Computer Standards & Interfaces: Yung Fu Chang, C.S. Chen, Hao Zhou
Computer Standards & Interfaces: Yung Fu Chang, C.S. Chen, Hao Zhou
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: This paper surveys most of the currently available smart phones in the market. It summarizes its features and
Received 5 December 2006 characteristics. From this study a set of must-have and desirable-to-have features for future generations of
Received in revised form 20 August 2008 smart phones are described. The main drivers of smart phones that enable convenient and secure mobile
Accepted 28 September 2008
commerce services such as electronic wallet, electronic payment, 3G broadband Internet access, and
Available online 26 October 2008
multimedia content are then described. Finally, payer-centric payment architecture is advocated to facilitate
Keywords:
the adoption of smart phones for mobile commerce applications, in contrast to the current prevalent mode of
Smart phone payee-centric payment practice.
M-commerce © 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Electronic wallet
Electronic payment
Payer-centric payment
0920-5489/$ – see front matter © 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.csi.2008.09.016
Y.F. Chang et al. / Computer Standards & Interfaces 31 (2009) 740–747 741
Listed below are nineteen recommended features for the ideal computer and make use of the work done on both devices also
smart phone. The first eleven are must-have and the last eight are becomes essential. Here are some of the popular synchronization
desirable-to-have features. technologies:
i. HotSync — HotSync is the registered trade name for a sophis-
1. Multi-tasking operating system ticated method of linking between a Palm handheld computer
To satisfy the multi-tasking, multi-application nature of the smart and a more substantial notebook, desktop, or other computer.
phone, a multi-tasking operating system is the absolute necessary Such a link can be done using a so-called HotSync cable, or
foundation. The current popular operating systems such as iMac using a wireless connection.
OS.X, Symbian, Microsoft Windows Mobile, Palm, and Linux all ii. ActiveSync — ActiveSync is a synchronization program devel-
have multitasking characteristics. oped by Microsoft Corporation. The purpose of the program is
2. Powerful SOC application processor and DSP communication to synchronize files, favorites, Personal Information Manager
processor Data etc. between a Windows PC and a PDA running Windows
Multi-tasking operating system won't go too far without the support Mobile or Windows CE for handheld PC or for Palm-size PC.
of a powerful processor. Multi-tasking calls for more and more pow- iii. SyncML — SyncML (Synchronization Markup Language) is the
erful application specific processors and DSP (Digital Signal former name (currently referred to as: Open Mobile Alliance Data
Processing) communication processors. Three classes of processors Synchronization and Device Management) for a platform-
need to be incorporated as the brain into the smart phone. The first independent information synchronization standard.
one is the radio processor for cellular communication function. The 10. Voice communication and voice-mail
second one is the DSP processor for streaming media capability. The Smart phone, being a phone, still needs to support these basic
third one is the data processor for data manipulation and general vocal call features.
device control functions. Here are some of the example combina- 11. WiFi for VoIP and Bluetooth for cable replacement
tions used in today's smart phones: Due to its free or low cost, phones with integrated Wi-Fi and VoIP
i. Intel XScale (ARM core) and MicroSignal (using ADI DSP core) capabilities are being introduced into the market and have the
ii. TI OMAP and OMAP2 (ARM core and TI DSP core) potential to replace land line telephone services. Smart phones that
iii. IBM cell processor. support WiFi are best suited for local use such as corporate or home
3. Real QWERTY keyboard networks. Bluetooth enables hand free operation of the smart
For e-mail, SMS, IM, a real QWERTY keyboard is a must-have feature. phone, as well as communication with other computing devices.
Here are some of the popular forms of the smart phone keyboard: 12. Gaming
i. Two hands holding and two thumbs typing According to Ziff Davis Media's Annual “Digital Gaming in
ii. One hand holding and one thumb of holding hand typing America” [6], cell phone gaming continued its meteoric rise in
iii. One hand holding and one thumb of other hand typing. 2005: the number of households engaged in cell phone gaming
4. QVGA or larger display with high screen resolution nearly doubled again, jumping from 16.3 million in 2004 to
Larger display with high resolution is needed, especially for web 27.9 million in 2005. Gaming is a desirable-to-have feature, ex-
browsing, MMS, gaming, etc. Here are some of the examples: tending the smart phone usage and potentially replacing another
i. Palm 650 has a screen with 320 × 320 resolution at dedicated gaming gadget.
44 mm× 44 mm, which is 7.2 pixels/mm density 13. Camera
ii. HP 6315 has a screen with 240 × 320 resolution at Without question, camera phones have rapidly become a staple of
54 mm× 72 mm, which is 4.4 pixels/mm density the mobile phone market. According to InfoTrends [5], by 2009,
iii. HP 6515 has a screen with 240 × 240 resolution at 85% of the mobile phones shipped throughout the world will
56 mm × 56 mm, which is 4.3 pixels/mm include an embedded digital camera. Same trend should apply for
iv. Apple iPhone has a 3.5 inch screen with 480 × 320 resolutions at smart phones.
50.8 mm × 76.2 mm, which is 6.4 pixels/mm. 14. File management and manipulation
5. Internet access at 2.5G or 3G speed With the added capability for taking and storing pictures, playing
To be able to serve e-mails, web browsing, multi-media audio/ music, movies, as well as running business application tools,
video streaming, Internet broadband access at 2.5G or 3G is a comes with the need for file management and manipulation.
must-have feature. 15. Video/audio streaming
6. Business productivity tool Video and audio streaming is another desirable-to-have feature,
As smart phones are replacing notebooks and PDAs, they must extending the smart phone usage and potentially replacing
have application software and corporate database access for another dedicated viewing gadget.
business information including business metrics, real-time busi-
ness events update, sales and financial information, and inventory
information for product availability.
7. E-mail, SMS, MMS, IM services
These become the basic features of a mobile phone and business/
personal tools for the digital age. According to a Yankee Group study
[4], wireless e-mail has transitioned from a nice-to-have to a must-
have application in many enterprises, which is driving adoption of
wireless data solutions. Needless to say, they are must-have features.
8. Personal Information Management (PIM)
Features like Phonebook, appointment book, task-book, notes,
and calculator are the basic features of PDA, hence these are must-
have features for smart phones, if the smart phones are positioned
to replace PDAs.
9. Host synchronization
With the increasing functionality of the smart phone, such as e-mails,
PIM, business tools, the ability to synchronize with another host Fig. 1. 2007 global handset market share.
742 Y.F. Chang et al. / Computer Standards & Interfaces 31 (2009) 740–747
Over the years, form factors of the smart phones went through a lot of
changes, with the constant trend toward compactness, more feature
packing, and convenience. But they are coming all in two basic types:
clamshell and bar. Clamshell, a.k.a., folder phone, is a form resembling
the shell of a clam, with the ability to open up in the same way. Most
clamshell phones have a feature called Active Flip, which means that
calls can be answered and ended by simply opening and closing the
phone. Bar, a.k.a. candy-bar or block, is the most basic style. The entire
phone is one solid monolith, with no moving parts aside from the
Fig. 2. Motorola V3.
buttons and possibly antenna.
The following are four of the most popular form factors by today's
smart phones:
16. Music player and mobile TV
Having the ability to play music or movie is a desirable-to-have 1. Clamshell Vertical (Clamshell-V)
feature, extending the smart phone usage and potentially replacing Clamshell-V is the style of the phones that flip vertically. This is one
another dedicated gadget, such as an MP3 player and handheld TV. of the most popular styles, as preferred by its compactness, ability
17. GPS and navigation to fit into small pockets, etc. A good example is Motorola V3, as
Having the ability to serve as a GPS system and provide navigation shown in Fig. 2. Ideal size is 50 × 100 × 12 mm.
help is a desirable-to-have feature, extending the smart phone 2. Clamshell Horizontal (Clamshell-H)
usage and potentially replacing another dedicated gadget. Clamshell-H is the style of the phones that flip horizontally. Closest
18. Open standard IO communication and storage expansion example is Nokia 9300, as shown in Fig. 3. Ideal size is
Some new smart phones feature built-in expansion card slots that 50 × 110 × 20 mm.
support SD, SDIO, and MMC formats. SD and MMC enable smart 3. Bar
phone users to add instant memory. SDIO card enables smart phone Inherited from their ancestor bar type basic voice phones, today's
users to connect peripherals such as a navigation system, Wi-Fi (IEEE smart phones are bigger in size. Some of the closest examples are:
802.11b) card, credit-card reader and printer, bar-code reader, or RFID HP6315, HP 6515, RIM 7100, Palm 650, BenQ P50 and Motorola Q, as
readers. All of these extend the smart phone for extended usages. shown in Fig. 4. Ideal size is 50 × 110 × 16 mm.
19. RFID and biometric features like fingerprint 4. Bar with slide QWERTY keyboard
RFID (Radio Frequency Identification) is beginning to be deployed These bar type smart phones are equipped with a sliding QWERTY
in large enterprises and retailers. Having the ability to read RFID or keyboard, for complex applications that require keyboard input.
The closest example: Samsung i730, Siemens SX66, as shown in 3. Palm Treo 650 (Fig. 7)
Fig. 5. Ideal size is 50 × 100 × 18 mm. - High resolution 320 × 320 LCD display.
4. HP 6315 (Fig. 8)
5. Smart phone supplier with unique features - HP's first cellular wireless Pocket PC
- Onboard Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, making it the first Pocket PC to
In this section, a few smart phones from various suppliers with incorporate all three wireless standards.
some unique features are profiled: 5. HP 6515 (Fig. 9)
- First device with 240 × 240 pixels squire display with
1. Nokia 9300
2.205×2.205 in. screen
- Clamshell-H, as shown in Fig. 3
- Has a full functional GPS receiver and free mapping software
- Full QWERTY keyboard
- An integrated thumb QWERTY keyboard.
- Symbian OS v7.0s.
6. Samsung i730 (Fig. 10)
2. RIM Blackberry 7100 (Fig. 6)
It is Samsung's first PDA phone with EV-DO high-speed data, first
- Thumbwheel
with a slide-out QWERTY mini-keyboard, and first with built-in
- No touch panel
Wi-Fi.
- 2-alpha/key Suretype for QWERTY vs. 1 alpha/key full QWERTY
7. Siemens SX66 (Fig. 11)
or 3 alpha/key traditional phone dial-pad
- HTC's third generation Pocket PC phone. HTC designs and/or
- E-mail server push.
manufactures many fine PDAs and smart phones, including
several HP iPAQ Pocket PCs, the Treo 650 and the Audiovox
SMT5600.
Fig. 9. HP 6515.
Phone brand Battery Battery weight (g) Rest of unit weight (g)
Nokia 9300 970 mAh Li-Polymer 21 149
Sony-Ericsson Z500A 700 mAh Li-Polymer 16 95
BenQ P50 1240 mAh Li-Ion 32 148
BenQ P30 (UIQ) 1050 mAh Li-Polymer 30 119
Palm 650 1900 mAh Li-Ion 42 134
RIM 7100 950 mAh Li-Ion [122]
HP 6315 1800 mAh Li-Ion [190]
HP6515 1200 mAh Li-Ion [165]
Motorola RAZR V3 710 mAh Li-Ion 16 86
Motorola Q 1130 mAh Li-Ion [115]
Apple iPhone 1400 mAh Li-Ion
4. Other one-time payments, such as downloading of digital contents, electronic fund transfer and can clear much faster than paper
purchasing of service, etc. check. Typically, it involves the use of ACH.
The payment mechanisms used by M-commerce are mostly the same The motivating factors for using smart phones in mobile com-
as those listed below used in a more traditional electronic payment merce over the use of desktop or notebook PC can be summarized
environment: below:
1. Electronic cash — the electronic cash systems replicate the cash
1. Convenience; consumers can initiate the transaction anytime and
over Internet. Electronic Cash, Digicash, Cybercoin and Netcach [8] anywhere on the move at their convenience.
systems
2. Instant notification and delivery via e-mail, SMS, EMS, or IM.
2. Represent the electronic cash systems that are used in E-commerce 3. Ease of use; much simpler to use than a PC.
transactions
4. Time/cost saving; without incurring the time and cost of acquiring
3. Credit card — payment using credit card is the most popular form of and setting up a PC.
electronic payment for cyber shopping
4. Debit card — debit card is similar to credit card in operation from Most of the current electronic payment implementation is payee-
the merchant's point of view, but differs in credit extending from centric system. The system is initiated by merchant payees and the
card holder and banking institution point of view electronic invoices are presented to the payer. This mechanism puts a
5. Smart phone for small amount — sometimes the charge is directly payer in an inconvenient position of having to deal with a number of
billed to the phone number, usually for a small amount purchase, merchant payees one-by-one using mobile device. The inconvenience
such as purchase of music, video, games, etc of the system may well discourage the adoption of the M-commerce
6. E-Check via ACH (Automated Clearing House) — the electronic from the user point of view.
check resembles the ordinary paper check, which triggers an On the other hand if the payment system is payer-centric. The
payer could establish an account with a central clearing house such as
a banking institution or a credit card/debit card company. The payer
then has the ability to make payments to multiple payees through the
central clearing house. The payment transaction is routed to the
appropriate payment processor and the payment status is delivered to
the payer. A secure and reliable ease-of-use payment system is critical
to the wide-spread adoption of M-commerce.
9. Conclusion
In this paper we have examined the more popular smart phones from
various vendors in terms of its features, form factor, weight, and energy
analysis. We then proposed a set of nineteen ideal smart phone features
including eleven must-have and eight desirable-to-have features for the
mobile commerce applications.
For the mobile commerce to become commonplace, its infrastruc-
ture must be built on established habits and practices with add-on
specific mobile values. Keys drivers for its adoption are stated in this
paper as convenience, ease-of-use, security, privacy, and reliability.
The challenge is to implement a secure payment scheme which is
convenient and simple to use. Towards that end, payer-centric pay-
ment architecture is advocated, in contrast to the current prevalent
Fig. 14. Apple iPhone. mode of payee-centric payment practice.
Y.F. Chang et al. / Computer Standards & Interfaces 31 (2009) 740–747 747
This paper is unique in its systematic survey of the most major smart Radio Frequency
Identification: (RFID) is a new transponder technology for the contactless
phones and their use in mobile commerce. It focuses on proposing must- recognition of object using devices called RFID tags. An RFID tag
have and desirable-to-have features. It outlines the key drivers of mobile is a small object, such as an adhesive sticker, that can be
commerce, and finally a payer-centric payment application is proposed attached to or incorporated into a product. RFID tags contain
antennas to enable them to receive and respond to radio
as a candidate for mobile commerce platform standard. frequency queries from an RFID transceiver.
Secure Digital: (SD) card is a stamp-sized flash memory card used for extra
storage capacity for data, programs, and music files and is
References easily transferable between a mobile device and a desktop
computer.
[1] Gartner Says Mobile Phone Sales Will Exceed One Billion in 2009, http://www. Secure digital
gartner.com/press_releases/asset_132473_11.html. input/output: (SDIO) card slots accept not only memory but also expansion
[2] Smart phone sales to reach 126 m units by 2009, ARC Group, 15 November, 2004. hardware such as Bluetooth short range wireless standard
[3] http://www.strategicanalytics.com. adaptors.
[4] http://www.informationweek.com/story/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=53701337, Short Message Service: (SMS) is a wireless messaging service for sending alphanu-
Mobile Pipeline News, Nov. 22, 2004. meric messages to a wireless phone.
[5] http://store.infotrendsresearch.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=65326, User Interface IQ: (UIQ) is a user-interface platform for Symbian OS-based smart
Worldwide Camera Phone and Photo Messaging Forecast: 2004–2009. phones.
[6] http://www.mobiledia.com/news/34942.html, Mobile Gaming Doubles Again. Extensible Markup
[7] Andreeff et al., Electronic bill presentment and payment — Is it just a click away? Language: (XML) is a World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) recommen-
Economic Perspectives, 4Q/2001. dation for creating special-purpose markup languages.
[8] Dani, Krishna, An E-Check Framework for Electronic payment Systems in the Web
Based Environment, EC-Web 2001, LNCS 2115, 2001, pp. 91–100.
Dr. Yung-Fu Chang is CEO of AtomID, Inc in Medina, OH and
Adjunct Professor of Electrical and Computer Engineering
Department at Miami University in Oxford, OH. He served
Glossary recently as CEO of AWID in Morgan Hill, CA and CEO and
Founder of Accelent Systems Inc. in Akron, OH. Previously, he
served as CTO and EVP of Telxon Corporation in Akron, OH.
Third Generation: (3G) is the next generation of wireless technology beyond personal
He received a BSEE degree from National Taiwan University in
communication services. 3G promises increased bandwidth, up to
Taipei, Taiwan, an MBA degree from National Chiao-Tung
384 Kbps, when a device is stationery or moving at pedestrian speed,
University in Hsin-Chu, Taiwan, an MSEE degree from the
128 Kbps in a car, and 2 Mbps in fixed applications.
University of Houston in Houston, TX, and a Ph.D. from the
Bluetooth: is a technical industry standard that facilitates communication between
University of Akron in Akron, OH. Dr. Chang was awarded
wireless devices such as mobile phones, personal digital assistants
nine patents in the portable and hand-held computing field
(PDAs), and wireless-enabled laptop or desktop computers and
and received a distinguished Corporate Inventor award from
peripherals.
the National Inventors Hall of Fame in Akron, OH in 1995. He also published multiple
Digital Signal
articles in technical journals. His research interest includes embedded system, wireless
Processor: (DSP) is a circuit that is specially designed for digital signals in processor-
communication, hand-held computing, and platform development of smart phone and
intensive applications, such as wireless communications links.
RFID.
Enhanced Data
GSM Environment: (EDGE) is one of the 3G upgrade options available to GSM networks,
along with GPRS and HSCSD. EDGE is designed to deliver data at rates
up to 384 Kbps and enable the delivery of multimedia and other C.S. Chen is professor and the founding chair of the Electrical
broadband applications to mobile phone and computer users. The and Computer Engineering Department at Miami University in
EDGE standard is built on the existing GSM standard, using the same Oxford, Ohio. Previously he served as the department head and
TDMA frame structure and existing cell arrangements. There will be the interim engineering dean at the University of Akron in
two versions of EDGE, ECSD and EGPRS. Akron, Ohio. He received the BSEE degree from the National
Enhanced General Packet Taiwan University in Taipei, Taiwan, and MSEE and Ph.D. from
Radio Systems: (EGPRS) is a version of EDGE that enhances GPRS data rates. the University of Rochester in Rochester, N.Y. His research
Enhanced Message interests include signal processing, measurement and control.
Service: (EMS) is an extension of SMS that enables the sending of a He was a co-founder of Quatech Inc. Quatech designed and
combination of simple melodies, images, sounds, animations, manufactured data communication, data acquisition and
and formatted text as an EMS message to another EMS- industrial control equipment for test and measurement
compatible phone. industry. He is a member of IEEE (senior membership), ASEE,
General Packet Radio Sigma Xi, Eta Kappa Nu and Tau Beta Pi.
Service: (GPRS) is a radio technology for GSM networks that adds
packet-switching protocols. GPRS promises data rates from
56 up to 114 Kbps.
Hao Zhou is a technical leader working for Cisco Systems,
Global Positioning
Inc. He received a BS Physics degree from Beijing University,
System: (GPS) is a worldwide radio-navigation system that was de-
Beijing, China and an MSEE and MS Physics from the
veloped by the U.S. Department of Defense. GPS is widely used
University of Akron in Akron, Ohio. He also received an
in marine and terrestrial navigation.
MBA degree from the Cleveland State University in Cleve-
Global System for Mobile
land, Ohio. His research interest and area of expertise
Communications: (GSM) is the most widely used digital mobile phone system in
include security, wireless LAN, embedded system, mobile
Europe. GSM is a time division multiplex (TDM) system and is
device, and device management. He is the inventor/co-
implemented on 800, 900, 1800, and 1900 MHz band.
inventor of nine US patent applications and one awarded
Instant Messaging: (IM) is a facility to send and receive instantaneous text
patent in the security, wireless, and management comput-
messages over the Internet.
ing field. He is co-author of multiple IETF RFCs and Internet
Personal Information
drafts. He regularly attends IETF and Open Mobile Alliance
Management: (PIM) programs that store personal and business information
standard organizations.
such as appointments, contacts, notes, lists, and memos.
Quarter video graphics
array: (Quarter VGA or QVGA) is a computer display with 320-×-240
resolution. QVGA displays are used in mobile phones and PDAs,
generally in portrait mode and are referred to as 240-×-320
displays.
QWERTY: is the modern-day layout of letters on most English language
computer and typewriter keyboards. QWERTY keyboards
have Q, W, E, R, T, and Y as the top row from the left.