from Library and Archives Canada under the reference number 4315254.
10.17 Commercial Sport and Spectating

RUSSELL FIELD, FACULTY OF KINESIOLOGY AND RECREATION MANAGEMENT, UNIVERSITY OF

MANITOBA

Figure 10.42 A full house at Maple Leaf Gardens, 1932. Note the
1930s-vintage jumbotron.

Modern sport emerged in the second half of the 19th century under the conditions of industrial capitalism in urban
contexts. Embraced by uppermiddle-class professional men, who had both leisure time and a belief that the prac-
tice of physical competition would inculcate the values and skills of civic leadership, early organized sport was
imbued with the ideologies and regulations of amateurism. The classed and gendered realities of amateur sport,
which was almost exclusively male until the 1920s, informed global movements such as the Olympics and con-
tinued to hold sway until the 1970s.

Despite the influence of middle-class notions of respectability in establishing the values of amateur sport, sporting
events were also included within the popular commercial amusements of the late-19th and early-20th centuries.
Often organized around one-off contests in individual sports such as rowing, boxing, foot-racing, and horse-
racing commercial sport was associated with disreputable practices such as drinking, gambling, and rowdy
behaviour among spectators. Moreover, the professional athletes who earned a living through such events were
castigated by amateur sport leaders as having sacrificed the character-building aspects of amateurism and the pur-
suit of sport for sports sake.

By the 1930s, the sanctification of professionalism as a marker of ability rather than a moral failing was well
underway. One of the most significant features of this shift were the spaces that were built to accommodate paying
customers (spectators), most prominently in the 1920s. In the decades prior, spectator behaviour was a significant
issue for entrepreneurs. Profit was tied to the respectability that was conferred upon the practice of spectating.
Indeed, one of the earliest appearances of women as sport spectators was the late-19th century creation of Ladies
Days at baseball grounds. (Baseball was one of the few team sports that did not attract the interest of amateur

648
 10.17 COMMERCIAL SPORT AND SPECTATING 649

sport leaders.) Women were admitted free to games in the hopes that their presence would improve the behaviour
of the men in the stands and on the field.

By the 1920s, the built-spaces for sport had evolved considerably. Consider the case of hockey in Toronto and
New York. Ontarios first artificial ice rink, Arena Gardens, opened in December, 1912 and had, according to the
Toronto Daily Star, room for 2,000 skaters and 7,000 spectators. Typical of arenas built in this era, when facili-
ties were intended as much for participation as spectating, Arena Gardens management set aside Friday nights for
public skating. Cultural and economic circumstances were markedly different for commercial hockey in Toronto
only two decades later, and public skating was not a feature of the arenas built in the 1920s to 1930s. The defining
feature of these new sporting palaces was that, above all, they catered to spectators interested in spending dispos-
able income on watching sporting events. The experience of the sport spectator did not occur within a vacuum,
but among an increasing array of consumption possibilities in the 1920s and 1930s. The building of sport spaces
needs to be understood alongside the construction of other major sites of public consumption in interwar cities,
including vaudeville theatres and music halls, cinemas for the new talking motion pictures, department stores,
and museums.

To compete in the burgeoning entertainment economy of the late 1920s, entrepreneurs located their arenas in
entertainment districts. The new Madison Square Garden, for example, was built in 1925 only a block from the
Broadway theatre district, far removed from its eponymous square. Investors in these facilities envisioned sport
spaces that would project an aura of middle-class respectability. Architects with experience designing non-sport-
ing spaces of consumption such as theatres and department stores were called upon to create these new arenas.
In both Toronto and New York, architects sought to gentrify the practice of sport spectating without eliminating
the possibility of distinctions within the arena. The nature of the seating, for example, was increasingly less com-
fortable as one travelled higher in the arena, and the building was designed to prevent spectators from moving
between the different tiers of seats.

Figure 10.43 Respectable but rough.

Entertainments at the newly erected Maple
Leaf Gardens are very masculine but also
overseen by fair-minded referees. Note that
the NHL banners include 10 teams (not the
so-called Original Six that survived the
Depression and WWII). From the Leafs first
match at Maple Leaf Gardens in 1931.

Into such spaces entrepreneurs hoped to attract a respectable middle-class spectator, one who was likely male but
who would feel that the new arena offered sufficient comfort to bring a female companion. An analysis of ticket
subscription records from the mid-1930s reveals that Maple Leaf Gardens attracted a crowd of middle-class men
and women. But the presence of a middle-class audience does not imply that its members always spectated in
respectable ways. The spectator experience cannot be easily distilled to a single experience indeed, it was a
pastiche of many different experiences. Former box-seat patrons at Maple Leaf Gardens recall the expectation to
650 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

be suitably (and formally) attired, while others who were located elsewhere in the arena remember the impact
that such demonstrations of respectability had on their own choices. By contrast, former spectators at Madison
Square Garden recall the highest tier of the arena being the denizen of the gallery gods. Designed with the narrow
confines of the boxing ring in mind, rather than the wider field of vision required for hockey, Madison Square
Gardens gallery required most patrons to stand, leaning forward, enjoying the spectacle in physical contact with
one another. Within this milieu, a culture of spectating unique within the arena developed from the practice of
racing upstairs to claim non-reserved seats to the insults and projectiles that were hurled.

Many spectators took pleasure in the spectacle that unfolded on the ice surface before them, both in the speed of
the game and its (often violent) physicality. But it was not the spectacle alone that attracted the spectator. For-
mer spectators recall the many ways in which hockey spectating was a social occasion: a parent taking a child to
his/her first game, a heterosexual couple going on a date, as well as couples choosing to attend with other cou-
ples. The dominant narrative is that many women entered arenas on the arms of the men escorting them to the
game. Despite this, there were women who went to hockey games at Maple Leaf Gardens in the interwar years
in the company of other women. One female spectator recalled how she and five companions, all female, went
to professional hockey games in Toronto every Saturday from 1925 to 1931. This dedicated group began spec-
tating prior to the opening of Maple Leaf Gardens in 1931, but, with the construction of the modern, new arena,
their weekly outings took on the air of an occasion as the sextet dressed in their finest each Saturday night. This
woman, whose grandson recounted this story, recalled the fashion show in the stands where she and her friends
sat in Maple Leaf Gardens gray seats, the cheapest seats, most distant from the ice. While sport spectating has
been constructed as a masculine pastime, in the new spaces of sport in the interwar years, women in Toronto also
used one of the citys most prominent public buildings as a site for their own socializing.

Key Points

The gentlemanly virtues of amateurism were at odds with the (largely working class) desire to be
paid to play (that is, professionalism). It was also at odds with gambling and more individualistic
sports like racing and fights.
The creation of modern arenas and stadia enabled the merchants of sports to present their products in
a more respectable environment that competed well against other entertainment options.
A barometer of respectability was the extent to which women felt welcome to the new arenas and
were eager to attend matches.

Additional Readings
Field, Russell. Constructing the Preferred Spectator: Arena Design and Operation and the Consumption of
Hockey in 1930s Toronto. The International Journal of the History of Sport, 25 (6), May 2008, 649-677.

Field, Russell. Theres more people here tonight than at a first night of the Metropolitan: Professional Hockey
Spectatorship in the 1920s in New York and Toronto. In Andrew Holman. (Ed.). Canadas Game: Hockey and
Identity. (Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 2009).
 10.17 COMMERCIAL SPORT AND SPECTATING 651

Howell, Colin. Blood, Sweat, and Cheers: Sport and the Making of Modern Canada (Toronto: University of
Toronto Press, 2001). See especially Chapter 3: Money.

Kidd, Bruce. The Struggle for Canadian Sport (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1996). See especially Chap-
ter 5: Brand-Name Hockey.

Attributions
Figure 10.42
Maple Leaf Gardens, Carlton St. north-west corner Church St.; Interior, Toronto, Ont. by Special Collections
Toronto Public Library is used under a CC-BY-SA 2.0 license.

Figure 10.43
MLG 1931w by Kordas is in the public domain.
 10.18 Tourism in 20th Century Canada

MICHAEL DAWSON, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, ST. THOMAS UNIVERSITY

Figure 10.44 Air travel for business and pleasure became more
common in the 1930s. Passengers at Vancouver Airport in 1937
get ready for a flight on United Air Lines Mainliner.

Mountains, lakes, totem poles, Mounties, moose, and a certain house said to have been inhabited by Anne of
Green Gables: what do these items all have in common? They have all become staples of Canadian guide books
and tourist itineraries.

Of course, sightseeing did not begin in the 20th century. Canada (and British North America before it) had long
been a popular destination for travellers keen to experience its natural wonders and pursue its animal life in the
hopes of demonstrating their skill and vigour in killing it. But the scope and scale of tourism in Canada expanded
dramatically over the course of the 20th century.

A number of factors facilitated this expansion.

First, technological advances played an important role as railways, roadways, and eventually air travel, dramati-
cally reduced travel times and encouraged visitors to embark upon more ambitious vacations. The invention of the
automobile was particularly transformative. Although an automobile was a rare sight in Canada at the beginning
1
of the 20th century, there were over 1 million cars traversing the countrys roads by the end of the 1920s. Gas
stations, motels, and diners quickly emerged to service automobile-propelled travellers.

Second, a relatively sustained period of economic growth from the late 1940s to the early 1970s ensured that
Canadians and international visitors possessed disposable income to spend on leisure travel.

1. In Search of the Canadian Car,accessed 8 September 2015 [Link]

1920/ . This was a North American phenomenon. See, for example, John A. Jakle, The Tourist: Travel in Twentieth-Century North America
(Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1985), Chapter 7.

652
 10.18 TOURISM IN 20TH CENTURY CANADA 653

Third, shifting attitudes toward leisure (from something to be mistrusted and frowned upon to something to be
embraced and celebrated) produced a social transformation that facilitated the expansion of Canadas tourism
industry. Canadians and international visitors thus secured increased opportunities to tour the country over the
course of the 20th century. But governments, too, played an important role. And the timing of government inter-
vention in the tourist industry is an important part of the story.

In the first three decades of the century, civic organizations and provincial authorities endeavoured to attract visi-
tors to their locales. Some of these bodies hoped that these visitors would return to settle as investors who would
bring agricultural and industrial wealth to their local communities. Others focused more directly on the money that
these visitors spent in the towns they visited and tried to maximize their immediate, short-term, economic impact.
The economic dislocation engendered by the Depression encouraged tourism promoters to focus their efforts even
more intently on maximizing tourists expenditures. At a time when jobs were scarce and retailers were desperate
to sell their wares, many observers argued, it made sense to encourage outsiders, especially Americans, to visit
2
Canadian communities, for in doing so they would be injecting outside money into local economies.

Pursuing this aim, many argued, required a coordinated and efficient campaign and thus the involvement of the
federal government. In response, Ottawa created the Canadian Travel Bureau in 1934. Tasked with expanding and
modernizing the nations tourist industry, the bureau offered advice to Canadian entrepreneurs keen to profit from
tourism, embarked upon hospitality campaigns that implored Canadians to treat visitors nicely, and orchestrated
3
publicity campaigns that aimed to lure tourists (especially Americans) to visit Canada.

Figure 10.45 Motor hotels (motels) were part of the commercial

infrastructure of the new tourism and car culture. Built in 1946 in
south Vancouver, 2400 Motel is a distinctive, bungalow-style
structure that was built, like other motels across North America,
along a major corridor.

Today, tourism plays a central role in Canadas economy. A recent estimate suggests that tourism is responsible,
4
directly or indirectly, for almost 1 in 10 Canadian jobs. This development did not happen overnight. It was,
instead, the product of important technological, economic, and social transformations over the course of the 20th
century that were, in turn, facilitated by consumer demand, entrepreneurial initiatives, and government support
and coordination.

2. On these competing yet overlapping rationales for tourism promotion campaigns, see Michael Dawson, Selling British Columbia: Tourism
and Consumer Culture, 1890-1970 (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2004), Chapter 2.
3. On the formation and development of the Canadian Travel Bureau, see Alisa Apostle, The Display of a Tourist Nation: Canada in Govern-
ment Film, 1945-1959, Journal of the Canadian Historical Association, 12, 1 (2001): 177-97, and Alisa Apostle, Canada, Vacations
Unlimited: The Canadian Government Tourism Industry, 1934-1959," Ph.D. dissertation. Queens University, 2003.
4. Tourism Industry Association of Canada, The Canadian Tourism Industry: A Special Report (Fall 2012), 7, accessed 8 September 2015
[Link] .
654 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Key Points

Tourism advanced in the modern era, helped along by improved modes of travel that included auto-
mobiles and aircraft.
Increased travel brought in its wake a service sector that provided fuel, food, and lodgings, as well as
tourist destinations.
Although there were signs of growth in this sector before 1945, after WWII it increased dramatically
thanks to greater disposable wealth in the population and more leisure time.
The involvement of government in the promotion of tourism from the 1930s established the industry
as a credible and lucrative source of incomes and jobs. Along with the technological, social, and eco-
nomic transformations that enabled the tourism phenomenon to occur, the expansion of the modern,
interventionist state played a role.

Attributions
Figure 10.44
DC-3A United Air Lines NC 16071 by James Crookall is in the public domain.

Figure 10.45
2400 Motel is in the pubic domain.
10.19 Summary

Figure 10.46 Eleanor Collins was one of mid-20th

century Canadas outstanding supper-club voices.

The modern world comes in many forms but it always travels in style. In the 19th century, countries around the
world did their level best to attract railway investment and to build efficient train lines. This was the case in the
industrializing world, and it was also the case in Africa, Latin America, and Asia. The CPR was, in that context,
part of a global fashion trend. In the 1950s and 1960s, as independence raced across the map of Africa in partic-
ular, colonial airlines were supplanted by national airlines, the newest and most modern expression of statehood
and technological sophistication. Whether their fleet of aircraft was large or small, the national airlines were sym-
bols of modern commerce, a certain kind of travelling glamour, and utterly dependent on the availability of skilled
technicians and petroleum. While these travel options were ramping up, the number of cruise ships on the high
seas fell precipitously. Sea travel by the mid-20th century had become plodding, inconvenient, and somehow very
19th century.

Modernity resists a concise definition, but we find its imprint across the 20th century, especially in the years
before the 1980s. It expresses itself in a kind of confidence that is shored up by validating measures like units sold,
crowd size, science (and quasi-science), media prominence, and distance from pre-modern and rural values. This
is why irreligion and the rise of stadium-venue evangelicals can co-exist on a continuum of modernism. It is how
we can speak of the hegemony of middle-class-style domesticity and the spread of divorce and female indepen-
dence as concurrently modern. It is how consuming the country through tourism and consuming country music
and folk culture could only happen in the modern era, even though they consistently reference the wilderness and
simpler, more bucolic times.

There were, as we have seen, antimodernist points of resistance. Some like hobby farming, scouting, weekend
hiking, and so on were largely benign and not very convincing; others, like the antimodernist sentiment of
conservative regimes in Quebec (as described in Chapter 9) were genuinely oppressive. However, even under
the archly Catholic Union Nationale or the conservative-protestant Social Credit regimes in Alberta and British
Columbia, the technocrats and urbanites had considerable influence.

655
656 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

The social, political, and intellectual movements and rebellions of the 1960s challenged many of the underpin-
nings of modernity. This is ironic insofar as it was the spread of good-paying jobs in an advanced industrial econ-
omy, better access to post-secondary education, and the communications infrastructure of modernity that enabled
it to be challenged. What followed was a change in national values and the beginnings of what would come to be
called postmodernism, a theme that is taken up in Chapter 12.

Hinged on values like progress, commercialization, and the growing influence of the nation-state, modernity is
also (importantly) a colonizing force: it colonizes its own people and it colonizes others. There is no way to under-
stand the processes of cultural and economic assimilation inflicted on Aboriginal populations in the 20th cen-
tury, outside of the paradigm of modernism. Schools, medical science, and bureaucratic management, as the next
chapter shows, were all complicit in the post-Confederation world of the First Nations; these were all modern
institutions. The reaction against these initiatives in the last generation of the 20th century was, therefore, both
postmodern and post-colonial.

Key Terms

abstract: An artistic technique that makes use of images that are not clearly representative of conven-
tional visual references.
Aird Commission: The Royal Commission on Radio Broadcasting, 1922 to 1932; recommended the
creation of what became the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC).
amateur: In the context of the history of modern sport, refers to athletes who do not accept pay to
play; also implies a middle- and upper-middle class ethos of fairplay and a hostility toward profession-
alism.
Arts and Crafts: The Arts and Crafts Movement was an anti-industrial and antimodernist decorative
tradition that looked to older hand-built styles of craftsmanship in visual arts, furniture, and domestic
architecture.
assembly line: Refers to manufacturing processes that are systematically organized; most often associ-
ated in the public mind with the building of automobiles.
Beaver Hall Group: A group of nearly two dozen painters based in Montreal whose modernist and
urban style was at odds with the Group of Sevens wilderness and nationalist abstractions.
big science: Associated with the large scale experiments and processes that became possible after the
Second World War.
British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC): Established in 1922, the BBC is a crown-owned public ser-
vice broadcaster. Its equivalent in Canada is the CBC.
Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC): In full, the CBC/Radio Canada; Public broadcasting sys-
tem established in 1932 following the recommendations of the Aird Commission; its status as a Crown
Corporation was clarified under the Canadian Broadcasting Act (1936); modelled in large measure on
the BBC.
Canadian Football League: Established in 1958 when Canadian-style rugby teams left the Canadian
Rugby Union to establish a nine-team professional league.
colour barriers: Racial segregation; specifically, the exclusion of people of colour from activities or
services enjoyed by European-Canadians.
 10.19 SUMMARY 657

commodification: In the context of the professionalization of sports and leisure, the process of turning
what originally was an informal and voluntary set of practices into a commodity to be bought and sold.
Contemporary Arts Society: Formed in 1939 in Montreal; lasted until the late 1940s; influential in its
production and advocacy for modern art.
Eastern Group of Painters: Established in Montreal in 1938.
escapist: Typically refers to entertainments that divert ones attention from banal features of everyday
life.
fan identification and representation: In the context of, principally, professional sports, the phenome-
non of fan allegiance to a team or player; manifest in the wearing of sports merchandise or loyalty to a
team or club, and consciously encouraged by local media.
fundamentalists: Any conservative theological movement that regards holy scripture as literal truth.
Group of Seven: A group of artists (also known as the Algonquin Group) who emphasized landscape
painting as the key to expressing Canadianness.
hegemony: The dominance of a set of ideas or a particular group or social class.
high culture (high style): Also called high style; refers to cultural activities associated with elites;
largely consistent across continents; spatially large with little differentiation (in contrast with vernacular
styles which are spatially narrow and come in many forms); examples include classical music, liturgies,
opera, many visual arts, and theatre.
high modernism, high modernity: A phase of modernism beginning in the interwar era and acceler-
ating during WWII; characterized by a deepened confidence in science and engineering. See also big
science.
Institut Canadien: Established in 1844 under the leadership of young francophone liberal professionals
(physicians, lawyers, notaries, teachers) who sought to enrich and secularize Canadien life; provided the
intellectual firepower of les Rouges.
International Olympic Committee (IOC): Established 1894; responsible for the organization and
operation of the Olympic Games (both winter and summer versions).
Les Automatistes: Surrealist painters and performers based in Montreal, 1942 to 1948; overlapped with
the Contemporary Art Society.
Montreal Amateur Athletic Association (MAAA): Created in 1881, a federation of non-professional
sports organizations, including bicycling, lacrosse, and ice hockey clubs; argued for a gentlemanly view
of athletics, one which built character and community; opposed to the professionalization of sports and
games.
moral panics: Public fears of declining values and worsening behaviours that could lead to social tur-
moil and/or crisis. Examples include temperance, anti-gambling crusades, the 1950s campaign against
comic books, and several recurring moral panics regarding adolescents.
Motion Picture Production Code (1930): Also called the Hays Code; operated until 1968; established
to address a public relations crisis in the film industry regarding risqu subject matter and scandals in
Hollywood; prescribed anodyne subject matter and self-censorship by filmmakers as regards profanity,
sex, nudity, and a long list of other perceived offences. It is worth noting that language, sexuality, and
humour had a much wider berth in the first 30 years of the century.
National Film Board (NFB): Established under the National Film Act, 1939 with a mandate to produce
658 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

propaganda films during wartime; subsequently a centre for creative excellence in documentary produc-
tion.
National Hockey Association (NHA): One of several early 20th-century professional hockey leagues
and the direct precursor of the National Hockey League.
National Hockey League (NHL): Established in 1917 after a dispute among team owners in the
National Hockey Association. It was, originally, an all-Canadian league but expanded in 1920 to Boston.
Its higher salaries and American market led to the decline and disappearance of other professional
leagues and the rise of an effective monopoly by the 1940s.
Pacific Coast Hockey Association (PCHA): One of several early 20th-century professional hockey
leagues; pioneered use of artificial ice in indoor arenas; merged with the Western Canada Hockey
League in 1924.
popular culture: Denotes arts, values, and ideas that are entrenched in a large slice of the population.
Popular in this respect signifies that it is both widely appreciated and desired, and generated by this
mainstream population. A 20th-century idea, it was sometimes referred to as pop culture in the later
20th century.
postmodern, postmodernism A complex of views arising in the late modernist period that questioned
the eras certainties, invited a skeptical analysis of conventions, focussed on pluralism rather than unity
(both politically and artistically); contains anti-modernist elements (such as the return to craft and arti-
sanal production) but is not otherwise anti-modern in the way that the original opponents to modernism
were.
professionalization: Generally, the creation of exclusive policies that limit entry into a particular busi-
ness or trade, such as the need for a teaching certificate from a recognized institution in order to become
a teacher; in sports, the phenomenon of paying players to play, which moved games and athleticism
away from the 19th century ideal of gentlemanly and unpaid (amateur) competition.
progress The view that the history of humanity is a constant movement forward toward a better and
better society.
rational recreation: A 19th-century response to the leisure activities of working people gambling,
competitions of strength, drinking, and low-brow performances which sought to replace these with
controlled, morally superior, and character-building (improving) activities.
representational value of sport: In the context of, principally, professional sports, the phenomenon of
athletes whose performance is seen by the community and by fans especially as representing the com-
munity and its members; applies to local and to national players/teams.
secularism: The separation of church and state; the belief that a modern state is best served by individ-
uals not directly associated with organized religion. See also anticlerical.
slumming: Colloquial for seeking recreation or entertainment in a locale that is associated with a lower
socio-economic class or different cultural group than ones own.
social hegemony: Influence enjoyed by one social group over all others; dominance in tastes, culture,
and values, among other indicators.
United Church of Canada: Created in 1925 as a result of a merger between three denominations: Con-
gregationalist, Methodist, and Presbyterian. Some members of each denomination remained outside of
the United Church but it was, nonetheless, immediately the third-largest denomination in Canada.
vernacular: In language, a local dialect; in design and cooking, styles developed in a specific locale
and which are, in the case of emigrants, transported to other locations intact where they are reproduced.
 10.19 SUMMARY 659

Examples of regional vernacular include Canadien stone houses influenced by the pre-Conquest era and,
among immigrants, Doukhobor communal housing.
welfare state: Initiatives taken on a large scale on the part of government to provide the population
with payments or services that ameliorate the worst effects of economic or social dislocation. Sometimes
called a social safety net.

Short Answer Exercises

1. What is modernity? In what ways can it be used to distinguish the mid-20th century from the Vic-
torian and the postmodern eras?
2. What resistance was mounted to modernity? What sources of authority were challenged by
modernity?
3. In what ways was consumerism part of something more than an economic model?
4. How were gendered roles changed in the modern era?
5. What role(s) did moral panics play in supporting and undermining modernity?
6. How was childhood changing in the 20th century?
7. In what ways were the arts changing in the modern era? What do they reveal about changing
social and national values?
8. What was the function and appeal of professionalizing and spectator sports?
9. How did tourism change in the 20th century?

Suggested Readings
Block, Tina. Religion, Irreligion, and the Difference Place Makes: The Case of the Postwar Pacific Northwest,
Histoire sociale/Social history, 43, Number 85 (Mai-May 2010): 1-30.

Nelson, Jennifer J. Panthers or Thieves: Racialized Knowledge and the Regulation of Africville, Journal of
Canadian Studies/Review dtudes Canadiennes, 45, Number 1 (Winter 2011): 121-42.

Rudy, Jarrett. Do You Have the Time?: Modernity, Democracy, and the Beginnings of Daylight Saving Time in
Montreal, 19071928, Canadian Historical Review, 93, Number 4 (December 2012): 531-54.

Sangster, Joan. Creating Social and Moral Citizens: Defining and Treating Delinquent Boys and Girls in English
Canada, 1920-65, in Contesting Canadian Citizenship: Historical Readings, Robert Adamoski, Dorothy E.
Chunn, and Robert Menzies, eds. Peterborough: Broadview Press, 2002.

Stanger-Ross, Jordan. Municipal Colonialism in Vancouver: City Planning and the Conflict over Indian
Reserves, 19281950s, Canadian Historical Review, 89, Number 4 (December 2008): 541-80.
660 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Swainger, Jonathan. Teen Trouble and Community Identity in Post-Second World War Northern British Colum-
bia, Journal of Canadian Studies/Review dtudes Canadiennes, 47, Number 2 (Spring 2013): 150-79.

White, Richard. Urban Renewal Revisited: Toronto, 1950 to 1970, Canadian Historical Review, 97, Number 1
(March 2016): 1-33.

Attributions
Figure 10.46
Eleanor Collins in South American costume (VPL Accession Number: 59988) by Vancouver Public Library is
in the public domain.
 PART 12

Chapter 11. First Nations from Indian Act to

Idle No More

661
11.1 Introduction

Figure 11.1 Tom Longboat (1887-1949)

was a legendary Onondaga distance
runner from the Six Nations Reserve in
Ontario. Given the experiences of
Aboriginal peoples in Canada over the
last 150 years, it seems right to start
with a marathoner.

The experiences of Aboriginal people since 1867 have appeared intermittently in the chapters of this history. As
what Laurier called Canadas century took shape, Canada became more urban and soon more modern; however,
most Aboriginal people did not travel this path. Overwhelmingly rural (insofar as the majority lived outside of city
limits), confined to reserves in many cases, excluded from the modern industrial and technological economy by
real and implicit barriers, mostly denied the fundamental rights of citizenship (including the vote), institutional-
ized and subjected to assimilationist policies while exposed to the worst expressions of racism, Aboriginal people
in Canada may be excused if they do not see themselves in the broad outlines of this countrys historic narrative.

Writing Aboriginal history presents many challenges. Most of the documentation that has been easily available
has come from sources whose job was to mainly manage or change or control First Nations. For structural and
systemic reasons, Aboriginal accounts have been fewer and further between. The effect of this limited Aboriginal
perspective has been the positioning of Aboriginal people as a community on which history has acted, rather than
as actors.

Opportunities to redress this stark imbalance have opened in the last 30 years. Aboriginal historians, traditional
oral accounts, and a succession of inquiries, royal commissions, court cases, and public hearings have given us
the privilege of access to Aboriginal voices from across the country. The effect has been to reposition Aboriginal
Canadians in the Canadian story, and to see that story, simultaneously, as a First Nations tale in which Canada is
a mostly external but consistently imposing participant. So, the challenge is to put First Nations, Mtis, and Inuit
at the centre of the story and Canada at the edge.

This chapter begins with a consideration of the First Nations population over 150 years. No group in what became

662
 11.1 INTRODUCTION 663

the provinces and territories of Canada has experienced such dramatic and confounding demographics. Subse-
quent sections explore aspects of the colonial relationship, attempting throughout to give priority to what Aborigi-
nal peoples thought they were pursuing. This approach involves a survey of the treaty process, efforts to assimilate
Aboriginal people into the economically and politically dominant non-Aboriginal society, and growing expres-
sions of frustration on the part of First Nations.

In the previous chapter, we explored aspects of modernity. The confidence that industrial urban society was the
emergent pinnacle of civilization and the preferred model of human relations drove Canadians to disregard and
attack alternative (alter-Native?) visions. As the modern gave way to the postmodern and as colonialism was con-
fronted by post-colonialism, awareness grew among Aboriginal peoples of the pathways that could restore and
nurture back to health traditional relations and beliefs while also sharpening modernist beliefs about human rights
into a weapon against the colonialists.

Aboriginal histories in the northern half of North America are complex. They include tales of resilience and
strength, but are sometimes so heavily laced with tragedy as to be unbearable. Due to the complex of jurisdictions
and the enormous differences between, for example, the Nuu-chah-nulth, Niitsitapi, and Nippising, one cannot
speak of one single history, although commonalities emerge. At the very least, one can say that Aboriginal his-
tories are the most effective way to understand Canada as a whole insofar as they hold up a mirror to both the
dominant society and the very idea of Canada in a way that no other histories can.

Learning Objectives

Assess the transformations of Aboriginal peoples resource bases since 1867.

Survey the main demographic changes in Aboriginal societies in the 20th century.
Describe the main contours of Aboriginal-Newcomer relations since 1867.
Identify the main features of the Treaties between Canada and Aboriginal peoples, and the issues
they have created.
Account for attempts to change Aboriginal economies through schools and farming.
Outline Aboriginal peoples response to Canadian colonialism since WWII, and assess its effects.
Describe and explain the changed political relationship between Aboriginal people and the Canadian
state since the 1990s.

Attributions
Figure 11.1
T Longboat, the Canadian runner Standing (HS85-10-18314) by Canadian Copyright Collection, Picturing
Canada Project, British Library is in the public domain.
 11.2 Environment and Colonialism

Figure 11.2 The Sinixt people of the Arrow Lakes controlled

salmon fisheries along the Columbia River system, including this
site at Fort Colville in what is now Washington State. Epidemics,
ranching, mining, industrial fisheries, and hydroelectric projects
reduced their numbers to such an extent that in 1956 they were
declared extinct by Ottawa, much to the chagrin of the Sinixt
still living in BC.

One of the more subtle features of colonialism is the way in which it creates environments that favour newcomers
over natives. NASA defines terraforming a staple of many science-fiction movies as the process of trans-
1
forming a hostile environment into one suitable for human life. But what kind of human life? If its European
human life, extensive grazing lands will be required for their dairy animals and meat herds, and even larger terri-
tories will be required for grain production and a variety of edible and non-edible crops that include tobacco and
cotton, among others.

European societies effectively terraformed North America to make it more amenable to their familiar and pre-
ferred food sources. By doing so, the kinds of animals and plants on which innumerable generations of Aborig-
inal peoples survived were reduced, removed, or eliminated. Bison herds, salal berries, camas roots, and many
other resources were chased off, burned away, or ploughed under to make way for beef cattle, strawberries, and
potatoes. This occurred in small plots across New France and British North America before 1867, and in the post-
Confederation years, the wholesale transformation of the Prairie West under the plough is one of the most rapid
and enormous examples of environmental colonialism in history. Accomplishing this required a reorganization of
the land itself (into lots), the addition of modern-era infrastructure (roads, rails, airports), and the development
of energy sources to keep this new economic order moving. From the mid-century to the present, hydroelectric-
ity projects have had the greatest impact on indigenous populations. The Columbia and Peace River projects in
British Columbia, Churchill Falls in Labrador, and the James Bay dams in northern Quebec have flooded more
than a million hectares of land. There have been cases (BCs Columbia Valley system, for example) where Euro-
Canadians have been displaced, but these are the exceptions that prove the rule. Mostly native land has been
terraformed so as to be unusable for anything other than the production of electricity.

1. Mars Team Online, accessed February 1, 2016, [Link]

664
 11.2 ENVIRONMENT AND COLONIALISM 665

Figure 11.3 By 1900 bison herds were virtually extinct, and their
rangeland was being converted to wheat fields.

Sometimes these changes have been less immediate but no less disastrous for Aboriginal economies and commu-
nities. The commercial salmon fishery in Georgia Strait (aka: the Salish Sea) in the early part of the 20th century
plundered the sockeye and spring runs so aggressively that fewer and fewer spawning fish made it into the Interior
along the Fraser and Thompson River systems. Communities that relied on these resources, and which had fewer
fallback alternatives, suffered from an industrialized fishery hundreds of miles away. However, the situation could
be worse: it is thought that the Sacramento River in California was the largest salmon spawning ground on the
west coast of North America in the 19th century, but today, the native fish are as good as extinct.

The loss of resources like salmon or bison is often used as a reason to relocate native communities. Having ter-
raformed Canada to suit the needs of the Euro-Canadian food and economic cultures, Canadian administrators
were tasked with finding spaces where alienated native people could be huddled together with alternative
resources or services delivered from the south. Thus, relocations and their consequent economic marginalization
became common themes in Aboriginal history in the 20th century.

Environmental historian Sean Kheraj (York University) describes how one mammal species bounced
back in a Europeanized environment.
666 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Key Points

Aboriginal people experienced the arrival Euro-Canadian agriculture and other industries as a
process that alienated land and food resources, as well as traditional spaces with more complex
meanings.
European food cultures have been historically incompatible with Aboriginal food resources.
The mega-projects of the 20th century displaced permanently large numbers of Aboriginal peoples
by utterly destroying their landscapes.

Attributions
Figure 11.2
PaulKane-BushCamp-ROM by Captmondo is in the public domain.

Figure 11.3
Herd of buffaloes in the National Park, Banff North West Territories, Canada Photo B (HS85-10-11286) by
Picturing Canada Project of the British Library is in the public domain.
 11.3 Natives by the Numbers

Figure 11.4 This is a strange pastiche from a pre-Photoshop era.

What The Evening of his Race conveys, however, is the belief
of many non-Aboriginals that First Nations days were numbered.

In the 19th century, Karl Marx predicted the withering away of the state, and John A. Macdonald and his contem-
poraries predicted the withering away of Aboriginal peoples.

Many non-Aboriginal people anticipated that it would be a matter of only a few generations until the First Nations
of Canada ceased to be. Some Native people would sacrifice their status and be assimilated into the mainstream
of Canadian society, but the bulk would simply perish. Viewed in this light, it is necessary to understand the ini-
tiatives like the treaties, reserves, and the industrial schools as temporary measures that would not be needed for
long. Why invest heavily in an educational system that wont be necessary in 20 years?

From where did this expectation of a vanishing population arise? Although the mid-19th century saw an improved
understanding of infectious diseases, it didnt do much to stop their spread. Germ theory was just beginning to
gain a toehold, and the prevention and cure of some illnesses was coming within reach. The Euro-Canadian pop-
ulation would experience enormous benefits from this revolution in medical science, but Aboriginal peoples did
not. Indeed, the non-Aboriginals tasked with the guardianship role envisioned by Ottawa were often misguided
in their understanding of how health sciences operated. Missionaries in the mid- and late-19th century debated
the health advantages of intermarriage between Aboriginal peoples and non-Natives. According to one historian,
the Moravian Church in Labrador during the 1860s began to sanction intermarriage on the grounds that Euro-
1
pean blood, with its resistance to Western diseases, might protect the Inuit from extinction. It certainly didnt
make much difference elsewhere. Exotic diseases were still having a severe impact on Aboriginal populations,
even where there had been decades of intermarriage. Smallpox was by no means done at the end of the 19th cen-
tury; as recently as 1862-1863, the last great smallpox epidemic burned through British Columbian Aboriginal
populations, claiming upwards of 20,000 lives. The Haida, to take one specific case, numbered in excess of 8,400
in 1840 and barely 1,600 in 1881; the Heiltsuk, to take another, were reckoned to total more than 2,000 in 1835

1. Lynne D. Fitzhugh, The Labradorians: Voices from the Land of Cain (St. Johns, NF: Breakwater, 1999), 250-251.

667
 668 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

and only 204 in 1890. The loss of access to resources that occurred around the same time on the West Coast and
the plains, in particular as settler societies arrived, reduced Aboriginal peoples access to traditional foods, and
thus povertys grip intensified and Aboriginal people became malnourished. This cycle was repeated for much of
the next century: vulnerability led to death; deaths led to dispossession; dispossession created greater vulnerabil-
ity; and so on.

An Overview
Canadians understanding of Aboriginal population numbers is somewhat akin to looking through the wrong end
of the telescope. Resettlement of the Prairies and British Columbia occurred when native numbers were already
slashed. However, historians disagree over the pre-contact demography of Canada. Only a few years ago, scholars
spoke with confidence of a probable 100,000 Aboriginals in what became Canada, but now moderate estimates
suggests that there were three to five times that number in the Pacific Northwest alone. By 1867, however, the
total number of First Nations was about 125,000, including roughly 10,000 Mtis in the West and 2,000 Inuit in
the North.

These numbers were not stable. Aboriginal demographics worsened up until the 1920s. Population numbers bot-
tomed out reached their nadir in most communities sometime between the 1890s and the interwar era, and
then began a slow but steady recovery. From 113,724 in 1921, the total more than doubled by 1951 and surpassed
2
half a million in 1971. The 1996 Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples used a more restrictive definition of
Aboriginal but, even so, it observed population increases of 42% from 1961 to 1971, 57% from 1971 to 1981, and
3
nearly 47% from 1981 to 1991.

This 20th century turn-around was fuelled by high fertility rates and came in the face of terrible health conditions.
Even at the end of the 20th century, by which time the fertility transition saw overall Canadian fertility drop to
below 2.1 births per woman (which is to say, below replacement levels), it was comfortably in the 3.0 range on
reserves. In the 1960s, the Aboriginal crude birth rate stood at 47 per 1,000 population, falling to 28 per 1,000 by
4
1980, and rebounding a little to 29.5 in 1991. Aboriginal fertility rates have resisted global and Canadian trends
toward smaller families in part because of socio-economic factors: educational attainment for mothers in par-
ticular is a strong predictor of life-time fertility and, generally, Aboriginal females have had fewer opportuni-
ties in this respect than non-Aboriginal women. Poverty, artificial and racist barriers to secondary education, and
cultural disinclinations to stay in school (partly a product of the dismal record of residential schools) contributed
to higher fertility throughout the 20th century and into the new millennium.

Having more babies, however, is only part of the equation. While there were additions (few of which, incidentally,
came from immigration unlike in a newcomer society), there were also significant subtractions. Poverty and
malnutrition, along with overcrowding on reserves, poor state-provided housing, and cramped living conditions
among children in residential schools were ideal circumstances for the spread of epidemic tuberculosis (TB).
Well-established within Aboriginal communities in the East by 1800, TB spread to the West Coast in the early
19th century, the Plains during the railway boom, the sub-Arctic in the early 20th century, and the Arctic soon
thereafter. Mortality rates were at record levels. Tuberculosis is more conventionally known as a disease associ-

2. Statistics Canada, Historical Statistics of Canada, 2nd ed., ed. F. H. Leacy (Ottawa, ON: Statistics Canada, 1983), A154-184.
3. Lance W. Roberts, Rodney A. Clifton, Barry Ferguson, Karen Kampen, and Simon Langlois, eds. Recent Social Trends in Canada,
1960-2000 (Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 2005), 32.
4. Juhee Suwal and Frank Trovato, Canadian Aboriginal Fertility, Canadian Studies in Population 25, no. 1 (1998): 75.
 11.3 NATIVES BY THE NUMBERS 669

ated with rapid urbanization, tenement housing, and slums, but its toll in industrializing Europe was surpassed
by rural, isolated Aboriginal communities. Fully 700 per 100,000 population died in First Nations communities
in the 1930s and 1940s and, even though this ranks as one of the worst rates recorded, it is utterly eclipsed by
5
the 8,000 per 100,000 mortality recorded in residential schools. By the 1950s, the TB epidemic among Inuit had
affected a third of the population, many of whom were sent south for treatment (that included surgical draining
of the lungs and the removal of ribs). It was not until advances in antibiotics and specifically the development of
streptomycin in the mid-1950s that mortality rates fell among Aboriginal peoples (the rest of Canadian society
already had experienced enough socio-economic improvements to reduce its mortality rates).

Removal and resettlement confounds any effort at a continuous demography of Aboriginal peoples. Although the
First Nations that signed (took) treaties had the expectation that the Canadians would provide medicine and
would exercise a guardian-like role, the colonial authorities proved incapable of settling on a consistent defi-
nition of aboriginal. Repeated efforts on the part of Canada to reduce its obligations produced fluid categories
and a shell-and-pea approach to counting people in Aboriginal communities. Doing so left Aboriginal peoples
exposed to health crises and, from the demographers perspective, continues to vex any understanding of the pop-
ulation history of Aboriginal peoples. Status and non-Status categories make matters slippery enough, but Mtis
self-identification compounds things considerably. From a fraction of the total in the pre-WWII period, Mtis, as
6
a share of the Aboriginal total, have leapt to 32%. Changes to the legal definition of Status and the reinstatement
of Aboriginal women and their children as Status Indians beginning in 1985 gave a major boost to Aboriginal
numbers and demonstrates: a) the arbitrariness of this census category, b) the way it was used by government to
give the false impression of declining numbers, and c) a sense of how badly undercounted Aboriginal populations
may have been in the 100 years after the Indian Act.

Other significant changes include growth in urban Aboriginal numbers. Winnipegs Aboriginal population, to take
7
one example, quadrupled from 1985 to 2010, rising to 10% of the citys total population. In the cities as well as
in rural areas, this population continues to be young: roughly one-quarter of the Aboriginal population is under
15 years of age, which reflects the high fertility rates that have pulled Aboriginal numbers up from the 1920s
nadir levels. It also reflects the high rates of morbidity and lower life expectancies of Aboriginal people. In 1975
Aboriginal males had a projected life expectancy of 59.2 years, whereas Canadian males generally were at 70.3
years. The gap closed significantly by 2000 to 69.5 and 76.0 years respectively, but the distribution of elders is
still starkly different: non-Aboriginals over 75 years of age constitute close to 6% of the non-Aboriginal popula-
tion, whereas Aboriginal elders constitute less than 1% of their population.

Mtis Populations
The significant Mtis presence in the West was almost overwhelmed after the defeat of the Northwest Rebellion
in 1885. Just as the Canadianization of Red River squeezed the Mtis out of southern Manitoba and into the
Saskatchewan River Valleys, the hanging of Riel was followed with further movement to the north and west. The
Mtis diaspora retained roots in what would become the province of Saskatchewan, although greater and greater

5. "TB and Aboriginal People," Canadian Public Health Association, accessed February 11, 2016, [Link]
achievements/02-id/[Link].
6. Statistics Canada, Aboriginal Peoples in Canada: First Nations People, Metis and Inuit, National Household Survey, 2011, Catalogue no.
99-011-X2011001 (Ottawa: Minister of Industry, 2013): 6.
7. Indigenous and Northern Affairs Canada, Fact Sheet - Urban Aboriginal Population in Canada, accessed February 11,
2016, [Link]
 670 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

numbers moved into Alberta. In 1900 Treaty 8 provided land grants to Mtis in the north, but poverty obliged
many to sacrifice those gains to make some ready cash.

At this time, the Mtis occupied an administrative and legal space that was neither as good nor as bad as that of
First Nations. They had little in the way of Treaty rights, but they were not as heavily administered as Reserve
bands. Racial discrimination was an increasing concern as the category of half-breed once almost a neutral
descriptor became a term of contempt. The ongoing Mtis relationship with the Catholic Church and allies in
Quebec, however, was both fortuitous and a strategy for survival in the emergent Canadian nation. Openness to
supporters and reinforcements in fact brought changes to the Mtis in the 20th century. In prairie communities
where the presence of Mtis francophones and the clergy attracted Qubecois settlers, the Mtis Canadien tradi-
tions and French identity became of greater importance; however, in those areas where connections with the Cree
were stronger, an Aboriginal identity became more apparent. These were only two of several emergent divisions
across Mtis communities in the West. The New Nation struggled with definitions that made it simultaneously
more and less inclusive. Was being Mtis a category into which anyone of mixed ancestry might fit or was it a
hybridized culture that was more than the sum of its Plains Native and Franco-Canadien parts?

Beginning in the 1930s, Mtis organizations emerged and gained traction politically. Although membership
inevitably included individuals who had Indian Status, most Mtis do not. For this reason, many Mtis have
not viewed organizations like the Native Indian Brotherhood bodies as sufficiently representative of Mtis inter-
ests. Nevertheless, inclusion in Section 35 of the Constitution Act of 1982 as Aboriginal peoples with legally
entrenched rights has presented an opportunity. There are now more than 400,000 Canadians who identify as
Mtis.

The Return of the Native

Bulked up Mtis numbers are only part of the current picture. In the 10 years after 1996, the number of Canadians
who identify themselves as Aboriginal in the census expanded from slightly under 800,000 to 1,172,790. What
happened after 1996? The changes that Bill C-31 (1985) introduced with respect to Status took a while to process,
8
but led inexorably to identity mobility. This was coupled with a growing emphasis on Aboriginal community
recovery, enthusiasm for reviving languages, and greater public awareness of First Nations issues. Although the
law and colonialism had dissuaded Aboriginals from claiming this identity in the past, the circumstances had
changed. The resumption of the mandatory long-form census in 2016 will likely reveal a continuing growth curve,
although possibly less dramatic. The reappearance of Aboriginal numbers at the millennium may well have been
a one-shot increase, although fertility rates remain outstanding.

Key Points

Aboriginal populations were declining severely until they reached their nadir in the years between
1890 and 1930.

8. Lisa Monchalin, The Colonial Problem: An Indigenous Perspective on Crime and Punishment in Canada (Toronto, ON: University of
Toronto Press, 2016), 8-9.
 11.3 NATIVES BY THE NUMBERS 671

Depopulation, which was accelerating in the late 19th century and made worse by TB in the early
20th, impacted Aboriginal peoples view of colonization and Canadas view of Native people.
Accessing reliable numbers of Aboriginal populations after Confederation is complicated by cate-
gories like Status and non-Status, relocation projects, and differing understandings of who qualified
as Mtis.
Population recovery in the 20th century has been aggressive, even though it has had to counter high
mortality rates and low life expectancy rates.
Aboriginal numbers in urban areas increased in the late 20th century as more First Nations, Inuit,
and Mtis people moved into cities and as those urban populations themselves experienced natural
increase (that is, births over deaths).

Attributions
Figure 11.4
The evening of his race (HS85-10-27674) by Picturing Canada Project of the British Library is in the public
domain.
 11.4 Aboriginal Newcomer Relations before
Confederation

JENNIFER PETTIT, DEPARTMENT OF HUMANITIES, MOUNT ROYAL UNIVERSITY

Relations between the Crown and Indigenous peoples in what is now Canada began hundreds of years ago and
have been affected by both internal and external forces. These interactions have changed over time and continue
to evolve today. While there were periods in which some have deemed the association a partnership, more often it
has been exchanges that were largely characterized by myopic policies and actions by the British, and later Cana-
dian federal government; a lack of consultation; and an absence of consent by Indigenous peoples in short,
Canada is built on colonialist foundations. Some, such as the recent Truth and Reconciliation Commission, have
1
even described the governments policies for Indigenous peoples as cultural genocide. In the words of historian
Susan Neylan:

most Canadians have trouble regarding themselves as living in an Aboriginal nation or seeing how historical legacies
have relevance for contemporary identities. However, scholars of Aboriginal History are well aware of how Canada was
founded upon acts of resettlement and dispossession. The erasure of its original inhabitants and their histories is the
byproduct of a persistent settler myth that views Aboriginal peoples as obstacles to, or in the least, passive players in
the real history of non-Indigenous peoples, who are presumed to have dealt peacefully and benevolently with those
2
Aboriginal societies.

This section and the three that follow trace the history of these dealings of the British and Canadian government
with Indigenous peoples from just prior to Confederation up until and including more recent events such as polit-
ical activism, land claims, confrontations such as Oka, and new movements such as Idle No More.

Economic and Military Allies

Historians such as J. R. Miller have described early interactions between Aboriginal peoples and non-Indigenous

1. Canada, Truth and Reconciliation Commission, Honouring the Truth, Reconciling for the Future: Summary of the Final Report of the Truth
and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, last modified July 23, 2015, [Link]
ing_the_Truth_Reconciling_for_the_Future_July_23_2015.pdf.
2. Susan Neylan, Colonialism and Resettling British Columbia: Canadian Aboriginal Historiography, 19922012, History Compass 11, no. 10 (2013): 833.

672
 11.4 ABORIGINAL NEWCOMER RELATIONS BEFORE CONFEDERATION 673
3
newcomers as an era of cooperation in which reciprocal relationships existed. These contacts began hundreds of
years ago when Europeans began to travel to North America in search of resources such as fish and timber. Soon
they discovered that furs, in particular beaver, was a profitable commodity. While the extent to which Indigenous
groups became involved in the fur trade varied, many willingly and readily became partners in furs, since they
4
too saw various benefits to being involved in the trade. However, in these early years, the British and French
clashed over control of the trade and other events external to North America. Before long, Indigenous peoples
were drawn into various battles and were also encouraging the British and French to join with them as allies in
their own conflicts.

Cognizant of the value and importance of military alliances with Indigenous peoples, in 1755, the British govern-
ment established the British Indian Department, which was divided into two parts: a Northern Department under
Sir William Johnson (1715-1774) who was named Superintendent of Indian Affairs, and a second department that
was to manage affairs with Indigenous peoples farther south. Both departments were under the jurisdiction of
the Commander of the British Forces in North America. Shortly after the creation of the Indian Department, the
Seven Years War broke out in which rivals Britain and France fought for control not only of what would become
the country of Canada, but beyond on a global scale. The main goal of the Indian Department during these battles
was to ensure that various Indigenous groups were allies, or at the very least remained neutral. In the end, the
British would gain control of Canada from the French, and Indigenous peoples would officially fall under British
imperial authority.

The Royal Proclamation

In 1763 shortly after the end of the Seven Years War, the British passed the Royal Proclamation that set aside a
large territory west of the British-American Thirteen Colonies and that more importantly, also recognized inher-
ent Indigenous land tenure rights or Aboriginal title to the land. The Proclamation set out a fiduciary or protector
relationship in which the Crown would act as a trustee who would supposedly act in the best interests of Indige-
nous peoples, overseeing the policy that Aboriginal title could be extinguished only by treaty with the Crown.
The Royal Proclamation also promised that Indigenous peoples would not be molested or disturbed. Alongside
these changes, the Indian Department grew in size and complexity, in part, because of the failure of the Royal
Proclamation to keep colonists off Indigenous lands, but primarily due to a series of other battles including the
American Revolutionary War (1775-1783). Thus, the main goal of the British government remained to maintain
Indigenous peoples as allies.

The Indian Problem and Early Government and Church Solutions

The end of the War of 1812 (1812-1815) initiated a new era of relations with Indigenous peoples. As the threat of
5
future North American wars retreated, increasingly, Indigenous peoples were seen as a problem. This situation
was exacerbated by the decline of the fur trade in some areas, growing demand for Indigenous land by settlers,

3. See works such as J. R. Miller, Skyscrapers Hide the Heavens: A History of Indian-White Relations in Canada, 3rd ed. (Toronto: University
of Toronto Press, 2000).
4. See Daniel Francis and Toby Morantz, Partners in Fur: A History of the Fur Trade in Eastern James Bay, 1600-1870 (Montreal and
Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 1983) and Robin Fisher, Contact & Conflict: Indian-European Relations in British Columbia,
1774-1890, 2nd ed. (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 1992).
5. See Noel Dyck, What is the Indian Problem: Tutelage and Resistance in Canadian Indian Administration (St. Johns, NF: Institute of
Social and Economic Studies, 1991).
 674 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

and increasing costs of supplying presents to First Nations groups to ensure their loyalty. With costs rising and
returns dwindling, the British government sought a new direction for their interactions with Indigenous peoples.
Thus, in 1829 under Major General H.C. Darling, Superintendent of Indians, a new plan was proposed that would
supposedly address the Indian problem.

Darling proposed a plan to civilize Indigenous peoples by assimilating them into Euro-Canadian society. This
plan would shape Canadian Indian administration thinking for many years. Whether or not this plan was assimi-
lation or genocide has been debated, although assimilation did become a justification in Canada for colonialism.
The plan to civilize and protect Indigenous peoples resulted in significant changes to the Indian Department in
1830, including moving control of the Department from the military to the civil arm of government.

This new civilization plan sought to turn Indigenous peoples into self-sufficient Christian farmers who would
6
integrate into settler society and no longer be a costly expense for the government. To keep up with the economic,
technological, and social changes in the Canada, Indigenous peoples were to be converted to Christianity; taught
to practice a trade (usually farming); and educated on how to live, act, and dress as Euro-Canadians. As a result,
model farming communities such as the one at the Coldwater Narrows reserve near Lake Simcoe were built. In
addition, treaties moved from a model of largely peace and friendship to treaties whose goal was land cession in
which First Nations peoples would be placed on reserves. The government argued that this was for the protection
of Indigenous peoples until they could assimilate or until they disappeared completely (what many at the time saw
as an inevitability). It also, of course, helped clear the path for non-Indigenous settlement.

Figure 11.5 The Mohawk Institute and Farm at Brantford, 1917.

Government officials felt it would be best to begin civilizing at an early age, which would take place in schools
in which children would be removed from the influences of their parents. While day schools existed, there was
not yet a manual labour or industrial school system in place in which students would receive basic academic
instruction and also be taught a trade. Soon, the first of these industrial schools, the Mohawk Institute, opened
7
in Brantford, Ontario in the 1830s under the auspices of the New England Company. While there would be an
initial outlay to construct and maintain the schools, these costs were borne largely by the churches, and it was
assumed that assimilation would happen quickly. Some officials such as Lieutenant-Governor Sir Francis Bond
Head (1793-1875), however, argued in the mid-1830s that any attempts to assimilate Indigenous peoples were
folly and that the Indigenous peoples of what is now Ontario should be gathered up and moved to Manitoulin
Island. Bond Heads plan failed to gain support, and the government forged ahead with Darlings civilization plan
instead.

From the 1830s to the 1850s, the British government also undertook a number of investigations into Aboriginal
affairs in the newly created united Province of Canada. As was the case up to this point, these inquiries were
made without any consultation with Indigenous peoples. One of the earliest of these studies, the Bagot Commis-
sion, reported in 1844, argued that changes needed to be made to a number of areas including the management

6. See Jennifer Pettit, 'To Christianize and Civilize': Native Industrial Schools in Canada (PhD dissertation, University of Calgary, 1997).
7. See Jennifer Pettit, From Longhouse to Schoolhouse: The Mohawk Institute 1834-1970 (MA thesis, University of Western Ontario, 1993).
 11.4 ABORIGINAL NEWCOMER RELATIONS BEFORE CONFEDERATION 675

of Indigenous land. A number of Acts followed, including the Gradual Civilization Act (1857), which promoted
voluntary enfranchisement and the gradual dissolution of reserve lands. Another significant change took place in
1860, when the British government transferred the control of Indian affairs to the Province of Canada.

Key Points

Pre-Conquest relations between Aboriginal nations and newcomers (principally French and British)
could be described as military and economic alliances and collaborations.
Beginning with the Royal Proclamation in 1763, Aboriginal title was recognized by the British
regime at a time when military alliances with powerful indigenous communities were sought after.
Military circumstances changed after 1815 and so too did the Euro-Canadian perspective on Aborig-
inal peoples.
The phase that followed focused on assimilating Aboriginal peoples into the economic and cultural
norms of Euro-Canadians. This process was known as civilizing.

Attributions
Figure 11.5
Mohawk Institute farm in Brantford, [Ont.] (Online MIKAN no.3309629) by John Boyd / Library and Archives
Canada is in the public domain.
 11.5 Aboriginal-Newcomer Relations since Confederation

JENNIFER PETTIT, DEPARTMENT OF HUMANITIES, MOUNT ROYAL UNIVERSITY

Figure 11.6 A Mikmaq delegation waiting to

meet with Governor General Marquess of Lorne
in 1878.

Additional attention to Canadian policy for Indigenous peoples came about as the result of Canadian Confedera-
tion in 1867. Section 91, Subsection 24 of the British North America Act made the federal government responsible
for all matters related to Indigenous peoples, and made First Nations peoples into wards of the Federal Gov-
ernment. The portfolio of Indian Affairs was placed under the guidance of the Secretary of State and, despite
some early failures, much of the earlier legislation and policies were maintained including the civilization plan,
treaties, and the reserve system. Additionally, some new legislation was passed including the Enfranchisement Act
(1869), which made enfranchisement compulsory in some cases (such as when an Indigenous woman married a
non-Indigenous man), promoted individual land ownership, and granted the government the power to impose an
elective band council system of governance. As had been the case in the past, these changes were made largely to
benefit non-Indigenous society without consultation with First Nations peoples. The government was concerned
with the territorial growth of Canada; acquiring land from the Hudsons Bay Company in the West; creating the
new provinces of Manitoba, British Columbia and Prince Edward Island; and creating an Indian Lands Branch in
the new Department of the Interior in 1873.

Christianize and Civilize

1
The most significant piece of legislation in this period was the passage of the Indian Act of 1876. Consisting
of 100 sections, the Indian Act consolidated earlier legislation and addressed a wide variety of areas concerning

1. See John Leslie, The Historical Development of the Indian Act (Ottawa, ON: Treaties and Historical Research Centre, 1978).

676
 11.5 ABORIGINAL-NEWCOMER RELATIONS SINCE CONFEDERATION 677

lands, status, and governance. At the core of the Act was the reinforcement of the policy of aggressive assimilation
and colonization. This Act, among other things, defined who was and was not an Indian according to the govern-
ment, described band election procedures, defined a band and reserve, and discussed the management of resources
including timber and band monies. Invasive and paternalistic, the Indian Act ignored the diversity among Indige-
nous groups in Canada, and treated Indigenous peoples as children who required management. Made into wards
of the state, Indigenous peoples were no longer autonomous according to the government. As was the case in
the past, central to the Indian Act and new policies was the plan to separate Indigenous peoples from their land
through a system of treaty-making and reserves, and increased farming instruction and schools for Indigenous
children. This plan was particularly important in Western Canada to clear the way for settlers who were central to
Prime Minister John A. Macdonalds National Policy, one part of which was the settlement of the West through
immigration (see Section 3.3). However, first, the government had to extinguish Indigenous title through a series
of treaties signed in the early and mid-1870s.

Given the changes brought about by the numbered treaties and the expanding importance of the Indian Affairs
portfolio, in 1880, the Indian Branch of the Department of the Interior was turned into a separate department called
the Department of Indian Affairs, although the Minister of the Interior continued to act as Superintendent-General
of Indian Affairs and oversaw the new department. There would be much to focus on, including strengthening the
civilization program through the promotion of farming instruction and schools.

Key Points

In 1867, the Dominion of Canada inherited Britains responsibility for maintaining relations and
honouring agreements made with Aboriginal peoples.
Between the years 1867 and 1900, the policy of civilization continued, to which was added a
greater focus on Christianization.
The Indian Act (1876) took a pan-Indian view of Native peoples and created categories and
processes that were both artificial and bureaucratic, which provided the means for aggressive colo-
nization and displacement.

Attributions
Figure 11.6
Micmac Indians Waiting to Receive Lord Lorne, Halifax (Online MIKAN no.2839092) by Library and
Archives Canada, Acc. No. 1984-45-1 is in the public domain.
 11.6 Living with Treaties

KEITH SMITH, DEPARTMENTS OF HISTORY AND FIRST NATIONS STUDIES, VANCOUVER ISLAND
UNIVERSITY

Not unlike communities in Europe or elsewhere, the Indigenous peoples of North America confirmed access to
resource sites, facilitated trade, resolved conflicts, settled alliances, and navigated the mass of other relations with
their neighbours by negotiating agreements. When European newcomers found their way into Indigenous territo-
ries, they realized it was in their interest, and often necessary for their survival, to learn Indigenous treaty proto-
cols and to fit themselves into Indigenous commercial networks. After these initial encounters, over time, treaty
making changed in intent and content, but whether for military alliance, access to land and resources, or for some
other reason, all of those involved understood that only agreements of this sort could protect the often divergent
1
strategic, cultural, and economic interests of the treaty partners.

The significance of treaty making to the newcomers is evident in Britains Royal Proclamation (1763) that, in part,
committed it and then Canada to gain the consent of Indigenous Nations before settling in their territories. This
commitment led to several treaties on Canadas West Coast, and in what became Ontario and southern Manitoba
prior to 1867. Soon after Confederation, the treaty process continued with the negotiation of the so-called num-
bered treaties, the first seven of which were concluded between 1871 and 1877 and covered the southern region
between Lake Superior and the Rocky Mountains. For its part, Canada was primarily concerned with the acqui-
sition of land and the fulfillment of its promise to British Columbia for a transcontinental railway. First Nations,
on the other hand, were generally interested in protecting their territories and resources from incursion, while at
the same time ensuring their cultural survival and independence. For them, these treaties were peace treaties. As
Piikani (Peigan) elder Cecile Many Guns (aka: Grassy Water) confirmed almost a century after the treaties, the
intent was that there would be no more fighting between anyone, everybody will be friends. Everybody will
2
be in peace.

From the perspective of the newcomers, the transfer of land stood above all other policy considerations, and the
numbered treaties were presented as successful mechanisms by both politicians of the day and many later histori-
ans. However, it is becoming increasingly recognized that rather than representing everything that was agreed to,

1. On treaty making in Canada across time see J. R. Miller, Compact, Contract, Covenant: Aboriginal Treaty-Making in Canada (Toronto: Uni-
versity of Toronto Press, 2009).
2. Interview with Mrs. Cecile Many Guns conducted by Dila Provost and Albert Yellowhorn Sr., n.d. University of Regina, oURspace,
[Link]

678
 11.6 LIVING WITH TREATIES 679

the written treaties are much more reflective of Canadas goals and Euro-Canadian interpretations of treaty-mak-
ing, and much less representative of the objectives of First Nations and of Indigenous understandings of treaty
processes. Many of the arrangements that were presented and agreed to orally during treaty negotiations are absent
3
or minimized in the text of the numbered treaties. The actual meaning of these treaties remains in dispute among
historians and in the courts.

Reserves
As a central provision of the numbered treaties, and where there were no treaties as Federal Government policy
initiatives, isolated enclaves called Indian reserves were created to accommodate Indigenous people. The reserve
system, as it developed in the mid to late 19th century, was meant as a temporary measure only, providing closed
sites where missionaries and agents of the state could indoctrinate Indigenous populations in the economic, polit-
ical, religious, and social conduct acceptable to settler Canada. Reserves offered residents refuge of sort from
the various forms of discrimination they faced in the outside world, but to policy makers and church officials,
they were laboratories of reform where residents could be observed and judged and where Indian-ness could be
4
instructed, legislated, or coerced out of Indigenous people. On these fragments of ancestral territories, Indigenous
residents held the right to occupancy only. Ownership and title remained in the hands of Canada.

Figure 11.7 Medals were issued to Aboriginal signatories of the

numbered treaties. This 1873 example was given to Muskeekee
Eyineer, one of the Manitoban signatories to Treaty 3.

Since non-Indigenous lawmakers took for themselves, even in treaty areas, absolute authority to decide who
would own land, reserve size depended largely on local settler demand. Even in areas covered by the numbered
treaties, reserve size was calculated differentially on the basis of between 160 and 640 acres per family of five,
while in British Columbia, for example, 10 acres per family was established as the standard. These inequities, and
the smaller average reserve land base in Canada compared to the United States, were recognized and challenged
by Indigenous political movements such as the Allied Tribes of British Columbia during the First World War and
5
Interwar period, but they have largely remained to the present day.

Regardless of the original size of reserves, even these small tracts remaining to Indigenous people were often
under threat. While the Federal Government restricted the ability of reserve communities to manage the lands they
lived on, Canadian officials were more than willing to alienate reserve lands themselves to meet settler demands
for mineral, forest, or agricultural lands; for the construction of transportation routes or military sites; or for a myr-
iad of other purposes. While often, though not always, Indigenous agreement of a sort was sought, this consent

3. Sarah Carter, Aboriginal People and Colonizers of Western Canada to 1900 (Toronto, ON: University of Toronto Press, 1999), 118-127.
4. Keith Smith, Liberalism, Surveillance, and Resistance: Indigenous Communities in Western Canada, 1877-1927 (Edmonton, AB: University
of Athabasca Press, 2009), 50.
5. Ibid., 132; Robert White-Harvey, Reservation Geography and Restoration of Native Self-Government, The Dalhousie Law Journal 17, no.
2 (1994): 588-589; Statement of the Allied Indian Tribes of British Columbia for the Government of British Columbia (Vancouver: Cowan &
Brookhouse, 1919) in LAC, RG 10, vol. 3821, file 59335, part 4A.
 680 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

was regularly acquired under circumstances that were at best questionable. Additionally, the sale of reserve lands
was consistently presented as being in the long-term interests of the reserve communities, although it was railway
and corporate executives and other members of the settler elite including senior Department of Indian Affairs
(DIA) and other public officials who gained possession of the alienated reserve lands during the late 19th and
6
early 20th centuries. Some of these land sales continue to be the subject of land claims and court challenges.

The contradictions here are apparent. While Canada presented its policies as beneficial to Indigenous peoples, and
while it maintained that its goal was to remake reserve residents into farmers, the best agricultural land was the
first to be removed from First Nations control. Even the right to use modern farming equipment and to participate
in training programs, farm organizations, and wheat pools like their non-Native neighbours were curbed by Cana-
dian officials. Further, amendments were made to the Indian Act soon after its creation, and more strictly applied
after the mid-1880s, whereby reserve residents were required to secure a permit before selling or giving away
any goods located or produced on reserves or by reserve residents. While some, like Cree elder John Tootoosis
(1899-1989), recognized the positive aspects of the permit system as a means to protect First Nations vendors and
consumers, he nonetheless saw it as a loaded gun that was, in the end, turned against those it was ostensibly
designed to protect. Certainly, there was ongoing resistance to all of this from Indigenous communities, but for
7
the most part, the protests were disregarded in Ottawa.

Restricting Movement and Cultural Practices

Most Canadians are secure in their right to move about freely and practice whatever form of spirituality they
choose, but in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, Canadian and church authorities went to some lengths to
restrict both for those they defined as Indians. The kinds of activities allowed on ever-shrinking reserves were
increasingly limited, restrictions were placed on movement, and cultural practices among reserve residents were
policed and penalized. The suppression of liberty among Indigenous peoples was central to Canadas Indian pol-
icy.

The Pass System

The confinement of Indigenous peoples to reserves was set in motion through the application of a matrix of laws,
regulations, and policies meant to elevate reserve residents while advancing the interests of non-Indigenous set-
tlers. In much of Canada, movement was limited through the vagrancy provisions of the Criminal Code or the
restrictions against trespass in the Indian Act. However, in the region that became the prairie provinces, the most
notorious and comprehensive element of the restrictive matrix was implemented through a Federal Government
policy known as the pass system. Under this initiative, a reserve resident was required to first secure a written
pass from their Indian agent if they wanted to visit family or friends in a nearby village; check on their chil-
dren at a residential school; participate in a celebration or attend a cultural event in a neighbouring community;
leave their reserve to hunt, fish, and collect resources; find paid employment; travel to urban centres; or leave the

6. Robert Cail, Land, Man and the Law: The Disposal of Crown Lands in British Columbia, 1871-1913 (Vancouver, BC: University of British
Columbia Press, 1974), 14; Peggy Martin-McGuire, First Nation Land Surrenders on the Prairies, 1896-1911 (Ottawa, ON: Indian Claims
Commission, 1998), 15-16, 42, 493-494, and 497-498.
7. Sarah Carter, Lost Harvests: Prairie Indian Reserve Farmers and Government Policy (Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queens University
Press, 1990), 253-258 and 156-158; Smith, Liberalism, Surveillance and Resistance, 99-103; Jean Goodwill and Norma Sluman, John
Tootoosis (Winnipeg, MB: Pemmican Publications, 1984), 123-125.
 11.6 LIVING WITH TREATIES 681
8
reserve for any other reason. According to Assiniboine Chief Dan Kennedy of the Carry the Kettle First Nation
9
in Saskatchewan, [t]he Indian reserve was a veritable concentration camp.

Official correspondence from the decade before 1885 reveals that procedures were already in place and that there
was a will at all levels of the D.I.A., the North-West Mounted Police, and political hierarchies, including Prime
Minister John A. Macdonald himself, to restrict Indigenous movement in the West. The Northwest Resistance of
1885 provided the justification for the application of a comprehensive pass system in the Prairie West, regardless
of whether individuals or their communities were part of the resistance.

All of those involved in the implementation of the pass system understood that it had no basis in Canadian law.
It was never included in the Indian Act or any other piece of Canadian legislation, which naturally put senior
police officials in a difficult position. The regulations were at odds with settlers who relied on Indigenous labour
and trade (and so opposed the restrictions), but high-ranking policemen also feared that they would be humiliated
once Indigenous people recognized the pass system lacked a legal foundation and then chose not to comply with
the policy. Generally, the NWMP/RNWMP/RCMP leadership preferred compliance by persuasion rather than by
force, although individual officers were at times even more zealous than Indian agents, and chose to apply force
when they felt it was necessary. Indigenous people naturally resisted their confinement to reserves and seem to
have made little distinction between being persuaded to remain on, or return to, their reserves and being escorted
back by a contingent of mounted policemen. They tended to choose to comply with the policy, or openly defy it,
according their own judgment of the specific situation.

There is textual evidence that passes continued to be issued until after World War I, and oral evidence that the
pass system remained in operation into the mid-1930s at least. Even though Canada never had the capacity to
forcibly restrict all off-reserve movement, the will of both the police and the D.I.A. to do what they could in this
regard regardless of the lack of legal foundation is evident, even if some in the upper echelons of the police
were sometimes uncomfortable.

Cultural Restriction

Figure 11.8 State and church combined to end

Aboriginal cultural practices. Ceremonies were
targeted, as were burial and mourning practices.
By 1907 memorial poles were combined with
headstones at Kitwanga as new forms are
adopted and older ones persist.

Not only were Indigenous people restricted in their right to move about freely, even in their traditional territories,
but also spiritual practices that were fundamental to personal and community identity and well-being and that
had been practiced since time immemorial were targeted for suppression. State and church officials alike were

8. This section on the pass system is drawn from Smith, Liberalism, Surveillance and Resistance, 60-77.
9. Dan Kennedy, Recollections of an Assiniboine Chief, ed. James R. Stevens (Toronto, ON: McClelland and Stewart, 1972), 87.
 682 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

intolerant of these practices, which they regarded as alien and immoral. Canadian and religious authorities also
recognized that spiritual systems were integral components of the cultural, political, economic, and social struc-
10
tures of Indigenous communities. To transform one, the others had to be reconfigured as well.

Figure 11.9 Potlatching continued at Alert Bay (aka: yalis) until

an RCMP crackdown in 1921.

While there is evidence of this cultural repression across the country, the ceremonies of West Coast peoples known
collectively as the potlatch received particular attention from politicians, missionaries, and government officials.
The term potlatch refers to a complex of strictly regulated ceremonies that continue to be of critical significance
to the Kwakwakawakw, Nuu-chah-nulth, Coast Salish, Haida, Tlingit, Tsimshian, Heiltsuk, and other peoples of
the North West Coast of North America. The potlatch is the central institution that binds each of these societies
together. Potlatches can be held to confirm leadership, alliances, or access to land and resources. Names (and,
thus, status) can be given or passed down, debts repaid, dishonour erased, marriages performed, births announced,
or the loss of loved ones memorialized. Potlatches provide a forum for history to be transmitted and verified, and
gifts are given to witnesses who are obliged to remember and confirm what they have experienced. In addition to
11
handling and healing earthly concerns, potlatches also have important spiritual components.

Many in late 19th and early 20th century settler society who were fortunate enough to witness potlatch ceremonies
first hand, or who benefited materially by providing supplies, supported their continuation. On the other hand,
Indian agents who saw families working for months to meet the expense of a potlatch denounced the institution
as foolish, wasteful, and demoralizing. It seemed to them that these ceremonies were held solely to give away
material goods, a concept that was directly opposite to settler goals of capitalist accumulation and private prop-
12
erty, and which simultaneously challenged settler understandings of what constituted wealth. Missionaries, for
their part, tended to see potlatches simply as a manifestation of evil. Thomas Crosby (1840-1914), who worked
as a Methodist lay missionary to Coast Salish peoples of southern Vancouver Island and the lower Fraser Valley,
from 1863 to the 1890s, said of potlatches, Of the many evils of heathenism, with the exception of witchcraft,
13
the potlatch is the worst, and one of the most difficult to root out.

Figure 9.10 Plains peoples like the Niitsitapi struggled to

preserve ceremonies like the sun dance in the face of Canadian
efforts to eradicate Aboriginal culture.

10. Katherine Pettipas, Severing the Ties that Bind: Government Repression of Indigenous Religious Ceremonies on the Prairies (Winnipeg, MB:
University of Manitoba Press, 1994), 3-4.
11. John Lutz, Makuk: A New History of Aboriginal-White Relations (Vancouver, BC: University of British Columbia Press, 2008), 58.
12. Robin Fisher, Contact and Conflict: Indian-European Relations in British Columbia, 1774-1890, 2nd ed. (Vancouver, BC: University of
British Columbia Press, 1992), 206-207; Jean Barman, The West Beyond the West: A History of British Columbia (Toronto, ON: University
of Toronto Press, 1991), 160.
13. Thomas Crosby, Among the An-Ko-me-nums or Flathead Tribes of Indians of the Pacific Coast (Toronto, ON: William Briggs, 1907), 106.
 11.6 LIVING WITH TREATIES 683

In 1884, the Indian Act was amended to include a ban on the potlatch along with the expressly spiritual dances
associated with plains ceremonial practices. Unlike the pass system, the prohibition against these institutions and
practices was backed up by the force of law that became ever more strict and comprehensive over time. Despite
the legislative prohibitions, many communities felt they had no alternative but to continue to hold potlatches and
dances, even if they went to considerable effort to make them more portable and keep them out of the view of
missionaries and Indian agents. Even with these precautions, there was a wave of prosecutions and subsequent
incarcerations soon after World War I. It wasnt until 1951 that the prohibitions against Indigenous ceremonies
were finally dropped from the Indian Act. Some of the masks and other spiritual objects confiscated during the
period of the ban have since been returned to their owners, but many others remain in the hands of museums and
private collectors.

Key Points

Treaties evolved as instruments for negotiating accommodation between Aboriginal peoples and the
newcomer society. By the late 19th century, the newcomers saw treaties as a means to acquire
resources and manage Aboriginal populations.
The final versions of the numbered treaties do not always or honestly reflect what was agreed (or
understood to have taken place) in the treaty-making processes.
Reserves were accepted by Aboriginal peoples as lands that were protected against intrusion; the
Canadians carved out reserves as contained spaces in which assimilative efforts could be conducted
more efficiently.
Reserve size and resources were determined more by settler needs than Aboriginal requirements or
expectations.
Federal policies like the pass system and prohibitions against the potlatch and the sun dance were
bureaucratic tools used to extinguish Aboriginal culture while restricting basic freedoms of move-
ment and belief.

Attributions
Figure 11.7
Indian Chiefs 1873 Medal, Presented to commemorate Treaty Number 3 (Queen Victoria) (Online MIKAN
no.2851194) by Library and Archives Canada, Acc. No. 1970-27-8M is in the public domain.

Figure 11.8
Totem pole with modern tombstone (Online MIKAN no.3349323) by Library and Archives Canada is in the
public domain.

Figure 11.9
In P49 Indian Potlach Alert Bay B.C. by City of Vancouver Archives AM54-S4-: In P49 is in the public
domain.

Figure 11.10
684 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Sun Dance, Blackfeet Indians (Online MIKAN no.3368318) by Trueman / Library and Archives Canada /
C-014106 is in the public domain.
 11.7 From Agricultural Training to Residential School

JENNIFER PETTIT, DEPARTMENT OF HUMANITIES, MOUNT ROYAL UNIVERSITY

Figure 11.11 The Numbered Treaties cover all of the Prairie West,
the western North, most of northern Ontario, and a quarter of
British Columbia.

By the time the numbered treaties and the reserve system were created, Indigenous peoples in what is now West-
ern Canada faced dire conditions. Many communities were ravaged by diseases such as smallpox, and devastated
1
by the whisky trade. The bison, on which they relied, was almost extinct. The Canadian government once again
decided that the solution was model farms to accompany a policy of peasant farming through which Indigenous
families were to receive 2 acres and a cow and through which they were not encouraged to utilize any labour-
saving machinery. The government felt this would ensure Indigenous peoples would be converted to sedentary
farmers, but would not be so successful that they would compete with the new settlers moving west. Not sur-
prisingly, the plan failed. Government bureaucrats at the time blamed the supposed lazy nature of First Nations
peoples. Historian Sarah Carter has since proven that Indigenous peoples were interested in farming, but that the
2
governments policies and practices undermined reserve agriculture. More important to the government was a
new system of schools for Indigenous children.

Though they had weak results in the early schools in central Canada, the Federal Government was optimistic that
expanding schools into the Prairies made sense, hopeful that the Indigenous peoples there could also be civilized
3
and Christianized. Starving and destitute, some Indigenous peoples also hoped the schools would teach their
children the skills necessary to adapt to changing conditions and, ideally, to learn a trade that would make them

1. See James Daschuk, Clearing the Plains: Disease, Politics of Starvation, and the Loss of Aboriginal Life (Regina, SK: University of Regina
Press, 2013).
2. See Sarah Carter, Lost Harvests: Prairie Indian Reserve Farmers and Government Policy (Montreal, QC: McGill-Queens University Press,
1990).
3. See J. R. Miller, Shingwauks Vision: A History of Native Residential Schools (Toronto, ON: University of Toronto Press, 1996) and John
Milloy, A National Crime: The Canadian Government and the Residential School System, 1879 to 1986 (Winnipeg, MB: University of Mani-
toba Press, 1999).

685
 686 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

self-supporting. What remained to be determined though was what kind of education system would best serve the
Indigenous peoples living in the West. To help answer that question in 1879, the government enlisted Nicholas
Flood Davin (1840-1901), a Regina newspaper editor and the M.P. for Assiniboia West, to study the American
system of industrial schools for Indigenous peoples. Notably, as was the pattern in government dealings with
Indigenous peoples, Davin did not consult First Nations. He concluded that industrial schools in which children
learned a trade and which were similar to those in the United States would be appropriate and useful in the West,
despite disappointing results in similar schools in Central Canada. Davin also suggested that the Canadian govern-
4
ment forge alliances with the churches to manage the schools. These industrial schools were costly, however,
and as a result, a parallel system of day and boarding schools was also created. Boarding schools were similar to
the industrial schools, but were typically smaller with a much reduced focus on trades instruction. The first of the
industrial schools the QuAppelle Industrial School and the Battleford Industrial School located in the future
province of Saskatchewan, and the St. Josephs School (also known as the High River or Dunbow school) south-
west of Calgary opened in the 1880s. These schools would lay the groundwork for a system of schools that
would eventually spread across the Prairies and into British Columbia and the North.

Figure 11.12 The Fort QuAppelle Indian Industrial School was

one of the first to open. Seen here ca.1885 with teepees and carts
outside the fence.

By the time the last school closed in 1996, over 130 would have operated and over 150,000 Indigenous children
5
would have been forced to attend what would ultimately be deemed tools of cultural genocide. Indigenous chil-
dren were taken from their homes, separated from their communities and families, and were forbidden to speak
their languages or practice their culture. Students were poorly fed; subjected to medical experiments; forced to
6
undertake manual labour; and were subjected to physical, sexual, and mental or spiritual abuse. The legacy of
7
this appalling treatment is still being felt in Indigenous communities today.

To ensure the schools succeeded, the government enacted a number of measures including compulsory atten-
dance in 1894 (and reinforced in further legislation in 1920). However, the parents of Indigenous students were
not passive participants in the plans of church and state to civilize their children, and many did whatever they
could to prevent their children from attending these schools and to demonstrate their displeasure. Parents were
angered that their children were being abused and that they were taken so far away from the reserves. Parents were
also upset that students were alienated from their culture, were forced to work long hours, were not properly cared
for, and could not find employment after graduation. This opposition took place, however, in a power relationship

4. Canada, Report on Industrial Schools for Indians and Half-Breeds by Nicholas Flood Davin. 14 March, 1879. Library and Archives Canada,
Record Group 10, Vol. 6001, File 1-1-1.
5. Canada, Truth and Reconciliation Commission, "Honouring the Truth, Reconciling for the Future: Summary of the Final Report of the Truth
and Reconciliation Commission of Canada," last modified July 23, 2015, [Link]
ing_the_Truth_Reconciling_for_the_Future_July_23_2015.pdf.
6. Ian Mosby, Administering Colonial Science: Nutrition Research and Human Biomedical Experimentation in Aboriginal Communities and
Residential Schools, 1942-1952, Histoire sociale/Social History 46, no. 91 (2013): 615-642.
7. Canada, Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples. Report of the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples. Vol. 5: Renewal: A Twenty-Year
Commitment. In For Seven Generations: An Information Legacy of the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples [CD-ROM] (Ottawa:
Libraxus, 1997.)
 11.7 FROM AGRICULTURAL TRAINING TO RESIDENTIAL SCHOOL 687

in which Aboriginal peoples were unable to bring about real change. Thus, their opposition had only a limited
effect. What did sway the administrators was rising costs.

Figure 11.13 St. Josephs (Cariboo) Indian Residential School

was established in 1891 as one of the several schools run by the
Catholic Church in BC.

Originally thought to be a quick and relatively inexpensive way to deal with what administrators deemed the
Indian Problem, the schools had evolved into a costly and complicated system that was not producing sig-
nificant results. As a consequence, Duncan Campbell Scott (1862-1947), who was appointed to the position of
Superintendent of Indian Education in 1909, changed the professed goal of schools for Indigenous peoples from
integration to segregation (in the words of Scott: for civilized life in his own environment). In 1923 officials
8
merged the industrial and boarding schools to create a new category of schools known as residential schools.
Scott, though, still very much believed in a policy in which Indigenous peoples should be obliterated as a distinct
community. In 1920 he made this now famous statement: I want to get rid of the Indian problem. I do not think
as a matter of fact, that the country ought to continuously protect a class of people who are able to stand alone.
Our objective is to continue until there is not a single Indian in Canada that has not been absorbed into the body
9
politic and there is no Indian question.

Key Points

Setting Aboriginal people down the path to become European-style agriculturalists was underfunded
and purposely organized to ensure they did not compete with European newcomers on the Prairies.
Canadian-organized schools appealed to Aboriginal people because they held out the hope of skills
and opportunities that would help their people escape poverty.
The industrial schools were augmented by boarding schools in which industrial skills were mini-
mized, the clergy were heavily involved, and costs were managed by obliging the children/pupils to
do maintenance work.
Compulsory attendance was legislated in 1894, enabling the abduction of children from their parents
by the local Canadian authorities.
By 1909 the objectives of the schools had changed again from integration to segregation and the
combination of industrial and boarding schools to produce residential schools. Superintendant Dun-
can Campbell Scott believed that Aboriginal peoples could never occupy an equitable position in
Canadian society and was satisfied to use the schools to build a marginalized people.

8. Brian Titley, A Narrow Vision: Duncan Campbell Scott and the Administration of Indian Affairs in Canada (Vancouver, BC: University of
British Columbia Press, 1986).
9. Duncan Campbell Scott, Deputy Superintendent General of Indian affairs, testimony before the Special Committee of the House of Com-
mons examining the Indian Act amendments of 1920, Library and Archives Canada, Record Group 10, vol. 6810, file 470-2-3, volume 7, pp.
55 (L-3) and 63 (N-3).
688 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Attributions
Figure 11.11
Numbered-Treaties-Map by Yug/ STyx/ Themightyquill is used under a CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.

Figure 11.12
Distant view of Fort QuAppelle Indian Industrial School with tents, [Red River] carts and teepees outside the
fence, Lebret, Saskatchewan, [May 1885?] (Online MIKAN no.3194883) by O.B. Buell / Library and Archives
Canada / PA-182246 in the public domain.

Figure 11.13
[Panorama of Cariboo Indian Residential School, Williams Lake, British Columbia, 1949].(Online MIKAN
no.4674075) by Canada. Dept. of Indian and Northern Affairs / Library and Archives Canada / e011080297_s1
in the public domain.
 11.8 WWI to 1970

JENNIFER PETTIT, DEPARTMENT OF HUMANITIES, MOUNT ROYAL UNIVERSITY

At the same time these events were transpiring, over 4,000 Indigenous people fought in World War I (see Section
1
6.12). They returned, not to significant progress for First Nations, but to a country in which some of their lands
had been taken without their permission and in which they were still not entitled to vote. While the Canadian
economy was strong in the 1920s, by the 1930s the Great Depression hit and the Department of Indian Affairs
was reduced to a branch of the Department of Mines and Resources. When WWII broke out, Indigenous peoples
once again volunteered in significant numbers. This time, however, they returned to a Canada with a burgeoning
concern for the conditions facing First Nations. As a result, in 1946 Parliament created a Special Joint Committee
of the Senate and the House of Commons to undertake a study of the Indian Act. Unlike earlier commissions, the
Joint Committee also sought feedback and consultation with Indigenous associations such as the North American
Indian Brotherhood and the Indian Association of Alberta. When they reported in 1948, the Committee recom-
mended a number of changes, including allowing Indigenous peoples to vote in federal elections; creating a treaty
claims commission; enacting self-government; giving title of reserve lands to Indigenous peoples; and encourag-
ing integration rather than assimilation. In the end, the federal government ignored many of these recommenda-
tions. There were, however, some changes made to the Indian Act in 1951, including lifting the ban on Indigenous
dances and ceremonies, permitting Indigenous groups to pursue land claims, and increasing the powers of chiefs
and band councils. However, it would not be until the 1960s that significant changes in the relationship between
the federal government and Canadas First Nations would begin to transpire.

Citizens Plus the 1960s

The Hawthorn Report

The decade of the 1960s saw significant changes begin to take place. The right to vote in federal elections was
extended to Indigenous peoples in 1960, and in 1961 the compulsory enfranchisement provisions were dropped
from the Indian Act. A stand-alone Department of Indian Affairs was created in 1966. Another significant event
was the Hawthorn-Tremblay Report entitled A Survey of the Contemporary Indians of Canada: Economic, Polit-

1. Canada, Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Canada, Aboriginal Contributions During the First World War, last modified Octo-
ber 24, 2014, [Link]

689
690 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

ical, Educational Needs and Policies. Based on a series of cross-Canada consultations, the 1966-1967 Hawthorn
Report concluded that Canadas First Nations were marginalized and disadvantaged due to misguided govern-
ment policies like the residential school system (which the Report recommended closing). Hawthorn argued that
Indigenous peoples needed to be treated as Citizens Plus and provided with the resources required for self-deter-
mination. As a result of this report, the Canadian government decided to take policies in an entirely new direction,
which were outlined in the White Paper of 1969.

The White Paper and the Red Paper

In the White Paper, the stated goal of Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau and Jean Chrtien, Minister for Indian
Affairs, was to achieve greater equality for Canadas First Nations. The White Paper called for an end to Indian
status, the closure of the Department of Indian Affairs, the dismantling of the Indian Act, the conversion of reserve
lands to private property, and immediate integration. While the federal government believed this to be desirable,
Indigenous groups across Canada were outraged, and argued that forced assimilation was not the means to achieve
equity and that the White Paper had not addressed their concerns. They responded with a document called Citi-
zens Plus, which became known as the Red Paper. In the Red Paper, Indigenous peoples stressed the importance
of land and upholding the promises made in the treaties, and called for political organization. In response, the
government withdrew the White Paper in 1970.

Over 200 years has passed since the passage of the Royal Proclamation of 1763, and yet the deeply flawed Indian
Act still remains in effect today. Altough there has been some progress, such as the entrenchment of Aboriginal
and treaty rights in the 1982 Constitution and the 2008 Federal Government apology for residential schools, much
remains to be done. The fight for this recognition has unfolded in a number of ways: peaceful movements like
Idle No More; violent clashes such as the events at Oka; issues such as land claims reconsidered in the courts;
and consultations that were part of studies, such as the 1996 Royal Commission and the more recent Truth and
Reconciliation Commission (discussed in Sections 11.9 and 11.11).

Key Points

Aboriginal leaders were finally able to secure Ottawas interest in their complaints shortly after the
Second World War.
Recommendations arising from the 1948 Special Joint Committee were acted on incrementally, first
by ending the ban on the sun dance and potlatch, removing the sanctions against legal claims against
Canada, and devolving authority to band leadership.
Winning the franchise in 1960 was followed by the Hawthorn Report of 1966-1967, which adopted
the approach of Citizens Plus.
Motivated to act, the Trudeau administration in 1969 issued the White Paper, which was instantly
rejected by Aboriginal leaders as assimilative. They responded with the Red Paper.
Issues that were identified decades earlier remained off the table and continue to be avoided by
Canadian governments.
11.9 The Aqueduct and Colonialism

ADELE PERRY, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, UNIVERSITY OF MANITOBA

Located at the forks of two major rivers and prone to flooding, the city of Winnipeg often seems awash in water,
but an adequate supply of clean drinking water has been a continual problem for the city from its earliest days as
the Red River Settlement to its incorporation as a city in 1874 to the present day. In his classic Winnipeg: A Social
History of Urban Growth, 1874-1914 (1977), Alan Artibise explains how in the last decades of the 19th century,
Winnipeg experimented with private companies and public water supply operations. They filtered river water and
dug artesian wells, but still had to deal with problems like hard water (with a high mineral content), inadequate
supply, and, more pressingly, annual outbreaks of typhoid. 1904 was especially bad: 1,276 people, or a little over
5% of 67,300 Winnipeggers, were diagnosed with typhoid.

By 1913 the ambitious settler city had decided to address its enduring problems with the water supply by building
an aqueduct to transport water from Shoal Lake. Located about 150 kilometers east, Shoal Lake straddles the
borders of Ontario and Manitoba, and is within Anishinaabe territory, which is covered by the provisions and
promises of Treaty 3, signed in 1873. Supporters of the Shoal Lake Aqueduct were well aware of just how expen-
sive and ambitious the plan was, and argued that the estimated cost of $13.5 million would be well worth it to
secure Winnipegs human and economic growth.

Figure 11.14 A spiders web of infrastructure radiates outward

from Winnipeg, claiming territory and water. Greater Winnipeg
Water District Map, 1918.

What this plan might mean for the Anishinaabe communities at Shoal Lake rarely entered into the conversations
about what the Aqueduct could do for the mainly settler city of Winnipeg. In 1914 the Federal Government used
its enormous powers under the Indian Act, first passed in 1876, to sell approximately 3,000 acres of land belong-
ing to Shoal Lake 40 Reserve to the Greater Winnipeg Water District (GWWD) for the sum of $1,500. In an effort
to separate dark water from the more palatable water destined for the city, the GWWD then built a canal and a
dyke, which effectively made the community of Shoal Lake 40 an artificial island.

691
692 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Shoal Lake water first flowed in Winnipegs water mains in 1919, less than half a year after the armistice of the
Great War and a few months before a General Strike would rock the prairie city. The project carried an enormous
price tag: it cost $17 million at the time, which translates to about $229,861,702 in 2016 terms. The Shoal Lake
Aqueduct project involved the building of a railroad, telephone lines, and tunnelling under multiple rivers, and
employed as many as 2,000 men at one time all during the labour shortages of World War 1. The Aqueduct has
served the city of Winnipeg well and continues to supply the city with its drinking water.

It did not take long for Winnipeggers to begin celebrating the Aqueduct as a triumph of engineering and public-
minded policy. It would take much, much longer and an enormous amount of activism and advocacy from Indige-
nous communities for awareness to grow with respect to what the Aqueduct cost the Anishinaabe communities of
Shoal Lake. Surrounded by Winnipegs water supply, Shoal Lake 40 nevertheless lacks a reliable source of fresh
water, and the community has been on a boil water advisory since 1998. (They are not alone: as of the summer
of 2015, there were about 175 drinking water advisories in Reserves across Canada.) Also, the approximately 250
people of Shoal Lake 40 lack a year-round way of coming and going from the community, and as a result, have
poor waste removal, emergency services, and postal services. During the winter, they use an ice road across water,
but for a few weeks every fall and spring, they face the danger of travel across thinning and uncertain ice.

The fact that the community of Shoal Lake 40s poor water supply and any chances for ameliorating it can be
tied directly to the Aqueduct that secured Winnipegs water supply tells us a lot about the history of colonialism
in modern Canada. The relative prosperity of non-Indigenous people in 20th century Canada has come at the
expense sometimes general and sometimes very specific of Indigenous people. Alongside the histories of
World War 1, the Winnipeg General Strike, and the provision of municipal services in Winnipeg and across
Canada, we also need to analyze the histories of Indigenous dispossession that undergirded the stories of settler
vision, conflict, and triumph.

Key Points

The ability to undertake large engineering projects in the 20th century recasts colonial relations
between Canada and Aboriginal communities like Shoal Lake 40; the issue is not simply the taking
of Aboriginal land, but any other resource that is needed by the colonial society. As is the case at
Shoal Lake 40, this is very much to the detriment of the colonized people.

Attributions
Figure 11.14
Map Showing Location of Aqueduct (1918) by Wyman Laliberte / Courtesy of University of Manitoba :
Archives & Special Collections is used under a CC-BY-2.0 license.
11.10 Canada and the Colonized, 1970-2002

The White Paper and the Red Paper demonstrated how far out of sync Ottawa was with respect to the Aboriginal
leadership across Canada. It was, however, a moment in Canadian history that catalyzed First Nations groups into
new political action.

When one looks at the period between the Great War and the late 1960s, it might seem that Aboriginal peoples
mustered very little opposition to colonialism. Although resistance was widespread, and small victories were
won at the immediate, on-reserve level, the systemic obstacles to Aboriginal protest were too significant to be
bypassed. Aboriginal people who held Status could not vote until 1960, so that avenue was closed. Moreover,
although band leadership was typically elected, it was often at the mercy of the local Department of Indian Affairs
Agent, whose interests were very frequently at odds with those of the bands. In the 1920s there were two telling
developments. Section 141 of the Indian Act forbade bands from hiring lawyers to pursue entitlements or dam-
ages owed by the federal government; raising funds to do so was itself a criminal offence. In a stroke, Ottawa
had criminalized legal action in support of Aboriginal rights. Almost simultaneously, the RCMP was directed to
be more aggressive in suppressing Aboriginal cultural events: one outcome of Dan Cranmers potlatch in 1921 at
Alert Bay was the arrest of more than 40 participants, and the conviction and imprisonment of roughly half their
number. (Another outcome was the confiscation and subsequent loss of several generations artistic creations,
sacred items, and cherished family possessions.) Starting in the 1930s, Aboriginal people from Coast to Coast
found themselves being relocated. In Nova Scotia in 1942, for example, 20 settlements were consolidated into 2
to ease administrative and assimilationist processes, entirely in the face of Mikmaq opposition. Housing and ser-
vices were inadequate for the growing populations, and by the 1950s, the provincial government in Halifax lost
interest in trying to fix the mess the Federal Government had created.

At mid-century, a similar situation emerged on the Labrador Coast. Davis Inlet (aka: Utshimassit) was attractive
to coastal traders from the late 18th century on because of its deep natural moorage. At around 1870, the Hudsons
Bay Company offered Aboriginal traders access to inoculation against smallpox and a variety of trade goods, but
the site had no profound, traditional meaning to the Innu who visited it only when it served their purposes. Mis-
sionary work in the region was intermittent at best until the 1950s. At that time, growing interest and commerce
in the region led to an outbreak of alcohol abuse. The missionaries stayed aloof from families and households
in which drinking was routine and/or problematic; the Innu who suffered from alcoholism also steered clear of
the church and held themselves separate from non-drinkers as well. This phenomenon exposed fissures within the
Innu population that when they were relocated wholesale north to New Davis Inlet became part of a new
dysfunctional and divided normalcy. Moving from tents into Euro-style housing appeared to observers outside

693
 694 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

the community to indicate permanence and settlement, but it concealed deep social problems that were to man-
1
ifest in violence, several kinds of abuse, and horrendous suicide rates.

Like so many other Aboriginal peoples, the Mikmaq at Shubenacadie and Eskasoni and the Innu at New Davis
Inlet were impoverished by relocation and the structural unemployment that was sustained by anti-Aboriginal
racism. Also, they were fearful of further decapitation of community leadership by governments that didnt seem
reluctant to incarcerate troublemakers. First Nations facing these conditions and others struggled to find strate-
gies and tactics suitable for the modern era of colonialism. In 1951 Ottawa lifted the barriers to raising funds for
legal challenges, sanctions against the potlatch and other ceremonies were dropped, and steps were taken toward
enfranchisement. A new era in Aboriginal-Newcomer relations was about to begin.

Figure 11.15 In 1953, at the start of the Cold War, Inuit

communities were relocated from Inukjuak to Resolute Bay (left
arrow) and Grise Fiord (right) to act as human flagpoles for
Canadian sovereignty in the high Arctic.

New Organizations
Political organizations had been struggling for years, but the White Paper gave them new life, as did 1960s
organizations like the American Indian Movement (AIM) and the civil rights movement in the United States.
Harold Cardinal (1945-2005) gave voice to Aboriginal concerns at the time in his 1969 book The Unjust Society,
which took its title from Prime Minister Pierre Trudeaus 1968 campaign slogan of a just society. The Union
of BC Indian Chiefs (UBCIC) and the National Indian Brotherhood (NIB) were established the same year as
a further response to the White Paper crisis. The NIB grew out of a foundation established by the Federation of
Saskatchewan Indians and the National Indian Council, and its creation also included a divorce from the leading
Mtis organization.

The movement faced challenges from the outset as First Nations with treaty rights pulled in one direction and
those without pursued solutions under Aboriginal rights. The leadership of George Manuel (1921-89) was criti-
cal in the early years of the NIB. A Secwepemc leader from Neskonlith on the South Thompson River, Manuel
emerged as a capable spokesperson and a theorist. His conception of the Fourth World, a category of largely
small and colonized Indigenous populations around the globe, resonated with those advocating for Aboriginal
rights, informed the thinking of Aboriginal organizations in Canada generally, and contributed to the establish-
ment of the World Council of Indigenous Peoples, which Manuel led in the mid-1970s. Manuel was able to secure
federal funding for research into a variety of native claims and set the movement on a solid financial footing for
2
the first time.

1. Lynne D. Fitzhugh, The Labradorians: Voices from the Land of Cain (St. Johns, NF: Breakwater, 1999), 261-263.
2. J. R. Miller, Skyscrapers Hide the Heavens: A History of Indian-White Relations in Canada, revised edition (Toronto, ON: University of
Toronto Press, 1991), 231-233. See also "George Manuel," accessed January 9, 2016, [Link]
nity-politics/[Link].
 11.10 CANADA AND THE COLONIZED, 1970-2002 695

The thrust of the NIBs efforts and those of its successor, the Assembly of First Nations (AFN), was to obtain
progressively greater and greater degrees of self-governance for Aboriginal communities. Social work and child
welfare were priorities, although it was in education that the greatest victories were won. As the role of the
Department of Indian Affairs and Northern Development (DIAND) was progressively reduced, band offices
took up a larger share of local responsibility. The AFN established in 1978 played a key role along with the
UBCIC in securing recognition for Aboriginal rights in Section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982.

New Legal Precedents

The first court case to significantly change the landscape of Aboriginal-Canadian relations came in 1973. The
Nisgaa First Nation of northwestern British Columbia successfully demonstrated that title to their land had never
been extinguished. The Calder Case worked its way through the BC court system and reached the Supreme Court
of Canada. Although the Court agreed that Aboriginal title existed before Confederation, it was split on whether
title persisted after 1871. The British Columbia government took this as a signal that they owed nothing to the
Nisgaa (nor, if it came to that, to any other First Nations with which post-1871 administrations had failed to nego-
tiate a treaty or purchase of land); Ottawa, however, took the view that the Calder decision demanded the start of a
new treaty negotiation process. The entrenchment of Aboriginal rights in the Constitution Act gave further weight
to this position and, with the election of a new NDP government in BC in 1990, Victoria joined in the process of
seeking a new generation of treaties. In 1998 the Nisgaa Final Agreement was reached. By that time, 13 other
post-1973 treaties had been negotiated.

At roughly the same time that the Nisgaa brought forward their initial claim, the Cree and Inuit of Northern Que-
bec sought a legal solution for their own situations. The expansion of Quebec into the Ungava Peninsula in 1911
was meant to be followed by a round of treaty negotiations, which never took place. Despite Aboriginal protests,
the Provincial Governments aggressive mid-century hydroelectricity development program around James Bay
uprooted and displaced First Nations. Late in 1973, the provincial courts made it clear that the provinces oblig-
ation to negotiate a treaty had not disappeared and, in the year that followed, an agreement was reached with the
Grand Assembly of the Cree and the Northern Quebec Inuit Association. Although this was an Agreement, it
was a Treaty in every other respect and is regarded as the first in 50 years. Using the courts to get provinces and
Ottawa to the bargaining table was rapidly becoming an accepted process.

Courtroom challenges and precedents were slowly won, and every time a significant watershed was crossed, it
happened at the Supreme Court of Canada. In 1990 the same year British Columbia joined in the treaty-making
process a precedent was set by the case of Regina v Sparrow. Five years earlier, Ronald Sparrow, a fisherman
and member of the Musqueam (aka: Xwmthkwiyem or xmkym) First Nation, was caught using a drift net
that exceeded the dimensions permitted by the Fisheries Act. Sparrow admitted the offence but challenged the
charge, citing Aboriginal rights provided under Section 35(1) of the Constitution Act (1982). The case was ini-
tially lost, but successive appeals were made, all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada where Justices reached
a unanimous decision that supported Sparrows position. Specifically, any activity or right that existed before
1982 that had not been explicitly and specifically extinguished was recognized as continuing unabated. This was
the first significant test of Aboriginal rights, and it was an important win for First Nations.

In the case of Delgamuukw v British Columbia, the Gitksan-Wetsuweten First Nations decided against the
slow federal treaty negotiation process (in which British Columbias Provincial Government had initially refused
 696 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

to participate) and sought a resolution through the legal system. At first this went very badly for the plaintiffs:
in 1991 Chief Justice Allan McEachern (1926-2008) ruled contrary to Calder that Aboriginal rights existed
only because, and so long as, the colonial power said they did. Moreover, he ruled that oral tradition did not consti-
tute a viable source of evidence. Also, McEacherns tone was condescending to such an extent that it swung public
support toward the Gitksan-Wetsuweten side. The Supreme Court of Canada decided in 1998 that McEachern
was wrong in both regards. On the topic of oral history, the court stated:

Notwithstanding the challenges created by the use of oral histories as proof of historical facts, the laws of evidence must
be adapted in order that this type of evidence can be accommodated and placed on an equal footing with the types of
3
historical evidence that courts are familiar with, which largely consists of historical documents.

As regards Aboriginal title, Delgamuukw was definitive that (a) it existed, and (b) it was exclusive. That is, a
province and/or Ottawa could not lay claim to land within traditional territories without extinguishing title first
through treaty negotiations.

This decision was further reinforced in Haida Nation v British Columbia in 2004 and as recently as 2014 in the
case of Tsilhqotin Nation v British Columbia, both of which involved provincial forest policies and grants. In
the case of Haida, a dispute over corporate access to forest resources on Haida Gwaii (aka: the Queen Charlotte
Islands), Crown rights to grant access, and Haida Aboriginal rights to harvest red cedar began in 1961. More than
40 years later, it was decided by the British Columbia Court of Appeals that the Crown has a duty to conduct
meaningful negotiations with First Nations over the use of resources in unceded territories and to accommodate
their interests. Tsilhqotin strengthened this position in 2014 in a dispute over licenses to log forests on unceded
traditional territory. Once again, appeals took the case from the provincial level to Ottawa and the Supreme Court
and, once again, the highest court in the country decided against the Provincial and Federal Governments. The
Court concurred with earlier decisions that Aboriginal title exists and, almost ironically, turned the Indian Act
back on the governments, stating that a fiduciary responsibility exists between the Crown and Indigenous people.
In short, governments cannot hand over to third parties resources that are unceded, since doing so would be to
cheat the First Nation in question out of their inherent value. The implications of Tsilhqotin Nation is still being
worked out but, on the face of it, it prohibits resource extraction on any unceded territories without the permis-
sion of the relevant First Nation(s). (It is worth noting at this point that the approach taken by settler society has
been to identify, catalogue, pursue, extract, and profit from individual and specific resources or commodities;
Aboriginal societies, in contrast, generally perceive their lands more holistically, not as a vault full of riches from
which one may selectively make withdrawals.)

The fact that so many of the key legal precedents come out of British Columbia speaks to its distinctive (although
not unique) experience of treaties. Apart from the dozen or so Douglas Treaties signed by Governor James Dou-
glas in the colonial era, and the part of Treaty 8 that spills over from Alberta into the British Columbian Peace
District, there were no attempts to extinguish title with the vast majority of First Nations in the province. On the
East Coast, as well, the treaty system developed very differently. Treaties were never signed with the Aboriginal
peoples of Newfoundland and Labrador. The Mikmaq of Newfoundland are politically related to their cousins on
the Maritime mainland but not in terms of treaty. The situation for the Innu and Inuit of Labrador is similar. They
have had full Canadian citizenship for about a century now, which includes voting rights, and they never have
been covered by the Indian Act; thus, notions of Status and non-Status are irrelevant to them. Moreover, they
never have been wards of the state. This means that they have escaped some of the worst effects of colonialism

3. Delgamuukw v. British Columbia, [1997] 3 S.C.R. 1010 at para. 84. File No.: 23799.
 11.10 CANADA AND THE COLONIZED, 1970-2002 697

but, at the same time, they were rendered invisible to the D.I.A. What the Innu call Nitassinan has been viewed
by outsiders as so bereft of human occupancy and culture that the region has been repeatedly pounded by NATO
4
aircraft on training missions.

A different story unfolded in the North West Territories (NWT) beginning in the late 1970s. Ottawa engaged the
Inuit Tapirisat of Canada (now called Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami) in negotiations over claims to the eastern third of
the NWT (what was, at the time, called the District of Keewatin). The idea of a separate, autonomous Inuit admin-
istrative unit gained ground and, in 1982, a referendum of residents of the whole Territory showed overwhelming
support for the idea. It took another decade to complete the land claims negotiation process (the Nunavut Land
Claims Agreement Act, 1992), and that was followed by legislation that created the new Nunavut Territory. The
government in Iqaluit represents a population that is more than 80% Inuit, and Inuktitut is the Territorys first offi-
cial language.

Reforming the Indian Act

The White Paper failed at the first hurdle, and the Red Paper set a new agenda for change. Nevertheless, legislative
change was slow in coming. The Penner Report in 1983 recommended to Ottawa a form of autonomy that repre-
sented to most Aboriginal leaders an advance on what had gone before it, but the government changed, and Prime
Minister Brian Mulroneys administration took a different approach. Informed by a neo-conservative fear of fiscal
mismanagement and public dependency, the Mulroney government first looked for ways to reduce spending on
band issues. Offering up a kind of municipal-level of self-government, the Tories hoped to dismantle the bureau-
cracy of guardianship that had existed for a century. To many native leaders, this looked like White Paper 2.0, and
they pointed to the implicit shift in dependence from Ottawa to the provinces (to which municipalities are sub-
servient); only a small number of bands perceived it as an opportunity to seize upon. The overall effect of the first
year of Conservative government was a sudden increase in rancour and bad press. The Mulroney administration
looked elsewhere to secure change.

Efforts were made in 1985 to reform some of the most egregiously discriminatory elements of the Indian Act.
The most noteworthy of these changes pertains to Status and Aboriginal women. Before Bill C-31, the Indian
Act specified that Aboriginal women who married non-Aboriginal men lost Status. Whats more, children of that
marriage also lost any claim to Status. Aboriginal men who married non-Aboriginal women, however, were not
similarly impacted. Since bands were (and are) funded based on the number of Status members on their lands, an
incentive exists to prevent non-Status members from residing on-reserve and making demands on band services.
Loss of Status meant that Aboriginal women and their children got the right to vote, which was offset by their
potential loss of community.

The 1985 reforms restored Status to Aboriginal women and children from whom it had hitherto been stripped. It
was celebrated at the time as a significant step forward for Aboriginal womens rights and, symbolically at least,
it was. However, the amended law simply carried forward into the next generation the prospect of losing Status
through marriage to non-Aboriginals. In that respect, it was more of a temporary amnesty rather than a wholesale
5
elimination of a discriminatory law.

4. Lynne D. Fitzhugh, The Labradorians: Voices from the Land of Cain (St. Johns, NF: Breakwater, 1999), 376-377.
5. The ways in which the new laws impose a two generation cut-off is described nicely in Thomas King, The Inconvenient Indian: A Curious
Account of Native People in North America (Toronto, ON: Anchor Canada, 2012), 167-169.
698 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Extra-Legal Protests
Several factors contributed to the rise of protest tactics among Aboriginal leaders. One was the American Indian
Movement (AIM) that appeared in the late 1960s in the United States. Sometimes described as Red Power (in a
nod to the Afro-American Black Power movement), AIM inevitably reached across the border to Canadian First
Nations with shared grievances against colonialist forces. Beginning in 1970, AIM-style demonstrations appeared
in Canada including road blockades, the occupation of government offices, and attempts to seize lands that had
either been unilaterally cut out of reserves or never covered by treaty. The frequency of protests increased through
the decade, many of which became high profile confrontations. In the North West Territories, Dene mobilized
to block the proposed Mackenzie Valley Pipeline. A Royal Commission from 1974 to 1977, chaired by Justice
Thomas Berger (b. 1933), accepted much of the Dene case and called for extensive land settlement agreements
before the pipeline project could proceed. Effectively, this established a moratorium on a major infrastructural
development, a significant win for Aboriginal activists. Similar confrontations took place in northern Quebec
over the James Bay hydroelectric development program, a process that hardened Innu and Cree sentiment against
Pquiste separatism.

Figure 11.16 Members of the Mohawk First Nation at the

barricades, Kanesatake, 1990.

The temper of events cooled in the 1980s, but when it returned, it had changed in tone. The town of Oka, a village
to the northwest of Montreal, in 1989 approved the expansion of a private golf course into land claimed by the
Mohawk of Kanesatake, and which contained a Mohawk graveyard. The bands response included a blockade of
access to the proposed construction site in July 1990, which engendered the Oka Crisis. Beginning with a party of
30 armed Mohawk band members, a teargas attack by the Sret du Qubec led to a firefight in which one Sret
member was killed. The ranks of the Oka protesters grew almost overnight to nearly 100 and then to 600. Another
Mohawk community at nearby Kahnawake supported the standoff by blockading access to the Mercier Bridge.
RCMP reinforcements were sent to Oka in support of the Sret, which were soon augmented by members of the
Canadian Armed Forces Royal 22nd Rgiment (the Van Doos). Seventy-eight days after the confrontation began,
the Mohawk forces at Oka stood down. Although the golf course expansion was cancelled, none of the outstand-
ing land claims issues were addressed.

Similar events unfolded at the other end of the country near Gustafsen Lake in central British Columbia in the
summer of 1995. Secwepemc spiritual leaders had established an annual sun dance on rangeland claimed by a
local rancher, and which was within the traditional and unceded lands of the Secwepemc. Despite initial coopera-
tion between the parties involved, goodwill evaporated in the winter of 1995, leading to a confrontation between
Indigenous and non-Indigenous allies against the RCMP. As at Oka, gunfire was exchanged, although there
were no fatalities. The RCMP mobilized enormous resources, including helicopters, armoured personnel carriers,
and several hundred tactical squad members. In September, the Aboriginal side dismantled its position and left
Gustafsen Lake. As at Oka, arrests of protesters followed, and 15 people received sentences of 6 months to 8
years.
 11.10 CANADA AND THE COLONIZED, 1970-2002 699

Gustafsen Lake was still simmering when another protest flared at Ipperwash Provincial Park at the south end of
Lake Huron, where a stretch of shoreline that contained an Anishinaabeg burial site was expropriated from Kettle
Point 44 Reserve under the War Measures Act during WWII. Ottawa promised to return the land at the end of the
war but did not follow through. In 1994 members of the Kettle Point band initiated a round of occupations and
protests to remind authorities that this issue had not been resolved. In September 1995, a group of protesters set up
a camp in the park for a more formal and sustained protest. At the outset, the Ontario Provincial Police attempted
to achieve a negotiated outcome so as not to repeat the mistakes of Oka, or to echo events concurrently underway
in British Columbia. This strategy was replaced by riot police with shields, batons, and helmets. On September
6, the two sides confronted one another in the park, and events quickly spiralled out of control. Gunfire occurred
(participants disagree as to whether shots were fired both ways), and Dudley George (1957-1995) was struck three
times by a police sniper. Attempts to get George to a hospital were blocked by the OPP, and the man bled out.
The sniper, Sergeant Ken Deane, was subsequently tried and found guilty of criminal negligence. The role of the
Ontario Provincial Government, led by Conservative Premier Mike Harris (b. 1945), was resolutely opposed to
the Anishinaabe protest. Harris was quoted by his Attorney-General as saying I want the fucking Indians out of
6
the park.

Figure 11.17 The Kettle Point 44 Reserve was appropriated by

Ottawa during WWII and never returned.

Four years after Ipperwash, confrontation over resources on the East Coast captured the headlines. The Burnt
Church Crisis of 1999-2002 bears similarities with Sparrow in that it proved a test of Aboriginal rights over
resource gathering. In this instance, the Burnt Church First Nation, a Mikmaq community at the mouth of the
Miramichi River in northeastern New Brunswick exercised what they understood to be their right to harvest rea-
sonable amounts of maritime resources, regardless of Department of Fisheries ideas of seasonality. Their attempt
to trap lobster out of season resulted in confrontations with non-Aboriginals (mostly commercial lobster trap-
pers) who attacked Mikmaq equipment and, reportedly, thousands of lobster traps. The conflict expanded into
a community-wide civil war with attacks launched by both sides against property and individuals. By 2002 the
Department of Fisheries itself was attacking Mikmaq boats as the region descended into near-lawlessness. Agree-
ments were reached in the same year that permitted the Mikmaq to fish for subsistence and not for commerce,
regardless of seasons.

Aboriginal people continue to pursue redress, compensation, and rights through legal avenues and protest. Demo-
cratic processes are limited in their ability to achieve results because First Nations constitute relatively small and
mostly isolated populations with limited ability to secure change through the ballot box. Even at the local level,
bands are not always united on the best strategy to pursue and so do not always speak with one voice in formal
negotiations. From a historical perspective, attempts to win advances using extra-parliamentary means speaks to
the fact that Aboriginal peoples have a working relationship with the Crown and an adversarial relationship with
Canada.

6. Ontario, Report of the Ipperwash Inquiry, Vol.1 (Ontario: Government of Ontario, 2007), 363.
700 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Key Points

Legal challenges to Canadas approach to Treaty obligations were essentially illegal until the 1950s,
which significantly dampened Aboriginal peoples recourse.
Resettlement and dispossession of traditional lands accelerated in the 20th century.
Once legal organization was permitted, new Aboriginal organizations like the UBCIC and the NIB
were established to advance First Nations concerns.
Following effective lobbying, Aboriginal rights were enshrined in the Constitution.
Legal precedents tended to favour Aboriginal claimants beginning in the 1970s with Calder, R. v
Sparrow, and Delgamuukw. These cases served to clarify the extent of Aboriginal title and rights,
particularly in the absence of treaties.
The benchmarks for Status were changed in 1985 in a move that remedied the situation of many
Aboriginal women and their children.
The failure of Parliament to address outstanding issues and the costs and slowness of pursuing legal
remedies encouraged some Aboriginal leaders to make use of more confrontational strategies begin-
ning in the 1980s, especially where the issues were immediate. Examples include Oka, Gustafsen
Lake, Ipperwash, and Burnt Church.

Attributions
Figure 11.15
Can high arctic relocation by University of Manitoba : Archives & Special Collections is used under a CC-BY-
SA-3.0 license.

Figure 11.16
Mohawks watching Oka crisis news on barricades (Online MIKAN no.3602895) by Benot Aquin / Library and
Archives Canada / e has nil restrictions on use.

Figure 11.17
[Kettle Point Reserve no. 44. Plan showing the Kettle Point and Stony Point Indian Reserves, Ont.] [carto-
graphic material] (Online MIKAN no. 3694469) by Library and Archives Canada is in the public domain.
 11.11 Residential Schools

Figure 11.18 Study period at the Roman Catholic Indian

Residential School, at Fort Resolution, NWT, n.d.

The goals of the Residential School system (described in Section 11.5 ) were explicitly assimilationist. The pro-
gram existed precisely to replace Aboriginal economic practices with those of the mainstream colonial economy,
substitute English and French for indigenous languages, erase indigenous belief systems with some kind of Chris-
tianity, and interrupt the transmission of social practices (including fundamental familial relationships) by captur-
ing children and keeping them away from their parents, siblings, and other relations. This needs to be underlined:
there was nothing accidental about the way the residential schools turned out; these were clearly stated goals and
tactics.

In the 1960s and 1970s, as plans advanced to end the program, the consequences of a century of residential schools
were everywhere visible. Traumatized children became traumatized adults. Social workers drawn from the colo-
nizing society were sent to reserves often with RCMP and other police supports to rescue children from
dysfunctional environments in which colonialism itself was heavily implicated. In the decade after 1955, as a
study by Christopher Walmsley points out, Aboriginal children in the care of the Province of British Colum-
bia jumped from less than 1% to 34.2%, and this pattern was repeated in other parts of Canada during the same
1
time. Just as residential schools were being closed, the Federal Governments monopoly over the management
of Aboriginal communities on-reserve began to fray, and provincial responsibilities increased:

The principal response of provincial child welfare authorities during the 1960s was the apprehension and removal of
Aboriginal children from their families and communities. Known as the sixties scoop, social workers explained their
2
actions by arguing that they were in the best interests of the children.

Citing poverty, health concerns, and even malnutrition, the secular authorities perpetuated the alienation of chil-
dren from their communities that had begun by missionaries and residential schools. Aboriginal children in care
were placed with non-Aboriginal families, and some were exported to the United States. In almost every case, the

1. Christopher Walmsley, Protecting Aboriginal Children (Vancouver, BC: University of British Columbia Press, 2005), 2.
2. Ibid., 13-15.

701
702 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

link between child and ancestral culture was severed. Whether in care or in residential schools, the same outcomes
prevailed: practices especially, but not exclusively, those censured by the anti-potlatch and sun dance laws
were inadequately passed from one generation to the next; the skills taught at woefully underfunded schools
prepared students for 19th century field labour but not 20th century factories or offices, let alone professions. Sub-
stance abuse on reserves, particularly alcohol, was extensive as generations self-medicated to deal with everything
from a personal sense of diminished self-worth to cultural alienation to systemic poverty and from generation
to generation to the loss of children. Whereas the reserve system and pass system were designed to keep Abo-
riginal people physically in check, the residential school system and the intervention of colonialist social workers
and police authorities were intended to keep them culturally in check.

The enormous educational, social, and moral failures of the residential school system are now widely known. The
system contained a single ineluctable contradiction: it proceeded from an explicitly racist assumption that indige-
nous cultures were inferior and proceeded to strip away those features with an eye to assimilating native people
into mainstream society, but neglected to address the inherent racist and discriminatory perspectives of Euro-
Canadians who would not hire, marry, work with, drink with, study with, lend money to, extend the franchise
to, or vote for Aboriginal people, regardless of whether they were schooled or not. Assimilation was entirely
about change, and not about inclusion. It could hardly be otherwise under the circumstances.

At the peak in the 1930s, there were roughly 80 residential schools in Canada. They were in seven of the nine
provinces; there were none in New Brunswick and Prince Edward Island, nor were in the Dominion (later, the
province) of Newfoundland. Most of the schools were located far from urban centres. As institutions go, the large
brick or stone structures were universally imposing. At Kamloops (Tkemlps), for example, the Indian Residen-
tial School, opened in 1893, was the largest brick structure in the Thompson Valleys and, indeed, between the
Lower Mainland and the CPR hotels of the Rocky Mountain national parks. An entire brickworks was established
to enable its construction. On Kuper Island, at Alert Bay, and in town after town across the Prairies, two- and
three-storey buildings were erected to enable the warehousing and transformation of generations of Native chil-
dren.

The involvement of the nations Christian churches from the outset was viewed by officials as a good way to
transmit Euro-Canadian cultural values, morals, and discipline. It was, as well, cheap, because missionary groups
would effectively work for free. Over half of the schools were run by the Catholic Church, most of the rest by
the Anglicans, and the remainder by the United Church and the Presbyterians. Conditions varied from place to
place, but few were adequately funded; by the second quarter of the 20th century, child labour was an essential
component of the residential school business model. Through most of their history, the general practice at resi-
dential schools was to provide only half-day schooling; the rest of the day was dedicated to labour in the fields
and workshops, and mopping the floors to keep the children busy and reduce operating costs. The schooling the
students received was light on the humanities, lighter still on sciences and math, and heavy on religion and theol-
ogy. Generally speaking, girls were taught domestic skills like cooking and sewing, while boys were taught basic
agricultural skills and some crafts.

Children were housed in dormitory rooms. Rows of beds allowed for little privacy. Boys and girls were separated
and kept separate: stories abound of brothers and sisters who were allowed no contact despite being kept in the
same building. Showers and baths were spartan. Meals were Dickensian, and children suffered from malnutrition.
Complaints of cold facilities are sustained by a terrible record of mortalities from illnesses, including tuberculosis
(which claimed as many as 60% of the student population). Every residential school has its own sad little grave-
 11.11 RESIDENTIAL SCHOOLS 703

yard, and some of them arent that little. As Mary-Ellen Kelm has pointed out, some schools kept their mortality
statistics low by shipping fatally ill children home to their families, which consequently inflated mortality rates on
reserves. Kelm also has noted that the transformation of Aboriginal diets to Euro-Canadian foods was part of an
3
attempt to colonize not only the mind but the Aboriginal body as well. Doing so could be lethal: only recently, it
has become known that nutritional experiments conducted on children under Ottawas auspices resulted in deaths.

If the colonizing society wasnt intervening in education or abducting children from what authorities judged as
poor environments, it was managing some of the health crises in which it was once again complicit. Indian
hospitals, separate from non-Aboriginal facilities, were established to deal with the specific illnesses (mostly
tuberculosis) that afflicted Aboriginal populations. On the whole, these Indian hospitals functioned as another ele-
ment in the governments management of Aboriginal lives.

Sainty Morris

In the mid-1940s, perhaps a little later, Sainty Morris still a very young child contracted tuberculosis
from his older brother, with whom he shared a bed in his parents home on the reserve near Duncan on
Vancouver Island. Soon thereafter, he was sent by medical authorities to the Nanaimo Indian Hospital,
more than 60 km north. He passed along this account from which I quote at some length to a histo-
rian of healthcare Laurie Meijer Drees. One would have to have a very flinty heart indeed to read this and
not be moved; more than that, however, it serves to show the severe disempowerment of Aboriginal people
and the complicity of far more than a handful of officials and professionals in the business of controlling
Aboriginal children.

In the hospital the food was good. At the time we were used to our native ice cream [made from berries and fish
grease whipped together] and other food that we were raise[d] on. At that time, my family had little money,
and we lived mainly off the land and the beaches. When I was in hospital, I wished I had clams, duck, and all that
food from home that I could not have.
The nurses when I first got in there were funny. They were mean and there was one nurse who used the strap on
us. I remember a particular time. It was when I first got to the hospital. They had what you called a rest period.
It was set for an hour in the morning and an hour in the afternoon. I was new there and could not force myself
to sleep so I picked myself up a book, a comic book. As I was lying there reading, I remember how suddenly the
book was smashed out of my hand. I got strapped! The nurse took my comic book away and strapped my hand
with leather.
On the other hand, there was another nurse who was very friendly. []I thought she was a very wonderful friend
as opposed to the other one. I wasnt the only one that was strapped. She strapped a lot of other children.
I was there off and on for, I cant remember, years, months, days. I was in there for a year and a half when they
sent me to Kuper Island Indian Residential School. After being there for a while, I was sent back to the Nanaimo
Indian Hospital.
[]One day the head nurse came to see me, and she told me I was going home. I was so happy! She said, We are
going to measure you for clothing and are ordering your clothes from Vancouver. Then you are going home. A
few weeks later, the nurses came and brought me to change into my new clothes. I got a bath and changed clothes,
and then I asked if I could visit my friends and relatives [in the hospital]. I was allowed to visit, and they said,
Well find you when the nurse is ready. Miss Fletcher finally showed up, and we got into her car and starting
heading south, towards where my family lived.

3. Mary-Ellen Kelm, Colonizing Bodies: Aboriginal Health and Healing in British Columbia, 1900-50 (Vancouver, BC: University of British
Columbia Press, 1998).
 704 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

We started going towards Chemainus [a town between Nanaimo and Duncan]. I thought we were going to a store
there, but when we got to the wharf, she told me to get out. I thought, What is going on? She told me, You
are going to Kuper Island Residential School. I told her, No, they told me I was going home. Thats when the
nurse told me, No, Ive got strict orders not to leave you until you get onto that boat. So I got onto the boat, and
they brought me there.

Figure 11.19 Kuper Island Residential School.

This school was another awful place. They [the hospital staff] didnt tell my parents they were shipping me to
Kuper Island! My parents didnt know where I was! My sister-in-law, Therese [another TB case at the Indian
Hospital], she phoned my parents to ask how I was doing, and thats when it turned out they didnt know where I
was. I finally wrote a letter to let them know I was at the school. When I asked the principal why they sent me to
Kuper Island, he said that I was here for a rest. Some rest that was. I tell you, I did not know why they did that!
As soon as I got there, they had me scrubbing things on my hands and knees and washing everything by hand.
After I finished one place, I had to wax. I had to do every room in that school, both the boy and girl sides. The
other kids were in school, and I went to class part of the time. One day they told me to go to the top dormitory and
to wash the outside of the building and to be careful not to fall down. There was no rope, no safety, and if there
was a streak I would have to go back and clean it. Eventually I got sick again, and I was sent back to the hospital
4
in Nanaimo.

Whether First Nations leaders found the concept of the industrial and then residential schools helpful to their peo-
ple or not, the reality fell very far short. Parents often resisted sending their children away, and it was one of the
functions of the RCMP and units like the BC Provincial Police to assist the clergy with annual roundups of stu-
dents. It wasnt until the late 1950s that the educational curriculum improved, nor was it until then that children
were allowed to visit with family over the holidays. The record suggests that a great many parents discovered that
their child had died at school only when the summer holidays began.

These are the elements of the systemic weaknesses and shortcomings of the residential schools. Underfunding
alone would have produced many of these negative outcomes. Tales of physical and sexual abuse operate at a dif-
ferent level. The principle Christian denominations were viewed by Euro-Canadian society as moral guardians; as
a result, Canadians found it difficult to accept tales of abuse. Evidence began to accumulate and patterns began to
emerge in the 1970s and 1980s. In 1990 the leader of the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs, Phil Fontaine (b. 1944),
publicly disclosed the sexual abuse he suffered as a child in residential schools, along with his reckoning that
every boy in his class was similarly mistreated. This disclosure led to others and, in 1991, a Royal Commission
on Aboriginal Peoples was convened. Seven years later, the Minister of Indian Affairs issued a formal apology
to victims of sexual abuse in the schools, and a multi-million dollar fund for healing was established. While this
process uncovered some very grim tales, it did not speak to the psychological, physical (in addition to sexual),
and emotional abuse experienced routinely in the schools. Priests and nuns alike, as well as secular workers at the
schools, were named, some charged, and some convicted of a wide range of sadistic practices. One survivor of

4. Sainty Morris, interviewed in Laurie Meijer Drees, Healing Histories: Stories from Canadas Indian Hospitals (Edmonton, AB: University of Alberta Press,
2013), xviii-xxx.
 11.11 RESIDENTIAL SCHOOLS 705

St. Annes Residential School at Fort Albany, ON went on record to describe the kind of abuse meted out by one
nun:

I remember being in the dining room having a meal. I got sick and threw up on the floor. Sister Mary Immaculate [Anna
Wesley] slapped me many times and made me eat my own vomit. So I did, I ate all of it. And then I threw up again
5
Sister Mary Immaculate slapped me and told me again to eat my vomit. I was sick for a few days after that.

Beginning in the 1950s, Aboriginal children were permitted to attend public schools for the first time, and as day-
students. Family connections were rebuilt, but the residential schools remained in place for most of the youngest
First Nations children in the country. In 1969 the D.I.A. took over the operation of the schools from the churches,
which coincided with the Red Paper and the rise of Aboriginal political organizations. However, this is not to say
that there was unanimity among First Nations as to what should happen next. Gradually, the responsibility for
the schools operations shifted to local band councils. By 1986 all of the schools were in the hands of Aboriginal
managers, and many had been closed down entirely. It is reckoned that 150,000 children passed through the sys-
tem from the end of the 19th century to the mid-1980s.

Some of the structures are still standing: St. Eugene near Cranbrook has been converted into a luxury resort/
casino and now generates revenue for the Ktunaxa First Nation; the Kamloops Indian Residential School houses
offices and a museum for the highly entrepreneurial Tkemlps te Secwepemc. Other schools are no more: the
Penelakut/Kuper Island school was demolished in the 1980s, as was St. Michaels at Alert Bay very recently in
both cases, the prohibitive costs of repair and rehabilitation were a factor, as was an unwillingness to tolerate the
gloomy presence of the buildings any longer.

In 1988 Ottawa issued the first of two official apologies for the residential school experiment. Lawsuits followed
and, by 2005, Ottawa had accepted a measure of culpability and set aside $1.8 billion in a compensation fund for
survivors of residential schools. In 2008 Prime Minister Stephen Harper issued a fulsome apology in the House of
Commons; in an unprecedented move, the leaders of Canadas various Aboriginal political organizations attended.
Although the apology was a landmark in that it involved culpability and knowledge that children placed in the
care of the state were harmed, it did not accept liability. While some Aboriginal people were pleased with the
apology, for many it was insufficient. When Stephen Harper announced to the G-20 in 2009 that Canada has no
history of colonialism, questions were asked with respect to the sincerity and intelligence of his apology. Aspects
of the apology and the political movements arising from it are considered in the next section.

Key Points

The residential schools were a project devised to replace aboriginal culture with a version of Euro-
Canadian, Christian culture, and part of a larger concerted effort to interrupt the reproduction of cul-
tural traditions in Aboriginal communities.
Education and training did little to prepare Aboriginal pupils for the Canadian economy.
The 80 residential schools located in every territory and province other than New Brunswick, PEI,
and Newfoundland were operated by Christian clergy.

5. Jesse Staniforth, Cover up of residential school crimes a national shame, [Link], August 25, 2015, accessed January 31, 2016, [Link]
[Link]/opinion/commentary/2015/08/25/[Link].
706 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Conditions were very poor, resulting in malnutrition, vulnerability to disease, and high levels of
mortality.
There were extraordinarily high levels of physical, psychological, and sexual abuse in the schools,
principally by the clergy.
The schools began closing in the 1980s; all have now been closed, demolished, or repurposed.

Attributions
Figure 11.18
Priode dtude au pensionnat indien catholique de [Fort] Resolution, T. N.-O. (Online MIKAN no.4063309)
by Canada, Minister of the Interior, Library and Archives Canada / PA-042133 is in the public domain.

Figure 11.19
Kuper Island Indian Residential School (Online MIKAN no.4820442) by Canada. Dept. of Interior / Library
and Archives Canada / e011156551-v8 ; e011156551_s1-v8 is in the public domain.
 11.12 Idle No More

MARY-ELLEN KELM, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY

Figure 11.20 Idle No More marchers in Ottawa, 2013.

On June 11, 2008, Prime Minister Stephen Harper rose in Canadas House of Commons to give an official apology
for residential schooling. He called the treatment of Aboriginal children in the schools a sad chapter in our
1
history, for which the Government of Canada sincerely apologizes. Mr. Harper and the other party leaders
expressed palpable remorse for the past injustices of Canadian policy, and leaders representing First Nations,
Mtis, Inuit peoples, women, and urban Aboriginal people gravely responded to the apology from the floor of the
House.

For many Canadians, this promised to be a turning point in our relations with Aboriginal peoples. Until the 1990s
when stories of abuse in the schools hit the media and the courts, most Canadians had never heard of the schools.
Now the Prime Minister of Canada was admitting that a government policy had been wrong and that the attitudes
that inspired the policy have no place in Canada. More importantly, he promised a new relationship between
Aboriginal peoples and Canadians, one of shared history, renewed understanding, and new respect for all cultures,
2
traditions, and communities. Two processes were meant to bring this new relationship about. First there was com-
pensation for those who attended the residential schools. Second, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission
(TRC) was tasked with documenting the full history of the schools. Restorative justice scholars gave the Harper
3
apology high marks.

However, the apology was not a turning point. Its major failing was that it situated all the wrongs of government
policy in the past. It did not commit the Canadian Government in any concrete way to changing its actions towards

1. Stephen Harper, Statement of Apology to Former Students of Indian Residential Schools, House of Commons, Ottawa, June, 11, 2008,
accessed April 27, 2016, [Link]
2. Ibid.
3. Sheryl Lightfoot, Settler-State Apologies to Indigenous Peoples: A Normative Framework and Comparative Assessment, Journal of the
Native American and Indigenous Studies Association 2, no. 1 (2015): 33.

707
 708 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

First Nations, Inuit, and Mtis peoples in the present. This was a significant mistake because a changed relation-
4
ship with Canada was what Aboriginal people wanted.

By 2008, Aboriginal people in Canada had already begun to shift the conversation between themselves and Cana-
dians in really fundamental ways. In the 20th century, Aboriginal people demanded government recognition of
their rights and title to the land. As a new generation of Aboriginal leaders arose, they increasingly sought resur-
gence of their own cultures and communities rather than recognition. They wanted a new relationship with
Canada, the kind of relationship of sharing and mutual respect that their ancestors had expected when they signed
treaties.

Figure 11.21 The Jericho Diamond Mine pit in Nunavut, n.d.

The trouble was that Aboriginal people have not shared equally in Canadian wealth. In some parts of Canada,
5
Aboriginal people have poverty rates that are three times those of other Canadians. Less money is spent on
6
reserve schools and Aboriginal children are ten times more likely to end up in foster care. So while Mr. Harper
was apologizing for the damage done to Aboriginal children and families by residential schools, the legacies of
7
residential schooling continued unabated.

The Cree community of Attawapiskat has become emblematic of Canadas dysfunctional relationship with Abo-
riginal people. An isolated community on the shores of James Bay, Attawapiskat made the news repeatedly in
the early 2000s. Its only school was condemned as a health hazard, and student Shannen Koostachin took her
demands for a new school to Ottawa in 2007. Four years later, Chief Theresa Spence (b. 1963) declared a state
of emergency over inadequate housing. What made the situation worse was that the multinational corporation
DeBeers was just 80 km away making a steady profit mining diamonds from Cree lands. The agreement DeBeers
signed with Attawapiskat to share the mines benefits did not include infrastructure, such as schools and houses,
8
because that was, they argued, the responsibility of the Canadian government. On December 11, 2012, Spence
9
announced that she would go on a hunger strike to protest unfulfilled treaties.

When Spence announced her hunger strike, she joined an already growing wave of protest and resurgence among

4. Beverley Jacobs, Response to Canadas Apology to Residential School Survivors, Canadian Woman Studies 26, no. 3/4 (2008): 223;
Sheryl Lightfoot, Settler-State Apologies to Indigenous Peoples: A Normative Framework and Comparative Assessment, Journal of the
Native American and Indigenous Studies Association 2, no. 1 (2015): 33.
5. Shauna MacKinnon, The Harper Apology: Residential Schools and Bill C-10 (Winnipeg: Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, Mani-
toba Office, January 24, 2012); Aboriginal Children in Care Working Group, Aboriginal Children in Care: Report to Canadas Premiers
(Ottawa: Council of the Federation Secretariat, 2015): 45. July 2015: 45.
6. Don Drummond and Ellen Rosenbluth, The Debate on First Nations Education Funding: Mind the Gap, Working Paper, Queens Univer-
sity Policy Studies (Kingston: Queens University, December 2013); Aboriginal Children in Care Working Group, Aboriginal Children in
Care, 7.
7. Aboriginal Children in Care Working Group, Aboriginal Children in Care, 6.
8. Kelly Crichton, Producer, 8th Fire: Canada, Aboriginal Peoples and the Way Forward, Documentary Series, Canadian Broadcasting Corpo-
ration, 2012, accessed April 27, 2016, [Link]
2172311969/.
9. The Kino-nda-niimi Collective, The Winter We Danced: Voices from the Past, the Future, and the Idle No More Movement (Winnipeg, MB:
ARP Books, 2014), 391.
 11.12 IDLE NO MORE 709

Aboriginal people. The protest centred on government Bill C-45, a 457-page omnibus bill that loosened legal
restrictions inhibiting investment in Canadian resources. The changes that C-45 introduced to the Indian Act, for
example, made it easier to lease or surrender reserve land by removing the democratic requirement for a commu-
nity-wide vote. First Nations were not consulted on any of these changes. Within a month of C-45s first reading,
on 10 November 2012, four Aboriginal women in Saskatoon Sylvia McAdam, Nina Wilson, Jessica Gordon,
10
and Sheelah McLean conducted a teach-in on the bill, which they publicized under the name Idle No More.

For the next six months, Idle No More exemplified Aboriginal resurgence. Social media was a major force in Idle
No More: by May 2013, there had been over 1.2 million Twitter mentions of the #Idlenomore hashtag. The social
media profile of Idle No More underscores an important feature of the movement: it was diverse and dispersed
in its power and its leadership not linked to any mainstream Aboriginal organization. Idle No More acknowl-
edged the importance of women in Aboriginal communities, and they often took the stage at events. To honour
her leadership, the movement rallied behind Chief Spence in her hunger strike.

To emphasize the social media component is, however, to miss the incredible live experience of the movement.
Hundreds attended teach-ins across the country to learn more about bill C-45, and how it violated treaty rights.
Thousands marched on Parliament Hill on January 10, 2013 and participated in coordinated days of action across
the country.

The Harper apology in 2008 and the subsequent findings of the TRC, released in 2015, have given Canadians
ample reason to reflect on their failed relationship with Aboriginal people. Yet Aboriginal people ask not that
Canadians focus on the past, but on the present and the future. TRC Chair, Chief Justice Murray Sinclair, has said
that Canada will fail to uphold the spirit of the 2008 apology unless it commits to involving Aboriginal people
11
in decisions about their lands and resources. This too was Idle No Mores demand as the movement expressed
renewed pride among Aboriginal peoples for their grassroots leadership and traditional methods of peaceful social
change.

Key Points

The intent of Harpers 2008 apology was to bring an end to the saga of the residential schools, but it
provided little in the way of a plan for moving forward.
Compensation and a Royal Commission on Truth and Reconciliation followed.
Aboriginal peoples sought two things in particular: a resurgence, rebuilding of their cultures and
communities, along with an equitable share of Canadian prosperity. Substandard housing conditions,
water supplies, and school facilities on reserves became a focus.
Changes to the Indian Act introduced in 2012 promised to further weaken Aboriginal control over
reserve and traditional lands a prospect that spurred the Idle No More movement.
One result of these developments has been a shift in discourse among Aboriginal peoples and among
Canadians generally.

10. Ibid., 390.

11. APTN National News, PM Harper Has Failed to Live up to Promise of 2008 Residential School Apology: TRC, June, 2, 2015, accessed
April 27, 2016, [Link]
710 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Attributions
Figure 11.20
Idle No More 2013 Ottawa 1 by Michelle Caron (Moxy) is used under a CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.

Figure 11.21
Jericho Diamond Mine pit Nunavut Canada by Tomchurchill is in the public domain.
 11.13 Summary

Figure 11.22 Members of the Alkali Lake

Braves hockey team in Vancouver, 1932. A
few years later liquor became available to
the Esketemc and an alcoholism epidemic
was underway. The bands collective
recovery began in the 1970s and has
become legendary, although recovery from
cultural genocide, abuses in schools, and
on-reserve poverty continues to be a work in
progress.

The thrust of Canadian policy as regards Aboriginal people was, from 1867 on, assimilation. John A. Macdonald
said that the great aim of our legislation has been to do away with the tribal system and assimilate the Indian
1
people in all respects with the inhabitants of the Dominion, as speedily as they are fit for the change. There were
several obstacles to this project, one of which was the racism deeply embedded in Canadian society and laws that
implied that Indians would never be fit for inclusion. Another obstacle was the resistance mounted by Aborigi-
nal peoples to assimilationist institutions and laws.

To be sure, Canadian efforts on this front were also clumsy and largely ineffectual. Decades of promoting the
benefits of relinquishing Indian Status and joining Canadian society resulted in only 250 Aboriginal people taking
up the offer of enfranchisement by 1920. Despite the menacing look of the laws against the potlatch and the sun
2
dance, they were feebly enforced (with a few notable exceptions), as was the pass system. Residential schools
were much more efficient at crippling family relations and damaging childhoods than they were at producing new
Canadians ready to join the mainstream economy. Leaving the business of education in the hands of parsimo-
nious missionary religious orders meant that the absence of traditional cultural practices would not be replaced
with an education of comparable value. Aboriginal parents and communities who had hoped for relevant training
to prepare their children for a world with narrower resources and newly established economic structures would be

1. Quoted in J.R. Miller, Skyscrapers Hide the Heavens: A History of Indian-White Relations in Canada, revised edition (Toronto, ON: Univer-
sity of Toronto Press, 1991), 189.
2. ibid., 190-194.

711
712 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

disappointed. Children themselves resisted the sham of industrial and residential schools by running away, com-
mitting acts of vandalism and arson, and by being uncooperative.

The circumstances faced by Aboriginal peoples after 1867 varied by place and over time. The Mtis diaspora
or at least some of it was, culturally speaking, in a better position to integrate into the emergent Canadian
systems of land ownership, commerce, and knowledge. But at the same time, the Mtis lacked any kind of home-
land comparable to the reserves that provided First Nations with a base of operations. However, these reserves
offered little in the way of guaranteed community prosperity. This was especially the case among relocated com-
munities in the sub-Arctic and Arctic, Nova Scotia, the Kootenays, and along the Great Lakes (to name only a
few locations where people were shunted about to make way for efficiencies, the military, hydroelectricity, and
mines). Nothing flags poor conditions on reserves and across the North as much as the ubiquity of tuberculosis in
Aboriginal communities TB is a symptom of poverty, inadequate housing, and poor diets. Colonial-era changes
in traditional food supplies were coupled to immediate and general environmental degradation to produce con-
ditions that favoured tuberculosis. The fact that Aboriginal populations recovered in impressive numbers in the
face of these grim environmental circumstances begs the question: What would the demographic curve look like
if Aboriginal peoples from the 1920s to the 1980s had enjoyed better housing, water, food, schools, and incomes,
and less TB?

Dealing with TB required the further bureaucratization and institutionalization of Aboriginal life. Indian hospi-
tals joined a long list of systems that measured, monitored, rationalized, and individualized Native people. At the
same time, these modernist institutions schools, courts, prisons, hospitals, and Indian Affairs had to identify
Indian-ness to fulfill their task of expunging it. Treating all Aboriginal people as one was a kind of pan-Indian
approach that, along the way, made it possible for First Nations, Inuit, and Mtis to find common ground and to
build the foundations of a response.

Whatever the shortcomings of the colonialist experience, Aboriginal leaders could nonetheless play the role of
magpies, keeping their eyes sharp for the few shiny opportunities that became available. They found useful tools
for building up band offices, commercial enterprises, and social programs. The Tkemlps te Secwepemc (for-
merly the Kamloops Indian Band) exemplifies the ways in which First Nations people exploited Canadian assimi-
lationist policies to fashion an effective hybrid culture of entrepreneurship based on principles of band ownership.
Several of the Niitsitapi bands enjoy significant advantages arising from their oil-rich reserve lands. The Wei Wai
Kum and We Wai Kai of Campbell River and Cape Mudge have utilized other models of economic advance-
ment through commercial development and aboriginal tourism. Each of these experiments began in earnest in
the 1980s, and each has leveraged economic success to build cultural and linguistic recovery. It is trite to say that
not every experiment has met with victory and that many have faced criticism from within and without individual
bands; of course, that is the case. Failure, regrouping, and further trial and error is in the nature of experimenta-
tion.

It would be even more trite to suggest that the success of a few bands negates the fact that most Aboriginal
people continue to live in poverty. A disproportionate number are incarcerated, and violence, abuse, suicide, and
homicide are a reality of Aboriginal lives much more so than for non-Aboriginals. Racism has not gone away; it
remains a lived experience. One consequence of events since 1970, however, has been the emergence of a cadre
of Aboriginal leaders many of them highly educated and quite a few of them women whose prominence
in government, the arts, media, and commerce are impossible to miss. It is not the business of history to suggest
where this may go, nor are historians especially concerned with where we are right now. However, an exploration
 11.13 SUMMARY 713

of the experience of Aboriginal peoples in the past points to themes the continuing exploration of the relevance
of treaties and mutual sovereignty, the necessity of dialogue, the many acts of resistance mounted by native people
against colonialism, and the persistence of dramatic inequalities in a country that ostensibly places a high value on
humanism that have contributed to the energy and success of both Idle No More and the Truth and Reconcil-
iation Commission. The current context of that story the post-Cold War, post-colonial, and postmodern world
is examined in the next chapter.

Figure 11.23 Jody

Wilson-Raybould (b. 1971) is
a Kwakwaka-wakw politician
from Comox who was elected
in the riding of Vancouver
Granville in 2015. She is
currently the Federal Minister
of Justice the first
Aboriginal person to hold that
position.

Key Terms

Aboriginal rights: Defined in two ways: 1) as an abstract set of inherent and collective rights available
on principle only to Aboriginal peoples, which may include land, resource and treaty rights; 2) also or
alternately, cultural rights associated with traditional or customary practices that are thought to predate
European contact. The latter are protected in the Constitution Act, 1982.
Aboriginal tourism: Usually associated with cultural displays and/or performances, sometimes with
Aboriginal lifestyle experiences. The sector was very small in the 1990s, but since has become an annual
multi-million dollar industry.
Assembly of First Nations (AFN): The successor to the National Indian Brotherhood (NIB); the AFN,
a national advocacy organization that represents Aboriginal peoples, was established in 1982.
band offices: The administrative centre of a First Nation band; a unit of government within the First
Nation; applies principally to populations covered by the Indian Act (that is, Status Indians). The band
council is the decision-making assembly in the band office.
Burnt Church Crisis: Between 1999 and 2002, a confrontation between the Burnt Church First Nation
(a Mikmaq community in New Brunswick) and non-Aboriginal fishers and the Federal Department of
Fisheries.
Calder Case: Supreme Court case (Calder v British Columbia) in 1973 that decided that Aboriginal title
existed prior to colonization and persisted after 1871.
Criminal Code: Properly, an Act respecting the criminal law; the Criminal Code is a regularly amended
body of legislation pertaining to criminal as opposed to civil or statute law.
714 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

cultural genocide: Premeditated and systematic attempts to eliminate a culture while not necessarily
exterminating the population.
Delgamuukw v British Columbia: 1997 landmark decision in the Supreme Court of Canada; estab-
lished a test for the existence of Aboriginal title, extended title beyond evidence of past use to include
custodianship of territory, and thus includes a cultural relationship rather than simply an economic
relationship with the land.
Department of Indian Affairs and Northern Development: Created in 1966, a successor administra-
tive unit to the Department of Indian Affairs (D.I.A.).
Department of Indian Affairs (DIA): Established in 1888 to administer the Federal Governments
responsibilities as regards First Nations; was housed for many years under the office of the Minister of
the Interior (who was also responsible for settling the West with immigrants).
Douglas Treaties: Negotiated by Governor James Douglas of Vancouver Island in the colonial era and
concluded with 14 First Nations in the colony in the early 1850s; apart from Treaty No.8 in the Peace
District, the only treaties in British Columbia before the late 20th century.
Fourth World: A category of mostly small and colonized indigenous populations around the globe;
juxtaposed with First (northwestern European and North American), Second (Soviet bloc of developed
nations), and Third (developing) Worlds; formalized with the establishment of the World Council of
Indigenous Peoples led by George Manuel in the mid-1970s.
Idle No More: A peaceful protest and awareness-raising movement launched in 2012 by a group of
Aboriginal and allies; catalyzed by Federal Government legislation that threatened Treaty rights.
Mohawk Institute: First industrial school for Aboriginal people, principally Mohawk; taught basic aca-
demic instruction and trades; based in Brantford, Ontario; opened in the 1830s under the auspices of the
New England Company.
nadir: The opposite of zenith; it is the trough, and in demographic terms, it means the point at which a
falling population bottoms out and from which it recovers. In the case of First Nations populations, they
continued to fall until the 1920s at which point they began a steady recovery.
National Indian Brotherhood (NIB): Established in 1967-1968 and propelled into action by the
appearance of the White Paper (1969). See also Assembly of First Nations.
numbered treaties: Treaties struck between Canada and Aboriginal peoples from 1871 (Treaty 1) to
1921 (Treaty 11), covering a territory that stretches from Ontarios eastern boundary in the North West to
British Columbia, incorporating the whole of the Peace River Valley and the Mackenzie River drainage
basin. Areas not covered by numbered treaties include southern Ontario (including the Rainy River area
and Thunder Bay-Nippissing corridor), most of British Columbia, most of the Yukon and North West
Territories, and all of Quebec, the Maritimes, and Newfoundland-Labrador.
Oka Crisis: In 1990 armed Mohawk band members from Kanesatake blockaded access to the proposed
construction site of a golf course in Oka; the arrival of Canadian Armed Forces troops was followed by
disruptions of traffic through reserve lands to the south by Mohawk band members from Kahnawake.
pass system: Aboriginal reserve residents were required to secure a pass from their Indian agent in order
to leave the reserve.
Penner Report: Recommended to Ottawa in 1983 that Aboriginal peoples constitute a distinct order of
government and ought to be recognized as such.
post-colonial, post-colonialism: The range of experiences and perspectives that look beyond the para-
digm of colonial society and colonialism; associated with the late 20th century.
 11.13 SUMMARY 715

potlatch: Refers to ceremonies associated with First Nations cultures on the Pacific Northwest Coast.
Red Paper: Also called Citizens Plus; prepared by Harold Cardinal and the Indian Association of
Alberta in 1970, the Red Paper was a response to Ottawas 1969 White Paper (aka: The Statement of the
Government of Canada on Indian Policy, 1969); called for preservation of Treaty rights and recognition
of Aboriginal rights.
Red Power: A continent-wide movement led by Aboriginal peoples in the late 1960s and through the
1970s to place Aboriginal issues on the political agenda.
Royal Proclamation: 1763; Britains first constitution for post-Conquest Canada; recognized inherent
Indigenous land tenure rights or Aboriginal title to the land, making it impossible for any authority or
individual other than the Crown to alienate Aboriginal title; provoked objections among the American
colonists because it interfered with their plans for westward expansion; sometimes called the Indian
Magna Carta.
Section 35: Of the Constitution Act, 1982; recognizes and affirms Aboriginal rights.
sixties scoop: The apprehension and removal of Aboriginal children from their families and communi-
ties by provincial child welfare authorities during the 1960s.
Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC): A commission tasked in 2008 with documenting the
full history of the residential schools; report presented in 2015.
tuberculosis (TB): An epidemic associated with rapid urbanization, tenement housing, slums, and
poverty; spread rapidly in the post-Confederation period, becoming epidemic among Aboriginal popu-
lations; tuberculosis sanatoria were established and operating across Canada until the 1960s, by which
time antibiotics (especially Streptomycin) had severely reduced the incidence and morbidity associated
with TB.
Union of BC Indian Chiefs (UBCIC): Established in 1969 in response to the Federal Governments
White Paper; replaced rival coastal and interior groups.
vagrancy: The state of being without work or employment, homelessness, and (often) transience; asso-
ciated with poverty and begging. Vagrancy was treated as a crime and was listed in the Criminal Code
until 1972. The 21st century has seen the return of anti-vagrancy laws with different names.
wheat pools: Typically cooperatives made up of grain growers who combined (pooled) their output
and risk to reduce competition and overheads while securing the best price; replaced temporarily by
the Canadian Wheat Board in 1935; competed against private grain elevators in the post-war era.
White Paper: Also known as The Statement of the Government of Canada on Indian Policy, 1969; pro-
posed the dismantling of the Indian Act, an effective end to Indian Status, and the conversion of reserve
land to private property; introduced by the Liberal government of Pierre Trudeau and led by the Minister
of Justice, Jean Chrtien; met with strident opposition from Aboriginal leaders, part of which took the
form of the Red Paper.

Short Answer Exercises

1. In what ways did the Euro-Canadian colonization of Canada reduce the ability of Aboriginal peo-
ple to thrive?
2. What were the principal demographic forces governing Aboriginal populations in the post-Con-
716 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

federation era?
3. What principles and rights did Aboriginal peoples believe they enjoyed at the time of Confedera-
tion? How, why, and to what extent were these removed in the decades that followed?
4. How did the relationship between Canada and Aboriginal peoples change in the years from 1876
to the early 20th century?
5. What purposes lay behind the Numbered Treaties and schools? Consider both the Aboriginal peo-
ples goals and those of the Canadians.
6. Why did Canada attempt to dissolve the Indian Act in 1969 and what was the consequence of that
initiative?
7. Why did Aboriginal resistance increasingly take the form of court challenges and extra-legal
protests?
8. What was impact of the residential school experiment?
9. What is the historic context of Idle No More and the Truth and Reconciliation Commission?

Suggested Readings
Girard, Michel F. The Oka Crisis from an Environmental Perspective, 1870-1990. In Consuming Canada: Read-
ings in Environmental History, edited by Chad Gaffield and Pam Gaffield, 298-315. Toronto, ON: Copp Clark,
1995.

Kenny, James and Bill Parenteau. Each year the Indians flexed their muscles a little more: The Maliseet
Defence of Aboriginal Fishing Rights on the St. John River, 19451990. Canadian Historical Review 95, no.
2 (2014): 187-216.

Knickerbocker, Madeline Rose. namaa, Su Na chii kchige, ems taaw: Indigenous-Academic Collaborative
Histories. Histoire sociale/Social history 48, no. 96 (2015): 294-302.

Lutz, John. After the Fur Trade: The Aboriginal Labouring Class of British Columbia, 1849-1890. Journal of
the Canadian Historical Association 3 (1992): 69-93.

Lux, Maureen K. Care for the Racially Careless: Indian Hospitals in the Canadian West, 19201950s. Cana-
dian Historical Review 91, no. 3 (2010): 407-434.

Neimi-Bohun, Melanie. Colonial Categories and Familial Responses to Treaty and Metis Scrip Policy: The
Edmonton and District Stragglers, 187088. Canadian Historical Review 90, no. 1 (2009): 71-98.

Neylan, Susan. Colonialism and Resettling British Columbia: Canadian Aboriginal Historiography,
19922012. History Compass 11, no. 10 (2013): 833-844.

Rueck, Daniel. Commons, Enclosure, and Resistance in Kahnawke Mohawk Territory, 18501900. Canadian
Historical Review 95, no. 3 (2014): 352-381.
 11.13 SUMMARY 717

Attributions
Figure 11.22
CVA 99-4112 Indian Hockey Team [from] Alkali Lake by Stewart Thompson / City of Vancouver Archives
(AM1535-: CVA 99-4112) is in the public domain.

Figure 11.23
Jody Wilson-Raybould by Erich Saide is used under a CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.
 PART 13

Chapter 12. Canada at the End of History

718
12.1 Introduction

Figure 12.1 The National Film Board came under heavy fire in
the early 1990s when it produced a 3-part series, The Valour and
the Horror, on what it claimed were less-than-noble moments in
Canadas WWII record. The CBC aired the series and was
excoriated by politicians and veterans alike.

Just as 1914-1918 marks a watershed in the history of the modern world, so does 1989-1991. The end of the Cold
War signalled to some a turning point in international affairs and, thus, the end of the short 20th century.

Francis Fukuyama (b. 1952), an American political economist, argued in his 1992 book The End of History and
the Last Man that the centuries-long struggle between competing ideologies was essentially settled and that liberal
democracies with market economies had won. It wasnt that history itself was over but that the idea of history as
an unfolding of alternative models of social and economic relations was done. This constitutes a response to Karl
Marx the 19th century political economist who predicted, instead, the inevitable triumph of the industrial
proletariat, the elimination of national governments and states, and the emergence of global (though not Soviet)
communism.

One could debate endlessly whether Fukuyama was on target, premature, or a decade late. His work nevertheless
underscored the fact that the world had reached a watershed in the early 1990s. The growth of the nation state
since the 18th century as an idea and a phenomenon had dominated thinking about history for two centuries.
The Western perspective was severely linear and, after the mid-19th century, evolutionary as well. Nations devel-
oped from antiquity through feudalism, absolutism, capitalism, and sometimes communism, to something new.
Each nation moved along this course at its own speed because its economic needs favoured one system over the
last. This view was at the heart of Marxist theory but also the models of most other Western thinkers, journalists,
and importantly historians. For example, the Whig historians of the 19th and early 20th century argued
that the history of humanity was a constant movement forward progress toward a better and better society.
However, the Whigs were no Marxists; they were small-l liberals who believed that greater freedoms from
feudalism or monarchism, for example led to greater happiness and a better nation state. For the most part, the
business of writing history has been bound up with the question of how nations form and operate. This has been

719
 720 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

done in the service of the idea of a Fukuyama-esque history, the unfolding of a nations story from beginning to
end (or more cheerily) to a continuously brighter and better future.

If History (with a capital H) existed to serve (and serve up) the national story of progress, it was deeply rooted
in modernity. The modern age, with its emphasis on social and technological progress, was both the environment
of the state and a measure of its success. Democracy, a wider distribution of wealth and opportunity, and the latest
infrastructural fashions were the means and ends simultaneously. The blueprints of modernity, as we have seen
nearly two centuries ago, would inevitably require revision.

At the end of the Cold War, the balance of global power changed dramatically. International bipolarism was over,
and when the stand-off between the two superpowers evaporated, the necessity and perhaps the possibility of
mutually assured destruction (MAD) also went out the door, even though more nations had joined the nuclear
club. The urgency felt by successive governments in Canada to deliver the good life so to make communism
look less appealing was effectively gone as well. Beyond foreign affairs and domestic policies, however, the end
of history also suggested the end of the meta-narrative. In this new postmodern era, the saga of the nation had
outlived its purpose. History that assembling of stories about the past that offer insights into the affairs of
humans then and now could shift its focus away from what the popular historian Pierre Berton (1920-2004)
1
called the national dream. The spotlight could now fall on stories that had either been viewed as unimportant
or irrelevant to the main event, or to histories that actually countered modernitys forward march.

The most visible facet of that postmodernist trend in the writing of history has been post-colonialism. At one
stage in the history of Canada for something like 200 years colonization (biological settlement and populat-
ing) and colonialism (the intentional suppression of Indigenous peoples) were regarded approvingly as two of the
foremost elements of the Canadian project. Through that lens, Aboriginal history was almost an oxymoron, a
contradiction in terms. Post-colonialism made room for histories of First Nations that provided other perspectives
and, from time to time, spoke with Aboriginal voices.

This chapter engages with several of these ideas. What was Canada like in the first decade or so at the end of his-
tory? In what ways was the postmodern made manifest in domestic, social, economic, and international affairs?
How had our world and historic view changed? Could Canada continue to hide from its colonialist past in a post-
colonial world? Canadas emerging international and domestic preoccupations are explored, including the fringe
political movements of the day. As the meta-narrative of Canadian history began to fray, it became possible to look
with some detachment at the ways in which national identity and alternative identities were constructed in the 20th
century, which included challenges to the normal that were increasingly launched in the 1980s, 1990s, and the
new millennium. If the histories that sustained the national project were no longer vitally necessary or particularly
welcome in the academy, what replaced them? As the postmodern world fractured storylines into increasingly
specialized fragments, historians began to question whether a national history was even possible. This chapter
explores some aspects of the newer historical interests, including two considerations of digital histories.

History Wars
The idea that historical method has responded to this changed world is also engaged in this chapter. If the focus

1. Bertons history of the CPR, The National Dream, was first published in 1970 and was followed the next year by The Last Spike. Both
describe the project and the politicians and capitalists behind it in heroic, nation-building terms. These are, in all likelihood, the best selling
Canadian history books ever. A great popularizer of history, Berton was also a champion of the nationalist school.
 12.1 INTRODUCTION 721

of historical research is no longer the political history of the state, it moves from the parliamentary archives into
different places and employs different tools while asking different questions. History itself changes along with the
society that has emerged at historys end.

The writing of history proceeds unevenly for many and diverse reasons. In the 1960s and 1970s, there was a sud-
den explosion of excellent social and political history for three reasons. First, as a response to the baby boom
and a national Cold War-era commitment to further education (which, notably, replaced an earlier ideology of
exclusivity), there were vastly more university and college campuses and seats available to a rising generation.
Second, that cohort was itself more diverse than any other in Canadian post-secondary education to that time, and
it brought to the seminar table its own concerns about society and the stories we tell. Third, out of that hothouse
came a generation of scholars larger than any before it with a shared cultural experience and language that
enabled the transformation of historical studies. The benefits have been a rich legacy of investigations into the
society and culture of Canada with the chief liability being a bottleneck of Cold War-era academics whose views
continue to dominate as successive generations of historians strive to be heard.

By way of an example, we can look at histories of the West. Valerie Korinek, an authority on Prairie and queer
history, offers some insight into where Canadian history has failed to go, and calls for Western historians in par-
ticular to pay attention to the late 20th century:

This was a time of considerable transformation for the Prairie West (some might argue Western ascendancy, albeit uneven)
as it reconfigured from a primarily rural to an urban place, as it became an economic powerhouse, and as demographic
shifts made it an increasing social and political force within the country. This transformation needs to be explored and
assessed historically. Regretfully, Western historians have failed to participate in enumerating and evaluating these sub-
2
stantive historical changes in the second half of the twentieth century.

It is not fair to say that Western Canadian historians are stuck in the past (insert winking emoji here), but the truth
is that contemporary or even post-centennial histories are rare. What Korinek identifies is, in part, the challenge
of contemporary history. How old do events have to be before they slip from one side of the ledger (made up
of Politics, Economics, Sociology, etc.) over to the other side (where we find History)? Theres no ironclad rule
on this front. The 20th century historian Kenneth McNaught (1918-1997) is said to have claimed that everything
after World War One constituted current events. To someone born in 1918, that might make some sense but,
as all historians come to realize, that boundary is always in motion. The historians who came of age in the late
1960s mostly born in the 1940s might be excused for feeling uncomfortable with histories of life after 1939,
although that has not held back everyone. Alvin Finkels Our Lives: Canada after 1945 and Doug Owrams Born
at the Right Time: A History of the Baby Boom Generation show baby boomers successfully tackling the mid-
century as an historical environment. However, as Korinek points out, older discourses persist, narratives become
embedded within narratives, and we risk becoming unaware of the changes that history might reveal to us.

In Canadian History: Pre-Confederation, I describe the current state of historical writing, including the conflict
between generations of historians that took place in the 1990s. The so-called History Wars pitted the older
nationalist historians against the rising generation of scholars who argued there was no longer one meta-narrative
of the Canadian experience. Building a national identity out of a shared historic experience was the task set before
modern historians; deconstructing those stories to show how they implicitly privileged certain groups and per-
spectives was the challenge taken up by newcomers to the field.

2. Valerie Korinek, A Queer-eye View of the Prairies: Reorienting Western Canadian Histories, in The West and Beyond: New Perspectives on an Imagined
Region, eds. Alvin Finkel, Sarah Carter, and Peter Fortna (Edmonton, AB: Athabasca University Press, 2010), 281.
 722 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION
3
The nationalist historians went down swinging. While their leading figures Jack Granatstein among them
remained productive but increasingly marginalized from the innovative work in the discipline, their advocates
did not completely surrender the battlefield. Efforts to recast Canadian history as something comfortably familiar
were undertaken in the last decade by conservatives who regard the Pearson years and its pennant as the point
in time when Canada drifted from its moorings. For example, a cohort of British, imperialist, and fans of military
history sought to restore a common curriculum of nation-serving historical studies in the schools and universities.
They failed mostly. While English-Canadian historical research turns its back on nationalist histories, national-
ist views are increasingly embedded in the teaching of French-Canadian history in Quebec. The History Wars,
4
writes University of Guelph historian Mark Sholdice, are really not about history, but rather politics. The great
English historiographer E. H. Carr wrote: The facts speak only when the historian calls on them; the historian
5
decides to which facts to give the floor. We make those decisions based on, among other things, the politics
around us and the politics we live, be that green, feminist, conservative, separatist, religious, or nationalist. It isnt
that political history is at an end; rather, the net we cast to capture political change must necessarily be larger.

Learning Objectives

Account for the rise of identity politics in the post-Cold War era.
Explain the failure of both the Charlottetown Accord and the 1995 Referendum.
Describe the ways in which the end of the Cold War changed Canadas foreign policy and domestic
politics.
Identify ways in which historians have adapted their craft in a postmodern world.
Outline the ways in which the Canadian national character and symbols have been crafted and
changed since Confederation.

Attributions
Figure 12.1
Office national du film montreal by Chicoutimi is used under a CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.

3. There is no universally accepted collective noun for historians, but the phrase, "an argumentation of historians" is sometimes preferred.
4. Mark Sholdice, The History Wars in Canada, Toronto Review of Books, May 5, 2013, accessed January 27, 2016, [Link]
[Link]/2013/05/the-history-wars-in-canada/#_edn1.
5. E. H. Carr, What is History? 2nd ed. (Markham, ON: Penguin Canada, 1987), 11.
12.2 The End of the Cold War

Figure 12.2 Somali youths captured by the Canadian Airborne

Regiment, bound and wearing signs that say Thief. The Somalia
Affair would mark one of several low points in the peacekeeping
tradition in the 1990s.

The legacy of the Cold War continues to influence world affairs. After the dissolution of the Soviet Union, the
post-Cold War world became unipolar instead of bipolar, with the United States the sole remaining superpower.
Being caught geographically between two superpowers from 1945 to 1991 gave shape to Canadas international
role and its aspirations for middle power status. Defining a new international role in the post-Cold War era would
take Canada into new conflicts.

In November 1989, the world including foreign policy experts and espionage agencies from both sides of the
Iron Curtain watched in surprise as peaceful protesters in East Germany marched through guard stations at
the Berlin Wall. Within hours, people from both East and West Berlin flooded the checkpoints and began tearing
down large chunks of the wall. For months, demonstrations in East Germany had called on the government to
allow citizens to leave the country. These protests were one manifestation of a larger movement with origins in
Polands Solidarity (Solidarno) movement, which would sweep across East Germany, Hungary, Czechoslova-
kia, Bulgaria, and Romania, leading swiftly to revolutions most of them peaceful and resulting in the col-
lapse of Communist governments in Central and Eastern Europe.

In Budapest in 1956, and Prague in 1968, the Soviet Union had restored order through a large show of force. In
the case of Hungary, over a thousand Soviet tanks were involved, with 30,000 troops, and as many as 3,000 Hun-
garians died; in 1968 the USSR mustered half a million troops from the Warsaw Pact nations and more than 6,000
tanks to put down (with far less bloodshed) the Prague Spring. That these events were not reprised in 1989 was an
indication to all that the Soviet Union was itself collapsing. In July 1991, Soviet president Mikhail Gorbachev (b.
1931) and United States President George H. W. Bush (b. 1924) signed the Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty, or
START, which committed their countries to reducing their nuclear arsenals by 25%. A month later, in an attempt
to stop the changes begun by Gorbachevs reforms, Communist Party hardliners tried to remove him from power.
Protests arose throughout the Soviet Union, and by December 1991, the nation had collapsed. In January 1992, 12

723
 724 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

former Soviet republics formed the Commonwealth of Independent States to coordinate trade and security mea-
1
sures. The Cold War was over.

A More Dangerous World?

The dust had barely settled on the crumbling Berlin Wall when the global order began to shift. The United States
was, effectively, unleashed from whatever restraint the fear of provoking Moscow previously exerted. Cold war
subterfuge gave way to direct attacks on enemy and rogue states. In December 1989, the Bush administration
launched a military intervention in Panama and, claiming to be acting on behalf of human rights, deposed the
military dictatorship of Manuel Noriega (b. 1934). Former CIA connections between Bush and Noriega, as well
as United States interests in maintaining control of the Canal Zone, prompted the United Nations and world pub-
lic opinion to denounce the invasion as a power grab. Operations Desert Shield and Desert Storm followed in
1990-1991 as American forces backed Saudi Arabia and Kuwait against Iraq, which drew the American military
deep into the Middle East. Involvement in conflicts in two disintegrating countries Yugoslavia and Somalia
came soon after. A brazen attack on New York City and Washington, DC on September 11, 2001 resulted in the
deployment of American troops in Afghanistan, and two years later, the Second Gulf War (or the War in Iraq)
began.

Canadas relationship with the outside world would likewise turn more violent in the decades after the fall of the
USSR. Between 1956 and 1981, Canada began (and mostly completed) eight distinct peacekeeping missions with
the United Nations (UN), half of which were active in the 1970s. From 1981 to 1989, however, no new missions
were undertaken. Then, at the end of the cold war, Canadian involvement increased by an order of magnitude.
Missions sometimes repeat missions were undertaken from 1989 to 2000 in Namibia, Western Sahara, Cam-
bodia, Somalia, the Balkans, Haiti, Rwanda, Central Africa, East Timor, Sierra Leone, the Democratic Repub-
lic of Congo, and Ethiopia and Eritrea. The stability that had been provided by the Cold War was gone. This
was most clear in the former Yugoslavia, where a communist regime independent of Moscow and the Warsaw
Pact descended into bloody ethnic and religious conflict. Out-of-bounds to Western interference prior to 1989,
Yugoslavia became increasingly vulnerable to external influences, especially as its economy began to collapse.
Canadians were part of a large contingent of NATO troops sent into newly independent Croatia, Bosnia and Herze-
govina, and Kosovo. The situation in Somalia is perhaps more instructive: the Somali regime in the 1970s was
essentially Marxist and benefited from Soviet support and investment; in 1978, however, it switched its allegiance
to the United States. The end effect was that this strategically critical country on the east coast of Africa had built
up enormous military stockpiles and the largest army on the continent. When the dictatorship (supported by the
United States) began to crumble in the mid-1980s, neighbouring nations started picking at the edges while internal
dissent created the conditions necessary for civil war. No longer able to whipsaw the East against the West, Soma-
lia became a failed state in which there was no national administration, only warring factions. Canadian troops
trained as peacekeepers were stretched to their limits, particularly since most were now assigned to keep the peace
where no peace existed. Regular combat troops were added to the mix, including the Canadian Airborne Regi-
ment, which was sent into Somalia in December 1992 as part of the humanitarian mission. The Canadian Regi-
ments violent, arbitrary, and murderous behaviour led to several civilian deaths (including the beating to death of
Shidane Arone) and a political scandal at home, which was dubbed the Somalia Affair. Another consequence of
the East African fiasco was a loss of public confidence in the military and faith in the peacekeeping tradition.

1. OpenStax CNX, 31.3 A New World Order, U.S. History, OpenStax CNX, accessed January 24, 2016, [Link]
[email protected]:OCsuwNr2@2/A-New-World-Order.
 12.2 THE END OF THE COLD WAR 725

Clearly, the destabilization of global politics at the end of the superpowers era was taking Canadian diplomacy
and external affairs into new territory, both geographically and operationally. Foreign policy retained its focus on
multilateralism, but this emphasis was quickly swept up by the American sense of urgency in the Middle East.
In response to Iraqs invasion of Kuwait in 1990, the UN Security Council encouraged nations to help repel an
aggressor-state. The Canadian government opted to commit a limited force, believing that a contingent of CF-18
jets was both more feasible and more palatable to domestic opinion than a large ground force. Economic sanc-
tions were introduced while care was taken not to lose Iraq as a major buyer of Canadian grain. Opposition to
the mission was diffuse and incapable of mounting an anti-war campaign. What is more, some Canadians argued
that the post-Cold War environment itself called for a response. Bernard Wood, the Chief Executive Officer of the
Canadian Institute for International Peace and Security, made the case for military involvement:

If our decades of paralytic confrontations between the superpowers has led many Canadians to see themselves more as
spectators and critics than as actors on the world stage, they had better recognize, for better or for worse, that the world
2
has changed and we are once again called upon to act.

The goal of Canadian policy makers in these circumstances was to establish a multilateral, post-cold war order.
(External Affairs minister and former PM Joe Clark was not one of them.) In the case of Iraq, what began as
a UN initiative parallel to American objectives quickly became a United States-led, 34-nation coalition aimed to
push Iraq back to its own borders. Incredibly well armed after years of buying weapons and fighter aircraft from
Western nations and amassing Soviet-built Scud missiles, Iraqi forces were nevertheless quick to retreat behind a
flaming wall of sabotaged oilfields. The ground war was over in 100 hours. Brief though it was, the Gulf War (or,
as it became known a decade later, the First Gulf War) was the first conflict in which Canada was a belligerent
since Korea. Amazingly, Canadian forces suffered no casualties.

There was hope in the early 1990s that the end of the Cold War would bring with it a peace dividend. That is,
the cost of maintaining readiness in the face of the threat posed by the Warsaw Pact and other communist coun-
tries would come to an end, and resources could be spent in other ways. This was not to be the case globally,
since President Bush continued to pursue a New World Order. Canadians, however, were mostly sanguine about
playing an active military role internationally, and the Canadian Forces were positioned for severe cuts. Canadian
bases in Germany a holdover from both WWII and the Cold War were closed. Spending on Armed Forces
materiel, however, actually accelerated in the early 1990s until a change of government turned the tide against
National Defence Headquarters. As the new Liberal administration led by Jean Chrtien (b. 1934) rounded their
fiscal guns on the Forces, news of the Somalia Affair broke, and a Commission of Enquiry was launched. The
Commission produced a parade of embarrassments, including systemic misogyny at every level, cover-ups, con-
flicts of interest, defalcations, and outright lies. When the Commission presented its report in 1997, the Forces and
National Defence HQ were comprehensively blamed for illegal, immoral, undisciplined, irresponsible, and inhu-
mane behaviour. Recommendations for change were equally comprehensive, and the pressure was on to retool the
Armed Forces as a more diverse organization that more closely resembled civilian Canada. The peace dividend
proved to be illusory, and Canada adjusted to a more technological and expensive era of war making and peace-
keeping.

In the same year as the Somalia report, Canadian troops returned to the Balkans. In 1993 Canadian soldiers with
the United Nations Protective Forces (UNPROFOR) were deployed in the Medak Pocket, a region claimed by
Croatia and by invading Serbian troops. The Canadians were to create a barrier between the two forces but came

2. Quoted in Robert Davis, Canada and the Persian Gulf War, unpublished M. A. thesis, University of Windsor, 1997, 74.
 726 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

under fire from the Croatian side. This 15-hour firefight was the first significant challenge to Canadian ground
troops since Korea. Four years later, the focus shifted to Kosovo. Canadas involvement in this phase was as an
aerial combatant: CF-18s flew repeated sorties into Serbia in an effort to bring an end to ethnic cleansing in the
3
Albanian enclave. In the first decade after the fall of the Eastern Bloc, Canada engaged in more actual combat
missions than it had in the 20 years after the Korean War. The trend would continue into the new century.

Figure 12.3 Artist Elaine Gobles drawing of Romo

Dallaire (Rwanda has my soul) captures the personal and
emotional burden of the frustrated peacekeeper.

Rwanda

Genocide, the horror that the 20th century found the means to massify, was a feature of the conflict in
the former states of Yugoslavia and central Africa. Just as the end of the Cold War set free decades of
resentment in the Balkans, the end of colonialism let loose ancient hostilities and those newly developed
under European empires. Independence movements sprang up that pitted one formerly colonized people
against another. Divisions that tangled up ethnic histories, language, religious identity, ideology, unsettled
and conflicting claims to ancestral lands, and uneven distribution of the spoils of decolonization pitched
African communities into civil wars and military campaigns. This was the pattern in Rwanda, formerly
German East Africa and then, from 1919, occupied by the Belgians. Under the European imperialists, the
line between the minority (the more privileged Tutsis) and the majority (the less advantaged Hutus) became
sharpened. Distinct racial identities were ascribed to both groups and, under the Belgians, identity cards
were issued that signified whether one was Tutsi or Hutu. Generally speaking, European powers in the
region, along with the Catholic Church, favoured the Tutsi and their historic advantages were enhanced.
Things began to unravel as independence movements gained ground in the late 1950s and early 1960s.
Thirty years later, the legacies of colonialism in central Africa included a long-running battle between the
Hutu-led government of Rwanda and Tutsi-dominated Burundi next door. Tutsi populations from Rwanda
went into exile in Burundi and then fought to restore their position at home. A genocidal campaign against
Hutus in Burundi was launched in the 1970s (perhaps as many as 200,000 were killed), with the result that
thousands of Hutu were driven into Rwanda, where their resentment towards the Tutsi continued to grow.
By 1990 the Hutu-led administration and military in Rwanda began preparations for a final solution to
their rivalry with Tutsi populations. The 1991 invasion from Burundi of the Tutsi Rwandan Patriotic Front
(RPF) heightened tensions and, as civil wars erupted in both Rwanda and Burundi, led to the deployment
of a United Nations Assistance Mission for Rwanda (UNAMIR) in October 1993. UNAMIRs mandate
was to monitor the Arusha Accords between the Hutu and Tutsi factions and to oversea the crafting of a
transitional government and humanitarian aid. The UN placed Canadian Brigadier-General (subsequently
Major-General) Romo Dallaire (b. 1946) in charge of a small and poorly supplied force.
By January 1994, Dallaire was receiving intelligence to the effect that a massive genocidal attack on the
Tutsi minority was being planned. Weapons were being stockpiled, and Hutu were receiving clandestine
training. Dallaire passed his information to the UN in what became known as the Genocide Fax and

3. Desmond Morton, A Military History of Canada, 5th ed. (Toronto, ON: McClelland & Stewart, 2007), 277-292.
 12.2 THE END OF THE COLD WAR 727

made plans to raid suspected weapons caches. He was chastised for attempting to overstep the missions
mandate. Dallaires hands were officially tied.
Then, in April 1994, the recently elected Hutu president of Burundi and the Hutu president of Rwanda
were assassinated when the aircraft they were travelling in together was shot down over the Rwandan cap-
ital. The succession struggle that followed was rapid and bloody: the Prime Minister Agathe Uwilingiy-
imana was murdered by Rwandan troops, along with the 10 UNAMIR soldiers assigned to protect her.
Moderate leaders were hunted down and executed as the genocidal slaughter got fully underway. Dallaires
combined force of Canadian, Pakastani, Ghanaian, Tunisian, and Bangladeshi troops were sufficient to
protect 32,000 Tutsi in Kigali. Elsewhere, the campaign claimed some 800,000 lives.

Figure 12.4 Belgian personnel with UNAMIR were tortured and

executed at this site in Kigali, which is now a memorial.

Dallaires account of the outrages, Shake Hands with the Devil (2003), provides rare insight into peace-
keeping in the post-colonial, post-Cold War era. The Rwanda mission along with a decade of disasters
in Somalia and the Balkans led to reduced Canadian enthusiasm for the peacekeeping tradition that was
first presented to the world by St. Laurent and Pearson.

9/11
On September 11, 2001 the Canadian Armed Forces were probably as badly staffed, armed, and equipped as they
had been at any time in the 20th century. Naval craft were outdated, fighter aircraft dangerously old, and ground
equipment unsuited for a world in which guerrilla warfare, sniper fire, and land mines impeded the movement of
troops everywhere. The attacks on the World Trade Towers and the Pentagon brought a cry for revenge from the
United States, and President George W. Bush (b. 1946) declared the War on Terror. NATO was automatically
involved because of its foundational policy to respond to an attack on one as an attack on all. Faced with American
fears that the international boundary with Canada was an unguarded gateway for terrorists heading to targets in
the United States and the consequent closure of border crossings, Ottawa committed quickly to the American cru-
sade. The enemies, in this case, were principally the Taliban (the Islamic regime in Afghanistan) and al-Qaeda,
a jihadist group pieced together in the 1980s by the Americans to fight against the Soviet Union.

Canadas interests in the Middle East are complicated by its relationship with Israel, the central foe of organiza-
tions like al-Qaeda. One of the first countries to recognize Israel in 1947, Canada has maintained close relations
ever since, with a few important breaches. There was, for example, a broad loss of Canadian confidence in the
Israeli regime following the First Intifada in 1987; sympathy for the Israeli people was, however, aroused by Iraqi
missile attacks on Israel during the First Gulf War. Concurrent Canadian sympathy for Palestinians, however, has
not sat well with Tel Aviv. Despite these interruptions, the largely strong connection has been manifest in a bilat-
eral free trade agreement that was reached in 1996. When 9/11 produced the War on Terror, Islamicist groups
understood Canada to be first and foremost an ally of their sworn enemy. This was not a conflict in which Canada
might employ its historic commitment to multilateralism or negotiation.
728 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 12.5 Canadian infantry searching for Taliban and al-Qaeda

cave strongholds in the Tora Bora region in Afghanistan, May
2002.

The commitment of troops and materiel to the Afghanistan War was substantial. The first troops including
an elite team of snipers arrived in Afghanistan in 2001 with an anticipated end-date of 2003. Canadian oper-
ations included training local forces to protect the post-Taliban regime as well as relieving American troops in
Kandahar Province at the centre of al-Qaeda territory. In 2005 troop numbers were increased substantially as the
focus of the war shifted to dealing with a resurgent Taliban. Canadian involvement in Afghanistan is reckoned to
have involved 40,000 Armed Forces personnel from 2001-2014. Withdrawal from the fray has been announced
repeatedly, but to date it remains an inconclusive withdrawal Canadians continue to participate in developing
and training Afghanistan systems and forces engaged in anti-Taliban efforts, despite a formal declaration in 2014
that Canadian military involvement was at an end.

In fact, the official end of the Afghanistan campaign came just five months shy of the 100th anniversary of the
assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand (1863-1914) and the start of the Great War. Armed conflict had, in
this long 20th century, changed dramatically. Whereas, the World Wars introduced and refined industrial means of
killing large numbers, the War on Terror represents a return to guerrilla tactics of a kind with which 18th century
Canadians and First Nations had greater familiarity. Ambushes, traps, and sniper fire along with improvised
explosive devices (IEDs) and suicide bombers gave the conduct of war a very different shape. Although sta-
tistics on wartime casualties and fatalities are difficult to verify, it is thought that nearly 11% of Canadian troops
died between 1914 and 1918, and that the ratio of combat injuries to combat deaths in WWI was nearly 3:1; only
159 fatalities were recorded in Afghanistan (a mere 0.4% of the 40,000 troops deployed), although the ratio of
casualties to fatalities is more than 4:1. Guerrilla warfare is geared to inflicting injuries and depressing morale;
as well, medical advances make it possible to save the lives of badly damaged soldiers and other personnel and,
thus, inflate the casualty list. Nonetheless, it is clear that 21st century wars so far have been distinctive.

Another feature of war that has changed is the awareness and treatment of what has been called, since the 1970s,
post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). The Great War produced conditions that included heavy and continuous
shelling of military positions that could neither advance nor retreat; one consequence was a kind of psychological
condition called shell shock. Subsequently, after the Second World War, this was rebranded as combat stress, a
term that was used until the end of the Vietnam War. It was then that PTSD came into common use. The 20th
century is the first century in which psychology, psychiatry, and psychotherapy became recognized as both aca-
demically legitimate areas of study and publicly available forms of analysis and treatment. The mental health
consequences of warfare in the long 20th century could only be understood in the context of contemporary and
evolving ideas about the human mind. The post-Confederation period saw warfare evolve quickly: from pitched
sniper fire (of the kind conducted in Saskatchewan in 1885), through the appalling graveyard of trench standoffs
in WWI to the bombing of civilian targets (and the appearance of atomic weaponry) in WWII, on to the techno-
logically-reliant but seemingly less predictable conflict of the early 21st century. Adjusting to these changes has
taken a severe toll on the health of soldiers.
 12.2 THE END OF THE COLD WAR 729

Post-Cold War NATO

After the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989, NATO was drawn into the breakup of Yugoslavia, and conducted
its first military interventions in Bosnia, and later Yugoslavia in 1999. Politically, the organization sought
better relations with former Cold War rivals, and several former Warsaw Pact states joined the alliance in
1999 and 2004. The September 2001 attacks signalled the only occasion in NATOs history that Article 5
of the North Atlantic Treaty has been invoked as an attack on all NATO members. After the 9/11 attack,
troops were deployed to Afghanistan under NATOs leadership, and the organization continues to oper-
ate in a range of roles, including sending trainers to Iraq, assisting in counter-piracy operations, and most
4
recently, enforcing a no-fly zone over Libya.

Key Points

The collapse of the Warsaw Pact and the end of Soviet power produced a set of changed global con-
ditions.
The American policy of containment was superceded by more unilateral action, often in zones that
would have attracted the interest of the Soviet Union in the Cold War era.
Rather than becoming less involved internationally, in the two decades after the Cold War, Canada
became more engaged with military and peacekeeping missions, including several in Africa (but
most notably in Somalia and Rwanda) and in the former Yugoslavia.
Internal crises in the Canadian Armed Forces and changing military needs in a technologically
evolving era produced a simultaneous desire to reduce military costs while investing heavily in new
and more sophisticated systems and hardware.
After nearly three decades of Canadian satisfaction with peacekeeping missions, events in Somalia,
Croatia and Kosovo, and Rwanda turned public opinion against this tradition.
Canadas NATO obligations compelled it to participate in the American reaction to the events of 9/
11, leading to more than a decade of entanglement in Afghanistan.

Attributions
Figure 12.2
Canadian Airborne Regiment, Chaplain Capt. Mark Sargent Behind a Group of Bound and blindfolded Somali
Civilians (Online MIKAN no.3604003) by Commission of Inquiry into Deployment of Troups Somalia /
Library and Archives Canada is used with no restrictions.

4. Boundless, North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), Boundless U.S. History, July 21, 2015, accessed Dec. 17, 2015,
[Link]
atlantic-treaty-organization-nato-1173-11110/.
730 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 12.3
Rwanda has my soul [Romo Dallaire] (Online MIKAN no.3959433) by Library and Archives Canada, archival
reference number R13185-4, e010752967 is used with no restrictions.

Figure 12.4
UNAMIR Blue Berets memorial Kigali (4) by JA_ALT is in the public domain.

Figure 12.5
Operation Torri command post by SSGT Jeremy T. Lock / United States Air Force (ID 020504-F-JQ435-004)
is in the public domain.
12.3 Postmodern Politics

Figure 12.6 Reform of the Red Chamber the senate was an

increasingly prominent goal in constitutional talks and Canadian
politics in the 1990s.

For all intents and purposes, the function of federal politics from 1867 to 1987 was to knit together the economic,
political, social, and cultural concerns of the country and hold the federal structure together. When the Parti
Qubecois under Mssr. Lvesque was campaigning for sovereignty-association in 1980, every party in Ottawa
came out in support of federalism (while offering varying degrees of reform for the relationship between Quebec
and the ROC). The failure of the Meech Lake Accord shattered the illusion of a shared vision for federalism, even
in the ROC.

Return to Charlottetown
Charlottetown, the Prince Edward Island capital, is where confederation was first proposed to the Atlantic
colonies by the Canadians. That 1864 meeting enabled Charlottetown to bill itself as the Cradle of Confeder-
ation, despite the fact that PEIs representatives decided to give the offer a pass on the first try. The symbol-
ism of a return to where confederation began was clearly attractive to Conservative leader and Prime Minister
Brian Mulroney; in 1992 he convened another meeting of Premiers on PEI with an eye to approving what some
called Meech 2. Opponents of Meech Lake had pointed to the lack of consultation that preceded its creation,
and Mulroney sought to address this failing with a new agreement. Extensive public discussion took place over
nearly two years, including obtaining input and approval from the Assembly of First Nations, the Inuit Tapirisat,
and the Mtis National Council. The effect on the Charlottetown Accord was dramatic. Aboriginal rights were
enshrined, as was Quebecs distinct society clause. Senate reform was more clearly spelled out than in Meech,
similar changes extended to the Supreme Court, and there was a commitment to education and social policies
and principles. The overall trend was to empower the provinces and protect their ability to act independently on
cultural matters. One facet of this shift was the proposal to eliminate the disallowance clause against which 19th
century premiers like Oliver Mowat had railed.

731
732 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 12.7 Senate reform has a long pedigree. In 1899 cartoonist

J. W. Bengough shows an Irresponsible Senate bucking in the
background while Laurier holds out a harness labelled Senate
Reform. Jack Canuck (the voter) holds a whip marked
Responsible Government and wonders, Is the horse worth the
halter? Abolition, in other words, was an option.

All 10 premiers including Quebecs Liberal premier Robert Bourassa approved of the Accord. The three major
federal political parties the governing Progressive Conservatives, the opposition Liberals, and the NDP were
also committed. In this instance, however, whatever was agreed to at the table would need to be approved in a
national referendum.

Initially, broad public support seemed likely, even in Quebec (where it was, predictably, close). Several factors
contributed to its defeat, the first of which was strong campaigns in Quebec by separatists (who were uncompro-
mising in their view that a revived federal arrangement was not the same thing as autonomy) and the Prairie-based
Reform Party (which argued that the Accord did not do enough to transform political structures, that it was a pact
between old party elites, and that it gave too much to Quebec). The comprehensiveness of the Accord also invited
criticisms: there was inevitably something with which anyone could quibble. Prime Minister Mulroneys personal
unpopularity was also a factor; a vote against Charlottetown was seen by some as a vote against an unpopular
and (in some quarters) untrusted administration. A final and prominent component in the opposition camp was the
involvement once again of Pierre Trudeau. A widely-read critique in MacLeans magazine saw the former prime
minister describe it as the end of federalism and a recipe for a disintegrated Canada. Indeed, supporters of the
Accord similarly warned that a No vote could just as easily lead to the break-up of the country, which was a kind
of brinksmanship that, on balance, probably favoured inertia over change, a No vote over a Yes.

On October 26, 1992, Canadians went to the polls to vote in a very rare national referendum. The results were
complex, but the overall pattern was a victory for the No side with 54.4% of the vote. Four provinces voted against
British Columbians were the most adamant with 68% voting No and the Territories split (Yukoners opposed
it at 56%, but the NWT was 60.6% in favour). Without a strong tradition or experience of referenda, there was
confusion as to how Ottawa would interpret the results, but there was a general consensus that rejection by any
province could be a deal-breaker, particularly if that province was Quebec. In any event, Nova Scotia, Quebec,
and the Prairie Provinces joined BC and the Yukon in rejecting the Accord. Charlottetown was as dead as Meech.

The referendum result was a a blow to the Progressive Conservatives credibility. Conversely, it enhanced the
profile of the Reform Party and the Parti Qubecois. Examining the results of the Accord referendum in Quebec,
separatists began planning for a referendum of their own.

The 1995 Referendum

The 1993 federal election returned a Liberal majority government under Jean Chrtien. It was, as much as any-
thing else, a rout of the Mulroney Conservatives (now under the leadership of Kim Campbell). The Tories didnt
 12.3 POSTMODERN POLITICS 733

win a single province, having been completely replaced by Reform in British Columbia and Alberta, and the
Atlantic provinces provided the Conservatives with only one seat. The most ominous sign, however, was the
appearance of the reappearance of an anti-confederation party at the federal level: the Bloc Qubecois. Separatist
strength in Quebec was growing once again.

The origins of the Bloc Qubecois can be found in the long conflict between the federalist Liberals in Ottawa and
the separatists in Quebec. During the 1960s, 1970s, and 1980s, the role of Pierre Trudeau was pivotal in pushing
the Liberals away from their old tolerance for Quebec nationalism. The separatist Parti Qubecois offered a cred-
ible alternative at the provincial level (where, significantly, they defeated the provincial Liberals), but there was
nothing equivalent at the federal level. (Theoretically if not in practice all Conservatives and Liberals from
Quebec were federalists once they reached Ottawa.) In the 1980s, the anti-Liberal Pquistes increasingly looked
to the Conservative Party to carry forward their agenda federally. Then, the lack of success of the Meech Lake
Accord in 1990 drove the Conservative Minister of the Environment, Lucien Bouchard (b. 1938), to draft seven
Quebec MPs five Conservatives and two Liberals into a new party.

Unlike the 1867-vintage Anti-Confederate Party from Nova Scotia, the Bloc proved highly successful at the polls.
In its first outing in 1993, the BQ (or Bquistes or Bloquistes) won half the popular vote and more than two-thirds
1
of the seats in Quebec. This made the BQ the second-largest caucus in 1993-1997, despite being elected in only
one province. A separatist party was now Her Majestys Loyal Opposition, and Mr. Bouchard was its leader.

Success at the federal level was echoed 11 months later in Quebec when the Liberal government of Bourassa was
defeated by the Parti Qubecois, which had been revived under the leadership of Jacques Parizeau (1930-2015). It
is worth noting some of the numbers in this process: nearly 57% of Quebec voters voted No in the Charlottetown
Accord referendum in 1992; the Bloc Qubecois won 49.3% of the vote in Quebec in the 1993 federal election;
and the Parti Qubecois took just under 45% in the provincial election in 1994. Clearly, there was a bedrock of
support for separatist and/or sovereigntist positions, perhaps enough to win a second referendum on sovereignty.

Despite the separatist strength going into this referendum campaign, divisions soon racked the leadership.
Bouchard and Mario Dumont (b. 1970), the leader of the new conservative and populist Action dmocratique du
Qubec (ADQ) insisted that the referendum should include the option, and even the goal, of a continued economic
and social partnership with Canada this was the sovereigntist option. Parizeau and other hardliners argued for
a clean break, a separatist or indpendantiste position. Fearing a fatal schism in the movement, Parizeau agreed
to a referendum question that, if successful, would open sovereignty-association negotiations but, should those
talks fail, the provincial government would be automatically empowered to declare independence unilaterally.
The mechanisms for achieving autonomy were laid out in an Act Respecting the Future of Qubec (also called
the Sovereignty Bill or Bill 1), which passed first reading and waited on the Order Paper for the outcome of the
referendum. As was the case in 1980, however, confusion over objectives led to a convoluted question:

Do you agree that Quebec should become sovereign, after having made a formal offer to Canada for a new economic and
political partnership, within the scope of the Bill respecting the future of Quebec and of the agreement signed on 12 June
2
1995?

In the event of a successful referendum result, Bill 1 identified areas of partnership between Canada and the new

1. This is the one breakaway party that has not, to date, been reunited with its ancestor party/parties. After 20 years, it remains a credible politi-
cal entity.
2. Canada. Quebec. Quebec Sovereignty Referendum, 30 October 1995, in response to Bill 1 or the Sovereignty Bill.
734 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

country of Quebec, which included a customs union (essentially a free trade zone with a shared currency the
Canadian dollar); unfettered movement of individuals, services, capital, and goods; and a shared citizenship com-
parable to what could be found in the European Union. There was no clarity as to who would negotiate this agree-
ment on the part of Canada. (Could Mssr. Bouchard participate? Would his caucus be permitted to vote on the
outcome? What about Qubecois civil servants in the federal administration?) Nevertheless, Parizeaus conces-
sions were enough to forge an alliance with Bouchard and Dumont. Bouchard took over the leadership of the Yes
campaign in its last month, and the tide looked to be turning their way. One portent of the likely outcome came on
the eve of the vote as Ottawa moved to get its CF-18 fighter aircraft out of Quebec even as the Parizeau govern-
ment made plans to seize the Canadian Forces bases in the aftermath of a Yes victory.

When the ballots were counted, the No side had once again triumphed but this time by the narrowest of majorities.
More than 93% of the registered electorate turned out for the referendum, and 50.58% voted No. Leadership
blunders and demographic factors had undermined the Yes side. Parizeaus role could be singled out as polariz-
ing because of his tendency to make ethno-nationalist comments that favoured the Canadien heritage far more
than the pluralist society that Quebec had become. In the 15 years between the Lvesque referendum and the
Parizeau-Bouchard-Dumont referendum, Quebec had become even more diverse and less pure laine (dominated
by a population derived from the settlers of New France). The Francophone and Anglophone communities were
growing slowly and, of course, many Anglophones had moved away between 1975 and 1995 in reaction to the
Francization of daily life and commerce. A new and expanding community of immigrants with a higher fertility
rate was making its presence felt, and their lack of connection to the historic grievances of New France, Lower
Canada, and Quebec made the pitch for sovereignty that much more difficult. These newcomers often lumped
together as allophones bore the brunt of Parizeaus referendum night wrath. In a televised interview he claimed
that the Yes side was defeated by money Anglo and ethnic votes. The spectre of ethnic nationalism had been
raised once again.

Figure 12.8 Support for the Yes side in the 1995 referendum was
strongest in rural Quebec, particularly in the Saguenay. It was
weakest in the areas nearest Ottawa, in west Montreal, in the
Inuit/Innu/Cree-dominated lands of the north, in the Eastern
Townships, and along the borders with the United States and New
Brunswick.

Border Disputes

Both the 1980 and the 1995 referendums provided opportunities for Canadians to think again about terri-
torial assumptions. Quebec separatists viewed the entirety of the provinces boundaries as sacrosanct, but
both the Inuit of Nunavik the northern third of Quebec and the Cree announced through their own ref-
erendums their intention to stay in Canada. The position they took was the same as Quebecs: that they
had a right to national self-determination. Given that the Cree homeland includes the enormous James Bay
hydroelectric complex symbolically and economically a mainstay of modern Quebec the loss of that
territory would be a body blow to the proposed independent state of Quebec.
 12.3 POSTMODERN POLITICS 735

The idea of partition had supporters within urban Quebec as well. Pierre Trudeau said in 1980 that Si le
Canada est divisible, le Qubec doit tre aussi divisible. Anti-separatist anglophone communities in the
Eastern Townships and the western half of the island of Montreal have also indicated a readiness to secede
from Quebec so to maintain their connections with the rest of Canada.
What is more, Canadas strategic interests have repeatedly been invoked in this discussion. Would it be
necessary to create a Canadian corridor across southern Quebec to sustain connections with the Maritimes?
Similarly, Quebec politicians have voiced a belief that the boundary with Labrador is not what it should be
and that an independent Quebec would expect to receive some of that (iron ore rich) territory.
The effect of these challenges would be to pare Quebec back to something much more like Lower Canada
or what the province was at the very beginning of Confederation. Naturally, this line of arguing is regarded
in Quebec as highly provocative, and its opponents argue that it is unlikely to stand the test of international
law.

There were several important outcomes to the referendum. As constitutional language around distinct society
became more widely accepted in Canadian political culture, it was entrenched in legislation. The Calgary Decla-
ration of 1997 parcelled out veto powers over future constitutional change and received the endorsement of every
provincial government apart from Quebec. The next year, the Supreme Court declared on the question of unilat-
eral declarations of independence: contrary to Mssr Parizeaus plans, Quebec would not be able to simply walk
out of confederation, although negotiations for an exit would be required of both sides. Finally, the slim victory
of the No side pushed the Chrtien government to introduce the Clarity Act (2000) that demanded a clear question
and a decisive outcome at the polls in any future referendum of national significance.

Eventually, constitution and referendum fatigue set in, and no government since 2000 has had an appetite for more
debate on the subject. Quebec remains the only province that has not endorsed the Canada Act, and there is still
no formally approved amending formula in place. The Canada Act is now more than 30 years old, which means
it has outlasted both the Proclamation Act (1763) and the Act of Union (1840) and is currently the third longest-
functioning constitution in the history of British North America, despite being fundamentally flawed.

Figure 12.9 Three Prime Ministers in the second half of

the century shared Arthur Meighens unfortunate
experience of foreshortened tenure. Joe Clark held on
for 9 months, Kim Campbell (above) for less than 5,
and John Turner for 2 and a half.

The Campbell Moment

Something else happened in 1993 that marked a sea-change in Canadian political culture. The most visible was the
appointment of a woman Kim Campbell (b. 1947) as Prime Minister. Campbell won the Progressive Conserv-
ative leadership convention and took over the reins from Brian Mulroney as he retired in June. Despite a promis-
 736 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

ing start, Campbells popularity disintegrated once the election was called. Meech, the Free Trade Agreement, the
Goods and Services Tax (GST), the Gulf War, and the entire record of the Mulroney administration was placed
on Campbells shoulders. Whats more, the appearance of the Bloc in Quebec was mirrored by rising support in
the West for the Reform Party under Preston Manning. Although the Reform Party had campaigned on the slogan
The West Wants In from 1988, it was very much heir to a century of western alienation and was prepared to play
separatist cards of its own. The ideological contrast between the BQ and Reform was significant in that the former
pursued many of the social democratic and social justice issues that were the trademark of the Parti Qubecois,
whereas the latter was more archly conservative, in important ways, than the Mulroney and Campbell Tories. The
effect of having two parties speaking up for regional disenchantment was decisive: the Progressive Conservatives
suffered their most devastating loss on record as they were reduced to only two seats in the Commons. The NDP
faired only slightly better, holding on to 9 of their pre-election 44 seats. Campbell was defeated in her own Van-
couver-Centre riding and disappeared from politics.

An administration that lasts for only a couple of months might be said to have no legacy whatsoever. In the case
of the Campbell administration, one could argue instead that its wholesale collapse was legacy aplenty. Was its
rejection in 1993 a reaction to the neo-conservative, Thatcherite/Reaganomic posture taken by Mulroney or a
rejection of his vision of a renewed constitutional process? In some respects, the outcome is reminiscent of the
no-win situation faced by Laurier 90 years earlier when compromise only brought the contempt of Nationalist
and Imperialist alike. In Campbells case, the Tory record on the constitution was not enough for Quebec and too
3
much for the West. Campbells inability to reassure either side was certainly outstanding. One should also point
to the breakthrough of a woman leader, although Campbell shared this pioneering position with others. Jeanne
Sauv (1922-1993) became Canadas first female Governor-General, serving from 1984 to 1990. Rita Leichert
Johnston (b. 1935) was the first woman to lead a provincial government when, like Campbell, she took the poi-
soned chalice (in 1991) from a failing administration in British Columbia and lost in the very next election. In
the same year, Nellie Cournoyea (b. 1940) became the first First Nations person to lead a government as Premier
of the Northwest Territories (where a consensus-based selection process was used). Catharine Callbeck (b. 1939)
was elected Premier of Prince Edward Island in 1993 in a more conventional parliamentary system and thus broke
the curse of the appointed-successor. The fundamental breakthrough might properly belong to the federal NDP
who elected Audrey McLaughlin as its caucus leader in 1989, which meant that two parties went into the 1993
campaign under female leaders. McLaughlins caucus survived but only barely, and she was succeeded in 1994 by
Alexa McDonough. Sixty years after the Persons Case (1929), women were leading key parties and governments,
and success in this regard would increase from province to province so that by 2012, half of the premiers were
women.

Key Points

Although the costs and benefits of federalism have been repeatedly questioned since 1867, the last
30 years has witnessed several attempts to rethink it, reconstruct it, and reject it.
The failure of the Meech Lake Accord was followed by another, more consultative effort in the form

3. Sharon Carstairs and Tim Higgins, Dancing Backwards: A Social History of Canadian Women in Politics (Winnipeg, MB: Heartland Associ-
ates, 2004), 282-285.
 12.3 POSTMODERN POLITICS 737

of the Charlottetown Accord, which failed to win sufficient support in a national referendum.
The rise of the Bloc Qubcois as a federal separatist party was followed by another separatism ref-
erendum in Quebec. This was another No win, but only narrowly.
The 1995 referendum and its fall-out included increased tensions between some ethno-nationalist
Qubcois and the growing allophone population.
Aboriginal peoples in Quebec voted overwhelmingly against the referendum.
Changes in the Progressive Conservative Party began in 1993 with the election of a female leader
and the partys subsequent electoral collapse.

Attributions
Figure 12.6
Canadian-Senate-chamber by Makaristos is in the public domain.

Figure 12.7
Constitutional Harness for the Wild Nag (Online MIKAN no.3964533) by Library and Archives Canada,
R13244-171 is in the public domain.

Figure 12.8
Quebecref by Earl Andrew is in the public domain.

Figure 12.9
KimCampbell by Skcdoenut is used under a CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.
 12.4 Political Recalibrations

There are many examples of regional political movements in Canadas history, but most bought into the essential
ideas and values of confederation. These were essentially modern qualities in that they were in support of the
nation-state. The Parti Qubecois challenged the legitimacy of one nation-state by proposing that Canadian fed-
eralism undermined the legitimacy of another: the nation-state of French Canada. The failure of the 1980 referen-
dum and efforts to change the constitutional landscape seemed to address this, although by 1990, forces were at
work in Canada that wished to challenge the very model of modernity.

The West Wants In

The near-disappearance in 1993 of the Progressive Conservatives and a poor result for the NDP ushered in a new
era in Canadian federal politics. Conservatives especially the more ideologically pro-business and socially con-
servative or Blue Tories started shifting toward Preston Mannings Reform Party. This move was especially
the case in the West and BC; electoral success east of Manitoba, however, eluded Reform in the 1997 election,
which was due partly to the populist stance of Reform that often pandered to the electorates cynicism and bigotry.
Many of its MPs were on record as misogynists, homophobes, Francophobes, and racists, and the party expressly
1
embraced neo-liberalism to an extent that surpassed even the Mulroney Conservatives. Unable to expand its base,
Reform was nevertheless able to form the Official Opposition in 1997. The former occupant of Stornoway, the
separatist Lucien Bouchard, made way for Manning (b. 1942), the leader of a party that would rather see Quebec
leave than agree to additional concessions.

By moving into Stornoway something he promised not to do Manning alienated himself from some of his
erstwhile supporters. Further desertions came when he disciplined Reform MPs for making public statements
that supported discrimination and endorsed limitations on individual rights based on race, sexual orientation, and
health. The rise in the 1990s of the notion of political correctness provoked right-wingers within the party. Man-
nings inability or unwillingness to take to task the more outrageously outspoken elements in Reform led to deser-
tions from the party; at the same time, his half-hearted efforts to rein in the outliers led to other departures. One of
the Reform Party MPs who disagreed with Manning on several fronts was a young representative from Calgary,
Stephen Harper.

Mannings call for a decentralized Canada in which all the provinces were inherently equal took several forms.

1. David Laycock, Populism and the New Right in English Canada, in Populism and the Mirror of Democracy, ed. Francisco Panizza (Lon-
don, UK: Verso, 2005), 172-201.

738
 12.4 POLITICAL RECALIBRATIONS 739

Western Canadas long-standing appetite for Senate reform was a key measure, taking the form of a Triple-E
Senate elected, equal, efficient. Reforms like this were aimed at dismantling the effective stranglehold that
2
Quebec and Ontario had enjoyed in Canadian politics for more than a century. Without central Canadian support,
however, the Reform Party was going to be forever mired in the Opposition benches. The solution that Manning
sought was a fusion of conservative elements into one party.

The merger of the Tory and Reform parties was accomplished in 2000. The right-wing or blue elites in the Pro-
gressive Conservative Party joined with Mannings Reform supporters to form the Canadian Conservative Reform
Alliance. (This party name lasted for only one glorious weekend as journalists from one end of Canada to the other
noticed that if you added Party, the acronym became CCRAP.) Thereafter, it was the Canadian Reform Conserv-
ative Alliance (CRCA) and, in October 2003, the party of Macdonald, Borden, and Diefenbaker officially merged
with Reform to produce the Conservative Party of Canada. Gone was Progressive, and in the next year, former
Reform MP Stephen Harper was elected leader.

Not everyone in the old Progressive Conservative Party supported this move. Joe Clark was one of many old, and
very often Red Tories who could not support the new CPC. The Progressive Canadian Party appeared in 2003
or 2004 as a vehicle for some of the disenchanted Tories who feared the loss of a particular kind of conservatism
in Canadian politics. Its impact has thus far been inconsequential.

Politics as Performance Art

Figure 12.10 Doug Henning (seen here

levitating in 1976) first acquired some fame as
a stage magician and then ran for office as part
of the Natural Law Party in Britain, and then
in Canada.

Small and even self-consciously absurd political parties appear from time to time and are a feature of
many parliamentary democracies. Examples include Britains Monster Raving Loony Party and Australias
Deadly Serious Party; for several years in the 1970s, Vancouvers civic elections featured The Peanut Party
led by Mr. Peanut (alias Vincent Trasov), which was supported by an all-woman dance troupe called the
Peanettes. Satirical or joke parties serve several purposes, some of them not intentionally. They draw atten-
tion to the political process, even if they are criticizing its weaknesses. Assuming they succeed in making
voters laugh, they read the mood in the country and measure what the electorate regards as worth satiriz-
ing.
The Rhinoceros Party (Parti Rhinocros) has been the most successful and enduring of the joke parties
in Canada. It was established in 1960s Montreal as a means to satirize political campaigns and political
promises. They declared war on Belgium (because the Belgian comicbook character, Tintin, killed a rhino);

2. Richard Sigurdson, Preston Manning and the Politics of Postmodernism in Canada," Canadian Journal of Political Science 27, no. 2
(1994): 249-276.
740 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

promised to switch the right-of-way on Canadian roads from right to left (but this would be phased in grad-
ually, starting with large tractor-trailer trucks first, followed by buses, smaller cars, then last bicycles
and wheelchairs); and threatened to hold an inventory of the Thousand Islands to see if the Americans had
filched a few. The party briefly went dormant in the early 1980s when a Montreal-area candidate, Sonia
Chatouille/Tickle Ct finished second in her riding, ahead of the NDP and Tory candidates. The shock
of a near victory passed, but the Rhinos were effectively barred from further involvement in federal poli-
tics by new laws in 1993 that required a $1,000 deposit and no fewer than fifty candidates to enjoy official
party status.
Founded on the ideals of transcendental meditation, the Natural Law Party of Canada (NLPC) took the
new regulations in stride and ran 231 candidates in 1993 in their inaugural election campaign. Magician
Doug Henning (1947-2000) was a fixture in the partys leadership and an exemplar of yogic flying. Nat-
ural Law never presented itself as satirical; in fact, it sometimes seemed to take itself too seriously. Nev-
ertheless, it was so far out on the fringe as to add welcome relief in an election that was otherwise (rather
typically) mean-spirited. The Partys share of the vote topped at about 0.63% and thus it never really got
off the ground.

Not Easy Being Green

While parliamentary democracy allows for peculiar joke parties, it is also somewhat receptive to new serious
political movements. Small but growing in ambition and support is the Green Party of Canada. Established in
1983, it was initially a federation of like-minded local activists that has evolved into a fully-functioning national
organization with provincial wings. Setting aside its advances in the 21st century, the first 20 years of its existence
produced little in the way of material results. No candidates were elected, and the party organization effectively
went to sleep between election campaigns. In 2000 the Green share of the vote passed 0.81%, and four years later
it was 4.3%; it would take until 2011, however, for the election of the first Green MP.

Canadas political culture has several very deep and widely understood primary themes, one of which is the expec-
tation that political parties offer different visions of economic growth. It might be agricultural or industrial, cen-
tral Canadian versus regional, short-term or long-term, protective or free-trade, but there is always this note
that must be struck by competing parties a promise of more jobs. In this respect, the Green Party struggled in
the 20th century insofar as many of its fundamental platform planks have to do with restricting unbridled eco-
nomic growth, reducing environmental damage by reeling in resource exploitation and manufacturing, and plan-
ning urban growth more carefully. The century closed, however, with the growing realization that human-induced
climate change is a reality and that environmental concerns are no longer the monopoly of single-issue activists.

Like the NDP, which is a member of the Socialist International, the Greens belong to a worldwide family of parties
with a common list of objectives the Global Greens. It is worth noting that there are no parallel organizations
for Liberals or Conservatives.
 12.4 POLITICAL RECALIBRATIONS 741

Key Points

Changes in the political landscape in the post-Cold War years include the rise of the Reform Party
(which eroded the Tory base in the West) and the eventual disappearance of the PCs into the new
Canadian Conservative Party.
These changes brought Blue Tories into an alliance with Albertan conservatives whose populist poli-
tics were informed by Christian fundamentalism and a deep-seated mistrust of central Canadian
elites.
The structure of Canadian parliamentary democracy allows for the appearance, from time to time, of
fringe and new parties that illuminate the limits of the existing political order.

Attributions
Figure 12.10
Doug Henning 1976 by We Hope is in the public domain.
12.5 Identity Politics

The historic experience of Canadiens the descendants of the settlers of New France has been different
from the rest of Canadians. As a result, a separate and distinctive identity came easy for the Qubecois. The
same is not true of most non-francophone and non-Aboriginal peoples in Canada, most of whom are descended
from immigrants who arrived after Confederation. With few exceptions, these newcomers cannot lay claim to an
ancestral landscape within Canada, although some groups have been able to scaffold a separate identity onto the
different ways in which they have experienced Canada. In some instances, this is an outcome of the persecution
of their linguistic and artistic culture by Anglo-Celtic assimilationists, education systems, and marketplaces.
Some recalcitrant groups (like the Doukhobors, for example) have even faced jail time for failing to conform.
Experiences like these have fused identities that are as powerful as if not more powerful than conventional
nationalism.

There have been times when Quebecs French-Canadian population has reached out to les Francophones hors-
Qubec. These francophones number approximately a million, against the six million in Quebec, and they include
a quarter-million Acadiens, a half-million Franco-Ontariens, 70,000 Franco-Colombiens in BC, and more than
50,000 Franco-Albertains. The Bilingualism and Biculturalism Commission took seriously the historic and cur-
rent condition of French-Canadians across the country but, outside of New Brunswick where francophones repre-
sent more than 30% of the total population, and in parts of northern Ontario, the electoral power of this group was
small, and the strength of its collective identity was not enough to turn heads in Ottawa or in Quebec City.

Despite these limitations, les Francophones hors-Qubec constitute in total, and in their various parts, an impor-
tant identity group, one of the earliest to emerge anew in the post-WWII period. There are many others, so many
that a comprehensive list would be nearly impossible to assemble. However, among the earliest and most impor-
tant, we can include Aboriginal Canadians, women, Westerners, and Japanese- and Chinese-Canadians. These
groups stand out because they each had a grievance against the status quo, sufficient numbers to create political
noise, and were either widely distributed so as to be an issue everywhere or tightly concentrated so as to create an
important constituency in one or two locales. Respectively, they were able to bind together over issues of colonial-
ism, patriarchy, and regional disparities in federalism; the experience of internment and dispossession during the
Second World War; and a legacy of racism that included the Head Tax and legal barriers that divided families for
generations. To be an Aboriginal person anywhere in Canada was to experience at least some probably most
of the ills of colonialism; likewise, women everywhere were exposed to systemic sexual discrimination.

The 1960s saw the rise of identity politics that mobilized these groups in ways that proved impossible in the past.
The factors driving the change varied, but the common consequences were an abandonment of loyalty to one party

742
 12.5 IDENTITY POLITICS 743

or another; a weakening of the connection with the conventional story of Canada; and a sense that a collectivity
or a whole branch of Canadian society had experienced abuse, neglect, and a lack of authority. The three decades
that followed witnessed the emergence and consolidation of still more identity groups.

African Canadians and people whose identities and orientations were not heterosexual were part of this eruption of
identities. Northerners; the Inuit; rural Canadians; fundamentalist Christians; individuals who had been managed
by the state because of their mental health: in each instance, their identity became a critical factor in building
a political, economic, social, and civic role. It was no longer enough for politicians or merchants to roll out their
wares and see what appealed; in the late 20th, they had to go to where the identities were. Politicians and others
were told they had to speak to issues like residential schools, abortion, compensation for racist policies, religious
education, self-government, language preservation, and homophobia issues that had been kept off the table for
the first century of Confederation.

Hidden Histories

Figure 12.11 The largest of British Columbias mental health

asylums was variously known as Essondale and Riverview.
Deinstitutionalization of mental health patients in the 1980s
depopulated facilities of this kind.

The late 20th century witnessed increasing interest in the histories of groups that hitherto had eluded study.
Aboriginal Canadians, ethnic Canadians, and visible minorities were more intensively studied, as were
women who, because of patriarchal lenses, had never really been in focus. Working people were also more
fully examined. Three other categories joined these ranks in the years after the 1960s: children (explored
by Georgia Sitara in Section 10.9), the incarcerated, and people whose sexuality fell outside of the hetero-
sexual paradigm (the subject of Section 12.7).
Megan Davies (York University), a specialist on the history of madness, discusses conditions in asylums
in Canada in the 20th century. For reasons you might easily imagine, there are few firsthand accounts from
inmates or patients. French social theorist Michel Foucaults book Madness and Civilization (1964) con-
tinues to inspire scholars to ask questions about institutionalization and social power. Davies account of
asylums and forced sterilization provides a sense of how the growth of state power played out in the area
of mental (and often social and/or moral) deviance. In the second video, Professor Davies addresses dein-
stitutionalization and how it contributed to the growth of a new kind of identity.
 744 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

This multitude of voices and stories is viewed as one of the key qualities of the postmodern era. Multiculturalism
is part of a long-running nationalist narrative of tolerance in Canada, a storyline that has minimized difference
and maximized themes of inclusion. However, this is only one version of nationalism in Canada. In Quebec
particularly in the context of the 1995 referendum nationalism had an exclusive flavour. Inevitably, these
nationalisms wind up being measured against one another. As Eva Mackey observes, in the context of the Quebec
sovereignty campaigns, the demands of French Canada are equated [by Anglo-Canadians] with intolerance and
racism, and English Canada, in opposition, is constructed as the opposite, a modern tolerant nation. Different-
1
ness, therefore, is implicitly deployed ironically as a tool of unity. And yet, this unity itself has limits as
feminist and postmodernist critics have pointed out.

By the mid-1980s, these critiques were erasing smug nationalist perspectives on the countrys history. Systemic
racism, sexism, cultural genocide, and impoverishment were being revealed, often by historians. The new histories

1. Eva Mackey, The House of Difference: Cultural Politics and National Identity in Canada (Toronto, ON: University of Toronto Press, 2002),
4-16.
 12.5 IDENTITY POLITICS 745

that were emerging at this time gave identity groups their own narrativized mandates, setting up a postmodern,
post-colonial, post-patriarchal Canada in which the old constants like the Liberals and Conservatives alternat-
ing in Ottawa were not simply being questioned but gutted. (Just as the Tories were reduced to 2 seats in 1995,
keep in mind that the Liberals fell to third party status in the Commons in 2011 with only 34 seats.)

One of the keys to the rise of identity politics is the right to have an identity, which should be obvious but often it is
not. Gays, lesbians, members of ethnic and/or visible minorities, married couples with different racial ancestries,
individuals and groups belonging to religious creeds that constitute no more than a minority in their communities,
and even women were unable to advance their cause until their identity was recognized. Very often this recog-
nition came in the form of anti-discriminatory legislation. The 1953 Equal Pay Act in British Columbia served
to identify groups that had suffered from discrimination and established that they had a right to complain when
2
they were oppressed on the basis of that identity. Later in the 20th century, in 1988, the Japanese-Canadian com-
munity won an apology and wrung compensation out of the Federal Government for the humiliating internment
of WWII and the states confiscation and sale of their property in the 1940s. (Although 22,000 people had been
3
interned, only 1,400 received compensation for property losses prior to the 1980s.) Many Canadians, including
Pierre Trudeau, opposed this move, claiming that it would open the floodgates for similar complaints based on
past actions. Indeed, subsequent claims were made, although few achieved as much compensation as that awarded
to the survivors of internment. The larger effect of the redress settlement made to Japanese-Canadians was the
way in which it raised human rights abuses in Canada as a historic issue that needed to be confronted. This redress
has served to validate other identity groups such as residential school survivors whose claims of abuse are
not isolated to the distant past, since they took place in the post-war era when human rights was a concept well
known to government, the media, and the public.

The following two sections explore aspects of identity politics in Canada over the last century and more recently.
The images that shaped a mainstream Canadian identity can be contrasted with the ways in which some groups
were consciously excluded and punished for differentness.

Key Points

One feature of the Canadian experience has been the development of many, separate, and sometimes
conflicting identity groups, of which French-Canada is merely the most obvious.
Identity politics became more visible in the 1960s, and gained importance later in the 20th century.
The very fact of embracing multiculturalism and diversity has offered support to the growth of iden-
tity politics while, conversely, building a sense of shared experience and, thus, unity.
Identity politics contributed to the destabilization of the political status quo, which led to the loss of
hegemony by the federal Liberal and Conservative parties.

2. Dominique Clment, Equality Deferred: Sex Discrimination and British Columbias Human Rights State, 1953-1984 (Vancouver, BC: Uni-
versity of British Columbia Press, 2014), 86.
3. Audrey Kobayashi, "The Japanese-Canadian Redress Settlement and its Implications for Race Relations," Canadian Ethnic Studies 24, no.
1.
746 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Attributions
Figure 12.11
Building for Chronic Male Patients by Niall Williams is used under a CC-BY-SA-2.0 license.
 12.6 Building a National Identity

Figure 12.12 Inventing images that evoke a Canadian tradition

distinct from that of Britain or the United States has been a minor
industry in Canada. Here, Catholic traditions meet Quebec
folkways in Our Lady of the Snows, 1909.

A British subject I was born a British subject I will die.

1
John A. Macdonald, 1891

John A. Macdonald functions as something of an official repository of stirring and/or aggravating quotes. He
spoke these words on the campaign trail in 1891 when the Liberals were arguing for closer economic ties to the
United States. Evoking fear of annexation economic certainly, political probably Macdonald summoned up
what he thought was core to being Canadian: British subjecthood. In Macdonalds day and age, being part of the
biggest imperial chain on the planet was something to boast about, and he was counting on other Canadians to feel
the same way when he uttered this statement. He was, however, on the record as preferring a kind of arms-length
colonial relationship with Britain in which the Dominion was utterly loyal but mostly autonomous. The Canadian
High Commission in London was an expression of this: established in 1880, the High Commissioner represented
Canadian interests in Westminster and to the Crown, a slight reversal of the role played by the Governors-General.

More than a century later, what is the national identity? Canadians are not British subjects, regardless of the fact
that the Queen of Canada is also the Queen of Britain. It is difficult to imagine a Prime Minister today invoking
that connection the way Macdonald did (successfully, by the way) in 1891. Was there ever a common agreement
on that identity? No. The Provincial Rights movement of the late Victorian era eroded loyalty to the larger nation
even as the Dominion struggled to establish its bona fides. Fealty to region did not end with Confederation; it
survived throughout the 20th century, and not only in Quebec. A symbolic language of identity at odds with the
national equivalent has consistently acted as a counterweight to the notion of Canadian-ness.

These debates and divisions are important to note because they all contributed to the building of national and
provincial identities. In addition, they go some way to explaining why the history of Canada is so elusive.

1. John A. Macdonald, from 1891 election campaign speech: As for myself, my course is clear. A British subject I was born a British subject I will die.
With my utmost effort, with my latest breath, will I oppose the veiled treason which attempts by sordid means and mercenary proffers to lure our people
from their allegiance. Macdonald opposed the US commercial treaty proposed by the Liberals.

747
748 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Jack Little, a historian at Simon Fraser University, considers how early tourist accounts contributed to a
national sensibility among Canadians.

Making Canada, Making Canadians

In the language of 21st century marketers, Canada had a weak brand at the start of the post-Confederation era.
Was it a British colony or a free nation? The citizens were British subjects which meant what, exactly, in Que-
bec? Was Canada a North American nation or an extension of the British Isles and, maybe, Western Europe as a
whole? Such issues did not trouble the Americans who had nowhere to look but North America. They cut them-
selves loose from Europe in the 1780s and built their own continent-wide empire. The word patriot which
derives from the words pays and patris, thus meaning loyalty to the country of ones father was looked at
askance in Canada because it was associated with American revolutionaries in the 18th century and the Patriotes
of Lower Canada who led the 1837 rebellion against imperial authority. As well, for some more imperially-ori-
ented Canadians, being a nationalist implied loyalty to the nation-state as a structure rather than to the larger
ideals of the the empire, the Crown, and so on. The search for a common denominator, a shared bond that was
both affectionate and inspiring was underway.

What was Canada in 1867 other than a collection of colonies? Theyd fought no great battles together and, in fact,
theyd sparred with one another from time to time. Adding on three more colonies by 1873 did nothing to change
this. Settling and exploiting the West became something of a common project, although Westerners might argue
that their disadvantages under the National Policy ought not be considered a source of national identity or pride.
In the 19th century, the mechanisms for overcoming this alienation, or at least disinterest, were limited. There
was no national media (unlike in Britain where The Times of London circulated widely) and there was no national
education system (again, unlike in Britain); in point of fact, education proved to be one of the most divisive issues
in the early days of the two Dominions.

Imperialists jumped on adventures like the Boer War as a means of manufacturing national consciousness, much
as English-Canadians had thrown themselves into the 1885 events in the West. While nationalists might call for a
Canadian Navy, imperialists believed that a Canadian investment in the Royal Navy made the whole Imperial fleet
 12.6 BUILDING A NATIONAL IDENTITY 749

a symbol of Canada. The persistence of royal imagery in these years suggests that Britain was a stronger source of
icons than the Dominion itself. Certainly the monarch appears on Canadian postage stamps and currencies to the
exclusion of any other leader until the 20th century. Other more Canadian traditions were, however, making an
appearance. When Macdonald proclaimed himself a British subject forever in 1891, his campaign poster The
Old Flag, The Old Policy, The Old Leader had him astride the shoulders of a factory worker and a farmer
(both of whom look well pleased), brandishing a variant of the Red Ensign. The old flag in this case wasnt the
Union Jack after all, but a colonial model with the Union Jack prominent in the upper corner. The flag was far
from old and using it in this way was meant to inspire a sense of Canadian tradition.

Figure 12.13 Is this a statement of

emergent Canadian nationalism?

Artistic representations like this one cannot be underestimated as a source of Canadian identity and part of the
2
process of what historians call the invention of tradition. Posters were more easily mass-produced and more
colourful than the photographs of the time, and the Post Office served as a distribution system. The Federal Gov-
ernment could issue these images, as could the national political parties. In fact, the Post Office itself, with a pres-
ence in almost every community of any size, was an instrument in shaping the Canadian idea.

Putting a Stamp on Canadian Identity

Across the Western world in the late 19th century, several strategies were exploited to build national sentiment
in both new and old countries. Monuments and statuary were used in Germany, France, and the United States
to good effect. Caricature icons also became a vehicle for peoples collective identity, such as John Bull for
Britain and Uncle Sam for the United States. National holidays the 4th of July in the United States, La Fte
Nationale (aka: Bastille Day) in France on the 14th of July, the monarchs birthday in Britain (celebrated in June
since the 18th century), many Independence Days in Latin America, and countless saints days constituted
another convention and mechanism for identifying and rallying around a national storyline. Similar strategies were
deployed in Canada, but with less grip.

Nationalist statuary in Canada is, for whatever reason, less dramatic and less effective than in other countries.
Busts of royals show up everywhere, but there are few national heroes who got that sort of treatment before 1914
and even fewer after 1930 (see Alan Gordons discussion of Monuments and Memory in Section 12.12). There
are, moreover, no enormous triumphal arches in the major cities, no equivalent to New Yorks Statue of Liberty
(1886), and despite the importance of the Notre-Dame Basilica in Montreal no national cathedral. Attempts
have been made to create a personification of the nation in the form of Johnny Canuck, a sort of all-purpose
character who appeared in newspaper cartoons and other visual forms from the late 1860s on. Typically, a fine
physical specimen wearing a Mountie-style Stetson and riding boots, Johnny (sometimes Jack) Canuck (in these

2. Eric Hobsbawm, Introduction: Inventing Traditions, in The Invention of Tradition, eds. Eric Hobsbawm and Terence Ranger (Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 1983), 1-14.
750 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

iterations at least) served as a counterpoint to John Bull and Uncle Sam (the former being corpulent and the latter
what Shakespeare might call lean and hungry). Canuck, however, doesnt appear to stand for anything pros-
perity? freedom? ironic detachment? and so hasnt seen much action over the years. Whats more, there was
no feminine equivalent: nothing to match Britains Britannia, Americas Columbia, or Frances Marianne.

Generally, national holidays have proved more durable and effective. The monarchs birthday (now held on the
24th of May) was transplanted from Britain. Dominion Day (renamed Canada Day in 1982) was celebrated on
the first anniversary of the British North America Act and every 1st of July thereafter. Labour Day followed and
was officially recognized by Ottawa in 1894, even though it had been celebrated by trade unionists since 1872.
(Saint-John-Baptiste Day is older than both, but it had a much rougher time acquiring government sanction and
did not become a parallel national holiday until 1925.) Thanksgiving in Canada was an imported American event
grafted onto existing celebrations of the harvest and was proclaimed a national holiday in 1879. These days off
from work may not seem to have much to do with building Canadian identity, but they were an effective means
of disseminating shared customs and practices (turkey dinners, parades and marches, and picnics in civic parks)
to both established Canadians and newcomers who needed to be assimilated into the mainstream culture. Such
tactics could be seen perhaps most clearly in Canadian classrooms. Even in the absence of a national education
program, the infrastructure of schooling contained many secular images designed to promote a national identity.
Portraits of the current monarch adorned most classrooms, as did maps that underlined Canadas enormity. Well
into the 20th century images of the current Prime Minister gazed down on rows of schoolchildren as well. In
offices across the country, one could find portraits of Laurier or Macdonald depending on whether the occu-
pant was a Liberal or a Tory long after the two statesmen were out of office, which is a symbol of the power of
patronage and party loyalty more than a shared national character.

Figure 12.14 A gathering of national

personifications from Britain and the United
States.

Figure 12.15 Johnny (or Jack) Canuck appears

more as an everyman character, often scowling
at Uncle Sams antics and invariably being a
good son to Britain.

Another venue for disseminating a national identity was still more humble and assuming. The 1890s ushered in
 12.6 BUILDING A NATIONAL IDENTITY 751
3
an era of unprecedented image-making expressed through postage stamps. Pre-Confederation stamps included
images of a beaver and symbols of the British connection; these were followed, after Confederation, by three
decades of stamps bearing the likeness of Queen Victoria. As a reminder of the countrys principal loyalties, this
use of the Queens likeness was itself a powerful message. Then, in 1898, the first post-Confederation stamp
without any relation to the Queen appeared, which was a map of the world in which Canada is prominent at its
centre and the lands of the British Empire are highlighted in bright red. Thereafter, historic themes are gradually
explored, including five commemorative stamps that appeared in 1908 to mark the tercentenary of the founding
of Quebec City (and thus Canada and New France). Nothing more would be done on this theme until 1917 when
a commemorative of the Charlottetown Conference of 1864 was produced.

A similar venue for imagery is the national currency. Paper currency was in circulation from before Confederation,
and images of logging recur, for example, on the 1898 dollar bill. The more widely-circulated 25 cent bill the
shinplaster, so called because of its small size and square-ish shape was, however, the preserve of royal
imagery. The first coin minted in Canada did not appear until 1908. Like many of its contemporary bills and
stamps, it featured a royal head (Edward VII) and more subtly a winding vine of maple leaves. In the case
of both postage and currency, the appearance of Canada was itself a simple and subtle building block of national
identity.

All of these modes of expressing and shaping a national brand experienced a boom in the 1930s as Canada gained
greater independence from Britain, although some of the key elements had already been established. Royals,
political leaders, and maple leaves were among the most favoured themes. The creation of the CBC shifted the
symbolic language of national identity to radio waves; advances in photography and photographic publication in
magazines and other documents were also important. Historians Ian McKay and Robin Bates have demonstrated
how the provincial tourism industry of Nova Scotia took advantage of developments in printing to disseminate,
4
within and beyond, images with strong historic reference points. This process, which they call the making of
the public past, created a new and arbitrary iconography. Parallels can be found in every province, examples of
an emergent national consciousness at the regional level. McKay and Bates have demonstrated that this process
introduces a shift in focus from history to heritage:

If both draw on the actual events of the past, history as such necessarily upholds a notion (however nuanced and qualified)
that some stories about the past are better more accurate, complex, verifiable, ethical than others. [] Unlike his-
tory, heritage does not advance falsifiable positions, not even when it comes to us arrayed in the forms of history: It uses
historical traces and tells historical tales, but these tales and traces are stitched into fables that are open neither to critical
5
analysis nor to comparative scrutiny.

Heritage speaks to group identity in a manner that History cannot. We hear references to our railway heritage
or our fiddle-music heritage that are meant to evoke an inclusion (suggested by our) and, by definition, an
exclusion (not everyone is we or us). In addition, heritage elevates an iconography of the past without prob-
lematizing conflict. Our railway heritage or our prairie homestead heritage looks very different to a Canadian
of settler descent whose ancestors were given a quarter section of free land and another whose Aboriginal great-
grandparents land was seized, carved up, and given away.

3. Eric Hobsbawm, Mass Producing Traditions: Europe, 1870-1914, in The Invention of Tradition, eds. Eric Hobsbawm and Terence Ranger
(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983): 281-282.
4. Ian McKay and Robin Bates, In the Province of History: The Making of the Public Past in Twentieth-Century Nova Scotia (Montreal and
Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 2010).
5. Ibid., 15.
 752 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Such simplifications and mythologizing explain, in part, the durability in the Canadian mind of Anne of Green
Gables, the Cariboo gold miner, the homesteader, Champlain and the heroic age of New France, and the Franklin
Expedition. These are symbols that are comprised overwhelmingly of European faces and values, in which Abo-
riginal peoples are noticeably missing. Asian- and African-Canadians are similarly conspicuous by their absence.
By creating a language of national heritage that excludes other stories, this focus on the Euro-Canadian narra-
tive (invariably told as a narrative of success) eclipsed other possible identities and narrowed the possible stories
available to be told.

Figure 12.16 Green Gables Heritage Place in PEI is a shrine to a

literary character but, of course, the house was merely the
inspiration for Lucy Maud Montgomerys imaginary setting.
What heritage is actually being commemorated?

Advancing these images and others became part of the national project (and parallel provincial and regional pro-
jects as well). The same processes occurred in other countries, and we continue to see these enterprises today, if
we take the time to look.

Two Founding Nations

At the time of Confederation, there was little appetite in English-Canada (especially Orange Ontario) for a dualist
vision of the country. Catholicism was regarded by many leading anglophones as treasonous, and French peo-
ple were characterized as backward and superstitious. Anglophones and Protestants, by contrast, were regularly
depicted as vital, aggressive, dynamic, and tough-minded. Anglicizing the West the clearing away of the
French-Catholic Mtis was not an accident, and French-Canadians generally were on solid ground when it
came to fears of assimilationist intentions on the part of their neighbours. If the English-Canadians could not elim-
inate the French fact in reality, they would often do so symbolically. For proof one has only to remember the lyrics
to Canadas other national anthem, The Maple Leaf Forever, which thrillingly recounts the defeat of Montcalm by
Wolfe, the dauntless hero, and the fact that the thistle, shamrock [and] rose entwine the Maple Leaf implied
that the fleur-de-lis was not allowed to take its turn.

Listen to the original version of The Maple Leaf Forever.

Most often, nationalistic music excludes the foreign but, in the case of The Maple Leaf Forever, it actually
excludes a core group of Canadians. As one specialist explains:

Rather than representing the nation as a whole and serving purposes beneficial to everyone, nationalist music acquires
more specific functions, perhaps the dissemination of a restrictive set of ideological values or the aggrandizement of a
ruling group or an elite oligarchy. Music presents the nation with a way of preserving its past and thus writing the history
of its present. By injecting nationalist sentiments into national music collections, scholars and government agencies
6
alike ipso facto make room for some residents of a nation while taking away space from others.

6. Philip V. Bohlman, World Music: A Very Short Introduction (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002), 94, quoted in Robin Elliott, "Maple Cottage,
 12.6 BUILDING A NATIONAL IDENTITY 753

Dualism clearly presented problems when it came time to imagine Canada as a product. How to build it? How to
maintain it? If the strength of the Dominion derived from its British traditions and military might, then how does
one celebrate the culture of a different and ostensibly defeated culture? Military symbols were among the
most powerful of the Victorian and Edwardian eras through to the Great War. It is no accident that the North West
Mounted Police uniform is modelled on that of a British regiment in occupied Ireland: the red tunics announce
Britishness. Moreover, the force was recruited exclusively from anglophone Canada. The Mounties are the symbol
of Canadian authority par excellence in the West; read differently, they are evidence of intolerance for a dualistic
national ideal.

And yet dualism emerged in the 20th century as the most durable of the national myths. Two founding nations
has its roots in the BNA Act, which seeks to preserve French and Catholic institutions at the provincial level. The
French-Canadians who negotiated the constitution argued that the provisions of the BNA Act would also enable
the co-building by both French and English of a larger country. Anglophone contemporaries understood it differ-
ently: French-Canadian Catholicism was now corralled within one province where it would stay. Again, one may
turn to the separate schools debates across the country in the pre-WWI era for evidence of how these two visions
were mutually exclusive. Gradually in the 20th century, there opened up a little more tolerance in some areas,
while in others the space for dualism closed further and faster.

Several landmark events fostered a growing nationalism that contained space for both French and English sen-
timents. The Great War marks a turning point in this respect, since it was a source of pride for Canadians with
respect to the performance of the nations troops in the face of extremely grim circumstances and under what
was generally thought to be poor British leadership. It was also divisive, however, in that the conscription crisis
divided French and English Canada. There followed a series of events that both built on the embryonic patriotism
fostered by the war and downplayed the contentious issue of conscription.

The first of these is the Halibut Treaty of 1923, an agreement struck directly between Canada and the United States
without the involvement of Britain. Shortly thereafter, in the same year, Prime Minister William Lyon Mackenzie
King attended the Imperial Conference in London, at which it was agreed that Commonwealth countries could
now pursue their own foreign policy initiatives independent of the Empire. Effectively, this agreement put an
end to the Canadian Imperialist dream except insofar as Canada remained an important part of a loose alliance
of nations with Britain at the centre. These changes were enshrined in the Balfour Declaration of 1926 and the
Statute of Westminster in 1931. In 1939, O Canada was officially declared a companion national anthem, along-
side God Save the King/Queen a symbolic but important change.

In these years as well, both the Liberal and Conservative Parties nationally took steps to reduce internal fissures
between French and English elements. The Liberals enjoyed far greater success in this regard by adopting an
7
informal or de facto policy of alternating leadership between English and French Prime Ministers. Following
the Second World War, it became possible for the first time to hold Canadian citizenship under new 1946 leg-
islation. Finally, in the 1960s, three events occurred in close succession. Under the Pearson regime, the Royal

Leslieville, Toronto: (De)Constructing Nationalist Music History," Institute for Canadian Music Newsletter, ISSN 1705-1560, accessed June 22,
2015, [Link]
7. However, there is some slight of hand involved in this alternation. While it is true that Laurier was succeeded by King, St. Laurent was not
Kings choice -- he would have preferred his Finance Minister Douglas Abbott (1899-1987), an anglophone from Montreal. Following St.
Laurent, Lester Pearsons rise was meteoric, given the Nobel Prize for Peace, so it is difficult to imagine any other contender at the time from
any part of Canada becoming PM. In addition, while Pierre Trudeaus ascent was also dramatic, it is easy to forget that the field was made up
of many credible candidates and that the leadership convention vote went to an unprecedented four ballots before Trudeau won 50.9% of the
vote against the now entirely forgotten Bob Winters (1910-1969) who had a very credible 40.3%.
 754 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Commission on Bilingualism and Biculturalism was established in 1963, made a preliminary report in 1965, and
concluded with a full report in 1969. Its existence and six years of work did much to change the tenor of nationalist
discourse in the country. Coincidentally, the replacement of the Red Ensign with the Maple Leaf flag in 1965 was
seen as a nationalist step that placed further distance between Canada and the Imperialist (implicitly anti-nation-
aliste) vision. Finally, the celebration of the centennial of Confederation in the form of Expo 67 in Montreal was
another step toward a thaw in English-Canadian attitudes toward dualism. The fact that this took place against a
backdrop of growing French-Canadian nationalism and separatist feeling was, of course, ironic.

What is sometimes regarded as the genius of Pierre Trudeau was his ability to move beyond dualism to a multicul-
tural nation state. This was an expression of the reality in Canadas cities in particular, but also the West generally,
which were home to a multitude of ethnicities for whom the French vs. English debate in central Canada was less
and less meaningful. The nationalism of Bourassa (essentially a dualistic vision of Canada as a continent-wide
home for French and English alike), the nationalism of Maurice Duplessis (which fostered a view of Quebec as
French-Canada in its entirety and closed off from the rest of Canada), and the nationalism of the Diefenbaker-
Pearson years (which espoused a de-hyphenated national identity) were thus superceded by a national pluralism
in which multiculturalism was a dominant value.

Heritage Fare
In 1972 a popular CBC radio show host, Peter Gzowski (1934-2002), opened a competition to find a Canadian
equivalent to the phrase as American as apple pie. The winning submission came from a Sarnia, Ontario
woman, Heather Scott, who suggested as Canadian as possible under the circumstances. Generations that fol-
lowed have been, on the whole, more or less content to agree. Indeed, the popular self-perception Canadians have
is of a humble nation not given much to flag-waving, which is certainly a convenient place to land after decades
of Union Jack-waving that only divided Canadians.

Yet the symbolic language of national identity continues to constitute a small industry. Every national monument
or park, every backpack bearing a Maple Leaf flag, and every debate about Quebecs place in Confederation
(never English-Canadas place in Confederation) is part of that discourse. So, too, are nationalistic uses of sports:
lacrosse was declared the national sport in 1859 and demoted to Canadas National Summer Sport in 1994 when
hockey was elevated to a parallel status for winter. (The fact that the professional leagues in both sports play from
autumn into late spring is evidently neither here nor there.) Olympic and other international competitions have
been exploited for nationalistic momentum and examined by journalists and scholars alike for signs of what it
8
means to be Canadian.

The struggle to construct nationalisms leans heavily on history, and history has tended to serve nationalism. One
need only think of early accounts of the NWMP/RCMP as a bold and venturesome extension of Canadian will
as opposed to a brutal and often clumsy and undignified imposition of foreign rule for an example. As histo-
rians Laura Peers and Robert Coutts point out, as Canadian history has privileged the accounts of Euro-Canadian
experiences, it has necessarily downplayed Aboriginal stories:

Prior to the 1980s, Aboriginal people were seldom mentioned in either scholarly texts or at historic sites; when they were,
the discussions emphasized colonial control over Aboriginal people within historical narratives that celebrated the estab-

8. If I sound cynical on this score, it is only fair that you should know that I am wearing a Canadian soccer jersey in support of the women's
team in the 2015 World Cup.
 12.6 BUILDING A NATIONAL IDENTITY 755

lishment of that control. Thus, the choice of sites, figures, and events for commemoration emphasized great men (such
as explorers) and their discoveries, military forts as representations of the establishment of European control in a region,
9
and technological advances associated with nation building such as water locks that facilitated shipping.

In thinking about the history of Canada one must, therefore, make space for the history of the idea of Canada.
Too often that gets bound up in notions of Canadian heritage, which it is not. What the concept of Canadian-
ness has accommodated and left out tells us, as historians, a great deal about the society that people in the past
thought they were building, and the place in which they believed they lived.

Lament for a Nation

One of the most powerful 20th century essays on the state of Canada appeared in 1965. Lament for
a Nation was a social conservative reply to the decision reached by the Liberal government of Lester
B. Pearson to host American nuclear missiles on Canadian soil. It was written by George Parkin Grant
(1918-1988), a philosophy professor at McMaster University in Hamilton.
Grant took the position that human freedom is the end-goal of history. He maintained that Canada had a
special role to play in that process by dint of being a North American country steeped in French and British
political philosophical traditions, and yet distinct from the republic to the south with its powerful legacy
of slavery. Continentalism was, in this respect, the enemy. Grant was alert to the changes in symbolic lan-
guage that pointed in that direction: to him the loss of the Red Ensign flag was a signal that Canada was
casting off one of the ropes that tied it to European perspectives. Like many Canadian nationalists, his
vision of Canada was one that engaged globally and led internationally, rather than one tied to a North
American economic engine: material wealth was less important to him as a measure of national greatness
than engagement globally.
Lament was viewed at the time (and has been almost revered since) as a radical statement of Canadian
nationalism in the face of creeping Americanism. Was Grant on the outside looking in? Or was Lament
a manifesto of elite despair? Indeed, one can hardly imagine someone more entitled to the title estab-
lishment figure than George Parkin Grant. He was the grandson of two Canadian Imperialists: on his
mothers side George Robert Parkin and on his fathers side George Monro Grant. His mothers sister,
Alice Parkin (1880-1950), married Vincent Massey (1887-1967, of the Massey-Ferguson agricultural
implement fortune) who became from 1952-1959 the first Canadian-born Governor-General. Raymond
Massey (1896-1983), uncle Vincents brother, was one of the great Broadway and screen stars of the mid-
century, a celebrity in his own right. Grants father and his mothers father Parkin were both principals of
Torontos elite private school Upper Canada College; grandfather Grant was president of Queens Univer-
sity. Historian, polemicist, and politician Michael Ignatieff (b. 1947) is the nephew of George Grant, an
indication of how the value of a Canadian establishment pedigree continues to carry weight.

Exercise: History Around You

The Mountie always Gets his Man

Consider the noble Mountie. Strikingly clad in his scarlet tunic, astride his noble steed, the leather of his

9. Laura Peers and Robert Coutts, Aboriginal History and Historic Sites: The Shifting Ground, in Gathering Places: Aboriginal and Fur Trade Histories,
eds. Carolyn Podruchny and Laura Peers (Vancouver, BC: University of British Columbia Press, 2010), 276.
 756 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

high riding boots and the jet-black of his thick belt. Atop his head is a cute pillbox hat tilted coyly to one
side with a strap pulled tightly under his clean-shaven chin.
Wait, that cant be right.
Yes, the earliest iteration of the Mountie uniform included a hat more usually associated with 20th century
bellhops, elevator operators, cigarette girls, and car valets. Its successor was a white pith helmet (pith being
another word for cork) that stood tall on the wearers head and which is mainly thought of today as having
something to do with imperialists in the tropics and Africa. The flat-brimmed Stetson was the third-time-
lucky alternative.

Figure 12.17 Members of the North West Mounted Police

detachment at Fort Walsh in 1878, photograph by Auderton
George. At that time, NWMP wore hats that were perfectly
designed to keep the sun in their eyes and the rain streaming
into their faces.

Does it matter? Perhaps. As representatives of Canadian authority in the West, theres a reason why the
Mounties looked like the Royal Irish Constabulary or a regiment sent in to suppress a rising in Rhodesia.
These were the shock troops of Canadian imperialism and an expression of Anglo-Canadian virility. As a
familiar icon of Canadian culture, how has this been used? How does it continue to be used?
In 1995 the image of the RCMP (and its predecessor the NWMP) was sold to the Disney Corporation.
Canadians were outraged. Only a few years earlier, Constable Baltej Dhillon, a Sikh-British Columbian
member of the force, achieved national notoriety when he won the right to wear his turban in place of the
Stetson. A chorus of Canadians were equally outraged at that development as well. As historian Michael
Dawson points out, many people considered the Mountie to be an important national symbol and, in
some respects, an inviolate symbol at that. He adds:

Mythologies, like the one surrounding the Mountie, are instrumental in forming a cohesive bond of shared Eng-
lish-Canadian sentiment a sentiment essential for English-Canadian nationalism given Canadas proximity to
the United States and the necessity of developing some response to an increasingly boisterous Quebec national-
10
ism.

Look at ways in which you encounter images of the RCMP and the archetypal Mountie. Consider the
pose, the backdrop, the circumstances (royal visit, Canadian trade delegation abroad, opening of a public
building), the material and medium (photograph, plastic doll, film, cartoon, music), and the typology of
the individual Mountie (male, female, Euro- or Asian- or African- or Aboriginal-Canadian). What is the
message being transmitted? What does it say about the force and/or Canada? Is it a national icon, a short-
hand for Canada as a whole, or something satirical? If this is a part of the national identity, one based in
historical traditions, then it deserves scrutiny.

10. Michael Dawson, The Mountie from Dime Novel to Disney (Toronto, ON: Between the Lines, 1998), 1-5, 25.
 12.6 BUILDING A NATIONAL IDENTITY 757

Key Points

The history of the nation must include a history of national images.

Canadas ability to generate coherent and widely accepted icons and symbols of the national charac-
ter, values, and binding events has been challenged by divisive historical circumstances.
There are many means of transmitting a nationalist message, including anthems, postage stamps,
national holidays, and currency.
Heritage and history get bound up in one another, as the former expresses common experiences that
are meant to be unifying but are often insufficiently problematized from a historical perspective.
Dualism grew through the 20th century as the dominant national trope, and was succeeded after the
1960s by multiculturalism.

Attributions
Figure 12.12
Our Lady of the Snows A Strictly Canadian Character (Online MIKAN no.3622536) by Keystone View
Co. / Library and Archives Canada / PA-207560 is in the public domain.

Figure 12.13
The Old Flag The Old Policy The Old Leader [Sir John A. Macdonald] : 1891 electoral campaign (Online
MIKAN no.2834401) by Library and Archives Canada, C-006536 is in the public domain.

Figure 12.14
The Great Rapprochement by AnonMoos is in the public domain.

Figure 12.15
Canadas Pork Opportunity by Skeezix1000 is in the public domain.

Figure 12.16
Green Gables House front view by Markus Gregory is used under a CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.

Figure 12.17
Police Fort Walsh 1878 by Jean Gagnon is in the public domain.
12.7 Queer and Other Histories

JOHN BELSHAW AND TRACY PENNY LIGHT, THOMPSON RIVERS UNIVERSITY

Figure 12.18 Herbert Norman, Canadian

diplomat, was suspected by the RCMP of
being a homosexual.

The literature on queer history is still in its infancy although it is a robust infant. In a country in which het-
erosexual narratives overlapped so completely with the nation-building saga, finding queer histories constitutes a
huge challenge in its own right.

In the pre-Confederation period, homosexual relations were punishable by death. This extreme stricture seem-
ingly never enforced nevertheless served to keep homosexuality buried deep in the closet. After 1868 the Crim-
inal Code described same-sex relations as an act of gross indecency, and a conviction could and frequently
enough did result in severe jail time and even flogging. These laws would not change substantially for a cen-
tury.

Conditions in public and private life were hardly better than in the courts. Religious authorities of every stripe
regarded homosexuality as starkly immoral. Regarded widely as sexually and psychologically deviant, and crim-
inal, homosexuality if discovered could, and commonly resulted in, the loss of employment and social
ostracism. To be sure, there are many examples of women engaged in what were euphemistically described as
Boston marriages and many confirmed bachelors whose sexual orientation was a public secret. Hidden histo-
ries of this order include Charlotte Whitton (1896-1975), the first woman elected mayor of a leading Canadian city
(Ottawa), who spent more than two decades in a same-sex relationship. The accomplished film animator Norman
McLaren (1914-87) was able to sustain a relationship with another National Film Board director, Guy Glover,
from the 1930s to the 1980s. The possibility of living a fulfilling homosexual life was rarely possible, and exam-
ples such as these are the exceptions to the rule. Probably more typical of the 20th century experiences was that of

758
 12.7 QUEER AND OTHER HISTORIES 759

the accomplished Saskatchewan novelist, Sinclair Ross (1908-96), whose homosexuality was only disclosed after
his death.

Fruit Machines and Protest

By the mid-20th century, there were growing calls to liberalize both the perception and legal status of homosex-
uality as activists drew on the experiences of the civil rights and womens liberation movements. These early
campaigns were contemporaneous with increasing suspicion and surveillance of homosexuals by the intelligence
community. Security circles had linked sexual deviance (which encompassed sex of any kind for any purpose
other than reproduction) with political deviance, at least since the time of the First World War. Homosexuality
came to be regarded as disloyal in and of itself, and homosexuals were thought to be easily turned against their
own nation. The very illegality of homosexuality, of course, created an environment in which lesbians and gays
were vulnerable to blackmail.

Figure 12.19 The fruit machine.

During the Cold War, the Canadian military and RCMP worked assiduously to root out from their ranks, and from
higher levels of the civil service, anyone thought to be homosexual or otherwise sexually deviant. Security offi-
cials exposed subjects to homo-erotic images and used a device that measured pupil dilation to determine whether
the subject was aroused. The so-called fruit machine was bad science, and it damaged (and destroyed) careers,
as did Cold War-era interrogations of suspected security risks associated with homosexual orientation. The dis-
tinguished, intellectually gifted, and unmarried Canadian diplomat Herbert Norman (1909-57) was grilled in the
early 1950s regarding suspicions that he was gay; his subsequent suicide is thought by some to have been con-
nected with his sexual orientation and fear of exposure.

Social standards had changed by the mid-1960s, and there was a greater appetite to decriminalize homosexuality.
One catalyst for this shift was the conviction to indefinite detention (potential life sentence in an institution) of
a North West Territories man, George Klippert (1926-1996), who had had sexual relations with consenting adult
males on four separate occasions. As was the case with lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender women and men
in earlier generations, Klipperts behaviour was at first couched in a language of perversion and psychological
illness. A stable and fearlessly honest man, Klippert stood in for everyone whose lifestyle might come under ran-
dom scrutiny. His conviction was to be the last of its kind. Revision of the Criminal Code followed in 1968, and
in 1969, homosexual relations between consenting adults was made legal.

Watch this video on Pierre Trudeaus Omnibus Interview. Prime Minister Trudeau, who had been the
Minister of Justice only months earlier, was able with a single famous aphorism to shift standards in
regard to homosexual relations between consenting adults.
 760 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Four years later, the Diagnostics and Statistics Manual of mental disorders the guidebook for psychological
assessment and treatment in North America expunged homosexuality as a form of mental illness.

Megan Davies, a York University historian of institutionalization and mental health, describes the links
between social constructions of mental illness and social attitudes toward sexual orientation and identity.

From Penal to Pride

Being gay prior to 1969 could lead to jail, so being out was both dangerous and unlikely to attract support. This
does not mean, however, that gays and lesbians did not find opportunities to create cultures and to build connec-
tions before the Criminal Code was amended. Most major cities contained at least a few discrete venues that were
known to be safe sites for queer gatherings. The Castle Hotel on Vancouvers Granville Street, the Odyssey Club
in Regina, the Happenings Social Club in Winnipeg, the steambaths of Toronto, and bars along Montreals Stan-
ley Street were locations where gay men in particular could meet and form relationships or satisfy sexual needs.
Even after changes in the Criminal Code, however, gay men experienced persecution by the nations police forces.
Legal acceptance of the right to quietly engage in private sexual relations did not extend to public identification
of homosexuality, and a closeted existence continued to seem, for many, the best choice.

However, 1969 marked a turning point in the ability of the LGBT communities to announce their collective pres-
ence and to organize campaigns for rights. As more and more Canadians emerged tentatively from the closet,
they launched one campaign after the next for gay liberation and gay rights. These campaigns met with
the inevitable and strident objections of Canadians (straight and some gay) who were raised in generations
where homosexuality equated, in public discourse and the press, with sexual perversion and even predatory and
pedophilic behavior. Under these circumstances, gays and lesbians who were outed by the police or the courts
could still face stigmatization. Suicides remained a common enough occurrence as a result. Strategies of confor-
mity did not, therefore, disappear overnight. In the short term, as one study has it, many in the LGBT community
1
simply built a bigger closet.

1. Valerie Korinek, A Queer-eye View of the Prairies: Reorienting Western Canadian Histories in The West and Beyond: New Perspectives on
an Imagined Region, eds. Alvin Finkel, Sarah Carter, and Peter Fortna (Edmonton, AB: Athabasca University Press, 2010), 287.
 12.7 QUEER AND OTHER HISTORIES 761

Gradually, the homophile community turned to public displays of solidarity. The pink triangle used by the German
National Socialist regime of the 1930s and 1940s to identify, humiliate, and persecute homosexuals (in what is
sometimes referred to as the homocaust) was appropriated by the gay rights movement as a symbol of shared
suffering and resistance. Gay Pride events began to appear in the early 1970s, starting very small and culminat-
ing in marches that in little more than a decade became major festive occasions in the nations largest cities.

The AIDS Epidemic and the Charter

Although there is evidence for an earlier start in Vancouver in the 1970s, many members of Vancouvers LGBT
community indicate 1981 as the year of the first official pride parade. This is significant in that 1981 also marks
the beginning of the human immunodeficiency virus infection and acquired immune deficiency syndrome (HIV/
AIDS) pandemic in North America. The following year saw the first HIV/AIDS case in Canada. It struck demo-
graphics outside of the gay community, but AIDS was most firmly associated in the media and in the popular
mind with gay sexual relations; it was, for a while, sneered at as the gay plague. The tragedy of HIV/AIDS
which multiplied through the 1980s and into the 1990s was both fuel to the homophobic lobby and a spur
to increased gay rights and LGBT solidarity.

Just as HIV/AIDS was beginning to chew its way along its disease vector, a further change was coming to the
legal status of lesbians and gays. The Charter of Rights and Freedoms in 1982 provided a new foundation for
gay rights, thereafter tested and approved by the courts. Despite intermittent outbursts of homophobic violence,
LGBT Canadians thereafter claimed an increasing share of civic and cultural life. In 1988 Svend Robinson (b.
1952) became the first openly gay Member of Parliament, and 10 years later, Glen Murray (b. 1957) became the
first openly gay mayor of a major city (more than 45 years after Whitton was elected mayor of Ottawa). In 2001
Libby Davies (like Robinson, a British Columbia NDP MP) came out as a lesbian, the first in Parliament. As the
shadows hiding homosexuality rolled back, further gains were made in the courts and legislatures. Rights to ben-
efits and pensions for same-sex couples were granted in different jurisdictions, gays and lesbians were permitted
to serve in Canadas military, same-sex couples were allowed adoption rights, the definition of hate crimes was
broadened to include anti-homosexual cases, and at the turn of the century, the civil laws prohibiting same-sex
marriages were crumbling.

The extension of legal tolerance at first, and then actual, legally enshrined rights for gays and lesbians from the
1960s on is a manifestation of the growing rights culture in Canada during those years. Although LGBT Cana-
dians could not be ghettoized in the same way as poor immigrants or visible minorities, they endured significant
disadvantages through the 20th century, which included the psychological and physical costs of being socially
marginalized, physically threatened, and closeted. The gay community, however, had the significant advantage of
cultural capital and representatives (and allies) atop some of the commanding peaks of the media, cultural indus-
tries, and the academy, and so were able to speak out in ways that other more visible minorities could not. (Con-
trariwise, Charlotte Whitton has been criticized for using her advantages as a white middle-class woman in power
against the rights and needs of ethnic minorities in Canada.) Some of the gains made by the LGBT rights move-
ment have acted as an example for other communities rights, especially since the 1980s.

In 2002 a Durham, Ontario 12th grader, Marc Hall, made plans to bring his 21-year old boyfriend to prom night.
The Catholic school that Hall attended, however, instructed him that this would be forbidden on the grounds that
the Catholic Church did not accept homosexuality. The case wound up in court where, on the morning of the prom,
 762 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

the judge provided an injunction in favour of Hall. In this instance, the provincial governments stand against dis-
crimination on the basis of sexual orientation, at least temporarily, trumped the religious freedom rights of the
school and its board. For Marc Hall, this was a personal victory; from a historic standpoint, it was rather more.
It revealed that the moral arbiters of Canadian society a half century earlier had either lost their authority or had
changed their position dramatically. Far from being declared sexually insane and incarcerated, Hall was applauded
across the country. The case also pointed to the strength of identity politics at the start of the new millennium, and
the ways in which the Charter had rearranged the legal landscape. Historic events such as this one thus serve to
reveal as much about the past as they suggest about the future.

A caveat needs to be registered. Historians and social scientists have drawn attention to the fact that the rights
2
gained by LGBT Canadians might be considered heterosexual rights. Gay marriage, for instance, heterosex-
ualizes queer couples and legitimizes their unions within the boundaries of a particular notion of normal (one
that includes, for example, ideals of life-long monogamy). In terms of current issues, there is ample evidence that
many groups continue to be marginalized (transfolk, for instance); from a historical perspective, it is instructive
to see how invisible their experiences remain in the literature. However, these histories are being brought to light
by historians, many who are making good use of interviews to document experiences in the mid-20th century.

Visit the Archives of Lesbian Oral Testimony website. Elise Cheniers work on archiving lesbian oral his-
tory is both a landmark and a benchmark.

Key Points

Regulations against homosexual relations and homosexuality itself remained on the books in Canada
until the late 1960s.
Although LGBT Canadians often found ways of expressing, exploring, and pursuing their sexuali-
ties, the various pressures to conform to a heterosexual norm constituted a powerful force.
The persecution of gay men in particular increased during the Cold War and, in the security and mili-
tary services, dubious methods of interrogation were deployed to identify homosexual threats.
In 1968 Pierre Trudeaus government took the position that the state has no place in the bedrooms of
the nation and effectively legalized homosexuality.
The decade that followed saw the stirring of gay pride movements; the 1980s witnessed significant
gay liberation and, simultaneously, the HIV/AIDS pandemic.

Attributions
Figure 12.18
E. Herbert Norman (1909-1957), External Affairs (Online MIKAN no.3203917) by Canada. National Film
Board / Library and Archives Canada / PA-134317 is in the public domain.

2. See, for an early example, Marianne Valverde, Sex, Power, and Pleasure (Toronto, ON: Womens Press, 1985).
 12.7 QUEER AND OTHER HISTORIES 763

Figure 12.19
The Fruit Machine from Rebel Youth Magazine is used under a copyleft license.
12.8 The Art of War

The invention of the smartphone has created the most photographed generation in history. Perhaps it is difficult
to recall, as a consequence, how rare and special visual and audio images were in the past. The technology neces-
sary to the creation and dissemination of photography and recordings was only just coming into being at the time
of Confederation. Whereas, with very scarce exceptions, the pre-Confederation era was recorded on canvas, the
post-Confederation period would be preserved in great variety of ways. Visual artifacts, therefore, constitute mul-
tiple histories: evidence of what they ostensibly document, evidence of changes in styles, evidence of evolving
audiences and tastes, and evidence of changes in the technologies of representation, reproduction, and dissemina-
tion.

The late 19th century saw the rise of poster-art, as new printing technologies met new styles. The art nou-
veau movement gave way to Art Deco and, in between, commercial art became a growing part of an embryonic
consumer economy. Whether for vaudeville or for serious theatre, CPR hotels or new household products, posters
became increasingly colourful, far less fussy, and powerfully expressive.

Recruitment posters for the Great War remain iconic a century later. In the United Kingdom, Lord Kitcheners
face was so familiar to the public that his name was left out of the phrase Wants You. The Americans subse-
quently borrowed the stern look and the pointing finger for their famous Uncle Sam Wants You poster that came
out in 1917. In Canada, the war imagery started in a jolly mood with a sense of adventure and little sense of actual
fighting or danger (Figure 12.20).

Figure 12.20 A ca. 1915 poster aimed at

French Canadians captures some of the
positive and even light-hearted sentiment
at the start of the Great War.

As the war dragged on the messages and images changed. A psychological approach appeared, one in which men
were shamed into enlisting or their women encouraged to give them a push (Figure 12.21).

764
 12.8 THE ART OF WAR 765

Figure 12.21 To the Women of Canada

Wont You Help and Send a Man to Enlist
To-Day?

Appeals were made, too, to ethnic groups. The relationship between the Irish and the British was fraught during
the Great War but that didnt stop Canadian recruiters from imposing their expectations of loyalism on the Irish-
Canadian community (Figure 12.22).

Figure 12.22 This 1915 call to arms

Small Nations Must Be Free
applies as much to Irish aspirations as
it does to Belgium.

The same could be said for Canadian Jews, whose experience of Christian-Canadian tolerance included Clifford
Siftons efforts to keep them out of the country entirely from 1896 to 1906. The emancipation (removal of civil
restrictions and barriers to public service based on faith) of the Jews in Britain in 1858 is echoed here (Figure
12.23) as the warrior-to-be announces, You have cut my bonds and set me free Now let me help you set others
FREE!

Figure 12.23 Britain Expects Every Son of

Israel to Do His Duty.

The artwork itself was evolving: 20th-century lettering and aerial combat, along with an entirely different repre-
sentative style makes an appearance in this 1916 poster (Figure 12.24).
766 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Figure 12.24 To Build Anything, To Fight Anything.

5th Overseas Pioneer Battalion C.E.F.

If recruitment posters could not do the job, then Victory Bonds might. The range of Victory Bond posters is stag-
gering, and their complexity and colours are striking (Figure 12.25).

Figure 12.25 What the Canadian troops

faced was trench warfare, disease, mud,
madness. Here, the brave Canadian
infantryman stands tall on a dry battlefield
against an onslaught of artillery fire.

Images of children were conscripted to the task of selling Victory Bonds. A famous version of this was the British
What did you do during the Great War, Daddy? poster (Figure 12.26).

Figure 12.26 Do it again Daddy Please! Buy

Me a Victory Bond.

Figure 12.27 Images of women in France,

obliged to pull the plough in triple-harness
because their men and horses have been
conscripted, are used to shame Canadians
into subscribing funds to Victory Bonds.
 12.8 THE ART OF WAR 767

Even at wars end, the posters continued to appear, calling for citizens help to reintegrate the returning soldier
(Figure 12.28).

Figure 12.28 Buy Victory Bonds.

Modern artistic styles become more obvious in this 1919 painting by Frederick Etchells, Armistice Day, Munitions
Centre (Figure 12.29).

Figure 12.29 Frederick Etchells, 1919.

Beaverbrook Collection of War Art, Canadian
Museum of Civilization.

By the outbreak of World War II, Canadian art had become more mature and sophisticated. The Group of Seven
were by now well established (see Section 10.14). One of their number A.J. Casson produced this glorious
work as the collection of donations for a new generation of Victory Bonds, which got underway in 1941 (Figure
12.30).

Figure 12.30 Help Finish the Job. Buy Victory

Bonds.

Art-deco-meets-gothic-knights in this Department of National Defense recruitment poster (Figure 12.31).

Figure 12.31 Canadas New Army Needs

Men like You.
768 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Wartime brought a variety of moral panics, including fear of spies, saboteurs, slackers, and sexually transmitted
diseases. The last of these became associated with loose women and prostitutes, rather than with enlisted men.
Campaigns against venereal diseases often portrayed women as infectious sexual predators who were sapping the
strength of the nation (Figure 12.32).

Figure 12.32 He picked up More than a

Girl.

The final word goes to the Wartime Information Board, who deployed strong colours and graphics in service of
the newest Victory Bonds campaign (Figure 12.33).

Figure 12.33 Choose your Bonds.

Art histories of the 20th century generally dont provide much space for these utilitarian creations but histories of
social and cultural values should. These are documents that show us the past, while shaping the past at the same
time.

Key Points

Posters became both a cultural form and an important means of communicating values, goals, and
other messages in the 20th century, as the poster-art of Canada at war reveals.

Attributions
Figure 12.20
Canadiens franais enrlez-vous au 150ime Carabinier Mont-Royal : recruitment campaign (Online MIKAN
no.3635539) by Library and Archives Canada, Acc. No. 1983-28-803 is in the public domain.

Figure 12.21
To the Women of Canada, Enlist Today (Online MIKAN no.3667208) by Library and Archives Canada, Acc.
No. 1983-28-834 is in the public domain.
 12.8 THE ART OF WAR 769

Figure 12.22
Irish Canadians enlist in an Irish and Canadian Battalion by Skeezix1000 is in the public domain.

Figure 12.23
The Jews the world over love liberty poster by Mbz1 is in the public domain.

Figure 12.24
To build anything, to fight anything 5th Overseas Pioneer Battalion, C.E.F. by Library of Congress Prints
and Photographs Division is in the public domain.

Figure 12.25
Back Him Up! Buy Victory Bonds : victory loan drive. (Online MIKAN no.2894437) by Library and Archives
Canada, Acc. No. 1983-28-606 is in the public domain.

Figure 12.26
Do It Again Daddy Please! Buy Me a Victory Bond. (Online MIKAN no.3667091) by Library and Archives
Canada, Acc. No. 1983-28-653 is in the public domain.

Figure 12.27
Canada WWI Victory Bonds2 (ID: cph 3g10650) by Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division is in
the public domain.

Figure 12.28
Re-establish him Its up to us Buy Victory Bonds : victory loan drive. (Online MIKAN no.3635524) by
Library and Archives Canada, Acc. No. 1983-28-613 is in the public domain.

Figure 12.29
Frederick Etchells Armistice Day, Munitions Centre by Frederick Etchells / Labattblueboy is in the public
domain.

Figure 12.30
Give Us the Tools and We Will Finish the Job Help Finish the Job Buy Victory Bonds : victory loan drive
(Online MIKAN no.2834370) by Library and Archives Canada, Acc. No. 1983-30-585 is in the public domain.

Figure 12.31
Canadas New Army Needs Men Like You : recruitment campaign (Online MIKAN no.2834359) by Library
and Archives Canada, Acc. No. 1983-30-303 is in the public domain.

Figure 12.32
He Picked Up More Than a Girl : sensitive campaign against venereal disease (Online MIKAN no.2851781)
by Library and Archives Canada, Acc. No. 1985-35-8 is in the public domain.

Figure 12.33
Choose Your Bonds. Buy the New Victory Bonds by Labattblueboy / Wartime Information Board, Ottawa /
McMaster University Libraries, Identifier: 00001665 is in the public domain.
 12.9 The Historical Record in the Born-Digital Age

IAN MILLIGAN, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, UNIVERSITY OF WATERLOO

Just as Big Data is reshaping contemporary society, for better or worse, so too will it reshape the historical pro-
fession. The astounding growth of digital sources since the advent of the World Wide Web from 1990 to 1991
presents tremendous new opportunities for social and cultural historians, but it can also be terrifying in the sheer
amount of information that these sources will contain about how life is now lived.

Web archives, created by web crawlers that systematically download websites, subsequently stored and preserved
in repositories ranging from the Internet Archive to national libraries like the British Library and the Bibliothque
Nationale de France, contain incredible recollections: the everyday thoughts of Canadians, recorded on social
media, blogs, websites, and beyond. You can access them yourself if you know the exact address with the
Internet Archives Wayback Machine or if you want to try searching some old Canadian websites, visit
[Link]

First the opportunity. Imagine what this might mean. As James Gleick has argued in his book The Information,
the norm before the digital age was that human information would vanish but now, expectations have inverted.
1
Everything may be recorded and preserved, at least potentially.

We can see the signs of this enormous resource already. The old gold standard of historical data included collec-
tions like the records of the Old Bailey (now digitized), the central London criminal court that provides so much
insight into the lives of English people between 1674 and 1913. Its custodians can today rightfully claim that it
is the largest body of texts detailing the lives of non-elite people ever published. Until now, that is. The online
network [Link], which between 1994 and 2009 let everyday people create their own personal websites
for no charge, saw the creation of some 38 million documents, generated by as many as seven million users. Or,
during the #IdleNoMore protests in January 2013, consider that, on one day alone 11 January 2013 some
55,334 tweets used that hashtag.

Herein lies the problem, however, to temper this considerable opportunity. You cant read 38 million documents,
nor can you feasibly read all of these tweets. To use these sources, historians will need to use computers, but thats
not in itself a simple solution. To really understand how computer programs are parsing these sources, I think that

1. James Gleick, The Information: A History, a Theory, a Flood (London: Vintage, 2012), 3967.

770
 12.9 THE HISTORICAL RECORD IN THE BORN-DIGITAL AGE 771

historians need to know how to program. This doesnt mean that historians all need to become computer scien-
tists, of course, but rather that they begin to think algorithmically and bring a basic digital awareness to bear on
these questions that will so profoundly affect us.

This is critically important because historians can apply a sensitive humanist sensibility to these questions. Ethical
dimensions may be particularly pronounced, as we begin to discuss what it means to access and use the sources
generated by millions, soon billions, of people the vast majority of whom are unaware that their sources are
being preserved. Are blogs or tweets fair game for the historian, now or in the future? As historians have consid-
erable experience with ethical discussions, both from print and oral sources, it is yet another reminder that we can
take a leading role in these conversations.

This is where resources like the Programming Historian, a free, open access online textbook that shows historians
how to program, or my own Exploring Big Historical Data: The Historians Macroscope come in handy. These
are team-written projects that try to give historians the tools to interpret digital sources, and also make the case
that historians need to embrace collaboration, learn their own digital skills, and face the challenges of the 21st
century head on.

All historians will benefit from fruitful, technically sound, and ethically principled engagement with web archives.
As we begin to write histories of the 1990s (strange as it may sound, we are almost as far from the 1990s as we
were from the 1960s when histories of that decade began to appear), we will need web archives to do justice to the
period. Yet, imagine: military historians will have the thoughts of soldiers deployed overseas who tweeted or used
discussion boards to communicate with loved ones; political historians can trace how elections in the 1990s or
2000s played out online, or how governments forged ties with communities; and social and cultural historians can
see how our societies functioned. It will require some rethinking of how we as historians approach our profession,
but the results will be worth it.

Key Points

The task of the historian changes along with the character of source material. Digital records pose
new challenges and opportunities.
Just as the data opens up new frontiers, it presents the obligation to think anew about ethical issues
in archival research.
 12.10 Digital Histories

JOHN BONNETT, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, BROCK UNIVERSITY

Scholars, be they historians or humanists, are often charged with having a complex about computers. They
shouldnt be. If you examine the histories of fields such as history, classics, and literary studies, you will find
scholars from the earliest days of computing who used it to better understand the writings of Saint Thomas
1
Aquinas, to determine the authorship of anonymous documents relating to the creation of the American constitu-
2 3
tion, and to better understand the shape and size of families in Early Modern Europe. Humanities scholars, put
simply, were present at the creation of the computer. There was, however, a common refrain in the early days of
digital history: scholars used the computer to manipulate two things, texts and numbers.

And while those efforts produced contributions, the story I want to tell here is one that focuses on historians use
of forms of expression that are not text and are not number. Here, Im talking about expressive forms that have
two-, three- or even four-dimensions (like, for example, a model of a heritage building). Here, Im also talking
about forms of expression that are dynamic they move and do so in a way that is autonomous. They perform
behaviours without the direct intervention of an author or programmer. This capability enables scholars to create
simulations of historic battles, economies, and even cities.

Now, why would we want to use forms like these? The simple answer is that sometimes different forms of
expression can express an idea, an historical event or a pattern more clearly than words or numbers. Consider for
example the stock market. Many of us see reports on its daily progress on the news, and we watch its movements
because were interested in its behaviour. Has it gone up? Has it gone down? Has its behaviour been stable, or
have prices veered all over the place? In principle, there are two ways we can communicate that information. We
could present our audience with a list of prices. But that option is ultimately not a very good one, in large measure
because it forces viewers to look at that list and then visualize the performance of the market in their head. Its
a lot of work. A better solution is to use the formalism the form of expression that you see in most news
reports, namely the graph. The graph is the better solution because it enables the viewer to obtain a comprehensive
view of the markets behaviour with a simple glance and little cognitive work. In short, then, historians are explor-

1. Robert A. Busa, Foreword: Perspective on the Digital Humanities, in A Companion to Digital Humanities, Susan Schreibman, Ray
Siemens, John Unsworth, eds. (Oxford, UK: Blackwell Publishing, 2004): xvi-xxi.
2. Hugh Craig, Stylistic Analysis and Authorship Studies, in A Companion to Digital Humanities, Susan Schreibman, Ray Siemens, John
Unsworth, eds. (Oxford, UK: Blackwell Publishing, 2004): 284-286.
3. Peter Laslett and R. Wall, Household and Family in Past Times (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1972).

772
 12.10 DIGITAL HISTORIES 773

ing the use of different forms to help them better teach, represent, and explore the past. They are using computers
because doing so makes it easier to create and disseminate those forms.

One means of creating forms is through the use of software known as Geographic Information Systems (G.I.S.).
The basic idea behind G.I.S. is simple: it combines two things: lists (otherwise known as databases) and maps.
More specifically, it assigns each item in our database-list a spatial location, and plots that location on a map using
a pin, a dot, or a polygon. The idea is simple but in practice, it often produces powerful results for historians.
Plotting information on a map can often reveal important spatial patterns that can deepen our understanding of
4
social, economic, urban, and environmental history. Using this method, for example, historians have been able to
challenge the received wisdom on topics such as the circumstances behind the emergence of the dust bowl in the
1930s. Traditionally, historians have faulted farmers for the dust storms, pointing to methods of cultivation that
were not sustainable. In the 1990s, however, the historian Geoff Cunfer, using G.I.S., was able to demonstrate that
the actual cause of the storms was drought, not farmers. In almost every case, the storms emerged in sections of
5
the United States that were not farmed. Hot weather caused the storms, not farmers. Scholars have used G.I.S. to
qualify or challenge our received wisdom on other topics as well. Michael McCormick, for example, used G.I.S.
to demonstrate that Europes economy revived much more quickly after the collapse of the Roman Empire than
6
historians had customarily thought. Historians John Lutz and Pat Dunae and their colleagues used G.I.S. to argue
7
that 19th century residents of Victoria were not as racist in their behaviour as historians have usually assumed.

This Roaring Twenties recording charts noise in New York City in the past. It is an example of how map-
ping and social behaviour in the past can be brought together in ways that are layered and impossible to
convey through conventional historical description.

Historians and historical scientists have also used dynamic, autonomous forms to deepen their understanding of
the past, using software that creates historical models known as agent-based simulations. The basic idea behind
agent-based simulations is simple. You (as a historian) define the agents you want for your simulation. The agent
can be a person, a microbe, or even a multi-national corporation. It can also be all of the above, in which case you
have different classes of agents. Once you have defined your agents, the next step is to define their behaviour:
to specify how they interact with each other and how they interact with their environment. Once you have stipu-
lated their rules of conduct, your next step is to flip the switch, run the simulation, and see what kinds of patterns
emerge. Researchers in the social sciences and the humanities have found these simulations to be extremely pow-
erful because they have produced patterns that match, or nearly match, patterns that scholars have located in data
from the past and present. They present a way for us to test theories and deepen our understanding of how historic
economies worked, the circumstances leading to the emergence of individual cities and systems of cities, and the
trajectory of significant battles in history. One reason that agent-based simulations are important is they provide a
8
way for historians to assess the relative importance of one cause versus another in initiating a historic event.

Take the Battle of Trafalgar as a case in point; it occurred in 1805 during the Napoleonic Wars and pitted the

4. Amy Hillier and Anne Kelly Knowles, eds., Placing History: How Maps, Spatial Data, and GIS Are Changing Historical Scholarship (Red-
lands, CA: ESRI Press, 2008).
5. Geoff Cunfer, On the Great Plains: Agriculture and Environment (College Station, TX: Texas A and M University Press, 2005).
6. Michael McCormick, Origins of the European Economy: Communications and Commerce AD 300-900 (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Uni-
versity Press, 2002).
7. John S. Lutz, Patrick A. Dunae, Jason Gilliland, Don Lafreniere, and Megan Harvey, Turning Space Inside Out: Spatial History and Race in
Victorian Victoria, in Historical GIS Research in Canada (Calgary: University of Calgary Press, 2014): 1-26.
8. Jonathan Rauch, Seeing Around Corners, The Atlantic Monthly, April 2002.
 774 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

British Royal Navy against a combined fleet from Britain and France. Britain emerged as the decisive victor. It
lost no ships, while the Franco-Spanish fleet lost 22 of the 33 ships it had deployed. In explaining Britains vic-
tory, scholars have had two possible explanations. First, Britain had bigger and better guns and ships. Second, the
fleets commander, Admiral Horatio Nelson (1758-1805), was a tactical genius. What scholars have not had is a
way to differentiate the relative importance of each cause. In 2003, researchers Giuseppe Tratteur and Raniero
Virgilio created an agent-based simulation to see if they could determine which of the two causes was more impor-
tant. Their simulations suggested that, ultimately, it was Britains equipment that was critical. Britain would have
won the conflict, even without Admiral Nelson. What Admiral Nelson contributed was the best tactics, methods
of fighting that minimized Britains losses in equipment and personnel, but he or another commander could have
9
contributed less and the Royal Navy still would have carried the day.

Key Points

Digital histories represent an opportunity to explore historical problems with fresh eyes and to repre-
sent them to readers, students, and peers in innovative and helpful ways.

9. G. Trautteur and R. Virgilio, An agent-based computational model for the Battle of Trafalgar: a comparison between analytical and simula-
tive methods of research, in Enabling Technologies: Infrastructure for Collaborative Enterprises, 2003. WET ICE 2003. Proceedings.
Twelfth IEEE International Workshops. (9-11 June 2003): 377-382.
12.11 Oral History: The Stories Our Grandmothers Tell Us
and More

KATRINA SRIGLEY, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, NIPISSING UNIVERSITY

What is Oral History?

At its heart, oral history is about listening to and learning from stories of the past. Rooted in ancient storytelling
traditions, oral history happens all the time around dinner tables, along trap lines, in coffee shops, and classrooms.
It happens between generations, among students and teachers, and researchers and historical actors. The nature
of listening and sharing depends on who is involved and what participants are hoping to learn or share: sacred
teachings, practical skills, or an understanding of events and experiences in the past.

Why Do We Record Oral Histories?

Oral histories have different purposes and they must be analyzed in this spirit. As historian Winona Wheeler
reminds us about the Ininiw (aka: Cree) epistemological context, stories are gifts given from one person to another.
Some are sacred and are not knowable outside families or communities; some can only be shared in certain sea-
sons of the year; some will not be shared until relationships built on trust and reciprocity are established. It can
take years to earn the right to listen. In these contexts, oral history has always been used as a methodology for
recording, sharing, and archiving. Historians trained in Euro-Western intellectual contexts embraced oral history
methodology in increasing numbers after the 1970s because it allowed them to do history from below, uncov-
ering perspectives and experiences not commonly available in the written documentary record. These historians
were interested in eyewitness testimonies that allowed them to develop a more complete picture of the past. By
the late 1980s, the field expanded to include historians interested in memory and memory making. They recorded
stories to explore how and why people remember the past in the way that they do.

No matter the context, before sitting down to listen to and record stories with a smartphone, computer, digital
voice recorder, or just a pair of ears, the best oral historians reflect on the following questions: why do I want
to hear these stories? What do I plan to do with what I learn? Are there cultural protocols I should observe? Is
there anything I might ask that would be upsetting or uncomfortable? How will I provide support if necessary?

775
776 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

How will I thank the participant for their time? We take these steps to uphold the highest principle of ethics: to do
no harm. In Canada, researchers are guided by the Tri-Council Policy Statement: Ethical Conduct for Research
Involving Humans (TCPS), 2nd edition.

How Do We Analyze Oral Histories?

As with other aspects of oral history, analysis takes different forms depending on the purpose and nature of shar-
ing. In history classrooms we teach our students to contextualize in ways that are mindful of oral histories as
historical sources created in the present and shaped by both teller and listener. We ask why was the oral history
recorded and for whom, while also exploring how stories are shaped by the context in which they are shared. It
stands to reason that strangers hear the same stories differently than do family members. Further to this, people
forget things, remember things differently, exaggerate, and even lie. As such, you must ask: what is the relation-
ship between past and present in this story? Why does a person or community members remember the past in a
particular way? Analyzing oral histories is a multilayered process and what any one listener takes away varies
dramatically. This makes oral history one of the most rewarding and challenging methodologies for learning about
the past.

Key Points

Oral history offers the possibility of accessing the historical experiences of people about whom the
standard texts and archives have little to say.
The ethical requirements of doing oral history well and professionally are necessarily rigorous and
should never be conducted without approval under an ethics review process.

Sources
Abrams, Lynn. Oral History Theory. London: Routledge, 2010.

Berger Gluck, Sherna and Daphne Patai. Womens Words: The Feminist Practice of Oral History. New York:
Routledge, 1991.

Cruikshank, Julie. Life Lived Like a Story: Life Stories of Three Native Yukon Elders. Vancouver: University of
British Columbia Press, 1990.

Frisch, Michael. A Shared Authority: Essays on the Craft and Meaning of Oral and Public History. New York:
SUNY Press, 1990.

Leddy, Lianne. Interviewing Nookomis and Other Reflections of an Indigenous Historian. Oral History Forum/
dhistoire orale, 30 (Special Issue-2010:): 1-18.

Llewellyn, Kristina, Alexander Freund and Nolan Reilly. The Canadian Oral History Reader. Montreal &
Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 2015.
 12.11 ORAL HISTORY: THE STORIES OUR GRANDMOTHERS TELL US AND MORE 777

Perks, Robert and Alistair Thomson. The Oral History Reader, 2nd edition. New York: Routledge, 2006. New
edition being released in 2016.

Portelli, Alessandro. The Death of Luigi Trastulli and Other Stories: Form and Meaning in Oral History. New
York: SUNY, 1990.

Srigley, Katrina. Breadwinning Daughters: Young Working Women in a Depression-era City. Toronto: University
of Toronto Press, 2010.

Srigley, Katrina. Stories of Strife? : Remembering the Great Depression. Oral History Forum/dhistoire orale,
Volume 29, (Special Issue-2009): 1-20.

Wheeler, Winona. Reflections on the Social Relations of Indigenous Oral Histories. In Walking a Tightrope:
Aboriginal People and their Representations. David McNab, ed. Waterloo, ON: Wilfrid Laurier Press, 2005.

Yow, Valerie. Recording Oral History: A Guide for the Humanities and Social Sciences, 2nd Edition. New York:
Altamira Press, 2005.

Zembrzycki, Stacey. According to Baba: a Collaborative Oral History of Sudburys Ukrainian Community. Van-
couver: University of British Columbia Press, 2014.
 12.12 Monuments and Memory

ALAN GORDON, DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, UNIVERSITY OF GUELPH

Figure 12.34 The western aspect of The Response.

In May 1939, only months before the outbreak of the Second World War, King George VI presided over the inau-
guration of Canadas National War Memorial in Ottawa. Dubbed The Response, the memorial presented an ide-
alized view of Canadas reaction to the First World War, and its inauguration was rich with symbolism evoking
triumphant patriotism and devotion to the monarch. This monumental unveiling represents the culmination of a
period of monument building in Canada. Indeed, most monuments still seen on Canadas streets date from the era
between 1890 and 1939. Although monuments continued to be raised after WWII, the monumental landscape was
largely established by 1939, reflecting the values of that era.

Canada was not alone in these efforts. A similar process began slightly earlier in Europe, Britain, and the United
States, as 19th century nations sought ways to honour important people and commemorate events. They began
building monuments for reasons associated with what English historian Eric Hobsbawm has called the mass-pro-
1
duction of traditions. As nations industrialized and grew in size, they began to formalize and ritualize symbols of
power and national cohesion. Monuments aided this process in a number of ways. As memorials, they helped per-
petuate memories and aid civic education by recognizing great leaders and accomplishments; they helped direct
common values, offering examples of civic virtue for mass consumption. Thus, monuments helped shape a sense
of national history that was closely linked to national institutions: they presented political, ideological messages.
Yet, while official monuments attempted to enshrine an official narrative of Canadas past, monuments could be
hotly contested, since different groups saw history differently.

Certainly, there had been monuments raised in Canada prior to the industrial revolution. In the 18th century, Amer-
ican soldiers occupying Montreal during the American Revolution destroyed a bust of George III standing in a

1. Eric Hobsbawm, Mass-Producing Traditions, Europe, 1870-1914, in The Invention of Tradition, eds. Eric Hobsbawm and Terence Ranger
(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983), 1-14.

778
 12.12 MONUMENTS AND MEMORY 779

city square in Montreal, which demonstrated the deep and contested meanings monuments represented for people.
In 1809, following the death of Admiral Horatio Nelson in the Battle of Trafalgar, Montreal raised another and
2
more enduring monument to the hero, an action that was repeated around the British Empire. In the 1820s, Lord
Dalhousie tried to pacify local sentiments by placing a monument honouring both Wolfe and Montcalm in Quebec
City. In the middle years of the century, other heroes, such as Generals Wolfe and Brock, as well as events such
as the Battles of Sainte-Foy and Ridgeway, were also memorialized by monuments. However, it was not until the
late 1880s that Canadians begin to raise monuments in significant numbers.

Between 1885 and 1922, the lives of eight Canadian statesmen were celebrated with monuments on Parliament
Hill in Ottawa, linking central Canadian politics to a particular vision of historical significance. However, away
from the capital, monument raising focused on other heroes and events, and reflected other ideas about history. For
instance, at Quebec City in 1898, civic leaders argued over the best depiction of Samuel Champlain in the monu-
ment they were building. The interpretation that emerged from these disputes purged Champlains religious iden-
3
tity to make him simply the governor of New France, a precursor of Canadas Governor-General. After WWI,
the focus in much of the country turned away from great figures towards the common soldiers who had laid down
their lives to defend their hometowns. As historian Jonathan Vance documents, Canadian communities from Coast
to Coast designed and built monuments to honour the local sons who had fought for king and country in the Great
4
War, which culminated in the unveiling of the National War Memorial. This phenomenon was less pronounced in
Quebec where the war had been unpopular and where monument building in the 1920s turned instead to heroes of
5
Quebecs past. Despite efforts to stamp a singular message on Canadas monuments, the histories they told could
be highly contentious.

Figure 12.35 Memorials have ceased to be the monopoly of

heroic figures and leading politicians as Enclave (the 1992
Ottawa Womens Monument to women murdered as a result of
domestic violence) attests.

Two University of Toronto historians offer different perspectives on commemoration and public celebra-
tions. Cecilia Morgan offers her thoughts here,

2. On the history of the "Napoleonic columns" in Canada, see John Douglas Belshaw, Canadian History: Pre-Confederation (Vancouver, BC:
BCcampus, 2015), Section 11.1.
3. Ronald Rudin, Founding Fathers: The Celebration of Champlain and Laval in the Streets of Qubec, 1878-1908 (Toronto, ON: University of
Toronto Press, 2003).
4. Jonathan Vance, Death So Noble: Memory, Meaning and the First World War (Vancouver, BC: University of British Columbia Press, 1997);
see also Vances article, Documents in Stone and Bronze: Monuments and Memorials as Historical Sources," in Building New Bridges/Btir
de nouveaux ponts: Sources, Methods, and Interdisciplinarity/Sources, mthodes et interdisciplinarit, eds. Jeff Keshen and Sylvie Perrier
(Ottawa, ON: University of Ottawa Press, 2005), 185-195.
5. Alan Gordon, Making Public Pasts: The Contested Terrain of Montreals Public Memories, 1891-1930 (Montreal and Kingston: McGill-
Queens University Press, 2000).
780 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

and here,
 12.12 MONUMENTS AND MEMORY 781

and her colleague Ian Radforth makes his observations here.

782 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Key Points

Monuments and memorials have been used to assert authority, acknowledge the legitimacy of mem-
bers of a society, and craft the basic outlines of history itself.
Outwardly straightforward, monuments and statuary in Canada have often been divisive and inter-
preted (or reinterpreted) in conflicting ways.

Attributions
Figure 12.34
National War Memorial in Ottawa (1) by R. Wolsak is used under a CC-BY-NC-SA-2.0 license.

Figure 12.35
MintoParkMemorial by Padraic Ryan is used under a CC-BY-SA-3.0 license.
12.13 Summary

Figure 12.36 Alternately thrilling and terrifying, hilarious and

horrifying, the post-Confederation era bears comparison to a
fairground ride where it is easier to assume that someone,
somewhere exercises some kind of reasonable control than to
actually enquire.

Closing with the end of history is a useful way to consider the short 20th century, from 1914-1991, as a chap-
ter in human history that now recedes from view. The Cold War, suburbanization, domestic women and bread-
winner men, peacekeepers and peaceniks, and industrial capitalism were themes that will, in all likelihood, never
again be the obsessions that they once were.

It is absolutely true that there are continuities of which we need to be aware. Colonialism in Canada remains
largely intact, as demonstrated every day by the rotten conditions on reserves, the grotesque over-representation
of Aboriginal men and women in the penal system, and the appallingly low life expectancy of Indigenous peoples.
When we look at differential lifetime wages for men and women, we will find the fingerprints of sexual discrimi-
nation everywhere. Canada remains mainly a hewer of wood and a drawer of water to the world; our economy is
based on an export model that continues to favour raw, unprocessed staples like oil, natural gas, and mineral ores.
At the same time, Central Canadas manufacturing sector and the unions that have organized its workforces
still has tremendous political and economic influence. Suburbs continue to be built, sprawl continues to eat
up agricultural land, and notwithstanding improvements in public transit and bicycle lanes automobilism
continues to define our cities. Most child-rearing is unpaid work done by women (aka: mothers). The political
elites survive: Paul Martin Jr. and Justin Trudeau are no doubt the best known examples of sons following in their
fathers footsteps, but prominent Liberal Sheila Copps followed her father into politics as well, as did Manitoba
Senator Sharon Carstairs, the daughter of a former Nova Scotian premier and senator.

Against all this, I would argue, urban densities and planning models today would be unrecognizable (and largely
unappealing) to people in the 1970s. Oil and copper may be volatile exports, but so far they havent led us into
a crisis like the one the wheat economy provided in 1929-39. Aboriginal people are suffering, without a shadow
of doubt, from the legacy of colonialism but now their stories are front and centre and increasingly regarded as a

783
784 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

truth that must somehow be reconciled. We are, it is increasingly understood, all treaty people and that realization
alone would have been beyond the ability of Cold War Canadians.

Surely the most important and the most obvious continuity is that of Canada itself. Despite attempts to dismantle
or even fundamentally rethink the Confederation bargain of 1867, the nation-state continues to tick along. The
2015 election results suggest a country more in agreement than it has been since 1984; the Atlantic provinces and
the North gave every seat they had to offer to the Liberals, and only Alberta and Saskatchewan offered succour
to the previous Harper Government, as it chose to brand itself. If a study of Canadas political history teaches us
anything, however, it is that governments are more often voted out than in; the Liberal victory in 2015 will one
day receive proper historical assessment, but at this time it seems safe to say that it was the result of a strong anti-
Harper (if not anti-Conservative) reaction more than a stampede to the Liberal platform. Building a consensus
over what we all dislike is a rather different proposition from a shared vision of what the country is, needs, and
might become.

Still, it has to be said that a cabinet that is evenly divided between men and women marks a significant change.
How significant? Pauline Jewett (1922-1992) was a Liberal MP first elected in Pearsons 1963 win. She subse-
quently left the Trudeau administration in 1970 over the War Measures Act and joined the NDP but, before then,
she was an aspirant backbencher who believed she ought to be in the Cabinet. She enjoyed telling the story of
the day she approached Prime Minister Pearson and made her pitch. As Jewett was nobodys fool and a Harvard
Ph.D. to boot, one can imagine that she made a compelling case for a ministerial post. Pearson listened patiently
and then replied, But Pauline, we already have a woman in the Cabinet. In that context, Justin Trudeaus deci-
sion to populate his 2015 Cabinet with women and to seek out diversity that more closely reflects the complexion
of the Canadian population was not merely laudable it was (a) badly overdue by any measure, and (b) proof
that Cold War modernity had, to use a modernist phrase, left the building.

In many respects, this open textbook reflects some of the changes in both the history and the historiography of
postmodern Canada. Being available online and being a document that can be changed, it is a sharp contrast with
the modern era textbook, which was a very finite object. The historians who contributed to this project, you will
have noticed, work principally in areas outside of the traditional political historical focus. Most of them, too, are
drawn from a generation that is much younger than the New Social History cohort of the 1960s and 70s. Their
sources have changed, as have the questions they ask.

Has this enabled the book you are now reading to achieve comprehensiveness? Hardly. There is not enough here
on womens and feminist history, environmental histories are barely hinted at, and there are themes in Aboriginal
history that deserve much more space. There are, as well, debates among historians that space and time do not
allow us to explore here. Postmodern history finds a place for the stories of common people, marginalized people,
and people for whom the nation state was at best a neutral thing, at worst an oppressive entity. Getting at those
histories requires innovation in historical research; transmitting those histories requires a willingness to think out-
side of the paradigm of the textbook and journal article. History is built into the fabric of our communities, our
environment, and our identities; finding these stories will be the task of the generation to come.

Welcome to the end of this textbook and congratulations. Perhaps it has stimulated in you an interest to pursue
some questions further or to explore other histories. Perhaps youve absolutely reached your limit. Either way,
you need to know that historians have a saying:

You may be through with history, but history is not through with you.
 12.13 SUMMARY 785

Key Terms

9/11: Has come to signify the terrorist attacks on multiple targets in the United States on 9 September
2001, and the beginning of the War on Terror.
Afghanistan War: Following 9/11, an alliance of forces including Canada which initiated a military
campaign against the Taliban in Afghanistan in 2001. Troop withdrawals from active duty were com-
plete in 2014.
al-Qaeda: A jihadist group pieced together in the 1980s by Americans to fight against the Soviet Union.
Big Data: Refers to collections of enormous data sets that typically include large quantities of demo-
graphic information useful in social analysis.
bipolar: The essence of the Cold War in that there were two superpowers in existence. Juxtaposed with
the unipolar world at the end of the Cold War.
Calgary Declaration: Also called the Calgary Accord; in 1997, an agreement signed between all
provinces but Quebec; established principles for future constitutional change while enshrining principles
regarding equality of rights, inclusion, and multiculturalism.
Charlottetown Accord: 1992; a package of proposed constitutional changes; defeated in a national ref-
erendum.
contemporary history: The study of very recent history.
deconstructing: An examination of the relationship between text and meaning.
ethnic cleansing: A variant on genocide in that it combines extermination with expulsion of an identi-
fiable ethnic group; strongly associated with the war in the former Yugoslavia.
failed state: A country that has no national administration; usually associated with civil wars.
fruit machine: A device intended to measure levels of arousal in a test subject; applied by Canadian
security services in their efforts to identify sexual deviants and homosexuals.
History Wars: Conflict between generations of historians that spiked in the 1990s; pitted national/
nationalist historians against historians of society and culture.
identity politics: An orientation in politics that begins with a sense of oppression or loss among a con-
stituency (an identity) and moves toward an agenda of initiatives that will address those inequities; dis-
tinct from ideological politics, which begin from a position of principles and ongoing goals that are
society-wide.
nationalist historians: Or national historians; scholars who believe that the principal role of history
is to analyze and explain the history of the nation state.
New World Order: In the context of the post-Cold War era, a United States-dominated international
stage in which diminished expenditures on nuclear arsenals would be turned into resources to build up
economies globally; in the context of wars in the Gulf and Middle East, an effort to impose the (West-
ern) rule of law on recalcitrant states.
partition: The potential for, or the act of, formally dividing an established jurisdiction. In the case of
Canada, Quebecs separation from Canada would not constitute partition because it existed before Con-
federation, but the removal of anglophone-dominated areas and Inuit and Cree territories would consti-
tute a partition of Quebec.
peace dividend: At the end of the Cold War it was widely predicted that the cost of maintaining readi-
786 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

ness in the face of the threat posed by the Warsaw Pact and other communist countries would come to
an end and resources would be spent in other ways.
political correctness: A provocative (and often ironic) term to describe attempts to modify language in
such ways as to minimize unnecessary offence, typically of minorities, women, and vulnerable popu-
lations. The inclusive ethos of sensitive language which was essentially self-reflection on the ways
in which language binds social roles and relationships has been challenged by privileged groups in
particular who regard restrictions on the ability to defame others as a loss of freedom.
post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD): Mental health consequences of trauma, typically within the
context of warfare; associated with research in the fields of psychology, psychiatry, and psychotherapy.
queer history: The study of the historic experience of LGBT individuals and communities; also the
analysis of popular and governmental attitudes toward LGBT communities.
regional disparities: Term used increasingly in the 1970s to describe the existence of have and have-
not provinces whose inequalities were a product of long-term economic circumstances.
rights culture: Beginning in the 1960s; a belief in the existence of un- or under-recognized rights as
well as the importance and value of extending and enshrining rights to under-protected groups.
Senate reform: The upper house has been the subject of chronic criticism for decades. These critiques
intensified in the 1960s and especially in the 1980s. See also Triple-E Senate.
Somalia Affair: Political and military scandal arising from Canadian Airborne Regiments violent, arbi-
trary, and murderous behaviour which led to several civilian deaths (including the beating death of Shi-
dane Arone).
START: Three Strategic Arms Reduction Treaties, the first of which was signed in 1991; committed
the signatories the USSR and the United States to making substantial reductions in their nuclear
arsenals and delivery systems.
Taliban: The fundamentalist Islamic regime in Afghanistan; deposed in 2001 following the NATO inva-
sion in response to 9/11.
Triple-E Senate: Call for reform of the upper house that would see it become elected, equal, and effi-
cient; a plank in the Reform Party platform since the 1980s.
unipolar: Following on the collapse of multipolar global relations in the 1940s, and the subsequent age
of bipolar superpowers, the unipolar era was defined by one superpower (the United States) dominating
global affairs.
War on Terror: Initially a military campaign launched against non-state organizations responsible for
targeted attacks on American bases or civilians; after 9/11, included military attacks on regimes support-
ive of organizations regarded as terrorist; conducted by a broad alliance of nations predominantly in
the West.

Short Answer Exercises

1. In what ways does the end of the Cold War signal a turning point in world and Canadian affairs?
2. How did the business of peacekeeping change in the post-1991 period?
3. What was the objective of further constitutional negotiations in the 1990s? Why did the Charlotte-
 12.13 SUMMARY 787

town Accord follow Meech Lake into the waste basket of history?
4. Why did the 1995 Quebec referendum fail so narrowly?
5. What breakthroughs occurred for women in Canadian politics in the post-Cold War era?
6. How and why did the Progressive Conservative Party change after Brian Mulroney?
7. What has been the cause and the effect of the rise of identity politics and rights cultures?
8. In what ways has the idea of being a Canadian changed since 1867?
9. What are some of the distinctions between history and heritage?
10. In what ways did the rights of LGBT Canadians change in the last quarter of the 20th century,
and what does it reveal about Canadian society generally?
11. In what ways has the job of the historian changed in recent years?

Suggested Readings
Dick, Lyle. The Queer Frontier: Male Same-sex Experience in Western Canadas Settlement Era, Journal of
Canadian Studies/Review dtudes Canadiennes, 48, no. 1 (Winter 2014): 15-52.

Farrugia, Peter. Convenient Truths: History, Memory, and Identity in Brantford, Ontario, Journal of Canadian
Studies/Review dtudes Canadiennes, 46, no. 2 (Spring 2012): 122-46.

Hayday, Matthew. Fireworks, Folk-dancing, and Fostering a National Identity: The Politics of Canada Day,
Canadian Historical Review, 91, no. 2 (June 2010): 287-314.

Korinek, Valerie J. Were the Girls of the Pansy Parade: Historicizing Winnipegs Queer Subcultures,
1930s1970, Histoire Sociale/Social History, 45, no. 89 (Mai/May 2012): 117-55.

Kee, Kevin, Shawn Graham, Patrick Dunae, John Lutz, Andrew Large, Michel Blondeau, and Mike Clare.
Towards a Theory of Good History Through Gaming, Canadian Historical Review, 90, no. 2 (June 2009):
303-26.

McKay, Ian. The Folk under Conditions of Postmodernity, in The Quest of the Folk: Antimodernism and Cul-
tural Selection in Twentieth-century Nova Scotia (Montral and Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press,
1994): 274-311.

Milligan, Ian. A Haven for Perverts, Criminals, and Goons: Children and the Battle for and Against Canadian
Internet Regulation, 1991-1999, Histoire Sociale/Social History, 48, no. 96 (Mai/May 2015): 245-74.

Attributions
Figure 12.36
[Two girls on midway ride] CVA 260-930 by James Crookall / City of Vancouver Archives is in the public
domain.
Appendix: Glossary

This glossary is a summary of all key terms that appear at the end of each chapter.

Glossary

9/11 (ch 12): Has come to signify the terrorist attacks on multiple targets in the United States on 9 Sep-
tember 2001, and the beginning of the War on Terror.
abolitionists (ch 3): Individuals and groups associated with the movement to end slavery in the United
States. In Canada, abolitionists assisted African-Americans fleeing the United States, whether they were
slaves or otherwise. The abolitionist movement built the foundation for subsequent social movements in
Canada.
Aboriginal rights (ch 11): Defined in two ways: 1) as an abstract set of inherent and collective rights
available on principle only to Aboriginal peoples, which may include land, resource and treaty rights; 2)
also or alternately, cultural rights associated with traditional or customary practices which are thought to
predate European contact. The latter are protected in the Constitution Act, 1982.
Aboriginal tourism (ch 11): Usually associated with cultural displays and/or performances, sometimes
with Aboriginal lifestyle experiences. The sector was very small in the 1990s, but since has become an
annual multi-million dollar industry.
abstract (ch 10): An artistic technique that makes use of images that are not clearly representative of
conventional visual references.
academic freedom (ch 9): The privilege and responsibility on the part of scholars to conduct enquiry
and communicate findings free of sanction by external authorities.
Act of Union (ch 1): The third Canadian constitution since the Conquest in 1763. The Act of Union con-
tained measures for the management of French-Canadians, built on the premise (from Lord Durhams
1839 Report on the Affairs of British North America) that assimilation of French-Canadians was essen-
tial to the future of the larger colony.
Afghanistan War (ch 12): Following 9/11, an alliance of forces including Canada which initiated a mil-
itary campaign against the Taliban in Afghanistan in 2001. Troop withdrawals from active duty were
complete in 2014.
Agent Orange (ch 9): A herbicidal defoliant, used by the United States Army to destroy jungle cover
in the Vietnam War.

788
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 789

Aird Commission (ch 10): The Royal Commission on Radio Broadcasting, 1922 to 1932; recom-
mended the creation of what became the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC).
Alaska Highway (ch 9): A highway built during WWII to facilitate the movement of troops and
materiel from the United States to its northern territory (not yet a state), Alaska. It was constructed
between Dawson Creek, BC, and Delta Junction, Alaska, and completed in 1942. It served to open the
Yukon to greater traffic and activity.
allophone (ch 5): A person whose first language is neither French nor English.
al-Qaeda (ch 12): A jihadist group pieced together in the 1980s by Americans to fight against the Soviet
Union.
amateur (ch 10): In the context of the history of modern sport, refers to athletes who do not accept pay
to play; also implies a middle- and upper-middle class ethos of fairplay and a hostility toward profes-
sionalism.
American Federation of Labor (AFL) (ch 3): Established in 1886 as an umbrella organization of craft
unions in the United States.
American Indian Movement (AIM) (ch 9): Founded in 1968, an advocacy group established to
counter the United States governments Indian Termination policies of the 1950s and 1960s. Inspired by
the civil rights movement it was influential among Canadian First Nations activists.
anarchist (ch 5): An individual who advocates the dismantling of the state and the creation of a struc-
ture based on voluntary association and participation.
anticlerical, anticlericalism (ch 4): Someone who believes that the separation of church and state in
civic life is essential for the well-being of a successful democratic society.
antimodernism (ch 5): A retreat from modernization and modernity, often associated with rural and
traditional values, spirituality, and social hierarchies.
anti-party (ch 7): The position that political parties constitute an unwelcome constraint on democratic
politics.
apartheid (ch 9): A political and social system predicated on racial discrimination and/or segregation;
associated with the Republic of South Africa from 1948 to 1994.
appeasement (ch 6): Refers to Britains policy of avoiding war with Germany by making concessions.
art deco (ch 6): A visual and decorative style associated with the first three decades of the 20th century
and, in its emphasis on symmetry and its association with technological advancement, is often regarded
as the foremost modernist style.
Arts and Crafts (ch 10): The Arts and Crafts Movement was an anti-industrial and antimodernist dec-
orative tradition that looked to older hand-built styles of craftsmanship in visual arts, furniture, and
domestic architecture.
assembly line (ch 10): Refers to manufacturing processes that are systematically organized; most often
associated in the public mind with the building of automobiles.
Assembly of First Nations (AFN) (ch 11): The successor to the National Indian Brotherhood (NIB),
the AFN, a national advocacy organization that represents Aboriginal peoples, was established in 1982.
asymmetrical federalism (ch 9): A federation in which one or more constituent parts enjoys more
autonomy and/or authority than one or more of the other constituent parts. In the case of the Meech Lake
Accord, it was suggested that recognition of Quebec as a distinct society would create an asymmetry in
confederation.
790 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

automation (ch 3): A manufacturing process in which assembly or some other part of the production
system is performed by machines that are subject to control systems.
Auto Pact (ch 8): The Canada-US Automotive Products Agreement was signed in 1965. It removed
tariffs on vehicles and automotive parts traded between Canada and the United States, creating a much
more dynamic Canadian automobile sector and improving the trade deficit in the sector.
Avro Arrow (ch 9): An interceptor jet aircraft designed and built by [Link] (Avro) Canada in the
1950s, capable of Mach 1.98. Production of the Arrow was stopped in what remains, in the mind of
many Canadians, a controversial political decision.
back-to-the-land (ch 5): Refers to any of several anti-urban agrarian movements in which city dwellers
are encouraged to return to simpler, pre-modern ways of living.
balance of power (ch 6): In international relations, refers to a complex of evenly weighted alliances
that theoretically prohibit any one participant or side from going to war.
balance of power (ch 7): IIn parliamentary politics, describes a minority government that is dependent
on another party to provide enough votes to prohibit defeat through a vote of non-confidence.
Balfour Declaration (ch 6): In 1926, a statement released at the Imperial Conference and named
for the conference chair, Lord Balfour. Formally recognizes the Dominions of the British Empire as
autonomous nations capable of independent action internationally and in the workings of the new British
Commonwealth of Nations.
band offices (ch 11): The administrative centre of a First Nation band; a unit of government within the
First Nation; applies principally to populations covered by the Indian Act (that is, Status Indians). The
band council is the decision making assembly in the band office.
Bank of Canada (ch 8): Canadas central bank, introduced by R. B. Bennett, January 1935, as part of a
federal government economic intervention.
Barr Colony (ch 5): Located west of Saskatoon covering a massive area that extended to and across
what would become the Saskatchewan-Alberta border, the colony was populated by some 2,000 immi-
grants recruited directly from Britain.
Battle of Ballantyne Pier (ch 8): 18 June 1935; a violent confrontation between striking Vancouver
dockyard workers and a force made up of city police, provincial police, and RCMP.
Battle of Britain (ch 6): A series of aerial attacks launched by Germany against Britain beginning in
July 1940 and countered by an aerial defence. Along with the strategic night bombing campaign that
followed (the Blitz), it can be said to have lasted for nearly one year.
Battle of the Atlantic (ch 6): A nearly continuous series of naval confrontations that began in 1939 and
ended only with the fall of Germany in 1945.
Bay Street (ch 9): In Toronto, the location of Canadas leading financial offices, banks, and corpora-
tions, as well as the Toronto Stock Exchange.
Beaver Hall Group (ch 10): A group of nearly two dozen painters based in Montreal whose modernist
and urban style was at odds with the Group of Sevens wilderness and nationalist abstractions.
bedroom communities (ch 9): Suburbs to which commuters return at the end of the day to do little
other than sleep before commuting out to jobs elsewhere; applies especially to those suburbs that are
largely free of industry and other sources of employment.
Beothuk (ch 2): Aboriginal people of Newfoundland; believed to have disappeared due to exotic
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 791

diseases, loss of territory, and armed conflict with European colonists by the second quarter of the
19th century.
big band (ch 9): A musical group involving as many as two dozen players; associated with jazz and
swing music from the interwar and early post-WWII years.
Big Data (ch 12): Refers to collections of enormous data sets that typically include large quantities of
demographic information useful in social analysis.
big science (ch 10): Associated with the large scale experiments and processes that became possible
after the Second World War.
Bill 101 (ch 9): The Charter of the French Language, passed into law in 1977 which advanced the pro-
visions of the Official Language Act (Bill 22) of 1974, and which made French Quebecs official lan-
guage. Bill 101 established the primacy of French in day to day life.
Bill 178 (ch 9): One of several amendments to the Charter of the French Language (see Bill 101); intro-
duced and proclaimed in December 1988 in response to a Supreme Court ruling that would end the
unilingual French signage provisions of the Charter. It is significant for its reference to the notwith-
standing clause of the federal Charter of Rights.
bipolar (ch 12): The essence of the Cold War in that there were two superpowers in existence. Juxta-
posed with the unipolar world at the end of the Cold War.
birth control (ch 9): Any method or practice aimed at reducing fertility or preventing the complete ges-
tation of an infant; may include abstinence, the use of chemicals/drugs, termination, and prophylactics.
blacklist (ch 3): Sanctions taken by employers against workers whom they associate with labour orga-
nization, strikes, certain ideological movements, or other actions contrary to the employers interests.
Technically, a list of individuals who were denied work on the basis of their involvement in pro-labour
activities.
Blacklist (ch 9): A list of people suspected of having Communist sympathies who were denied work as
a result.
Black Tuesday (ch 8): 24 October 1929 (a Tuesday) was the day the New York Stock Exchange
crashed, beginning the decade-long Great Depression.
block settlements (ch 5): An initiative in settling the West with groups drawn from the same ethnicity
or creed allocated contiguous lands so as to take advantage of cultures of mutual support.
Bloody Saturday (ch 3): 21 June 1919; during a mass demonstration of solidarity (after ten OBU lead-
ers were arrested, including J. S. Woodsworth) in which a buildup of state resources (troops, Mounties
and Specials) were brought in. 30 protesters were injured and two killed.
Bloody Sunday (ch 8): Sunday at daybreak, 19 June 1938, while the Vancouver Police peacefully evac-
uated the Art Gallery (occupied by unemployed protesters); the RCMP stormed the Post Office with tear
gas and truncheons. A window-smashing campaign followed and, hours later, a demonstration of sup-
port took place at an East End park where 10-15,000 locals gathered. Many were hospitalized that day.
Bolshevik (ch 3): A workers party that led the Russian Revolution in October 1917 under the leader-
ship of Vladimir Lenin.
boondoggles (ch 8): Meaningless routine work, associated with work relief for the unemployed,
intended to keep them busy but not necessarily productive.
boosters (ch 3): Civic promoters.
792 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

bootlegging (ch 5): Unlicensed, typically illegal production of alcohol. Also, in some instances, the sale
of the same or of other illicit goods.
branch plants (ch 4): Typically American-owned companies that avoided tariff barriers by establishing
plants on the Canadian side of the border.
Bretton Woods (ch 8): Established in July 1944, a system of institutions, principles, and processes by
which the international monetary system could be managed. The Bretton Woods system lasted until
1971, when the United States ended the convertibility of the dollar to gold.
British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) (ch 10): Established in 1922, the BBC is a crown-owned
public service broadcaster. Its equivalent in Canada is the CBC.
British Commonwealth of Nations (ch 6): A voluntary association of Britain and its former colonies.
Established incrementally after 1919 and especially in the Balfour Declaration (1926).
British Invasion (ch 9): A surge of popularity enjoyed in North America by British musicians, artists,
writers, and film makers in the 1960s.
brownfield projects (ch 8): Civic projects that re-purpose (sometimes at enormous cost) or rehabilitate
industrial spaces for post-industrial use.
Burnt Church Crisis (ch 11): Between 1999 and 2002, a confrontation between the Burnt Church First
Nation (a Mikmaq community in New Brunswick) and non-Aboriginal fishers and the Federal Depart-
ment of Fisheries.
business unions (ch 3): Trade or craft unions that approach activism from a non-revolutionary position;
associated with the unions of the AFL, the TLC, and later the CLC.
Calder Case (ch 11): Supreme Court case (Calder v British Columbia) in 1973 that decided that Abo-
riginal title existed prior to colonization and persisted after 1871.
Calgary Declaration (ch 12): Also called the Calgary Accord; in 1997, an agreement signed between
all provinces but Quebec; established principles for future constitutional change while enshrining prin-
ciples regarding equality of rights, inclusion, and multiculturalism.
Canada Act (1982) (ch 9): Federal legislation that enabled the patriation of the Canadian constitution
and the possibility of its amendment in Canada, rather than in Britain.
Canada First (ch 4): Established in 1868, an English-Canadian nationalist movement.
Canada Pension Plan (CPP) (ch 9): Introduced by the federal government in 1965; the first publicly
funded pension plan in Canada; transfers earnings from working people to retired citizens.
Canada Student Loans (ch 9): Replaced the Dominion-Provincial Student Loan Program (1939-1964);
guaranteed the banks risk in extending loans to post-secondary students under the auspices of the pro-
gram.
Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC) (ch 10): In full, the CBC/Radio Canada. Public broad-
casting system established in 1932 following the recommendations of the Aird Commission. Its status
as a Crown Corporation was clarified under the Canadian Broadcasting Act (1936). Modelled in large
measure on the BBC.
Canadian Caper (ch 9): The rescue of six American diplomats during the Iranian Revolution of 1979
to 1980.
Canadian content (CanCon) rules (ch 9): Under the authority of the Canadian Radio-Television and
Telecommunications Commission (CRTC), CanCon regulations were established to ensure a quota of
Canadian creative product in various media, particularly television and radio.
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 793

Canadian Expeditionary Force (CEF) (ch 6): The name given to the troops sent overseas during the
Great War (World War I).
Canadian Football League (ch 10): Established in 1958 when Canadian-style rugby teams left the
Canadian Rugby Union to establish a nine-team professional league.
Canadian Labour Congress (CLC) (ch 3): Founded in 1956 in a merger of the Trades and Labour
Congress (TLC) and the Canadian Congress of Labour (CCL). Subsequently joined with the Coopera-
tive Commonwealth Federation (CCF) to create the New Democratic Party (NDP).
Canadian National Railway (ch 6): Created in 1919 out of several financially troubled railway compa-
nies that had been inherited by Ottawa, including the Canadian Northern Railway and the Grand Trunk
Railway; constituted a trans-continental operation in competition with the CPR.
Canadian Radio-Television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) (ch 9): An independent
government agency established in 1968 to regulate and supervise all elements of the broadcasting sys-
tems.
Canadian Wheat Board (ch 8): Canadas Marketing Board for wheat and barley was introduced by R.
B. Bennett in July 1935 as part of a federal government economic intervention.
Canadian Womens Army Corps (CWACs) (ch 6): Established in 1941 as a separate non-combatant
unit of the Canadian Army; provided support mainly as office staff, drivers/mechanics, and canteen
workers; some served overseas.
capitalism, capitalists (ch 3): An economic system (and its practitioners) that is based on the ability of
private individuals to accumulate and invest money (capital) in profit-making enterprises. Also, a sys-
tem that is dominated by the private ownership of the means of production.
Capital markets (ch 8): A combination of institutions that enable the buying and selling of money
through instruments like loans and securities.
Cariboo Wagon Road (ch 2): A pair of routes to the gold-bearing regions on the Interior Plateau of
British Columbia, initiated in 1860. One begins in Fort Douglas, the other at Yale.
Carruthers Commission (ch 9): Established in 1963 and reported out in 1966; recommended a devo-
lution of authority from Ottawa to the North West Territories; headquartered at Yellowknife.
CGEPs (ch 9): Publicly funded pre-university colleges in Quebec.
cellular (ch 8): A telecommunications system involving a wireless connection. Cellular telephones first
became available to the public in the mid-1980s.
Centennial (ch 9): A 100th anniversary; in Canada, is used as shorthand to refer to the 1967 celebration
of 100 years of Confederation.
Central Business District (ch 9): The concentration of commercial, business, and finance enterprises
generally in the centre or downtown of most cities. Some cities, like Toronto, have several such hubs.
Central Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) (ch 9): Created under the National Housing
Act, 1944; enabled low income families (including demobilized servicemen and women) to obtain low
cost mortgages; created social housing; funded construction of new rental housing; and continues to
function in 2016.
centrifugal federalism (ch 8): Federalism as a dynamic process of decentralization and recentraliza-
tion, or centrifugal versus centripetal forces.
Charlottetown Accord (ch 12): 1992; a package of proposed constitutional changes; defeated in a
national referendum.
794 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Charter of Rights and Freedoms (ch 9): Also known simply as the Charter; incorporated by the British
government in the Canada Act, 1982; comprises the first part of the Constitution Act, 1982.
chilled steel plough (ch 3): A significant late 19th century advance in plough manufacturing. Stronger
steel enabled the cutting of faster and deeper furrows and the breaking of densely packed prairie soil.
Chinatowns (ch 5): Colloquial term for enclaves of Chinese immigrants. In Canada and primarily in
British Columbia, these appeared from 1858 on, with the greatest increase occurring during the con-
struction of the Canadian Pacific Railway. Created by external forces (Euro-Canadian civic authority
limiting Chinese property ownership and business licenses to a small area) and internal needs (the con-
centration of Chinese financial and social institutions).
Chinese Benevolent Association (ch 5): An organization that coordinated the interests and politics of
the various community organizations in Chinatowns, and provided different levels of social support for
its members.
Citizens Committee of One Thousand (ch 3): During the Winnipeg General Strike, 1919, an organi-
zation established by the citys business and political elites to break the strike and challenge the authority
of the Strike Committee.
Civil Rights Movement (ch 9): In the United States, beginning in the mid-1950s, this was a movement
to secure the rights promised in court decisions. Widespread protest, frequent violence, and growing
support throughout the USA much of which was televised influenced Canadians who sought to
address inequities in their own society.
Clear Grit (ch 1): Reformers in Canada West (Ontario) before Confederation. Anti-Catholic and largely
anti-French, the Grits opposed John A. Macdonalds Tories and advocated the annexation of Ruperts
Land. In the post-Confederation period they became one section of the Liberal Party.
Cold War (ch 9): The prolonged period of tension between the United States and the Soviet Union,
based on ideological conflicts and competition for military, economic, social, and technological supe-
riority, and marked by surveillance and espionage, political assassinations, an arms race, attempts to
secure alliances with developing nations, and proxy wars.
collective bargaining (ch 3): Negotiation of working conditions, pay, and other issues or benefits by an
association a union of employees. Replaced the many individual arrangements made in one-on-
one agreements.
colour barriers (ch 10): Racial segregation; specifically, the exclusion of people of colour from activi-
ties or services enjoyed by Euro-Canadians.
command-led economy (ch 8): An economic order in which government is the principal buyer of goods
produced, for itself or for distribution. See demand-led economy.
commercialization (ch 8): In late 20th century post-secondary education, the search for opportunities
to develop revenue streams by taking new ideas to market.
commodification (ch 10): In the context of the professionalization of sports and leisure, the process of
turning what originally was an informal and voluntary set of practices into a commodity to be bought
and sold.
company store (ch 3): An outlet owned by an employer, one that sells goods to employees of the same
firm. Commonplace in company towns. See also company towns.
company towns (ch 3): A community with one major employer and few other employers; one in which
most or all services in some instances including housing and the supply of food are controlled by
the employer. Associated with remote resource extraction communities.
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 795

Comintern (ch 7): Also the Communist International, the Third International; 1919-1943; called for
world revolution and the establishment of communist regimes.
concentration camps (ch 6): A prison camp established to contain and punish captured populations.
The British ran concentration camps for Boer prisoners in the Second Boer War; Canada placed sus-
pected enemy aliens Ukrainians and Germans in the Great War, Germans, Italians, and Japanese in
the Second in camps that were not punitive but nor were they appropriately provisioned; and the Ger-
mans infamously used concentration camps as the means of executing large numbers of Jewish prisoners
(along with other enemies of the Reich). Concentration camps continue to be used.
Confederation League (ch 2): Founded by Amor de Cosmos and John Robson in 1868, promoting
the idea of union with Canada through newspapers and direct lobbying of administrations in Victoria,
Ottawa, and London. Their goals included responsible government in the colony, reciprocity with the
United States, and austerity measures to address colonial debt.
confessional schools (ch 4): Religious schools run by Catholic or Protestant denominations.
consumer durables (ch 8): Products that last a long time and which consumers do not have to buy
often; for example, cars, furniture, and appliances.
containment (ch 9): The American policy that sought to limit the expansion of Communism abroad.
Contemporary Arts Society (ch 10): Formed in 1939 in Montreal, lasted until the late 1940s; influen-
tial in its production and advocacy for modern art.
contemporary history (ch 12): The study of very recent history.
context group (ch 5): In a society comprised of some diversity, refers to the most influential group
whose culture other groups seek to adopt or are obliged to assimilate into. See also, reference group.
continuous voyage requirement (ch 5): Regulation passed by the federal government in 1908 to
restrict immigration from India and Japan; required immigrants to reach Canada by means of a single,
continuous, unbroken voyage. Would affect long journeys that necessitated a stop in either Japan or
Hawaii. Tightened in 1914, leading to the challenge posed by the Komagata Maru.
cooperative movement (ch 7): Also spelled co-operative. Established in growing numbers in Britain in
the mid-19th century and is associated with the Rochdale Pioneers; several typologies; goals include
making available goods and/or supplies to members at low costs by taking advantage of economies of
scale as a group, also obtaining optimal prices for community products by pooling output for sale. Sur-
pluses and profits are redistributed to members of the cooperative; some have an educational mandate
as well. Examples include grocery stores, housing co-ops, and the dairy industry. See also wheat pools.
Corn Laws (1794-1846) (ch 8): A result of population growth and an economic downturn at the end
of the Napoleonic Wars; tariffs and restrictions were imposed on imported grain (to Britain), which
increased prices in an attempt to give domestic producers an edge.
corporate welfarism (ch 3): Equates subsidies to corporations with social welfare paid to individuals.
In 1972, NDP leader David Lewis coined the phrase corporate welfare bums as a way of identifying
what he perceived as the hypocrisy of attacks on the poor by anti-welfare business leaders.
counter culture (ch 5): A challenge to mainstream culture posed by a groups rejection of dominant
values. In the 1960s youth movements and specifically the hippy movement constituted a counter cul-
tural moment.
Court of Chancery (ch 7): In England, the Court dealt primarily with trusts; dissolved in 1875.
craft capitalism (ch 3): Refers to a transition to capitalism led by craftworkers.
796 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

creative economy (ch 8): In the late 20th century, the idea that the economy was shifting away from an
industry-dominated model to one in which ideas and creativity would matter more.
Criminal Code (ch 11): Properly, an Act respecting the criminal law; the Criminal Code is a regularly
amended body of legislation pertaining to criminal as opposed to civil or statute law.
crude birth rate (ch 9): The number of births occurring in a community or nation per 1,000 population.
cultural genocide (ch 11): Premeditated and systematic attempts to eliminate a culture while not nec-
essarily exterminating the population.
cultural mosaic (ch 5): In contrast to the concept of a melting pot, refers to a multi-ethnic and multi-
cultural society in which differences are permitted to continue, rather than face assimilation into a single
typology.
declericalization (ch 9): A movement to replace church authority with state authority in the running of
schools and other institutions.
deconstructing (ch 12): An examination of the relationship between text and meaning.
deindustrialization (ch 8): The process of moving away from an old-style industrial order, which typi-
cally involves the shuttering of declining industries.
Delgamuukw vs. British Columbia (ch 11): 1997 landmark decision in the Supreme Court of Canada;
established a test for the existence of Aboriginal title, extended title beyond evidence of past use to
include custodianship of territory, and thus includes a cultural relationship rather than simply an eco-
nomic relationship with the land.
demand-led economy (ch 8): An economic order in which the free market dominates and in which
industries and consumers are the principal buyers of goods, thereby determining what goods will be pro-
duced. See command-led economy.
demonstrations (or demos) (ch 9): Protest events; includes marches, sit-ins, and occupation of offices,
as well as other forms.
Department of Indian Affairs and Northern Development (ch 11): Created in 1966, a successor
administrative unit to the Department of Indian Affairs (DIA).
Department of Indian Affairs (DIA) (ch 11): Established in 1888 to administer the Federal Govern-
ments responsibilities as regards First Nations; was housed for many years under the office of the Min-
ister of the Interior (who was also responsible for settling the West with immigrants).
deskilling (ch 3): Mechanization and automation of work, as well as assembly lines permits the sys-
tematization of work and a commensurate reduction in the skills and training needed to perform key
functions. The work is said to be deskilled and, thus, the workforce too is deskilled.
dtente (ch 9): The relaxation of tensions and improvement of relations between the West and the East
in the Cold War during the 1970s.
devolution (ch 9): This when a senior level of government hands some of its authority to a lower level
or ostensibly lower level of administration. In Canada in the 1960s, authority over the North-West Ter-
ritories devolved to the new administration in Yellowknife, NWT.
Dieppe Raid (ch 6): 19 August 1942; also known as Operation Jubilee; an attack on the north coast of
France that was meant to gather intelligence for a larger subsequent invasion; of the 6,000 Allied troops
involved, 5,000 were Canadian. The mission was badly planned, atrociously researched, and tragic in its
execution. Nevertheless, it contributed intelligence that helped at Normandy three years later.
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 797

disallowance (ch 2): An effective veto held by Ottawa that could be used to overturn provincial legisla-
tion.
Displaced Persons (ch 5): Peoples (principally in Europe) dislocated by World War II; refugees.
Distant Early Warning Line (ch 9): The northernmost of three Cold War radar systems aligned from
west to east to identify incoming Soviet missiles in the event of an attack.
distinct society (ch 9): A term devised during the Quiet Revolution to describe Quebec vis--vis the rest
of Canada; a distinct society clause was created that would recognize and enshrine that difference. In
the Charlottetown Accord, this was spelled out as recognition of a French speaking majority, a unique
culture and a unique civil law tradition.
dole (ch 8): Colloquial term for relief or welfare payments.
dollar-a-year men (ch 6): Leading entrepreneurs, financiers, and manufacturers on loan from their
companies to the federal government for the duration of the Second World War for a nominal fee of one
dollar.
Dominion Lands Act (ch 2): 1872; the legal mechanism that made possible the distribution of western
lands.
domino theory (ch 9): The theory that if Communism made inroads in one nation, surrounding nations
would also succumb one by one, like a chain of dominos toppling one another.
dot-com bubble (ch 8): A late 20th, early 21st century investment frenzy based on advances in Internet-
based commerce that burst with the collapse of the market in 2000, crippling growth in the sector for
several years.
Douglas Treaties (ch 11): Negotiated by Governor James Douglas of Vancouver Island in the colonial
era and concluded with 14 First Nations in the colony in the early 1850s; apart from Treaty No.8 in the
Peace District, the only treaties in British Columbia before the late 20th century.
Doukhobors (ch 5): An immigrant group comprised of pacifists belonging to a Russian dissident reli-
gious movement. Settled first on the Prairies then mostly relocated to British Columbia. Persecuted in
the 20th century for their pacifism and their rejection of material culture.
dower laws (ch 3): Formal recognition of a widows lifetime interest in matrimonial property on the
death of her husband. See also homestead rights.
draft dodgers (ch 9): Principally refers to American men who avoided mandatory, selective service in
the Vietnam War by fleeing to Canada in the 1960s and 1970s.
dualism (ch 4): The idea that Canada could or should construct its culture and institutions around two
cultures, French and English. In contrast with unification (which favours one culture) and pluralism or
multiculturalism in which French in particular is at risk of becoming a minority culture.
Dunkirk (ch 6): Refers to the hurried evacuation of Canadian, British, and other troops from the port of
the same name following their retreat in the face of Germanys invasion of northern France in 1940.
Dust Bowl (ch 8): Describes the drought conditions that occurred across the prairies and plains of North
America in the 1930s and the concurrent poverty associated with the economic depression.
Eastern Bloc (ch 9): The alliance of pro-Soviet (or USSR-dominated) countries in Eastern Europe in
the post-WWII era, consisting of Poland, East Germany, Czecho-Slovakia, Hungary, Romania, Bulgaria,
and, more loosely, Albania. Yugoslavia, another communist-dominated country, regularly declared itself
separate from the Eastern Bloc; formalized in the mutual security agreement, the Warsaw Pact, 1955.
Eastern Group of Painters (ch 10): Established in Montreal in 1938.
798 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

equal rights (ch 3): In the context of feminism, the belief that rights accorded to men and women ought
to be the same. Diverges somewhat from maternal feminism which claims rights based on gendered dif-
ferences.
equalization (ch 8): Refers to programs and policies geared to redistribution of wealth between
provinces to ensure a comparable level of services and quality of life in all parts of Canada.
escapist (ch 10): Typically refers to entertainments that divert ones attention from banal features of
everyday life.
Escheat Movement (ch 2): An organized movement in 19th century Prince Edward Island with the
objective of ending absent landlordism and the distribution of lands to tenant farmers.
Esquimalt & Nanaimo Railway (ch 2): 1871; the E&N was built to connect the coalfields of the central
island with the British Columbia capital, Victoria.
essential industries (ch 3): Sectors identified in a crisis (such as wartime) as fundamental to the sur-
vival of the economy or society or war effort. Workers in those sectors are typically protected against
conscription and may also be restricted in their ability to move to other jobs. In some instances, the state
takes direct control of the industries for the duration of the crisis or longer.
established churches (ch 7): Organized religion recognized by the state. In Canada there are no offi-
cially recognized sects but the Anglican Church is the established church of England and the Queen
is its head. Similarly, the Catholic Church was historically the official church of French Canada and it
retains in the post-Confederation period a de facto official status.
establishment (ch 9): An elite, colloquially in the 1960s; the conventional social and economic order.
ethnic cleansing (ch 12): A variant on genocide in that it combines extermination with expulsion of an
identifiable ethnic group. Strongly associated with the war in the former Yugoslavia.
eugenics (ch 7): An early theory respecting genetic transmission of physical, social, intellectual, and
moral qualities which sought to advantage races that it considered superior stock against those that it
regarded as inferior.
evangelicalism (ch 7): In Christianity, a belief that salvation is achieved through faith in Jesus; individ-
ualistic in that redemption occurs at a personal, not a social level; evangelical denominations are often
associated with fundamentalism as well.
Executive (ch 1): Also called the Cabinet. The highest offices either elected or appointed in Cana-
dian politics: before the 1840s, a mostly appointed Executive Council led by the Governor General; after
1867, an elected body comprised of members of the current House of Commons and supported by a
majority of votes in the House of Commons.
Expo 67 (ch 9): A Worlds Fair held in Montreal in 1967; part of the Centennial celebrations.
exurban (ch 5): Refers to residential lands that lay beyond the suburban fringe.
Fabian (ch 7): A belief that reforms to capitalism can produce a social and economic order of fairness
for working people; sometimes called gradualism.
failed state (ch 12): A country that has no national administration; usually associated with civil wars.
Family Compact (ch 3): The elite network in pre-Confederation Canada that dominated colonial poli-
tics; in Quebec (aka: Canada East, Lower Canada) it was referred to as the Chateau Clique.
family reconstitution (ch 1): In demographic studies, the consolidation of population information from
censuses, church records, and civic documents to enable a complete history of a family, street, or com-
munity in terms of births, marriages, deaths, divorces, movement, and other demographic behaviours.
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 799

fan identification and representation (ch 10): In the context of, principally, professional sports, the
phenomenon of fan allegiance to a team or player; manifest in the wearing of sports merchandise or loy-
alty to a team or club, and consciously encouraged by local media.
Father of Confederation (ch 1): Term used to describe anyone involved in the Charlottetown or Que-
bec Conferences leading to Confederation; sometimes extended to the first premiers of the new Domin-
ion as well; term sometimes used to describe Newfoundland Premier Joey Smallwood from 1949.
federation (ch 1): An assemblage of states or provinces with roughly comparable rights in which all the
constituent parts relinquish some of their authority to a separate, central government.
Fdration National Saint-Jean-Baptiste (FNSB) (ch 3): Founded in 1907, francophone Catholic
women activists who also saw themselves as maternal feminists.
female suffrage (ch 3): One of the central issues of the first wave feminists, involving a protracted cam-
paign with feminist activists laying claim to full political citizenship.
feminism (ch 3): An ideological position that advances the ideal of equality of women and men.
Fenian (ch 1): Irish-Americans, bound together as an anti-British army; mounted and/or threatened
invasions of British North America in the 1860s and 70s.
fertility transition (ch 7): Demographic trend in which populations move from a level of high fertility
to a much lower level; associated with urbanization and modernization.
fifth column (ch 9): A population within a community that supports the efforts of an external force to
topple that community or nation; examples include Cold War fears of Canadian communists who were
loyal to Moscow rather than Ottawa.
first wave (ch 3): More fully: first wave feminists. Advocates for womens rights in the late 19th and
early 20th centuries; also sometimes called maternal feminists.
First Quebec Conference (ch 6): Held in August 1943; a top-secret high level meeting between leaders
and representatives of the Canadian, British, and American governments. Canadas actual involvement
did not extend far beyond hosting the event.
Flag Debate (ch 9): Arising out of PM Lester Pearsons decision to replace the Red Ensign in the early
1960s.
flapper (ch 6): Term used to describe fashionable young women in the interwar years; associated with
hedonism, social rebellion, and style.
first-past-the-post (ch 7): Electoral system in which the candidate receiving the greatest number
(though not necessarily a majority) of ballots wins; considered problematic by some when a party wins
a majority of seats while winning much less than a majority of votes.
forward linkages (ch 8): Other industries are developed or expanded to help to link a product or staple
export from the suppliers to the customers, as part of the distribution chain, for example, transportation,
grain elevators, and port facilities.
fossil fuels (ch 3): Includes coal, oil, natural gas, and petroleum; any fuel based on the compression of
carbon matter over geological time.
founder population (ch 1): A population deriving from a small initial influx of immigrants.
founding nations (ch 5): In Canada, typically refers to French and British Canadians.
Fourth World (ch 11): A category of mostly small and colonized indigenous populations around the
globe; juxtaposed with First (northwestern European and North American), Second (Soviet bloc of
800 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

developed nations), and Third (developing) Worlds; formalized with the establishment of the World
Council of Indigenous Peoples led by George Manuel in the mid-1970s.
free labour (ch 3): Workers who are not tied to a feudal relationship, slavery, or indentured servitude
and are able to move from one employer (or location) to another based on the size of pay and the char-
acter of the work.
free love (ch 9): Sexual relations outside of the institution of marriage; critical of the idea of marital
monogamy.
free speech (ch 9): A movement that begins in earnest in the early 20th century, calling for the elimina-
tion of laws barring public discussion of any number of topics; some subjects regarded as seditious
including calls for violent overthrow of the regime have been subject to intermittent bans.
Free Trade Agreement (FTA) (ch 8): Between Canada and the United States; signed in 1988, brought
into effect in 1989; the FTA created a single market for most goods and services.
fruit machine (ch 12): A device intended to measure levels of arousal in a test subject; applied by Cana-
dian security services in their efforts to identify sexual deviants and homosexuals.
Fulton-Favreau Formula (ch 9): A formula for amending the British North America Act (1867) devel-
oped in the 1960s; rejected by Quebec in 1965; provided the framework for subsequent discussions in
1982.
fundamentalists (ch 10): Any conservative theological movement that regards holy scripture as literal
truth.
Galicia (ch 5): Term formerly used to describe an area of what is now part of Ukraine and Poland, which
produced many immigrants to Western Canada. Also the name of a part of Spain, which did not.
garden city (ch 8): A movement among city planners beginning in the late 19th century imposed order
on new communities, including extensive greenspace and boulevards. A garden city is simultaneously
modernist and antimodernist.
general strike (ch 3): A labour stoppage involving most or all unions or workplaces. General strikes
have been held that call on all workers in a particular city or a particular sector or across an entire coun-
try.
generation gap (ch 7): Notable differences in values, tastes, interests, and practices between individuals
and whole cohorts from different generations. In the 1960s, used extensively to describe the conflict in
values between people born before WWII and the baby boom generation.
Geneva Convention (ch 9): 1864, 1906, 1929, 1949; a succession of international agreements on the
treatment of prisoners of war (POWs) and civilians.
genocide (ch 7): The premeditated extermination of an identifiable group of humans, often defined by
race or ethnicity. See also cultural genocide.
Gentlemens Agreement (ch 5): 1908; also known as the Lemieux-Hayashi Agreement; the Japanese
government agreed to restrict the number of people leaving Japan for Canada. A loophole allowing
wives to join their husbands led to significant use of the picture bride system thereafter.
germ theory (ch 7): The identification of microorganisms as the cause of some illnesses, particularly
infectious diseases.
ghost towns (ch 3): Abandoned communities; associated principally with resource extraction often
mining towns that have a very short lifespan and which close up once the resource is removed or the
market disappears.
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 801

Ginger Group (ch 7): An alliance of progressive MPs in Ottawa that led to the founding of the Coop-
erative Commonwealth Federation (CCF).
gold standard (ch 8): In monetary policy, the linking of a nations currency to the value of gold, which
is also called the gold exchange standard. Canada (and Britain) abandoned the gold standard at the start
of the First World War, resumed using the system in 1926, and then left it permanently in 1929.
Gouzenko Affair (ch 9): Post-WWII espionage case involving a clerk at the Soviet embassy in Ottawa
who disclosed the existence of a spy ring in Canada.
Governor-General (ch 6): The Crowns representative in Canada; appointed by the King or Queen.
gradualism (ch 3), gradualist (ch 7): The idea that great change can occur incrementally, in slow,
small, and subtle steps, rather than by large uprisings or revolutions. Among left-wing activists, a belief
that reforms to capitalism can produce a social and economic order of fairness for working people;
sometimes called Fabianism; derided by revolutionaries as delusional. In the context of Quebecs
independence movements the equivalent term is tapisme. See also reformist and impossibilist.
Grand Noirceur (ch 9): In Quebec, the period from 1944 to 1959 in which policies were introduced
under the Union Nationale government of Maurice Duplessis.
graving dock (ch 2): Also called a dry dock; repair facility for shipping.
Great Coalition (ch 1): In 1864, an alliance between the Bleu-Conservatives and the Clear Grits in the
Province of Canada. The Great Coalition launched a renewed effort to revise the Canadian constitution,
a campaign that culminated in Confederation.
Greenpeace (ch 7): An environmental movement founded in Vancouver in the early 1970s as part of an
international anti-nuclear arms movement; became more directly associated with environmental issues
like sealing and whaling.
Gross Domestic Product (GDP) (ch 8): The value of all goods produced in a country during a specified
period of time.
Group of Seven (ch 10): A group of artists (also known as the Algonquin Group) who emphasized
landscape painting as the key to expressing Canadianness.
Harbour Grace Affray (ch 2): 1883 Newfoundland dispute in which Orange Lodge Protestants and
Catholic neighbours came to blows; led to five deaths and a dozen casualties.
have-not (provinces) (ch 8): As opposed to have provinces, the prosperity of have-not provinces
is below the average for the country as a whole; equalization payments were designed to address these
inconsistencies.
Head Tax (ch 5): A fee levied by the British Columbian and then the federal government on Chinese
immigrants, beginning in 1885 and continuing to 1923.
Hegemony (ch 10): The dominance of a set of ideas or a particular group or social class.
high culture (high style) (ch 10): Also called high style; refers to cultural activities associated with
elites; largely consistent across continents; spatially large with little differentiation (in contrast with ver-
nacular styles which are spatially narrow and come in many forms); examples include classical music,
liturgies, opera, many visual arts, theatre.
high modernism, high modernity (ch 10): A phase of modernism beginning in the interwar era and
accelerating during WWII; characterized by a deepened confidence in science and engineering. See also
big science.
hippies (ch 9): A youth movement originating in the 1960s that was anti-war (specifically, opposed to
802 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

the war in Vietnam), critical of social conventions, and associated with experimentation with psyche-
delic drugs.
History Wars (ch 12): Conflict between generations of historians that spiked in the 1990s; pitted
national/nationalist historians against historians of society and culture.
hobo jungles (ch 8): Homeless mens camps, usually in marginal spaces in cities and towns, proliferated
during the 1930s Depression.
homestead (prologue): A grant of free land of typically 160 acres available to males over 21 years of
age, with the obligation that they improve no less than 40 acres and build a permanent dwelling on
the land within three years; made available under the Dominion Lands Act of 1872; modelled on similar
legislation in the United States.
homestead rights (ch 3): The Dominion Lands Act protected womens interest in homesteads by for-
bidding the sale of the homestead by a husband without the wifes written consent.
Home Children (ch 5): Over 100,000 children who were exported from Britain to Canada between
1869 and the late 1930s. Organized by charitable church organizations to alleviate overcrowding and to
provide improved and more healthy alternatives. Stories of abuse abound, although many of the children
who were distributed to farms across Canada did enjoy improved circumstances.
House of Industry (ch 3): A facility typically funded out of philanthropic/charitable donations that pro-
vides housing and food for impoverished citizens with the expectation that they will do work in return.
In the 19th century, associated with workhouses for the poor.
household wage (ch 3): A way of measuring income that extends beyond the breadwinner model and
incorporates incomes earned by every member of the household/family.
housewives (sing. housewife) (ch 9): A married woman whose principle (unpaid) occupation is the
maintaining of her household, including preparing food, cleaning clothes, providing pre-school educa-
tion, and cleaning house.
human rights (ch 5): Any right thought to belong to every person. Enshrined in the United Nations
Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1947.
Hutterites (ch 5): Along with the Mennonites and Amish, the Hutterites are an Anabaptist sectarian
group; emigrated from Europe in the late 19th and early 20th century, where they faced oppression for
their pacifist beliefs and the practice of adult baptism; many arrived in Canada after attempts to settle in
the United States. A communal farming community that resists modernization.
Hyde Park Agreement, Hyde Park Declaration (1941) (ch 6): A wartime pact between Canada and
the United States; allowed Canadian-made goods manufactured for export to Britain to be covered under
the Britain-USA Lend-Lease Agreement.
identity politics (ch 12): An orientation in politics that begins with a sense of oppression or loss among
a constituency (an identity) and moves toward an agenda of initiatives that will address those inequities;
distinct from ideological politics, which begin from a position of principles and ongoing goals that are
society-wide.
Idle No More (ch 11): A peaceful protest and awareness-raising movement launched in 2012 by a group
of Aboriginal and allies; catalyzed by Federal Government legislation that threatened Treaty rights.
illegitimate (ch 9): In legal and demographic terms, a child born to unmarried parents (or out of wed-
lock).
impossibilists (ch 7): Among left-wing activists, a belief that it is impossible to reform capitalism and
that it must be overthrown rather than overhauled. See also gradualist and reformist.
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 803

Indian Agent (ch 2): An agent of the federal governments Department of Indian Affairs (or, later,
DIAND) with responsibility for managing and/or supervising one or more Aboriginal communities.
industrial relations (ch 3): The diplomatic business of negotiating contracts and conditions between
employers and employees; typically between employers and labour organizations (unions).
information age (ch 8): A view of the post-industrial economy in which digitized information is the
basis of a new economic order.
Institut Canadien (ch 10): Established in 1844 under the leadership of young francophone liberal pro-
fessionals (physicians, lawyers, notaries, teachers) who sought to enrich and secularize Canadien life;
provided the intellectual firepower of les Rouges.
intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBMs) (ch 9): Cold War-era surface-to-air missiles with no less
than a 5,000 km range; typically nuclear-tipped.
internationalist (ch 7): In the history of organized labour, the belief that workers of all countries had
more in common than they did with co-nationals who belong to other social classes. Views nationalist
movements as antithetical to the interests of working people.
International Olympic Committee (IOC) (ch 10): Established 1894; responsible for the organization
and operation of the Olympic Games (both winter and summer versions).
International Monetary Fund (IMF) (ch 8): Created at Bretton Woods in 1944 to work with the World
Bank to reinvigorate post-war economies by achieving currency stability, stimulating international trade,
and rescuing national economies in distress.
interwar (ch 6): The period between 1918 and 1939.
Iron Curtain (ch 9): A term coined by British Prime Minister Winston Churchill to refer to portions
of Eastern Europe that the Soviet Union had incorporated into its sphere of influence and that no longer
were free to manage their own affairs.
isolationism (ch 6): The policy of isolating ones nation-state from international turmoil and alliances.
Jewish holocaust (ch 5): The campaign launched in the 1930s and early 1940s by the German National
Socialist government aimed at the eradication of the Jewish population in Europe. Estimates of the num-
ber killed run to 6 million or more.
Jim Crow Laws (ch 5): In the United States, post-Civil War racial segregation laws that discriminated
against African-Americans; most formal elements dissolved in the 1950s and 60s in the Civil Rights
Movement; was one cause of African-Americans emigrating to Canada in the Laurier and Borden eras.
jingoism (ch 6): Term coined in the 1870s; denotes patriotism applied in an aggressive foreign policy.
Canadas involvement in the Second Boer War contained elements of jingoism.
Juno (ch 6): The invasion of France in 1944 code-named Operation Overlord targeted a series of
beaches, each of which was assigned its own operational name associated with alphabet call-letters. The
American forces struck at Utah and Omaha; the British attacked Sword and Gold; the Canadian assault
came at Juno. Originally the British and Canadian beaches were named for fish (i.e.: Swordfish, Gold-
fish) and Juno was called Jellyfish, but British Prime Minister Winston Churchill objected to the idea
that soldiers were bound to die on a beach code-named Jelly and insisted on the change to Juno.
Kanakans (ch 2): Hawaiians or Pacific Island workers; this term may have been used disparagingly or
in a derogatory fashion, however, the word means human being in the Hawaiian language.
Keynesian economic principles (ch 8): Named for the British economist, John Maynard Keynes, it
broke with orthodox thinking by advocating government spending during downturns so as to stimulate
804 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

the economy; these principles also encouraged aggressive taxation during times of prosperity to offset
recovery-era spending. Resisted and rejected by orthodox economic thinkers and conservatives who
deplore the idea of a large, bureaucratic, and interventionist state.
King-Byng Affair (ch 6): Also known as the King-Byng Thing, a constitutional crisis arising from
Mackenzie Kings test of Governor-General Byngs authority to call an election when requested by a
Prime Minister.
Klondike (ch 9): The locus of the 1890s gold rush in the Yukon Territory, along the Klondike River
valley; used to describe the gold rush as a whole.
Knights of Labor (ch 3): Fully, the Noble and Holy Order of the Knights of Labor. Established in
the United States in 1869-70; expanded into Canada in the next decade; organized workers regardless
of race (apart from Asians), sex, or skill levels. Competition with the new craft unions resulted in the
Knights expulsion from the Trades and Labour Congress in 1902, and its gradual disintegration there-
after.
knowledge economy (ch 8): In the late 20th century, the trade in intellectual property and educational
property; the preeminence of technological and other kinds of knowledge and information as economic
drivers.
Korean War (ch 9): A war that began in 1950 and ended inconclusively in Armistice in 1953; this was
Canadas first Cold War era military engagement, and it involved significant casualties.
Ku Klux Klan (KKK) (ch 6): An explicitly racist, anti-Catholic illegal organization with roots in the
American South; established a presence and substantial following in Saskatchewan in the 1920s, where
it played a role in the outcome of the 1929 provincial election. Largely dissipated thereafter, the Klan
briefly reappeared in the 1970s in British Columbia, Alberta, and Ontario.
Labour Party (ch 3): In Britain, the political face of the Trades Union Congress; established in 1906.
While Labour Parties also appeared in Australia and New Zealand, one never fully materialized in
Canada.
labourism (ch 3): Canadian Liberal-Labour (Lib-Lab) candidates promoted an agenda that consisted
mostly of democratic reforms, the 8-hour work day, a minimum wage, and educational opportunities for
all.
Laurier boom (ch 8): The period of economic and demographic growth that coincides with the coming
to office of the Laurier Liberals in 1896; concludes in 1912-14.
League for Social Reconstruction (LSR) (ch 7): A socialist think-tank established by Frank Underhill
and F.R. Scott in 1932.
League of Nations (ch 6): A post-Great War international assembly established in 1919, of which
Canada was a founding member. Its principal objective was to create conditions of collective security
through a mutual defence pact and the application of economic sanctions; failed largely because of the
United States refusal to join and member states (including Canadas) fear of being embroiled in con-
flicts (military or economic) abroad.
Left (ch 7): Coined during the French Revolution to describe opponents of the monarchy; since then,
used to describe a spectrum of reform and radical positions and political organizations that includes
some Liberals, the Cooperative Commonwealth Federation, the New Democratic Party, the Socialist
Party of Canada, and at the far end of the Left the Communist Party and, in some instances, anar-
chists. See also Right.
Legislative Assembly (ch 1): Until 1968 all Canadian provinces had a Legislative Assembly, either as
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 805

their only house of elected representatives or as a lower house in either instance equating to the fed-
eral and British House of Commons. In 1968 the Quebec Assembly was renamed the National Assembly
of Quebec. Sitting members are described in most provinces as Members of the Legislative Assembly
(MLAs) and in Ontario as Members of the Provincial Parliament (MPPs). In Quebec they are Members
of the National Assembly (MNAs).
Les Automatistes (ch 10): Surrealist painters and performers based in Montreal, 1942-48; overlapped
with the Contemporary Art Society.
Lend-Lease Agreement (ch 6): Prior to declaring war against the Axis Powers in 1941, the United
States agreed to support the Allied war effort by selling materiel to Britain on a deferred-payment pro-
gram. Canada was able to take advantage of this arrangement, which led to rapid industrial recovery and
expansion. See also Hyde Park Declaration.
Liberal-Labour (also Lib-Lab) (ch 3): Typically a pro-labour candidate, sometime running under a
Labour or Independent Labour banner, who joined the Liberal caucus on being elected.
liberalism (prologue): A political philosophical position that, in the late 18th and 19th centuries,
enjoyed widespread acceptance; prioritizes the rights of the individual (that is, the individual adult
male), private property, equality (again, among adult typically white males), and the values of a
democratic system.
Mackenzie-Papineau Battalion (ch 7): A 1,500-strong contingent of Canadian volunteers in the war
against the Fascists in Spain during the Civil War, 1937-38; took their name from the two leaders of the
Rebellions of 1837-38, Louis-Joseph Papineau and William Lyon Mackenzie (the grandfather of Prime
Minister William Lyon Mackenzie King).
Matre chez nous (Masters of our own house) (ch 9): The slogan used by Jean Lesages Liberals in
Quebec in 1960 election, ushering in the Quiet Revolution.
Manhattan Project (ch 6): 1942-46; a secretive and international Second World War research and
development project conceived to develop the first atomic bomb. Canada contributed the uranium and,
at what was still a prototype reactor on the Chalk River in Ontario, developed the processes for extract-
ing weapons-grade plutonium.
manifest destiny (ch 1): American notion that it could control, and was destined to control, the whole
of North America; literally, it was the will of God (destined) and it was apparent (manifest) in the incre-
mental territorial expansions of the United States.
Manitoba schools question (ch 4): In 1890 the provincial government turned its back on commitments
in the Manitoba Act (1870) to provide a dual French and English system of education, a move that
was stimulated by declining French and Catholic populations. The Privy Council determined (twice) that
the federal government had the power to reverse this decision. In opposition, Wilfrid Laurier blocked
Ottawas attempt at disallowance; in government he negotiated a compromise with Manitoba.
Maritime Rights (ch 8): An interwar-era political common front in New Brunswick, Prince Edward
Island, and Nova Scotia that argued for greater federal support for the regional economy.
Maritime Union (ch 1): A proposal to create one colony out of New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, and
Prince Edward Island; the original impetus for the Charlottetown Conference; abandoned in favour of
Confederation.
marketing boards (ch 9): An agricultural producers marketing tool; often established by the producers
themselves or by government, which acts as a buyer of output and then a marketer. Constitutes a kind of
monopoly in that producers cannot sell their goods through any other means. See also wheat pools.
806 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Marshall Plan (ch 8): Also called the European Recovery Plan (ERP), an American program giving
billions of dollars of aid to rebuild European economies after WWII, in part to restore markets but also
to offset the appeal of Communism.
Marxist-Leninist (ch 7): Building on the scientific socialism of Karl Marx, which argued that socialist,
worker-led governments would supersede bourgeois capitalism, the Leninist thread arising in revo-
lutionary and post-revolutionary Russia introduced the idea of a vanguard of the proletariat, single-
party rule, internationalism, and a state-run economy. In Canadian communism, one of several variants
on Marxist doctrine.
Mason-Dixon Line (ch 1): Boundary between the American colonies, then states, of Maryland and
Pennsylvania; also used to define the American South from the American North, and slave and non-
slave states.
maternal feminism (ch 3): Also called first wave feminism; a movement to achieve greater civic rights
for women; based its appeal on the biological differences between women and men, arguing that women
have a natural nurturing instinct and ability which ought to be welcomed in a democratic system; women
could apply the knowledge and attributes acquired from their universal role as mothers to address vari-
ous inequities and social ills.
maternal feminists (ch 7): Adherents to the ideals of maternal feminism.
mechanization (ch 3): The process of replacing manual labour with machinery; distinct from automa-
tion, which is a later phase in the deskilling process.
Medicine Line (ch 2): The 49th parallel north, so named by the First Nations of the Plains because it
worked as an invisible barrier to stop attacks northward by United States soldiers.
mediums (ch 6): Individuals thought to possess the ability to act as a bridge between the living and the
dead; they were the media through which messages could be transmitted; part of an early 20th century
trend toward spiritualism that was fed, in part, by the enormous mortality of WWI.
Meech Lake Accord (ch 9): 1987; an agreement reached between all the provincial premiers and the
Prime Minister that provided for a constitutional amending formula, a distinct society clause for Que-
bec, senate and Supreme Court reforms, and a devolution of some immigration issues to the provincial
level. Despite a promising start, the Accord failed to achieve final approval.
Mennonites (ch 5): Along with the Hutterites and Amish, the Mennonites are an Anabaptist sectarian
group; emigrated from Europe in the late 19th and early 20th century, where they faced oppression for
their pacifist beliefs and the practice of adult baptism; settled in communities in Ontario, in Manitoba
and across the Prairies, and in parts of British Columbia. A communal farming community that has
resisted modernization, though with less intensity than the Hutterites.
mercantilism (ch 8): The system of economic relations established between European empires and their
colonies; emphasis is on the use of merchants in the home country to establish production in the colony
of largely unprocessed goods that would be shipped to the home ports; leaves colonies economically
dependent and underdeveloped.
Metro (ch 9): The federated Municipality of Metropolitan Toronto.
middle power (ch 9): The idea that Canada might occupy a position between great power states like
Britain and the United States and, after the World War II, at a level between the superpowers (the US
and the USSR), the second tier of military and economic powers (e.g.: Britain and France), and other
nations; tied to Lester Pearsons vision of peacekeeping and Canada as a referee or fair broker.
modernity (ch 3): Also modern and modernism; term given to a constellation of behaviours and beliefs
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 807

associated with the industrial, urban era. It is associated with challenges to traditional values and ways
of looking at the world, and is often used in connection with 20th century artworks, literature, and archi-
tecture.
Mohawk Institute (ch 11): First industrial school for Aboriginal people, principally Mohawk; taught
basic academic instruction and trades; based in Brantford, Ontario; opened in the 1830s under the aus-
pices of New England Company.
Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact (1939) (ch 7): A mutual non-aggression treaty signed between Germany and
the USSR; allowed Germany to move forward with its attacks on France and the Low Countries while
the Soviet Union annexed territories in the Baltic region.
monetarism (ch 8): In macroeconomics, the theory that the money supply and central bank policies are
key to understanding inflation and fluctuations in GDP. By controlling the money supply, monetarists
argue, one can contain inflation. One instrument for achieving these goals is to raise interest rates
making money more expensive and thereby reducing its velocity. Monetarist policies were introduced
along with austerity measures in Britain under the Thatcher government from 1979. Similar efforts
(without austerity) were attempted in the United States under Ronald Reagan. Both were influential on
Canadian fiscal policy.
Montreal Amateur Athletic Association (MAAA) (ch 10): Created in 1881, a federation of non-pro-
fessional sports organizations, including bicycling, lacrosse, and ice hockey clubs; argued for a gentle-
manly view of athletics, one which built character and community; opposed to the professionalization
of sports and games.
moral panics (ch 10): Public fears of declining values and worsening behaviours that could lead to
social turmoil and/or crisis. Examples include temperance, anti-gambling crusades, the 1950s campaign
against comic books, and several recurring moral panics regarding adolescents.
Moravian Brethren (ch 2): An early Protestant sect from central Europe; established missions in
Labrador, with the first permanent site established at Nain in 1771.
Motion Picture Production Code (1930) (ch 10): Also called the Hays Code, operated until 1968;
established to address a public relations crisis in the film industry regarding risqu subject matter and
scandals in Hollywood; prescribed anodyne subject matter and self-censorship by filmmakers as regards
profanity, sex, nudity, and a long list of other perceived offences. It is worth noting that language, sexu-
ality, and humour had a much wider berth in the first 30 years of the century.
muscular Christianity (ch 6): A late 19th century combination of Christian piety and athleticism, espe-
cially as regards masculinity.
mutually assured destruction (MAD) (ch 9): The Cold War belief that the sheer number of thermonu-
clear devices and delivery systems in the hands of the Soviet Union and the United States meant that
neither side would survive an assault initiated by the other. By assuring their mutual destruction, they
would be deterred from initiating a nuclear war.
nadir (ch 11): The opposite of zenith; it is the trough and in demographic terms it means the point at
which a falling population bottomed out and from which it recovers. In the case of First Nations popu-
lations, they continued to fall until the 1920s at which point they began a steady recovery.
National Action Committee on the Status of Women (ch 7): Established in 1971 to agitate for imple-
mentation of the recommendations of the Bird Commission. See also Royal Commission on the Status
of Women.
National Council of Women of Canada (NCWC) (ch 3): A feminist activist group formed in 1893;
predominantly Anglo-Celtic Protestant women who mostly identified themselves as maternal feminists.
808 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

National Energy Program (NEP) (ch 8): Controversial legislation introduced under Pierre Trudeaus
administration in 1980-1985. The thrust of the policy was to secure Canadian oil for Canadian markets
in eastern Canada (hitherto dependent on cheaper but, in the context of the second OPEC shock, inse-
cure imported oil). Prices for Albertan oil in Quebec would be lower than in the United States (to
which most of Canadas oil was sent), which meant lower profits in the oil patch.
National Film Board (NFB) (ch 10): Established under the National Film Act, 1939 with a mandate to
produce propaganda films during wartime. Subsequently a centre for creative excellence in documen-
tary production.
National Hockey Association (NHA) (ch 10): One of several early 20th century professional hockey
leagues and the direct precursor of the National Hockey League.
National Hockey League (NHL) (ch 10): Established in 1917 after a dispute among team owners in
the National Hockey Association. It was, originally, an all-Canadian league but expanded in 1920 to
Boston. Its higher salaries and American market led to the decline and disappearance of other profes-
sional leagues and the rise of an effective monopoly by the 1940s.
National Indian Brotherhood (NIB) (ch 11): Established in 1967-68 and propelled into action by the
appearance of the White Paper (1969). See also the Assembly of First Nations.
National Policy (ch 3): John A. Macdonalds linkage of three policies into one: a tariff wall to exclude
American manufactures; an transcontinental railway (the CPR) to link the Maritimes with British
Columbia; and the settlement of the West. Although most of the components were in place by 1876, it
was only touted as a single National Policy in 1879.
nationalist historians (ch 12): Or national historians; scholars who believe that the principal role of
history is to analyze and explain the history of the nation state.
nationalization (ch 9): The imposition of state ownership over a corporation or sector; examples
include the provincial nationalization of hydroelectricity providers (e.g.: Ontario Hydro, Hydro-Qubec,
and BC Hydro) and the water transport monopoly in British Columbia (BC Ferries).
nativist (ch 5): A movement or individual committed to preserving privileges to established members of
a community over newcomers; often translates into anti-immigration attitudes; many nativists are them-
selves merely earlier immigrants; has nothing to do with Native peoples.
Nativist millenarians (ch 2): Movements among mostly Indigenous peoples under imperialism that
attempt to throw off their occupiers and return to an idealized past way of living; sometimes imbued
with a mystical element that could involve divine intervention.
natural increase (ch 1): The growth of population from more births than deaths; that is, not by immi-
gration and not factoring in emigration.
neo-liberalism (ch 8): An ideological position that favours smaller government, deregulation, freer
trade, and lower taxes; and is tied to monetarism.
Neverendum (ch 9): The series of referendums dealing with Quebec separatism (or sovereignty-associ-
ation) and proposed changes to the constitution, beginning in 1980.
New Canadians (ch 5): Term used since the late 1960s to describe recent immigrants, particularly those
arriving from non-traditional sources like South Asia, Latin America, and Africa.
New Democratic Party (NDP) (ch 7): Successor to the Cooperative Commonwealth Federation; cre-
ated out of the union of the Canadian Labour Congress (CLC) and the CCF in 1961.
New Left (ch 9): Associated with campus radicalism in the 1960s and the writings of German philoso-
pher Herbert Marcuse; less interested in the class struggle and labour power than with social justice.
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 809

New West (ch 8): Term used to describe the Prairie provinces following their move from a monocultural
economy based almost entirely on grain production and export to an economy with diverse and more
valuable bases.
New World Order (ch 12): In the context of the post-Cold War era, a United States-dominated inter-
national stage in which diminished expenditures on nuclear arsenals would be turned into resources to
build up economies globally; in the context of wars in the Gulf and Middle East, an effort to impose the
(Western) rule of law on recalcitrant states.
non-conformist churches (ch 7): A descriptive term attached to dissenting Protestant sects that broke
with the Anglican Church as early as 1660; associated specifically with Methodism, Congregationalism,
and the Baptist Church.
Nootka Sound (ch 5): On the west coast of Vancouver Island; traditional territory of the Nootka (Nuu-
chah-nulth) First Nation; site of sustained contact between European, Mexican, and American traders
and Aboriginal peoples, along with a significant population of imported Chinese labourers in the late
18th century.
North American Aerospace Defense Command (NORAD) (ch 9): Arising from a pact signed with
the United States in 1957; provides detection and defence against Soviet missile and other airborne
attacks on North America.
North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) (ch 8): 1994; trade pact with the United States and
Mexico. Expands on the Free Trade Agreement (FTA) signed in 1988.
North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) (ch 8): Established by the North Atlantic Treaty of 1949
that brought together the Treaty of Brussels nations (Britain, Belgium, Netherlands, Luxembourg, and
France), Canada, the United States, Iceland, Denmark, Norway, Italy, and Portugal as a mutual defense
league an attack on one would be an attack on all.
notwithstanding clause (ch 9): Section 33 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms
(1982) allows any provincial, federal, or territorial government to override some select rights in the
Charter for a fixed period of time.
nuclear family (prologue): Describes a household comprised of one or two adults and their children.
Households that include adult siblings are called consangineal and those that include an older genera-
tion (that is, grandparents) is called extended.
numbered treaties (ch 11): Treaties struck between Canada and Aboriginal peoples from 1871 (Treaty
1) to 1921 (Treaty 11), covering a territory that stretches from Ontarios eastern boundary in the North
West to British Columbia, incorporating the whole of the Peace River Valley and the Mackenzie River
drainage basin. Areas not covered by numbered treaties include southern Ontario (including the Rainy
River area and Thunder Bay-Nippissing corridor, most of British Columbia, most of the Yukon and
North West Territories, and all of Quebec, the Maritimes, and Newfoundland-Labrador.
Nunavut Land Claims Agreement (ch 9): 1993; set the stage for the Nunavut Act, 1999 that created
the new territory of Nunavut; the first major land claims agreement negotiated by the federal government
since Treaty 11 (1920 to 1921).
October Crisis (ch 9): This was a combination of events in October 1970 including the kidnapping of
James Cross and Pierre Laporte, attempts to ransom the two men, the execution of Cross by his abduc-
tors, and the use of the War Measures Act for the first time in peacetime.
Official Opposition (ch 7): In parliamentary systems, the party with the second largest number of seats
in the House of Commons. On occasion, the second largest caucus has refused the title of Official Oppo-
sition.
810 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

official party status (ch 7): The recognition of a political partys representatives in an assembly as suf-
ficient to merit certain parliamentary privileges, including the right to ask questions during question
period. In Ottawa, the federal House of Commons requires that a party have no fewer than 12 MPs in
order to qualify for official status.
off-shore production (ch 8): Manufacturing of goods or parts in another country.
Ogdensburg Agreement (ch 6): 1940, a wartime accord signed between United States President
Franklin D. Roosevelt and Canadian Prime Minister William Lyon Mackenzie King; produced the Per-
manent Joint Board of Defence.
oil patch (ch 8): Shorthand for Albertas oil industry, from mining and processing to sales and financing,
from the field to the head offices in Calgary and Edmonton.
Oka Crisis (ch 11): In 1990 armed Mohawk band members from Kanesatake blockaded access to pro-
posed construction site of a golf course in Oka; the arrival of Canadian Armed Forces troops was fol-
lowed by disruptions of traffic through reserve lands to the south by the Mohawk band members from
Kahnawake.
one big union, One Big Union (OBU) (ch 3): In the first instance, the idea (pioneered by the Knights of
Labor) that working people should belong to a single organization that can fight for their rights collec-
tively; secondly, an actual organization the OBU formed after 1919, as a revolutionary industrial
union (which included workers in support of the Bolshevik and other left-wing revolutions).
On-to-Ottawa Trek (ch 8): Beginning in June 1933, the Relief Camp Workers Union mobilized the
unemployed in British Columbia to abandon the camps and put their issues directly before Prime Minis-
ter Bennett, travelling across Canada on railway boxcars. The Trek started in Vancouver but was stopped
in Regina and culminated in a riot.
Orange (ch 4): Refers to the Orange Order, its members, and its values; a Protestant fraternal associa-
tion with roots in Ireland; marked by a strong antipathy for Catholics and Catholicism, as well as a fierce
loyalty to the Crown. Supported Protestant immigrants and made use of violence and political networks
to achieve its ends.
Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) (ch 8): Established in 1960 as a regulating
body for the oil industrys biggest producers, most of which were located in the Middle East and Africa.
By 1970 decolonization had advanced so far that emerging countries sought greater control over the
value of their oil exports. OPEC responded by setting higher prices, which triggered the first oil shock
of the decade.
other (prologue): Usually represented as the other or an other, refers to the idea of groups or indi-
viduals different from ones own or ones self. The effect of recognizing an other is to sharpen ones
sense of self in terms of what one is not. Historically, some groups have been otherized or constructed
in argument and in systems as not belonging to the mainstream. This is part of the process of isolating
and possibly persecuting certain groups and individuals.
outsourcing (ch 8): The export of jobs; part of the process of deindustrialization.
Pacific Coast Hockey Association (PCHA) (ch 10): One of several early 20th century professional
hockey leagues; pioneered use of artificial ice in indoor arenas; merged with the Western Canada
Hockey League in 1924.
Pacific Scandal (ch 2): 1873; Macdonalds Conservative Party was given significant funds from the
Canadian Pacific Railway, which caused the CPR to lose the opportunity to complete the Intercolonial
Railway, cost Macdonald his administration, and brought the Mackenzie Liberals into office.
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 811

pacifism (ch 5): An anti-war position; pacifists typically will not volunteer for and refuse to be con-
scripted into conflict. Many eastern European religious groups brought pacifist beliefs with them to
Western Canada before 1914.
paparrazi (ch 9): Photo-journalists who principally target celebrities and public figures and whose
technique is sometimes intrusive.
partial franchise (ch 3): With the passage of the Wartime Elections Act in 1917, female relatives of
Canadian soldiers were granted the vote.
partition (ch 12): The potential for, or the act of, formally dividing an established jurisdiction. In the
case of Canada, Quebecs separation from Canada would not constitute because it existed before Con-
federation, but the removal of anglophone-dominated areas and Inuit and Cree territories would consti-
tute a partition of Quebec.
pass system (ch 11): Aboriginal reserve residents were required to secure a pass from their Indian agent
in order to leave the reserve.
paternalism (prologue): A system in which a source of authority exerts control over the behaviour,
conditions, and rights of its subjects; may occur at the state level but also in the workplace (as managers/
employers determine how workers should behave and perform) and underlies patriarchal households
wherein the eldest productive male constitutes the principal source of authority.
patriarchy (ch 7): A socio-economic system in which males have legal, political, social, and economic
primacy and privilege, sometimes to the complete exclusion of women. Under a patriarchy, control over
children is also a male (fatherly) prerogative.
patriation (ch 9): The transfer to Canada from Britain of the British North America Act (an Act of the
British Parliament) and thus enabling its amendment in Canada.
peace dividend (ch 12): At the end of the Cold War it was widely predicted that the cost of maintaining
readiness in the face of the threat posed by the Warsaw Pact and other communist countries would come
to an end and resources would be spent in other ways.
peace, order and good government (POGG) (ch 2): From Section 91 of the BNA Act as regards resid-
ual or residuary powers (granted to the Queen, the Senate, and House of Commons to make laws),
and which could cover anything and everything that was either not itemized or as yet not imagined in
the constitutional division of authority.
peacekeeping (ch 9): Under the United Nations in the Cold War and post-Cold War era, the use of mili-
tary and other military personnel in non-combatant roles to maintain peace between adversaries so as to
enable the peace-making process.
Penner Report (ch 11): Recommended to Ottawa in 1983 that Aboriginal peoples constitute a distinct
order of government and ought to be recognized as such.
Permanent Joint Board of Defense (ch 6): Established in 1940. See Ogdensburg Agreement.
Phoney War (ch 6): Having declared war against Germany on 3 September 1939, France and Britain
made no effort to engage the enemy in combat for the next eight months. Note that in Canadian and
British English it is always spelled Phoney, with an e, whereas in American English it is spelled
Phony.
Pig War (ch 2): Colloquial name for a dispute between the United States and the British Empire over
the San Juan Islands, from 1859-1873.
(the) Pill (ch 9): Refers to the first successful oral contraceptive, approved for public use in 1960.
812 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Planned Parenthood Federation of Canada (ch 9): Established in 1964, the Federation was the
descendant of a long line of organizations advocating education and support around birth control.
pluralism (ch 5): In contrast to dualism, supports the concept of a community or state made of diverse
parts, particularly as regards aspects like ethnicity, creed, and/or language.
political correctness (ch 12): A provocative (and often ironic) term to describe attempts to modify lan-
guage in such ways as to minimize unnecessary offence, typically of minorities, women, and vulnerable
populations. The inclusive ethos of sensitive language which was essentially self-reflection on the
ways in which language binds social roles and relationships has been challenged by privileged groups
in particular who regard restrictions on the ability to defame others as a loss of freedom.
Poor Laws (ch 7): A series of laws enacted in Britain, including several amendments in the 19th cen-
tury; aimed at providing support for the unemployed and impoverished; characterized by the use of
poor houses and workhouses in which conditions were sufficiently appalling to keep all but the least
able-bodied and most desperate off of the public dole.
popular culture (ch 10): Denotes arts, values, and ideas that are entrenched in a large slice of the pop-
ulation. Popular in this respect signifies that it is both widely appreciated and desired, and generated
by this mainstream population. A 20th century idea, sometimes referred to as pop culture in the later
20th century.
popular front (ch 6): A political alliance of left-wing, progressive parties and organizations to counter
fascism in the 1920s, 30s, and 40s.
populism (ch 3), populist (ch 2): In politics, an appeal to the interests and concerns of the community
by political leaders (populists) usually against established elites or minority or scapegoat groups.
The rhetoric of populists is often characterized as vitriolic, bombastic, and fear-mongering.
pop music (ch 9): A music sub-genre within the larger rock and roll (rocknroll) genre; adheres to obvi-
ous structural qualities, tends to be melodic, and aims at a younger audience.
post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) (ch 12): Mental health consequences of trauma, typically
within the context of warfare; associated with research in the fields of psychology, psychiatry, and psy-
chotherapy.
post-colonial, post-colonialism (ch 11): The range of experiences and perspectives that look beyond
the paradigm of colonial society and colonialism; associated with the late 20th century.
postmodern, postmodernism (ch 10): A complex of views arising in the late modernist period that
questioned the eras certainties, invited a skeptical analysis of conventions, focussed on pluralism rather
than unity (both politically and artistically); contains anti-modernist elements (such as the return to craft
and artisanal production) but is not otherwise anti-modern in the way that the original opponents to mod-
ernism were.
post-war settlement (ch 8): A suite of agreements between employers, unionized workers, and the
state in 1946; allowed for responsible labour activity while prohibiting excessive militance; commit-
ted employers and the state to recognizing unions and supporting the checkoff of union dues. See Rand
Formula.
potlatch (ch 11): Refers to ceremonies associated with First Nations cultures on the Pacific Northwest
Coast.
pragmatic (ch 4): In politics, the focus on existing conditions rather than ideological considerations or
objectives. Also called realpolitik.
Prague Spring (ch 9): 1968, a brief period of liberalization of government policies and democratic
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 813

rights in Czechoslovakia; countered by the invasion of Warsaw Pact troops under the command of the
Soviet Union.
preferential tariff (ch 4): Charges (a tax) added to imported goods so as to make their sale price higher
than domestic goods and, thus, make domestic goods more competitive; some trade partners are less
discriminated (they are preferred) over others.
presentism (preface): Or the presentist fallacy; the belief that the events of the past are directly
responsible for conditions in the present. Presentism often ignores intervening events. It also tends to
thank the past for positives (such as current freedoms) while it seldom holds the past accountable for
liabilities (such as a lacklustre economy, continuing struggles over equality, etc.).
Prime Ministers Office (PMO) (ch 9): Also the Office of the Prime Minister or the PMO; the centre
of political decision making in the Parliamentary system, consisting of the Prime Minister and her/his
chief political advisors; in Ottawa, located in the Langevin Block on Parliament Hill.
prisoner of war (POW) (ch 6): In modern warfare there are conventions regarding the appropriate
treatment of captured soldiers or POWs. Most POWs are held for the duration of the war in guarded
POW camps. Camps were established in Canada to handle POWs from the European theatre of war in
the Second World War.
Privy Council Order PC 1003 (1944) (ch 8): Allowed unions for the first time to engage in widespread
organization and to bargain collectively for job contracts.
professionalization (ch 10): Generally, the creation of exclusive policies that limit entry into a particu-
lar business or trade, such as the need for a teaching certificate from a recognized institution in order to
become a teacher; in sports, the phenomenon of paying players to play, which moved games and athleti-
cism away from the 19th century ideal of gentlemanly and unpaid (amateur) competition.
profiteers (ch 3): Industrialists and others who were able to profit from government contracts in
wartime.
progress (ch 10): The view that the history of humanity is a constant movement forward toward a better
and better society.
progressive (ch 7): In politics and social policy, the belief in the improvability of human society. In
partisan politics, associated with the Progressive Party (below) and the Progressive Conservative Party.
In music, indicates a sub-genre of rock and roll which tends to be more symphonic and influenced by
electronic jazz.
Progressive Party (ch 6): Formed in 1920 as an alliance of the various United Farmer MPs elected to
Ottawa; initially a rural protest party with strong roots in Ontario.
prohibition (ch 3): A total ban on the production, sale, and consumption of alcohol products.
proletarianization (ch 3): The transformation of non-industrial workers or skilled workers and small
employers into wage labourers.
proportional representation (ch 3): Distinct from the first-past-the-post system; can take several forms
but common aspect is that political parties will be elect a number of seats that reflect in some measure
the percentage of votes the parties receive. For example, in a first-past-the-post system a party might
win 49% of the votes in every constituency but not elect a single candidate if the only other party run-
ning wins 51% of the votes; proportional representation (sometimes called PR) would ensure that the
second-place party received something closer to 49% of the seats.
province building (ch 8): The strategy pursued by some provinces to become more substantial players
814 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

in their jurisdictions by investing in economic expansion and engaging in a growing number of social
programs. Associated with the post-WWII period.
proxy wars (ch 9): Cold war era conflicts conducted by third party countries in which the United States
and the Soviet Union had a stake, rather than a direct conflict between the two superpowers.
punk rock (ch 9): A variant of rocknroll that appeared for the first time in the late 1970s; marked by
an anti-establishment, anti-authority stance.
queer history (ch 12): The study of the historic experience of LGBT individuals and communities; also
the analysis of popular and governmental attitudes toward LGBT communities.
Quiet Revolution (Revolution tranquille) (ch 9): A period of rapid and consequential change in the
character of Quebec politics and society beginning in the late 1950s.
race suicide (ch 7): A public opinion poll for registered voters, the results of which may or may not be
binding. Members of Parliament debate actual bills that they can see and hold, and on which they may
offer suggestions and amendments; referenda typically ask for general agreement on a broad principal
without providing any of the details.
racializing (prologue): To ascribe inherent qualities to an identifiable group and to explain the presence
of those qualities as a product of race which is itself a social construct.
racism (ch 5): A set of beliefs and practices that involve the creation of largely arbitrary categories of
human peoples and assigning to them behaviours, traits, and tendencies that are essentialized that is,
thought to be an inherent and immutable part of who they are. For example, laziness, alcoholism, unbri-
dled libido, personal restraint and self discipline, deceitfulness, superior or inferior intelligence, greed,
corruptibility, cowardice, and courage have, at various times, been regarded as unchangeable qualities
of one race or another. As an ideology, argues that the assumed existence of these differences justifies
and necessitates the development of social policies that reduce the impact that might be had by
the less desirable races.
Rand Formula (1946) (ch 8): Based on a landmark legal ruling by Mr. Justice Ivan C. Rand, the Rand
Formula provided unions with a pathway to gain legitimacy and long-term stability if, but only if, they
agreed to conduct themselves responsibly.
rational recreation (ch 10): A 19th century response to the leisure activities of working people gam-
bling, competitions of strength, drinking, and low-brow performances, and which sought to replace these
with controlled, morally superior, and character building improving activities.
Reaganism (ch 8): Also Reaganomics; associated with the neo-liberal (also neo-conservative) goal of
reducing the size of government, expenditures of government, and size of personal and capital gains
taxes; tied, as well, to monetarism.
recession (ch 8): Generally a down-cycle in economics characterized by price inflation, rising unem-
ployment, industrial failures, and lower household income.
Reciprocity Treaty (ch 1): 1854 agreement between the British North American colonies and the
United States; enabled freer trade; was cancelled by the Americans at the end of the Civil War.
Red Paper (ch 11): Also called Citizens Plus; prepared by Harold Cardinal and the Indian Associ-
ation of Alberta in 1970, the Red Paper was a response to Ottawas 1969 White Paper (aka The State-
ment of the Government of Canada on Indian Policy, 1969). called for preservation of Treaty rights and
recognition of Aboriginal rights.
Red Power (ch 11): A continent-wide movement led by Aboriginal peoples in the late 1960s to through
the 1970s to place Aboriginal issues on the political agenda.
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 815

Royal Proclamation (ch 11): 1763; Britains first constitution for post-Conquest Canada; recognized
inherent Indigenous land tenure rights or Aboriginal title to the land, making it impossible for any
authority or individual other than the Crown to alienate Aboriginal title; provoked objections among the
American colonists because it interfered with their plans for westward expansion; sometimes called the
Indian Magna Carta.
Red Scare (ch 3): A complex of political, social, economic, and cultural responses to the rise of pro-
communist feeling in Canada and internationally; fear of communist revolution at home or abroad
and particularly of pro-communist spies and supporters working clandestinely to advance a communist
agenda; manifest in security campaigns against perceived enemies of the state, the creation of blacklists,
and other acts of intimidation.
Red Tory (ch 9): A Canadian Progressive Conservative who takes an essentially 19th century conserv-
ative position on the social obligations of the upper classes; a position sometimes described as noblesse
oblige.
reference group (ch 5): In a society comprised of some diversity, refers to the most influential group
whose culture other groups seek to adopt or are obliged to assimilate into. See also context group.
referenda (ch 7): A public opinion poll for registered voters, the results of which may or may not be
binding. Members of Parliament debate actual bills that they can see and hold, and on which they may
offer suggestions and amendments; referenda typically ask for general agreement on a broad principal
without providing any of the details.
reformist (ch 7): Among left-wing activists, a belief that incremental changes to capitalism can produce
a social and economic order of fairness for working people; derided by revolutionaries as delusional.
See also gradualist and impossibilist.
Regina Manifesto (ch 7): 1933; the original statement of purpose and beliefs of the Cooperative Com-
monwealth Federation.
Regina Riot (ch 8): 1st of July 1935, at the conclusion of the On-to-Ottawa Trek, a rally called by
the Relief Camp Workers Union in Reginas Market Square culminated in a confrontation between the
Trekkers and their supporters and the RCMP.
regional disparities (ch 12): Term used increasingly in the 1970s to describe the existence of have
and have-not provinces whose inequalities were a product of long-term economic circumstances.
Regulation 17 (ch 6): In Ontario, a provincial program to reduce the availability of French language
education; introduced shortly before the Great War; contributed to tensions between Francophone Que-
bec and Anglophone Ontario and the federal government.
relief camps (ch 8): The federal governments response to the massing of unemployed single men
in Vancouver early in the 1930s Depression; in 1932, a nationwide system of generally quite isolated
camps run by the Department of National Defense that became hotbeds of radical opposition to govern-
ment inaction on the economic crisis.
relocation programs (ch 9): A federal government initiative in the mid-20th century to move Aborig-
inal peoples in the North to locations where they would serve as a sign of Canadian sovereignty and/or
where services (education, healthcare, administration, and the church) might be more effectively central-
ized. A program to which Inuit in particular were subjected, their lives disrupted, and their economies
severed.
rep-by-pop (ch 1): Representation by population; the higher the population of a province, the higher
the number of seats allocated for that province in the House of Commons.
816 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

reparations (ch 8): At the end of the First World War, Germany accepted responsibility for acts of
aggression leading to the conflict; the Treaty of Versailles (1919) ordered Germany to make extensive
payments as a consequence. Both the idea of war guilt and reparations became a contentious issue in
Germany; the countrys inability to pay the enormous reparations fees led to severe international eco-
nomic instability, particularly when Germany sharply devalued its own currency to pay the debts more
easily.
representational value of sport (ch 10): In the context of, principally, professional sports, the phenom-
enon of athletes whose performance is seen by the community and by fans especially as representing the
community and its members; applies to local and to national players/teams.
resistance armies (ch 6): Also resistance forces, resistance movements; forces aligned against either a
legitimate regime or an occupying regime; an unofficial army typically comprised of soldiers who have
deserted the national armed forces, as well as civilians who offer services and support to actual fighters
and sometimes fight themselves.
respectability (ch 3): A term used and an ideal pursued by mid-19th century organized labour partic-
ularly skilled craft workers and some of their successors; embraced the ideals of fair treatment, law-
abiding behaviour, equality, and a commitment to the nations stability and growth. Manifest in many
ways including working class campaigns for literacy, temperance, and rational recreation.
responsible government (ch 1): Government in which the Executive level (or Cabinet) is responsible
to and can be dismissed from office by the majority of votes in the Assembly. In contrast to pre-
Confederation systems in which the Executive was appointed by and was responsible to the Crown or
its representative.
Rest Of Canada (ROC) (ch 9): A term used to describe all Canada apart from Quebec; has the advan-
tage of avoiding the idea of dualism (as in English- vs. French-Canada).
Right (ch 7): Individuals, groups, and parties espousing a conservative perspective; a broad continuum
that includes Red Tories, Blue Tories, neo-liberals/conservatives, the late 20th century Reform Party,
and far to the Right fascists.
rights culture (ch 12): Beginning in the 1960s, a belief in the existence of un- or under-recognized
rights as well as the importance and value of extending and enshrining rights to under-protected groups.
rock and roll (ch 9): Also rocknroll and rock & roll; a musical style originating in the 1950s charac-
terized at first by a synthesis of blues, jazz, country, western, and boogie-woogie; became in the 1960s
and later an umbrella term for many styles that incorporated any of these elements, including a strong
youth component; regarded at mid-century as rebellious in its presentation and content.
Rouge (ch 4): Also Parti rouge. Political party and tradition in Quebec; established in the 1840s, it
became increasing more pro-secular, anticlerical, and opposed to hereditary privilege; opposed to Con-
federation, embraced provincial rights; after 1867, merged with the Clear Grits to form the Liberal Party.
RCAF (Womens Division) (ch 6): Formed in 1941 when women from the British Royal Air Force
(RAF) arrived in Canada to assist training. Embarrassed, the RCAF agreed to accept women and became
the first branch of the armed forces to actively recruit women.
Royal Canadian Air Force (RCAF) (ch 6): Established in 1924 on the remains of several Great War
flying corps with Canadian personnel.
Royal Commission on Bilingualism and Biculturalism (ch 9): Created in 1963 and reported out in
1969; co-chaired by A. Davidson Dunstan and Andr Laurendeau (who was succeeded at his death by
Jean-Louis Gagnon); identified underrepresentation of Franco-Canadians in many areas of public life,
second-rate services in French in national and relevant provincial systems, and poor opportunities for
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 817

Francophones in post-secondary institutions outside of Quebec; recommended the establishment of a

Commissioner of Official Languages.
Royal Commission on the Status of Women (ch 7): Created in 1967 and reported out in 1970; chaired
by Florence Bird; produced 167 recommendations that focussed on issues of equality of opportunity and
identifying the many institutional, legal, and systemic barriers to the same. While most of the recom-
mendations have been adopted, provision of day care remains an outstanding exception. The RCSW did
not address issues associated with sexual identity or sexual orientation and its failure to discuss violence
against women was a major oversight. The Office for the Status of Women was established as a conse-
quence of the Commissions report.
rural depopulation (ch 9): Movement of people generally younger people off the land and into
the cities; associated with urbanization and also with the collapse of village and town economies.
rust belt (ch 8): Former heavy manufacturing regions that have experienced deindustrialization.
Salvation Army (ch 7): Founded in England in 1865; a Christian denomination identified with charita-
ble works in urban industrial areas; adopted a military model with uniforms, marching bands, and ranks.
Introduced to Canada in 1882, where it is also known as the Sally Ann, sometimes as the Starva-
tion Army. Keenly interested in social justice issues, the Salvation Army was instrumental in the social
gospel movement.
scientific racism (ch 7): The use of scientific technique or pseudo-scientific technique to provide a
rational and empirically verifiable basis of racial discrimination. Utterly demolished as a theory in the
postwar period, it nevertheless contributed not only to the spread of racism in Euro-Canadian communi-
ties but to its legitimation and respectability.
scrip (ch 2): A system introduced by Canada for extinguishing Mtis land title, beginning in 1870. Scrip
documents indicated individual entitlement to land, although not necessarily to land on which one was
already settled. While the numbered treaties dealt with whole First Nations communities collectively,
scrip was negotiated on an individual and household basis.
second industrial revolution (ch 3): Usually placed between ca. 1870 and 1914, renewed technological
innovation which saw a significant expansion in iron and steel production, railway construction, and
communications technologies like the telegraph and telephone.
Second Vatican Council (Vatican II) (ch 9): Convened by Pope John XXIII in 1959; ended 90 years
of papal infallibility by opening dialogue regarding doctrine and the relationship between the Catholic
Church and the modern world; upset many long-standing convictions about unchanging features of
Catholic life; in Canada, contributed to the sense of social, spiritual, and secular fluidity that was bound
up in the Quiet Revolution.
second wave feminist (ch 7): A renewal of movement feminism in the postwar era; focussed on rights
in the workplace, equality of opportunity and pay, reproductive rights, and violence against women. See
also Womens Liberation
Section 35 (ch 11): Of the Constitution Act, 1982; recognizes and affirms Aboriginal rights.
Section 98 (ch 6): Refers to Section 98 of the Criminal Code, which bans unlawful associations; intro-
duced following the Winnipeg General Strike of 1919; targeted organizations which advocate political
change through violent means; used to target the Communist Party in the 1920s and 1930s.
section and quarter section (block system) (ch 2): The system used by land surveyors to divide land
and property. One section is meant to be 1 mi (1.6 km) square.
818 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

secularism (ch 10): The separation of church and state; the belief that a modern state is best served by
individuals not directly associated with organized religion. See also anticlerical.
seigneurial system (ch 2) / seigneury (prologue): Used in New France; based on a feudal system in
which land was granted under a royalty system, and the tenant was responsible for farming the land to
meet their physical needs (food, heat, and shelter). This system was abolished in 1854.
Senate reform (ch 12): The upper house has been the subject of chronic criticism for decades. These
critiques intensified in the 1960s and especially in the 1980s. See also Triple-E Senate.
service sectors (ch 8): Those parts of the economy that support the financing, governing, feeding,
administering, training, and health of the rest of the economy and the population. Examples include gov-
ernment bureaucracy, education, restaurants, police, and financial services. Also called the tertiary sec-
tor, as distinct from the primary (resource extraction) and secondary (processing and manufacturing)
sectors.
sex ratio (ch 1): The ratio of men to women. A sex ratio of 2:1 indicates that there are two men for
every one woman.
sexual revolution (ch 9): A complex of social changes associated with the 1960s; loosening of moral
codes as regards premarital sex, illegitimacy, divorce and remarriage, pornography, and sex for pleasure
(as opposed to procreation).
Silicon Valley (ch 8): Term used to describe the concentration of high-technology industries in the Bay
Area of California, particularly after the 1970s.
Sinophobic (ch 5): Fear of China or Chinese.
sixties scoop (ch 11): The apprehension and removal of Aboriginal children from their families and
communities by provincial child welfare authorities during the 1960s.
sleeper agents (ch 9): Espionage agents who are deeply embedded in the host community and dormant,
awaiting activation.
slumming (ch 10): Colloquial for seeking recreation or entertainment in a locale that is associated with
a lower socio-economic class or different cultural group than ones own.
social control (ch 7): The regulation of social behaviour through direct (laws, policing) and indirect
(social pressure, moral suasion) means.
social credit (ch 7): Primarily an economic theory and monetary policy, developed in the 1920s and
touted as a solution to the Depression in Canada by Social Credit political parties.
social democratic (ch 7): A political movement that advocates reform that will achieve greater social
equality, a degree of socialist governance, and the preservation of democratic institutions. Associated
with the Cooperative Commonwealth Federation and New Democratic Party.
Social Gospel (ch 3): A social reform movement stimulated by Christian beliefs that linked personal
engagement with social salvation.
social hegemony (ch 10): Influence enjoyed by one social group over all others; dominance in tastes,
culture, and values, among other indicators.
social reformers (ch 7): Advocates of change at the social rather than individual level; associated
with 19th century social movements like the suffragettes, maternal feminism, and temperance agitation.
social mobility (ch 9): The movement of individuals, households, or communities through social hier-
archies; generally associated with upward mobility but downward is also a possibility.
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 819

sojourners (ch 5): Immigrants whose intent is to work for a period of time, accumulate savings, and
return to their home country (or province). Historically associated mostly with Chinese labourers who
were brought to Canada under contract to the Canadian Pacific Railway, for example.
Somalia Affair (ch 12): Political and military scandal arising from Canadian Airborne Regiments vio-
lent, arbitrary, and murderous behaviour which led to several civilian deaths (including the beating death
of Shidane Arone).
Sons of Freedom (ch 5): Or Freedomites; a radical anarchist faction within the Doukhobor diaspora in
Canada; broke away from the main settlements in Saskatchewan and resettled in southeastern British
Columbia; anti-materialist protests and anti-statism led to confrontations with the provincial government
in the 1920s, and 1950s-1960s.
space race (ch 9): Competition between the United States and the Soviet Union to establish a dominant
commercial, scientific, and military presence in near space; initiated with the launch of the Soviet satel-
lite, Sputnik I in 1957; marked by American determination to reach the moon first.
Space Shuttle (ch 9): A low orbit space craft developed by NASA in the 1970s and launched first in
1981; includes reusable sections and the craft is capable of reentry and a controlled surface landing on
return. Nine Canadians have flown in Space Shuttle missions.
Specials (ch 3): Volunteer police drawn from a local population; in the case of the Winnipeg General
Strike, the Specials were recruited from the Citizens Committee.
split labour market (ch 5): A labour market in which employers have the option of hiring cheaper
labour that is differentiated by race, ethnicity or, possibly, creed. Doing so improves profits and it will
embitter relations between the two labour supplies. Used as a theory (split labour market theory) to
explain racial divisions between workers.
Sputnik (ch 9): The first artificial satellite, launched by the Soviet Union on 4 October 1957; credited
with starting the space race between the USSR and the United States.
squirearchy (ch 3): Colloquial term used to describe the elite in colonial British Columbia.
stagflation (ch 8): Stagnant economic growth coupled with persistently high rates of inflation.
standing army (ch 3): A full-time, permanent, usually salaried army, as opposed to a volunteer militia.
staple economy, staples model (ch 8): The staples theory argues that an economy dominated by valu-
able and traditional commodities will be shaped in terms of the larger economy, the polity, and the
society by the needs and nature of the primary staple(s). Also a model for understanding the political
economy of a country in which staples are fundamental to the export economy. An approach developed
by historians Harold Innis and W. A. Mackintosh.
START (ch 12): Three Strategic Arms Reduction Treaties, the first of which was signed in 1991; com-
mitted the signatories the USSR and the United States to making substantial reductions in their
nuclear arsenals and delivery systems.
Status Indians (ch 6): A legal identity created in the Indian Act, 1876. The Act determines who is, in
law, an Indian and who is not for the purposes of government services, annuities, suffrage, etc.
strikebreakers (ch 3): Colloquial term for a worker who continues working, or who takes a job, while
a strike is ongoing. Also called a scab.
suburban, suburban sprawl (ch 9): The low density housing districts beyond the city limits; the
expansion of cities beyond their boundaries into bordering municipalities, creating low density and car-
dependent districts with few amenities other than housing.
820 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Suez crisis (ch 9): The 1956 invasion of Egypt by Israel, followed by France and Britain with the objec-
tive of seizing the Suez Canal. The failure of England and France to inform their former Allies espe-
cially the United States of their plans led to a rift between Britain and the USA in particular. Canadas
response, led by Lester Pearson, was to propose a large multi-national peacekeeping force in the region.
suffrage (ch 7): The right to vote in elections; associated strongly with womens suffrage.
superpower (ch 8): A leading economic and military power with a nuclear arsenal; a cold war era term
applied mainly to the USSR and the United States.
sweated labour (ch 3): Work that takes place over long hours; exhausting and generally poorly paid;
very often involves outwork, the taking home of materials that are assembled there, usually by female
employees, who are paid on the basis of output.
sympathy strike (ch 3): A labour stoppage by supportive workers who are not directly involved in a
dispute.
syndicalist (ch 3): Advocate of syndicalism, the belief that industry would be best run by syndicates
made up of industrial workers who would own and operate the factories themselves.
Taliban (ch 12): The fundamentalist Islamic regime in Afghanistan; deposed in 2001 following the
NATO invasion in response to 9/11.
tariff (ch 3): Charges (a tax) added to imported goods so as to make their sale price higher than domestic
goods and, thus, make domestic goods more competitive.
temperance (ch 3): One strand of the anti-liquor campaign in the 19th and 20th centuries, focussed on
the personal impact of alcohol and personal resolve in limiting or giving up drink. Contrast with prohi-
bition, which called for an all-out ban on the production, sale, and consumption of liquor.
Thalidomide (ch 9): A drug prescribed to pregnant women for morning sickness; available in Canada
from 1959 to 1962; resulted in catastrophic side effects, including severe disfigurement and defects in
more than 100 infants in Canada alone.
Thatcherism (ch 8): Simultaneously the approach taken by and leadership style of British Conservative
Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher, and the array of anti-trade union, pro-free market policies and eco-
nomic philosophies that were popular in the Conservative Party from the 1970s through the 1980s; con-
tains some elements of neo-liberalism and what has been described as Reaganomics.
third parties (ch 7): Political parties other than the Liberals and Conservatives; distinguished from
fourth or fringe parties by their more respectable showing at the polls. Principally, the CCF-NDP,
Social Credit, and Reform Party of Canada. The Bloc Qubcois occupies a special place in this respect
because it has enjoyed a large following and has formed the official opposition in Ottawa, but is not a
national party.
Thirteen Colonies of Britain (ch 1): The Atlantic Coast colonies established in the 17th and 18th cen-
turies; rebelled against British rule in 1775-83 and became the core elements of the United States.
Three Wise Men (ch 9): Les trois colombes, a term used mainly by commentators to describe the trio
of Jean Marchand, Gerard Pelletier, and Pierre Trudeau when they were recruited to the federal Liberal
Party in the 1960s.
tied housing (ch 3): In company towns, housing that is owned by the employer and provided to
employees. In some cases, residence in tied housing is a condition of employment, which enables the
employer to evict strikers during labour disputes.
total war (ch 3): Describes the engagement of the whole nation in conflict, and not just the military. In
the 20th century, applies only to the two World Wars.
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 821

Trades and Labour Congress of Canada (ch 3): A national association of craft unions modelled on the
American Federation of Labor; established in 1883 and merged with the Canadian Congress of Labour
(CCL) in 1956 to create the Canadian Labour Congress (CLC).
Treaty of Paris 1763: (ch 2): Ended the Seven Years War. France ceded all of its territory east of the
Mississippi to Britain (including all of Canada, Acadia, and le Royale) and granted Louisiana and lands
west of the Mississippi to its ally Spain. Britain returned to France the sugar islands of Guadeloupe.
France retained St. Pierre and Miquelon along with fishing rights on the Grand Banks.
trickle-down effect (ch 8): In neo-liberal economics, particularly Reaganomics, the idea that reducing
taxes on the wealthy and corporations will result in their increased profits trickling down to lower
socio-economic classes. Referred to also as free market economics and voodoo economics.
Triple-E Senate (ch 12): Call for reform of the upper house that would see it become elected, equal,
and efficient; a plank in the Reform Party platform since the 1980s.
truck shop (ch 3): An outlet owned by an employer, one that sells goods to employees of the same firm.
Commonplace in company towns. See also company store.
Trudeaumania (ch 9): Term used principally by journalists to describe public and media fascination
with Pierre Trudeau in the course of the 1968 Liberal leadership convention and then the general elec-
tion; alludes to the phenomenon of Beatlemania, associated with the British Invasion.
Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) (ch 11): A commission tasked in 2008 with document-
ing the full history of the residential schools; reported presented in 2015.
tuberculosis (TB) (ch 11): An epidemic associated with rapid urbanization, tenement housing, slums,
and poverty; spread rapidly in post-Confederation period, becoming epidemic among Aboriginal popu-
lations; tuberculosis sanatoria were established and operating across Canada until the 1960s, by which
time antibiotics (especially Streptomycin) had severely reduced the incidence and morbidity associated
with TB.
two founding nations (ch 9): The narrative of Canadian history that privileges the idea of the French
and British as co-equal founders of Canada; ignores roles played by Aboriginal nations and implicitly
reduces the importance of Canadians drawn from other ethnicities and countries; is at the heart of dual-
ism.
ultramontanist (ch 2): Elements in Catholicism that emphasize papal authority over secular authority
and, after 1870, papal infallibility. Seeks a large, extensive role for the church in daily life and objects
to the main features of modernity, especially the growth of the secular state. Although ultramontanism
faded in Europe after 1870, it remained a powerful force in Canada to the 1960s.
Union of BC Indian Chiefs (UBCIC) (ch 11): Established in 1969 in response to the Federal Govern-
ments White Paper; replaced rival coastal and interior groups.
unipolar (ch 12): Following on the collapse of multipolar global relations in the 1940s, and the subse-
quent age of bipolar superpowers, the unipolar era was defined by one superpower (the United States)
dominating global affairs.
United Church of Canada (ch 10): Created in 1925 as a result of a merger between three denomina-
tions: Congregationalist, Methodist, and Presbyterian. Some members of each denomination remained
outside of the United Church but it was, nonetheless, immediately the third largest denomination in
Canada.
United Nations (UN) (ch 9): An international body established in 1942; originally was the rough equiv-
alent of the Allied Nations in the Second World War; expanded to a post-war role in 1945 as an intergov-
822 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

ernmental assembly and series of agencies tasked with reducing international tensions and addressing
international social and economic crises.
universal adult suffrage (ch 3): Introduced a year after the partial franchise, to grant adults the right
to vote; however, select populations of women and men were explicitly left disenfranchised: Aboriginal
people, as well as Chinese, Japanese, and Indian immigrants.
Universal Health Care (ch 9): Provision of health insurance coverage to all members of society;
pioneered in German in the 1880s; similar programs appeared first in the British Commonwealth in
New Zealand (1939); in Canada, introduced first in Saskatchewan in 1962 and nationally in stages in
1966-72.
universal male suffrage (ch 3): Extension of the franchise the right to vote to all adult males.
In practice in Canada, it excluded non-Euro-Canadians (i.e. Aboriginal and Asian) adult males until the
mid-20th century. Also constrained by residency requirements until the mid-20th century.
U-boat (ch 6): German term for a submarine.
vagrancy (ch 11): The state of being without work or employment, homelessness, and (often) tran-
sience; associated with poverty and begging. Vagrancy was treated as a crime and was listed in the Crim-
inal Code until 1972. The 21st century has seen the return of anti-vagrancy laws with different names.
VE-Day (ch 8): Victory in Europe Day, 7 May 1945; marked the end of WWII in Europe.
vernacular (ch 10): In language, a local dialect; in design and cooking, styles developed in a specific
locale and which are, in the case of emigrants, transported to other locations intact where they are repro-
duced. Examples of indigenous vernacular include Canadien stone houses influenced by the pre-Con-
quest era and, among immigrants, Doukhobor communal housing.
vertical integration (ch 3): In economics and business, a system in which the whole or most of the sup-
ply chain is owned by the same individual(s) or firm. Early examples come from the steel industry which
in some cases controlled the production of coking coal, the supply of iron ore, foundries, and railways
that consumed the final product.
Veterans Charter (ch 9): Introduced in 1944; provided funds to enable the transition to civilian life of
Canadian troops; included free university education, payment for time served, life insurance, and money
for civilian clothes. The Charter also guaranteed that ex-servicemen and women could reclaim their for-
mer jobs, which had the effect of displacing women who had worked in industry during wartime.
Victoria Charter (1971) (ch 9): An agreement to patriate the British North America Act, which
included an amending formula, new civil, personal, and language rights, and provisions for regional
equalization; achieved agreement from nine provinces and narrowly failed to secure Quebecs approval
from Premier Robert Bourassa.
Victory Bonds (ch 6): Voluntary savings scheme originating in the Great War; purchasing 5 to 15 year
bonds was a means of lending funds to the federal government with which to conduct the war; paid back
with interest on their maturation.
V-J Day (ch 6): Victory in Japan Day, 15 August 1945; marked the end of the war against Japan and
thus the end of the Second World War.
Waffle (ch 7): A faction within the NDP in 1969-1971 that embraced left-wing nationalism, feminism,
and social activism, and called for an independent socialist Canada.
wage and price controls (ch 9): Introduced as part of the Anti-Inflation Act, 1975 as a response to an
inflation rate approaching 11%; marked the beginning of a move away from the post-war settlement in
 APPENDIX: GLOSSARY 823

that it established new restrictions on organized labour. The controls and the Anti-Inflation Board were
dismantled in 1978.
war brides (ch 5): At the end of both World Wars, European women principally British who mar-
ried Canadian servicemen and relocated to Canada when their husbands returned home.
war crime trials (ch 5): Internationally-convened trials to address allegations of crimes against human-
ity including (but not limited to) murder of civilian populations and enslavement.
War in the Woods (ch 7): 1992-1996; a series of mass protests against logging in old growth forests in
British Columbia.
War on Terror (ch 12): Initially a military campaign launched against non-state organizations respon-
sible for targeted attacks on American bases or civilians; after 9/11 included military attacks on regimes
supportive of organizations regarded as terrorist; conducted by a broad alliance of nations predomi-
nantly in the West.
welfare state (ch 10): Initiatives taken on a large scale on the part of government to provide the pop-
ulation with payments or services that ameliorate the worst effects of economic or social dislocation.
Sometimes called a social safety net.
western alienation (ch 8): The growing sense from the mid-20th century of the four western provinces
that Canadian political machinery and culture favoured Ontario and Quebec and that federal economic
policies were devised to favour central Canada over the West.
Westminster (ch 1): Refers to the seat of British parliamentary government in Westminster, London.
wheat boom (ch 3): An expanding demand for wheat leading to a rapid expansion of farmland dedi-
cated to wheat production; in Canada from ca. 1880-1914.
wheat pools (ch 11): Typically cooperatives made up of grain growers who combined (pooled) their
output and risk so as to reduce competition and overheads while securing the best price; replaced
temporarily by the Canadian Wheat Board in 1935; competed against private grain elevators in the post-
war era.
white dominions(ch 3): Former British colonies dominated by a European population or elite; includes
Canada, Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, and Newfoundland to ca. 1934-1949.
white flight (ch 9): Colloquial term for the migration of middle and working class European-Canadians
from declining and multi-ethnic city centres for the suburbs; associated earlier in the United States with
racial tensions in cities and more homogeneously Euro-American suburbs.
White Paper (ch 11): Also known as The Statement of the Government of Canada on Indian Policy,
1969; proposed the dismantling of the Indian Act, an effective end to Indian Status, and the conversion
of reserve land to private property; introduced by the Liberal government of Pierre Trudeau and led
by the Minister of Justice, Jean Chrtien; met with strident opposition from Aboriginal leaders, part of
which took the form of the Red Paper.
wildcat strikes (ch 8): Labour disputes launched by workers without the authorization or permission
of the union leadership; an unofficial strike that does not follow the established procedures for taking
industrial action.
Winnipeg Declaration (ch 7): Fully, the 1956 Winnipeg Declaration of Principles of the Co-operative
Commonwealth Federation; replaced the Regina Manifesto; significant in that it moved the party away
from socialism and closer to democratic socialism and a pro-union position; made possible the align-
ment of the CCF with the CLC very soon after.
witch hunts (ch 9): Colloquial term used to describe security campaigns conducted in capitalist democ-
824 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

racies during the Cold War which targeted, mainly, communists but also homosexuals and any other
group regarded as potential seditious.
Womens Christian Temperance Union (WCTU) (ch 3): One of the largest and most effective anti-
drink lobbies in Canada. Established in 1874, months after its first branch was announced in the United
States, the WCTU emerged as a vehicle for contiguous reforms in public behaviour, the political envi-
ronment, and social conditions.
Womens Liberation Movement (ch 7): Both an informal and loose organization of various womens
advocacy and political groups, and an alternative term for second wave feminism; first appeared in 1968.
Womens Royal Canadian Naval Service (WRCNS): Last of the womens corps to be established;
founded in 1942, it was disbanded in 1946 and reformed as a reserve force during the Korean War.
World Bank (ch 8): Created at Bretton Woods in 1944 to work with the International Monetary Fund
to reinvigorate post-war economies. Dominated by the United States, it was used also as an instrument
to reduce communist influence in western Europe.
world music (ch 9): An umbrella term used to describe mostly non-European, non-North American
styles of music, including indigenous and hybridized form. The term is problematic in that it includes
essentially everything while, at the same time, implicitly otherizing anything that is not North American
mainstream.
Worlds Fair (ch 8): Alternatively, World Exposition, hence Expo; first organized in the mid-19th
century to showcase industrial and technological advances; the first Expo was hosted in Canada in
1967 at Montreal, by which time the fairs were more about national showcases and culture; Canadas
only other Expo was held in Vancouver in 1986.
World Wide Web (ch 8): A network of information connected via the Internet; emerged in the late
1980s.
Yale Convention (ch 2): Meeting between British Columbian delegates to determine the colonys
demands as regards joining Confederation.
Yippie (Youth International Party) (ch 9): Countercultural youth movement originating in the United
States in 1967; combined anarchist views with environmentalist perspectives.
Young Womens Christian Association (YWCA) (ch 7): Originated in Britain in 1855 as a faith-based
organization in support of the first generations of women in urban industrial settings; first Canadian
chapter established in Saint John in 1870.
About the Author and Contributors

John Douglas Belshaw, Ph.D. has a long connection with Thompson Rivers University as a History professor
and is now a faculty member in the Open Learning Division. He is also a consultant to the post-secondary sector
and a writer. Belshaw has authored, co-authored, and edited several articles and books on the history of British
Columbia.

Contributing Historians
Robin Anderson, M.A., Department of History, University of the Fraser Valley

Kelly Black, M.A., Department of History, Vancouver Island University

Tina Block, Ph.D., Department of Philosophy, History & Politics, Thompson Rivers University

John Bonnett, Ph.D., Department of History, Brock University

Melanie Buddle, Ph.D., Department of History, Trent University

Lisa Chilton, Ph.D., Department of History, University of Prince Edward Island

825
826 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Chris Clarkson, Ph.D., Department of History, Okanagan College

Michael Dawson, Ph.D., Department of History, St. Thomas University

Lisa Dillon, Ph.D., Dpartement de Dmographie, Universit de Montral

Christopher Dummitt, Ph.D., School for the Study of Canada, Trent University

Norm Fennema, Ph.D., Department of History, University of Victoria

Russell Field, Ph.D., Faculty of Kinesiology and Recreation Management, University of Manitoba

Nancy M. Forestell, Ph.D., Department of History, St. Francis Xavier University

Alan Gordon, Ph.D., Department of History, University of Guelph

Esyllt Jones, Ph.D., Department of History, University of Manitoba

Mary-Ellen Kelm, Ph.D., Department of History, Simon Fraser University

Tracy Penny Light, Ph.D., Department of Philosophy, History & Politics, Thompson Rivers University

Peter McInnis, Ph.D., Department of History, St. Francis Xavier University

Ian Milligan, Ph.D., Department of History, University of Waterloo

Doug Owram, Ph.D., Department of History, University of British Columbia Okanagan

Adele Perry, Ph.D., Department of History, University of Manitoba

Jennifer Pettit, Ph.D., Department of Humanities, Mount Royal University

Katharine Rollwagen, Ph.D., Department of History, Vancouver Island University

Robert Rutherdale, Ph.D., Department of History & Philosophy, Algoma University

Eric Sager, Ph.D., Department of History, University of Victoria

Daniel Samson, Ph.D., Department of History, Brock University

R. Scott Sheffield, Ph.D., Department of History, University of the Fraser Valley

Jonathan Swainger, PhD., Department of History, University of Northern British Columbia

Georgia Sitara, Ph.D., Department of History, University of Victoria

Keith Smith, Ph.D., Departments of History and First Nations Studies, Vancouver Island University

Katrina Srigley, Ph.D., Department of History, Nipissing University

Jordan Stanger-Ross, Ph.D., Department of History, University of Victoria

 ABOUT THE AUTHOR AND CONTRIBUTORS 827

Timothy J. Stanley, Ph.D., Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa

Pamela Sugiman, Ph.D., Department of Sociology, Ryerson University

Robert Sweeny, Ph.D., Department of History, Memorial University of Newfoundland

Sharon Wall, Ph.D., Department of History, University of Winnipeg

Miriam Wright, Ph.D., Department of History, University of Windsor

Other Books by John Douglas Belshaw

Canadian History: Pre-Confederation (Vancouver: BCcampus, 2015).

Vancouver Confidential, editor and author (Vancouver: Anvil Press, 2014).

Vancouver Noir: 1930-1960, with Diane Purvey (Vancouver: Anvil Press, 2011).

Becoming British Columbia: A Population History (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2009).

Private Grief, Public Mourning: The Rise of the Roadside Shrine in British Columbia, with Diane Purvey (Van-
couver: Anvil Press, 2009).

Colonization and Community: The Vancouver Island Coalfield and the Making of the British Columbia Working
Class (Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press, 2002).

828
Versioning History

This page provides a record of edits and changes made to this book since its initial publication in the BC Open
Textbook Collection. Whenever edits or updates are made, we make the required changes in the text and provide
a record and description of those changes here. If the change is minor, the version number increases by 0.1. How-
ever, if the edits involve substantial updates, the version number goes up to the next full number. The files on our
website always reflect the most recent version, including the Print on Demand copy.

If you find an error in this book, please fill out the Report an Open Textbook Error form. If the book was produced
in partnership with BCcampus, we will contact the author, make the necessary changes, and replace all file types
as soon as possible. If we did not produce the book, we will make note of the error on this page and contact the
original producer of the textbook. Once we receive the updated files, this Versioning History page will be updated
to reflect the edits made.

829
830 CANADIAN HISTORY: POST-CONFEDERATION

Version Date Change Details

Book added to
May 17, the BC Open
1.1
2016 Textbook Col-
lection.
Section 12.13: The quote You may be through with history, but history is not
through with you. had been incorrectly attributed to John Belshaw in a footnote.
Removed an
That footnote was removed.
incorrect foot-
May 25,
1.2 note and fixed
2016 Section 4.3: Macdonald did what generations of 70-somethings would do from
a capitalization
error. the 1880s to the present: He booked a railway tour. The capital H in He was
changed to a lowercase.

Removed a Section 5.12: Figure 5.24 appeared both in this section and in Section 5.11, but
June 28,
1.3 duplicate with different captions. The image in the previous section was removed and their
2016
image. captions combined in Figure 5.24.

Section 7.12: Original: If two ride a horse, one must ride in front: Married
Womens Nationality and the Law in Canada 1880-1950,
July 29, Fixed a cita-
1.4
2016 tion. Changed to: If two ride a horse, one must ride in front': Married Womens
Nationality and the Law in Canada 1880-1950,

Section 8.18: In the same decade, processes enabled changed to In the Same
decade, new processes enabled..

Section 9.1: could remember World War II almost as clearly as World War
II. The first World War II changed to World War I.
Fixed a number
August
1.5 of wording Section 9.1: a turning point that overturned changed to a turning point
31, 2016
errors. that toppled

Section 9.13: Removed the comma after the and in An African-Canadian neigh-
bourhood in Vancouver and, in Winnipegs Rooster Town, a Mtis community,
were both cleared

Section 11.3: The significant Mtis presence in the West almost disappeared
changed to The significant Mtis presence in the West was almost over-
whelmed
September Fixed errors in
1.6 Section 11.3: The ongoing Mtis relationship with the Catholic Church and allies
25, 2016 wording.
in Quebec, however, provided allies. changed to The ongoing Mtis relation-
ship with the Catholic Church and allies in Quebec, however, was both fortuitous
and a strategy for survival in the emergent Canadian nation.

Section 10.8: Chinatowns, like the one in Vancouver (the largest in Canada) in its
September Fixed an error
1.7 early years changed to Chinatowns, like Vancouvers (the largest in Canada),
28, 2016 in wording.