DAILY MAIL COMMENT: This House is a blot on the constitution 

By DAILY MAIL COMMENT

Published: | Updated:

Let one thing be clear from the outset. Though the Mail believes it is both morally right and vital for Britain’s future to curb the £30billion a year cost of tax credits, this paper shares many of the reservations expressed by rebel Tories and the Opposition over where George Osborne’s planned cuts will fall.

The very essence of the Tories’ election-winning message was that they would make work pay and reward those who do the right thing.

Yet under the proposals as they stand, many hard-working families will suffer heavily, with just cause to feel betrayed.

Scroll down for video 

The House of Lords, pictured,  has become a blot on the British constitution with far too many members

The House of Lords, pictured,  has become a blot on the British constitution with far too many members

Among the most recent recruits is bra designer Michelle Mone, or Baroness Mone of Mayfair, pictured 

Among the most recent recruits is bra designer Michelle Mone, or Baroness Mone of Mayfair, pictured 

Before next month’s Autumn Statement, therefore, the Chancellor will surely be wise to adjust his measures and soften the blow to those least able to bear it.

   

More from Daily Mail Comment...

But that said, it is nothing short of scandalous that Opposition peers threaten to mobilise their majority in the Upper House to throw out Mr Osborne’s cuts – central to the Government’s election pledge to slash £12billion from welfare.

Yesterday, former Cabinet Secretary Lord Butler summed it up when he said that the Lords is getting ‘too big for its non-elected boots’.

Indeed, whether or not peers carry out their threat, in defiance of the 100-year-old convention that tax matters are for the Commons to decide, the very fact that they have made it highlights the crying need for reform of the Upper House.

Put simply, the Lords has become a blot on the British constitution. For a start, it is far too big – a legislative assembly beaten only in size by the National People’s Congress of China.

Meanwhile, it is stuffed to the rafters with dodgy party donors, superannuated members of the political class, tawdry celebrities and cronies of past and present prime ministers.

Indeed, a glance at this year’s 45 recruits – including a bra designer and 11 vanquished Lib Dems – shows why the House has become a laughing stock.

True, there is no simple formula for Lords reform, as successive governments can testify. But in his four remaining years at No 10, David Cameron should make it his mission to succeed where so many of his predecessors have failed.

What we need is a slimmed-down chamber, drawing on the best brains in science, business, the professions and the arts. If Mr Cameron can deliver this, his legacy will be assured.

Great deal ... for China

AS President Xi Jinping flies off after the fawning pomp of his state visit, doubts have been raised over Mr Cameron’s claim that the deals struck this week are worth £40billion.

What is certain is that China, with its appalling record of cyber theft and espionage, has been handed a key role in major British infrastructure projects – not least, the highly sensitive renewal of our nuclear power industry.

Would any sum be large enough to justify taking such a risk?

Yes, it is strongly in our national interest to do business with the world’s second largest importer (though the thousands of British steelworkers who have lost their jobs through China’s unscrupulous trading practices have reason to think otherwise).

But after all the sucking up – and the hugely generous terms the Chinese have been offered – will Beijing treat our firms more favourably in future?

Or will they just think of us as suckers?

After this week's visit of President Xi, left, will Beijing treat British firms more favourably in future

After this week's visit of President Xi, left, will Beijing treat British firms more favourably in future

  • How can soldiers do their job, under constant threat of prosecution for their actions in the heat of battle? As it emerges that police are investigating more than 100 Afghan insurgents’ claims of ill-treatment, the Tories must keep their promise to protect our forces (and taxpayers) from ambulance-chasing lawyers without delay.

 

Most watched News videos