Hezbollah's Gaza Strategy Flaws
Hezbollah's Gaza Strategy Flaws
2024 Sprıng 35
COMMENTARY HILAL KHASHAN
H
amas’ decision to launch Op- and that his party’s measures aimed
eration al-Aqsa Flood on Is- at lending support to Gaza mainly by
rael last October took Hezbol- forcing one-third of the Israeli mili-
lah by surprise since all indicators at tary to deploy near the border with
the time suggested that Hamas ought Lebanon. He warned that Israel’s war
pacification with Israel and focused, on Gaza would blow up the entire
instead, on managing Gaza and con- region and that he would not go into
solidating its rule over the besieged details about the battlefield decisions
sector, the world’s most congested that Hezbollah intended to take, pre-
territory. Hezbollah was in no way ferring to leave Israel confused.
interested in fighting Israel, despite
its pompous claims to the contrary. Hezbollah has been using the claim
Hezbollah’s anti-Israel role ended in of resistance to Israeli occupation and
2000 when it pulled out unilaterally its purported claim of achieving a de-
from Southern Lebanon without even terrent military capability vis-à-vis
reaching an agreement with Lebanon. the Jewish state to camouflage its sta-
Since then, the occasional minor at- tus as Iran’s premier regional proxy.
tacks it launched on Northern Israel Its decision to open a secondary front
aimed at swapping Lebanese prison- of solidarity with Hamas turned out
ers with Israelis to justify the useful- to be a miscalculated gambit, and it
ness of its military wing for Lebanese fell into Israel’s trap. Its ideological
factions that resented its failure to dis- affinity with Iran did not shield it
arm like all other local militias. While against Israeli retaliation, revealing
Hezbollah continued to express its ul- Iran’s military weakness and aversion
timate objective of driving Israel from to military confrontation. Stuck in its
still-occupied Lebanese territory in conflict with Israel, Hezbollah now
the South, it practically served as faces severe domestic challenges to
Iran’s leading regional proxy in serv- disarm like all other Lebanese fac-
ing the interests of the Islamic Repub- tions that gave up their arms at the
lic, mainly in Syria and Iraq.1 end of the civil war in 1989.
36 Insight Turkey
HEZBOLLAH’S SHORTSIGHTED STRATEGY FOR THE WAR IN GAZA
2024 Sprıng 37
COMMENTARY HILAL KHASHAN
38 Insight Turkey
HEZBOLLAH’S SHORTSIGHTED STRATEGY FOR THE WAR IN GAZA
Hezbollah
attacked Israel’s
Amad military
enemy that you are unable to destroy gering an all-out war, he still had base in the Ain
and force to recognize its existence.10 doubts about Israel’s intentions. He Zeitim and Upper
declared that if the war broke out, it Galilee region
Hezbollah took Israel’s threats of with Katyusha
would be because Israel wanted it to
missiles, on July
massive escalation lightly. Right after happen. He admitted, however, that 12, 2024.
Hamas’ operation last October, Israeli Hezbollah expected Israel’s war on SAMIR ABDALHADE /
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu Gaza to be brief, as in previous en- AA
said he would “change the Middle counters over the past 15 years: “We
East.”11 His statement implied that didn’t expect the war would last this
the situation on the Northern front long because we didn’t think that
would not return to the pre-attack Netanyahu was that foolish.”12 Israel
period. Hezbollah did not take Net- insists that Hezbollah’s withdrawal
anyahu’s warning seriously and chose from the border area, i.e., 10 kilome-
to escalate militarily, although in a ters, means losing 70 percent of its
carefully calculated manner, to avoid ability to strike Israeli targets and de-
massive Israeli retaliation. Still, Israel priving its strikes of their importance.
deemed Hezbollah’s military restraint The geographical nature of Lebanon
irrelevant given the unprecedented in the border region gives the party’s
shock of Hamas’ attack, which it had fighters the advantage of operating in
completely ruled out as irrational and primarily high-forested areas. Topog-
suicidal. raphy enables them to use direct and
uncurved missiles fired at targets in
Even though Hezbollah’s Deputy Israeli settlements located below Leb-
Chief, Naeem Qassem, made it clear anese territory, creating a dilemma
that his party had no interest in trig- for Hezbollah. If the party’s fighters
2024 Sprıng 39
COMMENTARY HILAL KHASHAN
evacuate the border area, they will dismantling Hamas in the South, it
lose the ability to launch guided mis- did not face a significant escalation
siles, forcing them to use ineffective from Hezbollah. Encouraged by Hez-
curved and unguided projectiles.13 bollah’s trepidation, Israel started
attacking its forces across Lebanon
The Hamas’ operation resulted in sig- in December. By December, Hez-
nificant shifts in the balance of the bollah appeared to be implementing
conflict between Hezbollah and Is- a tactical retreat, as most of its Rad-
rael, going beyond breaking the rules wan’s elite forces withdrew to avoid
of engagement that existed since the precision raids by Israel. Hezbollah
2006 war. The attack brought about avoided responding forcefully to the
radical changes in the nature and con- Israeli attacks, fearing it could trig-
cept of the war between the two sides, ger an all-out war, fully aware that it
negatively impacting the settlements would lose.15 Israeli Defense Minister
in Northern Israel and Southern Leb- Yoav Galant said during a visit to the
anese villages; it turned into a battle- headquarters of the Northern Com-
field that led to the displacement of mand that his forces killed about half
more than 90 thousand citizens, the of Hezbollah’s field commanders in
destruction of thousands of homes, Southern Lebanon and that the com-
the burning of agricultural lands, and ing period will be decisive.16 Usually,
the death of hundreds of thousands killing the enemy’s field command-
of livestock. Nasrallah did not hide ers suggests the presence of plans to
his fear about the chances for the mil- launch a sizeable ground operation.
itary situation to slide into a full-scale
war after he realized that the rules of The chairperson of the Israeli parlia-
engagement that existed before Octo- ment’s Foreign Affairs and Defense
ber 7 had expired due to Israel’s esca- Committee reiterated Israel’s deter-
latory strikes. He realized that Israel, mination to end Hezbollah’s presence
which possesses enormous firepower, on the border with Israel, diplomati-
mandated that Hezbollah introduce cally or militarily. Western diplomats
new, unconventional weapons to the frequently visit Beirut to sway the
battlefield to restore a semblance of Lebanese government to pull out of
deterrent capability. Nasrallah ac- the border area to avert a significant
knowledged heavy human and ma- Israeli military campaign. Hezbollah
terial losses attributable to his forces’ has adamantly rejected the propos-
carefully calculated fighting, which als of evacuating the South or even
refrained from expanding the scope considering accepting a ceasefire
of confrontations. However, Nasral- while Israel’s war on Gaza continued.
lah stressed that if Israel imposed a Hezbollah’s Chief, Hasan Nasral-
war, there would be no controls on lah, said he would not listen to such
Hezbollah’s use of its full firepower.14 proposals.17
After the Israeli army took control Hezbollah says it will end its military
of most of Northern Gaza and began operations against Israel once a cease-
40 Insight Turkey
HEZBOLLAH’S SHORTSIGHTED STRATEGY FOR THE WAR IN GAZA
2024 Sprıng 41
COMMENTARY HILAL KHASHAN
42 Insight Turkey
HEZBOLLAH’S SHORTSIGHTED STRATEGY FOR THE WAR IN GAZA
ern Israel, embarrassing the party 2. Iran has had a tumultuous history for the past
two centuries with Russian and British intrusion
and forcing it to take responsibility on its territory. Also, the U.S. manipulated its do-
for the incident.26 mestic affairs, notably the 1953 Operation Ajax
that overthrew the government of the democrat-
Hezbollah faces an inhospitable Leb- ically elected Prime Minister Mohammad Mosad-
degh and restored the reign of Mohammad Reza
anese environment that rejects its Pahlavi. The 1979 Islamic Revolution introduced
involvement in the armed conflict, the Arab Policy, which sought to spread the rev-
which is getting worse due to the diffi- olution into Arab countries to increase Iran’s for-
eign policy leverage and shield it against Western
culty in reaching a ceasefire that Hez- schemes.
bollah wants today and not tomorrow.
3. Rafiq Khoury, “Dawr Hezbollah al-Iqlimi Yu’atil
However, the fighting is likely to con- Dawr Lubnan [Hezbollah’s Regional Role Hinders
tinue because Israel has set condi- Lebanon’s Role],” Independent Arabia, (December
tions, such as the party’s withdrawal 24, 2022).
from the border region. It rejected 4. Mat Nashed, “Can Lebanon’s Hezbollah Afford
Hezbollah’s demands to withdraw to Go to War with Israel?” Al Jazeera, (October 16,
2024), retrieved from https://www.aljazeera.com/
from occupied Lebanese territories in news/2023/10/16/can-lebanons-hezbollah-af-
Shebaa Farms and Kfar Shuba Hills. It ford-to-go-to-war-with-israel.
is unlikely that when the war ends, it 5. “Mafhum Wahdat al-Sahaat: Hilf NATO Musagh-
will be according to Hezbollah’s terms. har li_Iran wa Jama’atiha [The Concept of Unity
2024 Sprıng 43
COMMENTARY HILAL KHASHAN
of Fronts: A Mini-NATO for Iran and Its Groups],” 16. “Galant: Nisf Qadat Hezbollah al-Maydaniyin
Radio Sawa, (May 22, 2023). Tamat Tasfiyatuhum wa al-Fatra al-Qadima Ha-
6. “Nasrallah: Muawarat Hezbollah Ja’at li Tu’ak- sima [Galant: Half of Hezbollah’s Field Command-
kid ‘ala Jahiziyat al-Muqawama wa Israel Taraja’at ers Have Been Eliminated, and the Coming Period
‘an Tahdidatiha [Nasrallah: Hezbollah’s Maneu- Will Be Decisive],” RT Arabic, (April 24, 2024).
vers Came to Confirm the Readiness of the Resis- 17. Dan Williams and Tom Perry, “Israel Wants
tance, and Israel Backed Down from Its Threats],” Hezbollah Away from Border, Lawmaker Says,” Re-
Al Jazeera, (May 25, 2023). uters, (December 13, 2023), retrieved from https://
7. “Israel Tuhaddir min Mukhatataat Hezbollah www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/israel-
[Israel Warns of Hezbollah’s Plans],” Al Hurra, (May wants-hezbollah-away-border-lawmaker-says-
22, 2023). 2023-12-13/.
8. “Nasrallah: Inkharatna fi al-Harb min al-Bidaya 18. Justin Salhani, “Is Israel Hoping to Escalate
wa Mustamirrun Fiha [Nasrallah: We Were In- Hostilities with Hezbollah in Lebanon?” Al Jazeera,
volved in the War from the Beginning, and We Are (March 12, 2024), retrieved from https://www.alja-
Continuing It],” Al Jazeera, (November 3, 2023). zeera.com/news/2024/3/12/is-israel-hoping-to-
escalate-hostilities-with-hezbollah-in-lebanon.
9. Jana Dhaybi, “Ma’alat Nusf ‘Aam min Harb
Musagghara bayn Israel wa Hezbollah [The Con- 19. Omer Dostri, “To Provide Security for Its Citi-
sequences of Half a Year of a Minin-War between zens, Israel Must Go to War with Hezbollah,” Yedi-
Israel and Hezbollah],” Al Jazeera, (April 4, 2024). oth Ahronoth, (February 26, 2024), retrieved from
https://www.ynetnews.com/article/r149ynknp.
10. Nidal Kanaana, “Al-I’tibaraat al-Isralilia Qabl
Fath Harb ‘ala Hezbollah [Israeli Considerations 20. “Hezbollah Tam’ana Iran: lan Najurrakum ila
before Opening a War on Hezbollah],” Sky News Harb Ghaza wa Sanuqatil Wahdana [Hezbollah
Arabia, (January 24, 2024). Reassured Iran: We Will Not Drag You into the
Gaza War, and We Will Fight Alone],” Al-Arabiya,
11. “Netanyahu Says Israel’s Response to Gaza (March 15, 2024).
Attack Will Change the Middle East,” Reuters,
(October 9, 2023), retrieved from https://www. 21. Hilal Khashan, “Hezbollah’s Last Stand,” Geo-
reuters.com/world/middle-east/netanyahu-says- political Futures, (December 13, 2023), retrieved
israels-response-gaza-attack-will-change-mid- from https://geopoliticalfutures.com/hezbol-
dle-east-2023-10-09/. lahs-last-stand/.
12. “Qassem Stresses Hezbollah’s Determination 22. Hilal Khashan, “Iran’s Strategic Dilemma,” Geo-
to Avoid Full-Scale War,” L’Orient-Le Jour, (April 19, political Futures, (April 10, 2024).
2024), retrieved from https://today.lorientlejour. 23. Huda Husseini, “Sallimu al-Silah Yaslam al-
com/article/1410972/qassem-stresses-hezbol- Janub [Hand over the Weapons, the South Will Be
lahs-determination-to-avoid-full-scale-war.html. Safe],” Ash-Sharq al-Awsat, (March 28, 2024).
13. Nadhir Rida, “Hezbollah Yatamassak bi al-Baqa’ 24. “Iran la Tuman’ fi Qasqasat Ajnihat Hezbollah li
‘ala Hudud Janub Lubnan Tajannuban li Khisarat Mana’ Tawassu’ al-Harb [Iran Does Not Mind Clip-
al-Ta’thir al-‘Askari [Hezbollah Insists on Remaining ping Hezbollah’s Wings to Prevent the Expansion
on the Borders of Southern Lebanon to Avoid Los- of the War],” Al-Arab, (March 16, 2024).
ing Military Influence],” Aawsat, (January 18, 2024).
25. “Iran Tu’akkid li Washington Annaha la Tu-
14. “Al-Sayyid Nasrallah: Musta’iddun li Harb min rid Tawsi’ al-Tawatturat maa’ Israel [Iran Assures
Dun Dawabitwa min Dun Saqf [Sayyid Nasrallah: Washington That It Does Not Want to Expand
We Are Ready for War without Controls and with- Tensions with Israel],” Ash-Sharq al-Awsat, (April
out Ceilings],” Al-‘Ahd News, (January 4, 2024). 18, 2024).
15. Yonah Jeremy Bob, “Why Israel Yet Has to 26. Jonny Fakhry, “Tamalmul wa Ghadab fi Bi’at
Launch a Full-Blown War on Hezbollah?” Jerusa- Hezbollah [Restlessness and Anger in Hezbollah’s
lem Post, (March 13, 2024). Environment],” Al-Arabiya, (December 1, 2021).
44 Insight Turkey
Copyright of Insight Turkey is the property of Insight Turkey and its content may not be
copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's
express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for
individual use.