Distributed Generation Roundtable
Distributed Generation Roundtable
discussion paper
www.pwc.com/utilities
Contents
Introduction 3
The growth and challenges of distributed energy
resources 4
Financing – developments in PPA-based
distributed generation 6
Technological transformation and the growth
of storage in energy 8
The roundtable
Senior executives and experts from 16 countries and four continents gathered for
a PwC roundtable on market design in Madrid. The event brought together leading
players with substantial experience from the regulatory and corporate spheres to discuss
the regulatory, commercial and technological barriers to implementing distributed
generation and integrating renewables into the grid.
Jeroen van Hoof, Global Leader, Power & Utilities, Assurance, PwC Netherlands
Steve Hunter, Senior Project Developer and PPA Leader - EMEA, GE Renewable Energy
Carlos Fernandez Landa, Global Leader, Power & Utilities Renewables, PwC Spain
Jan Teichmann, VP, Global Markets, Fluence, a Siemens and AES Company
Ken Zagzebski, President, AES Southland Energy and Executive Chairman of the Board,
Indianapolis Power & Light Company and Dayton Power and Light Company
Introduction
Distributed generation is The roundtable brought together leading
figures from the utilities sector to discuss these
a fast-growing feature of challenges, the lessons learnt so far and to look
modern electricity systems. at what the future might bring, not just the
It is transforming the technological and sector impact that lies ahead
but the possible financial mechanisms of the
traditional centralised grid future as well. The roundtable event is part of
model and, in parts of the PwC’s industry programme for power & utilities
world without developed grid companies worldwide. This report focuses its
summary of the roundtable discussion on:
systems, it offers leapfrog • Growth – meeting the challenges of
opportunities to increase distributed energy resources
access to electricity. • Financing – developments in PPA- (power
purchase agreement) based distributed
But the complexities – generation
technological, regulatory, • Technological transformation and the growth
of storage in energy
commercial and financial – of
integrating renewables and
distributed generation into the
grid are immense. They carry
wide sector impact and require
fresh thinking about company
business models and the
role of grids. “It’s a ‘burning
platform’ issue for utilities
globally,” observed Norbert
Schwieters, PwC’s Global
Power & Utilities Leader as he
welcomed participants to the
roundtable event.
Q&A
very promising but it raises the risk My concern is what looks good today is
that today’s investments may have not going to look good ten years from now.
a much shorter working life than So the critical criterion that I’m asking
one actually expects. How do you my team to use is that it has it has to add
respond to that risk? customer value. If you’re not looking
Technology Jean Rappe, CEO, Engie Solar:
specifically at customer value, whether it’s
a transmission line or distribution assets, I
investment risk That’s why PPAs are important. Without
PPAs, investors would need to assume
think you have got a real risk of stranded
investments.
much faster amortisation cost because
the pace of technological progress is such Mark McCullough, EVP Generation,
that investments are rapidly becoming American Electric Power:
obsolete. The PPAs provide for long- We see evidence in the media quite often
term stable revenue, making it possible today where large investment has been
to reduce the cost of capital and make the cause of write-offs and so forth. This
renewables more competitive. One good points us more towards smaller solutions
thing about renewables that investors like like distributed generation and I couldn’t
is that variable costs are very low. Once agree more with the statement about
you have invested, there is very little cost customer value; it has to be the highest
to run, so the likelihood of you not being customer value solution for it to work.
able to sell your production is zero.
Q&A
seeing more like ten years. Developers
Weero Koster, Partner Energy, would love to see 20, but they’re just not
Sustainability & Climate Change, being written at the moment, so ten years
Aeolian: Yes, depending on different is about the maximum in Australia.
markets. In the Nordics we see PPAs
Longevity of that are much shorter. Speaking about
my home market in the Netherlands, the
Steve Hunter, Senior VP Global
Markets Development, GE: Around ten
PPAs PPA market is still very much driven by
subsidies. Subsidy schemes are 15 years
years is about the minimum if you want to
finance a new-build project. We’re trying
so the PPAs are based on the length of the to work on opportunities where we could
subsidy. Fifteen years is very difficult for perhaps bundle some ten-year volume and
most of the corporate clients. What I’m some shorter volume and see if we can still
going for is trying to make the product get the project past financial close on that
more liquid, so that at least you can basis. But that increases the complexity so
get out of the PPA by transferring it to goes against the simplification that we’re
somebody else. You need to go into an trying to achieve.
investment with the exit in mind.
Companies are responding to the Greenlots, whose SKY platform aims Markets, Fluence, explained: “We are
pace of technological change with the to provide real-time charger health focusing on projects greater than 1MW,
launch of new business units, new status, utilisation data, dynamic so what you would generally define as
partnerships and a stronger emphasis pricing capabilities and a seamless utility grid scale. Nobody buys storage
on collaborative working across and charging experience for EV customers. just because it looks good. It is only if
beyond the traditional boundaries of the “The Greenlots business model is to there is an economic case.” To date,
sector. One such example is the coalition whiteboard this for the utility company over 500MW of Fluence storage has
of power industry and other partners or the automaker based on open been deployed or been awarded in 16
that are backing Energy Impact Partners standards,” said Fitzgerald. different countries around the world.
(EIP), a US-based investment platform
that seeks to invest in emerging trends, Fitzgerald outlined another key The advantages of storage are widely
new technologies and innovative investment theme: “There’s so much recognised in relation to integrating
business models to build a better energy inefficiency in the system that we renewables into the grid, but Teichmann
future. believe there is a ton of opportunity explained how storage also makes
in the digitisation of the grid. We lose economic sense in a wide variety of
EIP’s Chief Utility Officer Kevin between 60 to 70% of the product situations. Storage for reliability,
Fitzgerald told the roundtable: “The before it is finally consumed. Utilities frequency, resilience and critical power
network that we have behind us makes can create substantial customer value security are among the reasons for
it the largest clean energy network on in core grid infrastructure through deploying storage, as well as the obvious
the planet.” He explained that one of optimisation of the platform. And that one of adding an on-demand capability
the themes driving their investment may be done with all the new tools in to renewables. Energy cost control is
strategy is that the renewable energy the tool kit, like distributed generation, another motivation for customers of
transition and DER proliferation will battery storage, EV charging etc.” battery storage. In Finland, Fluence has
go hand in hand. He outlined EIP’s installed 1.6MW of storage in a Helsinki
investment in two companies, AutoGrid Electricity storage, long viewed as shopping centre, enabling the customer
and Opus One, as examples of creating the holy grail for the power industry, to cut grid consumption at times of peak
the software pillars that will be needed is coming of age with utility-scale prices.
for a DER-rich grid. storage solutions being deployed at an
increasing rate. One of the companies In other situations, storage is integral
Electric vehicles will be a key element leading the storage charge is Fluence, a to energy security. For example, storage
in a future DER world. EIP is an investor joint venture collaboration between AES can be used for black start recovery
in EV-charging software company and Siemens. Jan Teichmann, VP, Global of gas-fired generation, getting it
Q&A
platforms. Do we need to consider we need to think as network orchestrators
splitting up roles and start thinking and as platform businesses. Look at
about a distribution owner and a other sectors, what happened in tourism,
system operator at the distribution mobility, real estate. There are network
level? orchestrators that are eating margins of
Implications Leonardo Benítez, Head of Utilities,
traditional capex-intensive players and
it’s clear that when it comes to energy
of distribution Indra: I do believe that will be the future.
The DSO will become a platform operator,
we have to go in the same direction. I
think today the energy business, also the
networks as generating a playing field where there
will be other companies, new companies
energy solution business, is still a pipeline
business. We generate leads, we develop
platforms coming in and offering new services. solutions and then we sell, implement and
operate those solutions. I think we need
Jan Teichmann, VP, Global Markets, to move to the next level because we want
Fluence: I’m not sure that something to be less capital-intensive, we want to
like this should be forced. I think some move to a softer intelligent solution. So
regulatory topics are too complicated for the direction is clear but the jury is still
change to be forced. It needs to evolve. out on how we are going to get there.
platform” – e-City, e-Home, e-Industries and “The grid is becoming more complex
e-Mobility. Eliano Russo heads up the and growing faster than existing
Kevin Fitzgerald, Chief Utility e-Industries division, providing a range control methods and tools can
Officer, Energy Impact Partners of energy efficiency and distributed handle,” observed Benitez. “We
generation technology services and need fundamental changes in how
the creation of off-grid and demand we monitor and control a far more
response solutions. complex system. Utilities need real-time
monitoring and control infrastructure
Enel’s acquisition of Enernoc has helped to achieve situational awareness. The
to secure its position as a demand Industrial IoT is a key technology which
response aggregator: “We are managing will enable utilities to have visibility on
more than 6GW of demand response what’s happening in the medium to low
capacity” said Russo. “It’s changing the voltage, to be able to control, react, and
customer relationship substantially. be able to do things like self-healing.”
Greece
Territory contacts Vangellis Markopoulos Middle East and Africa
Telephone: +30 210 6874035
Asia-Pacific Email: vangellis.markopoulos@gr.pwc.com Middle East
Australia Jonty Palmer
Mark Coughlin Ireland Telephone: +971 56 683 8192
Telephone: +61 3 8603 0009 Kim McClenaghan Email: jonty.palmer@pwc.com
Email: mark.coughlin@pwc.com Telephone: +353 7920 6912
Email: kim.a.mcclenaghan@ie.pwc.com Anglophone & Lusophone Africa
China John Gibbs
Lisa B Wang Israel Telephone: +27 11 797 4461
Telephone: +86 10 6533 2729 Eitan Glazer Email: john.gibbs@pwc.com
Email: binhong.wang@cn.pwc.com Telephone: +972 3 7954 830
Email: eitan.glazer@il.pwc.com Francophone Africa
India Noel Albertus
Kameswara Rao Italy Telephone: +33 1 5657 8507
Telephone: +91 40 6624 6688 Giovanni Poggio Email: noel.albertus@fr.pwc.com
Email: kameswara.rao@in.pwc.com Telephone: +39 06 570252588
Email: giovanni.poggio@it.pwc.com The Americas
Indonesia Argentina/Latin America
Sacha Winzenried Netherlands Ezequiel Mirazon
Telephone: +62 21 52890968 Viviana Kooistra-Voorwald Telephone: +54 11 4850 4714
Email: sacha.winzenried@id.pwc.com Telephone: +31 (0)88 792 33 53 Email: ezequiel.mirazon@ar.pwc.com
Email: viviana.voorwald@pwc.com
Japan Brazil
Yoichi Y Hazama Norway Roberto Correa
Telephone: +81 90 5428 7743 Hildegunn Naas-Bibow Telephone: +55 31 3269 1525
Email: yoichi.y.hazama@pwc.com Telephone: +47 9526 0118 Email: roberto.correa@pwc.com
Email: hildegunn.naas-bibow@pwc.com
Korea Canada
Lee-Hoi Doh Poland Brian R. Poth
Telephone: + 82 2 709 0246 Piotr Luba Telephone: +1 416 687 8522
Email: lee-hoi.doh@kr.pwc.com Telephone: +48227464679 Email: brian.r.poth@pwc.com
Email: piotr.luba@pwc.com
Europe Mexico
Austria Portugal Eduardo Reyes Bravo
Michael Sponring Joao Ramos Tel: +34 915 684 400
Telephone: +43 1 501 88 2935 Telephone: +351 213 599 296 Email: eduardo.reyes.bravo@mx.pwc.com
Email: michael.sponring@pwc.com Email: joao.ramos@pt.pwc.com
United States
Michael A. Herman
Telephone: +1 312.298.4462
Email: michael.a.herman@pwc.com
2018 PwC. All rights reserved. Definition: PwC refers to the PwC network and/or one or more of its member firms, each of which is a separate legal entity. Please see
www.pwc.com/structure for further details. This content is for general information purposes only, and should not be used as a substitute for consultation with
professional advisors. At PwC, our purpose is to build trust in society and solve important problems. We’re a network of firms in 157 countries with more than 223,000
people who are committed to delivering quality in assurance, advisory and tax services. Find out more and tell us what matters to you by visiting us at www.pwc.com.