Audit Control Best Practices
Audit Control Best Practices
INTRODUCTION
The document is a set of best practices and is not intended to represent either an all-encompassing list of controls or
the only controls that should be considered in performing an audit. This document may be used as a guide to assist
users to identify control activities that may address, individually or in combination, a control objective. As part of
considering the design of a control activity for a specific engagement, the practitioner should challenge the
appropriateness of the default coverage level, which is a suggestion rather than an absolute state, given the particular
circumstances for that engagement (e.g., the rigor with which a control activity is performed, the qualifications of the
individuals performing the control activity). This document is divided into two sections. The first section relates to
Segregation of Duties and the second section to Control Activities. The two sections are organized by business cycle.
The control objectives related to a business cycle are grouped together with each relevant best practice control activity.
The following are the account balances which are addressed by each of the Business Cycle:
1
Cost of Sales Receiving and storing raw materials
Requisitioning materials
Producing/costing inventory
Handling finished products
Shipping finished products
Maintaining inventory master file
Payroll and Personnel Cycle Salary Expense Hiring personnel
Wages Expense Terminating personnel
Payroll Related Expenses Recording time
Payroll Related Accruals Calculating payroll
Payroll Related Provisions Disbursing payroll
Maintaining payroll master file
Revenue Cycle Sales Managing and processing orders
Receivables Invoicing, sales returns and adjustments
Processing cash receipts
Maintaining customer master files
Treasury Cycle Notes Payable, Long-Term Debt Borrowing
Investments/Derivatives Managing cash and investments
Off-balance Sheet Derivative Transactions Managing derivative transactions
Investment Income
Interest Expense
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION..................................................................................................1
TABLE OF CONTENTS........................................................................................3
MATRIX OF CONTROL OBJECTIVES..................................................................
EXPENDITURE CYCLE...................................................................................4
FIXED ASSET CYCLE.....................................................................................5
INVENTORY MANAGEMENT..........................................................................6
PAYROLL AND PERSONNEL..........................................................................7
REVENUE CYCLE...........................................................................................8
TREASURY CYCLE.........................................................................................9
CONTROL ACTIVITIES..........................................................................................
EXPENDITURE CYCLE ...............................................................................11
FIXED ASSET CYCLE...................................................................................14
INVENTORY MANAGEMENT........................................................................18
PAYROLL AND PERSONNEL........................................................................22
REVENUE CYCLE.........................................................................................24
TREASURY CYCLE.......................................................................................27
3
Matrix of control objectivcs
4
Matrix of control objectivcs
5
Matrix of control objectivcs
INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
ACCOUNT BALANCES Inventory Cost of Sales
CONTROL OBJECTIVES
MANAGING INVENTORY
Inventory is salable or usable. Valuation &
allocation
Inventory is adequately safeguarded. Rights &
Obligations
Adjustments to inventory prices or quantities relate to valid price changes and Occurrence Occurrence
physical inventory differences. Completeness Completeness
Accuracy Accuracy
Adjustments to inventory prices or quantities are recorded timely and in the Cutoff Cutoff
appropriate period.
Adjustments to inventory prices or quantities are recorded accurately. Accuracy Accuracy
Inventory reflects the existing business circumstances and economic conditions in Valuation &
accordance with the accounting policies being used. allocation
Financial information is appropriately presented, and all information that is Classification
necessary for fair presentation and compliance with professional standards or legal
requirements is disclosed.
RECEIVING AND STORING RAW MATERIALS
Raw materials are received and accepted only if they have valid purchase orders. Occurrence
Raw materials received are recorded accurately. Accuracy Accuracy
All raw materials received are recorded. Completeness Completeness
Receipts of raw materials are recorded timely and in the appropriate period. Cutoff Cutoff
REQUISITIONING MATERIALS
All transfers of raw materials to production are recorded accurately and in the Accuracy Accuracy
appropriate period. Cutoff Cutoff
Completeness
PRODUCING/COSTING INVENTORY
All recorded production costs are consistent with actual direct and indirect expenses Occurrence Occurrence
associated with production. Accuracy Accuracy
All direct and indirect expenses associated with production are recorded as Completeness Completeness
production costs. Accuracy Accuracy
All direct and indirect expenses associated with production are recorded accurately Cutoff Cutoff
and in the appropriate period.
All transfers of completed units of production to finished goods inventory are Accuracy Accuracy
recorded completely and accurately in the appropriate period. Completeness Completeness
All defective products and scrap resulting from the production process are valid and Accuracy Accuracy
recorded completely and accurately in the appropriate period. Completeness Completeness
Cutoff Cutoff
Occurrence Occurrence
HANDLING FINISHED PRODUCTS
Finished goods received from production and/or returned from customers are Accuracy Accuracy
recorded completely and accurately in the appropriate period. Completeness Completeness
Cutoff Cutoff
Goods received from production or returned by customers are only accepted in Existence
accordance with the organization’s policies.
SHIPPING FINISHED PRODUCTS
All shipments are recorded. Occurrence Occurrence
Shipments are recorded accurately. Accuracy Accuracy
Shipments are recorded timely and in the appropriate period. Cutoff Cutoff
Inventory is relieved only when goods are shipped with approved customer orders. Completeness Completeness
Costs of shipped inventory are transferred from inventory to cost of sales. Occurrence Completeness
Costs of shipped inventory are recorded accurately. Accuracy Accuracy
Amounts posted to cost of sales represent those associated with shipped inventory. Completeness Occurrence
Costs of shipped inventory are transferred from inventory to cost of sales timely and Cutoff Cutoff`
in the appropriate period.
MAINTAINING INVENTORY MASTER FILE
All valid changes to the inventory management master file are input and processed. Existence Existence
Completeness Completeness
Changes to the inventory management master file are accurate. Accuracy Accuracy
Inventory management master file remains pertinent. Completeness Completeness
Existence Existence
6
Matrix of control objectivcs
7
Matrix of control objectivcs
REVENUE CYCLE
ACCOUNT BALANCES Sales Receivables
CONTROL OBJECTIVES
Managing and Processing Orders
Orders are only processed within approved customer credit limits. Valuation &
allocation
Orders are approved by management as to prices and terms of sale. Occurrence Occurrence
Orders and cancellations of orders are input accurately. Accuracy Accuracy
Order entry data is transferred completely and accurately to the shipping Accuracy Accuracy
and invoicing activities. Completeness Completeness
All orders received from customers are input and processed. Completeness Completeness
Only valid orders are input and processed. Occurrence Occurrence
Invoicing, Sales Returns and Adjustments
Invoices are generated using authorized terms and prices. Accuracy Accuracy
Invoices are accurately calculated and recorded. Accuracy Accuracy
Credit notes and adjustments to accounts receivable are accurately Accuracy Accuracy
calculated and recorded.
All goods shipped are invoiced. Completeness Completeness
Credit notes for all goods returned and adjustments to accounts receivable Existence Existence
are issued in accordance with organization policy.
Invoices relate to valid shipments. Occurrence Occurrence
All credit notes relate to a return of goods or other valid adjustments. Completeness Completeness
All invoices issued are recorded. Completeness Completeness
All credit notes issued are recorded. Occurrence Occurrence
Invoices are recorded in the appropriate period. Cutoff Cutoff
Credit notes issued are recorded in the appropriate period. Cutoff Cutoff
Accounts Receivable reflect the existing business circumstances and Valuation &
economic conditions in accordance with the accounting policies being allocation
used.
Sales and Accounts Receivable information is appropriately presented, Classification Classification
and all information that is necessary for fair presentation and compliance
with professional standards or legal requirements is disclosed.
Processing Cash Receipts
Cash receipts are recorded in the period in which they are received. Cutoff
Cash receipts data is entered for processing accurately. Accuracy
All cash receipts data is entered for processing. Occurrence
Cash receipts data is valid and is entered for processing only once. Completeness
Cash discounts are accurately calculated and recorded Accuracy Accuracy
Timely collection of accounts receivable is monitored. Valuation &
allocation
Maintaining Customer Master File
All valid changes to the customer master file are input and processed. Completeness Completeness
Existence Existence
Changes to the customer master file are accurate. Accuracy Accuracy
Customer master file data remains pertinent. Completeness Completeness
Existence Existence
8
Matrix of control objectivcs
TREASURY CYCLE
ACCOUNT BALANCES Notes Payable, Investments/ Off-balance sheet Investment
Long-Term Derivatives Derivative Income Interest
Debt Transactions Expense
CONTROL OBJECTIVES
BORROWING
Recorded debt represents a valid liability of the Rights &
organization. Obligations
Borrowings are recorded accurately as to Accuracy
amounts and terms.
All borrowings are recorded. Completeness
Borrowings are recorded in the appropriate Cutoff
period.
All interest is accurately calculated and recorded Completeness
in the appropriate period. Occurrence
Accuracy
Cutoff
Recorded loan repayments are valid. Completeness
Loan repayments are accurately recorded. Accuracy
All loan repayments are recorded. Occurrence
9
Matrix of control objectivcs
10
Control Activities - Expenditure
PURCHASING
Purchase orders are placed only for approved requisitions.
Management must approve all purchase orders, with higher level management authority required for unusual
purchases (such as capital outlays or standing orders) and all purchases that exceed established limits. Board
approval is required for specified types of purchases and this approval is appropriately documented.
Purchase orders are reviewed and approved by management prior to mailing to the supplier.
Purchase orders are entered accurately.
Purchase order entry data is compared to source documents by individuals who are independent of the purchase
order entry process.
Purchase orders are batched and batch input is balanced; out-of-balance batches are corrected promptly.
Purchase order data is edited and validated; identified errors are corrected promptly.
All purchase orders issued are input and processed.
Purchase orders are sequentially prenumbered. The sequence of purchase orders processed is accounted for.
Purchase orders are batched and batch input is balanced; out-of-balance batches are corrected promptly.
Purchase requisitioning, purchasing, inventory management, and accounts payable functions are performed by an
integrated application system. The general ledger is automatically updated for receipt and disbursement
transactions.
11
Control Activities - Expenditure
Goods received at, before, or after the end of an accounting period are scrutinized and/or reconciled to ensure
complete and consistent recording in the appropriate period.
Accounts payable are only adjusted for valid reasons.
Statements received from suppliers are reconciled to the supplier accounts in the accounts payable subledger
regularly and differences are investigated.
Management reviews and approves credit notes and adjustments prior to posting to accounts payable.
Electronic queues are used by management to approve credit notes and adjustments; access to the queues is
restricted by logical security.
Management reviews all recorded nonsystematic debits to accounts payable.
Credit notes and other adjustments are accurately calculated and recorded.
Statements received from suppliers are reconciled to the supplier accounts in the accounts payable subledger
regularly and differences are investigated.
Invoices, credit notes, and other adjustments related to accounts payable are batched and batch input data is
balanced; out-of-balance batches are corrected promptly.
All valid credit notes and other adjustments related to accounts payable are input and
processed.
Statements received from suppliers are reconciled to the supplier accounts in the accounts payable subledger
regularly and differences are investigated.
Invoices, credit notes, and other adjustments related to accounts payable are batched and batch input data is
balanced; out-of-balance batches are corrected promptly.
Goods returned notes are matched to credit notes; differences are investigated promptly.
Goods returned notes are sequentially prenumbered. The sequence of goods returned notes is accounted for and
long outstanding unmatched goods returned notes are reviewed and investigated.
Credit notes and other adjustments are recorded in the appropriate period.
Statements received from suppliers are reconciled to the supplier accounts in the accounts payable subledger
regularly and differences are investigated.
Supplier invoices and credit notes received at, before, or after the end of an accounting period are scrutinized and/or
reconciled to ensure complete and consistent recording in the appropriate period.
Goods returned at, before, or after the end of an accounting period are scrutinized and/or reconciled to ensure
complete and consistent recording in the appropriate period.
PROCESSING DISBURSEMENTS
Disbursements are only made for goods and services received.
Actual expenditures are compared to budget regularly; management reviews and approves significant variances.
Management reviews supporting documentation before approving payments. Supporting documentation is
canceled once payment is made.
Management reviews a listing of supplier payments prior to release.
Disbursements are distributed to the appropriate suppliers.
Checks are restrictively endorsed by the preparer to ensure that they are paid to the specified payee.
Management reviews supporting documentation before approving payments. Supporting documentation is
canceled once payment is made.
Management reviews a listing of supplier payments prior to release.
Disbursements are accurately calculated and recorded.
Statements received from suppliers are reconciled to the supplier accounts in the accounts payable subledger
regularly and differences are investigated.
Actual expenditures are compared to budget regularly; management reviews and approves significant variances.
Management reviews supporting documentation before approving payments. Supporting documentation is
canceled once payment is made.
Payment batch input data is balanced; identified errors are corrected promptly.
Disbursement input data is edited and validated; identified errors are corrected promptly.
All disbursements are recorded.
Statements received from suppliers are reconciled to the supplier accounts in the accounts payable subledger
regularly and differences are investigated.
Bank statements are reconciled to the general ledger regularly.
Management reviews an aged accounts payable analysis and investigates any unusual items.
Checks are sequentially prenumbered; the sequence of checks processed is accounted for. Spoiled checks are
voided to prevent reuse and filed for subsequent inspection.
Disbursements are recorded in the period in which they are issued.
Bank statements are reconciled to the general ledger regularly.
12
Control Activities - Expenditure
Disbursements at, before, or after the end of an accounting period are scrutinized to ensure complete and
consistent recording in the appropriate accounting period.
MAINTAINING SUPPLIER MASTER FILE
All valid changes to the supplier master file are input and processed.
Supplier master file data is periodically reviewed by management for accuracy and ongoing pertinence.
Requests to change the supplier master file data are logged; the log is reviewed to ensure that all requested
changes are processed timely.
Requests to change the supplier master file data are submitted on prenumbered forms; the numerical sequence of
such forms is accounted for to ensure that all requested changes are processed timely.
Changes to the supplier master file are accurate.
Supplier master file data is periodically reviewed by management for accuracy and ongoing pertinence.
Recorded changes to the supplier master file are compared to authorized source documents to ensure that they
were input accurately.
Supplier master file data is edited and validated; identified errors are corrected promptly.
Supplier master file data remains pertinent.
Supplier master file data is periodically reviewed by management for accuracy and ongoing pertinence.
Suppliers that have not been used for a significant period of time are reviewed and marked for deletion by the
application, if appropriate.
13
Control Activities – Fixed Assets
14
Control Activities – Fixed Assets
Management monitors compliance with all significant policies concerning fixed assets. All exceptions to fixed
asset policies and procedures noted are raised to the appropriate level within the entity and pursued to proper
resolution.
Depreciation charges are accurately calculated and recorded.
The balances in fixed assets and accumulated depreciation are rolled forward from one processing cycle to the
next using independently obtained asset acquisition, asset disposal, and depreciation expense data.
Depreciation is independently recalculated.
Standard programmed algorithms perform depreciation calculations.
Depreciation exception items (in terms of expectations established by management) are consistently identified,
monitored, and corrected.
All depreciation charges are recorded in the appropriate period.
The balances in fixed assets and accumulated depreciation are rolled forward from one processing cycle to the
next using independently obtained asset acquisition, asset disposal, and depreciation expense data.
Depreciation is independently recalculated.
Depreciation charges are reviewed by management, including consideration of the recording of such charges in
the appropriate accounting period.
Depreciation exception items (in terms of expectations established by management) are consistently identified,
monitored, and corrected.
DISPOSING OF FIXED ASSETS
Recorded fixed asset disposals represent actual disposals.
The fixed asset register and/or master file data are periodically reviewed by management for accuracy and
ongoing pertinence and are reconciled to the corresponding general ledger accounts. Any reconciling items are
identified and addressed in a timely manner.
Activity recorded in the lease register, fixed asset register, and/or fixed asset master file is reviewed by
management, including comparison to the capital expenditure budget.
Periodic counts of fixed assets are performed and reconciled to the fixed asset register and/or master file.
Recorded changes to the fixed asset register and/or master file are compared to authorized source documents to
ensure that they were input accurately.
All recorded disposals of fixed assets are approved by management.
All fixed asset disposals are recorded.
The fixed asset register and/or master file data are periodically reviewed by management for accuracy and
ongoing pertinence and are reconciled to the corresponding general ledger accounts. Any reconciling items are
identified and addressed in a timely manner.
Activity recorded in the lease register, fixed asset register, and/or fixed asset master file is reviewed by
management, including comparison to the capital expenditure budget.
Periodic counts of fixed assets are performed and reconciled to the fixed asset register and/or master file.
Requests to change the fixed asset register and/or master file data are logged; the log is reviewed to ensure that
all requested changes are processed timely.
Requests to change the fixed asset register and/or master file data are submitted on prenumbered forms; the
numerical sequence of such forms is accounted for to ensure that all requested changes are processed timely.
All authorized source documents supporting fixed asset acquisitions, disposals, and other changes to the fixed
asset register and/or master file data are compared to the fixed asset register and/or master file to ensure they
were input.
Fixed asset disposals are accurately calculated and recorded.
The fixed asset register and/or master file data are periodically reviewed by management for accuracy and
ongoing pertinence and are reconciled to the corresponding general ledger accounts. Any reconciling items are
identified and addressed in a timely manner.
Activity recorded in the lease register, fixed asset register, and/or fixed asset master file is reviewed by
management, including comparison to the capital expenditure budget.
Periodic counts of fixed assets are performed and reconciled to the fixed asset register and/or master file.
Recorded changes to the fixed asset register and/or master file are compared to authorized source documents to
ensure that they were input accurately.
The balances in fixed assets and accumulated depreciation are rolled forward from one processing cycle to the
next using independently obtained asset acquisition, asset disposal, and depreciation expense data.
Standard programmed algorithms perform the calculation of the profit or loss upon disposal of an asset.
The profit or loss upon disposal of an asset is independently recalculated.
Asset-related transactions affecting the fixed asset register and/or master file are edited and validated; identified
errors are corrected promptly.
Fixed asset disposals are recorded in the appropriate period.
15
Control Activities – Fixed Assets
Requests to change the fixed asset register and/or master file data are logged; the log is reviewed to ensure that
all requested changes are processed timely.
Requests to change the fixed asset register and/or master file data are submitted on prenumbered forms; the
numerical sequence of such forms is accounted for to ensure that all requested changes are processed timely.
Asset-related transactions at, before, or after the end of an accounting period are scrutinized and/or reconciled to
ensure complete and consistent recording in the appropriate accounting period.
MANAGING FIXED ASSETS
Records of fixed asset maintenance activity are accurately maintained.
Asset maintenance schedules are prepared, updated, and monitored by management and activity per the asset
maintenance schedule is reconciled to the asset maintenance history register regularly.
Management periodically reviews asset maintenance activities, per the asset maintenance history register, to
ensure compliance with management's objectives.
Changes to the asset maintenance history register are compared to source documents to ensure that they were
input accurately.
Asset maintenance activities are edited and validated upon data entry; exceptions are investigated and resolved.
Fixed assets are adequately safeguarded.
Fixed assets are located in an appropriately secured area where access is restricted to authorized personnel.
Security personnel monitor all incoming and outgoing vehicles and ensure all goods leaving the premises are
accompanied by duly completed documentation.
Prenumbered identification tags are attached to fixed assets on acquisition to facilitate accurate identification of
assets and recording of details.
Management monitors compliance with all significant policies concerning fixed assets. All exceptions to fixed
asset policies and procedures noted are raised to the appropriate level within the entity and pursued to proper
resolution.
Fixed asset maintenance records are updated timely.
Asset maintenance schedules are prepared, updated, and monitored by management and activity per the asset
maintenance schedule is reconciled to the asset maintenance history register regularly.
Management periodically reviews asset maintenance activities, per the asset maintenance history register, to
ensure compliance with management's objectives.
Maintenance activity is recorded on prenumbered sheets/work orders; numerical sequence of such forms is
accounted for.
Fixed assets reflect the existing business circumstances and economic conditions in accordance
with the accounting policies being used.
Management periodically reviews the valuations and/or realizability of fixed assets to identify permanent
impairments and to properly record such.
MAINTAINING FIXED ASSET REGISTER AND/OR MASTER FILE
All valid changes to the fixed asset register and/or master file are input and processed.
The fixed asset register and/or master file data are periodically reviewed by management for accuracy
and ongoing pertinence and are reconciled to the corresponding general ledger accounts. Any
reconciling items are identified and addressed in a timely manner.
Activity recorded in the lease register, fixed asset register, and/or fixed asset master file is reviewed by
management, including comparison to the capital expenditure budget.
Requests to change the fixed asset register and/or master file data are logged; the log is reviewed to
ensure that all requested changes are processed timely.
Requests to change the fixed asset register and/or master file data are submitted on prenumbered
forms; the numerical sequence of such forms is accounted for to ensure that all requested changes are
processed timely.
All authorized source documents supporting fixed asset acquisitions, disposals, and other changes to
the fixed asset register and/or master file data are compared to the fixed asset register and/or master
file to ensure they were input.
Periodic counts of fixed assets are performed and reconciled to the fixed asset register and/or master
file.
Changes to the fixed asset register and/or master file are accurate.
The fixed asset register and/or master file data are periodically reviewed by management for accuracy
and ongoing pertinence and are reconciled to the corresponding general ledger accounts. Any
reconciling items are identified and addressed in a timely manner.
Activity recorded in the lease register, fixed asset register, and/or fixed asset master file is reviewed by
management, including comparison to the capital expenditure budget.
16
Control Activities – Fixed Assets
The balances in fixed assets and accumulated depreciation are rolled forward from one processing
cycle to the next using independently obtained asset acquisition, asset disposal, and depreciation
expense data.
Recorded changes to the fixed asset register and/or master file are compared to authorized source
documents to ensure that they were input accurately.
Periodic counts of fixed assets are performed and reconciled to the fixed asset register and/or master
file.
Asset-related transactions affecting the fixed asset register and/or master file are edited and validated;
identified errors are corrected promptly.
Fixed asset register and/or master file data remains pertinent.
The fixed asset register and/or master file data are periodically reviewed by management for accuracy
and ongoing pertinence and are reconciled to the corresponding general ledger accounts. Any
reconciling items are identified and addressed in a timely manner.
17
Control Activities – Inventory Management
18
Control Activities – Inventory Management
Goods received are logged; the log is reconciled to receipts input to the inventory management system that is
used to record movements of inventory in the financial records.
Goods received are matched on-line or manually with purchase order details and/or invoices; long outstanding
goods receipt notes, purchase orders, and/or invoices are investigated timely and accrued as appropriate;
documents are canceled once matched or on payment of the invoice to prevent reuse.
Management reviews recorded purchases (receipts of goods) based on its knowledge of day-to-day activity.
Goods receipt vouchers (proof-of-delivery documentation) are prenumbered; the sequence of such vouchers is
accounted for.
Supplier statements are reconciled to goods receipt records regularly.
Invoices not matched to goods receipt notes (or other appropriate supporting documentation for services received)
are investigated; payments on unmatched invoices require specific management approval.
Receipts of raw materials are recorded timely and in the appropriate period.
Physical inventory is counted periodically by persons independent of day-to-day custody or recording of inventory.
Inventory counts are reconciled to inventory records and inventory records are reconciled to the general ledger.
Goods received are logged; the log is reconciled to receipts input to the inventory management system that is
used to record movements of inventory in the financial records.
Goods received are matched on-line or manually with purchase order details and/or invoices; long outstanding
goods receipt notes, purchase orders, and/or invoices are investigated timely and accrued as appropriate;
documents are canceled once matched or on payment of the invoice to prevent reuse.
Management reviews recorded purchases (receipts of goods) based on its knowledge of day-to-day activity.
Goods receipt vouchers (proof-of-delivery documentation) are prenumbered; the sequence of such vouchers is
accounted for.
Goods received at, before, or after the end of an accounting period are scrutinized and/or reconciled to ensure
complete and consistent recording in the appropriate period.
Supplier invoices and credit notes received at, before, or after the end of an accounting period are scrutinized
and/or reconciled to ensure complete and consistent recording in the appropriate period.
REQUISITIONING MATERIALS
All transfers of raw materials to production are recorded accurately and in the appropriate
period.
Physical inventory is counted periodically by persons independent of day-to-day custody or recording of inventory.
Inventory counts are reconciled to inventory records and inventory records are reconciled to the general ledger.
Inventories received, including transfers, are counted and compared to receipt or transfer documentation that is
used to record movements of inventory in the financial records by personnel in the area assuming responsibility
for the inventory and are recorded in the appropriate period.
Raw materials received by production are logged; the log is reconciled to raw material movement reports that are
used to record movements of inventory in the financial records.
PRODUCING/COSTING INVENTORY
All recorded production costs are consistent with actual direct and indirect expenses associated
with production.
When standard costing is used, management approves the standard costs and reviews variances between actual
and standard costs. Significant variances are investigated and adjustments to inventory and cost of sales are
approved by management.
When actual costing is used, costs associated with raw materials, labor, and overhead are independently
reconciled to appropriate supporting records.
When actual costing is used, management reviews actual costs based on their knowledge of day-to-day activities.
All direct and indirect expenses associated with production are recorded as production costs.
When standard costing is used, management approves the standard costs and reviews variances between actual
and standard costs. Significant variances are investigated and adjustments to inventory and cost of sales are
approved by management.
When actual costing is used, costs associated with raw materials, labor, and overhead are independently
reconciled to appropriate supporting records.
When actual costing is used, management reviews actual costs based on their knowledge of day-to-day activities.
All direct and indirect expenses associated with production are recorded accurately and in the
appropriate period.
When standard costing is used, management approves the standard costs and reviews variances between actual
and standard costs. Significant variances are investigated and adjustments to inventory and cost of sales are
approved by management.
19
Control Activities – Inventory Management
When actual costing is used, costs associated with raw materials, labor, and overhead are independently
reconciled to appropriate supporting records.
When actual costing is used, management reviews actual costs based on their knowledge of day-to-day activities.
All transfers of completed units of production to finished goods inventory are recorded
completely and accurately in the appropriate period.
Finished goods sent to the warehouse are logged; the log is used to ensure that all finished goods are recorded in
the inventory records.
All defective products and scrap resulting from the production process are valid and recorded
completely and accurately in the appropriate period.
Rejected work in progress is adequately segregated from other work in progress and is monitored to ensure it is
scrapped or reworked on a timely basis.
Management, based on their knowledge of day-to-day activities, reviews records of scrapped and reworked items
and checks whether such items have been correctly identified and properly recorded in the appropriate accounting
period.
HANDLING FINISHED PRODUCTS
Finished goods received from production and returned by customers are recorded completely
and accurately in the appropriate period.
Physical inventory is counted periodically by persons independent of day-to-day custody or recording of inventory.
Inventory counts are reconciled to inventory records and inventory records are reconciled to the general ledger.
Goods received are logged; the log is reconciled to receipts input to the inventory management system that is
used to record movements of inventory in the financial records.
Goods received at, before, or after the end of an accounting period are scrutinized and/or reconciled to ensure
complete and consistent recording in the appropriate period.
Inventories received, including transfers, are counted and compared to receipt or transfer documentation that is
used to record movements of inventory in the financial records by personnel in the area assuming responsibility
for the inventory and are recorded in the appropriate period.
Goods received from production or returned by customers are only accepted in accordance with
the organization’s policies.
Quality control inspections are performed for finished goods returned by customers and/or received from
production to assess whether such goods should be returned to inventory, reworked, or scrapped.
SHIPPING FINISHED PRODUCTS
All shipments are recorded.
Physical inventory is counted periodically by persons independent of day-to-day custody or recording of inventory.
Inventory counts are reconciled to inventory records and inventory records are reconciled to the general ledger.
Management reviews relevant sales, accounts receivable, costs of sales, and inventory reports related to order
entry, shipping, invoicing, and accounts receivable; significant unusual relationships are monitored and acted
upon.
Sales order entry, shipping, and invoice processing are performed by an integrated application system. The
general ledger is automatically updated for shipping and invoicing transactions.
Delivery notes are sequentially numbered; the sequence of delivery notes processed is accounted for.
Orders are sequentially numbered. The sequence of orders processed is accounted for.
Shipments of goods to customers are logged. The log is used to ensure that all shipments are invoiced and that
all invoices are recorded.
Shipments are recorded accurately.
Physical inventory is counted periodically by persons independent of day-to-day custody and recording of
inventory. Inventory counts are reconciled to inventory records and inventory records are reconciled to the
general ledger.
Management reviews relevant sales, accounts receivable, cost of sales, and inventory reports related to order
entry, shipping, invoicing, and accounts receivable; significant unusual relationships are monitored and acted
upon.
Data input to the invoicing subsystem is compared to priced order and shipment data per the separate,
nonintegrated order entry and/or shipping applications; differences require management approval before invoices
can be processed.
Shipments are recorded timely and in the appropriate period.
Physical inventory is counted periodically by persons independent of day-to-day custody or recording of inventory.
Inventory counts are reconciled to inventory records and inventory records are reconciled to the general ledger.
20
Control Activities – Inventory Management
Goods shipped at, before, or after the end of an accounting period are scrutinized and/or reconciled to ensure
complete and consistent recording in the appropriate accounting period, including the raising and recording of the
related invoice.
Inventory is relieved only when goods are shipped with approved customer orders.
Before goods are shipped, the details of the approved order are compared to actual goods prepared for shipment
by an individual independent of the order picking process.
Security personnel monitor all incoming and outgoing vehicles and ensure all goods leaving the premises are
accompanied by duly completed documentation.
Costs of shipped inventory are transferred from inventory to cost of sales.
Management reviews relevant sales, accounts receivable, cost of sales, and inventory reports related to order
entry, shipping, invoicing, and accounts receivable; significant unusual relationships are monitored and acted
upon.
Costs of shipped inventory are recorded accurately.
Management reviews relevant sales, accounts receivable, cost of sales, and inventory reports related to order
entry, shipping, invoicing, and accounts receivable; significant unusual relationships are monitored and acted
upon.
IM5035 Amounts posted to cost of sales represent those associated with shipped inventory.
Management reviews relevant sales, accounts receivable, cost of sales, and inventory reports related to order
entry, shipping, invoicing, and accounts receivable; significant unusual relationships are monitored and acted
upon.
Costs of shipped inventory are transferred from inventory to cost of sales timely and in the
appropriate period.
Management reviews relevant sales, accounts receivable, cost of sales, and inventory reports related to order
entry, shipping, invoicing, and accounts receivable; significant unusual relationships are monitored and acted
upon.
MAINTAINING INVENTORY MASTER FILE
All valid changes to the inventory management master file are input and processed.
Inventory master file data is periodically reviewed by management for accuracy and ongoing pertinence.
Requests to change inventory master file data are logged; the log is reviewed to ensure that all requested
changes are processed timely.
Requests to change inventory master file data are submitted on prenumbered forms; the numerical sequence of
such forms is accounted for to ensure that all requested changes are processed timely.
List prices of composed products are automatically calculated based on the list prices of components of such
products.
Changes to the inventory management master file are accurate.
Inventory master file data is periodically reviewed by management for accuracy and ongoing pertinence.
Recorded changes to inventory master file data are compared to authorized source documents to ensure that they
were input accurately.
List prices of composed products are automatically calculated based on the list prices of components of such
products.
Inventory master file input data is edited and validated; identified errors are corrected promptly.
Inventory management master file remains pertinent.
Inventory master file data is periodically reviewed by management for accuracy and ongoing pertinence.
The salability of finished goods and usability of raw materials are assessed regularly, including a review during
physical inventory counts.
21
Control Activities – Payroll and Personnel
22
Control Activities – Payroll and Personnel
CALCULATING PAYROLL
Payroll is recorded in the appropriate period.
Payroll transactions at, before, or after the end of an accounting period are scrutinized and/or reconciled to ensure
complete and consistent recording in the appropriate accounting period.
Compliance with the payroll disbursement processing schedule is monitored by management.
Payroll (including compensation and withholdings) is accurately calculated and recorded.
Salary and hourly payroll reports (including compensation and withholding information) are reviewed and approved
by management prior to disbursement.
Standard programmed algorithms perform significant payroll calculations.
Overtime hours worked and payments for such overtime are authorized by management for all salaried employees
who are paid for overtime.
The detailed payroll records show all pertinent data describing the payroll (including total compensation, related
income taxes, and other withholdings) and the related balances are reconciled, in a timely manner, to corresponding
general ledger accounts or entries by persons who do not have unrestricted access to cash. All reconciling items
are investigated and cleared on a timely basis.
Payroll related accruals/provisions reflect the existing business circumstances and economic
conditions in accordance with the accounting policies being used.
All payroll suspense accounts are reconciled and reviewed by management or other supervisory personnel on a
timely basis. Transactions recorded in the payroll suspense accounts are proper suspense items; other items are
investigated and resolved in a timely manner.
DISBURSING PAYROLL
Payroll disbursements and recorded payroll expenses relate to actual time worked.
Salary and hourly payroll reports (including compensation and withholding information) are reviewed and approved
by management prior to disbursement.
Time reported by employees is reconciled regularly between clock cards/timesheets and payroll reports.
Overtime hours worked and payments for such overtime are authorized by management for all salaried employees
who are paid for overtime.
Payroll is disbursed to appropriate employees.
All payroll queries are followed up by persons independent of the payroll preparation and disbursement process.
Access to the payroll bank transfer tape is restricted to authorized personnel.
Employees sign for cash received; compliance is monitored by management.
MAINTAINING PAYROLL MASTER FILES
All valid changes to the payroll master files are input and processed.
Departmental managers periodically review listings of current employees within their departments and notify the
personnel department of necessary changes.
Requests to change the payroll master file data are logged; the log is reviewed to ensure that all requested changes
are processed timely.
Requests to change the payroll master file data are submitted on prenumbered forms; the numerical sequence of
such forms is accounted for to ensure that all requested changes are processed timely.
Changes to the payroll master files are accurate.
Departmental managers periodically review listings of current employees within their departments and notify the
personnel department of necessary changes.
Recorded changes to the payroll master files are compared to authorized source documents to ensure that they
were input accurately.
Payroll master file data is edited and validated; identified errors are corrected promptly.
Payroll master files data remains pertinent.
Payroll master file data is periodically reviewed for accuracy and ongoing pertinence.
Departmental managers periodically review listings of current employees within their departments and notify the
personnel department of necessary changes.
Variations between payroll master files and the time recording system are investigated and appropriate action taken
if necessary.
23
Control Activities – Revenue
24
Control Activities – Revenue
25
Control Activities – Revenue
Cash receipts at, before, or after the end of an accounting period are scrutinized and/or reconciled to ensure
complete and consistent recording in the appropriate accounting period.
General ledger balances are reconciled to the accounts receivable subsidiary ledger and differences are resolved in
a timely manner.
Cash receipts data is entered for processing accurately.
Cash sales are recorded using a cash register. Customers are provided with a copy of the register receipt and total
daily receipts per the register are balanced to cash deposited to the bank.
Shipment of goods ordered via EDI initiates an automatic draft withdrawal from the customer’s bank account.
Cash receipts input data is edited and validated; identified errors are corrected promptly.
Cash receipts transactions are batched and batch input data is balanced; out-of-balance batches are corrected
promptly.
All cash receipts data is entered for processing.
Cash sales are recorded using a cash register. Customers are provided with a copy of the register receipt and total
daily receipts per the register are balanced to cash deposited to the bank.
Shipment of goods ordered via EDI initiates an automatic draft on the customer’s account.
Customers are provided with a form acknowledging receipt of any cash payments (i.e., a cash receipt form) and
cash receipts forms are balanced to cash deposited to the bank. Cash receipt forms are sequentially prenumbered
and the sequence of such forms is accounted for.
Cash receipts transactions are batched and batch input data is balanced; out-of-balance batches are corrected
promptly.
Cash receipts data is valid and is entered for processing only once.
Cash sales are recorded using a cash register. Customers are provided with a copy of the register receipt and total
daily receipts per the register are balanced to cash deposited to the bank.
Customers are provided with a form acknowledging receipt of any cash payments (i.e., a cash receipt form) and
cash receipts forms are balanced to cash deposited to the bank. Cash receipt forms are sequentially prenumbered
and the sequence of such forms is accounted for.
Cash discounts are accurately calculated and recorded
Available cash discounts are automatically calculated by the application system using standard programmed
algorithms and established terms of sale.
Management reviews the level of recorded discounts granted to customers.
Timely collection of accounts receivable is monitored.
Collection procedures established by management for overdue accounts are performed as intended.
Accounts receivable aging reports are prepared regularly and analyzed.
MAINTAINING CUSTOMER MASTER FILES
All valid changes to the customer master file are input and processed.
Requests to change customer master file data are logged; the log is reviewed to ensure that all requested changes
are processed timely.
Requests to change customer master file data are submitted on prenumbered forms; the numerical sequence of
such forms is accounted for.
Changes to the customer master file are accurate.
Recorded changes to customer master file data are compared to authorized source documents or confirmed with
customers to ensure that they were input accurately.
Customer master file input data is edited and validated; identified errors are corrected promptly.
Customer master file data remains pertinent.
Customer master file data is periodically reviewed by management for accuracy and ongoing pertinence.
Reports of customers who have not placed orders within a specified period of time are reviewed to ensure that
customer master file data remains pertinent.
26
Control Activities – Treasury
27
Control Activities – Treasury
28
Control Activities – Treasury
Management reviews recorded investment purchases, sales, and maturities of investments based on knowledge of
day-to-day activity.
Investment transactions are edited and validated; identified errors are corrected promptly.
All investment transactions are recorded.
Investment transactions are reconciled/compared to third-party statements or documents of title. Statements
received for which no assets are recorded are investigated.
Management reviews recorded investment purchases, sales, and maturities of investments based on knowledge of
day-to-day activity.
Investment transaction order, confirmation, and settlement are separately input and are automatically matched by
the application system; discrepancies are followed up by an individual who is independent of transaction initiation.
Investment transactions are recorded in the appropriate period.
Investment transactions are reconciled/compared to third-party statements or documents of title. Statements
received for which no assets are recorded are investigated.
Management reviews recorded investment purchases, sales, and maturities of investments based on knowledge of
day-to-day activity.
Investment transactions at, before, or after the end of an accounting period are scrutinized and/or reconciled to
ensure complete and consistent recording in the appropriate accounting period.
All investment income is accurately calculated and recorded in the appropriate period.
Investment transactions are reconciled/compared to third-party statements or documents of title. Statements
received for which no assets are recorded are investigated.
Calculations of interest expense are reviewed by management and/or independently reperformed.
Interest income is calculated by an automated system.
Investment income is reconciled to third-party statements regularly and differences are acted upon.
Management anticipates investment income, which is reviewed to ensure that all payments are received and
recorded timely.
Calculations of investment income are reviewed by management and/or independently reperformed.
Loans and investments reflect the existing business circumstances and economic conditions in
accordance with the accounting policies being used.
Management periodically reviews the valuations and/or realizability of investments to identify fair value adjustments
and to properly record such adjustments.
MANAGING DERIVATIVE TRANSACTIONS
Senior management has an understanding of the organization’s derivative activities.
Senior management has approved and communicated to the treasury function the organization’s policies and
procedures related to derivatives activities and monitors compliance, including monitoring the nature and volume of
the derivative activities.
Recorded derivative transactions represent assets or liabilities of the organization.
Management approves derivative transactions to ensure that they are valid and in compliance with the
organization’s policies and procedures.
Management reviews summary reports of derivative transactions and balances based on their knowledge of the
day-to-day activity.
Recorded or disclosed derivative transactions are independently reconciled to external records; discrepancies,
including non-receipt of counterparty confirmations, are promptly resolved by persons independent of the treasury
function.
Disclosed off-balance sheet derivative transactions represent valid transactions.
Management approves derivative transactions to ensure that they are valid and in compliance with the
organization’s policies and procedures.
Management reviews summary reports of derivative transactions and balances based on their knowledge of the
day-to-day activity.
Recorded or disclosed derivative transactions are independently reconciled to external records; discrepancies,
including non-receipt of counterparty confirmations, are promptly resolved by persons independent of the treasury
function.
Derivative transactions are accurately recorded.
Management approves derivative transactions to ensure that they are valid and in compliance with the
organization’s policies and procedures.
Management reviews summary reports of derivative transactions and balances based on their knowledge of the
day-to-day activity.
Derivatives input data is edited and validated; identified errors are corrected promptly.
29
Control Activities – Treasury
30
Control Activities – Treasury
All interest expense on derivative transactions is accurately calculated and recorded in the
appropriate period.
Calculations of interest expense are reviewed by management and/or independently reperformed.
Interest expense is calculated by an automated system.
Interest expense is reconciled to third-party statements and differences are promptly resolved.
Management anticipates interest expense, which is reconciled to the recorded expenses and reviewed to ensure
that recorded interest expenses are valid and recorded timely.
Derivative transactions at, before, or after the end of an accounting period are scrutinized and or reconciled to
ensure complete and consistent recording in the appropriate accounting period.
Calculations of interest expense on derivative transactions are reviewed by management and/or independently
reperformed.
31