Mass Transer Operation
Mass Transer Operation
PART A
Molecular diffusion
Eddy diffusion
Thermal diffusion (diffusion induced by temperature )
Pressure diffusion(diffusion induced by total pressure and not partial pressure)
4. Molecular diffusion:
is caused by the movement of individual molecules through a substance by virtue of
their thermal energy.
A A
10. What are the two bases is derived to derive relationships between flux and
velocity?
(i)
Relative to a stationary interface
(ii)
Relative to the phase as a whole.
11. Diffusivity-Explain
Ficks law proportionality, D AB, is known as mass diffusivity (simply as diffusivity)
or as the diffusion coefficient. D AB has the dimension of L 2 / t, identical to the
fundamental dimensions of the other transport properties: Kinematic viscosity, =
( / ) in momentum transfer, and thermal diffusivity, (= k / C ) in heat transfer.
Diffusivity is normally reported in cm2 / sec; the SI unit being m2 / sec. Diffusivity
depends on pressure, temperature, and composition of the system. Diffusivities of
gases at low density are almost composition independent, increase with the
temperature and vary inversely with pressure. Liquid and solid diffusivities are
strongly concentration dependent and increase with temperature.
AB
1
p
D AB T 2
Diffusivity of a component in a mixture of components can be calculated using the
diffusivities for the various binary pairs involved in the mixture.
Determine the diffusivity of Co 2 (1), O 2 (2) and N 2 (3) in a gas mixture having
the composition: Co2 : 28.5 %, O2 : 15%, N 2 : 56.5%, The gas mixture is at 273 k
and 1.2 * 10 5 Pa. The binary diffusivity values are given as: (at 273 K)
D 12 P = 1.874 m 2 Pa/sec
D 13 P = 1.945 m 2 Pa/sec
D 23 P = 1.834 m 2 Pa/sec
5. Oxygen is diffusing in a mixture of oxygen-nitrogen at 1 std atm, 25C.
Concentration of oxygen at planes 2 mm apart are 10 and 20 volume %
respectively. Nitrogen is non-diffusing.
(a) Derive the appropriate expression to calculate the flux oxygen. Define units
of each term clearly.
(b) Calculate the flux of oxygen. Diffusivity of oxygen in nitrogen = 1.89 * 10 5
m 2/sec.
6. In a gas mixture of hydrogen and oxygen, steady state equimolar counter
diffusion is occurring at a total pressure of 100 kPa and temperature of 20C. If the
partial pressures of oxygen at two planes 0.01 m apart, and perpendicular to the
direction of diffusion are 15 kPa and 5 kPa, respectively and the mass diffusion flux
of oxygen in the mixture is 1.6 * 10 5 kmol/m 2.sec, calculate the molecular diffusivity
for the system.
gas solubility
volatility
corrosiveness
cost
viscosity
6. What is flooding?
With a large pressure difference in the space between trays, the level of liquid leaving a
tray at relatively low pressure and entering one of high pressure must necessarily assume
an elevated position in the downspouts.
7. Write note on HETP (Height Equivalent to a Theoretical Plate)
With a tray column, the vapours leaving an ideal plate will be richer in the more
volatile component than the vapour entering the plate by one equilibrium "step". When
packings are used instead of trays, the same enrichment of the vapour will occur over a
certain height of packings, and this height is termed the height equivalent to a theoretical
plate (HETP).
8. Write short note on Number of transfer units (NTU)
The number of transfer units (NTU) required is a measure of the difficulty of the
separation. A single transfer unit gives the change of composition of one of the phases
equal to the average driving force producing the change. The NTU is similar to the
number of theoretical trays required for trayed column. Hence, a larger number of
transfer units will be required for a very high purity product.
9. Write short note on height of a transfer unit (HTU)
The height of a transfer unit (HTU) is a measure of the separation effectiveness of the
particular packings for a particular separation process. As such, it incorporates the mass
transfer coefficient that we have seen earlier. The more efficient the mass transfer (i.e.
larger mass transfer coefficient), the smaller the value of HTU. The values of HTU can be
estimated from empirical correlations or pilot plant tests, but the applications are rather
restricted.
10. Define Tray efficiency.
Tray efficiency is the fractional approach to an equilibrium stage which is attained by a
real tray.
11. What is meant by desorption?
When a mass transfer occurs in the opposite direction as that of absorption i.e. from the
liquid to the gas, the operation is called desorption or stripping. These operations are used
for solute recovery or solute removal.
12. Define Overall tray efficiency.
EO = Number of ideal trays required / Number of real trays required
13. Define stage efficiency.
Stage efficiency is defined as the fractional approach to equilibrium which are real stage
produces.
14. Define Murphee efficiency.
Murphee efficiency is the fractional approach of one leaving stream to equilibrium with
the actual concentration in the other leaving stream.
EMG = yn - y n+1
y*n - y n+1
15. Define Permeability.
At the two faces of a membrane the equilibrium solubility of the gas in the polymer is
directly proportional to the pressure.
P = DA SA
P Permeability
DA - Diffusivity of A
S A - Solubility coefficient (or) Henrys law constant
PART B
1. Explain how the number of stages can be theoretically determined for an
absorber.
2. What are the types of typical tower packings used in packed bed absorbers? State
their principal requirements.
3. Discuss the concept of HTU and HETP in absorption operations.
4. Explain with neat sketches the various types of contactors available for gas-liquid
operations.
5. Explain the terms channeling and flooding velocity with reference to packed
towers. How are they checked for a controlled operation?
6. How will you choose a good solvent for absorption?
7. Discuss multi component gas absorption.
PART B
1. A liquid feed consisting of 1200g moles of mixture containing 30%
naphthalene and 70% dipropylene glycol is differentially distilled at 100
mmHG pressure and final distillate contains 55% of naphthalene. The VLE
data are
X
: 8.4
11.6 24.8 50.6 68.7 80.6
88
Y
: 22.3 41.6 62.9 74.8 80.2 84.4
88
(i) Determine the amount of distillate.
(ii) Determine the concentration of naphthalene in residue and distillate.
2. Write short notes on
(i)
Azeotropic distillation
(ii)
Molecular distillation
(iii)
Extractive distillation
3. i) Derive Rayleighs equation for batch distillation.
ii) Write short notes on Flash Distillation and its application.
4. A feed of 50 mole % hexane and 50 mole % octane is fed into a pipe still
through a pressure reducing valve and then into a flash disengaging
chamber. The vapor and liquid leaving the chamber are assumed to be in
equilibrium. If the fraction of the feed converted to the vapor is 0.5, find the
composition of the top and bottom products. The following table gives the
Equilibrium data for this system.
Mole fraction of
Hexane in liquid
1.00
0.69
0.40
0.192
0.045
0.00
Mole fraction of
Hexane in vapor
1.00
0.932
0.78
0.538
0.1775 0.00
0.16
0.30
0.4
0.5
0.7
0.82 1.00
Mole fraction of
benzene in vapor : 0.13 0.30 0.45 0.06 0.72 0.83 0.92 1.00
9. A continuous fractionating column is to be designed for separating 4000kg/h
of liquid mixture containing equimolar mixture of methanol and water into
an overhead product containing 95% methanol and a residue containing 3%
methanol.
The feed is 30% vaporized. Calculate
(i)
molar flow rate of overhead and bottom product.
(ii)
The number of actual plates assuming overall tray efficiency of
0.7.
Use reflux ratio of 1.75 times minimum.
(iii)
Locate the feed tray
Equilibrium data:
Mole fraction
of methanol
in liquid
0.1
0.2
0.30
0.40
0.50
0.60 0.70
0.80
0.90
Mole fraction
of methanol
in vapour
0.417 0.579 0.669 0.729 0.78 0.825 0.879 0.915 0.959
10.
A mixture of 35 mole % A and 65 mole % B is to be separated in
afractinating column. The concentration of A in the distillate is 93 mole % and 96
mole % of all product A is in the distillate. The feed is half vapor and the reflux ratio
is to be 4.0. The relative volatility of A to B is 2.0 . Calculate the number of
theoretical plates in the column and locate the feed plate. The equilibrium relation
may be obtained using the following relation
y= x/1+ (-1)x.
11.
Explain in detail the method of estimation of number of stages by Mc CabeThiele method.
5. Define
Plait
Point
The plait point point is located near the top of the two-phase envelope, at the inflection
point. It represents a condition where the 3-component mixture separates into two phases,
but the phases have identical compositions.
6. How to select the solvent for extraction
The choice of the solvent should be done based on the following parameters
Selectivity -- compare the equilibrium ratio of solute in each phase
Distribution Coefficients -- y/x at equilibrium; large values preferable
Insolubility -- solvent should not be soluble in carrier liquid
Recoverability -- consider constraints (i.e. azeotropes)
Density -- must be different so that phases can be separated by settling
Interfacial Tension -- if too high, liquids will be difficult to mix
Chemical Reactivity -- solvent should be inert and stable
Viscosity, Vapor Pressure, Freezing Point -- low values make storage easier
Safety -- toxicity, flammability
Cost
7. Define Leaching
Leaching is the preferential solution of one or more compounds from a solid mixture by
contact with a liquid solvent. Percolation of the liquid through a fixed bed of the solid.
8. Give some examples of Leaching
the metals industry for removing mineral from ores (acid solvents)
the sugar industry for removing sugar from beets (water is solvent)
the oilseeds industry for removing oil from soybeans, etc. (hexane or similar
organic solvents)
9. Define Decoction.
Decoction refers specifically to the use of the solvent at its boiling point.
10. State the principle of ion exchange.
Chemical reactions between an electrolyte in solution and an insoluble electrolyte
with which the solution is contacted.
Positively charged ions (cations) of a solution which are capable of diffusing
through the pores will exchange with the Na+ ions of such a mineral(Na2O)
11. Define the term Distribution Coefficient.
This is the ratio y* / x at equilibrium.
X = concentration of A in the liquid, mole fraction
Y* = y in equilibrium with x, mole fraction
Y = concentration of A in the gas, mole fraction
12. Define elution.
When the soluble material is largely on the surface of an insoluble solid and is merely
washed off by the solvent, this operation is called elution.
13. What is lixiviation?
Synonym for leaching refers specifically to the leaching of alkali from wood ashes.
14. Write any two applications of leaching?
(i)
Copper minerals are dissolved from their ores by leaching with
sulfuric acid or ammonical solutions
(ii)
Gold is separated from its ores with aid of sodium cyanide solutions.
15. Define Integral heat of adsorption.
The Integral heat of adsorption at any concentration X of adsorbate adsorbent
combination minus the sum of the enthalpies of unit weight of pure solid adsorbent
and sufficient pure adsorbed substance to provide the required concentration X, all at
the same temperature.
PART B
1.
How will you select the appropriate solvent for extraction operations?
2.
Explain briefly the various types of contacting devices available for liquid-liquid
extraction operation.
3.
A solution containing 20 mass per cent of acetone in water is to be extracted using
monochlorobenzene (MCB) containing 0.5% acetone by weight by counter current
extraction process. MCB and water may be considered to be immiscible within the
operating range. The equilibrium data are as follows:
Kg of acetone
Per Kg of water 0.0258 0.0739 0.1605 0.267
Kg of acetone
Per Kg of MCB 0.0288 0.0704 0.156 0.237
i)
Compute minimum solvent ratio to obtain a raffinate containing 1% acetone.
ii)
What are the suitable extractors for this operation.
3) 1000 kg/hr of the water dioxane solution containing 20% dioxane
is to be continuously and counter currently extracted with benzene at 25C to recover
80% dioxane. Water and benzene are essentially insoluble and the equilibrium
distribution of dioxane between them are as follows:
wt% of dioxane in water (100 x) 5.1 18.9 25.2
wt% of dioxane in benzene (100 y) 5.2 22.5 32.0
Determine the number of stages required if the solvent rate is 1.5 times the minimum
benzene is used. Benzene is free from dioxane.
4)
An aqueous solution C is to be extracted with pure solvent B to recover the
solute. The equilibrium data in terms of weight % of solute in the two layers are given
below.
Aqueous layer : 2 8 15 20
Solvent layer : 8 22 35 45
5) A feed 20% by weight of solute is to be treated in two consecutive cross current
cascades using aqueous solution is to solvent ratio 1.8. Calculate
(i) Concentration of final farrinate
(ii) Amount of raffinate
(iii) % recovery of solute
(iv) Amount of solovent to be used for a single stage extraction to obtain the
same final concentration.
(v) Water and solvent are immiscible with each other.
the
isotherms permit higher solid loadings at lower solution concentrations. These tend to
start out steep and level out. Isotherms which start out flat are "unfavorable", since they
only work well at high concentrations of solute. Usually, as temperature increases the
amount adsorbed decreases (permitting thermal regeneration).
The Freundlich isotherm describes physical adsorption from liquids and can also be used
for the adsorption of hydrocarbon gases on activated carbon. It is a two parameter model,
of the form
which assumes that the number of adsorption sites is fixed and that adsorption is
reversible.
5. Breakthrough Curves
Adsorption is a transient process. The amount of material adsorbed within a bed depends
both on position and time. Consider the time dependence. As fluid enters the bed, it
comes in contact with the first few layers of absorbent. Solute adsorbs, filling up some of
the available sites. Soon, the adsorbent near the entrance is saturated and the fluid
penetrates farther into the bed before all solute is removed. Thus the active region shifts
down through the bed as time goes on.
The fluid emerging from the bed will have little or no solute remaining -- at least until the
bulk of the bed becomes saturated. The break point occurs when the concentration of the
fluid leaving the bed spikes as unadsorbed solute begins to emerge. The bed has become
6.
Define external Reflux ratio. How is it related with internal reflux ratio?
The molar ratio of the reflux to the distillate withdrawn from the column is the reflux
ratio.
R=L/D
7. Define critical solution temperature
The lower critical solution temperature (also known as the LCST) is the critical
temperature below which a mixture is miscible in all proportions. It can also be seen as
the shared minimum of the concave up spinodal and binodal curves. The LCST is in
general pressure dependent, with increased pressure generally increasing the LCST.
The upper critical solution temperature (also known as the UCST) is the critical
temperature above which a mixture is miscible in all proportions. It can also be seen as
the shared maximum of the concave down spinodal and binodal curves. The UCST is in
general dependent on pressure, and in polymer mixtures on polymer degree of
polymerization and polydispersity.
8. Define Decoction
A decoction is a method of extraction by boiling of dissolved chemicals, or herbal or
plant material, which may include stems, roots, bark and rhizomes.
9. Adsorption Hysteresis
Adsorption is a transient process. The amount of material adsorbed within a bed depends
both on position and time. Consider the time dependence. As fluid enters the bed, it
comes in contact with the first few layers of absorbent. Solute adsorbs, filling up some of
the available sites. Soon, the adsorbent near the entrance is saturated and the fluid
penetrates farther into the bed before all solute is removed. Thus the active region shifts
down through the bed as time goes on.
The
fluid
emerging from the bed will have little
or no
solute remaining -- at least until the bulk of the bed becomes saturated. The break point
occurs when the concentration of the fluid leaving the bed spikes as unadsorbed solute
begins to emerge. The bed has become ineffective.
A more general flux relation which is not restricted to isothermal, isobaric system
dy A
could be written as J A C DA B
, using this expression, NA could be written
dZ
as
N
C DA B
dy A
y
dZ
The mass (or molar) flux NA of a given species is a vector quantity denoting the amount
of the particular species, in either mass or molar units, that passes per given increment of
time through a unit area normal to the vector. The flux of species defined with reference
to fixed spatial coordinates, NA is
N
A A
or
kc
Cp
f
2
this situation, we can estimate mass transfer coefficients from heat transfer coefficients
or from friction factors.
State Kremer- Brown- Souder Equation and its significance
3.
The equation has been the tool for obtaining the maximum allowable vapor velocity in
vapor-liquid separation vessels (variously called flash drums, knockout drums, knockout
pots, compressor suction drums and compressor inlet drums). It has also been used for
the same purpose in designing trayed fractionating columns, trayed absorption columns
and other vapor-liquid contacting columns.
A vapor-liquid separator drum is a vertical vessel into which a liquid and vapor mixture
(or a flashing liquid) is fed and wherein the liquid is separated by gravity, falls to the
bottom of the vessel, and is withdrawn. The vapor travels upward at a design velocity
which minimizes the entrainment of any liquid droplets in the vapor as it exits the top of
the vessel.
where:
V = maximum allowable vapor velocity, m/s
L = liquid density, kg/m
V = vapor density, kg/m
k = 0.107 m/s (when the drum includes a de-entraining mesh pad)
4.
When do the operating lines of stripping and rectifying sections coincide with
diagonal in McCabe Thiele method?
At total reflux condition the operating lines of stripping and rectifying sections coincide
with diagonal in McCabe Thiele method
The total reflux condition represents operation with no product removal. All the overhead
vapor is condensed and returned as reflux. Consequently, the reflux ratio (L/D) is infinite.
This, in turn, makes the operating lines the 45 degree line (prove it to yourself by setting
D=0, and noticing that consequently L=V). With the operating lines on the diagonal, they
are as far as they can get from the equilibrium curve, so if the number of plates are
stepped off using the diagonal and the equilibrium curve, the number of theoretical stages
will be a minimum.
5.
6.
7.
Lixiviation
8.
Lixiviation is the process of separating soluble from insoluble substances by dissolving
the former in water or some other solvent. lixiviation is the process of leaching alkaline
salts from ashes by pouring water on them.
9.
Adsorption Isotherm
10.
In the first falling rate period after the critical point, the liquid/vapor meniscus retreats
into pores of the body. The moisture still exerts its full vapor pressure and is transferred
mainly by capillarity, as liquid is in the funicular state.
In the second falling rate period moisture is held in the finest capillaries and
evaporation occurs inside the body at the boundary between the funicular (continuous
liquid) and pendular (isolated pockets of liquid) regions. Transport in pendular region
occurs by evaporation-condensation mechanism. The drying rate decreases sharply and
takes place in all inner portions of the material.
y 2
D 12
where y 2
y 3
Therefore
y 3
D 13
y2
y2 y3
0.15
0.21
0.15 0.565
0.565
0.79
0.15 0.565
y3
y2 y3
D 1m P
1
0.21
0.79
1.874 1.945
= 1.93 m 2.Pa/sec
Since P = 1.2 * 10 5 Pa,
1.93
D 1m
1.2 * 10
1.61 * 10 5 m 2 sec
y 1
D 21
Where y 1
y 3
D 23
y1
y1 y3
0.285
0.335
0.285 0.565
y 3
y3
y1 y3
0.565
0.665
0.285 0.565
and
D 21 P = D 12 P = 1.874 m 2.Pa/sec
Therefore
D 2m P
1
0.335 0.665
1.874 1.834
= 1.847 m 2.Pa/sec
D 2m
1.847
1.2 * 10 5
1.539 * 10 5 m 2 sec
D AB
dCA
----------------------------------------- (2)
dz
D AB
dCA
dz
----------------------------- (3)
NA NA NB
CCA
D AB
dCA
dz
Rearranging the terms and integrating between the planes between 1 and 2,
dz
cD
AB
C A2
A1
dC A
N AC C A N A N B
-------------- (4)
C C A2
1
ln
NA
C C A1
Therefore,
NA
CD AB
z
ln
C C A2
C C A1
---------------------------- (5)
Replacing concentration in terms of pressures using Ideal gas law, equation (5) becomes
NA
D AB P t
RTz
ln
P t P A2
P t P A1
--------------------------- (6)
where
D AB = molecular diffusivity of A in B
P T = total pressure of system
R = universal gas constant
T = temperature of system in absolute scale
z = distance between two planes across the direction of diffusion
1 0. 2
3. Methane diffuses at steady state through a tube containing helium. At point 1 the
partial pressure of methane is p A1 = 55 kPa and at point 2, 0.03 m apart P A2 = 15 KPa.
The total pressure is 101.32 kPa, and the temperature is 298 K. At this pressure and
temperature, the value of diffusivity is 6.75 * 10 5 m 2/sec.
iii)
calculate the flux of CH 4 at steady state for equimolar counter diffusion.
iv)
Calculate the partial pressure at a point 0.02 m apart from point 1.
Calculation:
For steady state equimolar counter diffusion, molar flux is given by
N
Therefore;
NA
D AB
RT z
p A1 p A 2
--------------------------- (1)
6.75 * 10 5
55 15 kmol
8.314 * 298 * 0.03
m 2 . sec
kmol
3.633 * 10 5
m 2 sec
6.75 * 10 5
55 p A
8.314 * 298 * 0.02
p A = 28.33 kPa
4. In a gas mixture of hydrogen and oxygen, steady state equimolar counter
diffusion is occurring at a total pressure of 100 kPa and temperature of 20C. If the
partial pressures of oxygen at two planes 0.01 m apart, and perpendicular to the
direction of diffusion are 15 kPa and 5 kPa, respectively and the mass diffusion flux
of oxygen in the mixture is 1.6 * 10 5 kmol/m 2.sec, calculate the molecular diffusivity
for the system.
Solution:
For equimolar counter current diffusion:
D AB
p A1 p A2 ------------------------ (1)
NA
RTz
where
N A = molar flux of A (1.6 * 10 5 kmol/m 2.sec):
D AB = molecular diffusivity of A in B
R = Universal gas constant (8.314 kJ/kmol.k)
T = Temperature in absolute scale (273 + 20 = 293 K)
z = distance between two measurement planes 1 and 2 (0.01 m)
P A1 = partial pressure of A at plane 1 (15 kPa); and
P A2 = partial pressure of A at plane 2 (5 kPa)
Substituting these in equation (1)
D AB
1.6 * 10 5
15 5
i) N A C D AB
dy
dz
N A N B
Given
NB = - NA
Therefore N A C D AB
dy
dz
D AB
dz
pA
where pA is the partial pressure of A; such that p A + p
RT
= P)
d p A RT
dz
For isothermal system, T is constant
Therefore N A D A B
dCA
Therefore N A
D AB d p A
RT
Z2
(i.e.)
N
d z
dz
RT z
d pA
RT
Z1
D AB
P A2
D AB
p A1 p A2
P A1
---------------------------------- (1)
where Z = Z 2 Z 1
Given: D AB = 0.275 cm 2/sec = 0.275 * 10 4 m 2 /sec ; T = 0C = 273 k
0.275 * 10 4
1.5 * 1.01325 * 10 5 0.5 * 1.01325 * 10 5
A
8314 * 273 * 0.2
k mol
6.138 * 10 6
m 2 sec
dy
dz
N A N B
given: N B = - 0.75 N A
Therefore N A C D AB
dy
C D AB
N A 0.25 y
dz
dy
dz
N A 0.75 N A
0.25 y
dy
C D AB
d z C D AB
dy
dz
1 0.25 y
d z CD AB
Z1
y A2
dy
y A1
1 0.25 y
A
A
dx
1
a b x b ln a b x
4 CD AB
1
y
ln 1 0.25 y A y A2
A1
0
.
25
1 0.25 y A 2
ln
1 0.25 y A 1 ---------------------------------- (2)
N A z C D AB
Given:
C
p
2 * 1.01325 * 10 5
0.0893 K mol m 3
RT
8314 * 273
A1
A2
p A1
1.5
0.75
2
0.5
0.25
2
P
p A2
P
Substituting these in equation (2),
NA
dy
dz
N A N B
dy
Given: N B = 0 ,Therefore N A CD AB
Z2
N A d z CD AB
Z1
y A2
NA
1 y
ln
1 y
A2
A1
0.0893 * 0.275 * 10 4
0.2
kmol
1.349 * 10 5
m 2 . sec
y A1 1 y A
CD AB
Z
dy
dz
1 0.25
ln 1 0.75
g/cc respectively. Molecular weight of Butanol (C 4 H 9 OH) is 74, and that of water
18.
Calculations
For steady state unidirectional diffusion,
NA
D AB
z
x A1 x A2
x B, lm
avg
A1
A2
0.1 74
0.026
0.1 74 0.9 18
0.04 74
0.04 74 0.96 18
0.010
18.56 kg Kmol
0.04 74 0.96 18
M1
M2
0.1 74
1 M 1 2
M2
avg
= 0.0517 gmol / cm 3
= 51.7 kmol/m 3
x B,lm
(i.e.)
x B 2 x B1
ln x B 2 x B1
x B,lm
1 0.01
1 x A2 1 x A1
1 x A2
ln
1 x A1
1 0.026
1 0.01
ln
1 0.026
0.016
0.982
0.0163
D AB
x A1 x A2
2 M avg
x B, lm
Therefore N A
5.9 * 10 6 * 10 4 * 51.7
2
0.1 * 10
kmol
4.97 * 10 7
m 2 sec
gmol
1.789
m 2 .hr .
g
1.789 * 74
2
m . hr .
g
132.4
m 2 . hr .
0.026 0.010
0.982
column. If you are using the equilibrium curve to step from, you are determining ideal
stages.
If you don't want to draw, you can do the same thing, iteratively solving for the various
equation intersections. You'll need to be pretty careful with your "bookkeeping" if you try
this.
To apply Murphree tray efficiencies, construct an effective equilibrium curve between the
equilibrium and operating curves, and step using the effective curve to determine actual
separation stages. Remember that a partial reboiler or partial condenser is by definition an
ideal stage, so you use the ideal equilibrium curve (not the effective) for these stages.
The optimum feed tray is the triangle with one corner on the rectifying line and one on
the stripping line. Putting the feed anywhere else increases the number of stages needed
to make the separation. To visualize this, notice that the closer the operating line is to the
equilibrium curve, the smaller the stepping triangles become. Introducing the feed at the
intersection of the rectifying and stripping lines maximizes the size of the triangles and so
leads to the fewest steps.
When analyzing existing distillation systems, the actual feed entry point may not be at the
optimum (the tray where the operating lines intersect). In this case, the tray stepping
should switch from the rectifying line to the operating line at the actual feed tray location.
8. Enthalpy-Concentration Method or PONCHAN SAVARIT METHOD
Distillation calculations can be performed graphically on an enthalpy-concentration (Hx)
diagram. This approach is sometimes called the Ponchon-Savarit Method. Working on
the Hx diagram is more general than a McCabe-Thiele construction, because it takes
direct account of the thermal effects and does not require an assumption of equimolal
overflow.
The very shape of the Hx diagram provides a clue as to the importance of the energy
balances. If the dew point and bubble point lines are more or less straight and roughly
parallel, it indicates that the latent heat of vaporization is basically constant with respect
to composition. This is the prerequisite for assuming equimolar overflow, and so the
energy balances may be neglected. If the saturation curves show significant changes in
curvature or separation, it suggests that to assume equimolar overflow will introduce
error.
Points for the feed and product can be located on the Hx diagram; for our purposes we'll
call them the F, D, and B points. The coordinates are their composition and enthalpy. If
the products are saturated liquid, as is the case for total condensers without subcooling
and for partial reboilers, these points will lie on the bubble point curve on the Hx
diagram.
Reflux Ratio
As before, the reflux ratio can be determined from the L/V ratio, and for this formulation
is given by:
R;D = 'quot(h;Dp - H;y1,H;y1 - h;D)
where hD is the enthalpy of the overhead product, Hy1 the enthalpy of the vapor entering
the condenser, and hDp the adjusted enthalpy of the overhead. Notice that this represents
the ratio of distances on the Hx diagram: the numerator is the vertical distance between
the hDp point and the dew point saturation curve, while the denominator is the distance
between the saturation curves.
A calculation often begins by using the overhead product composition and temperature to
obtain hDand Hy1. These in turn are used with the reflux ratio to get hDp. Then the overall
enthalpy line is drawn from hDp through the feed point, and the intersection with xB gives
hBp.
Summary of Procedure
1. Obtain enthalpy-composition diagram
2. Fix the feed point F, and product points D and B using stream compositions and
enthalpies
3. Use the overhead product enthalpy and the reflux ratio to find the adjusted
enthalpy of the overhead. Plot it as point D', on a vertical line with point D.
4. Construct the overall enthalpy line from point D' through the feed point. It
intersects a vertical line drawn through point B at point B'.
5. Plot point V1. For a total condenser, the composition entering the condenser is the
same as the overhead product, so this point will be vertically above point D on the
saturated vapor curve.
6. Follow the tie line from point V1 to the saturated liquid curve. This intersection
will be point L1.
7. Construct an operating line connecting points D' and L1. The intersection of the
operating line with the saturated vapor curve will be point V2.
8. Repeat the two preceding steps until one of the V or L points is to the left of the
overall enthalpy line. Once it is crossed, construct operating lines using points Li
and B'.
9. When xi is less than xB, construction is finished.
The number of stages can be read as the number of complete triangles.
Limiting Conditions
At total reflux, operating lines are vertical (infinite slope). This can be used to determine
the minimum number of stages. Not that operating curves are not required to do this -only the endpoint compositions.
While doing constructions on the yx diagram, a "pinch" was defined as the intersection
point between the equilibrium curve and the operating curve. On an Hx diagram, there
isn't an equilibrium curve -- it has expanded to a region, and each point from the xy
equilibrium curve is represented by a tie line. The "pinch point" also expands, resulting in
a single line where the operating and tie lines overlap.
Minimum reflux still corresponds to a pinch at the feed conditions, so to determine the
minimum reflux a line must be constructed so that the overall enthalpy line coincides
with the tie line that runs through the feed point.
Thermal diffusivit y
----------------------------- (3)
k
C p --------------------------- (4)
and
Mass diffusivit y D AB --------------------------- (5)
It can be shown that each of the diffusivities has the dimensions of L 2 / t, hence, a ratio of
any of the two of these must be dimensionless. The ratio of the molecular diffusivity of
momentum to the molecular diffusivity of heat (thermal diffusivity) is designated as the
Prandtl Number
Cp
Momentum diffusivit y
Pr
Thermal diffusivit y
------------------------ (6)
Momentum diffusivit y
Sc
Mass diffusivit y
D AB
D AB -------------- (7)
The ratio of the molecular diffusivity of heat to the molecular diffusivity of mass is
designated the Lewis Number, and is given by
Thermal diffusivit y
k
Le
Mass diffusivit y
D AB
C p D AB ------------- (8)
dC
D AB
dy
y 0
------------------------- (9)
When the boundary concentration, CAs is constant, equation (4.9) may be written as
N
d C A C As
D AB
dy
---------------------- (10)
y 0
Equation (1a) and (10) may be equated, since they define the same flux of component A
leaving the surface and entering the fluid
k
C A s
D AB
d
C
dy
As
y 0
---------(11)
d C A C As d y
C A C A
-------------------- (12)
y 0
d C A C As d y
C A S
C A L
y 0
----------------- (13)
The right hand side of equation (13) is the ratio of the concentration gradient at the
surface to an overall or reference concentration gradient; accordingly, it may be
considered as the ratio of molecular mass-transport resistance to the convective masstransport resistance of the fluid. This ratio is generally known as the Sherwood number,
Sh and analogous to the Nusselt number Nu, in heat transfer.
10. Types of reboilers
The most critical element of reboiler design is the selection of the proper type of reboiler
for a specific service. Most reboilers are of the shell and tube heat exchanger type and
normally steam is used as the heat source in such reboilers. However, other heat transfer
fluids like hot oil or Dowtherm (TM) may be used. Fuel-fired furnaces may also be used
as reboilers in some cases.
Commonly used heat exchanger type reboilers are:
convection and radiant sections. Image 3 depicts a fired heater being used in a
configuration that provides recirculation of the column bottoms liquid. However, with
some relatively minor changes inside the bottom section of the distillation column, a fired
heater can also be used in once-through configuration.
The heat source for the fired heater reboiler may be either fuel gas or fuel oil. Coal would
rarely, if ever, be used as the fuel for a fired heater reboiler.
the carrier phase is a liquid, not a solid, so the physical separation techniques will
change, and
two distinct phases develop, so the simplicity of uniform solution is lost.
Common applications of liquid extraction include: the separation and purification of lube
oils, separation of penicillin from fermentation broth, etc. Extraction is driven by
chemical differences, not by vapor pressure differences, and so can be used in situations
when distillation is impractical. For instance, it can be used to separate materials with
similar boiling points (so that distillation is impractical) or mixtures containing
temperature sensitive compounds.
Distillation and evaporation produce finished products; liquid extraction generally does
not. The products are still mixtures, although with new compositions, and these must be
separated to obtain final products. Secondary separation often requires distillation or
evaporation. The overall process cost thus must be considered when choosing extraction.
Extraction may become economical for dilute aqueous solutions when evaporation would
require vaporization of very large amounts of water.
Terminology
Certain terms are commonly used when describing extraction processes. The solution to
be extracted is called the feed, the liquid used in contacting is the solvent. The enriched
solvent product is the extract and the depleted feed is called the raffinate.
Extraction processes may be be single stage, multistage crosscurrent, or countercurrent.
Cocurrent extraction offers no advantages over a single stage (convince yourself of this!).
This class will primarily be concerned with countercurrent systems.
Equilibrium
Extraction calculations
require an understanding
of ternary equilibrium. You
probably should refresh
your memory on how
ternary diagrams are read
and used. I would
anticipate that you learned
this in your material
balance course.
One new term that may not
be familiar is the plait
point. This point is located
near the top of the twophase envelope, at the
inflection point. It
represents a condition
where the 3-component
mixture separates into two phases, but the phases have identical compositions. (Compare
this with an azeotropic mixture of liquid and vapor.)
There are two main classes of liquid-liquid equilibrium that occur in extraction. A Class I
system is the one I expect you are familiar with; it has one immiscible pair of compounds
and produces the familiar envelope. Class II mixtures have two pair of immiscible
compounds, and so the two-phase envelope crosses the triangular diagram like a bridge.
Class I mixtures are the most common and are
preferable -- so if you can pick a solvent to get
a Class I, you usually want to do so. Classes
can change with temperature, so that is also a
concern.
Solvent Selection
One of the key decisions when designing an extraction process is the choice of the
solvent to be used. Issues include:
Figure 1 represents a typical drying curve for virtually any product. Drying occurs in
three different periods, or phases, which can be clearly defined.
The first phase, or initial period, is where sensible heat is transferred to the product and
the contained moisture. This is the heating up of the product from the inlet condition to
the process condition, which enables the subsequent processes to take place. In some
instances, pre-processing can reduce or eliminate this phase. For example, if the feed
material is coming from a reactor or if the feed is preheated by a source of waste energy,
the inlet condition of the material will already be at a raised temperature.
The rate of evaporation increases dramatically during this period with mostly free
moisture being removed.
During the second phase, or constant rate period, free moisture persists on the surfaces
and the rate of evaporation alters very little as the moisture content reduces. During this
period, drying rates are high, and higher inlet air temperatures than in subsequent drying
stages can be used without detrimental effect to the product. There is a gradual and
relatively small increase in the product temperature during this period.
Interestingly, a common occurrence is that the time scale of the constant rate period may
determine and affect the rate of drying in the next phase.
The third phase, or falling rate period, is the phase during which migration of moisture
from the inner interstices of each particle to the outer surface becomes the limiting factor
that reduces the drying rate.