Vertical Integration
Corporate Strategy
Saif Ullah Khan
Vertical Chain
Raw
Vertical Integration = FI + BI
Material
Forward Integration Manufacturer
Backward Integration
Distributor
Final Consumer
Can Vertical Integration Create Competitive
Advantage
Yes, if it meets the VRIO Criteria
1. It is Value able
2. It is rare
3. It is Costly to imitate
4. The firm is organized to take advantage of it.
Value of Vertical Integration
Market vs. Integrated Economic Exchange
Markets and integrated hierarchies are ‘forms’ in which economic exchange can take place
Economic exchange should be conducted in the form that maximizes value for the focal firm. thus, firms assess which
form is likely to generate more value.
Integration makes sense when the focal firm can capture more value than a market exchange provides.
Value of Vertical Integration
Three Value Considerations
Leverage Manage Exploit
Capabilities Opportunism Flexibility
• Firm capabilities may • opportunism may • internalizing is
be sources of competitive be checked by usually less
advantage in other internalizing Different flexible
businesses Mechanism
• internalizing must • flexibility is
• if not, then don’t be less costly than prized when
integrate exchange opportunism uncertainty is high
Value of Vertical Integration
Integration vs. Non-Integration
Firm can create rarity both by integrating and not by integrating.
Pepsi Vs. Coke
Imitability of Vertical Integration
Form, per se, can be imitated.
The value-producing function of integration may be costly to imitate, if:
The integrated firm possesses resource combinations that are the result of:
1. Historical Uniqueness
2. Causal Ambiguity
3. Social Complexity
Small Number Prevent Further Integration
Capital Requirements are Prohibitive
Organizing Vertical Integration
CEO’s Role
Cooperation
Accounting Finance Marketing HR Engineering
Cooperation
Conflict
Original Original Original Original Original
Business Business Business Business Business
New New New New New
Business Business Business Business Business
Conflict
Organizing Vertical Integration
Management Controls:
1. Cooperation and competition among and between functions.
2. The integration of new businesses into the existing business.
3. Time horizon of managers
Budgets Board Committees
separating strategic and operational Provide Oversight and direction to
budgets managers
Strategic Inputs and Outputs Help ensure that strategic direction is
maintained
Operational Outputs
Organizing Vertical Integration
Rewards are given on the basis of:
1. Controlling Opportunism
2. Leveraging Capabilities
3. Exploiting Flexibility