Transformers
Transformers
1.1. INTRODUCTION:
The transformer is a device that transfers electrical energy from one electrical
circuit to another electrical circuit. The two circuits may be operating at different
voltage levels but always work at the same frequency. Basically transformer is an
electro-magnetic energy conversion device. It is commonly used in electrical power
system and distribution systems. It can change the magnitude of alternating
voltage or current from one value to another. This useful property of transformer is
mainly responsible for the widespread use of alternating currents rather than direct
currents i.e., electric power is generated, transmitted and distributed in the form of
alternating current. Transformers have no moving parts, rugged and durable in
construction, thus requiring very little attention. They also have a very high
efficiency as high as 99%.
What is a Transformer?
A transformer is a static piece of equipment used either for raising or lowering the
voltage of an AC supply with a corresponding decrease or increase in current.
The use of transformers in transmission system is shown in the Figure below.
Fig.1-1
• Conservator
• Tank
• Butchholz Relay
• Breather
• Silica Gel
• Oil Level Scale
• Primary Winding
• Secondary Winding
• Drain Valve
• Porcelain Bush
• Radiator
1. CONSERVATOR:
Conservator is a type of tank, used to help oil filling this is situated
upper portion of the power transformer mainly these are cylindrically
shaped.
2. TANK:
Basically this is a container used to keep windings (both) and cooling
oil.
3. BUTCHHOLZ RELAY:
This is a protecting device used to protect transformer windings. This
is a double ended device one end is connected to conservator other is
connected to tank. there are two windings inside the relay one for
detecting oil level going to empty and other is
connected to a alarm circuit for warning.
4. BREATHER:
Breather is a device used for absorbs the moisture content of an oil
and sucked air
5. SILICA GEL:
It is a chemical material these are the only one main component
inside the breather basically silica gel is a blue colored one after the
absorption silica gel become pink
6. OIL LEVEL SCALE:
This is an ordinary part situated on the side of the conservator for
proper oil checking oil tank wants a specific amount of oil
7. PRIMARY WINDING:
The winding which is connected to supply then the winding is called
primary winding.
8. SECONDARY WINDING:
The winding which is connected to the load then the winding is called
secondary winding.
9. DRAIN VALVE:
This valve is used for taking damaged oil from the oil tank for the
proper oil collection this valve is situated under the oil tank
10. PORCELAIN BUSH
This is an outer unit this is used to prevent unwanted leakage of
electricity
11. RADIATOR:
These are used for cooling of the transformer oil.
1.3. PRINCIPLE OF OPERATION
Depending upon the number of turns of the primary (N 1) and secondary (N2), an
alternating emf (E2) is induced in the secondary. This induced emf (E2) in the
secondary causes a secondary current I2. Consequently, terminal voltage V2 will
appear across the load. If V2 > V1, it is called a step up-transformer. On the other
hand, if V2 < V1, it is called a step-down transformer.
In practice, these losses are very small so that output power is nearly equal to the
input primary power. In other words, a transformer has very high efficiency.
Core-Type Transformer: If the windings are wound around the core in such a way
that they surround the core ring on its outer edges, then the construction is known
as the closed core type construction of the transformer core. In this type, half of the
winding is wrapped around each limb of the core, and is enclosed such that no
magnetic flux losses can occur and the flux leakages can be minimized. This type of
arrangement proves quiet useful for the flux circulation, such that each limb is
covered by the windings and hence the flux circulates through the complete core.
But during this circulations, a bit of leakages also occur.
Shell-Type Transformer: This method of construction involves the use of a double
magnetic circuit. Both the windings are placed round the central limb to ensure a
low-reluctance flux path.
Fig. Core type and Shell type transformer
The winding are uniformly distributed on two The natural cooling does not exist as the
limbs hence natural cooling is effective Windings are surrounded by the core.
Preferred for low voltage transformers. Preferred for high voltage transformers.
or E1 = 4.44fN1 Фm
Similarly, E2 = 4.44fN2 Фm
In an ideal transformer, E1 = V1 and E2 = V2
Note: It is clear from equ. (2) above that emf E1 induced in the primary lags behind
the flux by 900. Likewise, emf E2 induced in the secondary lags behind flux by 900.
Volt-Ampere Rating
Transformer rating is specified as the product of voltage and current and called VA
rating.
The full load primaty and secondary currents which indicate the safe maximum
values of currents which transformer windings can carry can be given as:
Hence total losses depend on V and I. Since rating of transformer depends upon
losses and losses depend upon V and I, hence the rating of transformer depends
upon V×I, which is also termed as VI rating. As losses are independent of the power
factor of load, the rating of the transformer is also independent of load and can be
only decided based on losses. That’s why transformer is generally specified with
apparent power rating (VA or KVA) and not in KW.
1.8.Concept of Ideal Transformer
NOTE:
For an ideal transformer, the primary applied voltage V1 is same as the
primary induced emf E1 as there are no voltage drops.
Ideal Transformer on No Load
Consider an ideal transformer in Fig. below. For no load I2 =0. I1 is just necessary
to produce flux in the core, which is called magnetising current is very small and
is denoted as Im. Im lags V1 by 900 as the winding is purely inductive.
According to Lenz's law, the induced e.m.f opposes the cause producing it which is
supply voltage V1. Hence E1 and E2 are in antiphase with V1 but equal in
magnitude and E1 and E2 are in phase.
The reduction of main flux Φ –by Faraday’s law- could also reduce the induced
voltage in primary winding E1. Consequently E1 is now smaller than the supply
voltage V1, then the primary current would be increased due to that potential
differences. Therefore on loaded transformer, the primary current has an additional
current of I1’.
The extra current I1’ which flowing in the primary winding N1 produces flux Φ1
which naturally react according to Lenz’s law, demagnetize the flux Φ2. Therefore
the net magnetic flux in the core is always maintained at original value, it is the
main flux Φ (the flux which produced by the magnetizing current).
The magneto motive force (mmf) source N2I2 at the secondary winding produces flux
Φ2, while the mmf N1I1’ produces flux Φ1. Since the magnitude of Φ1 equal to
magnitude of Φ2 and the reluctance seen by these two mmf sources are equal, thus
N1 I1’= N2I2
1.9. Practical Transformer
A practical transformer differs from the ideal transformer in many respects. The
practical transformer has (i) iron losses (ii) winding resistances and (iii)
magnetic leakage, giving rise to leakage reactance.
(i) Iron losses. Since the iron core is subjected to alternating flux, there
occurs eddy current and hysteresis loss in it.
(iii) Leakage reactance. Both primary and secondary currents produce flux.
The flux Φ which links both the windings is the useful flux However,
primary current would produce some flux Φ which would not link the
secondary winding and is called mutual flux (for more information
review Lecture Note 2) (See Fig. below).
Practical Transformer on No Load
Consider a practical transformer on no load i.e., secondary on open-circuit as
shown in Fig. (i). The primary will draw a small current I 0 to supply (i) the iron
losses and (ii) a very small amount of copper loss in the primary. Hence the
primary no load current I0 is not 90° behind the applied voltage V1 but lags it by
an angle f0 < 90° as shown in the phasor diagram in Fig. (ii)
As seen from the phasor diagram in Fig. (ii), the no-load primary current I0
can be resolved into two rectangular components viz.
• The component IW in phase with the applied voltage V1. This is known as
active or working or iron loss component and supplies the iron loss and a
very small primary copper loss.
IW = I0 cos f0
Fig. below shows a practical transformer with the assumption that resistances
and leakage reactances of the windings are negligible. With this assumption,
V2 = E2 and V1 = E1. Let us take the usual case of inductive load which causes
the secondary current I2 to lag the secondary voltage V2 by f2. The total
primary current I1 must meet two requirements viz.
• It must supply the no-load current I0 to meet the iron losses in the
transformer and to provide flux in the core.
• It must supply a current I'0 to counteract the demagnetizing effect of
secondary currently I2. The magnitude of I'2 will be such that:
The total primary current I1 is the phasor sum of I'2 and I0 i.e.,
I1 = I'2 +I0
where I'2 = -KI2
Note that I'2 is 180° out of phase with I2.
Phasor diagram. Fig. below shows the phasor diagram for the usual case of
inductive load. Both E1 and E2 lag behind the mutual flux f by 90°. The current I'2
represents the primary current to neutralize the demagnetizing effect of secondary
current I2. Now I'2 = K I2 and is antiphase with I2. I0 is the no-load current of the
transformer. The phasor sum of I'2 and I0 gives the total primary current I1. Note
that in drawing the phasor diagram, the value of K is assumed to be unity so that
primary phasors are equal to secondary phasors.
Primary p.f. = cos Ф1
Secondary p.f. = cos Ф2
N1I'2 = N 2I2
or I'2 = N2 I2 = KI2
The total primary current I1 will be the phasor sum of I'2 and I0 i.e.,
Phasor Diagram:
Fig. below shows the phasor diagram of a practical transformer for
the usual case of inductive load, both E1 and E2 lag the mutual flux f
by 90°. The current I'2 represents the primary current to neutralize
the demagnetizing effect of secondary current I2. Now I'2 = K I2 and is
opposite to I2. Also I0 is the no-load current of the transformer. The
phasor sum of I'2 and I0 gives the total primary current I1.
Note that counter emf that opposes the applied voltage V1 is -E1.
Therefore, if we add I1R1 (in phase with I1) and I1 X1 (90° ahead of I1)
to -E1, we get the applied primary voltage V1. The phasor E2
represents the induced emf in the secondary by the mutual flux. The
secondary terminal voltage V2 will be what is left over after
subtracting I2R2 and I2X2 from E2.
Load power factor = cos Ф2
Primary power factor = cos Ф1
Input power to transformer, P1 = V1I1 cos Ф1
Output power of transformer, P2 = V2I2 cos Ф2
Note: The reader may draw the phasor diagram of a loaded transformer for (i) unity
p.f. and (ii) leading p.f. as an exercise.
1.10. Equivalent circuit of Transformer
The term equivalent circuit of a machine means the combination of fixed and
variable resistances and reactance’s, which exactly simulates performance and
working of the machine.
For a transformer, no load primary current has two components,
Im = Io sinΦo = Magnetizing component
Ic = Io cosΦo = Active component
Im produces the flux and is assumed to flow through reactance X o called no
load reractance while Ic is active component representing core losses hence is
assumed to flow through the reactance Ro. Hence equivalent circuit on no load can
be shown as in the Fig. 1. This circuit consisting of Ro and Xo in parallel is called
exciting circuit. From the equivalent circuit we can write,
Ro = V1/Ic
and Xo= V1/Im
When the is connected to the transformer then secondary current I2 flows. This
causes voltage drop across R2 and R2. Due to I2, primary draws an additional
current
I2' = I2/ K. Now I1 is the phasor addition of Io and I2'. This I1 causes the voltage
drop across primary resistance R1 and reactance X1.
Hence the equivalent circuit can be shown as in the Fig.below
But in the equivalent circuit, windings are not shown and it is further simplified by
transferring all the values to the primary or secondary. This makes the transformer
calculation much easy.
So transferring secondary parameters to primary we get,
R2'= R2/K2 , X2' = X2/K2' , Z2' = Z2/K2
While E2' = E2/K' I2' = K I2
Where K = N2 /N1
While transferring the values remember the rule that
Low voltage winding High current Low impedance
High voltage winding Low current High impedance
Thus the exact equivalent circuit referred to primary can be shown as in the
Fig. Below
Similarly all the primary value can be referred to secondary and we can obtain the
equivalent circuit referred to secondary.
R1' = K2 R1 , X1' = K2 X1, Z1' = K2 Z1
E1'= K E1, Io' = I1 /K' Io' = Io /K
Similarly the exciting circuit parameter also gets transferred to secondary as
Ro'and Xo '. The circuit is shown in the Fig.below,
Now as long as no load branch i.e. exciting branch is in between Z 1 and Z2', the
impedances can not be combined. So further simplification of the circuit can be
done. Such circuit is called approximate equivalent circuit.
Approximate Equivalent Circuit
To get approximate equivalent circuit, shift the no load branch containing R o
and Xo to the left of R1 and X1. By doing this we are creating an error that the drop
across R1 and X1due to Io is neglected. Hence such an equivalent circuit is called
approximate equivalent circuit.
So approximate equivalent circuit referred to primary can be as shown in the
Fig. below,
In this circuit now R1 and R2' can be combined to get equivalent resistance
referred to primary R1e as discussed earlier. Similarly X1and X1' can be combined to
get X1e. And equivalent circuit can be simplified as shown in the Fig. 6.
1.11.Losses in a Transformer
The power losses in a transformer are of two types, namely;
1. Core or Iron losses 2. Copper losses
NOTE: The above losses appear in the form of heat and produce (i) an increase in
temperature and (ii) a drop in efficiency.
1. Core or Iron losses (Pi)
These consist of hysteresis and eddy current losses and occur in the transformer
core due to the alternating flux.
NOTE: The hysteresis loss can be minimized by using steel of high silicon content
whereas eddy current loss can be reduced by using core of thin laminations.
2. Copper losses (PC)
These losses occur in both the primary and secondary windings due to their ohmic
resistance. These can be determined by short-circuit test
Total copper Cu losses:
Like any other electrical machine, the efficiency of a transformer is defined as the
ratio of output power (in watts or kW) to input power (watts or kW) i.e.
In practice, open-circuit and short-circuit tests are carried out to find the
efficiency,
For a load of given pf, efficiency depends upon load current I2. Hence, the efficiency
to be maximum the denominator should be minimum i.e.
Hence efficiency of a transformer will be maximum when copper losses are equal to
constant or iron losses.
From above, the load current I2 corresponding to maximum efficiency is:
NOTE: In a transformer, iron losses are constant whereas copper losses are
variable. In order to obtain maximum efficiency, the load current should be such
that total Cu losses become equal to iron losses.
Output kVA corresponding to Maximum Efficiency
Let PC = Copper losses at full-load kVA
Pi = Iron losses
x = Fraction of full-load kVA at which efficiency is maximum
Total Cu losses = x2 ×PC
or
The ratio of output in kWh to the input in kWh of a transformer over a 24-hour
period is known as all-day efficiency i.e.:
The +ve sign is for lagging p.f. and -ve sign for leading p.f.
NOTE: It may be noted that % voltage regulation of the transformer will be the
same whether primary or secondary side is considered.
UNIT II TESTING OF TRANSFORMERS
Open and short circuit tests are performed on a transformer to determine the:
1. Equivalent circuit of transformer
2. Voltage regulation of transformer
3. Efficiency of transformer
The power required for open circuit tests and short circuit tests on a
transformer is equal to the power loss occurring in the transformer.
Usually high voltage (HV) winding is kept open and the low voltage (LV) winding is
connected to its normal supply. A wattmeter (W), ammeter (A) and voltmeter (V) are
connected to the LV winding as shown in the figure. Now, applied voltage is slowly
increased from zero to normal rated value of the LV side with the help of a variac.
When the applied voltage reaches to the rated value of the LV winding, readings
from all the three instruments are taken.
The ammeter reading gives the no load current I 0. As I0 itself is very small, the
voltage drops due to this current can be neglected.
The input power is indicated by the wattmeter (W). And as the other side of
transformer is open circuited, there is no output power. Hence, this input power
only consists of core losses and copper losses. As described above, no-load current
is so small that these copper losses can be neglected. Hence, now the input power
is almost equal to the core losses. Thus, the wattmeter reading gives the core losses
of the transformer.
Sometimes, a high resistance voltmeter is connected across the HV winding.
Though, a voltmeter is connected, HV winding can be treated as open circuit as the
current through the voltmeter is negligibly small. This helps in to find voltage
transformation ratio (K).
The two components of no load current can be given as,
Iμ = I0sinΦ0 and Iw = I0cosΦ0.
cosΦ0 (no load power factor) = W / (V1I0). ... (W = wattmeter reading)
From this, shunt parameters of equivalent circuit parameters of equivalent circuit
of transformer (X0 and R0) can be calculated as
X0 = V1/Iμ and R0 = V1/Iw.
(These values are referring to LV side of the transformer.)
Hence, it is seen that open circuit test gives core losses of transformer and shunt
parameters of the equivalent circuit.
The connection diagram for short circuit test or impedance test on transformer
is as shown in the figure below. The LV side of transformer is short circuited and
wattmeter (W), voltmere (V) and ammeter (A) are connected on the HV side of the
transformer. Voltage is applied to the HV side and increased from the zero until the
ammeter reading equals the rated current. All the readings are taken at this rated
current.
The ammeter reading gives primary equivalent of full load current (I sc).
The voltage applied for full load current is very small as compared to rated voltage.
Hence, core loss due to small applied voltage can be neglected. Thus, the wattmeter
reading can be taken as copper loss in the transformer.
From the above transformer tests, it can be seen that Cu loss of a transformer
depends on current, and iron loss depends on voltage. Thus, total transformer loss
depends on volt-ampere (VA). It does not depend on the phase angle between
voltage and current, i.e. transformer loss is independent of load power factor. This
is the reason that transformers are rated in kVA.
2.2. SUMPNER'S TEST OR BACK TO BACK TEST ON TRANSFORMER:
Sumpner's test
Sumpner's test or back to back test can be employed only when two identical
transformers are available. Both transformers are connected to supply such that
one transformer is loaded on another. Primaries of the two identical transformers
are connected in parallel across a supply. Secondary’s are connected in series such
that emf's of them are opposite to each other. Another low voltage supply is
connected in series with secondary’s to get the readings, as shown in the circuit
diagram shown below.
From above test results, the full load efficiency of each transformer can be given
as -
The phasor diagram under this case is shown in the Fig. 3. The two impedances Z 1
and Z2 are in parallel. The values of Z1 and Z2 are with respect to secondary.
Z1 and Z2 are in parallel therefore the equivalent impedance is given by,
1/Zeq = 1/Z1 + 1/Z2 Zeq = Z1 Z2 /(Z1 + Z2 )
As seen from the phasor diagram
I1 Z1 = I2 Z2 = I Zeq
I1 = I Zeq/ Z1 = I Z2 /( Z1 + Z2 )
I2 = I Zeq/ = I Z1/( Z1 + Z2 )
Multiplying both terms of above equation by voltage V 2,
V2 I1 = = V2 I Z2 /( Z1 + Z2 )
V2 I2 = V2 I Z1/( Z1 + Z2)
But V2 I x 10-3 is Q i.e. the combined load in KVA
From this KVA carried by each transformer is calculated as,
𝑍2 1
𝑄1 = 𝑄. = 𝑄.
𝑍1 + 𝑍2 𝑍
1 + 𝑍1
2
𝑍1 1
𝑎𝑛𝑑 𝑄2 = 𝑄. = 𝑄.
𝑍1 + 𝑍2 𝑍
1 + 𝑍2
1
𝐸1 𝐸2
+
𝑍1 𝑍2
𝐼𝐿 =
𝑍 (𝑍 + 𝑍2 )
1+ 𝐿 1
𝑍1 𝑍2
𝐸1 𝐸2
+
𝑍1 𝑍2
𝐼𝐿 =
𝑍 𝑍
1 + 𝑍𝐿 + 𝑍𝐿
2 1
𝐸1 𝐸2 𝐸1 𝐸2
𝑍1 + 𝑍2 𝑍1 + 𝑍2
𝑉2 = 𝐼𝐿 𝑍𝐿 = [ ] 𝑍𝐿 =
𝑍 𝑍 1 1 1
1 + 𝑍𝐿 + 𝑍𝐿 +𝑍 +𝑍
2 1 𝑍𝐿 2 1
The two transformers will operate at different power factor Φ 1 and Φ2 are the power
factor angles of these two transformers whereas Φ is the combined p.f. angle.
Here EA and EB have the same phase but there may be some phase difference
between the two due to some difference of internal connection as for the connection
in parallel of a Star/Star and a Star/Delta 3 phase transformers.
2.4. AUTOTRANSFORMERS:
Let,
• V1 – primary applied voltage
• V2 – secondary voltage across the load
• I1 – primary current
• I2 – load current
• N1 – number of turns between A and B
• N2 – number of turns between C and B
• Neglecting no load current, leakage reactance and losses,
• V1 = E1 and V2 = E2
Therefore the transformation ratio
Equation (1) and (2) shows that the ampere turns due to section BC and AC
balance each other which is characteristic of the transformer action.
VOLTAMPERE RELATIONS:
• A 2-winding Transformer transfers electrical power from primary to
secondary by induction.
• Where as in an auto transformer transfers electrical power between primary
and secondary circuits partly through the magnetic link (induction) and
partly by direct electrical connection (conduction).
• Thus auto transformer has two types of volt amperes (I) Transformed Volt
ampere and (II) Conducted Volt ampere
• Transformer action takes place in between winding AC and winding CB.
• In other words, the volt amperes across winding AC are transferred by
transformer action to the load connected across winding CB.
• Therefore Transformed VA = VAC IAC = (V1-V2)*I1.
• Total input VA to transformer = V1*I1 = output VA
Therefore Transformed VA / Input VA = (1-K)
i.e. Out of the input volt amperes V1I1 only VAC IAC are transformed to the
output by transformer action.
• The rest of the volt amperes are conducted directly from the input.
• Therefore conducted VA = Total input VA – Tranformed VA = V1I1-(V1-V2)I1 =
V2I1
Therefore Conducted VA / Input VA = K
Neglecting internal impedance drops and losses,
1. Additive Polarity
2. Subtractive Polarity
• Ratings:
kVA rating as an autotransformer/kVA rating as a two winding transformer =
Primary input voltage V1 * Primary input current I1 /Primary voltage across wdg AC
* primary current in AC = V1 I1 / (V1 – V2) I1 = 1/ (1-k)
• Losses:
Per unit full load losses as auto transformer / per unit full load losses as two
winding transformer = (1-k)
• Impedance drop:
Per unit impedance drop as an auto transformer / per unit impedance drop as
two winding transformer = (1-k)
• Voltage regulations:
Regulation as an auto transformer / Regulation as two winding transformer =
(1-k)
• Short Circuit Current:
Per unit short circuit current as an auto transformer / per unit short circuit
current as two winding transformer = 1/ (1-k)
Advantages:
• An autotransformer requires less Cu than a two-winding transformer
of similar rating.
• An autotransformer operates at a higher efficiency than a two-winding
transformer of similar rating.
• An autotransformer has better voltage regulation than a two-winding
transformer of the same rating.
• An autotransformer has smaller size than a two-winding transformer of the
same rating.
• An autotransformer requires smaller exciting current than a two-winding
transformer of the same rating.
Applications:
VLP 3VP
K
VLS 3VS
• Two serious concerns on Y-Y connection
1- If loads on transformer cct. are unbalanced, voltages on phases of
transformer severely unbalanced, also source is loaded in an unbalanced
form.
2- Third harmonic voltages can be large (there is no path for passage of
third harmonic current)
• Both concerns on unbalance load condition & large 3 rd Harmonic voltages
can be rectified as follows:
• Solidly grounding the neutrals of windings, especially primary winding, this
connection provide a path for 3 rd harmonic current flow, produced and do
not let build up of large 3rd voltages. Also provides a return path for any
current imbalances in load.
• Adding a third winding (tertiary) connected in Δ
• (a) 3rd harmonic components of voltage in Δ will add up, causing a
circulating current flow within winding
• (b) tertiary winding should be large enough to handle circulating currents
(normally 1/3 of power rating of two main windings)
• One of these corrective techniques should be employed with Y-Y, however
normally very few transformer with this type of connection is employed
(others can do the same job).
•
WYE-DELTA CONNECTION
• VLP=√3 VφP, while : VLS= VφS
• Voltage ratio of each phase : VφP/ VφS=K
• VLP/ VLS= √3 VφP/ VφS= √3 K Y-Δ
• Y-Δ doesn’t have shortcomings of Y-Y regarding generation of third harmonic
voltage since the Δ provide a circulating path for 3rd Harmonic
• Y-Δ is more stable w.r.t. unbalanced loads, since Δ partially redistributes any
imbalance that occurs.
• This configuration causes secondary voltage to be shifted 30◦ relative to
primary voltage.
• If secondary of this transformer should be paralleled with secondary of
another transformer without phase shift, there would be a problem.
• The phase angles of secondary’s must be equal if they are to be paralleled, it
means that direction of phase shifts also should be the same
• In figure shown here, secondary lags primary if abc phase sequence applied,
• However secondary leads primary when acb phase sequence applied
DELTA-WYE CONNECTION
• In Δ-Y primary line voltage is equal to primary phase voltage VLP=VφP, in
secondary VLS=√3VφS
• Line to line voltage ratio ;
• VLP/ VLS = VφP/ [√3 VφS ]=K/√3 Δ-Y
• This connection has the same advantages & phase shifts as Y- Δ
• And Secondary voltage lags primary voltage by 30◦ with abc phase sequence
DELTA-DELTA CONNECTION
• In Δ-Δ connection VLP= VφP and VLS= VφS
• Voltage ratio : VLP/VLS= VφP / VφS =K Δ-Δ
• This configuration has no phase shift and there is no concern about
unbalanced loads or harmonics