2019 IEEE PES Innovative Smart Grid Technologies Asia

Grounding Current of Converter Transformer Core and

Core Clamp and Its Harmonic Characteristics
Minghong Su, Xiao Yao, Dianbo Zhou, Yuhang He, Jing Zhang
State Grid Sichuan Electric Power Research Institute
Chengdu, China

Abstract—The energized test of grounding current of converter converter station sometimes exceeds 100 mA. However, none
transformer core and core clamp is helpful to detect the of the above transformers have any abnormality. The
grounding fault of converter transformers. In this paper, the operation condition of converter transformers is quite different
grounding current of core and core clamp of tens of converter from that of conventional AC power transformers [9]. The
transformers in a ±500 kV and ±800 kV converter station were valve side winding of a converter transformer connected to the
measured and corresponding harmonic characteristics were converter valves withstands both AC, DC and harmonics
obtained, respectively. The results showed that the grounding voltages [10]. This is expected to result in various harmonics
current of core and core clamp contain a lot of harmonics. The and contribute to the total grounding current of core and core
fundamental current is much smaller than the total grounding
clamp. Therefore, this prompts us to pay attention to the
current as the harmonics contribute much to the total grounding
fundamental current and harmonics of grounding current of
current. The harmonics contained in the total grounding current
of core and core clamp should be considered together with its
core and core clamp rather than just to the total grounding
fundamental current when condition assessment is performed current. Up to now, few publications have presented the
for converter transformers. harmonic characteristics of grounding current of converter
transformer core and core clamp with the field energized test
Index Terms—converter transformer, grounding current, core data.
and core clamp, harmonic characteristics
TABLE I. ALARM VALUE OF GROUNDING CURRENT OF CORE
I. INTRODUCTION
Equipment category Alarm value
Converter transformers are the key equipment in high transformers with the rated voltage of 1000 kV ≤300 mA
voltage direct current (HVDC) and ultra high voltage direct Converter transformers and smoothing reactors in
≤300 mA
current (UHVDC) transmission systems [1-3]. The core and a ±800 kV converter station
Other transformers ≤100 mA
core clamp of transformers are required to be one-point
grounded to avoid the floating potential and consequent
discharge [4-5]. If they are multi-point grounded, the large This paper presents some basic onsite measuring results of
loop current between the grounding points may result in the grounding current of transformer core and core clamp in a
overheat of the transformer core, increase in core loss and ±500 kV converter station and a ±800 kV converter station,
decomposition of the insulating oil, and may even lead to respectively. The total and fundamental current were
certain catastrophic power accidents [5-6]. Based on this presented and then the basic harmonic characteristics of the
principle, the grounding current of core and core clamp of grounding current of core and core clamp were obtained and
converter transformers is usually monitored to indicate the discussed.
condition of the converter transformers and it is of great
importance to the safe operation and condition-based II. ENERGIZED TEST OF GROUNDING CURRENT OF CORE
maintenance of converter transformers [7]. AND CORE CLAMP

There have been no universal criteria for grounding current A. Information on the Converter Transformers
of core and core clamp of converter transformers up to now. In In this paper, the energized test of grounding current of
China, the Chinese enterprise standard Q/GDW 11368—2014 core and core clamp was conducted for 12 converter
Site application guide for live test technology of ground transformers in a ±500 kV converter station and 24 converter
current of transformer core recommends that the grounding transformers in a ±800 kV converter station, respectively. The
current of core should meet the following criteria listed in ±500 kV converter station has two poles and the rectifying
Table I [8]. However, it is sometimes found that the grounding section in each pole consists of 1 typical single 12-pulse valve
current of core of a converter transformer in a ±800 kV bridge, as shown in Fig. 1. Likewise, the ±800 kV converter
converter station exceeds 300 mA. Likewise, the grounding station has two poles and the rectifying section in each pole
current of core of a converter transformer in a ±500 kV consists of 2 typical single 12-pulse valve bridges. The rated

Project supported by State Grid Sichuan Electric Power Company, China

(Project No. 521997170012)

978-1-7281-3520-5/19/$31.00 ©2019 IEEE 2655

capacity and voltage of this HVDC and UHVDC transmission Pole I YDA, Pole I YDB, Pole I YDC, Pole II YDA, Pole II
line project is 3000 MW and 500 kV, and 8000 MW and 800 YDB and Pole II YDC, respectively. Similarly, sequence
kV, respectively. During the test, both of the converter stations numbers 1 to 24 are used to represent the 24 converter
were in the bipolar operation condition. transformers in the ±800 kV converter station, and the number
1 to 24 corresponding to the converter transformers with the
label of Pole I HYYA, Pole I HYYB, Pole I HYYC, Pole I
LYYA, Pole I LYYB, Pole I LYYC, Pole II LYYA, Pole II
LYYB, Pole II LYYC, Pole II HYYA, Pole II HYYB, Pole II
HYYC, Pole I HYDA, Pole I HYDB, Pole I HYDC, Pole I
LYDA, Pole I LYDB, Pole I LYDC, Pole II LYDA, Pole II
LYDB, Pole II LYDC, Pole II HYDA, Pole II HYDB, Pole II
HYDC, respectively. YY/YD refer to the winding connection
type of the converter transformers and A/B/C means the phase
of the transformers. For example, the label “Pole I YYA”
corresponding to the sequence number 1 stands for the
converter transformer of phase A in pole I with Y/Y winding
connection. For the transformers in the ±800 kV converter
station, H and L stands for the transformers connected to the
rectifying unit that generates the high voltage of 0~±400 kV
and ±400~±800 kV, respectively.

Figure 1. Schematic of 12-pulse valve bridge

The transformers in both converter stations are all single-

phase two-winding converter transformers. For the ±500 kV
converter station, there are twelve converter transformers in
total, with six converter transformers in each pole. For the six
transformers in each pole, the winding connection of three
transformers of them is Y/Y and the other three Y/D. For the
±800 kV converter station, there are twenty-four converter
transformers in total, with twelve converter transformers in
each pole. For the twelve transformers in each pole, the
winding connection of six transformers of them is Y/Y and the Figure 2. Grounding current of core of transformers in the ±500 kV converter
other six Y/D. station

B. Detecting and Analyzing Method

The grounding current of core and core clamp was
measured with a handheld tester in the form of energized test.
The clamp ammeter was adopted as the sensor to acquire the
signal of grounding current. The measurement was performed
by clamping the outgoing line of the grounding wire of core
and core clamp, respectively. When each sampling time was
due, the total grounding current of core and core clamp and
their harmonics whose number was no more than 20 were
calculated and recorded by the tester.

III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

A. Grounding Current of Core and Core clamp
1) Grouding current of core Figure 3. Grounding current of core of transformers in the ±800 kV converter
station
Fig. 2 and Fig. 3 depict the grounding current of core for
each converter transformer in the ±500 kV converter station It is obviously seen that, for all the 12 converter
and the ±800 kV converter station, respectively. For the transformers in the ±500 kV converter station, the total
convenience of expression, sequence numbers 1 to 12 are used grounding current of core is over the alerting value, i.e., 100
to represent the 12 converter transformers in the ±500 kV mA. However, none of those converter transformers
converter station, and the number 1 to 12 corresponding to the underwent grounding fault and no other abnormalities were
converter transformers with the label of Pole I YYA, Pole I found. The fundamental current is much smaller compared
YYB, Pole I YYC, Pole II YYA, Pole II YYB, Pole II YYC, with the total grounding current of core, and this indicates that

2656
the grounding current of core contains considerable Fig. 6 shows the harmonic content of grounding current of
harmonics. Likewise, for 23 out of the 24 converter core of the 12 converter transformers in the ±500 kV converter
transformers in the ±800 kV converter station, the total station. In this paper, the harmonic content refers to its ratio to
grounding current of core is over the alerting value, i.e., 300 the fundamental harmonic in terms of percentage. The
mA. However, none of the converter transformers underwent grounding current of core has multiple harmonics. The content
grounding fault. of most harmonics exceeds 20 percent and some even exceeds
100 percent. This indicates that the harmonics contribute
2) Grounding Current of Core clamp much to the total grounding current of core.
Fig. 4 and Fig. 5 present the grounding current of core
clamp for each converter transformer in the ±500 kV
converter station and the ±800 kV converter station,
respectively. Similar to the grounding current of core, the
fundamental current of core clamp is much smaller than the
corresponding total grounding current, which also indicates
that the grounding current of core clamp contains considerable
harmonics.

Figure 5. Grounding current of core clamp of transformers in the ±800 kV

converter station

The harmonic characteristics exhibit some differences

considering the connection type of the transformer windings.
For the converter transformers with Y/D winding connection,
the harmonics with the odd order are quite obvious compared
Figure 4. Grounding current of core clamp of transformers in the ±500 kV with the even harmonics. For the converter transformers with
converter station
Y/Y winding connection, the harmonics are more uniformly
distributed compared with those of transformers with Y/D
B. Harmonic Characteristic of Grounding Current of Core winding connection, i.e., the difference between odd and even
and Core clamp harmonics in harmonic content is much smaller.
1) Harmonic characteristic of grouding current of core

2657
 Figure 6. Harmonic content of grounding current of core

Table II lists the order of harmonics of grounding current Because of space constraints, this paper does not present the
of core whose content is over 50 percent. For the converter harmonic content of grounding current of core and core clamp
transformers with Y/Y winding connection, the content of 3rd for the 24 converter transformers in the ±800 kV converter
harmonic is over 50 percent for 5 out of the 6 converter station.
transformers. The other odd harmonics whose content is over
50 percent are not distinct for all the 6 converter transformers. 2) Harmonic characteristic of grouding current of core
The content of 6th harmonic is over 50 percent for 3 out of the clamp
6 converter transformers. For the converter transformers with Fig. 7 shows the harmonic content of grounding current of
Y/D winding connection, the content of 3rd harmonic is over core clamp of the 12 converter transformers in the ±500 kV
50 percent for all the 6 converter transformers, the content of converter station. Similar to the grounding current of core, the
5th, 7th, 9th, 13th, 15th, 17th and 19th harmonic is over 50 grounding current of core clamp has multiple harmonics. The
percent for 5 out of the 6 converter transformers, and 11th for content of most harmonics exceeds 20 percent. This indicates
4 out of the 6 converter transformers. It should also be noted that the harmonics contribute much to the total grounding
that the content of 6th harmonic is over 50 percent for 4 out of current of core clamp. For the converter transformers with
the 6 converter transformers. Y/D and Y/Y winding connection, the differences between
them are similar to that of grounding current of core, i.e., the
distinct contrast between the odd harmonics and even
TABLE II. HARMONICS WITH CONTENT EXCEEDING 50 PERCENT OF harmonics for transformers with Y/D winding connection
GROUNDING CURRENT OF CORE
versus the more uniform distribution of odd harmonics and
Sequence Transformer
Order of harmonics even harmonics for transformers with Y/Y winding
number label connection.
1 Pole I YYA 1,3
2 Pole I YYB 1,2,7,18,19 Table III lists the order of harmonics of grounding current
3 Pole I YYC 1,3 of core clamp whose content is over 50 percent. For the
4 Pole II YYA 1,3,5,6,11,17 converter transformers with Y/Y winding connection, the
5 Pole II YYB 1,3,4,6,9,12,18
content of 3rd harmonic is over 50 percent for 5 out of the 6
6 Pole II YYC 1,3,4,5,6,12,13,19
7 Pole I YDA 1,3,5,7,9,11,13,15,17,19
converter transformers. The other odd harmonics whose
8 Pole I YDB 1,3,5,6,9,11,13,15,19 content is over 50 percent are not distinct for all the 6
9 Pole I YDC 1,3,6,7,9,13,15,17,18 converter transformers. The content of 6th harmonic is over 50
10 Pole II YDA 1,3,5,7,9,15,17,19 percent for 3 out of the 6 converter transformers. For the
11 Pole II YDB 1,3,5,6,7,9,11,13,17,19 converter transformers with Y/D winding connection, the
12 Pole II YDC 1,3,5,6,7,9,11,13,15,17,18,19 content of 3rd, 9th and 17th harmonic is over 50 percent for all
the 6 converter transformers, the content of 5th and 19th
The harmonic characteristics of grounding current of core harmonic is over 50 percent for 5 out of the 6 converter
of the 24 converter transformers in the ±800 kV converter transformers, and the 7th, 11th, 15th for 4 out of the 6
station is similar to those of the 12 converter transformers in converter transformers. It should also be noted that the content
the ±500 kV converter station. The main difference is that the of 6th harmonic is over 50 percent for 4 out of the 6 converter
number of odd and even harmonic whose content exceeds 50 transformers.
percent increases, regardless of the winding connection type.

2658
 Figure 7. Harmonic content of grounding current of core clamp

The harmonic characteristics of the grounding current of core

TABLE III. HARMONICS WITH CONTENT EXCEEDING 50 PERCENT OF clamp of the 24 converter transformers in the ±800 kV converter
GROUNDING CURRENT OF CORE CLAMP station is similar to those of the 12 converter transformers in the
Sequence Transformer ±500 kV converter station. The main difference is that the number
Order of harmonics
number label of odd and even harmonic whose content exceeds 50 percent
1 Pole I YYA 1,3 increases.
2 Pole I YYB 1,2,7,18,19
3 Pole I YYC 1,3 C. Discussions
4 Pole II YYA 1,3,5,6,11
5 Pole II YYB 1,3,4,6,9,12,13,18 From this energized test result of grounding current of
6 Pole II YYC 1,3,6,13 converter transformer core and core clamp, it can be seen that a
7 Pole I YDA 1,3,5,6,7,9,11,13,15,17,19 large grounding current of core and core clamp does not
8 Pole I YDB 1,3,5,6,9,11,13,15,17,19 necessarily indicate a transformer grounding fault. To a large
9 Pole I YDC 1,3,6,9,17,18 extent this large value can be attributed to the harmonics. The
10 Pole II YDA 1,3,5,7,9,15,17,19 harmonics of grounding current are both associated with the
11 Pole II YDB 1,3,5,6,7,9,11,13,17,19
12 Pole II YDC 1,3,5,6,7,9,11,15,17,19
converter transformer windings that connected to the AC and DC
side. Supposing that harmonics contained in the AC side are
negligible, the odd harmonics of the grounding current then
mainly derives from the nonlinear behavior of the 12-pulse

2659
converter valve connected to the DC side. The even harmonics, [1] D. Martin, J. Marks, T. K. Saha, O. Krause and N. Mahmoudi,
especially the 6th harmonic, may come from the unbalanced load "Investigation Into Modeling Australian Power Transformer Failure and
Retirement Statistics," IEEE Trans. Power Deliv., vol. 33, no. 4, pp. 2011-
of the three-phase network but need to be further verified. 2019, Aug. 2018.
As the operation condition of converter transformers is quite [2] M. Duval, A. D. Pablo, I. Atanasova-Hoehlein, and M. Grisaru,
"Significance and detection of very low degree of polymerization of paper
different from that of conventional AC transformers, this indicates in transformers," IEEE Electr. Insul. Mag., vol. 33, pp. 31-38, Jan. 2017.
that the alarm value for grounding current of converter [3] A. Teymouri and B. Vahidi, "CO2/CO concentration ratio: A
transformer core and core clamp could be differentiated in complementary method for determining the degree of polymerization of
comparison with that of conventional AC transformers, rather power transformer paper insulation," IEEE Electr. Insul. Mag., vol. 33, pp.
than just follow that of the conventional AC transformers. For 24-30, Jan. 2017.
[4] K. Deželak, M. Petrun, M. Rošer, D. Dolinar and G. Štumberger, "The
converter transformers, it is suggested that attention should be Impact of Iron Core Model on Dynamic Behavior of Three-Phase Power
paid to not only the total grounding current of core and core Transformer Dynamic Model," IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 51, pp. 1-4, Jan.
clamp but also to the harmonics it contained. The fundamental 2015.
current of the grounding current should also be paid attention to. [5] P. Marketos and T. Meydan, "Novel Transformer Core Design Using
More future work should be conducted to collect more grounding Consolidated Stacks of Electrical Steel," IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 42, pp.
current data and find the characteristic harmonic that is indicative 2821-2823, Oct. 2006.
[6] F. Marketos, D. Marnay and T. Ngnegueu, "Experimental and Numerical
of grounding fault. Furthermore, the relation between the Investigation of Flux Density Distribution in the Individual Packets of a 100
grounding current, the harmonic content and the converter station kVA Transformer Core," IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 48, pp. 1677-1680, Apr.
operation mode and the power transmitted should also be 2012.
thoroughly investigated. [7] Li S, Li J, "Condition monitoring and diagnosis of power equipment: review
and prospective," High Vol., 2017, vol. 2, pp.82-91, Jun. 2017.
[8] Site application guide for live test technology of ground current of
IV. CONCLUSIONS transformer core, State Grid Standard Q/GDW 11368—2014, 2015.
This paper presents the energized test result of grounding [9] J. Li, L. Bao, J. Zhang and X. Li, "Adequacy of dual-variable Weibull
current of core and core clamp of converter transformers in a failure distribution for oil-impregnated paper under pulsating DC voltage,"
IEEE Trans. Dielectr. Electr. Insul., vol. 23, pp. 1555-1561, Jun. 2016.
±500 kV converter station and a ±800 kV converter station. The [10] Bao, L, Li J., Zhang J. et al, "Influences of temperature on partial discharge
main conclusions are summarized as follows. behavior in oil-paper bounded gas cavity under pulsating DC voltage,"
IEEE Trans. Dielectr. Electr. Insul., vol. 23, pp. 1482-1490, Jun. 2016.
a) For the grounding current of core of Y/Y connected
converter transformers in the ±500 kV converter station, the 3rd
harmonic is the most obvious among the odd harmonics. For the
grounding current of core of Y/D connected converter
transformers, there are more odd harmonics whose content
exceeds 50 percent. The even harmonic like 6th harmonic is
obvious for most of the converter transformers. There are more
harmonics whose content exceeds 50 percent for the grounding
current of core and core clamp of the converter transformers in the
±800 kV converter station.
b) The harmonic characteristics of grounding current of core
clamp is similar to that of core. For the Y/Y connected converter
transformers, the 3rd harmonic is the most obvious among the odd
harmonics. For the Y/D connected converter transformers, there
are more odd harmonics whose content exceeds 50 percent. The
even harmonic like 6th harmonic should also be paid attention to.
More harmonics whose content exceeds 50 percent for the
grounding current of core and core clamp was found for the
converter transformers in the ±800 kV converter station.
c) The total grounding current of core and core clamp is much
greater than its fundamental current and the multiple harmonics
contribute to the total grounding current. The harmonics in the
grounding current should be paid attention to together with the
fundamental current when the condition assessment of converter
transformers is performed.

REFERENCES

2660