Fmeca: Failure Modes, Effects and Criticality Analysis
Fmeca: Failure Modes, Effects and Criticality Analysis
MANEESH NIDHUL
FMECA
Failure Modes = Incorrect behaviour of a subsystem or component due to a physical or procedural malfunction. Effects = Incorrect behaviour of the system caused by a failure. Criticality Analysis = The combined impact of The probability that a failure will occur The severity of its effect
DEFINITION
FMECA can be explained as a group of activities intended to
Recognise and evaluate the potential failure of a product or process and its effects Identify actions that could eliminate or reduce the chance of potential failures Document the process
Purpose of FMECA
Select the most suitable design with high reliability and high safety potential in the design phases. List potential failures and identify the severity of their effects in the early design phases. Develop criteria for test planning and requirements. Provide necessary documentation for future design and consideration of design changes. Provide a basis for maintenance management. Provide a basis for reliability and availability analyses.
TYPES OF FMECA
Design FMECA It aids in the design process by identifying known and foreseeable failure Ranking failures according to relative impact on the product Process FMCEA Helps to identify potential manufacturing or assembly failures in order to establish controls for occurrence, reductions and detections
Equipment FMECA
Creating a FMECA
FMECA is usually applied as a bottom up technique in which a study is made of how components can fail; the causes of failure and the effects are subsequently identified. This knowledge is then used to study the next higher level of integration and so on until a full understanding is gained of every potential mode of failure throughout the product.
an understanding of how a product can fail at system level can guide the designer in the detailed design of assemblies and components and enable him to better understand how the system may fail from the end users point of view
updated as design evolves Produces a relative measure of the significance of the effect a failure mode has on the successful operation and safety of the system. Two types Quantitative Approach Qualitative Approach
QUANTITATIVE APPROACH
Used when there is sufficient failure rate data available to calculate item criticality numbers The value of each failure mode criticality number is defined as
Cm= pt
Cm - Failure mode criticality - The conditional probability of mission loss - Failure mode ratio p - part failure rate t - Duration of applicable mission phase (in hrs or number of operating cycles)
QUALITATIVE APPROACH
Used when specific part or item failure rates are not available
Identifies failure modes in terms of probability of occurrence when failure rate data is not available
levels
The probability of occurrence of each failure is grouped into discrete levels (single failure mode probability)
(0.20-0.10)
(0.10-0.01) (0.01-0.001) (>0.001)
Benefits of FMECA
Systematic review of component failure modes ensures that any failure produces minimal damage to the product or process.
It is possible to determine the effects that any failure will have on product or process and their functions. Determining those parts whose failure will have critical effects on the product or process operation. Calculating the probabilities of failures Eliminating or minimising the adverse effects that assembly failures could generate .