Government Extra Credit
ECON-200 Principles of Microeconomics
1. A senator wants to raise tax revenue and make workers better off. A staff member
proposes raising the payroll tax paid by firms and using part of the extra revenue to
reduce the payroll tax paid by workers. Would this accomplish the senator’s goal?
Explain.
This would not make a difference. The economic incidence of a tax depends on the
elasticity, not on who the government collects the tax from. If we see the first graph
sketched, the tax burden is the same for both parties. Therefore, it’s worse for the
workers. Otherwise, if the supply curve were more inelastic, we would accomplish
reducing that tax burden for the workers and they would be better off.
2. After economics class one day, your friend suggests that taxing food would be a good
way to raise revenue because the demand for food is quite inelastic. In what sense is
taxing food a “good” way to raise revenue? In what sense is it not a “good” way to raise
revenue?
According to the two graphs I sketched, you can see that if it was a normal product
(normal supply and demand) the Deadweight loss would be large. On one hand, if we do
the same graph but with an inelastic good, we can see that the deadweight loss is not that
big. Thanks to this little deadweight loss, a tax raises revenue. Also, thanks to the
inelastic demand, difference in quantity does not vary that much.
On the other hand, households will have to spend more money on supplying their
products and poorer people will struggle more.
3. At Fenway Park, home of the Boston Red Sox, seating is limited to about 38,000. Hence,
the number of tickets issued is fixed at that figure. Seeing a golden opportunity to raise
revenue, the city of Boston levies a per ticket tax of $5 to be paid by the ticket buyer.
Boston sports fans, a famously civic-minded lot, dutifully send in the $5 per ticket. Draw
a well-labeled graph showing the impact of the tax. On whom does the tax burden fall –
the team’s owners, the fans, or both? Why?
Because the supply curve is perfectly inelastic, the tax burden falls on the team’s owners.
The price paid by fans does not rise nut the team receives 5 bucks less per ticket.
4. Draw a supply-and-demand diagram with a tax on the sale of a good. Show the
deadweight loss. Show the tax revenue.