This document discusses alternatives to microcontrollers for embedded systems applications, including ASICs, CPLDs, FPGAs, DSPs, PLCs, and microprocessors. It provides brief descriptions of each alternative's characteristics, such as speed and flexibility. The document concludes by listing factors to consider when selecting a microcontroller, such as computational power required, programming ease, interfacing needs, and system requirements.
This document discusses alternatives to microcontrollers for embedded systems applications, including ASICs, CPLDs, FPGAs, DSPs, PLCs, and microprocessors. It provides brief descriptions of each alternative's characteristics, such as speed and flexibility. The document concludes by listing factors to consider when selecting a microcontroller, such as computational power required, programming ease, interfacing needs, and system requirements.
Alternatives to µC: ASIC Application Specific Integrated Circuit
Fully-Custom: All layers of the IC are
optimized for the application.
Semi-Custom: Bottom layers are
optimized. “Top layer available.”
EE 260 Lecture 4: Appropriate Microcontroller Use
Alternatives to µC: ASIC • Application Specific Integrated Circuit! • Fully-Custom: All layers of the IC are optimized for the application.! • Semi-Custom: Bottom layers are optimized. “Top layer available.”! • VERY Fast! • Not very flexible. EE 260 Lecture 4: Appropriate Microcontroller Use Alternatives to µC: CPLD • Complex Programmable Logic Device! • in between a PAL and a FPGA! • Logic Block: Macro cell “sea-of-gates”! • Chip contains non-volatile memory! • Fast and somewhat flexible
EE 260 Lecture 4: Appropriate Microcontroller Use
Alternatives to µC: FPGA • Field Programmable Gate Array! • Large interconnection matrix, logic gates, RAM! • May have analog capability e.g., A/D and D/A! • Programmed by a computer (VHDL)
EE 260 Lecture 4: Appropriate Microcontroller Use
Alternatives to µC: DSP • Digital Signal Processor! • Serious number crunching! • Designed around inputs and outputs (digital and analog)! • May include ! • quadrature decoders! • PWM! • Serial Communications EE 260 Lecture 4: Appropriate Microcontroller Use Alternatives to µC: PLC • Programmable Logic Controller! • Designed for Industrial Applications! • Expandable via modules! • Very broad range of capabilities! • Can do centralized or decentralized control! • Often programmed graphically
EE 260 Lecture 4: Appropriate Microcontroller Use
Alternatives to µC: µP • Powerful Processing—math! • Design with certain peripherals in mind! • Not able to directly interface with either analog or digital inputs (excp: audio)! • Significant memory! • Runs an OS! • May be single-board EE 260 Lecture 4: Appropriate Microcontroller Use Alternatives to µC: µC • Arduino (20 varieties)! • MAKE Controller! • PICKAXE! • BASIC Stamp
EE 260 Lecture 4: Appropriate Microcontroller Use
Selection of MCU How do you choose the MCU? • Define the System Requirements! • Choose the processor technology! • List all good candidates! • Finalize the selection
EE 260 Lecture 4: Appropriate Microcontroller Use
System Requirements 1. Computational 7. Interfacing / 14. Timer/Counter Power! Compatibility! Functions! 2. Ease of 8. Overall cost! 15. Handling media! Programming! 9. Versatility! 16. Overall time 3. Speed of required to 10. Communication Operation! assemble! w/other devices! 4. Interrupts! 17. EMI/EMC! 11. Safety! 5. Reconfiguration! 18. Size! 12. Upgradability! 6. Power/Heat! 19. Availability 13. Memory!