Plastics 2
Plastics 2
Bangalore - India
Case-Study Report
Plastic Recycling
Esha Shah
Rajaram
December 1997
Waste management and its various stakeholders now form a rapidly growing area of interest.
The role played by small and microenterprises and communities, however, is still much
neglected. UWEP aims to generate, analyse, document and customize the information that is
gathered during research and pilot projects, in order to enhance the expertise of the UWEP target
groups, ultimately aiming at an improved integrated sustainable waste management system. This
will in the long run lead to an improved environment, create more employment and offer
improved urban services for everyone.
One of the UWEP research topics was plastic recycling and the possibilities of responsible re-
use by involving small enterprises. This report, "Plastic Recycling in Bangalore - India ",
reflects the results of a case-study research done by Esha Shah and Rajaram, commissioned by
WASTE, the executing agency of the UWEP programme. Similar researches on the topic of
plastic recycling were undertaken in Chile, Colombia and Peru. By publishing these casestudy
reports, we explicitly aim at divulging the data gathered during the researches. UWEP sees this
report as one of the ways of focusing attention on small and microenterprises, community
involvement and their invaluable role in urban waste management.
Hopefully this publication helps you to form a picture of the role the various stakeholders play
in urban waste management. More information and an overview of the other UWEP reports and
books can be obtained from WASTE.
The UWEP Case-study Report series are published informally by WASTE. In order that the
information contained in them can be presented with the least possible delay, the typescript has
not been prepared in accordance with the procedures normally adhered to. WASTE accepts no
responsibility for errors.
1
CONTENTS
PREFACE ...................................................................................................................................1
CONTENTS ...................................................................................................................................2
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION...................................................................................................5
1.1 Research Methodology .........................................................................................................5
1.1.1 Plastic Recycling Units .............................................................................................5
1.1.2 Middle Dealers and Wholesalers...............................................................................6
2
3.8.1 Razaque Bhaiya III rd Cross, S.G. Narayana Layout J.C. Road Bangalore.........39
3.8.2 Mahaboob Ali Khan Asian Plastic Traders 16/1 Jolly Masjid Road Bangalore. .44
CHAPTER 6 ISSUES.................................................................................................................111
6.1 Plastic Recycling Industries as Small Scale Industries..................................................111
6.1.1 Finance ..............................................................................................................112
6.1.2 Technology........................................................................................................112
6.1.3 Industrial Cluster...............................................................................................112
3
4
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION
The objective of the current research is to analyse practices followed by small scale plastic
recovery and recycling units in Bangalore, India. It attempts to inquire into how plastic recycling
units functions with relation to technical, environmental/health and financial/economic aspects.
It also intends to identify possible sources of occupational health hazards due to recycling. It
finally discusses relevant national and global policy issues and suggests possible ways for
improvement.
Chapter two outlines plastic industry and plastic recycling industry in India with relevant facts
and figures. Processes, practices and financial analysis of plastic recovery and plastic recycling
units are described in chapter three and four respectively. Chapter four describes possible
sources of occupational health hazards and the final chapter discusses issues and suggestions.
5
1.1.2 Middle Dealers and Wholesalers
Given the nature of this part of the recycling industry, a person with long working experience of
working with waste pickers and middle dealers was approached for research assistance. The
friendly relations made by the research assistant with Middle dealers during his previous job
with one of the NGOs made it possible to access the information. He not only obtained the data
but also cross checked with his own understanding of interviewees' dealings through years.
Along with him, place of the Middle dealer was visited a number of times. Besides, the data was
further cross checked by interviewing the waste pickers supplying at Middle dealers' places. Out
of a total 7 Middle dealers contacted, only 4 were found appropriate and hence presented here.
The Middle dealers contacted provided further linkages to the wholesalers. A Middle dealer
introduced us to a wholesaler who in turn introduced us to another wholesaler. All this cosseted
number of visits and lots of talking, often completely irrelevant matter. There was no way to
cross check the wholesalers data except by taking opinion of the Middle dealer supplying at his
place. Only two wholesalers agreed to provide financial data within the time limit of this
research.
Clarification
While trying to understand the logic of sorting, packing and selling the waste from Middle
dealer's point of view we came across a system, though has its own order, not very easy to grasp
by a researcher during the limited time of exposure. There were many practical problems (other
than the Middle dealers' apparent reluctance to talk about business) encountered when we tried
to fit their logic into the framework of this research. Following are some of the issues.
The practice of sorting vary widely from one person to another. Although apparently waste is
sorted according to type and quality, we felt that sorting is done ultimately, according to the
likely price a category of waste may fetch. For instance, a sorting category known as 'article'
comprises combs, toothpaste cover and acrylic sheet with various other components. Though
seemingly unrelated in terms of type and quality these various components are packed in to a
sack and sold at one price. Moreover, price is negotiated depending upon the number of
acrylic sheets in the sack and it varies any where between Rs. 11 /kg to Rs. 35 /kg. This is
also true for other categories of waste. The final price depends upon the negotiation capacity
of Middle dealer which in turn depends on his experience, knowledge and relation with other
actors in the business. Similarly, what a Middle dealer pays to a waste picker also varies
depending upon the period of association with a waste picker, regularity of waste supply and
quantity.
It is not very clear what exactly falls into a 'category' of waste. Pugga is one such category.
What we saw as Pugga at one Middle dealer's place differed drastically from what we saw at
another place. However, eventually we felt that the norms followed in waste collection,
sorting and packing are very informal and contextual. They depend on the tradition, the
demand from the Wholesaler, type of waste received and, most importantly, the capacity of
the middle dealer to negotiate the price.
6
A major problem was encountered when we tried to understand the quantities of waste
collected and sold. In the absence of any written records, a Middle dealer depends upon his
memory, which may not capture seasonal fluctuation.
Besides, the logic of quantity of waste purchased and sold also do not tally. The quantity of
waste purchased is expressed as kgs.. per day, whereas the quantity sold is expressed in kgs..
per week. The data was provided by the most experienced person in the shop ( in majority of
the cases the proprietor himself) even then the data on quantities in different contexts was
differently told. This may have to do with the highly uncertain field of waste collection and
trade. It varies widely from day to day, leave apart the seasonal variation. Given the
informality of the entire business, proper documentation is least expected. Besides,
quantities were expressed in a range of plus or minus 20 kgs.. per day. This can create a
discrepancy of half a tone when counted on monthly basis. Further, it does not match with
the same category of waste sold.
After juggling with seemingly incomprehensive data encountered in the first round we
decided to follow some other method. Hence, we combined three ways to make our own
judgment
we took the quantity told by the middle dealer as base figure and modified it depending
upon the number of waste pickers and Kabadiwalas selling at his place.
the quantities of waste sold was also modified after talking to a number of waste pickers.
The figures were cross checked with the help of other knowledgeable people in the
business.
Hence, we clarify that the idea here is to give broad understanding of a Dealer's practice. This
invariably imposes several limitations on the quality of financial analysis.
7
CHAPTER 2 PLASTIC INDUSTRY IN INDIA
The estimated per capita demand of plastics in India is 0.800 Kgs. which is one of the lowest in
Asia. The projected demand in 2000 A.D. is 2.16 Kgs. per capita (KSSPMA, 1992). A boom in
the consumption of plastic is experienced with the economic liberalisation since 1991. Plastic
consumption in India has more than doubled from 0.85 million tones during 1990-91 to 1.79
million tones during 1995-96. Demand for commodity plastics is growing at the rate of 15 % per
year. As per the survey conducted by the All India Plastic Manufacturers Association the total
capacity to produce PE, PVC, PP and PS was 1.39 million MT and demand was 1.55 million MT
in 1995 which has increased to 1.8-1.9 million MT for 1996-97 (KSSPMA,1992). This is
concentrated in three major sectors according to the Plast India figures: infrastructure (power,
telecommunications, roads, bridges and construction) which is 30 % of the total, packaging is 25
% of the total and 24 % for agriculture and water (Nanavaty, 1997). Based on the end use
consumption pattern the plastic waste generated has more than doubled to 0.8 million tones
during 1995-96. It is estimated that at a macro level 50 % of the quantity of virgin raw material
consumed reaches municipal waste stream annually. Although on weight basis the level of
plastics waste in municipal waste stream is only 3 % to 4 %, they occupy 25 to 30% of the
volume. It is projected that the plastic waste generation will reach the level of 1.6 million tones
annually by year 2001-02 (Sundaresan, 1996).
2.1.1 History
It is difficult to trace back when exactly the recycling would have started in India. In 1950s and
1960s, with the growth of large scale petrochemical industries, the small scale processing units
were established in Western Indian states of Gujarat and Rajasthan. On the basis of informal
interaction with various people in the field of recycling it may be suggested that recycling of the
waste generated from the manufacturing and processing units would have been the first step. The
machinery required for the reprocessing is technically similar to the processing machinery.
However, the widespread recycling of plastic waste, both from industrial and municipal origin
might have been started in late 1970s and early 1980s. This was the time when the liberalisation
attitude was set in with Janatha Government in power in 1977. The Government explicitly
recognised the small scale manufacturing sector through exemptions from excise duties and
other taxes, reduced paper work and adhoc licensing scheme started for tiny industries. And with
the New Economic policy started in 1984 by the Congress Government industrialisation was
promoted which gave enormous boost to consumer market. Simultaneously the upper limit for
small scale industries1 was increased calling for corresponding boost in the small scale
1
Currently Small Scale Industries in Indian context are characterised by having 5-25 employees and having less
than RS. 3,00.00.000 of investment.
8
industries. Plastic processing and reprocessing industries can be considered as one among many
such newly established small scale units at that time.
The wide spread recycling of the plastic waste is generally associated with the commencement of
milk packing in plastic sachets. It also corresponds with the time when plastic carry bags were
also started to be used. The substantial amount of plastic waste started reaching streets
approximately the same time. However, it is felt that the waste from the newly proliferated
processing units might have made recycling economically viable. Recycling of municipal/ post
consumer waste may be an offshoot of such industries mainly meant to recycle industrial waste.
It seems that recycling units were first established in Gujarat, Rajasthan and some parts of West
Bengal which were further spread to other parts of India.
There is no accurate data available on nature and number of plastic recycling units in India
although various estimates are available. The current plastic recycling rate is estimated as 60%
by Plast India Foundation (KSSPMA, 1992). But the discussions with knowledgeable persons
reveal it to be anywhere between 80% to 93%. One estimate is that about 20,000 micro
enterprises are engaged in reprocessing and recovery of plastic waste in addition to 180,000 of
various sorting and washing units, 60% of which are unregistered (Harriman Chemsult, 1996).
Delhi alone has estimated 53,400 units and Delhi and Bombay together process over 50% of
India's waste plastics. There is heavy concentration of recycling units reported in Gujarat and
Goa, which, as a whole, account for 40%. As per other estimates there are about 18,000
recycling units spread all over the country, with about 2500 palletizing units with an average
output of 350 MT/ year and an over all output of over 875 kTA ( Nanavaty, 1997).
India nevertheless has some of the world's largest plastic waste markets. Notable among them
are: Jawalapuri in Delhi for PVC, Nand Nagari in New Delhi where trading level reaches 1000
MT/day, Dharavi in Bombay and Jolly Mohalla in Bangalore. Figure 1 shows the recycling
centers in India and Figure 2 schematically represents the region wise distribution of recycling
industry in India (Nanavaty, 1997).
9
Figure 1 Recycling Centres in India
10
Table 1. Reprocessing in Recycling Industry: Region wise and Polymer wise in kTA
Table 2. Region wise and Polymer wise Turnover of Recycling Industry at Pelletisation
stage in Rs. Crore ( 1 crore = 10 million)
Each region is also specialized in one type of plastic, viz. North: PVC; South: HDPE; West: all
types but more emphasis on LDPE and LLDPE; East: PP. It was suggested that one million tone
of waste plastic would have been recycled or otherwise reused in 1996 - including 40% of 1995
consumption of virgin plastic and 30 % of pre 1995 production which had been reprocessed
before.
The number of people engaged in recycling sector is unknown but vast. Some figures suggest
that 750,000 people are employed including 86,000 rag pickers specialized in plastics (Harriman
Chemsult, 1996). On an average 15 persons are required to process 240 MT/annum. Using this
norm it is estimated that more than 54,000 people are employed in processing alone.
11
2.2 Recycling Industry in Bangalore
2.2.1 Overview
As per an estimate, Bangalore has around 300 reprocessing units with main thrust on recycling
of all polyolefins and PVC although PVC recycling units are only 7 to 10. 70 % to 80 % of the
collected, post-consumer waste is exported to Delhi, Bombay and Gujarat for reprocessing.
Jolly Maholla is the center for the purchase of scrap material whereas the reprocessing units are
spread all over Bangalore with more concentration in Nayandahalli and New Timber Market on
Mysore Road. In Nayandahalli itself around 100 pelletisation and product manufacturing units
are located.
In addition there are estimated 3000-4000 itinerant waste buyers in Bangalore and if they collect
average 10 kgs of plastic waste per day for 25 days of a month, 250 kgs of plastic waste is
collected by a itinerant waste buyer in a month. If it is averaged out to 30 days of collection in a
month an IWB collects 8 kgs per day of plastic waste. This amounts to total 28 tons of plastic
waste collected by all itinerant waste buyers in Bangalore. If 80% of total 164 tons of plastic
waste traded is exported out of Bangalore, remaining 20% i.e. 32.8 tons per day of post-
consumer plastic waste is circulated in Bangalore. Assuming 250 kgs per day of recycling
capacity of a unit and estimated 300 such units in Bangalore 75 tons of plastic waste is recycled
everyday. Of which 32.8 (43%) tons is post consumer waste and rest is acquired through
industrial sources.
12
The reprocessing units are clustered in a similar pattern as small scale textile units are clustered
in Gujarat and tannery units in parts of Tamilnadu. Although an individual unit is operated and
managed in small scale, the units are located side by side in a series and are identical in terms of
technology, processing methods, type and variety of raw material used and final products
manufactured. The "mysteries" of trade become no mysteries and nothing is "business secret" in
such an environment.
The final product of the units, be it pellets or consumer items, is generally produced only on
order basis. Majority of the units even purchase the scrap only after receiving the order for either
pellets or product with specifications. Depending upon the order specifications in terms of type,
desired strength, purpose, color and shape the nearest suitable type of scrap is either purchased
or sorted from the mixed waste in-house. Evidently each unit is specialized in specific type/types
of waste and both purchase of scrap and sale of final product take place through contacts which
are developed through years of experience in the business. Some of the units also accept job
work wherein the scrap is purchased and sent for processing to the recycling unit by a concerned
party. In such case the task for the recycling unit is to provide labor, service and machinery and
flat rate per kg of plastic recycled is charged.
Since the industry operates on demand basis, the proximity of the market is very essential. In
other words the ability to respond quickly to the market needs seems to be the key factor for
survival of this industry. This could explain why the scrap, rather than the pellets or products is
exported to Northern and Western parts of India.
13
Wastes Produced During Fabrication
This category includes mainly machine waste generated during both processing and reprocessing
plastic. Generally, in the next cycle itself they are ground and processed within the processing
unit or sold to recycling unit.
Extrusion produces waste from equipment start up and from trimming and cutting of the
final product.
Injection molding produces wastes from runners and sprues in addition to machine setup
and purging.
In blow molding waste originates from pinch off.
In addition to these types of plastics fairly clean varieties of plastic waste is generated from other
industrial or agricultural sectors as well. Discarded Electric conduits are one such source. Other
sources include pipes used for irrigation and water conveyance or automobile waste generated in
the garages. These varieties of the waste are collected from the source of generation itself and
hence remain relatively clean.
Any plastic looses, once recycled for the first time, 10-15% of its original properties if additives
are not mixed. A second recycling would further decrease the quality by 30-40%. Hence, the
final product is manufactured with a combination of grades or in combination with virgin plastic.
The blend is decided on the basis of the desired quality of the final product.
The manufacturers seem to have a tendency to add some amount of recycled plastic even in the
product supposed to be made of virgin plastic. This is possible because most of the plastic
processing units are also small scale, micro enterprises and the difference in terms of machinery
and expertise used for processing or reprocessing of plastic items is marginal.
There are four types of reprocessing units based on the final product:
Pellet making units: These units make pellets on the basis of order. They also rent the
unit, labor and machinery for job work.
Pellet-cum-Product making Units: These units produce pellets or products and purchase
and reprocess the scrap on the basis of the order for the final product.
Recycled Product making Units: These units purchase recycled pellets and make
products out of reprocessed pellets only.
Product making Units: These units make products of either virgin plastic, blend or
reprocessed plastic.
In Bangalore mainly polyolefins [which include High Density Polyethylene (HDPE), Linear
Low Density Polyethylene (LLDPE), Low Density Polyethylene (LDPE), High Molecular
Weight Polyethylene (HMPE), and Polypropylene (PP)] and Poly Vinyl Chloride (PVC) are
14
reprocessed. Part of the polyolefins, PVC in addition to Polystyrene and PET are exported to
other parts of India.
The Department of Chemicals and Petrochemicals in the Ministry of Chemicals and Fertilizers of
the Government of India is the nodal agency for petrochemicals including plastics. On producers
side, there are two prominent associations of polymer producers, viz., Chemicals and
Petrochemicals Manufacturers Associations and PVC Manufacturers Association. There are
various national and regional organisations of plastic processing and conversion industries.
Significant among them at the national level are: All India Plastic Manufacturers Association,
Organisations of Plastic Processors of India, Plast India Foundation, All India Federation of
Plastics Industries and Indian Plastics Federation, The Plastics Woven Sacks Manufacturers
Association and All India Flat Tape Manufacturers Association. Institutions like Central Institute
of Plastics Engineering and Technology (CIPET) and Indian Plastics Institute play a catalytic
role for human power development and technology feedback. Plastic recyclers are organised into
Waste Dealers Association and All India Plastic Waste Recycling Industries Association
(TPMA, 1995).
There are mainly three approaches to recycling: mechanical recycling, mixed waste recycling
and feed stock recycling. For all practical purposes, plastic waste is recycled by mechanical
recycling in India. This method needs unmixed waste material in economically viable quantities.
Mechanical recycling undergoes four typical stages: sorting, size reduction, washing, separation
15
at chop level and melt processing. Mechanical recycling lines have been developed for nearly all
major thermoplastics.
Mixed waste processing involves use of coupling agent. This technology is not widely used as
plastic waste is sorted and used as single material for mechanical processing. In the process of
feed stock recycling the macromolecular structure is broken down to basic monomers/ chemical
and this is subsequently used for the manufacture of plastics. In India this technique is restricted
to materials like PET and Polyamide.
2.5.1 Regulation
The National Waste Management Council of Environment and Forest, of which State Municipal
Commissioner and Environment Secretaries are members, periodically discusses plastic waste
management practices to arrive at future strategies. The National task force on plastic waste
management is also set up by the Ministry of Environment and Forestry. The Ministry has issued
criteria for labeling plastic products as environmentally friendly under "Ecomark Scheme" in
association with Bureau of Indian Standards. These criteria suggest end use of recycled plastic
products. Bureau of Indian Standards has also developed specifications for thermoplastic
products such as molded briefcases, packaging material, reflector and light fittings, and
polythene buckets (TPMA, 1995). However these standards and specification are not mandatory
and hence non-enforceable.
References:
Harriman Chemsult. 1996. "Major Growth Market Addresses Modern Plastics Waste
Management", News Letter No. 37, Dec.
Leidner J. 1981. Plastics Waste, New York: Marcel Dekker Inc.
Nanavaty K. 1997. "Recycling of Plastics: Indian Experience", Paper Presented at 3 rd
International Plastics Exhibition and Conference on Environment/Recycling of Plastics,
New Delhi: Plast India Foundation.
Sundaresan E. 1996. "Environment and Plastics Recycling Future", IPI Transactions: Reliance
Industries Limited, Mumbai.
The Karnataka Small Scale Plastic Manufacturers' Association. 1991-92. A Guide to Plastics,
Bangalore.
16
CHAPTER 3 PLASTIC RECOVERY : PROCESS, PRACTICES AND
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS
However, not all plastic is collected by waste pickers. Only that plastic which has direct salable
value is picked up as waste picking is primarily an economic activity. Widely sought after
materials in Bangalore include all items made of HDPE, LLDPE, LDPE, HMPE and PP. Milk
sachets and carry bags are regular items collected by a waste picker. A close observation of the
waste pickers activity revealed that not all types of the plastic has salable value. Small bits of
plastic, contaminated with food material or dust and mud are not collected. Even milk sachets are
left uncollected if highly contaminated and smelly. Plastic covers on medicine strips, bottles
used for packing edible oil, cold drink bottles like Pepsi etc., are some of the striking examples
of uncollected material. Furthermore, composite plastics, for example used for packing chips,
tea, chocolates etc., are not taken obviously as they can not be recycled easily.
Generally a waste picker sells his/her waste everyday. The collected plastic matter may be
further sorted into milk sachets, Pugga, road waste and mixed category ( or Masala as it is
known in their language). There seems to be no standardization in classifying the collected waste
as what plastic waste falls in what category depends on the waste pickers perception and his/her
capacity to negotiate price. It is felt that at this level the plastics which can be easily associated
with its previous use are put in Pugga, those which can not be easily identified are labeled as
mixed, which also contains carry bags, and small, contaminated bits are packed in road waste
category. Milk covers are either categorized as Pugga or kept separately if given better price.
Majority of the waste pickers interviewed told that around 10 % of plastics collected is discarded
by the Junk Dealer before paying the price.
17
3.2 Kabadiwala
Kabadiwalas (or cyclewala) collect waste directly from household. The quality of their waste is,
therefore, higher. They collect milk sachets, which are separately kept after washing, bottles,
broken buckets, baskets, toys and other household items. Since the collected waste is generally
sorted and stored by householders not much sorting is required by a Kabadiwala. On an average
plastic items account for 14% of their income.
The main sources of waste collection are waste pickers, Kabadiwalas, servants, citizens,
institutions and industries. As per an assessment the share of supply is as follow: waste pickers
(28 %), factories (25 %), Households (24 %), Kabadiwalas (19 %) and institutions (4 %). This is
a broad figure covering all types of waste and does not indicate supply of plastic material. On an
average plastics amounts for 35 to 45% of sales of a Junk Dealer's shop.
A Junk Dealer runs his business in a small shop generally located in a residential area. It is
estimated that Bangalore has 600 and odd number of Junk Dealers shops. A shop barely
measures a maximum of 20 ft x 20 ft and is piled up with sorted and unsorted waste. Sorting is
done either in the open space in front of the shop or near his residence. A few may have access to
an open plot, generally a public property. Shops have minimum accessories like weighing scale
and generally do not have electricity.
A fixed number of waste picker supply at his place. Prices are negotiated and are not changed
frequently. A waste pickers reputation with a Junk Dealer brings him/her a better price rather
than the quality of the waste for, regularity of waste supply is more important for a Junk Dealer
than quality. The relationship between waste pickers and Junk Dealers is a mutual one. In
exchange of the regular supply of waste, a Junk Dealer extends credit to a waste picker. A Junk
Dealer may use waste pickers services for sorting and in turn either give him place to stay or
protect him from police harassment. It is essential for both the parties to build long lasting
relationship for the success of their respective businesses. In addition, labor of a relative staying
at Junk Dealer's place and other family members like wife and children may also be employed
for sorting.
A major investment for a Junk Dealer is towards land and building. In most of the cases, the
shop is rented for a fixed advance which is the only investment other than the money spent for
the weighing scale. He has to have working capital for a month in his hand before starting the
business. Investment money is raised from family sources. Loans, other than small credits from
Wholesalers in time of need, are least expected. Sometimes money is raised by selling the village
land or borrowed from village sources.
It takes time to understand the intricacies of waste business. Before starting his own business a
Junk Dealer generally works at a relative's shop either as a shop keeper or as a Kabadiwala and
18
inherits contacts along with business skills. A waste picker starting his own business as Junk
Dealer is very rare.
The waste is sold generally once a week as a shop has storing capacity of a week's waste. Each
Junk Dealer has a set of regular customers and different categories of waste are sold to different
Wholesalers specialized in the categories of waste. Depending upon the demand transportation
charges are borne by the either of the party. If in need of waste, Wholesaler sends a tempo,
otherwise transportation charges are born by the Junk Dealer.
3.3.1 Sorting
Depending upon his capacity a Junk Dealer sorts waste in to the varieties mentioned below.
However, only the highest and the lowest level of sorting generally done at this stage are
mentioned below. Between these extreme levels of sorting, there exists range of levels of sorting.
Pugga: hard plastic, buckets, baskets, canes, toothpaste covers, disposable cups,
cosmetics and detergent bottles, etc.
Karak: Lids of all bottles.
Soft footwear, one variety of plastic bag made of HMPE.
Milk covers, oil and Ghee covers, thick variety of plastic packing bag.
Super white plastic thick cover ( for example packing bag for Surf detergent powder).
Hard footwear and broken lids.
Kala(black) Pugga: same as Pugga but black in color.
Carry bags are sorted in five different colors (rose, blue, green, white and yellow).
Sanitary pipes, irrigation pipes (hard), electric conduits.
Water pipes (soft).
Article: comb, switches, iron handles etc.( sometime acrylic sheets are kept in this
category).
Sheet Kadak: window planks, vegetable cutting planks, radio case, cassette covers etc.
Kadak: is like Pugga but different type of plastic. This type releases fresh and pleasant
smell immediately on breaking.
19
Above varieties indicate only broad categories of sorting and not the exact description of the
material sorted.
3.4 Wholesalers
Wholesaler generally deal with one category of waste. A plastic waste Wholesaler purchases
waste from Junk Dealers, institutions, shops and industries. Waste is sorted according to type of
plastic at this level. The separate categories of plastic such as PP or PE or PVC are recognised
hence forth. The methods generally adopted for sorting are still the same. While sorting
knowledge of type of plastic and its previous utility is more relied upon than any other method
for sorting. However, a bucket made of PP or HDPE is ascertained by smelling the plastic after
breaking. Typical categories in to which the collected waste is sorted is presented in the financial
analysis.
A Wholesaler sells waste directly to the industry. His contacts (which are built through years of
experiences in the business) with the suppliers and end users of waste is the key factor for his
business. As in the case of Junk Dealer, the Wholesaler supplies to regular customers. The
Wholesaler also exports waste outside Bangalore for which they need to obtain permit for
movement of waste across the border of various federal states.
Plastic Wholesalers are located mainly in Jolly Mohalla in Bangalore. A shop and godown
typically measures around 2000 sq. ft. Many of them have a separate shop for the business
dealings and the waste is sorted and stored in the godown.
As in the case of MIDDLE DEALER, main investment for a Wholesaler is land and building.
The Wholesalers contacted for this study received support from the family and raised money
through private loans at interest rate as high as 2 % to 5 % a month.
A typical analysis of the quantity and type of waste collected by waste pickers is presented
bellow. The results are based on sample of 55 respondents, mainly women, from Kuntigrama
slum and 61 respondents, mainly men, from Bharatmata slum. Generally, a waste picker goes for
waste picking on an average 17 to 20 days a month.
20
Brown Board 15-20 0.75 13
Card Board 3-4 2.50 10
Record 5-6 2.50 15
Plastic
Road Waste 4 2.00 8
Pugga and Milk Covers 2-3 9.00 24
Kadak 2 6.00 12
Glass
Beer Bottle 5-6 No. 2.00/No 12
Whisky Bottle 10 No. 0.75/No 7.5
Phenyl and Small 2-3 No. 0.50/No 1.5
Metal (all) 1 20 20
Total Rs./day 123
Considering waste picking for 17 days a month, total income per month = Rs. 2091
3.6 Kabadiwala
The following representation is aggregate of 11 Kabadiwala interviewed in Malleswaram area of
Bangalore.
21
Table 2.1 Quantity and Type of Material Collected by Kabadiwala
Type Quantity Buying Total Buying Selling Price Total
Kg/day Price Rs./day Rs./kg Selling
Rs./kg Rs./day
Paper
News Paper English 30 3.50 105 4.00 120
News Paper Kannada 25 3.00 75 3.50 88
Card Board 10 2.00 20 4.00 40
Magazines 12 2.00 24 2.50 30
Plastics
Milk Covers 3 6.00 18 8.00 24
Plastic Bottles/Items 3 8.00 24 12.00 36
Glass
Bottles Big 7 0.50 3.5 0.75 5
Beer 11 1.50 16.5 2.00 22
Whisky 5 1.00 5 2.00 10
Phenyl 10 0.50 5 0.75 8
Metal (all) 2 10.00 20 20.00 40
Total Rs./day 316 422
Profit = Rs. 106 per day x 26 days = Rs. 2756 /Month
The shopkeeper was working as a Kabadiwala in J.P. Nagar and Jayanagar area. He used to sell
his collected waste to his uncles shop. In 1980, he opened his shop with the assistance of his
uncle and capital raised from his village. Initial capital was spent towards the land, building and
purchase of scales etc.
22
None of the waste picker stay with him. His wife and brother help him in managing business. He
has a small godown, 20 ft x 30 ft, near his place to store the sorted waste.
Running Cost
23
Table 3.1.2 Other Inputs
Type Total Rs./Month
Transportation 1600
Labor for Sorting (1 Man and 2 Women) 3000
Others and Electricity 1000
Total 5600
Capital Cost
24
Table 3.1.4 Sale after Sorting
25
Total = Rs. 65,628 per Month
Net profit.
Gross profit 10540 Rs. per Month
Less Interest and Depreciation 435 Rs. per Month
-------------------------
Total 10105 Rs. per Month
Rentability Analysis
5. Vulnerability analysis
Note: This ratio is calculated only for plastics purchased and sold by the junk dealer.
Purchase price of different plastic scrape is averaged out to Rs. 5000 /ton. The average
sale price of virgin plastic is taken as Rs. 52,000 per ton.)
26
3.7.2 Vazeer Ahemad
Bharatmata Slum
Pillana Garden
Bangalore - 560 045.
Vazeer belongs to Bangalore. He first started a cycle mechanic shop when he moved in to
Bharatmata slum in 1989. Later, he started his own scrap with the help of a relative who deals
with metal and iron scrap. Metal scrap is easily available on Tannery road and number of waste
pickers in the slum of his residence sold appreciable quantity of scrap. He started his shop within
the slum in the corner of his home and later expanded it to his sisters house. At present, 8-10
waste pickers and surrounding households supply their waste to him.
Running Cost
27
Table 3.2.2 Other Inputs
Type Total Rs./Month
Rent 300
Transportation 650
Labor for Sorting 2500
Others 350
Total 3800
Capital Cost
28
Table 3.2.4 Sale after Sorting
Material Type Amount Selling Price Total Selling Price
Kg/Week Rs./Kg Rs./Week
Brown Paper 890 0.80 712
Card Board 40 3.50 140
Record 120 3.00 360
Carry Bags 168 4.00 1032
Milk Covers 50 12.00 600
Pugga 35 18.00 630
Bucket Items 35 18.00 630
Hard Pieces 60 6.00 360
Chappal 15 7.00 105
Cable Wires and Pipes 28 6.00 168
Iron 240 6.00 1440
Aluminium 9 40.00 360
Tin 14 5.00 70
Steel 13 14.00 132
Bottles 360No 2.00/No 720
Total 7509
Total Rs. per Month 30036
29
Net profit.
Gross profit 6012 Rs. per Month
Less Interest and depreciation 75 Rs. per Month
Total 5937 Rs. per Month
Rentability Analysis
5. Vulnerability analysis
Note: This ratio is calculated only for plastics purchased and sold by the junk dealer.
Purchase price of different plastic scrape is averaged out to Rs. 6666 /ton. The average
sale price of virgin plastic is taken as Rs. 52,000 per ton.)
Babu started his business in 1980. Prior to that he was working as a Kabadiwala in his Uncles
shop. He worked there for 6 years. He hails from Nagucoil from Tamilnadu and came to
Bangalore in 1974. While working with his Uncle he developed contacts with wholesalers.
Eventually, some of the waste pickers selling to his Uncle started selling to him and with his
Uncles financial help he started his own business. He also occupied an open space near his
residence in a slum as a storage place. At present, 8-10 waste pickers supply to him.
Running Cost
30
Table 3.3.1 Raw Material
Type Volume Volume Purchase Total
Dealt Dealt Price Rs./Kg Purchase
Kg/Day Kg/Week Price
Rs./Week
Brown Board, Record Mixed 136 816 0.75 612
News Paper 6 33 3.00 99
Card Board 49 294 2.25 661
Road Waste 40 240 2.00 480
Milk Covers, Pugga and Mixed 42 250 8.00 2000
Tin 0.25 9 3.00 27
Iron 20 120 4.00 480
Beer Bottles 50No. 300 No. 1.00/No. 300
Whisky Bottles 70No. 420 No. 0.75/No. 315
Big Bottles 20No. 120 No. 0.50/No. 60
Total 5034
Total Rs. per Month 20136
31
Capital Cost
32
Gross profit before depreciation and interest
Net profit.
Gross profit 6644 Rs. per Month
Less Interest and depreciation 79 Rs. per Month
Total 6565 Rs. per Month
Rentability Analysis
5. Vulnerability analysis
Note: This ratio is calculated only for plastics purchased and sold by the junk dealer.
Purchase price of different plastic scrape is averaged out to 5000 Rs./ton. The average
sales price of virgin plastic is taken as 52,000 Rs. per ton.)
33
3.7.4 Ibrahim
Nagashettyhalli Main Road
RMV Extension, Bangalore - 94
Ibrahim started his waste buying shop in 1976 with the help of his elder brother who is a small
wholesaler in Jolly Mohallah. Prior to starting this shop, he was working in his brothers shop.
Initially he was purchasing waste from 10 -12 waste pickers living in the slum where he was
staying. In 1983, he rented the shop from where he is operating at present. Besides this shop, he
has two more shops which are managed by his younger brother and his son. Around 25 waste
pickers and 12 kabadiwalas are selling their waste to him. The waste materials purchased in the
three shops are stored in a godown situated in his slum. Data presented in this section is based
on the quantities bought and purchased in one shop.
34
Financial Data Analysis
Running Cost
Raw Material
Type Volume Volume Dealt Purchase Price Total Purchase Price
Dealt Kg/Month Rs./Kg Rs./Month
Kg/Day
Paper
Brown Board 97 2520 0.70 1764
News Paper English 97 2520 5.00 12600
News Paper Kannada 92 2400 3.00 7200
Magazines 35 920 4.00 3680
Card Board 38 990 2.50 2475
Record 82 2136 2.50 5340
Plastic
Road Waste 17 450 2.00 900
Pugga and Mixed 15 402 8.00 3216
Kadak 14 354 6.00 2124
HDPE 6 144 10.00 1440
Metal
Tin 35 840 4.00 3360
Iron 50 1200 5.00 6000
Steel 50 1200 10.00 12000
Mixed 3 65 20.00 1300
Bottles
Beer Bottles 40No. 1040 No. 2.00/No. 2080
Whisky Bottles 90No. 2340 No. 0.75/No. 1755
Phenyl 35No. 840 No. 0.50/No. 420
Small Bottles White 15No. 360 No. 0.50/No. 180
Small Bottles Color 25No. 600 No. 0.40/No. 240
Total Rs. per Month 68074
35
Other Inputs
Type Total Rs./Month
Transportation 12800
Labor for Sorting 10400
Others 4000
Total 27200
Capital Cost
36
Pugga 170 14.00 2380
Kala Pugga 75 9.00 675
Bucket Items 180 14.00 2520
PP White 150 5.00 750
PP Color 150 4.00 600
Kadak Light 90 14.00 1260
Kadak Heavy 70 18.00 1260
Karak 30 40.00 1200
Iron 1200 7.00 8400
Tin 840 5.00 4200
Aluminum 20 58.00 1160
Brass 12 75.00 900
Copper 28 100.00 2800
Rods 1200 20.00 24000
Beer Bottles 1000No. 2.50/No. 2500
Whisky Bottles 2000No. 1.00/No. 2000
Phenyl Bottles 840 No. 0.75/No. 630
Small White Bottles 360 No. 0.75/No. 270
Small Color Bottles 600 No. 0.50/No. 300
Broken Cullets 300 0.50 150
37
Total Rs. per Month = 1,16,220 Rs.
Net profit.
Gross profit 13946 Rs. per Month
Less Interest and depreciation 528 Rs. per Month
Total 13417 Rs. per Month
Rentability Analysis
5. Vulnerability analysis
Note: This ratio is calculated only for plastics purchased and sold by the junk dealer.
Purchase price of different plastic scrape is averaged out to 6500 Rs./ton. The average
sales price of virgin plastic is taken as 52,000 Rs. per ton.)
38
3.8 Wholesaler
Before starting this business in 1982, Razaque Bhaiya was involved in leather business. He
moved to Bangalore from Tamilnadu as he incurred loss in leather business. He first joined his
two brothers involved in waste plastic and metal trade. They eventually helped him to set up
business of his own. He owns one godown-cum-shop and one godown originally purchased by
his brother in 1975. He deals only with plastic waste. He gets waste from 8-10 Junk Dealers, 6-8
Kabadiwalas, 4 companies and institutions and a few shops from J.C. road. He also receives oil
and Jerry cans from shops located on J.C. road.
Running Cost
39
Table 4.1.2 Other Inputs
Type Total Rs./Month
Transportation 25000
Labor for Sorting 12200
1. Men (2) @ Rs. 1500 per Month 3000
2. Women (2) @ Rs. 1000 per Month 2000
3. Boys (8) @ Rs. 80 per Day, 3 days a week 2880
4. Loading, unloading, transporting 4320
Others 5000
Total 42200
Capital Cost
40
Sale after Sorting
Material Type Amount Kg/Month Selling Price Rs./Kg Selling Rs./Month
Pugga
HDPE (Kodams, Cans) 2000 20.00 40,000
LDPE (Toilet Items) 1200 16.00 19,200
LDPE (Cans, Buckets) 900 4.00 21,600
HDPE and PP 1840 16.00 29,440
PP Black 600 20.00 12,000
Leyland Sheet (Bus Seat Covers etc.,.) 400 12.00 4800
HMPE (Bags, Stopper etc.,) 720 15.00 10,800
PVC Items 1000 22.00 35,200
Kadak
PVC + PP 800 12.00 9,600
ABS 1600 20.00 32,000
Acrylic Sheet 900 14.00 12,600
Gown Katha (Items made of Virgin PVC) 280 20.00 5,600
Hard Pieces
Black PVC 1200 9.00 10,800
White PVC 800 10.00 8,000
Derlyne (Drips etc.,) 800 10.00 16,000
x-ray Items 100 40.00 4,000
Slipper
Foam 640 10.00 6,400
Sandak 720 10.00 7,200
Hard Pieces 720 11.00 7,920
HDPE Bags
HDPE Bags 2400 14.00 33,600
Super Bags 1800 15.00 27,000
Carry Bags
PP I 2000 20.00 20,000
PP II 900 8.00 7,200
LDPE Bags 2400 10.00 24,000
HM Bags 1600 8.00 14,400
Rejected Bags 400 6.00 2,400
41
Total = Rs. 4,67,760 per Month
Net profit.
Gross profit 40,080 Rs. per Month
Less Interest and depreciation 633 Rs. per Month
Total 41,447 Rs. per Month
Rentability Analysis
5. Vulnerability analysis
Note: The purchase price of different plastic scrape is averaged out to 12416 Rs./ton. The
average sales price of virgin plastic is taken as 52,000 Rs. per ton.)
43
3.8.2 Mahaboob Ali Khan
Asian Plastic Traders
16/1 Jolly Masjid Road
Bangalore.
His business is 11 years old. Prior to starting waste shop he had retail shop for waste purchase in
Bamboo Bazar and provision stores. With expanding business his four sons also joined him and
they restricted themselves to plastic purchase and selling. He owns a small blow mounlding
plastic recycling unit as well.
Running Cost
Raw Material
Type Volume Dealt Purchase Price Total Rs./Week
Kg/Week Rs./Kg
Pugga 650 20.00 13,000
Kadak 400 25.00 10,000
Super 700 15.00 10,500
PVC 500 15.00 7,500
Road Waste 1200 12.00 14,400
Total Rs. per Month 2,21,600
44
Other Inputs
Type Total Rs./Month
Transportation 15000
Labor for Sorting 8060
1. Men (2) @ Rs. 1950 per Month 3900
2. Women (4) @ Rs. 1040 per Month 4160
Rent 6000
Water 600
Electricity 300
Telephone 2000
Total 31960
Capital Cost
45
Sale after Sorting
46
Gross profit before depreciation and interest
Net profit.
Gross profit 40,240 Rs. per Month
Less Interest and depreciation 433 Rs. per Month
Total 39,806 Rs. per Month
Rentability Analysis
5. Vulnerability analysis
Note: The purchase price of different plastic scrape is averaged out to 17400 Rs./ton. The
average sales price of virgin plastic is taken as 52,000 Rs. per ton.)
References
47
CHAPTER 4 PLASTIC REPROCESSING: PROCESS, PRACTICES AND
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS
CHAPTER I: PROCESS AND PRACTICES
4.1 Definition
Plastic is an organic material which on application of adequate heat and pressure can be caused
to flow and take up a desired shape which will be retained when the applied heat and pressure
are withdrawn. Chemically, a polymer is defined as a substance composed of very large
molecules. The molecular structure corresponds to a chain composed of many small molecules
joined by chemical bonds. One or more types of small molecules, also known as monomers, are
incorporated into the polymer as it is synthesized in control conditions (Brandrup, 1975).
From the view point of recycling, plastics (or polymers as it is known in the language of material
sciences) can be subdivided in two main categories: thermoplastics, which consists of individual
long chain molecules and any product made of this plastic can be reprocessed; and thermoset
plastics which contain infinite three dimensional network which is formed when the product is in
the final form and can not be broken down by reheating (Brandrup, 1975). Hence, for the
purpose of this report only thermoplastics are analysed.
By definition plastics can be reheated and modified in different shape. Theoretically this process
can be repeated number of times but practically it depends upon the physical conditions in which
it is processed and reprocessed.
4.2 Reprocessing
Polyolefins
Polyolefins are the worlds most important class of polymer in terms of volume usage and
simplest in terms of composition. They are long chain hydrocarbons consisting of polymer of
alpha-olefins, with molecular weight ranging from a few thousands to few millions. There are
various varieties of polyolefins and they differ from one another in molecular weight.
Polyolefins are the thermoplastics with easy processing and reprocessing characteristics and
hence widely sought after polymer for recycling all over the world.
Important varieties in this category are: Polyethylene-Low Density(LDPE) has moderate degree
of crystallinity (50%) because the molecular chain has numerous short chain branches. It is non
brittle plastic with easy processibility, moderate hardness and low softening temperature.
Polyethylene-High Density (HDPE) has little or no branching or side chains. It has higher
stiffness, strength and melting point. Polyethylene-Linear Low Density (LLDPE) has a degree of
48
crystallinity and properties generally intermediate between conventional high and low density
polyethylene. Commercially available Polypropylene has high degree of crystallinity, high
stiffness, strength and melting point (Mcmillan, 1996; Ross, 1996).
PVC
Polyvinyl chlorine resin, or PVC are derived from vinyl chloride monomer in which vinyl
chloride accounts for 50 to 100% by weight. Vinyl chloride monomer is a gaseous, chlorine
containing hydrocarbon. In world wide commercial importance, PVC resins outrank other
polymers in terms of application and total tonnage of the products made. PVC is unique in
another sense that it is least stable for the commercial use. A host of the additives are required to
increase the processibility and heat resistance capacity. In addition to antioxidants, fire resistants,
impact modifiers etc., are added. Additives sometimes comprise 60% by weight of a finished
product.
PVC has remained controversial all through due to two reasons: the toxic hazards posed by the
industries producing vinyl chloride and other additives and probable impact of products of the
plastic when in use and when subjected to the extreme environment. The impact is not only on
those workers coming in intimate and prolonged physical contact with the material in question
but also influences the larger population in a variety of ways.
PVC, as such is difficult to process without stabilisers and plasticisers. Reprocessing is even
more difficult as additives are consumed in the first cycle itself and contaminants make it more
susceptible to degradation (Batiuk, 1977).
Methods of Sorting
All types of Polyethylene are compatible and great care is not taken to separate them, although
the previous use largely determines the type. However, PP and PVC require careful separation
from each other and from PE, as all the three have different molecular weight and hence different
49
melt flow index and viscat flow temperature. For example, HDPE contaminated with PP can lead
to polymer segregation as PP melts at 40o C higher than HDPE, whereas PET remains solid at
normal processing temperature and any unmelted PET present can quickly plug melt delivery
channels. The difference in densities gives the potential to separate them.
Generally, visual methods and judgements are employed to differentiate between the types of
plastics. These methods depend on the knowledge of type of plastic used for the manufacture of
the original product. Others in use include touch, feel and sound methods. When these methods
are proven insufficient, the plastic is broken and smelled or burnt. The nature of smell or fire
decides the type. This method, though scientifically proven is rarely used in practice.
Instead, water with different densities is used to separate PP, PE, PS and PVC. When soaked in
water all PE and PP float having densities less than water, whereas PS and PVC settle down. To
further separate PP from PE and separate all varieties of PE alcohol is added in water to reduce
density less than one. In 25 liters of water 2-3 liters of alcohol is added to make PP float. On
further addition of alcohol LLDPE and LDPE float and HDPE sinks. The mixture of PVC and
PS are separated in salt water with density more than one, wherein PS floats and PVC sinks. This
method, although used frequently, is not considered accurate as some varieties of plastics can not
be identified on the basis of density. For example, some grades of PP settles with PVC and PS.
This can cause problem at the time of melt processing. Hence, visual methods are considered
most reliable.
Milk sachets are generally purchased after they are separated from other plastic sheets and then
cut and cleaned manually. They are further fed into beater where mud, sand and other heavy
contaminants are removed by pounding. The same is then washed in automatic washer for two to
three times and dried before converting into chips which are fed into the extruder. Similar
procedure is followed for carry bags and other plastic sheets.
A. Polyethylene
When waste reaches the reprocessing industry it is fairly sorted as the industry generally
purchases one variety of the scrap. For example the industry may purchase scrap mainly
containing buckets, mugs, baskets, kodams, toys or milk sachets or carry bags or shampoo and
detergent bottles etc. Sorted material in terms of their previous use ensures uniformity of the
material being reprocessed. Further, sorting based on color is done in-house if the scrap contains
mixture of buckets, kodams, mugs etc. This helps to achieve uniform color of recyclate but more
importantly it ensures uniformity of the scrap being recycled. By thumb rule more times the
plastic is recycled the more it becomes darker and dull. To camouflage the degraded patches
dark blue, green, red and ultimately black color are added at the time of reprocessing. The color
and shine of the plastic scrap is therefore an important indicator to decide how many times it
might have been recycled. It is important to separate more time recycled scrap from the other
scrap to ensure quality. This judgement requires knowledge and experience based on practice.
50
For example, blow molded water carriers (locally known as Kodams) made of HDPE are
available in three qualities: Rafiya which is the highest grade and is made from used
fertiliser sacks or from milk sachets; the next quality grade is known as super which is made
from one time used bottles like Johnson powder and detergent bottles; and, the lowest
quality medium grade is made from once used Kodams.
B. Polypropylene
Polypropylene is used for thin carry bags, buckets, Kodams, household items, automobile spare-
parts, sacks etc. Different types of carry bags are separated on the basis of sound they make
when rubbed between two hands. PP gives crisp and cracking sound compared to other plastics.
In case of confusion the edge of the plastic is burnt to identify PP which gives a scented smell.
This requires skilled, experienced workers. While separating, bags are also cleaned manually to
broadly remove dust and mud and no other washing is done. These bags are then fed into
extruder to be converted into lumps which are crushed and again extruded to make granules.
Sometime the lumps are straight used to make blow molded suitcases.
Items like automobile spare parts are further sorted to remove nylon or PVC items and then
ground. The chips are put, with or without washing, in to high speed mixer to remove moisture.
If required the masterbatch of the color is mixed at this stage. The chips are fed into the extruder
at high temperature and converted into lumps which are again extruded to make granules or
straight used for product making. In a similar way, buckets, baskets, mugs and household items
are reprocessed. The reprocessed granules or lumps are used to make battery separator, buckets,
mugs, Kodams and household items.
C. PVC
It is not difficult to differentiate PVC from other plastic items. Footwear, drainage and water
pipes, irrigation pipes, electric conduits are the main PVC items which appear in the waste
stream. Uniform type is very essential for PVC recycling and hence generally one type of waste
is purchased from one wholesaler.
Garden hose, footwear and electric conduits are recycled into footwear and drainage pipes. PVC
rigid pipes and medicine covers are recycled into conduits and rigid pipes. Generally, waste is
not washed before it is ground. The chips are sometimes put in the water to ascertain the type
vis-a-vis other plastics.
Size Reduction
Once uniformity of plastic to be reprocessed is ensured the material is reduced in size depending
upon type of plastic. Thin carry bags of LDPE, LLDPE or even PP are directly fed into extruder
with or without washing. Hard plastic like buckets, baskets, mugs etc. are fed into shredder and
converted into flakes or chips of around 3 mm diameter. Whereas HDPE bags are cut and
51
converted into chips. This operation ensures uniformity in the size of input material and hence
higher output.
Both, vertical axis and horizontal axis, locally fabricated shredders were found in use. The
matter is fed at the top and the chopped flakes are collected at the bottom. This is a very noisy
operation which also generates dust. In many places shredders are operated in such a way that
few cut pieces are thrown out at high velocity. Covering the input and output sides with a cloth
bag is a simple remedy to prevent both cut pieces and dust emissions.
Coloring
Second or third time recycled plastic has to be colored to cover the degraded patches and also to
give new, uniform look. Previously coloring was done with powdered pigments which is still
followed by a few reprocessors. Major disadvantage of this method is that different batches of
the same colored matter fed into extruder get different shades in spite of strict controlling of the
amount of pigments added. Also, the different shades are obtained with same amount of
pigments added if the matter is extruded at different temperature. In addition, the color is not
uniformly dispersed throughout. These disadvantages are overcome with the method of adding
color in the form of masterbatch. Masterbatch is a capsule of concentrated colors with certain
additives: Silicon Dioxide for uniformity and handling ease, dispersing agents like easter and
waxes and coupling agents like salts of Silicon and Titanium. These additives are mainly to
improve the color mixing and have no impact on processing. Few brands of masterbatch are
available in market and the exact formula of different ingredients is generally maintained as a
business secrete.
Commonly used colors are Titanium oxide (white), Thelocynine (green and blue), Scarlet City
and Iron Oxide (red), Benzandine (yellow), and Cadmium (red) in addition to carbon black.
Most of the color pigments are complex organic compounds, usually with a metal chelate, which
provides the typical color. Common pigments are thallocyannins, e.g., blue, green, red etc.
Metals present include Cadmium, Copper, Iron, Tin etc. It is often seen that the pigments used
by the reprocessors are not always standard, with some pigments not being clearly identifiable as
to their composition etc.
52
Pigments used form a small proportion of the plastic being reprocessed, of the order of 0.1% of
the plastic by weight. Thus, in a typical reprocessing unit having a production capacity of 400
Kgs per day, the amount of pigment used is about 0.4 Kgs, equivalent to a metal usage of 0.05-
0.1 Kg per day.
Carbon black is usually added to make the material black in color. While other pigments are
added with a dispersing agent to prevent dust formation, in case of carbon black no such agent is
used, probably because with carbon black there would be dust anyway. Carbon black is usually
colloidal in size, and tends to deposit everywhere, and can also be inhaled and deposited in the
lungs.
Additives
The basic Polymers to which the plastic industry owes its existence are in most cases
unsuitable for processing into useful articles in their pure unmodified form.
Plastic additives may be divided into two main categories: those which modify Polymer
properties by physical means, such as plasticiser, lubricants, impact modifiers, fillers, pigments
etc.; and, additives which achieve their effect by chemical reactions such as PVC heat stabilisers,
antioxidants, ultraviolet absorbers and flame retardants.
PVC with its susceptibility requires maximum number of additives. A plasticiser improves
flexibility and processibility and alters temperature dependent properties. A widely used
plasticiser added for reprocessing is dioctyl phthalates. This plasticiser, although known for its
low toxicity and low volatility and ease of handling besides being cheap, has poor extraction
properties, is inflammable and unsuited for continuous use at elevated temperatures. Tribasic
lead sulphate, dibasic lead sulphate and lead stearate are most commonly used stabilisers to
prevent decomposition at the normal processing temperature. These stabilisers are cheap,
efficient but are toxic and should not be preferred for food packaging. However, PVC is rarely
recycled into food packaging articles. Calcium stearate, glysrene mono stearate, paraffin wax
and hydro carbon wax are commonly used lubricants in reprocessing of PVC. In addition, fillers
are added to lower the cost of composition. Additives are added and mixed in high speed mixer
but actually compounded when passed through the extruder.
All Polymeric materials are subject to oxidative degradation at elevated temperature necessary
for processing. Antioxidants- phenolic compounds should be added to combat the effect of
oxidation during reprocessing as well as subsequent service life. Particularly polyolefins are
more susceptible to oxidative degradation at processing (for that matter reprocessing as well)
temperature and unless compounded with antioxidants not only the subsequent service life is
severely shortened but odorous elements are also produced when being extruded. However, for
reprocessing of Polyolefins additives are very rarely used except pigments, which in fact,
promote the oxidative degradation. This part is further discussed in the chapter on Environmental
Effect (Nass, 1977; Beadle, 1971; Chanda, 1987).
53
Extrusion
A plastic material is forced through an orifice of the required shape under pressure to achieve the
desired section. This is the fundamental principle of the extrusion. Extrusion is the crucial
operation and extruders are widely used machines in processing and reprocessing of plastics. As
per an estimate, 50 % of the main thermoplastics consumed are finally extruded. However,
extruders are also used for various other purposes of plastic processing, namely, as reactors, melt
pumps, compounders, devolatilisers etc. (Schenkel, 1966; Brydson, 1973). Extrusion for
reprocessing purpose fundamentally follows the same technology as for processing.
History
In a broad sense the extrusion of plastic materials is known for at least hundred and fifty
years. The first patent was granted in 1845 for an extruder for processing of thermoplastics. The
development of continuously operating extruders for thermoplastics began in the middle of
nineteenth century in the large cable factories of England and Germany. However, the real boost
for commercially available extruded plastics came with the world war II. Flexible PVC
insulating coating for electrical wires and cables represent the earliest commercial application
for extruded plastic during world war II (Schenkel, 1966). Technically, the extruder employed
for reprocessing is essentially same as the one utilised for processing.
Types of Extruders
The extruder machines are generally heated by electric resistance heaters although many other
forms of heating may be found, for example, steam, oil etc. Electrical resistance heaters are used
in India for processing and reprocessing of plastics. Ideally, the temperature regulation of the
extruder barrel is fully automatic. For this purpose the barrel is divided into a number of zones to
allow variation of temperature along the length. Similarly, cooling is done with air or water as
heat transfer media (Braun, 1971).
C. Vented Extruders
54
Specially designed vented extruders have degassing zone to remove the volatile matter. The
vented extruders are considered as landmark achievement in extrusion technology, although they
are hardly used in India. The concept and design of vented extruders are further discussed in the
next section (Deutcher, 1980; Brydson, 1973).
55
The Extrusion Process: Theory
The barrel and screw section of the extruder has four principle functions: pumping, heating,
mixing and pressurising. The length of extruder can be divided in to three zones: a feed zone
starting at hopper, followed by a compression zone and then a melt or metering zone.
The granules or flakes are collected in the feed zone from feed hopper and transported up the
screw channel. The granules/flakes begin to heat up and compact, building up pressure as they
advance down the screw. For efficient pumping the granules/flakes must not be allowed to stay
in the screw channel. As the matter shifts from feed zone to melt zone there is an increase in the
screw diameter. This will cause compression of the matter forcing the air trapped in between
back towards the hopper. The melting should occur around the compression zone. In the melt
zone the polymer is brought to correct consistency and pressure required for extrusion. A high
melt pressure is required in the metering zone in order to mix the melt to give it constant
properties throughout and to obtain smooth extrudates. This pressure is generated by restrictions
to flow in the melt zone and die head. It will also increase with an increase in melt viscosity ( by
lowering the melt temperature) (Brydson, 1973; Balachandani, 1980).
Breaker Plate
At the end of melt zone there is a breaker plate. This is usually perforated disc of greater
thickness. This has several important functions. It helps to further increase back pressure, it turns
rotational flow of the melt into flow parallel to the screw axis, it holds back impurities and it
57
holds back unplasticised material. The ability of breaker plate to fulfill these functions are
enhanced by interposing wire mesh screens between breaker plate and screw.
Temperature Control
The Melt Flow Index is a rough measure of the molecular weight and melt viscosity of the
Polymer. It indicates how readily molten Polymer will flow in processing machinery. It is a
function of temperature, molecular weight of the Polymer, shear generated by the screw speed,
pressure and contaminants present in the polymer. In other words, the resistance to flow under
specified temperature and pressure conditions is called Melt Index. Theoretically developed Melt
Index do not take into account the actual conditions of processing but is a reasonably accurate
indicator to predict how Polymer will behave when processed.
Lower the Melt Index value of the Polymer higher the viscosity, hence processing low Melt
Index Polymer will require higher operating temperature and more mechanical power in the
processing equipment. Moreover, due to difference in such flow properties mixing of two
batches of widely different Melt Index Polymers would give very poor finishing surface or may
make processing difficult or even impossible. Melt Flow Index denotes wide range of
temperature at which the Polymer will be melt viscous under processing and reprocessing
conditions (Mark, 1989). The temperature for Polyolefin is denoted in Table 1. PVC free from
additives can start degrading at temperature as low as 500C but generally is processed at 175-
1800C compounded with various additives.
Large part of the melting occurs at the interface between melt film and solid bed. Heat is
conducted from the hot barrel surface through the film into the interface. Furthermore, the
relative velocity of barrel and screw shears the thin film thus generating considerable amount of
heat by viscous dissipation. It is necessary to control heat supply because if the material becomes
excessively hot it may decompose, degrade or become too fluid. If excessively cold it will be
insufficiently plasticised. Variations in temperature will also cause variations in flow rate. In
order to optimise the efficiency, temperature is varied along the barrel. Two to six heating zones
are normal with a steady temperature gradient increasing from the feed to die. Temperature
control in all these zones is very crucial and should be achieved by the automatic temperature
control mechanism and by cooling the parts of the barrel with air or water circulation
(Balachandani, 1980).
Degassing
Polymer melts may contain varying amount of air, moisture, solvent or monomer. These
contaminants may be removed by applying vacuum and allowing volatile to diffuse out for
quality output. Otherwise this causes extrudates to bubble and exhibit porosity (Deutcher, 1980).
Contaminants like air and moisture, in case of polyolefin, promote oxidization and eventually
degradation at the time of processing. This can be reduced by using a screw with decompressing
zone with a sudden change in the diameter of the screw. The flight in the decompression zone
58
will have no pressure on the melt. A vent hole is drilled at this point in the barrel to allow gases
to escape added with vacuum ( Brydson, 1973).
Extruders generally used for reprocessing in Bangalore are locally fabricated in the workshops or
in the industry itself. It is very common to fabricate extruders from second-hand or discarded
machinery and have bare minimum parts. It was a usual sight that heaters and electrical wiring
connected with barrel are exposed without any casing. The wiring, in many cases, was connected
without even insulation tapes. In such case, the proper design of the screw to suit the type of the
polymer being reprocessed and auotomatic temperature control can not be expected. The
extruders are single screw type with or without increasing root diameter from feed to metering
zones. The vented extruders are rarely used as the cost of such machines is manyfold higher than
the non-vented ones.
The temperature range for melting particular type of Polymer is fixed on the basis of practice.
There are two ways of temperature control: manual off and on of heaters or cooling with water
manually. The automatic temperature control systems known as Pyromatric temperature control
system which automatically disconnects when temperature exceeds the prescribed limit are
rarely used. The second system of temperature control, wherein heating can be stopped for set
timing, say 10 % or 20 % of the heating time, are also not commonly used as they are difficult to
maintain. Generally, manually switching on and off systems are used in addition to cooling the
barrel manually with water.
Flakes or chips are preheated in high speed mixer and fed into the hopper. The matter is then
pushed into the barrel with long spade or wooden stick to maintain continuous flow with
relatively high pressure. The process normally starts with hot barrel to achieve maximum benefit
of the heat generated due to shear and heat conducted through barrel. A high screw speed and
low temperature setting is the ideal condition when all the heat may come from viscous
dissipation. The heating of the barrel creates the thin film of the melt on the solid bed and once
this is formed the heaters can be disconnected. Acheivemtn of this equilibrium demands lot of
efforts and in most of the reprocessing cases is not achieved simply because the process is
interrupted number of times due to contaminants clogging the wire mesh. Hence, manual cooling
the barrel with water in addition to switching off the power supply in extreme condition is the
only means of temperature control. The machine operator keeps a jug of water handy and ready
and pours it on barrel now and then.
Aarriving at a right kind of processing temperature suited to particular kind of Polymer is also a
task of the skilled operator. Although type of the Polymer being reprocessed is known, the
characteristic features like number of times reprocessed before, level and types of contaminants,
molecular weight (with each reprocessing the molecular weight of the Polymer is likely to
decrease by 30 % to 40 %) which influence the actual processing are largely unknown. Hence,
arriving at right kind of reprocessing conditions is an art more than the science. The rate of out
59
flow and homogeneity of the plastic coming out are indicators to decide the correct temperature
which may differ widely for the same type of polymer.
Breaker Plate
A wire mesh is attached to the breaker plate to remove contaminants. There is invariably a fair
amount of impurities in the shredded material loaded into extruder. The mesh placed before
breaker plate is meant to trap these impurities. In normal operation the mesh gets clogged very
fast, and needs to be replaced almost every minute. This causes frequent, though very short,
stoppages of extrusion, and again results in variations in temperature and a reduction in
production. As a result the actual production is about 50% of the total capacity. Thus most units,
which have a production capacity of 400 Kgs per day, actually produce only 200-250 Kgs per
day. The increased energy losses in turn lead to uncomfortable working conditions. Wire mesh is
changed manually and then burnt to remove impurities. The breaker plate is also burnt at least
once a day.
Power Shutdowns
Bangalore faces a severe shortage of power supply. As a consequence there is a power shutdown
of 2 hours each every morning and afternoon. In addition, industries are barred from using
power from 6 P.M. to 10 P.M. This has a considerable impact on the production and the
extrusion process. Extrusion is usually a continuous process, and in ideal conditions the machine
runs non-stop for a run of one week or more.
Frequent stoppages for replacing the mesh do not cause a large drop in the temperature of the
barrel and the die. Production is thus interrupted only when the stoppage occurs. However, in
case of power shutdowns, the barrel and the die cool down considerably, and take about an hour
to heat up. This causes, first, a considerable drop in the production and second, material in the
barrel of extruder solidifies and needs to be reheated, leading to degradation and loss. This
particularly causes problems in case of PVC as long residence time at elevated temperature in
the extruder leads to degradation. When the degraded material is removed from extruder after
power is restored, highly odorous volatile matter is emanated which may contain toxic vinyl
chloride, hydrogen chloride in addition to carbon monoxide and other products of incomplete
combustion.
60
Plastic thus recycled is passed through the extruder 2-3 times before reshaped into final
product.
Physical Environment:
Grinding scrap is a noisy operation. Some times noise level may go up to 95 db. Small scale
enterprises are often not designed for the reprocessing purpose. Adequately designed
ventilation to quickly remove the gaseous products and heat is generally not present. Lack
of space for easy movement makes it further congested.
Cleaning:
Caustic Soda and other cheap detergents are used for cleaning. The flakes or chips are soaked
in detergent for anywhere between 1 to 3 days. Before rinsing they are washed with hands.
This operation would require a worker to keep her/his hands in soap solution for 6 to 8 hours
a day.
Grinding:
Major products of grinding are RPM2 (respirable particulate matter) and SPM (suspended
particulate matter). Air quality monitoring (the results are attached as annexure) in one of the
plastic reprocessing unit in Bangalore revealed RPM = 241 mcg/cu.m and SPM = 1491 mcg/cu.
m.
Coloring
With the addition of color in the form of masterbatch the harmful effects of powder pigments
are curtailed. Nevertheless, the leaching out effect of pigments in the final product is a
complex phenomenon and it has to largely do with the conditions of reprocessing and type of
the pigments used.
Extrusion
Impact of Heating
It involves the mechanical scission of polymer chain in its viscous environment. This
produces highly reactive microradicals that in the presence of small amount of oxygen
dissolved in the polymer can form peroxyl radicals and hydroperoxides. As a result
hydrogen is abstracted from each C-H bond leading to rapid reduction in molecular
weight. This has two manifestations, one, the polymer becomes more susceptible to
2
Smoke arising of heating and grinding processes comprise soot, fine dust and ash in a mixture of gases. Size of
particles range from 0.5 to 100 micron particle size. Particles above 10 micron size known as suspended particulate
matter (SPM) do not enter human breath, between 5 to 10 micron size are retainedin upper respiratory tract and
particles less than 5 microns, known as respirable paniculate matter (RPM) reach lungs. 75 mcg/cu.m. is the
proposed higher limit for RPM in India (Agrawal, 1996).
61
degradation and second, its tensile strength is considerably reduced making subsequent
product life shortened.
Overheating can lead to degradation and gaseous matter generated as a result can even
cause extruder blow up. This was reported particularly in case of PP. Thin carry bags
made of PP are carefully separated from PE and extruded into lumps. Here the presence
of air, moisture or even other polymer can lead to degradation and clogging of the screw
channel. When there is no venting point point for volatile matter, there can be explosion
given high temperature (Papaspyrides, 1996; Chanda, 1987).
Impact of Pigments
The pigments used are mostly based on inexpensive metal oxides that acts as
prooxidants at high temperature at the time of extrusion. Some of the pigments, for
instance chromium based green pigment, can catalyse the thermooxidative degradation
of HDPE when present even in trace quantities. Virgin PE is usually stabilised to prevent
in-service degradation but with processing this antioxidants are consumed and these
pigments may exert prodegradant effect. Since reprocessed Polyolefins are rarely
stabilised the pigments further promote degradation when the product is subjected to
heat, light and pressure in service (Scheirs, 1996).
Impact of Contaminants
The various contaminants present may be due to labelling content, packaging content,
the products with which plastic come in contact with during the service life,
contamination with other polymers and contamination due to environment and
additives. During the in service use plastic may be photodegraded and can form low
molecular weight oxygenated products like aldehydes, acids, ketones, waxes etc. These
low molecular weight impurities can lead to segregation at the time of reprocessing and
further sensitise the reprocessed polymer to photodegradation (Scheirs, 1996).
Volatilisation
Degradation
The stability of the polymer against thermal degradation and chemical nature of thermal
decomposition vary widely from one material to another. The stability of the polymer
62
depends upon heat history it has been subjected to, the contaminants present and
molecular weight (Williamson, 1992). It is absolutely impossible to know the heat
history of the polymer being recycled given the level of technology used for both
processing and reprocessing. Each time it is heated to be molten it becomes more prone
to degradation unless the previous heat history ( rate and intensity of heating and
cooling) is repeated. First or second time recycled plastic contains fair amount of
contaminants and that makes it more susceptible to degradation. Lastly, each time the
polymer is subjected to heating to be molten its average molecular weight decreases
which also has profound effect on its stability against degradation. Hence, even under
the normal conditions of reprocessing part of the plastic is subjected to degradation
unless heat stabilisers are added (which are rarely added in case of polyolefins).
Besides, there are low flow regions in the machine known as "hang up" zones where,
material is likely to be stuck up and degrade.
The real threat is posed by frequent power fluctuation in Bangalore. If there is power
failure when the machine is in running condition there is no way that the matter stuck
up inside can be removed. The machine has to be reheated to process the matter after
power is restored. In such a situation material degrades being subjected to repeated
heating particularly in case of PVC.
Lastly, the contaminants filtered by assembly of wire mesh and breaker plate are
removed by burning. These contaminants also contain gels or black specks and
unplasticised particles. When burnt these elements are subjected to decomposition.
Products of Degradation
This is highly unpredictable part of the polymer science. Various additives and other
contaminants present may produce complex mixture of toxic and non toxic matter in specific
processing conditions which are largely unknown. On the basis of the experiments conducted in
controlled conditions the following products are at least expected of degradation of the polymers.
Form the point of view of identification there are three types of products of thermal degradation:
substances of the lowest molecular dimension known as monomers, volatile substances produced
at degradation temperature and involatile residue. The specific products of thermal degradation
of some important polymers are as follow. In addition to volatile matter like carbon monoxide,
carbon dioxide, NOX, particulate matter and suit.
63
The Product Impact
A senior official in IPCL (Indian Petro-chemical Ltd.) reported that products made of recycled
plastic can have leaching out effect wherein the outcome of in service degradation may migrate
to the matter coming in contact with it. This may have serious manifestation, for example,
Kodams ( water pots) made of recycled HDPE has huge market in urban areas facing severe
water shortage. They are not only used to fetch water but are also utilised to store it for drinking
and cooking purposes.
The porosity of the recycled material due to partial degradation during the process of extrusion
helps in both migration of substance into the polymer coming in contact with it (which
eventually behaves as contaminant for the next cycle of reprocessing adding in the degradation)
and extraction of products of in service degradation into the immediate matter or environment
(Briston, 1974).
64
PART II : FINANCIAL ANALYSIS
History:
The unit was started in 1978 and Mr. Balchandani, a qaulified engineer, is the proprietor. Earlier
he had a machinery manufacturing business. The machinery for the plastic reprocessing business
he eventually set up was fabricated by himself.
Motivation:
While he was in the business of manufacturing machinery for small scale industries, he realised
that there existed a good scope for plastic recycling. After he made an assessment that what it
takes to get into this business he found it may be profitable and was therefore motivated to get
into plastics recycling. He also has a high awareness level of environmental concerns and
thought this was one way to contribute to waste management.
Recycling Process:
This small scale plastic recycling unit uses mainly road waste as raw material. However,
machine waste from plastic processing industries and even virgin material is some times
processed. Sorting and segregation of the road waste is done in-house by women workers,
followed by size reduction, extrusion and pelletization. Sorting is done to segregate the waste by
type of the plastic. Big plastic pieces are broken down manually by beating with a mallet or
hammer and in the process metal parts or other pieces removed. Wastage from sorting is minimal
and accounts for about 1-2% of the total. In case of PP first lumps are extruded which are then
ground again to be extruded and pelletised. Following is the flow chart:
In addition, the men and machinery are given on hire for external job work. For the job work raw
material belongs to the customer. The customer sends scrap he wants to be pelletized and the
unit will convert it to pellets for them.
65
Source of Raw Material:
From wholesale plastic dealers and plastic factories who send their waste material for recycling.
Additives Used:
1. Carbon black
2. Coupling agents
3. Pigments
Type of machinery :
1 Grinder 10hp 1 no
2 High Speed Mixer 10hp 1 no
3 Extruder 75mm 1 no
4 Pelletizer 10hp 1 no
All machinery was fabricated in-house since the proprietor is an engineer and had previously a
machinery fabrication business.
Capacity:
Installed Capacity 15 tons per month
Actual capacity 12 tons per month
66
Time taken to process one ton of plastic is from 15 to 40 hours depending on the contaminants
and the power situation.
PP Rs. 9000/ MT
LDPE Rs. 8000/MT
Sales price
PP Rs. 20000/MT
LDPE Rs. 17000/MT
Labor costs
Management:
The unit is managed by the proprietor for all practical business purpose. The machine operator is
trained to manage the production and 5 male and two female workers perform sorting and other
work.
67
Financial Analysis
1. Running Cost
Raw Material
Material Type Volume Dealt with Purchase Price Total Purchase Price
Kg/Month Rs./Kg Rs./Month
PP 5,000 9.00 45,000
LDPE 2,000 8.00 16,000
Total 61,000
Laborers or Staff
Type No. Salary Paid Rs. Per No of Days in Salary per Month
Day Month Rs.
Men 5 100.00 25 12,500
Women 2 50.00 25 2,500
Total 15,000
Inputs
Type Cost Rs. per Month
Power and Utilities 9,000
Others 20,000
Total 29,000
2. Capital cost
68
3. Sales
Type Amount Kgs per Sales Price Rs. per Total in Rs.
Month Kg
PP 5,000 20.00 100,000
LDPE 2,000 17.00 34,000
Jobwork 5,000 8.00 40,000
Total 12,000 174,000
Net profit.
Gross profit Rs. 69,000 per Month
Less Interest and depreciation Rs. 5,808 per Month
Total Rs. 63,192 per Month
Rentability Analysis
69
4. Financial capacity analysis
Interest ratio = 3,350/66,542 x 100% = 5.03%
5. Vulnerability analysis
a) Quality ratio =
PP 41,000/50,000 x 100 = 82%
LDPE 42,000/50,000 x 100 = 84%
History:
The unit, a partnership firm, was started in 1974 by Mr Shukla and Mr. Pandey, who have a
background of family business.
Motivation:
Motivation for this business was the increased use of PP woven sacks in the 1970s.
Knowing that large qaunities of waste would be generated from the production of woven sacks,
the entrepreneur found an opportunity to recycle this good quality machine waste and therefore
were motivated to set up this unit.
Recycling Process:
This small scale plastic recycling unit uses waste generated from factories and
manufacturers of PP woven sacks which are used extensively in the cement and fertilizer
industries. The process involves, size reduction (in some instances when the waste is in lumps),
mixed with color master batches, extrusion and pelletization. There is no sorting required since
the waste material is of one type. Following is the flow chart:
SCRAP => (GRIND) => HIGH SPEED MIXER (ADD COLOR) =>
FEED EXTRUDER => PELLETIZING => BALING STRAPS
70
Source of raw material:
The unit uses very little amount of water since the raw material is clean machine waste. The
water is required only for cooling of extruded plastic.
The unit is located in a commercial area of the city near the city railway station. Although
the surrounding areas are busy commercial areas, the unit is located in a cross road which is
relatively quiet. The shed common to many small industries in the country, is 3000 sqft and is
moderately ventilated. Being a high roof and large area it does not seem very congested. The
volume of light PP waste occupies much of the space during processing. The work area is fairly
clean.
Additives used :
Type of machinery:
1. Extruder 75mm 1 no
2. Pelletizer 75mm 1 no
3. Bailing strap plant 1 no
4. Water pump 1 no
71
Capacity:
Management:
Flow chart:
Manager (Partners)
Supervisor
Machine operator
72
Financial Analysis
1. Running Cost
Raw Material
Material Type Volume Dealt with Purchase Price Total Purchase Price
Kg/Month Rs./Kg Rs./Month
PP White 8,000 35.00 280,000
Total 280,000
Laborers or Staff
Type No. Salary Paid Rs. No of Days in Salary per Month
Per Day Month Rs.
Men 6 25
Women 4 25
Total 17,700
Inputs
Type Cost Rs. per Month
Power and Utilities 19,000
Others 25,000
Total 44,000
2. Capital Cost
Assets Capital Cost Rs. Investment Cost Rs.
Land and Bldg 500,000
Extruder 150,000
Pelletiser 35,000
Baling Strap Machinery 190,000
Water Pump 10,000
Total 385,000 885,000
73
3. Sales
Net profit.
Gross profit Rs. 58,300
Less Interest and depreciation Rs. 12,059
Total Rs. 46,241
Rentability Analysis
74
Interest ratio = 8,850/55,091 x 100% = 16.06%
5. Vulnerability analysis
History:
The unit is a proprietorship firm and was started by the proprietor in the year 1991.
Motivation:
The motivation for Mr. Kewal came from his desire to do a small business which does not call
for much sophistication in processes and one which was simple enough for him to do.
Recycling Process:
This unit uses HDPE scrap such as buckets and other household articles. The scrap is sorted into
different colors and then broken down into smaller pieces, ground, washed, dried, extruded and
pelletised.
75
Source of Raw Material:
Wholesale dealers.
This unit occupies one such shed of 2000 sqft with poor ventilation.
The inside of the factory was poorly maintained with swarm of the mosquitoes.
Additives used :
1. Pigments (Master Batch) 10 kgs/month
2. Titanium Dioxide 10 kgs/month
Type of Machinery:
1. Extruder 75mm 1 no
2. Pelletizer 10hp 1 no
3. Water pump 1 hp 1 no
4. Washing machine 5 hp 1 no
All machinery was fabricated locally. The machinery were visibly fabricated from second hand
discarded parts of the old machinery. The wires connected with the extruder for heating were all
open without casing. The grinder also looked very old and was rather throwing the cut pieces
out. The unit had high level of noise with poor ventilation and unhygienic working conditions.
76
Capacity:
Installed Capacity 30 tons per month
Actual capacity 15 tons per month
Time required to convert 1 ton of waste 2 day
Working hours 8 hours/day
Working days 25 days/month
Sales price
HDPE Rs. 32,000/MT
Management:
Flow chart
Manager (Proprietor)
Machine operator
Financial Analysis
1. Running Cost
Raw Material
Material Type Volume Dealt with Purchase Price Total Purchase Price
Kg/Month Rs./Kg Rs./Month
HDPE scrap 15,000 20.00 300,000
Total 300,000
Laborers or Staff
77
Type No. Salary Paid Rs. No of Days in Salary per Month
Per Day Month Rs.
Men 4 80.00 25 8,000
Women 5 50.00 25 6,250
Machine 1 2,500
Operator
Total 16,750
Inputs
Type Cost Rs. per Month
Power and Utilities 9,000
Others 15,000
Total 24,000
2. Capital Cost
Assets Capital Cost Rs. Advance Rs.
Land and Bldg 40,000
Extruder 80,000
Pelletiser 30,000
Grinder 25,000
Water Pump 10,000
Washer and other 20,000
Total 165,000 205,000
3. Sales
Type Amount Kgs Sales Price Rs. per Total in Rs.
per Month Kg
HDPE Granules 15,000 32.00 480,000
Total 480,000
78
Gross profit before depreciation and interest
Net profit.
Rentability Analysis
5. Vulnerability Analysis
79
4.4.4 Neha Pladtics
9, Naresha Block
Venkateshpura
PH: 5467019
Contact Person : Mr Damodaran, Proprietor
History:
The unit was started in 1978 by Mr Damodaran and is a proprietorship firm. He got into business
when he came to Bangalore from Rajasthan and at that time milk sachets in plastic pouches were
getting popular.
Motivation:
Considering the increasing daily consumption of milk, he forecasted an opportunity for recycling
the waste plastic and was therefore motivated to set up a unit to recycle the waste milk sachets.
Recycling Process:
This unit recycles milk pouches. The waste plastic pouches are purchased from wholesalers. The
process involves cleaning the waste in a circular drum beater which removes the grit and mud,
this is then fed to a size reduction machine which chops it into small flakes of 5-8mm. It is put
into a large motor driven drum washer to remove the dried milk and other contaminants. Manual
rinsing is then done twice in large basins. It is then spread out onto a large open space to dry
under the Sun. When sufficiently dry, it is put in to a high speed mixer and then fed into an
extruder and a pelletizer.
Being plastic of a single type, there is no sorting done except to check for contaminants by way
of other plastics which sometimes creep in. This is easily sorted.
SCRAP -> REMOVE DIRT (MECHANICAL) -> GRIND (SIZE REDUCTION) ->
WASH (MECHANICAL) RINSE (MANUAL) HEATING (HSM)
EXTRUSION PELLETIZING
80
Sanitary and Water
A fairly large quantity of water is used in this unit since the milk sachets have to be thoroughly
washed. The unit has a borewell for its water supply and is drained out in an open drain out of
the unit.
Additives used:
1. Pigments (master batch)
2. Whitener (Titanium Dioxide & Tinopal)
Type of Machinery :
1. Rotary drum beater/ cleaner 5hp 1 no
2. Grinder 10hp 1 no
3. Centrifugal washer 5hp 1 no
4. High Speed Mixer 10 hp 1 no
5. Extruder 75mm 1 no
6. Pelletizer 10 hp 1 no
Machinery is fabricated locally and apparently are made of lower quality machinery parts.
Capacity:
Installed Capacity 0.6 tons per day
Actual capacity 0.5 tons per day
Time taken to produce 1 ton of pellets 2 days
Working hours 8
Working days per month 24
81
Sales price
Pellets Rs. 34,000/MT
Management:
The unit is managed by the proprietor.
Flow chart
Manager (Proprietor)
Machine operator
Asst. Operator
Financial Analysis
1. Running Cost
Raw Material
Material Type Volume Dealt with Purchase Price Total Purchase Price
Kg/Month Rs./Kg Rs./Month
HDPE Milk Covers 13,000 15.00 195,000
Total 195,000
Laborers or Staff
Type No. Salary Paid Rs. No of Days in Salary per Month
Per Day Month Rs.
Men 5 80.00 26 10,400
Women 5 40.00 26 5,200
Machine Operator 1 2,500
Asst. Operator 1 1,500
Manager 1 3,000
Total 20,100
82
Rent 8,000
Power and Utilities 13,000
Others 10,000
Total 31,000
2. Capital cost
3. Sales
Type Amount Kgs Sales Price Rs. Total in Rs.
per Month per Kg
HDPE Granules 13,000 34.00 442,000
Total 442,000
83
Gross profit before depreciation and interest
Sales Rs. 4,42,000
Marginal costs Rs. 2,46,100
Total Rs. 1,95,900
Net profit.
Gross profit Rs. 1,95,900
Less Interest and depreciation Rs. 6,080
Total Rs. 1,89,820
Rentability Analysis
5. Vulnerability analysis
84
4.4.5 Contact Person: Mr. Ismail Mohamad
Nayandahalli, Bangalore
This was a small unit without any official name. The business is being run without any license.
There are a few such units in Nayandahalli. What is required for such unit is a power connection,
an extruder and minimum 15 ft. x 20 ft. of working space. The following details belong to one
such tiny unit.
History:
The proprietor is a Muslim person and has background of scrape wholesaling. Previously he was
working in pertnership with a plastic recycling unit using HDPE milk covers. He started this unit
in 1994.
Process:
White PP carry bags are purchased from a wholesaler and further sorted to remove any possible
contamination with HDPE, LDPE, LLDPE or HM bags. The skilled laborers mainly use their
judgement for sorting. The common method employed for sorting is based on the sound of the
bag if rubbed between two hands. PP gives cracking sound. If uncertain, the edge of the plastic is
burnt, a sweet, scent smell is emanated if it is PP.
The sorted bags are directly fed into extruder without any washing or chopping. The
extruded lumps are sold. Apparently the lumps are further extruded to make granules. The
granules are used for blow molded suitcase making.
85
amount of moisture it is likely that the extruder may explod. Such incidents seems to have
happened in the past.
The work area was occupied with heaps of waste carry bags and house keeping was not very
clean.
Type of Machinery:
Extruder 1 No.
Capacity
Installed Capacity 6 tons per month
Actual Capacity 150 kgs/day
Working Days in a Month 26
Working Hours in a Day 8 hours
Financial Analysis
1. Running Cost
Raw Material
Material Type Volume Dealt with Purchase Price Total Purchase Price
Kg/Day Rs./Kg Rs./Month
PP white carry bags 150 15.00 46,800
Total 46,800
Laborers or Staff
Type No. Salary Paid Rs. No of Days in Salary per Month
Per Day Month Rs.
Men 3 80.00 26 6,420
Women 6 40.00 26 6,420
Total 12,480
86
Inputs and Rent
Type Cost Rs. per Month
Power and Utilities 4,000
Others 2,000
Total 6,000
2. Capital cost
Assets Capital Cost Rs. Advance Rs.
Land and Bldg 75,000
Extruder and other Equipments 80,000
Total 80,000 1,55,000
3. Sales
Type Amount Kgs Sales Price Rs. Total in Rs.
per Month per Kg
PP Lumps 3,900 22.00 858,000
Total 858,000
87
Gross profit before depreciation and interest
Sales 858,000 Rs. per Month
Less Marginal costs 65,280 Rs. per Month
Total 20,520 Rs. per Month
Net profit.
Gross profit 20,520 Rs. per Month
Less Interest and depreciation 1,958 Rs. per Month
Total 18,562 Rs. per Month
Rentability Analysis
1. Product ratio = 39000/858,000 x 100% = 45.45%
Sales price 858,000
Cost price 468,000
Product margin 39,000
5. Vulnerability analysis
88
4.4.6 Hindustan Plastics
285, 8th Cross, 2nd Main
Prakashnagar
Bangalore - 560 021
Contact Person : Mr Rajesh, Proprietor
History:
The unit was started in 1981 by the proprietor Mr Rajesh.
Motivation:
The motivation for this business came from the availability of waste raffia for which he had
access to from known sources. In working out the feasibility he estimated the business to be
profitable and offered him the line he was looking for.
Recycling Process:
This unit processes only Raffia which is waste PP woven sack material. This is largely
machine waste (post industrial) from PP woven sack manufacturing units. The first round of the
process involves extrusion for lumps making. The lumps are then ground for size reduction and
again extruded in pellets. Sorting is hardly ever required since the raw material is uniform
quality, post industrial waste.
89
Location and Work Area:
The unit is located in an industrial shed of 2500 sqft in a residential area of the city. Over all
ventilation is poor and there are no provisions for cross ventilation. The work area is fairly clean.
Type of machinery :
1. Grinder 25hp 1 no
2. High Speed Mixer 10hp 1 no
3. Extruder 75mm 1 no
4. Pelletizer 10hp 1 no
5. Water pump 1 no
Capacity:
Installed Capacity 20 tons per month
Actual capacity 15 tons per month
Sales price
PP Rs 42,000/MT
Management:
The unit is managed by the proprietor.
90
Financial Analysis
1. Running Cost
Raw Material
Material Type Volume Dealt with Purchase Price Total Purchase Price
Kg/Month Rs./Kg Rs./Month
PP Woven Sack 15,000 32.00 480,000
Manufacturing waste
Total 480,000
Laborers or Staff
Type No. Salary Paid Rs. No of Days in Salary per Month
Per Day Month Rs.
Men 2 100.00 25 5,000
Women 3 50.00 25 3,750
Machine Operator 1 3,500
Secretary 1 2,500
Total 14,750
91
2. Capital Cost
Assets Capital Cost Rs. Advance Rs.
Land and Bldg 60,000
Extruder 150,000
Pelletiser 25,000
High Speed Mixer 70,000
Grinder 70,000
Water Pump 5,000
Total 320,000 380,000
3. Sales
Net profit.
Gross profit 98,250 Rs. per Month
Less Interest and depreciation 6,466 Rs. per Month
Total 9,784 Rs. per Month
92
Rentability Analysis
5. Vulnerability analysis
a) Quality ratio =
PP 23,000/55,000 x 100 = 41.81%
History:
Mr. Bhatia was working as an employee before 1979. In 1979 he started a Kodam ( water pots)
making unit which he closed in 1984 due to adverse credit and pay back conditions. From 1984,
he is running his own unit of recycling.
Motivation:
Mr. Bhatia is a first generation businessman and though he was working as an employee earlier,
he had an urge to have business of his own. Plastic recycling at that time, in 1976 was an
emerging area which seemed attractive with its margins and relatively law level of investments.
93
Recycling Process:
This unit processes only machine waste. Much of the production is through job work, wherein
machines, labor and other facilities are given on hire to an outside person who brings the raw
material. A flat amount per tone of the plastic is charged. The process involves size reduction,
high speed mixing followed by extrusion and pelletisation.
Type of Machinery:
1. Grinder 15hp 200 kgs per hour 1 No
2. High Speed Mixer 10hp 25 kg 1 No
3. Extruder 75mm/25 hp/ 30 kg/hour 1 No
4. Pelletiser 1 hp 1 No
Capacity:
Installed Capacity 15 tons per month
Actual Capacity 14 tons per month
94
Management:
The unit is managed by the proprietor, though all day-to-day supervision and operation of
the factory is done by the machine operator/supervisor.
Financial Analysis
1. Running Cost
Raw Material
Material Type Volume Dealt with Purchase Price Total Purchase Price
Kg/Month Rs./Kg Rs./Month
PP Woven Sack 4000 15.00 60,000
Manufacturing
waste
Total 60,000
Laborers or Staff:
Type No. Salary Paid Rs. No of Days in Salary per Month
Per Day Month Rs.
Men 5 100.00 25 12500
Women 2 50.00 25 2500
Over Time at 50 % 7500
Machine Operator 1 3000
Secretary 1 1500
Total 27000
95
2. Capital Cost
Assets Capital Cost Rs. Advance Rs.
Land and Bldg 45,000
Extruder 120,000
Pelletiser 30,000
High Speed Mixer 25,000
Grinder 45,000
Water Pump 3,000
Total 223,000 268,000
3. Sales
Type Amount Kgs Sales Price Rs. Total in Rs.
per Month per Kg
PP Granules 4000 35.00 140,000
Job work 10000 8.00 80,000
Total 220,000
Net profit.
Gross profit Rs. 93,000 per Month
Less Interest and depreciation Rs. 4,583 per Month
Total Rs. 88,462 per Month
96
Rentability Analysis
1. Product ratio = 80000/140,000 x 100% = 57.14%
Sales price Rs. 1,40,000 per Month
Cost price Rs. 60,000 per Month
Product margin Rs. 80,000 per Month
5. Vulnerability analysis
a) Quality ratio =
PP 20,000/55,000 x 100 = 40.00%
History
The unit was started in 1984. The proprietor migrated to Bangalore from Gujarat. Mainly PVC is
recycled in this unit. The unit is located in south Bangalore. The factory consists of 2000 sq ft
area for production with two rooms and one godown-cum-sorting place measuring the same area.
The house keeping is exceptionally good.
PVC electric cable wires are recycled. The raw material is obtained through a wholesaler who is
a regular supplier to this unit.
97
Recycling Process:
The electric cables are sorted according to color and then cut into small pieces manually. The cut
pieces are then ground in the grinder and put in the high speed mixer along with color
masterbatch. No additives are used. The ground matter is fed in the extruder at high temperature.
The pellets are either sold or used for manufacturing of irrigation pipes in-house.
Type of Machinery:
1. Grinder 15hp 1 No.
2. High Speed Mixer 10 hp 1 No.
3. Extruder 75mm/25 hp 1 No.
4. Pelletiser 1hp 1 No.
Capacity:
Installed Capacity 15 tons per month
Actual Capacity 12 tons per month
Financial Analysis
1. Running Cost
Raw Material
Material Type Volume Dealt with Purchase Price Total Purchase Price
Kg/Month Rs./Kg Rs./Month
PVC Electric Cables 12,000 25.00 300,000
and Wires
Total 300,000
Laborers or Staff
Type No. Salary Paid Rs. Per Salary per Month
Month Rs.
Men 4 2,000 8,000
Women 10 900 9,000
Machine Operator 1 2,800 2,800
Total 19,800
98
Inputs and Rent
Type Cost Rs. per Month
Power and Utilities, Transportation, Additives 40,000
etc.,
Rent 6,000
Total 46,000
2. Capital Cost
Assets Capital Cost Rs. Advance Rs.
Land and Bldg 15,000
Extruder 175,000
Pelletiser 45,000
High Speed Mixer 45,000
Grinder 45,000
Total 310,000 325,000
3. Sales
Type Amount Kgs Sales Price Rs. Total in Rs.
per Month per Kg
PP Granules 12,000 38.00 456,000
Total 456,000
99
Net profit.
Gross profit 90,200 Rs. per Month
Less Interest and depreciation 5,833 Rs. per Month
Total 84,367 Rs. per Month
Rentability Analysis
1. Product ratio = 156000/456,000 x 100% = 34.21%
5. Vulnerability analysis
a) Quality ratio = 21,000/46,000 x 100 = 40.00%
( price of the virgin PVC = 46,000 Rs./ton)
References
Agrawal G.D., 1996. Dust and Occupational Diseases in IndiaIn: Jaitli H. Dusty Down, New
Delh: Society for Participatory Research in India
Balachandani N.M. 1980. Extrusion of Plastics, Bangalore: Anit Industrial Publications.
Batiuk M. 1977. Polyvinyl Chloride Extrusion, In: Nass L. (ed). Encyclopedia of PVC, New
York: Marcel Dekker.
Beadle J.D. (ed). 1971. Plastics Forming, London: Mcmillan Engineering Educations.
Brandrup J. (ed). 1975. Polymer Handbook, London: John Wiely and Sons.
Braun K.J. Extrusion, In: Beadle J.D. (ed). Plastics Forming, London: Mcmillan Engineering
Educations.
Briston J.H. 1974. Plastics in Contact with Food, London: Food Trade Press Ltd.
Brydson J.A. 1973. Principles of Plastics Extrusion, London: Applied Science Publications.
Chanda M. 1987. Plastics Technology Handbook, New York: Marcel Dekker Inc.
Mark Heman. et al., (ed)., 1989. Encyclopedia of Polymer Science and Engineering, New York:
John Wiely and Sons.
Deutcher I. 1980. Devolatilisation of Plastics, Germany: VDI-Verlag Gmbh.
Mcmillan F. 1996. Polyolefin Overview, In: Joseph Solomon, (editor in chief), Polymer
Materials Encyclopedia, London: CRC Press.
Nass L. (ed). Encyclopedia of PVC, New York: Marcel Dekker.
100
Ohtani H. 1996. Degradation, In: Joseph Solomon, (editor in chief), Polymer Materials
Encyclopedia, London: CRC Press.
Papaspyrides D.C. 1996. Recycling Plastics, In: Joseph Solomon, (editor in chief), Polymer
Materials Encyclopedia, London: CRC Press.
Ross J.F. 1996. Plyethylene (Commercial), In: Joseph Solomon, (editor in chief), Polymer
Materials Encyclopedia, London: CRC Press.
Scheirs J. 1996. Polyethylene Recycled, In: Joseph Solomon, (editor in chief), Polymer
Materials Encyclopedia, London: CRC Press.
Schenkel G. 1966. Plastic Extrusion Technology and Theory, London: ILIFFE Books Ltd.
Williomson C.J. 1992. 150 Years of Plastics Degradation, In: Allen N.S. et al. (ed). Polymers
in Conservation, London: Royal Society of Chemistry.
101
CHAPTER 5 OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH IMPACT OF PLASTIC
RECYCLING
Dr. Vasundhra3
This chapter outlines the possible health impacts on the various actors involved in the process of
plastic recycling viz. the waste pickers, Junk Dealers and wholesalers involved in the recovery of
plastic from the municipal waste stream and those working in the plastic reprocessing unit. Data
on the possible health impact was collected through observation of the activities performed by
the various actors and through informal discussion with them.
Waste for the reprocessing industry as mentioned in the earlier chapter, is recovered by a chain
of actors starting from the waste pickers, junk dealers and the whole salers. In some
communities, house to house collection of waste has been started employing the waste pickers.
For the purpose of this study, a community based waste collection scheme, a Junk Dealers shop
and a wholesalers shop were visited. The health risks observed during the visit is presented in
table 1
3
This paper is an abridged version of a report prepared by Dr. Vasundhara, commissioned for this Study. Dr.
Vasundhra has served as Prof. Prof, and Head of Department of community medicine since 1980. She is a
consultant with government of India on maternal and child health. She is also an expert on industrial health.
102
Table 1 Health Hazards of Waste Recovery
Waste Picker Collection from the -Cuts and injuries due to presence of broken glass,
bins sharps, needles which may lead to septic wounds and
tetanus.
-Exposure to fumes causing irritation of nose, throat
and lungs. Vulnerability to upper respiratory ailments
like rhinitis, shortness of breath, and asthma.
-Contact with feacal matter and the risk of
contracting gastrointestinal diseases and worm
infestations.
-Vulnerable to blood borne diseases if hospital waste
is collected.
Community Based -Exposure to sun, radiation and rain.
Collection Schemes
-Vulnerable to worm infestation as waste is sorted
bare hand.
Itinerant Buyer --Injuries due to sharps in the waste.
-Callosities4 on the fingers observed .
Whole saler Washing, sorting Health risks can occur during the washing stage as
and baling cheap detergents and caustic soda are used.
Continuos exposure can cause shriveled skin known
as washermans hands/ Contact with washing soda
may produce blisters.
4
Hardening and drying of skin due to repeated fiction.
103
5.2 Health Impact of Plastic Reprocessing
Reprocessing of plastic involves the following stages: size reduction, mixing of additives,
Extrusion and pelletisation. For the purpose of this study four recycling enterprises were visited
and air quality monitoring test was conducted in one of the units.
The possible health impact due to the procedures adopted in the various stages are presented in
the Table 2. and Table 3. presents the case studies of the four units .
Size reduction of During this operation, tiny particles of plastic are ejected at high speed
grinding and the shredder is electrically operated. Dust particles are also
generated during this operation.
Effect of Additives Use of stabilisers like lead sulphate or sterate which are highly toxic
(Plasticisers and may enter the food chain if used for food packaging. Plasticers used
coloring pigments) in the industry are highly inflammable and can lead to fire accidents.
104
constriction of chest, dryness of throat and slight cough.
Lead: This gains entry to the body through ingestion, inhalation and
absorption through the skin. Hazards of organic lead sulphide
compound include insomnia, loss of weight, anorexia, nausea and
psychological disorder like restlessness, hallucination and suicidal
tendency.
Extrusion At this stage volatile matter is released. The vapors released are
styrene and benzene. These can cause pharyngitis, rhinitis and
unproductive cough.
Inhalation of fumes released are chlorine and HCL can affect the
upper respiratory tract and lachrynation of eyes.
Vibration and mechanical friction that occur during this process can
cause white fingers and continuous friction may lead to callosities.
It is to be noted that there is a long latency period between the point of exposure and the
occurrence of the disorder which makes it difficult to correlate any illness to the type of
exposure.
Product Manufacturing
As the combustion process during the recycling process is rarely complete and the material is
porous, there is a possibility of lechate of toxic mateirals (eg.pigments) if the products are used
for storing food or water.
105
Table 3. Case studies : The results of the case studies are presented below:.
Parameters Case Study 1: Case Study 2 Case Study 3 Case Study 4
affecting
health
End Product Pellets Pellets Pellets Irrigation pipes
106
Parameters Case Study 1: Case Study 2 Case Study 3 Case Study 4
affecting
health
End Product Pellets Pellets Pellets Irrigation pipes
-Possibility of -Headache ,
endangering irritation, fatigue
reproductive health and deafness due to
which need to be the noise level
verified further. present possible.
-Dust particles
present may cause
fibrosis of lungs.
-Possibility of
affecting the
reproductive health
.
107
Parameters Case Study 1: Case Study 2 Case Study 3 Case Study 4
affecting
health
End Product Pellets Pellets Pellets Irrigation pipes
-Monitoring of air
quality to be made
mandatory.
-Shredder design to
be improved for
preventing
accidents
108
5.3 Air Quality Monitoring
Air quality and noise monitoring test was conducted in one of the units located in a residential
area. The test yielded the following results:
109
5.4 Recommendation
The present case studies were limited in observation and a detailed medical examination
is required to confirm the health risks involved.
The growing demand for post-consumption recycled products is increasing exposing
greater number of people to hazards of plastic reprocessing. This calls for a study on
health economics of this venture.
As hospital waste is retrieved by the waste pickers, a study on the life cycle of plastic
waste from hospitals is required.
Impact of plastic recycling on the reproductive health need to be studied in detail.
References
110
CHAPTER 6 ISSUES.
This preliminary research suggests that the financial viability of plastic recycling industries may
not be a sole function of inflow and outflow of money. There seems to be various other forces at
work which substantially contribute towards financial effectiveness of these enterprises.
Following is a suggestive overview of such factors which make these industries possible to be
run on profitable level.
They are protected from competition from large scale industries, hence as per SSI policy, no
industry can have more than Rs. 3,00,00,000 of investment in plastic processing and
reprocessing unit.
Many of the SSI units in India are exempted from payment of excise duty on the final
products. Plastic recycled products were exempted from payment of excise duty till two
years back which was increased to 7 % till recently. It is currently kept at 3 % which also is
being lobbied by the plastic association to be removed.
They are also exempted from the tiresome procedural formalities. A plastic recycling unit
needs to have a power point passed by the local electricity board at the least. If they want
they can register with Industrial Development Corporation which is not mandatory. As a
result most of the plastic processing and reprocessing units in Bangalore has an unregistered
existence. Power may be illegally drawn from the neighbouring unit, minimum of 600 sq.m.
of space and an extruder can be enough to start plastic recycling business.
Most of them having less than 5-7 employees can not be covered under labor law.
Plastic processing and reprocessing industries are exempted from monitoring by Pollution
Control Board.
On the one side, plastic recycling industries significantly benefit due to Government's industrial
policy favoring them, on the other, they not only survive but play a crucial role in the overall
5
It means that large scale industries, having more than Rs. 3,00,00,000 of capital investment, can not establish
plastic recycling industries. Hence, these industries are protected from the competition from large scale industries.
111
development of the industrial sector with very marginal institutional support. Following are
some of the issues discussed in this context with reference to plastic processing and reprocessing
industry:
6.1.1 Finance
Majority of the plastic processing and reprocessing units seem to have raised funds for
investment through personal sources and very rarely are dependent on State financing
institutions. Marwari community dominantly has the ownership of plastic reprocessing units in
Bangalore and also in other parts of India. It has a social structure which although is
decentralised in space, is centralized by conventions (Solomon, 1996). As a result it has a vast
and efficient economic networking and not only the business but the skills, ethos, conventions
and contacts are passed from one generation to another. This may be true for any other business
community in India. Not only clustering together, dominance by a particular community in
business plays a crucial role in the development of the industry.
6.1.2 Technology
Though level of technology in the plastic reprocessing unit apparently is primitive, close
proximity of individually managed units promotes a vibrant system of spread of technological
innovation. There exist a collective system through which a new idea is easily picked up and
further developed. For example, a local fabricator developed a method for production of kodam
to avoid an entire round of extrusion, which is widely used by all other industries in Bangalore.
The other case in reference is PVC coated light tension cable production in one of the slums in
Delhi. Here 2000 such firms located in a neighbourhood control 30% of the countrys market.
Highly informal, home based existence of these industries produce 27 different varieties of cable
which require fairly developed technical skills (Solomon, 1996).
Other than playing an important role for technological innovations, clustering of individual units
promotes competition in cooperation. It facilitates interaction among the industries to improve
negotiation with market and authorities. They formulate self-regulatory mechanisms, e.g., the
Karnataka Small Scale Plastic Manufacturers Association in Bangalore or the Tamilnadu
Plastic Manufacturers Association in Madras. This also facilitates trade of machines, material
and promote economy of scale.
All the above factors significantly contribute towards financial viability and profitability of these
enterprises. It is suggested that a judgment about their efficiency and effectiveness based on
inflow and outflow of the money might not prove appropriate.
112
Further Scope for Improvement
Given the not-so-simple nature of this industry, it may not be easy to suggest means for
improvement. However, following points are made which may give clue for the same,
Given their nature, these industries may have relatively higher cost of production
compared to larger industries.
To seek out ways to sustain their profit they may use cheaper inputs, pay low wages, and
hire temporary or casual labor.
Further technical improvements which may influence working environment or even
quality of the product (unless it has market) may not be adopted.
This can have two fold impact on workers health and on quality of product. Simple process
control measures and technological improvement can largely avoid pollution and health hazards.
some example of which are suggested below,
Washing of waste materials thoroughly before extrusion which substantially makes it less
susceptible to degradation and reduces emission of hazardous gasses.
Use of vented extruder which can remove moisture and gasses at the early stage of
extrusion and further reduces chances of degradation.
However, it would be appropriate to mention that these measures may not be adopted by large
section of plastic recyclers, not due to lack of knowledge or awareness but for the
simple reason that they increase cost of production manyfold. Cost of production being
function of various other factors it might not be easy task to influence plastic recyclers to
change their practices.
Plastic Recovery
Plastic is one of the most sought after waste items as it has huge business at waste trading and
recycling level. It is high time that both waste recovery and trading activities are recognised and
legitimized by the Municipal or Government authorities to at least minimise harassment of those
dependent on it for livelihood. There are various ways by which municipal or government
authorities can provide support to these activities, for example, provision of space for sorting and
cleaning at subsidized or reduced rent. At more advanced level, it would be highly desirable if
design of waste management technology and system take into consideration these informal
activities and create more space for them.
NGOs can play crucial role by organizing those dependent on waste recovery and trading into
cooperatives or any other organisational form which may be felt suitable. However, it would be
important to note that such efforts should make the stakeholders more equipped instead of
dependent on the organizing agency. For example, it is felt that provision of micro credit and
113
subsidized place for sorting, cleaning and storing waste materials can prove highly appropriate
for a group of waste pickers or IWBs to improve their socio-economic and living standards.
NGOs' support may be in terms of training in accounting and management and lobbying with the
official agencies. At broader level, w NGOs can lobby for enactment of legislation in support of
waste recovery and trading activities.
Plastic Recycling
Development of safe and low cost technology for which it might not have capacity. At
least it can provide institutional and scientific support for such innovations.
Development and dissemination of safety, process and product standards in consultation
with plastic associations and made mandatory.
The entire organisation of plastic recycling business may be much more complex than what it
may be grasped through limited exposure for this research. Information generated for this
research at least indicate that various forces such as national and international industrial policies,
traditional community structure and its influence on financial viability of these industries are at
work. Understanding of the interplay of these forces may take much more detailed study and
wider sample, particularly before any suggestions are made for the improvement.
The real support may be provided to minimise occupational health hazards to which not only
workers but the owners of the premises are also exposed, though in lesser degree. Here, probably
NGOs can play a catalytic role in generating and disseminating information through its
networking. They can also help by providing multidisciplinary consultation to the recyclers and
their workers.
Basel Convention
The International Regulation of Transboundary Traffic in Hazardous Wastes, The 1989 Basel
convention of which India is one of the signatories prohibits transboundary movement of
Wastes from production, formation and use of resins, latex, plasticisers, glues and adhesives,
Wastes collected from households (Kummer, 1992)
This is an important aspect as it influences issue of import of plastic waste and their
environmental health impact and hence discussed here.
The Basel Ban Proposal sponsored by Nordic countries which prohibits transboundary trade of
all waste including those meant for recycling, was unanimously adopted in March 1994. The
amendment, although, did not include distinction between disposable and recyclable waste, it
offers several loopholes which India could exploit in order to ensure continuous import of
recyclable waste (EPW, 1995). The amendment also provides that the movement of the
disposable waste be banned with immediate effect, while movement of recyclable waste be
114
prohibited from 1 January 1998. Hence India still continues to provide licenses for import of
waste used as raw material. Although, recently a division bench of Supreme Court passed an
interim order banning import of hazardous and toxic waste. The Court has directed the Center
and the States not to issue any fresh import licenses for this purpose (Down to Earth, 1997).
However it is important to note that definition of hazardous waste adopted by Basel convention
differs from what is included in the Hazardous Waste (Management and Handling) Rules, 1989
of Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 of Government of India. In fact, India had earlier voted
for the alternative draft of Basel Ban Proposal proposed by OECD countries, which made
distinction between disposable and recyclable waste.
However within India, plastic processing and reprocessing industries are exempted from
monitoring by Pollution Control Board. It is ironical enough that those requirements of
International agreements which will affect the transnational movement would be better
monitored, while those that have an impact at the local level - local consumers or workers or
environment - would continue to be neglected.
In reality import of plastic scrap for recycling may not be very attractive as it is projected. The
entrepreneur who buys this plastic waste has to purchase it in large quantities viz. a container
weighing 22 tons for which he /she requires enough storage space and capital to pay $260 per
ton (1994 rates) (Saskia, 1994). However the case of PET bottles is different. Two plants in
India has the technology to recycle PET bottle waste and they import waste for that purpose.
Interestingly, PET waste from the municipal waste stream is not collected by the waste pickers
as it has no market value due to limited capacity of both plants and cheap availability of clean
waste from abroad. It is a point for discussion whether import of plastic waste would have any
impact on domestic plastic recovery and recycling.
115
References
M.H. Balasubramaniya. 1995. Reservation Policy for Small Scale Industry: How it Delivered
the goods?, Economic and Political Weekly, May 17.
Editorial. 1995. Waste Pact, Economic and Political Weekly, Oct. 7.
Katharina Kummer, 1992. The International Regulation of Transboundary Traffic in Hazardous
Wastes: The 1989 Basel Convention, International and Comparative Law Quarterly, July.
G.C. Pain. 1990. A Manual on Occupational Health in Small Scale Industries of India, Calcutta:
All India Institute of Hygiene and Public Health.
Saskia Jordens. 1995. Plastic Recycling Enterprises in Bangalore, India, Thesis Submitted to
Universiteit van Amsterdam.
Solomon Benjamin. 1985. Neighbourhood as Factory: the Influence of Land Development and
Civic Politics on an Industrial Cluster in Delhi, India, Ph.D. Thesis Submitted to
Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
1997. Tirade Against Toxins, Down to Earth, May 31.
The Tamil Nadu Plastics Manufacturers Association. 1995. Proceedings of the Seminar on
Energy Savings and Ecofriendly Processing in Plastics, Madras.
116
117
ANNEX 1 EXAMPLE OF CERTIFICATE
118
119