Skip to content

Clarification on *.vsix offline installs #3300

Closed

Description

@CBtiger

you have many posts clarifiying the problem that the standard *.vsix package causes errors at the first start because the cpptools extensions wants to download extensions. I think I read all your issues on that and I also found the Release folders where you provide the different version per OS.

What I do not understand is that nobody is asking why the main target version seems to be missing there. You provide

  • Linux32
  • Linux (I take its Linux64)
  • MacOS
  • Win32

What about Win64? The majority of downloaders should run a Win X64 platform. I ran into the described problem with the standard .vsix download. Now I am confused. Would I compromise my Win x64 system my installing the win32 version? I did not see a '.vsix' uninstall...

You would help people a lot when addind a small section in your ReadMe.md about "Offline Install". Because its surprising to users that your extension is the only one that does not work for an offline case. Technically totally feasible that dependencies vary with the traget system, why not just telling people in the readme that everyone who downloaded the "standard" *.vsix file should consider to take one (or more) of those . If you could add a sentence what Win-64bit users should select than you would have made my day!

Activity

  1. bobbrow commented on Mar 15, 2019

    @bobbrow
    Contributor

    Thanks for the feedback. Adding a section to the readme on this is a good suggestion. Our extension should be outputting an error message with instructions when it tries to download dependencies in the "offline" scenario, but it's possible that people might not see them.

    Win32 binaries run on Win64, so all Windows users can install the same package. But I think renaming these would be good to reduce the potential for confusion.

  2. CBtiger commented on Mar 16, 2019

    @CBtiger
    Author

    You are welcome, glad if you find it useful.
    I must say I am very impressed by your Extension and even more by your support.

    Your instructions included indeed. Just ran it again. It says to download the release vsix files. So that is great and very helpful. After reading the message I only hung at the x64bit naming issue.

    The very best solution imho is leave every file name as it is and add a section in your Readme.md. Its not too long to become unreadable. And its fine to put this section "Offline use" to the very end for such a non-standard use case. But I would really appreciate to understand the issue before hand and get the links just there. To any coder it should be easy to understand that

    "..the tools are OS dependent and thus can not be resolved in the single vsix download. Thus initiual setup must be online or for pure offline use the correct files should be used . Win32 is for x64 and x32."

    (your wording will be better) That would be an outrageous documentation, indeed!

  3. locked and limited conversation to collaborators on Oct 12, 2020
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions