Glass Ceiling Factors, Job Satisfaction and Job Switching Decisions of Female Employees in Private Sector Enterprises of Bangladesh
Glass Ceiling Factors, Job Satisfaction and Job Switching Decisions of Female Employees in Private Sector Enterprises of Bangladesh
net/publication/330397209
Glass Ceiling Factors, Job Satisfaction and Job Switching Decisions of Female
Employees in Private Sector Enterprises of Bangladesh. The Business Review,
5, 79-97, ISSN: 1996-3637.
CITATIONS READS
0 56
3 authors:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Religiosity and Fraud Triangle Elements Towards Petty Corruption View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Dr. Nazrul Islam on 03 January 2020.
79
The Business Review Vol. 5, 2016
- t Intnooucuon
Glass Ceiling means invisible baniers that impede the career advancement of
women employees. It refers to situations where the advancement of qualified
women within the hierarchy of an organization is halted at a particular level because
ofdiscrimination, most commonly sexism or racism. This situation is refened to as
a "ceiling" as there is a limitation, blocking upward advalcement, and "glass"
(transparent) because the limitation is not immediately apparent and is normally an
unwritten and unofficial policy which is invisible in nature (Afza & Newaz, 2008)'
Several studies show that the disparity between male and female participation
in
public and private sector business is wicle in most of the third world countries'
Women have little or unequal access to emplolment. An insignifrcant number of
women occupy key decision making positions (United Nations, 1989)' Women are
unable to exert power over economic strucflrle in their societies They are virtually
poorly representerl in economic decision making (Platform for Action, n d') Social
and economic policies wholly or partially directed towards women remain inad-
equate in resoiving problems as they often reflect male perceptions, thereby,
contributing to inequalities between the male and female employees (Afza &
Newaz, 2008). In the workplaces ofBanglaclesh, women are discriminated based on
stereotypical perceptions. It is generally argued that in the developing world, like
Bangladesh, where almost half the population is women, the need for involving
women in the development process can make them more empowered and hence
increase the chances for development (Afza & Newaz, 2008).
Recent research suggests that improved education and training facilities for
women can open up more opporfunities for women as far as getting access in the
process ofdevelopment. According to Afza and Newaz (2008), in Bangladesh, the
itereotypical perception reiults in differing attitude in both genders regarding
women's participation in di{ferent sectors ofthe economy ln the society, women
are portrayed as weak, unassuming, passive, feminine, submissive, and dependent'
In tle workplaces, it is observed that the discriminatory practices against female
employees that include attitudes of employers suggesting women are not capable
enough physically mentally and emotionally. Studies show that women become
temperamental very easily and do not possess enough motivation to do theirjobs
weli and hence the common beliefis that women perform well in haditionalroles
that include teaching in primary schools, working in the NGOs' social, health and
welfare organizations instead of working in administrative and management
positions. The stereotype about female employees is that they are committed and
efficient only for a short period of time and are generally not reliable'
80
Nazmul, et al. : Glass Ceiling Factors, Job Sali{aclior, and Job Switching of Fenale Enployees
Women are believed to have health concems and are easily wlnerable to sickness
and therefore frequently remain absent from work. In addition, it is believed that
pregnancies intenupt women's regular work and their careers are disrupted by
family obligations (Zafarullah, 2000). According to Hossain (2007), there is a com-
ponent of knowledge in the literature about women's career within organizations
that suggests that it is the organization itself that plays a key role in the advance-
ment of women in the organizational hierarchy (e.g. Liff & Ward, 2001; Benschop
& Dooreward, 1998). Hence, this study attempts to determine the extent to which
female employees ofBangladesh face glass ceiling barriers, its type aad that factors
that create this banier.
The term 'Glass Ceiling' has fust been identified by Carol Hymowitz and
Timothy Schellhardt in an article, published on March 24th edition of the "Wall
Street Joumal" in 1986. The article revealed the invisible barriers that impede the
career advancement of women in the American workforce. The term glass ceiling
was coined prior to 1984 by two women at Hewlett-Packard in 1979, Katherine
Lawrence aad Marianne Sclreiber described that there seemed to be a clear path
of promotion, but in actuality women seemed to hit a point where they seemed
unable to progress beyond. However, Gay Bryant used the term prior to that, in
one ofhis articles published in Adweek in March 1984. According to Davidson
and Burke (2000), the concept of glass ceiling refers to an invisible, but imper-
meable banier that limits the career advancement of female employees.
81
The Busi ess Review VoL 5, 2016
In the same research, they found evidence of a glass ceiling for women, but
racial inequalities among men do not follow a similar pattem. Glass ceiling
appeared to be a distinctively gender phenomenon. The concept of glass ceiling
is an oft-used metaphor for the relative disadvantages regarding women's career
opportunities, alluding to the growing difficulties for women when moving up to
the career ladder (e.g. Cotter et a1.,2001; Charles & Grusky, 1995). It creates a
situation where there is a definite stop for women at a certain level in the hierar-
chy of the organization (Baxter & Wright, 2000; Britton & Williams, 2000)'
Present research studies in the developed countries further reveal that female
employees achieve progression in their career ladders ascribe it to the efforts of
their organizations (Hossain, 2007). These employees state that their organiza-
tions identify and develop high-potential employees, provide high visibility
assignments, social support, and mentoring programs for female employees
(Burke & Nelson, 2002). Similarly, in some developing countries like Bangla-
desh, India, the govemment has been taking initiatives to promote female partici-
pation in employment, by providing special provision such as quota protection
for women (Hossain, 2007). This is working as a positive incentive for female
graduates to embrace a career in the governmentjob. Howevet, some reseatchers
argue that the quota system is linked to the concept of reverse discrimination.
Under this system, an employer would be required by law to employ a certain
proportion ftom the marginalized group, such as females. It may cause psycho'
logical strain on quota appointees as they generally look down upon by the selec-
tion process on the basis of merit (Zafarullah & Kian, 1989).
Several reasons for difficulties in career opportunities for women have been identi-
fied in research. Ffust, men in managerial positions prefer people with cultural prefer-
ences similar to their own, or that managers have a preference for appointing people
similar in this respect to others already employed in the otganization (Kanter, 1997).
Q.)
r
Nozmul, el al. : Glajs Ceiling Factors, Job Satisfaction, and Job Switching of Female Employees
This kind of homo-sociality implies that men have a tendency to prefer men to
self-reflection, relaxation and social support, the intention being to confirm their
own identity and cultural norms (Lipman-Blumen, 1976; Maume Jr, 1999).
Alother tlpe ofexplanation is based on prevalence ofsexist attitudes, e.g. that men
are better suited t0 leadership positions than are women (Kanter, 1997; Reskin &
Hartrnann, 1986). Such attitudes could be used by men in shategies to secure
power, authority and other privileges (Acker, 1990). Employers avoid promoting
women because women as a group are absent ftom work more than men, child
bearing and childcare responsibilities (where women are assumed to have larger
responsibilities than men) (Rosenfeld, Van Buren, & Kalleberg, 1998). Despite a
well-developed child care system, there seems to be a conflict between work and
family, which cause practicai problem, especially for women with small children
(Ginn et al., 1996). As a consequence, women's aspirations could be lowered and
their career prospects obstructed. Al1 the above mentioned reasons are clearly
comected to the idea ofglass ceiling existence in an organization.
84
Vol' 5' 2016
The Busoless Review
1.3 Discrimination
at Work I
AccordingtoHosain(reeer.illtY$'lr'.',.111
where male dominance
u!" uri
ovet \\ur
U..11t-t,1,1
p"** 1"."#il.,i orJr'*o*.n *g.11*.oroorn
i|.ji::ffi*$f, \
are said ro exercise
tii., *.t ;p., of g.na.,
erw. income and women's
labut r,* to, niti.,
relations within
B.trrcltdt:lit:^il ,l ,o.r.rv, .*proTl^l_,,nui.,
*u .uuru_
been on tbe same
,.*, ,J l,i.arrf;ns as for r
tvi]]Ifi;;; in occupa-
females have not sex segregation
rffiffdfi.f#'ffiiil:#ilffi\
;i:'m-l:;;ril1:!:1,*:*,f.ffi:r***'*llff:.trH
i*i:'yl*,:.'I:!*
financial
Hltill*in*r,nt*."
srtrrutt@a,t.i"
independence. Dur
ot
rqvv'
rrrlrr rru,rrr.*son.
women artu
l9gl).
tu'1ure exp
"a I
\
I
tion and discrimination I
lfrffi F.*iliiiffi
resulr in occuparional
segreganon
*'-*":ffiand socia[ in
restrictioos are imPosed
females with males'
on rne iirrn.i'"rr"ott,a,
''.'-{ffi
86
et al. : Glass Ceilihg Factots, Job Satisloctio , and Job Switching oJ Female Enployees
^tazmul,
Jn the other hand, in the family, a female person's life is controlled through
rle authority, by imposing the whole burden of domestic work upon her, in
dition to the paid work or employment in the public sphere or at the worlglace.
iost males feel that domestic work like child-rearing, childbeadng, cooking,
ad washing clothes are not their job, and also some of them thinks that it is
,elow their dignity to perform those responsibilities. By defining females as
ximary domestic workers and sexual and reproductive property of men, and by
assigning priority to male paid employment, society devalues both the educa-
tional talent, ard the economic and social contributions offemales.
Nevertheless, recent studies show that as with all quota systems, there have
been administrative issues in relation to equitable and fair heatment (Hossain,
2007). It has been found that many positions reserved for females are not filled
because ofgender biases in administration. Also, in several cases, these reserved
positions are filled from within the regional quotas. Thus, most females who are
bom and raised in rural areas fail to get into the public or civil service due to lack
of access to information. The Public Service Commission @SC) in Bangladesh
has also been unable to improve the actual implementation ofthe quota system
and the way it is perceived. This is partly because ofthe abuse by adminisfrators
to drive their relatives and friends into the system. Unfofunately, neither the
PSC nor the govemment organizations on a regular basis, monitor and evaluate
the working ofthe quota system and its impact on equity and access issues. As
evident from the case ofBangladesh, quotas have actually limited the opportuni-
ties for females to enter the civil service and have failed to eliminate discrimina-
tion against females (Zafarullah, 2000).
87
T
in organiza-
thal women's plofessional careers
The review of literature reveals
norms' political pressues
,t#;;;;rt fl,enced by familv' socio-cultural
ly t
mav also influence a person's
*offi "
*tff as social life' In Bangladesh'
ll
ll
Nazn , el al. : Glass Ceiling Factors, Job Satisfaction, and Job Switching of Female Employees
. 2. DATAAND METIIOD0L0GY
This quaatitative study conducted stmctured questionnaire survey of 177 female
employees from two private sector industries - banking and telecommunication in
Bangladesh. The data were collected in December 20 I 6 by using random sampling
techniques. This research used Ordered Logit Models, since the variables were
measured on an ordinal scale ftom highly satisfied to highly dissatisfied. Other
reasons for using logit model are:
i. 0utcome variable is categorical from predictor variables that are continuous
and/or categorical.
ii. The outcome variable must be discrete.
Regression Model
The study used Ordered Logit and Binary Logit regressions. The functional
forms ofthe equations are as follows:
x33)
Y1=/(X1, ..., (1)
Y2= l(x1,...,x33) a)
The measurements ofthe variables are as follows:
x29 Discriminatedinfinancialbenefitsofthejobaswomen,yes=3.No!sure=2,
no=l)
skl1ls recognition as women' yes=3'
Nol
x30 Ois"ii.ioation in .fficiencyi
sure=2, no=1)
x31 Lessjob security women, yes=1, no=0)
as
91
The Business Review, Vol. 5, 2016
Table 3. Regression ouryut on the factor influencing thejob satisfaction of female employees
Model 1 Model 2
Variable
Odd Ratio Frob. Odd R.atio Prob,
xl 1.040613 0.4526 1.022 0;7062
x2 1.094481 0.8019 0.282 0.0158
x3 1.041287 0.917'7 0.388 0.1105
x4 1.127',7 45 0.8118 0.432 0.3031
x5 0.147'79 0.0064 l6.l6l 0.096
0.515702 0.0874 2.095 0.1906
x7 0.838299 0.6468 1.522 0.4523
x8 0.714881 0.1324 1.355 0.4089
x9 1.619891 0.0279 0.546 0.1207
x10 2.1t2387 0.0276 0.546 0.2228
xll 0.641346 0.2725 3.888 0.014
xt2 0.741333 0.4804 1.853 0.3392
92
t'
I
.
Nazmxl, et al. : Glass Ceiling Factots, Job Satisfaction, ohd Job Switchi g ol Fehale Employees
YI Y2
Dependent Variable
Model Tlpe Ordered Logit Binary Logit
Pseudo R-squared 0.124748
Schwarz criterion 3.1091 I 1 .77 6957
Hannan-Quinn criter. 2.7t 4437 1.414285
LR statistic 51.13822
Prob(LR statistic) 0.029805
Akaike info criterion 2.445169 1.166849
Log likelihood -179.397
Restr. log likelihood 204.967 -69.26613
Avg. log likelihood -1.01355 -0.391334
Mean dependent var 0.531073 0.531073
S.E. ofregression 0.395235 0.395235
22.33814 22.33814
The Odd ratios are calculated as d$
93
The Business Review, Vol. 5, 2016
There are several demographic, job related, and glass ceiling related factors
that statistically significantly affect the plan of changing the cunent job (Y2) of
the women employees. Some of the variables show Odd ratio more than l,
indicating having influences on willingness to shifting or changing jobs within 5
years. Those who have training (X1 l) or consider themselves more skilled would
like to switch or change to better jobs. Those who have refused to take job
anytime before (X16) also would like to change their present jobs.
More importantly, unlike the job satisfaction, there are several glass ceiling
factors that influence the plan of changing the present job (Y2) of the women
employees. Those women employees, who feel that they are discriminated by
any male colleague (X2 I ), discriminated for moving up the higher management
positions (X27), discriminated for promotion (X28), and holding lessjob security
(X31) would like to switch to better jobs. Though theses glass ceiling factors
show statistically significant relationship with their plan to change job, only
8-16% ofthe employees agreed that these glass ceiling factors are available in
their present jobs. On the other hand, some other factors show a statistically
significant relationship with not willing to change jobs, like the married women
(X2) or the women who like to be isolated in the workplace $24) or those who
have a good network and understanding within the organization (X32).
4. DISCUSSIONS
Women's professional careers in organizations are mainly influenced by
family, socio-cultural norms, political pressures and these may also influence a
person's working as well as social life. Among the women, those who are involved
in their presentjob for a long time and satisfied about their salaries are also satis-
fied in their presentjobs. Beyond the job satisfaction, women employees are also
likely to change their jobs if they have training or consider themselves more
skilled as well as in the case ifthey have refused to take job an1'time before. Inter-
estingly, there is no glass ceiling related variables that are statistically significant
with the job satisfaction, but there are several glass ceiling factors that influence
the plan of changing or switching the present job. Those who feel that they are
discriminated by any male colleague, discriminated for moving to higher manage-
ment positions, discriminated for promotion, and holding less job security would
likely to change theirjobs. 0vera11, the women employees working in the banking
sector hold more job satisfaction than those of the telecommunication sector- This
study has attempted to determine the extent to which female employees of
Bangladesh face the problem ofglass ceiling and the types of barriers they face,
in order to provide recommendations that would help overcome the problem. This
study has certain significant implications. It has been suggested whether glass
ceiling is an acute problem for female employees in Bangladesh. Also, *re study
revealed the reasons for the prevalence ofglass ceiling in Bangladesh.
94
Nazmul, et al. : Glass Ceiling Factots, Job Satisfaction, ahd Job Switching of Female Enployees
I factors Gender discrimination and salary disparities were reported by women partici-
(Y2) of pating in this study, as was resenfinent by men toward women regarding affirma-
than l, tive action issues. Women in this study also believe that corporate culhres and
within 5 maintenance of men's power results in several unwitten rules: like women are
d would fine to be hired, but only for certain types ofjobs in certain areas such as commu-
ake job nications, customer service where women will work harder than men, and
because women are willing to work harder, they will be given more work.
ceiling The literature suggests that both organizational cultural factors and extemal
women environmental factors of an organization can account for the low proportion of
rted by female employees at the top level of different organizations and these factors are
Sement very much contexlspecific. Thus the focus of this research is, to identifu and
ecurity examine obstacles, which lead to female employee absence in the top manage-
factors ment level ofprivate sector industries in Bangladesh. It aims to provide a current
r, only understanding ofthe career experiences of female employees based on organiza-
rble in tional culture typologies, which could lead to better utilization oftalented women
tically
in the present competitive private sector industries in Bangladesh. The essential
r'omen
foundation of constructive social change is good understanding, ard the research
e who
will hopefully contribute to both. This study made an attempt to identifu the
causes of glass ceiling effects in the private sectors of Bangladesh and recom-
mended solutions for such.
:d by
5. CONCLUSIONS AND R.ECOMMENDATIONS
nce a
This research on women employees discovered a significant relationship
olved
between the gender stereotype of a woman employee and her career aspiration.
satis-
: also The findings also reveal that women employees possess all the attributes for top
more management; but what affects them are family issues, individual factors
nter- (gender-imposed) and organizational factors. From the analysis, some sugges-
icant tions provided by successful female managers on what can make women better
ence managers or leaders are grouped and listed as: Gender-sensitivity in the orgaaiza-
I ate tion, women's education/education of the girl child, male involvement in home
age' front care, leadership training and development for women, mentoring of
ould women and social networking among women. In order to improve the situa-
king tion, several initiatives need to be taken in the organizations. Awareness creation
Ihis or awareness building about gender discriminations and gender sensitivities
iof among the male and female employees can improve the situation. Moreover,
'ace,
organizational policies need to be focused on standard and ethical Human
fhis
Resource (HR) practices. There should be strict and standard HR policies and
lass
guidelines to deal with issues or cases ofdiscriminations, harassments and other
rdy
related gender sensitive matters.
95
Naztfiul, et al. : Glass Ceiling Faclors, Job Satitfaction, a d Job Syritching of Female Employees
Rrrnnnncns
- Ill Acker. J. (1990). Hierarchies,
iobs. borlies: A theory of gendered organiz tions. Gen.ler
tociety, 412\.l3g-lsg &
t2l ADB (200J). Asian Development
Asia _ Oulook 2003: Ecohomic Trends dnd prospects
i Developihg
Bansradesi.philioiner.
-A,,un ,' ",J"nll""ti#j,10 o",
b;;;p;;;;"
pl Arsar,
iT:r]*J*;lll;:,p"cumentsriooks,ADor20o:lban.,sf
K. (1999). Is milrotiok tranf*,ing^tttral povirty to urban areas?
tonqitudinat sumey dara An analysis of
of Dhala rin. luper
presenr,ea ai rtr;';;t;;"p:t;rg.,
Determtnants^of Urban poveny.
L4l
f*rr,-Cr*.* S"rk.'-"--*.,"
Dhaka. C'ranea, ""d
f,i,i;*rt ##1X"6;,Y,ioi'"','"t"Ll;i':'ro't"''ioing *'" r'"-'*e orGlass ceiring and
in Bangladesh. BMC Univenitt Joumal,
92. J(l), g5_
t5l Astin. H. & Davjs. D. (19g5). Research ?rodlctivity
iacf jrlarors and predictors for across the Life and Career Cycles:
Women. r" rr,I r
I:ues P:oblet-n:, ond Sotutioas tpp. t47_t60). ro* r-eir.i i"* ir,irr )fr,iruunrg,
.. ." -.." .,
tsaxter. J.. & Wrighl E. O.
Boulder, CO: "i*t,
w.irui.ir.
t6l r2000r. ft" gtass ceifing-hypothe; i.orpuru,lr"
un rred $are-s. sweden. an d " study of rhe
awmlia. Gender & Soueryi t lq)1,,
U) Betlas. M. L. r t992). The Effecrs 2j 5l-2g?'-
h aculty Men: The (House
of varirats,"*. ilWi;;;;;;;yment on fie Salaries of
oenscnop. y.. & Doorewaard.
) Wile Bonus. 6erde r & ,\o, i"^) t\
Ano A11
l j"*,
t81 H. { t998 i. six of one.-anj i ^t
subtext ofTaylorism and eam-based rher: The gender
work. Ge d"r, W"rf &"if "j,rr.;i;;.
;rgr;;,;;,
tel tsfiagen. E.. & Ohls. M. a2006). The plass ;:i;
ceiling r^,here is il? Women.s and mm,s
prospects in the prilate vs. the oubic sector career
rkvaw, 54lll,2o-4., .
in sweden 1979-2000.The Sociological
3,i#:&rj];;fr#illiams c L
t10l (2000) Response to Baxter
and wigft.Gehder &
tl ll Burke, R. and Nelson, D. (2002).
ldua, women's
Careers: Research and practice.
Massachusetts. USA:
Massachusetts,
u2l a.n1,::;., &
usA: Wit"rs\".i7aiirbiiffi
w,*.-o,*u,,,-,, ...",11j-lg
Crusky- D a Liesii Moa.k-ro,
ill-"'
aescribir8 fie underlying srructure
ol sex
segte$atfin. Amprican Joumal oJ Sociologt.
tuul4 ), gJl_qj l .
t13l Cole, J. R., & Zuckerman, H. ttStZr. i
scrence. -trrealrfc 4nencan. 25612),,
,r-,
jil'"'"' motherhood and research performance in
tl4) Lotter. D. A., Herms€n. J. M., Ovadia. s' &
efiect. ;ocial Forces, Sq2),655481.
vanneman' R (2001) The glass ceiling
u5l Davidson, M. & Burke, R. Womer .-ug"ment:
riiwiq6lur.rrr'
uaudson. R. J. B
Davidson. & R_.1 rL. rF,lc
1ZOOO1.
\ 'l \Curent
urrmr research issues.
r: In M. J.
Burke rr/o*r;';;','
(tdq.). ,,.^_--.- ._, ,r,ln
yanafey?n \pp r-l'
l-7). Lonoon:sage.
London: Sage.
ESC{p 11999y.
tl6l ESC{P r I99sr Gender nt*---:^-- . r-'-:'"''-wv'
can,to,Dimensions.l
tconomic and
Economic Socral a-^-_;.;^-
an.l s6.,,1
. -"
.^_ -, ,
opulal,ton and D?velopment
u(vetopnent u in South'Fdst
South-Easr Atia
Asia.
Commission for. thi L sra and Pacific. Asian Popularion
t)U. United
150, N,r;^nc
Lrni*rt Nations. Srudies Senes No.
u7l E\tefts,l. (19961. Gender akd Career in Scie
s& LaBtte(rt1g'
f.li "
Engineering. London:
Lonoon: Iaylor&
u8l Human
Humax Develonfr.nr a.-^n ,r^^i.
Development n.porr rZOO:f. ,,.,xce
lavlor & Fmnct!.
Franci!.
.\atrcns b t:nd Human po,.,, u"* Goals ) conpacr Anong
ir:x :,!:r,y: :y :
tlel Plat{orn for ALtion tn.d)
*",. Y",i
r^.0.'K!i!1,?-?:'"1.*,:,
ror.t worfJ- -" "''
:i,,.,r, o"iti r;#ffi;J?ff",f
vurYltJ'v rr(ss (-'xlord
I ee5 seprember. Beijing.
( hma. Rerrieved from h*r,***,,"
3*",-"*::'3'*s lyx*,.r*;ffi
'''""'"''"
^-^.131f.:Tli,9l
t20l Ginn. J.. tuber. S.. Brannen, J., Orte. e1- i-
Y*.":
;;;*;;dlffi;J
J
(l'ireo). Feminisr faltacies: a renrt ,^ Ir",, jl-'..:-1!1; P' Pahl Roberts, c. & Ruber).
,"'H"i- l" '""l,1fi:"":,{iiiii^;;Iff";i,; SI,-,,2i '; J.
i:::*J:?{i'i 161 -17 4. " ",,
f?}i;;;
Sociologt, 47(t),
i2tl Goetz. A. M. l2OOl). Women deyeloDhent
a*ghaosn. sicr;tffi;;;; ;;:'#;#'oers: tmptenenihs rurat *edit proerummes in
l) )1 Hossarn. J. (1999).
Gender Eqtnliry Jssu, lhe
u6tr. t oJ Bangladesh. Atr rl".i, .,to. co"i.]1 .construction lndusrry o[ Grearer Dhaka
-yq-1. Asiar bstirure oITechnology, Thaila[d.
96
Nazmul, a al. : Glass Ceilirg Factors, Job Sati:faction, and Job Switching
of Fenate Etryloleer
97