Veterinary Practice Management Secrets
Veterinary Practice Management Secrets
Medical Publishers
210 South 13th Street
Philadelphia, PA 19107
(215) 546-7293;800-962-1892
FAX (215) 790-9330
Web site http//www.hanleyandbelfus.com
Note to the reader: Although the information in this book has been carefully re-
viewed for correctness of dosage and indications, neither the authors nor the
editor nor the publisher can accept any legal responsibility for any errors or
omissions that may be made. Neither the publisher nor the editor makes any
warranty, expressed or implied, with respect to the material contained herein.
Before prescribing any drug, the reader must review the manufacturer's current
product information (package inserts) for accepted indications, absolute
dosage recommendations, and other information pertinent to the safe and ef-
fective use of the product described.
00-023118
© 2000 by Hanley & Belfus, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be
reproduced, reused, republished, or transmitted in any form, or stored in a
data base or retrieval system, without written permission of the publisher.
When asked by Hanley & Belfus, Inc. to write this Secrets text, we felt
very complimented; they have published more than 45 well-respected books
in The Secrets Series'". While Phil Seibert and I seldom fully agree on the
best answer to a specific issue or challenge, and in some cases disagree on
some of the alternatives in this text, we do concur that the diversity of this
profession requires the wide spectrum of ideas that we have compiled.
We need to thank the members of the American Animal Hospital
Association, the clients of Catanzaro & Associates, Inc., and the many prac-
tices sending inquiries into Veterinary Practice Consultants". Without these
2400-plus practices, including the over 300 practices we support every year,
the questions and answers would not have flowed.
The second group of folks we need to thank is our support team: Sylvia
Zamperin, our new Client Relations Director, who ensures that our clients
receive the most exacting of compassionate care; Courtney Edwards, our
Communications Director, who assembled and grammar-proofed these sub-
missions; Debbie Catanzaro, our Fiscal Director, who keeps our finances
straight; Michael Catanzaro, our Continuing Education and Public Relations
Director, who ensures that our multiple meetings and seminars stay coordi-
nated and on track; and certainly our team of consultant associates (see them
at our web site: www.v-p-c.com). who give us the freedom to share ideas
and perspectives with the veterinary profession. We also must thank Karyn
Gavzer, MBA, CVPM, a remarkable woman who we have known and ad-
mired for many years, for her contribution of 12 insightful marketing ques-
tions. Also, Judi Leake, DVM must be acknowledged for her continued
support and vast knowledge of ancillary services.
Finally, we must thank our families, who not only help us stay balanced
in life, but who endure many, many days and nights alone on the home front
while we travel the world to pursue our chosen endeavors!
Thomas E. Catanzaro, DVM, MHA, FACHE
Philip Seibert, Jr, CVT
vii
INTRODUCTION
I. VETERINARIANS' INCOME
The study used terms like "similar professions" and "median income" to
help set a base for comparison. To enhance the data, we would like to in-
clude human healthcare compensations for 1998: general practice physicians
have an average income of $86,000; family practice specialists (boarded)
have an average income of $132,000. These numbers are compatible with
2 Introduction
First, the sample appeared too small and not calibrated to the em-
ployment groups being compared. Most practices currently are owned by
men that graduated two or more decades ago. Their compensation comes
from clinical medicine, rental of building and land, and return on invest-
ment. Women are predominantly new entries into this profession and have
only one source of income-elinical compensation. A stronger case can
be made for income differences due to age differences rather than gender
differences.
Second, most individuals 30 or younger-men and women-want a
balanced life. New graduates are seeking outside-practice lifestyle develop-
ment and a reasonable work week, not the 60-80 hours that past genera-
tions endured.
Introduction 3
Millennium graduates have four to six job offers, and the AVMA Job
Bank shows six to eight jobs for every applicant. These two reality factors
were not included in any of the summarized research by this joint
Committee, but these numbers strongly suggest a growing demand for both
traditional and nontraditional veterinary services.
The study shows that client awareness and projected access should
exceed the demand. We can assist practices in their effort to increase return
rates. Higher return rates allow a practice to lower their fees, which in turn
allows the clients who consider their pets members of the family to access
more veterinary care within their available discretionary income levels. We
can increase access virtually anywhere, from mixed animal to companion
animal practices, if the cornerstone of the practice's healthcare delivery is
compassionate care that celebrates the human-animal bond. (See Chapters
1,5, and 7.)
4 Introduction
5. SUPPLY OF VETERINARIANS
Most new graduates have never done a basic dental cleaning and polish-
ing, much less an extraction; have not treated a cat fight abscess; and, in
6 Introduction
many cases, have not developed basic population control surgery skills. Yet
the study states "clinical skills remain very high." As for "their perception of
what they can contribute to society," neither the survey data nor our experi-
ence in this profession shows a lack of social contribution by the practition-
ers in a community. To the contrary, most practices support church, Rotary,
civic organizations, and their community with time and money.
Here, the question is: "How do veterinarians get the business skills and
aptitude to make their business successful?" The answer is obvious, yet
seldom stated in this profession. Just buy them! Any practice owner can
"buy" a banker, a good corporate attorney, a savvy CPA for tax reporting,
and an ethical veterinary-specific consultant to form their business team.
What most practices have done is buy the cheapest support available, and
they have gotten what they paid for as well as a bucket of frustrations. If this
profession's advisors/associations continue to think that a veterinarian can
"do it all," then they do not understand the requirements of the business
place. Financial planners are essential for developing a protected retirement
fund-sorry, you cannot live off the practice sale anymore. Ethical consul-
tants-ones who do not advocate deep-discount competition programs, or
blindly push rapid fee increases, or take a portion of the growth as their com-
pensation-are extremely beneficial when looking for alternatives (See
Chapters 1-9.)
year). If we look at the Pfizer study data, alternatives leap forward and
yell to be addressed, as they do in these chapters.
• We see some states severely restricting the role of the veterinary tech-
nician and nursing staff, while the human healthcare market embraces
the physician extender. Yet association and university VTH experts do
not address these fallacies and political misconceptions. Again, it is in-
dividual practitioners who must pick up the team approach and pursue
success!
• We see many underpaid practice staffs because "We have always done
it this way"; because "The national average says so"; or because "We
center on expense control rather than income production." The key here
is to accept the cost of a new staff replacement (> $23,000) and use
that money to keep highly qualified staff members in this profession.
• We have significantly increased practice net without reducing the staff
compensation. We have doubled practice incomes with high-density
scheduling and staff leveraging methods. And we have given practice
leaders more time with their families while increasing practice liquid-
ity. These facts appear to reflect a basic restructure/redesign concern
rather than a veterinary market concern.
We know that our profession often is fragmented-yet there are innova-
tors like the Buffalo veterinary practices who cooperate monthly and bring
outstanding continuing education to their community, or the Northwest
Veterinary Managers Association who selflessly share trend information at
their monthly meetings. We also know that most practices want to do better
and will respond to positive guidance, rather than a list of negative "The Sky
Is Falling" findings.
We hope this reference text provides the basis for many hours of prac-
tice discussion and debate, as well as new ideas and alternatives that previ-
ously seemed impossible. We have organized the most common practice
management and leadership issues into general categories, and then included
what we brain-stormed to be the most applicable alternatives for each. This
arrangement allows the reader to have choices for positive and progressive
action at his or her own level of commitment and capabilities. We wish for
the reader to see that the "one best solution" of the past is not the best solu-
tion for the future. Most of all, it is our hope that the readers of this Secrets
reference see the secrets of this profession as being founded in people, com-
munication, and change, and see themselves as change agents for improving
this profession we love and cherish.
I. STARTING YOUR PRACTICE
9
10 Starting Your Practice
2. Where do I start?
The basis of any new endeavor is the basis of the business, and in veteri-
nary medicine, that means centering on healthcare programs. New gradu-
ates have a tertiary care focus (required to pass boards), but the average
practitioner has a client-centered focus. This focus in one of a patient advo-
cate offering wellness programs and, occasionally, addressing sickness
and/or injury. The "bread and butter" of most veterinary medical practices
lies in the programs offered.
Veterinary health care programs are centered on the core values of the
primary provider. In start-up practices, this is usually a "no-brainer" since
there is no other staff. As a practice grows, however, the need to quantify and
share the core values grows, but this communication seldom happens in an
overt, premeditated manner.
Starting Your Practice II
practice, the most profitable programs ensure healthy and happy animals in a
household environment. In boarding operations, such programs offer a
home-like environment to keep the stewards of the animals satisfied.
LOCATION-LOCATION-LOCATION
for the new start of housing areas (in the U.S., where there are no restrain-
ing boundaries or geographic barriers, most communities grow to the North
and West).
10. List the features I should seek when selecting a new site.
• Traffic counts are misleading, since pet owners must return home to
get their pets. Look at demographics that are similar to stand-alone drug
stores and childcare centers, which have similar domicile-distance patron-
age patterns.
• In average communities, $50-60 million of community income per
FfE doctor impacting the catchment area.
• In average communities, 4000-5000 population per FfE doctor im-
pacting the catchment area.
• In average communities, 1500-2000 companion animals per FfE
doctor impacting the catchment area.
• No other practices within a 15-minute drive (this is just a wild dream
in most metroplex areas).
• A boundary on the catchment area that opens to a larger, diverse popu-
lation-without a blocking practice, geographic barriers, or psychological
barriers.
11. Is there a good "rule of thumb" to use for sizing up the potential of
a practice area?
There are many different ways to do this, but one quick and easy method
starts with deciding (1) how much money you want to make from your prac-
tice (see the size and impact figures in Question 10), and (2) how much you
have to invest in the start-up. Next, obtain a population count for the area
you intend to serve (usually available at the public library, city hall, a mar-
keting research firm, or a reputable veterinary consulting firm).
• Estimate the number of households (HH) by dividing the population
by two.
• Estimate the number of pet-owning HH by multiplying by 0.60.
14 Starting Your Practice
BUDGETING
check-writing system so they can produce their own monthly P&L and bal-
ance sheet-in real time, on a cash basis. Then the accountant need only take
the practice-developed monthly reports and generate a single quarterly
report, converting to accrual for estimating taxes.
the faxes you receive to make more permanent copies, consider switching to
a plain paper fax-it could further reduce your costs.
For on-the-road long distance, take a pre-paid calling card along. It will
save you money over the high surcharges hotels add to phone calls dialed di-
rectly from your room, and usually is cheaper than a phone company calling
card, too.
COMPUTERIZATION
25. How can I pick the right computer system for my practice?
Most standard veterinary computer systems of the past two decades have
been electronic cash registers hooked to word processors with a mail-merge
feature. This is rapidly changing, and touch screens, the ability to add pic-
tures to medical records, and integrated appointment logs all are great and
available. The processors are getting faster, and laser and ink-jet printers
now replace dot-matrix printers in almost all applications because they are
quieter, faster, and cheaper.
During the initial system screening, count how many times the vendor
tells you something to the effect, "... you will only need to modify your
practice style a little..." While some practice documentation methods may
need to be modified, invite back only those who are willing to modify their
system rather than your practice philosophy.
The system must be selected on predetermined practice needs. The deci-
sion should depend on the staff's computer literacy, the vendor service sup-
port of the locality, and the philosophy of the practice-not the salesman's
opinion. Keep control of the selection process, and computerization will not
hurt . . . honest!
Tips For Selecting a Computer System
• The longer a computer product has been on the market, the greater the chance for
increased savings.
• Technological upgrades sometimes are missing from the older systems. Don't dis-
count vendors that you've never heard of in favor of a brand name. Remember
that even Intel, Microsoft, and America Online were "newbies" once!
• Arrange for a private demonstration. Let the vendor know that this will be the first
part of a two-step process-ifthey make the final cut, you will ask them back to
demonstrate their system again (indicates you're not going to be pressured into
signing a contract that day).
• Tell the vendor to show you how their system accomplishes tasks on your list;
don't accept a prepared "demo" outlining features.
Table continued on next page.
20 Starting Your Practice
it's often an exercise in frustration dealing with two technical support depart-
ments-the hardware people say it's a software problem, and the software
people say it's a hardware problem.
• Now you can train a new employee without huge time commitments
from the rest of the practice team!
d. Allow for the customization of software after it has been used for a
period of time, to make it more adequately meet your practice needs.
These changes should not impact the warranty.
e. Release of source codes (programming details) is a must. This allows
protection of the purchaser in cases where the vendor decides to
cease support or update functions, for economic or other reasons.
Check the maintenance agreement. Again, never accept the standard
clause. Some vendors offer free maintenance for a period after the warranty
term, and it may be possible to negotiate a cap for annual maintenance fee
increases.
Check plans for manufacturer's updating of the software. This
needs to be done in a timely manner during the warranty. Maintenance peri-
ods must be specified to meet state and federal laws and regulations that
impact the software program. Obtain the counsel of a competent attorney to
better understand your rights.
36. List some critical points for concern regarding operation of veteri-
nary software.
• Count the times any vendor says, "You only have to change a little ..."
during the discussions, since this indicates the gap between what you want
and what they have to offer.
• Review the appointment log. See how easily the appointment times
can be changed, within a column as well as between columns. Determine
how a doctor can be scheduled into two rooms, out of sync, for high-density
scheduling.
• Review how easy it is to change the narratives on the reminder cards,
and how easily the merge is to change from postcards to letters to envelopes
to e-mail.
• Look at the inventory management module for ease of changing dis-
pensing fees, minimum charges, surcharges for controlled substances, sea-
sonal reorder points, and vendor history evaluations.
26 Starting Your Practice
time of day means that it is here to stay. Learn to use the resources of the
Internet so that you can:
• continue learning through online courses, interact with other profes-
sionals, and search for answers to challenges of the practice
• communicate with and educate clients or prospective clients (a prac-
tice-building tool)
46. When using Internet marketing, how do we show visitors the way
back to our site?
If you are doing a good job of marketing your web site-getting it
listed in search engines and linked to other sites, especially the commu-
nity's Chamber of Commerce-new visitors will find your web site
every day of the week. If you have good content, friendly pictures, and
information on your site, visitors may print it out for future reference.
But what happens when they pull that printout from their files a month or
two later? Will they remember your website address? Don't count on it.
Additionally, if they reached your site through a link from another web
site, there's a chance that the originating site will prevent your address
from being shown. Make sure visitors can find their way to you by in-
cluding your address in text at the bottom of every web page.
Marketing tip: always include information for new residents, such
as animal control numbers, community standards for rabies and leash
laws, and names of kennels where they can keep their animals while
moving in.
SAFETY ALWAYS!
49. Where can I get the key elements for a veterinary safety program?
The Right to Know Program, Chemical Hazard Communication
Program, and Radiation Safety Program all offer industry support, such as
vendor Material Safety Data Sheet booklets, state/province radiation inspec-
tion programs, and similar regulatory efforts. Zoonotic diseases, mechanical
injury, and women in the workplace often require veterinary-specific assis-
tance to tailor programs to the practice. Disability concerns, like pregnancy
or broken bones, require a physician's involvement so that employee limita-
tions can be conveyed to the employer (practice owner).
Starting Your Practice 31
Every practice should obtain Veterinary Safety and Health Digest, which
provides basic, bimonthly updates (www.v-p-c.com/PhiVOSHAIlinks.htm).
This publication usually deals with just one or two topics per issue, so the
practice has ongoing reminders about safety upgrades.
EARLY STAFFING
Note that pay periods should be twice a month to allow the best budget
comparisons.
card and say, "If you ever want to get out of the food service business, give
me a call. I can use someone with your attitude and people skills in our hos-
pital's client relations program."
If you have accepted this method-hiring for attitude; training to pro-
vide skills and knowledge; and "growing" your own staff-use the Internet
to help you out (e.g., online AVMA credentialed veterinary technician pro-
grams, AVMA study interactive staff development texts, AAHA training
videotapes, CD-ROM learning sessions, and a host of other resources).
57. We have been growing so fast that the staff is leaving due to the
pressures. How do we keep good people?
Fast growth is always stressful, so keep it light; make humor and laugh-
ter an integral part of the practice culture.
In a fast-paced practice, decisions often are stove-piped. Get everyone
involved in the client-centered service mission and thinking like patient ad-
vocates, and ask leading questions of the team before making a policy deci-
sion or change in the established processes.
When business is brisk, the clients' needs often become secondary to
healthcare delivery. These entities are codependent, so have the staff partici-
pate in some form of client survey and satisfaction inquiry, including making
remedial responses to the findings.
Increased demands can be dehumanizing. Patients become syndromes;
clients become numbers; and caring departs the practice's delivery process.
Change the environment by changing labels: receptionists to "client relations
specialists," technicians to "outpatient nurses," and animals to "patients in
need." Also, have the team address how to improve the situation, and em-
power them to react and respond.
Starting Your Practice 35
58. Clients come in different shapes and sizes •••what are they?
The A client visits the veterinarian multiple times a year and does what-
ever the doctor says is needed, when it is needed, with little thought about
cost.
The B client visits the veterinarian multiple times a year and eventually
does most of the things the doctor says are needed, with some concern about
costs when they exceed the family budget threshold (about $500 per episode
for 50% of pet owners).
The C client visits the veterinarian once a year, listens to what the
doctor says is needed, and eventually makes a decision about the needs (usu-
ally after 5 or more exposures). The C client has strong concerns about vet-
erinary costs as they relate to the family's discretionary income.
The D client visits the veterinarian irregularly, generally when health-
care or legal needs demand the action.
59. Can we attract new clients with coupons and free services?
Yes. However, a 20% discount requires a 500% increase in business in
most practices just to break even ... and this requires a great team to
achieve!
The better-paying clients (categories A and B) do not follow coupons
and free services unless a practice breaks a bond with them-we see this
with the large pet supply retailers who offer veterinary services. The C and D
clients follow the coupons and bargains, but they seldom visit their veteri-
narian 3 to 6 times a year like an A or B client.
Some metroplex families select two veterinary facilities-one quality
practice that they trust for medicine and surgery, and one economical, fast-in
and fast-out clinic for wellness services. A quality practice can offer both,
with some planning!
62. How can we target one preferred segment of the pet-owning population?
About 60% of clients choose their veterinarian from the selection avail-
able within a 15-minute drive from their home. In rural communities, this
distance is extended and depends on the shopping habits of the community.
About the same number also ask a neighbor or pet store about the quality of
local veterinarians when making their choice. In mixed species practices,
word-of-mouth is more significant than location, especially in production
animal environments where pennies per hundred weight can make a profit
difference.
Practices that join the Chamber of Commerce and have a page on the
Chamber's website (or on other community-based websites) get some traffic
due to "first known name" recognition factors. A few clients are referred
from AAHA hospital to AAHA hospital. National awareness of the
American Animal Hospital Association certification process is still minimal
in most areas.
Starting Your Practice 37
Note that a client who comes by word of mouth typically forgives a bad
first impression, whereas coupon and discount clients react negatively and
may start a word-of-mouth program giving you a bad reputation. A poor
community reputation can take as long as 10 years to reverse, so client bond-
ing is critical during the first visit.
63. What is the best method to increase our access to new clients?
Clients are community and practice specific, so there is no single best
method. Retention and nurturing of existing clients feeds the word-of-mouth
reputation, which is the strongest new-client program available.
Price-centered practices, like "shoot and scoot" vaccination clinics and
"pay and spay" programs, deal strictly in volume, so the widest exposure
possible is essential. Consider radio ads played during rush-hour traffic.
A recovered client program is a new twist, because it brings back the
clients who selected the practice, but then did not return. At just one recov-
ered client a day, 6 days a week, 50 weeks a year, with 1.5 pets per house-
hold and 4 visits per pet per year, annual net income can increase well over
$100,000 without changing anything else in the practice.
64. What are the minimum essential services to offer in a new practice?
There is no menu of services for new practices and mate practices (i.e.,
satellite second practice with same owner). If you are going to bond with
clients, start with a solid set of core values based on sound medical and sur-
gical beliefs. Offer the best veterinary care by clearly stating needs, then be
quiet until the client speaks. If you must speak after stating a need (yours or
an animal's), only ask, "Is this the level of care you want for Spike today?";
then fall silent again.
Minimum essential services should include many "two-yes" options,
such as: a titer screen and a vaccination, two-lead cardiac screen as well as a
full seven-lead method, two types of electronic monitoring in surgery, two
levels of preanesthetic screening, and/or two levels of pain management.
Clients who are given two-yes choices at a new practice select appropriate
care more than 75% of the time (in mature practices, this two-yes method
moves positive responses to more than 95% ofthe time). When given a yes-
no choice, 50% acceptance is a good rate.
Additionally, the minimum essential is a scope of services and prod-
ucts that is appropriate for you. An outpatient practice doesn't offer many
inpatient services, and a specialty practice doesn't offer outpatient well-
ness care if they want to keep referrals coming from other veterinarians.
Look in the mirror and determine what quality healthcare means to you,
clearly state that belief to your staff, and then tell everyone in the practice
38 Starting Your Practice
68. What do I do when the guy down the road starts to bad mouth our
work?
• Keep a civil tongue while taking defensive action. Speak no evil!
• Spread the word. Let all the staff and clients know up front that you
will never engage in this type of unprofessional reference. Bad-mouthing an-
other veterinarian or veterinary practice rarely pays. Know why your prac-
tice is special, and speak directly of the benefits of your practice and your
delivery system. Be proud of what you stand for in the community.
• Probe for more information. Assess what was said, why it was said,
and by whom. Was the source a client objection to something done in your
practice? Do you need to perform damage control, or is it totally unfounded
(remember, perceptions are real!).
• Inform your staff. Credible proof only cancels out erroneous infor-
mation if the staff knows the facts and can deliver the information with pride.
• Share the good news. Let your service speak for itself. Don't be afraid
to speak up and "correct the record," but do it based on your own honesty
and dedication to the animals of the community.
fered for their travel files. Include Lyme disease information for trips to the
Northeast, valley fever for the Southwest, salmon disease for the Northwest,
endemic parasites for the Southeast, etc. Maps are always helpful!
A magnet that shows animal control, poison control, and your veterinary
practice phone numbers is likely to be prominently displayed on the client's
refrigerator.
71. How do I get my new doctor (receptionist team) to sell our products?
In veterinary healthcare delivery, the only thing we "sell" is peace of
mind; all else the client is "allowed to buy."
Some see selling as a competitive situation; arm them with self-assur-
ance that your practice is special for the patients. Others are self-conscious
about the cost; focus them on the client's concern and the animal's welfare.
Still others are self-centered and do not believe in the product or service for
their own reasons; help them listen hard to the client's concern and respond
to the client's needs and requests before they add their own bias.
Concentrate on the accomplishments of the practice. Flaunt the
strengths of the individuals on your staff. Be proud of the equipment capa-
bilities in the hands of your practice's providers.
72. I think we are "breaking client bonds" too often; what can we do
better?
Broken promises come in many forms, from honoring the appointment
to calling a client at the time agreed upon. Broken promises are a foundation
for broken client bonds. There is a social contract that is embraced in all
healthcare delivery, and it starts with "Do no harm" and continues to "Do
Starting Your Practice 41
what is needed." If the client perceives pain, or feels too much pressure to
buy something they did not ask for, the client bond is weakened.
Clients come to a practice stressed, and instead ofthe practice paying at-
tention to them, they are put into a "holding pattern." They feel ignored.
Slighting a stressed client is often cause for that person to try another veteri-
nary practice.
Be careful of telling a client that a computer will not allow it, that it is
against hospital policy, or other forms of arguments. While a client may not
always be right, they are seldom wrong! Do not blame a client; do not argue
with a client-just ask, "What can we do to make it right?"
The high-tech world has caused some practices to put an eletronic sort-
ing device between themselves and clients (those stressed people telephon-
ing your practice). Ensure a real person answers and listens before a client is
put into the electronic world of voice mail or electronic routing.
Client bonding is very similar to pricing; if the client believes he or she
received more value than what was spent, it was a bargain. If a client felt im-
portant to the practice and known by the practice team, then the value in-
creased in the client's mind, and the bond was enhanced.
2. HUMAN RESOURCES
43
44 Human Resources
A good job description embraces the core values of the practice and
shows the "training commitment" to a new candidate for the introductory
period. The time-line for the introductory period should be adjusted for indi-
vidual capabilities and learning rate, as determined by the practice training
team. Traditionally, the period is 30 to 90 days.
6. What key actions can I take to make my practice more efficient and
improve productivity?
Four of the most overlooked areas are:
• Use technicians as "doctor extenders" so that you can see more pa-
tients in your practice.
• Improve your inventory management by improving the number of
turns. Try to turn your inventory 8-12 times per year to maximize prof-
itability.
• Match your practice hours to the hours in your community to make it
easier for pet owners to make and keep appointments.
• Try high-density scheduling to maximize the number of patients you
see each hour.
10. What will encourage the team to execute a new practice program?
First, it must be presented as something special. There is an art to pre-
sentation. In advertising, it's called "sell the sizzle," which comes from the
television ads that display sizzling bacon, implying the aroma and flavor, but
never addressing the cholesterol-laden fat of an animal that wallows in mud.
Human Resources 47
Start the program with excitement, and test it on the fly. Never try to
predict all the problems before starting-it will never get started. Instead
have a plan A and a plan B, and maybe even a C, D, and E, and expect the
program to be tweaked daily by the team.
Stay centered on the outcome, and avoid process dissection. Get a
"buzz" going on the team involvement and progress, not the speed bumps in
the road. Start to brag about people and their efforts, and celebrate the partic-
ipation (process) as well as the success (outcome).
13. What type of incentives add to the CQI environment and staff
harmony?
"Open-book management" concepts are a good foundation, but must be
adjusted for a veterinary practice, Staff members know what is deposited
each day, but they don't know the expenses. Think about the following
"recognition" ideas (bonus and incentive are inappropriate terms for health-
care workers):
• Guarantee the staff salary as a percentage of gross (start with historical
levels), Extra monies left at the end of each quarter are divided between staff
members who have a full quarter of participation (40% of savings distributed
immediately, 30% held for holiday surprise, and the balance held for Uncle
Sam's tax requirements).
• Know the quarterly cost of drugs and medical supplies, but don't mix
in diagnostic supplies, nutritional products, or boutique items. Take drug and
medicine costs as a percentage of gross, and share 20% of the savings with
the inventory management team when they reduce inventory costs.
• The nutritional counselors, who manage the nutritional inventory, also
should track the net for their product lines. Quarterly they can be paid 20%
of the earnings over 30% net.
Create a creativity corner, where people can go to think new and won-
drous things. Add an erasable white board for brainstorming, so that ideas
and mind maps can grow from a group effort. Add pictures, decorations, and
media resources that provide innovation fuel.
Make generating ideas fun and fearless. Stage a stupid idea week and
hold a contest. Encourage camaraderie and be aware that "stupid" ideas
often lead to great ideas. Post entries on the bulletin board and conduct an
awards ceremony each day at lunch, with daily winners being entered in the
drawing at the end of the week at a celebration luncheon.
Turn a staff hallway wall into a hall of fame. Exhibit photos and exam-
ples of specific staff members and their great idea(s).
16. I feel alone when making changes and decisions. How do I combat
that feeling?
Build a network among creative friends from your place of worship,
Rotary, and/or civic groups. This effort may be supplemented by hiring a
consulting firm, attending university courses, enrolling in Dale Carnegie or
Toastmasters, or even attending a short course on a topic of interest. Use all
the brains you can find, beg, or borrow.
DISCIPLINE MATTERS
• Take the person aside and ask directly, "Why are you late?"
• Look at the person, lower your voice, and ask, "Is everything okay?"
POLICY MANUALS
TRAINING ISSUES
26. How do we make the time for in-service training and other
meetings?
Time is never "made"; it is only scheduled and sequenced effectively.
Think of the logger who must produce at ever higher levels of produc-
tion, but never takes the time to sharpen his ax during the day. Production
drops over time. The logger who routinely undertakes brief sharpening ef-
forts maintains a sharper ax; cutting is easier, fatigue is less, and produc-
tion is improved. It is the same in every mind, in every practice: a few,
short (20-minute), individualized training efforts keep the skill level honed
and sharp!
Trainers can go to the individual and grab a few moments one-on-one as
the situation allows. If the trainers are rotated, a new staff member receives
the current level of knowledge across all aspects of the job position.
MILLENNIUM MANAGEMENT
31. Veterinary practices are scrambling to find clients and keep net
income. What's happening, and what can we do?
The rules are changing, and the old methods don't work. Vaccination
and pet population income is waning, pet populations have stabilized, and
the number of store-front practices has increased in most metroplex commu-
nities. Practices must accept these changing environmental factors.
Be the first practice to use new healthcare delivery ideas, such as nurs-
ing appointments, high-density scheduling, more visits at lower average
client transaction rates, alternative medicine, VIP resort suites for pet guests,
and behavior management advisors.
Develop a strategic foresight. Make assumptions on the community's
future using the best information from the city planners, chamber of com-
merce, rotary contacts, church sources, and other merchants and civic leaders.
Look at a team redesign. Include new duty area accountabilities, target
outcomes, and client-centered services. Ask clients what is needed to make
them return more often with all of their family pets.
Feed the innovation engine residing in the minds of every staff
member, every client, and every community contact. Look at things upside
down and inside out to find the unusual approach to being unique in the
community.
In the coming century, knowledge is all that America can really broker.
We have the educational and developmental edge to make a difference in the
world market of information sharing.
Client awareness is developed by environmental influences. The under-
current of veterinary practice in the past century was selling things. The dri-
ving force in the new millennium will be brokering knowledge.
34. The words we use set the tone of the practice. What are the new
words for the new millennium?
The words you use shouldn't be just buzz phrases ... you must walk the
walk!
New Words Old Words
A performance Ajob
Act of commitment Puttin' in the time
Memorable Close enough
Wow, gee whiz! Blah
Team members Employees
A signature piece It has always been this way
Epitome of character Faceless
Innovation and creativity Predictable and safe
Mastery of excellence Acceptable work
Exhausting effort Numbing existence
Talent rules Hierarchy habits
Adventuresome Risk-averse
Growth experience Another day
It matters! No big deal ...
38. Can I use benchmarking in this new millennium quest for innovation?
"Benchmarking" is a 1990 corporate term for brain-picking. Brain-
picking is simply using all the brains you can beg, borrow, or steal. It in-
volves applying others' impressive ideas to your own projects.
Benchmarking has been used by some veterinarians and veterinary
managers as an excuse not to change, because they only look inside the
Human Resources 59
veterinary profession and do not see anything new or exciting. The idea
is to look outside a specific industry for new ideas that worked in other
industries or professions.
Life is brimming with new, stimulating experiences. It takes a little
nerve and a trust that your team will be able to "adjust on the fly" to
make the idea work better each day.
3. STAFF TRAINING AND ORIENTATION *
61
62 Staff Training and Orientation
• The staff will not abide by the safety rules if the veterinarian owner of
the practice believes in a "Do as I say, not as I do" philosophy.
• This goes for attendance at required training functions also!
• The presence and participation of the practice leaders sends the mes-
sage that the issue is important.
• Likewise, the leaders' absence sends the message that this stuff
isn't serious enough to get their attention, so it must not be very
important.
Perhaps the best way for the leadership to support a training program is
to make time in the schedule for it. Successful practices recognize that
staffing at a level barely adequate to cover the workload on an average day
leaves little room in the schedule for staff improvement. Staff meetings or
training sessions after working hours or during other nonbusiness periods
will be resented as intrusions into personal time. Additionally, the staff will
get the impression that the message (training) wasn't important enough to
take time away from the routine, so it's just another one of those boring, use-
less meetings. However, by conducting training on "company time," the
business is sending the message that the topic is relevant and important.
Finally, the leadership must create the expectation that all staff members
will participate and support the training. Associate veterinarians or senior
technical staff members cannot be allowed to disrupt the timing or flow of
the training. Routine treatments, telephone calls, and deadlines are impor-
tant, but so is training, and neither should overshadow the other. Only the
senior leadership of the hospital can make training as important as any other
part of the practice.
the time to examine the materials he or she would have during the first few
days.
• One-on-one is not the same as "Follow Jane around; she'll show you
what you need to know." That's not training at all-it's simply throw-
ing the person into the work and expecting eventual learning.
topic (or point them in the right direction), and make sure they understand
what the focus of the session should be.
Remember, planning is the key to success when it comes to training, and
the first step is creating a schedule so that everyone knows the plan.
of a message are all types of training that can be accomplished with memos,
notes, and signs. As a general rule, no more than two "directives" should
be circulating or posted at a time. Multiple memos are likely to confuse the
staff, and they may just ignore all of them. Likewise, remove old messages
from the bulletin board after all staff members have seen and initialed
them. This action reduces clutter and gives the impression that the message
is important.
Another method is the practice training manual. Get a three-ring
binder and label it appropriately. When you take down a notice or when a
memo has been initialed by everyone, put it in the binder along with all
handouts, quizzes, and written information from real-time meetings. This
way, there's always a record of what information was put out. Additionally,
new employees obtain an "institutional memory," without actually having
been present, by reviewing the training manual when they are first hired. The
manual also helps when you have one staff member who just doesn't get it.
He or she can review the handouts and session material without much addi-
tional time from the supervisor.
71
72 Regulatory Matters
printed copy from the U.S. Government Printing Office; (2) purchasing a
CD-ROM version from the U.S. Government Printing Office or from several
commercial vendors; (3) viewing, printing, or downloading copies from the
OSHA web site (www.osha.gov); (4) purchasing a veterinary-specific
OSHA compliance kit that "deciphers" the rules and. gives implementation
advice (check out the web site www.v-p-c.comlphil for examples).
occur. The plan always should be in writing and reflect what is actually done.
The perfect plan is useless if nobody does it that way! Train the staff on the
expectations, and enforce the plan. You may get some grumbling from a few
staff members at first, but soon the new method becomes a habit.
Pay particular attention to the safety equipment required. Make sure that
your equipment is appropriate for protecting the user and fits properly. A
great example is the radiation protection gloves in most practices. Although
they may be appropriate for the radiation present, if the staff members can't
use them because they are too big, too small, or simply not flexible enough,
they are inadequate.
that stuff for your own good." "I'll get in trouble if OSHA comes in here and
sees you not wearing your goggles and apron." Here are some examples of
the correct perspective: "Janie, you have been trained in the safety principles
rules of this practice, and I expect you to follow them." "Joe, I must assume
that you still have questions about the safety rules of the practice since
you're still not wearing the required protective devices." In the first exam-
ples, the leadership tried to enforce a rule without accepting responsibility;
in the second examples, it is clear that employees are expected to follow the
rules.
• Second, check employee understanding of the requirement. Provide
additional training if necessary.
• Third, specify for the employee the parts of the program with which he
or she is noncompliant. Most consultants advocate a verbal approach at this
point, but be sure to keep a record of the conversation.
• Fourth, if the staff member continues to violate the safety rules, give
them a written letter of admonishment. Many hospital leaders avoid this
step because it takes time to do, but the use of a standard form or stock letter
can make it easier. As a general rule, after this step the majority of employ-
ees adjust their behavior and no further steps are necessary.
• Fifth, follow the disciplinary procedures outlined in the hospital
policy manual, but at this point many people advocate an administrative sus-
pension without pay. Simply send them home for the rest of the day (or even
2 days) without pay.
• Finally, in the extremely rare circumstance that the employee refuses
to follow the hospital rules, despite proper training and verbal or written rep-
rimands, begin proceedings for dismissal. Most human resource managers
and employment attorneys affirm that dismissal for failure to follow estab-
lished safety procedures is legal, and, in most cases, the employee is not eli-
gible for unemployment compensation. As always, this can vary by state or
locality; if you have questions, be sure to contact a counselor familiar with
your local situation.
23. Are there any safety restrictions on eating and drinking in the
practice?
Yes. The potential for illness from ingestion of pathogens or harmful
chemicals is present in most veterinary hospitals. Although some veterinari-
ans joke that immunity only comes from exposure, OSHA is serious about
rules against eating and drinking in hazardous areas. Several years ago, a
veterinarian was fined for allowing employees to eat lunch on the treatment
table. Although not specifically mentioned in OSHA standards, the treat-
ment table is a potential contamination source.
Regulatory Matters 79
Always ask whether the injured employee wants to go to the doctor for a
consultation and/or tetanus booster. If he or she wants to go, make the
arrangements. If they refuse, no big deal; just note it.
An accident report should be completed for all needle stick injuries
(except for sterile, unused needles), even if they seem minor at the time. Of
course, not every incident is turned into the insurance company, but you do
want to have a record of the situation if it turns into a problem later.
33. Must we have a separate x-ray monitoring badge for every staff
member, even if they don't take a lot of x-rays?
OSHA requires that each person who is occupationally exposed to ion-
izing radiation be supplied with a personal dosimetry device if they can re-
ceive 25% of the allowable dose in any calendar quarter. This generally
means that staff members must be provided with the badge and required to
wear it if they participate in taking more than one or two x-rays a month.
Staff members who do not participate in the exposure phase of the procedure
are not required to have or use monitoring devices.
35. What protective equipment is required for the staff when taking
radiographs?
Minimum protective equipment includes full-hand gloves and an apron
that covers the torso with a rating of at least 0.5 mm of lead equivalency.
Hand shields that cover just the top of the hands do not meet OSHA require-
ments for protective equipment. Mitts with a slit in the palm can be used if
the animal's paw is pulled into the glove, but not if the staff member's hands
or fingers stick out of the glove.
Thyroid shields and radiopaque glasses are recommended during fluo-
roscopy procedures, but are not required by OSHA.
36. What are the shielding requirements for the walls in an x-ray room?
Normally, the room where the x-ray machine is located must be shielded
to prevent unintentional exposure to occupants of adjacent areas. In some
cases, exterior walls or those that border unoccupied spaces do not require
shielding because there is little chance of someone being on the other side of
the wall when an x-ray is taken. If shielding is required, it should be a con-
Regulatory Matters 83
37. Can the x-ray machine be located in the treatment area, or must it
be placed in a separate room?
Unless state rules prohibit it, radiographic machines can be installed in
the treatment room as long as the room is clear of people when radiographs
are taken.
39. Can the used fixer and developer be discarded in the sewer?
Normally the quantity, strength, and nature of the developing solution is
of minimal concern for municipal waste treatment facilities, and it can be
discharged into the sewer directly. Practices with septic systems should not
dump this chemical into the drains because of possible damage to the mi-
crobe action that is the heart of the system.
The fixer, however, is another matter. Since fixer contains a heavy metal
(silver), it should never be discharged directly into any sewer or septic
system. Basically, there are two disposal methods available to the average
practice: filtration of the fixer solution prior to disposal into the sewer, or
total removal of the bulk chemical by a company in that business.
84 Regulatory Matters
• Simple recovery units are available for automatic processors for less
than $50. Recovery systems for manual developing operations also are avail-
able, but are slightly more time-consuming than the average practice is will-
ing to endure. In any event, if this method is used, it is essential that the
directions for the device be followed exactly and that the device be checked
periodically and changed when necessary.
• Perhaps the best method for most practices is to contract with a li-
censed hazardous waste hauler to collect and properly dispose of the chemi-
cals. Many x-ray suppliers will perform this service for their customers.
There is usually a fee, but most practices feel it is worth the peace of mind.
40. Besides needles and sharps, what other items in a veterinary prac-
tice are considered hazardous medical waste?
• All waste from chemotherapy operations.
• Tissues from animals suspected to have a disease that can be transmit-
ted to humans.
• Culture (bacterial, fungal, or viral) media with growth.
• Medical devices (e.g., blood tubes, IV bags and lines, and catheters)
containing human pathogens or that have been used on an animal with a dis-
ease that can be transmitted to humans.
• Waste from animals infected with a disease contagious to humans
(which can be transmitted by means of the waste).
<In some states (e.g., Florida), all materials used on nonhuman primates
are considered hazardous medical waste.
46. How many fire extinguishers are required for a veterinary hospital?
There must be enough fire extinguishers placed strategically throughout
the hospital so that one is always less than 75 feet from any point in the
building.
The rating and type of extinguisher depends on the function of the hos-
pital and the chemicals that may be present. In general, most veterinary hos-
pitals use dry chemical or carbon dioxide (C0 2)-type extinguishers, but
check with your local fire marshal to be sure. Dry chemical extinguishers are
known to be corrosive to electronic equipment, so ask the computer and lab-
oratory equipment supplier for their advice also!
visually check each extinguisher to ensure that it is still properly charged and
hasn't been removed or damaged. Do this on a monthly basis! This monthly
check should be annotated on the reverse side of the inspection tag. The date
and person's initials are sufficient.
51. I've heard that every door in the building must have a sign saying
either "EXIT" or "NOT AN EXIT." Is this correct?
No, it's a myth. OSHA's requirement (and what makes the most sense)
is to have the routes to exits, as well as the exits themselves, clearly marked.
For instance, if a staff member is standing in the treatment room and cannot
see a clearly marked exit, there should be signs over or on the doors leading
to the exits. Note, however, that if a door can be mistaken for an exit (for in-
stance an old exterior door that looks like a way out but is locked or
blocked), then it must be clearly marked "NOT AN EXIT."
88 Regulatory Matters
54. Must we provide a first aid kit for employee or client use?
OSHA requires that a first aid kit be available when the workplace is not
in "near proximity" to a hospital, infirmary, or clinic, or when normal
Emergency Medical Systems (EMS) services are not available. If your city
or county has an established EMS, then you should rely on their expertise in
an emergency. In reply to several inquiries, OSHA has defined "near prox-
imity" to mean "within 3-4 minutes of an accident involving suffocation,
severe bleeding, or other life-threatening injuries ... or within 15 minutes
where a life-threatening accident or illness is unlikely."
Obviously, any situation can quickly become life threatening, but the
key here is whether such a scenario is "reasonably expected." Access to
emergency treatment within 15 minutes is the standard for almost every vet-
erinary practice.
56. If we are in ''near proximity," does this mean I can't have a first aid
kit in the practice?
Not at all. Most practices have found a happy medium with "self-aid"
kits, in which common items like adhesive bandages and antiseptic ointment
are available. If the injured person is not capable of self-aid, then the acci-
dent is serious enough to warrant treatment by a physician.
Mobile practices should follow the same rules as for a fixed installation.
Have a self-aid kit available in each unit, but if the injury is more serious, use
the cellular phone or two-way radio to summon EMS assistance.
CONTROLLED SUBSTANCES
58. Are there any simple checklists for staying in compliance with the
U.S. Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA)?
The many rules and regulationsfor DEA compliance can be overwhelming.
Checklist for Easing DEA Compliance
Registration
• Are all veterinarians who prescribe controlled substances. or cause them to be
dispensed or administered on the premises. registered with the DEA?
• If the veterinarians administer or dispense controlled substances at more than
one location (e.g .• satellites). are they registered to each location with the DEA?
Table continued on next page.
90 Regulatory Matters
LITIGATION CONCERNS
Progress notes are on lined paper under the patient data sheet, with
client and patient name at the bottom (prongs are at the top); for annotations,
use the problem-oriented medical record format. The Subjective-Objective-
Assessment Plan was made popular by the University of Illinois in the mid-
1970s and has not changed much since then.
• After the date is the "client concern"-in the client's words.
• The "subjective" is just the history, and the "objective" is the findings
of your own professional observations/exam.
• The "assessment" is what you tell the client you are treating the animal
for; it's sometimes a tentative diagnosis. (A differential diagnosis
seldom is used in real practice, since it is an academic pursuit and con-
fusing to the staff for sequential contact.)
• The "plan" includes diagnostics, medications, procedures, and the ex-
pectation for the next contact (three Rs-recall, recheck, and/or
remind).
62. Which are the best supplemental forms to add to a medical record?
Forms are not "added to a medical record." Forms are used to establish
quality healthcare delivery habits and are dynamic instruments based on the
healthcare required for the case.
The best supplemental forms are simply "break-and-stick" labels that
affix directly to the progress notes, so that the chronological care of each pa-
tient stays organized and systematized (a picture is worth a thousand words).
Pictures of dental arcades, eyes, body shape for dermatology, and even labo-
ratory or surgical procedures can make annotation of medical records faster
and easier.
The AVMA Directory has a simple hospitalization/authorization form
(circa 1982), and there are sample forms available in Building The
Successful Veterinary Practice: Programs & Procedures (Volume 2) and in
the Signature Series Monographs at www.v-p-c.com.
63. How long do I need to keep medical records after the pet is gone?
Medical records should be held 3-7 years from last contact with the pa-
tient or client. Ask the state or province veterinary medical association for
the specific ruling in your jurisdiction. When an animal dies or is euthanized,
the final entry of the master problem list should show the date and cause of
death. This is when the clock starts ticking.
Move the pink or blue patient data sheet with the master problem list to
underneath the client welcome form. Remove the balance of the records for
that animal from the active medical record file, and chronologically file them
in storage for the required time.
5. RIGHTS OF THE EMPLOYED
95
96 Rights of the Employed
DOCTOR CONTRACTS
Divide by 60. This is the value of your time per minute. Multiply by 3 to
determine the value of a 3-minute phone call. Multiply by 5 to establish the
cost of a 5-minute interruption.
BENEFITS PACKAGES
BOARDING
99
100 Ancillary Services
"exploration zone" (playground for animals) rather than the yard or the
back field.
• Bed and breakfast for cats and dogs, with historical tours or
named suites. In some cases, VIP suites are indicated (8 feet x 6 feet or 8
feet x 8 feet), accessed by a 48-inch half door instead of bars, with beds,
a towel bar with monogrammed towels, television, and windows to the
outside.
• Pet hotel, hotel manager, spa services, and similar anthropomorphic
terms, often associated with a boutique.
• A "camp" for field trial dog areas, including retrieving exercises,
swimming sessions (stock tank), and socialization time.
GROOMING
8. What are special boutique services or products that have been suc-
cessful elsewhere?
• A drawing for a free photographic portrait each month for patrons of
the boutique. Pet photographers often provide free sittings because they
know that if the photos are good, people will buy additional ones.
• Seasonal promotions linked with the practice promotions, including
a drawing for a free pet health insurance policy for patrons of the previous
30 days during National Pet Month.
• A nutritional center, with signed veterinarian endorsement (posted
sign) of the recommended diets for each stage of life.
102 Ancillary Services
• Kitten carrier classes (the name is used to tell clients how a cat should
be transported at all times), to orient clients about the most current care of
cats.
• A practice lending library for animal books and videos, web site, and
other client-education enhancements.
• Operation Pet 1.0., with digital camera photos, name tags, microchips,
tattoos, and "puppy passports" as anniversary gifts to clients, instead of re-
minders.
7. GROWING BEYOND ONE DOCTOR
FINDING AN ASSOCIATE
105
106 Growing Beyond One Doctor
4. What are the key points to focus on initially when expanding the
practice team?
Note that you must build the right model before you expand it.
• Build a management team that understands how to use a program-
based budget (see Appendix B).
• Refocus attention from process to outcome excellence. Each manage-
ment team member must understand "why" as well as "what," and the leader
must develop the team's belief in the vision of the practice.
• Challenge the management team to become a leadership team by de-
veloping the practice vision in other staff members. Thus, the core values
change from mere words to the working philosophy of the practice.
• Develop others on the practice staff to bond with clients, be patient ad-
vocates, and promote practice operational harmony.
tables, not doctors. Increase the use of outpatient nurses; implement high-
density scheduling; and ensure that continuity of care issues are recorded in
the medical records.
Not all practice owners can expand, due to demographics, the inabil-
ity to release control (basic trust of others), or facility size. If anyone of
these three areas indicates poor potential, then focus on expanding your
volume. Single-doctor practices start to reach peak performance at about
450 transactions per month. Most veterinary practices need to change
from the doctor-centered habits that built the practice to team-centered
programs that grow the practice (this usually requires about $500,000
gross income).
We suggest a staff ratio of four paraprofessionals to one doctor. In a
single-doctor practice that leverages the staff and increases the staff-client
contacts, the staff number can be double this traditional level and still have
great performance.
using the three Rs: recall, recheck, remind. Look to improving efficiencies
before expanding staff.
A nutritional counselor can effect 30 to 60 additional clinic visits a
month. Your practice must have the discipline to share the rewards with the
outpatient staff that will be needed to keep this wellness outreach program
operational in the client's mind.
A dental hygiene specialist can effect 20 to 30 dentistries a month, es-
pecially in grades one and two dental hygiene levels. These are easier den-
tals, usually not requiring doctor involvement for extraction. Your practice
must provide the training and share the rewards with the nursing staff to
build a dental program.
Nursing telephone outreach can greatly increase client return rate.
Under-staffing, compounded with low wages, often makes this task a last
priority instead of a primary responsibility of a caring veterinary healthcare
team. Give the staff adequate time to perform this critical bonding function.
sued by an injured party on the grounds that the corporation is no more than
the "alter ego" of the owner. The Limited Liability Corporation (LLC) or
Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) usually has greater taxation issues than
a Sub-S, and a C Corp usually has a better structure for retirement invest-
ments. Local legal advice and estate planning information will be needed to
research the various tax consequences and succession planning issues.
11. What other issues besides liability should be considered before de-
ciding to incorporate?
The corporate structure may require you to observe certain legal for-
malities regarding the way you run your business, and may expose you to
taxes or annual fees that do not have to be paid if the business is a sole pro-
prietorship or partnership. It usually is smart to "exteriorize" the building
and land into a family estate with multiple owners, so they are not part of the
estate upon an untimely demise.
Some small practices do benefit from incorporating. For example, the
business' image may be enhanced. Depending on circumstances, incorpora-
tion may have tax benefits as well. The bottom line: consult with both your
attorney and your accountant, and get all the facts you need to make the right
decision for your business.
13. How do I know when my prices are exceeding the community com-
fort zone?
In most cases, as a result of negative customer feedback, the doctor will
curtail fees before the whole community is aware. As long as your practice is
Growing Beyond One Doctor III
within 10% of the top of the marketplace, quality and value can make the
practice a bargain.
Value comes with client education; in the absence of knowledge, clients
make decisions based on price. The nursing staff can educate, but the pride
shown by the staff when presenting the invoice or healthcare plan costs will
be perceived as quality. In healthcare, high pride = high quality; indiffer-
ence = mediocrity.
8. CLIENT/CUSTOMER SERVICES
(SMART MARKETING)
[13
114 Client/Customer Services
PRICE SHOPPERS
aside for possible followup in the future. Months later, their priorities shift.
Suddenly, the service or product they were thinking about purchasing
"sometime" becomes what they need now. However, that first piece of litera-
ture you sent may be filed, misfiled, buried at the bottom of a stack of things
to do, or even tossed out during a kitchen table cleanup campaign.
Position your practice to win those delayed sales by following up regu-
larly for at least 6 months with newsletters or reminders. Make your initial
followups once every month for 6 months if the prospect seemed genuinely
interested. After that, followup with your quarterly newsletter. Newsletters
or health alerts don't have to be elaborate or costly; even a postcard with a
reminder to check your web site for new information is beneficial. Notices
of special programs are good ways to keep in touch and keep your name and
practice scope fresh in potential clients' minds.
If your practice has an 80% or better appointment log fill rate, the good
news is that you are busy. The bad news is that you are limiting client access,
and some are going elsewhere.
In some communities, the phrase "Appointment Required" litters the
yellow pages and phone greetings. The message "Walk-ins Welcome," which
conveys accessibility and convenience, causes a 25% increase in new client
access.
lands." The contract has four parts, starting with the traditional Greek med-
ical premise, "First, do no harm!" The other parts are: do only what is
needed; restore well ness in the patient; and assign fair and appropriate
remuneration.
The social contract is an unspoken commitment made by opening the
doors of a hospital. It is not optional; it is a common expectation-of the
client, the staff, the local regulatory agencies, and responsible doctors.
WELLNESS PROCEDURES
Second, there is no animal alive that can survive without some form
of nutritional intake. The veterinary practice can balance life needs with
nutritional intake parameters and extend the lives-as well as the quality
of life-of their patients. You're selling the benefits of nutrition rather
than the food per se, and offering clients something they can do for the
members of their family with fur, fins, or feathers. The most rewarding
aspect for clients is watching their pets thrive on a premium, balanced
diet.
Nutritional counseling is the purview of the nursing staff. They are the
nutritional advisors and can share the value of quality food. They can make
25-40% net, which is valuable to the practice. The key issue is benefits:
cat food offers better-smelling litter boxes; dog food offers smaller, firmer
stools; balanced, quality diets offer longer lives, better hair coats, and
higher digestibility (fewer internal complications).
Consider including the pain injection in the bundle for every surgery,
just as anesthesia is included, and then offer an upgrade to a patch. Here is a
possible narrative:
"Pain control is essential with this procedure, so we have included
a 12- to 24-hour pain control injection in the procedure price. But
for only an additional $22.50. we can use a patch which extends the
pain management for 3 to 5 days. Which do you prefer today?"
MARKETING PERSPECTIVES
21. What's the single most important decision I can make for my
practice?
Location, location, location. A well-located practice has a hard time fail-
ing. A good location means:
• The sign and building are visible to passing traffic.
• The building is attractive and inviting.
• It's easy to get to from the road.
• There's sufficient parking.
• The space is affordable.
In the case of specialty referral practices, all of the above are null and void.
All clients come by way of maps provided by the practice's real clients-the
practices that refer to the specialty practice.
25. What do I say when the local Little League, High School Yearbook
Committee, or other group comes knocking on my door for donations?
Always ask yourself, "Does this make sense for my practice?" This
question doesn't mean you should not support your community. These ad-
vertisement donations are just that: community charity.
Ask yourself what is most important to you. If you think it would be
smarter to limit your donations to pet-related causes, then do just that. For
instance, you and your staff could organize a dog wash and donate the pro-
ceeds to the local animal shelter. This would bring people to your hospital,
earn goodwill, and help pets. It's the kind of donation that does you good
while doing good.
If you believe in the youth of your community and want to help them,
then the decision is not a management concern: the donation is a community
service and a personal commitment. If it feels good, and you like the feeling
of helping the group, then just do it!
times each day?" "What appointment hours do clients ask for that we don't
provide?"
You may find that you can work fewer hours if you match the hours you
are open to those that are best for your clients. For instance, you may be able
to close Fridays at noon if you'll work until 3 PM on Saturdays. You may be
able to close all day on Wednesdays if you provide early drop-offs and late
pick-ups on the other days of the week.
and 60% of new residents look first at the location. The second thing they do
is ask a neighbor for a recommendation (in good practices, 60% of new
clients come from word of mouth). Thus, a visitation agent who makes a per-
sonal recommendation, rather than just leaving "paper," makes a difference.
Some Welcome Wagon programs require that a premium or discount be
offered. After deduction of rent, ROI, and adequate clinical salary, most
practices have less than 15% net income. Therefore, any "free" premium
offer or discount coupon requires many more times the business than can be
generated by the visitation program.
Welcome Wagon and other visitation programs can provide name
recognition. If used strategically, with a staff trained to affect repeat visits
after the first coupon use, they can help build an awareness of a new practice
during the first 18 to 24 months of operation.
spending generally is far more flexible than that of a growing family with
child demands.
There are more women (137.2 million) of all ages in the U.S. population
than men (131.6 million), and the ratio of women to men increases dramati-
cally with age. At ages 65 and over, there are 20.1 million women and 14.1
million men. At ages 85 and over, there are 2.8 million women vs. 1.1 mil-
lion men. Among these women who are 65 and older, in 1997 almost half
were widows and about 7 in lO of these women lived alone.
The local senior citizen newspaper often is their primary communica-
tion means, except for those communities with a senior's center. Volunteer to
write a regular pet care column or offer to come and speak to their monthly
meeting. The bond will grow!
9. SUCCESSION PLANNING
127
128 Succession Planning
Many people have the titles but not the responsibility or authority to
commit resources to achieve the end result. If you want to share leadership,
clearly assign outcome expectations, discuss limitations and milestones, re-
lease the control of resources to the program manager, and stand back.
Become a mentor, and do not try to control the process. Let the people try
their way as long as it is within the original parameters and limitations. Be
waiting at each milestone to ask, "Are we helping you enough to reach your
objective? and "Can we provide additional assistance to help you achieve
our goals in this race?"
RETIREMENT CONCERNS
131
132 And Then There Is Tomorrow ...
All men are not created equal ... over half are women!
No client is worse than no client.
Doctors deal in needs, not recommendations and soft hints.
When in doubt, the front door must swing!
While doctors produce gross, the staff earns the practice its net.
The only way to control chaos is to create it!
The secret is in the questions, not in the answers.
There are always more alternatives.
How you treat your staff is how your staff will treat your clients.
Give people more than they expect, and do it cheerfully.
Too many people overvalue what they are not and undervalue what they are.
When you say, "I'm sorry,"look the person in the eye.
Directive training starts the delegation process; then persuasion and coach-
ing are required to build the confidence needed to accept delegation.
Hire for attitude; train for skills and knowledge.
The greatest mistake is to imagine that we never will err.
Never laugh at anyone's dreams.
In disagreements, fight fairly. No name calling. Disagree, but do not make the
other person wrong!
Don't judge people by their relatives.
Talk slowly, but think quickly.
When someone asks you a question you don't want to answer, smile and ask,
"Why do you want to know?"
The art of using moderate abilities to advantage often brings greater results
than actual brilliance.
Call you mother just to say "Hi, I love you."
When you lose, don't lose the lesson.
135
136 Appendix A
Remember the three Rs of staff development: respect for self and others; re-
sponsibility for all your actions; and recognition of the effort of others.
Don't let a little dispute injure a great friendship.
When you realize you've made a mistake, take immediate steps to correct it,
and ask, "What can we do better next time?"
Smile when picking up the phone. The caller will hear it in your voice.
Spend some time alone.
Open your arms to change, but don't let go of your values.
Remember that silence is sometimes the best answer.
A smart veterinary business person is one who makes a mistake, learns from
it, and never makes it again. A wise veterinary business person is one
who finds a smart veterinary business person and learns from him or her
how to avoid the mistakes.
Live a good, honorable life. Then when you get older and think back, you'll
get to enjoy it a second time.
A caring atmosphere in your practice is so important. Do all you can to
create a nurturing, harmonious practice environment.
In disagreements with others, deal with the current situation; don't bring up
the past. Look to future behavior changes for all parties.
He who bravely dares must sometimes risk a fall.
Share your knowledge. It's a way to achieve immortality.
Nothing draws a crowd like a crowd.
Be careful of black-tongued dogs.
Time and money are interchangeable. You can always save one by spending
more of the other.
Mind your own business.
Once a year, go someplace you've never been before.
Put 10% of every earned dollar immediately into investments. If you make a
lot of money, put it to use helping others while you are living; that is
wealth's greatest satisfaction.
Remember that not getting what you want is sometimes a stroke of luck.
Learn the rules, then break some. Call it a test!
Appendix A 137
The most fatal illusion is the settled point of view. Life is growth and motion.
A veterinarian's purpose is to give the client peace of mind while the disease
takes its course in the patient.
Everyone has creative potential; the unique expression of yourself is the be-
ginning.
Be part of the healing team; be positive about opportunities and challenges.
"What if I spent money on training an employee, and then they leave?" What
if you don't, and they stay?
The person who says it cannot be done should not interrupt the person
doing it.
There's never time to do it right, but there's always time to do it over.
Read more books, and watch less TV.
You're more likely to receive forgiveness than permission.
Try a thing you haven't done three times: once, to get over the fear of doing
it; twice, to learn how to do it; and a third time to figure out whether you
like it or not.
Profit is not a four-letter word.
Success =attitude + training + vision + procedure
A failure to plan is a plan to fail.
Plan your work. Work your plan.
None of us is as important as all of us.
You can't manage what you don't measure.
You can't expect what you don't inspect.
Management by intimidation brings compliance, but it does not bring
commitment.
Don't believe all you hear, spend all you have, or sleep all you want.
Remember that great love and great achievements involve great risk.
Be gentle with the earth.
Have a life outside practice. Love deeply and passionately. You might get
hurt, but it's the only way to live life completely.
You can teach someone to talk nice, but you can't teach someone to be nice!
Appendix A 139
B
behavior: the actions people take, or the things they say, while coping with
other people, problems, opportunities, and situations
benchmarking: otherwise known as brain-picking; using all the brains you
can beg, borrow, or steal
body language: nonverbal body movements, facial expressions, or gestures
that may project and reveal underlying attitudes and sentiments; may
convey a message similar to, or different from, the words used
141
142 Appendix B
c
catchment area: primary geographical areas served by an institution; demo-
graphic area from which clients come
commitment: the individual team member's belief and investment in the
practice's core values, his or her job role, and the feedback process
communication method: the form or technique by which information is com-
municated; includes attitude, performance, appearance, speech, demon-
stration, and deed
communication process: the verbal and nonverbal giving and receiving of in-
formation and understanding as a result of thinking, doing, observing,
talking, listening, writing, and reading; exchange between two or more
people, leading to a desired action or attitude
core values: personal standards of excellence and philosophy of operations
that underlie all decisions; inviolate beliefs of a leader on which others
also can depend
CQ/: continuous quality improvement; embraces change in a never-ending
quest for improved healthcare delivery
D
decision making: evaluating alternative solutions and making a choice
among them; part of the problem-solving process
delegation: the assignment to others of organizational responsibilities or
obligations along with appropriate practice authority, power, and rights
division of work: the principle that performance is more efficient when a
large job is broken down into smaller, specialized jobs
E
employee-centered supervision: management emphasis on a genuine con-
cern and respect for staff members as human beings and on maintaining
effective relationships within a work group
Appendix B 143
F
facilitating: assisting and guiding others in their efforts to perform their jobs,
rather than emphasizing orders and instructions
feedback: some return of the output of a mechanism, process, or system, as
input; informative reaction or response
free association of ideas: the ability of the mind to unconsciously visualize
relationships between seemingly different objects and ideas ("brain
storming")
G
grapevine: informal network that staff members use to convey informa-
tion of interest to them; fast, but lacks a high degree of accuracy and
reliability
group dynamics: the interaction among members of a work group and
concurrent changes in their attitudes, behavior, and relationships;
similarly, the interaction between a work group and others outside the
group
H
halo effect: a generalization whereby one aspect of performance, or a single
quality of an individual's nature, is allowed to overshadow everything
else about that person
healthcare: the medical, dental, or veterinary delivery of services, products,
and empathy
HEAP: history, evaluation, assessment, plan; one way to organize medical
records
human-relations management: an approach that seeks to stimulate coopera-
tion via understanding of, and genuine concern for, staff members as in-
dividuals and as critical elements of a work group
144 Appendix B
I
infinity model: a leadership and management single-flow diagram; a process,
not a program; starts as a total commitment by the leaders, and grows
toward endless possibilities
inner strength: internal values and beliefs a person possesses that allow con-
fidence and determination in outward activities
J
jargon: the technical terminology or characteristic idiom of a special activity
or group; used within a practice team, but seldom appropriate for use
with clients or outside the practice
job aids: materials on or near the work area to help employees remember
key points (what to do and how to do it) and perform effectively
job role: the team member's part in the practice's operational environment
L
leader: someone who gives credit and takes blame; gets things done through
other people
litigious: inclined toward involvement in lawsuits
M
management development: a systematic program to improve the knowledge,
attitudes, and skills of supervisors and managers
manager: an individual who plans, organizes, directs, and controls the work
of others in an organization
mentor: a knowledgeable, often influential, individual who takes an interest
in, and advises, another person to assist in making them successful
mind mapping: obtaining as many "wild and crazy" ideas as possible in a
short period of time
modeling: the process in which a skilled coworker or supervisor demon-
strates the performance of a key job skill and simultaneously explains
the steps involved and the reasons for doing them; in management, also
a graphic representation of a system
motivation: highly individual needs for survival, security, companionship,
respect, achievement, power, growth, and personal worth that impel a
person to behave in a certain manner
Appendix B 145
o
objectives: also referred to as goals and standards; the short-term and long-
term targets toward which an organization strives
ogre: the doctor after a 22-hour shift
outer strength: elements of management and personality that are displayed
to others in the practice's operational environment
p
Q
quality assurance: establishing milestones and outcome accountabilities for
a plan and spot-checking measurements of success toward the end
result(s)
quality control: an aggregate of activities designed to ensure that a process is
followed with a high degree of consistency
quality of work life: the idea that work must be psychologically and spiritu-
ally, as well as materially, rewarding
quick fix: an expedient, often inadequate, solution to a problem
R
regulations: special rules, orders, and controls set by an authority to restrict
the conduct of individuals or organizations
responsibility: a duty or obligation to perform a prescribed task or service or
to attain a specified objective
s
satisfaction: the state that exists when truly motivating factors are provided,
such as interesting and challenging work, full use of one's capabilities,
and recognition for achievement
SOAP: subjective, objective, assessment, plan; one way of organizing med-
ical records
stasis: act or condition of standing or stopping; in healthcare, it equals stag-
nation
stress: on- or off-job pressures that place a burden on an individual's physi-
cal, mental, and nervous system
succession planning: the evolution of practice ownership
Appendix B 147
T
TQM: total quality management; improvement movement in industry
TQSITMS: total quality service/total management service; "copy-cat" man-
agement ideas of lateral organizations trying to reinvent TQMlCQI
u
unity ofdirection: the principle that there should be a set of goals and objec-
tives that unifies the activities of everyone in an organization
v
values: a set of personal beliefs that form the foundation for life decisions
w
work: that four-letter word for employment; provides the means to pay the
bills
Some terms were adapted from Bittel LR, Newstrom JW: What Every Supervisor Should
Know, 6th ed. New York, McGraw-Hili, 1990.
APPENDIXC:
STAFF TRAINING & ORIENTATION FORMS
149
150 Appendix C
monthly
yearly
9. Provide feedback to your supervisor about the process
of orientation and the ideas and techniques learned during
this phase of your training
10. View the following AAHA training films and workbooks:
Understanding Client Pet Loss
Counseling Clients'
The Loss of Your Pet
15. View the following AAHA video training tapes and workbooks:
Dental Prophylaxis
Bereavement Counseling
APPENDIX D:
READING LIST
159
160 Appendix D
Costello, Bill. Awaken Your Birdbrain. LeBoeuf, Michael. The Greatest Man-
Bowie, MD, Thinkorporated, 1998. agement Principle in the WorLd.
Kravetz, Dennis J. The Human Re- New York, Berkley Books, 1985.
sources RevoLution: Implementing
Progressive Management Practices NEW TACTICS FOR
for Bottom-Line Success. San Fran- MANAGERS
cisco, Jossey-Bass, 1988.
Bardwick, Judith M. Danger in the
Levering, Robert. A Great Place to Comfort Zone: From Boardroom
Work. New York, Random House, to Mailroom-How to Break the
1988. EntitLement Habit That's Killing
Matejka, Ken E. Why This Horse Won't American Business. New York,
Drink: How to Win and Keep Em- AMACOM,1991.
pLoyee Commitment. New York, Bittel, Lester R., and John W. Newstrom.
American Management Association, What Every SupervisorShouLd Know,
1991. 6th ed. NewYork,McGraw-Hili, 1990.
Roethlisberger, Fritz Jules. Management Horton, R., and Peter C. Reid. Beyond
and Morale. Cambridge, MA, Har- the Trust Gap: Forging a New Part-
vard University Press, 1941. nership Between Managers and
von Oech, Roger. A Kick in the Seat of Their Employees. Homewood, IL,
the Pants. New York, Harper and Business One Irwin, 1991.
Row, Perennial Library, 1986.
Leebov, Wendy, and Gail Scott. HeaLth-
care Managers in Transition. San
MANAGEMENT SKILLS Francisco, Jossey- Bass, 1990.
THAT WORK Shonk, James H. Team-Based Organi-
Douglass, Merrill, et al. Manage Your zation:Developing a Successful Team
Time, Your Work, Yourself. New Environment. Homewood, IL, Busi-
York, AMACOM, 1993. ness One Irwin, 1992.
Jellison, Jerald M. Overcoming Resist-
ance: A Practical Guide to Pro- REACH YOUR CUSTOMERS
ducing Change in the Work Place.
New York, Simon and Schuster, Albrecht, Karl, and Lawrence J. Brad-
1993. ford. The Service Advantage: How
to Identify and Fulfill Customer
Kaplan, Robert E. Beyond Ambition: Needs. Homewood, IL, Dow Jones-
How Driven Managers Can Lead Irwin, 1990.
Better and Live Better. San Fran-
cisco, Jossey-Bass, 1991. Carlzon, Jan. Moments of Truth. Cam-
bridge, MA, Ballinger, 1987.
Katzenbach, Jon R., and Douglas K.
Smith. The Wisdom ofTeams: Creat- Connellan, Thomas K., and Ron Zemke.
ing the High-Performance Organi- Sustaining Knock-Your-Socks-Off
zation. Boston, Harvard Business Service. New York, AMACOM,
School Press, 1993. 1993.
162 Appendix D
Davidow, William H., and Bro Uttal. Seiwert, Lothar J. Time Is Money: Save
Total Customer Service: The Ulti- It. Homewood, IL, Dow Jones-Irwin ,
mate Weapon. New York, Harper 1989.
and Row, 1989.
Webber, Ross Arkell. Becoming a Coura-
LeBoeuf, Michael. How to Win Custo- geous Manager: Overcoming Career
mers and Keep Them for Life. New Problems of New Managers. Engle-
York, Berkley Books, 1987. wood Cliffs, NJ, Prentice Hall, 1991.
163
164 Index