Problem Solving
Problem Solving
SOLVING
Thinking
Thinking is perhaps one aspect of our mental activity which continues even
when we are asleep.
The difference between what is thinking and what is not thinking is just our
awareness about the particular thinking process.
Some problems take little time where as some take much time
to solve.
Knowledge-Rich Problems:
Knowledge-Lean Problems:
requires specific knowledge
can be solved (though not
or skill to solve the problem –
always skillfully) by use of
e.g., calculus,
instructions for the task and
computer-programming.
general problem solving skills
– e.g., finding a parking space
in the mall
ACTIVITY
Problem 1
Anagrams: Rearrange the
letters to form a word. (You
Problem 2
can also construct some
Joining dots:
similar words)
Without lifting your pencil
NAGMARA
from the paper, connect all
BOLMPER
nine dots by drawing four
SLEVO
straight lines.
STGNIH
● ● ●
TOLUSONI
● ● ●
● ● ●
Two Kinds of
Problems Ill-structured or
Ill-defined
a problem usually
Well-structured or having multiple
well-defined possible solutions;
a problem having a cannot be solved by
clear cut solution; an algorithm
can be solved by an – E.g., writing a hit
algorithm song or building a
– E.g., crossword career
puzzle or
3x = 2 (solve for x)
WELL-DEFINED PROBLEMS
THE STRATEGIES
OR THE OPERATORS
Plan a solution
Implementing
Strategies and
Evaluating Progress
• Generate-test method
(“trial and error”) – would take too long
The problem solver simply generates
alternative courses of action, not
necessarily in a systematic way, and then
notices in turn whether each
course of action will work.
Involves trying a number of different
solutions and ruling out those that do not
work. This approach can be a good option if
you have a very limited number of options
available. If there are many different
choices, you are better off narrowing down
the possible options using another
problem-solving technique before
attempting trial-and-error.
Plan a solution
Implementing
Strategies and
Evaluating Progress
• Means-end analysis
(a heuristic strategy)
Using this problem-solving strategy does allow
people to simplify complex problems and reduce
the total number of possible solutions to a more
manageable set.
Aims to reduce discrepancy between current
situation and desired goal at multiple
intermediate points
– break problem into sub-goals.
The problem solver analyzes the problem by
viewing the end—the goal being sought —and
then tries to decrease the distance between the
current position in the problem
space and the end goal in that space
.
In some cases, the solution to a
Plan a solution problem can appear as a sudden
Implementing
insight. According to researchers,
Strategies and
Evaluating Progress insight can occur because you realize
Algorithm that the problem is actually similar
An algorithm is a step-by-step procedure to something that you have dealt
that will always produce a correct solution. with in the past, but in most cases,
A mathematical formula is a good example
the underlying mental processes
of a problem-solving algorithm. While an
that lead to insight happen outside
algorithm guarantees an accurate answer, it
is not always the best approach to of awareness.
problem-solving. This strategy is not
practical for many situations because it can
be so time-consuming. For example, if you
were trying to figure out all of the possible
number combinations to a lock using an
algorithm, it would take a very long time!
Plan a solution
Implementing
Strategies and
Evaluating Progress Working backward
The problem solver starts
at the end and tries to
work backward from
there.
Working Forward
The problem solver starts
at the beginning and tries
to solve the problem from
the start to the finish.
HOW TO ACQUIRE
THESE STRATEGIES?
There are at least three
ways to acquire new
In a famous study reported in
problem-solving 1898, Thorndike placed cats in
“puzzle boxes.” The boxes could
operators. We can be opened by various nonobvious
means. For instance, in one box,
acquire new operators by
if the cat hit a latch, the door
discovery, by being told would fall open. The cats, which
were hungry, were rewarded with
about them, or by food when they got out. Initially,
Discover a cat would move about randomly,
observing someone else We might discover how a behaving ineffectively in other
use them. new microwave oven works ways until it happened to hit the
by playing with it and so unlatching device. After
learn a new operator for repeated trials in the same
preparing food. Or a puzzle box, the cats eventually
scientist might discover a arrived at a point where they
new drug that kills bacteria would immediately hit the
and so invent a new operator unlatching device and get out.
for combating infections.
Each of these examples
involves a variety of
reasoning processes.
Learning by Being Told or
by Example
We can acquire new
operators by being told
about them or by observing Analogy
someone else use them.
Is the process by which a problem
It might seem that the most
efficient way to learn new solver extracts the operators used
problem-solving operators to solve one problem and maps
would be simply to be told
about them, but seeing an them onto a solution for another
example is often at least as problem.
effective as being told what
Sometimes, the analogy process
to do.
can be straightforward. For
instance, a student may take the
structure of an example worked
out in a section of a mathematics
text and map it into the solution
for a problem in the exercises at
Problem solving tools are determined by
* the requirements of the problem and
* the amount of time to solve the problem.
There are four basic steps in problem solving regardless of size
or complexity:
2. GENERATING ALTERNATIVES
ALTERNATIVES
4. IMPLEMENTING SOLUTIONS
Complex.
When your problem is simple,
the solution is usually obvious,
Step 1 - Understanding the
and you don't need to follow
Problem.
the four steps we outlined
The key to a good problem
above.
statement is ensuring that you
A complex problem is likely to
deal with the real problem – not its
be complex when it is difficult
symptoms.
to understand due to the web
Use tools to help you ask the right
of interrelated issues. On a
questions, and work through the
more complex problem you will
layers of a problem to uncover
typically take a more formal
what's really going on.
approach to solve your
It is also important to ensure that
problem.
you look at the issue from a
variety of perspectives.
THE PROBLEM-SOLVING
CYCLE
Problem 2. Problem
1.
identification definition and
representation
Do we actually
have a problem? What exactly is
our problem?
THE PROBLEM-SOLVING
3. Strategy formulation: How can
CYCLE
we solve the problem?
in the
For example, better students are more likely than
problem fit poorer students to spend more time in the initial
together? phase, deciding how to solve a problem, and less
time actually solving it. By spending more time in
advance deciding what to do, effective students
are less likely to fall prey to false starts, winding
paths, and all kinds of errors. When a person
allocates more mental resources to planning on a
large scale, he or she is able to save time and
7. Evaluation
THE PROBLEM-SOLVING
CYCLE Did I solve the problem correctly?
Our emotions can influence how we
6. Monitoring
implement the problem-solving
cycle. In groups with participants
Mental Set
A common problem-solving obstacle is
known as a mental set, which is the
tendency people have to only use Assumptions
solutions that have worked in the past When dealing with a problem,
rather than looking for alternative people often make assumptions
ideas. about the constraints and
A mental set can often work as a obstacles that prevent certain
heuristic, making it a useful solutions.
problem-solving tool. However, mental
sets can also lead to inflexibility,
making it more difficult to find
effective solutions.
Incubation
effect
6. Participate in Yoga
The powerful combination of body
awareness, breathing, and meditation
that is required during yoga practice
has been shown to significantly raise
cognitive test scores. Other
results from a University of Illinois
study include shorter reaction times,
more accuracy, and increased
attention.
CREATIVITY:
THINKING OUT
OF THE BOX
You might have wondered at
times how some one for the
first time, thought of acts like
planting a seed, or devising a
wheel, or decorating the walls
of caves with drawings, etc.
There are countless others
whose creativity has led to the
present day scientific and
technological progress that we
now enjoy. Music, painting,
poetry, and other forms of art
that give us pleasure and joy,
are all products of creative
thinking.
Everyone has
the potential Creative thinking can be applied in almost any
to be area of human activity at different levels.
creative. It could be reflected in activities like
- writing,
- teaching,
- cooking,
- enacting roles,
- story telling,
- conversation, dialogues,
- asking questions,
- playing games,
- trying to solve day-to-day problems,
- organizing activities,
- helping others
- resolve conflicts, and so on.
This concept of ‘Everyday Creativity’, which is
reflected in one’s way of perceiving thinking
and problem solving, is different from the
‘special talent creativity’
seen in outstanding creative achievements.
Convergent thinking refers to
Nature of thinking that is required to solve
Creative problems which have only one
Thinking correct answer.
The mind converges to the correct
solution. To illustrate, look at the
question given below. It is based on
Creative thinking is a number series, where you have to
distinguished from other types find the next number. Only one
of thinking by the fact that it right answer is expected.
involves the production of novel Q. 3,6,9….. what will come next?
Ans. 12.
and original ideas or solutions
to problems.
Creative thinking thus refers to
originality and uniqueness of
ideas or solutions that did not
previously exist.
Everyone has
the potential Creative thinking can be applied in almost any
to be area of human activity at different levels.
creative. It could be reflected in activities like
- writing,
- teaching,
- cooking,
- enacting roles,
- story telling,
- conversation, dialogues,
- asking questions,
- playing games,
- trying to solve day-to-day problems,
- organizing activities,
- helping others
- resolve conflicts, and so on.
This concept of ‘Everyday Creativity’, which is
reflected in one’s way of perceiving thinking
and problem solving, is different from the
‘special talent creativity’
seen in outstanding creative achievements.
Now you try to think of certain
questions for which there is no one
right answer but many answers. A few
such questions are given below: Answers to the above questions
• What improvements will you suggest require divergent thinking
in a chair so that it becomes more which is an open-ended thinking
comfortable and aesthetically where the individual can think
pleasing? of different answers to the
• What will happen if examinations questions or problems in terms
are abolished in schools? of her/his experiences. Such
kind of thinking helps in
producing novel and original
ideas.
Divergent
thinking
Abilities generally
include fluency,
flexibility,
originality, and
elaboration.
Divergent
thinking
Flexibility
Indicates variety in
thinking. It may be
thinking of different
uses of an object, or
Fluency different
Is the ability to interpretation of a
produce many ideas picture, story or
for a given task or a different ways of
problem.
solving a problem.
The more ideas a
In case of uses of a
person produces, the
paper cup, for
higher his fluency
example, one may
ability.
give an idea to use it
For example, more as a container or to
the number of uses of draw a circle, etc.
a paper cup, more
would be the fluency.
Divergent
thinking
Elaboration
Originality
Is the ability to produce Is the ability that
ideas that are rare or enables a person
to go into details Divergent thinking abilities facilitate
unusual by seeing new
generation of a variety of ideas which
relationships, combining and workout
may not seem to be related. For
old ideas with new ones, implications of new example,
looking at things from ideas. what are the common ideas for
different perspectives
enhancing food production?
etc. Research has shown
The likely answers would be related to
that fluency and
quality of seeds, fertilizers, irrigation,
flexibility are the
and so on. If someone thinks of
necessary conditions for
cultivation in a desert for extracting
originality. The more
protein from weeds, it would be a
and varied ideas one
remote idea. The association here is
produces, the greater
between ‘food production’ and ‘desert’
the likelihood of original
or ‘weeds’.
ideas.
Process of
Creative Thinking
1. Preparation
This is the first stage in which the
Research has thinker formulates the problem
made it clear and collects facts and materials
necessary for the solution. He/she
that thinking of finds that the problem cannot be
new and unusual solved after days, weeks, or months
ideas involve of concentrated effort.
Unable to solve the problem the
more than a flash thinker deliberately or involuntarily
of insight. There turns away from the problem,
are stages initiating stage two i.e. incubation. At
this stage of problem solving, it is
before and after important to overcome negative
the new ideas consequences of mental set and
any kind of mental set or bias.
come.
Process of
Creative Thinking
2. Incubation 3. Illumination
This is a stage of no solution In this stage a potential
and involves a number of solution to the problem seems
emotional and cognitive to be realized
complexities. However, the as if from nowhere. It is
negative effects of mental set, about having the insight
about the possible solution.
functional fixedness, and other
Illumination occurs with its
ideas that interfere with the “aha” experience when a
solution tend to fade. Perhaps, sudden idea or solution
fatigue and too much of appears into consciousness.
concern with the problem also
mount up during this period.
Further, the unconscious
thought processes involved in
creative thinking are at work
during this stage.
Process of
Creative Thinking
5. Revision
4. Evaluation Revision is required in the
In this stage the obtained case a solution which is not
solution is verified or tested to satisfactory.
see if it works. Frequently, the
insight may turn out to be
unsatisfactory, and may need
some modification in the
strategy of approaching the
problem.
Process of
Creative Thinking