Developing Healthcare Leaders
Developing Healthcare Leaders
1
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
Table of Contents
Introduction................................................................................................................................3
Analysis:.....................................................................................................................................4
The Reflective Practitioner.....................................................................................................4
Ethics and Professional Aspects of Leadership.....................................................................7
Exploring Culture, Diversity and Values...............................................................................10
Ethical Issues and Their Impact on Healthcare Practice......................................................13
Conclusion...............................................................................................................................16
References...............................................................................................................................18
2
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
Introduction
In current times, commanding leadership is significant in healthcare. It's essential for
managing tough spots, sparking new ideas, and making sure premium care is given. As
healthcare faces issues like tech progress, changing population, and shifting rules,
more skilled leaders are needed. Because of this, growing these leaders is a vital task
for organizations wanting to succeed in a world that never stops changing.
Wong and Cummings' crucial research in 2007, points to the importance of leadership
growth in the healthcare sector. They suggest it's strongly linked with better
organizational results and improved patient care. Not only do leadership growth
programs build vital abilities, but they also foster a spirit of teamwork, flexibility, and
ongoing enhancement within healthcare organizations (Cummings and team, 2018).
The COVID-19 crisis really showed how crucial strong health leadership is in managing
emergencies. Good leaders swiftly adapted to new problems like never before. They led
their teams through doubts, always keeping patient safety and employee health first
(Chowkwanyun & Reed, 2020). This crisis pointed out the demand for tough, forward
thinking leaders. These leaders can guide health organizations through emergencies.
They, do this while keeping things running smoothly and providing caring assistance.
The healthcare field has seen big changes recently. New technology, different patient
needs, and shifts in population have driven these changes. Healthcare is now more
digital. Records are now electronic. Patients can now see doctors from their own
homes. Uses of artificial intelligence are changing the field. These changes required
leaders to rethink their roles (Topol, 2019). Leaders need to understand new
technologies and how they'll impact patient treatments. Leaders must also support new
ideas and digital learning in their workplaces.
Lately, healthcare has seen big changes due to technology, people's ages, and what
patients expect. Healthcare has gone digital; it adopted electronic health records,
telemedicine, and artificial intelligence. It's like it transformed care delivery and needed
3
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
a fresh look at old leadership models (Topol, 2019). Leaders need to know about these
new technologies and what they mean for patient care. They also need to support
innovation and digital know-how in their organizations.
Also, changes in population such as older people and staff, make healthcare leaders
face new issues and possibilities. The stepping down of seasoned leaders and the
arrival of younger, tech-smart workers highlights the need for teamwork and sharing
knowledge across generations to build leadership skills (Schultz & Gutek, 2019). To be
successful, leaders need to connect with different age groups. They should use the
skills of varied groups to ensure the success of their organization and create an
environment where everyone feels included and valued.
This paper looks at how to create good leaders in healthcare. It does this by studying
best practices, new trends, and research. It hopes to explain the ways to encourage
great leadership in healthcare. By giving leaders and future leaders the right skills, they
can help health services change as needed and create lasting benefits for patients,
doctors, and communities.
Analysis:
In today's health field, leading well and managing teams are crucial. They help improve
patient care and meet goals. Schon's Reflective Model is a compass for leaders and
managers. It says reflection is good. This way of thinking promotes ongoing learning,
creativity, and progress. In this piece, we will look at how Schon's Reflective Model
affects health leadership and team handling.
4
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
Figure 1: Healthcare Leadership Skills
(Source: Divyaa., 2022)
Evidence and recent studies back this up. Reviewing its influence shows how the model
grows level-headed leaders and unified teams, ultimately boosting the level of care
patients receive.
5
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
On the other side, reflection-on-action is thinking deeply and examining an event after it
happened. These two cycles allow professionals to inspect their steps, accepted facts,
and fundamental theories. This way, they can improve their choices and ways to solve
problems.
Instance: Dr Smith, a hospital boss with an intense budget but needs to deliver best-in-
class patient care. Dr. Smith uses reflection-on-action to assess cost-saving tactics,
keeping in mind the patient results. With most situations as a guide and suggestions
from involved parties, Dr. Smith spots are as for growth. Then, he introduces smart
solutions that increase productivity but do not affect patient care quality.
Instance: Moreover, Schon's Reflective Model gives health chiefs tools to sail through
moral issues and push for patient focused care. Take Dr Jones, a health boss, for
example, he frequently stumbles upon clashes between set hospital rules and what
patients want. By thinking, Dr Jones figures out how to juggle group targets with
personal patient requirements, boosting faith and teamwork in the health squad.
6
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
Instance: Let's bring Schon's Reflective Model into the world of team leadership with
Nurse Manager Martinez. She's in charge of a busy operation centre. Martinez uses
reflection in action to urge her team to tweak their routines to cope with fluctuating
patient requirements and the ever-changing availability of resources. She fosters a
sense of responsibility by encouraging honest conversations and seeking thoughts from
employees directly involved in the workload, resulting in enhanced patient care and
happier staff.
Schon's Reflective Model also encourages teamwork and growth in healthcare. A 2016
study by Edmondson and colleagues discovered that mixed teams that practice
reflection respect each other more, trust increases, and they share similar thought
processes. Managers in healthcare can thus tap into the unique insights and
experiences of team members, using this combined knowledge to solve complex
problems and spark new ideas.
7
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
Schon's Reflective Model is a key tool for improving healthcare leadership and
teamwork. Its impact comes from how it encourages reflecting, learning, and innovating
in health organizations. The model tells us to reflect during and after actions. This helps
health leaders and managers to make better decisions and work better together. They
also can adapt to new challenges faster.
Using Schon's model allows them to understand complex situations better. They learn,
find places to boost, and think of ways to help take care of patients better. They also
make their organization more efficient. Also, Schon's model helps teams work well
together. Managers who follow the model let everyone talk and reflect together. This
lets teams use everyone's knowledge and experience to solve problems better and
make good choices.
When health groups follow Schon's model, they make stronger leaders who can deal
with change. These leaders also motivate teams to perform well. By making reflection
and continuous learning important, change can happen. This helps take care of patients
better and provide better care.
As things change in healthcare, Schon's model remains an important tool. The model
helps bring confidence into the uncertain and creative world of healthcare. It helps
leaders make sure they take care of patients.
8
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
In hospitals and clinics, good leadership considers both ethical and professional values.
This is because health matters are serious. Healthcare leaders face tough ethical
choices. They need to consider a patient's independence while also doing what's best
for them. They need to distribute limited supplies fairly and respect a patient's privacy
(Beauchamp & Childress, 2019). In addition, they should create a safe environment that
assures quality and responsibility. This helps patients receive kind, research-backed
care (Institute of Medicine, 2001).
In healthcare, leading with ethics and professionalism involves balancing values, rules,
and actions. This balance guides how leaders make decisions and interact with others.
Different experts have different views on this, showing it's not a one-size fits all
approach in healthcare leadership.
Yukl (2013) views ethics in leadership as sticking to moral values while using authority
wisely. Trevino and Brown (2005) stress the same, pointing out how it cultivates trust,
honesty, and responsibility in a team. This means a great leader should promote
honesty, fairness, and openness. Such qualities are essential when dealing with
everyone involved be it patients, workers, or the community at large.
Experts, including Ciulla (2012), believe that ethics in leadership should be considered
from a wider perspective. This includes considering things like virtue ethics and building
a moral character. In Ciulla's view, ethical leaders show qualities like empathy, courage,
and humility. These are important for developing ethical cultures and getting others to
9
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
follow. This point of view highlights how leadership plays a role in molding the culture
and values of an organization. It also impacts how the ethical environment feels within
healthcare facilities.
In 2011, Selznick brought up an idea. It was about moral leadership. This is not just
about following rules and laws. It is about caring more about doing right and helping
society. Moral leaders speak up for everyone's benefits. They stick to good values even
when it is hard or when society has problems. In the field of health, you can see moral
leadership. Leaders doing this prioritize patient well-being. They speak out for equal
access to healthcare. They also tackle big system problems like uneven healthcare
availability.
In healthcare, ethics and good leadership matter a lot. Leaders who act morally can
build safe places for patients and trust in the team. They also help to make healthy
places honest. For instance, a leader who thinks the patient needs are key might bring
in rules that focus on these needs. This can lead to patients feeling happy and getting
better. In the same way, a leader who acts honestly can spark a team to act profe-
ssionally when dealing with patients and other staff.
Therefore, in healthcare, leadership has a professional and ethical side. This covers a
set of values, rules, and actions that direct leaders in making choices and relating with
others. By closely examining different views and meanings, healthcare leaders can
understand many sides of ethical leadership. They see how crucial it is to offer quality
care and make their organization efficient.
Leaders in healthcare and other sectors need to have strong ethics and professional
traits. These skills are shaped by philosophy and modern management theories. Ethical
leaders stand by integrity, responsible action, and care for society. Upholding these
aspects and acquiring professional skills helps leaders face ethical problems, motivate
their team, and bring good changes to their group.
10
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
In healthcare, I have noted that both leadership's ethical and professional sides often
come into play in different situations. For example, leaders sometimes show their
dedication to patient security. They do this by launching strong initiatives to improve
quality and by building a sense of responsibility among employees. Important
communication skills also play a significant role in solving tricky ethical situations. These
might involve disagreements between what the patient wants and the advice doctors
give.
I have watched how leaders have honest talks with patients and their loved ones about
possible treatments. This ensures everyone is fully aware and respects the patient's
choices. Another area where ethical leadership matters is the fair distribution of scarce
resources. Leaders work to share these evenly while also working to provide the best
patient care. The examples given show how leadership ethics and professionalism can
directly make a difference inpatient treatment and the success of a healthcare
establishment.
This piece will look at four crucial ethical concepts and guides necessary for training
great healthcare leaders: cultural understanding, diversity and inclusion, values based
leadership, and team ethics. They serve as lighthouses in shaping leaders. They help
navigate the tricky world of healthcare, while always maintaining honesty, empathy, and
fairness.
By using these ethical guides in training programs, healthcare bodies can create a team
of leaders ready for the challenges of today's health sector. They are champions for
ethical behavior and the best organisational skills.
This piece will explore these principles, how they work, why they matter and their impact
on creating ethical healthcare leaders ready for our changing health environment.
11
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
Understanding Different Cultures in Healthcare Leadership: Knowing how to treat
people from various backgrounds is key for medical staff. This idea comes from the
Cultural Competence Model. It says we need to be aware of differences, learn about
them, and handle them right.
This helps give patient focused care and make health services equal for everyone.
Leaders have to see how culture affects how patients think about health, how they act,
and what treatment they prefer. If we include this type of training in leadership courses,
we can help leaders learn how to work in a range of cultural situations and give care
that fits with the patient's culture.
Instance 2: A healthcare organization working with a diverse community could hire and
coach multilingual employees to act as cultural links. Such employees can make
conversation easier and forge a strong bond with patients who are not fluent in English.
This improves care access and patient happiness.
For healthcare leadership growth, tapping into the benefits of diversity and inclusion is
decisive for spearheading innovation, sparking creativity, and encouraging teamwork.
Leaders need to actively embrace diverse viewpoints, experiences, and novel ideas to
fuel the organizational victory.
A diverse and inclusive leadership approach in our healthcare organizations can attract
top manpower, enhance patient care results, and boost organizational delivery.
Instance 1: A training course for healthcare leaders incorporates diversity and inclusion
elements, with subjects such as unconscious bias, embracing cultural differences, and
inclusive management practices.
For those learning to be healthcare leaders, it's important to stick to our values. This
encourages ethical choices, establishing trust, and pushing for the highest standards.
Leaders need to show us the right path with their honesty, understanding, and ethical
actions. By making organizational values a part of leadership training, healthcare
organizations can build leaders rooted in ethical principles and honesty.
Instance 1: A health association identifies its main principles like kindness, dignity, and
superiority. These are combined into its training course for leaders. Members study
actual cases and participate in thought provoking tasks. They use these principles in
their leadership behaviour and choices.
Instance 2: In periods of company shifts or troubles, leaders can maintain principles like
honesty and fairness. They do this by talking freely to workers and those involved,
tackling issues, and asking for responses. This guides choics.
Healthcare Leadership and Team Ethics: This concept puts emphasis on making
morally sound choices in healthcare team settings. It champions team cooperation,
mutual regard, and joint responsibility (Ulrich et al., 2010).
Instance 1: Healthcare leader training programs include ethics lessons done in teams.
These lessons have communication training and ways to resolve disagreements. They
also cover how to make ethical choices when working in groups. People in the program
13
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
do teamwork activities, mock scenarios, and talk about cases. This helps them get
better at working together in a moral way within teams of different disciplines.
Instance 2: In a medical team, folks sometimes face tricky situations about patient care
choices, resources sharing, or possible clashes of interest. Leaders can help by
encouraging everyone to talk and work together. This aids in discussing ethics,
welcoming different views, and helping the group agree on the right steps to take.
In summary, developing moral leaders in the industry of healthcare is difficult and for
this thorough awareness of values, culture and diversity is need. Cultural competence is
key. It helps communicate effectively and provide respectful services to diverse
patients.
The final end product is better health outcomes and happy patients. Diversity and
inclusion are crucial for ethical leadership in healthcare! They fuel innovation and
teamwork. A diverse team helps solve problems quicker, make better decisions, and
improves the organization's performance. Value based leadership is about matching
organizational values to leadership actions.
Leaders who show integrity, compassion, and accountability earn trust, motivate teams,
and make the organization successful. Then there's team based ethics. It is all about
making ethical decisions within a team. It encourages teamwork, respect, and
accountability. The final result is better patient care and a more effective organization.
By adopting these practices into leadership programs, we can develop leaders who are
ready for the challenging healthcare scene. They will uphold ethical standards and
boost organizational excellence. Continuing education, training, and organizational
support help healthcare leaders adapt to changing patient, staff, and community needs.
It is a step towards ethical healthcare leadership and high quality care.
Healthcare is filled with ethical problems. They touch everything doctors, bosses, and
even the rules makers struggle. They have to juggle tough choices, care for patients,
and stick to ethical guidelines. Based on my experiences and studies, let us dive into
four big ethical problems that strongly influence healthcare.
14
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
When people are ill, they often have to make decisions about their medical care. It's
important that they understand their options. This is called patient autonomy and it's a
key value in healthcare (Beauchamp & Childress, 2019). Healthcare professionals
respect patients' abilities to decide what's best for them. They encourage patients to
understand their treatments and make choices that reflect their values and goals. Of
course, sometimes these values can conflict with what doctors believe is best. Doctors
aim to benefit their patients.
Imagine a time when a patient living with an ongoing health issue chooses not to go for
a treatment which could save his or her life. This patient's personal views tie into this
choice. It is a tricky situation. Doctors respect patients' rights but also wrestle with the
moral duty to step in and try to extend the patient's life. Delicate care is taken to balance
the patient's values, the quality of their life, and their health outlook. It usually involves
talks between the patient, their loved ones and the medical staff.
For example, Once, there was a time when I came across a person who was very sick.
They did not want to get better because of what they believed in. Lots of doctors and
nurses did not know what to do. They thought about helping the patient even more,
maybe even making them live longer. But all of us got together. The patient, their family,
and us medical folk, all talked. We solved the tough question. It was about weighing
what the patient wanted versus helping them get better.
The goal is to help as many people as possible with the minimum harm while ensuring
that they are allocated fairly and effectively. The arrival of COVID-19 pushed this issue
15
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
to the fore. Our medical services faced a critical lack of protective gear, breathing
machines, and limited ICU beds. In making tough choices, ethics like utilitarianism
played a crucial part, aiming to help the largest amount of people. But trying to weigh
fairness, equal rights, and the needs of every individual against the scale of the crisis
and finite resources proved to be a hurdle.
In the face of COVID-19, healthcare groups had a severe lack of protective gear,
breathing machines, and critical care beds. Ethical principles like utilitarianism, focusing
on the most benefits for the most people, steered choices. Hospitals, for instance,
deployed sorting systems for scarce supplies. They considered aspects like forecasted
outcomes, survival chances, and years possibly saved.
Also, I have seen, there were moments when private patient details got shared
unintentionally due to poor protections or accidental leaks. Instances like talking about
patient cases in public spaces or wrongly sharing details in team meetings can put
privacy at risk. Healthcare groups must focus on learning, training, and solid privacy
rules to reduce risks and protect patient privacy rights.
16
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
Caring for people near death poses great moral concerns. These revolve around the
choices one has to make about stopping life saving treatment, easing pain, and
following patients' wishes outlined in advance. Healthcare professionals' duty to respect
patient independence means they must honour their care preferences as they near
death. This includes their choices on processes such as resuscitation, breathing aid
using machines, and special kind of care. But making these choices can bring both
emotional and moral challenges to patients, their families, and those providing
healthcare (Wendler & Rid, 2011).
In their day-to-day work, professionals in health may face situations where patients
have not laid out clear advance instructions about their wishes as they near death. This
can cause ethical differences and discomfort among those who provide healthcare. It's
especially true when family members argue over what action should be taken. Skills that
are much needed then include open, caring conversations, supporting patients and their
families emotionally, and involves making shared choices. These are vital parts of care
for those nearing the end of life.
For example, I have seen, families often grapple when making last stage decisions for
beloved ones without any set out plans or clear guidance. Trouble starts when there is
disagreement among family on what is the right thing to do. This leads to feelings of
upset and shaky morals among those giving medical care. It is crucial to have a kind,
open talk and give backing to those sick and their families. These are key parts of giving
ethical care when someone's life is nearing its end.
In a nutshell, healthcare is laced with moral matters. They mould decisions, rules, and
the bond between patients and providers. Things like patient choice, resource sharing,
privacy, and end of life care are just some of the moral puzzles in healthcare. But, by
noticing, studying, and tackling these moral hurdles, we can steer through them. With
ethical thought, learning, and teamwork in decision-making, we can boost high ethical
behaviour and focus on patient care.
17
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
Conclusion
Using Schon's Reflective Model in healthcare leadership, paired with a focus on ethics
and professional growth, gives a strong structure to handle complex healthcare
organization challenges. Schon's model boosts reflection, learning, and new ideas. It
helps leaders and teams work through doubt, change, and improve patients' results.
Reflecting while and after acting lets healthcare leaders make better choices, work
better together, and boost efficiency. Thinking this through not only helps understand
complex situations but also promotes steady improvement and better patient care.
Leaders who stick to strong ethics play a key role in delivering excellent care and
managing healthcare resources well. Such leaders build trust, inspire teams, and help
the organization succeed by sticking to its core values and putting patients first.
Embracing different cultures and groups sparks new ideas, improves team work, and
ramps up the organization's performance. Healthcare leaders who understand and use
these differences can meet patients' and communities' unique needs, leading to
improved health results. Team-based ethics, focusing on teamwork, respect, and
responsibility, are key to making good decisions in healthcare teams. By promoting
open conversations and shared responsibilities, leaders can encourage teamwork in
problem solving, leading to improved patient care. Ongoing education, training, and
leadership support are vital to developing ethical healthcare leaders ready to deal with
the ever-changing healthcare delivery world.
18
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
References
● Wong, C. A., & Cummings, G. G. (2007). The relationship between nursing
leadership and patient outcomes: a systematic review. Journal of Nursing
Management, 15(5), 508-521.
● Cummings, G. G., Spiers, J. A., Wong, C. A., Bunce, A. E., & Rowe, L. (2018).
Mismatched expectations: Nurses' experience with transition from education to
the practice setting. Nursing Leadership, 31(2), 58-70.
● Chowkwanyun, M., & Reed, A. L. (2020). Racial health disparities and Covid-19
—caution and context. New England Journal of Medicine, 383(3), 201-203.
● Brown, M. E., & Trevino, L. K. (2006). Ethical leadership: A review and future
directions. The Leadership Quarterly, 17(6), 595-616.
● Daly, J., Speedy, S., & Jackson, D. (2010). Leadership in healthcare: A review
and synthesis. Journal of Nursing Management, 18(8), 957-969.
19
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
● Institute of Medicine. (2001). Crossing the quality chasm: A new health system
for the 21st century. National Academy Press.
● West, M. A., Lyubovnikova, J., Eckert, R., & Denis, J. L. (2014). Collective
leadership for cultures of high quality health care. Journal of Organizational
Effectiveness: People and Performance, 1(3), 240-260.
● Ulrich, C. M., Taylor, C., & Soeken, K. L. (2010). Ethical climate, ethics stress,
and the job satisfaction of nurses and social workers in the United States. Social
Science & Medicine, 71(12), 2082-2090.
● Klein, D. A., Floyd, D. L., & Harland, L. (2014). The Handbook of Organizational
Culture and Climate. Routledge.
● Ulrich, C. M., Taylor, C., & Soeken, K. L. (2010). Ethical climate, ethics stress,
and the job satisfaction of nurses and social workers in the United States. Social
Science & Medicine, 71(12), 2082-2090.
20
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
● Beauchamp, T. L., & Childress, J. F. (2019). Principles of biomedical ethics. Oxford
University Press.
● Institute of Medicine. (2001). Crossing the quality chasm: A new health system for the
21st century. National Academy Press.
21
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
22
Student Reference Number: BP0123456
23
Student Reference Number: BP0123456