Low-Noise Audio Amplifier Design
Low-Noise Audio Amplifier Design
audio amplifiers
In any system, the front-end amplifier sets important limits to
performance. This article examines the limitations of low-noise
amplifers as defined by the laws of physics and the practicality
of real-world components.
WILFRIED ADAM
ince the invention of electronic ampli 100Hz right up into the multi-CHz range. of thermal noise increases with tempera
UJ""
mechanisms and methods of combating
distortion, together with a better under
(GOdB) . 90
Optional weighting
filters to CClR or NAB
r--- ...
Output for
I
I oscilloscope
I
I...... n1
Rs 20 to 20kHz
Variable bandpass filter
gain amp. with 36dB/Oct
in 10dB roiloff;
steps gain: OdB 30dB
Precision full-wave Meter
rectifier with two
time constants:
330ms/l0s
Fig.3. Block diagram of a noise measurement circuit for white noise and flicker noise.
62k
Device
under test NE5534
2k
TL071
+ 1k 1k
680n 680n
.
Rs
1)J:; 47k + TL071
11
/1 1k2 Full scale
Input for power -30dBm
supply noise 3k3
measurements -100dBm
10k
10000" -110dBm
I
1.1OOOO)J
33k
-120dBm
100k
-130dBm
82k
82k
l
2k 1n
1k White 20 . . 20kHz
680n 680n TL071
+ +
+ TL071 +
TL071 82k
12 n 1 TL071
Flicker
0.14
to 30Hz
3k3
3k3
82k
100
30dB
10k
1}J3�1!'1I +
TL071
'--+----1+
+
Time constant for:
1k
White noise: 330ms
TL071
Flicker noise 10s
�------�/
Average reading meter (ARM)
and for a gain of +32dBm the output noise the same conditions. The magnitude of the
will be -90dBm and so on. collector current influences the value of the
base spreading resistance Rbb and thus the
Optimum source resistance. By taking a achievable optimum source resistance of a NE
series of measurements with different resist particular circuit. This is demonstrated in 5534
ance values, preferably using fixed-value Fig.8 for the LM394 transistor.
metal film resistors, connected to the input The base spreading resistance is effective
R= 250
of the device under test, it is possible to ly in series between the input terminal and
determine the optimum source resistance of the base of the transistor and generates most
--�-- ---�-- 15V
the amplifier under test. This is the source of the noise within the transistor. Unfortu
1= El-0.6V
resistance at which the difference between nately the value of base spreading resistance R
the noise generated by the amplifier and the is not normally stated in manufacturers' Adjust Rl= R2 so that the voltage drop
noise of the source resistance is at a mini data sheets and it cannot be measured easily. across them is 2.5Vapprox.
mum. Figure 7 shows an example for the This leaves the designer with three op
popular low-noise op-amp NE5534. From tions when selecting a transistor for low Fig.9. NE5534 op·amp with substituted
this diagram it can be seen that the optimum noise circuits: differential transistor pair for optimum
source resistance is approximately 5kD. 1. Use special transistors designed for low- source resistance matching.
LOW-NOISE CIRCUITS
In designing a low-noise amplifier, the fore
most task is to adapt the optimum source
resistance of the amplifier (that source
Fig.IO. Microphone amplifier with op·amp and transformer for optimum source
resistance at which the amplifier is quietest)
resistance matching.
to the value of the AC source resistance
provided by the transducer. It is usually a
noise purposes such as the MAT01 (dual)\ optimum source resistances between 3n good idea to measure the resistance of the
MAT03 (dual)4, MAT04 (quad)4, LM394 and approximately 10kn. If the source re source, as manufacturers' data usually states
(duaI)5. This may be expensive or the devices sistance is higher it worth considering field only the DC resistance, which in our case
may be hard to obtain, but the advantage is effect transistors. However, bipolar transis does not help, or some sort of nominal value.
that one can be sure that these devices are tors might be preferable even for source Source resistance is best measured by con
matched and will be essentially free of flicker resistances where field effect transistors necting a resistor across the source termin
or popcorn noise, because they have been might be used, because bipolar devices have als and determining the resistance value at
screened by the manufacturer. a much lower flicker noise corner frequency which the output drops by half. This is
2. Use medium-power RF transistors. By of 1Hz to 100Hz; fets exhibit corner frequen preferably done at several frequencies - say
design these transistors exhibit a low value cies between 100Hz and 1kHz. 100Hz, 1kHz and 10kHz - within the audio
of base spreading resistance, 4-30n being band. The average of these values is taken as
Field-effect transistors. If the source resist
common, and they are usually free of flicker the source resistance to which the optimum
ance is higher, than approximately lOkn,
and popcorn noise, although it can be source resistance of the amplifier is to be
n-channel field-effect transistors should be
worthwhile to check this using the noise matched. The maximum value of the three
used on account of their lower current noise
measurement circuit outlined above. A good should be multiplied by 10, giving the input
at high input resistances8. P-channel fets are
example is the BFW16A with its Rbb' of less resistance value for which the amplifier has
noisier than n-channel ones. Here again,
than Sn6. to be designed.
special low-noise devices such as 12029,
3. Use medium-power AF transistors. The There are three different ways to lower the
J2039, NFS10110, 2N4867AIO, 2N6483
familiar B0140 or medium current switch optimum source resistance of a given ampli
(dual)ll may be used although the good old
ing transistors such as the 2N44037 will fier.
dirty 2N3819 or BF264A will still do the
work well because the chip is fairly large, as • Collector current through the transistor.
trick, if measured for noise. Modern low
they are designed to handle currents of Let us consider a common dynamic micro
noise fets can be made to work at optimum
around lA. They therefore exhibit a corres phone having an average source resistance
source impedances as low as soon if you
pondingly low value of base spreading resist of lOOn and a common low noise op-amp
dare (noise corner up to 1kHz).
ance. They are easily available, but before with an optimum source resistance of Skn
being used in a low-noise amplifier should be Mosfets have no place in the front-end of (Fig.7). As Fig.8 shows, the collector cur
screened individually for low flicker and low-noise amplifiers because their optimum rent determines the optimum source resist
popcorn noise with the noise measurement source resistance is well above 100Mn or ance of a transistor stage. For the given
circuit. SOI2. source resistance the corresponding collec
If the optimum source resistance obtained tor current is around 2mA per transistor. If
with one transistor is not low enough, Bipolar, fet and c-mos op-amps. Bipolar such a diagram is not at hand, for example
several may be connected in parallel. This op-amps can be selected by the noise voltage when using medium-power transistors
method suffers from diminishing returns, quoted in the data sheet and the curve giving whose noise performance is not specified by
because the noise-free gain increases by the the optimum source resistance. The flicker the manufacturer, the following rule20 may
factor n, where n is the number of devices in noise corner frequency of bipolar op-amps be applied:
parallel. For example, 50 transistors are ranges between 1Hz and 100Hz compared to
paralleled within the LM394. Moreover each 100 to 1kHz for fet op-amps. C-mos op-amps le
_ VF
40xRs
transistor may have to be screened for low also have corner frequencies in the region of
flicker and popcorn noise. This can become 1kHz. With cheaper types of bipolar beware where le is the collector current, !3 is the
quite unpractical when using a large num of flicker and popcorn noise. Frequently current gain of the transistor and Rs is the
ber of devices per amplifier. Emitter resis op-amps are stated to have low noise; this source resistance. The collector current
tors are necessary because transistors ex may have been so at the time they were first must be within the limits given in the data
hibit wide tolerances, but this increases marketed, or they may be the lowest-noise sheet of the transistor.
noise because any emitter resistors are effec devices of a quite noisy family. One can, of course, place a differential
tively in series with the input. Low-noise op-amps by today's standards stage running at 2mA per transistor in front
Bipolar transistors may be used with are the LTl02813, LTl03i4, OP4,4, OP374, of the NESS34, but this creates stability
the introduction of additional thermal noise have spent many hours, happy and other
from the feedback resistors. The NE5344 wise, finding this one. The only thing to do is
supports this, being capable of driving a to use very large and therefore electrolytic
600n load without reduced output voltage. capacitors so as to achieve a cut-off frequen
Fig.n. Noise performance of the inverting
• Paralleling. When going for even lower cy of well below O.OlHz. Bypass the elec
summing amplifier with five inputs.
source resistances, several transistors can be trolytics with ceramic capacitors, if you
directly paralleled as outlined above. Howev must. Remove any low-frequency signal
er, to avoid excessive offsets at the output, components after the low-noise amplifier
-96dB. So, surprisingly, this stage must be
the transistors should be selected so that stage.
designed for low noise by using, for example,
each one carries the same current. Spurious oscillations. Be warned that inter
the circuit of Fig.9 as the operational ampli
• Resistance transformation through a modulation products of RF oscillations pro
fier. What is even worse, the more inputs,
transformer. A transformer converts a low duced by an unstable amplifier will cause
the noiser the summing amplifier will be.
impedance into a high impedance and vice unexpected noise. •
versa. If a low signal source resistance is to
TRAPS AND PITFALLS
be matched to the higher optimum source References
resistance of an amplifier the required trans Besides taking into account the design rules 1. Harris, Analog Pocket Application Guide No.5:
former turns ratio is given by outlined above, you should note some pit Operational amplifiers (Audio) 1988, p.76.
falls to avoid. 2. Rohde and Schwarz, Operating Instructions for
n= '\/&m. UPGR.
V Rs Reverse biasing of transistors. During tests 3. Ray Dolby, D. Robinson and K. Gundry,
with an ohmmeter or while the circuit is CCIR/ARM: A practical noise-measurement
where n is the turns ratio of the transformer, method, Journal of the Audio Engineering Society
being switched off, the transistors may be
Rs the source resistance and Ropt the opti
come reverse biased, leading to an increase Vol. 27, No 3, March 1979. p.149-157.
mum source resistance of the amplifier. 4. PMI, Linear and Conversion Products 1986/87
in flicker and popcorn noise. If, for example,
With Rsat lOOn and Roptat5kn, n=7. Data Book.
a circuit measures well the first time after it
Fig.10 shows the use of a 1:7 step-up 5. National Semiconductor, LM394 Data Sheet.
1 has been switched on and develops noise the
transformer with a rather clever circuit2 .22 6. E.H. Nordholt and R.M. van Vierzen, Ultra-low
next time it is used, it is very likely that the
which allows the gain to be varied over a very noise preamplifier for moving coil phono car
transistors are briefly reverse-biased during
wide range of 60dB by a single linear poten tridges, Journal of the Audio Engineering Society
tiometer, whilst maintaining optimum switch-off. This fault can be cured only by Vol. 28, N04, April 1980, p.219-223.
changing the discharging time constant in 7. D. Self, Design of moving-coil head amplifiers,
noise conditions (i.e. first-stage gain is
question and replacing the front-end tran Electronics & Wireless World December 1987,
always higher than the gain of the second
sistor. p.1206-1209.
stage). 8. John Maxwell, The low-noise JFET - the noise
Don't be put off by rumours that transfor Power supply noise. Noise can be injected problem solver, National Semiconductor, Ap
mers have a bad reputation. In the days of into an otherwise low-noise power amplifier plication note AN 151.
valves with their high optimum source via the power supply. Circuits usually exhibit 9. Intersil, Data book.
resistances (30kn or more), there was no good power supply noise rejection ratios of 10. National Semiconductor, Fet databook.
other way than to use step up transformers typically 120dB at 50 or 100Hz, but values 11. Steven W. Smith, Internal noise of low
frequency preamplifiers, Review of Scientific In
with ratios up to 1:20 with consequently decrease significantly to 20 -40dB in the
struments 55, May 1984, p.812/813.
nasty frequency response and distortion range between 1 and 20kHz. This means, for 12. M. Hartley Jones, A practical introduction to
characteristics, and with less-than-perfect example, if there is a noise level of -60dBm electronic circuits, Cambridge University Press,
p roduction techniques and materials. on the power supply voltages (a value typical p.40-51.
However, modern audio transformers are for most fixed-value voltage regulators), a 13. Linear Technology, Linear Databook 1986.
produced using much improved materials noise voltage of -1 OOdBm will appear at the 14. Linear Technology, Linear Databook Supple
and techniques, and excessive step-up ratios output of the low-noise amplifier, if its ment 1988.
15. Ferranti, Technical Handbook Standard ICs.
are no longer necessary, thanks to the lower power supply rejection ratio is 40dB. So
16. PMIISSM, Products Data Book
optimum source resistance of modern tran some care must also put into the design of
17. Transamp LZ Data Sheet.
sistors and op-amps. low-noise power supplies. Consequently all 18. Hugh Ford, Matchamp XTX 129 mic. preamp.,
types of switching power supply should be Broadcast Sound January/February 1984. p.52-
Inverting summing amplifiers have their avoided in such applications because they 55.
particular noise problems, which are due cannot be made to run sufficiently quiet. 19. Deane Jensen, JE990 Discrete operational
Zener diodes also produce significant amplifier, Journal of the Audio Engineering Soci
firstly to the unavoidable series input resis
ety Vol. 28 No 1/2, January/February 1980, p.26-
tor and secondly to the amount of noise gain amounts of white noise if not properly
34.
as defined in Fig.H, which shows the circuit bypassed with low series-resistance capaci
20. A. Foord, Introduction to low-noise amplifier
of a typical summing amplifier with five tors. design, Wireless World April 1981, p.71-73.
inputs. As far as each input is concerned, the Noise levels of power supply voltages can 21. Steve Dove, Designing a professional mixing
gain of this stage is OdB. But as far as noise be measured by connecting the supply vol console, Part 4: The Mixer Frontend, Studio
gain is concerned there is 14dB of noise gain tage via a capacitor to the input of the Sound December 1980, p.40-48.
(2.2kn divided by the 440n of the five NE5534 amplifier (Fig.4). Note that in this 22. Steve Dove, Designing a professional mixing
parallel input resistors). This consequently case 20dB must be subtracted from the console, Part 12: The Channel Frontend, Studio
increases the noise level of, say, -llOdB to calibration values of the stepped gain switch. Sound October 1981, p.70-72.